"A new patent granted to aircraft, defense and security company Boeing is taking its cues from science fiction. Just like the glowing energy shields seen protecting troops, machines and even spacecraft in Star Wars and Star Trek, the design -- named "Method and system for shockwave attenuation via electromagnetic arc" -- uses energy to deflect potential damage.
As it is described, the system is not designed to prevent direct impact from shells or shrapnel; rather, it is designed to protect a target -- such as a vehicle or building -- from the damaging effects of shockwaves from a nearby impact.
The patent is for a shockwave attenuation system, which consists of a sensor capable of detecting a shockwave-generating explosion and an arc generator that receives the signal from the sensor to ionise a small region, producing a plasma field between the target and the explosion using lasers, electricity and microwaves.
Original Title
Method and system for shockwave attenuation via electromagnetic arc
"A new patent granted to aircraft, defense and security company Boeing is taking its cues from science fiction. Just like the glowing energy shields seen protecting troops, machines and even spacecraft in Star Wars and Star Trek, the design -- named "Method and system for shockwave attenuation via electromagnetic arc" -- uses energy to deflect potential damage.
As it is described, the system is not designed to prevent direct impact from shells or shrapnel; rather, it is designed to protect a target -- such as a vehicle or building -- from the damaging effects of shockwaves from a nearby impact.
The patent is for a shockwave attenuation system, which consists of a sensor capable of detecting a shockwave-generating explosion and an arc generator that receives the signal from the sensor to ionise a small region, producing a plasma field between the target and the explosion using lasers, electricity and microwaves.
"A new patent granted to aircraft, defense and security company Boeing is taking its cues from science fiction. Just like the glowing energy shields seen protecting troops, machines and even spacecraft in Star Wars and Star Trek, the design -- named "Method and system for shockwave attenuation via electromagnetic arc" -- uses energy to deflect potential damage.
As it is described, the system is not designed to prevent direct impact from shells or shrapnel; rather, it is designed to protect a target -- such as a vehicle or building -- from the damaging effects of shockwaves from a nearby impact.
The patent is for a shockwave attenuation system, which consists of a sensor capable of detecting a shockwave-generating explosion and an arc generator that receives the signal from the sensor to ionise a small region, producing a plasma field between the target and the explosion using lasers, electricity and microwaves.
United States Patent
00898
261B)
«2 (0 Patent No: US 8,981,261 BI
Tillotson (45) Date of Patent: Mar. 17, 2015
(4) METHOD AND SYSTEM FoR SHOCKWAVE S4a0688 A 1995 Eins ta
ALTENUATION VIA ELECTROMAGNETIC 5730.488 A 4/1998 Girard
aL 3000 Sens ta
fi, Fitor Scene
Blo 7atol Fagvetal
(75) Investor: Brian J-Totson, Kent, WA (US) Br tato) Lada
BL itor Serene
93) Assignee: “The Roving Company, Chicago I Be ates Serena
(73) Aiqnes: The Boeing Company. Chica, easier BL 112003 Retort ta
Shaa9o0 nov ‘Pao Bane soitat
(4). Notice: Subject to an disclaimer, the erm of this (Contino)
patent extended or ated under 35
USC. 1540) by 330 dys FORFIGN PATENT DOCUMENTS
wo onsen sig97
(21) Appl. No 13/483,995 wo ‘DOL 48165 122011
(22) Feds May 30,2012 OritBR PUBLICATIONS
(sb) Inch Rei ofa atest Shosk Blt vas gta Des
Paap sss (200601) .
rain sao? (200.01)
tesa Primary Braniner —Joseph M Pelham,
‘USPC vo 219/383; 219/201; 219/202; 89/3601; (74) Attorney, Agent, or Firm — Thompson Hine LLP
$9136.07, 8936.08 89/3609
(58) Field of Clasiticaion Search Co) ABSTRACT
None Amethod and system for atoning a sookwave prop
Sev application efor complte search history: ing tng fit medium by heating selected region othe
fint uid medium rapidly to create socom transient
6) References Cited tod tha infrcepts the shockwave and temats its
US. PATENT DOCUMENTS
LUO A 8116 Leon
Zango A E194 Nicolas
Ysisz% A 71980 Albert
50707 § $196) Baker ca
ee0'951 A $972 Cadel
35768 111973 Minas
BW A 41075 tke
Sma A 31976 Pasay
4218630 A KIDS). Hagelborg tal
A3Ist A V10s Holm
488872 4 101985 Graham eal
Sha0al1 A * ‘61991 Rowan sot
Hit H 91903. Richart
SA4L718 A £1994. Woodall tal
E8878 A 31905 Geileet al.
energy density before it reaches a protected aset. The second
‘mediuin may arene the shockwave by one or more of
reflection, reliction, dispersion, absorption and momenta
transfer. The method and system may inelude a sensor for
detecting a shockwave-prodocing event, determining a dice-
‘ion and distance of the shockwave relative to a defended
‘angel and calculating & fring plan, and an are generator for
creating the second medium, The arc generator may erate the
second medium by ereating an electric ae that trvels along
an eletrcally conductive path utilizing atleast one of high
intensity laser pulses, pellets forming # conductive ion ti,
sacrificial conductors, projectiles tailing electrical wires, and
‘magnetic induction
23 Claims, 7 Drawing SheetsUS 8,981,261 BI
Page 2
66)
T0TTo49
Tana
Tea
721936
Taso?
782790
7866.250,
7878103
ona
0s. 762
Bata
ISLTIO
386.730
san
References Cited
USS. PATENT DOCUMENTS
8
BD
Bit
Bo
BI
5
B
B?
B
bo
BL
Bo
BD
BD
72006
Sonn
4008
3-008
oun
112010
en
mm
ro2011
Hort
32012
4302
$2013
Soon
Shumow ta
James
Smith
Inbal a.
Faint a
Beach ta
Panella
Fuetal
Fischbach tl
Barger eta
9113
sass me
8385-765 BL
Non566 12"
2oosorni9st Al*
Sooa107927 Al
aonauniaa7 Ale
20070008725 AL
aou71so9s AL
aoiwnr9i2%6 AL
2oooottaost AL
aoo0268226 AL
aoin0si9s24 Al
gorn0si9se6 Al
2orv0120204 1
soutotesoot AL
aoiumoroM AL
20120060677 AL
* cited by examiner
52013
102013
2ol4
122008
‘62004
‘e200
007
£2007
$2008
52000
102009
122010
12010
‘Sour
oll
a0
52012
tna ta
Basler etal
Tilleton 12215
Nemier
Waddle
Faring tal
Parnell tal
Tit ta
Beach eta
Honezar
fuel
FincaU.S, Patent Mar. 17,2015 Sheet 1 of 7
24 26 10
t \ ic wt
30 Sensor
\ 34
7 = ARC
| Mediu Generator
FIG. 1
FIG. 2
US 8,981,261 BLU.S. Patent Mar. 17,2015 Sheet 2 of 7 US 8,981,261 B1
410A
FIG. 3
4
108
4 0 4g “ 38 %
52 20
24- Ps f 1
48. AK - nnn
0 \ 86
10B
FIG. 4U.S. Patent Mar. 17,2015 Sheet 3 of 7 US 8,981,261 B1U.S, Patent
Mar. 17, 2015
Sheet 4 of 7
Prior to Shock Interaction
FIG. 8A
US 8,981,261 BL
74
veU.S, Patent Mar. 17, 2015
Sheet 5 of 7 US 8,981,261 B1
P
— 74
‘ 18
24 i
v \ ' wd
22 —<— $=)
————————
———— 1
38
After Shock Interaction
FIG. 8B
Prior to Shock Interaction
FIG. 9A,U.S. Patent Mar. 17,2015 Sheet 6 of 7 US 8,981,261 B1
“te
After Shock Interaction
FIG. 9BU.S. Patent Mar. 17,2015 Sheet 70f7 US 8,981,261 B1
24
FIG. 11US 8,981,261 BI
1
METHOD AND SYSTEM FOR SHOCKWAVE,
ATTENUATION VIA ELECTROMAGNETIC
ARC
FIELD
‘The disclosure relates to methods and systems for shock
‘wave attention, and more particularly to methods and sys-
tems for attenuating shockwaves by rapidly heating. ait 10
Jnerpose an intermediate medium between the shockwave
and a protected region.
BACKGROUND
Explosive devices are being used increasingly in asymmet
rie warlareto cause damageand destruction to equipment and
Joss of life, The majority ofthe damage caused by explosive
‘devices results fom shrapnel and shockwaves. Shrapnel is
material such as meta fragments, that is propelled rapidly,
away from the blast zone and may damage stationary strc
tures, vehicles, or ther targets. Damage from shrapnel may
be prevented by for example, physical hrriers. Shoekwaves
are traveling discontinuities in pressure, temperature, density,
and other physical qualities throwgh a medium, such as the
‘ambient atmosphere, Shockwave damage is more dllcult to
prevent because shockwaves can traverse an intermediate
‘medium, including physical barriers.
‘Damage from shockwaves may be lessened or prevented
by interposing an attenuating material between the shock-
‘wave source and the object be protected. This attenuating
‘material typically may be designed or selected to absorb the
‘energy fiom the shockwaveby wilizing a porous material at
distorts a the energy of the shockwave i absorbed,
US. Pat. No. £394,786 to Gettle et al. describes a shock-
wave attenuation device that uilizes an absorbing medium.
‘Thatassembly includes porous screens that fom an enclosure
filed with a pressure wave attenvating modivm, This atten
ting medium may be an aquenis foam, gas emlsion, ge, oF
granular or other solid particles, However, as shown and
described in the drawings of that patent, the shockwave
attenuating assembly most be positioned before the explosion
‘occurs andl surround thearea to be protected. Forexample, the
‘sembly may’be pesitioned onthe sideof a vehicle to prevent
‘damage o the vehicle or passengers within
‘A similar shockwave attenuation device is described in
US. Patent Publication No, 20070006723 to Waddell, eet
‘al. That device includes a number of calls filled with an
‘attenuating material, sich as aqueous foams. However, like
the device described in Getle et al, the pressure-attenvatng
material and device must be positioned on a structure, su=
face, or person desired tobe protected by the system before
the explosion occurs
‘One feature common among prior art shockwave atten
tion systems is that they require an intermediate medium or
struct that ets to aftentate the foree of the shockwave by
absorbing the enemzy of the shockwave. Although only a
portion ofthe shockwave may passthrough the medium, the
‘enerayof the shockwave isnevertheless significantly reduced
by the intermediate medium. However, bocause these ystems
‘are structural, they must be fixed in place belorea shockwave
is created. Further, these shockwave sentation systems may
not protect an entre vehicle or person. For example, attem-
ting panels are not transparent and therefore cannot be
placed over windows or used as facemasks in helmets, They
also may be bulky and heavy, and therefore negatively impact
the performance ofa vehiele on whieh they are mounted
0
o
2
Such prior art shockwave attenuation systems may not be
effective to provet highly mobile land asets for whieh an
‘incoming threat may be in the form of baliste shel, rocket,
IED, or landmine, or waterborne assets for which an incom-
ing threat may be inthe form of a torpedo, ballistic shell
‘bomb ora naval mine. Therefore anced exists for a shoek=
‘wave attenuation device that is capable of dynamically inter-
posing a medium between an explosion source and a pro-
tected aset. There i ls0 need Foran intermediate medinm
that effectively attenuates the energy froma shockwave and
that allows for prowetion of a protected asset in @ marine
enviroment
SUMMARY,
resented is a systom and method for attenuating a shock
wave propagating in a fist medium by detecting a shoek-
‘wave-producing event, determining a direction ofthe shock-
wave relative 10 protected asset, and interposing a second,
transient medium, different from the frst medium, berween
the shockwave and the protected asset such that a shockwave
produced by the event contacts the second medium and is
fattened in energy thereby prior to reaching the protected
asset. The second medium may be formed by rapidly heating
‘aregionof the fist medium so that the second medium differs
trom the first medium in atleast one of temperature, density
and composition,
Tn one embodiment, system for attesting a shockwave
propagating ina frst medium may include sensor for detet-
Jing a source of the shockwave nnd generating a detection
signal, an are generator in communication with the Sensorand
configured to ceive the detection signal therefrom, and in
response thereto create at electromagnetic are to heat a
selected region ofthe frst fil medium pil to create the
second, ansient medium, different Irom the fist medium,
interposed between the shockwave and the protected region
such that the shockwave contacts the second, trasient
‘medium. The are generator may be configured to hest the
selected region by generating an electromagnetic ae, suet as
fn clectre arc or laser ar microwave are, between the pro-
tected region and the incoming shockwave, In one embod
meat, the are generator may include a power supply for gen-
crating the are and may provide a conducting pat.
Tn embodimenls Ihe are generator may be configured 10
szeneratea focused microwave heam ora focused laser beam,
Inch case, the beam may rapidly heat the fuid mestum in
the selected region to ereate the second medium, In one
embodiment, in which the fluid medium is atmospheric ae,
the focused beam rapidly heats the air in the selected region
and changes its tempersture, density and composition, the
Jatterthe result of the eeation of free electrons.
nother embodiments, heare generator may be adapted to
develop and drive a large electric current through the fui
‘medium rapidly. Inthe embodiment in which the medium is
atmosphere air, the second medium may differ from ambient
tir in temperature, density and composition. With these
embodiments, the are generator may be adapted to create a
‘ontucting path for the electric current, Accordingly, the are
generator may’ be configured to generate one of more of &
Jaser-indveed plasma channel (LIPC) from converging laser
‘beams, ionizing tracer pelos fired along converging paths,
‘and projectiles tiling fine eloctical wires fied along con:
verging paths. In each ofthese embodiments, an electric are
may be generated to travel along. condocting path eeated by
Giclectnc breakdown of ionized ambient sir at the selected
eiUS 8,981,261 BI
3
Ins otherembstiments, these eneator ay incase
social condor that may aot ely on cent el long
‘pth fone ai Rater, the are poneator may incl 9
porwr suplytataplies camrentioacondotorinthe fom of
‘on ormor sips or wie of conductive material. The high
‘arent fwing throngh the conc fom the poe soph
nay vaporize the condor, forming condotive chanel of
“por tat may rapidly heat and oni the an the elected
region fo create a rapidly expanding second medium. An
‘vantage of isembodimeat thatthe sara sonductor
ima’ e attach diety tothe protec asst, sh 2h
vehicle
Such embodiments described above may reduce the
energy density ofthe shockwave by crating a saond
ined inthe path of the advancing shock hat reo,
refaet, aso and deflects test portion othe shock
‘wave Tit may ret fom eeting second medio tat
{ifr frm the smbieat msi (espe i) in
‘density, temperate andlor composition, Sich difleences
tay change te index of reftacton ofthe wave font a it
ones the second medium, casing atleast some of the
shockwave tobe rflcted fiom the surice ofthe second
medium, fo diverge ae the shockwave tnvels thug the
tes, and tae elle and diverge frie asthe sok
‘rave contacts the rearward boundary ofthe soon mdm
The second medium, sane enbodent cif absorb ts
coer ofthe shockwave the medium my be inte in
tempore
In 3st other embodiments, the are gonertor eens the
secon matium by magnetic industion. The are goertor
may be adap to crete chanel or enized ai When cone
tieied by an avncing shockave the condocting enna
imay be deformed asionizediris pasha inward This move-
tment does mechanical work, which removes enc fom the
shockyne, making st weaker. none ape he channels
may not be Fig and maybe pushed y the shockwave
aaint he ambient athat he chanelsaredigplacing which
tay transfer energy’ fom the shockate to Knee ener of
{isplced ar Inanother aspect, ars of ihe eondnsivechan-
nels re not rigid bith channels of onze arp hed
‘tthe magne fn are ismpetan broken util they orm
new channels though the ar that eet the ar At Test
ponton othe shockwave energy may be transformed to
Fration energy oir ions and in peseure-volume-trpert-
tire eng of expand ha
Tost another spotthe conductive chanelsof magnetic
hx are raid myn he defommed hy comet ih the
‘advancing shockwave Instead, the fox my be compressed
ty contac with the shockwave which may increase the eee-
ticcuent inthe condictivechannls. This nerenscorent
‘ols om enegylstby the shockwave. The ar generator
nay be config sch thatthe exces cute may bypass
the power suply and be shunted to het a resistive had, ot
‘hangoacoactor whore itm bese ater power tbe are
eneion
‘With mach embodiments, the advaning shockwave is
imine in fre a the eneray of the shockwave con.
verted either into mechan energy, a when i deforms
naynsic induction channels, or io clerical ener. a3
hen interets with gid magnetic Bx channels tis
bitin tho scope of this disclosure wo provide a syste and
mnaod inshihcombinations ofthe foregoing ebosimen's
fre deployed to defend.a proce asst, oF in which an
“Embodiment i deployed mati times aginst an incoming
thr
“The fetes, functions, and advantages tat have been
siscunsed an be achieve independent a various enbodke
0
o
4
ments of the present invention oF may be combined in yet
‘other embodiments further details of which ean be seen with
reference tothe following description, drawings and claims.
BRIEP DESCRIPTION OF DRAWINGS
FIG. isa schematic diagram of theelementsofadisclosed
system, aecording fo an embodiment;
FIG. 2 isan elevational, schematic view of the disclosed
system mounted on a profeted asset generating an are 10
encounter a shockwave from an explosion;
FIG. 3 is an elevational, schematic view of the disclosed
system configured to utilize converging laser or microwave
beams;
FIG. 4 isan elevational, schematic view of the disclosed
system configured to utilize pellets leaving conductive trails;
FIG. isan elevational, schematic view of the disclosed
system configured t0 utilize projectiles trailing conductive
FIG, 6 isan elevational, schematic view of the disclosed
system configured to uilize a sacrificial conductor;
PIG. 7 isan elevational, schematic view ofthe system of
FIG. 6 surface mounted on a protocted asset,
FIGS, 8A and 8B are schematic viewsof an embodimentof
the heating element of the disclosed system configured 10
generate an are using flexible electrodes;
FIGS, 9A and 9B are schematic viewsofan embodimentof
the are generator ofthe disclosed system configured to gen-
crate an arc using relatively rigid electrodes: and
FIGS. 10 and 11 are digrams showing some of the effects
ofa shockwave impacting the second, Nuid medium.
DETAILED DESCRIPTION
‘The disclosed shockwave attenuation method and system
may utilize a second, trnsient uid medium that may be
dynamically deployed in a first fluid medium between an
explosion and a protected asset within a protected region
‘When contacted by anxvaneing shockwave produced by the
cexplasion raving through the fist fluid medium, the second
‘uid medium may ttemiate the enengy ftom the shockwave
through several vectors, rather than simply by absorbing the
eneray of the shockwave, While the following discussion
{describes various embadiments of the disclosed system and
‘method as operating ina frst fd medium of atmosphere ie,
itisto be understood tha the Fist Mid medium may be water,
such tha the disclosed system and method may be deployed
‘As shovsn in FIG. 1, in one embodiment, the system for
attenuating 2 shockwave via electromagnetic arc, generally
designated 10, may include sensor 12 including o incorpo-
ring a computer 14, and an are generator, generally desig-
‘ted 16. The sensor 12 and computer 14 may be mounted on
or incorporated in a provected asset, such as a vehicle 18,
‘which may be a military vehicle as shown in PIG. 2, or they
:may be piysically separate from the vehicle. Although FIG. 2
shows vehicle 18 as a military vehicle, iis to be understood
{hat the depicted vehicle 18 also may represent other types of
Jand vehicles, such as automobiles, armored vehicles such as
‘tanks and armored personne! caer; fxed structures suelias
cencampments, bunkers, revetment, buildings or portions of
buildings such as halconies; marine vessels such as surface
ships, submarines, a hovereaft or air-cushion vehicles, off
shore platforms, and other structs that operate in, under oF
Adjacent a body of water aieft including fixed wing
rll, vertical takeoff and landing (VTOL) erat and belicop-US 8,981,261 BI
5
‘ers; and people and animals, Bach ofthe foregoing would be
placed in protected region 20
Refering (0 FIG. 1, the sensor 12 may be selected (0
provide measurements that enable the computer 14 to est-
mate the location and time ofan explosion 22, eitherbefore oF
aller it occurs, and direct the are generator 16 to respond In
‘one embodiment, the sensor 12 is configured t0 detect an
‘explosion 22 tht as occurred, but before the shockwave 24
catsed by the explosion, taveling through a fist tid
tedium 26, which inthis embodiment is atmospheric air at
ambient temperature and pressure, reaches the prowcted
region 20. This type of sensor 12 may be eoafigured to detect
‘any oneor oreo the electromagnetic signals emited during
‘chemical detonations, including microwave bursts, ashes of
infrared radiation, flashes of visible light, flashes oT ultavio-
Jet ight, and x-ray bursts bodiment a sensor 12 may
be configured to deiet two or more ofthe foregoing types of
clecicomagnetic radiation, which may result in the sensor
detecting fewer falbe positives, In variation of such an
‘embodiment, the sensor 12 may be inthe fmm of two discrete
sensor, each configured to deteta different typeof electo-
‘magnetic radiation, In an embodiment i which the sensor 12
is selected for use in a marine environment (eto detect
Underwater explosions from naval mines or torpedoes), the
sensor 12 may be configures to detect electromagnetic radia-
Gionat wavelenaths for which water is substantially tranpare
‘ent, uch as visible ight near-ultraviolt ight and near-nfa
red ight
nsome embodiments, one the sensor 12 has detected an
‘explosion 22, the sensormay be onfiguredto estimate oneor
more ofthe magnitude, distance, and avimthal position of
the explosion and provide the estimates othe computer 14 oF
to the are generator 16, In sore embedimeats, the compote
44 may measure the signature ofthe explosion 22 and co
pare it with stored known explosion signatures ofa plality
‘f diferent known explosive deviees. The computer 14 may.
then datermine a probability thatthe explosions from one of
the known explosive devices. The computer 14 may then
calculate an estimated probability. cistibution function
(4. oFexplosion magnitudes and locations relative to the
protected asst 18 or protected epion 20 based onal least one
‘f stored data about the typeof explosive device, location of
the explosion, and the shape, relative orientation and relative
motion of the protected aset and make a determination to
‘counter the explosion 22, including determining when and
‘where to activate the are generator 16, or not counter the
‘explosion, based on one of stored data, models of vulnerabil-
iy ofthe protect asset to shockwaves, and data froma least
‘oncof dataand models ofprfarmanee ofthe ae generator 16.
‘with respect attenuating shockwaves fromat leat one of an
‘estimated explosion magnitude and location, Sch calcula-
tions and estimates may prevent the deployment of the are
generator 16 in the event that the explosion 22.0 faraway
‘or too weak 10 generate a shockwave 26 that damages the
protected region 20 significantly
Tnanother embodiment, the sensor 12 may be configured to
detect an incoming threat 28 containing an explosive device
‘or deviees, such 3s a balistie shell, bomb, torpedo, depth
‘charge, naval mine or bomb-laden surface vessel. In suc an
‘embodiment, the sensor 12 may be configured to use radar,
Visible orinfiared ight, pasive or active acoustic sensor, oF
‘other threat detection method known to those skilled inthe
fart as well as trajectory tracking and prediction methods
known to those stalled in the ar.
Tnyet another embodiment, the sensor 12 may be config-
tured to detect oth the incoming threat 28 and the explosion
22 fiom the threat, In one embodiment, two systems 10 may
0
o
6
be deployed on a protected asset 18 in which one system is
configured 0 detect an incoming threat 28 and the other
system is configured to detect an explosion 22, In yet another
variation of such an embodiment, he sensor 12 may bein the
orm of two discrete sensors: one configured to detect an
‘incoming threat 28, and the other configured to detect an
explosion 22 from that incoming threat.
Tn some embodiments, the computer 14 may receive mea-
surements from the sensor 12, estimate where and when an
incoming treat 28 will detonate, or has already’ detonated,
and directs the system 10 to deploy. When used with sensor
12 that may detect an explosion that already has occurred, the
computer 14 may be configured to receive infomation from
the sensor pertaining tone or more ofthe direction, location,
time, distance and magnitude of the explosion 22, the com
puter determines when and where to activate theare generator
16.
TIn.an embosliment wherein the sensor 12 is configured 10
detect an incoming threat 28 before explosion 22 has
‘ceured, the computer 14 may be configured to compare the
signature ofthe incoming threat 28 with stored known signa-
tures of various threats (e.g. particular missiles). The com
puter 14 then estimates how probable each type of threat is,
And, based on the stored data about the type of warhead for
‘ach threat, the measured motion ofthe incomsingobjeet (with
associated uncertainty) and the shape trajectory, orientation,
speed and motion ofthe protected asset 18 inthe protected
region 20, the computer estimates a probability distribution
funetion (p 4) of explosion magnitudes and Ioeations re
tive tothe protected asset
sed on data oF models of vulnerability ofthe protected
asset 18 to shockwaves 24 of various magnitudes from var
fous directions (including crew injures ikely to result fro
shockwaves) stored ina database (either locally or available
‘over a netsork) together with data or models of what tbe are
fgenemtor 16 can do to attenate shockwaves in what posi
‘ions and ia what time interval, the computer 14 may thea
{orm ring plan to counter the threat a minimum cost. Cost
‘may inelnde not only’ the cast operate the ae generator 16,
bt also the probable cost of damage from the attenuated
shockwave. In eases where the probable explosion yield is
‘mall and he probable distance of the explosion 22 from the
protected region is lame, the lowest cost plan may’ be not 10
‘ploy the system 10,
‘As shovsn inthe embodiments of FIGS, Land 2, the are
genenitor 16 may be configured fo create a transient second
‘medium 30 between the advancing shockwave 24 resulting
{rom the explosion 22 and the protected region 20, which may
contain a protected asset 18. As shown in FIG. 2, generally
speaking, the sensor 12 may generate w detection signal in
response t0 detecting at least one of the explosion 22 or
explosive device such as incoming threat 28, The detection
Signal is received by are generator 16, and in response, may
create an electromagnetic are through the frst medium 26
‘which rpdly heats the medium to change one or more of its
‘composition and temperature to ereate the second, transient
‘medium 30, diferent fom te fist medium 26. The location
‘ofthe second medium 30 may be ia selected region calew-
Jated by the computer 14 ofthe sensor 12 to be interposed
between te shockwave 24, or predicted shockwave path, and
the protected region 20. Thus, the shockwave 24 contacts the
second, tensient medium 30 and is attennated in energy
density before it reaches the protected region 20, The are
genenitor 16 shown schematically in FIG. 1 may take the
form of multiple, diserete arc generators, cach connected 10
and controlled by the sensor 12US 8,981,261 BI
1
Inone embodiment, shown schematically ia FIG. A, the are
generator 16 is configured o direct a bearn Mo electromag
netic energy to focus ina selected region where the second
‘diam 30 may be ereated. The beam 34 may be in the fom
‘ofa relatively powerfl mierovawe beam or laser beam. The
‘lecric field of the intense heams 34 may cause dielectric
breakdown of the ambient air atthe foal point ofthe focused
beams, in which the electrons are separated frm the mol-
‘ecules in the ait. The free electrons are accelerated by’ the
‘leczic field and strike other molecules to knock other elo
‘tons loose, creating a cascade of electrons and ions.
As the density of fee charge carriers inthe air increases,
the air becomes opaque to the incoming electromagnetic
beams and ropidly absorbs enengy from the beams as beat
‘which raises the temperature of the air as well as its density
‘and composition, thus creating the sevond medium 30 10
imereept the advancing shockwave 24, The composition
‘changes of the second fuid medium 30 may include adding
fie electrons, which have a relatively low molar mass, ion-
ization of molecules so that they interact more strongly and
therefore propagate shockwaves at higher speeds, and break
ing diatomic molecules such s molecular oxygen into single
toms, which reds the average molar mass
Tn some embodiments, the beam 34 may be a microwave
beam. The are generator 16 may inchde a vacuum tube
amplifier (eg..8 magnetron) aul focused by a state Focusing
device et, dish antenna o¢ a Fresnel plate), or produced
‘and focused by other means of combisations apparent 10
those skilled inthe ant. In other embodiments the beam 34 is
laser beam, The laser beam may bea single beam focused to
‘point by optics, or multiple beams converging ta common
point. In either ease, the Beam 34 may'ereate single or mul-
tipleares 32 (FIG. 2) Insomeembodiments the arc generator
16 may use many converging beams 4 to create one are 32.
Jn other embodiments one beam 34 may be used multiple
times in quick suocession to ereate many ares 32. The beams
may be fied or steerable.
‘As shown in FIG. 3, in another embodiment of the system
10, the are genemor 16 (FIG. 1) may be configured to
generatean electric are 36 through volume of ambient air 26
to create the second medinm 30, Electrical resistance to the
‘current heats the air, changing its temperate, density and
‘composition to create the second medium 30 to attenuate the
shockwave 24. The change in composition may include ad-
ing free electron, whieh have very low molar mass, ioniza-
tion of molecules so they interact at longer distance and
therefore propagate shockwaves at higher speed, and beak
ing diatomie molecules ike oxygen into single atoms, whieh
reduces the average molar mass of the lid in the Second
medium 30,
The are generator 16 (FIG. 1) ofthe system 10A of this
‘embodiment may include a power supply 38 configured 10
initiate a large electri current quickly typically on the
‘onder ofa few milliseconds oF less, Such @ power supply 38
‘may include a capacitor, a superconducting storage coil, and
fn explosive Thix compression generator The first two
‘examples may require fast-acting, high-current switchgear
such as a gas-insbated switch, 10 turn on a large current
‘Quickly (or the capacitor orto divert itquickly from a shunt
to the electric are (forthe storage evil).
In one aspect ofthis embodiment, the ae generator 16
‘reates an electrically conductive path from the power supply
38 tothe selected region between the shockwave 24 and the
protected region 20 o establish the ae, and back to the power
supply. none embodiment, shown ia FIG, 3, the are gener
tor l6createss laser-induced plasma channel (LIPC). The are
enerator 16 fires two high-intensity laser beams 40,42 along
0
o
8
‘converging paths. The loser wavelengths and intensities are
Selected to fonize the ar along their paths, thereby fonming
the plasma channels. The power supply 38 applies voltage
across the terminals atthe bases of the two channels 40, 42
‘nd the voltage is sufficient wo form the are 36 throug the air
26 where the beams are close to each other. Current flows
‘through the channels of the LIPC and induces a magnetic
field, The current interacts with the magnetic field and pro-
duces an outward force (113). Ths foree acts to widen the
area enclosed by the eurrent loop.
“As shown in FIG. 4, ia another embostiment ofthe system
109 the are generator 16 (FIG. 1) sa gua, which may haveat
east two or multiple barrels 4,46 hat fire two pellets $8, 50
‘long converging paths. The pellets 48,50 are configured to
create trails 82, 84 of ions, for example, by burning silver
iodide, in the manner of tracer bullets. The two trails $2, 54
form condvetive channels through the air (the fist find
medium), and the power supply 38 applies voltaze across
terminals atthe bases of the 10 conductive channels, pref-
crably the barrels 44,46, The voltage is sulicieat to form aa
are $6 through the aie26 between the two tails $2, $4 (.2..the
conductive channels) where they are at their closest. The are
‘S6hcats the air26to create the second transient uid mesinm
30. In other embodiments, the pellets 48, $0 may be selected
‘o melt or bum up completely, thereby avoiding ereating 2
Inward forby stander,
‘As shown in FIG. 8, in another embodiment ofthe system
10C the are yeneraor 16 (FIG. 1) is a projectile launcher
configured to laineh projectiles $8, 60 trsling conductive
wires 62, 64 much likea Taser8, The power supply 38 applies
vollage across the two wires suicient to form an are 66
‘through the ar 26 where the paths ofthe projectiles $8, 60 are
closest to each other. The are 66 eats the si 26, foeming the
second tid mediu 30 in a selected region between the
‘advancing shockwave 24 and the protected asset 18 in the
protected region 20, As elecrical current flows through the
‘wires 62, 6, which form conductive channel, the current
‘urtherheats and ionizes the sit 26. In someembodiments, the
current is suficent to vaporize the wires 62, 64, thezcby
heating aditional nearby air 26
‘As shown in FIGS, 6 and 7, in another embodiment the
system 10D includes are generator 16(FIG.1)intheformot
‘one or more sacrificial conductors 68 connected to te poser
supply 38. The heating mechanism of this embodiment does
pot rely on dielectric breakdown of the air 26 to ereate a
ceurrent channel, The sacrificial condvetor 68 may be in the
orm of strips or wires made of clecrieally conductive mate-
Fal. Insome embodiments, the conductor 68 may be mounted
fon the protected asset 18
Todeploy the system 10D, the are generator 16 actuatesthe
power supply 38 to supply current to one of more of the
eonductors 68, frst vaporizing it then ionizing ito form a
cconcdctive channel of vapor 70. Due to both the resultant
‘magnetic fied (JB) force and the expansion othe hot vapor
created by vaporizing the conductr, the ionized vapor moves
‘outward rom its initial position and heats and ionizes the
nearby air to create the second fluid medium 30
In one embodiment, shown in FIG. 7, the sacrificial con-
ductor 68 may be attached to a protected asset 18, which may
be the land vehicle shown. The conductor 68 may beattoched
{o. wider insulating strip 72 that in turn is mounted on the
asset If, With such a placement of the conductor 68, the
conductor 68 may be protected from routine vehicle oper
tions, and may be furher protected by overlaying it with a
‘oat of paint, When energized by the poser supply 38 (FIG.
{),the conductor 68, which may bea metallic stip, vaporizes,
and the heated and ionized air may expand from the vehicleUS 8,981,261 BI
9
surface and move away ffom the vehiele to ereate the second
‘medivin 30 in the seleted region.
In yet another embodiment, the sacrificial conductor 68
say be made partly or eotirelyof lili. Lithium has a very
Jow molecular weight, and consequently a higher shock speed
and lower effective index of refraction than other metalic
vapors. Further it disperses into nearby air 26 more quickly,
‘hich ilps to heat the air more rapidly
nother embodiments, the are generator 16 may be config
ured to attenuate the advancing shockwave by magnetic
Jndvetion. As shown in FIG. 8A, the are penerator 16 may be
powered by the power supply 38 to ereate an electric are 72
that forms » conducting channel between two electrodes 74,
76 that are nt rigid, such as thin rod antennae. The conduct-
ing channel 72 interacts with ts own magnetic field to pro-
‘duce an outward force F=xB (where Fis the outward force,
‘isthe curent density and B isthe magnetic field lux).
‘When the shockwave 24 created by an explosion 22
reaches the are 72, a8 shown ia FIG, 8B, the shockwave
‘deforms the are in directions perpendicular tothe conductive
‘channels. Specifically, the shockwave 24 pushes the ionized
Bir created hy or making up the are 72 invand, an thectrent
tends to floss where the ait 26 is ionized. This movement hy
the shockwave 24 may’ do mechanical work against the mag
netic field force F and remove energy from the shockwave,
making it weaker. hough not show, the movement by the
shockwave 24 also may deform the electrodes 74, 76, whieh
also represents physical work that drwins energy from the
shockwave 24
Inthe embodiment shown ia FIGS. 88 and 8B, because the
‘electrdes 74, 76 may be relatively non-rigid, these parts and
the conductive channel 72 push against the ai 26 they are
«displacing. This may transform energy Feo the shockwave
25 nto kinctic energy of isplaced air. In some cases it may be
possible fr the conductive channels 72 nd electrodes 74, 76
to push the air so fast tt they may ereate new shockwaves
raving away from the protected region 20
Tina variation, the parts of the conductive channels 72 and
‘electrodes 74, 76 may no be rigid, but the channels ionized
tir pushed alcad of the magnetic Hx are disrupted (broken)
‘when they flow rapidly though the air 26, Bach time a chan-
rel 72 breaks, the electric current briefly stops. When it tops,
the (capped magnetic Mux erates an electromotive force
‘rong enough (ofonize anew channel trough the aie 26 and
then hea that air, This may transform energy fom the shoek-
wave 24 into ionization energy of ar tons and ino pressure-
volume-temperature energy of expanded hot air,
Tn the embodiment shown in FIGS. 9A snd 9B, the are
generator 16 may be configured to have rigid electrodes 78,
80 joined by a ear wall 82 to form three sides ofa box. An are
‘84 may be formed by the pawer supply 38 of the are generator
between electrodes 78,80. When the are 84 iscontacied by
the shockwave 24, the magnetic hx (represented by the
‘erossed circles 86) is deflected inward but movement i con
strand by the eloctrodes 78,80 and wall 82. Instead, the x
86 is compressed and increases the electric current in the
‘electrodes 78,80. In one embodiment, the power supply 161s,
‘configured so that this atonal electric cterent bypasses the
power supply and instead is directed to a resistive load 88.
Resistive load 8B also may take the fom oF aeapacitor, which
may receive a charge from the additional electric current.
“Tins, with the embodiments of FIGS, 8 and 9, magnetic
induction isusedto remove energy from the advancing shock-
wave hy the additonal mechanism of converting the shock
‘wave energy to mechanical energy or enverting the shock
ave enemy fo current
0
o
10
A system 10 may be comprised of multiple copies of each
‘embodiment. In an embodiment system 10 may include a
Single sensor 12 connected to and eontolliag molipl,
cree are generators 16, each mounted on the protected asset
18, In some applications, an embodiment may proce a
relatively nar, substantially Fines are of ho, ionized at
‘Moliple copies ofeach embodiment may be used increase
the frontal area as desired. Altematively, a single copy of an
embodiment may be used multiple times in rapid succession,
producing multiple arcs that collectively caver the desired
protected repion 20. Further, these embodiments may be
‘combined. For example, a system 10 may ulize ionizing
{rgoer pellets fo protect am asset 18 from explosions 22 re
tively faraway, and employ sacrificial conduetors to protect
the same asset from explosions at short range.
‘With each ofthe embodiments discussed, the system 10s
deployed to attenuate the energy of an advancing shockwave
24 forman explosion 22 by erestinga second lid medi 30
‘that difers from the fist fluid medium 26, which may be
ambient sir, positioned so that it interacts with thesbockwave,
As shown in FIG. 10, as the shockwave contacts the interface
‘90 betwen the fist uid medium 26 and the second nid
seium 30, the difference in refractive index reflects a fme-
tion of the incoming energy toward the explosion 22, as
indicated by areows A. This partial reflection occurs a second
time as the shockwave passes through the second fluid
‘medium 30 and contacts the interface 92 between the second
‘medium al the ambient 262 exits the second mest, All
gradients or discontinuities in the medium provide a reflec-
‘ion point forthe incoming shockwave 24, For example, ithe
second medium 30 is non-uniform, refiction will occur at
each of many places within the medium
"As shown i FIG. 11, shockwaves 24 obey Fermat's theory
ofleast ime and therefore an effective refractive index forthe
shockwavecan be defined tht is inversely proportional tothe
shock speed. The properties or composition of the second
‘medium 30 are chosen sch that he effective refractive index
‘of the socond medinm 30 differs from the first mest 26 in
at least one of temperature, molecilar weight and composi-
tion, AS the shockwave passes into or oUt of the sevond
redium 30, the diflersice in effective refactive index
reffacts the wave, as shovsn by lines B, diverting it and defo-
ccusing it away from the protected asset 18. In the disclosed
‘embodiments, the second medium 30 is ereated such that the
shockwave ravels faster in the second medium 30 than in the
first medium 26, so the refractive index of the second medinm
is Tess than that of the frst medium. Further, the second
‘medium is eeated to have a convex shape and therefore acts
as a divergent lens, so thatthe energy of the shockwave 24
spreads out, as shown by ines C80 it intensity drops as it
Approaches the protects asset 18,
Tnaddition, the second medium 30 may absorb some shock
‘energy asthe shock travels through it. Factors contributing to
the absorption of energy include energy retained in the mol-
ecules of the second medium itself e-2, enanced rotational
energy, excited molecular hands, excited electrons, molecu-
Jar decomposition, and ionization) and shock energy con-
verted to electromagnetic energy through blackbody emis
sion from hot particles or photon emission from de-exciting
various excited states.
‘A further mechanism for attenuating the energy density of
the shockwave 24 is momentum exchange. If the second
‘medium 30 is moving relative to the fist medium 26, then it
‘ill exchange momentum with the shockwave 24. The reslt
isa combination of reflection, slowing. and redirection ofthe
shockwave. Any of all of the foregoing mechanisms may
‘operate in # given embodiment, The composition, temperUS 8,981,261 BI
u
ture, speed and location of the second mediums 30 may be
‘chosen or created to create any one or all of the aforemen-
tioned mechanisns
‘While the method and forms of apparates disclosed herein
constitute preferred aspects of the disclosed shockwave
altenuation apparatus and method, other methods and forms
‘of apparatus may be employed without departing from the
scope ofthe invention
‘What is claimed is
1. A shockwave attenuation system, comprising
1 sensor for generating 4 detection signal based on atleast
‘one of detecting an explosion capable of producing &
shockwave traveling through a fist uid medium 0 3
protected region, and estimating location and time of
the explosion, and detecting an explosive device and
estimating a location and time of an explosion from the
‘explosive device that is capable of producing the shock=
wave traveling through the fist ud medium; and
‘an are generator ia communication with the sensor for
‘receiving the detection signal thorefrom,andin response
thereto heat a selected region ofthe first uid medium
rpidly to ereste a second, transient medium, different
fiom the frst medium, intesposed between the shocks
‘wave and the protected region such that the shockwave
‘contaets the second, transient medium and is attenuated
in energy density before it reaches a protected asset in
the protected region,
2, The system of claim 1, wherein the second mestum