Masdar-

AHP

18

ECFA

2007

2010

2010

2010

54.657
79-98

106.617
92-106

572.623
94-104

42.34
82-100

83.6
94-104

1.
21.1
92-98
2.
70.03

227.59
94-99

2009

42.34
82-100

923.06 1,735.42
991.38 2,201.22 3,911.41
843.79 5,854.32

1.51 1,360.28 2,246.29

1,056.32 8,505.92

18,350.70 1,065.14

18.10 1,111.00 1,132.32

5,205.36 4,062.66

10,688.83 1,714.57

4,822.37 5,577.99

25,298.95

4,359.81
434.40
509.53
259.07 2,460.01
2.18 2,553.40
906.06
5,136.95 6,866.21
0.00
18.77
472.32 1,085.15
19,400.00

92,898.00

1,159.67

413.13 1,000.35 1,045.79

1,156.63
859.52

1,322.82 3,520.66
1,592.31 7,868.91

95.32 2,580.58

1,742.01
851.78
2,257.47 1,579.98 2,702.05
57.17 1,420.55

189,562.82 64,233.20 25,471.42

189,562.82 64,233.20 25,471.42
0.00 1,555.97 13,803.03
189,562.82 65,789.16 39,274.45

2,658.48
7,104.00
6,698.11
3,608.08
9,562.24
19,415.84
2,261.41
9,268.02
12,403.40
10,400.36
25,298.95
4,794.21
3,228.60
3,461.64
12,003.16
1,576.24
19,400.00
92,898.00
1,159.67
2,459.27
2,016.15
4,843.48
9,461.22
2,675.90
2,593.79
6,539.50
1,477.72
279,267.44

279,267.44
15,359.00
294,626.44

2010

()
1996

2006

2010

17

2009(/KM2)
75,000 to 120,000
60,000 to 75,000
45,000 to 60,000
30,000 to 45,000
15,000 to 30,000
10,000 to 15,000
5,000 to 10,000
0 to 5,000

kilometers

1.
2.
3.
4.
5. 2017
6. 65
201010.7%206041.6%
2010

()
2017

20
18

18.0
16.6

16

14
12

7.6

6.5

10

6
4

2017

5.2

5.7

2
0
1990

2000

2010

2010

2020

2030

2040

2050

2060

 (84-97)

(%)
(0/00) (0/00) (/)
(0/00)

(%)
(0/00) (0/00) (/)
(0/00)

84

9.12

-2.23

6.89

3.36

3.23 425,591

9.46

2.75

12.21

3.67

3.62

325,294

85

8.54

-3.23

5.31

3.24

3.93 442,310

9.23

2.58

11.81

3.54

4.77

341,605

86

8.35

-6.59

1.76

3.17

2.50 453,379

9.23

6.4

15.63

4.05

356,011

87

5.95

12.11

18.06

3.11

3.72 470,257

6.35

-6.42

-0.07

3.45
3.37

2.11

363,680

88

6.22

2.77

8.99

3.04

3.14 485,011

6.68

-4.01

2.67

3.31

2.07

371,349

89

7.22

2.93

10.15

3.00

2.58 497,546

7.91

-4.38

3.53

3.27

1.61

377,440

90

4.91

-2.30

2.61

2.95

1.83 506,632

5.06

-3.23

1.83

3.24

1.28

382,320

91

4.04

5.98

10.02

2.91

2.53 519,444

4.67

-7.55

-2.88

3.19

1.08

386,510

92

3.33

-3.43

-0.10

2.86

1.56 527,560

3.61

-0.31

3.30

3.15

1.70

393,196

93

2.65

-0.45

2.2

2.81

1.86 537,377

2.88

-1.71

1.17

3.11

1.37

398,676

94

2.23

-3.57

-1.34

2.78

1.21 543,892

2.44

0.71

3.15

3.07

1.62

405,229

95

2.00

0.68

2.68

2.75

1.31 551,009

2.42

-0.30

2.12

3.03

1.32

410,631

96

2.08

1.78

3.85

2.71

1.80 560,921

2.04

-2.97

-0.93

3.00

1.05

414,985

97

1.64

1.70

3.34

2.67

1.83 571,166

1.74

-2.46

-0.72

2.96

1.32

420,551

4.55

0.41

4.96

2.76

2.2 472,806

5.27

-1.49

3.77

3.24

2.07

381,963


35,000
30,000
25,000
20,000
15,000
10,000
5,000
0
71 72 73 74 75 76 77 78 79 80 81 82 83 84 85 86 87 88 89 90 91 92 93 94 95 96 97

6,000
5,000
4,000
3,000
2,000
1,000
0
71 72 73 74 75 76 77 78 79 80 81 82 83 84 85 86 87 88 89 90 91 92 93 94 95 96 97


2010


20,000
18,000
16,000
14,000
12,000
10,000
8,000
6,000
4,000
2,000
-

91

92

93

94

95

()
1,500.00
1,000.00
500.00
0.00

2009

2008

2007

2006

2005

2004

2003

2002

2001

2000

1999

1998

96

98

1,672 1,053
26

166 67%
31 -

954 639.18
56

56

2,891
56.31

695.18

684

601

109 68%

446 303.28

146 -

146

97

146

1,394
146

449.28
2,382 1,653

1,602 1,144

4,487

(A)

35.70%

(B)

25.51%

(C)

17.65%

90-99()

90
91
92
93
94
95
96
97
98
99Q2

41
36
43
56
75
81
67
51
37
27
515

19
22
20
33
34
54
44
40
25
11
301

Statistics
Mean
Std.
Deviation
Range
Minimum
Maximum
Sum

51.54
30.13
18.10

13

54
27
81
515

42
11
54
301

52
30
1602

3153
8220

90-99

90 275,065 506,207 364,955 252,941 189,724 414,495

91 276,023 361,580 263,351 266,201 217,971 361,171
92 264,268 337,991 322,679 199,783 201,520 425,672
93 241,125 368,613 359,016 429,187 326,245 555,429
94 276,954 440,662 396,821 317,707 338,602 752,573
95 237,997 527,344 393,466 325,808 538,293 814,172
96 258,744 605,384 337,191 371,697 435,253 674,684
97 296,097 600,003 279,631 242,345 397,068 514,878
98 298,233 590,400 250,397 130,191 254,537 366,751
99q1-6

98,595

174,997

82,344

100,530

113,505

274,177

90-99

5,000,000
4,500,000

4,000,000

3,500,000

3,000,000

2,500,000

2,000,000

1,500,000

1,000,000

500,000
0
90

91

92

2010

93

94

95

96

97

98

99q1-6

90-99

&V
V
&

&
V
W

&
V

&V
V
&&
&
V
&V V
&
&V
V
&V

&V
V
& &
&V
V
& V

&
&
V
&V
V
&
V
&
V

&
V

&
V
&V
V
&
&
V

&
V
&
V

&
&V
V

1.

2.

3.

V
&V
&V
& V
&
&V
V
&V
&
V
&
&V
V
&V
V
&
&V
&
&
V
&
&V
V
V
&V
&V
V
&
&
V
&
&
V
V
&
&
V
&V
V
&
V
&
&V
V
&&
V
&V
V
&V
V
&
&
&
&
V
&V
V
&V
&
&V
V
&
V
&
&V
V
&V
&V
V
&
V
&
V
&V
&
V
&
V
&
&
V
&
V
&
V
&
V
& V
V
&V
V
&
& V
&
V
&V
&
&
V
& V
V
& V
&V
V
&
V
&&
V
&
&V
&
VV
&V
V
&
&
V
& V
&V
V
V
&V
&
&
&V
V
&
&
V
V
&
V
& V
&V
&
V
&
& V
&V
&
V
&V
V
&&
V
&
V
&
&
V
&
V
&
&V
V
& V
V
&V
V
&
&V
&V
V
&V
V
& V
V
&
V
&
&
V
&V
&
&
V
&&
V
&
V
&V
V
&V
V
&
&
V
V
&
V
&
V
&
&
V
&
&
V
&V
V
V
&V
&
& V
&
V
& V
V
&V
&
&
V
V
& V
&V
&V
&
&
&V
&
V
&V
&V
&V
&V
V
V
&V
& V
&V
&
&
&V
&V
&& V
&
V
&
V
&& V
V
&
V
& V
V
&
V
& V
&V
&& V
&V
V
&
V
V
&
& V
V
& V
V
&
&
&
&V
&V
&
V
V
&
&V
&V
V
&V
&
&V
&
&
V
&V
V
& V
V
&
V
&
V
&V
&V
&
&V
&V
&
&
V
V
V
&&
&
&
&
V
V
&
V
& V
&V
V
V
&V
V
& V
&
V
&
&
V
& V
&V
V
&
V
V
&
&V
&V
V
V
&V
&
&
V
&
&
V
V
&
&
&V
V
&V
V
&
&
&V
V
&
&
V
V
&
&
V
&
V
&
V
&
V
&
V
&
V
&
&V
V
&V
& V
&
&V
&
& V
& V
&V
V
&V
&V
V
&V
&
&V
&V
&V
&
V
& V
V
&V
V
& V
&
V
&
&V
V
&
V
&
&
V
&
V
&
V
&
V
V
&
&
&
V
V
&
V
&
V
&
V
&
V
&
V
&V
V
&
V
&
&
V
&V
V
&
V
&
&
& V
V
&
&V
V
&V
&
V
&
V
&
V
&
V
&
V
&
V
V
&
&V
V
&
V
&
V
&
& V
V
&
V
&
&
V
V
&
&
V
&
&
V
V
&
&V
V
& V
&V
V
&
V
&
V
& V
&
V
&
&
V
&
V
&
V
&
V
V
&
V
&
&
V
&
& V
V
&
V
&
& V
V
&
V
&
V
&
V
&
V
&
V
&
V
&
V
&
V
&V
&
V
&
& V
V
&V
V
&
&
V
&
V
&
V
&
&
V
&V
V
&V
V
&
&
V
&
&
V
&
&V
V
V
&V
&
V
&
&
V
&
V
&V
V
&V
V
V
& V
&
&
&
V
%
U
&
V
&
V
V
&
&V
V
&
&
V
&
V
&
&V
& V
V
&
V
&V
&V
V
&

&
V

&
V

&
V
&
V

V
&
&
V
&
V

&
V
&
V

&
V

%
U

&
V

&
V

&
V

500 0 500100015002000 Meters

E
S

&
V
&V
V
&
&
V

&
V
&
V

& V
V
& &
V
&
V
&
V
&
V

V
&V
&

&
V

&V
V
&&
&
V
&V V
&
&V
&V
V

&V
V
& &
V
&V
& V

&
&
V
V
&V
&
V
V
&

&
V

&
V

&
V
&V

1.

2.

3.

4.

V
&V
&V
& V
&
&V
&
V
V
&V
&
V
&V
V
&V
&
V
&V
&
&
V
&V
V
&V
V
&
V
&
&
&&V
&
V
V
&
&
V
&V
V
V
&
&
&
V
&
V
&V
V
V
&V
&V
&
&
&
&
V
&V
&V
V
&
&V
V
&
V
&
&V
V
&V
&V
V
&
V
&V
V
&
V
&
&V
V
&
&
V
&
V
&
V
V
& V
&V
V
&
&& V
&
V
&V
&
&
V
& V
V
& &
V
&V
V
&
&&
V
&V
&V
V
&V
V
&
V
&
& V
&V
V
V
&V
&
&
&V
V
&
V
&
&
V
& V
&V
V
V
&
&
& V
&V
V
&
&V
V
&&
V
&
V
&
&
V
V
&
&
&V
V
V
& V
V
&V
&
&V
&V
V
&V
V
V
& V
&
&
V
&
&V
V
&
&
V
&&
V
&
V
&V
V
&V
V
&
V
&
V
V
&
&
V
&
V
&
&
&
V
&V
V
&V
&
V
&
& V
V
V
& V
&V
V
&
V
&
& V
&V
&V
&
&
&V
V
&
&V
&V
&V
&V
V
V
&V
& V
&V
&
&
&V
&V
&& V
V
&
&
V
&& V
V
V
&
& V
V
&
V
& V
V
&V
&& V
&V
V
&
V
&
V
& V
V
&
&
&
& V
V
&V
V
&
V
&
&V
V
&V
V
&V
&
&V
&
&
V
&V
V
& V
V
&
V
&
V
&V
&V
&
&V
&
&V
V
&
V
&&
V
&
&
V
&
V
&
V
& V
&V
V
V
V
&V
& V
&
V
&
&
V
& V
&V
V
&
V
&
V
&V
&V
V
&V
V
&
V
&
&
&
V
&
V
&
&V
V
&V
&
V
&
V
&V
&
V
&
V
&
&
V
&
V
&
V
V
&
&
V
&
V
&
&V
&V
V
& V
&
&V
&
& V
& V
&V
V
&V
&V
V
&V
&
&V
&V
&V
&
V
& V
V
&V
V
& V
V
&
&
&V
V
&
V
&
&
V
&
V
&
V
&
V
V
&
&
&
V
V
&
V
&
V
&
V
&
V
&
V
&V
V
&
V
&
&
V
&V
V
&
&
V
&
& V
V
&
&V
V
&V
&
V
&
V
&
V
V
&
&
V
&
V
&
V
V
&V
&
V
&
&
V
& V
V
&
&
V
&
V
&
V
&
V
&
V
&
&
V
&V
V
& V
V
&V
&
V
&
& V
V
&
V
&
&
V
&
V
&
V
V
&
&
V
&
V
&
V
&
& V
V
&
V
&
& V
V
&
V
&
V
&
V
V
&
&
V
&
V
&
V
&
&V
V
&
V
&
& V
V
V
&V
&
V
&
&
V
V
&
&
&
V
&V
V
&V
V
&
&
V
&
V
&
&
V
&V
&V
V
V
&
&
&
V
&
V
&V
V
&V
V
& V
&
V
&
&
V
&
V
&
V
V
&
&
V
&V
V
&
&
V
&
V
&
&V
& V
V

80
V
&
80 - 81
&
V
81 - 82
&
V
82 - 83
V
&
83 - 84
&
V
84 - 85
&
V
85 - 86
&
V
86 - 87
&
V
87 - 88
&
V
88 - 89
&
V
89 - 90
&
V
90 - 91
V
&
91 - 92
&
V
92 - 93
&
V
93 - 94
&
V
94 - 95
&
V
95 - 96
&
V
96 - 97
&
V
97 - 98
&
V

&
V
&V
&V
V
&

&
V

&
V

V
&
&
V

&
V
&
V
V
&

&
V
&
V
&
V
&V
V
&
&
V

&
V
&
V

500 0 500100015002000 Meters

E
S

&V
V
&V
&
&
V
&
V

&
V

& V
V
& &
V
&
V
&
V
&
V


20002009

2010


20002009

2010

2010

2009
2008
5yr

1,527,914 1,242,973 2,770,887

571,166
420,551
991,717
2.74
2.76

3.03
3.24

2.89
3.00

5yr

2.15

0.96

1.56

15yr

4.96

3.77

4.37

A15yr

1,002

394

1,396

A215yr

2,746
7,697
7.68
2.80

1,446
1,951
4.95
1.35

4,192
9,648
6.32
2.08

15yr

B
C1=B/A5yr
C2=B/A 15yr

2008,2009
2010P.34
2010

1,672
26
684
0
2,382

1,053
0
601
0
1,653

166 67%
31 109 68%
146 -

(A)
(B)
(C)
(D)
(E)153.0/

954 639.18
56
56
446 303.28
146
146
1,602 1,144

2,891
56.31
1,394
146
4,487

35.70%
25.51%
17.65%
653,977
217,992

1,14450%
240%80035
3/ 653,977217,993

2,947

1,540

4,487

10yr

695

449

1,144

A15yr

139

90

229

A210yr

70

45

114

A315yr

46

30

76

A420yr

35

22

57

B10yr

30

52

82

C1=A1/B 5yr

4.61

1.74

2.80

C2=A2/B 10yr

2.31

0.87

1.40

C3=A3/B 15yr

1.54

0.58

0.93

C4=A4/B 20yr

1.15

0.44

0.70

1202

2010

2009

14,473

255.6

14,729

12,599

9,884

171

10,055

10,457

68%

67%

68%

83%

953

307

1,260

18,899

10,837

478

11,315

29,356

(A1)5yr

2,167

96

2,263

5,871

(A2)10yr

1,084

48

1,131

2,936

(A3)15yr

722

32

754

1,957

(A4)20yr

542

24

566

1,468

B10yr

177

138

315

282

C=A/B

61.23

3.47

35.94

104.04

C1=A/B 5yr

12.25

0.69

7.19

20.81

C2=A/B 10yr

6.12

0.35

3.59

10.40

C3=A/B 15yr

4.08

0.23

2.40

6.94

C4=A/B 20yr

3.06

0.17

1.80

5.20

(A)

1200%1.22
200962%31.54
TOD5

1998~ 2008
2009

N
W

N
E

-
-
-0.86 - -0.58
-0.58 - -0.38
-0.38 - -0.28
-0.28 - -0.19
-0.19 - -0.09
-0.09 - 0.03
0.03 - 0.15
0.15 - 0.27
0.27 - 0.39
0.39 - 0.51
0.51 - 0.79
0.5 0 0.5 1 1.5 Kilometers

E
S

-
-
-22.99 - -11.6
-11.6 - -4.81
-4.81 - -2.36
-2.36 - -1.1
-1.1 - -0.15
-0.15 - 0.82
0.82 - 1.88
1.88 - 3.07
3.07 - 4.53
4.53 - 6.53
6.53 - 9.83
0.5 0 0.5 1 1.5 Kilometers

AHP


1 90.3
TOD
compact city
2
1
2

3
4
3
4

AHP
1

AHP
1
2

3
4
5

0.394

0.346

0.26

0.308
0.262
0.197
0.129
0.106
0.246
0.168
0.165
0.165
0.129
0.127
0.289
0.275
0.186
0.163
0.088

12

2010

10

201
2010

2246
2010

5
3

2010

2010

10

25

375

2010

R8

R21 &
&
R20 &
R19 &

400-600
0-400

&

&

&

()

R18 &

R17 &

R16 &

&

R15 &

TOD
&

R14 &

R13 &
&
R12 &
&
R11
&
&

O5R10
R8

E
S

&

O5R10 &
O4 &

O1 &

O2 &

O6&

&

&

O8 &

O7

O9 &
O10 &

R9 &

R8 &

R7 &

R6 &

R5 &

R4A &

R4 &
R3 &

2010

0#

0#

0#

0#

A.

0#

0#

\&
\&

0#

B.
8" 8" 8"0# 8" 8" C.
8"
\& 8"
8"
8"
0#

R13

8"
\&
8"

\&

8"
0#

8"
0#

0#

8"

\0#&
0#

8"
8"
\&
\&
0# 0# 8" 8" 0#

0#

8" 8"
8"
0#
8"
8" 0#
8"
D.
8"

8"

8"
8"

C
0#

0#

8"
8"
0#8"

8"
0#
0#
0#
0#

2010

1
30

2
2

1.5

30

60


1
2
3
4

TOD

1
2

1
2


1:
2:
3:
4:
5:
6:
7:

8:

9:

10:
11:

12:O11

13:
14:-

15:

15

13

10

14

12

11

88

3.5

kilometers

2
3
4
5
6
1
2

TOD
1

2 122

4
5 O5/R10
6

3
4

Public Facilities Requirements

Revenue Sources

(Requlation tool of land use)

Land Acquisition


1
2
3

4
5

2 TOD

1 ()

1 70

1 O11

10

11

()

319.89

1,741.26

443.26

34.71

8.01 11

732.79 ()

17.29

3.04
2,246.00

96.17

1 R8

0.91

5.24

12

1.47

13

47.21

14

1 R5

15

2.4

16

2.38

17

3.02

18

19

1 O5R10

500

1,300.00

20.3

20

()

13.79
63.05

21

22

1,000.00

23

2,246.00

24

2,246.00 --(96

25

183.88

26

2 ,

119.21

27

28

29

6.78
24.47

106.73

30

3 2

9.11

31

3 3

5.52

32

3 5

13.93

33

3 6

2.4

34

3 8

19.92

35

3 4

10.43

36

3 7

9.95

37

20.45

38

3 11

9.14

39

10.31

12

()

40

3 14

9.33

41

3 1

9.25

42

3 15

10.33

43

3 16

14.29

44

3.2

45

3 17

6.2

46

3 10

57.53

47

3 13

23.65

48

49

3 _20

50

51

52

3 1

53

3 1

54

3 2

55

3 (26.20)

56

32.8

57

4.46

58

0.8

59

1.22

60

7.3

61

10.86

62

3 205

58.15 58.15

17

0.91 90.1.
15.24 40
2.83

374.43

10.77

1.1
116.23
10.94

()

63

3 _21

16.68

64

3 _1-22

75.91

65

3.12

66

0.26

67

1.56

68

57.79

69

106.59

70

6.8

71

0.53

72

73

74

75

11.15 e

0.96 e

48.26 6869

209.7

76

84.65

77

46.86

78

4.85

41

79

15.16

41

80

2.86

41

81

11.87

40

82

3.38

40

83

84

8.06 66

85

2.19 66

146.58

()

86

1.29 392

87

1.54 276.393

88

2.12

89

24.81

90

22.04

91

0.46 66

92

11.34

93

132.21

94

3.03

95

20.2

96

4 ()

0.47

97

4 ()

26.017

98

0.54

99

1.48

100

0.31

101

102

6.06

103

42.37

104

22.79

105

11.04

106

11.25

107

1.38

108

1.36

109

1.76

110

111

2.69

112

1.78

58.48

35.64

()
175.81

113

114

0.81

115

4 ()

75.1

116

4 ()

117

118

119

120

121

122

123

124

28.89

152.75

10
97.81

0.5

4.57

610.32

11.31

4 1

0.83

125

4 2

126

4 4

0.59

127

2.68

128

1.68 418 67

129

4 ()1

3.64

68

130

4 ()2

23.16

68

131

4 ()3

13.08

68

132

4 3

10.03

60

133

134

1.31 276357

135

0.67 48

136

4 ()4

7.92 . 69

137

4 ()v5

0.06 68

138

139

140

42

2.4 38

25 [

1 -

1213 [

2000 [

19,721.39