The Marshall Project

One Way To Deal With Cops Who Lie? Blacklist Them, Some DAs Say

Newly elected prosecutors won’t take cases from unreliable officers—but are these "no call" lists fair?

In the racially divided city of St. Louis the chief prosecutor has embraced a controversial tool to hold police accountable: blacklisting cops who she says are too untrustworthy to testify in court.

So far, Kim Gardner has dropped more than 100 cases that relied on statements from the 29 officers who got on the list for alleged lying, abuse or corruption. And she won’t accept new cases or search-warrant requests from them, either.

From to Houston to Seattle, district attorneys recently elected on platforms of criminal justice reform are building similar databases of their own. Often known as “do not call” lists, they are also called “exclusion lists” or

You’re reading a preview, subscribe to read more.

More from The Marshall Project

The Marshall Project8 min readPsychology
When Going To The Hospital Is Just As Bad As Jail
A new lawsuit claims Black Americans with mental illness are being forced into traumatic emergency room stays.
The Marshall Project7 min readMedical
Lax Masking, Short Quarantines, Ignored Symptoms: Inside a Prison Coronavirus Outbreak in ‘Disbeliever Country.’
The latest COVID-19 surge is happening behind bars, too. Here’s three accounts from an upstate New York prison hit by the pandemic.
The Marshall Project4 min readCrime & Violence
I Wasn’t a Superpredator. I Was a Kid Who Made a Terrible Decision.
At age 14, Derrick Hardaway took part in the murder of an 11-year-old. The media used the crime to build the myth of the superpredator—and stuck him with a label he struggles to shed.

Related Books & Audiobooks