Professional Documents
Culture Documents
- --
-- -- - ---
--
object (OR) the objector continues - tasya vikritvaaviee=while its(the selfs) change is no different (than others)
Page 1
http://www.advaitin.net/PranipataChaitanya/AdvaitaMakarandaverse15.pdf
( tath) tmana api=similarly the Self also - sva-bhva-vieea=owing to its special character/nature --
sva-itara-vikraanusandhna=rememberance(knowing) its own and others changes
upapatte=is proper only na ca= also it is not valid that (OR)
the objector continues tena tena vikrea
vikrai=than the changes atyanta abhedasya=total nondifference anagkrt=is not stressed kim
na ca svajanma na v draumarhati kacana |
tau hi prguttarbhvacaramaprathamakaau ||15||
Page 2
http://www.advaitin.net/PranipataChaitanya/AdvaitaMakarandaverse15.pdf
---- prk-uttara-abhva-carama-prathamakaau=the last moment of prior non-existence and the first moment of
posterior non-existence (respectively).
And no one can ever see ones own birth or death. The birth is the
final moment of prior non-existence (earlier absence) and the death
is the first moment of posterior non-existence (the later absence),
respectively.
- -
--
- -- -- -
--- -- ----
- ---
--
- ----- -
-- -- --- - ---
---- -
---
--
- -na ca iti | kacana kacit nipua api sva-janma sva-utpatti nam
dhvasam v draum jtum na arhati na aknoti iti artha | tatra
hetum ha -- tau hi itydin hi yasmt tau janma-nau prg-uttaraabhva carama-prathama-kaau prg-uttarau yau abhvau prgabhva-pradhvasa-abhvau tayo yau carama-prathama-kaau tau
prg-uttara-abhva-carama-prathama-kaau prg-abhva-caramakaa utpatti vastuna pradhvasa abhva-prathama-kaau na
iti artha | yasmt janma-nau prg-uttara-abhva-carama-prathamakaau tasmt sva-janma nam v draum na arhati iti sambandha |
idam atra ktam -- tm hi sva-samna-klika-vasti eva jnti iti
Advaita Makaranda with Rasa-abhivyanjika
Page 3
http://www.advaitin.net/PranipataChaitanya/AdvaitaMakarandaverse15.pdf
however expert he can be - sva-janma = - sva-utpatti his own birth () nam (v) = dhvasam v or his
meaning(proven fact)
-- tatra hetum ha -tau hi itydin= in this regard the author presents the reasoning starting
with the words tau hi. hi = yasmt-since being so tau =
- janma-nau those two birth and death --
-- prg-uttara-abhva carama-prathama-kaau { -
Page 4
http://www.advaitin.net/PranipataChaitanya/AdvaitaMakarandaverse15.pdf
death ----- prg-uttara-abhva-caramaprathama-kaau = the last moment of prior absence and first moment
of posterior absence tasmt= therefore -
sva-janma nam v draum na arhati iti
sambandha = it cannot know its own birth and death is the connection.
idam atra ktam = the meaning conveyed is this
--- tm hi sva-samnaklika-avasti eva jnti iti vaktavyam=the Self can be said to know the
happenings during its time of presence only (since Self is subject to
changes including birth and death by the opponent) --- dpa iva sva-samna-klika-padrthaavabhsaka= like the lamp illumining objections while it is glowing
tath ca= while being so - avasthnasamaye avidyamnayo= of those two which cannot be known during its
presence --- prg-abhva-pradhvasaabhvayo= namely of prior absence and posterior absence
katham=how ---- - prg-abhva-caramakaa-rpam sva-janma=ones own birth in the form of last moment of
prior non-existence --- pradhvasa
abhva-prathama-kaa-rpam nam ca=and also ones own death in
the form of first moment of posterior non-existence jniyt= can
the Self know? na kathacid api iti artha=
Page 5
http://www.advaitin.net/PranipataChaitanya/AdvaitaMakarandaverse15.pdf
dehendriyamanaprhaktibhyo vilakaa |
projjhiteaabhvavikrastvapadbhidha ||iti||
Totally distinct from the body; senses, mind, pra and ego is that which
is the Self, therefore, it is absolutely free from the six-modifications,
which material things must necessarily undergo. This Self is the
indicative meaning of the term thou.
tata ca tm nirvikratvd
brahma eva iti artha = therefore owing to this reason also that the
Self/Atman is free from changes it ought to be Brahman only. This is the
conclusion.
Page 6