Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Jailed because of a cough! As the foreman of the jury got to his feet to deliver his verdict at the climax of the two-day trial, the traditional tense silence descended on the court. For the defendant Alan Rashid, it was the moment of truth. Unfortunately for him it was also the moment when a member of the jury couldnt control the tickle in the back of his throat any longer. He suddenly coughed just at the moment when the foreman declared Mr Rashid not guilty. Because of the cough nobody heard the word not so in an instant an innocent man was turned into a convicted criminal! As 32-year-old Mr Rashid, who is unemployed, stood devastated in the dock and with the puzzled jury wondering what on earth was going on Judge Michael Gibbon jailed him for two years on a charge of making a threat to kill. Mr Rashids lawyer tried to console him as he was taken to the court cells to wait for the van to take him to prison. Judge Gibbon then thanked the jurors at Cardiff Crown Court for their efforts during the trial and let them go. But as they walked out of court a puzzled member of the jury asked a court official why Mr Rashid had been sentenced for two years after being found not guilty. The official immediately realized there had been a mistake and called everyone back to court. Mr Rashid was taken back into the dock and Judge Gibbon told him he was free to go. Mr Rashids lawyer said afterwards, He was totally confused. One moment he was facing two years in prison and the next he was going home on the bus.
Article 2
Jurors cough clears throat but jails innocent man A man found not guilty by a jury was jailed by mistake because somebody coughed as the foreman delivered the verdict. Judge Michael Gibbon sentenced Alan Rashid to two years imprisonment believing he had been found guilty of making a threat to kill. But the ill-timed cough drowned out the vital word not, leaving the court and defendant convinced that he had been convicted. Judge Gibbon, 68, told Rashid, The maximum sentence for making a threat to kill is ten years. Taking everything into consideration, the least sentence I can give you is two years imprisonment. Mr Rashid, 32, of Llanrumney, Cardiff, was led to the cells at Cardiff Crown Court and the judge discharged the jury. But as Mr Rashid waited for a van to take him to jail, a mystified juror asked a court usher why a man they had acquitted was being imprisoned. The court was hastily reconvened and Mr Rashid was freed. Nicholas Williamson, the court manager, said, It was very bizarre. The jury foreman indicated a guilty verdict and the court proceeded to sentence the defendant. One of the jurors was puzzled why he was jailed after being found not guilty, and the judge was informed. Mr Rashid was a very relieved man when the judge explained what had happened. Jurors had not spoken up earlier during the hearing on Wednesday because they believed that Mr Rashid had been convicted of other offences. Glossary foreman leader of a jury or a group of workers convict say sb is guilty the dock the place in a court where the accused person sits or stands
cell small room, e.g. in a prison defendant person who is accused of sth in a court of law acquit say sb is not guilty
three days away from home. The man had started to live his lie when he failed the second year of medical college and didnt want to disappoint his parents. This case is exceptional but gives further proof that it is very difficult for most people to spot a liar. Adapted from the New York Times