Professional Documents
Culture Documents
This chart highlights the variance between different sources reporting the death toll numbers for the belligerent nations during World War I. Different sources cite differing figures. The scale on the left of each chart gives the number of casualties, the colored dots represent different sources of information, while the dotted lines give percentage differences between some of the largest inconsistencies.
France
18 16.3 Eckhardt 20% Britannica, Brzezinski, Davies, Encarta, Gilbert, Hammond, S&S, Wallechinsky Urlanis
Belgium
120
Bulgaria
Germany
2.5 2.4 1.2 Eckhardt 214% 1.15
Greece
1,000 Urlanis 950 Eckhardt 26
Italy
Eckhardt 27% Britannica, Brzezinski, Davies, Encarta, Gilbert, Hammond, S&S, Wallechinsky E&C
Casualties (in thousands)
2.3
Eckhardt
88
Eckhardt
91% Higher
95 90
Paschall Hammond
E&C, Paschall
420%
76
Britannica, Brzezinski, Davies, Encarta, Gilbert, Hammond, Paschall, S&S, Wallechinsky Urlanis E&C 20% Higher
542%
214%
38
462 460
Paschall
Urlanis 177%
28
Britannica, Compton's, Davies, Hammond,Tucker
Eckhardt
28
5 Britannica, Brzezinski, Davies, E&C, Eckhardt, Encarta, Gilbert, Hammond, S&S, Wallechinsky 0
13.7 14
S&S
Japan
400 Britannica, Brzezinski, Compton's, Davies, E&C, Eckhardt, Encarta, Gilbert, Hammond, Paschall, S&S, Tucker, Urlanis,Wallechinsky Casualties (in thousands) 4
Montenegro
14
Britannica, Brzezinski, Compton's, Davies, E&C, Eckhardt, Encarta, Gilbert, Hammond, Paschall, S&S, Tucker, Urlanis,Wallechinsky
Portugal
400 Eckhardt 375 340 335 13
Romania
3.2
Eckhardt Paschall Britannica, Brzezinski, Compton's, Davies, E&C, Eckhardt, Encarta, Gilbert, Hammond, Paschall, S&S, Tucker, Urlanis,Wallechinsky E&C 36%
Russia
300 Eckhardt 278 Urlanis 2.95
Serbia
900 804 Urlanis
Turkey
130 126 116
United States
Eckhardt Paschall
74%
Casualties
7.2 7
Urlanis
128
Eckhardt, E&C
518%
220
1.8 1.7
Urlanis, E&C
450
Eckhardt
250
Urlanis
189%
Paschall
Compton's
E&C
300
80%
E&C
70 45
0 0
48
Designed by Neil Anderson, 2008 Sources: White (2008), Encyclopaedia Britannica (1992), Brzezinski (1993), Comptons (1997), Davies (1998), Eckhardt/Sivard (1987), Ellis & Cox (2001), Encarta (1995), Gilbert (1997), Hammond (1996), Paschall, Small & Singer (1982), Tucker (1999), Urlanis (1971), Wallechinsky (1995)
Notes: Eckhardt in some cases mixes civilian death tolls with military death tolls. Which cases? Nobody knows for sure. Urlanis is the only Russian Soviet author in my list of sources (Brzezinski was Polish). The majority of the sources listed here are British of various descent (Davies, Gilbert, Ellis & Cox, et.al.).
39%
Urlanis
46%
102
E&C
16%