Appellate Docket

Source: SUPREME COURT, CALIFORNIA

CASE INFORMATION

Case Title: BARSAMYAN v. APPELLATE DIVISION (PEOPLE)

Court: SUPREME COURT
Case Number: S148712
Case Type: APPEALS
Case Subtype: REVIEW - CRIMINAL ORIGINAL (NON-H.C.)
Key Nature of Suit: CRIMINAL; APPEAL (150.05)
Date Filed: 12/11/2006
Case Status: FULLY BRIEFED
Related/Companion Cases: COURT OF APPEAL CASE: SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT, DIV. 7
B188695; TRIAL COURT CASE: LOS ANGELES COUNTY SUPERIOR
COURT - MAIN (COUNTY COURTHOUSE) BS099858 LOS ANGELES
COUNTY SUPERIOR COURT - MAIN (COUNTY COURTHOUSE)
BS099858 LOS ANGELES COUNTY SUPERIOR COURT - MAIN
(COUNTY COURTHOUSE) 5WL01545

LOWER COURT INFORMATION

Court of Appeal District/Division: SECOND APPELLATE DISTRICT, DIV. 7

Court of Appeals Docket Number:
Court of Appeals Disposition
Information:
Miscellaneous Information:
B188695
PETITION DENIED AFTER ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE ISSUED;
11/01/2006
TRIAL COURT: LOS ANGELES COUNTY SUPERIOR COURT - MAIN
(COUNTY COURTHOUSE); TRIAL COURT CASE NUMBER: BS099858,
TRIAL COURT: LOS ANGELES COUNTY SUPERIOR COURT - MAIN
(COUNTY COURTHOUSE); TRIAL COURT CASE NUMBER: BS099858,
TRIAL COURT: LOS ANGELES COUNTY SUPERIOR COURT - MAIN
(COUNTY COURTHOUSE); TRIAL COURT CASE NUMBER: 5WL01545

PARTICIPANT INFORMATION

Name: BARSAMYAN, VARDUI ROSE

Type: PETITIONER
Attorney: JOHN HAMILTON SCOTT
Attorney Address: 320 W. TEMPLE STREET, ROOM 590
LOS ANGELES, CA
Firm Name: OFFICE OF THE PUBLIC DEFENDER

Name: APPELLATE DIVISION OF THE SUPERIOR COURT, LOS ANGELES

COUNTY
HON.
Type: RESPONDENT
Address: 111 NORTH HILL STREET
LOS ANGELES, CA 90012
Attorney: MARVIN M. LAGER
Attorney Address: 111 N HILL ST #412 DEPT 38
LOS ANGELES, CA
Firm Name: JUDGE, SUPERIOR COURT-LOS ANGELES
Attorney: MARK TODD ZUCKMAN
Attorney Address: 11701 SOUTH CIENEGA BLVD.
LOS ANGELES, CA
Firm Name: L A SUPERIOR COURT - AIRPORT COURTHOUSE, DEPT. 141

Name: THE PEOPLE

Type: REAL PARTY IN INTEREST
Attorney: KATHARINE H. MACKENZIE

Attorney Address: 200 N MAIN STREET, 5TH FLOOR

LOS ANGELES, CA
Firm Name: OFFICE OF THE CITY ATTORNEY

Name: LOS ANGELES COUNTY DISTRICT ATTORNEY

Type: AMICUS CURIAE
Attorney: LAEL RONNA RUBIN
Attorney Address: 210 W. TEMPLE STREET, 18TH FLOOR
LOS ANGELES, CA
Firm Name: ATTORNEY AT LAW
Attorney: PHYLLIS CHIEMI ASAYAMA
Attorney Address: 320 W. TEMPLE STREET, SUITE 540
LOS ANGELES, CA
Firm Name: LOS ANGELES COUNTY DISTRICT ATTORNEY'S OFFICE
Attorney: TRACEY WHITNEY LOPEZ
Attorney Address: 320 WEST TEMPLE STREET, SUITE 540
LOS ANGELES, CA
Firm Name: OFFICE OF THE DISTRICT ATTORNEY

2
DOCKET PROCEEDINGS

Date: Entry #: Description: Date Docketed: Party:

01/04/2008 Docket Entry: FILED LETTER FROM: Document

Description: RPI THE PEOPLE ATTORNEY
KATHARINE H. MACKENZIE, DATED 1-4-08
RESPONSE TO PETITIONER'S LETTER BRIEF
DATED: 12-17-07

12/18/2007 Docket Entry: FILED LETTER FROM: Document

Description: PETITIONER VARDUI ROSE
BARSAMYAN DEPUTY PUBLIC DEFENDER
JOHN HAMILTON SCOTT SUBSEQUENT TO
THE FILING OF PETITIONER'S ANSWER TO
THE AMICUS BRIEF ON BEHALF OF THE L.A.
COUNTY P.D. LETTER DATED DEC., 17, 2007.

11/13/2007 Docket Entry: RESPONSE TO AMICUS CURIAE

BRIEF FILED Document Description:
PETITIONER VARDUI ROSE BRSAMYAN'S
RESPONSE TO AMICUS BRIEF OF THE LOS
ANGELES COUNTY DISTRICT ATTORNEY BY
JOHN HAMILTON SCOTT, DEPUTY PUBLIC
DEFENDER)

11/13/2007 Docket Entry: APPLICATION FILED Document

Description: FROM PETITIONER BARSAMYAN
TO EXCEED THE WORD LIMIT RE: A.C.
RESPONSE.

11/13/2007 Docket Entry: RECEIVED: Document

Description: FROM PETITIONER BARSAMYAN
RESPONSE TO A.C. BRIEF OF DISTRICT
ATTORNEY [EXCEEDS WORD LIMIT]

10/22/2007 Docket Entry: AMICUS CURIAE BRIEF FILED

Document Description: RIVERSIDE COUNTY
PUBLIC DEFENDER IN SUPPORT OF
PETITIONER

10/22/2007 Docket Entry: PERMISSION TO FILE AMICUS

CURIAE BRIEF GRANTED Document
Description: THE APPLICATION OF RIVERSIDE
COUNTY PUBLIC DEFENDER FOR
PERMISSION TO FILE AN AMICUS CURIAE
BRIEF IN SUPPORT OF PETITIONER IS
HEREBY GRANTED. AN ANSWER THERETO
MAY BE SERVED AND FILED BY ANY PARTY
WITHIN TWENTY DAYS OF THE FILING OF
THE BRIEF.

3
10/22/2007 Docket Entry: AMICUS CURIAE BRIEF FILED
Document Description: LOS ANGELES COUNTY
DISTRICT ATTORNEY IN SUPPORT OF REAL
PARTY IN INTEREST.

10/22/2007 Docket Entry: PERMISSION TO FILE AMICUS

CURIAE BRIEF GRANTED Document
Description: ON APPLICATION OF THE LOS
ANGELES COUNTY DISTRICT ATTORNEY
FOR PERMISSION TO FILE AN AMICUS
CURIAE BRIEF IN SUPPORT OF REAL PARTY
IN INTEREST IS HEREBY GRANTED. AN
ANSWER THERETO MAY BE SERVED AND
FILED BY ANY PARTY WITHIN TWENTY
DAYS OF THE FILING OF THE BRIEF.

10/11/2007 Docket Entry: RECEIVED APPLICATION TO

FILE AMICUS CURIAE BRIEF Document
Description: WITH THE WRONG COLOR
COVER FROM RIVERSIDE COUNTY PUBLIC
DEFENDER BY RICHARD V. MYERS, DEPUTY
PUBLIC DEFENDER CRC 8.25

10/10/2007 Docket Entry: RECEIVED APPLICATION TO

FILE AMICUS CURIAE BRIEF Document
Description: OF THE LOS ANGELES COUNTY
DISTRICT ATTORNEY IN SUPPORT OF THE
PEOPLE APPLICATION AND BRIEF UNDER
SAME COVER.

09/10/2007 Docket Entry: REPLY BRIEF FILED (CASE

FULLY BRIEFED) Document Description:
PETITIONER VARDUI ROSE BARSAYAN

08/17/2007 Docket Entry: EXTENSION OF TIME GRANTED

Document Description: ON APPLICATION OF
PETITIONER AND GOOD CAUSE APPEAIRNG,
IT IS ORDERED THAT THE TIME TO SERVE
AND FLE THE PETITIONER'S REPLY BRIEF
ON THE MERITS IS EXTENDED TO AND
INCLUDING SEPTEMBER 10, 2007.

08/10/2007 Docket Entry: REQUEST FOR EXTENSION OF

TIME FILED Document Description: TO FILE
REPLY BRIEF/MERITS VARDUI ROSE
BARSAMYAN, PETITIONER

07/23/2007 Docket Entry: ANSWER BRIEF ON THE

MERITS FILED Document Description: RPI THE
PEOPLE ATTORNEY KATHARINE H.
MACKENZIE

4
06/29/2007 Docket Entry: EXTENSION OF TIME GRANTED
Document Description: ON APPLICATION OF
REAL PARTY IN INTEREST AND GOOD
CAUSE APPEARING, IT IS ORDERED THAT
THE TIME TO SERVE AND FILE THE ANSWER
BRIEF ON THE MERITS IS EXTENDED TO
AND INCLUDING JULY 23, 2007.

06/27/2007 Docket Entry: REQUEST FOR EXTENSION OF

TIME FILED Document Description: TO
ANSWER BRIEF/MERITS TO JULY 23, 2007
DEPUTY CITY ATTORNEY KATHARINE H.
MACKENZIE

05/18/2007 Docket Entry: EXTENSION OF TIME GRANTED

Document Description: ON APPLICATION OF
REAL PARTY IN INTEREST AND GOOD
CAUSE APPEARING, IT IS ORDERED THAT
THE TIME TO SERVE AND FILE THE ANSWER
BRIEF ON THE MERITS IS EXTENDED TO
AND INCLUDING JULY 2, 2007.

05/15/2007 Docket Entry: REQUEST FOR EXTENSION OF

TIME FILED Document Description: TO FILE
ANSWER BRIEF/MERITS TO 07-02-2007.
DEPUTY CITY ATTORNEY KATHARINE H.
MACKENZIE

05/15/2007 Docket Entry: RECEIVED: Document

Description: LETTER FROM OFFICE OF THE
CITY ATTORNEY

04/18/2007 Docket Entry: EXTENSION OF TIME GRANTED

Document Description: ON APPLICATION OF
REAL PARTY IN INTEREST AND GOOD
CAUSE APPEARING, IT IS ORDERED THAT
THE TIME TO SERVE AND FILE THE ANSWER
BRIEF ON THE MERITS IS EXTENDED TO
AND INCLUDING MAY 21, 2007.

04/16/2007 Docket Entry: REQUEST FOR EXTENSION OF

TIME FILED Document Description: RPI THE
PEOPLE CITY ATTORNEY , ROCKARD
DELGADILLO

03/21/2007 Docket Entry: OPENING BRIEF ON THE

MERITS FILED Document Description:
PETITIONER VARDUI ROSE BARSAMYAN
DEPUTY PUBLIC DEFENDER JOHN
HAMILTON SCOTT
02/21/2007 Docket Entry: PETITION FOR REVIEW
GRANTED (CRIMINAL CASE)

5
 Document Description: VOTES: GEORGE, C.J.,
KENNARD, BAXTER, WERDEGAR, CHIN,
MORENO, AND CORRIGAN, JJ.

02/02/2007 Docket Entry: TIME EXTENDED TO GRANT OR

DENY REVIEW Document Description: TO AND
INCLUDING MARCH 9, 2007

01/12/2007 Docket Entry: REPLY TO ANSWER TO

PETITION FILED Document Description:
VARDUI ROSE BARSAMYAN, PETITIONER
JOHN HAMILTON SCOTT, DEPUTY PUBLIC
DEFENDER

01/02/2007 Docket Entry: ANSWER TO PETITION FOR

REVIEW FILED Document Description: RPI THE
PEOPLE CITY ATTORNEY, ROCKARD
DELGADILLO

12/14/2006 Docket Entry: RECEIVED COURT OF APPEAL

RECORD

12/12/2006 Docket Entry: RECORD REQUESTED

12/11/2006 Docket Entry: PETITION FOR REVIEW FILED

Document Description: VARDUI ROSE
BARSAMYAN, PETITIONER JOHN HAMILTON
SCOTT, DEPUTY PUBLIC DEFENDER