Professional Documents
Culture Documents
H 3845/2010
,
.. * ,
. () ,
,
, ,
,
,
(1930)1
- :
................................. 2
-
................................................................................................ 8
-1 ................................... 8
-2 43 .
4 ....................................................................................... 10
-3
.................................................................................. 12
-
................................... 13
-1 ........ 13
-2 .......................................... 14
-3
............................................... 16
* ...
1
Addendum to the eighth report on State responsibility, in:
Yearbook of the International Law Commission 1980, Vol. II, . 13 ., . . 25.
-3 ............. 18
- : ; ...................................... 20
- :
6 3845/2010 (
65/06.05.2010)
-
, , 3,
,
.
,
. ,
:
()
,
:
,
,
2.
,
, , ,
.
.
, ,
,
(odious
debt).
3,
. ,
() ,
A. Kruger,
Sovereign Debt Restructuring Mechanism (SDRM),
4
,
5.
.
,
,
6.
,
- ,
: ,
. ,
7,
(Washington consensus,
.
M. H. Bouchet, The political economy of International Debt: Who, what, how much
and why? 1987, J. Bulow, First World Governments and Third World Debts Brookings
Papers on Economic Activity, 2002, 229.
4
, ..
.
5
A. O. Krueger, A New Approach to Sovereign Debt Restructuring, International
Monetary Fund, April 2002, . P. Bolton, Toward a Statutory Approach to Sovereign
Debt Restructuring: Lessons From Corporate Bankruptcy Practice Around the World, IMF
Staff Papers No. 41, Jan. 1, 2003.
6
A. O. Krueger, A New Approach to Sovereign Debt Restructuring, International
Monetary Fund, . 12-14.
7
(conditionality)
Bretton Woods
.
Articles of Agreement
1950 . . S. D.
Krasner, Sovereignty: Organized Hypocrisy, Princeton University Press, Princeton, 1999, .
84-85.
8.
,
,
,
9.
,
10
. ,
sovereign debt, .
, ,
.
, ,
.
.
,
12
2001,
11. 25 . 1 ,
,
G. Soros, The Crisis of global capitalism, Public Affairs, New York, 2002, . 128,
. J. Stiglitz, Globalization and its discontents, Norton, New York, 2002, p. 53.
9
,
. Affaire de lindemnit Russe, UNRIAA,
Vol. XI, 431, . 443. . 13 14. . . ,
, , , 1980, . 21 ..
10
., , R. Dolzer, Staatliche Zahlungsunfhigkeit: Zum Begriff und zu den
Rechtsfolgen im Vlkerrecht, in: Jekewitz (ed.), Des Menschen Recht zwischen Freiheit und
Verantwortung: Festschrift fr Karl Josef Partsch zum 75. Geburtstag 1989, . 550, P.
Schantz, Verbraucher und Recht VuR 2006. 210, . 211.
11
Responsibility of States for Internationally Wrongful Acts, Annex to the Resolution
of the United Nations General Assembly A/RES/56/83.
8
.
(ICJ)12.
,
(salus populi suprema lex est),
13.
1938,
,
,
,
14.
- .
15,
25.561 6 2002
, , ,
. , 256/2002
6 2002 ,
.
16.
17,
12
Judgment of the International Court of Justice of 25 September 1997, GabcikovoNagymaros Project (Hungary/Slovakia), I.C.J. Reports 1997, . 7, . 51.
Addendum to the eighth report on State responsibility, in: Yearbook of the
International Law Commission 1980, Vol. II, . 13, Addendum to the eighth report on State
responsibility, in: Yearbook of the International Law Commission 1980, Vol. II, . 13
13
( )
. .
, French Company of Venezuelan Railroads Case,
UNRIAA, Vol. X, p. 285 (353))
14
Permanent Court of International Justice (PCIJ), Series C, no. 87 (1938-1939), 187
.., .. 205 ... . Lbbe-Wolff
BVerfG 2 BvM 1-5/03.
15
. . IMF, Report on the
Evaluation of the Role of the IMF in Argentina, 1991-2001. June 30, 2004.
16
. J. F. Hornbeck Argentinas Sovereign Debt Restructuring, Congressional
Research Service RL32637, The Library of Congress, Washington, 2004.
17
. , A.C. Porzecanski, From Rogue Creditors to Rogue Debtors:
Implications of Argentinas Default, CHICAGO JOURNAL OF INTERNATIONAL LAW,
Summer 2005, 331.
18. ,
(International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes ICSID-)
,
3 2006 LG&E Energy
Corp
2001
2003 19.
, ,
,
, acta iure imperii20.
(Schutzpflicht)
21.
.
1921,
- 22.
,
23. , ,
, 24
25.
(odious debt)26.
.
,
,
( , .., ),
,
27.
.
2007
, ,
, , 28,
20/11/2008
http://www.vatican.va/index.htm): () ,
. . Desmond Tutu, Debt
cancellation a victory for the world, The Baltimore Sun, May 7/2008
25
El Hadji Guis, "
,
, ." United Nations, Economic and
Social Council, Commission on Human Rights, Sub-Commission on Prevention of
Discrimination and Protection of Minorities, The Realization of Economic, Social and
Cultural Rights: The Question of Transnational Corporations, E/CN.4/Sub.2/1998/6, June 10,
1998, . 1
26
E. F. Mancina, Note: Sinners in the Hands of an Angry God: Resurrecting the Odious
Debt Doctrine in International Law, 36 GEO. WASH. INTL L. REV. 2004. 1239 . 167,
Anupam Chander, Odious Securitization, 53 EMORY L.J. 2004, 923, M. Kremer, S.
Jayachandran1,
Odious
Debt,
Harvard
Seminar,
2002
:
http://204.180.229.21/external/np/res/seminars/2002/poverty/mksj.pdf. .
http://www.odiousdebts.org.
27
. T. Lothian, The Criticism of the Third-World Debt and the Revision of
Legal Doctrine, 13 WIS. INTL L.J. 1995.421, . 439. . P. Adams, Odious Debts: Loose
Lending, Corruption and the Third Worlds Environmental Legacy, Earthscan, Toronto, 1991,
. 165.
28
.
No.
472/2007,
http://www.auditoriadeuda.org.ec/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&catid=35&i
d=51&Itemid=55..
24
29. ,
2012
2008 2030
2009.
30.
, ,
30%
31.
-
-1
.
25 2010,
11
2010. III IV
,
,
,
.
( ,
)
28 . 2
. ,
(, ,
29
http://www.auditoriadeuda.org.ec/images/stories/documentos/Libro_CAIC_English.pdf.zip.
30
L. C. Buchheit and G. Mitu Gulati, The Coroners Inquest, INTERNATIONAL
FINANCIAL LAW REVIEW, September 2009, 2.
31
A. C. Porzecanski, When Bad Things Happen to Good Sovereign Debt Contracts:
The Case of Ecuador. MPRA Paper No. 20857, American University, February 2010,
http://mpra.ub.uni-muenchen.de/20857, . 15.
), ,
, 28 . 132.
, )
)
.
33.
34,
.
,
, ,
(letter of intent)
.
(
) 35
, .
,
9 ,
36.
,
. ,
, .
-
.
. , :
, 09/05/2010.
33
2001. . J.R. Klein, The Battle for Rule of Law in
Thailand: The Constitutional Court of Thailand, 2003, :
http://www.cdi.anu.edu.au/CDIwebsite_19982004/thailand/thailand_downloads/ThaiUpdate_Klien_ConCourt%20Apr03.pdf
34
, . 3 .
35
.
,
soft law. . , , ..
36
. EBS/10/77 .
32
,
37
38,
,
( )
. 2 28
.
,
9 3847/2010. (
. , -3).
: ,
.
, , ,
.
, , . 3845/10,
( ),
,
.
-2 43 . 4
,
. . 1. . ,
,
,
,
, ,
(conditionality)
,
. .
T. Lothian, The Criticism of the Third-World Debt and the Revision of Legal
Doctrine, 13 WIS. INTL L.J. 1995.421, . 442.
38
,
,
1897
.
. . .
, . , . , , ,
1941, 27-31.
37
10
.
. 4 43
.
, ,
,
. ,
,
. 3845/2010
, , ,
39.
, , ,
, ,
. , ,
minimum
, 40.
, -
,
41, .
. 3845/2010
, , - ,
. 945/1979, 2
: ,
,
42,
.
, (
,
,
, .
, .
40
. . , Corpus, , . , - 1982, . 508,
J. Charpentier, Les lois cadres et la fonction gouvernementale, R.D.P.
1958.253; -
.
41
. , , , ,
1991, . 121, . . , , , . ,
, 1997, . 67.
42
. 407/80, 1980.437 . , ,
, , 2003, . 349.
39
11
) ,
` . , ,
-,
43.
, ,
43 . 4,
. 5 78 ,
.
43 . 4,
44.
-3
4 ,
,
, , ,
- ,
,
. , ,
,
. , , 9
3847/2010 ( 67/11.5.2005)
,
.
,
28 . 1 ,
,
, 45
. . , , . , ,
2007, . 55, 56 . , , , . ,
2007, . 439, 441, . . 1466/1995, . 2304/1995.
44
. . , Corpus, , . , - 1982, . 585.
45
, ,
9 .
43
12
. 36
. 2 , , ,
, ,
,
, ,
46.
, , . 4 ,
43 2 4.
78 . 5 (
,
)
,
.
-
. 1. .
,
.
-1
18 1985 ( 179 `)
,
,
,
47.
.
. ,
; ,
,
46
47
. 94/1995.
(.) 2289/1987, 955/1988, 1975/1991, . 2426/1983.
13
,
48.
, ,
, 82 . 1
, ,
. ,
, (sic),
, !
. , , ,
,
,
. ,
.
-2
49, ,
. 9,
.
.
,
. . 7
.
,
22 . 1
, -
.
, 22 . 1 2
48
49
, . 1.
. . , , , 19/5/2010.
14
, 50.
51,
52. 53
54. , ,
,
55.
,
, . 9 ,
,
25
,
. , ,
. 22 . 1 ,
50
. . , , . , , 2006, .
133 k.e.
. . , , .., . 164, . ,
, 1978.1.
52
.
, CG/Ch. Soc. (74) 14. . 6) . 211.
18 ,
.
53
"" 4
" ,
." ( , . 26 . . ,
, 1961-1976, , 28, 1976.198. . 212.
54
. 2 .
, ""
.
55
.
, . 6, . . , - , 2009, .
32 43 ., . , , 1976, . 126, .
, , .., . 522, . ,
22 . 1 , ,
, , 1987.113, . 124, . ,
, .
- ,
, , 1977, . 104.
. ,
- , 2006, . 93-125.
51
15
56,
.
, ,
2000/43/ 29 2000 2000/78/
27 2000,
. 3304/2005
,
, ,
57.
-3
.
, . 2
. 2258. ,
,
59,
.
8
151/1978 60,
, 5
154/198161,
62.
16
, 6 12 63
.
,
,
,
,
,
64.
, ,
,
, ,
65.
(-1)
.
, . 8
. , ,
, 5 . 1
, 66. : ,
, ,
,
,
67.
1
,
. 1426/1984.
() 632/1978, 1978, . 178.
65
() 2287/1987, 1987, . 1096, 1987, . 250,
1975/1991, 1991, . 392
66
B., , . , , ,
2004, 13 . 5 ., 58 ., . , , , ,
1999, . 3 .
67
1465/2001, 2003, . 986
63
64
17
,
68.
, "
" " "
, , ,
, ,
69.
,
,
70.
-3
,
() 71.
,
73 . 2 ,
, .
,
72.
. 3845/2010 ,
. , ,
,
73.
.
, ...., Pressos Compania Naviera SA 20.11.1995,
Pine Valley Development 2.11.1991,
28.3.2000, 3739/1999, .... 1999, . 16
69
. () 40/1998, 33/2002
70
Van der Mussele v. Belgium, 23 1983, Series A no. 70, .
23, . 48, Pine Valley Developments v. Ireland 29 1991, Series
A no. 222, . 23, . 51; Pressos Compania Naviera S.A. v. Belgium, 20
1995, Series A no. 332, . 21, . 31, . . ,
, 2005, 547 1295/2004
104/2009, (.) 33/2002, 1465/2001, () 40/1998, 510/2002, 957/2002,
71/2003, 79/2003.
71
, . 6.
72
(.) 301/1987.
73
. . , , .., . 166 .., .
,
, . , , 2004, . 385 .., . ,
, , , 1994, . 24 .
,
, 1991.665 737 . (
68
18
,
1
, ,
,
.
,
,
74,
75.
, ,
:
1 76.
77.
, ,
, ,
78.
79 80
81,
82.
,
.
, , 1992.409, . ,
. 2048/92, 1992.745.
74
20.6.2002
75
22.10.2009, . 39574/07
76
A Gratzinger Gratzingerova ,
10.7.2002, . 39794/98.
77
A Wanda Paruszewska 16-4-96, .
995/04, 3458/02, 2776/00, 3739/99
78
898/79, 2973/91, 450/78.
79
967/87, 1 2914/83, 1511/82, 1508/82, 40/85, 797/77.
80
2149/2001, 3824/2000, 2745/1999, 1635/89, 241/89, 2913/83, 3852/79
81
139/2002, 2888/1999, 3127/2000, 4516/1997, 3177/1998, 3010/1998
82
2022/82.
19
83,
84.
- : ;
--; (
)
,
.
, ,
:
.
,
.
,
:
.
2009-43-01 21 2009
10% 70%,
85.
".
,
( 109
) ( 91),
( 1).
C-754
60 62 2014,
Conclusions XVIII-1 (Greece) . 13, Conclusions XVIII-1 (United Kingdom), .
520. Conclusions XVI- 1, Statement of Interpretation on Article 12, . 11. . G.
Katrougalos, Constitutional limitations of Social Security Privatisations: A human rights
approach, European Journal of Social Security, 2010, . 16.
84
B.
2/9/2010, 1 BvL 1/09, 1 BvL 3/09, 1 BvL 4/09
43/95, 32/91, 26/93
,
, , 85, 86 87.
85
. ,
, . . 1/2010, . 2.
83
20
.
,
, paripassu 1990 86.
22 2003,
-
13%87.
,
.
, :
,
,
: ,
,
, .
,
;
, ,
:
, 119%
, 2013,
, 150% 177% 88,
()
89.
, 90,
,
21
,
! (
,
5%
3%).
,
.
( )
"" ()
91.
,
100-150 92.
,
,
(, , )
.
.
,
, 93:
,
,
. ,
25% . (
). ,
. ,
150 , .
,
.
:
,
with Other Departments, EBS/10/77, . 21.
230% .
91
. , , 2010,
http://www.protagon.gr/Default.aspx?tabid=70&smid=382&ArticleID=2121.
92
,
. M. Dickerson, A Politically Viable Approach To Sovereign Debt Restructuring 53
EMORY L.J., 2004.997.
93
. . , ibidem.
22
. ,
,
,
.
.
,
.
Inter IMF et EU non silent leges.
Sine leges Res Publica non stat.
23