-

PUBLIC MEETING - AGENDA -

Auditorium Thursday, 40 College Street, 2nd Floor June 20, 2013 Toronto, Ontario at 1:30 PM ___________________________________________________________________________ 1:30 PM 1:45 PM: Opening of the Meeting

Approval of the Previous Minutes: 1. Confirmation of the public minutes from the meeting held on May 22, 2013

1:45 PM 2:15 PM: Presentations 2. (A) June 06, 2013 from Joseph Pennachetti, City Manager, City of Toronto Re: City of Toronto Shared Services Study Mr. Rob Rossini, Deputy City Manager and Chief Financial Officer, will deliver a presentation to the Board on the recommendations pertaining to the Toronto Police Services Board and the Toronto Police Service. A copy of Appendix C the Final Report prepared by KPMG on the Citys Shared Services Study was circulated separately to Board members and can also be accessed at: www.toronto.ca/legdocs/mmis/2013/ex/bgrd/backgroundfile-58362.pdf

(B) June 03, 2013 from Alok Mukherjee, Chair Re: City of Toronto Shared Services Study

3. May 21, 2013 from William Blair, Chief of Police Re: Parking Enforcement - Roles of the Toronto Police Service and the City of Toronto Ms. Kimberly Rossi, Manager, Toronto Police Service Parking Enforcement Unit, and Mr. Anthony Fabrizi, Manager, Utility Billing and Parking Ticket Operations, City of Toronto, will deliver a presentation to the Board.

2:15 PM 3:00 PM: Reports to be Received 4. (A) June 07, 2013 from Marie Moliner, Board Member & Chair, Street Check SubCommittee Re: Update Toronto Police Services Board Street Check Sub-Committee

(B) June 05, 2013 from Jeff Griffiths, Auditor General, City of Toronto Re: Deferral of Auditor Generals Review of Police Collection of Demographic Data

5. May 22, 2013 from William Blair, Chief of Police Re: Chiefs Internal Organizational Review Status of 54 and 13 Divisions

6. May 22, 2013 from William Blair, Chief of Police Re: Chiefs Internal Organizational Review Methodology Update

7. May 14, 2013 from William Blair, Chief of Police Re: Court Services Staffing and Special Constables

8. April 24, 2013 from William Blair, Chief of Police Re: Integrated Records and Information System Project Staffing Implications

9. (A) March 06, 2013 from William Blair, Chief of Police Re: Annual Report 2012 Public Sector Salary Disclosure Deferred from the March 27, 2013 meeting.

(B) April 17, 2013 from William Blair, Chief of Police Re: Additional Members Who Earned More than $100,000 in 2012 as a Result of Paid Duties

10. (A) May 28, 2013 from Alok Mukherjee, Chair Re: Disposition Report: Review of Complaint Concerning the Conduct of Councillor Michael Thompson, Vice-Chair, TPSB

(B) October 09, 2012 from Dhun Noria, Member Re: Disposition Report: Review of Complaint Concerning the Conduct of Councillor Michael Thompson, Vice-Chair, TPSB

11. May 10, 2013 from William Blair, Chief of Police Re: Annual Report 2012 Police Towing Contracts

12. May 07, 2013 from William Blair, Chief of Police Re: Annual Report 2012 Race and Ethnocultural Equity Policy

13. May 27, 2013 from William Blair, Chief of Police Re: Annual Report 2012 Training Programs

14. May 03, 2013 from William Blair, Chief of Police Re: Annual Report 2012 Service Performance A copy of the complete report has been circulated separately to Board members.

15. May 14, 2013 from Christian Paradis, Minister of Industry and Minister of State Re: Correspondence Response to Recommendation for Legislation - Disabling Stolen Mobile Communication Devices

16. May 24, 2013 from Kathleen Wynne, Premier of Ontario Re: Correspondence Response to Recommendations Pertaining to the Interest Arbitration System in Ontario

3:00 PM 3:15 PM: Reports to be Approved 17. (A) June 06, 2013 from Alok Mukherjee, Chair Re: Status of Discussions: Toronto Transit Commission Special Constables and Toronto Port Authority Policing

(B)

May 29, 2013 from William Blair, Chief of Police Re: Toronto Port Authoritys Request for Pre-Clearance Staffing by the Toronto Police Service at the Billy Bishop Toronto City Airport

18. May 28, 2013 from Alok Mukherjee, Chair Re: Canadian Association of Police Boards: Amendment to By-Laws

19. June 05, 2013 from Alok Mukherjee, Chair Re: Motion from Toronto City Council Parking Ticket Activity

20. June 05, 2013 from Alok Mukherjee, Chair Re: Motion from Toronto City Council Parks Plan 2013-2017 A copy of the Parks Plan 2013-2017 is available in the Board Office or can be accessed at: www.toronto.ca/legdocs/mmis/2013/pe/bgrd/backgroundfile-57282.pdf

21. April 30, 2013 from William Blair, Chief of Police Re: Employee and Family Assistance Program Services Award

22. June 07, 2013 from Alok Mukherjee, Chair Re: Ratification of Board Decision Appointment of Acting Vice-Chair: May 30, 2013 to June 11, 2013, Inclusive

23. May 31, 2013 from Alok Mukherjee, Chair Re: Special Fund Request for Funds: 2013 World Police and Fire Games Reception

24. May 29, 2013 from Alok Mukherjee, Chair Re: Special Fund Request for Funds: Toronto Police Service Cricket Club and Standing Authority for Future Annual Funds

NEXT REGULAR MEETING: Date: Time: Thursday, July 18, 2013 1:30 PM

__________________________________________________________________________ Members of the Toronto Police Services Board: Dr. Alok Mukherjee, Chair Councillor Michael Thompson, Vice-Chair Councillor Michael Del Grande, Member Ms. Marie Moliner, Member Dr. Dhun Noria, Member Councillor Frances Nunziata, Member Mr. Andrew Pringle, Member

1. Confirmation of the public minutes from the meeting held on May 22, 2013

2. (A) June 06, 2013 from Joseph Pennachetti, City Manager, City of Toronto Re: City of Toronto Shared Services Study Mr. Rob Rossini, Deputy City Manager and Chief Financial Officer, will deliver a presentation to the Board on the recommendations pertaining to the Toronto Police Services Board and the Toronto Police Service. A copy of Appendix C the Final Report prepared by KPMG on the Citys Shared Services Study was circulated separately to Board members and can also be accessed at: www.toronto.ca/legdocs/mmis/2013/ex/bgrd/backgroundfile-58362.pdf

(B) June 03, 2013 from Alok Mukherjee, Chair Re: City of Toronto Shared Services Study June 3, 2013

To:

Members Toronto Police Services Board Alok Mukherjee Chair CITY OF TORONTO SHARED SERVICES EFFICIENCY STUDY

From:

Subject:

Recommendations: It is recommended that (1) The Board receive the Executive Committee recommendations of May 28, 2013 and the City of Toronto Shared Services Efficiency Study, (2) The Board advise the City Manager that the Board will work in cooperation with him during his on-going review and implementation of shared services opportunities, (3) Given that the Board does not have its own internal auditors, the City Manager be requested to advise whether the Citys Internal Audit services can be made available to the Board, upon request, to conduct audits with respect to the Toronto Police Service; and, (4) The Chair, in consultation with the City Manager and the TPS/TPSB Manager of Labour Relations, provide to the Board, for consideration at its October meeting, a draft process for ensuring that the Citys strategic labour relations priorities are communicated to, and considered by, the Board in its preparations for collective bargaining Financial Implications: As it pertains to the Toronto Police Services Board, the financial implications of the recommendations and opportunities identified in the Shared Services Efficiency Study are unknown, at this time. Background/Purpose: I anticipate that the Board will receive the City of Toronto Shared Services Efficiency Study at its public meeting on June 20, 2013. I have invited Mr Rob Rossini, Deputy City Manager and CFO, to attend the Board meeting and make a brief presentation with respect to this report.

Discussion: The City of Torontos Executive Committee considered the Shared Services Efficiency Study at its meeting on May 28, 2013. A copy of the Executive Committee decision is included with Mr Rossinis report. The Shared Services report presents a number of opportunities for potential collaboration or enhanced and continued collaboration particularly in the areas of human resource management, labour relations and internal audit. The report also discusses a number of areas where the Toronto Police Service and the Toronto Police Services Board already share services or extensively collaborates with the City; namely, legal services, procurement, IT infrastructure and real estate services. In terms of the potential for expanded sharing or collaboration, I am proposing that the Board explore the possibility of accessing the Citys internal audit division for the provision of quality assurance services to the Board. The Toronto Police Service Quality Assurance Unit reports to the Chief and conducts audits and reviews, the results of which are not made available to the Board. I recommend that the Board explore the possibility of accessing the expertise of the Citys Audit Services Division and, if collaboration is possible, the Board develop an audit policy reflecting this collaboration and setting out the scope and process of auditing at the Toronto Police Services Board. With respect to human resources management and labour relations, it is my recommendation that the Board refer this portion of the Shared Services report to me for the preparation of a report back to the Board in the autumn of 2013. I propose to consult with the City Manager and the TPS/TPSB Manager of Labour Relations, and provide to the Board, for consideration at its October meeting, a draft process for ensuring that the Citys strategic labour relations priorities are communicated to, and considered by, the Board in its preparations for collective bargaining Conclusion: The shared services report discusses opportunities for further collaboration with the City of Toronto. At this early stage, the details of the potential sharing are not yet clear nor are the potential efficiencies defined or known; however, Executive Committee has endorsed an implementation plan for the City Manager and I propose that the Board cooperate to the fullest extent possible with the City Managers implementation plans. Respectfully submitted,

Alok Mukherjee Chair A:\shared_services_june3_13

3. May 21, 2013 from William Blair, Chief of Police Re: Parking Enforcement - Roles of the Toronto Police Service and the City of Toronto Ms. Kimberly Rossi, Manager, Toronto Police Service Parking Enforcement Unit, and Mr. Anthony Fabrizi, Manager, Utility Billing and Parking Ticket Operations, City of Toronto, will deliver a presentation to the Board. May 21, 2013

To:

Chair and Members Toronto Police Services Board William Blair Chief of Police PARKING PRESENTATION ROLES OF THE TPS AND THE CITY

From:

Subject:

Recommendation: It is recommended that the Board receive this report. Financial Implications: There are no financial implications relating to the recommendations contained within this report. Background/Purpose: At its meeting of February 19, 2013, the Board approved a motion that the Chief provide a presentation on the manner in which parking tags are issued, distinguishing between the role of the Toronto Police Service and that of the City of Toronto for the Boards May 2013 meeting (Min. No. P35/2013 refers). The presentation was subsequently deferred to the Boards June 20, 2013 meeting. Discussion: A PowerPoint slideshow will be presented at the public Board meeting to clarify the roles of the Toronto Police Service which is responsible for the enforcement of Municipal Parking Bylaws and the City of Toronto, who establishes the bylaws, and handles the customer service element, processing, cancellations, collections and court scheduling. The presentation will also include a discussion on customer service, collections, cancellations and strategies for 2013 and beyond and the necessary collaborative efforts that are employed to achieve a successful parking program in the City of Toronto.

The presentation will be delivered by Ms. Kimberly Rossi, Manager, Toronto Police Service, Parking Enforcement Unit and Mr. Anthony Fabrizi, Manager, Utility Billing and Parking Ticket Operations, City of Toronto. Conclusion: This report provides the Board with the information that will be presented regarding the roles and responsibilities associated with the parking program in Toronto. Deputy Chief Mark Saunders, Specialized Operations Command, will be in attendance to answer any questions that the Board may have regarding this report. Respectfully submitted,

William Blair, C.O.M. Chief of Police WB/kr ParkingPresentationBoardReport.docx

4. (A) June 07, 2013 from Marie Moliner, Board Member & Chair, Street Check SubCommittee Re: Update Toronto Police Services Board Street Check Sub-Committee June 7, 2013 To: Chair and Members Toronto Police Services Board Marie Moliner, Board Member and Chair, Street Check Sub-Committee UPDATE - TORONTO POLICE SERVICES BOARD STREET CHECK SUBCOMMITTEE

From:

Subject:

Recommendation: It is recommended that the Board receive the following report. Financial Implications: There are no financial implications arising from the Boards receipt of this report. Background/Purpose: In its last update report to the Toronto Police Services Board, the Street Check Sub-Committee proposed a series of recommendations which were adopted, as amended, by the Board as follows: a. That, as an interim measure, the Chief implement by no later than July 1, 2013, the use of Form 306, proposed by the Chief at the Board meeting in December 2012, for all stops where a FIR (208) is required to be completed. b. If the Form 306 continues to include a reference to community engagement, that the Chief provide the Board, for its information, a copy of the written instructions to TPS members defining what types of interactions constitute community engagement. c. That the Chief prepare a public communiqu to be posted on the TPS website and on Divisional web pages, which explains the purpose of the relevant Street Check forms and how they inter-relate. For ease of reference by the public, the current forms being used (208/FIR/306) should be posted to the website as part of this communiqu. d. That the Chief provide a report to the Board responding to the deputants requests for revisions to Form 208/FIR and to the viability of providing a carbon copy or equivalent record so that individuals are more fully informed of what has resulted from the stop and able to obtain appropriate information.

e. That the Chief provide, to the Sub-committee, a list and summary of all materials the TPS has gathered on the collection of race-based data on stops. f. That, as offered by the Chief at the Boards meeting in December 2012, the Chief produce a standardized quarterly report for the Board on Street Check practices beginning with the first quarter of 2013; including information about the implementation of Form 306, about the age and race of persons stopped and additional information which will enable an analysis of the nature and quality of Street Check activity and its impact on community safety (Min. P271/12 refers). g. That the Chief provide a status report at the June 2013 public Board meeting on the implementation of these directions. The Board also approved a recommendation which requested that the Chief work closely with the Sub-Committee as it works through the various tasks enumerated in the Sub-Committees draft Terms of Reference (Board Min. P121/13 refers). Discussion: Since the last update report the Street Check Sub-Committee has held two meetings. On May 21, 2013, the Street Check Sub-Committee convened a meeting to which it invited City of Toronto Auditor General Jeff Griffiths and his staff. The Auditor General attended this meeting in light of the Boards 2012 request that he conduct an analysis of TPS community contacts. (Report from Auditor General filed separately) The Sub-Committee received an update from Deputy Chief Peter Sloly who advised that extensive work is being done within the Toronto Police Service to review and substantially revise the current Field Information Report (FIR) process and to consider the most workable format for an interim receipt. The Sub-Committee was advised as to the complexity of this work and the challenges the Service is facing to complete its Street Check review and develop an appropriate receipt, print and distribute the receipt, and conduct training for Service members prior to the Board-approved July 1, 2013 implementation date. Given the on-going review and revision process within the Service, the Sub-Committee determined that, with respect to items (a) through (g) in its April 25, 2013 report (cited above) it is reasonable to expect that, while most of the requested items can be addressed by July, items (e) and (f) will not be available to the Board until late 2013, at the earliest. The Sub-Committee met again on May 28, 2013. At this meeting, the Sub-Committee invited a number of community stakeholders to hear Deputy Sloly and members of his team describe the revisions that are being contemplated to the Street Check process and the challenges presented by the timelines approved by the Board, particularly for the implementation of the receipt. This Sub-Committee meeting was attended by several individuals, organizations and institutions interested in the issue including Mr. Alvin Curling, co-author of the Roots of Youth Violence Report, Mr. Doug Ewart, Policy Lead, Roots of Youth Violence Report, and a representative of the Jamaican Canadian Association.

The stakeholders were invited to attend because of the impending new developments in the TPS approach to Street Checks and because of the timelines with respect to the work of both the Street Check Sub-Committee and the Chiefs internal review on police-community interaction in public places, being led by Deputy Sloly. Deputy Sloly outlined the proposed, revised process for Street Checks and explained the various challenges including those presented by the implementation schedule approved by the Street Check Sub-Committee and the Board. Sub-Committee members expressed appreciation for the thoughtful input provided by the stakeholders. The Sub-Committee committed to providing the stakeholders with an update prior to the June 20, 2013 Board meeting. Conclusion: There has been significant work done over the past 6 weeks by Deputy Chief Peter Sloly and his team. The Street Check Sub-Committee looks forward to the Boards consideration of the report from Chief Blair at the June 20, 2013 Board meeting and to .

Respectfully submitted,

Marie Moliner Chair, Street Check Sub-Committee

A:\update_june7_13

(B) June 05, 2013 from Jeff Griffiths, Auditor General, City of Toronto Re: Deferral of Auditor Generals Review of Police Collection of Demographic Data

AUDITOR GENERALS REPORT ACTION REQUIRED Deferral of Auditor Generals Review of Police Collection of Demographic Data
Date: To: From: Wards: Reference Number: June 5, 2013 Toronto Police Service Board Auditor General All

SUMMARY
The purpose of this report is to inform the Police Services Board of the deferral of the Auditor Generals review of police collection of demographic data. The Auditor General determined that the deferral was necessary and appropriate given the Police Services plan to implement significant changes to street checks conducted by officers. In response to the Boards request to conduct a project on police collection of demographic data, the Auditor General assigned staff to begin planning for the requested project. In addition, the Auditor General held four separate meetings in April and May 2013 with the Chair of the Board, the Chief of Police, the Deputy Chief of Police, and the Director of the Citys Legal Services Division to discuss the proposed terms of reference for the project. The Auditor General also attended the Street Check Sub-Committees May 21, 2013 meeting, and presented his draft project terms of reference to the Sub-Committee. During the meeting, Deputy Chief Sloly advised that the Service has been undertaking an internal review of the street check practice, and would be implementing significant changes that will take effect July 1, 2013. The planned changes, according to the Deputy Police Chief, would substantially alter and improve police policies and procedures, data collection and retention, officer training, and officer performance evaluation relating to street checks.

Conducting any audit when significant changes to policies and procedures are being implemented provides little to no value and results in the inefficient use of audit resources. In view of the latest information from the Police Service, the Auditor General has decided to defer the review until after the Service has implemented the planned changes. A review by the Auditor General may be contemplated after the new policies and procedures have been in effect for at least 12 months. The decision to defer the Auditor Generals review was supported by members of the Street Check Sub-Committee, the Director of the Citys Legal Services Division, and the Deputy Police Chief at the Street Check Sub-Committees May meeting. The Auditor General also consulted the Chair of the Board on the deferral prior to preparing this report.

RECOMMENDATION
The Auditor General recommends that: 1. This report be forwarded to the Citys Audit Committee for information. Financial Impact The recommendations in this report have no financial impact.

DECISION HISTORY
At its April 5, 2012 meeting, the Toronto Police Services Board approved a report containing the following recommendations: 1. (that) the Board, in order to establish baseline data showing the pattern of contact between the police and members of the community in general, and young people from certain ethno-racial backgrounds in particular, request the City of Toronto Auditor General conduct a project to collect and analyze data related to such contacts between the police and the community; and 2. (that) the Auditor General be requested to report to the Board in public on the results of the project, no later than the December 2013 meeting of the Board. The Board also approved, inter alia, the following Motion: THAT the Auditor General be requested to meet and consult with the Chief of Police and the Police Services Board in the development of terms of reference for this study and identify any procedural issues that may require the Boards direction. In response to the Boards request, the Auditor General included in his 2013 Audit Work Plan a review of police collection of demographic data. The 2013 Audit Work Plan was adopted by City Council at its November 2012 meeting. The 2013 Audit Work Plan is available at: http://app.toronto.ca/tmmis/viewAgendaItemHistory.do?item=2012.AU9.4

COMMENTS
In accordance with the 2013 Audit Work Plan, audit staff began preliminary planning for the requested project in early 2013. Planning activities included reviews of the following information: relevant deputations and reports to the Board police policies and procedures governing street checks the form used to collect street check data related newspaper articles and other published studies consultation with academics with expertise in police services.

In addition, in accordance with the Boards request and the approved Motion, the Auditor General held separate meetings with the Chair of the Board, the Chief of Police, the Deputy Chief of Police, and the Director of the City Legal Services Division in April and May 2013 to discuss the development of the terms of reference for the requested project. Based on results of preliminary audit reviews and consultations, the Auditor General decided to broaden the scope of the requested project to include other areas in addition to a quantitative analysis of street check statistics. The expanded scope included other aspects of street checks such as: the design and implementation of supervision and monitoring data collection and retention officer training performance evaluation.

A draft audit terms of reference had been developed based on the expanded scope. The draft terms of reference was presented and discussed at the Street Check Sub-Committees May 21, 2013 meeting by the Auditor General. During the meeting, Deputy Chief Sloly advised that the Service has been undertaking an extensive internal review of police street checks and would be implementing substantial changes to the practice starting July 1, 2013. The planned changes, according to the Deputy Chief, would significantly improve existing policies and procedures governing street checks, types of information collected, record retention, officer training, and the design of officer performance evaluation in relation to street checks. After considering the latest information from the Deputy Police Chief, the Auditor General determined that a review should not be conducted during a time when the Service would be introducing significant changes to its street check practice. A review by the Auditor General may be considered after all of the changes have been in effect for at least 12 months. With support from members of the Street Check Sub-Committee, the Director of the Citys Legal Services Division, and the Deputy Police Chief, the Auditor General decided to defer the planned review until a later time when the Police Service has completed the implementation of changes

to improve the street check practice. Prior to preparing this report, the Auditor General also consulted with the Chair of the Board on the deferral of the planned review.

CONTACT
Alan Ash, Director, Auditor Generals Office Tel: 416-392-8476, Fax: 416-392-3754, E-mail: aash@toronto.ca Jane Ying, Senior Audit Manager, Auditor Generals Office Tel: 416-392-8480, Fax: 416-392-3754, E-mail: jying@toronto.ca

SIGNATURE

_______________________________ Jeff Griffiths, Auditor General

13-TPS-01

5. May 22, 2013 from William Blair, Chief of Police Re: Chiefs Internal Organizational Review Status of 54 and 13 Divisions May 22, 2013

To:

Chair and Members Toronto Police Services Board William Blair Chief of Police CHIEFS INTERNAL ORGANIZATIONAL REVIEW (CIOR) - CLOSING 54 AND 13 DIVISIONS

From:

Subject:

Recommendation: It is recommended that the Board receive this report. Financial Implications: There are no financial implications relating to the recommendation contained within this report. Background/Purpose: As first reported to the Board at its meetings on April 19 and May 18, 2012, the Service is currently conducting a comprehensive internal review of all aspects of policing in the Toronto Police Service (Min. Nos. C125/12 and C165/12 refer). This review is known as the Chiefs Internal Organizational Review (CIOR). As reported to the Confidential Board in July 2012 the Service was conducting a review into the closing of 13 and 54 Divisions (Min. No. C236/12 refers). This review concluded on November 21, 2012. The CIOR Steering Committee supported the review teams recommendation to not close the divisions. The completion of this review was reported to the Board in January 2013 (Min. No. C1/13 refers). The decision to not close the divisions was reported to the Board in March 2013 (Min. No. C56 refers). Discussion: On May 2, 2012 a CIOR review was approved to assess the viability of closing Divisions 13 and 54. Part of the justification for initiating the review was the end of life cycle replacement of these two divisions which were next for replacement on the capital project list. The planned for expenditures on these divisions was thirty nine (39) and thirty six (36) million dollars for 13 Division and 54 Division respectively. The review team was asked to consider all relevant factors. These factors included the following for both communities:

efficient and effective delivery of policing services stakeholder needs risks to public safety risks to officer safety the opportunities for fiscal savings opportunities for efficiency alternative delivery models including consolidation to other divisions capacity issues at alternative facilities risks to the organization a full cost benefit analysis

There was extensive consultation of internal stakeholders. External stakeholder consultations included the following: Meeting with Councillors Fragadakis, Davis, and Palmer (rep.) June 21, 2012 Town Hall with Councillor Palacio July 4 , 2012 Meeting with Councillor Mihevic July 5 , 2012 Oakwood Village BIA Board meeting July 11 , 2012 13 Div. Jewish Community meeting July 12 , 2012 Meeting with Councillor Colle July 17, 2012 13 Div. meeting with Gesher Canada July 17, 2012 Town Hall with Councillor Colle July 18 , 2012 Town Hall with Councillor Fragadakis July 18 , 2012 Meeting with Ministry of the Attorney General July 19 , 2012 Telephone conferences with City of Toronto Planning Division August 2012 Town Hall with Councillor Davis September 5, 2012 Town Hall with Councillor Parker September 11, 2012

The review was presented to the CIOR Steering Committee. The CIOR Steering Committee did not recommend closing the divisions. Conclusion: The CIOR will continue to focus on creating an enhanced and sustainable model of policing for the Toronto Police Service. Deputy Chief Michael Federico, Corporate Command, will be in attendance to answer any questions that the Board may have. Respectfully submitted, William Blair, C.O.M. Chief of Police WB:sw Filename: CIOR Review to Close D54 and D13.doc

6. May 22, 2013 from William Blair, Chief of Police Re: Chiefs Internal Organizational Review Methodology Update May 22, 2013

To:

Chair and Members Toronto Police Services Board William Blair Chief of Police CHIEFS INTERNAL ORGANIZATIONAL REVIEW METHODOLOGY AND UPDATE

From:

Subject:

Recommendation: It is recommended that the Board receive this report. Financial Implications: There are no financial implications relating to the recommendation contained within this report. Background/Purpose: As first reported to the Board at its meetings on April 19 and May 18, 2012, the Service is currently conducting a comprehensive internal review of all aspects of policing in the Toronto Police Service (Min. Nos. C125/12 and C165/12 refer). This review is known as the Chiefs Internal Organizational Review (CIOR). As identified at the April 25, 2013 Board meeting, City Council requesed the Chair, Toronto Police Services Board to report back to the Deputy City Manager and Chief Financial Officer on the outcomes of the Chief's Internal Organizational Review. The Chair has requested the Chief report on the methodology and outcomes, to date, of the Chiefs Internal Organizational Review (CIOR) (Min. No. P115/13 refers). This report will describe the methodology of the CIOR and the outcomes to date. Discussion: In February 2012, Chief William Blair commenced a Review of the Toronto Police Service, including its services delivered, business processes and organizational structure. The purpose of this review was to examine how the Service was conducting business, and considered the questions: Can we do it better? Can we do it more effectively and more

economically? Are we delivering services of value to our community? Are we efficiently meeting our obligations? Are there alternatives methodologies to deliver service in a more efficient, effective and economical manner? To initiate the process two senior officers with business and project management experience were assigned to create a process and to facilitate the CIOR. This team is known as the CIOR Team (CIORT). While the mandate of the CIOR was to create a more efficient, effective, and economical Service, while looking for opportunities to achieve excellence in service delivery, the mandate of the CIORT was to engage members from all areas of the Service to participate in that process. The philosophy was to engage those who know best about their areas of business to bring ideas forward to improve service delivery, and to participate in that change process. This was facilitated in part by a communication strategy and an internal website which included transparency of all ideas and reviews. All members of the Service were encouraged to put forward ideas for improvement. The CIOR established three methods for members to suggest changes and efficiencies for the Service. These methods included a simple suggestion by email, a more explicit suggestion known as an idea generation, and a fully developed review proposal. The Chief and his Command were committed to hear all ideas to facilitate engagement of the membership. Once ideas are developed fully to review proposals they are scored against a matrix of opportunities and limits by a panel of experts, from all business areas of the Service, sitting as an Assessment Team. The Assessment Team then amplifies the proposal. Proposals are presented to the Command which sits as a Steering Committee and includes two Board members in an advisory capacity. The Steering Committee assesses and decides which proposals are worthy of a full review. The Steering Committee also determines a review team lead who is a senior manager with subject matter expertise. The CIORT supports the review team that is assigned ensuring consistency in project management, document management, review methodology, business analysis, and the preparation of the final report. Upon conclusion of a review the final report is presented to the Assessment Team. This team ensures a thorough review was conducted, all stakeholders were addressed, assumptions are challenged and a thorough business analysis was conducted. The CIORT present the Final Report with recommendations to the Steering Committee for deliberation. If approved for implementation, a team is tasked and once again managed by the CIORT. The CIOR has utilized internal and external expertise to build the process. The external expertise included business academics and industry experts. Two reviews have been conducted by external consultants with expertise in organizational structure and business process and labour optimization. CIOR Update As of May 2013 there are seven (7) CIOR reviews in the implementation stage: Divisional Prisoner Management, Flexible Schedules for Specialized Units (8&6), TPS Auxiliary Policing

Program, the Review to Civilianize Forensic Identification Officers, the CopLogic Shoplifting Diversion review, and the Organizational Structure review (see Table 4 below). A review into the use of technology to improve traffic safety in Toronto is also complete although that review continues in part, to determine the best model for TPS traffic service delivery and deployment. Employee Engagement and overall CIOR business is reflected in the following table (Table 1). Table 1 Employee Engagement Reviews/Ideas/Suggestions Generated Suggestions to Date Ideas Generated Reviews Proposed Active CIOR Reviews Pending Final Approval to Review Reviews Completed Reviews Completed and in Implementation

Number 99 58 28 13 0 10 7

All reviews and their current status are itemized on the table below (Table 2). Table 2 Status of Review Projects (continued) P.P. Partnerships Cost Avoidance/ Savings Shared Services Civilianization Review Status Consolidation Privatization Outsourcing

Efficiency Service Excellence Technology

Description Y potential N N/A Divisional Prisoner Management Flexible Schedules for Specialized Units (8&6)

Implement

$2.1 million upon full implementation

Implement

To Be Determined (TBD)

TPS Auxiliary Policing Program N N N N N Table 2 Status of Review Projects (continued)

Implement

Nil

Potential Annualized Economies (estimates)

P.P. Partnerships

Cost Avoidance/ Savings

Shared Services

Civilianization

Review Status

Consolidation

Privatization

Outsourcing

Efficiency Service Excellence Technology

Description Y potential N N/A Civilianize Forensic Identification SOCO Officers CopLogic and Theft (shoplifting) Call for Service Diversion AccentureOrganizational Structure, Span of Control, Civilianization, Delayering Review Traffic Safety and Technology (Centralization of traffic still under way) Outsourcing of Courts Screening Positions

Implement

Civilianization of four positions: $95,000 annualized upon completed implementation

Implement

TBD

Implement

TBD

Implement

TBD

Complete

TBD

Civilianization and Centralizing of the School Crossing Guard Program Y

Complete

Closing Divisions 13 and 54 Divisions N Y N N N N Y Table 2: Status of Review Projects (continued)

Complete

$2-300,000 implementation deferred Capital: $36 million (D54); $39 million (D13). Operations dependent. Not implemented

Potential Annualized Economies (estimates)

P.P. Partnerships

Cost Avoidance/ Savings

Shared Services

Civilianization

Review Status

Consolidation

Privatization

Outsourcing

Efficiency Service Excellence Technology

Description Y potential N N/A Multi-Agency Collaboration to Assist Community Development HUB Model Traffic Safety and Technology Civilianization and Combining of Divisional Positions Emergency Services Efficiencies Review Training and Course Facilitation (TPC) Special Events Resource Assignment Community Engagement and Intelligence Gathering Customer Service Review Internal External Processes (includes civilianization and automation)

Active Active (complete in part)

TBD

TBD

Active

TBD

Active

TBD

Active

TBD

Active

TBD

N N

N N

N N

N N

N N

N N

N N

Y Y

Y Y

N N

Active Active

TBD TBD

Active

TBD

Employment Background Consultants Y N N N N N Y Table 2: Status of Review Projects (continued)

Active

TBD

Potential Annualized Economies (estimates)

P.P. Partnerships

Cost Avoidance/ Savings

Shared Services

Civilianization

Review Status

Consolidation

Privatization

Outsourcing

Efficiency Service Excellence Technology

Description Y potential N N/A Duty Operations Centre Review Civilianization of SOCO Positions The Right Number Review Conclusion:

N Y N

Y Y N

N N N

N N N

N N N

N N N

Y Y Y

Y Y Y

Y Y N

N N N

Active Active Active

TBD TBD TBD

Economies and efficiencies will continue to be identified in the ongoing reviews that are in progress or in implementation. Importantly, it must be stated that standards of service delivery to the community will not be sacrificed, and opportunities to achieve excellence in that delivery will continue to be sought. The CIOR will continue to focus on creating an enhanced and sustainable model of policing for the Toronto Police Service. Deputy Chief Michael Federico, Corporate Command, will be in attendance to answer any questions that the Board may have. Respectfully submitted,

William Blair, C.O.M. Chief of Police WB:sw Filename: CIOR Board Report Methodology and Outcomes May 2013 Public.doc

Potential Annualized Economies (estimates)

7. May 14, 2013 from William Blair, Chief of Police Re: Court Services Staffing and Special Constables May 14, 2013

To:

Chair and Members Toronto Police Services Board William Blair Chief of Police COURT SERVICES STAFFING AND SPECIAL CONSTABLES

From:

Subject:

Recommendation: It is recommended that the Board receive this report. Financial Implications: There are no financial implications relating to the recommendations contained within this report. Background/Purpose: At the Confidential Board meeting held on March 27, 2013, the Board approved an additional motion related to the Chiefs Internal Organizational Review (CIOR) Update and requested: information about the staffing of Court Services in terms of the members uniform or civilian status, positions and function; the reason why 611 of 619 court officers have been appointed as special constables, as well as whether this has been the case since the inception of the unit or whether this has occurred over a period of time, and if it is the latter, when was the decision to do this taken and why; and a year by year breakdown showing the number of appointments each year since the first appointments were approved by the Board (Min. No. C56/2013 refers).

Discussion: Court Services Staffing and Function In the early 1980's, the Service initiated the hiring of civilian personnel to fill the position of court officer. Court officers are primarily responsible for the safety and security of all persons within Toronto's court locations, as well as the transportation, security, and safety of all prisoners attending court each day.

Prior to 1980, this function was performed by police officers under the supervision of a sergeant at each court location. In 1980, the first class of twenty civilian employees were appointed by the Police Services Board to replace the uniformed police officers at the court locations. These court officers were sworn in as special constables, pursuant to the provisions of the Police Services Act. As the Citys policing needs expanded, so did the continued civilianization and growth of Court Services. In 1984, the first civilian supervisors were trained to replace the sergeants. In the mid 1980s, the Summons Bureau became a part of Court Services and the Civilian Summons Servers and support staff took on an expanded role under the newly created Document Services Section (DSS). The title, Summons Server, was changed to Document Server to reflect the expanded responsibilities. Document Servers are responsible for serving summonses, subpoenas and other court documents on individuals required to attend Toronto courts. Court Services was later assigned responsibility for overseeing the Matrons, now known as Custodial Officers, tasked with managing female prisoners at 55 Division. Court Services was also assigned responsibility for Computer Assisted Scheduling of Courts (CASC), an area responsible for ensuring efficient and effective selection of Provincial Offences Act (POA) trial dates. By 1990, court officers had been assigned responsibility for transporting prisoners in specialized wagons between the court locations, divisions and correctional facilities; a task previously performed only by police officers. This centralized service became known as the Prisoner Transportation Section. By 1995, Court Services promoted its first civilian to the position of location administrator, replacing the detective sergeants who were formerly in charge of the court locations. Today, all sections within Court Services are managed by civilian location administrators. These location administrators report directly to a manager or staff inspector, who in turn reports to the Superintendent of Court Services. Until January of 1990, the Province of Ontario and then Metropolitan Toronto were involved in a cost sharing agreement for court security. In November 1989, Bill C-187 (The Police and Sheriffs Statue Law Amendment Act) was passed and the responsibility for safety, security and prisoner custody at all court facilities in Metropolitan Toronto was downloaded to the Metropolitan Board of Commissioners of Police. Upon proclamation of Bill C-187, all cost sharing ceased and the Board was required to hire an additional 75 full time court officers and 98 part time court officers to meet its legislated responsibilities. In addition to increasing the responsibilities of the Service, there was also an increase in the number of courthouses for which the Service was responsible. The increase in court facilities and courtrooms continued throughout the 1990s. Between the end of 1990 and 1993, the number of courtrooms that Court Services was responsible for increased from 138 to 147. By 2004, the number of courtrooms had increased to 240. There are currently 16 locations staffed

by Court Services members across Toronto with a total of 274 court rooms encompassing criminal, civil, POA, family and hearing rooms. In October 2008, the Provincial Government committed to fulfil its responsibility to pay for court security and prisoner transportation costs which were costing police services millions of dollars annually. In 2012, the Province began uploading costs associated with court security and prisoner transportation. The Province will fully upload these costs by 2018. In September of 2012, Court Services began placing court officers in divisions to take on the function booking officer, replacing police officers. Court Services has an establishment of 769 members, comprised of 17 uniform positions and 752 civilian positions, working in criminal and civil court locations as well as Prisoner Transportation, DSS, CASC, Planning, Risk Management, Training and now as divisional bookers. In 2012, Court Services was responsible for: the continued detention and supervision of 80,851 persons in custody the transportation of 155,668 persons in custody serving 19,045 Subpoenas/Summonses processing 584,218 POTs (Part I) creating 34,777 Provincial Court Informations

Court Services Staffing - Uniform Number of Uniform Positions Positions Superintendent 1 Staff Inspector 1 Detective Sergeant 8 Sergeant/Detective 5 PC/DC 2 17 Total Uniform

Court Services Staffing - Civilian Civilian Positions Number of positions Assigned Special Constable Status # of Assigned Special Constable Positions 9 11 45 415 165 5 2* 8 2 16 678

Manager 1 no Location Admin. 9 yes Shift Supervisor 11 yes Supervisor 45 yes Court officer 415 yes Part time court officer 165 yes Custodial Officer 5 yes A08 - Civilian 1 no A07 - Civilian 1 no A06 - Civilian 3 yes A05 - Civilian 32 no A04/35 - Civilian 38 no A04/40 - Civilian 8 yes Supervisor/DSS 2 yes Document Server 16 yes 752 Total Civilian Total Civilian & 769 Uniform *one class 6 position in DSS does not require special constable status

Since 2006, key efficiencies, specialized service delivery and increased responsibilities were identified and Court Services staffing changes were approved and implemented through the following methods: At its meeting on April 26, 2007, the Board approved a motion (Min. No. P174/07 refers) which resulted in an increase in: 90 full time positions due to new court room openings including 1 Sr. Admin Court Officer (shift supervisor) 6 Senior Court Officers (supervisor) 83 Court Officers 3 Department Of Justice (DOJ) disclosure clerks

At its meeting on June 14, 2007, the Board approved a motion (Min. No. P213/07 refers) which established the civilian coordinator position, which was reclassified to manager in 2010.

At its meeting on November 15, 2007, the Board approved a motion (Min. No P386/07 refers) which resulted in the hiring of 24 disclosure clerks. At its meeting on August 26, 2010, the Board approved a motion (Min. No. P226/10 refers) to hire 10 court officers and 1 supervisor to fulfill legislated security requirements at new POA court locations. During the years 2009 2011 Court Services Unit underwent a reorganization which resulted in the following: decrease of 10 court officer positions increase of 10 supervisor positions transfer of 10 uniform positions out of Court Services decrease in Uniform Senior Officer Position Staff Inspector

Court Services Staffing Establishment Changes from 2006 to 2013 2006 2013 Uniform Positions Superintendent 1 1 Staff Inspector 2 1 Detective Sergeant 8 8 Sergeant/Detective 12 5 Police Const./Detective 7 2 Const. 30 17 Total Uniform 2006 2013 Civilian Positions Manager Location Administrator Shift Supervisor Supervisor Court officer Part Time Court Officer Custodial Officer A08 - Civilian A07- Civilian A06 - Civilian A05 - Civilian A04/35- Civilian A04/40 - Civilian Supervisor/DSS Document Server Total Civilian Total Civilian & Uniform 7 4 36 330 190 5 1 1 3 8 38 8 1 16 651 681 1 9 11 45 415 * 165 5 1 1 3 32 38 8 2 16 752 769

*As of April 17, 2013, sixty-one (61) court officers are currently being deployed as booking officers in Divisional Policing Command Special Constable Appointments Special Constable Status is conferred upon members when entering a position with duties that require the special constable status. With this Status members are able to enforce the Criminal Code of Canada (s25, s495), Public Works Protection Act (s2, s3), The City of Toronto Act (s103) and the Courts of Justice Act (s137). The appointment of members as special constables is managed actively by both Court Services and the Special Constable Liaison office. At any given time some members of Court Services may not have special constable status due to medical or administrative restrictions. Each Special Constable application for appointment describes the purpose for which special constable status is being requested: Purpose of Appointment - Court Officer & Court Supervisor: Searching, guarding and management of persons in custody; providing for the safety and security of persons in custody, staff and members of the public; service or execution of legal documents and warrants and other court orders; transportation of persons in custody. Purpose of Appointment - DSS (Document Server, Document Services Supervisor & Duty Clerk) Serving court processes and swearing to informations as a common informant within the Province of Ontario. Purpose of Appointment - Custodial Officer Searching, guarding and management of persons in custody. Year by Year Breakdown A year by year breakdown showing the number of appointments each year since the first appointments are only available back to 2008 as previous years were not tracked by the Service. While the Board Minute made a reference to there being 619 court officers, the current number is actually 678. The number of members appointed as special constables can fluctuate month to month due to normal staffing changes (ie: retirement, resignation, transfer and accommodations). *Appointment or Reappointment 158 198 109 35 129 Resignation, Retirement 34 20 19 17 11 Transfer to P.C. 35 16 4 11 Transfer to other unit 2 1 1Transfer in from other unit 1 2 1 1

Year 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012

Hired 48 75 25 21

2013 77 9 (to date) *inclusive of court officer, custodial officer, supervisor, duty clerk. Conclusion:

Court Services fulfills a critical operational and legislative requirement for the Service. In the early 1980's, the Service initiated the hiring of civilian personnel to fill the position of court officer to take on duties previously assigned to police officers. As civilianisation has evolved, the Citys demand for additional court rooms increased and additional responsibilities were added, Court Services has responded to work successfully in an increasingly complex environment. Deputy Chief Mark Saunders, Specialized Operations Command, will be in attendance to answer any questions that the Board may have regarding this report. Respectfully submitted,

William Blair, C.O.M. Chief of Police WB/swk Filename:court_services_staffing_and_special_constables.doc

8. April 24, 2013 from William Blair, Chief of Police Re: Integrated Records and Information System Project Staffing Implications April 24, 2013

To:

Chair and Members Toronto Police Services Board William Blair Chief of Police INTEGRATED RECORDS AND INFORMATION SYSTEM (IRIS) PROJECT STAFFING IMPLICATIONS

From:

Subject:

Recommendation: It is recommended that the Board receive this report. Financial Implications: There are no financial implications relating to the recommendation contained within this report. Background/Purpose: The Board, at its meeting of June 15, 2012, considered a report from the Chief of Police in relation to the electronic disclosure system award of contract for product and services, and the entering into a licensing and software maintenance agreement with eJust Systems Inc. for a specified period (Min. No. P149/12 refers). Following consideration of this report, the Board approved the following motions: 1) That the Board approve a contract for the delivery of professional services in relation to the acquisition and implementation of an electronic disclosure system to eJust Systems Inc. at a cost not to exceed $360,000 (including taxes); 2) That the Board approve entering into a licencing and software maintenance contract with eJust Systems Inc. at an estimated cost of $630,000 per year (including taxes) for a five year period commencing from the date of implementation of the system (expected to be November 1, 2013) for a total cost of $3.15 million over the contract term; 3) That the Board authorize the Chair and Vice-Chair to execute any required agreements and related documents on behalf of the Board, subject to the conditions approved by the Board in the in camera meeting (Min. No. C181/12 refers), and approval as to form by the City Solicitor; and 4) That the Chief of Police provide a report on any staffing reductions that may occur as a result of moving to the electronic disclosure system.

The purpose of this report is to inform the Board of the projected staffing implications resulting from the Integrated Records and Information System (IRIS) project and the implementation of the Versadex police operations management system and the eJust electronic disclosure system. Discussion: In October 2011, the Board approved the award of contract for the supply and delivery of software, maintenance, and professional services to Versaterm Inc. in relation to the acquisition and implementation of a police operations management system (Min. No. P262/11 refers). Electronic disclosure capabilities were envisioned as part of the business process change that would support the achievement of optimal benefits from the Integrated Records and Information System (IRIS) implementation. The eJust charge management system fully integrates with Versadex and extracts information seamlessly from the police operations management system to enable the transmission of disclosure material to the courts in an electronic format (Min. No. P149/12 refers). A determination of the future state business processes and staffing implications stemming from the IRIS project is linked to the implementation of both major technology elements (Versadex and eJust). As the Service prepares for implementation in Q4 2013, numerous site visits and consultations with police agency partners across the province were held to establish best practices currently in place in law enforcement agencies using Versadex and the eJust charge management products. As a result of this research, coupled with consultations with internal and external stakeholders, the Service does not envision any staffing reductions but rather full time equivalent (FTE) efficiency savings through improved operational business processes. For example, it has been determined that centralized occurrence review and centralized disclosure are the preferred business models. By centralizing these two key operational functions, and bridging the technology of the new police operations management and electronic disclosure software, it will provide the Service with the operational ability to realize substantial benefits including optimal utilization of available resources. Existing job functions and staffing levels across the Service have been examined at length to identify the number of positions where job duties will change with the automation and streamlining resulting from the project implementation. It must be noted that the Service is still in the planning stage but preliminary estimates indicate that approximately 50 civilian positions will be made available for reinvestment. The Service will utilize this FTE efficiency savings to assist in staffing the new operational business functions introduced by the IRIS project centralized occurrence review, centralized disclosure, the Master Name Index process, and sustainment. Any remaining shortfall in staffing these functions will be found from within; the Service will not require any new hires. As stated above, the Service is in the planning phase with regards to the staffing of the new operational business functions. Discussions are on-going with Toronto Police Service Human

Resources, Labour Relations, and Toronto Police Association representatives in preparation for staffing to be place by Q4 2013. Training plans are underway to enable the redeployment of personnel in the new, automated environment. As well, work has also been initiated with respect to facility and equipment requirements. A more comprehensive assessment of how staff will be realigned to coincide with the IRIS implementation will be available Q3 2013. Conclusion: It is anticipated that the police operations management system and the electronic disclosure system will be in place and fully operational by Q4 2013. It is not anticipated that there will any staff reductions as a result of the IRIS project implementation but rather the opportunity for the Service to realize FTE efficiency savings through automation and streamlining of business processes. These person savings will be reinvested to align with the new operational business functions that will be introduced by the project. The Board will continue to be kept apprised of the overall staffing implications stemming from the IRIS project. A more definitive assessment of the full staffing impact associated with the IRIS project implementation will be available Q3 2013. Deputy Chief Peter Sloly, Divisional Policing Command, will be in attendance to answer any questions that the Board may have. Respectfully submitted,

William Blair, C.O.M. Chief of Police KY/lc Electronic Disclosure_Staffing.doc

9. (A) March 06, 2013 from William Blair, Chief of Police Re: Annual Report 2012 Public Sector Salary Disclosure Deferred from the March 27, 2013 meeting. March 6, 2013

To:

Chair and Members Toronto Police Services Board William Blair Chief of Police ANNUAL REPORT: 2012 PUBLIC SECTOR SALARY DISCLOSURE

From:

Subject:

Recommendation: It is recommended that the Board receive this report. Financial Implications: There are no financial implications relating to the recommendation contained in this report. Background/Purpose: The Public Sector Salary Disclosure Act, 1996 (PSSDA) and the Public Sector Salary Disclosure Amendment Act, 2004 were passed to make Ontarios public sector more open and accountable to taxpayers. Therefore, in accordance with the PSSDA, the Toronto Police Service (TPS) is required to disclose the names, positions, salaries and taxable benefits of employees who were paid $100,000 or more in a year. The report includes active, retired and terminated members. This information, which includes Toronto Police Service and Toronto Police Services Board employees, is also submitted to the City of Toronto Pension, Payroll and Employee Benefits Division for inclusion in a corporate report filed, by the City, with the Ministry of Municipal Affairs and Housing. Beginning in 2009, the Ministry of Finance requires that organizations with members seconded to other ministries file the listing of those members with the appropriate ministry. For the 2012 reporting year, TPS had 24 members seconded to the Ministry of Community Safety and Correctional Services. A separate listing of the members appearing on the Public Sector Salary Disclosure listing has also been provided to that agency. Discussion:

The Public Sector Salary Disclosure Act, 1996 defines Salary Paid as the amount paid by the employer to the employee in a given year, as reported on the T4 slip (Box 14 minus Taxable Benefits total). The salary paid amount includes regular salary, acting pay, premium pay (including court time, call backs and overtime), and retroactive adjustments paid in 2012. In 2012, the definition of salary was amended to include per diems and/or retainers paid by an organization to an individual who is a director or holder of office elected or appointed under the authority of an Act of Ontario. Furthermore, in 2010, the Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) altered T4 reporting requirements. Consequently, payments to members for retiring allowances, such as sick pay gratuities, are now reported on the T4. However, such amounts are not reported in Box 14 and therefore do not require disclosure as salary paid. Taxable benefits are reported as a separate line item. Taxable benefits for TPS members include the value of life insurance premiums for coverage provided by the employer and employerprovided parking. Taxable benefits also include an amount for the standby charge and operating benefit of being assigned and utilizing an employer provided vehicle for non-business related travel. Number of Employees on the 2012 Disclosure Listing (Appendix A Alphabetic order and Appendix B Descending order by salary paid): In 2012, 3,181 employees earned more than $100,000. This total includes 1,770 employees whose base salary is normally under $100,000. The earnings for these employees were the result of their combined base salary, premium pay and other payouts such as final vacation pay. Normally, the TPS has 26 payrolls in any given year. However, the 2012 year contained 27 pay periods, an occurrence that happens once every 11 years in organizations with a bi-weekly pay process. For 2012, the 27th pay was made on December 31, 2012. All 27 payrolls were included in T4 balances for 2012. Furthermore, in January 2012, senior officers received retroactive pay for the 2011 salary settlement and in April 2012, the TPS reached an agreement with Public Safety Canada regarding the overtime hours worked by senior officers during the 2010 G20 event. As a result, senior officers were reimbursed overtime hours over and above their regular earnings, which contributed to their salary paid amount on their T4. The foregoing factors contributed to senior officers earnings being higher than their base salaries. Base salaries have increased over the years due to contract settlements. The following table depicts the salary ranges for uniform positions during 2012, the number of employees in each category at December 31, 2012 and the corresponding number of members appearing on the Public Sector Salary Disclosure report for the 2012 year. The number of employees differs since the listing is for the entire year, and captured at the members rank at the end of the year, whereas the employee total is only shown for the end of the year at a point in time. Category Salary range at Salary range at Employees per Numbers January 1, 2012 July 1, 2012 HR system at category December 31, PSSD 2012 per on

Detective Sgt/Staff $106,812 Sgt 114,470 Detective/Sergeant $96,599 104,260 Plainclothes/Training $90,857 Constable 98,518 Police Constables $85,107 92,770

to $108,392 116,164 to $98,030 105,803 to $92,202 99,975 to $86,366 94,144

to 274 to 971 to 1,132 to 3,039

274 957 842 904

The table above shows that the majority of members at the Detective/Sergeant rank and that all members at the Detective/Staff Sergeant rank earn a base salary over $100,000. Premium pay is the result of court attendance, overtime earned when members work beyond their regular shift and call-backs when members are requested to return to work for various operational reasons or special projects. For example, in 2012, the continuation of the Toronto Anti-Violence Intervention Strategy (TAVIS) initiative increased the number of call-backs and therefore, the premium pay earned by members. Provincial TAVIS grant funds are used to fund these call-backs. In addition, members earned premium pay as part of the Summer Safety Initiative. Premium pay is carefully managed, and the TPS has significatly reduced premium pay costs over the last two years. However, some premium pay (e.g. court time) is unavoidable and increases members earnings, and therefore is a contributing factor to the number of TPS members who earned more than $100,000. 24 members of the TPS seconded to the Ministry of Community Safety and Correctional Services have been included in the complete report as their earnings exceeded $100,000 for the 2012 year. Paid Duty Earnings: Most paid duty requests are centrally managed and distributed to units. Members are paid for the hours worked on paid duties by the individuals or businesses requesting the service. The Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) requires that paid duty earnings be reported on a T4 separate from members regular earnings. As a result of this change in reporting, the TPS contacted the Ministry of Finance to determine if there was now a requirement to report paid duty earnings as part of the Public Sector Salary Disclosure listing. The Ministry has confirmed that since the officers are being paid by the client, the earnings are not considered salary paid under the PSSDA. Therefore, members paid duty earnings have no impact on and are not taken into account in the preparation of the TPS public sector salary disclosure listing. The TPS is working on the implementation of an on-line paid duty system that will change how paid duties are administered. In order to comply with CRA statutory deduction and garnishment requirements, the TPS plans to begin paying officers who perform paid duties directly and

requiring the client to pay the TPS for the entire amount of the paid duty and not just the administrative fee and vehicle/equipment rentals as is currently done. Once this change is made, the TPS will again contact the Ministry of Finance to determine if this administrative change has impacted the PSSD requirement. Conclusion: In accordance with the PSSDA, this report provides the names, positions, salaries and taxable benefits of TPS and Board employees who were paid more than $100,000 in 2012. The information is provided in alphabetical order as required by the Ministry and in salary paid descending order as requested previously by the Board. The report is provided to the Board for information, and has been forwarded to the City for inclusion in a corporate report filed with the Ministry of Municipal Affairs and Housing. Mr. Tony Veneziano, Chief Administrative Officer, Administrative Command, will be in attendance to answer any questions from the Board. Respectfully submitted,

William Blair, C.O.M. Chief of Police /SAC Filename: annual report 2012 public sector salary disclosure.doc

Appendix A RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Given Name Position SOPHIA SEHER Police Constable DEBORAH LYNN Staff Sergeant MAHER Detective AL RAHIM Senior Technical Analyst HOVIG Police Constable MATHEW CHRISTOPHER Plainclothes Police Constable SHERI DARLENE Detective RICHARD ANTHONY Police Constable CHRISTOPHER ALLAN Police Constable EDWARD HIERONIM Detective BARBARA ANNE Detective MICHAEL JASON Sergeant BRADLEY DEAN Police Constable CLAYTON EDWARD Detective JAMES GRAHAM Sergeant DIANA LOUISE Sergeant ROBERT Senior Technical Analyst STEVEN CABRAL Police Constable MANDEEP SINGH Police Constable MANSOOR Police Constable SYED OMAR Police Constable ANTONIO Plainclothes Police Constable SCOTT DOUGLAS Plainclothes Police Constable LUCILE VERITY Plainclothes Police Constable SHAWN CAMPBELL Police Constable AARON JOSEPH Plainclothes Police Constable WALID Police Constable ALI TALIB Police Constable VIJEYAKUMAR Parking Enforcement Officer ADELIO PERADA Police Constable JASON JOHN Sergeant PASQUALE Plainclothes Police Constable IRVIN JOHN Plainclothes Police Constable JEFFERY PAUL Sergeant LUKASZ Police Constable BRENDAN JAMES Police Constable CHRISTOS Police Constable CHARLES BOLTON Detective DAVID WALTER Detective LYNNE MARIE Plainclothes Police Constable DEMITRIOS Plainclothes Police Constable ASIF IFTIKHAR Sergeant GAVIN RAYMOND Police Constable SCOTT DOUGLAS Police Constable GORDON SCOTT Police Constable DARREN LEE Detective MICHAEL DAVID Detective NICHOLAS DAVID Plainclothes Police Constable JEFFREY SCOTT Detective ELAINE HUNTER Sergeant MARK ANDREW Staff Sergeant WADE LEONARD Staff Sergeant ANTHONY CHRISTOPHER Police Constable DOMENIC JOESPH Plainclothes Police Constable JORGE DAVID Police Constable KENNETH LAWRENCE Police Constable SCOTT CHRISTOPHER Plainclothes Police Constable SEAN DAVID Police Constable ANIL Inspector CARL HENRIK Plainclothes Police Constable JAMES JOSEPH Plainclothes Police Constable WILLIAM JASON Training Constable JOHN PAUL Police Constable SARAH LYNN Sergeant IULIAN Police Constable ALEXANDRU Plainclothes Police Constable DARREN RONALD Police Constable JOHN DOUGLAS Plainclothes Police Constable ALI AKBAR Detective JASON CHRISTOPHER Plainclothes Police Constable

Surname ABBASI ABBOTT ABDEL-MALIK ABDULLA ABKARIAN ABRAMOVITZ ACCIAROLI ACHAIBAR ACORN ADACH ADAM ADAM ADAMS ADAMS ADAMSON ADDERLEY AGNEW AGUIAR AHLUWALIA AHMAD AHMAD AIELLO AIKMAN AIRD AITKEN AKESON AL-NASS AL-ROUBAIAI ALAGURAS ALAMAG ALBANESE ALBERGA ALBRECHT ALDERDICE ALEKSANDROWICZ ALEXA ALEXAKIS ALEXANDER ALEXANDER ALEXANDER ALEXIOU ALI ALIAS ALLAN ALLDREAD ALLDRIT ALLEN ALLEY ALLINGTON ALLISON ALPHONSO ALPHONSO ALS ALTOBELLO ALVAREZ AMBLER AMLIN AMOS ANAND ANDERSEN ANDREJISHYN ANDREW ANDREWS ANDREWS ANDRICI ANDRUS ANGUS ANGUS ANSARI ANSTEY

Salary Paid $ 103,499.53 $ 122,422.25 $ 124,308.56 $ 121,894.14 $ 100,699.76 $ 106,768.38 $ 116,815.21 $ 104,973.25 $ 136,438.24 $ 109,152.49 $ 115,237.08 $ 109,422.74 $ 100,729.33 $ 123,603.15 $ 109,833.87 $ 106,993.03 $ 104,869.36 $ 118,417.03 $ 101,146.24 $ 100,335.73 $ 103,440.63 $ 122,862.91 $ 117,709.06 $ 100,134.72 $ 100,633.50 $ 114,354.24 $ 120,417.03 $ 104,932.37 $ 109,575.04 $ 100,550.33 $ 108,949.00 $ 109,238.05 $ 126,484.99 $ 113,023.01 $ 115,759.42 $ 114,015.39 $ 123,334.81 $ 114,583.30 $ 123,784.77 $ 113,233.16 $ 107,280.57 $ 104,546.86 $ 107,306.85 $ 105,577.57 $ 107,989.22 $ 126,720.89 $ 116,785.97 $ 102,096.99 $ 121,128.09 $ 108,771.97 $ 121,646.27 $ 119,793.37 $ 101,017.45 $ 114,642.05 $ 100,350.06 $ 100,703.16 $ 124,794.92 $ 107,075.89 $ 148,574.70 $ 125,265.27 $ 101,491.28 $ 102,674.10 $ 102,999.32 $ 106,662.82 $ 120,720.22 $ 100,928.19 $ 108,237.63 $ 113,516.51 $ 106,453.60 $ 119,993.70

Benefits $662.93 $744.60 $701.67 $280.88 $658.58 $678.70 $701.67 $657.76 $669.95 $717.06 $708.56 $701.67 $684.37 $701.67 $717.06 $708.56 $280.88 $669.95 $662.93 $669.95 $386.14 $686.42 $693.44 $693.44 $684.37 $686.42 $669.95 $662.93 $595.54 $676.70 $701.67 $686.42 $686.68 $701.93 $662.93 $675.34 $662.06 $717.06 $708.56 $686.16 $700.32 $701.67 $654.23 $670.20 $676.70 $717.06 $701.67 $666.29 $701.67 $717.06 $744.60 $744.60 $673.00 $678.70 $669.95 $684.37 $686.42 $678.56 $792.69 $700.32 $686.42 $685.20 $684.37 $683.99 $669.95 $678.70 $661.19 $674.22 $283.58 $683.37

Appendix A RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Given Name Position KEVIN FRANCIS Police Constable GIANPIERO Plainclothes Police Constable JOHN Detective G. DIMITRIOS Plainclothes Police Constable MARCEL Police Constable PAUL WILLIAM Police Constable BRIAN CHRISTOPHER Police Constable BENJAMIN GONZALO Police Constable PEDRAM Police Constable CHRISTOPHER RICHARD Police Constable DAVID LAWRENCE Patrol Supervisor FREDERICK SHANE Plainclothes Police Constable KAREN Police Constable MARK RICHARD Sergeant RICHARD DAVID Staff Sergeant ROBERT KENNETH Plainclothes Police Constable ROBERT PAUL Plainclothes Police Constable ROBERT WILLIAM Plainclothes Police Constable SANJEE Detective JAMES ANDREW Plainclothes Police Constable SANDRA Plainclothes Police Constable PEGLAR Plainclothes Police Constable GERRARD NIMALAN Training Constable MARK NICHOLAS Detective AILEEN ALBERTA Director of Human Resources PAUL ALEXANDER Plainclothes Police Constable ROBERT EDWARD Police Constable GLENN ANDRE Detective SHAUN DAVID Police Constable ANDREI Police Constable ROBERT Police Constable CHERRY MAXINE Police Constable GRAHAM STEPHEN Plainclothes Police Constable JAMES JONATHAN Police Constable JEFFREY BRUCE Detective Sergeant JANE MARILYN Sergeant DAVID FRANCIS Police Constable ASHRAF SAMIR Sergeant JOSE MATIAS Detective JOHN JAMES Staff Sergeant JARED MICHAEL Sergeant SUSAN ZACHARIAH Group Leader CHRISTOPHER DAVID Sergeant LESLIE DOUGLAS Detective ANDREW MARTIN Training Constable KENRICK PATRICE Plainclothes Police Constable ROBERT BRUCE Plainclothes Police Constable JAMES SIMON Police Constable DON XIN Police Constable KENNETH Police Constable PAUL CRAIG Sergeant KAREN ANN Police Constable STANISLAW Sergeant JASON ROBERT Police Constable RICHARD JAMES Sergeant RICHARD TIMOTHY Training Constable FAIZAL ANTHONY Police Constable DANIEL ALAN Police Constable ARTUR Plainclothes Police Constable KOWSIHAN Plainclothes Police Constable ANDREW SEBASTIAN Police Constable MICHAEL ANDREW Detective JEFFREY Detective DONNA Detective WAYNE MICHAEL Detective Sergeant ROBIN HORATIO Sergeant SANTI Police Constable CHARLENE Staff Sergeant ROBERT SCOTT Inspector ANTONIO Sergeant MICHELLE TERESA Detective

Surname ANTOINE ANTONELLI APOSTOLIDIS APOSTOLOPOULOS AQUILINA ARBUS ARCAND ARDILES ARMANI ARMSTRONG ARMSTRONG ARMSTRONG ARMSTRONG ARMSTRONG ARMSTRONG ARMSTRONG ARMSTRONG ARNOTT ARODA ARP ARRUDA ARTINIAN ARULANANDAM ASHLEY ASHMAN ASKIN ASNER ASSELIN ASSELSTINE ASTAPKOVICH ASTOLFO ATKINS ATKINSON ATKINSON ATTENBOROUGH AUCLAIR AUDETTE AWAD AZARRAGA BABIAR BABINEAU BABUJI BACHLY BACKUS BACON BAGNALL BAGSHAW BAHULA BAI BAILIE BAINARD BAIRD BAJ BAKER BAKER BAKER BAKSH BALACHOREK BALAGA BALASUBRAMANIAM BALET BALINT BANGILD BANKS BANKS BANTON BANYAEM BAPTIST BAPTIST BARATTO BARATTO

Salary Paid $ 113,424.25 $ 110,009.10 $ 118,480.90 $ 102,475.65 $ 105,871.14 $ 100,452.49 $ 105,776.77 $ 101,047.69 $ 100,448.09 $ 108,634.07 $ 110,448.42 $ 114,660.87 $ 106,795.79 $ 120,398.76 $ 116,551.88 $ 125,333.20 $ 107,337.13 $ 116,834.20 $ 131,627.65 $ 125,806.87 $ 105,035.81 $ 105,560.93 $ 101,807.85 $ 122,884.83 $ 211,089.35 $ 113,934.56 $ 104,778.35 $ 118,320.75 $ 127,764.42 $ 100,080.89 $ 110,501.36 $ 101,175.93 $ 104,295.90 $ 106,068.72 $ 124,608.04 $ 111,164.33 $ 132,176.44 $ 112,251.31 $ 123,509.98 $ 156,179.03 $ 110,534.12 $ 108,458.76 $ 112,499.14 $ 120,559.83 $ 101,346.97 $ 104,462.38 $ 105,771.54 $ 111,886.02 $ 103,484.79 $ 101,378.14 $ 113,659.87 $ 101,452.46 $ 122,902.79 $ 103,345.64 $ 101,196.92 $ 101,938.26 $ 104,550.20 $ 104,640.93 $ 127,737.03 $ 107,233.36 $ 105,648.60 $ 129,684.82 $ 130,667.86 $ 106,151.44 $ 140,864.72 $ 107,263.81 $ 111,571.79 $ 119,640.87 $ 152,765.52 $ 103,347.15 $ 125,642.37

Benefits $682.76 $687.86 $701.67 $662.93 $669.95 $679.71 $662.93 $667.87 $669.95 $675.44 $616.46 $686.42 $682.76 $717.06 $312.74 $686.42 $686.42 $700.32 $701.67 $686.42 $686.42 $686.42 $685.20 $717.06 $1,164.17 $686.42 $669.17 $714.50 $662.93 $665.53 $400.05 $669.95 $686.42 $684.37 $738.48 $480.96 $684.37 $701.67 $708.56 $744.60 $701.67 $171.41 $701.67 $717.06 $685.20 $678.70 $700.32 $642.32 $669.95 $684.37 $717.06 $684.37 $717.06 $669.95 $701.67 $693.44 $662.93 $669.95 $686.42 $671.99 $662.93 $701.67 $276.69 $566.90 $744.60 $708.56 $663.97 $650.16 $949.04 $504.02 $717.06

Appendix A RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Given Name Position TRISHA Police Constable TAMMY LYNN Police Constable JAMES FRANCIS Police Constable GLENN KARL Detective Sergeant MARK EDWIN Inspector MURRAY WINSTANLEY Detective WALLACE CRISPIN Plainclothes Police Constable TIMOTHY MICHAEL Police Constable FRANCISCO JAVIER Staff Sergeant NELSON Plainclothes Police Constable BERTRAND STANLEY Plainclothes Police Constable MICHAEL STEVEN Detective Sergeant ALAN ANDREW Police Constable DANIEL ALBERTO Police Constable JASON MITCHELL Police Constable HANNAH FAY Plainclothes Police Constable DAVID ERIC Detective LORNE WILLIAM Police Constable STEVEN JEFFREY Sergeant BARRY MICHAEL Police Constable KIMBERLEY MICHELE Detective SANDY Staff Sergeant TIMOTHY BRIAN Sergeant WAYNE EDWARD Detective ANDREW ISTVAN Sergeant JACQUELINE SANDRA Sergeant JOHN ARTHUR Police Constable BRIAN GEORGE Detective BENJAMIN JAMES Plainclothes Police Constable CHRISTOPHER DENNIS Sergeant SHANE REGINALD Police Constable JOSEPH ANDRE Police Constable SACHA LUCY Plainclothes Police Constable PAUL JOSEPH Sergeant MARC Plainclothes Police Constable JOANNA RUTH Inspector CHRISTOPHER Police Constable CLAY ALBERT Manager of Radio and Electronics MARCEL ARMAND Plainclothes Police Constable DANIEL JOSEPH Sergeant DONALD RENE Staff Sergeant LISA GABRIELLE Plainclothes Police Constable DANIEL Detective Sergeant DARYL EDWARD Plainclothes Police Constable KATHLEEN BRIGID Plainclothes Police Constable NEIL GREGORY Police Constable FRANCOIS MARIE Plainclothes Police Constable NEIL DOUGLAS Plainclothes Police Constable LAURENT HUGUES Police Constable CORINNE Detective Sergeant ANTHONY Police Constable DIANNA Police Constable MARK DANIEL Detective RICHARD FERREIRA Plainclothes Police Constable PAUL Plainclothes Police Constable MARIANO JOSEPH Training Constable BRIAN ROBERT Sergeant JOANNE Detective TREVOR Sergeant WINSTON ANTHONY Staff Sergeant PETER Plainclothes Police Constable CHRISTOPHER JOHN Police Constable HORST ALBERT Police Constable JASON REGIS Plainclothes Police Constable LISABET JANE Detective Sergeant RODNEY WELLON Plainclothes Police Constable CHRISTOPHER JOHN Plainclothes Police Constable RENNIE Detective JOHN Detective ROBERT NESTOR Plainclothes Police Constable MICHAEL ANDREW Sergeant

Surname BARBERO BARCLAY BARDGETT BARENTHIN BARKLEY BARNES BARNES BARNHARDT BARREDO BARREIRA BARRETTO BARSKY BARTLETT BARTLETT BARTLETT BARTZ BARWELL BASS BASSINGTHWAITE BATES BATES BATES BATES BATES BATOR BAUS BAYES BEADMAN BEARD BEATTIE BEAUDOIN BEAULAC BEAULAC BEAUPARLANT BEAUSOLEIL BEAVEN-DESJARDINS BECKWITH BEERS BEGIN BELANGER BELANGER BELANGER BELL BELL BELL BELLAND BELLEC BELLEFEUILLE BELLION BELLON BELMONTE BENALLICK BENALLICK BENEVIDES BENGE BENINCASA BENNETT BENNETT BENNETT BENNETT BENNEY BENNOCH BENOIT BENOIT BENOIT BENSON BENTLEY BERCHARD BEREZOWSKI BEREZOWSKY BERG

Salary Paid $ 107,600.45 $ 110,425.52 $ 111,668.43 $ 121,442.63 $ 147,915.06 $ 119,418.17 $ 107,369.91 $ 108,923.62 $ 134,687.50 $ 110,358.05 $ 103,726.64 $ 137,236.17 $ 109,042.23 $ 101,068.99 $ 100,792.39 $ 104,459.89 $ 118,780.42 $ 121,955.65 $ 106,073.73 $ 139,067.32 $ 123,601.15 $ 119,254.41 $ 110,205.19 $ 133,294.76 $ 109,066.06 $ 104,753.22 $ 116,126.65 $ 108,275.20 $ 109,875.56 $ 101,551.50 $ 104,704.31 $ 103,472.53 $ 111,034.87 $ 126,789.28 $ 116,050.22 $ 155,054.63 $ 105,768.49 $ 162,020.38 $ 103,402.34 $ 115,992.15 $ 124,812.31 $ 100,781.87 $ 184,684.52 $ 107,075.60 $ 105,987.97 $ 102,323.55 $ 135,664.44 $ 102,667.37 $ 128,046.55 $ 119,413.92 $ 100,965.50 $ 102,704.87 $ 114,112.11 $ 108,592.88 $ 107,858.71 $ 101,433.66 $ 108,017.20 $ 105,919.12 $ 107,199.78 $ 125,396.87 $ 121,382.12 $ 112,816.35 $ 101,215.43 $ 109,529.67 $ 105,843.53 $ 109,031.43 $ 112,039.26 $ 109,870.57 $ 116,226.96 $ 100,132.10 $ 114,643.24

Benefits $654.23 $669.95 $684.37 $744.60 $792.69 $701.67 $678.70 $662.93 $744.60 $686.42 $686.42 $744.60 $680.68 $662.93 $675.18 $686.42 $292.08 $684.37 $686.98 $259.39 $717.06 $319.62 $717.06 $717.06 $717.06 $670.19 $669.95 $708.56 $686.42 $685.16 $662.93 $669.95 $673.82 $711.97 $696.19 $949.04 $674.83 $823.06 $700.32 $708.56 $703.83 $686.42 $602.94 $686.42 $700.32 $669.95 $686.42 $275.34 $669.95 $602.94 $684.37 $676.70 $708.56 $678.70 $700.32 $683.98 $675.80 $708.56 $286.99 $742.00 $700.32 $667.87 $673.95 $686.42 $689.30 $686.42 $686.42 $717.06 $717.06 $693.44 $701.67

Appendix A RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Given Name Position FRANCIS Superintendent CYNTHIA LEE Plainclothes Police Constable DAVID ANTHONY Plainclothes Police Constable EDUARDO MADEIROS Training Constable ISRAEL FARIA Sergeant KEVIN Police Constable JOSHUA MICHAEL Police Constable STEPHEN ROGER Sergeant KIMBERLY Plainclothes Police Constable DAVID RUSSELL Plainclothes Police Constable MARK WILLIAM Sergeant GORDON Training Constable WILLIAM Detective KATHRYN ANNE Detective LYNN Plainclothes Police Constable DONALD Manager of Corporate Planning FILIPPO Detective GIULIO Police Constable ELLA ELIZABETH Police Constable HARJEET SINGH Police Constable RAJAN-SINGH Police Constable DANIELA Plainclothes Police Constable CHRISTOPHER ROLAND Police Constable STEPHEN Sergeant DAVID ANDREW Training Constable MICHAEL DOUGLAS Police Constable SACHBINDER SINGH Sergeant JOHN THOMAS Plainclothes Police Constable ALLAN SCOTT Plainclothes Police Constable ANNE-MARIE Staff Sergeant DAVID Detective Sergeant LEONA Sergeant STEPHEN Detective KIRAN Plainclothes Police Constable PAUL MARCEL Sergeant JANELLE RUTH Plainclothes Police Constable FREDERICK Detective GUY Sergeant ARLINGTON Staff Sergeant JEFFREY KELVIN Police Constable WILLIAM STERLING Chief of Police JANICE Sergeant RICHARD Staff Sergeant STUART WILLIAM Sergeant ANDREW FREDDY Police Constable RICHARD ROBERT Sergeant CORY Inspector WARREN PETER Training Constable CHRISTOPHER EDWARD Staff Sergeant LOUIE MARK Plainclothes Police Constable PAUL ROBERT Sergeant NIKOLAJ Plainclothes Police Constable MARTHA ANN Senior Analyst KEVIN VICTOR Plainclothes Police Constable PETER JOHN Police Constable MARLIN Detective MICHELE LOUISE Plainclothes Police Constable KENNETH COURTLAND Detective GURMOKH Sergeant GURWINDER Detective MATTHEW PAUL Police Constable BRIAN Detective Sergeant SUSANNE JOSEPHENE Plainclothes Police Constable BORIS ILIEV Police Constable MARK ROBERT Plainclothes Police Constable MARCELINUS HENDRIKUS Plainclothes Police Constable CHRISTINE Manager of Human Resources JO-ANNE ELLEN Police Constable STEPHANIE ELIZABETH Police Constable DENNIS Police Constable WILLIAM Detective Sergeant

Surname BERGEN BERNARD BERNARD BERNARDO BERNARDO BERNOBIC BERRY BERRY BERTUCCA BESCO BESON BEVAN BEVAN BEVERIDGE BEVERIDGE BEVERS BEVILACQUA BEVILACQUA BHARDWAJ BHATHAL BHOGAL BIANCHI BIBEAU BILAK BILBY BINNS BIRING BIRRELL BISHOP BISHOP BISHOP BISHOP BISHOP BISLA BISSONNETTE BLACKADAR BLACKER BLACKLOCK BLACKMAN BLAIR BLAIR BLAKELEY BLANCHARD BLOWER BLUNK BOBBIS BOCKUS BODDAERT BODDY BOGLES BOIS BOKALO BOLCSO BOLDUC BONCARDO BOND BOND BOOTH BOPARA BOPARA BORCH BORG BORG BORISSOV BORNEMAN BORSBOOM BORTKIEWICZ BORTOLUSS BORUN BOSSERT BOSWARD

Salary Paid $ 172,938.53 $ 133,145.79 $ 103,155.65 $ 101,180.85 $ 124,466.77 $ 109,505.86 $ 108,303.75 $ 105,648.85 $ 100,120.40 $ 103,951.43 $ 106,238.15 $ 102,914.42 $ 120,047.33 $ 133,830.44 $ 108,459.77 $ 173,322.81 $ 118,460.05 $ 102,297.03 $ 106,120.69 $ 112,501.22 $ 107,211.73 $ 102,875.90 $ 107,853.54 $ 129,328.87 $ 100,056.30 $ 100,610.17 $ 105,729.30 $ 122,142.84 $ 110,866.35 $ 119,611.44 $ 125,973.80 $ 110,639.84 $ 132,519.93 $ 101,482.27 $ 112,984.80 $ 105,427.23 $ 108,656.01 $ 108,823.44 $ 121,118.80 $ 113,769.24 $ 367,719.94 $ 121,857.34 $ 123,052.90 $ 111,849.20 $ 101,462.76 $ 153,440.00 $ 156,530.22 $ 104,665.56 $ 120,454.13 $ 105,916.42 $ 116,353.11 $ 111,555.09 $ 105,228.21 $ 110,255.24 $ 109,985.99 $ 126,981.81 $ 105,430.02 $ 121,434.65 $ 117,965.19 $ 112,004.57 $ 100,769.75 $ 144,835.07 $ 111,590.98 $ 101,522.43 $ 103,021.25 $ 115,745.76 $ 157,154.20 $ 111,932.46 $ 100,816.49 $ 114,112.18 $ 125,532.38

Benefits $13,757.32 $686.42 $678.70 $685.20 $701.93 $662.93 $237.08 $369.05 $693.44 $678.70 $694.83 $700.32 $717.06 $717.06 $700.32 $1,038.45 $701.67 $669.95 $669.95 $662.93 $662.93 $687.11 $669.95 $610.54 $685.20 $676.70 $276.69 $693.44 $686.42 $737.72 $744.60 $717.06 $717.06 $686.42 $694.79 $686.68 $717.06 $717.06 $319.62 $669.95 $3,006.72 $717.06 $744.60 $701.67 $669.95 $701.67 $792.69 $685.20 $312.74 $678.70 $701.67 $700.32 $280.88 $686.42 $675.19 $292.08 $686.42 $744.60 $701.67 $708.56 $656.84 $319.62 $686.68 $662.93 $700.32 $686.42 $991.86 $669.95 $668.65 $676.70 $744.60

Appendix A RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Given Name Position BRYAN Inspector ROBERT DANIEL Detective SCOTT Detective JEAN PHILIP Plainclothes Police Constable DOUGLAS Sergeant ROCH ERIC Police Constable MARC ALAN Police Constable COLLEEN LISA Plainclothes Police Constable BRIAN Staff Sergeant MICHAEL GLEN Plainclothes Police Constable CHRISTOPHER GEORGE Plainclothes Police Constable RONALD Staff Sergeant ANDREW Police Constable EDWARD Inspector KAREN LINDA Plainclothes Police Constable DENIS Plainclothes Police Constable DAYNA KATHLEEN Plainclothes Police Constable JEREMY JEFFREY Sergeant JASON EDWARD Plainclothes Police Constable KENNETH Staff Sergeant LAURA ANN Police Constable SCOTT GORDON Detective CHRISTOPHER Police Constable KEITH Detective PETER GORDON Plainclothes Police Constable LORNE GORDON Detective MICHAEL JOSEPH Sergeant MICHAEL Detective DARRYL DERMOT Plainclothes Police Constable SHANE Staff Sergeant GURSHARNJIT SINGH Police Constable SHANE GURSHARAN Detective WALTER Sergeant JAMES RAYMOND Plainclothes Police Constable JAZEN LORNE Sergeant GEOFFREY ROBERT Plainclothes Police Constable WARREN SPENCER Plainclothes Police Constable FRANCIS Superintendent JAMES Training Constable LORENZO Detective JEAN Police Constable BRYAN DONALD Police Constable RENE ALYRE Plainclothes Police Constable CHRISTOPHER NEAL Plainclothes Police Constable NORMAN Detective Sergeant OMARI KAMAU Police Constable JOHN WILLIAM Police Constable SERGIO AGOSTINHO Police Constable FRANCES Sergeant AARON NATHANIEL Police Cadet-in-Training ALEXANDER Sergeant JAMES Detective TANYA LISETTE Police Constable LEVERNE MCCOURCEY Police Constable RALPH Staff Sergeant MICHAEL Plainclothes Police Constable PETER WERNER Police Constable SEAN Staff Sergeant PETER WILLIAM Plainclothes Police Constable DOUGLAS Sergeant JACQUELINE Plainclothes Police Constable JAMES Staff Sergeant ROBERT Staff Sergeant SCOTT DEREK Plainclothes Police Constable JIMMY Sergeant TERRENCE Detective Sergeant PAMELA Training Constable RICCARDO Training Constable GLEN WINSTON Police Constable DOMENICO D. Sergeant CHARLOTTE ANN Plainclothes Police Constable

Surname BOTT BOUCHER BOULET BOURGEOIS BOURQUE BOUVERAT BOWER BOWKER BOWMAN BOWMASTER BOWRY BOYCE BOYD BOYD BOYD BOYER BOYKO BOYKO BOYLE BOYLE BRABANT BRADBURY BRADLEY BRADSHAW BRADY BRAGG BRAKE BRAMMALL BRANKER BRANTON BRAR BRAR BRASCA BRAUND BRAUTIGAM BRAYMAN BREEDON BREEN BREMNER BRESSAN BRESSE BRETT BRIDEAU BRIGGS BRINN BRISCOE BRISTER BRITO BRITTON BROAD BROADFOOT BRONS BRONSEMA BROOKES BROOKES BROOKS BROSKE BROSNAN BROUGHTON BROWN BROWN BROWN BROWN BROWN BROWNE BROWNE BRUCE BRUNATO BRUNELLE BRUZZESE BRYAN

Salary Paid $ 148,704.41 $ 131,138.84 $ 114,178.70 $ 101,755.15 $ 123,011.37 $ 102,208.57 $ 101,094.53 $ 101,598.72 $ 129,089.81 $ 107,852.84 $ 103,442.46 $ 132,599.23 $ 109,461.02 $ 149,477.83 $ 102,793.49 $ 114,187.47 $ 102,351.93 $ 111,691.36 $ 104,826.14 $ 129,319.97 $ 100,727.33 $ 110,535.99 $ 100,291.49 $ 119,174.60 $ 100,532.31 $ 108,618.60 $ 108,855.72 $ 144,444.53 $ 101,260.57 $ 116,547.88 $ 121,018.69 $ 107,214.93 $ 121,443.47 $ 100,639.12 $ 107,971.74 $ 101,630.54 $ 106,067.39 $ 169,571.27 $ 102,606.60 $ 115,883.68 $ 111,137.22 $ 117,756.46 $ 107,980.49 $ 100,230.37 $ 119,292.74 $ 107,563.69 $ 105,529.12 $ 115,836.73 $ 117,329.63 $ 100,324.09 $ 111,071.46 $ 128,858.69 $ 101,849.87 $ 125,995.94 $ 120,384.81 $ 103,348.34 $ 103,991.61 $ 121,930.29 $ 122,488.43 $ 119,393.39 $ 113,960.32 $ 128,666.28 $ 121,395.46 $ 108,472.11 $ 115,649.40 $ 138,979.30 $ 102,787.13 $ 104,418.11 $ 105,811.04 $ 109,576.55 $ 110,822.28

Benefits $792.69 $708.56 $717.06 $680.93 $717.06 $662.93 $662.93 $686.42 $744.60 $686.42 $678.85 $744.60 $669.95 $949.04 $558.66 $700.32 $686.42 $701.67 $683.98 $744.60 $662.93 $701.67 $676.70 $292.08 $673.82 $701.67 $717.06 $717.06 $678.70 $422.92 $669.95 $708.56 $717.06 $686.42 $701.67 $686.42 $681.54 $8,756.97 $700.32 $717.06 $526.21 $662.93 $686.42 $684.34 $744.60 $662.93 $536.83 $667.20 $717.06 $169.78 $715.78 $715.78 $682.76 $689.50 $744.60 $700.32 $684.37 $744.60 $686.42 $717.06 $693.44 $429.80 $744.60 $684.59 $717.06 $744.60 $700.32 $698.04 $670.56 $717.06 $684.34

Appendix A RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Given Name Position DAVID Police Constable KEITH XAVIER Sergeant ALAN MICHAEL Training Constable ROBERT FRANCIS Sergeant BOGUMIL Police Constable LAWRENCE NEIL Staff Sergeant GREGORY MICHAEL Plainclothes Police Constable DONALD Sergeant JAMES Plainclothes Police Constable TAM THACH Detective CALVIN MILORAD Police Constable NEIL Staff Sergeant WARREN JAMES Plainclothes Police Constable TROY Sergeant CHRISTOPHER JOHN Detective DARRYL WILFRED Plainclothes Police Constable GARY EDWIN Sergeant MICHAEL DAVID Police Constable SUSAN JOYCE Detective HERBERT Sergeant CHARLES DEAN Detective Sergeant DAVID JOSEPH Plainclothes Police Constable ANSON RICHARD Police Constable GRANT NEIL Staff Sergeant ROY BRIAN Police Constable STEPHEN GEORGE Sergeant SEAN KELLY Police Constable TIMOTHY SCOTT Sergeant SHAWN CECIL Detective HARRY SANTIAGO Police Constable PHILIP MICHAEL Plainclothes Police Constable CELESTE BARBARA Sergeant FASIEH UZ Police Constable STEPHEN MILLER Police Constable BERNADETTE Inspector DEREK JONATHAN Sergeant MICHAEL Police Constable ELIZABETH Superintendent ERASMO Plainclothes Police Constable JAMES MICHAEL Police Constable PAUL Sergeant ALAN WILLIAM Detective SANDRA ANGELA Manager of Financial Management PETER EDWARD Staff Sergeant BRIAN MICHAEL Detective JOSE Sergeant TOMMY Police Constable ALAN Plainclothes Police Constable NEIL ROBERT Police Constable EMANUELE Sergeant ANDREW JAMES Plainclothes Police Constable BRYAN EDWARD Detective CLAYTON DOUGLAS Detective DEBORAH ANNE Senior Operations Supervisor DONALD ALEXANDER Superintendent DOUGLAS Sergeant JOANNE ELIZABETH Executive Director, Police Services Board MARCIA Sergeant MICHELLE DIANE Sergeant MURRAY SMEATON Sergeant NICOLE Plainclothes Police Constable PHILLIP SCOTT Plainclothes Police Constable STEVEN D. Training Constable STEVEN JAMES Plainclothes Police Constable STEVEN ROBERT Plainclothes Police Constable ANTONIO Plainclothes Police Constable DAVID Plainclothes Police Constable ANGELO GIUSEPPE Police Constable MARK Training Constable PAUL BRET Police Constable MARLENE Plainclothes Police Constable

Surname BRYAN BRYAN BRYANT BRYCE BRYL BRYSON BUCHANAN BUCKLEY BUDDO BUI BULBROOK BULLOCK BULMER BURGESS BURKE BURKE BURKE BURKE BURKE BURKHOLDER BURKS BURLEY BURNETT BURNINGHAM BURNS BURNS BURNSIDE BURROWS BURRY BUSTOS BUTLER BUTT BUTT BUTT BUTTON BYERS BYERS BYRNES CACCAVALE CAIN CAISSIE CAKEBREAD CALIFARETTI CALLAGHAN CALLANAN CAMACHO CAMARA CAMERON CAMERON CAMPANILE CAMPBELL CAMPBELL CAMPBELL CAMPBELL CAMPBELL CAMPBELL CAMPBELL CAMPBELL CAMPBELL CAMPBELL CAMPBELL CAMPBELL CAMPBELL CAMPBELL CAMPOLI CANEPA CANNATA CANNELLA CANNING CANNING CANNON

Salary Paid $ 100,458.93 $ 113,948.62 $ 102,747.02 $ 110,148.86 $ 115,972.59 $ 135,071.90 $ 100,751.66 $ 115,237.70 $ 102,875.52 $ 137,924.99 $ 106,985.40 $ 119,419.94 $ 100,129.08 $ 115,009.92 $ 108,866.18 $ 102,526.36 $ 105,146.29 $ 123,776.53 $ 108,664.50 $ 109,942.90 $ 121,314.06 $ 119,863.87 $ 115,829.64 $ 120,473.84 $ 103,870.24 $ 108,973.53 $ 109,757.88 $ 104,215.04 $ 109,669.46 $ 115,117.59 $ 113,566.46 $ 113,170.47 $ 105,192.18 $ 106,300.75 $ 152,053.42 $ 112,004.21 $ 103,785.21 $ 176,693.63 $ 108,006.41 $ 101,051.25 $ 113,640.31 $ 115,448.93 $ 157,556.04 $ 133,923.92 $ 112,757.34 $ 111,874.51 $ 101,403.06 $ 110,222.87 $ 100,104.79 $ 113,502.52 $ 107,083.08 $ 115,555.12 $ 106,188.26 $ 115,357.29 $ 174,083.24 $ 116,920.04 $ 172,745.23 $ 111,719.61 $ 123,307.45 $ 108,461.09 $ 118,754.31 $ 118,138.72 $ 102,791.79 $ 106,707.80 $ 135,909.26 $ 136,197.53 $ 117,619.47 $ 117,077.93 $ 111,754.98 $ 100,324.10 $ 102,910.45

Benefits $684.37 $717.06 $699.18 $717.06 $684.37 $744.60 $686.42 $717.06 $700.32 $701.67 $675.34 $744.60 $693.44 $717.06 $283.58 $686.42 $701.67 $684.37 $715.78 $717.06 $744.60 $686.42 $665.53 $681.64 $654.23 $708.56 $662.93 $708.56 $701.67 $662.93 $678.70 $683.99 $654.23 $674.83 $792.69 $701.67 $684.37 $9,811.87 $693.44 $669.95 $717.06 $708.56 $823.06 $744.60 $701.67 $717.06 $675.44 $700.32 $662.93 $717.06 $673.82 $701.67 $701.67 $713.15 $17,756.30 $717.06 $855.62 $702.66 $698.82 $702.97 $700.32 $686.42 $700.32 $666.29 $686.42 $700.32 $700.32 $669.95 $698.61 $662.93 $700.32

Appendix A RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Given Name Position MICHAEL Staff Sergeant GREGORY Staff Sergeant GIUSEPPE DINO Detective DAVID JOSEPH Police Constable JOSEPH Detective ROGER DOMINIC Detective MIKE Detective TODD Plainclothes Police Constable PAUL SCOTT Detective GEORGE WILLIAM Police Constable STEPHEN JAMES Plainclothes Police Constable STEPHEN FRANCIS Sergeant BRIAN PATRICK Plainclothes Police Constable DALE Sergeant MARVA MARIE Project Leader MAXWELL Staff Sergeant RANDOLPH Inspector SCOTT Detective SALVATORE Plainclothes Police Constable AVELINO MOTA Sergeant KELLY Sergeant JAMES AUSTIN Plainclothes Police Constable JENNIFER ANNE Plainclothes Police Constable GERALD Inspector SEAN ANDREW Plainclothes Police Constable TIFFANY ALICIA Plainclothes Police Constable ANTHONY Sergeant MARIO Plainclothes Police Constable STEVEN RICHARD Police Constable MATTHEW MICHAEL Plainclothes Police Constable RANDAL DELBERT Police Constable GLEN Detective LORENZINO MICHAEL Police Constable MAURIZIO Plainclothes Police Constable ANDREW JOHN Financial Planner COURTNEY Staff Sergeant ALPHA HAWK-BUNG Police Constable CHUN KWONG Plainclothes Police Constable CHU THAO Detective NEVILLE Sergeant JAMES ELLIOT Plainclothes Police Constable KAREN Detective MARK Detective JEFFREY PATRICK Police Constable ANTHONY Detective Sergeant STEPHANE REJEAN Plainclothes Police Constable MARK Detective WILLIAM OLIVER Plainclothes Police Constable NICHOLAS Plainclothes Police Constable MAGHFOOR AHMAD Planner STEPHEN Sergeant WEI PIN Plainclothes Police Constable ALAN LAP Police Constable CHING TIN Sergeant GADMAN DANIEL Plainclothes Police Constable NICKY TIN-FU Police Constable AJAY Plainclothes Police Constable MARCEL ANDRE Sergeant YVETTE MARIE Police Constable CYNTHIA Detective Sergeant AMANDA DANIELLE Plainclothes Police Constable CHRISTOPHER CLIFFORD Detective SIN-YI Sergeant HYUNG EUN Police Constable ROBERT Detective DEXTER MICHAEL Plainclothes Police Constable STEPHEN Police Constable DMITRY Plainclothes Police Constable HAROLD Sergeant LAWRENCE CHI Detective WING YEM Police Constable

Surname CANNON CANTELON CAPIZZO CAPONE CAPUTO CARACCIOLO CARBONE CAREFOOT CARGILL CARL CARLETON CARMICHAEL CARSWELL CARTER CARTER CARTER CARTER CARTER CARUSO CARVALHO CASCADDEN CASEY CASH CASHMAN CASSIDY CASTELL CASTELLUCCI CATENACCIO CATES CATON CAVE CECILE CENSONI CERESOLI CERNOWSKI CHAMBERS CHAN CHAN CHANG CHANNER CHANT CHAPMAN CHAPMAN CHARBONNEAU CHARLES CHARRON CHARUK CHASE CHAUDHARY CHAUDHRY CHELLEW CHEN CHENG CHEUNG CHEUNG CHEUNG CHHABRA CHIASSON CHIASSON CHILDS CHILVERS CHILVERS CHIU CHO CHOE CHOO-WING CHORNOOK CHOURYGUINE CHOW CHOW CHOW

Salary Paid $ 124,799.65 $ 123,551.45 $ 116,466.73 $ 128,740.48 $ 124,778.74 $ 119,171.72 $ 146,552.95 $ 117,052.92 $ 115,612.61 $ 109,075.69 $ 101,640.60 $ 105,586.66 $ 103,454.14 $ 111,296.09 $ 114,800.68 $ 127,282.74 $ 152,808.96 $ 110,244.61 $ 105,516.55 $ 122,484.63 $ 108,880.12 $ 106,231.89 $ 104,601.33 $ 154,828.88 $ 103,657.26 $ 106,216.46 $ 115,178.65 $ 142,127.20 $ 118,535.95 $ 117,335.00 $ 102,342.54 $ 126,279.21 $ 111,773.72 $ 112,078.44 $ 128,825.33 $ 126,122.79 $ 104,432.21 $ 112,906.25 $ 128,409.73 $ 107,674.08 $ 114,419.20 $ 109,885.72 $ 108,967.98 $ 100,325.80 $ 126,769.45 $ 106,076.80 $ 109,738.24 $ 119,958.68 $ 102,766.62 $ 107,237.44 $ 110,030.37 $ 107,810.76 $ 103,256.34 $ 114,222.38 $ 101,031.57 $ 102,053.99 $ 120,735.52 $ 121,609.96 $ 106,260.91 $ 135,815.59 $ 102,796.11 $ 123,186.81 $ 106,706.51 $ 106,910.29 $ 116,646.81 $ 127,875.16 $ 107,247.71 $ 109,993.38 $ 117,738.13 $ 107,467.98 $ 100,768.26

Benefits $744.60 $744.60 $708.56 $679.04 $717.06 $701.67 $717.06 $700.32 $708.56 $684.37 $686.42 $701.67 $673.82 $717.06 $303.15 $744.60 $792.69 $717.06 $673.82 $708.56 $292.08 $678.70 $682.15 $634.24 $681.54 $678.70 $715.78 $673.21 $682.76 $686.42 $684.37 $715.78 $662.93 $686.42 $886.80 $744.60 $690.96 $693.44 $701.67 $708.56 $686.42 $701.67 $708.56 $669.95 $744.60 $686.42 $717.06 $686.16 $667.41 $654.56 $717.06 $678.70 $662.93 $701.67 $686.42 $662.93 $678.70 $708.56 $669.95 $744.60 $685.81 $701.67 $709.80 $662.06 $339.65 $686.42 $684.37 $678.70 $711.97 $283.58 $662.93

Appendix A RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Given Name Position PHILIP BRUCE Police Constable PETER Detective YIORGO RICHARD Police Constable MYRON Detective PHILIP Detective RODCLIFF RODGER Sergeant RYAN ANTHONY Sergeant YONG SUL Police Constable DOODNATH DEODATH Sergeant CLINTON FRANK Police Constable CLAUDIA IRENE Plainclothes Police Constable JAROSLAW Police Constable SUSAN HELENA Plainclothes Police Constable JOHN ROBERT Police Constable MARC ANGELO Sergeant MICHAEL ANTHONY Plainclothes Police Constable MICHELLE PAULINE Detective CATHERINE ANN Police Constable CORINNE Detective DANA JOHN Plainclothes Police Constable DAVID JAMES Plainclothes Police Constable JAMIE ANDERSON Sergeant KARAH DAWN Police Constable NANCY PATRICIA Communications Operator PRESTON MICHAEL Plainclothes Police Constable RUSSELL Sergeant STEVEN Detective TRAVIS DAYMOND Sergeant CALVIN PETER Police Constable DOUGLAS Plainclothes Police Constable JEFFERY HOWARD Police Constable JOHN Detective MATTHEW FRANCIS Plainclothes Police Constable PAUL EGERTON Police Constable STACYANN MARIA Detective STEVEN Detective Sergeant DONALD Police Constable JEFFREY Sergeant HOWARD Police Constable MARK WILLIAM Detective HUGH ANTHONY Police Constable PETER Staff Sergeant CHARLES JAMES Plainclothes Police Constable PHILIP Police Constable JAMES GARFIELD Staff Sergeant ALAN LAWRENCE Plainclothes Police Constable MELISSA KELLY Plainclothes Police Constable DONALD Staff Sergeant GREGORY Inspector JASON ARTHUR Detective CRAIG EDWARD Police Constable JONATHAN DAVID Plainclothes Police Constable ROBERT SCOTT Sergeant ADAM STEPHEN Police Constable BRIAN MATTHEW Police Constable AARON ARTHUR Police Constable CHRISTOPHER PAUL Plainclothes Police Constable DOMENICO Police Constable TIMOTHY KENNETH Plainclothes Police Constable DALE Sergeant JOHN PAUL Police Constable BRUCE ALEXANDER Plainclothes Police Constable JASON ARTHUR Training Constable THOMAS WILLIAM Plainclothes Police Constable LEE SCOTT Police Constable ALBERT GEORGE Plainclothes Police Constable CHRISTOPHER ROBERT Police Constable RICHARD Training Constable ROBERT Detective ABDUL-KHALIK YAHYA Plainclothes Police Constable LUIGI Plainclothes Police Constable

Surname CHRISTIAN CHRISTIE CHRISTODOULOU CHUDOBA CHUNG CHUNG CHUNG CHUNG CHURKOO CIBULIS CID CIESLIK CIESLIK CILIA CIOFFI CIOFFI CIPRO CLAPP CLARK CLARK CLARK CLARK CLARK CLARK CLARK CLARK CLARK CLARK CLARKE CLARKE CLARKE CLARKE CLARKE CLARKE CLARKE CLARKE CLAUDIO CLEMENS CLEMENTS CLENDINNING CLIFFORD CODE COFFEY COFFIN COGHLIN COHEN COHEN COLE COLE COLE COLEMAN COLLIN COLLINS COLLYER COLLYMORE COMBDON COMISSION CONIGLIO CONLEY CONNELL CONNOLLY CONNOR CONTANT COOK COOKE COOMBS COOPER COOPER COOPER COOVADIA COPAT

Salary Paid $ 101,696.97 $ 108,707.60 $ 100,078.38 $ 123,673.94 $ 111,784.74 $ 103,810.21 $ 111,134.37 $ 104,569.69 $ 149,338.05 $ 130,998.24 $ 104,559.26 $ 102,173.81 $ 115,219.25 $ 106,998.15 $ 108,348.23 $ 111,822.77 $ 103,409.39 $ 100,964.10 $ 108,691.06 $ 113,949.82 $ 114,030.17 $ 108,665.92 $ 103,896.62 $ 109,828.56 $ 117,582.89 $ 113,444.24 $ 113,136.82 $ 118,598.82 $ 102,760.78 $ 116,708.40 $ 103,377.83 $ 120,108.89 $ 118,060.12 $ 101,919.99 $ 114,022.41 $ 119,209.29 $ 111,860.63 $ 114,522.47 $ 113,114.05 $ 121,708.51 $ 106,662.63 $ 134,823.95 $ 100,206.47 $ 112,710.14 $ 118,444.24 $ 128,779.61 $ 107,462.55 $ 121,902.14 $ 154,807.83 $ 122,780.82 $ 101,402.22 $ 103,214.55 $ 115,768.52 $ 106,785.29 $ 114,249.18 $ 103,655.66 $ 105,255.04 $ 100,280.20 $ 102,324.25 $ 109,003.20 $ 119,150.03 $ 123,517.37 $ 102,249.80 $ 105,831.47 $ 139,940.18 $ 115,592.04 $ 100,081.01 $ 101,044.17 $ 108,584.50 $ 107,210.94 $ 110,906.40

Benefits $662.93 $292.08 $650.69 $717.06 $292.08 $701.67 $678.95 $662.93 $701.67 $662.93 $680.93 $679.56 $700.32 $675.34 $701.67 $678.70 $701.67 $662.93 $717.06 $686.42 $686.42 $701.67 $244.97 $634.42 $686.42 $717.06 $717.06 $689.78 $662.93 $700.32 $669.95 $717.06 $686.42 $676.70 $701.67 $319.62 $675.34 $386.06 $684.37 $717.06 $662.93 $599.31 $664.61 $684.37 $596.06 $673.61 $673.21 $744.60 $949.04 $717.06 $669.95 $686.42 $717.06 $669.95 $662.93 $237.95 $686.42 $662.93 $671.99 $418.00 $670.20 $686.42 $685.20 $671.78 $669.95 $700.32 $662.93 $260.83 $717.06 $693.44 $700.32

Appendix A RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Given Name Position WESLEY MARCUS Plainclothes Police Constable ELIZABETT MARIA Sergeant BRIAN JAMES Detective CHRISTOPHER Police Constable KHALID MOHAMMED Plainclothes Police Constable DALE Sergeant ANTONIO Police Constable DAVID RODRIGUEZ Detective IRWIN Police Constable BRYAN MEDEIROS Plainclothes Police Constable JEFFERY Plainclothes Police Constable NEIL DAVID Superintendent ANTHONY Staff Sergeant SALVATORE Detective Sergeant SEAN DAVID Police Constable ANGELO Sergeant ZENON PIO Detective GINO Police Constable PATRICK WILLIAM Police Constable KEVIN JAMES Police Constable WILLIAM Staff Sergeant JOHN ALAN Detective Sergeant SHANE DUSTIN Sergeant JASON MILES Detective ANDREW JAMES Police Constable ANDRIA Sergeant JAMES Sergeant LAWRENCE Sergeant DARREN ANDREW Sergeant SHAWNA MICHELLE Staff Sergeant ROBERT Police Constable PATRICK KEVIN Plainclothes Police Constable ALECHIA CYNTHIA Plainclothes Police Constable STEPHEN Sergeant DAVID Sergeant SCOTT Sergeant DAVID ALAN Police Constable ROBERT JASON Police Constable ANTHONY JOHN Plainclothes Police Constable JASON RICHARD Police Constable ALEXANDER Police Constable WILLIAM Detective Sergeant NORMAN Sergeant JOHN JAMES Detective GUIDO Police Constable ANGELO Director of Finance and Administration SUSAN Detective Sergeant TIMOTHY Staff Sergeant LISA CATHERINE Detective DANIEL PATRICK Staff Sergeant JANINE Detective ANTONIO RAMON Plainclothes Police Constable OWEN Police Constable MATTHEW DOUGLAS Plainclothes Police Constable HELEN MARGARET Manager of IT Governance IRKA KATHERINE Senior Analyst OLIVER Police Constable STEVEN Plainclothes Police Constable GIUSEPPE Plainclothes Police Constable REMO Detective ANTONIO Plainclothes Police Constable ALLISTER Plainclothes Police Constable PHILIP Police Constable RYAN ASHLEY Police Constable TYRON IAN Police Constable ANTONIO NORBERTO Police Constable JOSE Police Constable JIMMY BERNARDO Police Constable JOSE PAULINO Police Constable VYTAUTAS Plainclothes Police Constable DALE Detective

Surname CORBIE CORDEIRO CORMACK CORNFORD COROGHLY CORRA CORREA CORREA CORREA CORREIA CORREIA CORRIGAN COSCARELLA COSENTINO COSGROVE COSTA COSTA CORREIA COSTABILE COSTELLO COTE COULSON COULTER COULTER COULTHARD COURT COWAN COWAN COWL COX COXON COYLE COYNE CRACKNELL CRADDOCK CRAGHILL CRAIG CRAMPTON CRANE CRAWFORD CRAWFORD CREWS CREWS CRICHTON CRILLY CRISTIANO CRISTOFARO CRONE CRONE CROOKER CROSBY CROWLEY CRUZ CULLETON CUNNINGTON CURTIN CUSHING D'ABREO D'ALIMONTE D'ANGELO D'ANTONIO D'ONOFRIO D'SILVA D'SOUZA D'SOUZA D'SOUZA DA COSTA DA SILVA DA SILVA CRISTOPULO DABU DABUZINSKAS DAFOE

Salary Paid $ 119,169.02 $ 113,847.79 $ 124,381.04 $ 101,010.17 $ 110,337.43 $ 109,308.38 $ 105,107.49 $ 112,659.18 $ 137,192.98 $ 118,140.31 $ 114,781.83 $ 168,564.67 $ 118,656.12 $ 149,906.83 $ 103,579.68 $ 119,330.78 $ 135,204.61 $ 120,636.76 $ 111,056.45 $ 108,443.41 $ 119,723.17 $ 124,566.42 $ 106,425.68 $ 113,009.07 $ 113,198.00 $ 108,198.78 $ 110,973.53 $ 112,399.36 $ 127,571.13 $ 114,553.37 $ 101,652.50 $ 111,433.32 $ 108,433.37 $ 124,411.90 $ 109,406.86 $ 110,051.85 $ 100,804.71 $ 101,499.45 $ 100,558.37 $ 105,888.45 $ 104,210.12 $ 120,978.02 $ 112,541.03 $ 105,290.02 $ 156,487.27 $ 184,452.63 $ 120,622.27 $ 134,391.77 $ 119,939.19 $ 119,670.90 $ 109,372.20 $ 112,608.71 $ 103,780.55 $ 106,492.39 $ 156,946.81 $ 106,360.95 $ 100,186.51 $ 102,398.44 $ 100,969.57 $ 105,604.69 $ 119,417.98 $ 115,938.88 $ 103,353.59 $ 111,026.63 $ 115,275.64 $ 108,685.66 $ 117,835.41 $ 104,321.43 $ 100,988.09 $ 102,774.19 $ 113,475.48

Benefits $680.58 $645.60 $701.67 $286.81 $678.70 $711.97 $668.42 $701.67 $684.37 $686.42 $678.70 $15,692.36 $737.72 $602.94 $675.44 $717.06 $701.93 $689.50 $662.93 $669.95 $744.60 $744.60 $701.93 $701.67 $662.93 $708.56 $717.06 $717.06 $710.11 $730.70 $684.37 $678.70 $684.34 $717.06 $717.06 $717.06 $669.95 $669.95 $677.53 $662.93 $684.37 $744.60 $717.06 $701.67 $684.37 $1,088.82 $744.60 $337.04 $701.67 $726.24 $717.06 $675.04 $684.37 $686.42 $823.06 $280.88 $662.93 $683.30 $693.44 $701.67 $678.70 $686.42 $676.70 $250.62 $662.93 $676.70 $306.61 $662.93 $669.95 $275.34 $717.06

Appendix A RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Given Name Position JULIANO Plainclothes Police Constable MAURO ANGELO Police Constable DONALD Sergeant KEVIN Police Constable TIMOTHY WILLIAM Training Constable ZAHIR Project Leader RODNEY Detective RYAN WILLIAM Plainclothes Police Constable JEFFERY CLARENCE Plainclothes Police Constable MARK CHARLES Detective MICHAEL-LEE DENIS-PAUL Plainclothes Police Constable JAMES EDWARD Staff Sergeant ANDREW JOSEPH Police Constable DANIEL ROBERT Detective STEVEN WILLIAM Plainclothes Police Constable ONIL Training Constable AMY LEE Plainclothes Police Constable DEREK JAMES Plainclothes Police Constable SEAN ANDREW Plainclothes Police Constable THOMAS Sergeant TIMOTHY Detective Sergeant COSMA Police Constable ROBERT EARLE Detective JASON BRIAN Plainclothes Police Constable SHARON Staff Sergeant STACEY DEE Sergeant BRIAN GORDON Police Constable CHRISTOPHER OLUFEMI Plainclothes Police Constable AMAAN Police Constable GEORGE JOSEPH Staff Sergeant KEITH Sergeant SHANNON INEZ Detective VICKI Sergeant NATHAN DAVID Training Constable JEFFREY PAUL Police Constable LISA GERMAINE Plainclothes Police Constable RYAN EVERT Police Constable NOEL ENRIQUEZ Plainclothes Police Constable FRANK PAUL Sergeant JUAN CARLOS Plainclothes Police Constable MARK Police Constable JOHN PAUL Plainclothes Police Constable MICHAEL BRIAN Plainclothes Police Constable JULIUS THEODORE Senior Analyst GREGORY JOHN Plainclothes Police Constable TIMOTHY WILLIAM Police Constable BERTRAND Police Constable JESSE RUSSELL Plainclothes Police Constable ROBERT FREDERICK Police Constable WANDA MARIE Sergeant JOHN Detective Sergeant MICHAEL Plainclothes Police Constable HIBA JOSEPH Parking Enforcement Officer AHMET Plainclothes Police Constable MYRON ANDREY Inspector KEVIN Detective AARON Sergeant MARK Plainclothes Police Constable JOSEPH FRANCOIS Plainclothes Police Constable JOHN PAUL Police Constable JEROME JEREMY Police Constable ROGER HENRI Detective CHRISTOPHER LEE Plainclothes Police Constable PHILIP Detective WILLIAM RONALD Police Constable NORMAN Staff Sergeant JAMIE DUNCAN Plainclothes Police Constable ROBIN HUGH Sergeant PIARA SINGH Police Constable SURINDERJIT Senior Technical Analyst RUBINDER Sergeant

Surname DAL BIANCO DAL GRANDE DALE DALEY DALEY DAMANI DAMASO DANCE DANIELS DANIELS DAOUST DARBYSHIRE DARMITZ DARNBROUGH DARNLEY DAS GUPTA DAVEY DAVEY DAVEY DAVEY DAVEY DAVID DAVIES DAVIS DAVIS DAVIS DAWN DAWODU DAWOOD DAWSON DAWSON DAWSON DAWSON DAYLER DE CAIRE DE COSTE DE GRAAF DE GUZMAN DE LIO DE LOS RIOS DE LUGT DE SOUSA DE ZILVA DESILVA DEABREU DEACON DEAN DEAN DEARBORN DECOSTE DECOURCY DELPORT DEMIAN DEMIRDEN DEMKIW DEMOE DENNIS DENTON DESJARDINS DESMARAIS DESROCHERS DESROCHERS DEVEREUX DEVINE DEWLAND DEWLING DEWSNAP DEY DHALIWAL DHALIWAL DHATT

Salary Paid $ 103,080.31 $ 101,708.68 $ 115,639.98 $ 127,230.05 $ 100,102.13 $ 114,311.73 $ 121,351.74 $ 104,628.64 $ 113,107.29 $ 125,076.59 $ 111,607.92 $ 121,489.95 $ 101,322.23 $ 126,808.63 $ 111,915.32 $ 101,671.04 $ 101,505.58 $ 100,257.64 $ 106,479.24 $ 110,314.41 $ 120,953.88 $ 100,918.25 $ 124,529.58 $ 115,852.64 $ 121,568.06 $ 105,527.28 $ 100,752.70 $ 102,486.14 $ 102,911.01 $ 132,031.77 $ 112,177.11 $ 116,985.27 $ 108,973.89 $ 102,976.76 $ 108,988.86 $ 108,077.06 $ 102,235.25 $ 101,142.12 $ 120,743.21 $ 102,045.45 $ 105,194.25 $ 123,991.81 $ 110,731.77 $ 117,797.67 $ 105,606.67 $ 102,370.85 $ 120,284.59 $ 117,805.27 $ 118,537.89 $ 103,397.37 $ 120,991.57 $ 102,792.78 $ 109,794.69 $ 104,239.37 $ 146,891.78 $ 109,331.90 $ 110,930.09 $ 117,512.40 $ 119,082.19 $ 106,038.94 $ 103,691.94 $ 117,848.57 $ 104,436.57 $ 108,751.14 $ 100,409.51 $ 120,110.13 $ 109,256.73 $ 122,748.76 $ 101,487.36 $ 122,244.40 $ 115,246.06

Benefits $700.32 $684.37 $717.06 $679.56 $692.20 $303.15 $701.67 $686.42 $678.70 $708.56 $686.42 $744.60 $662.93 $717.06 $686.42 $692.20 $261.44 $674.43 $686.42 $717.06 $319.62 $568.49 $701.67 $678.09 $744.60 $701.67 $662.93 $686.42 $662.93 $744.60 $717.06 $701.93 $717.06 $686.42 $651.62 $686.42 $662.93 $340.14 $708.56 $693.44 $684.37 $686.42 $686.42 $280.88 $678.70 $662.93 $633.02 $678.70 $684.37 $701.67 $744.60 $700.32 $170.56 $665.73 $947.86 $717.06 $701.67 $700.32 $673.21 $669.95 $669.95 $701.67 $686.42 $717.06 $237.95 $744.60 $686.42 $717.06 $662.06 $280.88 $701.67

Appendix A RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Given Name Position JAGJIT SINGH Police Constable RANBIR SINGH Plainclothes Police Constable RAJEEV Police Constable MUNISH Plainclothes Police Constable ZEESHAN AYUB Plainclothes Police Constable ROBERTO Detective DOMENICO Detective JULIE Detective EMILIO Detective MONICA FRANCA Operations Supervisor MARIO Superintendent ROBERTO Detective Sergeant ANGELA MARIA Police Constable PEDRO EDUARDO Detective MICHAEL DAVID Plainclothes Police Constable CRAIG WILLIAM Police Constable DAVID THORPE Detective BRETT GORDON Plainclothes Police Constable MICHELE Detective ADAMIRA MARIA Plainclothes Police Constable GIUSEPPE Sergeant DANIEL Detective CHRISTOPHER Detective JEREMY MICHAEL Plainclothes Police Constable RAYMOND MARTIN Sergeant SHARON Sergeant TONY Sergeant JOSE BENEDICTO Detective BEVERLY ROSE Police Constable CHRISTIAN DANIEL Plainclothes Police Constable ANDREW Police Constable LESLIE GRAHAM Plainclothes Police Constable RANDIE Training Constable BRADEN SPENCER Plainclothes Police Constable RICHARD MICHAEL Detective Sergeant VITTORIO SALVATORE Police Constable PAUL LAURIE Detective BRADLEY JAMES Detective KIM Police Constable STEPHEN Training Constable NICKOLAS CHARLES Plainclothes Police Constable JOSEPH THOMAS Project Leader FRANCIS JUSTIN Police Constable BARBARA ANN Detective JEFFREY Sergeant STEPHEN MICHAEL Plainclothes Police Constable JEFFERY JONATHON Plainclothes Police Constable THOMAS Police Constable CHRISTOPHER PATRICK Plainclothes Police Constable KEVIN CHRISTOPHER Police Constable WILLIAM Sergeant RYAN JOSEPH Sergeant KIRSTAN GILES Police Constable CRAIG Detective JASON Plainclothes Police Constable MAREK Police Constable PAUL Detective JOAO RODRIGO Plainclothes Police Constable DAVID Sergeant JEAN Sergeant SCOTT Sergeant MICHAEL RYAN Police Constable PATRICK PETER Plainclothes Police Constable RICHARD HUGH Detective MARJORIE ARLEEN Sergeant ERIC Sergeant BRIAN DOUGLAS Sergeant JOSE JOB Police Constable EVERETT CLAIR Police Constable JEANINE Detective MELISSA JOY Plainclothes Police Constable

Surname DHILLON DHILLON DHINGRA DHOUM DHUKAI DI GIACOMO DI PASSA DI PASSA DI POCE DI TOLLO DI TOMMASO DIDANIELI DIAZ DIAZ DICK DICKIE DICKINSON DICKSON DICOSOLA DIDIC DIGIOVANNI DION DIONNE DIPOCE DIRENZO DISALVO DIVIESTI DIZON DOBBS DOBBS DOBRO DODDS DODSON DOHERTY DOKURNO DOMINELLI DOMINEY DONAIS DONISON DONOVAN DORAZIO DOREY DORRINGTON DOUGLAS DOUGLAS DOUGLAS DOUPE DOWNING DOYLE DRAKE DRAKE DRAPACK DRAPER DRENNAN DREWS DROZDZOWSKI DRURY DUARTE DUBE DUBREUIL DUCKWORTH DUCUSIN DUERDEN DUFFUS DUFFY DUGAN DUKE DULATAS DUNBAR DUNCAN DUNCAN

Salary Paid $ 118,185.41 $ 103,177.96 $ 110,586.25 $ 115,957.11 $ 102,984.07 $ 123,843.44 $ 141,325.35 $ 116,360.97 $ 116,947.64 $ 101,356.17 $ 172,181.08 $ 131,500.46 $ 106,444.11 $ 126,110.79 $ 108,661.55 $ 116,194.16 $ 129,287.11 $ 100,581.14 $ 125,906.00 $ 102,333.33 $ 135,864.76 $ 107,464.64 $ 108,709.03 $ 100,245.85 $ 106,759.90 $ 110,609.34 $ 111,271.42 $ 125,377.54 $ 101,495.21 $ 112,939.69 $ 104,953.00 $ 110,388.49 $ 101,951.00 $ 105,064.89 $ 120,724.51 $ 109,498.96 $ 130,736.45 $ 100,973.02 $ 110,942.00 $ 102,596.60 $ 103,207.08 $ 114,562.18 $ 101,585.52 $ 121,445.23 $ 111,513.66 $ 110,457.77 $ 104,743.38 $ 102,863.50 $ 101,280.04 $ 132,547.05 $ 118,450.65 $ 112,764.38 $ 108,820.24 $ 127,911.38 $ 117,409.88 $ 101,125.06 $ 115,172.12 $ 118,819.60 $ 110,882.81 $ 123,656.06 $ 110,901.27 $ 101,224.48 $ 104,705.54 $ 123,903.76 $ 112,075.27 $ 115,164.32 $ 108,851.29 $ 101,315.12 $ 103,095.49 $ 107,172.25 $ 112,450.61

Benefits $658.58 $677.53 $662.93 $671.99 $678.70 $701.67 $715.78 $292.08 $717.06 $665.63 $13,209.87 $744.60 $678.14 $708.56 $678.70 $669.95 $701.67 $679.71 $708.56 $684.34 $717.06 $710.11 $292.08 $686.42 $708.56 $711.97 $717.06 $701.67 $654.23 $678.70 $684.37 $686.42 $686.68 $686.42 $744.60 $662.93 $701.67 $689.22 $684.37 $700.32 $667.46 $303.15 $662.93 $708.56 $717.06 $686.42 $686.42 $696.66 $663.49 $669.95 $717.06 $695.77 $665.53 $717.06 $686.42 $683.37 $575.40 $686.42 $717.06 $717.06 $717.06 $669.95 $670.21 $708.56 $708.56 $717.06 $717.06 $654.23 $662.93 $710.42 $686.42

Appendix A RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Given Name Position PETER Detective PHILLIP ZVI Plainclothes Police Constable LISA TERRA Police Constable NIGEL PETER Training Constable LESLIE Detective JAMES MICHAEL Plainclothes Police Constable JOHN PAUL Detective BEVERLY Police Constable JAMES WILLIAM Police Constable ANDREW RICHARD Police Constable DOUGLAS Detective ADRIAN ROGELIO Police Constable CAMERON EDWARD Staff Sergeant DAVID LEONARD Police Constable NED Police Constable GREGORY FRANCIS Training Constable PETER Plainclothes Police Constable BENJAMIN MICHAEL Detective ROBERT Sergeant ANTHONY Plainclothes Police Constable HENRY JACOB Plainclothes Police Constable GEOFFREY THOMAS Training Constable STAISLAW Police Constable EDWARD Staff Sergeant RICHARD GEORGE Police Constable DAWN MICHELLE Detective LISA CHRISTINE Sergeant MICHAEL Staff Inspector PETER Police Constable DOUGLAS BRIAN Plainclothes Police Constable POOYA Police Constable ANDREW DOUGLAS Sergeant DAVID GRENVILLE Detective Sergeant LESLIE ADAM Plainclothes Police Constable GLENN RAYMOND Sergeant ALEXIS GRACE Detective JAMES MICHAEL Training Constable REGINALD Sergeant STUART Inspector KAREN ELIZABETH Plainclothes Police Constable BENJAMIN GEORGE Police Constable CHRISTOPHER PAUL Detective EVERETT Plainclothes Police Constable JOHN Plainclothes Police Constable PAUL Sergeant SHAWN WILLIAM Sergeant GEOFFREY WILLIAM Plainclothes Police Constable MATTHEW AUSTIN Police Constable MICHAEL DAVID Manager of Facilities Management SIU-MIA Plainclothes Police Constable DAVID Sergeant JEFFREY BRIAN Plainclothes Police Constable CHRISTIAN RENE Police Constable DAVID Detective WARREN CLAYTON Plainclothes Police Constable ROBERT GALDINO Detective DALE Staff Sergeant TSUI-CHEE Project Leader JONATHAN AARON Senior Intelligence Analyst INDREK Detective GLEN Police Constable EULIALIA Detective CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL Police Constable DAVID Sergeant SIMON QUINCEY Police Constable BART Sergeant BRYCE Staff Inspector JACQUELINE Sergeant DION Manager of Communications Services JOEL JAMSON Police Constable JOHN ALFRED Sergeant

Surname DUNCAN DUNCAN DUNK DUNKER DUNKLEY DUNLOP DUNLOP DUNN DUNNE DUNNING DUNSTAN DURAN DURHAM DUROCHER DURRAN DURST DURST DURY DUTHIE DWYER DYCK DYKE DZIEMIANKO DZINGALA DZINGALA EAGLESON EAGLESON EARL EASTER EATON EBRAHIMI ECKLUND ECKLUND EDGAR EDWARD EDWICKER EICHENBERG ELDRIDGE ELEY ELGAR ELLIOT ELLIOTT ELLIOTT ELLIOTT ELLIOTT ELLIOTT ELLIS ELLIS ELLIS ELZINGA EMIGH EMMS EMOND ENTWISTLE ENTWISTLE ERMACORA ERVICK ESCUDERO WHU ESDON ESKEN ESPIE ESTWICK ETHIER EUSTACE EUTENEIER EVANS EVANS EVANS EVELYN EVELYN EVEREST

Salary Paid $ 105,922.12 $ 113,630.36 $ 100,609.98 $ 105,781.88 $ 136,847.25 $ 110,318.66 $ 116,055.61 $ 126,760.33 $ 100,744.03 $ 118,657.18 $ 142,627.55 $ 137,754.04 $ 124,640.75 $ 116,760.12 $ 109,566.18 $ 102,600.10 $ 105,934.78 $ 115,558.41 $ 116,214.46 $ 102,820.16 $ 105,065.61 $ 100,415.10 $ 128,366.92 $ 119,535.92 $ 128,450.00 $ 117,407.86 $ 106,363.57 $ 163,046.56 $ 104,663.09 $ 121,882.03 $ 104,104.09 $ 148,607.82 $ 141,870.96 $ 104,737.75 $ 106,425.88 $ 109,322.95 $ 106,485.16 $ 109,619.76 $ 148,380.04 $ 101,127.49 $ 105,924.05 $ 108,067.92 $ 163,537.66 $ 102,596.60 $ 119,300.11 $ 106,248.12 $ 109,087.62 $ 104,290.26 $ 147,513.60 $ 103,118.92 $ 111,773.61 $ 104,155.55 $ 101,517.48 $ 115,800.83 $ 106,732.75 $ 106,476.51 $ 132,814.07 $ 115,763.35 $ 108,900.07 $ 111,035.74 $ 100,150.11 $ 105,919.75 $ 102,056.09 $ 122,516.06 $ 114,557.96 $ 110,049.10 $ 164,061.16 $ 110,190.45 $ 137,026.86 $ 103,278.73 $ 114,930.19

Benefits $708.56 $686.42 $683.03 $685.20 $717.06 $681.54 $717.06 $684.37 $669.95 $682.76 $717.06 $675.90 $744.60 $665.53 $669.95 $700.32 $275.34 $701.93 $717.06 $700.32 $253.72 $686.42 $689.50 $744.60 $684.37 $701.67 $708.56 $15,306.21 $684.37 $672.60 $662.93 $701.67 $724.28 $686.42 $701.67 $701.67 $685.46 $717.06 $792.69 $696.19 $662.93 $701.67 $700.32 $700.32 $717.06 $708.56 $678.49 $642.62 $949.60 $686.42 $717.06 $678.49 $662.93 $717.06 $544.76 $708.56 $744.60 $303.15 $682.73 $717.06 $662.93 $708.56 $662.93 $717.06 $658.58 $717.06 $14,147.30 $402.26 $607.88 $673.61 $717.06

Appendix A RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Given Name Position CHARLES Police Constable SCOTT CARL Police Constable MICHAEL PAUL Sergeant MOHAMAD Police Constable JAMES STEPHEN Police Constable GREGORY Detective FRANK Sergeant ROBERT Plainclothes Police Constable JEANETTE ISABEL Manager of Labour Relations DANIEL HAROLD Plainclothes Police Constable CHRISTINE MARIE Detective DOUGLAS JAMES Training Constable GEORGE Staff Sergeant MARIE Detective SUSAN ELISABETH Police Constable GREGORY DAVID Plainclothes Police Constable OLIVER Sergeant MATTHEW MICHAEL Senior Technical Analyst MICHAEL Deputy Chief MYKOLA Police Constable BRENDA ELIZABETH Police Constable PAUL Police Constable DAVID M. Superintendent JASON ROBERT Police Constable MARK DANIEL Sergeant PATRICK WALLACE Police Constable HUGH Superintendent JAY MARIE Detective SCOTT CAVANAGH Detective STEPHEN Detective CHRISTOPHER ROBIN Police Constable CHRISTOPHER Inspector DWAYNE ANTHONY Plainclothes Police Constable KERI ANN Detective MICHAEL A. Plainclothes Police Constable MICHAEL FREITAS Police Constable ROLAND ANDREA Training Constable ROSS SAVIO Plainclothes Police Constable SELWYN JOHN Superintendent MARK Plainclothes Police Constable KEVIN Sergeant LISA Sergeant MANIE THERESE Plainclothes Police Constable JASON WAYNE Detective MICHAEL BERNARD Sergeant ANDREW CLARENCE Police Constable CAMERON DOUGLAS Detective Sergeant SHAWN MICHAEL Police Constable RADOSLAW Police Constable GIANNI ALAN Plainclothes Police Constable RYAN MCLEAN Plainclothes Police Constable ALLAN Sergeant ZACHARY JONATHON Police Constable DAVID ANTHONY Plainclothes Police Constable BRADLEY Sergeant SUSAN Police Constable MIRAN Plainclothes Police Constable CHRISTOPHER ALLAN Plainclothes Police Constable GRISEL Plainclothes Police Constable THOMAS Superintendent TODD MATTHEW Sergeant JAMES Plainclothes Police Constable ALBERT Detective CANDICE LYNN Detective MANUEL ALEJANDRO Police Constable LUIS GUILLERMO Police Constable TRACY LYNN ANGELA Plainclothes Police Constable STEPHEN Detective Sergeant BRETT GORDON Police Constable GORDON Plainclothes Police Constable DAVID WILLIAM Plainclothes Police Constable

Surname EXTON EZEKIEL FACOETTI FADEL FAIRCLOUGH FALCONER FALKINSON FALLIS FARAHBAKHSH FAREWELL FARRELL FARRELL FARRELL FARRUGIA FASSBENDER FEAGAN FEBBO FEDERICO FEDERICO FEDORY FEGAN FEGAN FENTON FENTON FERADAY FERDINAND FERGUSON FERGUSON FERGUSON FERGUSON FERKO FERNANDES FERNANDES FERNANDES FERNANDES FERNANDES FERNANDES FERNANDES FERNANDES FERREIRA FERRIS FERRIS FERRIS FERRY FERRY FIDLER FIELD FIELDING FIGLARZ FILIPPIN FINDLAY FINLAY FIRTH FISCHER FISHER FISHER FISTER FITKIN FITKIN FITZGERALD FLANDERS FLETT FLIS FLIS FLORES FLOREZ FLUMIAN FODEN FOGG FOOTE FORBES

Salary Paid $ 118,643.39 $ 101,947.97 $ 130,585.64 $ 104,910.73 $ 103,172.51 $ 125,579.37 $ 108,695.71 $ 110,398.64 $ 153,767.77 $ 102,203.69 $ 119,420.07 $ 104,071.46 $ 130,562.94 $ 118,215.31 $ 105,317.00 $ 113,913.01 $ 122,988.47 $ 121,433.04 $ 243,469.38 $ 101,993.16 $ 105,390.88 $ 102,355.83 $ 174,505.55 $ 110,289.81 $ 108,576.62 $ 102,836.77 $ 177,219.02 $ 125,545.26 $ 116,547.88 $ 114,170.86 $ 107,545.16 $ 153,729.64 $ 102,130.63 $ 108,169.80 $ 101,590.98 $ 111,167.82 $ 100,133.72 $ 103,836.17 $ 171,267.58 $ 129,282.07 $ 110,452.50 $ 126,542.85 $ 110,531.28 $ 106,147.37 $ 157,139.50 $ 128,302.11 $ 122,001.18 $ 138,950.10 $ 105,892.78 $ 105,014.58 $ 100,089.57 $ 120,206.72 $ 102,192.94 $ 102,238.45 $ 112,532.37 $ 118,943.31 $ 108,781.05 $ 103,413.66 $ 103,622.88 $ 185,501.10 $ 107,679.32 $ 105,472.80 $ 119,175.74 $ 106,133.41 $ 102,400.76 $ 102,833.67 $ 100,713.59 $ 119,684.70 $ 105,571.31 $ 102,596.60 $ 102,788.44

Benefits $684.37 $669.95 $708.56 $662.93 $674.83 $717.06 $717.06 $699.28 $815.58 $686.42 $708.56 $685.20 $744.60 $717.06 $669.95 $686.42 $711.97 $705.86 $15,218.59 $662.93 $673.70 $695.52 $14,683.36 $669.95 $717.06 $676.70 $13,569.05 $717.06 $737.72 $717.06 $669.95 $949.04 $686.42 $701.67 $271.21 $662.93 $693.44 $686.42 $9,390.22 $699.28 $717.06 $717.06 $686.42 $701.67 $717.06 $662.93 $602.94 $662.93 $662.93 $686.42 $686.42 $717.06 $656.84 $686.16 $715.78 $684.37 $700.32 $397.00 $686.42 $12,244.35 $701.67 $271.21 $710.42 $708.56 $668.56 $662.93 $677.81 $744.60 $676.70 $275.34 $680.56

Appendix A RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Given Name Position ANTONIO Staff Sergeant JAMES BERNARD Police Constable ANDREW RION Police Constable ROGER ANTHONY Sergeant RYAN Detective GREGORY Sergeant MICHAEL Sergeant ROSS Plainclothes Police Constable LOUIS-MARIE RAYMOND Detective Sergeant ANTHONY JOSEPH Police Constable LORNE DAVID Police Constable ROY Detective GEORGE Sergeant CORY TRENTON Police Constable MARIE-JOSEE Plainclothes Police Constable GORDON BRUCE Police Constable SCOTT MACKENZIE Sergeant WAYNE LEONARD Detective JAMES Sergeant STEVEN ANDREW Police Constable CHRISTOPHER ROBERT Police Constable MARILYN IRENE Plainclothes Police Constable RICHARD Plainclothes Police Constable RANDY Staff Inspector SIMON Sergeant SPENCER ROBERT Plainclothes Police Constable TRACEY Sergeant ANTONIO RUDOLPH Police Constable ERIC MICHAEL Plainclothes Police Constable JEFFREY BRYANT Police Constable JOHN Staff Sergeant ROBERT Plainclothes Police Constable KEVIN DAVID Detective GORDON Plainclothes Police Constable THEODOR Detective JAY JACKSON Detective Sergeant RONALD Sergeant DANIEL SCOTT Plainclothes Police Constable HOWARD WAYNE Assistant Manager, Payroll Services ROBERT PAUL Police Constable KAY Police Constable JOHN Plainclothes Police Constable ADRIAN Detective Sergeant BRONAGH MARIA Detective MATTHEW THOMAS Police Constable DEANNA LYNN Plainclothes Police Constable VITO Detective SYED SEAN Plainclothes Police Constable YEKATERINA Police Constable ROLAND GERHARD Police Constable WENDY Sergeant KONSTANTINOS Plainclothes Police Constable ALEXANDRU Plainclothes Police Constable IAN JAMES Police Constable JOHN ASHLEY Police Constable DENISE Sergeant KELLY-ANN Detective Sergeant ROBERT Detective STACY Detective Sergeant TIMOTHY Sergeant DANIEL Plainclothes Police Constable ARRAN Police Constable DEBORAH GRACE Police Constable TODD Training Constable ETELVINO MANUEL Police Constable ROBERT SCOTT Police Constable RONALD FRANKLIN Sergeant MARINA EDUARDOVNA Plainclothes Police Constable RICHARD FREDRICK Plainclothes Police Constable HEIDI ELSIE Detective Sergeant PATRICK JOHN Plainclothes Police Constable

Surname FORCHIONE FORCILLO FORD FORDE FORDE FORESTALL FORESTELL FORSYTHE FORTIN FOSTER FOSTER FOSTER FOTOPOULOS FOUGERE FOURNIER FOWLDS FOWLDS FOWLER FOX FOX FRANCO FRANK FRANKLIN FRANKS FRASER FRASER FRASER FREDERICK FREEMAN FREEMAN FRENCH FRIGON FRIMETH FRITZ FRITZ FROSCH FRY FUNCHION FURNESS FURYK FYDENCHUK FYFE FYNES FYNES GABRIEL GAGLIARDI GAGLIARDI GAJRAJ GALAMIYEVA GALDIKS GALES GALIOTOS GALL GALLAGHER GALLAGHER GALLANT GALLANT GALLANT GALLANT GALLANT GALLO GANJ GARBUTT GARBUTT GARCIA GARDINER GARDNER GARLAND GARRETT GARRISON GARROW

Salary Paid $ 120,738.77 $ 106,800.89 $ 107,868.78 $ 109,792.44 $ 113,038.63 $ 136,497.50 $ 125,772.10 $ 118,947.14 $ 125,887.12 $ 104,397.19 $ 100,438.10 $ 121,676.92 $ 113,609.23 $ 115,592.49 $ 105,461.31 $ 107,358.17 $ 119,434.90 $ 116,832.52 $ 109,812.75 $ 108,786.39 $ 101,923.49 $ 101,205.41 $ 117,346.18 $ 160,613.34 $ 110,171.07 $ 111,784.33 $ 107,375.35 $ 108,702.16 $ 104,293.18 $ 112,900.74 $ 126,959.99 $ 126,327.66 $ 138,818.87 $ 116,847.23 $ 118,600.65 $ 122,782.35 $ 113,715.09 $ 105,530.53 $ 106,085.01 $ 108,849.34 $ 102,641.23 $ 120,412.12 $ 120,172.75 $ 109,755.56 $ 101,943.32 $ 106,440.44 $ 119,970.67 $ 107,782.98 $ 101,983.83 $ 106,806.13 $ 103,584.77 $ 103,096.69 $ 105,474.97 $ 103,553.00 $ 103,050.69 $ 106,720.79 $ 119,404.39 $ 127,658.23 $ 118,772.82 $ 129,231.57 $ 106,701.36 $ 110,371.04 $ 102,057.57 $ 103,846.50 $ 105,998.38 $ 101,011.57 $ 108,495.29 $ 101,173.46 $ 101,092.12 $ 116,547.88 $ 101,063.35

Benefits $303.30 $639.53 $662.93 $701.67 $701.67 $717.06 $717.06 $700.32 $744.60 $669.95 $662.06 $717.06 $713.86 $684.59 $678.70 $685.51 $708.56 $717.06 $717.06 $669.95 $651.62 $686.42 $700.32 $13,413.15 $717.06 $686.42 $708.56 $669.95 $686.42 $682.76 $744.60 $700.32 $708.56 $700.32 $717.06 $319.62 $717.06 $673.82 $378.33 $662.93 $684.37 $693.44 $744.60 $701.67 $664.49 $686.42 $701.67 $686.42 $658.58 $669.95 $456.72 $686.42 $683.30 $662.93 $669.95 $285.13 $492.76 $717.06 $742.52 $708.56 $686.42 $662.93 $670.20 $693.44 $662.06 $669.95 $701.67 $686.42 $678.70 $312.74 $686.68

Appendix A RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Given Name Position ANDREW FREDERICK Police Constable DERRICK Sergeant KEITH Plainclothes Police Constable LEO Detective PAUL RICHARD Sergeant MARC ROBERT Police Constable DARYL Police Constable KEVIN WAI Police Constable WILLIAM EDWARD Police Constable SHAUN Detective GLEN Sergeant KEITH JOSEPH Police Constable KEVIN Plainclothes Police Constable JOHN Police Constable DARYLE Staff Sergeant DONALD Staff Sergeant MATTHEW JAMES Police Constable SHAWN Detective Sergeant HAMAYAK Police Constable MAKDA Financial Planner CELESTINO Director of Information Technology LOUIS Sergeant REBECCA NICOLE Plainclothes Police Constable RICHARD Sergeant ANDREW NEIL Sergeant GRAHAM Detective Sergeant JAMES Staff Sergeant NATHAN EDWARD Plainclothes Police Constable ROGER Sergeant JIM FRANK Detective KAROL ZYGMUNT Detective Sergeant CHAD ALLEN Plainclothes Police Constable DONNA ELLEN Information Security Officer SCOTT Inspector SHAWN WILLIAM Sergeant LEAH DAWN Detective Sergeant AMANPREET SINGH Police Constable DALBINDER SINGH Police Constable JASON GOWAN Plainclothes Police Constable SUKHJIT SINGH Police Constable JEFFREY JOHN Plainclothes Police Constable ANDREA Plainclothes Police Constable MICHAEL PATRICK Plainclothes Police Constable DAVID WILLIAM Staff Sergeant GUILLERMO STEVE Plainclothes Police Constable DAVID Plainclothes Police Constable MARTIN REMI Police Constable NANCY LYNNE Plainclothes Police Constable FRANCESCO Plainclothes Police Constable GARY Detective Sergeant RYAN CHRISTOPHER Plainclothes Police Constable DAVID Police Constable JUSTIN JOSEPH Plainclothes Police Constable LYDIA STEPHANY Detective Sergeant PHILLIP Sergeant CAROLINE Detective GREGORY DAVID Detective CLAUDIO Plainclothes Police Constable GLENN PATRICK Police Constable NAD Police Constable ANDRE PIERRE Manager of Diversity Management GOPALA KRISHNA Project Leader ANATOL Police Constable ERIC CHARLES Detective JUSTIN DAVID Plainclothes Police Constable SUSAN ELIZABETH Detective ANGELO ENRIQUEZ Police Constable DERRICK Training Constable JOANNE MICHELE Senior Administrator Civilian Recruitment ELLA RILEY Plainclothes Police Constable RALPH Sergeant

Surname GARVEY GAUDET GAUTHIER GAUTHIER GAUTHIER GAUVREAU GAZEY GEE GEE GENOVY GEORGE GEORGE GEORGOPOULOS GERRITS GERRY GERRY GERRY GETTY GHAZARIAN GHEYSAR GIANNOTTA GIBB GIBBONS GIBILLINI GIBSON GIBSON GIBSON GIBSON GIBSON GICZI GIEDROYC GIESCHE GILBERT GILBERT GILBERT GILFOY GILL GILL GILL GILL GILLAN GILLESPIE GILLESPIE GILLIS GINI GINN GIRARD GIRARDI GIRMENIA GIROUX GITTUS GLANCY GLASGOW GLAVIN GLAVIN GLEN GLENDINNING GOBBO GODDARD GOEBELL GOH GOKEDA GOLDLIOUST GOLDSMITH GOMES GOMES GONZALES GOOBIE GOODING GOODWIN GOODWIN

Salary Paid $ 100,389.47 $ 112,644.41 $ 103,540.07 $ 116,590.76 $ 104,887.85 $ 102,036.24 $ 105,603.44 $ 101,074.50 $ 136,338.38 $ 112,357.32 $ 123,879.45 $ 101,803.58 $ 110,656.03 $ 124,005.95 $ 122,467.53 $ 118,067.02 $ 100,570.02 $ 122,883.70 $ 110,298.67 $ 128,822.09 $ 183,097.27 $ 110,840.95 $ 105,939.87 $ 116,014.43 $ 114,291.11 $ 148,396.21 $ 121,752.97 $ 115,637.23 $ 117,154.25 $ 118,750.40 $ 117,641.40 $ 112,123.73 $ 117,315.15 $ 153,792.99 $ 101,390.54 $ 118,052.30 $ 114,299.30 $ 104,066.92 $ 120,922.46 $ 101,888.19 $ 117,476.68 $ 102,884.52 $ 108,753.95 $ 119,211.04 $ 107,319.81 $ 109,267.15 $ 103,854.32 $ 103,630.59 $ 105,722.70 $ 160,235.12 $ 101,027.30 $ 129,690.37 $ 102,488.75 $ 117,401.27 $ 123,098.99 $ 109,900.90 $ 121,705.84 $ 102,898.34 $ 110,712.74 $ 101,753.64 $ 145,464.67 $ 105,408.29 $ 101,249.61 $ 109,062.98 $ 108,079.52 $ 145,515.83 $ 106,420.60 $ 105,667.77 $ 112,021.88 $ 102,396.52 $ 115,002.94

Benefits $668.66 $710.11 $700.32 $710.11 $701.67 $669.95 $682.82 $658.58 $669.95 $717.06 $717.06 $662.93 $686.42 $684.37 $744.60 $738.48 $662.93 $744.60 $662.93 $886.80 $1,088.82 $717.06 $686.42 $717.06 $713.54 $744.60 $744.60 $678.70 $717.06 $708.56 $312.74 $686.42 $728.13 $949.04 $694.59 $737.72 $669.95 $669.95 $686.42 $662.93 $686.42 $700.32 $678.70 $744.60 $678.70 $700.32 $662.93 $686.42 $673.61 $319.62 $670.77 $676.70 $686.42 $737.72 $717.06 $711.97 $717.06 $700.32 $669.95 $684.37 $367.71 $707.82 $662.93 $701.93 $686.42 $708.56 $669.95 $700.32 $823.35 $666.29 $649.01

Appendix A RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Given Name Position CHRISTOPHER Sergeant JASON JAMES Police Constable JAMES ELWOOD Detective Sergeant BRIAN Staff Sergeant MICHAEL Staff Sergeant RONALD EDMUND Police Constable ROBERT RANDALL Sergeant JEFFREY MICHAEL Police Constable ANTHONY LEO Plainclothes Police Constable CRAIG JOSEPH Sergeant DERECK FRANCIS Plainclothes Police Constable TODD JOHN Sergeant CAROL LYNN Administrator Document Services TIMOTHY Plainclothes Police Constable GORDON Detective Sergeant KEVIN JOSEPH Police Constable LEE MICHAEL Sergeant MICHAEL GEORGE Police Constable SALVATORE FRANCESCO Sergeant DINO Detective PIETRO Plainclothes Police Constable CHRISTOPHER RICHARD Police Constable CINDYLOU CHRISTINA Project & Policy Co-ordinator KEVIN Plainclothes Police Constable PATRICIA ANN Sergeant ROBERT-THEO Police Constable GLENN Staff Sergeant PAULINE Detective Sergeant ROBERT Sergeant BRANDON LLOYD Plainclothes Police Constable JAMES Plainclothes Police Constable JOHN Detective RONALD TERRY Police Constable COLIN Detective Sergeant FIONA Detective MICHAELA SARA Police Constable KIMBERLEY ANNE Police Constable CYNTHIA Police Constable JAMES Detective Sergeant KIMBERLEY SARA Staff Superintendent MARIE Detective Sergeant THOMAS ROBERT Detective ROBERT K. Staff Sergeant ROBERT R. Detective SANDRA Sergeant TREVOR PIXLEY Police Constable ROBERT Detective MICHAEL Detective DHARMENDRA SINGH Police Constable THIERRY Detective MICHAEL Detective TREVOR SCOTT Police Constable GARY Plainclothes Police Constable LINDSAY GLENA Police Constable PAUL Police Constable SHAIN MICHAEL Sergeant DAVID Detective SEAN RONALD Sergeant ROBERT MICHAEL Sergeant LISA Sergeant SCOTT WILLIAM Plainclothes Police Constable KIMBERLY Detective Sergeant PAVEL Manager of Information Systems TODD Sergeant GREGORY Detective Sergeant JOSEPH ANDREW Plainclothes Police Constable DALE Sergeant KEVIN Staff Sergeant MICHAEL Detective JACK JACOB Sergeant JANICE Plainclothes Police Constable

Surname GORDON GOSS GOTELL GOTTSCHALK GOTTSCHALK GOTTSCHLING GOUDIE GOUGH GOULAH GOUTHRO GOUVEIA GOWAN GOWANLOCK GRACE GRAFFMANN GRAHAM GRAHAM GRAMMATIKOS GRANATA GRANBERG GRANDE GRANT GRANT GRANT GRANT GRAVELIJN GRAY GRAY GRAY GREAVES GREAVETTE GREEN GREEN GREENAWAY GREENAWAY GREENE GREENER GREENLAW GREENWOOD GREENWOOD GREER GREER GREGORY GREGORY GREGORY GREGORY GREIG GREKOS GREWAL GRIALDI GRIERSON GRIEVE GRIEVES GRIFFIN GRIFFIN GRIFFIN GRIFFITHS GRIFFITHS GRIS GRISOLIA GRONDIN GROSS GROSS GROVER GROVES GUERREIRO GUEST GUEST GURMAN GURR GUTHRIE

Salary Paid $ 107,688.24 $ 101,216.29 $ 124,328.00 $ 120,755.78 $ 119,454.23 $ 102,339.86 $ 109,714.49 $ 109,983.73 $ 113,716.35 $ 109,450.77 $ 100,094.44 $ 103,395.15 $ 112,996.62 $ 114,197.39 $ 119,209.29 $ 102,060.80 $ 109,442.13 $ 100,150.81 $ 112,964.26 $ 111,704.19 $ 120,222.86 $ 103,142.51 $ 135,114.14 $ 105,766.76 $ 108,419.19 $ 100,885.40 $ 123,389.65 $ 134,550.55 $ 111,942.58 $ 101,470.61 $ 102,538.62 $ 111,073.83 $ 102,711.93 $ 119,209.29 $ 108,992.46 $ 106,633.37 $ 101,402.84 $ 105,367.64 $ 121,612.87 $ 187,100.31 $ 119,716.75 $ 120,014.84 $ 119,832.26 $ 108,604.12 $ 111,820.52 $ 100,227.96 $ 116,987.11 $ 119,645.00 $ 109,683.67 $ 117,725.96 $ 110,007.17 $ 107,375.82 $ 105,158.25 $ 104,283.47 $ 106,495.71 $ 108,607.63 $ 126,529.67 $ 117,355.11 $ 106,640.43 $ 107,654.48 $ 114,611.60 $ 122,943.71 $ 157,155.15 $ 107,985.86 $ 132,372.84 $ 106,961.88 $ 108,576.62 $ 119,338.04 $ 124,155.08 $ 105,048.49 $ 100,135.76

Benefits $393.76 $307.93 $737.72 $744.60 $571.46 $669.95 $708.56 $237.95 $686.42 $708.56 $693.44 $701.67 $240.65 $681.67 $744.60 $669.95 $717.06 $669.95 $717.06 $708.56 $691.36 $669.95 $886.80 $700.32 $701.67 $662.93 $744.60 $744.60 $292.08 $666.29 $692.91 $717.06 $259.39 $744.60 $292.08 $662.93 $669.95 $684.37 $744.60 $10,622.31 $744.60 $708.56 $744.60 $717.06 $715.78 $662.93 $717.06 $708.56 $685.20 $708.56 $711.97 $675.34 $275.34 $669.95 $684.37 $701.67 $717.06 $717.06 $695.77 $712.28 $686.42 $744.60 $991.86 $712.59 $739.50 $686.42 $292.08 $744.60 $717.06 $386.87 $268.46

Appendix A RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Given Name Position JAMSHID Police Constable ELIZABETH ANNE Police Constable PETER Police Constable FAZAL MOHAMMED Plainclothes Police Constable AMIN Sergeant DAVID Police Constable LORI LYNN Detective EHSAN Police Constable GREGORY KRIKOR Detective DAVID JOSEPH Police Constable DAVID PAUL Sergeant KEITH Staff Sergeant RICHARD PAUL Plainclothes Police Constable GARY Sergeant MOHAMMAD ABID Police Constable ADAM RYAN Plainclothes Police Constable KEITH JOHN Police Constable RHONDA GAYLE Plainclothes Police Constable MARK HARIVALD Police Constable ALVIN DALTON Sergeant JOHN Police Constable NEIL HARCOURT Plainclothes Police Constable WILLIAM MICHAEL Plainclothes Police Constable DARREN Staff Sergeant KEVIN STEWART Police Constable MICHAEL S. Police Constable MICHAEL J. Staff Sergeant ROWAN ALLEN Police Constable SCOTT ANDREW Police Constable JANINE RHONA Sergeant KIMBERLY Detective AMY CHRISTINE Plainclothes Police Constable PHILIP ALLEN Detective CHRISTINE Plainclothes Police Constable ERIN VALENTINE Plainclothes Police Constable DALJIT Sergeant KATHLEEN ANN Police Constable PETER Police Constable JEFFREY Plainclothes Police Constable RUSSELL Police Constable ROBERT Sergeant ADAM MICHAEL Plainclothes Police Constable ALEXANDER PETRIE Police Constable DAVID Sergeant ROBERT Detective MICHAEL STEVENS Police Constable USMAN Police Constable JOHN Detective JULIA ANNE Police Constable CRAIG EDWARD Police Constable DAVID C. Detective DAVID ANTHONY Senior Analyst DEBBIE Detective KIMBERLEY ANN Plainclothes Police Constable RICHARD VICTOR Detective STEPHEN ARTHUR Staff Inspector KEITH ISSAC Police Constable DOUGLAS Detective DEBORAH Detective THOMAS JOSEPH Detective DONALD Plainclothes Police Constable MARK Sergeant MELISSA ANNE Police Constable ANDREW Plainclothes Police Constable ALAN Detective Sergeant BERNARD THOMAS Sergeant MICHAEL BROWNLEE Plainclothes Police Constable HILARY LAURENE Plainclothes Police Constable ROBERT GEOFFREY Plainclothes Police Constable JEREMY MATTHEW Detective ROY EDWARD Plainclothes Police Constable

Surname HABIBULLAH HADDEN HADDRELL HAFFEJEE HAFIZ HAGERMAN HAGGETT HAGHSHENAS HAGOPIAN HAIN HAINES HAINES HAINES HAITZER HAJI HALAGIAN HALES HALEY HALJASTE HALL HALL HALL HALL HALMAN HAMILTON HAMILTON HAMILTON-GREENER HAMLET HAMPSON HANCOCK HANCOCK HANDSOR HANDSOR HANDY HANLON HANS HANSEN HANSEN HANTON HARDY HARGAN HARKER HARLEY HARLOCK HARNETT HARNISH HAROON HARRAS HARRINGTON HARRIS HARRIS HARRIS HARRIS HARRIS HARRIS HARRIS HARRISON HART HARTFORD HARTFORD HARVEY HARVEY HASIUK HASSALL HAUNTS HAWCO HAWKEN HAWKINS HAWKINS HAYES HAYES

Salary Paid $ 108,630.09 $ 118,214.70 $ 100,470.12 $ 117,412.06 $ 117,983.26 $ 113,158.76 $ 106,117.17 $ 109,849.76 $ 106,651.08 $ 102,519.42 $ 109,258.84 $ 134,527.29 $ 119,052.15 $ 109,130.55 $ 104,112.69 $ 101,167.11 $ 107,772.46 $ 104,880.36 $ 116,566.06 $ 118,780.45 $ 108,257.02 $ 123,708.64 $ 129,069.32 $ 121,380.86 $ 100,934.17 $ 100,367.02 $ 126,936.39 $ 108,368.13 $ 137,227.80 $ 108,272.74 $ 115,609.23 $ 107,983.96 $ 122,452.38 $ 101,444.17 $ 120,497.74 $ 108,659.83 $ 108,830.74 $ 104,192.37 $ 102,805.79 $ 100,756.05 $ 131,521.20 $ 100,561.17 $ 103,897.14 $ 115,482.31 $ 137,617.38 $ 109,004.07 $ 116,830.15 $ 122,269.34 $ 101,885.95 $ 102,212.54 $ 118,519.37 $ 104,628.21 $ 163,028.95 $ 109,111.61 $ 118,671.84 $ 159,333.33 $ 109,633.14 $ 126,381.17 $ 111,993.22 $ 116,432.01 $ 104,256.31 $ 119,451.01 $ 103,111.89 $ 104,261.96 $ 120,754.47 $ 112,602.01 $ 100,742.53 $ 102,120.81 $ 102,668.38 $ 126,253.54 $ 111,238.04

Benefits $662.93 $676.70 $684.37 $681.54 $717.06 $694.22 $566.90 $658.58 $701.67 $669.95 $701.67 $744.60 $679.01 $370.78 $669.95 $686.42 $669.95 $686.42 $675.34 $708.56 $684.37 $686.42 $686.42 $740.97 $674.22 $684.37 $744.60 $669.95 $669.95 $708.56 $717.06 $686.42 $701.67 $693.44 $684.34 $717.06 $683.13 $684.59 $558.66 $676.70 $717.06 $681.80 $662.93 $717.06 $710.11 $669.95 $662.93 $717.06 $662.93 $684.37 $717.06 $280.88 $717.06 $261.44 $701.67 $14,255.20 $662.93 $717.06 $717.06 $292.08 $275.34 $710.11 $675.34 $700.32 $744.60 $714.50 $671.78 $261.44 $686.42 $701.67 $700.32

Appendix A RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Given Name Position SHAWN EARL Police Constable MICHAEL BANCROFT Sergeant ANDREW EDWARD Plainclothes Police Constable CHRISTOPHER SEAN Plainclothes Police Constable ERNEST DAVID Plainclothes Police Constable HARMAN SINGH Police Constable DARRELL MAURICE Police Constable MARK Sergeant SANDRA DAWN Police Constable STEVEN ROSS Plainclothes Police Constable CHRISTINE Senior Operations Supervisor MICHAEL DAVID Detective GERALD Staff Sergeant CHRISTOPHER SHAYNE Sergeant JASON MARK Plainclothes Police Constable CORY MICHAEL Plainclothes Police Constable NATALIE MONIQUE Detective RICHARD Inspector KARL Staff Sergeant ROBERT MATTHEW Detective GEORGE JOHANNES Plainclothes Police Constable GEOFFREY PAUL Police Constable NORMAN GEORGE Manager of Fleet and Materials Management KEITH Detective BART Plainclothes Police Constable HEINZ Detective ANN-MARIE PATRICIA Manager of Benefits and Employment PETER Staff Sergeant CHRISTOPHER KEITH Police Constable CLIFFORD Police Constable GEOFFREY Detective DEBORAH Police Constable DONALD Plainclothes Police Constable STEPHEN MARK Police Constable ELIZABETH JANINE Manager of Budgeting and Control BROOKE LESLIE Plainclothes Police Constable KENT Sergeant PHILIP JOSEPH Detective MARCIE LYNN Detective STEPHEN Sergeant ANDREW CRAIG Sergeant ELISA Sergeant TODD ELLIOT Plainclothes Police Constable LYNDA DAWN Sergeant SHAUN CHRISTOPHER Plainclothes Police Constable LESLEY Staff Sergeant ELIOT LEWIS Police Constable IRA NORMAN Detective SHANE Detective TODD GARRY Sergeant JASON SABINO Plainclothes Police Constable TYRONE CHRISTOPHER Detective D'ARCY LIAM Police Constable GORDON IAN Police Constable PATRICK JAMES Plainclothes Police Constable ALEC KAI-KWUN Parking Enforcement Officer JOSEPH CHOA Plainclothes Police Constable KENNY KONG-LEUNG Staff Sergeant MATTHEW WEI-EN Police Constable OLIVER NICHOLAS Plainclothes Police Constable ALAN GARY Sergeant TERENCE ALEC Plainclothes Police Constable STEPHANIE Detective ADAM ROY Plainclothes Police Constable DOUGLAS Police Constable MARK GREGORY Police Constable FREDERICK ALVIN Police Constable JASON JOSEPH Plainclothes Police Constable CHRISTOPHER ALEXANDER Plainclothes Police Constable GREGORY RODNEY Plainclothes Police Constable RUSSELL DANIEL Detective

Surname HAYES HAYLES HAYNES HAYNES HAYNES HAYRE HAYWARD HAYWARD HAZELL HEAD HEADLEY HEALY HEANEY HEARD HEARD HEDGEMAN HEGARTY HEGEDUS HEILIMO HEITZNER HEMPEN HENDERSON HENDERSON HENDRICKS HENDRIKS HENKEL HENRY HENRY HENSCHELL HERRON HESSE HEUGHAN HEUGHAN HEWITT HEWNER HEWSON HEWSON HIBBELN HICKMOTT HICKS HIGGINS HIGGITT HIGO HILBORN HILDEBRAND HILDRED HILL HILL HILL HILLHOUSE HILLIER HILTON HIND HINES HISCOX HO HO HO HO HO HOBBINS HOBOR HOCHRADL-ZORKO HOCKADAY HODGERT HODGINS HODGSON HODKIN HOELLER HOFFMAN HOFFMEYER

Salary Paid $ 100,217.87 $ 107,345.54 $ 103,711.49 $ 106,357.68 $ 106,955.78 $ 100,178.53 $ 101,543.60 $ 159,804.91 $ 104,851.43 $ 108,947.25 $ 110,426.74 $ 114,852.22 $ 122,430.07 $ 129,146.18 $ 109,254.50 $ 111,117.87 $ 107,051.92 $ 148,670.25 $ 120,184.76 $ 120,034.90 $ 101,886.77 $ 113,866.62 $ 169,379.76 $ 109,795.00 $ 100,113.48 $ 115,467.42 $ 146,231.71 $ 122,753.47 $ 107,053.93 $ 102,209.10 $ 112,938.34 $ 110,598.17 $ 111,339.38 $ 149,811.47 $ 161,546.29 $ 118,536.92 $ 111,609.49 $ 115,524.75 $ 103,781.10 $ 113,069.47 $ 107,533.53 $ 101,696.72 $ 116,230.93 $ 109,024.29 $ 111,669.80 $ 121,478.33 $ 106,880.11 $ 122,668.14 $ 116,577.65 $ 108,172.86 $ 106,670.68 $ 117,242.23 $ 112,193.69 $ 107,217.27 $ 107,419.43 $ 100,081.39 $ 109,497.72 $ 117,625.87 $ 102,775.48 $ 104,238.87 $ 103,739.64 $ 105,496.69 $ 109,508.60 $ 118,804.48 $ 119,859.00 $ 116,335.14 $ 105,766.89 $ 105,724.90 $ 111,311.80 $ 109,647.09 $ 106,413.99

Benefits $669.95 $701.93 $678.70 $693.44 $686.42 $669.95 $669.95 $717.06 $669.95 $686.42 $713.15 $717.06 $737.72 $362.28 $686.42 $676.05 $647.77 $949.04 $744.60 $708.56 $686.42 $669.95 $1,038.45 $717.06 $693.44 $717.06 $952.79 $744.60 $669.95 $259.39 $717.06 $684.37 $700.32 $673.61 $1,009.30 $686.42 $717.06 $292.08 $701.67 $717.06 $701.67 $695.77 $691.88 $713.86 $686.42 $744.60 $669.95 $717.06 $708.56 $708.56 $678.70 $701.67 $682.76 $669.95 $677.88 $595.54 $693.44 $730.70 $662.06 $682.50 $701.67 $635.42 $708.56 $678.09 $684.37 $669.95 $669.95 $686.42 $678.70 $678.49 $701.67

Appendix A RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Given Name Position MATTHEW ROBERT Sergeant JAMES Detective Sergeant ADKIN Detective PAUL Plainclothes Police Constable MARK LEWIS Plainclothes Police Constable RICHARD WARREN Plainclothes Police Constable NEIL Plainclothes Police Constable JOHN Sergeant GLENN Inspector PAWEL Police Constable ANDREW Police Constable KEVIN JOSEPH Sergeant BRADLEY Detective JEFFREY DAVID Detective RICHARD FREDERICK Police Constable GREGORY ALLEN Police Constable GAVIN Detective BRIAN Police Constable CHRISTOPHER NEIL Plainclothes Police Constable RYAN KNIGHT Plainclothes Police Constable DEBRA Staff Sergeant JEANETTE MARIE Compensation and Benefits Analyst JOEL MICHAEL Police Constable GWENYTH Detective ELDON Police Constable SHAWN Police Constable JEFFREY Staff Sergeant JOHN Staff Sergeant WAYNE VINCENT Plainclothes Police Constable WAYNE Plainclothes Police Constable MARIO Sergeant MICHAEL THOMAS Plainclothes Police Constable YI Police Constable SIMON Plainclothes Police Constable ERWIN WERNER Plainclothes Police Constable SIMONE GABRIELLE Plainclothes Police Constable NOEL MCNAIR Police Constable GUY Police Constable LYNN Sergeant TRUDY Detective REGINALD GUY Plainclothes Police Constable JUSTYN DAVID Plainclothes Police Constable JAMES Staff Sergeant JEFFREY Plainclothes Police Constable LESLIE FAN Police Constable CHRISTOPHER DAVID Plainclothes Police Constable GLEN STEPHEN Police Constable PETER Plainclothes Police Constable ROBERT Detective KAREN Sergeant JASON COLIN Plainclothes Police Constable JASON LESLIE Police Constable WILLIAM ANTHONY Staff Sergeant MOHAMMED SALEEM Detective RIYAZ Inspector WILLIAM Detective DANIEL WILLIAM Sergeant MARK DEREK Police Constable TRACEY LYNN Police Constable THOMAS YUNG-YIH Police Constable SCOTT ANDREW Plainclothes Police Constable VLADIM ADRIAN Police Constable HANK Detective Sergeant JOHN CHRISTOPHER Detective DANIEL JAMES Plainclothes Police Constable THOMAS ALLEN Detective PAUL LEO Plainclothes Police Constable CRAIG NORMAN Police Constable DEAN FRANCIS Sergeant ALESSANDRO Detective MORGAN HARRIS Police Constable

Surname HOFLAND HOGAN HOLDER HOLDER HOLLAND HOLLINGSHEAD HOLLYWOOD HOLMES HOLT HOLUBKO HONG HOOPER HOOVER HOPKINS HOPTON HORNBY HORNER HORTON HORTON HORWOOD HOUSTON HOUSTON HOUSTON HOVEY HOWARD HOWARD HOWELL HOWELL HOWELL HOWLETT HREPIC HRYHORSKY HU HUBBARD HUBER HUBER HUDSON HUGHES HUGHES HUGHES HUGHSON HUMENIUK HUNG HUNG HUNG HUNT HUNT HUNT HUNT HUNTE HUNTER HURLEY HURLEY HUSAIN HUSSEIN HUTCHEON HUTCHINGS HUTCHINGS HUTCHINGS HWANG HYLAND IANCU IDSINGA IHASZ ILSON IMRIE INGLEY INGLIS ION IONTA IRELAND

Salary Paid $ 103,457.23 $ 117,564.44 $ 107,360.88 $ 113,961.91 $ 111,155.87 $ 110,880.09 $ 112,206.08 $ 112,189.51 $ 152,677.12 $ 107,710.61 $ 128,424.74 $ 106,233.80 $ 112,622.16 $ 105,591.56 $ 107,960.40 $ 111,623.59 $ 130,555.63 $ 117,534.45 $ 107,699.22 $ 107,488.72 $ 117,496.83 $ 112,460.69 $ 100,426.76 $ 108,725.64 $ 132,390.92 $ 123,588.28 $ 121,173.37 $ 125,151.89 $ 113,187.49 $ 105,221.31 $ 113,936.85 $ 115,089.38 $ 108,382.39 $ 129,191.34 $ 107,468.07 $ 101,306.49 $ 100,569.53 $ 122,010.42 $ 108,506.72 $ 111,314.01 $ 110,156.09 $ 109,685.56 $ 117,674.95 $ 103,952.32 $ 107,619.07 $ 111,770.31 $ 103,466.01 $ 102,600.60 $ 116,962.93 $ 110,178.94 $ 104,584.50 $ 116,125.07 $ 120,985.63 $ 116,521.85 $ 152,632.83 $ 112,203.99 $ 104,880.84 $ 101,529.20 $ 100,513.25 $ 105,306.38 $ 101,841.57 $ 113,194.60 $ 156,615.97 $ 123,507.11 $ 113,831.05 $ 110,168.82 $ 113,935.13 $ 107,218.32 $ 100,637.45 $ 106,517.44 $ 124,978.16

Benefits $701.67 $596.06 $566.90 $693.44 $686.42 $700.32 $693.44 $717.06 $949.04 $662.93 $669.95 $701.67 $292.08 $701.67 $662.93 $676.70 $717.06 $679.56 $686.42 $685.20 $738.97 $825.49 $669.95 $717.06 $684.37 $676.70 $744.60 $744.60 $686.42 $700.32 $708.56 $686.42 $662.93 $693.44 $686.42 $686.42 $651.62 $683.13 $708.56 $377.92 $693.44 $686.42 $731.34 $686.42 $662.93 $678.70 $678.20 $700.32 $717.06 $708.56 $672.39 $662.93 $744.60 $701.93 $792.69 $717.06 $701.67 $662.93 $663.19 $244.97 $678.70 $662.93 $313.99 $717.06 $678.70 $701.67 $675.65 $669.95 $691.73 $701.67 $669.95

Appendix A RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Given Name Position DAVID Detective PETER Plainclothes Police Constable TIMOTHY GARNET Detective ZACHARY JAMES Plainclothes Police Constable STEPHEN Inspector DAVID ANTHONY Plainclothes Police Constable RICHARD MATTHEW Police Constable WILLIADOR JR. Plainclothes Police Constable CHRISTOPHER Police Constable PETER ANTONI Police Constable STEVEN Staff Inspector LAURIE Staff Sergeant PAUL EDWARD Police Constable ROBERT MICHAEL Police Constable TIMOTHY ALFRED Detective SHELDON ALEXANDER Police Constable ALLISTAIR WINSTON Police Constable BRIAN STEVEN Police Constable GARY Plainclothes Police Constable RITA ANNE Police Constable JAMES WILLIAM Police Constable JOSHUA PAYAM Detective Sergeant DANIEL MARCIN Police Constable GARY AMBROSE Plainclothes Police Constable LILJANA Plainclothes Police Constable ANGELO TYRELL Sergeant GAWAIN MARIO Sergeant RUSSELL Detective Sergeant ELAN Plainclothes Police Constable MONISH SINGH Police Constable CLINT Police Constable ASIF ALI Police Constable ALLEN Sergeant CLINTON RICHARD Training Constable CHARANJIT Police Constable FRANCISCO RAUL Police Constable GEORGE Plainclothes Police Constable ROBERT LYNDON Plainclothes Police Constable TODD JOESEPH Detective CHRISTOPHER GUNSTEIN Plainclothes Police Constable JEANILLE MARIA Detective MARK DOUGLAS Plainclothes Police Constable DAVID EDWARD Detective JENNIFER ANNE Staff Sergeant KEVIN WILLIAM Police Constable MARTIN NATHANIEL Police Constable ROBERT Inspector BRENT ANDREW Plainclothes Police Constable BRIAN HUGH Detective CHARLES Sergeant JEFFREY Plainclothes Police Constable JOHN DAVID Plainclothes Police Constable TRICIA MARLENE Detective WENDY ELIZABETH Sergeant ADRIANNE Staff Sergeant ANDREW PAUL Detective Sergeant TIMOTHY Detective RAZMIKE AVEDIKE Police Constable COREY LEE Sergeant DOUGLAS ALBERT Plainclothes Police Constable GORDON Inspector JASON NEIL Police Constable LEANNE Sergeant PAUL CHRISTOPHER Detective SANDRA MAUREEN Sergeant THOMAS Plainclothes Police Constable LHAWANG TOPGYAL Detective RONALD RAJESH Police Constable TREVOR JOHN Police Constable ADAM KIRK Police Constable MLADEN Sergeant

Surname IRISH IRISH IRISH IRVINE IRWIN ISABELLO ISHERWOOD ISIP ITO IZDEBSKI IZZETT JACKSON JACKSON JACKSON JACOB JACOBS JAMES JAMES JAMES JAMES JAMISON JAMSHIDI JANECZKO JANES JANKULOVSKI JANSZ JANSZ JAROSZ JARVIS JASWAL JATTAN JEEVA JENKINS JENKINS JHAJJ JIMENEZ JIRI JITTA JOCKO JODOIN JOHN JOHNS JOHNSON JOHNSON JOHNSON JOHNSON JOHNSON JOHNSTON JOHNSTON JOHNSTON JOHNSTON JOHNSTON JOHNSTON JOHNSTON JOHNSTONE JOHNSTONE JOHNSTONE JOKAKELIAN JONES JONES JONES JONES JONES JONES JONES JONES JONGDONG JOSEPH JOSEPH JOSEPHS JOSIFOVIC

Salary Paid $ 119,282.67 $ 103,437.57 $ 119,689.47 $ 105,893.73 $ 147,898.37 $ 118,801.16 $ 104,476.15 $ 102,625.36 $ 106,993.59 $ 108,118.40 $ 151,937.14 $ 120,701.20 $ 119,404.21 $ 104,958.62 $ 132,023.54 $ 101,285.76 $ 107,596.14 $ 113,483.31 $ 113,020.08 $ 110,171.36 $ 114,106.11 $ 117,797.47 $ 104,828.09 $ 110,692.56 $ 105,274.77 $ 107,699.83 $ 122,618.05 $ 124,803.17 $ 102,596.60 $ 100,273.14 $ 121,347.40 $ 104,419.25 $ 115,700.26 $ 100,942.61 $ 122,237.07 $ 117,448.63 $ 110,290.85 $ 109,541.82 $ 122,823.81 $ 104,865.75 $ 106,290.40 $ 104,591.22 $ 109,459.22 $ 114,345.22 $ 100,399.10 $ 106,209.71 $ 147,309.79 $ 116,110.53 $ 131,147.51 $ 115,671.11 $ 136,570.30 $ 123,808.71 $ 108,072.25 $ 104,690.55 $ 114,142.39 $ 126,859.75 $ 137,433.25 $ 109,788.50 $ 115,590.61 $ 102,879.70 $ 168,419.96 $ 104,599.41 $ 113,557.30 $ 106,619.45 $ 106,703.89 $ 111,337.13 $ 116,758.48 $ 107,457.77 $ 111,089.57 $ 103,965.50 $ 123,152.18

Benefits $717.06 $700.32 $708.56 $686.42 $949.04 $674.68 $662.93 $686.42 $662.93 $662.93 $6,852.32 $742.52 $684.37 $669.95 $708.56 $669.95 $677.27 $669.95 $700.32 $669.95 $244.97 $730.70 $662.93 $686.68 $686.42 $695.77 $701.67 $744.60 $275.34 $662.93 $684.37 $661.19 $292.08 $680.58 $676.70 $662.93 $686.42 $685.46 $701.67 $686.42 $708.56 $686.42 $708.56 $730.70 $669.95 $662.93 $946.68 $686.42 $717.06 $708.56 $700.32 $686.42 $701.93 $689.87 $730.70 $737.72 $717.06 $669.95 $701.67 $700.32 $949.04 $418.11 $715.78 $701.67 $566.90 $637.36 $701.67 $656.84 $669.95 $676.70 $717.06

Appendix A RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Given Name Position JOSEPH Staff Sergeant RICHARD ANDREW Plainclothes Police Constable ALEXANDER GYOZO Plainclothes Police Constable JAMIE CHRISTINE Police Constable BRUCE Police Constable DAMIEN JOHN Police Constable ANGELA CHRISTINE Plainclothes Police Constable GEORGE Sergeant DAVID Police Constable SHAWN GERALD Police Constable GURJOT SINGH Police Constable JESSY TARA Plainclothes Police Constable IVAN ALEKSANDROVICH Police Constable KEVIN JOHN Training Constable PANAYIOTIS NICKOLAS Sergeant GERALD GEORGE Police Constable HANUMANTHA Senior Analyst BRADLEY JOSEPH Police Constable TREVOR VINCENT Plainclothes Police Constable TREVOR DANIEL Plainclothes Police Constable FAIZAL SHIRAZ Police Constable JAMES Police Constable DAWID WALDEMAR Police Constable JOCELYN Sergeant STELLA STAUROULA Sergeant BRANDON CHRISTOPHER Plainclothes Police Constable JOSEPH LUDWIK Police Constable CONSTANTINE Plainclothes Police Constable KAJAMUGANATHAN Plainclothes Police Constable AMAR SINGH Police Constable TIMOTHY Sergeant BRIAN Detective COLIN Staff Sergeant GRANT MICHAEL Police Constable WILLIAM DONALD Police Constable DEVIN Detective Sergeant PATRICK Detective Sergeant JASON YVON Plainclothes Police Constable CHRISTOPHER THOMAS Plainclothes Police Constable JASON WADE Plainclothes Police Constable JEFFREY STEWART Police Constable BRIAN MURRAY Police Constable TREVOR PAUL Police Constable BRIAN WAYNE Detective Sergeant DENISE EUGENIA Police Constable DIANE MARY Police Constable RYAN ANDREW Plainclothes Police Constable TERENCE PETER Detective WILLIAM Staff Sergeant DARRYL MARTIN Plainclothes Police Constable CHRISTOPHER Police Constable DORNA TRESIA Police Constable GEOFFREY Sergeant IAN DANIEL Detective BRIAN Staff Sergeant SUZANNE Detective GEOFFREY Police Constable KYLE Detective MICHAEL WILLIAM Plainclothes Police Constable ROBERT Police Constable SAMUEL WILLIAM Police Constable STEVEN HAROLD Plainclothes Police Constable ZELJKO Police Constable RYAN MATHEW Plainclothes Police Constable GARY Staff Sergeant AHMAR ALI Police Constable MOHAMMAD ASAD ULLAH Police Constable OMAR ASHRAF Detective RONALD ARLINGTON Staff Sergeant WAHID Police Constable ARSHAD SADIQ Training Constable

Surname JOSTIAK JUDD JUHASZ JUHASZ JUPP KACHUR KAHNT KALDIS KALWIES KANE KANG KAPITANY KAPLIOUK KAPOSY KARAGAN KARAKOCHUK KARAVADI KARGES KARJALAINEN KARKOULAS KARMALI KARPIK KARPUC KARR KARRAS KARSTOFF KASZYCA KATAFIGIOTIS KATHIRAVELU KATOCH KAVANAGH KAY KAY KAY KAY KEALEY KEANE KEEFER KEELER KEHLER KELL KELLAR KELLOWAY KELLY KELLY KELLY KELLY KELLY KEMP KEMPSTER KENNEDY KENNEDY KENNEDY KENNEDY KENNY KERNOHAN KERR KERR KERR KERR KERR KERR KESIC KEVEZA KEYS KHAN KHAN KHAN KHAN KHAN KHAWAJA

Salary Paid $ 122,651.50 $ 110,742.59 $ 121,594.01 $ 102,944.35 $ 123,961.92 $ 102,129.42 $ 103,742.70 $ 110,415.74 $ 101,523.99 $ 106,127.81 $ 114,441.09 $ 103,793.06 $ 106,258.46 $ 100,837.20 $ 109,006.89 $ 102,123.92 $ 104,928.21 $ 115,269.15 $ 114,172.34 $ 123,047.30 $ 104,155.04 $ 116,341.64 $ 100,296.66 $ 112,612.24 $ 113,834.69 $ 104,259.07 $ 108,579.12 $ 109,809.76 $ 104,517.26 $ 101,565.28 $ 113,484.75 $ 126,420.13 $ 137,715.88 $ 104,146.88 $ 131,817.73 $ 119,303.47 $ 119,435.49 $ 111,559.90 $ 121,229.51 $ 108,963.73 $ 120,020.62 $ 102,946.44 $ 104,140.97 $ 122,114.49 $ 100,346.03 $ 107,811.04 $ 105,703.94 $ 126,493.51 $ 125,656.97 $ 106,684.26 $ 110,358.58 $ 103,994.32 $ 112,907.97 $ 107,392.71 $ 119,506.04 $ 112,486.27 $ 104,506.72 $ 111,657.58 $ 106,311.66 $ 115,869.69 $ 112,116.80 $ 106,876.89 $ 101,905.64 $ 110,205.36 $ 119,567.13 $ 128,842.32 $ 104,004.46 $ 130,163.02 $ 129,814.64 $ 103,055.97 $ 100,151.25

Benefits $709.32 $686.42 $678.70 $662.93 $684.37 $663.19 $673.61 $717.06 $589.93 $662.93 $662.93 $678.70 $669.64 $686.42 $701.67 $654.23 $280.88 $669.95 $696.19 $686.16 $675.44 $684.37 $662.93 $717.06 $701.67 $686.42 $683.37 $686.42 $676.31 $676.70 $717.06 $717.06 $728.28 $662.93 $669.95 $319.62 $429.80 $686.42 $693.44 $686.42 $669.95 $669.95 $654.23 $737.72 $654.23 $682.76 $686.42 $708.56 $744.60 $254.03 $676.70 $685.20 $717.06 $701.67 $744.60 $717.06 $684.37 $717.06 $686.42 $684.37 $684.37 $686.42 $682.76 $678.70 $744.60 $662.93 $662.93 $701.67 $646.03 $662.93 $693.44

Appendix A RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Given Name Position SUHAIL RASHID Police Constable MILPREET SINGH Plainclothes Police Constable ZULFIQAR ALI Parking Enforcement Officer ALI NADER Plainclothes Police Constable SIEWING Counsel SHEIKH AHMAD Police Constable CHERYL NOREEN Human Resources Application Specialist JAMES JEFFREY Plainclothes Police Constable ASTRID Training Constable KATHLEEN LAUREN Police Constable KRISTINE JEAN Director of Corporate Services ANTON Police Constable CHARLES WON-JIN Sergeant HOON (RICHARD) Police Constable HYOK KYUN Police Constable JIN HOI (JOE) Police Constable JONG WOO Police Constable MIN CHUL Police Constable SAMUEL-CHONG Police Constable SANG HYUP Police Constable SANG-RAE SAM Manager of Enterprise Architecture SIN-JOONG SIN Plainclothes Police Constable DAVID RUSSELL Police Constable CHERYL Staff Sergeant DWAYNE EDWARD Plainclothes Police Constable STUART MACPHERSON Sergeant SCOTT ANTHONY Sergeant SHAWN IAN Police Constable KATHRYN Sergeant MICHAEL PETER Police Constable RANJAN WICKRAMASINGHE Police Constable CHRISTOPHER JOHN Detective Sergeant ANDREW Sergeant DARIUSZ Police Constable CHARLES SAFO Plainclothes Police Constable ANDREW JAMES Detective PETER Plainclothes Police Constable CAROL Sergeant BRIAN Police Constable JOSEPH CHRISTIAN Plainclothes Police Constable STEPHEN ROBERT Police Constable SHAWN EDWARD Plainclothes Police Constable GERARD WILLIAM Sergeant CHRISTOPHER JOSEPH Police Constable JOHN Sergeant JOHN Staff Sergeant WADE Plainclothes Police Constable ROBBERT NICOLAAS Staff Sergeant JULIE Plainclothes Police Constable GRAHAM KENNETH Plainclothes Police Constable KEITH PERCY Police Constable SIMON Police Constable DAVID Detective ALEKSANDAR SASHA Police Constable DAVID SUKJIN Police Constable BARBARA LOUISE Detective WENDY ELAINE Police Constable ANDREW Plainclothes Police Constable SANDRA Plainclothes Police Constable JASON Detective KAZIMIERZ Staff Sergeant PAUL LOUIS Plainclothes Police Constable MICHAEL Police Constable ARTUR JACEK Sergeant JULIA MARIE Police Constable JOSEPH MARK Police Constable FREDERICK JOSEPH Sergeant JASON Sergeant LORI PATRICIA Sergeant JOSEPH ANTHONY Detective MICHELLE MARLAINE Training Constable

Surname KHAWAJA KHERA KHIMANI KHOSHBOOI KHOW KHURSHID KICKSEE KIDD KIENS KIJEWSKI KIJEWSKI KILLY KIM KIM KIM KIM KIM KIM KIM KIM KIM KIM KIMMERER KING KING KING KINGDON KINGHORN KINNEAR KIPROFF KIRINDE KIRKPATRICK KIS KISIELEWSKI KISSI KITCHENER KLAAS KLACZA KLEIN-HORSMAN KLIMTSCHUCK KLINE KLODT KLUNDER KLUTZ KMIECIAK KNAAP KNAAP KNAPPER KNIGHT KNILL KNOBLAUCH KNOTT KNOWLES KOCANOVIC KOH KOHL KOHOUT KOLAR KOMARNISKY KONDO KONKEL KORAC KOSTIUK KOTAS KOTES KOVACIC KOZAR KRAFT KRANENBURG KRANJAC KRAWCZYK

Salary Paid $ 117,252.39 $ 102,519.46 $ 107,584.94 $ 117,587.44 $ 142,699.43 $ 115,322.39 $ 106,882.61 $ 103,174.10 $ 104,453.20 $ 100,224.34 $ 187,568.61 $ 105,259.21 $ 105,746.51 $ 102,924.92 $ 119,842.40 $ 102,841.94 $ 103,896.38 $ 128,145.79 $ 100,683.68 $ 102,102.30 $ 169,589.24 $ 109,138.21 $ 108,133.49 $ 119,911.16 $ 103,141.30 $ 121,293.66 $ 108,591.43 $ 100,814.54 $ 120,155.18 $ 100,892.58 $ 138,352.68 $ 119,845.95 $ 113,597.69 $ 116,787.12 $ 103,743.63 $ 121,476.91 $ 113,211.88 $ 108,747.24 $ 111,157.19 $ 110,743.91 $ 111,491.70 $ 113,656.19 $ 107,169.47 $ 103,103.91 $ 154,468.48 $ 119,209.29 $ 103,243.00 $ 123,939.80 $ 113,227.00 $ 110,079.83 $ 111,175.69 $ 108,395.41 $ 129,100.63 $ 100,545.82 $ 105,582.10 $ 111,960.36 $ 100,648.03 $ 115,105.60 $ 106,079.57 $ 120,376.81 $ 120,296.43 $ 111,158.70 $ 111,197.58 $ 112,744.26 $ 103,160.54 $ 117,445.76 $ 108,746.43 $ 105,811.66 $ 104,538.84 $ 104,913.97 $ 101,451.22

Benefits $662.93 $673.61 $595.54 $666.29 $361.00 $668.42 $400.51 $576.24 $700.32 $667.87 $1,088.82 $683.13 $701.67 $662.93 $662.93 $662.93 $669.95 $677.27 $662.93 $662.93 $1,038.45 $675.44 $669.95 $737.72 $693.44 $717.06 $701.67 $662.93 $717.06 $669.95 $678.52 $716.79 $717.06 $684.37 $669.88 $717.06 $686.42 $717.06 $662.93 $686.42 $662.93 $693.44 $701.67 $669.95 $708.56 $319.62 $700.32 $744.60 $700.32 $686.42 $676.70 $684.37 $717.06 $669.95 $316.65 $708.56 $674.48 $700.32 $693.44 $717.06 $744.60 $686.42 $681.27 $701.67 $662.93 $669.95 $695.77 $701.67 $701.67 $701.67 $693.44

Appendix A RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Given Name Position PAUL THOMAS Detective RICHARD Police Constable PIOTR PAWEL Plainclothes Police Constable HEINZ Staff Inspector RENE MICHAEL Training Constable JOEL PATRICK Detective Sergeant TANIA CHARLENE Plainclothes Police Constable TOMMY WING Police Constable LISA CRYSTAL Sergeant SERGIY ANATOLYOVICH Police Constable SAVAS Detective Sergeant REGINA Plainclothes Police Constable JEFFERY GUY Police Constable DAVID VIKTOR Plainclothes Police Constable JOSEPH Police Constable BROCK YVES Training Constable MARY REGINA Sergeant DAVID Police Constable VICTOR TZE-KAU Police Constable DARREN S Detective RICHARD ANTHONY Police Constable WAYNE Sergeant LALLMAN Parking Enforcement Officer LESTER ROYSON Plainclothes Police Constable IAN WAYNE Police Constable ANTHONY Police Constable JAMES W Police Constable DARRYL BRADLEY Police Constable IAN DAVID Staff Sergeant DARRYL JAMES Plainclothes Police Constable JOEL CHRISTIAN Plainclothes Police Constable ARTHUR Plainclothes Police Constable MICHEAL WILLIAM Police Constable CHRISTAIN TREVOR Police Constable JAMES DOUGLAS Police Constable LYNN Plainclothes Police Constable MARK Sergeant ROBIN Plainclothes Police Constable SYLVAIN AURELE Plainclothes Police Constable STEPHEN WILLIAM Detective WINSTON Sergeant DANIEL Police Constable JORDAN CHRISTOPHER Detective Sergeant PETER Sergeant CHRISTOPHER ALLEN Sergeant MANFRED JAMES Police Constable GREGORY EDWARD Detective NEVILLE DONAVON Plainclothes Police Constable SHAWN Sergeant ANDREW AVERY Detective ANTHONY Sergeant JAMES THOMAS Sergeant NICHOLAS WILLIAM Police Constable TERRENCE ANTHONY Plainclothes Police Constable NAM-NHAT Police Constable KENTON WILLIAM Training Constable KEVIN JOHN Detective JASON DAVID Plainclothes Police Constable DEREK WILLIAM Police Constable ADAM LIONEL Plainclothes Police Constable NORMAN Detective Sergeant DAVID Sergeant KIM Sergeant DEREK RICHARD Police Constable JAE-WOOK Sergeant JAMES STANTON Plainclothes Police Constable JOHN Plainclothes Police Constable JORGE Plainclothes Police Constable KAREN Police Constable KENNY Sergeant KYU IL Plainclothes Police Constable

Surname KRAWCZYK KRAWCZYK KRUCZEK KUCK KUHN KULMATYCKI KUMMER KUNG KURTS KUZNETSOV KYRIACOU LA BORDE LA FOSSE LAVALLEE LABELLE LADURANTAYE LAHEY LAI LAI LAING LAING LAKEY LALL LALLA LAM LAMANNA LAMBE LAMBIE LAMOND LANDRY LANDRY LANE LANE LANGFORD LANGFORD LANGILLE LANGLOIS LANIGAN LAPENSEE LARAMY LAROCHE LATINCIC LATTER LAUFER LAUSH LAVERS LAWR LAWRENCE LAWRENCE LAWSON LAWSON LAWSON LAWSON LAZARUS LE LEFORT LEAHY LEAL LEARY LEBLANC LEBLANC LECK LEDGERWOOD LEE LEE LEE LEE LEE LEE LEE LEE

Salary Paid $ 111,366.20 $ 107,157.59 $ 107,959.79 $ 158,197.96 $ 105,149.66 $ 153,385.80 $ 109,039.99 $ 118,196.97 $ 103,467.62 $ 110,729.87 $ 121,682.11 $ 100,093.46 $ 108,668.60 $ 126,435.82 $ 116,982.98 $ 106,864.12 $ 120,353.79 $ 102,433.73 $ 130,915.83 $ 123,016.29 $ 105,849.61 $ 109,308.51 $ 110,148.64 $ 112,384.63 $ 121,702.15 $ 100,363.20 $ 103,654.58 $ 115,837.43 $ 123,107.56 $ 108,811.11 $ 110,534.44 $ 128,769.74 $ 118,412.81 $ 109,157.88 $ 103,963.07 $ 106,567.39 $ 108,871.75 $ 104,953.58 $ 109,446.17 $ 127,854.40 $ 108,761.38 $ 111,244.42 $ 116,547.88 $ 117,949.98 $ 107,717.17 $ 108,132.35 $ 122,697.97 $ 104,268.10 $ 131,475.43 $ 106,008.74 $ 111,487.33 $ 139,503.11 $ 111,281.56 $ 109,130.60 $ 100,270.38 $ 101,810.53 $ 107,942.85 $ 113,744.96 $ 111,030.79 $ 117,046.14 $ 120,363.93 $ 109,930.33 $ 107,826.70 $ 114,544.92 $ 104,444.34 $ 111,802.33 $ 105,690.29 $ 104,767.68 $ 105,110.95 $ 130,297.94 $ 102,305.96

Benefits $276.69 $684.37 $673.61 $980.34 $685.20 $643.28 $686.42 $665.53 $701.67 $665.53 $744.60 $268.46 $676.05 $261.44 $629.28 $685.20 $708.56 $662.93 $669.95 $717.06 $669.95 $710.11 $595.54 $686.42 $663.19 $684.37 $684.37 $662.93 $737.72 $673.61 $686.42 $700.32 $662.93 $665.53 $669.95 $690.34 $708.56 $700.32 $686.42 $701.67 $292.08 $662.06 $737.72 $717.06 $708.56 $658.58 $717.06 $686.42 $708.56 $701.93 $708.56 $717.06 $662.93 $679.71 $669.95 $685.20 $708.56 $683.98 $672.75 $686.42 $744.60 $717.06 $708.56 $676.70 $701.67 $681.80 $693.44 $678.70 $252.90 $701.67 $678.70

Appendix A RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Given Name Position KYUNG SOO Police Constable NICOLE DENISE Staff Sergeant NOEL THOMAS Staff Sergeant PHILIP BRIAN Detective RANDALL JAMES Sergeant STEVEN MINTEK Police Constable GORDON WILLIAM Police Constable WILLIAM ANTHONY Police Constable MARC Plainclothes Police Constable JASON Detective ROBERT JAMES Detective KRISTIN NICOLE Police Constable SEAN Detective Sergeant SCOTT TIMOTHY Police Constable KIRK DEMETRICE Police Constable PETER Superintendent PAUL TONY Detective ANNE Sergeant DOUGLAS CLINT Police Constable MICHIELE MARIO Detective Sergeant HAMIL THEODORE Sergeant DOUGLAS REYNOLDS Training Constable SHEUNG Detective BRYCE STERLING Police Constable MARTIN Sergeant GARTH ST. Police Constable SHARON MARISOL Police Constable BOYD Detective ROBERT CHAK Police Constable ROBERT JOSEPH Police Constable SHAWN GERALD Police Constable DONG HYEOK DAVE Plainclothes Police Constable RODNEY JAMES Plainclothes Police Constable MICHAEL Police Constable MICHAEL Police Constable HOWARD ROSS Sergeant JONATHAN Detective JOHN THOMAS Plainclothes Police Constable DARRYL ANDREW Detective CALOGERO Plainclothes Police Constable METODIOS Detective ANDREW BRADLEY Plainclothes Police Constable WILLIAM NORMAN Police Constable ARNULFO JR. Police Constable DAVID VICTOR Police Constable IRENE Detective KEVIN FRANCIS Training Constable ARTHUR Inspector DARRIN Detective DAVID Plainclothes Police Constable MICHELLE LYNNE Detective TERENCE ANTHONY Detective BRUCE ZHIYONG Police Constable JUN Senior Telecom Engineer SHUXIN TONY Senior Programmer BRADFORD Detective DONOVAN Sergeant ALAN Sergeant BEVERLEY Sergeant RAMDIAL TIWARIE Police Constable LORENZO Detective CHRISTINE Detective GARRY Detective JOHN MICHAEL Police Constable JUDE ALEXANDER Detective ROWAN CARL Plainclothes Police Constable CATERINA Police Constable TROY WILLIAM Plainclothes Police Constable STEVEN CYRIL Sergeant MARC LEONEL Plainclothes Police Constable BING YU Plainclothes Police Constable

Surname LEE LEE LEE LEE LEE LEE LEECE LEERMAKERS LEFEBVRE LEITCH LEMAITRE LEMBKE LENFESTY LENGYEL LENNON LENNOX LENTSCH LEONARD LEONARD LEONE LESLIE LETSCHE LEUNG LEVERT LEVESQUE LEVY LEYVA LI LI LICOP LILLIE LIM LIMA LIMSIACO LINDALE LINDSAY LING LINNEY LINQUIST LIONTI LIOUMANIS LIPKUS LIPSEY LISANIN LISKA LISKA LISOWSKI LITTLE LITTLE LITTLE LITTLE LITTLE LIU LIU LIU LLOYD LOCKE LOCKEN LOGAN LOKENATH LOMBARDI LONG LONG LONG LOPES LOPEZ LORIA LORIMER LORRIMAN LORTIE LOU

Salary Paid $ 108,246.38 $ 120,436.56 $ 123,263.14 $ 123,164.02 $ 113,964.35 $ 101,392.77 $ 102,237.53 $ 103,801.67 $ 102,971.58 $ 124,224.83 $ 107,842.73 $ 121,420.00 $ 113,890.80 $ 103,827.05 $ 105,642.52 $ 165,629.09 $ 113,733.15 $ 108,791.26 $ 100,705.48 $ 117,123.89 $ 104,377.72 $ 104,156.58 $ 121,123.28 $ 112,941.13 $ 105,426.90 $ 101,122.45 $ 101,828.20 $ 116,615.97 $ 124,949.31 $ 107,454.07 $ 101,389.43 $ 107,062.92 $ 110,472.97 $ 103,294.45 $ 105,986.49 $ 117,378.69 $ 109,618.36 $ 106,604.63 $ 114,310.19 $ 122,804.54 $ 128,690.06 $ 111,335.10 $ 114,803.62 $ 106,187.28 $ 110,258.84 $ 132,477.63 $ 103,897.46 $ 148,544.58 $ 108,580.62 $ 115,600.29 $ 131,333.49 $ 128,117.77 $ 105,151.27 $ 126,134.08 $ 108,899.00 $ 123,670.14 $ 113,523.33 $ 113,519.66 $ 114,198.69 $ 104,253.04 $ 116,576.63 $ 108,740.53 $ 124,596.06 $ 114,835.25 $ 116,024.44 $ 103,750.38 $ 100,165.40 $ 104,998.55 $ 103,599.16 $ 112,852.64 $ 112,448.30

Benefits $662.93 $744.60 $744.60 $705.81 $701.67 $662.93 $669.95 $671.78 $700.32 $708.56 $701.67 $662.93 $730.70 $669.95 $662.93 $12,879.38 $701.67 $292.08 $662.93 $737.72 $701.67 $685.20 $708.56 $669.95 $701.67 $662.93 $663.19 $701.67 $669.95 $676.70 $662.93 $679.01 $686.42 $669.69 $684.37 $717.06 $717.06 $686.42 $701.67 $686.42 $701.67 $686.42 $669.95 $662.93 $669.95 $717.06 $686.42 $524.06 $402.26 $700.32 $708.56 $701.67 $662.93 $742.07 $257.90 $708.56 $654.45 $717.06 $717.06 $646.97 $717.06 $292.08 $717.06 $684.37 $701.67 $669.09 $669.09 $686.42 $701.67 $686.00 $686.42

Appendix A RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Given Name Position CORINA MICHELLE Plainclothes Police Constable EDWARD Detective Sergeant RENATA Sergeant ADAM COLIN Plainclothes Police Constable ALLEN ROBERT Sergeant SCOTT MARTIN Sergeant ALAN Staff Sergeant PATRICK Detective MARK Police Constable RICHARD ALEXANDER Plainclothes Police Constable DANIEL Detective AIMEE ELISABETH Plainclothes Police Constable SOON Plainclothes Police Constable CHRISTOPHER BRYDON Police Constable GORDON Training Constable CHRISTOPHER Training Constable ROBERT KIRK Detective DEREK Police Constable JEFFREY HONG Police Constable YU PAU (SYDNEY) Plainclothes Police Constable NAZARET Detective OVID RUBEN Police Constable RICHARD DOUGLAS Detective Sergeant AARON ROYCE Detective ANNE Detective Sergeant BERNARD Sergeant GREGORY Staff Sergeant HECTOR MURDO Police Constable IAN KENNETH Detective JANICE Detective JOHN Staff Sergeant LEO Detective LORI-ANN Detective SCOTT JOHN Plainclothes Police Constable SUSAN Sergeant BRIAN Detective Sergeant JEFFERY JOHN Sergeant CRAIG ANTHONY Police Constable JASON JAMES Detective ROBERT FRANCIS Detective BRIAN PAUL Staff Sergeant RONALD ERNEST Police Constable SHARI PATRICIA Sergeant ROBERT DEAN Plainclothes Police Constable THOMAS BLAIR Training Constable RICHARD JAMES Plainclothes Police Constable JAMES Inspector PAUL Detective RODERICK Sergeant STEVEN JAMES Plainclothes Police Constable DONALD WADE Police Constable JUANITA Senior Advisor of Quality Assurance GARY LAWRENCE Police Constable ANTONIO DELGADO Detective JOHN Police Constable CRAIG TRAVIS Police Constable JAMES MURRAY Police Constable DANIEL WILLIAM Police Constable ALLAN NEIL Sergeant MARC ANDREY Plainclothes Police Constable BRYAN GERALD Plainclothes Police Constable BRYAN SANJEEV Plainclothes Police Constable ZALINA Supervisor MEHRDAD Police Constable TAYYAB Police Constable JULIE Plainclothes Police Constable SHAWN Detective DAVID Police Constable STEVEN Plainclothes Police Constable DANIEL Detective DEMETRIOS Plainclothes Police Constable

Surname LOUCKS LOUGHLIN LOUHIKARI LOURENCO LOVE LOWE LOWREY LUCAS LUCHETTA LUCZYK LUFF LUKINGS LUM LUPSON LUSBY LUSSOW LYON MA MA MA MAADANIAN MAC MACCHEYNE MACDONALD MACDONALD MACDONALD MACDONALD MACDONALD MACDONALD MACDONALD MACDONALD MACDONALD MACDONALD MACDONALD MACDONELL MACDONNELL MACDUFF MACGILLIVRAY MACGREGOR MACINNIS MACINTYRE MACKAY MACKAY MACKENZIE MACKENZIE MACKINNON MACKRELL MACKRELL MACLEAN MACNEIL MACPHERSON MACARAEG MACHELL MACIAS MACIEK MACKEY MACKRELL MACNAB MADILL MADRAMOOTOO MAGEE MAHARAJ MAHARAJ MAHMODIAN MAHMOOD MAHONEY MAHONEY MAILER MAILER MAISONNEUVE MAKRIS

Salary Paid $ 110,837.57 $ 119,209.29 $ 114,663.33 $ 111,717.86 $ 112,583.34 $ 108,915.62 $ 120,167.46 $ 127,407.07 $ 112,341.40 $ 107,286.56 $ 130,195.10 $ 101,123.22 $ 122,820.23 $ 125,369.74 $ 102,524.12 $ 105,365.84 $ 122,570.14 $ 105,834.16 $ 100,696.13 $ 112,409.66 $ 120,707.17 $ 109,432.34 $ 112,831.71 $ 124,067.61 $ 119,631.15 $ 106,421.27 $ 120,214.45 $ 109,966.20 $ 129,455.00 $ 106,467.82 $ 119,553.55 $ 129,839.77 $ 106,103.98 $ 110,823.13 $ 110,859.76 $ 142,653.31 $ 112,257.45 $ 104,419.45 $ 123,960.05 $ 113,554.99 $ 157,036.52 $ 103,640.74 $ 109,597.73 $ 104,383.74 $ 105,796.14 $ 111,107.93 $ 151,820.75 $ 108,947.83 $ 116,467.18 $ 113,840.21 $ 125,519.51 $ 132,952.85 $ 107,188.37 $ 108,857.61 $ 126,357.26 $ 101,592.58 $ 111,162.70 $ 106,320.74 $ 128,394.25 $ 102,337.66 $ 115,208.88 $ 126,726.33 $ 113,672.45 $ 103,760.38 $ 106,253.42 $ 115,003.07 $ 141,000.12 $ 103,041.08 $ 114,475.73 $ 124,115.35 $ 108,576.62

Benefits $686.42 $319.62 $717.06 $679.10 $701.67 $717.06 $744.60 $717.06 $646.97 $686.42 $717.06 $686.42 $700.32 $667.87 $694.95 $700.32 $708.56 $662.06 $662.93 $678.70 $701.67 $669.95 $725.35 $710.11 $744.60 $708.56 $744.60 $676.05 $708.56 $708.56 $744.60 $712.59 $283.58 $686.42 $717.06 $744.60 $701.67 $669.95 $701.67 $708.56 $744.60 $669.95 $701.67 $678.70 $685.20 $686.42 $949.04 $654.10 $717.06 $686.42 $669.95 $886.80 $662.06 $708.56 $683.13 $669.69 $661.19 $682.76 $598.38 $686.42 $680.58 $686.42 $303.15 $662.06 $662.06 $700.32 $717.06 $669.95 $686.42 $713.86 $292.08

Appendix A RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Given Name Position DAVID JOSEPH Detective ANDREW DEREK Plainclothes Police Constable MICHAEL CHRISTOPHER Plainclothes Police Constable ANITA MARIA Plainclothes Police Constable FRANCESCO Detective JOEL NICHOLAS Plainclothes Police Constable ALVIN KEITH Plainclothes Police Constable AMARJIT SINGH Plainclothes Police Constable MANDEEP SINGH Sergeant JOHN Police Constable RAMAN ROMI Police Constable DAVID JAMES Police Constable SANDRA Sergeant BRYAN LARRY Plainclothes Police Constable MELINDA ANNE Plainclothes Police Constable JOHN Detective ROGER Detective LEANNE Police Constable MICHAEL Plainclothes Police Constable FRANK Police Constable SERENA JANE Police Constable JOHN Detective MARTHA BUTROS Police Constable DAVID Staff Inspector KJELL KRISTOFFER Police Constable KEVIN GEORGE Police Constable KIRWIN Sergeant SHAWN TOBIN Sergeant HENRI Detective BRIAN Detective CLAUDIO Sergeant ANTHONY Plainclothes Police Constable CAROLINE Plainclothes Police Constable DANIEL ALEXANDER Sergeant JOSEPH JEAN Sergeant KATHRYN Superintendent PAUL GEORGE Plainclothes Police Constable RUDOLF Detective RYAN DAVID Plainclothes Police Constable CATHERINE ANN Corporate Psychologist VADYM Police Constable MATTHEW ALOIS Plainclothes Police Constable BRIAN WERNER Sergeant ROBERT HAROLD Plainclothes Police Constable MICHELLE Detective PAOLA Plainclothes Police Constable MAGDALENE MAGGIE Detective DAVID Plainclothes Police Constable BRANT Plainclothes Police Constable MELANIE JANE Plainclothes Police Constable MICHAEL Staff Sergeant JOSEPH BLAKE Sergeant SCOTT ANDREW Police Constable STEPHEN MICHAEL Detective WAYNE Detective MOUNTY JOSEPH Police Constable JOSEPH PAUL Detective DANNY Plainclothes Police Constable GEORGE BYRON Plainclothes Police Constable NATALIE ELIZABETH Police Constable ROGER Police Constable KENNETH Police Constable SCOTT Sergeant SHAWN LAWRENCE Police Constable JOSHUA BRANDON Plainclothes Police Constable JOSH MATTHEW Plainclothes Police Constable KEVIN Police Constable DAVID WILLIAM Police Constable PAUL IAN Detective Sergeant MELINDA JEAN Sergeant GARY Staff Sergeant

Surname MALE MALENFANT MALTAR MANCUSO MANCUSO MANHERZ MANIQUIS MANN MANN MANNING MANOTA MANSERRA MANSON MANTLE MANTLE MARCH MARCHACK MARCHEN MARCHEN MARCHESE MARCHIS MARGETSON MARJI MARKS MARO MARSHALL MARSHALL MARSHALL MARSMAN MARTELL MARTELLUZZI MARTIN MARTIN MARTIN MARTIN MARTIN MARTIN MARTIN MARTIN MARTIN-DOTO MARTSENYUK MARXER MASLOWSKI MASON MASTERS MASTRACCI MASTROKOSTAS MATHESON MATHEWS MATHIEU MATIC MATTHEWS MATTHEWS MATTHEWS MATTLESS MATTOS MATYS MAVROU MAXWELL MAY MAYERS MAYO MAYWOOD MC CONNELL MC KENZIE MC SWEENEY MCALEER MCALLISTER MCARTHUR MCASKILL MCBRATNEY

Salary Paid $ 106,789.24 $ 116,828.38 $ 119,005.80 $ 114,657.77 $ 130,604.29 $ 110,083.01 $ 107,630.50 $ 104,959.86 $ 104,094.84 $ 119,240.36 $ 104,703.47 $ 109,895.47 $ 116,123.84 $ 118,587.44 $ 106,795.02 $ 108,765.83 $ 124,297.42 $ 100,142.64 $ 116,070.55 $ 101,591.11 $ 109,546.76 $ 144,050.91 $ 100,415.65 $ 162,806.38 $ 100,409.59 $ 101,459.69 $ 113,938.52 $ 106,196.10 $ 118,669.88 $ 108,306.54 $ 121,264.90 $ 119,918.61 $ 112,730.34 $ 105,708.85 $ 110,350.54 $ 173,467.83 $ 112,478.66 $ 109,731.56 $ 108,652.14 $ 181,841.57 $ 112,161.79 $ 107,444.50 $ 112,777.76 $ 136,936.73 $ 118,842.07 $ 101,478.30 $ 106,112.28 $ 101,785.65 $ 101,194.39 $ 109,073.05 $ 123,745.46 $ 127,141.73 $ 121,702.68 $ 134,837.08 $ 131,440.30 $ 103,765.01 $ 123,668.07 $ 105,405.98 $ 105,566.86 $ 100,858.88 $ 104,653.47 $ 106,172.90 $ 108,576.62 $ 117,310.91 $ 106,359.98 $ 107,061.14 $ 107,440.74 $ 105,083.21 $ 119,209.29 $ 110,244.21 $ 122,665.80

Benefits $701.67 $686.42 $686.42 $700.32 $701.67 $686.42 $686.42 $686.42 $701.67 $684.37 $669.95 $662.93 $717.06 $684.34 $678.70 $717.06 $708.56 $685.38 $700.32 $684.37 $662.93 $708.56 $662.93 $12,092.78 $663.19 $669.95 $708.56 $689.22 $708.56 $710.11 $708.56 $699.28 $700.32 $701.67 $713.86 $9,676.92 $686.42 $669.84 $686.42 $1,088.82 $662.93 $677.88 $701.67 $700.32 $710.11 $686.42 $283.58 $603.28 $686.42 $686.42 $744.60 $708.56 $662.93 $701.67 $717.06 $662.93 $701.67 $666.29 $686.42 $654.23 $582.26 $684.37 $402.26 $658.58 $676.93 $678.70 $684.37 $669.95 $744.60 $701.67 $744.60

Appendix A RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Given Name Position RISE ANNE Operations Supervisor KEITH ROBERT Police Constable RAYMOND DOUGLAS Plainclothes Police Constable GLEN WILLIAM Detective ANASTASIA PAULINE Plainclothes Police Constable ANDREW JOHN Detective JAYANT JOHN Sergeant KEITH Training Constable LAURIE ANNE Plainclothes Police Constable CHEOLIVER DAX Police Constable KRISTOPHER RYAN Sergeant YOSHIO MICHAEL Detective DOUGLAS GORDON Police Constable ROBERT Sergeant SEAN MICHAEL Police Constable STEVEN LEONARD Police Constable RONALD FRANK Police Constable ROBERT BRUCE Plainclothes Police Constable BRADLEY Police Constable DARREN Plainclothes Police Constable DAVID Superintendent INKERI HELENA Sergeant JAMES Detective KEVIN Plainclothes Police Constable ROBERT Detective WILLIAM Detective Sergeant MICHAEL Detective DAVID Police Constable KRISTAL KASHMIR Plainclothes Police Constable DOUGLAS Detective SEAN CAMERON Sergeant DANIEL Sergeant JAMES WILLIAM Plainclothes Police Constable MATTHEW PETER Plainclothes Police Constable ROBERT JAMES Plainclothes Police Constable ROBERT Police Constable SPENCER MATTHEW Detective ROBERT GORDON Sergeant CLINTON WAYNE Plainclothes Police Constable BRIAN DENNIS Police Constable DANIEL GORDON Detective BRETT HARRY Sergeant JOHN ANTHONY Police Constable WILLIAM MICHAEL Detective WILLIAM Training Constable JESSE PATRICK Plainclothes Police Constable MICHAEL Sergeant MICHAEL JOSEPH Plainclothes Police Constable MICHAEL GEORGE Sergeant SEAN BARME Police Constable MICHAEL PATRICK Senior Analyst KENNETH Police Constable MONICA Plainclothes Police Constable JOHN Staff Sergeant KATHRYN Sergeant PATRICK Detective SEAN Police Constable AMY LOUISE Plainclothes Police Constable JEFFREY Staff Superintendent STEVEN GEORGE Sergeant PATRICK HARRY Police Constable JESSICA MICHELLE Sergeant DANIEL Detective JASON ALAN Plainclothes Police Constable CARYN Sergeant EDWARD Sergeant SCOTT Detective PETER SHELDON Plainclothes Police Constable ROBERT SEAN Sergeant DANN FRANCIS Police Constable AMANDA Sergeant

Surname MCBRATNEY MCBRIDE MCBRIDE MCBRYDE MCCABE MCCALL MCCALL MCCANN MCCANN MCCARTHY MCCARTHY MCCAUSLAND MCCAW MCCLELLAND MCCLOREY MCCONACHIE MCCONKEY MCCONNACH MCCONNELL MCCONNELL MCCORMACK MCCORMACK MCCORMACK MCCOURT MCCRAN MCCREADY MCCULLOCH MCCULLOUGH MCCULLOUGH MCCUTCHEON MCCUTCHEON MCDERMOTT MCDONALD MCDONALD MCDONALD MCDONALD MCDONALD MCDOUGALL MCEVOY MCFADYEN MCFADYEN MCFARQUHAR MCGAHERN MCGARRY MCGARVEY MCGEE MCGHEE MCGINN MCGIVERN MCGIVERN MCGOVERN MCGOWAN MCGOWAN MCGOWN MCGRADE MCGRADE MCGUINNESS MCGUIRE MCGUIRE MCILWAIN MCINERNEY MCINNIS MCINTOSH MCINTYRE MCKAY MCKAY MCKAY MCKENZIE MCKENZIE MCKERAGHAN MCKINNIE

Salary Paid $ 101,624.52 $ 105,166.92 $ 111,112.42 $ 106,168.30 $ 111,449.02 $ 125,803.03 $ 103,908.18 $ 107,876.26 $ 100,215.09 $ 100,795.76 $ 109,146.39 $ 108,038.44 $ 104,688.65 $ 123,688.33 $ 112,644.85 $ 104,227.51 $ 114,356.68 $ 100,716.63 $ 128,687.76 $ 102,976.64 $ 166,560.66 $ 109,656.31 $ 111,737.17 $ 118,028.66 $ 125,281.09 $ 122,037.72 $ 114,888.95 $ 138,344.44 $ 115,901.22 $ 111,483.85 $ 130,155.40 $ 118,597.60 $ 133,454.61 $ 100,641.15 $ 102,985.87 $ 101,719.77 $ 112,264.95 $ 135,626.04 $ 101,590.11 $ 103,767.53 $ 135,083.87 $ 104,237.80 $ 103,803.29 $ 110,645.52 $ 102,790.34 $ 103,167.56 $ 112,095.02 $ 117,019.36 $ 109,273.20 $ 101,193.53 $ 109,085.30 $ 107,400.30 $ 102,109.53 $ 119,863.16 $ 109,586.84 $ 110,239.95 $ 101,739.10 $ 100,958.50 $ 173,391.01 $ 111,978.51 $ 100,025.38 $ 109,500.78 $ 127,751.33 $ 100,848.69 $ 110,714.52 $ 109,823.62 $ 108,395.65 $ 108,955.99 $ 106,829.66 $ 107,930.18 $ 108,582.62

Benefits $382.31 $667.87 $685.20 $701.93 $673.21 $717.06 $701.67 $700.32 $681.54 $669.95 $701.67 $701.67 $244.97 $717.06 $693.61 $669.95 $684.37 $688.64 $684.37 $275.34 $16,564.27 $717.06 $717.06 $697.47 $717.06 $744.60 $708.56 $684.37 $684.34 $292.08 $701.67 $717.06 $686.42 $680.93 $256.82 $683.13 $701.67 $701.67 $671.53 $669.95 $701.67 $701.67 $684.37 $708.56 $700.32 $678.70 $708.56 $686.42 $717.06 $669.95 $280.88 $362.28 $693.44 $744.60 $292.08 $717.06 $680.08 $673.82 $5,954.83 $717.06 $669.95 $701.67 $708.56 $686.42 $717.06 $292.08 $708.56 $686.42 $701.67 $685.20 $717.06

Appendix A RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Given Name Position GREGORY Staff Inspector JAMES RUSSELL Detective KRISTINE ANN Plainclothes Police Constable IAN Sergeant JUNIOR SYLVESTER Police Constable MARTIN WILLIAM Police Constable BARBARA Staff Sergeant NANCY MARY Sergeant PATRICIA LOUISE Senior Technical Analyst MATTHEW ALEXANDER Plainclothes Police Constable PATRICK Training Constable VERNETT Superintendent JOSEPH Police Constable KATHY LYNN Plainclothes Police Constable EDWARD LYNN Plainclothes Police Constable DEREK Plainclothes Police Constable COLLEEN Sergeant RONALD Detective JOSEPH GORDON Detective GARY Detective SHERRY LYNN Police Constable HEATHER LYNN Police Constable SHAWN Detective ANDY Plainclothes Police Constable RAYMOND JOHN Sergeant PATRICK Sergeant VIVIAN Detective CAROL Detective GERHARD Inspector JAMES ALLEN Senior Operations Supervisor MARK ALEXANDER Police Constable SHAWN RONALD Staff Sergeant JOHN PHILLIP Detective ERWIN GONZALES Police Constable PHILIP MANILAY Sergeant CRAIG ANDREW Police Constable CHAD JOSEPH Plainclothes Police Constable MICHAEL Sergeant MARY Staff Inspector YAOMING Senior Technical Analyst FARHAAN AFTAB Police Constable PETER Plainclothes Police Constable STEVEN ANTHONY Police Constable RENE LIBRE Police Constable KAINE JOHANN Plainclothes Police Constable JEREMY OLIVER Plainclothes Police Constable DANY Police Constable JASON ANDREW Plainclothes Police Constable BRIAN JAMES Police Constable DUNCAN Sergeant HELEN DIANE Superintendent IAN MARK Plainclothes Police Constable JAMES ANTHONY Police Constable MATTHEW HAMILTON Police Constable PAUL Staff Sergeant RYAN KENETH Detective PAUL TERRANCE Plainclothes Police Constable KARLENE ANN Senior Analyst MARK NOBUYUKI Police Constable GEORGE Police Constable KRZYSZTOF EUSTACHY Senior Analyst DOUGLAS ALLAN Sergeant EDUARDO CANDIDO Plainclothes Police Constable BRUNO JOSEPH Detective SHAHRUKH Police Constable RICHARD JOHN Sergeant CHARLES Sergeant JODI LYNN Plainclothes Police Constable WAI-SANG Detective JEREMY CLARK Police Constable ANTHONY Police Constable

Surname MCLANE MCLANE MCLANE MCLAUGHLIN MCLAUGHLIN MCLAUGHLIN MCLEAN MCLEAN MCLEISH MCLEOD MCLEOD MCLEOD MCMAHON MCMAHON MCNABB MCNALLY MCNAMARA MCNEIL MCNEILLY MCQUEEN MCQUEEN MCWILLIAM MEANEY MEDEIROS MEECH MEEHAN MEIK MEISSNER MEISSNER MELANSON MELBYE MELOCHE MENARD MENDOZA MENDOZA MEREDITH MERRITT MERSEREAU METCALFE MI MIAN MIESZKALSKI MIGNARDI MIJARES MILDENBERGER MILES MILIC MILLAR MILLER MILLER MILLER MILLER MILLER MILLER MILLER MILLER MILLS MILLWOOD MINAMI MINASVAND MINEYKO MINOR MIRANDA MIRON MIRZA MISTEROWICZ MITCHELL MITCHELL MIU MOED MOFFAT

Salary Paid $ 156,277.49 $ 123,095.80 $ 100,071.15 $ 135,173.70 $ 106,047.43 $ 105,506.73 $ 132,328.37 $ 117,895.39 $ 116,457.96 $ 114,647.41 $ 104,722.29 $ 166,166.49 $ 102,720.18 $ 101,290.32 $ 108,159.45 $ 105,019.06 $ 102,988.75 $ 115,335.68 $ 136,117.89 $ 127,005.89 $ 122,561.90 $ 105,839.37 $ 124,414.56 $ 114,453.84 $ 111,204.51 $ 122,857.63 $ 122,790.14 $ 108,880.65 $ 154,844.14 $ 103,929.96 $ 106,888.85 $ 128,988.58 $ 110,510.82 $ 104,370.71 $ 119,527.79 $ 106,154.16 $ 100,139.73 $ 118,199.28 $ 158,554.60 $ 119,204.08 $ 106,210.65 $ 103,086.82 $ 102,818.76 $ 102,822.40 $ 114,463.58 $ 116,438.69 $ 128,565.54 $ 112,652.05 $ 106,027.84 $ 121,746.18 $ 169,596.81 $ 106,972.77 $ 100,467.57 $ 103,556.97 $ 120,450.20 $ 103,983.50 $ 103,828.60 $ 102,389.09 $ 100,361.00 $ 100,743.69 $ 105,865.81 $ 109,995.11 $ 111,470.41 $ 128,265.51 $ 110,455.56 $ 115,183.29 $ 108,934.17 $ 109,825.21 $ 110,299.33 $ 111,949.00 $ 118,759.02

Benefits $12,855.41 $717.06 $639.20 $717.06 $676.70 $669.95 $611.80 $708.56 $280.88 $681.80 $699.18 $19,167.81 $684.37 $678.70 $686.42 $596.28 $683.99 $717.06 $717.06 $663.80 $669.95 $675.34 $715.78 $686.42 $292.08 $717.06 $717.06 $717.06 $949.04 $288.17 $669.95 $744.60 $701.67 $662.93 $708.56 $669.95 $666.29 $717.06 $13,096.71 $280.88 $670.92 $700.32 $662.93 $662.06 $686.42 $686.42 $684.37 $678.70 $646.97 $717.06 $12,828.31 $678.85 $669.95 $662.93 $319.62 $701.67 $686.42 $280.88 $669.95 $244.97 $280.88 $708.56 $686.42 $701.93 $658.58 $685.16 $717.06 $590.76 $717.06 $669.95 $662.06

Appendix A RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Given Name Position MICHAEL Police Constable NATALIE BOBO Police Constable IOURI Senior Technical Analyst DEREK JAMES Police Constable ANTONIO Shift/Area Supervisor STEVEN Staff Sergeant ORANG Sergeant PATRICK JAMES Detective Sergeant THERESA Sergeant DION RAJESH Plainclothes Police Constable ALAIN JEAN Police Constable ROBERT Training Constable ELIZABETH HELEN Sergeant KIRK Police Constable DAVID WILLIAM Police Constable MICHELLE JAYNE Police Constable ADAM BENJAMIN Training Constable BRETT CALVIN Sergeant DARCY Sergeant KEVIN ROBERT Police Constable SCOTT WILLIAM Detective STEVEN Sergeant SYED Police Constable TIMOTHY Plainclothes Police Constable ERICK ODYR Police Constable RUTH MARIAN Detective DEBORAH Plainclothes Police Constable TODD DOUGLAS Plainclothes Police Constable PAUL ROBERT Plainclothes Police Constable RITA Sergeant JOHN Detective PETER MICHAEL Staff Sergeant ADAM Police Constable BARTON Plainclothes Police Constable MARK Police Constable CHRISTOPHER Police Constable DANIEL PHILIP Plainclothes Police Constable DEBORAH ANN Staff Sergeant CHRISTOPHER ROSS Plainclothes Police Constable HAROLD Detective LESLIE Detective MANDY DAWN Sergeant MARK LAVAROUS Sergeant NICKOLAS JOSEPH Police Constable PETER NEIL Training Constable BRUCE Staff Sergeant MICHAEL ROBERT Detective MICHELLE YVETTE Plainclothes Police Constable STEVEN CHRISTOPHER Police Constable TREVOR JAMES Police Constable STEPHEN Detective Sergeant VICTORIA JANE Plainclothes Police Constable KRYSTAL ANNE Plainclothes Police Constable RUEL Plainclothes Police Constable MAREK Plainclothes Police Constable DANNY LABAO Police Constable RONALD Plainclothes Police Constable JULIE SOLINE Police Constable DARREN KENNETH Detective IAN Staff Sergeant JEFFREY Sergeant MATTHEW IGNATIUS Staff Sergeant ROBERT Police Constable STEFAN Police Constable MICHAEL JEFFERY Detective GEORGE Staff Sergeant MATTHEW Detective ASHLEY Police Constable KELLY BRUCE Police Constable NEIL GERARD Detective RICHARD Staff Sergeant

Surname MOFFATT MOI MOISSEEV MOLE MOLINARO MOLYNEAUX MOMENI MONAGHAN MONAGHAN MONAHAR MONTCALM MONTEIRO MONTGOMERY MONTIETH MONTRAIT MOORCROFT MOORE MOORE MOORE MOORE MOORE MOORE MOOSVI MORAES MORAN MORAN MORASH MORDEN MOREAU MOREHOUSE MOREIRA MOREIRA MORELL MORETON MORETTI MORGAN MORGAN MORI MORRIS MORRIS MORRIS MORRIS MORRIS MORRIS MORRIS MORRISON MORRISON MORRISON MORRISON MORRISON MORSE MORSE MOSHER MOSQUITE MOSTOWSKI MOTA MOULTON MOUREAU MOXAM MOYER MOYER MOYER MOYNAGH MUELLER MULLEN MULLIN MUNGAL MUNRO MUNROE MUNROE MURDOCH

Salary Paid $ 107,352.03 $ 111,229.49 $ 104,913.21 $ 107,209.08 $ 138,956.66 $ 123,802.43 $ 154,284.58 $ 124,574.25 $ 110,560.21 $ 104,964.93 $ 103,847.45 $ 105,611.04 $ 108,131.40 $ 105,842.71 $ 106,972.15 $ 102,320.29 $ 103,207.77 $ 126,196.16 $ 108,771.26 $ 108,772.89 $ 108,360.01 $ 108,462.95 $ 104,113.16 $ 112,301.37 $ 100,443.37 $ 103,789.36 $ 100,507.44 $ 102,480.41 $ 112,027.49 $ 111,465.91 $ 112,355.86 $ 123,398.84 $ 114,639.21 $ 102,754.42 $ 100,319.04 $ 102,933.33 $ 113,296.03 $ 120,443.96 $ 104,923.59 $ 126,939.68 $ 138,474.02 $ 107,118.26 $ 105,496.71 $ 151,285.75 $ 111,995.45 $ 121,208.28 $ 120,781.87 $ 112,518.26 $ 101,956.39 $ 107,745.06 $ 117,950.37 $ 119,698.43 $ 108,490.56 $ 130,173.56 $ 110,695.38 $ 108,007.85 $ 102,596.60 $ 100,089.00 $ 111,334.46 $ 119,514.79 $ 111,104.79 $ 116,543.50 $ 109,793.33 $ 104,784.89 $ 132,432.88 $ 119,430.15 $ 118,516.93 $ 101,994.57 $ 130,281.09 $ 103,765.86 $ 119,272.04

Benefits $582.77 $669.95 $280.88 $669.95 $629.59 $744.60 $708.56 $744.60 $717.06 $686.42 $662.93 $685.20 $708.56 $259.39 $662.06 $662.93 $685.20 $701.67 $717.06 $675.44 $701.67 $713.86 $258.77 $693.44 $646.04 $638.71 $693.44 $686.42 $686.42 $433.74 $717.06 $737.72 $679.56 $700.32 $679.56 $662.93 $678.70 $744.60 $681.80 $710.11 $708.56 $706.31 $703.75 $684.37 $679.18 $744.60 $708.56 $700.32 $669.95 $665.53 $744.60 $686.42 $678.70 $679.80 $686.42 $669.95 $275.34 $662.93 $701.67 $744.60 $717.06 $723.68 $684.37 $687.22 $701.67 $744.60 $708.56 $684.37 $684.37 $701.67 $319.62

Appendix A RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Given Name Position DANIEL Detective JOHN Sergeant LIAM Sergeant ALICIA MARIE Plainclothes Police Constable DAVID Staff Sergeant DAVID GERARD Plainclothes Police Constable KAREN PATRICIA Training Constable NEAL ALLAN Police Constable SANDY Senior Advisor Policy and Communication SCOTT ROBERT Police Constable WILLIAM Plainclothes Police Constable KERRY-ANNE Senior Operations Supervisor KEVIN EARL Staff Sergeant ISHMAIL Sergeant CLAUDE Sergeant SUSANA Police Constable DAWN Plainclothes Police Constable GREGORY Sergeant MILTON Sergeant SHARON ELIZABETH Sergeant JOSE Project Leader GRAEME CLAYTON Sergeant SAJEEV Plainclothes Police Constable ARASH Police Constable ANDREW ANTONIO Police Constable JASON STANLEY Police Constable SHAUN Staff Sergeant FAISAL Police Constable STEFAN Plainclothes Police Constable AMAN Plainclothes Police Constable WILLIAM Staff Inspector PETER Detective WESLEY JOHN Detective KEVIN BRADLEY Plainclothes Police Constable ROSS ELLIOTT Sergeant NICHOLAS SHANG-LIN Detective STEPHEN Detective DAVID Plainclothes Police Constable PATRICK Detective MATTHEW ALBERT Sergeant BRUCE Staff Sergeant BRETT RYAN Plainclothes Police Constable DAVID Police Constable DEEDEE Detective CHI WAI Plainclothes Police Constable WILLIAM Police Constable YUEN Detective EDWARD SHING-KEUNG Senior Advisor of Quality Assurance IAN FRASER Detective HEATHER LAURY Detective LEONARD BRUCE Police Constable BRANDON RANDAL Police Constable MICHAEL JAMES Police Constable BRETT DONALD Detective Sergeant ROBERT Plainclothes Police Constable CHAD EDWARD Sergeant CHRISTIAN HINGE Manager of Shop Operations DANIEL Detective Sergeant MARK Sergeant HARJIT SINGH Sergeant RICHARD JAMES Sergeant BRIAN JONATHAN Police Constable WILLIAM JAMES Police Constable CHRISTOPHER Staff Sergeant CARL Detective Sergeant TIMOTHY JOHN Plainclothes Police Constable DARRYL JAMES Police Constable WILLIAM MICHAEL Police Constable ANDREW Staff Sergeant ROBERT Police Constable PRZEMYSLAW Plainclothes Police Constable

Surname MURPHY MURPHY MURPHY MURRAY MURRAY MURRAY MURRAY MURRAY MURRAY MURRAY MURRAY MURRAY-BATES MURRELL MUSAH MUSCLOW MUSSO DUARTE MUTIS MYERS MYERS MYERS NACCARATO NAIDOO NAIR NAMAYANDEH NANTON NANTON NARINE NASIM NASNER NASSER NEADLES NEAL NEAL NEATH NEEDHAM NEI NEVILL NEVIN NEVIN NEWHOOK NEWMAN NEWMARCH NEWTON NEWTON NG NG NG NGAN NICHOL NICHOLS NICHOLSON NICKERSON NICKSON NICOL NICOL NICOLLE NIELSEN NIELSEN NIEZEN NIJJAR NIMMO NISHIKAWA NIZIOL NOLAN NOLL NOONAN NORMAN NORMAN NORRIE NORRIS NORSKI

Salary Paid $ 101,959.41 $ 114,369.44 $ 111,888.28 $ 113,139.65 $ 123,298.53 $ 104,834.24 $ 109,543.32 $ 104,028.64 $ 129,106.56 $ 101,431.77 $ 111,991.35 $ 115,690.57 $ 121,709.81 $ 114,777.85 $ 115,300.43 $ 124,299.40 $ 103,375.45 $ 106,445.59 $ 109,342.93 $ 105,685.35 $ 113,663.06 $ 100,877.17 $ 112,495.51 $ 101,935.79 $ 103,443.51 $ 116,389.85 $ 131,526.21 $ 106,636.79 $ 113,943.09 $ 124,500.70 $ 165,593.09 $ 112,641.52 $ 128,130.73 $ 103,178.69 $ 108,578.37 $ 109,356.67 $ 109,634.01 $ 107,750.15 $ 122,988.75 $ 108,025.26 $ 122,561.61 $ 100,058.80 $ 100,790.58 $ 114,627.72 $ 101,814.05 $ 107,023.86 $ 108,966.23 $ 134,031.78 $ 118,463.84 $ 106,060.54 $ 105,397.75 $ 108,837.68 $ 109,275.30 $ 146,390.63 $ 107,490.29 $ 120,336.77 $ 145,464.67 $ 127,795.38 $ 113,738.23 $ 109,420.78 $ 109,288.45 $ 100,982.80 $ 104,574.67 $ 120,429.56 $ 125,315.47 $ 126,606.58 $ 103,191.11 $ 105,726.79 $ 131,528.98 $ 101,173.75 $ 116,678.77

Benefits $450.76 $717.06 $700.36 $686.42 $744.60 $686.42 $370.16 $662.93 $324.51 $669.95 $700.32 $713.15 $744.60 $701.67 $715.78 $676.70 $700.32 $710.11 $292.08 $701.67 $715.73 $683.99 $686.42 $665.53 $654.23 $662.93 $737.72 $662.93 $700.32 $678.70 $12,986.35 $292.08 $717.06 $686.42 $307.82 $701.67 $654.10 $697.72 $610.54 $708.56 $744.60 $686.42 $684.37 $717.06 $693.44 $662.93 $708.56 $886.80 $654.10 $386.87 $669.95 $654.23 $676.46 $731.22 $686.42 $708.56 $792.69 $539.14 $717.06 $701.67 $701.67 $658.58 $646.97 $744.60 $744.60 $700.32 $662.93 $669.95 $744.60 $684.37 $678.70

Appendix A RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Given Name Position ROBERT LLOYD Detective COLLEEN Detective JEFFREY JOHN Plainclothes Police Constable DAVID JOHN Detective JUDY Detective JAGMOHAN SINGH Parking Enforcement Officer DIANA Plainclothes Police Constable BRANKO Sergeant MARIA Plainclothes Police Constable MELISSA Plainclothes Police Constable VIORICA IOAN Senior Analyst DAVID Training Constable KENNETH Police Constable SEAN Sergeant BRIAN Inspector MIKE STEPHEN Plainclothes Police Constable FRANK Sergeant STEPHEN Sergeant DENNIS Plainclothes Police Constable GERAID DAVID Detective BARRY JOHN Plainclothes Police Constable BRIAN DONALD Plainclothes Police Constable JULIE Plainclothes Police Constable WAYNE JAMES Sergeant KIMBERLEY ANNE Staff Sergeant JAMES Plainclothes Police Constable MARK Police Constable TIMOTHY Detective ASHUR Police Constable SHEILA ELIZABETH Detective DAVID JIN Plainclothes Police Constable MATTHEW TYLER Plainclothes Police Constable PAUL Detective STEVEN RONALD Police Constable RAMON Sergeant SANDOR ERNEST Police Constable FRANK Detective SHAUN Sergeant GARY ALDRED Sergeant OLUFEMI Police Constable ROBERT BOND Plainclothes Police Constable RHOEL VILLEGAS Police Constable ANDREW Detective Sergeant EDWARD YUJI Plainclothes Police Constable IAN DUNCAN Plainclothes Police Constable BASSEY Sergeant ROBERT DANIEL Police Constable BRIAN OTTO Police Constable KEITH THOMAS Plainclothes Police Constable WALID AHMED Police Constable ARDIT Police Constable OLUSESAN OSOKOYA Police Constable VICTORIA Police Constable ANDREW Police Constable DAVID MARK Plainclothes Police Constable ROBERT BRUCE Police Constable NEDIM Senior Analyst JOHN Police Constable NICOLE MICHELLE Plainclothes Police Constable SUKHVINDERPAL SINGH Sergeant GLEN PATRICK Plainclothes Police Constable DEREK WILLIAM Police Constable HOWARD Inspector GIANCARLO Plainclothes Police Constable MICHELE Police Constable GLENN EDWIN Police Constable SCHARNIL VALERIAN Police Constable ANDREW JIN-HO Plainclothes Police Constable RASIH SAN Plainclothes Police Constable CARMINE Sergeant LOREDANA Plainclothes Police Constable

Surname NORTH NORTHMORE NORTHRUP NORTON NOSWORTHY NOTAY NOTO NOVINC NUNES NUNNO NUSSBAUM-VOINA O'BRIEN O'BRIEN O'BRIEN O'CONNOR O'CONNOR O'DOHERTY O'DONOVAN O'DRISCOLL O'KANE O'NEILL O'NEILL O'RILEY O'RIORDAN O'TOOLE OAKES OATLEY-WILLIS OBERFRANK ODISHO OGG OH OLIVER OLIVER OLIVER OLIVEROS OLLOS OLSEN OLSEN OLSON OLUKOYA OLVER ONG ONYSZKIEWICZ ONZUKA ORCHARD OSAGIE OSBORN OSBORNE OSBORNE OSMAN OSMANAJ OSOBA OTTEN OUELLET OUELLETTE OUELLETTE OZKAN OZOLS OZRETIC PABLA PABLO PAGE PAGE PAGLIA PAGNIELLO PAIS PAIS PAK PALA PALERMO PALERMO

Salary Paid $ 128,100.20 $ 128,626.53 $ 121,628.60 $ 114,893.03 $ 109,776.35 $ 107,541.82 $ 103,665.50 $ 110,127.02 $ 116,344.49 $ 106,644.39 $ 105,636.94 $ 108,807.80 $ 136,793.62 $ 112,077.65 $ 172,800.79 $ 122,859.21 $ 111,863.89 $ 117,430.36 $ 114,120.07 $ 111,750.92 $ 105,112.99 $ 100,678.04 $ 102,762.74 $ 112,626.92 $ 129,289.67 $ 116,190.25 $ 108,816.98 $ 132,877.42 $ 116,361.58 $ 141,390.83 $ 112,858.50 $ 113,234.11 $ 109,862.33 $ 108,722.79 $ 105,625.20 $ 101,698.43 $ 118,265.60 $ 108,558.34 $ 108,828.57 $ 101,873.06 $ 103,614.60 $ 137,251.35 $ 126,720.90 $ 101,691.17 $ 100,643.66 $ 108,346.53 $ 118,789.17 $ 100,481.66 $ 109,667.05 $ 102,090.02 $ 109,447.66 $ 101,375.58 $ 102,368.75 $ 102,295.87 $ 111,599.80 $ 103,974.15 $ 116,554.63 $ 119,327.33 $ 109,072.97 $ 108,240.63 $ 102,327.19 $ 103,496.51 $ 151,322.32 $ 105,514.47 $ 134,151.69 $ 107,485.94 $ 121,476.11 $ 114,577.68 $ 124,505.02 $ 110,836.67 $ 105,839.71

Benefits $701.67 $717.06 $693.69 $701.67 $402.26 $595.54 $681.80 $717.06 $693.44 $686.42 $280.88 $700.32 $684.37 $717.06 $792.69 $686.42 $292.08 $717.06 $700.32 $701.67 $686.42 $673.61 $275.34 $697.68 $728.00 $694.52 $684.37 $717.06 $662.93 $717.06 $678.70 $686.42 $717.06 $667.81 $701.67 $669.95 $717.06 $708.56 $717.06 $676.70 $693.44 $669.95 $445.54 $686.42 $268.72 $682.82 $662.93 $669.95 $678.70 $662.93 $662.93 $662.93 $0.00 $671.78 $686.42 $670.20 $280.88 $684.37 $678.70 $701.67 $678.70 $669.95 $949.04 $686.42 $669.95 $686.42 $662.93 $686.42 $681.80 $717.06 $683.98

Appendix A RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Given Name Position MICHAEL ANGELO Detective JOHN Sergeant ALESSANDRO ANTHONY Plainclothes Police Constable SARABHJEET SINGH Plainclothes Police Constable ANTHONY Sergeant KYRIAKOS Police Constable LEEANN Detective Sergeant CARLOS ADRIAN Police Constable KEVIN JAMES Police Constable JOSEF Police Constable SUNG JIN Plainclothes Police Constable FITZROY Police Constable TODD WILLIAM Police Constable ANDREW WILFRED Police Constable JAMES RALPH Training Constable MANDEEP SINGH Plainclothes Police Constable LEMONIA ALEXANDRA Police Constable SCOTT Plainclothes Police Constable MICHAEL ERIC Sergeant STUART MAGRUDER Plainclothes Police Constable RAMESH BRIAN Sergeant DAVID WILLIAM Police Constable FRANK Staff Sergeant ARMAND SYDNEY Plainclothes Police Constable RUDY Detective Sergeant CURTIS PAUL Police Constable ANDREA Plainclothes Police Constable RAJESHKUMAR Sergeant KYLE SCOTT Plainclothes Police Constable DAVINDER KUMAR Police Constable SAMIP Plainclothes Police Constable JAMES Sergeant MICHAEL JAMES Detective ROBERT Sergeant STEPHEN BRENT Plainclothes Police Constable STEVEN Staff Sergeant MOHIT Plainclothes Police Constable THEODORA Plainclothes Police Constable GREGORY JAMES Detective Sergeant KARL SCOTT Sergeant THEODORE ALGERNON Detective HOWARD LEWIS Sergeant JEFFREY Detective Sergeant JENNIFER LOUISE Police Constable CHRISTIAN JOSEPH Police Constable ADAM CHRISTOPHER Police Constable SHANE STEPHEN Sergeant ENRICO Senior Project Co-ordinator ERIK ARTUR Police Constable KENNETH VINCENT Police Constable TREVOR AARON Police Constable SEAN MICHAEL Staff Sergeant RAJENDRA Police Constable RAMACE Police Constable ANDREI VALERI Police Constable DONATO Plainclothes Police Constable CORNELIUS Police Constable KRISTAN MATHEW Plainclothes Police Constable CLIFFORD WILLIAM Police Constable BORIS Training Constable MICHAEL Police Constable STAVROS Plainclothes Police Constable KYLE JOHNATHON Sergeant RICHARD Detective MARK GORDON Sergeant JOHN Detective GRAEME Sergeant ADAM MARSHALL Police Constable RYAN BENJAMIN Police Constable NEWTON CHUN System Administrator PAULA Plainclothes Police Constable

Surname PALERMO PALMER PANDOLFI PANESAR PAOLETTA PAPADOPOULOS PAPIZEWSKI PAREJA PARGETTER PARK PARK PARKER PARKER PARKIN PARLIAMENT PARMAR PAROUSSOUDI PARRISH PARROTT PARSONS PARSRAM PARTRIDGE PARTRIDGE PARVIN PASINI PASSERINO PATCHING PATEL PATERSON PATHAK PATHAK PATTERSON PATTERSON PATTERSON PATTERSON PATTISON PAUL PAVLIDIS PAYNE PAYNE PAYNE PAYTON PEARSON PECK PELLETIER PENNER PENTON PERA PEREM PERINO PERKS PERREAULT PERSAUD PERSAUD PERSHIN PERSICHETTI PETERS PETERSEN PETERSON PETKOVIC PETRAKIS PETRAKIS PETRIE PETRIE PHAIR PHELPS PHILIPSON PHILLIPS PHILLIPS PHOON PICHE

Salary Paid $ 173,307.88 $ 108,773.99 $ 105,848.34 $ 105,873.70 $ 106,782.43 $ 140,757.98 $ 123,929.72 $ 102,588.08 $ 103,104.68 $ 108,656.07 $ 112,606.03 $ 101,524.03 $ 106,478.86 $ 126,376.40 $ 102,666.16 $ 125,816.63 $ 102,535.30 $ 102,776.97 $ 122,332.17 $ 116,832.37 $ 110,882.75 $ 104,898.18 $ 127,921.90 $ 107,327.51 $ 119,245.04 $ 101,367.84 $ 104,204.61 $ 105,723.88 $ 100,317.34 $ 101,626.13 $ 113,006.99 $ 118,861.56 $ 108,601.62 $ 116,159.42 $ 108,063.65 $ 119,218.04 $ 110,553.53 $ 103,169.87 $ 121,672.37 $ 107,441.94 $ 123,251.98 $ 115,633.96 $ 131,319.48 $ 105,277.91 $ 116,355.00 $ 118,405.71 $ 113,556.14 $ 130,140.87 $ 104,869.34 $ 114,484.05 $ 103,650.33 $ 118,947.91 $ 109,475.14 $ 105,577.81 $ 124,884.06 $ 111,636.66 $ 113,889.75 $ 113,468.23 $ 103,435.08 $ 102,873.73 $ 107,545.86 $ 104,875.54 $ 110,344.35 $ 134,261.38 $ 114,238.73 $ 109,673.86 $ 110,892.81 $ 110,990.87 $ 101,055.62 $ 110,279.78 $ 100,143.49

Benefits $701.67 $717.06 $686.42 $678.70 $708.56 $669.95 $738.22 $640.58 $662.93 $669.95 $686.42 $665.53 $669.95 $669.95 $685.46 $686.42 $654.23 $700.32 $701.67 $700.32 $708.56 $662.06 $744.60 $678.70 $744.60 $669.95 $697.72 $698.55 $666.29 $662.93 $673.21 $292.08 $701.67 $708.56 $678.70 $319.62 $671.53 $700.32 $744.60 $708.56 $717.06 $717.06 $744.60 $682.76 $669.95 $646.97 $701.67 $886.80 $662.93 $662.06 $658.58 $726.92 $669.95 $662.93 $662.93 $680.93 $669.95 $686.42 $662.93 $686.42 $677.88 $679.20 $701.67 $708.56 $708.56 $717.06 $708.56 $662.93 $667.87 $705.86 $686.62

Appendix A RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Given Name Position STEPHEN Plainclothes Police Constable TRAVIS GRAYSON Plainclothes Police Constable HILDOR Police Constable NEIL Police Constable TONY Police Constable JAMES WAYNE Sergeant KAMIL STANISLAW Police Constable KAREN ALISON Police Constable BRIAN Plainclothes Police Constable MATTHEW GEORGE Plainclothes Police Constable SUZANNE MARIE Sergeant STEPHEN Staff Sergeant MARK STEPHEN Plainclothes Police Constable DAVID CHARLES Plainclothes Police Constable PATRICK JOHN Plainclothes Police Constable LISA Detective LAUREN Detective Sergeant BRANDON VICTOR Plainclothes Police Constable MARK JOHN Plainclothes Police Constable KRISTINE RIAN Plainclothes Police Constable TIGE SAMUEL Sergeant CANDICE JENNIFER Police Constable RICHARD ANDREW Training Constable IAN Plainclothes Police Constable MARK VARKEY Training Constable DAINIAN ALLOY Police Constable ANDREW ZBIGNIEW Police Constable VIVIENNE SANJA Police Constable WILLIAM DEMETRE Plainclothes Police Constable MARTIN FABIAN Detective CATHY VERONICA Sergeant DANIEL JAMES Detective MICHELLE ELIZABETH Plainclothes Police Constable JOHN ERWIN Police Constable CHRISTOPHER REX Police Constable DUSAN DAN Detective STEFAN PATRICK Detective MICHAEL ALLEN Senior Firearms Officer BRIAN Inspector DEBRA Superintendent JAYME THOMAS Police Constable BRANDON LEE Detective DAVID RAYMOND Plainclothes Police Constable MARY Staff Sergeant ROBERT ARTHUR Police Constable TIMOTHY JOHN Police Constable BRIAN JAMES Sergeant KELLY SEAN Police Constable NORMAN EDWARD Staff Sergeant RICHARD P. Detective PAULA ANNE Sergeant MARK ANTHONY Police Constable KEVIN EDWARD Police Constable MARK Director of Corporate Communications JEREMY JAMES Police Constable SCOTT ROBERT Detective MICHAEL FRANCIS Detective AARON MATTHEW Plainclothes Police Constable KIMBERLEY JOAN Senior Advisor of Quality Assurance SUSAN Staff Sergeant JAMES Staff Sergeant DOUGLAS Inspector GRAHAM Staff Sergeant MARTIN Staff Sergeant JUAN CARLOS Sergeant MICHAEL MARC Sergeant SEAN LEE Plainclothes Police Constable AJWAID NIAZ Detective CORRADO Plainclothes Police Constable ALLAN ROGER Plainclothes Police Constable BARRY Detective

Surname PICKERING PICKETT PICKRAN PICKRELL PIGNATELLI PIKE PIKULA PILOTTE PINCHIN PINFOLD PINTO PIPE PISCHEDDA PITCHER PLUNKETT POCZAK POGUE POLAK POLIAK POLLARD POLLOCK POOLE POOLE POP PORANGANEL PORTER POSLUSZNY POTTER POULIMENOS POULIN POWELL POWELL POWELL POWRIE POYNTER PRAVICA PRENTICE PRESS PRESTON PRESTON PREVOST PRICE PRICE PRICE PRICE PRICE PRITCHARD PROCTOR PROCTOR PROCTOR PROSAVICH PROSPER PROULX PUGASH PULLA PURCHES PUTERBAUGH PUTMAN PUTNAM QUAIATTINI QUALTROUGH QUAN QUEEN QUIGG QUIJADA-MANCIA QUINN QUINN QURESHI RABBITO RACETTE RADFORD

Salary Paid $ 102,885.70 $ 105,873.05 $ 101,100.06 $ 107,640.50 $ 106,298.18 $ 108,773.63 $ 103,461.41 $ 102,443.42 $ 102,883.72 $ 124,284.62 $ 107,772.28 $ 130,064.93 $ 115,556.26 $ 101,329.50 $ 113,411.34 $ 109,232.86 $ 125,648.33 $ 110,582.89 $ 104,631.54 $ 100,568.76 $ 104,073.36 $ 112,154.36 $ 100,277.28 $ 112,245.44 $ 102,346.43 $ 100,915.27 $ 102,784.39 $ 101,372.83 $ 109,665.46 $ 116,454.23 $ 109,617.37 $ 110,212.29 $ 105,287.60 $ 104,621.85 $ 117,496.10 $ 130,982.80 $ 121,121.19 $ 122,303.84 $ 152,855.01 $ 168,237.71 $ 106,142.20 $ 121,538.02 $ 101,770.73 $ 122,091.40 $ 105,677.03 $ 112,339.52 $ 103,649.94 $ 103,315.23 $ 122,332.90 $ 119,426.67 $ 107,887.66 $ 100,656.29 $ 120,688.33 $ 190,198.32 $ 101,535.67 $ 128,908.74 $ 108,624.59 $ 101,069.76 $ 132,534.01 $ 119,325.67 $ 121,997.55 $ 153,421.23 $ 144,226.46 $ 117,211.25 $ 112,348.59 $ 166,408.76 $ 107,586.37 $ 123,938.64 $ 113,707.34 $ 109,650.94 $ 112,276.53

Benefits $700.32 $686.42 $684.37 $684.37 $676.70 $717.06 $658.58 $654.23 $700.32 $686.16 $708.56 $744.60 $686.42 $686.42 $686.42 $708.56 $744.60 $686.42 $686.42 $666.29 $693.14 $662.93 $692.20 $686.81 $686.42 $669.95 $662.93 $662.93 $678.70 $701.67 $701.67 $717.06 $688.50 $662.93 $669.95 $701.67 $701.67 $717.07 $949.04 $10,373.32 $237.95 $701.67 $662.93 $744.60 $662.06 $669.95 $276.69 $662.93 $744.60 $708.56 $701.67 $662.93 $669.95 $9,002.15 $662.06 $701.67 $283.58 $666.29 $461.82 $319.62 $744.60 $13,147.38 $744.60 $737.46 $701.67 $701.67 $686.42 $701.67 $686.42 $678.70 $717.06

Appendix A RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Given Name Position BRENDA REBECCA Manager of Property and Evidence THOMAS MICHAEL Police Constable KAMAL SEAN Plainclothes Police Constable TIMOTHY Staff Sergeant SANJAY RABINDRANAUTH Plainclothes Police Constable NEIL Sergeant DONALD Superintendent VICTOR Sergeant MARION GENEVIEVE Senior Analyst RAMNARINE Detective ALY RAZA Detective JOHN FITZGERALD Police Constable LERMY Assistant Manager of Accounting SUNIL Police Constable STEVEN Police Constable DAVID Senior Analyst DWARKH Police Constable MICHAEL TODD Police Constable CHRISTOPHER WILLIAM Police Constable RICHARD THEODORE Plainclothes Police Constable PALVINDER SINGH Police Constable MARK RICHARD Sergeant ANDREW Sergeant ADAM MICHEAL Police Constable KEVIN WILLIAM Police Constable MELANIE LYNN Police Constable ROY Plainclothes Police Constable LARRY Detective MARK ANDREW Plainclothes Police Constable JASON ANTHONY Plainclothes Police Constable JEFFREY Sergeant KIRBY ALBERT Detective AMANDA BROOKE Plainclothes Police Constable RICHARD Sergeant SUZANNE Staff Sergeant RONALD COLIN Staff Sergeant JENNIFER CHRISTINE Police Constable LAWRENCE Staff Sergeant DOUGLAS FREDRICK Staff Sergeant GAIL Detective PAUL FRANCIS Police Constable CHAD SCOTT Plainclothes Police Constable GREGOR JOHN Plainclothes Police Constable JOHN Training Constable JONATHAN DOUGLAS Detective KYLE THOMAS Plainclothes Police Constable WAVERLEY ELAINE Detective KENNETH BRIAN Detective Sergeant THOMAS ARTHUR Plainclothes Police Constable MICHAEL ARTHUR Police Constable RONALD GORDON Police Constable JASDEEP Plainclothes Police Constable BRADLEY GEORGE Detective SMEDLEY ANTHONY Sergeant BRIAN Police Constable ALEXANDER Detective BRIAN ANTHONEY Training Constable JASON DOUGLAS Plainclothes Police Constable PANAGIOTA Police Constable JASON DAVID Police Constable STEPHEN THOMAS Staff Sergeant SEYED ALI Police Constable DEAN GEORGE Police Constable REUBEN FRANCIS Plainclothes Police Constable CHARLES MICHAEL Detective MARCO Police Constable CLIVE Detective Sergeant ANDREW Sergeant SANDRA Inspector SHEILA ANN Sergeant SCOTT LESLIE Plainclothes Police Constable

Surname RADIX RAGELL RAHIM RALPH RAMBEHARRY RAMBHARACK RAMER RAMESAR RAMIREZ RAMJATTAN RAMJI RAMOS RAMOS RAMPAT RAMPERSAD RAMPERSAUD RAMPRASHAD RAMSAY RAMSBOTTOM RAND RANDHAWA RANDLE RANEY RANTISI RASMUSSEN RATHBONE RAWLUK REBELLATO REBELLO RECTOR REDDEN REDDIN REDICK REDIGONDA REDMAN REED REED-PYEFINCH REEVES REGAN REGAN REGAN REID REID REID REID REID REID REIMER REIMER REINARTAS REISE REKHI RELPH REMY RENDON RENNIE RENNIE RENNIE RETSINAS REYNOLDS REYNOLDS REZVANI RHEAULT RIBEIRO RICCI RICCIARDI RICHARDS RICHARDSON RICHARDSON RICHARDSON RICHE

Salary Paid $ 150,723.11 $ 105,173.16 $ 109,228.93 $ 126,827.34 $ 100,998.25 $ 103,297.87 $ 174,453.72 $ 115,728.06 $ 105,228.21 $ 122,435.65 $ 130,582.16 $ 104,177.28 $ 112,346.91 $ 100,673.45 $ 109,596.24 $ 105,605.77 $ 148,900.32 $ 100,268.02 $ 129,630.25 $ 124,692.72 $ 102,032.45 $ 126,206.71 $ 108,635.25 $ 109,921.77 $ 125,191.32 $ 103,783.05 $ 107,708.77 $ 132,014.88 $ 100,556.71 $ 110,505.49 $ 144,666.89 $ 126,416.65 $ 119,408.12 $ 109,216.23 $ 121,238.79 $ 134,223.45 $ 110,962.27 $ 124,929.25 $ 119,387.23 $ 109,701.23 $ 106,707.50 $ 118,640.46 $ 105,603.93 $ 102,625.10 $ 114,856.67 $ 112,497.15 $ 108,771.82 $ 137,559.78 $ 116,408.66 $ 102,716.30 $ 102,385.57 $ 105,791.55 $ 106,897.19 $ 108,301.44 $ 107,232.45 $ 118,352.02 $ 100,379.03 $ 100,550.45 $ 117,769.89 $ 106,657.90 $ 129,570.78 $ 111,059.79 $ 103,419.45 $ 113,346.03 $ 121,989.79 $ 117,658.56 $ 126,967.05 $ 112,172.51 $ 152,142.45 $ 110,527.63 $ 116,802.83

Benefits $949.60 $676.70 $686.42 $744.60 $686.42 $276.69 $10,744.97 $717.06 $280.88 $708.56 $717.06 $667.87 $823.35 $669.95 $669.95 $280.88 $676.70 $669.95 $669.95 $686.42 $662.06 $717.06 $711.97 $654.23 $662.93 $669.95 $700.32 $708.56 $678.23 $683.30 $717.06 $701.67 $681.80 $717.06 $733.32 $744.60 $682.76 $744.60 $744.60 $284.51 $662.93 $686.42 $670.21 $700.32 $605.69 $686.42 $717.06 $744.60 $666.29 $662.93 $667.87 $681.80 $706.06 $708.56 $662.93 $717.06 $685.20 $666.29 $676.70 $675.44 $744.60 $662.93 $662.93 $672.60 $701.67 $669.95 $744.60 $614.12 $792.69 $292.08 $684.59

Appendix A RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Given Name Position MICHAEL KENNETH Detective Sergeant ALAN Detective Sergeant LINDSAY DIANA Police Constable CHRISTOPHER ANDREW Police Constable JEFFERY JAMES Police Constable SETH ANDREW Police Constable BRIAN CHRISTOPHER Plainclothes Police Constable CHRIS Plainclothes Police Constable LEE ADAM Plainclothes Police Constable PAUL BARRY Detective SALVATORE TONY Police Constable MARK Detective BRETT LEWIS Police Constable ANTHONY FRANCIS Staff Inspector PAUL GEORGE Plainclothes Police Constable KEVIN SHAUN Plainclothes Police Constable ANGELA PATRICIA Plainclothes Police Constable DAVID Detective DEIGHTON ARTHUR Police Constable ANDREW CHARLES Police Constable BRANDON MICHAEL Plainclothes Police Constable DANIEL Sergeant MORGAN Detective Sergeant PATRICK ANTOINE Detective CHARLENE LYNN Plainclothes Police Constable CAROL Sergeant DEAN LLOYD Sergeant JULIUS ANTHONY Police Constable ROBERT DAVID Police Constable ALEXANDER Police Constable RICHARD Sergeant DANNY WILLIAM Police Constable JEAN-BERNARD Sergeant PHILLIP ROLAND Plainclothes Police Constable ANTHONY STEFANO Police Constable MARINO Police Constable NIGEL PATRICK Police Constable TREVOR MICHAEL Sergeant ANDREW MICHAEL Police Constable DAWN Detective DOUGLAS GRANT Sergeant HOWARD Police Constable LESTER EDWARD Detective EGIDIO Inspector MICHAEL DREW Sergeant CAMERON STEPHEN Police Constable DARLENE Detective KEITH Plainclothes Police Constable MATTHEW DOUGLAS Plainclothes Police Constable SCOTT JEREMY Plainclothes Police Constable WILLIAM Police Constable JOHN BENITO Sergeant RICHARD ALBERT Plainclothes Police Constable KIMBERLY DAWN Manager of Parking Support Services MARCELO OSVALDO Plainclothes Police Constable JOSEPH MICHEL Sergeant MATTHEW AARON Detective ANTOINETTE MARGARET Police Constable JOHN Detective RICHARD DAVID Sergeant CONRAD GEORGE Plainclothes Police Constable SAMANTHA MILDRED Sergeant DAVID Police Constable JOANNE LINDA Staff Sergeant STEPHEN Detective DAVID RAVINDRA Plainclothes Police Constable CHRISTOPHER KEITH Plainclothes Police Constable TRACI GWENDOLYN Plainclothes Police Constable LEONARD SASE Police Constable ALEXANDER Police Constable DAVID MICHAEL Police Constable

Surname RICHMOND RIDDELL RIDDELL RIEGERT RIEL RIETKOETTER RIGGS RIM RINKOFF RINKOFF RIOLO RIPCO RIVERS RIVIERE ROBB ROBBINS ROBERTS ROBERTS ROBERTS ROBINSON ROBINSON ROBINSON ROBINSON ROBITAILLE ROCHE ROCK RODNEY RODRIGUES RODRIGUEZ ROGATINSKY ROGERS ROHDE ROMAIN ROMAIN ROMANO ROMITO ROONEY ROONEY ROSBROOK ROSE ROSE ROSENBERG ROSETE ROSETO ROSINA ROSS ROSS ROSS ROSS ROSS ROSS ROSSANO ROSSEL ROSSI ROSSI ROUETTE ROUTH ROWE ROWETT ROWSOME ROZARIO ROZICH RUBBINI RUDNICK RUFFINO RUGHOO RUHL RUMNEY RUPNARINE RUSSELL RUSSELL

Salary Paid $ 117,909.54 $ 119,209.29 $ 126,277.28 $ 109,699.83 $ 103,453.16 $ 118,697.79 $ 106,568.45 $ 105,025.15 $ 106,561.19 $ 151,298.41 $ 106,214.89 $ 116,686.36 $ 101,169.36 $ 155,063.87 $ 110,173.12 $ 117,115.18 $ 105,021.66 $ 113,282.01 $ 108,948.00 $ 112,421.15 $ 104,273.44 $ 124,838.82 $ 120,586.24 $ 108,333.74 $ 103,732.17 $ 105,391.34 $ 107,831.98 $ 103,357.57 $ 107,507.49 $ 101,111.95 $ 105,917.37 $ 120,800.25 $ 109,301.93 $ 105,611.71 $ 101,280.59 $ 111,949.92 $ 110,694.79 $ 106,679.11 $ 102,917.95 $ 107,388.46 $ 158,137.43 $ 143,336.66 $ 121,302.77 $ 152,946.08 $ 106,113.98 $ 110,629.24 $ 108,593.87 $ 110,655.96 $ 109,413.24 $ 138,266.70 $ 112,405.43 $ 118,228.28 $ 103,373.07 $ 145,087.64 $ 104,414.03 $ 116,541.11 $ 118,671.83 $ 100,098.03 $ 108,576.62 $ 109,225.14 $ 110,237.47 $ 109,417.40 $ 118,402.49 $ 119,743.82 $ 119,773.39 $ 104,913.16 $ 102,835.73 $ 103,114.98 $ 102,714.94 $ 101,486.94 $ 105,209.26

Benefits $740.47 $319.62 $675.34 $658.58 $669.95 $662.93 $686.42 $675.65 $678.70 $701.67 $669.95 $669.84 $670.41 $8,977.53 $686.42 $681.80 $673.82 $717.06 $669.69 $675.34 $681.80 $717.06 $366.84 $701.67 $686.42 $608.22 $701.67 $666.57 $683.75 $401.05 $393.76 $669.95 $710.11 $686.42 $670.56 $669.95 $682.76 $701.67 $682.76 $710.11 $717.06 $259.39 $701.67 $949.04 $425.24 $662.93 $717.06 $694.69 $678.70 $689.54 $684.37 $717.06 $700.32 $949.60 $673.21 $717.06 $701.67 $677.27 $292.08 $701.67 $686.42 $708.56 $684.37 $744.60 $717.06 $686.42 $679.71 $686.42 $669.95 $684.37 $662.93

Appendix A RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Given Name Position JAMES JOSEPH Plainclothes Police Constable ROBERT GLENN Detective THOMAS Superintendent MONICA JANET Police Constable ALEXANDER Police Constable BARBARA Detective CLINTON DEREK Police Constable JENNIFER Detective RICHARD Detective STEPHEN CHARLES Detective Sergeant LESLIE Plainclothes Police Constable DAVID BRIAN Staff Sergeant WENDY Manager of Occupational Health and Safety DANIEL Detective Sergeant KIMBERLY JOAN Police Constable MICHAEL ALEXANDER Plainclothes Police Constable AZADEH Police Constable STEPHEN Sergeant MIR SIAMAK Police Constable MUSTAFA Police Constable LAWRENCE Sergeant SHARNJIT SINGH Police Constable RACHID Police Constable MARIUSZ ROBERT Police Constable JAVIER Police Constable RACHEL CATHERINE Plainclothes Police Constable CIRO JR. Police Constable GAYLE WINNIFRED Labour Relations Analyst SEAN RYAN Police Constable SAMUEL JUNIOR Sergeant DAVID Sergeant JEREMY CALVIN Plainclothes Police Constable ROBERT Sergeant MANUEL Plainclothes Police Constable JOHN MICHAEL Manager of Video Services NEIL GREGORY Police Constable JUDY MARY Manager of Records Management ROBERT Sergeant BALRAJ Police Constable HARJIT SINGH Plainclothes Police Constable MICHAEL JOSEPH Police Constable CHERYL-ANNE Detective NELSON ALFREDO Plainclothes Police Constable RICHARD Police Constable IAN DOUGLAS Police Constable GLENN DONATO Detective CHRISTOPHER SEAN Sergeant KEVIN RAMROOP Police Constable BAHEERATHAN Plainclothes Police Constable STEVEN Sergeant DAVID Inspector MARK Deputy Chief JASON LESLIE Police Constable LEONARDO Police Constable GIOVANNI Plainclothes Police Constable ANDREW LESLIE Detective DAVID ALLAN Police Constable KIMBERLY LYN Staff Sergeant GABRIELE Police Constable MARTIN KENDAL Police Constable HANS PETER Police Constable PHILIP Police Constable RONNIE MIKEAL Plainclothes Police Constable CHRISTOPHER Detective JOYCE Detective ANTHONY Detective ANDREW Staff Sergeant RICHARD AUGUSTIN Detective GLENN Detective MARK Detective FRANK THOMAS Police Constable

Surname RUSSELL RUSSELL RUSSELL RUTLEDGE RUTTNER RYAN RYAN RYAN RYAN RYAN RYCZKO RYDZIK RYZEK SABADICS SABADICS SABADIN SADEGHI SADLER SADRZADEH SAFARI SAGER SAGGI SAIB SALAMON SALERMO PANEQUE SALIBA SALINES SALOWSKI SALTMARSH SAMM SAMMUT SAMSON SAMUELS SAN PEDRO SANDEMAN SANDERS SANDFORD SANDFORD SANDHU SANGHA SANGUINETTI SANSON SANTIZO ORANTES SANTOS VICENTINO SAPSFORD SARDELLA SARGENT SARJOO SARVANANDAN SATTZ SAUNDERS SAUNDERS SAVILLE SAVINO SAVOIA SAWYER SAWYER SCANLAN SCAVONE SCEARCE SCHAFHAUSER SCHENK SCHERBEY SCHERK SCHERTZER SCHETTINI SCHNEIDER SCHOCH SCHOFIELD SCHUEDER SCHULZE

Salary Paid $ 101,989.41 $ 106,569.51 $ 185,918.58 $ 101,643.79 $ 134,611.37 $ 106,139.81 $ 107,487.45 $ 128,453.35 $ 133,913.04 $ 122,220.59 $ 103,174.93 $ 120,160.08 $ 125,156.68 $ 125,319.61 $ 111,585.50 $ 118,752.12 $ 100,452.24 $ 117,456.24 $ 123,159.22 $ 105,371.42 $ 113,618.30 $ 123,458.15 $ 100,233.07 $ 101,188.63 $ 104,922.02 $ 103,807.89 $ 100,434.22 $ 104,208.93 $ 101,154.11 $ 115,317.47 $ 127,499.67 $ 112,044.89 $ 109,975.23 $ 103,244.90 $ 163,208.98 $ 141,602.29 $ 156,772.11 $ 111,142.83 $ 103,990.34 $ 105,943.03 $ 100,086.22 $ 109,215.94 $ 112,827.88 $ 102,402.72 $ 111,017.25 $ 123,364.91 $ 108,140.38 $ 106,679.14 $ 116,815.79 $ 109,989.08 $ 155,396.30 $ 201,916.98 $ 116,049.21 $ 119,201.94 $ 107,631.36 $ 106,543.66 $ 107,142.29 $ 125,457.27 $ 105,642.14 $ 108,181.06 $ 109,050.93 $ 100,586.24 $ 103,464.98 $ 120,464.26 $ 153,808.10 $ 112,458.84 $ 128,817.80 $ 110,861.71 $ 124,385.55 $ 109,600.26 $ 118,975.21

Benefits $623.46 $701.67 $13,163.97 $669.95 $676.70 $708.56 $662.93 $708.56 $712.59 $744.60 $700.32 $742.52 $825.09 $744.60 $684.37 $686.42 $662.93 $717.06 $662.93 $662.93 $713.86 $662.93 $662.06 $668.91 $662.93 $678.70 $683.98 $796.08 $662.93 $708.56 $708.56 $674.13 $717.06 $558.66 $991.86 $669.95 $566.88 $717.06 $675.60 $630.48 $661.19 $717.06 $681.80 $679.30 $669.95 $701.67 $708.56 $662.93 $686.42 $717.06 $949.04 $10,965.52 $669.95 $669.95 $700.32 $709.80 $682.76 $744.60 $684.37 $662.93 $669.95 $684.37 $686.42 $708.56 $710.11 $717.06 $744.60 $701.67 $708.56 $717.06 $684.37

Appendix A RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Given Name Position SCOTT CURTIS Police Constable JONATHAN MICHAEL Plainclothes Police Constable DWAYNE Plainclothes Police Constable GORDON Detective MICHAEL ANDREW Plainclothes Police Constable PRESTON WAYNE Plainclothes Police Constable PATRICK Sergeant PAUL Staff Sergeant MICHAEL GEORGE Police Constable TREVOR Sergeant KEVIN ARTHUR Detective CHRISTIAN ARMAND Police Constable NITIN Plainclothes Police Constable WILLIAM Detective Sergeant TERRY WILLIAM Plainclothes Police Constable TAPAN KUMAR Project Leader JANNA LOUISE Plainclothes Police Constable ION VERONEL Project Leader KATHLIN Sergeant MATTHEW ANTONIO Plainclothes Police Constable GORDON DAVID Sergeant MICHAEL Detective JOSEPH EDWARD Police Constable JOSEPH RALPH Training Constable RICHARD Detective Sergeant JASON RAJESH Detective ATUL Police Constable ANDREW DOUGLAS Sergeant CARL Plainclothes Police Constable DAVID JOHN Sergeant KATHLEEN Detective Sergeant RICHARD JAMES Plainclothes Police Constable WILLIAM Plainclothes Police Constable GORDON WALTER Plainclothes Police Constable VIJAY RAMESH Sergeant LEI Police Constable GAIL PATRICIA Police Constable WILLIAM GORO Training Constable HAROLD Police Constable JAY HO Police Constable AMAR Plainclothes Police Constable CLARENCE BLAKE Staff Sergeant SCOTT DAVID Plainclothes Police Constable ANDREI Police Constable HAROON AHMED Police Constable ARVIND PRAKASH Police Constable GORPAL SINGH Sergeant SARBJEET KAUR Police Constable SUKHVINDER SINGH Plainclothes Police Constable TERRY Sergeant JOHN Sergeant GARRY Staff Sergeant ELOI BRUM Police Constable ALEXANDER DAVID Police Constable SERGIO Plainclothes Police Constable DUANE Police Constable DAVID Staff Sergeant OLIVER STAFFORD Police Constable RYAN JAMES Plainclothes Police Constable ANDREW MICHAEL Police Constable DOUGLAS CARL Plainclothes Police Constable IAN THOMAS Plainclothes Police Constable AMARJIT PURBA Detective AMRITPAL Senior Technical Analyst ANGADVIR Detective RAMINDARJIT SINGH Police Constable DOMENIC Detective Sergeant CHRIS Police Constable PETRICA CRISTIAN Police Constable DARREN Detective SURENDRAN Police Constable

Surname SCHULZE SCHUMACHER SCOTT SCOTT SCOTT SCOTT SCRIVEN SCUDDS SEABAN SEARLES SEDORE SEGUIN SEHDEV SELDON SELVER SEN SENYK SERBAN SEREMETKOVSKI SERRANO SERROUL SHANAHAN SHAND SHANGI SHANK SHANKARAN SHARMA SHAW SHAW SHAW SHAW SHAW SHAW SHEPHERDLY SHETTY SHI SHIELDS SHIKATANI SHIN SHIN SHREERAM SHREVE SHUTT SHYMCHONAK SIDDIQUI SIDHU SIDHU SIDHU SIDHU SIDORA SIEVERS SILLIKER SILVA SIMAKOV SIMAS SIMON SIMPKINS SIMPSON SIMPSON SIMS SINCLAIR SINCLAIR SINGH SINGH SINGH SINGH SINOPOLI SIRBOS SIRBU SISK SIVADASAN

Salary Paid $ 108,268.67 $ 107,072.97 $ 103,764.98 $ 114,120.01 $ 108,408.01 $ 112,288.34 $ 111,433.21 $ 121,311.32 $ 114,344.89 $ 111,827.87 $ 122,255.14 $ 102,141.22 $ 106,883.49 $ 128,114.70 $ 106,114.22 $ 113,983.53 $ 100,938.85 $ 105,882.40 $ 109,759.90 $ 114,037.28 $ 108,772.09 $ 108,576.62 $ 126,917.55 $ 101,243.68 $ 137,882.55 $ 149,538.11 $ 111,712.07 $ 145,025.87 $ 102,774.11 $ 110,410.00 $ 121,126.06 $ 115,765.00 $ 109,779.96 $ 100,275.49 $ 104,541.92 $ 104,352.32 $ 115,145.85 $ 100,002.16 $ 101,707.19 $ 101,377.77 $ 115,753.11 $ 119,420.54 $ 117,309.46 $ 112,367.51 $ 105,720.66 $ 117,526.55 $ 106,116.09 $ 111,708.76 $ 106,008.81 $ 124,656.81 $ 114,798.74 $ 123,021.12 $ 109,761.93 $ 106,015.65 $ 102,062.16 $ 116,863.36 $ 122,327.18 $ 101,169.92 $ 101,536.44 $ 111,985.63 $ 100,233.52 $ 111,976.19 $ 120,617.13 $ 124,194.95 $ 117,674.57 $ 110,294.00 $ 130,887.29 $ 103,428.14 $ 105,200.42 $ 108,892.62 $ 101,449.75

Benefits $662.93 $686.42 $700.32 $717.06 $686.42 $678.70 $717.06 $744.60 $662.93 $393.76 $701.67 $682.15 $678.70 $744.60 $686.42 $303.15 $673.21 $280.88 $698.82 $678.70 $292.08 $292.08 $662.93 $685.20 $737.72 $701.67 $662.93 $708.56 $700.32 $708.56 $744.60 $678.70 $700.32 $693.44 $701.67 $662.93 $681.27 $685.20 $669.69 $669.95 $686.42 $744.60 $686.42 $669.95 $662.93 $669.95 $708.56 $684.59 $686.42 $717.06 $710.11 $744.60 $662.93 $682.76 $673.21 $684.37 $744.60 $662.93 $684.34 $669.95 $666.29 $693.44 $708.56 $1,034.24 $701.67 $662.93 $744.60 $669.95 $658.58 $717.06 $662.93

Appendix A RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Given Name Position JUNIOR Sergeant KELLY SIMONE Detective ROBERT Staff Sergeant RONALD GARY Detective NICKOLAS Plainclothes Police Constable BARBARA ANN Police Constable ERIC Police Constable FRANK Detective Sergeant ALLYSON MARY Training Constable RICHARD SCOTT Plainclothes Police Constable WILLIAM Plainclothes Police Constable CHRISTOPHER STUART Sergeant PETER JOHN Deputy Chief BRYAN GEORGE Plainclothes Police Constable CHRISTOPHER DOUGLAS Police Constable GREGORY DAVID Plainclothes Police Constable MATTHEW WILLIAM Plainclothes Police Constable JOHN MICHAEL Plainclothes Police Constable BRIAN JOHN Sergeant BRIAN Detective BRYAN MICHAEL Police Constable DEAN LARENY Plainclothes Police Constable FREDERICK Staff Superintendent HUNTER WELLINGTON Detective JASON SEAN Police Constable JEAN-PAUL Police Constable JOHN GRAY Police Constable KEITH Staff Sergeant LAWRENCE OLIVER Staff Sergeant MICHAEL WAYNE Manager of Equipment and Supply RANDOLPH Inspector RAYMOND ERNEST Project Leader ROBERT DAVID Police Constable ROHAN ALEXANDER Police Constable RYAN ISAAC Police Constable STEPHEN AARON Training Constable STEPHEN PATRICK Detective STEVEN D. Detective CRAIG CHARLES Supervisor of Video Services TRACEY CAROLE Plainclothes Police Constable KAREN GRACE Staff Sergeant KENT Sergeant GORDON Inspector TODD JAMES Plainclothes Police Constable ROYAN JEFFERY Police Constable CHRISTOPHER STUART Plainclothes Police Constable YING HO Plainclothes Police Constable KARL Detective Sergeant EWA ANNA Police Constable CRAIG ALLAN Sergeant NIELS Staff Sergeant SANJAY Police Constable ROY Detective KONSTANTIN Training Constable PAUL ALEXANDRE Police Constable JONI Sergeant CHANTHIMA Plainclothes Police Constable DANIEL Detective DEBORAH Detective Sergeant BRIAN DAVID Plainclothes Police Constable JOHN Staff Sergeant BRENDAN JAMES Plainclothes Police Constable DAVID JOHN Plainclothes Police Constable ENNIS STEWART Sergeant JASON GUEVARA Plainclothes Police Constable JASON ALLAN Police Constable LAURA ELIZABETH Police Constable WAYNE Plainclothes Police Constable GERARD Plainclothes Police Constable SHARI Plainclothes Police Constable ALAN Detective

Surname SKEETE SKINNER SKINNER SKINNER SKLAR SKOLLY SKREPNEK SKUBIC SLATER SLATER SLAVEN SLOAN SLOLY SMALL SMALL SMALL SMALL SMISSEN SMIT SMITH SMITH SMITH SMITH SMITH SMITH SMITH SMITH SMITH SMITH SMITH SMITH SMITH SMITH SMITH SMITH SMITH SMITH SMITH SMYTH SMYTH SMYTHE SMYTHE SNEDDON SNEEP SNOW SO SO SOBOTKA SOKOLOWSKA SOMERS SONDERGAARD SONDHI SORGO SOUKATCHEV SOUSA SOUSA-GUTHRIE SOUVANDY SOVA SOVA SPADE SPANTON SPELMAN SPENCER SPENCER SPENCER SPENCER SPENCER SPENCER SPITZIG SPIVAK SPRATT

Salary Paid $ 108,877.46 $ 110,840.67 $ 119,986.37 $ 110,190.91 $ 102,596.60 $ 103,678.65 $ 109,966.05 $ 152,011.78 $ 102,596.60 $ 105,600.23 $ 126,039.37 $ 111,049.38 $ 255,499.83 $ 121,225.70 $ 115,109.97 $ 101,090.20 $ 103,104.43 $ 123,759.20 $ 125,897.81 $ 107,101.83 $ 101,157.37 $ 116,273.50 $ 183,415.10 $ 118,925.46 $ 109,474.14 $ 100,341.68 $ 109,901.92 $ 117,371.90 $ 116,979.73 $ 145,659.09 $ 148,575.92 $ 110,121.09 $ 103,377.71 $ 112,014.90 $ 104,207.27 $ 100,772.51 $ 116,972.16 $ 108,794.14 $ 124,575.70 $ 103,755.66 $ 118,417.43 $ 124,747.19 $ 152,678.51 $ 105,793.14 $ 102,339.28 $ 112,285.54 $ 105,521.51 $ 121,363.53 $ 101,392.55 $ 111,326.26 $ 119,836.27 $ 109,368.61 $ 109,318.98 $ 103,766.65 $ 106,541.94 $ 109,218.54 $ 107,185.21 $ 113,720.35 $ 113,085.38 $ 102,685.61 $ 123,896.25 $ 115,177.19 $ 104,853.61 $ 138,263.88 $ 107,941.34 $ 105,318.04 $ 114,434.36 $ 103,354.52 $ 116,973.59 $ 102,114.20 $ 113,699.85

Benefits $292.08 $701.67 $744.60 $717.06 $700.32 $662.93 $662.93 $744.60 $700.32 $678.49 $700.32 $701.67 $2,092.15 $678.70 $662.93 $686.42 $678.70 $686.42 $717.06 $710.11 $673.00 $693.44 $8,385.97 $701.67 $669.95 $676.70 $662.93 $739.50 $737.72 $949.60 $949.04 $303.15 $675.44 $669.95 $675.60 $685.20 $701.67 $712.59 $321.24 $700.32 $317.54 $708.56 $949.04 $678.70 $662.93 $686.42 $686.42 $744.60 $658.58 $701.67 $744.60 $685.81 $717.06 $685.20 $662.93 $283.58 $678.70 $717.06 $726.24 $686.42 $744.60 $696.33 $686.42 $701.67 $686.42 $669.95 $678.14 $698.61 $700.32 $693.44 $622.62

Appendix A RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Given Name Position SCOTT EDWARD Detective Sergeant BRETT HAROLD Plainclothes Police Constable ROBERT Detective Sergeant PETER Sergeant KAREY ALOYSIUS Police Constable PAULA Police Constable STEPHANE MARC Plainclothes Police Constable DUANE MARVIN Police Constable BRIAN Plainclothes Police Constable JOJI KAWAKAMI Police Constable DWAYNE Police Constable WILLIAM Detective Sergeant BRADLEY THOMAS Detective LESZEK EDWARD Detective Sergeant BRADLEY Plainclothes Police Constable TYLER FRANKLIN Police Constable THOMAS WARREN Sergeant RODNEY MORRIS Police Constable MICHAEL JOSEF Plainclothes Police Constable WARREN MARK Sergeant ANDREW TREVOR Detective ELENA Plainclothes Police Constable KATHERINE LYNN Detective CHARLES ANDREW Detective JOHN Sergeant BRENDAN LEIGH Plainclothes Police Constable KEVIN GLENN Police Constable SHANE Sergeant COLIN ALEXANDER Detective KERRY MARIE Plainclothes Police Constable PATRICK ALEXANDER Plainclothes Police Constable ROBERT Staff Sergeant TINA MARIE Detective CLINTON RODNEY Police Constable ROBERT LEE Plainclothes Police Constable ANDREW GORDON Detective ROBERT Staff Sergeant JOHN RICHARDSON Sergeant SEAN PAUL Plainclothes Police Constable TIBERIU NICULII Police Constable NENAD Police Constable SLOBODAN BOB Police Constable ROBERT GUIDO Detective CAROLYN RUTH Plainclothes Police Constable CHRISTOPHER GEORGE Plainclothes Police Constable CHRISTOPHER Police Constable TERENCE Training Constable MICHAEL Detective Sergeant TODD MELVYN Plainclothes Police Constable SANDRA LOUISE Police Constable JAMES ALEXANDER Training Constable KRYSTIAN Police Constable GARVAN AUGUSTINE Plainclothes Police Constable ROBERT JAMES Detective PAUL ROBERT Sergeant IAN Inspector KENNETH DAVID Police Constable LAWRENCE Sergeant MICHAEL ANTHONY Sergeant KIRK WAYNE Police Constable SHAWN RYAN Plainclothes Police Constable REUBEN Inspector MATTHEW JAMES Training Constable RICHARD Staff Superintendent DANA TERESE Manager of Quality Assurance KEVIN Staff Sergeant MARLENE Sergeant EMMANUEL Police Constable RAJEEV Detective TOM NILAN Police Constable SAM SHUO Police Constable

Surname SPRATT SPRIGGS SPROXTON SPURLING ST CLAIR ST CROIX ST GEORGE ST JEAN STACEY STALK STAMPLECOSKIE STANLEY STAPLETON STASIAK STE-CROIX STEEL STEEVES STEFFLER STEHLIK STEIN STEINWALL STEPANENKO STEPHENSON STERN STEVENS STEVENSON STEVENSON STEVENSON STEWART STEWART STEWART STEWART STEWART STIBBE STIBBE STINSON STIRLING STOCKFISH STOCKWELL STOICA STOJIC STOJKOV STOLF STONE STONE STONE STONE STONES STOREY STOYKO STRACHAN STRADZA STRAIN STRAIN STRANGWAYS STRATFORD STRATTON STRAVER STRENG STRILEC STRILEC STROBLE STUART STUBBINGS STYRA SUDDES SUDDES SUKH SUKUMARAN SUMAISAR SUN

Salary Paid $ 144,594.82 $ 112,575.97 $ 122,657.28 $ 112,387.98 $ 104,307.25 $ 102,516.81 $ 105,448.29 $ 109,973.06 $ 107,271.83 $ 102,715.13 $ 100,296.66 $ 119,209.29 $ 109,154.94 $ 121,579.74 $ 115,557.94 $ 106,982.37 $ 118,240.46 $ 116,342.82 $ 105,844.45 $ 114,607.17 $ 127,685.16 $ 113,638.79 $ 108,393.09 $ 124,732.66 $ 109,060.72 $ 117,164.84 $ 107,852.91 $ 111,451.82 $ 112,909.62 $ 113,839.25 $ 118,695.76 $ 119,484.54 $ 109,488.00 $ 101,089.44 $ 114,874.77 $ 147,135.87 $ 121,974.29 $ 110,077.72 $ 130,893.53 $ 111,175.91 $ 136,504.15 $ 105,055.94 $ 120,890.15 $ 103,334.28 $ 101,452.06 $ 103,101.54 $ 103,074.63 $ 120,806.42 $ 126,155.44 $ 105,407.51 $ 100,138.42 $ 107,433.28 $ 105,299.49 $ 118,493.30 $ 120,853.77 $ 146,458.58 $ 103,790.37 $ 111,721.73 $ 107,235.33 $ 101,066.31 $ 100,113.81 $ 151,336.63 $ 102,513.42 $ 186,118.93 $ 162,538.68 $ 153,882.16 $ 108,772.83 $ 108,466.98 $ 127,559.87 $ 102,992.72 $ 100,884.30

Benefits $742.00 $686.68 $744.60 $292.08 $662.93 $676.70 $686.42 $669.95 $700.32 $662.93 $662.93 $744.60 $701.67 $744.60 $681.66 $662.06 $697.68 $669.95 $686.42 $701.67 $701.67 $679.01 $701.67 $717.06 $717.06 $686.42 $668.88 $708.56 $701.67 $678.70 $678.70 $744.60 $717.06 $669.95 $679.10 $708.56 $739.50 $701.67 $686.42 $658.58 $669.95 $662.93 $701.67 $681.80 $678.70 $676.70 $700.32 $744.60 $686.42 $675.34 $692.20 $662.93 $686.42 $717.06 $708.56 $791.46 $669.95 $717.06 $701.67 $662.93 $678.70 $944.32 $685.20 $9,612.30 $991.86 $744.60 $717.06 $582.77 $708.56 $676.70 $662.93

Appendix A RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Given Name Position DANIEL RICHARD Plainclothes Police Constable KELLY MARIE Police Constable CHRIS Sergeant ALFRED Police Constable DOUGLAS Sergeant SCOTT WOODROW Police Constable COLIN DAVID Police Constable DARRIN HERBERT Sergeant BRIAN ARTHUR Police Constable GRANT ANTHONY Plainclothes Police Constable DANIEL Sergeant SEAN MATTHEW Plainclothes Police Constable PETER Training Constable VOLODYMYR VOLOD Police Constable BRENT Staff Sergeant AARON DOUGLAS Police Constable ROGER JOHN Plainclothes Police Constable CAROLYN Sergeant PAUL MARTIN Sergeant BOHDAN Plainclothes Police Constable HASSAN RAZA Police Constable TOM ANASTASIOS Police Constable MARIUSZ Police Constable SEBASTIAN Police Constable ROBERT JOSEPH Police Constable ALI SHUKRI Plainclothes Police Constable ADRIAN WILLIAM Police Constable JUDITH MAUREEN Sergeant KEITH HAMILTON Police Constable PAUL LEONARD Police Constable SCOTT JOHN Plainclothes Police Constable ROBERT Detective DARRYL THOMAS Sergeant NICOLAS RICHARD Plainclothes Police Constable WING Police Constable EDWARD TED Police Constable MARK ANTHONY Plainclothes Police Constable SHINGO OLIVER Plainclothes Police Constable DARLA Sergeant JOHN ALEXANDER Plainclothes Police Constable JASON THOMAS Plainclothes Police Constable JOHNNY Superintendent STEVAN TOSH Police Constable RONALD Staff Sergeant DEAN Detective MAURO Sergeant MICHAEL EASTWOD Plainclothes Police Constable KEITH GERARD Police Constable JEFFERY Sergeant RONALD EDWARD Superintendent ANDREW JAMES Detective ANDREW BRIAN Police Constable JASON PETER Plainclothes Police Constable JEFF Police Constable JEFFREY Staff Sergeant KENNETH Inspector KEVIN DWIGHT Plainclothes Police Constable MICHAEL BRYAN Plainclothes Police Constable MICHAEL KENNETH Plainclothes Police Constable ROBERT EDWARD Police Constable ROBERT ALLISTER Police Constable SCOTT DAVID Plainclothes Police Constable WAVENEY PATSY Police Constable FREDERICK LESLIE Police Constable STEVEN THOMAS Sergeant ANDREW PEREIRA Plainclothes Police Constable MARIO JORGE Staff Sergeant THANH Plainclothes Police Constable SARATH Plainclothes Police Constable ANGELA Sergeant DONALD Detective

Surname SUNGHING SUNGHING SUONGAS SURITA SURPHLIS SURRIDGE SUTCLIFFE SUTCLIFFE SUTHERLAND SUTHERLAND SUTTON SUTTON SVITAK SVITLYCHNYI SWACKHAMER SWAINE SWART SWEENIE SWEENIE SYBYDLO SYED SYRMBOS SZKOTAK SZULC TABOROWSKI TAHIRAJ TAIT TAIT TAIT TAIT TAIT TAKEDA TALBOT TALESNIK TAM TAMSE TAN TANABE TANNAHILL TANNER TANOUYE TANOUYE TANOUYE TAPLEY TAPP TATONE TATTERSALL TAURO TAVARES TAVERNER TAYLOR TAYLOR TAYLOR TAYLOR TAYLOR TAYLOR TAYLOR TAYLOR TAYLOR TAYLOR TAYLOR TAYLOR TAYLOR TEATERO TEDFORD TEIXEIRA TEIXEIRA THAI THAYALAN THERIAULT THERIAULT

Salary Paid $ 101,763.59 $ 100,105.61 $ 113,620.72 $ 124,581.05 $ 110,261.95 $ 102,811.49 $ 100,962.41 $ 109,644.49 $ 100,320.03 $ 101,324.02 $ 109,391.30 $ 107,577.93 $ 104,201.64 $ 104,209.20 $ 122,765.98 $ 101,460.31 $ 103,974.65 $ 108,772.66 $ 122,516.69 $ 109,697.25 $ 101,644.13 $ 115,492.12 $ 102,433.79 $ 104,536.32 $ 103,950.94 $ 105,775.77 $ 123,841.69 $ 104,800.56 $ 110,463.42 $ 108,816.18 $ 112,543.61 $ 116,256.79 $ 115,007.91 $ 100,027.74 $ 119,469.85 $ 100,782.92 $ 131,259.49 $ 123,802.08 $ 109,488.64 $ 104,044.89 $ 112,643.76 $ 171,168.76 $ 103,512.31 $ 122,650.12 $ 106,202.87 $ 108,778.17 $ 109,101.69 $ 108,057.90 $ 119,818.09 $ 169,388.12 $ 109,598.84 $ 103,455.53 $ 122,697.70 $ 101,605.52 $ 118,798.41 $ 147,828.33 $ 103,126.36 $ 102,697.65 $ 108,858.86 $ 107,641.15 $ 103,829.13 $ 118,841.61 $ 106,061.15 $ 108,661.37 $ 106,713.30 $ 113,917.34 $ 116,786.89 $ 102,809.03 $ 108,666.12 $ 113,602.82 $ 121,934.64

Benefits $686.42 $675.44 $717.06 $662.93 $717.06 $646.97 $662.93 $717.06 $667.87 $686.42 $717.06 $686.42 $698.04 $225.71 $742.00 $637.73 $686.42 $717.06 $701.67 $700.32 $662.06 $682.76 $669.95 $669.95 $662.93 $686.42 $669.95 $701.67 $684.37 $411.09 $685.20 $717.06 $661.34 $591.98 $676.70 $669.95 $680.56 $686.42 $409.50 $678.70 $680.56 $11,522.85 $662.06 $744.60 $708.56 $717.06 $674.22 $662.93 $701.67 $16,704.89 $701.41 $669.95 $686.42 $684.37 $742.00 $792.69 $686.42 $684.34 $678.70 $658.58 $662.93 $686.42 $669.95 $669.95 $708.56 $686.42 $732.32 $693.44 $678.70 $717.06 $712.59

Appendix A RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Given Name Position JOHN Detective ALLAN Police Constable JOHN ROBERT Sergeant CLAUDINE ANNE-MARIE Detective Sergeant LEROY Police Constable MICHAEL Police Constable RHONDA LEE Detective ROBERT Detective SONIA Staff Sergeant SYDNEY Staff Sergeant ELSIE TINA Supervisor JAMES DUNCAN Plainclothes Police Constable JENNIFER Plainclothes Police Constable MARLAND FINLAY Plainclothes Police Constable MICHAEL ALLISTER Plainclothes Police Constable MICHAEL Police Constable PAUL ANTHONY Police Constable HEATHER BERNADETTE Assistant Manager of Computer Operations ALLAN JOHN Detective SHIRLEY Staff Sergeant AMANDA DORIS Detective GREGORY JOSEPH Staff Sergeant MARK Staff Sergeant JOHN Detective KEVIN DOUGLAS Police Constable HARLEN Sergeant JULIE CHRISTINE Sergeant ROELOF Sergeant ROBERT Staff Sergeant DARIK GORDON Police Constable MARCIN ROBERT Police Constable JASON ALLAN Plainclothes Police Constable THEODORE Training Constable FREDERIC HALLEY Police Constable PAUL ANTHONY Police Constable BENJAMIN JOSEPH Plainclothes Police Constable STEVEN JAMES Police Constable JEFFREY SHAWN Police Constable DARREN Sergeant PHILIP ALEXANDER Detective SIMON ANDREW Police Constable CHRISTOPHER JAMES-ALBERT Sergeant MARK ROBERT Detective STEVEN Staff Sergeant NUNZIATO Detective BRADLEY ROBERT Police Constable REBECCA Patrol Supervisor MADELAINE Detective Sergeant JEFFREY EDWARD Sergeant ETHELWALD DIOSA Police Constable PETER JOHN Detective Sergeant CHRISTOPHER Sergeant BENEDETTO Sergeant DREW ALEXANDER Police Constable KENNETH Sergeant CHRISTINE JANE Plainclothes Police Constable TIMOTHY WALLACE Police Constable PETER Staff Sergeant LUIGI MOSE Plainclothes Police Constable ROBERT Detective MAUREEN ANN Sergeant TENZIN CHODON Plainclothes Police Constable DIMITRIOS Sergeant WING-IP Sergeant ADRIANA PATRICIA Plainclothes Police Constable BRIAN DOUGLAS Senior Technical Analyst BELINDA AGNES Plainclothes Police Constable TIMOTHY EDWARD Police Constable MICHAEL PATRICK Plainclothes Police Constable ROSARIO Staff Sergeant MYKOLA Police Constable

Surname THERIAULT THERRIEN THIBODEAU THOMAS THOMAS THOMAS THOMAS THOMAS THOMAS THOMAS THOMPSON THOMPSON THOMPSON THOMPSON THOMPSON THOMPSON THOMPSON THOMS THOMSON THORNING THORNTON THORPE TILLEY TILLSLEY TIMMS TINNEY TINT TJERKSTRA TOBIN TOHM TOMASZEWSKI TOMLINSON TOMPRAS TOMS TONNA TONOGAI TORRANCE TOUT TOWNLEY TOWNLEY TOYNE TRACEY TRACEY TRACY TRAMONTOZZI TRENOUTH TRENTON TRETTER TREUSCH TRIAS TRIMBLE TRITES TROINA TROTMAN TROTMAN TROTTER TROTTER TROUP TROVATO TRUBECKI TRUEMAN TSERING TSIANOS TSO TUCKER TUCKER TUCKWELL TUCKWELL TUGHAN TULIPANO TUMANSKIY

Salary Paid $ 117,108.03 $ 112,641.27 $ 118,023.67 $ 121,791.71 $ 108,998.48 $ 103,202.27 $ 106,441.33 $ 115,051.74 $ 132,840.79 $ 120,373.72 $ 113,991.20 $ 118,801.80 $ 102,187.16 $ 116,720.45 $ 110,866.25 $ 166,550.99 $ 114,991.94 $ 129,033.95 $ 127,861.47 $ 115,636.50 $ 117,147.78 $ 148,030.09 $ 121,540.76 $ 112,490.50 $ 102,559.87 $ 109,083.54 $ 106,083.20 $ 114,879.51 $ 127,156.52 $ 115,196.82 $ 107,494.47 $ 108,336.07 $ 106,553.82 $ 105,545.25 $ 102,607.56 $ 108,754.08 $ 100,107.64 $ 100,127.26 $ 109,418.11 $ 107,507.78 $ 102,385.88 $ 108,947.53 $ 106,393.90 $ 126,986.64 $ 127,360.89 $ 115,295.53 $ 102,234.82 $ 119,566.14 $ 109,782.31 $ 100,402.69 $ 147,988.25 $ 109,588.21 $ 108,752.62 $ 103,151.27 $ 110,701.96 $ 102,353.56 $ 102,622.55 $ 124,310.06 $ 105,279.24 $ 116,544.82 $ 101,094.43 $ 103,610.48 $ 128,944.45 $ 113,139.27 $ 107,682.44 $ 112,213.86 $ 100,510.55 $ 106,512.82 $ 109,788.44 $ 126,233.88 $ 108,603.81

Benefits $717.06 $684.37 $708.56 $728.14 $684.37 $684.37 $701.67 $717.06 $744.60 $744.60 $303.15 $681.80 $686.42 $686.42 $678.70 $684.37 $676.45 $886.80 $708.56 $732.32 $701.67 $743.56 $744.60 $717.06 $662.93 $705.05 $708.56 $717.06 $744.60 $684.37 $662.93 $686.42 $685.20 $662.93 $662.93 $674.43 $662.93 $669.95 $708.56 $701.67 $662.93 $701.67 $708.56 $744.60 $717.06 $662.93 $616.46 $744.60 $705.76 $662.93 $737.72 $710.11 $292.08 $662.93 $717.06 $686.42 $669.95 $744.60 $688.50 $717.06 $689.28 $591.98 $694.83 $710.11 $686.42 $280.88 $434.58 $669.95 $686.42 $744.60 $662.93

Appendix A RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Given Name Position ANN-MARIE Detective MICHAEL Sergeant RONALD JAMES Systems Integration Specialist KIMBERLY Police Constable JANICE Sergeant GARY Staff Sergeant EDWARD Staff Sergeant DEAN ALLAN Sergeant GERALD ROBERT Police Constable THOMAS FRIEDRICH Plainclothes Police Constable ALLAN JOSEPH Sergeant VISHAL Police Constable JON Training Constable THOMAS Sergeant JAMES ANDREW Police Constable BRIAN WILLIAM Sergeant BRIAN DAVID Police Constable KRISHNAMOORTHY Police Constable ENZO-LORETO Police Constable JOHN Detective ALVIN Training Constable SHEHARA Detective PHILLIP GEORGE Staff Sergeant STEVEN JOHN Police Constable JAN Plainclothes Police Constable MICHAEL DANIEL Plainclothes Police Constable KEVIN JOHN Sergeant PAUL Police Constable NANCY Detective DANIEL ROBINSON Plainclothes Police Constable MARTIN PHILIP Sergeant CAROLYN Sergeant HENDRIK Sergeant JUSTIN WILLIAM Detective Sergeant ANDREW NORMAN Police Constable GREGORY Police Constable GREGORY PATRICK Police Constable SHAFIQ ABDUL Plainclothes Police Constable DANIEL Plainclothes Police Constable OSWALD Sergeant KARTHIGESAN Sergeant TONYO Police Constable KATHARINE Sergeant LUIGI Sergeant TONY Chief Administrative Officer JOANNE MICHELE Sergeant LANCE SCOTT Police Constable BRADLEY DENNIS Plainclothes Police Constable ALBERT Detective DAVID Inspector ABILIO Staff Sergeant RITA ELSA Assistant Manager of Records Management DOUGLAS STEPHEN Police Constable SCOTT CHARLES Police Constable MATTHEW EDWARD Project Leader ANDREW Plainclothes Police Constable CAROL MARIE Corporate Psychologist ABDULHAMEED Police Constable MAHEEP KAUR Police Constable ERIC Training Constable THAO BA Plainclothes Police Constable MARIA Detective KENT Plainclothes Police Constable MARK GRANT Plainclothes Police Constable DAVID Plainclothes Police Constable FRANCIS Police Constable JAMES Staff Sergeant JEROME Manager of System Operations JOHN Sergeant KELLY LYNN Senior Operations Supervisor MARK DOYLE Police Constable

Surname TUPLING TURNBULL TURNBULL TURNER TURZA TUTCHENER TYMBURSKI TYNKALUK UCHMAN UEBERHOLZ UHRICH UPPAL URBAN URBANIAK URE URKOSKY URQUHART VADIVELU VALENTINI VALERIO VALLEDOR VALLES VAN ANDEL VAN DER KRABBEN VAN HET VELD VAN HOOGENHUIZE VAN SCHUBERT VAN SETERS VAN VEGHEL VANWART VANDALL VANDENBERG VANDENBRINK VANDER HEYDEN VANDERBURGH VANDERHART VANSPALL VAYANI VEGA VEIT VELAUTHAM VELLA VELLEND TAYLOR VENDRAMINI VENEZIANO VENN VERDOOLD VERSPEETEN VERWEY VICKERS VIEIRA VIGNA VILLEMAIRE VILLERS VINCENT VIOLOT VIPARI VIRANI VIRK VLACH VO VRUNA VUONG WADDELL WALKER WALKER WALKER WALKER WALKER WALKER WALKER

Salary Paid $ 112,049.35 $ 108,139.14 $ 113,351.45 $ 100,466.96 $ 112,090.67 $ 121,743.44 $ 119,675.46 $ 106,668.36 $ 105,144.42 $ 100,495.70 $ 113,380.28 $ 118,677.69 $ 100,427.05 $ 110,613.97 $ 106,001.81 $ 109,842.26 $ 102,185.47 $ 102,579.92 $ 111,794.00 $ 113,568.28 $ 104,374.70 $ 118,830.90 $ 123,482.60 $ 106,699.96 $ 102,198.88 $ 104,932.73 $ 108,329.14 $ 142,024.33 $ 158,087.82 $ 101,172.28 $ 113,775.87 $ 109,810.30 $ 109,438.25 $ 143,466.48 $ 100,889.89 $ 132,672.26 $ 109,289.82 $ 126,200.34 $ 100,772.60 $ 120,361.70 $ 115,124.49 $ 102,233.85 $ 116,958.61 $ 109,661.56 $ 254,143.85 $ 110,213.54 $ 108,355.06 $ 116,710.70 $ 113,366.16 $ 153,996.37 $ 119,979.52 $ 112,044.69 $ 113,411.67 $ 109,921.24 $ 112,655.16 $ 103,965.81 $ 183,063.30 $ 144,408.47 $ 120,603.44 $ 102,897.44 $ 115,785.88 $ 132,369.60 $ 100,436.79 $ 109,885.87 $ 109,063.11 $ 100,995.52 $ 121,855.35 $ 156,946.81 $ 112,923.61 $ 120,010.28 $ 101,035.68

Benefits $708.56 $708.73 $303.15 $259.39 $717.06 $744.60 $744.60 $708.56 $636.86 $261.44 $717.06 $669.95 $694.69 $717.06 $676.70 $701.67 $662.93 $662.93 $669.95 $717.06 $685.20 $654.10 $744.60 $669.95 $580.54 $666.29 $708.56 $684.37 $292.08 $686.42 $717.06 $710.42 $717.06 $630.10 $658.58 $684.37 $662.93 $678.70 $686.42 $715.78 $708.56 $598.00 $370.78 $717.06 $13,618.50 $712.59 $676.70 $678.70 $717.06 $949.04 $744.60 $823.35 $684.37 $675.44 $303.15 $696.19 $789.76 $676.70 $662.93 $700.32 $686.42 $708.56 $686.42 $686.42 $668.84 $684.37 $744.60 $823.06 $717.06 $713.15 $669.95

Appendix A RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Given Name Position SCOTT JAMES Police Constable STEVEN Plainclothes Police Constable SUSAN COLETTE Manager of Court Support Services ALEXANDER MATTHEW Plainclothes Police Constable JAMES Police Constable JOHN DAVID Plainclothes Police Constable PETER Sergeant ROBERT BOYD Plainclothes Police Constable ALYKHAN AMIR Police Constable CHRISTOPHER GEORGE Police Constable DEREK ANDREW Plainclothes Police Constable SUZANNE MARIE Staff Sergeant GREGORY Detective CHUAN Police Constable TIAM YEE Police Constable JEFFREY MICHAEL Plainclothes Police Constable BRETT TERRANCE Plainclothes Police Constable KEVIN WALTER Police Constable PAUL Detective PETER Plainclothes Police Constable VANESSA Detective ROLAND Sergeant WILLIAM Staff Inspector CHRISTINE Plainclothes Police Constable RUTH Detective RICHARD JOHN Plainclothes Police Constable ROBERT JOSEPH Plainclothes Police Constable KATHARINE ANN Detective JASON ROY Detective KERRY Detective ADAM MICHAEL Police Constable CHRISTOPHER Police Constable ERROL JOHN Training Constable IAN ANDREW Police Constable JERMAINE ANTONIO Plainclothes Police Constable GREGORY MILES Sergeant ROBERT ANDREW Police Constable STEVEN MARK Detective LIAM Plainclothes Police Constable VERNON Police Constable DAVID GREGORY Sergeant PETER MICHAEL Detective ARTHUR Staff Inspector RICHARD ANTHONY Plainclothes Police Constable DAVID ARCHER Police Constable MICHAEL Plainclothes Police Constable JONATHAN CLAYTON Plainclothes Police Constable DEREK MICHAEL Police Constable JEFFREY Police Constable JACK Sergeant LEE ANN Police Constable MICHAEL ADAM Plainclothes Police Constable CLINTON JON Police Constable DAVID JAMES Police Constable VICKI ANN Sergeant CHRISTOPHER ANDREW Plainclothes Police Constable ROBERT Detective GORDON Detective Sergeant CHRISTOPHER Police Constable KATHERINE ANNE Police Constable BARRY Detective CATHERINE MARLENE Sergeant CHRISTOPHER Superintendent DANIEL CAMPBELL Police Constable DEIDRA DENISE Manager of Customer Service DONALD GERALD Sergeant JOHN Staff Sergeant KEVIN JOSEPH Sergeant KEVIN Sergeant MARILYN EDNA Detective MARK Police Constable

Surname WALKER WALKER WALKER-KNAPPER WALLACE WALLACE WALLACE WALLACE WALLACE WALLI WALLS WALSH WALSH WALTERS WANG WANG WANNAMAKER WARD WARD WARD WARD WARD WARDLE WARDLE WARNER WARNER WARR WARRENER WASHINGTON WATERS WATKINS WATSON WATSON WATSON WATSON WATT WATTS WATTS WATTS WAUCHOPE WEAVER WEBSTER WEHBY WEIDMARK WELLER WELLS WELLS WELSH WENZEL WESLEY WEST WEST WEST WESTELL WESTERHOFF WESTERVELT WHALEN WHALEN WHEALY WHEELER WHELER WHITE WHITE WHITE WHITE WHITE WHITE WHITE WHITE WHITE WHITE WHITE

Salary Paid $ 117,716.32 $ 107,188.27 $ 143,300.45 $ 104,458.26 $ 161,711.41 $ 115,674.94 $ 112,356.88 $ 115,914.27 $ 109,052.80 $ 103,378.01 $ 102,085.59 $ 132,464.63 $ 120,022.44 $ 103,931.82 $ 100,918.89 $ 112,647.73 $ 105,469.10 $ 106,105.58 $ 141,458.69 $ 106,520.57 $ 125,846.58 $ 108,758.37 $ 161,863.55 $ 103,593.73 $ 110,158.17 $ 101,980.52 $ 110,299.61 $ 108,432.11 $ 115,983.83 $ 111,023.11 $ 104,514.67 $ 103,623.53 $ 104,123.31 $ 100,221.23 $ 104,344.38 $ 113,261.25 $ 101,203.49 $ 137,783.35 $ 127,557.29 $ 100,746.31 $ 120,473.17 $ 112,620.21 $ 162,569.57 $ 111,399.00 $ 101,138.48 $ 103,438.36 $ 109,104.52 $ 103,183.71 $ 102,283.02 $ 112,707.13 $ 109,377.58 $ 109,481.38 $ 100,645.43 $ 101,163.47 $ 107,205.05 $ 122,223.68 $ 122,174.50 $ 156,920.18 $ 124,495.92 $ 112,581.72 $ 110,316.10 $ 112,983.52 $ 174,294.88 $ 109,444.86 $ 159,845.85 $ 105,836.92 $ 126,774.76 $ 106,778.74 $ 110,415.70 $ 115,241.04 $ 104,923.20

Benefits $662.93 $700.32 $593.25 $673.21 $432.53 $686.42 $701.67 $686.42 $662.93 $669.95 $681.54 $744.60 $708.56 $662.06 $662.93 $686.42 $686.42 $662.93 $711.97 $275.34 $717.06 $292.08 $10,497.04 $700.32 $708.56 $686.42 $686.42 $708.56 $701.67 $717.06 $682.76 $675.18 $685.20 $677.88 $674.43 $701.67 $669.95 $717.06 $686.42 $684.37 $714.50 $701.67 $12,522.27 $693.44 $680.93 $275.34 $679.10 $662.93 $669.95 $717.06 $686.42 $679.01 $674.83 $662.93 $683.99 $686.42 $711.97 $744.60 $684.37 $677.27 $715.78 $714.50 $17,847.08 $662.93 $897.42 $701.67 $744.60 $689.22 $717.06 $717.06 $684.37

Appendix A RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Given Name Position PAUL Sergeant WILLIAM Sergeant LOUIS FRANCIS Police Constable RONALD Detective PAUL WILLIAM Plainclothes Police Constable SHAWN MICHAEL Police Constable SCOTT Detective ERNEST Detective Sergeant MICHAEL BRUCE Training Constable CARROL ANNE Senior Corporate Planner SVEN Police Constable MATTHEW STEWART Police Constable JANE Staff Superintendent PAUL Police Constable SUMMER LEE Detective RONALD Training Constable ANTHONY Detective CAROL Sergeant CLAYTON Sergeant DEIRDRE ELIZABETH Board Administrator GHERARDT Detective IAN Senior Intelligence Analyst KEVIN CHRISTOPHER Plainclothes Police Constable KYLE Detective MARK Training Constable MICHAEL JAMES Sergeant STEVEN THOMAS Plainclothes Police Constable CHARLES Training Constable DAVID GEORGE Senior Technical Analyst ANTON LAWRENCE Police Constable BRADLEY MICHAEL Plainclothes Police Constable CHRISTOPHER DAVID Plainclothes Police Constable DAVID W. Sergeant DAVID JAMES Police Constable DAWN KIMBERLEY Plainclothes Police Constable DEREK SCOTT Detective JULIE THERESE Sergeant TIMOTHY Detective WARREN Detective Sergeant WILLIAM Plainclothes Police Constable JOHN Police Constable TRACY GEORGINA Police Constable THEODORE JOHN Sergeant DAVID LEE Plainclothes Police Constable RICHARD Plainclothes Police Constable JEFFREY MATTHEW Plainclothes Police Constable JOHN Sergeant RYSZARD Sergeant JENNIFER AUTUMN Plainclothes Police Constable EARL Superintendent HENRYK Sergeant VICTOR BRUNISLAW Plainclothes Police Constable RAYMOND Detective CHUNG MAN Sergeant CONRAD EMERY Plainclothes Police Constable GORDON CHUNG-HOI Police Constable WAN-HOI Police Constable CHI SHING Senior Programmer JOHN ALAN Plainclothes Police Constable KIMBERLY ANN Senior Supervisor of Support Services NANCY Sergeant STEPHEN Sergeant DOUGLAS STEPHEN Police Constable GARY Sergeant CHARLES Detective RAYMOND Police Constable RYAN PETER Plainclothes Police Constable PAUL HAMILTON Detective PHILIP Sergeant SHAYNE WILLIAM Police Constable DARREN Detective

Surname WHITE WHITE WHITFIELD WHITLA WHITLEY WHITTALL WHITTEMORE WHITWORTH WHITWORTH WHYNOT WIGGERMANN WIGHTON WILCOX WILDEBOER WILLAN WILLERS WILLIAMS WILLIAMS WILLIAMS WILLIAMS WILLIAMS WILLIAMS WILLIAMS WILLIAMS WILLIAMS WILLIAMS WILLIAMS WILLIAMSON WILLMS WILSON WILSON WILSON WILSON WILSON WILSON WILSON WILSON WILSON WILSON WILSON WINCHESTER WINDLE WINDMOLLER WINDSOR WINFIELD WINTER WINTER WISZNIOWSKI WITHROW WITTY WOJDYLO WOJTKIEWICZ WOLF WONG WONG WONG WONG WOO WOOD WOOD WOOD WOODHOUSE WOODS WOODS WOOKEY WOOLLEY WOOTTON WORDEN WORRELL WORSDALE WORTH

Salary Paid $ 111,222.51 $ 116,734.96 $ 103,191.94 $ 115,838.86 $ 109,064.55 $ 101,572.11 $ 129,489.49 $ 127,153.66 $ 101,391.25 $ 145,627.76 $ 107,237.51 $ 130,849.23 $ 196,479.08 $ 101,686.42 $ 104,149.49 $ 100,146.63 $ 122,803.31 $ 110,042.31 $ 106,928.06 $ 112,427.15 $ 137,035.45 $ 109,120.44 $ 102,201.75 $ 129,418.39 $ 102,779.78 $ 113,183.78 $ 122,984.64 $ 109,328.25 $ 105,370.77 $ 102,149.98 $ 100,906.43 $ 112,010.03 $ 121,585.78 $ 107,719.67 $ 100,733.12 $ 107,374.25 $ 105,750.12 $ 109,978.54 $ 120,918.72 $ 102,786.70 $ 115,140.79 $ 104,983.36 $ 112,654.41 $ 105,592.79 $ 100,663.55 $ 121,733.65 $ 112,098.96 $ 108,601.37 $ 104,709.92 $ 121,106.61 $ 114,788.62 $ 108,006.97 $ 119,725.77 $ 125,191.25 $ 123,405.07 $ 106,192.39 $ 110,103.23 $ 107,823.49 $ 138,331.75 $ 107,031.15 $ 108,773.36 $ 121,540.37 $ 108,829.84 $ 112,372.15 $ 134,718.92 $ 107,542.53 $ 122,246.45 $ 124,958.82 $ 109,236.01 $ 108,459.05 $ 118,852.32

Benefits $717.06 $697.90 $675.34 $717.06 $678.70 $658.58 $717.06 $744.60 $692.20 $367.71 $662.93 $669.95 $10,163.76 $694.83 $701.67 $692.20 $708.56 $717.06 $708.56 $280.88 $717.06 $257.75 $686.42 $717.06 $700.32 $701.67 $686.42 $275.34 $280.88 $259.39 $686.42 $661.94 $717.06 $676.70 $678.70 $645.60 $701.67 $708.56 $744.60 $700.32 $684.37 $662.93 $717.06 $686.42 $285.45 $686.42 $717.06 $292.08 $686.42 $2,897.36 $717.06 $686.42 $717.06 $708.56 $666.29 $669.95 $684.37 $257.90 $686.42 $705.86 $669.84 $717.06 $669.95 $695.77 $708.56 $684.37 $678.70 $708.56 $708.56 $669.95 $701.67

Appendix A RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Given Name Position KANE WILSON Sergeant HETTY JOHANA Police Constable TERRENCE Detective ARTHUR Police Constable JAMES Plainclothes Police Constable LESTER Detective REGINALD GEORGE Detective JASON CHRISTOPHER Police Constable XU Police Constable EDUARDO IGNACIO Sergeant LESLIE ANN Plainclothes Police Constable RANDALL Sergeant TRAVERS Sergeant EVAGELOS Police Constable PETER SAMUEL Police Constable QIANLIANG Police Constable YANJIAO Enterprise Data Architect MEIYIN Plainclothes Police Constable RYAN ANTON Plainclothes Police Constable DAVID GEORGE Sergeant KIMBERLEY Staff Inspector MARK Sergeant IAN Plainclothes Police Constable DARREN ROY Detective YA-WEN Plainclothes Police Constable BLAIN Sergeant CRAIG Staff Sergeant DEREK Detective JENNIFER MARIE Police Constable PAUL ELIOT Plainclothes Police Constable RONALD Detective Sergeant WARREN H. Detective WARREN G. Training Constable CHAD ANDREW Plainclothes Police Constable JONATHAN NICHOLAS Police Constable ABDULLAH Drafting Technician CLIFFORD Police Constable KA WAI ERIC Police Constable PETER Staff Inspector ROBERT CHRISTOPHER Police Constable DAVID Detective JULIE Sergeant CARMELO Detective JEFFREY Sergeant DANIEL VALENTINO Plainclothes Police Constable GARY CHARLES Plainclothes Police Constable RAYMOND Staff Sergeant DAVID MICHAEL Sergeant JOHN DARYN Detective STEVEN CARL Plainclothes Police Constable STANLEY Police Constable LAWRENCE Sergeant JOHN Police Constable ALEKSANDRA Plainclothes Police Constable JOHN Plainclothes Police Constable MOHAMMAD Police Constable JOSEPH Staff Sergeant STEFAN Police Constable

Surname WORTH WOUDENBERG WRAY WRIGHT WRIGHT WRIGHT WRIGHT WRONG WU WULFF WYARD WYNIA WYNNE XINOS YAN YANG YANG YAP YARDE YARMOLUK YEANDLE YEANDLE YEE YEO YIN YOUNG YOUNG YOUNG YOUNG YOUNG YOUNG YOUNG YOUNG YOUNGER YOUROUKOS YOUSUFI YU YU YUEN YULE ZAJAC ZAJAC ZAMBRI ZAMMIT ZAMPARO ZANK ZARB ZEBESKI ZELENY ZETTLER ZIELENIEWSKI ZIMMERMAN ZIVCIC ZLOBICKI ZOLD ZUBAIR ZUBEK ZYCH

Salary Paid $ 147,067.40 $ 100,278.09 $ 117,673.17 $ 105,020.01 $ 102,596.60 $ 113,999.18 $ 120,502.97 $ 117,527.34 $ 101,819.23 $ 107,768.00 $ 102,081.49 $ 120,095.95 $ 111,353.51 $ 100,671.68 $ 104,807.94 $ 120,629.99 $ 128,791.51 $ 100,397.22 $ 108,222.49 $ 111,155.91 $ 163,157.55 $ 109,466.37 $ 103,865.61 $ 133,861.21 $ 103,294.64 $ 130,191.23 $ 123,922.39 $ 109,752.05 $ 124,226.00 $ 104,535.95 $ 121,061.40 $ 133,490.17 $ 102,932.47 $ 113,356.60 $ 108,017.62 $ 108,280.49 $ 105,701.68 $ 117,908.59 $ 151,854.40 $ 107,558.35 $ 116,541.12 $ 106,782.63 $ 128,133.71 $ 136,870.39 $ 116,403.60 $ 104,559.72 $ 124,856.15 $ 103,656.36 $ 119,380.71 $ 102,793.19 $ 117,673.56 $ 110,085.92 $ 112,843.00 $ 108,594.12 $ 108,625.40 $ 111,561.76 $ 119,209.29 $ 115,080.45

Benefits $708.56 $669.95 $717.06 $684.37 $700.32 $717.06 $717.06 $684.37 $662.93 $283.58 $678.70 $682.02 $717.06 $669.95 $683.37 $662.93 $461.82 $693.44 $686.42 $708.56 $11,396.41 $717.06 $686.42 $701.67 $678.70 $717.06 $744.60 $717.06 $253.72 $680.93 $744.60 $708.56 $700.32 $686.42 $662.93 $682.88 $684.37 $662.06 $10,208.50 $676.70 $717.06 $283.58 $708.56 $717.06 $686.42 $700.32 $429.80 $701.67 $717.06 $697.47 $684.37 $717.06 $662.93 $648.09 $682.87 $678.14 $319.62 $684.37

APPENDIX B RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Surname BLAIR SLOLY VENEZIANO FEDERICO ASHMAN SAUNDERS WILCOX PUGASH KIJEWSKI GREENWOOD STUBBINGS RUSSELL FITZGERALD BELL CRISTOFARO SMITH GIANNOTTA VIPARI MARTIN-DOTO FERGUSON BYRNES FENTON RAMER WHITE CAMPBELL MARTIN MCGUIRE BEVERS PALERMO BERGEN O'CONNOR CAMPBELL DI TOMMASO FERNANDES TANOUYE MILLER KIM BREEN TAVERNER HENDERSON CORRIGAN JONES PRESTON MCCORMACK THOMPSON QUINN MCLEOD LENNOX NEADLES EVANS ELLIOTT SANDEMAN YEANDLE EARL HARRIS MARKS WEIDMARK STYRA BEERS WARDLE WALLACE HEWNER FRANKS GIROUX WHITE HAYWARD HARRIS METCALFE KUCK Given Name WILLIAM STERLING PETER JOHN TONY MICHAEL AILEEN ALBERTA MARK JANE MARK KRISTINE JEAN KIMBERLEY SARA RICHARD THOMAS THOMAS DANIEL ANGELO FREDERICK CELESTINO CAROL MARIE CATHERINE ANN HUGH ELIZABETH DAVID M. DONALD CHRISTOPHER DONALD ALEXANDER KATHRYN JEFFREY DONALD MICHAEL ANGELO FRANCIS BRIAN JOANNE ELIZABETH MARIO SELWYN JOHN JOHNNY HELEN DIANE SANG-RAE SAM FRANCIS RONALD EDWARD NORMAN GEORGE NEIL DAVID GORDON DEBRA DAVID MICHAEL MICHAEL MARC VERNETT PETER WILLIAM BRYCE EVERETT JOHN MICHAEL KIMBERLEY MICHAEL DEBBIE DAVID ARTHUR DANA TERESE CLAY ALBERT WILLIAM JAMES ELIZABETH JANINE RANDY GARY DEIDRA DENISE MARK STEPHEN ARTHUR MARY HEINZ Position Chief of Police Deputy Chief Chief Administrative Officer Deputy Chief Director of Human Resources Deputy Chief Staff Superintendent Director of Corporate Communications Director of Corporate Services Staff Superintendent Staff Superintendent Superintendent Superintendent Detective Sergeant Director of Finance and Administration Staff Superintendent Director of Information Technology Corporate Psychologist Corporate Psychologist Superintendent Superintendent Superintendent Superintendent Superintendent Superintendent Superintendent Staff Superintendent Manager of Corporate Planning Detective Superintendent Inspector Executive Director, Police Services Board Superintendent Superintendent Superintendent Superintendent Manager of Enterprise Architecture Superintendent Superintendent Manager of Fleet and Materials Management Superintendent Inspector Superintendent Superintendent Police Constable Sergeant Superintendent Superintendent Staff Inspector Staff Inspector Plainclothes Police Constable Manager of Video Services Staff Inspector Staff Inspector Detective Staff Inspector Staff Inspector Manager of Quality Assurance Manager of Radio and Electronics Staff Inspector Police Constable Manager of Budgeting and Control Staff Inspector Detective Sergeant Manager of Customer Service Sergeant Staff Inspector Staff Inspector Staff Inspector Salary Paid $ 367,719.94 $ 255,499.83 $ 254,143.85 $ 243,469.38 $ 211,089.35 $ 201,916.98 $ 196,479.08 $ 190,198.32 $ 187,568.61 $ 187,100.31 $ 186,118.93 $ 185,918.58 $ 185,501.10 $ 184,684.52 $ 184,452.63 $ 183,415.10 $ 183,097.27 $ 183,063.30 $ 181,841.57 $ 177,219.02 $ 176,693.63 $ 174,505.55 $ 174,453.72 $ 174,294.88 $ 174,083.24 $ 173,467.83 $ 173,391.01 $ 173,322.81 $ 173,307.88 $ 172,938.53 $ 172,800.79 $ 172,745.23 $ 172,181.08 $ 171,267.58 $ 171,168.76 $ 169,596.81 $ 169,589.24 $ 169,571.27 $ 169,388.12 $ 169,379.76 $ 168,564.67 $ 168,419.96 $ 168,237.71 $ 166,560.66 $ 166,550.99 $ 166,408.76 $ 166,166.49 $ 165,629.09 $ 165,593.09 $ 164,061.16 $ 163,537.66 $ 163,208.98 $ 163,157.55 $ 163,046.56 $ 163,028.95 $ 162,806.38 $ 162,569.57 $ 162,538.68 $ 162,020.38 $ 161,863.55 $ 161,711.41 $ 161,546.29 $ 160,613.34 $ 160,235.12 $ 159,845.85 $ 159,804.91 $ 159,333.33 $ 158,554.60 $ 158,197.96 Benefits $3,006.72 $2,092.15 $13,618.50 $15,218.59 $1,164.17 $10,965.52 $10,163.76 $9,002.15 $1,088.82 $10,622.31 $9,612.30 $13,163.97 $12,244.35 $602.94 $1,088.82 $8,385.97 $1,088.82 $789.76 $1,088.82 $13,569.05 $9,811.87 $14,683.36 $10,744.97 $17,847.08 $17,756.30 $9,676.92 $5,954.83 $1,038.45 $701.67 $13,757.32 $792.69 $855.62 $13,209.87 $9,390.22 $11,522.85 $12,828.31 $1,038.45 $8,756.97 $16,704.89 $1,038.45 $15,692.36 $949.04 $10,373.32 $16,564.27 $684.37 $701.67 $19,167.81 $12,879.38 $12,986.35 $14,147.30 $700.32 $991.86 $11,396.41 $15,306.21 $717.06 $12,092.78 $12,522.27 $991.86 $823.06 $10,497.04 $432.53 $1,009.30 $13,413.15 $319.62 $897.42 $717.06 $14,255.20 $13,096.71 $980.34

APPENDIX B RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Surname ROSE VAN VEGHEL CALIFARETTI GROSS BORTKIEWICZ FERRY MACINTYRE CURTIN WALKER WHEALY SANDFORD IDSINGA BOCKUS CRISTIANO MCLANE BABIAR SAUNDERS RIVIERE BEAVEN-DESJARDINS MEISSNER CASHMAN COLE KMIECIAK MOMENI VICKERS SUDDES SCHERTZER GILBERT FARAHBAKHSH FERNANDES BOBBIS QUAN KULMATYCKI ROSETO PRESTON CARTER BAPTIST SNEDDON HOLT HUSSEIN RICHARDSON BUTTON SKUBIC IZZETT YUEN MACKRELL STROBLE PAGE RINKOFF MORRIS RADIX COSENTINO HEWITT SHANKARAN BOYD CHURKOO RAMPRASHAD BOTT HEGEDUS ECKLUND SMITH ANAND LITTLE GIBSON ELEY THORPE TRIMBLE BARKLEY IRWIN TAYLOR ELLIS Given Name DOUGLAS GRANT NANCY SANDRA ANGELA PAVEL CHRISTINE MICHAEL BERNARD BRIAN PAUL HELEN MARGARET JEROME GORDON JUDY MARY HANK CORY GUIDO GREGORY JOHN JAMES DAVID ANTHONY FRANCIS JOANNA RUTH GERHARD GERALD GREGORY JOHN ORANG DAVID KEVIN JOYCE SCOTT JEANETTE ISABEL CHRISTOPHER RICHARD ROBERT DOUGLAS JOEL PATRICK EGIDIO BRIAN RANDOLPH ROBERT SCOTT GORDON GLENN RIYAZ SANDRA BERNADETTE FRANK STEVEN PETER JAMES REUBEN HOWARD PAUL BARRY NICKOLAS JOSEPH BRENDA REBECCA SALVATORE STEPHEN MARK JASON RAJESH EDWARD DOODNATH DEODATH DWARKH BRYAN RICHARD ANDREW DOUGLAS RANDOLPH ANIL ARTHUR GRAHAM STUART GREGORY JOSEPH PETER JOHN MARK EDWIN STEPHEN KENNETH MICHAEL DAVID Position Sergeant Detective Manager of Financial Management Manager of Information Systems Manager of Human Resources Sergeant Staff Sergeant Manager of IT Governance Manager of System Operations Detective Sergeant Manager of Records Management Detective Sergeant Inspector Police Constable Staff Inspector Staff Sergeant Inspector Staff Inspector Inspector Inspector Inspector Inspector Sergeant Sergeant Inspector Staff Sergeant Detective Inspector Manager of Labour Relations Inspector Sergeant Inspector Detective Sergeant Inspector Inspector Inspector Inspector Inspector Inspector Inspector Inspector Inspector Detective Sergeant Staff Inspector Staff Inspector Inspector Inspector Inspector Detective Police Constable Manager of Property and Evidence Detective Sergeant Police Constable Detective Inspector Sergeant Police Constable Inspector Inspector Sergeant Inspector Inspector Inspector Detective Sergeant Inspector Staff Sergeant Detective Sergeant Inspector Inspector Inspector Manager of Facilities Management Salary Paid $ 158,137.43 $ 158,087.82 $ 157,556.04 $ 157,155.15 $ 157,154.20 $ 157,139.50 $ 157,036.52 $ 156,946.81 $ 156,946.81 $ 156,920.18 $ 156,772.11 $ 156,615.97 $ 156,530.22 $ 156,487.27 $ 156,277.49 $ 156,179.03 $ 155,396.30 $ 155,063.87 $ 155,054.63 $ 154,844.14 $ 154,828.88 $ 154,807.83 $ 154,468.48 $ 154,284.58 $ 153,996.37 $ 153,882.16 $ 153,808.10 $ 153,792.99 $ 153,767.77 $ 153,729.64 $ 153,440.00 $ 153,421.23 $ 153,385.80 $ 152,946.08 $ 152,855.01 $ 152,808.96 $ 152,765.52 $ 152,678.51 $ 152,677.12 $ 152,632.83 $ 152,142.45 $ 152,053.42 $ 152,011.78 $ 151,937.14 $ 151,854.40 $ 151,820.75 $ 151,336.63 $ 151,322.32 $ 151,298.41 $ 151,285.75 $ 150,723.11 $ 149,906.83 $ 149,811.47 $ 149,538.11 $ 149,477.83 $ 149,338.05 $ 148,900.32 $ 148,704.41 $ 148,670.25 $ 148,607.82 $ 148,575.92 $ 148,574.70 $ 148,544.58 $ 148,396.21 $ 148,380.04 $ 148,030.09 $ 147,988.25 $ 147,915.06 $ 147,898.37 $ 147,828.33 $ 147,513.60 Benefits $717.06 $292.08 $823.06 $991.86 $991.86 $717.06 $744.60 $823.06 $823.06 $744.60 $566.88 $313.99 $792.69 $684.37 $12,855.41 $744.60 $949.04 $8,977.53 $949.04 $949.04 $634.24 $949.04 $708.56 $708.56 $949.04 $744.60 $710.11 $949.04 $815.58 $949.04 $701.67 $13,147.38 $643.28 $949.04 $949.04 $792.69 $949.04 $949.04 $949.04 $792.69 $792.69 $792.69 $744.60 $6,852.32 $10,208.50 $949.04 $944.32 $949.04 $701.67 $684.37 $949.60 $602.94 $673.61 $701.67 $949.04 $701.67 $676.70 $792.69 $949.04 $701.67 $949.04 $792.69 $524.06 $744.60 $792.69 $743.56 $737.72 $792.69 $949.04 $792.69 $949.60

APPENDIX B RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Surname JOHNSON STINSON WORTH DEMKIW CARBONE STRATFORD NICOL HENRY SMITH WHYNOT GOMES GOH NIELSEN ROSSI SHAW BORG REDDEN SPRATT BRAMMALL VIRANI QUEEN MARGETSON VANDER HEYDEN ROSENBERG WALKER-KNAPPER KHOW MACDONNELL DUNSTAN CATENACCIO VAN SETERS ECKLUND SANDERS WARD OGG DI PASSA MAHONEY BANKS PAPADOPOULOS COOKE LAWSON BATES BROWNE MOLINARO FIELDING FRIMETH MORRIS KIRINDE MCCULLOUGH WOOD ROSS SPENCER BUI SHANK WATTS DURAN KAY HARNETT REIMER JOHNSTONE ONG BARSKY HAMPSON CORREA WILLIAMS EVELYN MASON ZAMMIT DUNKLEY O'BRIEN JOHNSTON STOJIC Given Name ROBERT ANDREW GORDON KANE WILSON MYRON ANDREY MIKE IAN BRETT DONALD ANN-MARIE PATRICIA MICHAEL WAYNE CARROL ANNE SUSAN ELIZABETH ANDRE PIERRE CHRISTIAN HINGE KIMBERLY DAWN ANDREW DOUGLAS BRIAN JEFFREY SCOTT EDWARD MICHAEL ABDULHAMEED GRAHAM JOHN JUSTIN WILLIAM HOWARD SUSAN COLETTE SIEWING BRIAN DOUGLAS MARIO PAUL DAVID GRENVILLE NEIL GREGORY PAUL SHEILA ELIZABETH DOMENICO SHAWN WAYNE MICHAEL KYRIAKOS LEE SCOTT JAMES THOMAS BARRY MICHAEL TERRENCE ANTONIO SHAWN MICHAEL KEVIN DAVID LESLIE RANJAN WICKRAMASINGHE DAVID JOHN ALAN SCOTT JEREMY ENNIS STEWART TAM THACH RICHARD STEVEN MARK ADRIAN ROGELIO COLIN ROBERT KENNETH BRIAN TIMOTHY RHOEL VILLEGAS MICHAEL STEVEN SCOTT ANDREW IRWIN GHERARDT DION ROBERT HAROLD JEFFREY LESLIE KENNETH JEFFREY NENAD Position Inspector Detective Sergeant Inspector Detective Inspector Detective Sergeant Manager of Benefits and Employment Manager of Equipment and Supply Senior Corporate Planner Detective Manager of Diversity Management Manager of Shop Operations Manager of Parking Support Services Sergeant Detective Sergeant Sergeant Detective Sergeant Detective Police Constable Staff Sergeant Detective Detective Sergeant Police Constable Manager of Court Support Services Counsel Detective Sergeant Detective Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Detective Sergeant Police Constable Detective Detective Detective Detective Detective Sergeant Police Constable Police Constable Sergeant Police Constable Detective Sergeant Shift/Area Supervisor Police Constable Detective Detective Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Detective Detective Sergeant Detective Police Constable Staff Sergeant Detective Detective Sergeant Detective Police Constable Detective Sergeant Police Constable Police Constable Detective Manager of Communications Services Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Detective Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Salary Paid $ 147,309.79 $ 147,135.87 $ 147,067.40 $ 146,891.78 $ 146,552.95 $ 146,458.58 $ 146,390.63 $ 146,231.71 $ 145,659.09 $ 145,627.76 $ 145,515.83 $ 145,464.67 $ 145,464.67 $ 145,087.64 $ 145,025.87 $ 144,835.07 $ 144,666.89 $ 144,594.82 $ 144,444.53 $ 144,408.47 $ 144,226.46 $ 144,050.91 $ 143,466.48 $ 143,336.66 $ 143,300.45 $ 142,699.43 $ 142,653.31 $ 142,627.55 $ 142,127.20 $ 142,024.33 $ 141,870.96 $ 141,602.29 $ 141,458.69 $ 141,390.83 $ 141,325.35 $ 141,000.12 $ 140,864.72 $ 140,757.98 $ 139,940.18 $ 139,503.11 $ 139,067.32 $ 138,979.30 $ 138,956.66 $ 138,950.10 $ 138,818.87 $ 138,474.02 $ 138,352.68 $ 138,344.44 $ 138,331.75 $ 138,266.70 $ 138,263.88 $ 137,924.99 $ 137,882.55 $ 137,783.35 $ 137,754.04 $ 137,715.88 $ 137,617.38 $ 137,559.78 $ 137,433.25 $ 137,251.35 $ 137,236.17 $ 137,227.80 $ 137,192.98 $ 137,035.45 $ 137,026.86 $ 136,936.73 $ 136,870.39 $ 136,847.25 $ 136,793.62 $ 136,570.30 $ 136,504.15 Benefits $946.68 $708.56 $708.56 $947.86 $717.06 $791.46 $731.22 $952.79 $949.60 $367.71 $708.56 $367.71 $792.69 $949.60 $708.56 $319.62 $717.06 $742.00 $717.06 $676.70 $744.60 $708.56 $630.10 $259.39 $593.25 $361.00 $744.60 $717.06 $673.21 $684.37 $724.28 $669.95 $711.97 $717.06 $715.78 $717.06 $744.60 $669.95 $669.95 $717.06 $259.39 $744.60 $629.59 $662.93 $708.56 $708.56 $678.52 $684.37 $686.42 $689.54 $701.67 $701.67 $737.72 $717.06 $675.90 $728.28 $710.11 $744.60 $717.06 $669.95 $744.60 $669.95 $684.37 $717.06 $607.88 $700.32 $717.06 $717.06 $684.37 $700.32 $669.95

APPENDIX B RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Surname FORESTALL ACORN GEE CANEPA MCNEILLY CAMPOLI DIGIOVANNI CHILDS BELLEC MCDOUGALL COSTA CORREIA MCLAUGHLIN GRANT MCFADYEN BRYSON MATTHEWS CODE WOOKEY BARREDO RUTTNER GRAY HAINES CRONE PETRIE REED PAGNIELLO NGAN CALLAGHAN RYAN YEO BEVERIDGE YOUNG MCDONALD BATES BERNARD MACARAEG OBERFRANK THOMAS ERVICK VANDERHART BOYCE DRAKE PUTNAM BISHOP LISKA WALSH MULLEN HOWARD GROVES VRUNA MCLEAN AUDETTE DAWSON JACOB REBELLATO KAY ARODA NORRIE NARINE HARGAN DIDANIELI LAWRENCE MATTLESS LITTLE PEARSON TAN JOHNSTON BOUCHER CIBULIS PRAVICA LAI Given Name GREGORY CHRISTOPHER ALLAN WILLIAM EDWARD ANTONIO JOSEPH GORDON STEVEN ROBERT GIUSEPPE CYNTHIA FRANCOIS MARIE ROBERT GORDON ZENON PIO IAN CINDYLOU CHRISTINA DANIEL GORDON LAWRENCE NEIL STEPHEN MICHAEL PETER CHARLES FRANCISCO JAVIER ALEXANDER PAULINE KEITH TIMOTHY RICHARD RONALD COLIN MICHELE EDWARD SHING-KEUNG PETER EDWARD RICHARD DARREN ROY KATHRYN ANNE WARREN H. JAMES WILLIAM WAYNE EDWARD CYNTHIA LEE JUANITA TIMOTHY SONIA DALE GREGORY RONALD KEVIN CHRISTOPHER KIMBERLEY JOAN STEPHEN IRENE SUZANNE MARIE MICHAEL JEFFERY ELDON GREGORY MARIA BARBARA DAVID FRANCIS GEORGE JOSEPH TIMOTHY ALFRED LARRY WILLIAM DONALD SANJEE ANDREW SHAUN ROBERT ROBERTO SHAWN WAYNE MICHELLE LYNNE JEFFREY MARK ANTHONY BRIAN HUGH ROBERT DANIEL CLINTON FRANK DUSAN DAN VICTOR TZE-KAU Position Sergeant Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Detective Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Detective Sergeant Project & Policy Co-ordinator Detective Staff Sergeant Detective Staff Sergeant Detective Staff Sergeant Police Constable Detective Sergeant Staff Sergeant Staff Sergeant Detective Staff Sergeant Police Constable Senior Advisor of Quality Assurance Staff Sergeant Detective Detective Detective Detective Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Plainclothes Police Constable Senior Advisor of Quality Assurance Detective Staff Sergeant Staff Sergeant Police Constable Staff Sergeant Police Constable Senior Advisor of Quality Assurance Detective Detective Staff Sergeant Detective Police Constable Detective Sergeant Detective Staff Sergeant Police Constable Staff Sergeant Detective Detective Police Constable Detective Staff Sergeant Staff Sergeant Sergeant Detective Sergeant Sergeant Detective Detective Detective Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Detective Police Constable Detective Police Constable Salary Paid $ 136,497.50 $ 136,438.24 $ 136,338.38 $ 136,197.53 $ 136,117.89 $ 135,909.26 $ 135,864.76 $ 135,815.59 $ 135,664.44 $ 135,626.04 $ 135,204.61 $ 135,173.70 $ 135,114.14 $ 135,083.87 $ 135,071.90 $ 134,837.08 $ 134,823.95 $ 134,718.92 $ 134,687.50 $ 134,611.37 $ 134,550.55 $ 134,527.29 $ 134,391.77 $ 134,261.38 $ 134,223.45 $ 134,151.69 $ 134,031.78 $ 133,923.92 $ 133,913.04 $ 133,861.21 $ 133,830.44 $ 133,490.17 $ 133,454.61 $ 133,294.76 $ 133,145.79 $ 132,952.85 $ 132,877.42 $ 132,840.79 $ 132,814.07 $ 132,672.26 $ 132,599.23 $ 132,547.05 $ 132,534.01 $ 132,519.93 $ 132,477.63 $ 132,464.63 $ 132,432.88 $ 132,390.92 $ 132,372.84 $ 132,369.60 $ 132,328.37 $ 132,176.44 $ 132,031.77 $ 132,023.54 $ 132,014.88 $ 131,817.73 $ 131,627.65 $ 131,528.98 $ 131,526.21 $ 131,521.20 $ 131,500.46 $ 131,475.43 $ 131,440.30 $ 131,333.49 $ 131,319.48 $ 131,259.49 $ 131,147.51 $ 131,138.84 $ 130,998.24 $ 130,982.80 $ 130,915.83 Benefits $717.06 $669.95 $669.95 $700.32 $717.06 $686.42 $717.06 $744.60 $686.42 $701.67 $701.93 $717.06 $886.80 $701.67 $744.60 $701.67 $599.31 $708.56 $744.60 $676.70 $744.60 $744.60 $337.04 $708.56 $744.60 $669.95 $886.80 $744.60 $712.59 $701.67 $717.06 $708.56 $686.42 $717.06 $686.42 $886.80 $717.06 $744.60 $744.60 $684.37 $744.60 $669.95 $461.82 $717.06 $717.06 $744.60 $701.67 $684.37 $739.50 $708.56 $611.80 $684.37 $744.60 $708.56 $708.56 $669.95 $701.67 $744.60 $737.72 $717.06 $744.60 $708.56 $717.06 $708.56 $744.60 $680.56 $717.06 $708.56 $662.93 $701.67 $669.95

APPENDIX B RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Surname STOCKWELL SINOPOLI WIGHTON DOMINEY BANGILD MANCUSO FACOETTI RAMJI FARRELL HORNER LEE MUNROE LUFF YOUNG MOSQUITE KHAN MCCUTCHEON PERA PIPE MACDONALD KHAN GLANCY BALINT RAMSBOTTOM REYNOLDS WHITTEMORE MACDONALD WILLIAMS BILAK BOYLE O'TOOLE DICKINSON FERREIRA GALLANT HUBBARD HEARD MURRAY KNOWLES BOWMAN HALL THOMS MELOCHE TSIANOS PURCHES BRONS KHAN CERNOWSKI GHEYSAR SCHNEIDER YANG COHEN LANE CAPONE LIOUMANIS MCCONNELL BROWN NORTHMORE MILIC RYAN DZINGALA HONG CHANG MADILL DZIEMIANKO FIDLER MIRON KIM ZAMBRI NEAL LITTLE SELDON Given Name SEAN PAUL DOMENIC MATTHEW STEWART PAUL LAURIE JEFFREY FRANCESCO MICHAEL PAUL ALY RAZA GEORGE GAVIN KENNY KELLY BRUCE DANIEL BLAIN RUEL OMAR ASHRAF SEAN CAMERON ENRICO STEPHEN LEO RONALD ARLINGTON DAVID MICHAEL ANDREW CHRISTOPHER WILLIAM STEPHEN THOMAS SCOTT IAN KENNETH KYLE STEPHEN KENNETH KIMBERLEY ANNE DAVID THORPE MARK TIMOTHY SIMON CHRISTOPHER SHAYNE SANDY DAVID BRIAN WILLIAM MICHAEL HEATHER BERNADETTE SHAWN RONALD DIMITRIOS SCOTT ROBERT JAMES AHMAR ALI ANDREW JOHN MAKDA ANDREW YANJIAO ALAN LAWRENCE ARTHUR DAVID JOSEPH METODIOS BRADLEY JAMES COLLEEN DANY JENNIFER RICHARD GEORGE ANDREW CHU THAO ALLAN NEIL STAISLAW ANDREW CLARENCE BRUNO JOSEPH MIN CHUL CARMELO WESLEY JOHN TERENCE ANTHONY WILLIAM Position Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Sergeant Police Constable Detective Detective Detective Sergeant Detective Staff Sergeant Detective Sergeant Police Constable Detective Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Sergeant Senior Project Co-ordinator Staff Sergeant Detective Staff Sergeant Police Constable Detective Police Constable Staff Sergeant Detective Detective Detective Sergeant Staff Sergeant Staff Sergeant Detective Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Senior Advisor Policy and Communication Detective Staff Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Assistant Manager of Computer Operations Staff Sergeant Sergeant Detective Detective Police Constable Financial Planner Financial Planner Staff Sergeant Enterprise Data Architect Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Detective Police Constable Staff Sergeant Detective Police Constable Detective Police Constable Police Constable Detective Sergeant Police Constable Police Constable Detective Police Constable Detective Detective Detective Detective Sergeant Salary Paid $ 130,893.53 $ 130,887.29 $ 130,849.23 $ 130,736.45 $ 130,667.86 $ 130,604.29 $ 130,585.64 $ 130,582.16 $ 130,562.94 $ 130,555.63 $ 130,297.94 $ 130,281.09 $ 130,195.10 $ 130,191.23 $ 130,173.56 $ 130,163.02 $ 130,155.40 $ 130,140.87 $ 130,064.93 $ 129,839.77 $ 129,814.64 $ 129,690.37 $ 129,684.82 $ 129,630.25 $ 129,570.78 $ 129,489.49 $ 129,455.00 $ 129,418.39 $ 129,328.87 $ 129,319.97 $ 129,289.67 $ 129,287.11 $ 129,282.07 $ 129,231.57 $ 129,191.34 $ 129,146.18 $ 129,106.56 $ 129,100.63 $ 129,089.81 $ 129,069.32 $ 129,033.95 $ 128,988.58 $ 128,944.45 $ 128,908.74 $ 128,858.69 $ 128,842.32 $ 128,825.33 $ 128,822.09 $ 128,817.80 $ 128,791.51 $ 128,779.61 $ 128,769.74 $ 128,740.48 $ 128,690.06 $ 128,687.76 $ 128,666.28 $ 128,626.53 $ 128,565.54 $ 128,453.35 $ 128,450.00 $ 128,424.74 $ 128,409.73 $ 128,394.25 $ 128,366.92 $ 128,302.11 $ 128,265.51 $ 128,145.79 $ 128,133.71 $ 128,130.73 $ 128,117.77 $ 128,114.70 Benefits $686.42 $744.60 $669.95 $701.67 $276.69 $701.67 $708.56 $717.06 $744.60 $717.06 $701.67 $684.37 $717.06 $717.06 $679.80 $701.67 $701.67 $886.80 $744.60 $712.59 $646.03 $676.70 $701.67 $669.95 $744.60 $717.06 $708.56 $717.06 $610.54 $744.60 $728.00 $701.67 $699.28 $708.56 $693.44 $362.28 $324.51 $717.06 $744.60 $686.42 $886.80 $744.60 $694.83 $701.67 $715.78 $662.93 $886.80 $886.80 $744.60 $461.82 $673.61 $700.32 $679.04 $701.67 $684.37 $429.80 $717.06 $684.37 $708.56 $684.37 $669.95 $701.67 $598.38 $689.50 $662.93 $701.93 $677.27 $708.56 $717.06 $701.67 $744.60

APPENDIX B RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Surname NORTH BELLION PARTRIDGE DRENNAN CHOO-WING THOMSON LARAMY NIELSEN ASSELSTINE MCINTOSH BALAGA STEINWALL GALLANT COX SUKUMARAN WAUCHOPE SAMMUT LUCAS TRAMONTOZZI CARTER DALEY TOBIN WHITWORTH MATTHEWS MCQUEEN TRACY BOND RICHARDS FRENCH MORRIS HAMILTON-GREENER SHAND JOHNSTONE RALPH DARNBROUGH BEAUPARLANT WHITE CHARLES DUNN MAHARAJ ONYSZKIEWICZ ALLDRIT NOONAN FERRIS GRIFFITHS KELLY ALBRECHT LAVALLEE KAY REDDIN HART PARKIN MACIEK FRIGON CECILE RIDDELL HAYES TULIPANO RANDLE VAYANI MOORE STOREY LIU CHAMBERS DIAZ SLAVEN BROOKES BISHOP DICOSOLA SMIT FORTIN Given Name ROBERT LLOYD LAURENT HUGUES FRANK CRAIG DEXTER MICHAEL ALLAN JOHN STEPHEN WILLIAM DANIEL SHAUN DAVID DANIEL ARTUR ANDREW TREVOR ROBERT DARREN ANDREW RAJEEV LIAM DAVID PATRICK NUNZIATO MAXWELL KEVIN ROBERT ERNEST JOSEPH BLAKE GARY STEVEN MARLIN CLIVE JOHN HAROLD MICHAEL J. JOSEPH EDWARD ANDREW PAUL TIMOTHY DANIEL ROBERT PAUL JOSEPH JOHN ANTHONY BEVERLY BRYAN SANJEEV ANDREW DARREN LEE TIMOTHY JOHN LISA DAVID TERENCE PETER IRVIN JOHN DAVID VIKTOR BRIAN KIRBY ALBERT DOUGLAS ANDREW WILFRED JOHN ROBERT GLEN LINDSAY DIANA JEREMY MATTHEW ROSARIO MARK RICHARD SHAFIQ ABDUL BRETT CALVIN TODD MELVYN JUN COURTNEY PEDRO EDUARDO WILLIAM LEVERNE MCCOURCEY DAVID MICHELE BRIAN JOHN LOUIS-MARIE RAYMOND Position Detective Police Constable Staff Sergeant Detective Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Detective Detective Sergeant Police Constable Detective Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Detective Sergeant Detective Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Detective Detective Staff Sergeant Police Constable Staff Sergeant Detective Sergeant Sergeant Detective Staff Sergeant Detective Detective Sergeant Staff Sergeant Detective Staff Sergeant Police Constable Detective Sergeant Staff Sergeant Detective Sergeant Staff Sergeant Detective Sergeant Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Sergeant Detective Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Detective Detective Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Detective Detective Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Police Constable Detective Staff Sergeant Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Senior Telecom Engineer Staff Sergeant Detective Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Detective Sergeant Detective Sergeant Detective Sergeant Salary Paid $ 128,100.20 $ 128,046.55 $ 127,921.90 $ 127,911.38 $ 127,875.16 $ 127,861.47 $ 127,854.40 $ 127,795.38 $ 127,764.42 $ 127,751.33 $ 127,737.03 $ 127,685.16 $ 127,658.23 $ 127,571.13 $ 127,559.87 $ 127,557.29 $ 127,499.67 $ 127,407.07 $ 127,360.89 $ 127,282.74 $ 127,230.05 $ 127,156.52 $ 127,153.66 $ 127,141.73 $ 127,005.89 $ 126,986.64 $ 126,981.81 $ 126,967.05 $ 126,959.99 $ 126,939.68 $ 126,936.39 $ 126,917.55 $ 126,859.75 $ 126,827.34 $ 126,808.63 $ 126,789.28 $ 126,774.76 $ 126,769.45 $ 126,760.33 $ 126,726.33 $ 126,720.90 $ 126,720.89 $ 126,606.58 $ 126,542.85 $ 126,529.67 $ 126,493.51 $ 126,484.99 $ 126,435.82 $ 126,420.13 $ 126,416.65 $ 126,381.17 $ 126,376.40 $ 126,357.26 $ 126,327.66 $ 126,279.21 $ 126,277.28 $ 126,253.54 $ 126,233.88 $ 126,206.71 $ 126,200.34 $ 126,196.16 $ 126,155.44 $ 126,134.08 $ 126,122.79 $ 126,110.79 $ 126,039.37 $ 125,995.94 $ 125,973.80 $ 125,906.00 $ 125,897.81 $ 125,887.12 Benefits $701.67 $669.95 $744.60 $717.06 $686.42 $708.56 $701.67 $539.14 $662.93 $708.56 $686.42 $701.67 $717.06 $710.11 $708.56 $686.42 $708.56 $717.06 $717.06 $744.60 $679.56 $744.60 $744.60 $708.56 $663.80 $744.60 $292.08 $744.60 $744.60 $710.11 $744.60 $662.93 $737.72 $744.60 $717.06 $711.97 $744.60 $744.60 $684.37 $686.42 $445.54 $717.06 $700.32 $717.06 $717.06 $708.56 $686.68 $261.44 $717.06 $701.67 $717.06 $669.95 $683.13 $700.32 $715.78 $675.34 $701.67 $744.60 $717.06 $678.70 $701.67 $686.42 $742.07 $744.60 $708.56 $700.32 $689.50 $744.60 $708.56 $717.06 $744.60

APPENDIX B RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Surname WARD PARMAR ARP MCCALL FORESTELL KEMP POGUE BARATTO FALCONER FERGUSON BOSWARD MACPHERSON SCANLAN BENNETT DIZON LUPSON ARMSTRONG SABADICS NOLL MCCRAN ANDERSEN RASMUSSEN WONG RYZEK HOWELL DANIELS IRELAND WORDEN LI REEVES PERSHIN ZARB ROBINSON BELANGER JAROSZ CANNON AMLIN CAPUTO SMYTHE STERN RAND SIDORA DURHAM ATTENBOROUGH LONG SURITA SMYTH MONAGHAN COULTER DAVIES PALA NASSER WHEELER BERNARDO MEANEY CRADDOCK SCHOFIELD CORMACK GOTELL TROUP ABDEL-MALIK MUSSO DUARTE MARCHACK PINFOLD YOUNG LEITCH SINGH GURMAN MAISONNEUVE MACDONALD GERRITS Given Name VANESSA MANDEEP SINGH JAMES ANDREW ANDREW JOHN MICHAEL WILLIAM LAUREN MICHELLE TERESA GREGORY JAY MARIE WILLIAM DONALD WADE KIMBERLY LYN WINSTON ANTHONY JOSE BENEDICTO CHRISTOPHER BRYDON ROBERT KENNETH DANIEL CARL ROBERT CARL HENRIK KEVIN WILLIAM CHUNG MAN WENDY JOHN MARK CHARLES MORGAN HARRIS PAUL HAMILTON ROBERT CHAK LAWRENCE ANDREI VALERI RAYMOND DANIEL DONALD RENE RUSSELL MICHAEL SCOTT CHRISTOPHER JOSEPH KENT CHARLES ANDREW RICHARD THEODORE TERRY CAMERON EDWARD JEFFREY BRUCE GARRY ALFRED CRAIG CHARLES PATRICK JAMES JOHN ALAN ROBERT EARLE RASIH SAN AMAN CHRISTOPHER ISRAEL FARIA SHAWN STEPHEN GLENN BRIAN JAMES JAMES ELWOOD PETER MAHER SUSANA ROGER MATTHEW GEORGE JENNIFER MARIE JASON AMRITPAL MICHAEL DANIEL AARON ROYCE JOHN Position Detective Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Sergeant Staff Sergeant Detective Sergeant Detective Detective Detective Detective Sergeant Police Constable Staff Sergeant Staff Sergeant Detective Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Sergeant Detective Sergeant Detective Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Sergeant Manager of Occupational Health and Safety Staff Sergeant Detective Police Constable Detective Police Constable Staff Sergeant Police Constable Staff Sergeant Sergeant Staff Sergeant Detective Sergeant Staff Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Sergeant Detective Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Staff Sergeant Detective Sergeant Detective Police Constable Supervisor of Video Services Detective Sergeant Detective Sergeant Detective Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Sergeant Detective Sergeant Detective Detective Detective Sergeant Staff Sergeant Detective Police Constable Detective Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Detective Senior Technical Analyst Detective Detective Detective Police Constable Salary Paid $ 125,846.58 $ 125,816.63 $ 125,806.87 $ 125,803.03 $ 125,772.10 $ 125,656.97 $ 125,648.33 $ 125,642.37 $ 125,579.37 $ 125,545.26 $ 125,532.38 $ 125,519.51 $ 125,457.27 $ 125,396.87 $ 125,377.54 $ 125,369.74 $ 125,333.20 $ 125,319.61 $ 125,315.47 $ 125,281.09 $ 125,265.27 $ 125,191.32 $ 125,191.25 $ 125,156.68 $ 125,151.89 $ 125,076.59 $ 124,978.16 $ 124,958.82 $ 124,949.31 $ 124,929.25 $ 124,884.06 $ 124,856.15 $ 124,838.82 $ 124,812.31 $ 124,803.17 $ 124,799.65 $ 124,794.92 $ 124,778.74 $ 124,747.19 $ 124,732.66 $ 124,692.72 $ 124,656.81 $ 124,640.75 $ 124,608.04 $ 124,596.06 $ 124,581.05 $ 124,575.70 $ 124,574.25 $ 124,566.42 $ 124,529.58 $ 124,505.02 $ 124,500.70 $ 124,495.92 $ 124,466.77 $ 124,414.56 $ 124,411.90 $ 124,385.55 $ 124,381.04 $ 124,328.00 $ 124,310.06 $ 124,308.56 $ 124,299.40 $ 124,297.42 $ 124,284.62 $ 124,226.00 $ 124,224.83 $ 124,194.95 $ 124,155.08 $ 124,115.35 $ 124,067.61 $ 124,005.95 Benefits $717.06 $686.42 $686.42 $717.06 $717.06 $744.60 $744.60 $717.06 $717.06 $717.06 $744.60 $669.95 $744.60 $742.00 $701.67 $667.87 $686.42 $744.60 $744.60 $717.06 $700.32 $662.93 $708.56 $825.09 $744.60 $708.56 $669.95 $708.56 $669.95 $744.60 $662.93 $429.80 $717.06 $703.83 $744.60 $744.60 $686.42 $717.06 $708.56 $717.06 $686.42 $717.06 $744.60 $738.48 $717.06 $662.93 $321.24 $744.60 $744.60 $701.67 $681.80 $678.70 $684.37 $701.93 $715.78 $717.06 $708.56 $701.67 $737.72 $744.60 $701.67 $676.70 $708.56 $686.16 $253.72 $708.56 $1,034.24 $717.06 $713.86 $710.11 $684.37

APPENDIX B RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Surname DE SOUSA JUPP MACGREGOR KNAPPER QURESHI PAPIZEWSKI YOUNG DUFFUS SPANTON GEORGE DI GIACOMO TAIT JOHNSTON MOLYNEAUX TANABE ALEXANDER BURKE SMISSEN MATIC HALL MCCLELLAND CHUDOBA LLOYD MATYS DUBREUIL ADAMS BATES HOWARD CANTELON CONNOR AZARRAGA IHASZ VAN ANDEL SAGGI WONG MOREIRA GRAY SARDELLA ALEXAKIS CAMPBELL MURRAY LEE PAYNE CHILVERS LEE SADRZADEH JOSIFOVIC LAMOND GLAVIN MCLANE BLANCHARD KARKOULAS SILLIKER LAING BOURQUE NEVIN FEBBO WILLIAMS GROSS BAJ ASHLEY GETTY AIELLO O'CONNOR MEEHAN JOCKO LUM LIONTI WILLIAMS MEIK FROSCH Given Name JOHN PAUL BRUCE JASON JAMES ROBBERT NICOLAAS AJWAID NIAZ LEEANN CRAIG RICHARD HUGH JOHN GLEN ROBERTO ADRIAN WILLIAM JOHN DAVID STEVEN SHINGO OLIVER DAVID WALTER MICHAEL DAVID JOHN MICHAEL MICHAEL NEIL HARCOURT ROBERT MYRON BRADFORD JOSEPH PAUL JEAN CLAYTON EDWARD KIMBERLEY MICHELE SHAWN GREGORY BRUCE ALEXANDER JOSE MATIAS JOHN CHRISTOPHER PHILLIP GEORGE SHARNJIT SINGH CONRAD EMERY PETER MICHAEL GLENN GLENN DONATO CHRISTOS MICHELLE DIANE DAVID NOEL THOMAS THEODORE ALGERNON CHRISTOPHER CLIFFORD PHILIP BRIAN MIR SIAMAK MLADEN IAN DAVID PHILLIP JAMES RUSSELL RICHARD TREVOR DANIEL GARRY DARREN S DOUGLAS PATRICK OLIVER STEVEN THOMAS KIMBERLY STANISLAW MARK NICHOLAS SHAWN ANTONIO MIKE STEPHEN PATRICK TODD JOESEPH SOON CALOGERO ANTHONY VIVIAN JAY JACKSON Position Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Detective Staff Sergeant Detective Detective Sergeant Staff Sergeant Detective Staff Sergeant Sergeant Detective Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Staff Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Staff Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Detective Detective Detective Sergeant Detective Detective Police Constable Staff Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Detective Staff Sergeant Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Staff Sergeant Staff Sergeant Detective Police Constable Sergeant Staff Sergeant Staff Sergeant Detective Detective Detective Police Constable Sergeant Staff Sergeant Sergeant Detective Staff Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Staff Sergeant Detective Sergeant Detective Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Sergeant Sergeant Detective Detective Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Detective Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Detective Detective Sergeant Salary Paid $ 123,991.81 $ 123,961.92 $ 123,960.05 $ 123,939.80 $ 123,938.64 $ 123,929.72 $ 123,922.39 $ 123,903.76 $ 123,896.25 $ 123,879.45 $ 123,843.44 $ 123,841.69 $ 123,808.71 $ 123,802.43 $ 123,802.08 $ 123,784.77 $ 123,776.53 $ 123,759.20 $ 123,745.46 $ 123,708.64 $ 123,688.33 $ 123,673.94 $ 123,670.14 $ 123,668.07 $ 123,656.06 $ 123,603.15 $ 123,601.15 $ 123,588.28 $ 123,551.45 $ 123,517.37 $ 123,509.98 $ 123,507.11 $ 123,482.60 $ 123,458.15 $ 123,405.07 $ 123,398.84 $ 123,389.65 $ 123,364.91 $ 123,334.81 $ 123,307.45 $ 123,298.53 $ 123,263.14 $ 123,251.98 $ 123,186.81 $ 123,164.02 $ 123,159.22 $ 123,152.18 $ 123,107.56 $ 123,098.99 $ 123,095.80 $ 123,052.90 $ 123,047.30 $ 123,021.12 $ 123,016.29 $ 123,011.37 $ 122,988.75 $ 122,988.47 $ 122,984.64 $ 122,943.71 $ 122,902.79 $ 122,884.83 $ 122,883.70 $ 122,862.91 $ 122,859.21 $ 122,857.63 $ 122,823.81 $ 122,820.23 $ 122,804.54 $ 122,803.31 $ 122,790.14 $ 122,782.35 Benefits $686.42 $684.37 $701.67 $744.60 $701.67 $738.22 $744.60 $708.56 $744.60 $717.06 $701.67 $669.95 $686.42 $744.60 $686.42 $708.56 $684.37 $686.42 $744.60 $686.42 $717.06 $717.06 $708.56 $701.67 $717.06 $701.67 $717.06 $676.70 $744.60 $686.42 $708.56 $717.06 $744.60 $662.93 $666.29 $737.72 $744.60 $701.67 $662.06 $698.82 $744.60 $744.60 $717.06 $701.67 $705.81 $662.93 $717.06 $737.72 $717.06 $717.06 $744.60 $686.16 $744.60 $717.06 $717.06 $610.54 $711.97 $686.42 $744.60 $717.06 $717.06 $744.60 $686.42 $686.42 $717.06 $701.67 $700.32 $686.42 $708.56 $717.06 $319.62

APPENDIX B RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Surname COLE SWACKHAMER HENRY DEY LAWR TAYLOR HILL MCBRATNEY SPROXTON JOSTIAK TAPLEY JANSZ LYON MCQUEEN NEWMAN SWEENIE EUSTACE BROUGHTON CARVALHO GERRY HANDSOR RAMJATTAN HEANEY ABBOTT PROCTOR PARROTT SIMPKINS PRESS HARRAS SEDORE WOOTTON DHALIWAL JHAJJ WHALEN RYAN WHALEN BIRRELL KELLY PRICE MCCREADY HUGHES FIELD QUALTROUGH RICCI STIRLING BASS THERIAULT BROSNAN COLE ABDULLA EATON BLAKELEY WALKER THOMAS GIBSON MILLER TUTCHENER WINTER MURRELL CLENDINNING GLENDINNING MATTHEWS LAM KYRIACOU FOSTER PAYNE ALPHONSO NORTHRUP GREENWOOD CHIASSON JUHASZ Given Name JASON ARTHUR BRENT PETER ROBIN HUGH GREGORY EDWARD JASON PETER IRA NORMAN GARY ROBERT JOSEPH RONALD GAWAIN MARIO ROBERT KIRK SHERRY LYNN BRUCE PAUL MARTIN DAVID PETER WILLIAM AVELINO MOTA DARYLE PHILIP ALLEN RAMNARINE GERALD DEBORAH LYNN NORMAN EDWARD MICHAEL ERIC DAVID MICHAEL ALLEN JOHN KEVIN ARTHUR RYAN PETER SURINDERJIT CHARANJIT CHRISTOPHER ANDREW STEPHEN CHARLES ROBERT JOHN THOMAS BRIAN WAYNE MARY WILLIAM GUY CAMERON DOUGLAS JAMES CHARLES MICHAEL ROBERT LORNE WILLIAM DONALD SEAN DONALD AL RAHIM DOUGLAS BRIAN JANICE JAMES CLAUDINE ANNE-MARIE JAMES DUNCAN GARY JEFFREY MATTHEW KEVIN EARL MARK WILLIAM GREGORY DAVID SCOTT ANDREW IAN WAYNE SAVAS ROY GREGORY JAMES MARK ANDREW JEFFREY JOHN JAMES MARCEL ANDRE ALEXANDER GYOZO Position Detective Staff Sergeant Staff Sergeant Sergeant Detective Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Staff Sergeant Detective Sergeant Staff Sergeant Staff Sergeant Sergeant Detective Police Constable Staff Sergeant Sergeant Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Staff Sergeant Detective Detective Staff Sergeant Staff Sergeant Staff Sergeant Sergeant Staff Sergeant Senior Firearms Officer Detective Detective Plainclothes Police Constable Senior Technical Analyst Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Sergeant Detective Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Sergeant Staff Sergeant Detective Sergeant Police Constable Detective Sergeant Staff Sergeant Detective Staff Sergeant Police Constable Detective Staff Sergeant Staff Sergeant Senior Technical Analyst Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Staff Sergeant Detective Sergeant Staff Sergeant Sergeant Staff Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Staff Sergeant Detective Detective Police Constable Police Constable Detective Sergeant Detective Detective Sergeant Staff Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Sergeant Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Salary Paid $ 122,780.82 $ 122,765.98 $ 122,753.47 $ 122,748.76 $ 122,697.97 $ 122,697.70 $ 122,668.14 $ 122,665.80 $ 122,657.28 $ 122,651.50 $ 122,650.12 $ 122,618.05 $ 122,570.14 $ 122,561.90 $ 122,561.61 $ 122,516.69 $ 122,516.06 $ 122,488.43 $ 122,484.63 $ 122,467.53 $ 122,452.38 $ 122,435.65 $ 122,430.07 $ 122,422.25 $ 122,332.90 $ 122,332.17 $ 122,327.18 $ 122,303.84 $ 122,269.34 $ 122,255.14 $ 122,246.45 $ 122,244.40 $ 122,237.07 $ 122,223.68 $ 122,220.59 $ 122,174.50 $ 122,142.84 $ 122,114.49 $ 122,091.40 $ 122,037.72 $ 122,010.42 $ 122,001.18 $ 121,997.55 $ 121,989.79 $ 121,974.29 $ 121,955.65 $ 121,934.64 $ 121,930.29 $ 121,902.14 $ 121,894.14 $ 121,882.03 $ 121,857.34 $ 121,855.35 $ 121,791.71 $ 121,752.97 $ 121,746.18 $ 121,743.44 $ 121,733.65 $ 121,709.81 $ 121,708.51 $ 121,705.84 $ 121,702.68 $ 121,702.15 $ 121,682.11 $ 121,676.92 $ 121,672.37 $ 121,646.27 $ 121,628.60 $ 121,612.87 $ 121,609.96 $ 121,594.01 Benefits $717.06 $742.00 $744.60 $717.06 $717.06 $686.42 $717.06 $744.60 $744.60 $709.32 $744.60 $701.67 $708.56 $669.95 $744.60 $701.67 $717.06 $686.42 $708.56 $744.60 $701.67 $708.56 $737.72 $744.60 $744.60 $701.67 $744.60 $717.07 $717.06 $701.67 $678.70 $280.88 $676.70 $686.42 $744.60 $711.97 $693.44 $737.72 $744.60 $744.60 $683.13 $602.94 $744.60 $701.67 $739.50 $684.37 $712.59 $744.60 $744.60 $280.88 $672.60 $717.06 $744.60 $728.14 $744.60 $717.06 $744.60 $686.42 $744.60 $717.06 $717.06 $662.93 $663.19 $744.60 $717.06 $744.60 $744.60 $693.69 $744.60 $708.56 $678.70

APPENDIX B RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Surname WILSON STASIAK DAVIS TILLEY WOODHOUSE PRICE DARBYSHIRE HILDRED KITCHENER PAIS DOUGLAS BRASCA BARENTHIN BOOTH FEDERICO LEMBKE BROWN BENNEY HALMAN SOBOTKA DAMASO JATTAN BURKS SCUDDS ROSETE KING MARTELLUZZI REDMAN KEELER SMALL MORRISON HOWELL ALLINGTON SHAW LEUNG PRENTICE BLACKMAN WITTY YOUNG BRAR DECOURCY HURLEY CREWS DAVEY GILL WILSON STOLF STRANGWAYS STONES ROHDE MORRISON GOTTSCHALK HAUNTS DE LIO FORCHIONE CHHABRA DOKURNO ANDRICI MAADANIAN JACKSON PROULX COSTABILE YANG CRONE SINGH VIRK ROBINSON BACKUS WRIGHT HANLON BURNINGHAM Given Name DAVID W. LESZEK EDWARD SHARON MARK STEPHEN BRANDON LEE JAMES EDWARD LESLEY ANDREW JAMES SCHARNIL VALERIAN BARBARA ANN WALTER GLENN KARL KENNETH COURTLAND MATTHEW MICHAEL KRISTIN NICOLE ROBERT PETER DARREN KARL RODNEY CLINT CHARLES DEAN PAUL LESTER EDWARD STUART MACPHERSON CLAUDIO SUZANNE CHRISTOPHER THOMAS BRYAN GEORGE BRUCE JEFFREY JEFFREY SCOTT KATHLEEN SHEUNG STEFAN PATRICK ARLINGTON EARL RONALD GURSHARNJIT SINGH JOHN WILLIAM ANTHONY WILLIAM TIMOTHY JASON GOWAN WARREN ROBERT GUIDO PAUL ROBERT MICHAEL DANNY WILLIAM MICHAEL ROBERT BRIAN ALAN FRANK PAUL ANTONIO AJAY RICHARD MICHAEL IULIAN NAZARET LAURIE KEVIN EDWARD GINO QIANLIANG SUSAN AMARJIT PURBA MAHEEP KAUR MORGAN LESLIE DOUGLAS REGINALD GEORGE ERIN VALENTINE GRANT NEIL Position Sergeant Detective Sergeant Staff Sergeant Staff Sergeant Sergeant Detective Staff Sergeant Staff Sergeant Detective Police Constable Detective Sergeant Detective Sergeant Detective Senior Technical Analyst Police Constable Staff Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Staff Sergeant Detective Sergeant Detective Police Constable Detective Sergeant Staff Sergeant Detective Sergeant Sergeant Staff Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Staff Sergeant Staff Sergeant Detective Detective Sergeant Detective Detective Staff Sergeant Superintendent Detective Sergeant Police Constable Detective Sergeant Staff Sergeant Detective Sergeant Detective Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Sergeant Detective Sergeant Detective Sergeant Police Constable Detective Staff Sergeant Detective Sergeant Sergeant Staff Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Sergeant Police Constable Detective Staff Sergeant Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Detective Sergeant Detective Police Constable Detective Sergeant Detective Detective Plainclothes Police Constable Staff Sergeant Salary Paid $ 121,585.78 $ 121,579.74 $ 121,568.06 $ 121,540.76 $ 121,540.37 $ 121,538.02 $ 121,489.95 $ 121,478.33 $ 121,476.91 $ 121,476.11 $ 121,445.23 $ 121,443.47 $ 121,442.63 $ 121,434.65 $ 121,433.04 $ 121,420.00 $ 121,395.46 $ 121,382.12 $ 121,380.86 $ 121,363.53 $ 121,351.74 $ 121,347.40 $ 121,314.06 $ 121,311.32 $ 121,302.77 $ 121,293.66 $ 121,264.90 $ 121,238.79 $ 121,229.51 $ 121,225.70 $ 121,208.28 $ 121,173.37 $ 121,128.09 $ 121,126.06 $ 121,123.28 $ 121,121.19 $ 121,118.80 $ 121,106.61 $ 121,061.40 $ 121,018.69 $ 120,991.57 $ 120,985.63 $ 120,978.02 $ 120,953.88 $ 120,922.46 $ 120,918.72 $ 120,890.15 $ 120,853.77 $ 120,806.42 $ 120,800.25 $ 120,781.87 $ 120,755.78 $ 120,754.47 $ 120,743.21 $ 120,738.77 $ 120,735.52 $ 120,724.51 $ 120,720.22 $ 120,707.17 $ 120,701.20 $ 120,688.33 $ 120,636.76 $ 120,629.99 $ 120,622.27 $ 120,617.13 $ 120,603.44 $ 120,586.24 $ 120,559.83 $ 120,502.97 $ 120,497.74 $ 120,473.84 Benefits $717.06 $744.60 $744.60 $744.60 $717.06 $701.67 $744.60 $744.60 $717.06 $662.93 $708.56 $717.06 $744.60 $744.60 $705.86 $662.93 $744.60 $700.32 $740.97 $744.60 $701.67 $684.37 $744.60 $744.60 $701.67 $717.06 $708.56 $733.32 $693.44 $678.70 $744.60 $744.60 $701.67 $744.60 $708.56 $701.67 $319.62 $2,897.36 $744.60 $669.95 $744.60 $744.60 $744.60 $319.62 $686.42 $744.60 $701.67 $708.56 $744.60 $669.95 $708.56 $744.60 $744.60 $708.56 $303.30 $678.70 $744.60 $669.95 $701.67 $742.52 $669.95 $689.50 $662.93 $744.60 $708.56 $662.93 $366.84 $717.06 $717.06 $684.34 $681.64

APPENDIX B RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Surname WEBSTER SCHERK BODDY MILLER MORI LEE NOLAN AL-NASS FYFE ARMSTRONG BROOKES KONDO THOMAS LEBLANC VEIT LAHEY NICOLLE KONKEL DEAN GRANDE MACDONALD FINLAY HEILIMO FYNES LOWREY RYDZIK KINNEAR DEWLING CLARKE WYNIA BEVAN HEITZNER WALTERS KELL GREER WALKER ANSTEY SKINNER VIEIRA GAGLIARDI CHASE CROOKER MARTIN KING BURLEY MCGOWN HODGERT KIRKPATRICK KIM SONDERGAARD GREGORY TAVARES ALPHONSO RUFFINO RUDNICK WOLF COULSON GREER MORSE IRISH FODEN TYMBURSKI CROSBY GREKOS BAPTIST MACDONALD BISHOP KEYS TRETTER MACDONALD DZINGALA Given Name DAVID GREGORY CHRISTOPHER CHRISTOPHER EDWARD PAUL DEBORAH ANN NICOLE DENISE CHRISTOPHER WALID JOHN MARK RICHARD RALPH JASON SYDNEY NORMAN OSWALD MARY REGINA CHAD EDWARD KAZIMIERZ BERTRAND PIETRO GREGORY ALLAN KARL ADRIAN ALAN DAVID BRIAN KATHRYN NORMAN JOHN RANDALL WILLIAM ROBERT MATTHEW GREGORY JEFFREY STEWART THOMAS ROBERT KELLY LYNN JASON CHRISTOPHER ROBERT ABILIO VITO WILLIAM OLIVER LISA CATHERINE ANTHONY CHERYL DAVID JOSEPH JOHN DOUGLAS CHRISTOPHER JOHN HYOK KYUN NIELS ROBERT K. JEFFERY WADE LEONARD STEPHEN JOANNE LINDA RAYMOND WILLIAM MARIE VICTORIA JANE TIMOTHY GARNET STEPHEN EDWARD DANIEL PATRICK MICHAEL CHARLENE ANNE ANNE-MARIE GARY MADELAINE JOHN EDWARD Position Sergeant Detective Staff Sergeant Staff Sergeant Staff Sergeant Staff Sergeant Staff Sergeant Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Staff Sergeant Detective Staff Sergeant Detective Sergeant Sergeant Sergeant Sergeant Staff Sergeant Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Staff Sergeant Sergeant Staff Sergeant Detective Sergeant Staff Sergeant Staff Sergeant Sergeant Staff Sergeant Detective Sergeant Detective Detective Detective Police Constable Detective Senior Operations Supervisor Plainclothes Police Constable Staff Sergeant Staff Sergeant Detective Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Plainclothes Police Constable Staff Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Staff Sergeant Police Constable Detective Sergeant Police Constable Staff Sergeant Staff Sergeant Sergeant Staff Sergeant Detective Staff Sergeant Detective Staff Sergeant Detective Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Detective Sergeant Staff Sergeant Staff Sergeant Detective Staff Sergeant Detective Sergeant Staff Sergeant Staff Sergeant Detective Sergeant Staff Sergeant Staff Sergeant Salary Paid $ 120,473.17 $ 120,464.26 $ 120,454.13 $ 120,450.20 $ 120,443.96 $ 120,436.56 $ 120,429.56 $ 120,417.03 $ 120,412.12 $ 120,398.76 $ 120,384.81 $ 120,376.81 $ 120,373.72 $ 120,363.93 $ 120,361.70 $ 120,353.79 $ 120,336.77 $ 120,296.43 $ 120,284.59 $ 120,222.86 $ 120,214.45 $ 120,206.72 $ 120,184.76 $ 120,172.75 $ 120,167.46 $ 120,160.08 $ 120,155.18 $ 120,110.13 $ 120,108.89 $ 120,095.95 $ 120,047.33 $ 120,034.90 $ 120,022.44 $ 120,020.62 $ 120,014.84 $ 120,010.28 $ 119,993.70 $ 119,986.37 $ 119,979.52 $ 119,970.67 $ 119,958.68 $ 119,939.19 $ 119,918.61 $ 119,911.16 $ 119,863.87 $ 119,863.16 $ 119,859.00 $ 119,845.95 $ 119,842.40 $ 119,836.27 $ 119,832.26 $ 119,818.09 $ 119,793.37 $ 119,773.39 $ 119,743.82 $ 119,725.77 $ 119,723.17 $ 119,716.75 $ 119,698.43 $ 119,689.47 $ 119,684.70 $ 119,675.46 $ 119,670.90 $ 119,645.00 $ 119,640.87 $ 119,631.15 $ 119,611.44 $ 119,567.13 $ 119,566.14 $ 119,553.55 $ 119,535.92 Benefits $714.50 $708.56 $312.74 $319.62 $744.60 $744.60 $744.60 $669.95 $693.44 $717.06 $744.60 $717.06 $744.60 $744.60 $715.78 $708.56 $708.56 $744.60 $633.02 $691.36 $744.60 $717.06 $744.60 $744.60 $744.60 $742.52 $717.06 $744.60 $717.06 $682.02 $717.06 $708.56 $708.56 $669.95 $708.56 $713.15 $683.37 $744.60 $744.60 $701.67 $686.16 $701.67 $699.28 $737.72 $686.42 $744.60 $684.37 $716.79 $662.93 $744.60 $744.60 $701.67 $744.60 $717.06 $744.60 $717.06 $744.60 $744.60 $686.42 $708.56 $744.60 $744.60 $726.24 $708.56 $650.16 $744.60 $737.72 $744.60 $744.60 $744.60 $744.60

APPENDIX B RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Surname MENDOZA MOYER KENNY STEWART TAM GOTTSCHALK HARVEY KEANE FOWLDS MULLIN PROCTOR SHREVE FARRELL BULLOCK BARNES D'ONOFRIO BELLON REDICK GALLANT JACKSON BROWN REGAN ZELENY GUEST COSTA OZOLS QUAIATTINI KEALEY ELLIOTT BRINN IRISH MURDOCH BATES PASINI MANNING PATTISON GILLIS CLARKE KNAAP LOUGHLIN RIDDELL ZUBEK GRAFFMANN GREENAWAY MCARTHUR STANLEY MI SAVINO FLIS BRADSHAW CARACCIOLO CORBIE CONNOLLY DESJARDINS HAINES MALTAR SCHULZE PERREAULT FORSYTHE FISHER SMITH PATTERSON WORTH MASTERS TAYLOR VALLES DUARTE HOCKADAY THOMPSON ISABELLO TAYLOR Given Name PHILIP MANILAY IAN BRIAN ROBERT WING MICHAEL MARK PATRICK SCOTT MACKENZIE GEORGE RICHARD P. CLARENCE BLAKE CHRISTINE MARIE NEIL MURRAY WINSTANLEY ANTONIO CORINNE AMANDA BROOKE KELLY-ANN PAUL EDWARD DOUGLAS DOUGLAS FREDRICK JOHN DARYN KEVIN ANGELO JOHN SUSAN DEVIN PAUL NORMAN DAVID RICHARD SANDY RUDY JOHN STEVEN DAVID WILLIAM STEVEN JOHN EDWARD ALAN JOSEPH GORDON COLIN PAUL IAN WILLIAM YAOMING LEONARDO ALBERT KEITH ROGER DOMINIC WESLEY MARCUS JOHN PAUL JOSEPH FRANCOIS RICHARD PAUL MICHAEL CHRISTOPHER FRANK THOMAS SEAN MICHAEL ROSS SUSAN HUNTER WELLINGTON JAMES DARREN MICHELLE SCOTT DAVID SHEHARA JOAO RODRIGO ADAM ROY JAMES DUNCAN DAVID ANTHONY JEFFREY Position Sergeant Staff Sergeant Staff Sergeant Staff Sergeant Police Constable Staff Sergeant Sergeant Detective Sergeant Sergeant Staff Sergeant Detective Staff Sergeant Detective Staff Sergeant Detective Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Sergeant Police Constable Sergeant Staff Sergeant Detective Staff Sergeant Sergeant Police Constable Staff Sergeant Detective Sergeant Sergeant Detective Sergeant Detective Staff Sergeant Staff Sergeant Detective Sergeant Police Constable Staff Sergeant Staff Sergeant Detective Sergeant Staff Sergeant Detective Sergeant Detective Sergeant Staff Sergeant Detective Sergeant Detective Sergeant Detective Sergeant Detective Sergeant Senior Technical Analyst Police Constable Detective Detective Detective Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Staff Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Detective Sergeant Detective Detective Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Staff Sergeant Salary Paid $ 119,527.79 $ 119,514.79 $ 119,506.04 $ 119,484.54 $ 119,469.85 $ 119,454.23 $ 119,451.01 $ 119,435.49 $ 119,434.90 $ 119,430.15 $ 119,426.67 $ 119,420.54 $ 119,420.07 $ 119,419.94 $ 119,418.17 $ 119,417.98 $ 119,413.92 $ 119,408.12 $ 119,404.39 $ 119,404.21 $ 119,393.39 $ 119,387.23 $ 119,380.71 $ 119,338.04 $ 119,330.78 $ 119,327.33 $ 119,325.67 $ 119,303.47 $ 119,300.11 $ 119,292.74 $ 119,282.67 $ 119,272.04 $ 119,254.41 $ 119,245.04 $ 119,240.36 $ 119,218.04 $ 119,211.04 $ 119,209.29 $ 119,209.29 $ 119,209.29 $ 119,209.29 $ 119,209.29 $ 119,209.29 $ 119,209.29 $ 119,209.29 $ 119,209.29 $ 119,204.08 $ 119,201.94 $ 119,175.74 $ 119,174.60 $ 119,171.72 $ 119,169.02 $ 119,150.03 $ 119,082.19 $ 119,052.15 $ 119,005.80 $ 118,975.21 $ 118,947.91 $ 118,947.14 $ 118,943.31 $ 118,925.46 $ 118,861.56 $ 118,852.32 $ 118,842.07 $ 118,841.61 $ 118,830.90 $ 118,819.60 $ 118,804.48 $ 118,801.80 $ 118,801.16 $ 118,798.41 Benefits $708.56 $744.60 $744.60 $744.60 $676.70 $571.46 $710.11 $429.80 $708.56 $744.60 $708.56 $744.60 $708.56 $744.60 $701.67 $678.70 $602.94 $681.80 $492.76 $684.37 $717.06 $744.60 $717.06 $744.60 $717.06 $684.37 $319.62 $319.62 $717.06 $744.60 $717.06 $319.62 $319.62 $744.60 $684.37 $319.62 $744.60 $319.62 $319.62 $319.62 $319.62 $319.62 $744.60 $744.60 $744.60 $744.60 $280.88 $669.95 $710.42 $292.08 $701.67 $680.58 $670.20 $673.21 $679.01 $686.42 $684.37 $726.92 $700.32 $684.37 $701.67 $292.08 $701.67 $710.11 $686.42 $654.10 $686.42 $678.09 $681.80 $674.68 $742.00

APPENDIX B RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Surname OSBORN HALL BARWELL GALLANT MOFFAT CAMPBELL SABADIN GICZI RIETKOETTER STEWART UPPAL HARRIS ROUTH MARSMAN DUNNING COSCARELLA EXTON REID FRITZ CLARK MCDERMOTT MANTLE DEARBORN HEWSON CATES HARRIS MUNGAL STRAIN APOSTOLIDIS NICHOL BEVILACQUA DRAKE COGHLIN SMYTHE AGUIAR LANE PENNER RUBBINI RENNIE ASSELIN OLSEN STEEVES ROSSANO FARRUGIA HADDEN MERSEREAU KUNG DHILLON CORREIA CAMPBELL GERRY CLARKE GILFOY MCCOURT THIBODEAU HAFIZ BOPARA MORSE LAUFER RICHMOND YU MCLEAN DESROCHERS DA SILVA DEAN DESILVA JAMSHIDI RETSINAS BRETT CHOW GRIALDI Given Name ROBERT DANIEL ALVIN DALTON DAVID ERIC STACY ANTHONY NICOLE MICHAEL ALEXANDER JIM FRANK SETH ANDREW PATRICK ALEXANDER VISHAL RICHARD VICTOR MATTHEW AARON HENRI ANDREW RICHARD ANTHONY CHARLES CHAD SCOTT THEODOR TRAVIS DAYMOND DANIEL BRYAN LARRY ROBERT FREDERICK BROOKE LESLIE STEVEN RICHARD DAVID C. MATTHEW ROBERT JAMES JOHN IAN FRASER FILIPPO WILLIAM JAMES GARFIELD KAREN GRACE STEVEN CABRAL MICHEAL WILLIAM ADAM CHRISTOPHER DAVID ALEXANDER GLENN ANDRE FRANK THOMAS WARREN JOHN BENITO MARIE ELIZABETH ANNE MICHAEL TOMMY WING JAGJIT SINGH BRYAN MEDEIROS PHILLIP SCOTT DONALD MATTHEW FRANCIS LEAH DAWN KEVIN JOHN ROBERT AMIN GURMOKH STEPHEN PETER MICHAEL KENNETH KA WAI ERIC NANCY MARY ROGER HENRI JOSE JESSE RUSSELL JULIUS THEODORE JOSHUA PAYAM PANAGIOTA BRYAN DONALD HAROLD THIERRY Position Police Constable Sergeant Detective Detective Sergeant Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Detective Detective Detective Police Constable Staff Sergeant Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Sergeant Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Detective Detective Detective Detective Detective Detective Sergeant Staff Sergeant Staff Sergeant Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Detective Detective Detective Sergeant Sergeant Detective Police Constable Sergeant Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Staff Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Sergeant Sergeant Detective Sergeant Sergeant Detective Sergeant Police Constable Sergeant Detective Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Senior Analyst Detective Sergeant Police Constable Police Constable Sergeant Detective Salary Paid $ 118,789.17 $ 118,780.45 $ 118,780.42 $ 118,772.82 $ 118,759.02 $ 118,754.31 $ 118,752.12 $ 118,750.40 $ 118,697.79 $ 118,695.76 $ 118,677.69 $ 118,671.84 $ 118,671.83 $ 118,669.88 $ 118,657.18 $ 118,656.12 $ 118,643.39 $ 118,640.46 $ 118,600.65 $ 118,598.82 $ 118,597.60 $ 118,587.44 $ 118,537.89 $ 118,536.92 $ 118,535.95 $ 118,519.37 $ 118,516.93 $ 118,493.30 $ 118,480.90 $ 118,463.84 $ 118,460.05 $ 118,450.65 $ 118,444.24 $ 118,417.43 $ 118,417.03 $ 118,412.81 $ 118,405.71 $ 118,402.49 $ 118,352.02 $ 118,320.75 $ 118,265.60 $ 118,240.46 $ 118,228.28 $ 118,215.31 $ 118,214.70 $ 118,199.28 $ 118,196.97 $ 118,185.41 $ 118,140.31 $ 118,138.72 $ 118,067.02 $ 118,060.12 $ 118,052.30 $ 118,028.66 $ 118,023.67 $ 117,983.26 $ 117,965.19 $ 117,950.37 $ 117,949.98 $ 117,909.54 $ 117,908.59 $ 117,895.39 $ 117,848.57 $ 117,835.41 $ 117,805.27 $ 117,797.67 $ 117,797.47 $ 117,769.89 $ 117,756.46 $ 117,738.13 $ 117,725.96 Benefits $662.93 $708.56 $292.08 $742.52 $662.06 $700.32 $686.42 $708.56 $662.93 $678.70 $669.95 $701.67 $701.67 $708.56 $682.76 $737.72 $684.37 $686.42 $717.06 $689.78 $717.06 $684.34 $684.37 $686.42 $682.76 $717.06 $708.56 $717.06 $701.67 $654.10 $701.67 $717.06 $596.06 $317.54 $669.95 $662.93 $646.97 $684.37 $717.06 $714.50 $717.06 $697.68 $717.06 $717.06 $676.70 $717.06 $665.53 $658.58 $686.42 $686.42 $738.48 $686.42 $737.72 $697.47 $708.56 $717.06 $701.67 $744.60 $717.06 $740.47 $662.06 $708.56 $701.67 $306.61 $678.70 $280.88 $730.70 $676.70 $662.93 $711.97 $708.56

APPENDIX B RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Surname WALKER AIKMAN HUNG SINGH ZIELENIEWSKI WRAY RICCIARDI GIEDROYC HO CANNATA KHOSHBOOI CLARK HOGAN HORTON WRONG SIDHU DENTON HOUSTON POYNTER GILLAN SADLER JIMENEZ KOVACIC O'DONOVAN HAFFEJEE DREWS EAGLESON GLAVIN LINDSAY SMITH GRIFFITHS FRANKLIN CATON BRITTON GILBERT MC CONNELL SHUTT KHAWAJA HILTON QUIGG STEVENSON GIBSON THORNTON LEONE ROBBINS THERIAULT CANNELLA CAREFOOT LEBLANC MCGINN GREIG DAWSON LABELLE SMITH SPITZIG SMITH HUNT VELLEND TAYLOR DI POCE CAMPBELL SIMON FRITZ ARNOTT FOWLER PARSONS HAROON MALENFANT SARVANANDAN ACCIAROLI RICHE KISIELEWSKI Given Name SCOTT JAMES SCOTT DOUGLAS JAMES ANGADVIR STANLEY TERRENCE MARCO KAROL ZYGMUNT KENNY KONG-LEUNG DAVID ALI NADER PRESTON MICHAEL JAMES BRIAN JASON CHRISTOPHER ARVIND PRAKASH MARK DEBRA CHRISTOPHER REX JEFFREY JOHN STEPHEN FRANCISCO RAUL JOSEPH MARK STEPHEN FAZAL MOHAMMED JASON DAWN MICHELLE LYDIA STEPHANY HOWARD ROSS KEITH SEAN RONALD RICHARD MATTHEW MICHAEL FRANCES DONNA ELLEN SHAWN LAWRENCE SCOTT DAVID SUHAIL RASHID TYRONE CHRISTOPHER MARTIN BRENDAN LEIGH ROGER AMANDA DORIS MICHIELE MARIO KEVIN SHAUN JOHN ANGELO GIUSEPPE TODD ADAM LIONEL MICHAEL JOSEPH ROBERT SHANNON INEZ JOSEPH LAWRENCE OLIVER GERARD STEPHEN PATRICK ROBERT KATHARINE EMILIO DOUGLAS DUANE GORDON ROBERT WILLIAM WAYNE LEONARD STUART MAGRUDER USMAN ANDREW DEREK BAHEERATHAN SHERI DARLENE SCOTT LESLIE DARIUSZ Position Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Staff Sergeant Detective Police Constable Detective Police Constable Detective Sergeant Staff Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Sergeant Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Staff Sergeant Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Police Constable Police Constable Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Detective Sergeant Sergeant Staff Sergeant Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Information Security Officer Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Detective Staff Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Detective Detective Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Detective Police Constable Staff Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Detective Sergeant Detective Sergeant Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Salary Paid $ 117,716.32 $ 117,709.06 $ 117,674.95 $ 117,674.57 $ 117,673.56 $ 117,673.17 $ 117,658.56 $ 117,641.40 $ 117,625.87 $ 117,619.47 $ 117,587.44 $ 117,582.89 $ 117,564.44 $ 117,534.45 $ 117,527.34 $ 117,526.55 $ 117,512.40 $ 117,496.83 $ 117,496.10 $ 117,476.68 $ 117,456.24 $ 117,448.63 $ 117,445.76 $ 117,430.36 $ 117,412.06 $ 117,409.88 $ 117,407.86 $ 117,401.27 $ 117,378.69 $ 117,371.90 $ 117,355.11 $ 117,346.18 $ 117,335.00 $ 117,329.63 $ 117,315.15 $ 117,310.91 $ 117,309.46 $ 117,252.39 $ 117,242.23 $ 117,211.25 $ 117,164.84 $ 117,154.25 $ 117,147.78 $ 117,123.89 $ 117,115.18 $ 117,108.03 $ 117,077.93 $ 117,052.92 $ 117,046.14 $ 117,019.36 $ 116,987.11 $ 116,985.27 $ 116,982.98 $ 116,979.73 $ 116,973.59 $ 116,972.16 $ 116,962.93 $ 116,958.61 $ 116,947.64 $ 116,920.04 $ 116,863.36 $ 116,847.23 $ 116,834.20 $ 116,832.52 $ 116,832.37 $ 116,830.15 $ 116,828.38 $ 116,815.79 $ 116,815.21 $ 116,802.83 $ 116,787.12 Benefits $662.93 $693.44 $731.34 $701.67 $684.37 $717.06 $669.95 $312.74 $730.70 $700.32 $666.29 $686.42 $596.06 $679.56 $684.37 $669.95 $700.32 $738.97 $669.95 $686.42 $717.06 $662.93 $669.95 $717.06 $681.54 $686.42 $701.67 $737.72 $717.06 $739.50 $717.06 $700.32 $686.42 $717.06 $728.13 $658.58 $686.42 $662.93 $701.67 $737.46 $686.42 $717.06 $701.67 $737.72 $681.80 $717.06 $669.95 $700.32 $686.42 $686.42 $717.06 $701.93 $629.28 $737.72 $700.32 $701.67 $717.06 $370.78 $717.06 $717.06 $684.37 $700.32 $700.32 $717.06 $700.32 $662.93 $686.42 $686.42 $701.67 $684.59 $684.37

APPENDIX B RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Surname TEIXEIRA ALLEN DUROCHER JONGDONG WHITE THOMPSON VERSPEETEN CLARKE RIPCO NORSKI CHOE LI GAUTHIER HILL LOMBARDI HALJASTE OZKAN ARMSTRONG BRANTON FERGUSON LATTER GARRISON TRUBECKI MOYER ZAJAC ROUETTE HUSAIN MACLEAN CAPIZZO MCLEISH POULIN MILES HARTFORD REIMER ZAMPARO NANTON ODISHO DI PASSA PELLETIER BOIS NUNES STEFFLER KARPIK HODGINS SMITH TAKEDA HIGO BEREZOWSKI DUTHIE DICKIE OAKES PATTERSON BAYES HURLEY MANSON JOHNSTON MARCHEN DUNLOP BEAUSOLEIL SAVILLE LOPES GIBILLINI BELANGER WATERS BRYL DHOUM D'SILVA WALLACE MCCULLOUGH BRESSAN KERR Given Name MARIO JORGE MICHAEL DAVID DAVID LEONARD LHAWANG TOPGYAL WILLIAM MARLAND FINLAY BRADLEY DENNIS DOUGLAS MARK PRZEMYSLAW ROBERT BOYD LEO SHANE LORENZO MARK HARIVALD NEDIM RICHARD DAVID SHANE SCOTT CAVANAGH JORDAN CHRISTOPHER HEIDI ELSIE ROBERT MATTHEW IGNATIUS DAVID JOSEPH MICHEL MOHAMMED SALEEM RODERICK GIUSEPPE DINO PATRICIA LOUISE MARTIN FABIAN JEREMY OLIVER THOMAS JOSEPH THOMAS ARTHUR DANIEL VALENTINO JASON STANLEY ASHUR JULIE CHRISTIAN JOSEPH PAUL ROBERT MARIA RODNEY MORRIS JAMES MARK GREGORY DEAN LARENY ROBERT TODD ELLIOT JOHN ROBERT CRAIG WILLIAM JAMES ROBERT JOHN ARTHUR JASON LESLIE SANDRA BRENT ANDREW MICHAEL JOHN PAUL MARC JASON LESLIE JUDE ALEXANDER RICHARD DANIEL JOSEPH JASON ROY BOGUMIL MUNISH ALLISTER ROBERT BOYD KRISTAL KASHMIR LORENZO ROBERT Position Staff Sergeant Detective Police Constable Detective Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Detective Detective Detective Detective Police Constable Senior Analyst Staff Sergeant Staff Sergeant Detective Detective Sergeant Detective Sergeant Detective Staff Sergeant Detective Sergeant Detective Sergeant Detective Senior Technical Analyst Detective Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Detective Police Constable Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Sergeant Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Police Constable Police Constable Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Detective Sergeant Sergeant Detective Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Police Constable Salary Paid $ 116,786.89 $ 116,785.97 $ 116,760.12 $ 116,758.48 $ 116,734.96 $ 116,720.45 $ 116,710.70 $ 116,708.40 $ 116,686.36 $ 116,678.77 $ 116,646.81 $ 116,615.97 $ 116,590.76 $ 116,577.65 $ 116,576.63 $ 116,566.06 $ 116,554.63 $ 116,551.88 $ 116,547.88 $ 116,547.88 $ 116,547.88 $ 116,547.88 $ 116,544.82 $ 116,543.50 $ 116,541.12 $ 116,541.11 $ 116,521.85 $ 116,467.18 $ 116,466.73 $ 116,457.96 $ 116,454.23 $ 116,438.69 $ 116,432.01 $ 116,408.66 $ 116,403.60 $ 116,389.85 $ 116,361.58 $ 116,360.97 $ 116,355.00 $ 116,353.11 $ 116,344.49 $ 116,342.82 $ 116,341.64 $ 116,335.14 $ 116,273.50 $ 116,256.79 $ 116,230.93 $ 116,226.96 $ 116,214.46 $ 116,194.16 $ 116,190.25 $ 116,159.42 $ 116,126.65 $ 116,125.07 $ 116,123.84 $ 116,110.53 $ 116,070.55 $ 116,055.61 $ 116,050.22 $ 116,049.21 $ 116,024.44 $ 116,014.43 $ 115,992.15 $ 115,983.83 $ 115,972.59 $ 115,957.11 $ 115,938.88 $ 115,914.27 $ 115,901.22 $ 115,883.68 $ 115,869.69 Benefits $732.32 $701.67 $665.53 $701.67 $697.90 $686.42 $678.70 $700.32 $669.84 $678.70 $339.65 $701.67 $710.11 $708.56 $717.06 $675.34 $280.88 $312.74 $422.92 $737.72 $737.72 $312.74 $717.06 $723.68 $717.06 $717.06 $701.93 $717.06 $708.56 $280.88 $701.67 $686.42 $292.08 $666.29 $686.42 $662.93 $662.93 $292.08 $669.95 $701.67 $693.44 $669.95 $684.37 $669.95 $693.44 $717.06 $691.88 $717.06 $717.06 $669.95 $694.52 $708.56 $669.95 $662.93 $717.06 $686.42 $700.32 $717.06 $696.19 $669.95 $701.67 $717.06 $708.56 $701.67 $684.37 $671.99 $686.42 $686.42 $684.34 $717.06 $684.37

APPENDIX B RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Surname DAVIS WHITLA LAMBIE BRITO BURNETT ENTWISTLE VO COLLINS SHAW ESCUDERO WHU ALEKSANDROWICZ SHREERAM BORSBOOM RAMESAR JENKINS MURRAY-BATES WALLACE JOHNSTON BROWNE DALE GIBSON THORNING PAYTON CARGILL HANCOCK LITTLE FOUGERE COOMBS JONES DURY STE-CROIX PISCHEDDA CAMPBELL HIBBELN SYRMBOS HARLOCK HENKEL CAKEBREAD CAMPBELL MCNEIL KHURSHID SAMM MUSCLOW TRENOUTH D'SOUZA KARGES DHATT WHITE BUCKLEY ADAM CIESLIK MAGEE TOHM MISTEROWICZ CASTELLUCCI SPELMAN DRURY DUGAN SHIELDS WINCHESTER VELAUTHAM BUSTOS SMALL KOLAR HRYHORSKY ZYCH THOMAS BURGESS TALBOT MAHONEY GOODWIN Given Name JASON BRIAN RONALD DARRYL BRADLEY SERGIO AGOSTINHO ANSON RICHARD DAVID THAO BA ROBERT SCOTT RICHARD JAMES TSUI-CHEE LUKASZ AMAR MARCELINUS HENDRIKUS VICTOR ALLEN KERRY-ANNE JOHN DAVID CHARLES JIMMY DONALD NATHAN EDWARD SHIRLEY HOWARD LEWIS PAUL SCOTT KIMBERLY DAVID CORY TRENTON ALBERT GEORGE COREY LEE BENJAMIN MICHAEL BRADLEY MARK STEPHEN BRYAN EDWARD PHILIP JOSEPH TOM ANASTASIOS DAVID HEINZ ALAN WILLIAM DEBORAH ANNE RONALD SHEIKH AHMAD SAMUEL JUNIOR CLAUDE BRADLEY ROBERT TYRON IAN BRADLEY JOSEPH RUBINDER MARILYN EDNA DONALD BARBARA ANNE SUSAN HELENA BRYAN GERALD DARIK GORDON RICHARD JOHN ANTHONY BRENDAN JAMES PAUL ERIC GAIL PATRICIA JOHN KARTHIGESAN HARRY SANTIAGO CHRISTOPHER DOUGLAS ANDREW MICHAEL THOMAS STEFAN ROBERT TROY DARRYL THOMAS JULIE RALPH Position Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Detective Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Project Leader Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Sergeant Senior Operations Supervisor Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Sergeant Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Staff Sergeant Sergeant Detective Detective Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Detective Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Detective Police Constable Sergeant Detective Detective Senior Operations Supervisor Detective Police Constable Sergeant Sergeant Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Sergeant Detective Sergeant Detective Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Sergeant Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Sergeant Police Constable Police Constable Sergeant Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Detective Sergeant Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Salary Paid $ 115,852.64 $ 115,838.86 $ 115,837.43 $ 115,836.73 $ 115,829.64 $ 115,800.83 $ 115,785.88 $ 115,768.52 $ 115,765.00 $ 115,763.35 $ 115,759.42 $ 115,753.11 $ 115,745.76 $ 115,728.06 $ 115,700.26 $ 115,690.57 $ 115,674.94 $ 115,671.11 $ 115,649.40 $ 115,639.98 $ 115,637.23 $ 115,636.50 $ 115,633.96 $ 115,612.61 $ 115,609.23 $ 115,600.29 $ 115,592.49 $ 115,592.04 $ 115,590.61 $ 115,558.41 $ 115,557.94 $ 115,556.26 $ 115,555.12 $ 115,524.75 $ 115,492.12 $ 115,482.31 $ 115,467.42 $ 115,448.93 $ 115,357.29 $ 115,335.68 $ 115,322.39 $ 115,317.47 $ 115,300.43 $ 115,295.53 $ 115,275.64 $ 115,269.15 $ 115,246.06 $ 115,241.04 $ 115,237.70 $ 115,237.08 $ 115,219.25 $ 115,208.88 $ 115,196.82 $ 115,183.29 $ 115,178.65 $ 115,177.19 $ 115,172.12 $ 115,164.32 $ 115,145.85 $ 115,140.79 $ 115,124.49 $ 115,117.59 $ 115,109.97 $ 115,105.60 $ 115,089.38 $ 115,080.45 $ 115,051.74 $ 115,009.92 $ 115,007.91 $ 115,003.07 $ 115,002.94 Benefits $678.09 $717.06 $662.93 $667.20 $665.53 $717.06 $686.42 $717.06 $678.70 $303.15 $662.93 $686.42 $686.42 $717.06 $292.08 $713.15 $686.42 $708.56 $717.06 $717.06 $678.70 $732.32 $717.06 $708.56 $717.06 $700.32 $684.59 $700.32 $701.67 $701.93 $681.66 $686.42 $701.67 $292.08 $682.76 $717.06 $717.06 $708.56 $713.15 $717.06 $668.42 $708.56 $715.78 $662.93 $662.93 $669.95 $701.67 $717.06 $717.06 $708.56 $700.32 $680.58 $684.37 $685.16 $715.78 $696.33 $575.40 $717.06 $681.27 $684.37 $708.56 $662.93 $662.93 $700.32 $686.42 $684.37 $717.06 $717.06 $661.34 $700.32 $649.01

APPENDIX B RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Surname THOMPSON EVEREST NORTON MCCULLOCH TJERKSTRA STIBBE REID HEALY LONG LIPSEY CARTER SIEVERS WOJDYLO CORREIA MUSAH LOUHIKARI ARMSTRONG MANCUSO MCLEOD BERG ALTOBELLO MORELL NEWTON GRONDIN STEIN ALEXANDER PAK DOREY EUTENEIER COXON LEE CLEMENS PERINO MAILER MILDENBERGER MEDEIROS KANG SPENCER CHANT MURPHY MCCONKEY AKESON JOHNSON SEABAN DAMANI LINQUIST GILL GIBSON COLLYMORE PHAIR CHEUNG LOGAN GRACE BOYER BOULET KARJALAINEN FERGUSON JOHNSTONE O'DRISCOLL SCOTT BOSSERT BENALLICK JAMISON SERRANO CLARK CLARKE ALEXA WRIGHT THOMPSON SEN LEE Given Name PAUL ANTHONY JOHN ALFRED DAVID JOHN MICHAEL ROELOF ROBERT LEE JONATHAN DOUGLAS MICHAEL DAVID JOHN MICHAEL WILLIAM NORMAN MARVA MARIE JOHN HENRYK JEFFERY ISHMAIL RENATA FREDERICK SHANE ANITA MARIA MATTHEW ALEXANDER MICHAEL ANDREW DOMENIC JOESPH ADAM DEEDEE SCOTT WILLIAM WARREN MARK CHARLES BOLTON ANDREW JIN-HO JOSEPH THOMAS SIMON QUINCEY SHAWNA MICHELLE DEREK RICHARD JEFFREY KENNETH VINCENT STEVEN KAINE JOHANN ANDY GURJOT SINGH LAURA ELIZABETH JAMES ELLIOT JOHN RONALD FRANK AARON JOSEPH JENNIFER ANNE MICHAEL GEORGE ZAHIR DARRYL ANDREW AMANPREET SINGH ANDREW NEIL BRIAN MATTHEW MARK GORDON CHING TIN BEVERLEY TIMOTHY DENIS SCOTT TREVOR VINCENT STEPHEN ADRIANNE DENNIS GORDON DENNIS MARK DANIEL JAMES WILLIAM MATTHEW ANTONIO DAVID JAMES STACYANN MARIA BRENDAN JAMES LESTER ELSIE TINA TAPAN KUMAR RANDALL JAMES Position Police Constable Sergeant Detective Detective Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Detective Police Constable Police Constable Project Leader Sergeant Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Detective Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Detective Plainclothes Police Constable Project Leader Police Constable Staff Sergeant Police Constable Sergeant Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Staff Sergeant Police Constable Project Leader Detective Police Constable Sergeant Police Constable Sergeant Sergeant Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Staff Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Police Constable Detective Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Police Constable Detective Supervisor Project Leader Sergeant Salary Paid $ 114,991.94 $ 114,930.19 $ 114,893.03 $ 114,888.95 $ 114,879.51 $ 114,874.77 $ 114,856.67 $ 114,852.22 $ 114,835.25 $ 114,803.62 $ 114,800.68 $ 114,798.74 $ 114,788.62 $ 114,781.83 $ 114,777.85 $ 114,663.33 $ 114,660.87 $ 114,657.77 $ 114,647.41 $ 114,643.24 $ 114,642.05 $ 114,639.21 $ 114,627.72 $ 114,611.60 $ 114,607.17 $ 114,583.30 $ 114,577.68 $ 114,562.18 $ 114,557.96 $ 114,553.37 $ 114,544.92 $ 114,522.47 $ 114,484.05 $ 114,475.73 $ 114,463.58 $ 114,453.84 $ 114,441.09 $ 114,434.36 $ 114,419.20 $ 114,369.44 $ 114,356.68 $ 114,354.24 $ 114,345.22 $ 114,344.89 $ 114,311.73 $ 114,310.19 $ 114,299.30 $ 114,291.11 $ 114,249.18 $ 114,238.73 $ 114,222.38 $ 114,198.69 $ 114,197.39 $ 114,187.47 $ 114,178.70 $ 114,172.34 $ 114,170.86 $ 114,142.39 $ 114,120.07 $ 114,120.01 $ 114,112.18 $ 114,112.11 $ 114,106.11 $ 114,037.28 $ 114,030.17 $ 114,022.41 $ 114,015.39 $ 113,999.18 $ 113,991.20 $ 113,983.53 $ 113,964.35 Benefits $676.45 $717.06 $701.67 $708.56 $717.06 $679.10 $605.69 $717.06 $684.37 $669.95 $303.15 $710.11 $717.06 $678.70 $701.67 $717.06 $686.42 $700.32 $681.80 $701.67 $678.70 $679.56 $717.06 $686.42 $701.67 $717.06 $686.42 $303.15 $658.58 $730.70 $676.70 $386.06 $662.06 $686.42 $686.42 $686.42 $662.93 $678.14 $686.42 $717.06 $684.37 $686.42 $730.70 $662.93 $303.15 $701.67 $669.95 $713.54 $662.93 $708.56 $701.67 $717.06 $681.67 $700.32 $717.06 $696.19 $717.06 $730.70 $700.32 $717.06 $676.70 $708.56 $244.97 $678.70 $686.42 $701.67 $675.34 $717.06 $303.15 $303.15 $701.67

APPENDIX B RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Surname HOLDER BROWN CLARK BRYAN NASNER MARSHALL HREPIC INGLEY ASKIN TEIXEIRA FEAGAN LENFESTY PETERS HENDERSON CORDEIRO MACNEIL STEWART KARRAS ILSON VANDALL BLAIR LEAL NIEZEN LENTSCH SOVA GOULAH FRY RABBITO SPRATT MAHARAJ NACCARATO BAINARD KLODT CAISSIE STEPANENKO DUNCAN SUONGAS SAGER FOTOPOULOS THERIAULT KIS VALERIO BUTLER JONES PENTON MACINNIS LOCKE LOCKEN ANGUS CAMPANILE KAVANAGH JAMES DAFOE PETERSEN CLARK ANTOINE VILLEMAIRE PLUNKETT UHRICH VERWEY YOUNGER TURNBULL RIBEIRO MORGAN ROBERTS WATTS OLIVER ALEXANDER KNIGHT KLAAS COURT Given Name PAUL JACQUELINE DANA JOHN KEITH XAVIER STEFAN KIRWIN MARIO PAUL LEO PAUL ALEXANDER ANDREW PEREIRA GREGORY DAVID SEAN CORNELIUS GEOFFREY PAUL ELIZABETT MARIA STEVEN JAMES KERRY MARIE STELLA STAUROULA DANIEL JAMES MARTIN PHILIP JEFFREY KELVIN JASON DAVID MARK PAUL TONY DANIEL ANTHONY LEO RONALD CORRADO ALAN ZALINA JOSE PAUL CRAIG SHAWN EDWARD PAUL ELENA PHILLIP ZVI CHRIS LAWRENCE GEORGE ANGELA ANDREW JOHN PHILIP MICHAEL LEANNE SHANE STEPHEN ROBERT FRANCIS DONOVAN ALAN JOHN DOUGLAS EMANUELE TIMOTHY BRIAN STEVEN DALE KRISTAN MATHEW RUSSELL KEVIN FRANCIS DOUGLAS STEPHEN PATRICK JOHN ALLAN JOSEPH ALBERT CHAD ANDREW RONALD JAMES REUBEN FRANCIS DANIEL PHILIP DAVID GREGORY MILES MATTHEW TYLER LYNNE MARIE JULIE PETER ANDREW JAMES Position Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Sergeant Police Constable Police Constable Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Detective Detective Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Supervisor Project Leader Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Sergeant Sergeant Sergeant Sergeant Detective Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Sergeant Detective Sergeant Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Sergeant Police Constable Detective Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Detective Plainclothes Police Constable Systems Integration Specialist Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Salary Paid $ 113,961.91 $ 113,960.32 $ 113,949.82 $ 113,948.62 $ 113,943.09 $ 113,938.52 $ 113,936.85 $ 113,935.13 $ 113,934.56 $ 113,917.34 $ 113,913.01 $ 113,890.80 $ 113,889.75 $ 113,866.62 $ 113,847.79 $ 113,840.21 $ 113,839.25 $ 113,834.69 $ 113,831.05 $ 113,775.87 $ 113,769.24 $ 113,744.96 $ 113,738.23 $ 113,733.15 $ 113,720.35 $ 113,716.35 $ 113,715.09 $ 113,707.34 $ 113,699.85 $ 113,672.45 $ 113,663.06 $ 113,659.87 $ 113,656.19 $ 113,640.31 $ 113,638.79 $ 113,630.36 $ 113,620.72 $ 113,618.30 $ 113,609.23 $ 113,602.82 $ 113,597.69 $ 113,568.28 $ 113,566.46 $ 113,557.30 $ 113,556.14 $ 113,554.99 $ 113,523.33 $ 113,519.66 $ 113,516.51 $ 113,502.52 $ 113,484.75 $ 113,483.31 $ 113,475.48 $ 113,468.23 $ 113,444.24 $ 113,424.25 $ 113,411.67 $ 113,411.34 $ 113,380.28 $ 113,366.16 $ 113,356.60 $ 113,351.45 $ 113,346.03 $ 113,296.03 $ 113,282.01 $ 113,261.25 $ 113,234.11 $ 113,233.16 $ 113,227.00 $ 113,211.88 $ 113,198.00 Benefits $693.44 $693.44 $686.42 $717.06 $700.32 $708.56 $708.56 $675.65 $686.42 $686.42 $686.42 $730.70 $669.95 $669.95 $645.60 $686.42 $678.70 $701.67 $678.70 $717.06 $669.95 $683.98 $717.06 $701.67 $717.06 $686.42 $717.06 $686.42 $622.62 $303.15 $715.73 $717.06 $693.44 $717.06 $679.01 $686.42 $717.06 $713.86 $713.86 $717.06 $717.06 $717.06 $678.70 $715.78 $701.67 $708.56 $654.45 $717.06 $674.22 $717.06 $717.06 $669.95 $717.06 $686.42 $717.06 $682.76 $684.37 $686.42 $717.06 $717.06 $686.42 $303.15 $672.60 $678.70 $717.06 $701.67 $686.42 $686.16 $700.32 $686.42 $662.93

APPENDIX B RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Surname IANCU HOWELL WILLIAMS BUTT HAGERMAN MURRAY TSO CLARK CLEMENTS DANIELS SOVA HICKS FORDE ALDERDICE JAMES COULTHARD PATHAK GOWANLOCK BISSONNETTE WHITE GRANATA LEVERT DOBBS HESSE WALKER STEWART KENNEDY CHAN FREEMAN OH LORTIE ZIVCIC MACCHEYNE SANTIZO ORANTES BENNOCH MASLOWSKI DRAPACK CALLANAN KOTAS MARTIN COFFIN WEST CORREA VINCENT WINDMOLLER MILLAR WANNAMAKER MCCLOREY GAUDET TANOUYE NEAL THERRIEN O'RIORDAN HOOVER WEHBY KARR CRUZ PARK HAWCO LOVE WHELER SPRIGGS TAIT CRICHTON FISHER MORRISON BHATHAL BACHLY REID NAIR TILLSLEY Given Name VLADIM ADRIAN WAYNE VINCENT MICHAEL JAMES CELESTE BARBARA DAVID ALICIA MARIE WING-IP STEVEN HOWARD JEFFERY CLARENCE DEBORAH STEPHEN RYAN JEFFERY PAUL GARY JASON MILES SAMIP CAROL LYNN PAUL MARCEL CATHERINE MARLENE SALVATORE FRANCESCO BRYCE STERLING CHRISTIAN DANIEL GEOFFREY JOHN COLIN ALEXANDER GEOFFREY CHUN KWONG JEFFREY BRYANT DAVID JIN MARC LEONEL JOHN RICHARD DOUGLAS NELSON ALFREDO CHRISTOPHER JOHN BRIAN WERNER RYAN JOSEPH BRIAN MICHAEL ARTUR JACEK CAROLINE PHILIP JACK DAVID RODRIGUEZ MATTHEW EDWARD THEODORE JOHN JASON ANDREW JEFFREY MICHAEL SEAN MICHAEL DERRICK JASON THOMAS PETER ALLAN WAYNE JAMES BRADLEY PETER MICHAEL JOCELYN ANTONIO RAMON SUNG JIN BERNARD THOMAS ALLEN ROBERT KATHERINE ANNE BRETT HAROLD SCOTT JOHN NORMAN BRADLEY MICHELLE YVETTE HARJEET SINGH CHRISTOPHER DAVID KYLE THOMAS SAJEEV JOHN Position Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Sergeant Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Detective Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Sergeant Sergeant Detective Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Plainclothes Police Constable Administrator Document Services Sergeant Sergeant Sergeant Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Sergeant Detective Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Detective Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Sergeant Sergeant Detective Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Sergeant Detective Project Leader Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Police Constable Sergeant Detective Detective Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Sergeant Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Salary Paid $ 113,194.60 $ 113,187.49 $ 113,183.78 $ 113,170.47 $ 113,158.76 $ 113,139.65 $ 113,139.27 $ 113,136.82 $ 113,114.05 $ 113,107.29 $ 113,085.38 $ 113,069.47 $ 113,038.63 $ 113,023.01 $ 113,020.08 $ 113,009.07 $ 113,006.99 $ 112,996.62 $ 112,984.80 $ 112,983.52 $ 112,964.26 $ 112,941.13 $ 112,939.69 $ 112,938.34 $ 112,923.61 $ 112,909.62 $ 112,907.97 $ 112,906.25 $ 112,900.74 $ 112,858.50 $ 112,852.64 $ 112,843.00 $ 112,831.71 $ 112,827.88 $ 112,816.35 $ 112,777.76 $ 112,764.38 $ 112,757.34 $ 112,744.26 $ 112,730.34 $ 112,710.14 $ 112,707.13 $ 112,659.18 $ 112,655.16 $ 112,654.41 $ 112,652.05 $ 112,647.73 $ 112,644.85 $ 112,644.41 $ 112,643.76 $ 112,641.52 $ 112,641.27 $ 112,626.92 $ 112,622.16 $ 112,620.21 $ 112,612.24 $ 112,608.71 $ 112,606.03 $ 112,602.01 $ 112,583.34 $ 112,581.72 $ 112,575.97 $ 112,543.61 $ 112,541.03 $ 112,532.37 $ 112,518.26 $ 112,501.22 $ 112,499.14 $ 112,497.15 $ 112,495.51 $ 112,490.50 Benefits $662.93 $686.42 $701.67 $683.99 $694.22 $686.42 $710.11 $717.06 $684.37 $678.70 $726.24 $717.06 $701.67 $701.93 $700.32 $701.67 $673.21 $240.65 $694.79 $714.50 $717.06 $669.95 $678.70 $717.06 $717.06 $701.67 $717.06 $693.44 $682.76 $678.70 $686.00 $662.93 $725.35 $681.80 $667.87 $701.67 $695.77 $701.67 $701.67 $700.32 $684.37 $717.06 $701.67 $303.15 $717.06 $678.70 $686.42 $693.61 $710.11 $680.56 $292.08 $684.37 $697.68 $292.08 $701.67 $717.06 $675.04 $686.42 $714.50 $701.67 $677.27 $686.68 $685.20 $717.06 $715.78 $700.32 $662.93 $701.67 $686.42 $686.42 $717.06

APPENDIX B RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Surname KERNOHAN MARTIN HOUSTON SCHETTINI DUNCAN LOU WILLIAMS ROBINSON MA ROSS COWL SPURLING LALLA WOODS SHYMCHONAK GENOVY WALLACE MOREIRA QUIJADA-MANCIA RAMOS LUCHETTA PRICE MORAES SCOTT SO RADFORD MCDONALD MACDUFF AWAD POP TUCKER HOLLYWOOD HUTCHEON HIND HOLMES DAWSON RICHARDSON MARTSENYUK POOLE GIESCHE KERR WINTER MCGHEE TURZA CERESOLI O'BRIEN DUFFY TUPLING SAMSON VIGNA BENTLEY MOREAU GOODING SMITH WILSON BOPARA BYERS MORRIS HARTFORD MURRAY SIMS MCILWAIN SINCLAIR KOHL ROMITO MOED GRAY BORTOLUSS DARNLEY MURPHY BAHULA Given Name SUZANNE PAUL GEORGE JEANETTE MARIE ANTHONY MELISSA JOY BING YU DEIRDRE ELIZABETH ANDREW CHARLES YU PAU (SYDNEY) WILLIAM LAWRENCE PETER LESTER ROYSON GARY ANDREI SHAUN PETER JOHN JUAN CARLOS LERMY MARK TIMOTHY JOHN TIMOTHY PRESTON WAYNE CHRISTOPHER STUART BARRY SPENCER MATTHEW JEFFERY JOHN ASHRAF SAMIR IAN BRIAN DOUGLAS NEIL WILLIAM D'ARCY LIAM JOHN KEITH ANDREW VADYM CANDICE JENNIFER CHAD ALLEN SAMUEL WILLIAM JOHN MICHAEL JANICE MAURIZIO SEAN MARJORIE ARLEEN ANN-MARIE JEREMY CALVIN RITA ELSA CHRISTOPHER JOHN PAUL ROBERT JOANNE MICHELE ROHAN ALEXANDER CHRISTOPHER DAVID GURWINDER DEREK JONATHAN PETER NEIL DEBORAH WILLIAM ANDREW MICHAEL STEVEN GEORGE IAN THOMAS BARBARA LOUISE MARINO JEREMY CLARK ROBERT JO-ANNE ELLEN STEVEN WILLIAM LIAM JAMES SIMON Position Detective Plainclothes Police Constable Compensation and Benefits Analyst Detective Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Board Administrator Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Sergeant Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Police Constable Detective Sergeant Detective Sergeant Assistant Manager of Accounting Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Detective Sergeant Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Senior Technical Analyst Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Police Constable Sergeant Sergeant Sergeant Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Sergeant Sergeant Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Sergeant Detective Plainclothes Police Constable Assistant Manager of Records Management Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Senior Administrator Civilian Recruitment Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Sergeant Training Constable Detective Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Police Constable Police Constable Sergeant Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Police Constable Salary Paid $ 112,486.27 $ 112,478.66 $ 112,460.69 $ 112,458.84 $ 112,450.61 $ 112,448.30 $ 112,427.15 $ 112,421.15 $ 112,409.66 $ 112,405.43 $ 112,399.36 $ 112,387.98 $ 112,384.63 $ 112,372.15 $ 112,367.51 $ 112,357.32 $ 112,356.88 $ 112,355.86 $ 112,348.59 $ 112,346.91 $ 112,341.40 $ 112,339.52 $ 112,301.37 $ 112,288.34 $ 112,285.54 $ 112,276.53 $ 112,264.95 $ 112,257.45 $ 112,251.31 $ 112,245.44 $ 112,213.86 $ 112,206.08 $ 112,203.99 $ 112,193.69 $ 112,189.51 $ 112,177.11 $ 112,172.51 $ 112,161.79 $ 112,154.36 $ 112,123.73 $ 112,116.80 $ 112,098.96 $ 112,095.02 $ 112,090.67 $ 112,078.44 $ 112,077.65 $ 112,075.27 $ 112,049.35 $ 112,044.89 $ 112,044.69 $ 112,039.26 $ 112,027.49 $ 112,021.88 $ 112,014.90 $ 112,010.03 $ 112,004.57 $ 112,004.21 $ 111,995.45 $ 111,993.22 $ 111,991.35 $ 111,985.63 $ 111,978.51 $ 111,976.19 $ 111,960.36 $ 111,949.92 $ 111,949.00 $ 111,942.58 $ 111,932.46 $ 111,915.32 $ 111,888.28 $ 111,886.02 Benefits $717.06 $686.42 $825.49 $717.06 $686.42 $686.42 $280.88 $675.34 $678.70 $684.37 $717.06 $292.08 $686.42 $695.77 $669.95 $717.06 $701.67 $717.06 $701.67 $823.35 $646.97 $669.95 $693.44 $678.70 $686.42 $717.06 $701.67 $701.67 $701.67 $686.81 $280.88 $693.44 $717.06 $682.76 $717.06 $717.06 $614.12 $662.93 $662.93 $686.42 $684.37 $717.06 $708.56 $717.06 $686.42 $717.06 $708.56 $708.56 $674.13 $823.35 $686.42 $686.42 $823.35 $669.95 $661.94 $708.56 $701.67 $679.18 $717.06 $700.32 $669.95 $717.06 $693.44 $708.56 $669.95 $669.95 $292.08 $669.95 $686.42 $700.36 $642.32

APPENDIX B RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Surname CAMACHO O'DOHERTY CLAUDIO BLOWER SEARLES CIOFFI GREGORY LEE VALENTINI CHUNG FRASER CENSONI EMIGH HUNT CANNING O'KANE MCCORMACK STRAVER CAMPBELL LOURENCO SHARMA SIDHU GRANBERG BOYKO HILDEBRAND BARDGETT KERR PERSICHETTI HORNBY HEWSON DAOUST OUELLETTE BORG SABADICS BANYAEM ZUBAIR KEEFER BOKALO DOUGLAS KLINE LAWSON MCCUTCHEON MIRANDA MOREHOUSE STEVENSON MCCABE COYNE SCRIVEN WELLER KRAWCZYK WYNNE HEUGHAN JONES LIPKUS MOXAM SOMERS HUGHES HOELLER CARTER LAWSON DIVIESTI LATINCIC HAYES MOI WHITE MEECH KOSTIUK STOICA KNOBLAUCH FERNANDES AUCLAIR Given Name JOSE FRANK DONALD STUART WILLIAM TREVOR MICHAEL ANTHONY SANDRA JAMES STANTON ENZO-LORETO PHILIP SPENCER ROBERT LORENZINO MICHAEL DAVID CHRISTOPHER DAVID MARK GERAID DAVID JAMES LAWRENCE MARCIA ADAM COLIN ATUL SARBJEET KAUR DINO JEREMY JEFFREY SHAUN CHRISTOPHER JAMES FRANCIS KYLE DONATO GREGORY ALLEN KENT MICHAEL-LEE DENIS-PAUL DAVID MARK SUSANNE JOSEPHENE KIMBERLY JOAN SANTI MOHAMMAD JASON YVON NIKOLAJ JEFFREY STEPHEN ROBERT ANTHONY DOUGLAS EDUARDO CANDIDO RITA SHANE ANASTASIA PAULINE PATRICK KEVIN PATRICK RICHARD ANTHONY PAUL THOMAS TRAVERS DONALD THOMAS ANDREW BRADLEY DARREN KENNETH CRAIG ALLAN TRUDY CHRISTOPHER ALEXANDER DALE NICHOLAS WILLIAM TONY DANIEL ROY EDWARD NATALIE BOBO PAUL RAYMOND JOHN MICHAEL TIBERIU NICULII KEITH PERCY MICHAEL FREITAS JANE MARILYN Position Sergeant Sergeant Police Constable Sergeant Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Detective Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Training Constable Detective Detective Sergeant Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Detective Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Detective Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Police Constable Sergeant Detective Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Sergeant Detective Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Police Constable Sergeant Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Sergeant Sergeant Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Sergeant Salary Paid $ 111,874.51 $ 111,863.89 $ 111,860.63 $ 111,849.20 $ 111,827.87 $ 111,822.77 $ 111,820.52 $ 111,802.33 $ 111,794.00 $ 111,784.74 $ 111,784.33 $ 111,773.72 $ 111,773.61 $ 111,770.31 $ 111,754.98 $ 111,750.92 $ 111,737.17 $ 111,721.73 $ 111,719.61 $ 111,717.86 $ 111,712.07 $ 111,708.76 $ 111,704.19 $ 111,691.36 $ 111,669.80 $ 111,668.43 $ 111,657.58 $ 111,636.66 $ 111,623.59 $ 111,609.49 $ 111,607.92 $ 111,599.80 $ 111,590.98 $ 111,585.50 $ 111,571.79 $ 111,561.76 $ 111,559.90 $ 111,555.09 $ 111,513.66 $ 111,491.70 $ 111,487.33 $ 111,483.85 $ 111,470.41 $ 111,465.91 $ 111,451.82 $ 111,449.02 $ 111,433.32 $ 111,433.21 $ 111,399.00 $ 111,366.20 $ 111,353.51 $ 111,339.38 $ 111,337.13 $ 111,335.10 $ 111,334.46 $ 111,326.26 $ 111,314.01 $ 111,311.80 $ 111,296.09 $ 111,281.56 $ 111,271.42 $ 111,244.42 $ 111,238.04 $ 111,229.49 $ 111,222.51 $ 111,204.51 $ 111,197.58 $ 111,175.91 $ 111,175.69 $ 111,167.82 $ 111,164.33 Benefits $717.06 $292.08 $675.34 $701.67 $393.76 $678.70 $715.78 $681.80 $669.95 $292.08 $686.42 $662.93 $717.06 $678.70 $698.61 $701.67 $717.06 $717.06 $702.66 $679.10 $662.93 $684.59 $708.56 $701.67 $686.42 $684.37 $717.06 $680.93 $676.70 $717.06 $686.42 $686.42 $686.68 $684.37 $663.97 $678.14 $686.42 $700.32 $717.06 $662.93 $708.56 $292.08 $686.42 $433.74 $708.56 $673.21 $678.70 $717.06 $693.44 $276.69 $717.06 $700.32 $637.36 $686.42 $701.67 $701.67 $377.92 $678.70 $717.06 $662.93 $717.06 $662.06 $700.32 $669.95 $717.06 $292.08 $681.27 $658.58 $676.70 $662.93 $480.96

APPENDIX B RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Surname MACKRELL KORAC KLEIN-HORSMAN YARMOLUK HOLLAND SANDFORD BRESSE CHUNG HEDGEMAN MCBRIDE MACKINNON MOYER JOSEPH GREEN BROADFOOT REZVANI COSTELLO SLOAN ESKEN BEAULAC LEARY D'SOUZA WATKINS SAPSFORD PHILLIPS COWAN REED-PYEFINCH DONISON DENNIS COPAT DUCKWORTH PHILIPSON DUBE PARSRAM HOLLINGSHEAD BISHOP THOMPSON SCHOCH MACDONELL GIBB SKINNER LOUCKS PALERMO MACDONALD BRYAN KLIMTSCHUCK JUDD DE ZILVA KUZNETSOV MCKAY GODDARD TROTMAN MOSTOWSKI ROONEY JANES GEORGOPOULOS ROSS MCGARRY BISHOP ROSS URBANIAK DISALVO HEUGHAN DHINGRA POLAK MONAGHAN PAUL BRADBURY LANDRY BABINEAU FERRIS Given Name JAMES MURRAY PAUL LOUIS BRIAN DAVID GEORGE MARK LEWIS ROBERT JEAN RYAN ANTHONY CORY MICHAEL RAYMOND DOUGLAS RICHARD JAMES JEFFREY TREVOR JOHN JOHN ALEXANDER SEYED ALI PATRICK WILLIAM CHRISTOPHER STUART INDREK SACHA LUCY DEREK WILLIAM RYAN ASHLEY KERRY IAN DOUGLAS ADAM MARSHALL JAMES JENNIFER CHRISTINE KIM AARON LUIGI SCOTT GRAEME DAVID RAMESH BRIAN RICHARD WARREN ALLAN SCOTT MICHAEL ALLISTER RICHARD AUGUSTIN SUSAN LOUIS KELLY SIMONE CORINA MICHELLE CARMINE SCOTT JOHN CHARLOTTE ANN JOSEPH CHRISTIAN RICHARD ANDREW MICHAEL BRIAN SERGIY ANATOLYOVICH CARYN GLENN PATRICK KENNETH MAREK NIGEL PATRICK GARY AMBROSE KEVIN KEITH WILLIAM MICHAEL LEONA CAMERON STEPHEN THOMAS SHARON DEBORAH RAJEEV BRANDON VICTOR THERESA MOHIT SCOTT GORDON JOEL CHRISTIAN JARED MICHAEL MANIE THERESE Position Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Police Constable Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Police Constable Detective Sergeant Police Constable Police Constable Sergeant Detective Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Detective Police Constable Police Constable Sergeant Police Constable Police Constable Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Sergeant Sergeant Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Sergeant Sergeant Detective Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Sergeant Police Constable Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Sergeant Police Constable Sergeant Sergeant Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Salary Paid $ 111,162.70 $ 111,158.70 $ 111,157.19 $ 111,155.91 $ 111,155.87 $ 111,142.83 $ 111,137.22 $ 111,134.37 $ 111,117.87 $ 111,112.42 $ 111,107.93 $ 111,104.79 $ 111,089.57 $ 111,073.83 $ 111,071.46 $ 111,059.79 $ 111,056.45 $ 111,049.38 $ 111,035.74 $ 111,034.87 $ 111,030.79 $ 111,026.63 $ 111,023.11 $ 111,017.25 $ 110,990.87 $ 110,973.53 $ 110,962.27 $ 110,942.00 $ 110,930.09 $ 110,906.40 $ 110,901.27 $ 110,892.81 $ 110,882.81 $ 110,882.75 $ 110,880.09 $ 110,866.35 $ 110,866.25 $ 110,861.71 $ 110,859.76 $ 110,840.95 $ 110,840.67 $ 110,837.57 $ 110,836.67 $ 110,823.13 $ 110,822.28 $ 110,743.91 $ 110,742.59 $ 110,731.77 $ 110,729.87 $ 110,714.52 $ 110,712.74 $ 110,701.96 $ 110,695.38 $ 110,694.79 $ 110,692.56 $ 110,656.03 $ 110,655.96 $ 110,645.52 $ 110,639.84 $ 110,629.24 $ 110,613.97 $ 110,609.34 $ 110,598.17 $ 110,586.25 $ 110,582.89 $ 110,560.21 $ 110,553.53 $ 110,535.99 $ 110,534.44 $ 110,534.12 $ 110,531.28 Benefits $661.19 $686.42 $662.93 $708.56 $686.42 $717.06 $526.21 $678.95 $676.05 $685.20 $686.42 $717.06 $669.95 $717.06 $715.78 $662.93 $662.93 $701.67 $717.06 $673.82 $672.75 $250.62 $717.06 $669.95 $662.93 $717.06 $682.76 $684.37 $701.67 $700.32 $717.06 $708.56 $717.06 $708.56 $700.32 $686.42 $678.70 $701.67 $717.06 $717.06 $701.67 $686.42 $717.06 $686.42 $684.34 $686.42 $686.42 $686.42 $665.53 $717.06 $669.95 $717.06 $686.42 $682.76 $686.68 $686.42 $694.69 $708.56 $717.06 $662.93 $717.06 $711.97 $684.37 $662.93 $686.42 $717.06 $671.53 $701.67 $686.42 $701.67 $686.42

APPENDIX B RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Surname RICHARDSON MENARD RECTOR ASTOLFO LIMA TAIT DOUGLAS MIRZA FERRIS ARMSTRONG HEADLEY BARCLAY KALDIS WHITE SHAW FALLIS DODDS GANJ KENNEDY BARREIRA MARTIN PETRIE COROGHLY DUNLOP WHITE DAVEY WARRENER MIU GHAZARIAN SINGH JIRI FENTON PHOON SURPHLIS LISKA BOLDUC CARTER MCASKILL MCGRADE ROZARIO CAMERON VENN POWELL KEVEZA BATES SKINNER EVANS HUNTE ROBB JAMES FRASER IMRIE WARNER HUGHSON BRYCE LALL NOVINC SMITH WONG ZIMMERMAN MANHERZ KNILL STOCKFISH CRAIG EVANS WILLIAMS CHELLEW ANTONELLI GRIERSON MINOR CHOURYGUINE Given Name SHEILA ANN JOHN PHILLIP JASON ANTHONY ROBERT RODNEY JAMES KEITH HAMILTON STEPHEN MICHAEL SHAHRUKH KEVIN DAVID LAWRENCE CHRISTINE TAMMY LYNN GEORGE KEVIN DAVID JOHN ROBERT LESLIE GRAHAM ARRAN CHRISTOPHER NELSON JOSEPH JEAN KYLE JOHNATHON KHALID MOHAMMED JAMES MICHAEL BARRY THOMAS ROBERT JOSEPH WAI-SANG HAMAYAK RAMINDARJIT SINGH GEORGE JASON ROBERT NEWTON CHUN DOUGLAS DAVID VICTOR KEVIN VICTOR SCOTT MELINDA JEAN PATRICK CONRAD GEORGE ALAN JOANNE MICHELE DANIEL JAMES RYAN MATHEW TIMOTHY BRIAN RONALD GARY JACQUELINE KAREN PAUL GEORGE RITA ANNE SIMON THOMAS ALLEN RUTH REGINALD GUY ROBERT FRANCIS LALLMAN BRANKO RAYMOND ERNEST WAN-HOI LAWRENCE JOEL NICHOLAS GRAHAM KENNETH JOHN RICHARDSON SCOTT BART CAROL STEPHEN GIANPIERO MICHAEL DOUGLAS ALLAN DMITRY Position Sergeant Detective Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Sergeant Patrol Supervisor Senior Operations Supervisor Police Constable Sergeant Sergeant Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable System Administrator Sergeant Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Sergeant Detective Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Detective Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Detective Sergeant Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Sergeant Detective Detective Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Parking Enforcement Officer Sergeant Project Leader Police Constable Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Sergeant Sergeant Sergeant Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Salary Paid $ 110,527.63 $ 110,510.82 $ 110,505.49 $ 110,501.36 $ 110,472.97 $ 110,463.42 $ 110,457.77 $ 110,455.56 $ 110,452.50 $ 110,448.42 $ 110,426.74 $ 110,425.52 $ 110,415.74 $ 110,415.70 $ 110,410.00 $ 110,398.64 $ 110,388.49 $ 110,371.04 $ 110,358.58 $ 110,358.05 $ 110,350.54 $ 110,344.35 $ 110,337.43 $ 110,318.66 $ 110,316.10 $ 110,314.41 $ 110,299.61 $ 110,299.33 $ 110,298.67 $ 110,294.00 $ 110,290.85 $ 110,289.81 $ 110,279.78 $ 110,261.95 $ 110,258.84 $ 110,255.24 $ 110,244.61 $ 110,244.21 $ 110,239.95 $ 110,237.47 $ 110,222.87 $ 110,213.54 $ 110,212.29 $ 110,205.36 $ 110,205.19 $ 110,190.91 $ 110,190.45 $ 110,178.94 $ 110,173.12 $ 110,171.36 $ 110,171.07 $ 110,168.82 $ 110,158.17 $ 110,156.09 $ 110,148.86 $ 110,148.64 $ 110,127.02 $ 110,121.09 $ 110,103.23 $ 110,085.92 $ 110,083.01 $ 110,079.83 $ 110,077.72 $ 110,051.85 $ 110,049.10 $ 110,042.31 $ 110,030.37 $ 110,009.10 $ 110,007.17 $ 109,995.11 $ 109,993.38 Benefits $292.08 $701.67 $683.30 $400.05 $686.42 $684.37 $686.42 $658.58 $717.06 $616.46 $713.15 $669.95 $717.06 $717.06 $708.56 $699.28 $686.42 $662.93 $676.70 $686.42 $713.86 $701.67 $678.70 $681.54 $715.78 $717.06 $686.42 $717.06 $662.93 $662.93 $686.42 $669.95 $705.86 $717.06 $669.95 $686.42 $717.06 $701.67 $717.06 $686.42 $700.32 $712.59 $717.06 $678.70 $717.06 $717.06 $402.26 $708.56 $686.42 $669.95 $717.06 $701.67 $708.56 $693.44 $717.06 $595.54 $717.06 $303.15 $684.37 $717.06 $686.42 $686.42 $701.67 $717.06 $717.06 $717.06 $717.06 $687.86 $711.97 $708.56 $678.70

APPENDIX B RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Surname SATTZ BONCARDO GOUGH WILSON SAMUELS ST JEAN MACDONALD SKREPNEK BURKHOLDER LECK RANTISI VILLERS SMITH GLEN MANSERRA WADDELL CHAPMAN BEARD BERCHARD OLIVER HAGHSHENAS URKOSKY ADAMSON CLARK MITCHELL MCKAY FOX VANDENBERG KATAFIGIOTIS HENDRICKS DEMIAN MOYNAGH FORDE JOKAKELIAN TUGHAN TREUSCH SHAW NOSWORTHY SILVA SEREMETKOVSKI BURNSIDE FYNES YOUNG CHARUK MARTIN GOUDIE REGAN RIEGERT SYBYDLO HUMENIUK GREWAL PHELPS BURRY OSBORNE POULIMENOS VENDRAMINI MCCORMACK RACETTE HOFFMAN SUTCLIFFE NEVILL HARRISON ELDRIDGE LING POWELL SCHUEDER TAYLOR MACKAY RAMPERSAD TRITES MCGRADE Given Name STEVEN PETER JOHN JEFFREY MICHAEL TIMOTHY ROBERT DUANE MARVIN HECTOR MURDO ERIC HERBERT DAVID ADAM MICHEAL SCOTT CHARLES JOHN GRAY CAROLINE DAVID JAMES MARK GRANT KAREN BENJAMIN JAMES RENNIE PAUL EHSAN BRIAN WILLIAM JAMES GRAHAM NANCY PATRICIA JODI LYNN EDWARD JAMES CAROLYN CONSTANTINE KEITH HIBA JOSEPH ROBERT ROGER ANTHONY RAZMIKE AVEDIKE MICHAEL PATRICK JEFFREY EDWARD WILLIAM JUDY ELOI BRUM KATHLIN SEAN KELLY BRONAGH MARIA DEREK MARK RUDOLF ROBERT RANDALL GAIL CHRISTOPHER ANDREW BOHDAN JUSTYN DAVID DHARMENDRA SINGH JOHN SHAWN CECIL KEITH THOMAS WILLIAM DEMETRE LUIGI INKERI HELENA ALLAN ROGER GREGORY RODNEY DARRIN HERBERT STEPHEN KEITH ISSAC REGINALD JONATHAN CATHY VERONICA MARK ANDREW JAMES SHARI PATRICIA STEVEN CHRISTOPHER KATHRYN Position Sergeant Police Constable Police Constable Detective Sergeant Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Sergeant Sergeant Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Detective Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Detective Police Constable Sergeant Sergeant Communications Operator Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Sergeant Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Parking Enforcement Officer Police Constable Sergeant Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Police Constable Sergeant Police Constable Detective Detective Detective Detective Sergeant Detective Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Detective Detective Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Detective Police Constable Sergeant Detective Sergeant Detective Detective Sergeant Police Constable Sergeant Sergeant Salary Paid $ 109,989.08 $ 109,985.99 $ 109,983.73 $ 109,978.54 $ 109,975.23 $ 109,973.06 $ 109,966.20 $ 109,966.05 $ 109,942.90 $ 109,930.33 $ 109,921.77 $ 109,921.24 $ 109,901.92 $ 109,900.90 $ 109,895.47 $ 109,885.87 $ 109,885.72 $ 109,875.56 $ 109,870.57 $ 109,862.33 $ 109,849.76 $ 109,842.26 $ 109,833.87 $ 109,828.56 $ 109,825.21 $ 109,823.62 $ 109,812.75 $ 109,810.30 $ 109,809.76 $ 109,795.00 $ 109,794.69 $ 109,793.33 $ 109,792.44 $ 109,788.50 $ 109,788.44 $ 109,782.31 $ 109,779.96 $ 109,776.35 $ 109,761.93 $ 109,759.90 $ 109,757.88 $ 109,755.56 $ 109,752.05 $ 109,738.24 $ 109,731.56 $ 109,714.49 $ 109,701.23 $ 109,699.83 $ 109,697.25 $ 109,685.56 $ 109,683.67 $ 109,673.86 $ 109,669.46 $ 109,667.05 $ 109,665.46 $ 109,661.56 $ 109,656.31 $ 109,650.94 $ 109,647.09 $ 109,644.49 $ 109,634.01 $ 109,633.14 $ 109,619.76 $ 109,618.36 $ 109,617.37 $ 109,600.26 $ 109,598.84 $ 109,597.73 $ 109,596.24 $ 109,588.21 $ 109,586.84 Benefits $717.06 $675.19 $237.95 $708.56 $717.06 $669.95 $676.05 $662.93 $717.06 $717.06 $654.23 $675.44 $662.93 $711.97 $662.93 $686.42 $701.67 $686.42 $717.06 $717.06 $658.58 $701.67 $717.06 $634.42 $590.76 $292.08 $717.06 $710.42 $686.42 $717.06 $170.56 $684.37 $701.67 $669.95 $686.42 $705.76 $700.32 $402.26 $662.93 $698.82 $662.93 $701.67 $717.06 $717.06 $669.84 $708.56 $284.51 $658.58 $700.32 $686.42 $685.20 $717.06 $701.67 $678.70 $678.70 $717.06 $717.06 $678.70 $678.49 $717.06 $654.10 $662.93 $717.06 $717.06 $701.67 $717.06 $701.41 $701.67 $669.95 $710.11 $292.08

APPENDIX B RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Surname BRUZZESE ALAGURAS DURRAN MARCHIS MURRAY JITTA BENOIT HOCHRADL-ZORKO BERNOBIC MCINNIS DOMINELLI HO TANNAHILL STEWART WEST PERSAUD SMITH YEANDLE BOYD JOHNSON GOUTHRO OSMANAJ LAPENSEE WHITE GRAHAM VANDENBRINK MAC ADAM NIJJAR TOWNLEY ROZICH ROSS CRAGHILL SUTTON WEST CROWLEY SONDHI NEI MYERS DEMOE WILLIAMSON EDWICKER SORGO LAKEY CORRA ROMAIN VANSPALL NIMMO NICKSON MCGIVERN GINN HAINES DEWSNAP HEARD ALBERGA WORRELL POCZAK RAHIM ROWSOME SOUSA-GUTHRIE REDIGONDA SANSON LANGFORD STAPLETON ADACH MCCARTHY KIM LAZARUS HAITZER WILLIAMS HARRIS Given Name DOMENICO D. VIJEYAKUMAR NED SERENA JANE KAREN PATRICIA ROBERT LYNDON JASON REGIS STEPHANIE KEVIN JESSICA MICHELLE VITTORIO SALVATORE JOSEPH CHOA DARLA TINA MARIE MICHAEL ADAM RAJENDRA JASON SEAN MARK ANDREW DAVID EDWARD CRAIG JOSEPH ARDIT SYLVAIN AURELE DANIEL CAMPBELL LEE MICHAEL HENDRIK OVID RUBEN MICHAEL JASON HARJIT SINGH DARREN SAMANTHA MILDRED MATTHEW DOUGLAS DAVID DANIEL LEE ANN JANINE SANJAY NICHOLAS SHANG-LIN MILTON KEVIN CHARLES ALEXIS GRACE ROY WAYNE DALE JEAN-BERNARD GREGORY PATRICK RICHARD JAMES MICHAEL JAMES MICHAEL GEORGE DAVID DAVID PAUL JAMIE DUNCAN JASON MARK PASQUALE PHILIP LISA KAMAL SEAN RICHARD DAVID JONI RICHARD CHERYL-ANNE CHRISTAIN TREVOR BRADLEY THOMAS EDWARD HIERONIM KRISTOPHER RYAN SIN-JOONG SIN TERRENCE ANTHONY GARY IAN KIMBERLEY ANN Position Sergeant Parking Enforcement Officer Police Constable Police Constable Training Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Police Constable Sergeant Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Detective Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Sergeant Police Constable Detective Sergeant Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Sergeant Sergeant Police Constable Sergeant Sergeant Sergeant Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Sergeant Police Constable Detective Police Constable Detective Sergeant Detective Training Constable Detective Detective Sergeant Sergeant Sergeant Police Constable Sergeant Police Constable Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Detective Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Sergeant Sergeant Detective Police Constable Detective Detective Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Senior Intelligence Analyst Plainclothes Police Constable Salary Paid $ 109,576.55 $ 109,575.04 $ 109,566.18 $ 109,546.76 $ 109,543.32 $ 109,541.82 $ 109,529.67 $ 109,508.60 $ 109,505.86 $ 109,500.78 $ 109,498.96 $ 109,497.72 $ 109,488.64 $ 109,488.00 $ 109,481.38 $ 109,475.14 $ 109,474.14 $ 109,466.37 $ 109,461.02 $ 109,459.22 $ 109,450.77 $ 109,447.66 $ 109,446.17 $ 109,444.86 $ 109,442.13 $ 109,438.25 $ 109,432.34 $ 109,422.74 $ 109,420.78 $ 109,418.11 $ 109,417.40 $ 109,413.24 $ 109,406.86 $ 109,391.30 $ 109,377.58 $ 109,372.20 $ 109,368.61 $ 109,356.67 $ 109,342.93 $ 109,331.90 $ 109,328.25 $ 109,322.95 $ 109,318.98 $ 109,308.51 $ 109,308.38 $ 109,301.93 $ 109,289.82 $ 109,288.45 $ 109,275.30 $ 109,273.20 $ 109,267.15 $ 109,258.84 $ 109,256.73 $ 109,254.50 $ 109,238.05 $ 109,236.01 $ 109,232.86 $ 109,228.93 $ 109,225.14 $ 109,218.54 $ 109,216.23 $ 109,215.94 $ 109,157.88 $ 109,154.94 $ 109,152.49 $ 109,146.39 $ 109,138.21 $ 109,130.60 $ 109,130.55 $ 109,120.44 $ 109,111.61 Benefits $717.06 $595.54 $669.95 $662.93 $370.16 $685.46 $686.42 $708.56 $662.93 $701.67 $662.93 $693.44 $409.50 $717.06 $679.01 $669.95 $669.95 $717.06 $669.95 $708.56 $708.56 $662.93 $686.42 $662.93 $717.06 $717.06 $669.95 $701.67 $701.67 $708.56 $708.56 $678.70 $717.06 $717.06 $686.42 $717.06 $685.81 $701.67 $292.08 $717.06 $275.34 $701.67 $717.06 $710.11 $711.97 $710.11 $662.93 $701.67 $676.46 $717.06 $700.32 $701.67 $686.42 $686.42 $686.42 $708.56 $708.56 $686.42 $701.67 $283.58 $717.06 $717.06 $665.53 $701.67 $717.06 $701.67 $675.44 $679.71 $370.78 $257.75 $261.44

APPENDIX B RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Surname WELSH TATTERSALL ELLIS MCGOVERN TINNEY CARL MATHIEU OZRETIC BATOR WHITLEY WALKER GOLDSMITH STEVENS WALLI SCHAFHAUSER BARTLETT KUMMER BENSON HILBORN KARAGAN HARNISH CONNELL THOMAS GREENAWAY DE CAIRE DAWSON BURNS CHAPMAN NG KEHLER MCKENZIE ALBANESE ROBERTS MACKRELL TRACEY HEAD MITCHELL BARNHARDT LOWE ESDON LIU SISK MEISSNER CASCADDEN SKEETE LANGLOIS BURKE TAYLOR MACIAS BRAKE DUKE FURYK NICKERSON HANSEN WOODS OLSON BLACKLOCK DRAPER OATLEY-WILLIS TAIT LANDRY O'BRIEN SMITH LEONARD FOX FISTER TATONE PALMER PIKE WOOD MOORE Given Name JONATHAN CLAYTON MICHAEL EASTWOD GEOFFREY WILLIAM MICHAEL PATRICK HARLEN GEORGE WILLIAM MELANIE JANE NICOLE MICHELLE ANDREW ISTVAN PAUL WILLIAM DAVID ERIC CHARLES JOHN ALYKHAN AMIR HANS PETER ALAN ANDREW TANIA CHARLENE RODNEY WELLON LYNDA DAWN PANAYIOTIS NICKOLAS MICHAEL STEVENS DALE LEROY FIONA JEFFREY PAUL VICKI STEPHEN GEORGE MARK YUEN JASON WADE PETER SHELDON JASON JOHN DEIGHTON ARTHUR PAUL CHRISTOPHER JAMES-ALBERT STEVEN ROSS CHARLES TIMOTHY MICHAEL SCOTT MARTIN JONATHAN AARON SHUXIN TONY DARREN CAROL KELLY JUNIOR MARK CHRISTOPHER JOHN MICHAEL KENNETH ANTONIO DELGADO MICHAEL JOSEPH BRIAN DOUGLAS ROBERT PAUL BRANDON RANDAL KATHLEEN ANN DOUGLAS STEPHEN GARY ALDRED GUY KIRSTAN GILES MARK PAUL LEONARD DARRYL JAMES DAVID STEVEN D. ANNE STEVEN ANDREW MIRAN MAURO JOHN JAMES WAYNE NANCY KEVIN ROBERT Position Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Senior Analyst Sergeant Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Sergeant Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Sergeant Police Constable Sergeant Police Constable Detective Police Constable Sergeant Sergeant Detective Detective Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Police Constable Detective Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Police Constable Sergeant Senior Intelligence Analyst Senior Programmer Detective Detective Sergeant Sergeant Sergeant Detective Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Sergeant Sergeant Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Sergeant Sergeant Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Training Constable Detective Sergeant Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Sergeant Sergeant Sergeant Police Constable Salary Paid $ 109,104.52 $ 109,101.69 $ 109,087.62 $ 109,085.30 $ 109,083.54 $ 109,075.69 $ 109,073.05 $ 109,072.97 $ 109,066.06 $ 109,064.55 $ 109,063.11 $ 109,062.98 $ 109,060.72 $ 109,052.80 $ 109,050.93 $ 109,042.23 $ 109,039.99 $ 109,031.43 $ 109,024.29 $ 109,006.89 $ 109,004.07 $ 109,003.20 $ 108,998.48 $ 108,992.46 $ 108,988.86 $ 108,973.89 $ 108,973.53 $ 108,967.98 $ 108,966.23 $ 108,963.73 $ 108,955.99 $ 108,949.00 $ 108,948.00 $ 108,947.83 $ 108,947.53 $ 108,947.25 $ 108,934.17 $ 108,923.62 $ 108,915.62 $ 108,900.07 $ 108,899.00 $ 108,892.62 $ 108,880.65 $ 108,880.12 $ 108,877.46 $ 108,871.75 $ 108,866.18 $ 108,858.86 $ 108,857.61 $ 108,855.72 $ 108,851.29 $ 108,849.34 $ 108,837.68 $ 108,830.74 $ 108,829.84 $ 108,828.57 $ 108,823.44 $ 108,820.24 $ 108,816.98 $ 108,816.18 $ 108,811.11 $ 108,807.80 $ 108,794.14 $ 108,791.26 $ 108,786.39 $ 108,781.05 $ 108,778.17 $ 108,773.99 $ 108,773.63 $ 108,773.36 $ 108,772.89 Benefits $679.10 $674.22 $678.49 $280.88 $705.05 $684.37 $686.42 $678.70 $717.06 $678.70 $668.84 $701.93 $717.06 $662.93 $669.95 $680.68 $686.42 $686.42 $713.86 $701.67 $669.95 $418.00 $684.37 $292.08 $651.62 $717.06 $708.56 $708.56 $708.56 $686.42 $686.42 $701.67 $669.69 $654.10 $701.67 $686.42 $717.06 $662.93 $717.06 $682.73 $257.90 $717.06 $717.06 $292.08 $292.08 $708.56 $283.58 $678.70 $708.56 $717.06 $717.06 $662.93 $654.23 $683.13 $669.95 $717.06 $717.06 $665.53 $684.37 $411.09 $673.61 $700.32 $712.59 $292.08 $669.95 $700.32 $717.06 $717.06 $717.06 $669.84 $675.44

APPENDIX B RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Surname SUDDES SWEENIE SERROUL ALLISON REID MOORE MARCH LAROCHE WARDLE TONOGAI GILLESPIE TROINA DEVINE KLACZA KOZAR LONG HOVEY OLIVER DIONNE CHRISTIE FREDERICK FALKINSON CLARK DA COSTA LA FOSSE THAYALAN CLARK BURKE DICK TEATERO HANS PARK BLACKER MARTIN RANEY ARMSTRONG HABIBULLAH ZOLD PUTERBAUGH BRAGG GRIFFIN GREGORY TUMANSKIY PATTERSON WISZNIOWSKI ZLOBICKI ROSS BENEVIDES KINGDON COOPER MCKINNIE LITTLE KASZYCA NEEDHAM MAYWOOD FERADAY GUEST MAKRIS ROWETT SHANAHAN OLSEN HUGHES GARDNER MOSHER BROWN SUKH MOORE CAMPBELL BEVERIDGE WORSDALE BABUJI Given Name MARLENE CAROLYN GORDON DAVID ELAINE HUNTER WAVERLEY ELAINE DARCY JOHN WINSTON ROLAND BENJAMIN JOSEPH MICHAEL PATRICK BENEDETTO PHILIP CAROL FREDERICK JOSEPH CHRISTINE GWENYTH STEVEN RONALD CHRISTOPHER PETER ANTONIO RUDOLPH FRANK CORINNE ANTONIO NORBERTO JEFFERY GUY SARATH JAMIE ANDERSON SUSAN JOYCE MICHAEL DAVID FREDERICK LESLIE DALJIT JOSEF FREDERICK RYAN DAVID ANDREW CHRISTOPHER RICHARD JAMSHID JOHN MICHAEL FRANCIS LORNE GORDON SHAIN MICHAEL ROBERT R. MYKOLA MICHAEL JAMES RYSZARD ALEKSANDRA DARLENE RICHARD FERREIRA SCOTT ANTHONY ROBERT AMANDA DARRIN JOSEPH LUDWIK ROSS ELLIOTT SCOTT MARK DANIEL DALE DEMETRIOS JOHN MICHAEL SHAUN LYNN RONALD FRANKLIN KRYSTAL ANNE SCOTT DEREK EMMANUEL STEVEN MURRAY SMEATON LYNN SHAYNE WILLIAM SUSAN ZACHARIAH Position Sergeant Sergeant Sergeant Sergeant Detective Sergeant Detective Sergeant Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Detective Sergeant Sergeant Detective Detective Police Constable Detective Detective Police Constable Sergeant Detective Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Detective Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Sergeant Police Constable Detective Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Detective Sergeant Detective Police Constable Detective Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Detective Sergeant Detective Police Constable Sergeant Sergeant Sergeant Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Detective Sergeant Sergeant Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Sergeant Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Group Leader Salary Paid $ 108,772.83 $ 108,772.66 $ 108,772.09 $ 108,771.97 $ 108,771.82 $ 108,771.26 $ 108,765.83 $ 108,761.38 $ 108,758.37 $ 108,754.08 $ 108,753.95 $ 108,752.62 $ 108,751.14 $ 108,747.24 $ 108,746.43 $ 108,740.53 $ 108,725.64 $ 108,722.79 $ 108,709.03 $ 108,707.60 $ 108,702.16 $ 108,695.71 $ 108,691.06 $ 108,685.66 $ 108,668.60 $ 108,666.12 $ 108,665.92 $ 108,664.50 $ 108,661.55 $ 108,661.37 $ 108,659.83 $ 108,656.07 $ 108,656.01 $ 108,652.14 $ 108,635.25 $ 108,634.07 $ 108,630.09 $ 108,625.40 $ 108,624.59 $ 108,618.60 $ 108,607.63 $ 108,604.12 $ 108,603.81 $ 108,601.62 $ 108,601.37 $ 108,594.12 $ 108,593.87 $ 108,592.88 $ 108,591.43 $ 108,584.50 $ 108,582.62 $ 108,580.62 $ 108,579.12 $ 108,578.37 $ 108,576.62 $ 108,576.62 $ 108,576.62 $ 108,576.62 $ 108,576.62 $ 108,576.62 $ 108,558.34 $ 108,506.72 $ 108,495.29 $ 108,490.56 $ 108,472.11 $ 108,466.98 $ 108,462.95 $ 108,461.09 $ 108,459.77 $ 108,459.05 $ 108,458.76 Benefits $717.06 $717.06 $292.08 $717.06 $717.06 $717.06 $717.06 $292.08 $292.08 $674.43 $678.70 $292.08 $717.06 $717.06 $695.77 $292.08 $717.06 $667.81 $292.08 $292.08 $669.95 $717.06 $717.06 $676.70 $676.05 $678.70 $701.67 $715.78 $678.70 $669.95 $717.06 $669.95 $717.06 $686.42 $711.97 $675.44 $662.93 $682.87 $283.58 $701.67 $701.67 $717.06 $662.93 $701.67 $292.08 $648.09 $717.06 $678.70 $701.67 $717.06 $717.06 $402.26 $683.37 $307.82 $402.26 $717.06 $292.08 $292.08 $292.08 $292.08 $708.56 $708.56 $701.67 $678.70 $684.59 $582.77 $713.86 $702.97 $700.32 $669.95 $171.41

APPENDIX B RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Surname COTE CRACKNELL WASHINGTON GRANT SCOTT MCKAY KNOTT STEPHENSON HU HAMLET MOORE VERDOOLD CIOFFI OSAGIE TOMLINSON ROBITAILLE VAN SCHUBERT MARTELL BERRY REMY YOUSUFI BEADMAN HANCOCK SCHULZE HALL LEE PABLA ANGUS YARDE COWAN SCEARCE HILLHOUSE FERNANDES MCNABB SARGENT TURNBULL KIMMERER LAVERS MONTGOMERY IZDEBSKI GOMES DE COSTE JOHNSTON ELLIOTT PATTERSON TAURO MCCAUSLAND NEWHOOK YOUROUKOS BENNETT MOTA WOJTKIEWICZ CACCAVALE ALLDREAD GROVER HANDSOR BRIDEAU BRAUTIGAM HOPTON KRUCZEK LEAHY SPENCER MCKERAGHAN PROSAVICH MCCANN FORD BENGE BIBEAU STEVENSON BOWMASTER LEMAITRE Given Name KEVIN JAMES ALECHIA CYNTHIA KATHARINE ANN PATRICIA ANN MICHAEL ANDREW SCOTT SIMON KATHERINE LYNN YI ROWAN ALLEN SCOTT WILLIAM LANCE SCOTT MARC ANGELO BASSEY JASON ALLAN PATRICK ANTOINE KEVIN JOHN BRIAN JOSHUA MICHAEL SMEDLEY ANTHONY ABDULLAH BRIAN GEORGE JANINE RHONA SCOTT CURTIS JOHN KYUNG SOO SUKHVINDERPAL SINGH DARREN RONALD RYAN ANTON ANDRIA MARTIN KENDAL TODD GARRY KERI ANN EDWARD LYNN CHRISTOPHER SEAN MICHAEL DAVID RUSSELL MANFRED JAMES ELIZABETH HELEN PETER ANTONI JUSTIN DAVID LISA GERMAINE TRICIA MARLENE CHRISTOPHER PAUL STEPHEN BRENT KEITH GERARD YOSHIO MICHAEL MATTHEW ALBERT JONATHAN NICHOLAS BRIAN ROBERT DANNY LABAO VICTOR BRUNISLAW ERASMO GORDON SCOTT TODD AMY CHRISTINE RENE ALYRE JAZEN LORNE RICHARD FREDERICK PIOTR PAWEL KEVIN JOHN JASON GUEVARA DANN FRANCIS PAULA ANNE KEITH ANDREW RION PAUL CHRISTOPHER ROLAND KEVIN GLENN MICHAEL GLEN ROBERT JAMES Position Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Police Constable Detective Police Constable Police Constable Detective Police Constable Sergeant Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Sergeant Detective Police Constable Sergeant Drafting Technician Detective Sergeant Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Sergeant Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Police Constable Sergeant Detective Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Sergeant Police Constable Police Constable Sergeant Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Detective Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Detective Sergeant Police Constable Sergeant Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Sergeant Training Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Salary Paid $ 108,443.41 $ 108,433.37 $ 108,432.11 $ 108,419.19 $ 108,408.01 $ 108,395.65 $ 108,395.41 $ 108,393.09 $ 108,382.39 $ 108,368.13 $ 108,360.01 $ 108,355.06 $ 108,348.23 $ 108,346.53 $ 108,336.07 $ 108,333.74 $ 108,329.14 $ 108,306.54 $ 108,303.75 $ 108,301.44 $ 108,280.49 $ 108,275.20 $ 108,272.74 $ 108,268.67 $ 108,257.02 $ 108,246.38 $ 108,240.63 $ 108,237.63 $ 108,222.49 $ 108,198.78 $ 108,181.06 $ 108,172.86 $ 108,169.80 $ 108,159.45 $ 108,140.38 $ 108,139.14 $ 108,133.49 $ 108,132.35 $ 108,131.40 $ 108,118.40 $ 108,079.52 $ 108,077.06 $ 108,072.25 $ 108,067.92 $ 108,063.65 $ 108,057.90 $ 108,038.44 $ 108,025.26 $ 108,017.62 $ 108,017.20 $ 108,007.85 $ 108,006.97 $ 108,006.41 $ 107,989.22 $ 107,985.86 $ 107,983.96 $ 107,980.49 $ 107,971.74 $ 107,960.40 $ 107,959.79 $ 107,942.85 $ 107,941.34 $ 107,930.18 $ 107,887.66 $ 107,876.26 $ 107,868.78 $ 107,858.71 $ 107,853.54 $ 107,852.91 $ 107,852.84 $ 107,842.73 Benefits $669.95 $684.34 $708.56 $701.67 $686.42 $708.56 $684.37 $701.67 $662.93 $669.95 $701.67 $676.70 $701.67 $682.82 $686.42 $701.67 $708.56 $710.11 $237.08 $708.56 $682.88 $708.56 $708.56 $662.93 $684.37 $662.93 $701.67 $661.19 $686.42 $708.56 $662.93 $708.56 $701.67 $686.42 $708.56 $708.73 $669.95 $658.58 $708.56 $662.93 $686.42 $686.42 $701.93 $701.67 $678.70 $662.93 $701.67 $708.56 $662.93 $675.80 $669.95 $686.42 $693.44 $676.70 $712.59 $686.42 $686.42 $701.67 $662.93 $673.61 $708.56 $686.42 $685.20 $701.67 $700.32 $662.93 $700.32 $669.95 $668.88 $686.42 $701.67

APPENDIX B RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Surname RODNEY LEDGERWOOD WOO KELLY CHEN GAJRAJ HALES PINTO WULFF NEVIN MORRISON WILSON LAUSH HOLUBKO RAWLUK JANSZ HORTON GORDON TUCKER FLANDERS CHANNER GRISOLIA TAYLOR PICKRELL SAVOIA MANIQUIS HUNG BARBERO JAMES QUINN KHIMANI SUTTON BRISCOE YULE PETRAKIS FERKO WOOLLEY NOTAY HIGGINS TOWNLEY RODRIGUEZ TOMASZEWSKI NICOL HORWOOD RYAN PAIS HUBER CHOW DION COHEN JOSEPH LICOP MARXER PAYNE MCALEER STRADZA HISCOX MCGOWAN KENNEDY ROSE GRIEVE FRASER WILSON BARNES HOLDER FOWLDS MOFFATT HAYLES ARMSTRONG PARVIN GINI Given Name DEAN LLOYD KIM CHI SHING DIANE MARY WEI PIN SYED SEAN KEITH JOHN SUZANNE MARIE EDUARDO IGNACIO DAVID TREVOR JAMES DAVID JAMES CHRISTOPHER ALLEN PAWEL ROY ANGELO TYRELL CHRISTOPHER NEIL CHRISTOPHER ADRIANA PATRICIA TODD MATTHEW NEVILLE LISA ROBERT EDWARD NEIL GIOVANNI ALVIN KEITH LESLIE FAN TRISHA ALLISTAIR WINSTON SEAN LEE ZULFIQAR ALI SEAN MATTHEW OMARI KAMAU ROBERT CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL CHRISTOPHER ROBIN RAYMOND JAGMOHAN SINGH ANDREW CRAIG PHILIP ALEXANDER ROBERT DAVID MARCIN ROBERT ROBERT RYAN KNIGHT CLINTON DEREK GLENN EDWIN ERWIN WERNER LAWRENCE CHI DANIEL MELISSA KELLY RONALD RAJESH ROBERT JOSEPH MATTHEW ALOIS KARL SCOTT KEVIN KRYSTIAN PATRICK JAMES KENNETH IAN DANIEL DAWN TREVOR SCOTT TRACEY DEREK SCOTT WALLACE CRISPIN ADKIN GORDON BRUCE MICHAEL MICHAEL BANCROFT ROBERT PAUL ARMAND SYDNEY GUILLERMO STEVE Position Sergeant Sergeant Senior Programmer Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Sergeant Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Sergeant Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Sergeant Sergeant Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Parking Enforcement Officer Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Parking Enforcement Officer Sergeant Detective Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Detective Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Detective Detective Police Constable Sergeant Detective Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Police Constable Police Constable Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Salary Paid $ 107,831.98 $ 107,826.70 $ 107,823.49 $ 107,811.04 $ 107,810.76 $ 107,782.98 $ 107,772.46 $ 107,772.28 $ 107,768.00 $ 107,750.15 $ 107,745.06 $ 107,719.67 $ 107,717.17 $ 107,710.61 $ 107,708.77 $ 107,699.83 $ 107,699.22 $ 107,688.24 $ 107,682.44 $ 107,679.32 $ 107,674.08 $ 107,654.48 $ 107,641.15 $ 107,640.50 $ 107,631.36 $ 107,630.50 $ 107,619.07 $ 107,600.45 $ 107,596.14 $ 107,586.37 $ 107,584.94 $ 107,577.93 $ 107,563.69 $ 107,558.35 $ 107,545.86 $ 107,545.16 $ 107,542.53 $ 107,541.82 $ 107,533.53 $ 107,507.78 $ 107,507.49 $ 107,494.47 $ 107,490.29 $ 107,488.72 $ 107,487.45 $ 107,485.94 $ 107,468.07 $ 107,467.98 $ 107,464.64 $ 107,462.55 $ 107,457.77 $ 107,454.07 $ 107,444.50 $ 107,441.94 $ 107,440.74 $ 107,433.28 $ 107,419.43 $ 107,400.30 $ 107,392.71 $ 107,388.46 $ 107,375.82 $ 107,375.35 $ 107,374.25 $ 107,369.91 $ 107,360.88 $ 107,358.17 $ 107,352.03 $ 107,345.54 $ 107,337.13 $ 107,327.51 $ 107,319.81 Benefits $701.67 $708.56 $257.90 $682.76 $678.70 $686.42 $669.95 $708.56 $283.58 $697.72 $665.53 $676.70 $708.56 $662.93 $700.32 $695.77 $686.42 $393.76 $686.42 $701.67 $708.56 $712.28 $658.58 $684.37 $700.32 $686.42 $662.93 $654.23 $677.27 $686.42 $595.54 $686.42 $662.93 $676.70 $677.88 $669.95 $684.37 $595.54 $701.67 $701.67 $683.75 $662.93 $686.42 $685.20 $662.93 $686.42 $686.42 $283.58 $710.11 $673.21 $656.84 $676.70 $677.88 $708.56 $684.37 $662.93 $677.88 $362.28 $701.67 $710.11 $675.34 $708.56 $645.60 $678.70 $566.90 $685.51 $582.77 $701.93 $686.42 $678.70 $678.70

APPENDIX B RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Surname ALIAS LUCZYK ALEXIOU STACEY BANTON CHORNOOK WIGGERMANN CHAUDHRY STRENG BALASUBRAMANIAM RENDON INGLIS HINES BRAR BHOGAL COOVADIA MOLE WESTERVELT BENNETT MACHELL WALKER SOUVANDY DUNCAN KLUNDER KRAWCZYK SAWYER MORRIS SMITH CAMPBELL AMOS BELL SCHUMACHER LIM MC SWEENEY HENSCHELL HEGARTY WOOD NG CILIA ITO ADDERLEY BULBROOK STEEL MILLER MONTRAIT GUERREIRO HAYNES WILLIAMS CHO RELPH MELBYE SEHDEV KICKSEE HILL KERR LADURANTAYE MCKENZIE GALDIKS FORCILLO ARMSTRONG MANTLE MALE COLLYER ZAJAC PAOLETTA WHITE ABRAMOVITZ DIRENZO ENTWISTLE GALLANT TEDFORD Given Name GAVIN RAYMOND RICHARD ALEXANDER DEMITRIOS BRIAN ROBIN HORATIO STEPHEN SVEN MAGHFOOR AHMAD MICHAEL ANTHONY KOWSIHAN BRIAN CRAIG NORMAN GORDON IAN SHANE GURSHARAN RAJAN-SINGH ABDUL-KHALIK YAHYA DEREK JAMES VICKI ANN TREVOR GARY LAWRENCE STEVEN CHANTHIMA JEANINE GERARD WILLIAM RICHARD DAVID ALLAN MANDY DAWN BRIAN ANDREW JAMES SEAN DAVID DARYL EDWARD JONATHAN MICHAEL DONG HYEOK DAVE JOSH MATTHEW CHRISTOPHER KEITH NATALIE MONIQUE KIMBERLY ANN WILLIAM JOHN ROBERT CHRISTOPHER DIANA LOUISE CALVIN MILORAD TYLER FRANKLIN IAN MARK DAVID WILLIAM JOSEPH ANDREW ERNEST DAVID CLAYTON HYUNG EUN BRADLEY GEORGE MARK ALEXANDER NITIN CHERYL NOREEN ELIOT LEWIS STEVEN HAROLD BROCK YVES ROBERT SEAN ROLAND GERHARD JAMES BERNARD KAREN MELINDA ANNE DAVID JOSEPH ADAM STEPHEN JULIE ANTHONY KEVIN JOSEPH MATHEW CHRISTOPHER RAYMOND MARTIN WARREN CLAYTON DENISE STEVEN THOMAS Position Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Police Constable Police Constable Planner Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Detective Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Sergeant Sergeant Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Sergeant Police Constable Police Constable Sergeant Detective Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Detective Senior Supervisor of Support Services Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Sergeant Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Police Constable Detective Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Human Resources Application Specialist Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Training Constable Sergeant Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Police Constable Sergeant Sergeant Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Sergeant Salary Paid $ 107,306.85 $ 107,286.56 $ 107,280.57 $ 107,271.83 $ 107,263.81 $ 107,247.71 $ 107,237.51 $ 107,237.44 $ 107,235.33 $ 107,233.36 $ 107,232.45 $ 107,218.32 $ 107,217.27 $ 107,214.93 $ 107,211.73 $ 107,210.94 $ 107,209.08 $ 107,205.05 $ 107,199.78 $ 107,188.37 $ 107,188.27 $ 107,185.21 $ 107,172.25 $ 107,169.47 $ 107,157.59 $ 107,142.29 $ 107,118.26 $ 107,101.83 $ 107,083.08 $ 107,075.89 $ 107,075.60 $ 107,072.97 $ 107,062.92 $ 107,061.14 $ 107,053.93 $ 107,051.92 $ 107,031.15 $ 107,023.86 $ 106,998.15 $ 106,993.59 $ 106,993.03 $ 106,985.40 $ 106,982.37 $ 106,972.77 $ 106,972.15 $ 106,961.88 $ 106,955.78 $ 106,928.06 $ 106,910.29 $ 106,897.19 $ 106,888.85 $ 106,883.49 $ 106,882.61 $ 106,880.11 $ 106,876.89 $ 106,864.12 $ 106,829.66 $ 106,806.13 $ 106,800.89 $ 106,795.79 $ 106,795.02 $ 106,789.24 $ 106,785.29 $ 106,782.63 $ 106,782.43 $ 106,778.74 $ 106,768.38 $ 106,759.90 $ 106,732.75 $ 106,720.79 $ 106,713.30 Benefits $654.23 $686.42 $700.32 $700.32 $708.56 $684.37 $662.93 $654.56 $701.67 $671.99 $662.93 $669.95 $669.95 $708.56 $662.93 $693.44 $669.95 $683.99 $286.99 $662.06 $700.32 $678.70 $710.42 $701.67 $684.37 $682.76 $706.31 $710.11 $673.82 $678.56 $686.42 $686.42 $679.01 $678.70 $669.95 $647.77 $705.86 $662.93 $675.34 $662.93 $708.56 $675.34 $662.06 $678.85 $662.06 $686.42 $686.42 $708.56 $662.06 $706.06 $669.95 $678.70 $400.51 $669.95 $686.42 $685.20 $701.67 $669.95 $639.53 $682.76 $678.70 $701.67 $669.95 $283.58 $708.56 $689.22 $678.70 $708.56 $544.76 $285.13 $708.56

APPENDIX B RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Surname CAMPBELL REGAN CHIU JONES GALLO VAN DER KRABBEN KEMPSTER SARJOO ROONEY HILLIER TYNKALUK ANDREWS CLIFFORD REYNOLDS HAGOPIAN NUNNO GRIS NASIM GREENE JONES LINNEY RUSSELL RIGGS LANGILLE RINKOFF TOMPRAS SAWYER SOUSA WARD IONTA TUCKWELL GRIFFIN CUNNINGTON EICHENBERG DAVEY PARKER ERMACORA MACDONALD ANSARI MYERS DIAZ THOMAS GAGLIARDI EDWARD COULTER MACDONALD GONZALES HOFFMEYER TRACEY EAGLESON CUSHING MC KENZIE HAYNES MACNAB KERR BUTT PIGNATELLI JOHN CHIASSON KAPLIOUK MAHMOOD ELLIOTT BESON HOOPER CASEY CASTELL RIOLO MIAN JOHNSON TAPP MARSHALL Given Name STEVEN JAMES PAUL FRANCIS SIN-YI SANDRA MAUREEN DANIEL STEVEN JOHN DARRYL MARTIN KEVIN RAMROOP TREVOR MICHAEL JASON SABINO DEAN ALLAN SARAH LYNN HUGH ANTHONY JASON DAVID GREGORY KRIKOR MELISSA ROBERT MICHAEL FAISAL MICHAELA SARA PAUL CHRISTOPHER JOHN THOMAS ROBERT GLENN BRIAN CHRISTOPHER LYNN LEE ADAM THEODORE ANDREW LESLIE PAUL ALEXANDRE PETER ALESSANDRO TIMOTHY EDWARD PAUL MATTHEW DOUGLAS JAMES MICHAEL SEAN ANDREW TODD WILLIAM ROBERT GALDINO JANICE ALI AKBAR GREGORY ANGELA MARIA RHONDA LEE DEANNA LYNN GLENN RAYMOND SHANE DUSTIN BERNARD ANGELO ENRIQUEZ RUSSELL DANIEL MARK ROBERT LISA CHRISTINE IRKA KATHERINE JOSHUA BRANDON CHRISTOPHER SEAN DANIEL WILLIAM MICHAEL WILLIAM STEPHEN MILLER TONY JEANILLE MARIA YVETTE MARIE IVAN ALEKSANDROVICH TAYYAB SHAWN WILLIAM MARK WILLIAM KEVIN JOSEPH JAMES AUSTIN TIFFANY ALICIA SALVATORE TONY FARHAAN AFTAB MARTIN NATHANIEL DEAN SHAWN TOBIN Position Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Sergeant Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Sergeant Police Constable Police Constable Detective Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Police Constable Police Constable Detective Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Training Constable Detective Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Training Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Detective Detective Detective Sergeant Police Constable Detective Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Sergeant Sergeant Police Constable Detective Detective Sergeant Senior Analyst Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Detective Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Sergeant Sergeant Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Detective Sergeant Salary Paid $ 106,707.80 $ 106,707.50 $ 106,706.51 $ 106,703.89 $ 106,701.36 $ 106,699.96 $ 106,684.26 $ 106,679.14 $ 106,679.11 $ 106,670.68 $ 106,668.36 $ 106,662.82 $ 106,662.63 $ 106,657.90 $ 106,651.08 $ 106,644.39 $ 106,640.43 $ 106,636.79 $ 106,633.37 $ 106,619.45 $ 106,604.63 $ 106,569.51 $ 106,568.45 $ 106,567.39 $ 106,561.19 $ 106,553.82 $ 106,543.66 $ 106,541.94 $ 106,520.57 $ 106,517.44 $ 106,512.82 $ 106,495.71 $ 106,492.39 $ 106,485.16 $ 106,479.24 $ 106,478.86 $ 106,476.51 $ 106,467.82 $ 106,453.60 $ 106,445.59 $ 106,444.11 $ 106,441.33 $ 106,440.44 $ 106,425.88 $ 106,425.68 $ 106,421.27 $ 106,420.60 $ 106,413.99 $ 106,393.90 $ 106,363.57 $ 106,360.95 $ 106,359.98 $ 106,357.68 $ 106,320.74 $ 106,311.66 $ 106,300.75 $ 106,298.18 $ 106,290.40 $ 106,260.91 $ 106,258.46 $ 106,253.42 $ 106,248.12 $ 106,238.15 $ 106,233.80 $ 106,231.89 $ 106,216.46 $ 106,214.89 $ 106,210.65 $ 106,209.71 $ 106,202.87 $ 106,196.10 Benefits $666.29 $662.93 $709.80 $566.90 $686.42 $669.95 $254.03 $662.93 $701.67 $678.70 $708.56 $683.99 $662.93 $675.44 $701.67 $686.42 $695.77 $662.93 $662.93 $701.67 $686.42 $701.67 $686.42 $690.34 $678.70 $685.20 $709.80 $662.93 $275.34 $701.67 $669.95 $684.37 $686.42 $685.46 $686.42 $669.95 $708.56 $708.56 $283.58 $710.11 $678.14 $701.67 $686.42 $701.67 $701.93 $708.56 $669.95 $701.67 $708.56 $708.56 $280.88 $676.93 $693.44 $682.76 $686.42 $674.83 $676.70 $708.56 $669.95 $669.64 $662.06 $708.56 $694.83 $701.67 $678.70 $678.70 $669.95 $670.92 $662.93 $708.56 $689.22

APPENDIX B RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Surname WONG CAMPBELL LISANIN MAYO MCBRYDE MEREDITH BANKS FERRY PREVOST RYAN FLIS KANE BHARDWAJ HAGGETT SIDHU SELVER ROSINA MASTROKOSTAS WARD MACDONALD FURNESS TINT KOMARNISKY CHARRON BASSINGTHWAITE ATKINSON BREEDON TAYLOR NICHOLS MCLAUGHLIN DESMARAIS MILLER SIMAKOV SIDHU LAWSON URE GARCIA BELL LINDALE SANGHA GIBBONS DURST ELLIOT DUNCAN ESTWICK BENNETT ROGERS BOGLES IRVINE FIGLARZ CRAWFORD SERBAN PANESAR PICKETT AQUILINA MINEYKO LAING PANDOLFI STEHLIK BENOIT MONTIETH PALERMO MCWILLIAM WHITE MA COOK KRAFT BRUNELLE MACKENZIE SNEEP REKHI Given Name GORDON CHUNG-HOI CLAYTON DOUGLAS ARNULFO JR. KENNETH GLEN WILLIAM CRAIG ANDREW DONNA JASON WAYNE JAYME THOMAS BARBARA CANDICE LYNN SHAWN GERALD ELLA ELIZABETH LORI LYNN GORPAL SINGH TERRY WILLIAM MICHAEL DREW MAGDALENE MAGGIE KEVIN WALTER LORI-ANN HOWARD WAYNE JULIE CHRISTINE SANDRA STEPHANE REJEAN STEVEN JEFFREY JAMES JONATHAN WARREN SPENCER WAVENEY PATSY HEATHER LAURY JUNIOR SYLVESTER JOHN PAUL BRIAN JAMES ALEXANDER DAVID SUKHVINDER SINGH ANDREW AVERY JAMES ANDREW ETELVINO MANUEL KATHLEEN BRIGID MICHAEL HARJIT SINGH REBECCA NICOLE PETER BENJAMIN GEORGE PETER EULIALIA JOANNE RICHARD LOUIE MARK ZACHARY JAMES RADOSLAW JASON RICHARD ION VERONEL SARABHJEET SINGH TRAVIS GRAYSON MARCEL KRZYSZTOF EUSTACHY RICHARD ANTHONY ALESSANDRO ANTHONY MICHAEL JOSEF LISABET JANE KIRK LOREDANA HEATHER LYNN DONALD GERALD DEREK THOMAS WILLIAM JASON GLEN WINSTON THOMAS BLAIR TODD JAMES JASDEEP Position Police Constable Detective Police Constable Police Constable Detective Police Constable Detective Detective Police Constable Detective Detective Police Constable Police Constable Detective Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Detective Police Constable Detective Assistant Manager, Payroll Services Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Detective Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Detective Detective Detective Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Project Leader Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Senior Analyst Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Sergeant Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Sergeant Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Police Constable Training Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Salary Paid $ 106,192.39 $ 106,188.26 $ 106,187.28 $ 106,172.90 $ 106,168.30 $ 106,154.16 $ 106,151.44 $ 106,147.37 $ 106,142.20 $ 106,139.81 $ 106,133.41 $ 106,127.81 $ 106,120.69 $ 106,117.17 $ 106,116.09 $ 106,114.22 $ 106,113.98 $ 106,112.28 $ 106,105.58 $ 106,103.98 $ 106,085.01 $ 106,083.20 $ 106,079.57 $ 106,076.80 $ 106,073.73 $ 106,068.72 $ 106,067.39 $ 106,061.15 $ 106,060.54 $ 106,047.43 $ 106,038.94 $ 106,027.84 $ 106,015.65 $ 106,008.81 $ 106,008.74 $ 106,001.81 $ 105,998.38 $ 105,987.97 $ 105,986.49 $ 105,943.03 $ 105,939.87 $ 105,934.78 $ 105,924.05 $ 105,922.12 $ 105,919.75 $ 105,919.12 $ 105,917.37 $ 105,916.42 $ 105,893.73 $ 105,892.78 $ 105,888.45 $ 105,882.40 $ 105,873.70 $ 105,873.05 $ 105,871.14 $ 105,865.81 $ 105,849.61 $ 105,848.34 $ 105,844.45 $ 105,843.53 $ 105,842.71 $ 105,839.71 $ 105,839.37 $ 105,836.92 $ 105,834.16 $ 105,831.47 $ 105,811.66 $ 105,811.04 $ 105,796.14 $ 105,793.14 $ 105,791.55 Benefits $669.95 $701.67 $662.93 $684.37 $701.93 $669.95 $566.90 $701.67 $237.95 $708.56 $708.56 $662.93 $669.95 $566.90 $708.56 $686.42 $425.24 $283.58 $662.93 $283.58 $378.33 $708.56 $693.44 $686.42 $686.98 $684.37 $681.54 $669.95 $386.87 $676.70 $669.95 $646.97 $682.76 $686.42 $701.93 $676.70 $662.06 $700.32 $684.37 $630.48 $686.42 $275.34 $662.93 $708.56 $708.56 $708.56 $393.76 $678.70 $686.42 $662.93 $662.93 $280.88 $678.70 $686.42 $669.95 $280.88 $669.95 $686.42 $686.42 $689.30 $259.39 $683.98 $675.34 $701.67 $662.06 $671.78 $701.67 $670.56 $685.20 $678.70 $681.80

APPENDIX B RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Surname DUNKER ARCAND TAHIRAJ BAGSHAW BECKWITH HODGSON GRANT WILSON KIM BIRING NORMAN HODKIN PATEL GIRMENIA SIDDIQUI MARTIN KELLY YU LEE MYERS PRICE GOOBIE BERRY BALET LENNON SCAVONE NUSSBAUM-VOINA OLIVEROS ROMAIN MONTEIRO DEABREU RAMPERSAUD D'ANTONIO REID GAZEY SLATER WINDSOR HOPKINS CARMICHAEL KOH PERSAUD ALLAN FOGG MAXWELL ARTINIAN TOMS FUNCHION BRISTER DAVIS SO CARUSO PAGLIA MCLAUGHLIN MORRIS HOBOR GALL FLETT WARD FOURNIER ST GEORGE BOND BLACKADAR LEVESQUE GOKEDA STOYKO MAVROU NICHOLSON ROCK FEGAN SAFARI WILLMS Given Name NIGEL PETER BRIAN CHRISTOPHER ALI SHUKRI ROBERT BRUCE CHRISTOPHER FREDERICK ALVIN KEVIN JULIE THERESE CHARLES WON-JIN SACHBINDER SINGH WILLIAM MICHAEL JASON JOSEPH RAJESHKUMAR FRANCESCO HAROON AHMED DANIEL ALEXANDER RYAN ANDREW CLIFFORD JOHN SHARON ELIZABETH ROBERT ARTHUR DERRICK STEPHEN ROGER ANDREW SEBASTIAN KIRK DEMETRICE GABRIELE VIORICA IOAN RAMON PHILLIP ROLAND ROBERT GREGORY JOHN DAVID REMO GREGOR JOHN DARYL RICHARD SCOTT DAVID LEE JEFFREY DAVID STEPHEN FRANCIS DAVID SUKJIN RAMACE SCOTT DOUGLAS BRETT GORDON GEORGE BYRON PEGLAR FREDERIC HALLEY DANIEL SCOTT JOHN WILLIAM STACEY DEE YING HO SALVATORE GIANCARLO MARTIN WILLIAM MARK LAVAROUS TERENCE ALEC ALEXANDRU JAMES BRETT TERRANCE MARIE-JOSEE STEPHANE MARC MICHELE LOUISE JANELLE RUTH MARTIN GOPALA KRISHNA SANDRA LOUISE DANNY LEONARD BRUCE CAROL BRENDA ELIZABETH MUSTAFA DAVID GEORGE Position Training Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Sergeant Sergeant Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Police Constable Training Constable Sergeant Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Senior Analyst Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Training Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Senior Analyst Detective Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Sergeant Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Project Leader Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Sergeant Police Constable Police Constable Senior Technical Analyst Salary Paid $ 105,781.88 $ 105,776.77 $ 105,775.77 $ 105,771.54 $ 105,768.49 $ 105,766.89 $ 105,766.76 $ 105,750.12 $ 105,746.51 $ 105,729.30 $ 105,726.79 $ 105,724.90 $ 105,723.88 $ 105,722.70 $ 105,720.66 $ 105,708.85 $ 105,703.94 $ 105,701.68 $ 105,690.29 $ 105,685.35 $ 105,677.03 $ 105,667.77 $ 105,648.85 $ 105,648.60 $ 105,642.52 $ 105,642.14 $ 105,636.94 $ 105,625.20 $ 105,611.71 $ 105,611.04 $ 105,606.67 $ 105,605.77 $ 105,604.69 $ 105,603.93 $ 105,603.44 $ 105,600.23 $ 105,592.79 $ 105,591.56 $ 105,586.66 $ 105,582.10 $ 105,577.81 $ 105,577.57 $ 105,571.31 $ 105,566.86 $ 105,560.93 $ 105,545.25 $ 105,530.53 $ 105,529.12 $ 105,527.28 $ 105,521.51 $ 105,516.55 $ 105,514.47 $ 105,506.73 $ 105,496.71 $ 105,496.69 $ 105,474.97 $ 105,472.80 $ 105,469.10 $ 105,461.31 $ 105,448.29 $ 105,430.02 $ 105,427.23 $ 105,426.90 $ 105,408.29 $ 105,407.51 $ 105,405.98 $ 105,397.75 $ 105,391.34 $ 105,390.88 $ 105,371.42 $ 105,370.77 Benefits $685.20 $662.93 $686.42 $700.32 $674.83 $669.95 $700.32 $701.67 $701.67 $276.69 $669.95 $686.42 $698.55 $673.61 $662.93 $701.67 $686.42 $684.37 $693.44 $701.67 $662.06 $700.32 $369.05 $662.93 $662.93 $684.37 $280.88 $701.67 $686.42 $685.20 $678.70 $280.88 $701.67 $670.21 $682.82 $678.49 $686.42 $701.67 $701.67 $316.65 $662.93 $670.20 $676.70 $686.42 $686.42 $662.93 $673.82 $536.83 $701.67 $686.42 $673.82 $686.42 $669.95 $703.75 $635.42 $683.30 $271.21 $686.42 $678.70 $686.42 $686.42 $686.68 $701.67 $707.82 $675.34 $666.29 $669.95 $608.22 $673.70 $662.93 $280.88

APPENDIX B RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Surname GREENLAW LUSSOW SPENCER FASSBENDER HWANG STRAIN CRILLY POWELL TROVATO PECK JANKULOVSKI KILLY COMISSION BOLCSO RAMIREZ HOWLETT RUSSELL SIRBU DE LUGT BUTT RAGELL MCBRIDE GRIEVES LIU KUHN BURKE UCHMAN O'NEILL LEE CORREA MCALLISTER DYCK DOHERTY STOJKOV GURR ARRUDA RIM ROBERTS WRIGHT MCNALLY FILIPPIN LORIMER WINDLE ACHAIBAR MONAHAR MANN JACKSON LANIGAN DOBRO VAN HOOGENHUIZE AL-ROUBAIAI KARAVADI MORRIS WHITE SALERMO PANEQUE KRANJAC MOISSEEV RUGHOO FADEL PARTRIDGE GAUTHIER HUTCHINGS HALEY PETRAKIS AGNEW PEREM JODOIN SPENCER HAZELL MURRAY JANECZKO Given Name CYNTHIA CHRISTOPHER JASON ALLAN SUSAN ELISABETH THOMAS YUNG-YIH GARVAN AUGUSTINE JOHN JAMES MICHELLE ELIZABETH LUIGI MOSE JENNIFER LOUISE LILJANA ANTON CHRISTOPHER PAUL MARTHA ANN MARION GENEVIEVE WAYNE DAVID MICHAEL PETRICA CRISTIAN MARK FASIEH UZ THOMAS MICHAEL KEITH ROBERT GARY BRUCE ZHIYONG RENE MICHAEL GARY EDWIN GERALD ROBERT BARRY JOHN KAREN ANTONIO DAVID WILLIAM HENRY JACOB BRADEN SPENCER SLOBODAN BOB JACK JACOB SANDRA CHRIS ANGELA PATRICIA ARTHUR DEREK GIANNI ALAN TROY WILLIAM TRACY GEORGINA RICHARD ANTHONY DION RAJESH AMARJIT SINGH ROBERT MICHAEL ROBIN ANDREW MICHAEL DANIEL ALI TALIB HANUMANTHA CHRISTOPHER ROSS MARK JAVIER JOSEPH ANTHONY IOURI DAVID RAVINDRA MOHAMAD DAVID WILLIAM PAUL RICHARD DANIEL WILLIAM RHONDA GAYLE STAVROS ROBERT ERIK ARTUR CHRISTOPHER GUNSTEIN DAVID JOHN SANDRA DAWN DAVID GERARD DANIEL MARCIN Position Police Constable Training Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Senior Analyst Senior Analyst Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Training Constable Sergeant Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Senior Analyst Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Detective Senior Technical Analyst Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Sergeant Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Senior Technical Analyst Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Salary Paid $ 105,367.64 $ 105,365.84 $ 105,318.04 $ 105,317.00 $ 105,306.38 $ 105,299.49 $ 105,290.02 $ 105,287.60 $ 105,279.24 $ 105,277.91 $ 105,274.77 $ 105,259.21 $ 105,255.04 $ 105,228.21 $ 105,228.21 $ 105,221.31 $ 105,209.26 $ 105,200.42 $ 105,194.25 $ 105,192.18 $ 105,173.16 $ 105,166.92 $ 105,158.25 $ 105,151.27 $ 105,149.66 $ 105,146.29 $ 105,144.42 $ 105,112.99 $ 105,110.95 $ 105,107.49 $ 105,083.21 $ 105,065.61 $ 105,064.89 $ 105,055.94 $ 105,048.49 $ 105,035.81 $ 105,025.15 $ 105,021.66 $ 105,020.01 $ 105,019.06 $ 105,014.58 $ 104,998.55 $ 104,983.36 $ 104,973.25 $ 104,964.93 $ 104,959.86 $ 104,958.62 $ 104,953.58 $ 104,953.00 $ 104,932.73 $ 104,932.37 $ 104,928.21 $ 104,923.59 $ 104,923.20 $ 104,922.02 $ 104,913.97 $ 104,913.21 $ 104,913.16 $ 104,910.73 $ 104,898.18 $ 104,887.85 $ 104,880.84 $ 104,880.36 $ 104,875.54 $ 104,869.36 $ 104,869.34 $ 104,865.75 $ 104,853.61 $ 104,851.43 $ 104,834.24 $ 104,828.09 Benefits $684.37 $700.32 $669.95 $669.95 $244.97 $686.42 $701.67 $688.50 $688.50 $682.76 $686.42 $683.13 $686.42 $280.88 $280.88 $700.32 $662.93 $658.58 $684.37 $654.23 $676.70 $667.87 $275.34 $662.93 $685.20 $701.67 $636.86 $686.42 $252.90 $668.42 $669.95 $253.72 $686.42 $662.93 $386.87 $686.42 $675.65 $673.82 $684.37 $596.28 $686.42 $686.42 $662.93 $657.76 $686.42 $686.42 $669.95 $700.32 $684.37 $666.29 $662.93 $280.88 $681.80 $684.37 $662.93 $701.67 $280.88 $686.42 $662.93 $662.06 $701.67 $701.67 $686.42 $679.20 $280.88 $662.93 $686.42 $686.42 $669.95 $686.42 $662.93

APPENDIX B RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Surname BOYLE YAN TAIT MUELLER ASNER LEE BAUS DOUPE EDGAR MCLEOD WITHROW DUERDEN BEAUDOIN MANOTA JOHNSTON MCCAW BODDAERT EASTER MAYERS BALACHOREK POLIAK DANCE HARRIS POWRIE CASH JONES JOHNS HUNTER NIZIOL CHUNG ZANK CID BAKSH ALI SHETTY KRANENBURG SZULC YOUNG KATHIRAVELU WATSON KERR ISHERWOOD BAGNALL BARTZ WALLACE KIENS LEE DEVEREUX CHAN MACGILLIVRAY JEEVA BRUNATO ROSSI FOSTER MACKENZIE LESLIE VALLEDOR MENDOZA SHI WATT DA SILVA CRISTOPULO ST CLAIR ATKINSON FREEMAN ELLIS GRIFFIN ROBINSON LAWRENCE HASSALL KARSTOFF HARVEY Given Name JASON EDWARD PETER SAMUEL JUDITH MAUREEN STEFAN ROBERT EDWARD JORGE JACQUELINE SANDRA JEFFERY JONATHON LESLIE ADAM PATRICK JENNIFER AUTUMN PATRICK PETER SHANE REGINALD RAMAN ROMI WENDY ELIZABETH DOUGLAS GORDON WARREN PETER PETER ROGER DANIEL ALAN MARK JOHN RYAN WILLIAM DAVID ANTHONY JOHN ERWIN JENNIFER ANNE JASON NEIL MARK DOUGLAS JASON COLIN WILLIAM JAMES YONG SUL GARY CHARLES CLAUDIA IRENE FAIZAL ANTHONY ASIF IFTIKHAR VIJAY RAMESH LORI PATRICIA SEBASTIAN PAUL ELIOT KAJAMUGANATHAN ADAM MICHAEL GEOFFREY RICHARD MATTHEW KENRICK PATRICE HANNAH FAY ALEXANDER MATTHEW ASTRID JAE-WOOK CHRISTOPHER LEE ALPHA HAWK-BUNG CRAIG ANTHONY ASIF ALI RICCARDO MARCELO OSVALDO ANTHONY JOSEPH ROBERT DEAN HAMIL THEODORE ALVIN ERWIN GONZALES LEI JERMAINE ANTONIO JIMMY BERNARDO KAREY ALOYSIUS GRAHAM STEPHEN ERIC MICHAEL MATTHEW AUSTIN LINDSAY GLENA BRANDON MICHAEL NEVILLE DONAVON ANDREW BRANDON CHRISTOPHER DONALD Position Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Sergeant Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Training Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Sergeant Police Constable Training Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Senior Analyst Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Sergeant Sergeant Sergeant Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Training Constable Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Training Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Training Constable Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Salary Paid $ 104,826.14 $ 104,807.94 $ 104,800.56 $ 104,784.89 $ 104,778.35 $ 104,767.68 $ 104,753.22 $ 104,743.38 $ 104,737.75 $ 104,722.29 $ 104,709.92 $ 104,705.54 $ 104,704.31 $ 104,703.47 $ 104,690.55 $ 104,688.65 $ 104,665.56 $ 104,663.09 $ 104,653.47 $ 104,640.93 $ 104,631.54 $ 104,628.64 $ 104,628.21 $ 104,621.85 $ 104,601.33 $ 104,599.41 $ 104,591.22 $ 104,584.50 $ 104,574.67 $ 104,569.69 $ 104,559.72 $ 104,559.26 $ 104,550.20 $ 104,546.86 $ 104,541.92 $ 104,538.84 $ 104,536.32 $ 104,535.95 $ 104,517.26 $ 104,514.67 $ 104,506.72 $ 104,476.15 $ 104,462.38 $ 104,459.89 $ 104,458.26 $ 104,453.20 $ 104,444.34 $ 104,436.57 $ 104,432.21 $ 104,419.45 $ 104,419.25 $ 104,418.11 $ 104,414.03 $ 104,397.19 $ 104,383.74 $ 104,377.72 $ 104,374.70 $ 104,370.71 $ 104,352.32 $ 104,344.38 $ 104,321.43 $ 104,307.25 $ 104,295.90 $ 104,293.18 $ 104,290.26 $ 104,283.47 $ 104,273.44 $ 104,268.10 $ 104,261.96 $ 104,259.07 $ 104,256.31 Benefits $683.98 $683.37 $701.67 $687.22 $669.17 $678.70 $670.19 $686.42 $686.42 $699.18 $686.42 $670.21 $662.93 $669.95 $689.87 $244.97 $685.20 $684.37 $582.26 $669.95 $686.42 $686.42 $280.88 $662.93 $682.15 $418.11 $686.42 $672.39 $646.97 $662.93 $700.32 $680.93 $662.93 $701.67 $701.67 $701.67 $669.95 $680.93 $676.31 $682.76 $684.37 $662.93 $678.70 $686.42 $673.21 $700.32 $701.67 $686.42 $690.96 $669.95 $661.19 $698.04 $673.21 $669.95 $678.70 $701.67 $685.20 $662.93 $662.93 $674.43 $662.93 $662.93 $686.42 $686.42 $642.62 $669.95 $681.80 $686.42 $700.32 $686.42 $275.34

APPENDIX B RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Surname LOKENATH DEMIRDEN HO MCFARQUHAR MCCONACHIE BURROWS CREWS SVITLYCHNYI SALOWSKI SMITH PATCHING SVITAK HANSEN RAMOS LETSCHE EMMS KARMALI WILLAN KAY KELLOWAY WATSON MOOSVI HAJI EBRAHIMI MANN POLLOCK FARRELL GILL TANNER MURRAY KHAN KENNEDY BROSKE SANDHU MILLER SWART OUELLETTE VIOLOT JOSEPHS LANGFORD HUNG BESCO TABOROWSKI WANG MELANSON MCCALL LISOWSKI HARLEY CLARK KIM BURNS YEE GIRARD MONTCALM GARBUTT FERNANDES TAYLOR MILLS LENGYEL CHUNG SALIBA MCGAHERN LEERMAKERS KAPITANY STRATTON MORAN BYERS RATHBONE HICKMOTT CULLETON MCFADYEN Given Name RAMDIAL TIWARIE AHMET OLIVER NICHOLAS BRETT HARRY STEVEN LEONARD TIMOTHY SCOTT ALEXANDER VOLODYMYR VOLOD GAYLE WINNIFRED RYAN ISAAC ANDREA PETER PETER JOHN FITZGERALD DOUGLAS REYNOLDS JEFFREY BRIAN FAIZAL SHIRAZ SUMMER LEE GRANT MICHAEL TREVOR PAUL ERROL JOHN SYED MOHAMMAD ABID POOYA MANDEEP SINGH TIGE SAMUEL DOUGLAS JAMES DALBINDER SINGH JOHN ALEXANDER NEAL ALLAN MOHAMMAD ASAD ULLAH DORNA TRESIA PETER WERNER BALRAJ RYAN KENETH ROGER JOHN ROBERT BRUCE ANDREW ADAM KIRK JAMES DOUGLAS JEFFREY DAVID RUSSELL ROBERT JOSEPH CHUAN JAMES ALLEN JAYANT JOHN KEVIN FRANCIS ALEXANDER PETRIE KARAH DAWN JONG WOO ROY BRIAN IAN MARTIN REMI ALAIN JEAN TODD ROSS SAVIO ROBERT ALLISTER PAUL TERRANCE SCOTT TIMOTHY RODCLIFF RODGER RACHEL CATHERINE JOHN ANTHONY WILLIAM ANTHONY JESSY TARA KENNETH DAVID RUTH MARIAN MICHAEL MELANIE LYNN MARCIE LYNN OWEN BRIAN DENNIS Position Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Police Constable Sergeant Police Constable Police Constable Labour Relations Analyst Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Training Constable Police Constable Police Constable Training Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Detective Police Constable Police Constable Training Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Sergeant Sergeant Training Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Detective Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Senior Operations Supervisor Sergeant Training Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Training Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Detective Police Constable Police Constable Detective Police Constable Police Constable Salary Paid $ 104,253.04 $ 104,239.37 $ 104,238.87 $ 104,237.80 $ 104,227.51 $ 104,215.04 $ 104,210.12 $ 104,209.20 $ 104,208.93 $ 104,207.27 $ 104,204.61 $ 104,201.64 $ 104,192.37 $ 104,177.28 $ 104,156.58 $ 104,155.55 $ 104,155.04 $ 104,149.49 $ 104,146.88 $ 104,140.97 $ 104,123.31 $ 104,113.16 $ 104,112.69 $ 104,104.09 $ 104,094.84 $ 104,073.36 $ 104,071.46 $ 104,066.92 $ 104,044.89 $ 104,028.64 $ 104,004.46 $ 103,994.32 $ 103,991.61 $ 103,990.34 $ 103,983.50 $ 103,974.65 $ 103,974.15 $ 103,965.81 $ 103,965.50 $ 103,963.07 $ 103,952.32 $ 103,951.43 $ 103,950.94 $ 103,931.82 $ 103,929.96 $ 103,908.18 $ 103,897.46 $ 103,897.14 $ 103,896.62 $ 103,896.38 $ 103,870.24 $ 103,865.61 $ 103,854.32 $ 103,847.45 $ 103,846.50 $ 103,836.17 $ 103,829.13 $ 103,828.60 $ 103,827.05 $ 103,810.21 $ 103,807.89 $ 103,803.29 $ 103,801.67 $ 103,793.06 $ 103,790.37 $ 103,789.36 $ 103,785.21 $ 103,783.05 $ 103,781.10 $ 103,780.55 $ 103,767.53 Benefits $646.97 $665.73 $682.50 $701.67 $669.95 $708.56 $684.37 $225.71 $796.08 $675.60 $697.72 $698.04 $684.59 $667.87 $685.20 $678.49 $675.44 $701.67 $662.93 $654.23 $685.20 $258.77 $669.95 $662.93 $701.67 $693.14 $685.20 $669.95 $678.70 $662.93 $662.93 $685.20 $684.37 $675.60 $701.67 $686.42 $670.20 $696.19 $676.70 $669.95 $686.42 $678.70 $662.93 $662.06 $288.17 $701.67 $686.42 $662.93 $244.97 $669.95 $654.23 $686.42 $662.93 $662.93 $693.44 $686.42 $662.93 $686.42 $669.95 $701.67 $678.70 $684.37 $671.78 $678.70 $669.95 $638.71 $684.37 $669.95 $701.67 $684.37 $669.95

APPENDIX B RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Surname SOUKATCHEV MUNROE MATTOS SCOTT MAHMODIAN SMYTH LOPEZ KISSI KAHNT HOBBINS ROCHE BARRETTO HAYNES DESROCHERS SKOLLY NOTO CASSIDY ZEBESKI COMBDON LAMBE PERKS PRITCHARD MACKAY GIRARDI WATSON FITKIN OLVER TSERING LORRIMAN WARNER GALES COSGROVE MILLER GALLAGHER GAUTHIER TANOUYE ABBASI PAGE BAI BEAULAC KURTS HUNT SCHERBEY PIKULA HOFLAND TAYLOR CARSWELL RIEL NANTON BOWRY AHMAD WELLS IRISH PETERSON SIRBOS RHEAULT FITKIN CIPRO BEGIN DECOSTE GOWAN WALLS CLARKE SMITH MUTIS ROSSEL RODRIGUES SPENCER D'SOUZA BROOKS BARATTO Given Name KONSTANTIN NEIL GERARD MOUNTY JOSEPH DWAYNE MEHRDAD TRACEY CAROLE ROWAN CARL CHARLES SAFO ANGELA CHRISTINE ALAN GARY CHARLENE LYNN BERTRAND STANLEY ANDREW EDWARD JEROME JEREMY BARBARA ANN DIANA SEAN ANDREW DAVID MICHAEL AARON ARTHUR JAMES W TREVOR AARON BRIAN JAMES RONALD ERNEST NANCY LYNNE CHRISTOPHER GRISEL ROBERT BOND TENZIN CHODON STEVEN CYRIL CHRISTINE WENDY SEAN DAVID MATTHEW HAMILTON IAN JAMES KEITH STEVAN TOSH SOPHIA SEHER DEREK WILLIAM DON XIN JOSEPH ANDRE LISA CRYSTAL GLEN STEPHEN RONNIE MIKEAL KAMIL STANISLAW MATTHEW ROBERT ANDREW BRIAN BRIAN PATRICK JEFFERY JAMES ANDREW ANTONIO CHRISTOPHER GEORGE SYED OMAR MICHAEL PETER CLIFFORD WILLIAM CHRIS DEAN GEORGE CHRISTOPHER ALLAN MICHELLE PAULINE MARCEL ARMAND WANDA MARIE TODD JOHN CHRISTOPHER GEORGE JEFFERY HOWARD ROBERT DAVID DAWN RICHARD ALBERT JULIUS ANTHONY WAYNE PHILIP MICHAEL ANTONIO Position Training Constable Detective Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Sergeant Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Sergeant Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Sergeant Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Sergeant Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Salary Paid $ 103,766.65 $ 103,765.86 $ 103,765.01 $ 103,764.98 $ 103,760.38 $ 103,755.66 $ 103,750.38 $ 103,743.63 $ 103,742.70 $ 103,739.64 $ 103,732.17 $ 103,726.64 $ 103,711.49 $ 103,691.94 $ 103,678.65 $ 103,665.50 $ 103,657.26 $ 103,656.36 $ 103,655.66 $ 103,654.58 $ 103,650.33 $ 103,649.94 $ 103,640.74 $ 103,630.59 $ 103,623.53 $ 103,622.88 $ 103,614.60 $ 103,610.48 $ 103,599.16 $ 103,593.73 $ 103,584.77 $ 103,579.68 $ 103,556.97 $ 103,553.00 $ 103,540.07 $ 103,512.31 $ 103,499.53 $ 103,496.51 $ 103,484.79 $ 103,472.53 $ 103,467.62 $ 103,466.01 $ 103,464.98 $ 103,461.41 $ 103,457.23 $ 103,455.53 $ 103,454.14 $ 103,453.16 $ 103,443.51 $ 103,442.46 $ 103,440.63 $ 103,438.36 $ 103,437.57 $ 103,435.08 $ 103,428.14 $ 103,419.45 $ 103,413.66 $ 103,409.39 $ 103,402.34 $ 103,397.37 $ 103,395.15 $ 103,378.01 $ 103,377.83 $ 103,377.71 $ 103,375.45 $ 103,373.07 $ 103,357.57 $ 103,354.52 $ 103,353.59 $ 103,348.34 $ 103,347.15 Benefits $685.20 $701.67 $662.93 $700.32 $662.06 $700.32 $669.09 $669.88 $673.61 $701.67 $686.42 $686.42 $678.70 $669.95 $662.93 $681.80 $681.54 $701.67 $237.95 $684.37 $658.58 $276.69 $669.95 $686.42 $675.18 $686.42 $693.44 $591.98 $701.67 $700.32 $456.72 $675.44 $662.93 $662.93 $700.32 $662.06 $662.93 $669.95 $669.95 $669.95 $701.67 $678.20 $686.42 $658.58 $701.67 $669.95 $673.82 $669.95 $654.23 $678.85 $386.14 $275.34 $700.32 $662.93 $669.95 $662.93 $397.00 $701.67 $700.32 $701.67 $701.67 $669.95 $669.95 $675.44 $700.32 $700.32 $666.57 $698.61 $676.70 $700.32 $504.02

APPENDIX B RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Surname BAKER STONE PROCTOR RAMBHARACK YIN LIMSIACO EVELYN CHENG SAN PEDRO KNAAP COLLIN MOORE DORAZIO THOMAS WHITFIELD NORMAN WENZEL NEATH DHILLON RYCZKO KIDD FAIRCLOUGH PAVLIDIS MCGEE KOTES BERNARD TROTMAN GRANT KING TAYLOR ELZINGA RUMNEY HASIUK PARGETTER SMALL KLUTZ STONE GALIOTOS DUNBAR MIESZKALSKI DAL BIANCO STONE KHAN GALLAGHER MAILER BORNEMAN ANDREWS SUMAISAR MCNAMARA MCDONALD DHUKAI DAYLER MCCONNELL LEFEBVRE KELLAR JUHASZ MORGAN YOUNG KIM ROSBROOK BEVAN DAWOOD CANNON GOBBO VLACH PICKERING GILLESPIE PINCHIN JONES BIANCHI BUDDO Given Name JASON ROBERT CAROLYN RUTH KELLY SEAN NEIL YA-WEN MICHAEL JOEL JAMSON ALAN LAP MANUEL WADE JONATHAN DAVID ADAM BENJAMIN NICKOLAS CHARLES MICHAEL LOUIS FRANCIS DARRYL JAMES DEREK MICHAEL KEVIN BRADLEY RANBIR SINGH LESLIE JAMES JEFFREY JAMES STEPHEN THEODORA JESSE PATRICK JULIA MARIE DAVID ANTHONY DREW ALEXANDER CHRISTOPHER RICHARD DWAYNE EDWARD KEVIN DWIGHT SIU-MIA TRACI GWENDOLYN MELISSA ANNE KEVIN JAMES MATTHEW WILLIAM CHRISTOPHER JOSEPH CHRISTOPHER KONSTANTINOS EVERETT CLAIR PETER JULIANO TERENCE WAHID JOHN ASHLEY DAVID MARK ROBERT JOHN PAUL TOM NILAN COLLEEN ROBERT JAMES ZEESHAN AYUB NATHAN DAVID DARREN MARC BRIAN MURRAY JAMIE CHRISTINE CHRISTOPHER WARREN G. HOON (RICHARD) ANDREW MICHAEL GORDON AMAAN MARLENE CLAUDIO ERIC STEPHEN ANDREA BRIAN DOUGLAS ALBERT DANIELA JAMES Position Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Training Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Training Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Training Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Training Constable Police Constable Police Constable Training Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Training Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Salary Paid $ 103,345.64 $ 103,334.28 $ 103,315.23 $ 103,297.87 $ 103,294.64 $ 103,294.45 $ 103,278.73 $ 103,256.34 $ 103,244.90 $ 103,243.00 $ 103,214.55 $ 103,207.77 $ 103,207.08 $ 103,202.27 $ 103,191.94 $ 103,191.11 $ 103,183.71 $ 103,178.69 $ 103,177.96 $ 103,174.93 $ 103,174.10 $ 103,172.51 $ 103,169.87 $ 103,167.56 $ 103,160.54 $ 103,155.65 $ 103,151.27 $ 103,142.51 $ 103,141.30 $ 103,126.36 $ 103,118.92 $ 103,114.98 $ 103,111.89 $ 103,104.68 $ 103,104.43 $ 103,103.91 $ 103,101.54 $ 103,096.69 $ 103,095.49 $ 103,086.82 $ 103,080.31 $ 103,074.63 $ 103,055.97 $ 103,050.69 $ 103,041.08 $ 103,021.25 $ 102,999.32 $ 102,992.72 $ 102,988.75 $ 102,985.87 $ 102,984.07 $ 102,976.76 $ 102,976.64 $ 102,971.58 $ 102,946.44 $ 102,944.35 $ 102,933.33 $ 102,932.47 $ 102,924.92 $ 102,917.95 $ 102,914.42 $ 102,911.01 $ 102,910.45 $ 102,898.34 $ 102,897.44 $ 102,885.70 $ 102,884.52 $ 102,883.72 $ 102,879.70 $ 102,875.90 $ 102,875.52 Benefits $669.95 $681.80 $662.93 $276.69 $678.70 $669.69 $673.61 $662.93 $558.66 $700.32 $686.42 $685.20 $667.46 $684.37 $675.34 $662.93 $662.93 $686.42 $677.53 $700.32 $576.24 $674.83 $700.32 $678.70 $662.93 $678.70 $662.93 $669.95 $693.44 $686.42 $686.42 $686.42 $675.34 $662.93 $678.70 $669.95 $676.70 $686.42 $662.93 $700.32 $700.32 $700.32 $662.93 $669.95 $669.95 $700.32 $684.37 $676.70 $683.99 $256.82 $678.70 $686.42 $275.34 $700.32 $669.95 $662.93 $662.93 $700.32 $662.93 $682.76 $700.32 $662.93 $700.32 $700.32 $700.32 $700.32 $700.32 $700.32 $700.32 $687.11 $700.32

APPENDIX B RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Surname PETKOVIC DOWNING KIM FERDINAND RUHL FLOREZ MIJARES DWYER MIGNARDI SURRIDGE THAI HANTON CHILVERS BOYD ZETTLER DELPORT CAMPBELL MCGARVEY FORBES BRUCE WILSON POSLUSZNY WILLIAMS PARRISH HO DABUZINSKAS SHAW CHAUDHARY O'RILEY CLARKE MORETON BRYANT MCMAHON REINARTAS STALK RUPNARINE GREEN BENALLICK TAYLOR SPADE ANDREW HAWKINS BELLEFEUILLE PARLIAMENT FYDENCHUK ISIP REID TROTTER TONNA BREMNER HUNT DURST FOOTE JARVIS MOULTON DONOVAN ELLIOTT SKLAR SLATER WRIGHT PAREJA VADIVELU TIMMS GREAVETTE PAROUSSOUDI BURKE LUSBY KHERA HAIN ST CROIX STUART Given Name BORIS THOMAS JIN HOI (JOE) PATRICK WALLACE CHRISTOPHER KEITH LUIS GUILLERMO RENE LIBRE ANTHONY STEVEN ANTHONY SCOTT WOODROW THANH JEFFREY AMANDA DANIELLE KAREN LINDA STEVEN CARL MICHAEL STEVEN D. WILLIAM DAVID WILLIAM PAMELA WILLIAM ANDREW ZBIGNIEW MARK SCOTT MATTHEW WEI-EN VYTAUTAS CARL NICHOLAS JULIE CALVIN PETER BARTON ALAN MICHAEL JOSEPH MICHAEL ARTHUR JOJI KAWAKAMI LEONARD SASE RONALD TERRY DIANNA MICHAEL BRYAN BRIAN DAVID WILLIAM JASON ROBERT GEOFFREY NEIL DOUGLAS JAMES RALPH KAY WILLIADOR JR. JOHN TIMOTHY WALLACE PAUL ANTHONY JAMES PETER GREGORY FRANCIS GORDON ELAN RONALD STEPHEN JOHN NICKOLAS ALLYSON MARY JAMES CARLOS ADRIAN KRISHNAMOORTHY KEVIN DOUGLAS JAMES LEMONIA ALEXANDRA DARRYL WILFRED GORDON MILPREET SINGH DAVID JOSEPH PAULA MATTHEW JAMES Position Training Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Training Constable Training Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Training Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Training Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Training Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Training Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Training Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Training Constable Police Constable Police Constable Training Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Training Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Training Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Training Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Training Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Training Constable Salary Paid $ 102,873.73 $ 102,863.50 $ 102,841.94 $ 102,836.77 $ 102,835.73 $ 102,833.67 $ 102,822.40 $ 102,820.16 $ 102,818.76 $ 102,811.49 $ 102,809.03 $ 102,805.79 $ 102,796.11 $ 102,793.49 $ 102,793.19 $ 102,792.78 $ 102,791.79 $ 102,790.34 $ 102,788.44 $ 102,787.13 $ 102,786.70 $ 102,784.39 $ 102,779.78 $ 102,776.97 $ 102,775.48 $ 102,774.19 $ 102,774.11 $ 102,766.62 $ 102,762.74 $ 102,760.78 $ 102,754.42 $ 102,747.02 $ 102,720.18 $ 102,716.30 $ 102,715.13 $ 102,714.94 $ 102,711.93 $ 102,704.87 $ 102,697.65 $ 102,685.61 $ 102,674.10 $ 102,668.38 $ 102,667.37 $ 102,666.16 $ 102,641.23 $ 102,625.36 $ 102,625.10 $ 102,622.55 $ 102,607.56 $ 102,606.60 $ 102,600.60 $ 102,600.10 $ 102,596.60 $ 102,596.60 $ 102,596.60 $ 102,596.60 $ 102,596.60 $ 102,596.60 $ 102,596.60 $ 102,596.60 $ 102,588.08 $ 102,579.92 $ 102,559.87 $ 102,538.62 $ 102,535.30 $ 102,526.36 $ 102,524.12 $ 102,519.46 $ 102,519.42 $ 102,516.81 $ 102,513.42 Benefits $686.42 $696.66 $662.93 $676.70 $679.71 $662.93 $662.06 $700.32 $662.93 $646.97 $693.44 $558.66 $685.81 $558.66 $697.47 $700.32 $700.32 $700.32 $680.56 $700.32 $700.32 $662.93 $700.32 $700.32 $662.06 $275.34 $700.32 $667.41 $275.34 $662.93 $700.32 $699.18 $684.37 $662.93 $662.93 $669.95 $259.39 $676.70 $684.34 $686.42 $685.20 $686.42 $275.34 $685.46 $684.37 $686.42 $700.32 $669.95 $662.93 $700.32 $700.32 $700.32 $275.34 $275.34 $275.34 $700.32 $700.32 $700.32 $700.32 $700.32 $640.58 $662.93 $662.93 $692.91 $654.23 $686.42 $694.95 $673.61 $669.95 $676.70 $685.20

APPENDIX B RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Surname GLASGOW DAWODU MORDEN APOSTOLOPOULOS PILOTTE SZKOTAK LAI SANTOS VICENTINO FLORES D'ALIMONTE GOODWIN MILLWOOD TOYNE REISE DEACON OTTEN FEGAN TROTTER BOYKO PORANGANEL CAVE GOTTSCHLING SNOW MADRAMOOTOO DIDIC PABLO CONLEY BELLAND MOORCROFT LEE BEVILACQUA OUELLET WESLEY CONTANT FISCHER LEECE DE GRAAF TRENTON VELLA HARRIS HERRON BOUVERAT FAREWELL WILLIAMS VAN HET VELD FIRTH THOMPSON URQUHART CIESLIK WILSON SEGUIN FERNANDES KACHUR KARAKOCHUK HAWKINS SPIVAK MCGOWAN KIM ALLEY OSMAN WALSH WYARD SIMAS GRAHAM GARBUTT ETHIER CHEUNG DE LOS RIOS GAUVREAU RANDHAWA MUNRO Given Name JUSTIN JOSEPH CHRISTOPHER OLUFEMI TODD DOUGLAS G. DIMITRIOS KAREN ALISON MARIUSZ DAVID RICHARD MANUEL ALEJANDRO STEVEN ELLA RILEY KARLENE ANN SIMON ANDREW RONALD GORDON TIMOTHY WILLIAM VICTORIA PAUL CHRISTINE JANE DAYNA KATHLEEN MARK VARKEY RANDAL DELBERT RONALD EDMUND ROYAN JEFFERY MARC ANDREY ADAMIRA MARIA GLEN PATRICK TIMOTHY KENNETH NEIL GREGORY MICHELLE JAYNE KYU IL GIULIO ANDREW JEFFREY JASON ARTHUR DAVID ANTHONY GORDON WILLIAM RYAN EVERT REBECCA TONYO CRAIG EDWARD CLIFFORD ROCH ERIC DANIEL HAROLD KEVIN CHRISTOPHER JAN ZACHARY JONATHON JENNIFER BRIAN DAVID JAROSLAW ANTON LAWRENCE CHRISTIAN ARMAND DWAYNE ANTHONY DAMIEN JOHN GERALD GEORGE HILARY LAURENE SHARI MONICA SANG HYUP NICHOLAS DAVID WALID AHMED DEREK ANDREW LESLIE ANN SERGIO KEVIN JOSEPH DEBORAH GRACE CHRISTOPHER MICHAEL NICKY TIN-FU JUAN CARLOS MARC ROBERT PALVINDER SINGH ASHLEY Position Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Senior Analyst Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Training Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Training Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Patrol Supervisor Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Salary Paid $ 102,488.75 $ 102,486.14 $ 102,480.41 $ 102,475.65 $ 102,443.42 $ 102,433.79 $ 102,433.73 $ 102,402.72 $ 102,400.76 $ 102,398.44 $ 102,396.52 $ 102,389.09 $ 102,385.88 $ 102,385.57 $ 102,370.85 $ 102,368.75 $ 102,355.83 $ 102,353.56 $ 102,351.93 $ 102,346.43 $ 102,342.54 $ 102,339.86 $ 102,339.28 $ 102,337.66 $ 102,333.33 $ 102,327.19 $ 102,324.25 $ 102,323.55 $ 102,320.29 $ 102,305.96 $ 102,297.03 $ 102,295.87 $ 102,283.02 $ 102,249.80 $ 102,238.45 $ 102,237.53 $ 102,235.25 $ 102,234.82 $ 102,233.85 $ 102,212.54 $ 102,209.10 $ 102,208.57 $ 102,203.69 $ 102,201.75 $ 102,198.88 $ 102,192.94 $ 102,187.16 $ 102,185.47 $ 102,173.81 $ 102,149.98 $ 102,141.22 $ 102,130.63 $ 102,129.42 $ 102,123.92 $ 102,120.81 $ 102,114.20 $ 102,109.53 $ 102,102.30 $ 102,096.99 $ 102,090.02 $ 102,085.59 $ 102,081.49 $ 102,062.16 $ 102,060.80 $ 102,057.57 $ 102,056.09 $ 102,053.99 $ 102,045.45 $ 102,036.24 $ 102,032.45 $ 101,994.57 Benefits $686.42 $686.42 $686.42 $662.93 $654.23 $669.95 $662.93 $679.30 $668.56 $683.30 $666.29 $280.88 $662.93 $667.87 $662.93 $0.00 $695.52 $686.42 $686.42 $686.42 $684.37 $669.95 $662.93 $686.42 $684.34 $678.70 $671.99 $669.95 $662.93 $678.70 $669.95 $671.78 $669.95 $685.20 $686.16 $669.95 $662.93 $616.46 $598.00 $684.37 $259.39 $662.93 $686.42 $686.42 $580.54 $656.84 $686.42 $662.93 $679.56 $259.39 $682.15 $686.42 $663.19 $654.23 $261.44 $693.44 $693.44 $662.93 $666.29 $662.93 $681.54 $678.70 $673.21 $669.95 $670.20 $662.93 $662.93 $693.44 $669.95 $662.06 $684.37

APPENDIX B RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Surname FEDORY RUSSELL GALAMIYEVA WARR MURPHY MORRISON DODSON EZEKIEL GABRIEL BAKER NAMAYANDEH FRANCO CLARKE KESIC GILL HEMPEN HARRINGTON OLUKOYA BRONSEMA HYLAND LEYVA WU NG LEFORT ARULANANDAM GEORGE MATHESON PRICE SUNGHING BOURGEOIS GOEBELL MCGUINNESS MCDONALD DAL GRANDE SHIN OLLOS CHRISTIAN HIGGITT ONZUKA WILDEBOER DAS GUPTA COYLE SYED RUTLEDGE CARLETON BRAYMAN PATHAK MCBRATNEY TAYLOR BOWKER MACKEY MARCHESE FERNANDES MCEVOY DORRINGTON WHITTALL KATOCH BEATTIE HAYWARD SIMPSON PULLA HUTCHINGS PARKER KALWIES BORISSOV EMOND DAVEY CRANE DOBBS ANDREJISHYN DHALIWAL Given Name MYKOLA JAMES JOSEPH YEKATERINA RICHARD JOHN DANIEL STEVEN CHRISTOPHER RANDIE SCOTT CARL MATTHEW THOMAS RICHARD TIMOTHY ARASH CHRISTOPHER ROBERT PAUL EGERTON ZELJKO SUKHJIT SINGH GEORGE JOHANNES JULIA ANNE OLUFEMI TANYA LISETTE SCOTT ANDREW SHARON MARISOL XU CHI WAI KENTON WILLIAM GERRARD NIMALAN KEITH JOSEPH DAVID DAVID RAYMOND DANIEL RICHARD JEAN PHILIP NAD SEAN ROBERT MAURO ANGELO HAROLD SANDOR ERNEST PHILIP BRUCE ELISA EDWARD YUJI PAUL ONIL ROBERT HASSAN RAZA MONICA JANET STEPHEN JAMES GEOFFREY ROBERT DAVINDER KUMAR RISE ANNE JEFF COLLEEN LISA CRAIG TRAVIS FRANK MICHAEL A. CLINTON WAYNE FRANCIS JUSTIN SHAWN MICHAEL AMAR SINGH CHRISTOPHER DENNIS DARRELL MAURICE RYAN JAMES JEREMY JAMES MARK DEREK FITZROY DAVID BORIS ILIEV CHRISTIAN RENE AMY LEE ROBERT JASON BEVERLY ROSE JAMES JOSEPH PIARA SINGH Position Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Detective Police Constable Training Constable Police Constable Police Constable Training Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Training Constable Training Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Training Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Operations Supervisor Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Sergeant Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Salary Paid $ 101,993.16 $ 101,989.41 $ 101,983.83 $ 101,980.52 $ 101,959.41 $ 101,956.39 $ 101,951.00 $ 101,947.97 $ 101,943.32 $ 101,938.26 $ 101,935.79 $ 101,923.49 $ 101,919.99 $ 101,905.64 $ 101,888.19 $ 101,886.77 $ 101,885.95 $ 101,873.06 $ 101,849.87 $ 101,841.57 $ 101,828.20 $ 101,819.23 $ 101,814.05 $ 101,810.53 $ 101,807.85 $ 101,803.58 $ 101,785.65 $ 101,770.73 $ 101,763.59 $ 101,755.15 $ 101,753.64 $ 101,739.10 $ 101,719.77 $ 101,708.68 $ 101,707.19 $ 101,698.43 $ 101,696.97 $ 101,696.72 $ 101,691.17 $ 101,686.42 $ 101,671.04 $ 101,652.50 $ 101,644.13 $ 101,643.79 $ 101,640.60 $ 101,630.54 $ 101,626.13 $ 101,624.52 $ 101,605.52 $ 101,598.72 $ 101,592.58 $ 101,591.11 $ 101,590.98 $ 101,590.11 $ 101,585.52 $ 101,572.11 $ 101,565.28 $ 101,551.50 $ 101,543.60 $ 101,536.44 $ 101,535.67 $ 101,529.20 $ 101,524.03 $ 101,523.99 $ 101,522.43 $ 101,517.48 $ 101,505.58 $ 101,499.45 $ 101,495.21 $ 101,491.28 $ 101,487.36 Benefits $662.93 $623.46 $658.58 $686.42 $450.76 $669.95 $686.68 $669.95 $664.49 $693.44 $665.53 $651.62 $676.70 $682.76 $662.93 $686.42 $662.93 $676.70 $682.76 $678.70 $663.19 $662.93 $693.44 $685.20 $685.20 $662.93 $603.28 $662.93 $686.42 $680.93 $684.37 $680.08 $683.13 $684.37 $669.69 $669.95 $662.93 $695.77 $686.42 $694.83 $692.20 $684.37 $662.06 $669.95 $686.42 $686.42 $662.93 $382.31 $684.37 $686.42 $669.69 $684.37 $271.21 $671.53 $662.93 $658.58 $676.70 $685.16 $669.95 $684.34 $662.06 $662.93 $665.53 $589.93 $662.93 $662.93 $261.44 $669.95 $654.23 $686.42 $662.06

APPENDIX B RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Surname RUSSELL BISLA MASTRACCI GREAVES BLUNK SWAINE MARSHALL BAIRD STONE KRAWCZYK SIVADASAN HANDY BENINCASA MURRAY CAMARA GREENER COLEMAN LEE SOKOLOWSKA WHITWORTH GILBERT LILLIE BAILIE SHIN OSOBA POTTER PASSERINO DI TOLLO BACON PITCHER SUTHERLAND DARMITZ DULATAS HUBER MCMAHON JACOBS ROMANO DOYLE BRANKER GOLDLIOUST SHANGI DUCUSIN GOSS BENOIT FRANK WATTS BAKER MATHEWS MCGIVERN SALAMON BERNARDO ATKINS NORRIS GARLAND VANWART SIMPSON RIVERS HALAGIAN WESTERHOFF SMITH SALTMARSH AHLUWALIA DE GUZMAN WELLS ELGAR DROZDZOWSKI LUKINGS LEVY ROGATINSKY PICKRAN BOWER Given Name ALEXANDER KIRAN PAOLA BRANDON LLOYD ANDREW FREDDY AARON DOUGLAS KEVIN GEORGE KAREN ANN CHRISTOPHER GEORGE MICHELLE MARLAINE SURENDRAN CHRISTINE MARIANO JOSEPH SCOTT ROBERT TOMMY KIMBERLEY ANNE CRAIG EDWARD STEVEN MINTEK EWA ANNA MICHAEL BRUCE SHAWN WILLIAM SHAWN GERALD KENNETH JAY HO OLUSESAN OSOKOYA VIVIENNE SANJA CURTIS PAUL MONICA FRANCA ANDREW MARTIN DAVID CHARLES GRANT ANTHONY ANDREW JOSEPH JOSE JOB SIMONE GABRIELLE KATHY LYNN SHELDON ALEXANDER ANTHONY STEFANO CHRISTOPHER PATRICK DARRYL DERMOT ANATOL JOSEPH RALPH MICHAEL RYAN JASON JAMES HORST ALBERT MARILYN IRENE ROBERT ANDREW RICHARD JAMES BRANT SEAN BARME MARIUSZ ROBERT EDUARDO MADEIROS CHERRY MAXINE ROBERT MARINA EDUARDOVNA DANIEL ROBINSON OLIVER STAFFORD BRETT LEWIS ADAM RYAN DAVID JAMES BRYAN MICHAEL SEAN RYAN MANDEEP SINGH NOEL ENRIQUEZ DAVID ARCHER KAREN ELIZABETH MAREK AIMEE ELISABETH GARTH ST. ALEXANDER HILDOR MARC ALAN Position Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Training Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Training Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Training Constable Sergeant Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Operations Supervisor Training Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Training Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Training Constable Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Salary Paid $ 101,486.94 $ 101,482.27 $ 101,478.30 $ 101,470.61 $ 101,462.76 $ 101,460.31 $ 101,459.69 $ 101,452.46 $ 101,452.06 $ 101,451.22 $ 101,449.75 $ 101,444.17 $ 101,433.66 $ 101,431.77 $ 101,403.06 $ 101,402.84 $ 101,402.22 $ 101,392.77 $ 101,392.55 $ 101,391.25 $ 101,390.54 $ 101,389.43 $ 101,378.14 $ 101,377.77 $ 101,375.58 $ 101,372.83 $ 101,367.84 $ 101,356.17 $ 101,346.97 $ 101,329.50 $ 101,324.02 $ 101,322.23 $ 101,315.12 $ 101,306.49 $ 101,290.32 $ 101,285.76 $ 101,280.59 $ 101,280.04 $ 101,260.57 $ 101,249.61 $ 101,243.68 $ 101,224.48 $ 101,216.29 $ 101,215.43 $ 101,205.41 $ 101,203.49 $ 101,196.92 $ 101,194.39 $ 101,193.53 $ 101,188.63 $ 101,180.85 $ 101,175.93 $ 101,173.75 $ 101,173.46 $ 101,172.28 $ 101,169.92 $ 101,169.36 $ 101,167.11 $ 101,163.47 $ 101,157.37 $ 101,154.11 $ 101,146.24 $ 101,142.12 $ 101,138.48 $ 101,127.49 $ 101,125.06 $ 101,123.22 $ 101,122.45 $ 101,111.95 $ 101,100.06 $ 101,094.53 Benefits $684.37 $686.42 $686.42 $666.29 $669.95 $637.73 $669.95 $684.37 $678.70 $693.44 $662.93 $693.44 $683.98 $669.95 $675.44 $669.95 $669.95 $662.93 $658.58 $692.20 $694.59 $662.93 $684.37 $669.95 $662.93 $662.93 $669.95 $665.63 $685.20 $686.42 $686.42 $662.93 $654.23 $686.42 $678.70 $669.95 $670.56 $663.49 $678.70 $662.93 $685.20 $669.95 $307.93 $673.95 $686.42 $669.95 $701.67 $686.42 $669.95 $668.91 $685.20 $669.95 $684.37 $686.42 $686.42 $662.93 $670.41 $686.42 $662.93 $673.00 $662.93 $662.93 $340.14 $680.93 $696.19 $683.37 $686.42 $662.93 $401.05 $684.37 $662.93

APPENDIX B RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Surname TRUEMAN GARRETT SMALL STIBBE GEE PUTMAN BARTLETT STRILEC GARROW PHILLIPS CAIN ARDILES COOPER WALKER CHEUNG GITTUS ALS GARDINER CORNFORD RAMBEHARRY WALKER DABU NISHIKAWA DONAIS D'ANGELO BELMONTE CLAPP SUTCLIFFE MCGUIRE JENKINS SENYK HAMILTON ANDRUS WANG DAVID PORTER WILSON KIPROFF VANDERBURGH GRAVELIJN SUN NAIDOO MAY MCINTYRE KAPOSY BORUN KINGHORN CRAMPTON MCCARTHY BARTLETT NEWTON TAMSE BELANGER VEGA SMITH BORCH CHOW HARDY DAWN BUCHANAN WEAVER DUNNE MINASVAND HAWKEN WILSON ADAMS BRABANT MCCONNACH FLUMIAN LEONARD AMBLER Given Name MAUREEN ANN RICHARD FREDRICK GREGORY DAVID CLINTON RODNEY KEVIN WAI AARON MATTHEW DANIEL ALBERTO KIRK WAYNE PATRICK JOHN RYAN BENJAMIN JAMES MICHAEL BENJAMIN GONZALO RICHARD MARK DOYLE GADMAN DANIEL RYAN CHRISTOPHER ANTHONY CHRISTOPHER ROBERT SCOTT CHRISTOPHER SANJAY RABINDRANAUTH FRANCIS JOSE PAULINO BRIAN JONATHAN BRADLEY JAMES GIUSEPPE ANTHONY CATHERINE ANN COLIN DAVID AMY LOUISE CLINTON RICHARD JANNA LOUISE KEVIN STEWART ALEXANDRU TIAM YEE COSMA DAINIAN ALLOY BRADLEY MICHAEL MICHAEL PETER ANDREW NORMAN ROBERT-THEO SAM SHUO GRAEME CLAYTON NATALIE ELIZABETH JASON ALAN KEVIN JOHN STEPHANIE ELIZABETH SHAWN IAN DAVID ALAN CHEOLIVER DAX JASON MITCHELL DAVID EDWARD TED LISA GABRIELLE DANIEL STEPHEN AARON MATTHEW PAUL WING YEM RUSSELL BRIAN GORDON GREGORY MICHAEL VERNON JAMES WILLIAM GEORGE MICHAEL BROWNLEE DAWN KIMBERLEY BRADLEY DEAN LAURA ANN ROBERT BRUCE TRACY LYNN ANGELA DOUGLAS CLINT KENNETH LAWRENCE Position Sergeant Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Training Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Detective Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Training Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Sergeant Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Training Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Training Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Salary Paid $ 101,094.43 $ 101,092.12 $ 101,090.20 $ 101,089.44 $ 101,074.50 $ 101,069.76 $ 101,068.99 $ 101,066.31 $ 101,063.35 $ 101,055.62 $ 101,051.25 $ 101,047.69 $ 101,044.17 $ 101,035.68 $ 101,031.57 $ 101,027.30 $ 101,017.45 $ 101,011.57 $ 101,010.17 $ 100,998.25 $ 100,995.52 $ 100,988.09 $ 100,982.80 $ 100,973.02 $ 100,969.57 $ 100,965.50 $ 100,964.10 $ 100,962.41 $ 100,958.50 $ 100,942.61 $ 100,938.85 $ 100,934.17 $ 100,928.19 $ 100,918.89 $ 100,918.25 $ 100,915.27 $ 100,906.43 $ 100,892.58 $ 100,889.89 $ 100,885.40 $ 100,884.30 $ 100,877.17 $ 100,858.88 $ 100,848.69 $ 100,837.20 $ 100,816.49 $ 100,814.54 $ 100,804.71 $ 100,795.76 $ 100,792.39 $ 100,790.58 $ 100,782.92 $ 100,781.87 $ 100,772.60 $ 100,772.51 $ 100,769.75 $ 100,768.26 $ 100,756.05 $ 100,752.70 $ 100,751.66 $ 100,746.31 $ 100,744.03 $ 100,743.69 $ 100,742.53 $ 100,733.12 $ 100,729.33 $ 100,727.33 $ 100,716.63 $ 100,713.59 $ 100,705.48 $ 100,703.16 Benefits $689.28 $678.70 $686.42 $669.95 $658.58 $666.29 $662.93 $662.93 $686.68 $667.87 $669.95 $667.87 $260.83 $669.95 $686.42 $670.77 $673.00 $669.95 $286.81 $686.42 $684.37 $669.95 $658.58 $689.22 $693.44 $684.37 $662.93 $662.93 $673.82 $680.58 $673.21 $674.22 $678.70 $662.93 $568.49 $669.95 $686.42 $669.95 $658.58 $662.93 $662.93 $683.99 $654.23 $686.42 $686.42 $668.65 $662.93 $669.95 $669.95 $675.18 $684.37 $669.95 $686.42 $686.42 $685.20 $656.84 $662.93 $676.70 $662.93 $686.42 $684.37 $669.95 $244.97 $671.78 $678.70 $684.37 $662.93 $688.64 $677.81 $662.93 $684.37

APPENDIX B RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Surname ABKARIAN MA KIM O'NEILL RAMPAT XINOS WINFIELD PROSPER KOHOUT WESTELL ORCHARD MCDONALD BRAUND ION AITKEN BINNS DUNK SCHENK DICKSON GERRY HUDSON POLLARD HARKER CRAWFORD REBELLO RENNIE ALAMAG KOCANOVIC BRADY HUTCHINGS TUCKWELL MORASH UEBERHOLZ OSBORNE HADDRELL MILLER TURNER BRYAN ARBUS SADEGHI ARMANI MORAN FOSTER VUONG SALINES URBAN HOUSTON MARJI DYKE MARO DEWLAND TRIAS JOHNSON YAP GARVEY RENNIE HAMILTON LAMANNA MINAMI ALVAREZ KELLY SMITH AHMAD CHARBONNEAU CANNING BROAD SUTHERLAND MORETTI PATERSON KARPUC STAMPLECOSKIE Given Name HOVIG JEFFREY HONG SAMUEL-CHONG BRIAN DONALD SUNIL EVAGELOS RICHARD MARK ANTHONY WENDY ELAINE CLINTON JON IAN DUNCAN MATTHEW PETER JAMES RAYMOND DEAN FRANCIS SHAWN CAMPBELL MICHAEL DOUGLAS LISA TERRA PHILIP BRETT GORDON MATTHEW JAMES NOEL MCNAIR KRISTINE RIAN ADAM MICHAEL ANTHONY JOHN MARK ANDREW JASON DOUGLAS ADELIO PERADA ALEKSANDAR SASHA PETER GORDON TRACEY LYNN BELINDA AGNES DEBORAH THOMAS FRIEDRICH BRIAN OTTO PETER JAMES ANTHONY KIMBERLY DAVID PAUL WILLIAM AZADEH PEDRAM ERICK ODYR LORNE DAVID KENT CIRO JR. JON JOEL MICHAEL MARTHA BUTROS GEOFFREY THOMAS KJELL KRISTOFFER WILLIAM RONALD ETHELWALD DIOSA KEVIN WILLIAM MEIYIN ANDREW FREDERICK BRIAN ANTHONEY MICHAEL S. ANTHONY MARK NOBUYUKI JORGE DAVID DENISE EUGENIA JEAN-PAUL MANSOOR JEFFREY PATRICK PAUL BRET AARON NATHANIEL BRIAN ARTHUR MARK KYLE SCOTT DAWID WALDEMAR DWAYNE Position Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Sergeant Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Training Constable Police Constable Police Constable Training Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Training Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Cadet-in-Training Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Salary Paid $ 100,699.76 $ 100,696.13 $ 100,683.68 $ 100,678.04 $ 100,673.45 $ 100,671.68 $ 100,663.55 $ 100,656.29 $ 100,648.03 $ 100,645.43 $ 100,643.66 $ 100,641.15 $ 100,639.12 $ 100,637.45 $ 100,633.50 $ 100,610.17 $ 100,609.98 $ 100,586.24 $ 100,581.14 $ 100,570.02 $ 100,569.53 $ 100,568.76 $ 100,561.17 $ 100,558.37 $ 100,556.71 $ 100,550.45 $ 100,550.33 $ 100,545.82 $ 100,532.31 $ 100,513.25 $ 100,510.55 $ 100,507.44 $ 100,495.70 $ 100,481.66 $ 100,470.12 $ 100,467.57 $ 100,466.96 $ 100,458.93 $ 100,452.49 $ 100,452.24 $ 100,448.09 $ 100,443.37 $ 100,438.10 $ 100,436.79 $ 100,434.22 $ 100,427.05 $ 100,426.76 $ 100,415.65 $ 100,415.10 $ 100,409.59 $ 100,409.51 $ 100,402.69 $ 100,399.10 $ 100,397.22 $ 100,389.47 $ 100,379.03 $ 100,367.02 $ 100,363.20 $ 100,361.00 $ 100,350.06 $ 100,346.03 $ 100,341.68 $ 100,335.73 $ 100,325.80 $ 100,324.10 $ 100,324.09 $ 100,320.03 $ 100,319.04 $ 100,317.34 $ 100,296.66 $ 100,296.66 Benefits $658.58 $662.93 $662.93 $673.61 $669.95 $669.95 $285.45 $662.93 $674.48 $674.83 $268.72 $680.93 $686.42 $691.73 $684.37 $676.70 $683.03 $684.37 $679.71 $662.93 $651.62 $666.29 $681.80 $677.53 $678.23 $666.29 $676.70 $669.95 $673.82 $663.19 $434.58 $693.44 $261.44 $669.95 $684.37 $669.95 $259.39 $684.37 $679.71 $662.93 $669.95 $646.04 $662.06 $686.42 $683.98 $694.69 $669.95 $662.93 $686.42 $663.19 $237.95 $662.93 $669.95 $693.44 $668.66 $685.20 $684.37 $684.37 $669.95 $669.95 $654.23 $676.70 $669.95 $669.95 $662.93 $169.78 $667.87 $679.56 $666.29 $662.93 $662.93

APPENDIX B RECORD OF EMPLOYEES' 2012 SALARIES AND BENEFITS Surname BRADLEY CONIGLIO WOUDENBERG POOLE SHEPHERDLY JASWAL LE RAMSAY DAVEY DIPOCE SINCLAIR SAIB BRIGGS GREGORY KIJEWSKI WATSON HAYES MCCANN COFFEY D'ABREO HAYRE LORIA KHAWAJA GRAMMATIKOS ESPIE WILLERS PICHE MARCHEN MERRITT STRACHAN GUTHRIE AIRD FERNANDES BEREZOWSKY BULMER TOUT BERTUCCA STRILEC HENDRIKS TORRANCE SUNGHING CAMERON DALEY ROWE GOUVEIA LA BORDE FINDLAY MOUREAU SANGUINETTI HO COOPER ASTAPKOVICH CHRISTODOULOU MCLANE NEWMARCH BILBY TALESNIK MCINERNEY SHIKATANI Given Name CHRISTOPHER DOMENICO HETTY JOHANA RICHARD ANDREW GORDON WALTER MONISH SINGH NAM-NHAT MICHAEL TODD DEREK JAMES JEREMY MICHAEL DOUGLAS CARL RACHID CHRISTOPHER NEAL TREVOR PIXLEY KATHLEEN LAUREN IAN ANDREW SHAWN EARL LAURIE ANNE CHARLES JAMES OLIVER HARMAN SINGH CATERINA ARSHAD SADIQ MICHAEL GEORGE GLEN RONALD PAULA LEANNE CHAD JOSEPH JAMES ALEXANDER JANICE LUCILE VERITY ROLAND ANDREA ROBERT NESTOR WARREN JAMES JEFFREY SHAWN KIMBERLY SHAWN RYAN BART STEVEN JAMES KELLY MARIE NEIL ROBERT TIMOTHY WILLIAM ANTOINETTE MARGARET DERECK FRANCIS REGINA RYAN MCLEAN JULIE SOLINE MICHAEL JOSEPH ALEC KAI-KWUN CHRISTOPHER ROBERT ANDREI YIORGO RICHARD KRISTINE ANN BRETT RYAN DAVID ANDREW NICOLAS RICHARD PATRICK HARRY WILLIAM GORO Position Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Training Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Training Constable Police Constable Police Constable Training Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Training Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Training Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Training Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Parking Enforcement Officer Police Constable Police Constable Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Training Constable Plainclothes Police Constable Police Constable Training Constable Salary Paid $ 100,291.49 $ 100,280.20 $ 100,278.09 $ 100,277.28 $ 100,275.49 $ 100,273.14 $ 100,270.38 $ 100,268.02 $ 100,257.64 $ 100,245.85 $ 100,233.52 $ 100,233.07 $ 100,230.37 $ 100,227.96 $ 100,224.34 $ 100,221.23 $ 100,217.87 $ 100,215.09 $ 100,206.47 $ 100,186.51 $ 100,178.53 $ 100,165.40 $ 100,151.25 $ 100,150.81 $ 100,150.11 $ 100,146.63 $ 100,143.49 $ 100,142.64 $ 100,139.73 $ 100,138.42 $ 100,135.76 $ 100,134.72 $ 100,133.72 $ 100,132.10 $ 100,129.08 $ 100,127.26 $ 100,120.40 $ 100,113.81 $ 100,113.48 $ 100,107.64 $ 100,105.61 $ 100,104.79 $ 100,102.13 $ 100,098.03 $ 100,094.44 $ 100,093.46 $ 100,089.57 $ 100,089.00 $ 100,086.22 $ 100,081.39 $ 100,081.01 $ 100,080.89 $ 100,078.38 $ 100,071.15 $ 100,058.80 $ 100,056.30 $ 100,027.74 $ 100,025.38 $ 100,002.16 Benefits $676.70 $662.93 $669.95 $692.20 $693.44 $662.93 $669.95 $669.95 $674.43 $686.42 $666.29 $662.06 $684.34 $662.93 $667.87 $677.88 $669.95 $681.54 $664.61 $662.93 $669.95 $669.09 $693.44 $669.95 $662.93 $692.20 $686.62 $685.38 $666.29 $692.20 $268.46 $693.44 $693.44 $693.44 $693.44 $669.95 $693.44 $678.70 $693.44 $662.93 $675.44 $662.93 $692.20 $677.27 $693.44 $268.46 $686.42 $662.93 $661.19 $595.54 $662.93 $665.53 $650.69 $639.20 $686.42 $685.20 $591.98 $669.95 $685.20

(B) April 17, 2013 from William Blair, Chief of Police Re: Additional Members Who Earned More than $100,000 in 2012 as a Result of Paid Duties April 17, 2013

To:

Chair and Members Toronto Police Services Board William Blair Chief of Police ADDITIONAL MEMBERS ON THE PUBLIC SECTOR SALARY DISCLOSURE LISTING AS A RESULT OF PAID DUTY EARNINGS

From:

Subject:

Recommendation: It is recommended that the Board receive this report for information. Financial Implications: There are no financial implications relating to the recommendation contained within this report. Background/Purpose: At its meeting of March, 27 2013, the Board was asked to receive the Public Sector Salary Disclosure (PSSD) listing for 2013, containing the Toronto Police Service (TPS) members who earned more than $100,000 in 2012 (Min. No. P69/13 refers). At that meeting, the Board approved the following motion: 1. THAT the Board defer the foregoing report until such time as the report requested in Motion No. 2 is provided; and 2. THAT the Board request the Chief of Police to provide a report containing information about the total number of staff who would have earned more than $100,000 in 2012 if their total salary and paid duty income were combined. The Public Sector Salary Disclosure Act (PSSDA) requires organizations who receive public funding to annually disclose the names, positions, salaries and taxable benefits of active, retired and terminated members. In 2010, the Ministry of Finance confirmed that paid duty income should not be included in the calculation of salary for disclosure purposes. Discussion:

The Police Services Act S. 49(2) allows the performance of policing duties in a private capacity, as long as such duties are arranged through the Police Service. As a result, TPS members perform paid duties, which are required by permit or requested by clients that are arranged through the Services Central Paid Duty Office. Officers receive payment directly from the client or through The Police Credit Union, if requested by the client. Prior to the 2010 Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) compliance audit, the TPS was reporting paid duty earnings to officers and the CRA on a paid duty statement. This practice had been discussed with and agreed to by the CRA. However, in 2010, the CRA requested that paid duty earnings be reported on a T4 separate from regular earnings. As a result, TPS retroactively issued T4s for the 2007 to 2009 audit period and has since issued a T4 separate from regular earnings for paid duty income. In June 2010, the Manager, Financial Management contacted the Ministry of Finance, requesting direction on how such earnings should be reported for the PSSD, given that the Ministrys instructions for preparing the report make reference to T4 earnings and that paid duties were now reported on a T4. A representative of the Office of the Provincial Controller, Ministry of Finance, confirmed that these amounts had no impact on the PSSD report and therefore, should not be included in the salary calculation. As a result, the TPS continues to exclude such earnings for the members reported on the PSSD. In order to address the Boards motion, members paid duty earnings were added to the salary calculated for the purpose of the PSSD. Through this process, it was determined that an additional 709 individuals would have earned more than $100,000 in 2012. Conclusion: In response to the Boards motion related to TPS members earning paid duty income, 3,890 members would have earned more than $100,000 in 2012, if their total salary and paid duty income were combined. Mr. Tony Veneziano, Chief Administrative Officer, Administrative Command will be in attendance to answer any questions from the Board. Respectfully submitted,

William Blair, C.O.M. Chief of Police /SAC PSSD for 2012 with paid duty earnings.doc

10. (A) May 28, 2013 from Alok Mukherjee, Chair Re: Disposition Report: Review of Complaint Concerning the Conduct of Councillor Michael Thompson, Vice-Chair, TPSB

(B) October 09, 2012 from Dhun Noria, Member Re: Disposition Report: Review of Complaint Concerning the Conduct of Councillor Michael Thompson, Vice-Chair, TPSB October 9, 2012

To:

Chair and Members Toronto Police Services Board Dr. Dhun Noria Member DISPOSITION REPORT - REVIEW OF COMPLAINT CONCERNING THE CONDUCT OF COUNCILLOR MICHAEL THOMPSON

From:

Subject:

Recommendation: It is recommended that the Board receive this report for information Financial Implications: There are no financial implications arising from receipt of this report. Background/Purpose: The Board, at its in camera meeting held on April 19, 2012, was in receipt of a complaint pertaining to an allegation that Councillor Michael Thompson had breached the Regulation to the Police Services Act governing Board member conduct, namely, O. Reg. 421/97 Members of Police Services Boards Code of Conduct (Minute C126/12 refers). Discussion: The Board decided to retain external legal counsel to review the complaint. At its in camera meeting on September 25, 2012, the Board received the report prepared by the Honourable Justice Sydney. L. Robins, Q.C. Following its review of the report, the Board concluded that Councillor Thompson had not breached O. Reg. 421/97 and, consequently, the Board decided that no further action should be taken with respect to the complaint. Conclusion: On behalf of the Board and, in accordance with the Boards policy, I will communicate the Boards decision, including the report prepared by Justice Robins, Q. C., to the Ontario Civilian Police Commission, for its information.

Respectfully submitted,

Dr. Dhun Noria Member

11. May 10, 2013 from William Blair, Chief of Police Re: Annual Report 2012 Police Towing Contracts May 10, 2013

To:

Chair and Members Toronto Police Services Board William Blair Chief of Police ANNUAL REPORT - POLICE TOWING CONTRACT JANUARY TO DECEMBER 2012

From:

Subject:

Recommendation: It is recommended that the Board receive this report. Financial Implications: There are no financial implications relating to the recommendations contained within this report. Background/Purpose: At its meeting of February 16, 2012 the Board approved the following Motion: THAT the following reports, which are currently submitted by the Chief on a semi-annual basis, be submitted annually in the future: Towing compliance with terms of the contracts

In accordance with the direction provided by the Board, the following report is being submitted. Discussion: The Toronto Police Service (Service) requires prompt and efficient towing and pound services on a 24 hour a day, 7 day a week basis. The need for this service arises from police contact with vehicles such as those recovered after being stolen, impounded for bylaw infractions or impounded following the arrest of the driver. At the same time, the Service also has an obligation to ensure that the towing and pound services provided to the public through the police are fair, equitable and in adherence to the terms and conditions of the contract between the Service and the contract towing agencies.

In an effort to ensure compliance, all contract towing service providers are subject to quarterly inspections, undertaken by Traffic Services personnel, of a random selection of invoices to ensure conformity with the billing requirements of the contract. Every receipt in this statistically relevant sampling is checked for In/Out time stamps and the accurate calculation of tow fees and storage costs. Any irregularities are noted; the receipts are photocopied and filed at Traffic Services. The management at each contract tow service provider is counselled regarding contract requirements and arrangements are made for customer reimbursement, if applicable. Further, all contract towing service providers are subject to semi-annual inspections of their equipment, licences and pound facilities. Any shortcomings are noted and arrangements are made with management to remedy the situation and comply with the conditions and requirements of the contract. Management are also advised of the comments and concerns raised from the Tow Service Feedback forms completed by Parking Enforcement officers (PEO). Areas of concern such as length of wait times or more specific concerns are discussed and expectations are highlighted if required. The video system used for security of the pound continues to be sampled by examining recordings for three random dates in the preceding ninety days to ensure compliance with that contract requirement. No deficiencies with respect to video recordings were noted during this current audit. In addition, as of July 13, 2012, Parking Enforcement East is now the custodian for all Service wide issued tow cards. Parking Enforcement East assists Traffic Services with compliance by auditing tow cards against entries made into the towing database. The information from tow cards inputted into the towing database is also examined regularly by Traffic Services pound officers. Any deficiencies are brought to the attention of the management of the specific contract tow service provider who address the issues by reaffirming internal processes with their employees. Invoice compliance audits for this report represent the period of January 1, 2012 to December 31, 2012. Receipts used for the audits were drawn from the following dates: Quarter One (1): Quarter Two (2): Quarter Three (3): Quarter Four (4): The results are as follows: District 1 JP Towing Service & Storage Limited The invoice audits of JP Towing, District 1, were conducted on these dates: March 14, 2012, May 30, 2012, October 18, 2012 and February 1, 2013. January 16 to January 22, 2012 March 19 to March 25, 2012 July 16 to July 22, 2012 October 15 to October 21, 2012

Audit Results Total number of receipts inspected Number of receipts contract compliant Number of receipts contract overcharged Comments:

783 782 1

The one (1) overcharge related to special equipment usage or medium duty tows. Management was reminded that without proper justification and reasonable proof for added charges that the regular tow rate will apply. A refund was issued. All inspected equipment, facilities and licences were found to be in compliance. There was one letter of complaint, which was resolved to the satisfaction of the Service and the parties involved. There were no complimentary letters registered during the inspection periods. There were a total of 8,256 street tows with police presence in District 1 for the year.

District 2 Walshs Auto Service Limited - o/a Bill & Son Towing The invoice audits of Bill & Son Towing, District 2, were conducted on these dates: March 13, 2012, May 31, 2012, October 17, 2012 and February 1, 2013. Audit Results Total number of receipts inspected Number of receipts contract compliant Number of receipts contract overcharged Comments: All inspected equipment, facilities and licences were found to be in compliance. There were no letters of complaint or compliment during the inspection periods. There were a total of 587 street tows with police presence in District 2 for the year.

152 152 0

District 3 1512081 Ontario Limited - o/a Abrams Towing Service Limited The invoice audits of Abrams Towing, District 3, were conducted on these dates: March 13, 2012, May 30, 2012, October 17, 2012 and January 31, 2013.

Audit Results Total number of receipts inspected Number of receipts contract compliant Number of receipts contract overcharged Comments:

266 266 0

All inspected equipment, facilities and licences were found to be in compliance. There were no letters of complaint or compliment during the inspection periods. There were a total of 1,817 street tows with police presence in District 3 for the year.

District 4 Williams Towing Service Limited The audits of Williams Towing, District 4, were conducted on these dates: March 12, 2012, May 29, 2012, October 16, 2012 and January 30, 2013. Audit Results Total number of receipts inspected Number of receipts contract compliant Number of receipts contract overcharged Comments: The one (1) overcharge related to special equipment usage or medium duty tow. Management was reminded that without proper justification and reasonable proof for added charges that the regular tow rate will apply. A refund was issued. All inspected equipment, facilities and licences were found to be in compliance. There were no letters of complaint or compliment during the inspection periods. There were a total of 947 street tows with police presence in District 4 for the year.

185 184 1

District 5 As a result of no bids being received for Towing District No. 5, the Service has realigned the boundaries for the adjacent districts, and has amended the respective agreements accordingly. Towing District No. 5 no longer exists. (Min. No. P90/12 refers).

District 6 A Towing Service Limited

The invoice audits of A Towing Service Limited, District 6, were conducted on these dates: March 12, 2012, May 29, 2012, October 16, 2012 and January 30, 2013. Audit Results Total number of receipts inspected Number of receipts contract compliant Number of receipts contract overcharged Comments: The seven (7) overcharges related to special equipment usage or medium duty. Management was reminded that without proper justification and reasonable proof for added charges that the regular tow rate will apply. Refunds were issued. All inspected equipment, facilities and licences were found to be in compliance. There were no letters of complaint or compliment during the inspection periods. There were a total of 12,461 street tows with police presence in District 6 for the year.

1034 1027 7

Conclusion: The pound audit process revealed a continuing compliance rate in excess of 98% based on the samples examined. There was one (1) letter of complaint from all sources which is down from the last period. All matters were resolved to the satisfaction of the Service and the parties involved. The contract tow service providers continue to improve their operations and provide consistent quality towing services to the Service and the public. Deputy Chief Mark Saunders, Specialized Operations Command, will be in attendance to answer any questions that the Board may have regarding this report. Respectfully submitted,

William Blair, C.O.M. Chief of Police WB/jw Filename: 2013 Annual Impound Storage Contract Report.docx

12. May 07, 2013 from William Blair, Chief of Police Re: Annual Report 2012 Race and Ethnocultural Equity Policy May 7, 2013

To:

Chair and Members Toronto Police Services Board William Blair Chief of Police ANNUAL REPORT: 2012 RACE AND ETHNOCULTURAL EQUITY POLICY

From:

Subject:

Recommendation: It is recommended that the Board receive the following report. Financial Implications: There are no financial implications relating to the recommendation contained within this report. Background/Purpose: On March 23, 2006, the Board approved the Race and Ethnocultural Equity Policy (Min. No. P81/06). This policy replaces the Services annual report to the Board on race relations and was to be provided to the Board annually in June of each year (Min. No. P211/06 refers). This report covers the period of January 1st to December 31st 2012. This report details the Services response to the Boards direction as contained in its Race and Ethnocultural Equity Policy. It also describes the Services commitment to promoting and strengthening race and ethnocultural relations between members of the Service and the communities it serves. These goals are being achieved through progressive diversity management initiatives, ongoing community partnerships, as well as improved individual and organizational competencies that enable the Service to provide a workplace and service delivery without discrimination or harassment, regardless of race, ethnicity, culture, nationality, religion or language. Discussion: The Service continues with initiatives that enhance race and ethnocultural equity within the workplace and in service delivery. These include: i. The Human Rights Project Charter (HRPC) partnership. The goals are to (i) identify and eliminate any discrimination that may exist in the employment practices of the Service

that may be contrary to the Ontario Human Rights Code; and (ii) identify and eliminate any discrimination that may exist in the provision of policing services by the Service to the residents of the City of Toronto that may be contrary to the Ontario Human Rights Code. In March 2012, the Diversity Institute, Ryerson University (DI), resumed the evaluation process of HRPC. In December 2012, the DI submitted a progress report that outlined a review of (i) information on the HRPC strategies, (ii) interviews, and (iii) relevant best practices. DI is in the process of completing their research and evaluation. It is anticipated that a final report will be completed by September 2013. ii. Human Rights Investigative Training program In 2012, human rights investigative training was developed and delivered by external experts, in consultation with Diversity Management. There were a total of 116 Senior Officers, Managers, Unit Complaints Coordinators (UCC) and PRS Investigators who attended the Human Rights Investigative training. It is anticipated that this training will continue to be offered to new investigators and UCCs. The Employment System Reviews (ESRs) - ESR implementation process continues to be monitored. By way of background, ESR 1 focused on uniform promotional processes to ensure that promotional policies and practices are equitable and that the practices associated with these systems are applied consistently, transparently and fairly to all uniform members. ESR 2 identified areas in the human resources systems that ensured fulfilment of the Services commitment to creating an equitable workplace for all civilian members. Finally, ESR 3 identified barriers in the workplace for police officers in general and in particular, the adverse impacts of barriers on five groups (Aboriginal peoples, lesbian, gay, bi-sexual and transgender (LGBT), persons with disabilities, racial minorities, and women). Currently, 98% of all recommendations have been implemented, or are in the implementation phase. The remaining 2% will be implemented when funding and resources become available. The Internal Support Networks (ISNs) ISNs provide peer support through guidance, assistance, mentoring and networking to members on various aspects of policing. The current ISNs include the Black ISN, South Asian ISN, East Asian ISN, Pilipino ISN, LGBT ISN and Womens ISN. In 2012 a new ISN was created that addressed the issues of disabilities. This ISN is called No Boundaries ISN. The Aboriginal ISN is in the developmental stages and should be established nearing the end of 2013.

iii.

iv.

In 2012, the ISNs initiated and participated in a variety of projects, events and partnerships. (see Appendix A ISN Events, Projects and Partnerships) v. Community Police Liaison Committees (CPLC) and Community Consultative Committees (CCCs) - The on-going proactive work of the CPLCs and the CCCs include community volunteers and Service representatives from the local divisions, senior management and various units. Each CPLC committee is inclusive and reflects the demographics of the local community, while the CCC committees serve specific communities on a city-wide basis. The mandate of these committees is to work with the Service in identifying, prioritizing and problem-solving of local policing issues by being

proactive in community relations, crime prevention, education, mobilization and communication initiatives and acting as a resource to the police and the community. vi. Youth in Policing Initiative (YIPI) This program aims to promote youth exposure and participation in police work environments. This includes the youth being involved in diverse, educational and productive work assignments. To enhance the link between the police and the community, the youth are selected from priority neighbourhoods and are reflective of our culturally diverse city. The Service engaged 150 YIPI students this summer who participated in a variety of policing assignments. This was the largest number of YIPIs involved to date. Toronto Anti-Violence Intervention Strategy (TAVIS) This initiative is an intensive violence reduction and community mobilization strategy intended to reduce crime and increase safety in our neighbourhoods. Neighbourhoods are chosen using crime trend analysis, hotspot occurrence mapping and community consultations. One of the key elements of TAVIS is to expand current relationships and partnerships and create new ones with the diverse communities of Toronto. In September 2011, Chief William Blair amalgamated the Toronto Anti-Violence Intervention Strategy (TAVIS) and the Community Mobilization Unit. The newly formed unit is now called the Divisional Policing Support Unit (DPSU).

vii.

DPSU includes a number of new areas, such as Neighbourhood Resource Officers and Youth Response Support. Members work in the communities with Community Response Unit officers from each division, and with the TAVIS Rapid Response Team, providing expertise on community and youth engagement. (See Appendix B TAVIS Community Engagement) DPSU provides a more effective, efficient and economical way of doing business both internally and externally in relation to Crime Prevention, while being more operational and supportive of field units. viii. Diversity Management (DM) the goals of DM are to develop, implement and support a comprehensive and strategic approach to the management of human rights, diversity and inclusion within the Service. These include the planning, programing, resourcing, communicating, training, developing, reporting, and monitoring of the Services diversity initiatives to achieve an inclusive and engaging workplace.

Recognizing that diversity and inclusion is a journey, DM works to develop customized strategies, programing and resources to promote new, interdisciplinary knowledge and practice about diversity that incorporates all the Ontario Human Rights Code grounds. Organizational and cultural change is imbedded in day-to-day operations and education, with the goal of ensuring that the Service continues to be an employer of choice for Torontos diverse communities. DM continues with specialised and customized training such as: Aboriginal Training & Development, Ethics & Inclusivity, Human Rights Investigative Training, Cultural Competency Training, Invisible Disabilities Development and Transgender Training.

DM hosted a workshop in 2012 titled, Invisible Disabilities. Over 250 people participated and included a significant number of front line members, as well as police officers from a variety of police services in Ontario. The workshop provided participants with tools when interacting with individuals with invisible disabilities. The workshop featured panel sessions that highlighted recent issues and developments regarding invisible disabilities as they relate to policing. DM is in the process of completing an invisible disabilities information booklet, which provides further information on invisible disabilities such as Learning Disabilities, Intellectual and Developmental Disabilities, Chronic Pain Disabilities, Speech and Language Disabilities, Deafblind Disabilities, Mental Health Disabilities, and Sensory Disabilities. ix. The Ambassador Program This program was launched in 2007 by the Benefits and Employment Unit. There are currently a total of 257 Ambassadors which include current, retired, civilian and uniform members throughout the Service, along with citizens in the community who proactively promote the TPS as an Employer of Choice. Ambassadors assist police recruiters at job fairs, community events and mentoring sessions in an effort to attract individuals of diverse backgrounds to ensure the Service is reflective of the community. Ambassadors also foster interest in the application process by promoting careers with the TPS whether on or off duty, in places of worship, sporting events, community gatherings or through friends. This was very successful and 50 new members joined the Ambassador Program. Most of the new Ambassadors were referred to the program from existing participants through word of mouth, others were internal members who wanted to assist with letting interested candidates know about upcomming initiatives. Community and Cultural celebrations - There are on-going cultural and community celebrations with Service members and communities. These include the Khalsa Day Parade, Black History Month, Asian Heritage Month, Caribbean Carnival Toronto KickOff and Parade, International Day for the Elimination of Racial Discrimination (IDERD), International Womens Day, Pride Day, National Aboriginal Pow Wow, Association of Black Law Enforcement (ABLE) Gala, Harry Jerome Awards Gala, Organization of South Asian Police Officers (OSPAO) Gala, International Francophone Day, Grenada Day, National Aboriginal Day Ceremony, Planet Africa Expo, Hispanic Fiesta, Pakistan Independence Day, China Town Festival, Taste of The Danforth and the Gerrard Street Festival of South Asia.

x.

In 2012 our Special Events Unit was involved with a number of events. (see Appendix C Special Events). xi. The Service continues to participate in town hall meetings to promote two-way dialogue and continues with the positive relationships that have been forged within our various communities. Procedural updates - The Service continues to monitor and update procedures that address and incorporate the Boards Race and Ethnocultural Equity Policy. This ensures that all existing procedures are current, relevant and reflect this Policy. (see Appendix D Procedural Updates)

xii.

Conclusion: The Service continues to lead in developing initiatives and procedures to support the Boards policy on race and ethnocultural equity relations. These goals are being achieved through progressive diversity management initiatives, as well as improved individual and organizational competencies, enabling the Service to provide better services and a workplace without discrimination or harassment, regardless of race, ethnicity, culture, nationality, religion or language. Deputy Chief Mike Federico, Corporate Command, will be in attendance to answer any questions that the Board may have regarding this report. Respectfully submitted,

William Blair, C.O.M. Chief of Police UB: SJ Filename: Annual Report: 2012

Appendix A ISN Events, Projects and Partnerships East Asian ISN o o o o o o o o LGBT ISN o

Seminars to the elderly Chinese communities on policing Participated in various Chinese Radio Talk Shows on policing Provided news articles to Ming Pao Daily News on various policing topics Celebrated Asian Heritage Month at 55 Division Attended an Asian Youth Athletic Association Assisted with public security for delegates from Shanghai, China Attended the 101st Anniversary of Taiwan Attended several Chinese town hall meetings

o o o o o

Organized and partnered in several LGBT social events with the LGBT community, including Pride Kickoff, IDAHO BBQ, Kyle Scanlon Memorial, Coffee with Cops, and Newcomers Night at 519 Church St Community Centre. Organized the LGBT Ghost Walk for Halloween Lunch & Learn with PFLAG & Transitioning in the Workplace Participated in the Pride Ceremony at City Hall Partnered with the CIBC Pride breakfast Presented at the Beyond Borders Seminar

Black ISN o Organized and sent care packages to TPS members in Afghanistan o Organized a Mix n Mingle event o Presented the Larry McLarty Award at the BBPA Scholarship and Awards ceremony No Boundaries ISN o Developed a web chatroom page for ISN use o Designed and printed an informational pamphlet o Attended and participated in the Invisibility Disabilities conference in November 2012 o Held a social at the Toronto Police Association Building Womens ISN o o o o Hosted a Lunch & Learn session on womens health issues Attended a Diversity Symposium at Ryerson University and promoted women in policing Participated in the Girls Making it On Their Own (G-MOTO) program Created a hand-out assisting women in the workplace with issues arising from pregnancy in the workplace and post-maternity leave child issues

Appendix B TAVIS Rapid Response Team Community Engagement o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o o Snowboarding with kids as part of the ProAction Cops and Kids program Tanridge BMX Bike Event Organized a Christmas Party Gala and Fundraiser - to assist the Womens Habitat shelter Bikes for Tykes - provided bikes to children in the neighbourhood Helmets for Helpers - enhance traffic safety among youth Celebrated Public Service Appreciation Day in the Sikh Spiritual Centre Toronto Jamestown Hub Community BBQ SOYAT (Somali Youth Association of Toronto) 23 Division Tour Pastor Walk - through the Mount Olive and Jamestown complexes Neighbours Night Out - Every Wednesday at a pre-selected local park Toronto West SDA Church Annual Anti-Drug & Anti-Violence Parade Ekklesia Kingdom Ministries Church Picnic Participated in the weekly Ladies Coffee Club at 23 Division Father Henry Carr High School Community Basketball Tournament Seniors Line-Dancing at Albion Mall Driftwood Public School Festival Derrydown and Calico Public School - FOR KICKS soccer program Downsview Secondary School - volleyball game Driftwood Community Festival - local artisans and community activities NTI Kick Off BBQ 5 Needle Firway Community BBQ 3685 Keele Street Smile Event BBQ 1875 Sheppard Avenue Ephraims Place - basketball tournament fundraiser Manantial Neighbourhood Services Local community youth displayed their singing talents at the Voices of Hope summer concert 45 Norfinch Drive, TPAAA Youth day of sport and skills training Neighbourhood BBQ, 10 Eddystone Artech Court - Block Party. The theme was Come meet your Neighbour Unity BBQ - local residents, bringing neighbourhoods together St Philip Neri Church - reaching out to local faith groups and congregations University Winston Larose Event - track and field event

Appendix C Special Events

Aga Khan World Partner Ashbridges Canada Day Fireworks Ashbridges Victoria Day Fireworks Autism Speaks Walk Backs in Motion 5K Bangladesh Canada Day - Dentonia Park Beaches Santa Parade Beaches Jazz Festival Beaches Easter Parade Bells on Bloor Bloorcourt Village Bloor Yorkville Ice Fest Brazilian Day Bum Run CHIN Picnic Canada Day Downsview Canada Day East York (Wadlow) Canada Day East York Parade Canada Day Parade - Scarborough Canadian National Exhibition Canadian National Exhibition Casino Cavalcade of Lights Chinatown Spadina Festival Church St. Halloween Festival Church Wellesley Village Fair Colombian Music Festival Colon Cancer Run Corso Italia Dyke March Easter Seals 24hr Relay Energizer 10K Festival on Bloor Festival of Praise Fire Fighters Memorial Freedom Walk Fusion of Taste Greek Independence Day Parade Greek International Ohi Day Parade Grey Cup Event (Festival & Game) Gumball Rally 3000 Harrys Spring Run Off - Prostate Cancer Heroes Highway Ride Honda Indy Highland Creek Parade International Womens Day March ISKCON Parade Junior Caribbean Carnival Parade Kensington Market - Red Pepper Spec. Khalsa Day Parade - CNE Kids of Steel Labour Day Parade Lakeshore Etobicoke Xmas Parade Light the Night Luminato Meagans Walk Midsummer Nights Run Milliken Mills Fireworks MS Bike Tour Nat'l Congress Chinese Canadians New Years Eve Run Nuit Blanche New Years Eve Downtown New Years Eve AFC Subway Olympic Parade Ontario Police Memorial Ontario Summer Games Palicio's Canada Day Police Services Day Parade Polish Festival Portuguese Parade Pride Festival Pride Remembrance Run Pride Parade Princess Margaret Cancer Ride Ride for Heart Ride 2 Remember Ribfest Canada Day Road Hockey to Conquer Cancer Run for the Cure Ryerson Student Parade Salsa on St Clair Santa Clause Parade Scotiabank Rat Race Scotiabank Waterfront Marathon Sikh Spiritual Center Khalsa Day Sporting Life 10K St Francis of Assisi Parade St Patricks Day Parade and Run Tarantella - Italian Fiera Taste of Danforth Taste of Italy Taste of Kingsway Taste of Lawrence Taoist Tai Chi Telus Walk to Cure Diabetes TO Caribbean Carnival Downtown Toronto 5K Run for Sick Kids Hospital Toronto Caribbean Carnival Parade Toronto Caribbean King & Queen Toronto 10 Miler Toronto Taste Toronto Yonge St. 10K Race Toronto Argos Victory Parade Toronto Criterium Toronto Challenge Run Toronto Freedom March Toronto Goodlife Marathon Toronto International Film Festival Toronto Motor Expo Toronto Triathlon (Ironman) Toronto Womens Half Marathon TPAAA Games UJA Walk Ukrainian Parade & Festival University of Toronto Walk Variety Village 5k - Wheels/Walk/Run Walk of Fame Walk for Values War of 1812 Warriors Day Parade Weekend to End Breast Cancer Weston Canada Day Weston Santa Parade Wheels on the Danforth Word on the Street Yorkville Exotic Car Show YMCA Relay for Strong Kids Yorkville 5k Run Zoo Run - Oasis

Appendix D Procedural Updates

No
01-02 05-16 05-16 05-22 Ch 13 Ch 13 Ch 13 Ch 13 Ch 13 13-02 13-03 13-04 13-05 13-06 13-07 13-14 13-18 14-18 14-19 14-29 14-30 15-16 15-16 16-07

Name
Search of Persons Hate/Bias Crime Appendix A - Excerpt from Guideline LE-029 - Preventing or Responding to Occurrences Involving Firearms Appendix A - Elder and Vulnerable Abuse Investigations Contact Information Appendix A - Unit Level Criteria / Conduct Penalties Appendix C - Progressive Discipline Appendix D - Letter of Suspension Appendix E - Letter of Revocation Appendix G - Expunge Police Services Act Conviction Uniform External Complaint Intake/Management Uniform Internal Complaint Intake/Management Uniform Unit Level Discipline Police Services Act Hearings Uniform Complaint Withdrawal Policy/Services Provided Complaints Human Rights Anonymous Reporting of Discreditable Conduct Internal Support Networks (ISN) Workplace Accommodation - Non Medical Change in Personal Information Re-Employment of Former Members and Lateral Entries Uniform, Equipment and Appearance Standards Appendix F - Appearance Standards - Officers and Civilian Uniformed Members Collection and/or Use and/or Reporting of Statistics Related to Prohibited Grounds

Routine Order
2012.12.031466 2012.01.190065 2012.01.190065 2012.08.090929 2012.11.221417 2012.11.221417 2012.11.221417 2012.11.221417 2012.12.071483 2012.11.221417 2012.11.221417 2012.11.221417 2012.11.221417 2012.11.221417 2012.11.221417 2012.10.231262 2012.11.221417 2012.10.261279 2012.10.231262 2012.01.190066 2012.01.190063 2012.11.281437 2012.11.281437 2012.06.070688

13. May 27, 2013 from William Blair, Chief of Police Re: Annual Report 2012 Training Programs May 27, 2013

To:

Chair and Members Toronto Police Services Board William Blair Chief of Police ANNUAL REPORT: 2012 TRAINING PROGRAMS

From:

Subject:

Recommendation: It is recommended that the Board receive this report. Financial Implications: There are no financial implications relating to the recommendation contained within this report. Background/Purpose: At the meetings of August 24, 1995 and January 20, 1999, the Board requested that the Chief of Police provide annual reports that assess the effectiveness of training programs. This report describes the training delivered by the Toronto Police College during the year 2012 (Min. Nos. P333/95 and P66/99 refers). Discussion: The Toronto Police Service (Service) continues to meet the training needs of its police officers and civilian members by providing quality learning both internally and externally. Members of the Service receive training through a number of different means: training offered by the Toronto Police College (TPC) through traditional in-class courses, unit specific training offered to members of a particular unit, courses offered on-line in an e-learning format, and course tuition reimbursement for training offered through external learning institutions. Attached is a detailed report on The Effectiveness of Police Training, which addresses the results of an effectiveness study conducted on four courses / programs delivered or sponsored by members of the TPC. This study focused on the transfer of classroom knowledge to field units and the impact of that knowledge on the Service and the community. The courses studied were as follows: 1. Effective Presentation Course (TM0032)

2. Domestic Violence Investigators Course (TC0042) 3. Booking Hall Safety and Procedure Course (TD0009) 4. In-Service Training Course-Uniform (TU0059) The Executive Summary for The Effectiveness of Police Training report is appended to this Board Report as Appendix A. Conclusion: This report will provide the Board with an overview of the training provided by the TPC during 2012. Deputy Chief Mike Federico, Corporate Command, will be in attendance to answer any questions from Board members. Respectfully submitted,

William Blair Chief of Police WB:ls Filename: Annual Report 2012 Training.docx

Appendix A

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
The Toronto Police Service (Service) continues to meet the training needs of its members by providing quality learning opportunities from within our Service, through partner organizations such as the Ontario Police College (OPC), and through outreach initiatives. Measuring the effectiveness of training is a difficult undertaking due to the numerous demands placed on our organization. While it may be presumed that performance improvement is due to training, it is difficult to verify. In order to effectively address the evaluation of Service training, members at Toronto Police College (TPC) apply the four-level Kirkpatrick Hierarchy of Evaluation, which includes the following criteria: 1. 2. 3. 4. Reaction, Learning, Transfer, and Impact.

Every course has a specific evaluation strategy. All courses are evaluated for reaction and learning at the time of delivery. Transfer and impact evaluations are much more labour intensive and are part of a long-term in-depth analysis. This long term in-depth analysis was conducted on selected programs. Specifically, four training courses / programs delivered in 2012 were reviewed based on the above listed criteria. These courses were as follows: 1. 2. 3. 4. Effective Presentation Course (TM0032) Domestic Violence Investigators Course (TC0042) Booking Hall Safety and Procedure Course (TD0009) In-Service Training Course-Uniform (TU0059)

Service training is an operational activity that supports identified needs, policies and statutes. The positive results measured by the transfer and synthesis of learning, as reported by members, is evidence that the teaching strategies employed by the TPC have had a positive impact on learners. With a reported transfer of learning ranging from 87% to 100%, this analysis revealed that the training members received throughout 2012 made a difference in their abilities to perform their duties. The TPC is continuing its efforts to meet and exceed the recommendations contained within the 2006 Auditor Generals report entitled, Review of Police Training, Opportunities for Improvement. To this effect, the report attached to this Board Report highlights areas where courses offered at the TPC have continued to evolve to address Service and community needs, as well as incorporate academic adult education best practices. Finally, course delivery strategies have continued to expand and liaisons with Federal, Provincial, and private partners have continued to grow throughout 2012, all of which have enhanced the ability of the Toronto Police College to deliver quality and relevant training to members of the Toronto Police Service in a timely and effective manner.

Toronto Police Service Toronto Police College

THE EFFECTIVENESS OF POLICE TRAINING

April 2013

TABLE OF CONTENTS
FROM: WILLIAM BLAIR ............................................................................................................................... 178

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY............................................................................................................ 180 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY............................................................................................................ 183 INTRODUCTION ....................................................................................................................... 184 EFFECTIVENESS STUDY ......................................................................................................... 184
SCOPE OF 2012 TRANSFER STUDY ......................................................................................................................... 185 METHODOLOGY ..................................................................................................................................................... 185

FINDINGS BY COURSE ............................................................................................................ 185

EFFECTIVE PRESENTATION COURSE ...................................................................................................................... 185 DOMESTIC VIOLENCE INVESTIGATORS COURSE ................................................................................................... 187 BOOKING HALL SAFETY AND PROCEDURE COURSE .............................................................................................. 189 IN SERVICE TRAINING COURSE UNIFORM ........................................................................................................... 191

TORONTO POLICE COLLEGE SECTION HIGHLIGHTS ....................................................... 193

INVESTIGATIVE TRAINING SECTION .......................................................................................................... 193 COMMUNITY POLICING SECTION ................................................................................................................ 197 ARMAMENT SECTION ..................................................................................................................................... 201 POLICE VEHICLE OPERATIONS ..................................................................................................................... 202 LEARNING DEVELOPMENT AND STANDARDS SECTION ........................................................................ 203 LEADERSHIP AND BUSINESS SYSTEMS SECTION ..................................................................................... 205

CONCLUSION............................................................................................................................ 206
APPENDIX A .......................................................................................................................................................... 208 2012 COURSES DELIVERED BY TORONTO POLICE COLLEGE .................................................................................. 208 ON-LINE AND TRAINING VIDEOS ........................................................................................................................... 208 APPENDIX B ....................................................................................................................................................... 215 2012 COURSES COMPLETED BY EXTERNAL UNITS AND ......................................................................................... 215 CONTINUING EDUCATION PROGRAMS/COURSES AND SEMINARS .......................................................................... 215

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
The Toronto Police Service (Service) continues to meet the training needs of its members by providing quality learning opportunities from within our Service, through partner organizations such as the Ontario Police College (OPC), and through outreach initiatives. Measuring the effectiveness of training is a difficult undertaking due to the numerous demands placed on our organization. While it may be presumed that performance improvement is due to training, it is difficult to verify. In order to effectively address the evaluation of Service training, members at Toronto Police College (TPC) apply the four-level Kirkpatrick Hierarchy of Evaluation, which includes the following criteria: 1. 2. 3. 4. Reaction; Learning; Transfer; and Impact.

Every course has a specific evaluation strategy. All courses are evaluated for reaction and learning at the time of delivery. Transfer and impact evaluations are much more labour intensive and are part of a long-term in-depth analysis. This long term in-depth analysis was conducted on selected programs. Specifically, four training courses / programs delivered in 2012 were reviewed based on the above listed criteria. These courses were as follows: 1. 2. 3. 4. Effective Presentation Course (TM0032) Domestic Violence Investigators Course (TC0042) Booking Hall Safety and Procedure Course (TD0009) In-Service Training Course-Uniform (TU0059)

Service training is an operational activity that supports identified needs, policies and statutes. The positive results measured by the transfer and synthesis of learning, as reported by members, is evidence that the teaching strategies employed by the TPC have had a positive impact on learners. With a reported transfer of learning ranging from 87% to 100%, this analysis revealed that the training members received throughout 2012 made a difference in their abilities to perform their duties. The TPC is continuing its efforts to meet and exceed the recommendations contained within the 2006 Auditor Generals report entitled, Review of Police Training, Opportunities for Improvement. To this effect, the report attached to this Board Report highlights areas where courses offered at the TPC have continued to evolve to address Service and community needs, as well as incorporate academic adult education best practices. Finally, course delivery strategies have continued to expand and liaisons with Federal, Provincial, and private partners have continued to grow throughout 2012, all of which have enhanced the ability of the TPC to deliver quality and relevant training to members of the Service in a timely and effective manner.

INTRODUCTION
The Service continues to meet the training needs of its members by providing quality learning opportunities from within, through partner organizations such as the OPC and through outreach initiatives. Members of the Service receive training through a number of different means including: training offered by TPC through traditional in-class instruction, unit specific training offered to members of a particular unit, courses offered on-line in an e-learning format, outreach training offered by TPC through a network of field training supervisors, and course tuition reimbursement for training offered through external learning institutions. A summary of the courses offered/completed is attached (see Appendices A and B).

EFFECTIVENESS STUDY
Measuring the effectiveness of training is a complex and challenging process. Many variables, both external and internal, affect the performance of any organization. While inferences may be drawn that performance improvement is due to training, it is often difficult to prove cause and effect. In order to effectively address this issue, the TPC applies the four-level Kirkpatrick Hierarchy of Evaluation, which includes the following: Reaction: Did participants find the program positive and worthwhile? This question has many sub-parts relating to course content including format, the approach taken by the facilitator, physical facilities and audio-visual aids. Learning: Did participants learn? Training focuses on increasing knowledge, enhancing skills, and changing attitudes. To answer the question of whether participants learned involves measuring skill, knowledge and attitude upon entry and again upon exit in order to determine changes. Transfer of Learning: Did the learning translate into changed behaviours in the workplace? This question asks if learners have been able to transfer their new skills to the workplace or community. Often, it is in this area that problems occur. There may not be opportunity or support to use what was learned. This may reflect on the course itself, but it may also be due to other variables. Methods used to measure transfer may include participant course surveys at the six-month mark, interviews with training co-ordinators and supervisors, and in-field training session observance of students by co-ordinators. Impact of Learning: Did the program have the desired impact? Assuming that the training program was intended to solve an organizational problem, this question asks, Was the problem solved?

The four categories of evaluation are carried out at different times during and after the program: 1. Reaction: occurs during and after the program. 2. Learning: occurs prior to, during, and at the end of a training program. 3. Transfer: occurs back in the work environment after at least six weeks.

4. Impact: cannot be measured for at least six months and may not occur for a considerable time after the delivery of a program. A key part of the analysis is determining the effectiveness of training. Every course has a specific evaluation strategy listed in the course training standard; all are evaluated on the reaction and learning categories. Transfer and impact evaluations are much more labour intensive. They are part of a long-term in-depth analysis conducted on selected programs. Scope of 2012 Transfer Study During 2012, four Service training courses were selected for review based on a number of considerations which included the number of members mandated to take the training, and the regulatory requirements. The courses chosen were as follows: 1. 2. 3. 4. Effective Presentation Course (TM0032) Domestic Violence Investigators Course (TC0042) Booking Hall Safety and Procedure Course (TD0009) In-Service Training Course-Uniform (TU0059)

Methodology To address the transfer of knowledge, anonymous surveys were used to collect data on whether learning translated into changed behaviours in the workplace. Paper surveys were created using Class Climate software. These surveys were completed by members, most of whom were randomly selected. These surveys were then returned anonymously to the TPC. A Scantron scanner populated the Class Climate database with aggregate data for analysis. If the course had smaller and more manageable enrolment numbers, all members who attended that course were surveyed. A larger enrolment base required a random sampling of members; again allowing for an anonymous return. To measure the impact of the In-Service Training (IST) program and the Domestic Violence Training survey data, member comments were used to assess qualitative data.

FINDINGS BY COURSE
Effective Presentation Course The Effective Presentation Course (TM-0032) is designed for members of the Service whose job function requires them to deliver presentations on behalf of the organization. Service members, namely police officers, are often required to persuade, direct and inform our stakeholders; this course provides learners with the necessary skills, knowledge and attitudes to enable them to do so effectively. The Effective Presentation Course is a four-day program. This course focuses on creating, designing and delivering presentations in a professional manner. The recognition and consideration to context, content and audience is emphasised, and learners are provided with the tools to engage in the delivery of impromptu and structured presentations.

The Effective Presentation course was reintroduced at the TPC following an assessment of demand surveys conducted by members. The surveys indicated the need for a course aimed at enhancing the presentation and communication skills and abilities of members. Transfer In order to assess transfer of learning for the Effective Presentation course, a survey of members who completed the training was administered. The anonymous survey was distributed and a total of 20 responses received. Respondents clearly indicated that they applied the knowledge gained in their training and listed the ways in which they used this new knowledge. Results indicated that a transfer of learning had occurred. The following charts provide a detailed breakdown of the responses to the Effective Presentation course transfer survey. I have applied the knowledge gained from the course in performing my duties within the Service. I feel that the learning acquired has helped me to improve my overall confidence. When you took the course in 2012, which unit were you assigned? School Resource Organized Crime Enforcement Intelligence Primary Response Unit Community Response Unit Drug Squad Other Which course topics were you able to apply the knowledge gained? Dynamic Presentations Impromptu Presentations Adult Learning Concepts The Learning Cycle Lesson Plans Evaluation Methodologies Practical Presentation (Delivery) 60% 75% 35% 30% 25% 10% 80% 10% 10% 10% 15% 10% 10% 35% 96% 100%

In what way did you apply your knowledge? As a result of the training, I am more confident in my ability to effectively present information on behalf of the Service As a result of the training, I understand the diversity of learning styles within audiences to which I present. As a result of the training, I can mitigate challenging behaviours in the classroom/audience when delivering presentations. As a result of the training, I have improved my overall presentation skills. As a result of the training, I have been delivering more dynamic presentations. As a result of the training, my confidence when delivering evidence has improved. As a result of the training, I can better structure a presentation plan. As a result of the training, I have been able to provide good presentation advice to my colleagues. Domestic Violence Investigators Course The Domestic Violence Investigators Course (DVI) is mandated by the Province of Ontario for those officers who are assigned to investigate domestic-related occurrences. This training is designed to enhance these domestic related investigations by promoting current best practices as well as victim sensitivity. The DVI course is a three-day course that is offered to police officers at all ranks, whose job responsibilities require them to investigate domestic-related incidents. This course is designed to ensure that domestic related occurrences are investigated in a consistent, systematic, and thorough manner, while maintaining sensitivity to the needs of victims and witnesses. The DVI course focuses on the Services procedure, relative to domestic related incidents, power and control dynamics in relationships, victim resources and legal issues surrounding domesticrelated investigations. The course is facilitated by members of the TPC, and utilizes outside agencies for their expertise in specific areas related to the investigation of domestic violence. Transfer To assess the transfer of learning and the impact of the DVI course, the 2012 course attendees were canvassed. In total, 122 written responses were recorded. Respondents clearly indicated that they applied the knowledge gained from their training and listed how they used it. Results revealed that a transfer of learning had occurred. In the DVI survey, 90% of respondents answered that they applied their knowledge in the performance of their duties, since taking the course. 80% 55% 40% 70% 40% 75% 60% 18%

The following charts provide a detailed breakdown of the responses to the DVI survey. I have applied the knowledge gained from the course in performing my duties within the Service. I feel that the learning acquired has helped me to improve my overall confidence. When you took the course in 2012, which Unit were you assigned? Criminal Investigation Bureau Youth Crime/Family Violence Primary Response Unit Street Crime/Major Crime Other Which course topics were you able to apply the knowledge gained? Power and Control Dynamics Toronto Police Service Procedures Firearms Interest Police Impact of Domestic Violence on Children Firearms Search/Seizure/Warrants Threat Assessment Domestic Violence Care Centre Gay Partner Abuse Program Victim Services/DVERS/Support Link Victim Witness Assistance Program Probation/Partner Assault Response Program Child and Family Services Act/Childrens Law Reform Act/Family Law Act Legal Issues Multilingual Community Interpreter Services Witness Assistance Relocation Program In what way did you apply your knowledge? As a result of the training, I am more confident in my ability to investigate domestic-related incidents. 59% 55% 12% 47% 10% 39% 25% 13% 52% 39% 17% 36% 41% 28% 5% 58% 18% 12% 1% 11% 96% 100%

88%

As a result of the training, I confidently apply the Services procedure and the legislative requirements when investigating domestic-related incidents. As a result of the training, I now recognize power and control dynamics when investigating domestic-related incidents. As a result of the training, I am effectively accessing data from the Firearms Interest Police system when investigating domestic-related incidents. As a result of the training, I recognize and assess the impact of domestic-related violence upon children and connect them with the appropriate resources. As a result of the training, I apply the relevant statutes and Service procedures when engaged in the search and seizures of firearms during domestic-related investigations. As a result of the training, I connect victims of domestic violence to various community and medical resources, which best suits their needs when investigating domestic-related occurrences. As a result of the training, I utilize the services of the Multilingual Community Interpreter Services (MCIS) when needed during the investigation of domestic-related offences. Booking Hall Safety and Procedure Course

61%

66%

16%

61%

33%

49%

32%

The Booking Hall Safety and Procedure Course is a two-day course designed for members who work in booking halls or lock-up facilities within the Service. This course was originally designed in 2000, as a result of numerous inquests involving in-custody deaths, and pursuant to the administrative investigation into the death of Mr Ronald Patrick Tobin. Learners are introduced to training related to suicidal behaviours, medical issues, sudden in-custody death, and Service policies and procedures. The goal of the course is to ensure that members working in booking halls and lock-up facilities respond safely, efficiently and appropriately during all prisoner management situations. This includes identifying, recognizing and responding to prisoners who are in a state of crisis, and taking the appropriate action necessary to de-escalate the situation. Transfer To assess the transfer of learning and impact for the Booking Hall Safety and Procedure course, the 2012 course attendees were surveyed. In total, 51 responses were recorded. Respondents clearly indicated that they applied the knowledge gained from their training and listed how they used it. Results indicated that a transfer of learning had occurred. In the Booking Hall Safety and Procedure course survey, 92% of respondents answered that they applied their knowledge during the course of their duties.

The following charts provide a detailed breakdown of the responses to the Booking Hall Safety and Procedure course survey. I have applied the knowledge gained from the course in performing my duties within the Service. I feel that the learning acquired has helped me to improve my overall confidence. When you took the course in 2012, which Unit were you assigned? Criminal Investigation Bureau Traffic Primary Response Unit Other Which course topics were you able to apply the knowledge gained? Booking Hall Safety, viewing persons in custody Crisis and de-escalation management TPS Procedures Search of Persons 01-02, Persons in Custody In- custody legal issues In-custody suicide Investigating deaths in custody Practical booking exercises In what way did you apply your knowledge? As a result of the training, I am more confident in my ability to effectively deal with persons in custody. As a result of the training, I confidently apply the Services procedures when interacting with persons in custody. As a result of the training, I de-escalate conflict situations when dealing with persons in custody. As a result of the training, I am effectively booking prisoners while applying the fundamentals of control and safety and the booking hall questionnaire. As a result of the training, I utilize the necessary booking folders, forms and procedures associated with the booking process. As a result of the training, I apply the relevant legislations and remain cognizant of the Charter considerations during the booking process and interactions with persons in custody. 94% 41% 51% 31% 25% 8% 57% 2% 4% 36% 58% 92% 96%

67%

59%

53%

73%

55%

47%

As a result of the training, I am aware of the suicidal tendencies of persons in custody and take appropriate steps to manage suicidal persons in custody. In Service Training Course Uniform

67%

In keeping with the provincial requirement of Ontario Regulation 926, members must recertify on the use of their firearms and less lethal use of force options at least once every twelve months. Members are required to attend recertification training before the expiry of the date of certification attained during the previous year. The In-Service Training Program - Uniform (ISTP-U) is mandatory for all front line officers and members of identified high risk plainclothes units. All other police officers (with the exception of the Senior Officers) attend the In-Service Training Program Investigative (ISTP-I). The 2012 ISTP-U is a blended program involving two days of training at the TPC and an ELearning component to be completed on line. The ISTP-U course incorporates practice and requalification on all use of force options with training on current issues in policing. This training provides officers with the tools to de-escalate aggressive behavior and to use sound judgment in selecting the most appropriate force option when confronted with violent behaviors. The emphasis of this program is to ensure that officers respond effectively, professionally, ethically and legally in all conflict resolution situations. Transfer To evaluate the transfer of knowledge obtained in the ISTP-U course, an anonymous survey was conducted. A total of 1,103 out of 3,904 members who attended the course in 2012 responded to this survey. Respondents indicated that the learning opportunity provided them with skills that they applied in the performance of their duties. Officers indicated that they are better able to effectively articulate themselves and are better able to present information in a confident and professional manner when engaging stakeholders. The feedback provided by officers indicated that they have applied knowledge acquired form the course from all three domains of learning: cognitive, affective, and psychomotor. The following charts provide a detailed breakdown of the responses to the In Service Training Program course survey. I have applied the knowledge gained from the course in performing my duties within the Service. I feel that the learning acquired has helped me to improve my overall confidence. 87% 90%

When you took the course in 2012, which Unit were you assigned? Criminal Investigation Bureau School Resource Traffic Youth Crime/Family Violence Primary Response Unit Street Crime/Major Crime Community Response Unit Divisional Policing Command (TAVIS) Other Which course topics were you able to apply the knowledge gained? Firearms Training and Provincial Qualification Defensive Tactics Training and Re-qualification (Including Baton annual re-qualification, and O.C. Stream annual refresher) Judgment Training (DST) Wellness: Emotional Survival Human Rights Tactical Communication and Major Mental Disorders Operational Preparedness C.E.W. Re-Certification In what way did you apply your knowledge? As a result of the training, I am more confident in my ability to engage our stakeholders. As a result of the training, I confidently apply the Services procedures when interacting with the public. As a result of the training, I effectively de-escalate conflict situations through the use of tactical communication. As a result of the training, I am able to effect an arrest appropriately. As a result of the training, I utilize the necessary legislative bodies to inform and articulate my actions. As a result of the training, I apply the relevant procedures and remain cognizant of the Charter considerations when performing my duties. 20% 32% 31% 36% 34% 20% 40% 20% 7% 5% 2% 18% 2% 46% 3% 8% 2% 14%

20% 37% 32% 28% 33%

As a result of the training, I am more confident when handling my firearm in the performance of my duties. As a result of the training, I am able to appropriately recognize and respond to persons with various disabilities. As a result of the training, I am able to make proper judgement calls and select the most appropriate use of force option whenever necessary. As a result of the training, I make the better health choices and engage in activities aimed at promoting my overall wellness. TORONTO POLICE COLLEGE SECTION HIGHLIGHTS INVESTIGATIVE TRAINING SECTION

39% 28% 36% 35%

The TPC Investigative Training Section provides criminal investigative, traffic and provincial statute training to officers serving in uniform and detective functions within the Service. The following courses are delivered on an on-going basis by members of the Investigative Training Section: General Investigations Sexual Assault Investigations Child Abuse Investigations Sexual Assault/Child Abuse Update Domestic Violence Investigations Plainclothes Investigations Introduction to Drug Investigations Firearms Investigations Youth Crime Investigations Asset Forfeiture Search Warrant Drafting Death Investigators Major Case Management Powercase (MCM software) Computer and Technology Facilitated Investigations Traffic Generalist Provincial Statutes Pipeline/ Convoy Technical Collision Investigations At Scene Collision Investigations Police Services Act (new) Impaired Investigations (new) Financial Crimes Investigations (new) Interviewing and Interrogations (currently being redesigned)

Appendix A provides a detailed listing of the courses offered by the Investigative Training Section, the number of sessions delivered in 2012, and the number of persons trained. In addition to the delivery of the standard courses described above, the Investigative Training Section in partnership with various police, community and government agencies facilitated the following seminars and workshops. Human Trafficking Seminar The TPC, in partnership with the RCMP, Peel Region Police Service, The U.S. Department of Homeland Security and Customs Enforcement, and the Public Prosecution Service of Canada (Peel Region) hosted three one-day workshops on Human Trafficking in December of 2012 at the TPC. Approximately 646 officers from Toronto and other GTA services received this training. Financial Crimes Seminar The TPC, in partnership with Toronto Police Financial Crimes Unit, Ontario Provincial Police, Ministry of the Attorney General, Canadian Payment Card Partners, and the Toronto Dominion Bank hosted a seminar for frontline officers with regard to financial crimes. The seminar was delivered to front line officers and was designed to provide trends and investigative techniques to officers dealing with modern financial crimes. Approximately 126 officers attended this training. Court Testimony Symposium On May 7, 2012, the TPC, partnered with the Ministry of the Attorney General, The Honourable Lloyd Budzinski, Defence Counsel Joseph Neuberger, and Dr Derick Pallandi, a forensic psychiatrist, to organize a one-day justice symposium on court testimony. This symposium was designed to provide training to frontline officers and investigators on giving credible and reliable testimony. Each speaker provided their own perspective on the skill of articulation for purposes of court testimony. NEWLY DEVELOPED COURSES AND INITIATIVES Interviewing and Interrogation (redesigned as Investigative Interviewing) As a result of a wide-ranging domestic and international consultation process, and recent developments in Canadian case law, the Interviewing and Interrogation Techniques course has been redesigned and renamed. The new course called Investigative Interviewing is an evidencebased approach to gathering information from victims, witnesses and suspects. The course aligns interview training more closely to the extensive body of scientific research that has been conducted in this field over the past thirty years.

This course also incorporates the field experience of foreign and domestic law enforcement agencies that have identified and implemented best practice approaches to investigative interviewing. One such best practice is the PEACE Model, which plays a significant role in the newly designed course. The new course addresses issues that are critical to the difficult task of reliably gathering information from people while effectively managing risk during criminal investigations. Topics covered include the PEACE interview model, the enhanced cognitive interview, the logic of effective questioning, memory, false confessions, tunnel vision, investigative error, wrongful convictions, and statement law. Financial Crimes Investigation Course Based on demand from the field, the TPC has collaborated with the Financial Crimes Unit and selected private sector partners to develop a week long Financial Crimes Investigation course for front line financial crimes investigators. This training will focus on practical and technical issues related to this increasingly complex area of criminal investigation. Topics to be covered will include tracing financial transactions and assets, identifying and securing sources of electronic evidence, investigating synthetic identities, money laundering, mass marketing fraud, and forensic accounting, to name a few. Police Services Act Course Members of the Investigative Training Section, in collaboration with members of the Professional Standards Unit, developed a week long Police Services Act (PSA) Investigators course for Unit Complaint Coordinators and complaint investigators assigned to Professional Standards. This training focuses on criminal and conduct investigations involving civilian and sworn members of the Service. Topics include the PSA and misconduct; Complaint Intake and the OIPRD process; Human Rights Investigations; Investigative Process and Report Writing; Case Law and Procedure, including Investigative Detention, Search Powers, Use of Force and Level 3 searches; Information Security; Labour Relations, including tribunals and grievances; and Prosecution requirements and processes. Guest speakers include Mr. Ken Cormier from the OIPRD, as well as subject matter experts from Professional Standards. Impaired Investigations Investigative Training Section members, in collaboration with subject matter experts from the Crown Attorneys office, Traffic Services, Professional Standards and Arrive Alive Canada developed a new three-day course on Impaired Driving Investigations. Some of the topics include the detection, arrest, processing and testimony specific to impaired driving and related cases. In addition to this course, members of the Investigative Training Section are also currently developing a Commercial Motor Vehicle course with assistance from members of Traffic Services.

Collaborative Training with External Agencies and Community Partners Members of the Investigative Training Section have continued to represent the Service on various committees, including the Sexual Assault Advisory Committee, the Domestic Violence Advisory Committee, the OACP Traffic Sub-committee and the Ontario Major Case Management Working Group. Members also continue to maintain and develop partnerships with various external agencies. These partnerships include the Ministry of Transportation, the Ministry of Community Safety and Security, the Ministry of Revenue, the Alcohol and Gaming Commission of Ontario (ACGO), Correctional Service of Canada, the Ministry of Housing, the Childrens Aid Society (Toronto, Catholic, Jewish and Native), Criminal Intelligence Services Ontario (CISO), Border Enforcement Security Task Force (BEST), Osgoode Hall Law School, Sexual Assault Care Centres, the Centre of Forensic Sciences, Multilingual Community Interpreter Services (MCIS), BOOST, and both public and separate school boards of Toronto. Also, the Child Abuse course continues to be delivered in partnership with the Childrens Aid Society, and the students consist of both Service members and social workers from the agency. In collaboration with the U.S. Southern Poverty Law Centre and the Services Intelligence Division, the TPC Investigative Training Section developed an officer safety training prcis on the fast growing Freeman-on-the-Land (FOTL) movement. FOTL members do not recognize the authority of police, judiciary or the government and are a Canadian manifestation of the radical and violent U.S. Sovereign Citizen movement. This training prcis was distributed to the field and provided officers with education on the movement and a balanced safety strategy for approaching and engaging the Freeman. Investigative Mentorship Network As in previous years, members of the Investigative Training Section deliver lectures on a variety of courses run by other sections within the TPC, including Leadership courses, Recruit training, Coach Officer courses, In Service Training programs, as well as Divisions and Specialized units upon request. Some of the topics covered included Domestic Violence, Sexual Assault Investigations, Investigative Detention, Articulation and Impaired Driving. Instructors also continue to provide assistance, guidance and support to individual members and units upon request. As such, in response to an identified need to assist officers in the development of skills in the area of court preparation and testimony, members of the Investigative Training Section have established the Investigative Mentorship Network (IMN) as a strategy to improve note taking and testimony. The IMN is intended to be a network of front-line and investigative officers throughout the Divisions who are experienced in the investigative process and are willing and able to mentor officers with less experience or who are having difficulty in these areas. The objectives and actions of this strategy are as follows: Conduct effective mock trials; Prepare officers for specific court cases; Mentor colleagues; Provide feedback to TPC on effectiveness of current training strategies; and

Encourage cultural shift wherein officers increasingly discuss and engage in these topics among themselves.

Members of the Investigative Training Section will provide support in the form of organized tutorials, reading materials (i.e., current case law) and assistance with running mock trials.

COMMUNITY POLICING SECTION The Community Policing Section of the TPC is responsible for the delivery of training to all police recruits, as well as training for Service members in the areas of Ethics, Professionalism, Customer Service, Diversity, Coach Officer, Lateral Entry Officers, Auxiliary Police Recruit Training and Electronic Disclosure. The Community Policing Section also assists in the delivery of Human Rights lectures, Investigative training lectures and Wellness lectures on the In Service Training program. The Community Policing Section offers training in Community Mobilization, which introduces the officer to the philosophy and principles of Community Mobilization, as well as Crime Prevention. The goal of this course is to increase community safety and security by enforcing laws, as well as encouraging and supporting citizens to take a more involved approach to becoming an independent and self-sustaining community. The Community Policing Section provides training to front line officers on innovative crime prevention and reduction techniques that will enhance their knowledge and skills to more effectively promote crime prevention within the community, including Crime Prevention Through Environmental Design (CPTED). The Community Policing Section is responsible for the delivery of Wellness programs to Service members (uniform and civilian). The Wellness Sub-Section is responsible for providing programs and training to support the Global Wellness initiatives, which include organizational health, fitness, nutrition, fatigue management and work-life balance. See Appendix A for a detailed listing of the courses offered by the Community Policing Section, the number of sessions delivered in 2012, and the number of persons trained. NEWLY DEVELOPED COURSES The Service is committed to the concept of diversity awareness and inclusivity within the community and workplace. In 2012, the Community Policing Section developed the following courses for civilian members in an effort to develop their skills, as well as to mentor potential supervisors and managers. Organizational Development This course is an intensive three day course designed to enhance the managerial skills of civilian members. The course is offered to civilian members who are currently supervisors or who have demonstrated the potential to be supervisors, as well as any uniform members who are or may be

working with civilian members in a supervisory capacity. The course provides an array of management skills necessary for members interested in supervisory positions. Topics include the discipline process, conduct, conflict resolution, performance appraisals, personnel management, power differentials in groups, emotional healing, note-keeping, and Provincial oversight. Ethics and Inclusivity in the Workplace Ethics and Inclusivity in the Workplace is mandatory for all civilian members of the Toronto Police Service who have not received any former ethics or diversity courses. This training has been updated to ensure awareness of new legislation in the area of human rights, to reinforce the standards of conduct and to discuss the importance of ethical decision making. Topics also include emotional intelligence and post-traumatic stress disorder. This course is offered to all civilian members of the Toronto Police Service. IN SERVICE TRAINING SECTION In keeping with the provincial requirement of Ontario Regulation 926, members must recertify on the use of their firearms and less lethal use of force options at least once every twelve months. Members are required to attend recertification training before the expiry of the date of certification attained during the previous year. Courses which are facilitated by the In-Service Training (IST) Section include the In-Service Training Program, Post-Aylmer Recruit Officer Safety, Plainclothes Tactical Course, Booking Hall Officer Safety, and all officer safety training provided to Court Officers, Auxiliary Officers, and Parking Enforcement Officers. In Service Training Program The IST programs enable officers to comply with the mandatory Provincial Use of Force requirements. These courses provide officers with the tools needed to effectively and efficiently deliver excellent customer service, while constantly maintaining the highest degree of public and officer safety. This training ensures that legal requirements are fulfilled, policies and procedures are reinforced, and operational needs are addressed. Furthermore, this training makes a significant contribution to Service risk management strategies and the critical areas of use of force, crisis resolution, emotionally disturbed persons, tactical communication and professional conduct. The In-Service Training Program consists of two courses, namely the In-Service Training Program Uniform (ISTP-U) and the In-Service Training Program - Investigative (ISTP-I). The ISTP-U is a two-day (20 hours) course that replaced the 2009 Crisis Resolution Officer Safety course. The ISTP-I is a two-day (16 hour) course that replaced the 2009 one-day Use of Force Recertification course. These courses offered a blended format with officers assigned to either course attending on the same dates and receiving the same training. The ISTP-U course is mandatory for all front line officers and members of identified high risk plainclothes units. All other police officers (with the exception of the Senior Officers) attended the ISTP-I.

In Service Training programs continue to build upon the foundations that were established in prior years with the Advanced Patrol Training program, which began in 2001. Over the years, training topics have been identified through research into current policing issues, a review of the Services use of force statistics, identified Priorities and Goals of the Service, and student feedback. The 2012 components delivered were as follows: Defensive Tactics; Firearms Training and Requalification; Dynamic Simulation Training; Operational Preparedness; Tactical Communications and Major Mental Disorders; Wellness Emotional Survival; Human Rights; and CEW requalification.

Use of Force Re-qualification The one-day Use of Force Re-qualification was limited to uniform Senior Officers. The purpose of this training was to re-qualify Senior Officers on their use of force options (firearm and baton) pursuant to Ontario Regulation 926 of the PSA. This training was also designed to enhance officer safety by providing refresher training with respect to tactical communications, defensive tactics, judgement training, Oleoresin Capsicum (OC) Spray, and tactical considerations. Plainclothes Tactical Officer Course The Plainclothes Tactical Officer course is offered to specialized units that normally operate in high risk environments. This training focuses on operational planning, dynamic entries, high risk vehicle stops and wounded officer recovery training. Officers participate in both classroom instruction and practical scenarios involving Dynamic Simunition Training. This course is a three-day (24 hours) program. School Lockdown Frontline Responder Front line officers received highly specialized lockdown training to confront active attackers in a school environment. This training involves a rigorous four-hour session delivered at various schools across Toronto throughout the school year. This training is conducted in partnership with the Toronto District School Board, the Toronto Catholic School Board, Divisional Policing Support Unit and the Emergency Task Force, all of whom participate in various scenarios where a threat has been identified within a Toronto school. This training has evolved from the initial curriculum delivered in 2003. Specifically, this training involves all stakeholders and is intended to provide a quick and effective response to a volatile situation. In 2012, five sessions were delivered to 187 officers from Divisions across the city.

International Deployment Tactical Orientation In 2012, the In Service Training Section, along with members of the Armament Section, provided training to 13 officers who were selected for an international peacekeeping mission to Afghanistan. Included within the training were components of cultural awareness, defensive tactics, firearms, and mission preparation. Court Officer Use of Force Re-qualification and Basic Training Course The Court Officer Use of Force Re-qualification Course re-qualifies Court Officers in their use of force options. This training is also designed to enhance officer safety by providing refresher training with respect to tactical communications, defensive tactics, crisis resolution, OC Spray, tactical training and handcuffing techniques. Annual training is a four-hour block of instruction that court officers must attend within every twelve-month period. There were 59 courses offered in 2012, and 603 Court Officers received this training. Auxiliary Use of Force Training Auxiliary officers continue to provide additional support and assist front line officers with multiple functions on a daily basis. The IST Section ensures that these volunteer members have the knowledge and training to deal with police specific issues. In 2012, ten Use of Force training sessions were delivered to 229 auxiliary members. Booking Hall Safety and Procedure Course The Booking Hall Safety and Procedure course is a two-day course originally designed to address recommendations from inquests, administrative investigations and a 55 Division unit audit. This course is specifically for officers who work in booking halls and/or are in charge of detention areas. With the aid of guest speakers, the course focused on the avoidance and deescalation of in-custody situations. The components covered within the program include crisis and de-escalation management, Service procedures, in-custody legal issues, along with practical scenarios. There were nine courses delivered in 2012, and 144 officers received this training. See Appendix A for a detailed listing of the courses offered by the In Service Training Section, the number of sessions delivered in 2012, and the number of persons trained. NEWLY DEVELOPED COURSES AND INITIATIVES 2012 In Service Training Program - Mental Health and Emotionally Disturbed Persons Component In 2012, members of the In Service Training Section designed a human rights component for the 2013 In Service Training Program. This component focused on Emotionally Disturbed Persons through the creation of video profiles featuring members of Voices from the Street, a community-based advocacy group. The video showcases community members sharing their difficulties and struggles with mental health and illness, and were designed to create a sense of empathy and understanding, and to de-stigmatize mental illness. The idea for this training, and

its subsequent collaboration, was derived from the partnership between the Toronto Police College and members of the Toronto Police Services Board Mental Health Sub-committee.

In 2012, members of the In Service Training Section assisted members of the Divisional Policing Support Unit with the development of training for Mobile Crisis Intervention Team (MCIT) members. Mobile Crisis Intervention Teams consist of a specially trained mental health nurse from a partner hospital and a police officer. The teams provide a secondary response to calls for service involving individuals experiencing a mental health crisis. This training was delivered in early 2013, also with assistance from members of the In Service Training Section, and covered a wide range of medical and forensic topics designed to enhance the effectiveness of the police officer and nurse partnership. Topics discussed included consumer-survivor perspectives, and de-escalation and client support. Both police officers and nurses attended this training. ARMAMENT SECTION The Armament Section, through the Armament Officer, is responsible for approving, setting and maintaining standards of firearms training, qualification and tactical training exercises for Service members. The Armament Section is also responsible for the purchase and maintenance of firearms and ammunition for the Service. The section further undertakes the research and review of new officer safety equipment for Service members. Conducted Energy Weapons Program The Armament Section, in conjunction with the In Service Training program, co-ordinates and manages the Conducted Energy Weapons (CEW) program for the Service. The CEW program was expanded to front-line supervisors in 2007, following a successful pilot program in 2006 (Min. No. P281/06 refers). It is a regulatory requirement for police officers to re-qualify on their CEW at least once every twelve months. Shotgun Re-qualification This course is designed to re-qualify members on the police shotgun, as required by the PSA Regulation 926. Learners must demonstrate competence and confidence in the use of the shotgun, as evaluated by instructional staff and must pass a practical proficiency test. Glock Pistol Training and Recertification The majority of Service officers are issued the standard Glock G22 .40 calibre pistol. The requirement for recertification is mandated by PSA Regulation 926 and Service Policy. The In Service Training and Armament Sections, through the In Service Training program courses, provide pistol recertification training to Service members. The Armament Section also provides Glock G27 Compact Pistol courses to specialized and approved members of the Service who require a small, easily carried and concealed pistol.

C8 Carbine and MP5 Submachine Gun Courses Specific units and members of the Service have been identified as requiring the use of specialized heavy weaponry, including the C8 Carbine and MP5 Submachine gun. While the Emergency Task Force (ETF) conduct their own firearms training and certification in-house, other units such as the Hold-up Squad, Intelligence, Drug Squad, and Guns and Gangs rely on the Armament Section for this specialized training. Recruit Firearms Training The In Service Training and Armament Sections provide police recruits with Glock pistol training before departing to the Ontario Police College (OPC) as part of the two week preAylmer recruit program. One course was delivered to 81 recruits in December 2012. After completing OPCs Basic Constable Training program, police recruits return to the TPC to complete the six-week post-Aylmer program. The post Aylmer program includes three days of pistol training. During this course, recruits are required to pass the Services firearms standards, as well as complete two days of Shotgun training and qualification. No post-Aylmer firearm training was delivered in 2012. See Appendix A for a detailed listing of the courses offered by the Armament Section, the number of sessions delivered in 2012, and the number of persons trained. POLICE VEHICLE OPERATIONS The purpose of Police Vehicle Operations (PVO) training is to advance the learners cognitive and psychomotor driving skills. This training enhances the learners driving skills, while considering multiple impact factors such as location, environment and skill level. The PVO team continued to deliver training to members of the Service throughout 2012. The key training programs delivered to members, including front line supervisors, were the Police Officers Driving Course and the Safe Skills and Emergency Driving Course. These proactive risk management initiatives were designed to deliver practical driver training to all front line officers. Suspect Apprehension Pursuits (SAP), which are governed by Ontario Regulation 546/99, comprise a significant component within PVO training. This regulation establishes detailed guidelines regarding police pursuits, which includes when and how pursuits are to be commenced and continued. SAP training is a mandatory requirement for any officer who may be engaged in a pursuit. SAP training was delivered to all Communication Dispatchers as an annual requalification, on all Coach Officer Courses, and to newly promoted front line supervisors. This course strongly emphasis alternatives to pursuits, such as strategic following and the importance of considering whether the need to apprehend outweighs the risk to public safety. The PVO team also provides specialized training in emergency driving to increase officer safety and reduce the risk to the public through collision avoidance. PVO is also responsible for delivering training on various other types of police vehicles, such as all-terrain vehicles, bicycles, wagons, community station vehicles and motorcycles. PVO members also deliver training for the

Services bicycle program. PVO continues to recognize the importance of other vehicles in assisting with the day to day functions of the Service, and strives to develop staff and build relationships with outside agencies to improve course development and the level of training offered to members of the Service. See Appendix A for a detailed listing of the courses offered by the Police Vehicle Operations Section, the number of sessions delivered in 2012, and the number of persons trained.

LEARNING DEVELOPMENT AND STANDARDS SECTION The Learning Development and Standards Section (LD&S) provides training to both uniform and civilian members of the Service. The section is responsible for e-learning, trainer accreditation, adult education, records coordination, field training supervisors: the Learning Network (TLN), and Quality Assurance (QA). When requested, the LD&S section provides assistance with reaction and learning evaluations for internal and external conferences. LD&S members manage training records in accordance with Provincial Adequacy Standards and the Services Skills Development and Learning Plan. The LD&S section is also responsible for the overall QA requests. This is a joint management of risk and liability. Through the QA initiative, LD&S assures that quality related activities are being performed without compromising the standards established by the Service and the TPC. Instructor Accreditation Program In 2007, the Humber College Teaching Effectiveness certificate program was selected as a program to accredit the Services trainers. This program forms the minimum qualification for instructors at the TPC and units with training cadres. The program is comprised of six courses that are each designed for individuals required to deliver training and facilitate the learning environment of adults. All courses are based on the League for Innovation and Humber Learning Exchange Networks (LENs) learning materials. In 2012, courses were offered in an in-class format by instructors from Humber College. The Learning Network Through the Learning Network (TLN), which is made up of supervisors who are directly responsible for training delivered at the unit level (training sergeants), timely and relevant training is provided to front line officers. This training is often delivered through DVD and print mediums. In 2012, five meetings were hosted to ensure that field training supervisors had an opportunity to question learning materials and to deliver consistent messages. This training is often delivered with the assistance of training videos. LD&S members assist with the development of in-house videos and are active members of the Ontario Police Video Training Alliance (OPVTA). See Appendix A for a detailed listing of the courses offered by the Learning Development and Section, the number of sessions delivered in 2012, and the number of persons trained.

NEWLY DEVELOPED COURSES AND INITIATIVES E-learning Courses In 2012, the need to produce shorter and more operational e-learning modules resulted in the acquisition of new computer software to facilitate this objective. The impetus for this need was to have subject matter experts develop presentations that can be quickly turned into e-learning. The first project rolled out was the e-learning module describing updates to the Digital Video Asset Management (DVAM) system. The LD&S section released three e-learning modules in 2012. These modules were Sikh Religion: Items of Religious Significance, Religion of Islam: Items of Religious Significance and IMS 100. The first module completed was the Sikh Religion: Items of Religious Significance elearning module. This course was part of a series of courses developed in response to a Human Rights Tribunal settlement, and members of the TPC worked with the World Sikh Organization to ensure the relevance and accuracy of the information presented. The second module was IMS 100, which was acquired from Emergency Services Ontario (EMO) and offered to members in the place of a full day course. This course was offered to ensure all Service members were able to complete the training by the end of 2012. The third module developed and released in 2012 was the Religion of Islam: Items of Religious Significance module. Members of the TPC worked collaboratively with the Ontario Police College and the Muslim community to ensure the relevance and accuracy of the information being delivered. Adult Learning Courses The Instructional Techniques and Effective Presentation courses were replaced with an Adult Learning Basic course, which gave learners an overview of teaching a lesson or delivering a presentation. Topics dealing with preparation, instructional skills and adult education were introduced. 2012 saw the re-emergence of the Effective Presentation Course and the re-design of the Adult Learning Basics course to form the Effective Teaching for Adult Learners (ETAL) course. The ETAL course is designed to provide members with an introduction to the principles and concepts of adult learning, teaching techniques, and evaluation strategies, which are incorporated when instructing or delivering training on behalf of the Service. The goal of the ETAL course is to incorporate current academic adult learning principles and best practices into all training delivered by the Service. Course Training Standards The LD&S section is responsible for reviewing Course Training Standards (CTS). The CTS is an important descriptor of training and is often disclosed during human rights tribunals, criminal proceedings, and inquests, to name a few. The document provides direction to instructors and is a means of ensuring that the training delivered meets the requirements and standards of the Toronto Police Service. It is an important aspect in managing some of the risks associated with police training. Originally, one member of the section had been assigned to this role; however in 2012, the LD&S section formed a CTS committee comprised of members from all sections

within the TPC. This committee developed a standardized CTS template that incorporated adult learning principles and academic course outcomes and objectives. Tracking System for Internal/External Lectures In 2012, the LD&S section, in conjunction with the Community Policing Section, developed a tracking and vetting process for both internal and external lectures utilized by the training sergeants for unit level training. This system ensures a standardized delivery of approved lecture material across the Service by guest speakers. This tracking is accomplished by having the speakers provide a copy of their topic material to the TPC to be vetted by the appropriate subject matter experts (SME). Once approved, the Speaker is added to a pool of approved lecturers and made available across the Service.

LEADERSHIP AND BUSINESS SYSTEMS SECTION The Leadership and Business Systems section is responsible for the supervisory and management training delivered to Service supervisors and managers. This section is also responsible for managing a number of the Service contracts with external organizations, such as St. John Ambulance and Toronto Emergency Medical Services. The Leadership and Business Systems Section is responsible for the development and delivery of information technology training and instructs members, including new recruits, civilians, and seasoned officers on the applications used throughout the Service. Advanced Leadership In 2012, one session of the Advanced Leadership Course was delivered to uniform and civilian middle managers. This course is an intensive two-week course designed specifically for Service leaders. This course provided an orientation to Service units whose mandates can assist in the management of risk and personnel. Participants were instructed on current leadership theories and practices by academically accredited leaders from within the Service, as well as selected external experts. Executive Development The Service continued its ongoing training for Senior Officers involving a series of sessions addressing current operational and managerial issues. Topics for the 2012 program were delivered by both internal and external subject matter experts, and included training in leadership, performance metrics, emloyee and family assistance programs, critical incidents, early interventions reporting, skills learning and development plans, incident management, and the forfeiture of seized assets. Senior officers were also provided updates on the progress of the 2015 Pan-American Games.

Occupational Health and Safety Along with the on-going Occupational Health and Safety (OH&S) training required by the Occupational Health and Safety Act, the Leadership and Business Systems section continues to facilitate the Joint Occupational Health and Safety training, as well as sector specific instruction, which are required by members of Joint Occupational Health and Safety Committees. Automated External Defibrillator Training Automated External Defibrillators (AED) training continued in 2012. This training, which is part of the Cardiac Safe City program, was coordinated by a member of the TPC and delivered by Toronto EMS personnel. Only members employed at units equipped with an AED completed this course. First Aid Training The TPC continues its partnership with St. John Ambulance for the delivery of CPR and First Aid training to members of the Service. This training was coordinated by a member of the TPC and delivered by St. John Ambulance personnel. Business Systems The Business Systems Training Section (BST) is responsible for the development and delivery of information technology training. This training includes case management and occurrence processing software, financial systems and administrative applications. See Appendix A for a detailed listing of the courses offered by the Leadership and Business Systems Section, the number of sessions delivered in 2012, and the number of persons. NEWLY DEVELOPED COURSES AND INITIATIVES Occupational Health and Safety Training A new one-day occupational health and safety course for Civilian Supervisors was developed and delivered in 2012. This course was met with positive feedback from those who attended. As well, much research was undertaken in an effort to best prepare the Service for anticipated changes to the Occupational Health and Safety Act. Members tasked with OHS training will be monitoring developments from the Ministry and incorporating these changes into the OHS instruction delivered to Service members.

CONCLUSION Service training is an operational activity that supports identified needs, policies and statutes. The positive results measured by the transfer and synthesis of learning, as reported by members,

is evidence that the teaching strategies employed by the TPC have had a positive impact on learners. With a reported transfer of learning ranging from 87% to 100%, this analysis revealed that the training members received throughout 2012 made a difference in their abilities to perform their duties. The TPC is continuing its efforts to meet and exceed the recommendations contained within the 2006 Auditor Generals report entitled, Review of Police Training, Opportunities for Improvement. To this effect, the report attached to this Board Report highlights areas where courses offered at the TPC have continued to evolve to address Service and community needs, as well as incorporate academic adult education best practices. Finally, course delivery strategies have continued to expand and liaisons with Federal, Provincial, and private partners have continued to grow throughout 2012, all of which have enhanced the ability of the TPC to deliver quality and relevant training to members of the Toronto Police Service in a timely and effective manner.

Appendix A 2012 Courses Delivered by Toronto Police College On-Line and Training Videos

Unit TPC TPC TPC TPC TPC TPC TPC TPC TPC TPC TPC TPC TPC TPC TPC TPC TPC TPC TPC TPC TPC TPC TPC TPC TPC TPC TPC TPC TPC TPC

Section ARM ARM ARM ARM ARM ARM ARM CP CP CP CP CP CP CP CP CP CP CP CP INV INV INV INV INV INV INV INV INV INV INV

Title C-8 Carbine Operator Course C-8 Carbine Requalification Glock 27 Compact MP5 Requalification Shotgun Training & Qualification X26 Taser Requalification X26 Taser Training TOTAL Auxiliary Crime Prevention Course Auxiliary Recruit Training Civilian Development Course Community Mobilization Crime Prevention Course Crime Prevention Through Environmental Design eDisclosure Emotional Survival For Civilian Ethics & Inclusivity In The Workplace Organizational Development Course Professionalism in Policing Uniform Coach Officer TOTAL Advanced Search Warrant Seminar Assets Forfeiture Child Abuse Investigators Course Computer and Technology Facilitated Investigations Court Testimony - Symposium Death Investigator Course Domestic Violence Investigator Drug Investigation Financial Crimes Seminar Firearms Investigation Course General Investigators-Blended

Course TF0023 TF0028 TF0010 TU0007 TF0002 TF0024 TF0026 TO6002 TO6001 TH0026 TH0023 TH0021 TH0022 TO0062 TH0027 TH0031 TH0026 TH0009 TM0027 TC0091 TC0009 TC0093 TC0106 TC107 TC0052 TC0042 TC0003 TO0076 TC0081 TC0013

Course Term (Days / Hrs) 4 1 1 1 2 1.5 hrs 1 2 100 hrs 3 5 3 7 1 1.5 hrs 3 3 2 5 3 3 5 5 1 5 3 3 1 3 5 Course Term (Days / Hrs) 1 5 10 8 2 3 5 3 10 5 3

Total Sessions 2 11 4 5 2 114 6 144 1 2 1 2 2 2 25 13 4 6 1 6 65 6 3 5 10 1 5 5 4 1 3 15

Total # of TPS Students Trained 28 82 29 16 21 513 46 735 18 68 18 30 34 29 173 212 49 78 16 118 843 73 128 109 185 181 198 199 107 94 117 308 Total # of TPS Students Trained 231 143 19 138 308 198 190 17 152 25 96 3216

Unit TPC TPC TPC TPC TPC TPC TPC TPC TPC TPC TPC

Section INV INV INV INV INV INV INV INV INV INV INV

Title Human Trafficking Seminar Interview Course Ontario Major Case Management Software Ontario Major Case Management - Full Operation Pipeline / Convoy Plainclothes Course Provincial Statutes Course SACA Update Sexual Assault Investigators Undercover Foundations Course Youth Crime Investigative Course TOTAL

Course TC0105 TC0024 TC0101 TC0102 TO0014 TC0005 TT0020 TC0027 TC0092 TC0057 TC0016

Total Sessions 3 9 3 7 6 4 8 2 5 1 3 109

Unit TPC TPC TPC TPC TPC TPC TPC TPC TPC TPC TPC TPC TPC TPC TPC TPC TPC TPC TPC TPC TPC TPC TPC TPC TPC TPC TPC TPC TPC TPC TPC TPC TPC TPC TPC

Section LBS LBS LBS LBS LBS LBS LBS LBS LBS LBS LBS LDS LDS LDS PVO PVO PVO PVO PVO PVO PVO PVO PVO PVO PVO PVO PVO PVO PVO PVO PVO PVO PVO PVO PVO

Title Occupational Health & Safety for Supervisors PowerPoint 2010 S.A.P. Unit Commander's Course Sector Specific JOHS Training Senior Officer Training Day Supervisory Leadership-Part 2 Systems Applications and Product TPS Links - User TRMS UPG Word 2010 Workstation Orientation TOTAL Adult Learning Basics Effective Presentation Teaching Effectiveness Certification TOTAL Advanced Bicycle Course All Terrain Side-by-Side Course All-Terrain Vehicle Course Auxiliary Vehicle operations Bicycle Instructor Bicycle Patrol Blue Card Civilian Vehicle Operations Command Post Course Community Station Trainers Community Station Operator Train the Trainer Community Station Ops Course Driver Assessment M/C Ops Requalification Course Police Officers Vehicle Ops Safe Skills Emergency Driving Truck & Trailer Class A Truck Operations and Trailer Truck Operations Course Truck Operators - Train the Trainer Uniform Civilian Vehicle Ops

Course TM0045 S00212 S00209 TO0002 TM0103 HU0011 S00162 S00206 S00200 S00211 S00040 LDS001 TM0032 LDS002 TV0057 TV0061 TV0025 TV0024 TV0028 TV0023 TV0052 TV0001 TV0020 TV0011 TV0044 TV0043 TV0040 TV0037 TV0003 TV0042 TV0056 TV0055 TV0019 TV0041 TV0002

Course Term (Days / Hrs) 1 1 4 hrs 2 1 15 2 4 hrs 2 1 1 5 4 90 hrs 4 10 hrs 2 0.5 4 2 1 hr 1 2 2 4 1 1 1 2 1 5 2 2 4 1

Total Sessions 8 7 7 1 2 1 7 2 8 7 1 205 3 4 1 8 4 2 6 1 2 56 29 2 5 1 1 2 17 1 6 63 5 2 20 13 24

Total # of TPS Students Trained 51 100 11 16 164 9 25 10 111 85 3 3004 40 20 11 71 37 8 21 22 23 193 54 3 9 2 1 2 22 4 24 281 5 2 39 31 39

Unit TPC

Section PVO

Title Wagon Trainers Course TOTAL GRAND TOTAL

Course TV0012

Course Term (Days / Hrs) 2

Total Sessions 33 295 1165

Total # of TPS Students Trained 36 858 15501

2012 On-Line Courses Completed

Total Sessions 1 32 72 157 195 92 163 188 326 123 75 31 124 17 125 106 27 192 292 170 36 59 2603 50 61 71 14 9 20 50 118 17 50 14 48 TOTAL OPVTA OPVTA OPVTA OPVTA OPVTA OPVTA OPVTA OPVTA OPVTA OPVTA OPVTA OPVTA Training Training Training Training Training Training Training Training Training Training Training Training OPVTA 024 Fast Lane OPVTA 030 Blue Canaries OPVTA 036 Sins of Testifying OPVTA 037 Crack OPVTA 038 Suspect Apprehension Pursuits OPVTA 052 Notebook Confidential OPVTA 055 Guaranteed Safe Arrival OPVTA 061 Cop's Best Friend OPVTA 063 Active Killers OPVTA 065 Feeney Warrants OPVTA 068 Grow House Menace OPVTA 069 Your Best Witness Total # of TPS Students Trained 35 32 88 296 428 130 1136 549 7248 238 104 31 378 17 197 194 28 6583 7498 771 39 62 26082 56 64 82 14 9 21 52 164 17 56 14 49

Unit CPKN CPKN CPKN CPKN CPKN CPKN CPKN CPKN CPKN CPKN CPKN CPKN CPKN CPKN CPKN CPKN CPKN CPKN CPKN CPKN CPKN CPKN

Section Training Training Training Training Training Training Training Training Training Training Training Training Training Training Training Training Training Training Training Training Training Training

Title Aboriginal Awareness Characteristics-Armed Person Fatigue Management General Investigative Training - Part 1 Healthy Eating Human Trafficking ICCS Update Training Identifying Staged Collisions IMS 100 In-Car Camera 2010 In-car Camera Operator 2009 Infectious Disease-Pandemic Interac Fraud Prevention Interviewing LGBT Racially Biased Policing Recog Emotionally Disturbed Person Religion of Islam: Item Religious Significance Sikh Religion: Item Religious Significance Source Management Stolen Innocence Suspect Apprehension Pursuits

Unit OPVTA OPVTA OPVTA OPVTA OPVTA OPVTA OPVTA OPVTA OPVTA OPVTA OPVTA OPVTA OPVTA OPVTA OPVTA OPVTA OPVTA OPVTA OPVTA OPVTA OPVTA OPVTA OPVTA OPVTA OPVTA OPVTA OPVTA OPVTA OPVTA OPVTA OPVTA OPVTA OPVTA OPVTA OPVTA OPVTA OPVTA OPVTA

Section Training Training Training Training Training Training Training Training Training Training Training Training Training Training Training Training Training Training Training Training Training Training Training Training Training Training Training Training Training Training Training Training Training Training Training Training Training Training

Title OPVTA 070 Cond Sentences OPVTA 078 Edged Weapons OPVTA 079 Live Wires OPVTA 082 Meth Labs OPVTA 083 First Off at Scene OPVTA 087 Char of Armed Pers OPVTA 088 Cooperative Driving OPVTA 090 Suicide Intervention OPVTA 091 Death Notification OPVTA 096 Child Exploitation OPVTA 097 Seized Firearm Safet OPVTA 098 Field Interviews OPVTA 100 Debit/Credit Fraud OPVTA 104 Domestic Violence OPVTA 104 Foot Pursuit OPVTA 105 Terrorism OPVTA 106 Comm Diseases OPVTA 107 Motorcycle Enforcement OPVTA 109 Spont Disorder OPVTA 110 Prescr Drug Enf OPVTA 112/113 Faith Diversity OPVTA 115 Sex Offenders OPVTA 116 Building Searches OPVTA 117 Psychosis OPVTA 118 Warrantless Search OPVTA 119 Liquor License Act OPVTA 120 Use of Force OPVTA 121 Training to Succeed OPVTA 122 Search of Persons OPVTA 123 Firearm Seizures OPVTA 124 From Call to Court OPVTA 125 The Balanced Life OPVTA 126 Obstruct Police OPVTA 127 CEW Tactics OPVTA 128 Trauma Doesn't Bleed OPVTA 129 Suspect Pursuits OPVTA 130 Social Media Pol OPVTA 131 Entry Warrants TOTAL GRAND TOTAL

Total Sessions 59 67 44 58 50 57 47 49 52 2 46 49 54 33 66 52 41 53 44 32 40 33 34 24 31 48 44 39 5 43 3 80 82 61 70 70 80 72 2336 4939

Total # of TPS Students Trained 66 79 50 62 55 66 48 53 55 2 46 49 65 38 78 59 43 54 48 32 44 40 35 25 34 52 48 42 5 44 3 89 96 66 76 96 104 92 2637 28719

2012 Front Line Training Videos

Course Name Rappel Instructors Course ETF Supervisory Leadership Part II Microsoft Excel Level 1 Course Code TO0013 HU0011 S00210 Session Number 1201 1202 1201 Name of Film Sanctum 12 Oclock High 1. Get to work in Excel 2010 2. Work with file in Backstage view 3. Do the basic on the home ta 4. Math, anywhere 5. Commands when you need them 6. Use of the keyboard 7. Keep your favourite buttons visible 8. Work between new and old Excel versions MCIS- Lost in Translation Feb 9, 2012 MCIS- Lost in Translation Apr 12, 2012 1. MCIS- Lost in Translation 2. The Other Guys MCIS- Lost in Translation

Domestic Violence Investigator Domestic Violence Investigator Sexual Assaults Investigators Sexual Assaults Investigators

TC0024 TC0024 TC0092 TC0092

1201 1202 1201 1202

APPENDIX B 2012 Courses Completed by External Units and Continuing Education Programs/Courses and Seminars
Course Term (Days/Hrs) 2 3 150 hrs 24 3 1 0.5 4 hrs 1hr 0.5 hrs 0.5 hrs 0.5 hrs 4 hrs 1 hr 1 hr 1.5 hrs 1 hr 1 hr 1 hr 1 hr 2 hr 1 hr 1 2 hrs 4 1 2 hrs 20 5 5 2 5 5 35 Total Sessions 2 1 1 1 1 28 39 20 1 2 1 4 1 1 4 8 2 2 3 1 2 1 1 6 5 1 9 1 1 1 1 1 1 7 TPS Students Only 39 10 18 22 16 259 252 351 15 29 13 47 5 30 52 101 35 26 37 11 37 17 55 242 110 19 364 5 5 7 6 4 6 89

Unit B&C COMM COMM CRT CRT CRT CRT CRT DT DT DT DT DT DT DT DT DT DT DT DT DT DT DMU DMU DMU DMU EFAP ETF ETF ETF ETF ETF ETF FIS

Title Budgeting Course Com Op Coach & Mentoring Course Police Com/ Call Taker Course Court Officer Course DNA Data Bank Training CPR Recertification/Court Services Only 2012 Court Off - Use of Force 2013 Court Officer U of F Requalification D11 Impaired Driving Lecture D11 Al-Anon & Alateen Presentation D11 Alzheimer Society of Toronto D11 TCH Presentation D11 TTC ES&ETST Proceeds of Crime-FCU Impound & Towing Presentation D23 Provincial Prosecutors Off Professional Standards Unit Awareness Pearson Airport Intel Unit Awa Sexual Assaults Investigations D53 Social Media Training D54 Prov Prosec-POT Use D54 LLA Licensed Premises Inspection DMU-Invisible Disabilities Workshop Drop-by-Drop: Human Rights DMU-Human Rights WIT Workshop DMU- Cultural Intel Development Program EFAP-Supervisory Training Basic Tactical Operations ETF Advanced Rappel (Master) ETF Rappel Instructors Course ETF Hostage Rescue ETF Advanced Sniper/Observer Course ETF Urban Sniper Ops ETF Scenes of Crime Officers Course

Course TO0024 TO0044 TS0002 T00001 TC0033 TR0002 TU0063 TU0069 LPE009 LPE010 LPE014 LPE022 LPE023 LPI010 LPI015 LPE012 LPI003 LPI004 LPI007 OPV001 LPE013 LPE024 TM0104 TO0058 TO0075 TO0077 TO0072 TO1001 TO1002 TO1003 TO1004 TO1010 TO1015 TC0048

Unit FIS MAR PDS PDS PDS PEMU PMO PMO PMO PSU PSU PSU PSU PSU PSU PSU PSU PSU TPS TSV TSV TSV TSV TSV TSV TSV TSV TSV TSV TSV YIPI

Title Intellibook/Livescan Fingerprint MAR Basic First Aid PDS - Gen Purpose Dog Training PDS - Quarry Course PDS - Drug & Firearm Detection Dog Property & Evidence Management Project Management Fundamentals Project Management Getting Started Microsoft Project Essentials PSU Basic Tactical Course PSU Tactical Trainer Course PSU-CBRN PRU Awareness Course PSU Incident Management System 200 PSU Incident Management System 300 PSU Basic Emergency Management PSU POU Less Lethal Weapons PSU Incident Management System 100 PSU - 2010 Block A Training Social Media in Communications Child Restraint Technician Course Traffic Collision Photography TS ASD Alcotest 6810 SFST-Stand Field Sobriety Test At Scene Collision Invest Technical Collision Invest. Collision Reconstruction Speed Measuring Radar Laser - Lidar Traffic Generalist Course Mobile Radar YIPI 1st Aid & CPR/AED TOTAL

Course TO0039 TO2011 TO0007 TO0008 TO0051 S00208 TO0033 TO0034 TO0036 TO3001 TO3002 TO3005 TO3008 TO3009 TO3011 TO3012 TO3015 TO3019 S00215 TO0030 TO0048 TO0073 TO5003 TT0001 TT0002 TT0005 TT0012 TT0014 TT0017 TT0027 TR0033

Course Term (Days/Hrs) 2 2 63 5 40 2 hrs 2 1 2 10 3 2 2 2 3 2 1 2 3 2 10 0.5 hrs 1 10 10 15 1 1 5 1 8 hrs

Total Sessions 31 1 2 10 1 3 1 2 1 1 1 2 8 3 9 2 14 5 4 1 3 62 1 4 1 1 11 68 8 38 3 463

TPS Students Only 291 9 2 10 1 13 14 34 14 27 6 40 104 27 92 29 136 284 83 3 6 1952 21 69 9 6 11 83 173 43 144 6070

Continuing Education Programs/Courses and Seminars

Title 11th Annual Ont Gang Inv Assoc '12 CAN Critical Incident Conf '12 Corp Secur Lias Committee '12 Intl Conf. Youth in Focus '12 ON Homicide Inv Assoc Wksp '12 Police Dog Explos Imprint 12th Anniv Drug Edu Conference 13th Ann Employment Law Summit 14th Ann Fugitive Conference 15th Labour & Employ Law Sympo 1st Resp Op Hazardous Material 2012 Arson Task Force Seminar 2012 CPO Forum Outsourc. Wksp 2012 Diversity Committee Trg. 2012 Int Conf on Sex CrimesInv 2012 Joint EDU Training 2012 MIAA Spring Workshop 2012 Morphotrack User Edu Conf 2012 OACP Hate Crime 360 Sympo 2012 OACP Traffic Seminar 2012 OAPE Annual Conference 2012 OCAP Annual Meeting 2012 ON Public Buyers Assoc 2012 Ont Gang Inv Assoc 2012 OPTVA AGM APT Trging Conf 2012 PRS and SIU Conf. 2012 Sex Crimes Inv Conferenc 2012 Versadex Users Conference 23rd Sched 2 Empl Group Conf 28th Annual Intoxilyzer Users 4th Ann.Alcohol & Gaming Wkshp 5th Annual IRG Conf & Masters 6th Ann NY/EC Chapter Training 9th Ann Safe Schools Seminar 9th Intl Conf Asian Org Crime Total Sessions 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 4 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 TPS Students Only 4 1 3 1 6 4 6 1 11 5 1 5 1 1 2 2 6 4 4 6 12 1 1 1 3 39 31 10 4 2 1 1 2 3 3

Title A New Frontier in Crim Law Sem Abuse and Harass in Workplace Access Data Wind Fore 7 Trg Accounting Basics Accouting 1 ACL Certified Training Addict, Criminal. & Mental ill Adjudicator & Prosectuion Sem Administrative law Administrative Law Anl. Update Adobe Acrobat Forms Adobe Live Adujudicator & Prosecution Sem Adv Adobe Acrobat X Pro Adv Communications Technique Adv Computer Forensic Wksp Adv Crime Prev. thro Envir Des Adv Foowear Impression Compare Adv Friction Ridge Analysis Adv Missing Persons & ID Remai Adv Photoshop for Photographer Adv. Internet Child Exploitat. Advance Blood Pattern Analysis Advanced Digital Imaging Advanced Digital Photography Advanced Footwear Analysis Advanced Pipelin/Convoy Advanced Proceeds of Crime Advanced Render Safe Procedure Advanced Tire Analysis Advanced Undercover Techniques Advd Pipeline CMV Crse Air Craft Investigation Al-Anon & Alateen Presentation ALEA Thermal Imagery Cert. Alzheimer's & Related Dementia American Sign Language

Total Sessions 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 2 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1

TPS Students Only 1 2 2 1 1 2 1 6 1 1 1 12 1 8 2 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 2 2 1 6 2 1 2 5 1 1 10 5 10 1

Title American Sign Language 101 American Sign Language 102 Annual Police Labour Conf. Annual Update on Human Rights AODA Applied Behaviour Anal II Applied Forensic Videography Applied Research Methods II APT - Investigative Detention APT - Law Drinking and Driving APT - Srch Seizure w/o Warrant Arrive Alive Drive Sober Coun Asoc of Pub Com off APCO Can ASP Baton Course ASP Tactical Baton Instructor Assessing Police Learning Asset Forfeiture Asset-Based Policing make Diff Auditing in Law Enforc. Org. Auto Criminal Intel Info Sys. Avaya Aura Contact Ctr Admin Avoiding the Legal Pitfalls Bachelor of Applied Arts Bar Asoc Litigat. Charter Aps Basic Blood Pattern Recog. Basic Emergency Management Basic Investigation Skills Beat the Bugs and Biosecurity Beretta Armourers Course Bike on the Bricks Training Bloodstain Patt Analysts Conf. Breaching Course Breaking Silence/Mental Health Build. Crime Resist. Community Business Analyst Essentials Business Continuity Planning

Total Sessions 1 1 1 1 158 1 1 1 3 1 2 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1

TPS Students Only 2 1 1 1 1136 1 2 1 3 1 2 6 2 19 1 1 2 3 1 1 3 1 1 1 2 1 1 2 1 3 2 1 1 1 2 1

Title Business Writing for Results CA Assoc of Fire Inv. Seminar CA Police Airport Command Conf CA Police Chaplian Assoc Trg Cable Des Princ Install Pract. CAMH Sexual Beh Clinic Edu Day CAN Ident Society Ann Edu Conf Can Internet Child Exploitatio CAN Payroll Assoc Conference Canadian Criminal Justice Canadian Socal Problems Canadian Tactical Trg Conf. CAPP Seminar CBRN-E Live Agent Training Cdn Firearm Registry:PO Safety Cdn Rail Incident Inv Guide Centr Missing & Exploit Child Cert. Forensic Computer Exam. CEW Instr Trainer Course Chem Treatment and Fluors Tech Child Seat Installation Course CISNB Human Source Workshop Civil Mili Sem on Hum Dis Resp Clan Lab for Support Workers Clan Lab Inv. Recertification Clan Lab. for Support Services Clandestine Lab Investigation Clandestine Lab Seminar Close Protection Course Close Protection Operator Cmptncy-based Mgt for Policing Cnducted Enrgy Weapons Oper Coach Officer Training Cognos Report: Studio Collaborative Governance College Writing Skills

Total Sessions 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 6 1 1 2 2 8 1 1 1 2 1 1 1 1 2 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 5

TPS Students Only 1 1 1 1 2 1 1 1 1 1 13 6 1 15 2 8 1 2 1 3 4 1 1 5 8 2 14 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 5

Title Com. with Diplomacy and Prof. Comm. Centre Supervisors Community Ass. Team Comp. & Tech Facilit. Invest. Complete Business Analysis Computer Science 2 Conflict Resolution Conform to IIA Quality Standar Contemporary Canadian Issues COTS FSA Cus Fac Acc Test Counter Narc Intell. Analysis Counterfeit & Fraud Workshop Covert Operations Handler Covert Video Course 2012 CPA Employee of Self-Employed CPIC Query Narrative CPKN Natl Advisory Board Meet. CPTED Acred. and Cert. CPTED Trg Basic and Adv. Level Crime Analysis Application Crime and Opportunity Crime Prev. thru Envir. Design Crimes Against Children Conf. Criminal Code Criminal Intelligence Analysis Criminolgy Criminological Theory Criminological Theory II Crisis Intervention Conf 2012 Crisis Intervention Team Intl. Crisis Negotiators Critical Reflect. in Adult Edu Critical Thinking Advanced Crown Attny Div Trg Articula Crtcl Incdnt Stress Mgt (FR) Crush Energy Analysis Course

Total Sessions 1 2 1 1 1 1 2 1 1 1 1 1 2 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 2 1 2 1 1 2 1 1 3 1 1 109 1 1

TPS Students Only 1 3 2 1 1 1 2 1 1 3 1 5 9 1 1 1 1 1 1 5 1 1 4 1 20 5 1 12 2 1 3 1 1 215 1 1

Title CSIS Domestic Extrmism seminar Cultural Intell Develop Wkshop Current Legal Issues Curric Dsgn for Adult Learners CVSA Lvl 1 Inspect. Course Cybercrime -Dig. Terror/Crime Dallas Children's Advoc Ctr Data Structures Death Investigation Deception Detection Tech Deeley Harley-Davidson Defensive Tactical Seminar Design & Devel Mic. Sharepoint Design Metadata Models V10.1 DIFLE Course Digital Imaging Enhancement Digital Surveillance Photograp Digital Tech for Investigators Dir. Read Supply Chain Mgmt I Disaster Risk Management Dispute Resolution Div. Pop and Applied Settings Diversity at Work 2012 DMU-Human Rights Inv Workshop DNA Data Bank Sample Coll. DNA Forensic Evidence Sympos. Dom Viol. - High Risk Proj Sem Domest and Workplace Violence Domestic Violence in Wkplace Domestic Violence Investigator Domestic Violence Trainer Drinking and Driving Drive Clean Insp/Repair Techn Drive Clean Inspector Drug Investigation Drug Investigative Techniques

Total Sessions 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 3 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 5 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 124 2 2 5 1

TPS Students Only 6 1 1 3 1 1 1 1 4 3 1 2 1 2 1 1 2 6 1 1 1 1 3 1 2 1 2 1 1 1 1 181 3 3 10 4

Title DVAM System Update East CAN Robbery Inv. Seminar E-Government Elder Abuse Conference Electronic Purchasing OPBA Electronics Technician Program English Enhancing Gender Diversity Enterprise Arch Tool Fun Train Enterprise Architecture Summit Environmental Science Equity, Policy, Law & Planning ESRI Canada User Conference Ethics & Justice System Ethics, Org. Value & Profesion EU Study Tour Excel Beyond the Basics Semina Excited Delirium Syndrome Executive Strategic Mangmnt Explosives Disp Conf EDCON '12 Explosives Tech & Radiography Face of the Offender Face to Face CRTC Emer Sys GR Family Stat. & Duty to Accomod FBI - Law Enforc. Exec. Trg. FBINAA NY/EC Chapter Training Fd Parolees & Corrections Team Federal Legislation Fight Fraud on the Front Line Fin. Inv - Payment Card Fraud Finance Financial Inv Investment Fraud Firearms ID for Public Agents Firearms Ident for PO Firearms Inv Firearms Verification

Total Sessions 175 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 2 2 1 1 1 9 1 1 1 2 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 10 1 8 2 1 1 11 20 38 1

TPS Students Only 755 13 1 4 1 1 1 1 21 2 1 1 2 26 2 1 3 2 1 2 1 2 2 1 3 8 11 3 8 4 1 1 12 22 41 1

Title Force Science Certification Forens. Trg in Child Abuse Inv Forensic Evidence Collection Forensic ID Pre-course Forensic Identification Forensic Identification Off. Forensic Mental Health for Pro Forensic Post Disaster Proced. Forensic Shooting Scene Examin Found. of Adult Education Fraud Investigation French Beginner - 2 Friction Ridge Identification Frnsic Coll & Rcv Human Remain Frontline Supervisor "Org Skil Frontline Supv Leadership Frontline Supvr Org Skills Frontline Supvr Perf Mgmt Frontline Supvr Self-Manage Gang & Org Crime Prof Dev Con Gang Investigation Gang Investigators Gang& Crime Prof Dvlp Conf Geneva Centre for Autism Intl. Gigatribe Training Global Collaborative Teams Global Economic Environment Global Issues in Business Gov't Video Expo Graffiti Investigation GREAT Gang Resist Edu & Trg Great Grammar, Painless Proofr Great Lakes Motorcycle Seminar Hate Crime Adv Training Hate Crimes Awareness High Perform Business Writing

Total Sessions 1 1 1 1 2 1 1 1 1 2 4 1 2 1 1 14 7 7 7 4 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 5 1

TPS Students Only 1 1 1 1 3 2 1 2 2 2 6 1 5 1 1 14 7 8 7 14 2 3 5 1 2 1 1 1 3 1 2 1 7 5 5 1

Title Homemade Explosives Homicide Honour Based Violence HR Workplace Investigative Wrk Human Resource Dvlp Human Resource Management Human Resource Mgmt Principles Human Rights Inv. Training Human Rights Invest Workshop Human Rights Workplace Human Source Development Human Source Dvlp HUSAR Canine Certification IAFCI Crime Investigators Conf IBM Cognos B1 Overview v 10.1 IBM Cognos, Ad Hoc Reports IBM Info on Demand 2012 ICAC National Conference IIA Gov. Relat. Edu Sessions IIA National Conference 2012 IIA Toronto Ch '12, Edu Series Impact of Family Violence Conf Impct Fam Violenc, South Asian IMS IMS 150 Independent Study-Penal Policy Info and Comms Tech Commit. Info Mgmt, Access & Privacy Insp. & Maint. Storage Racks Install & Server Admin Rel8.50 Instructional Strategies Instructor Update Int Assoc of Women Police Conf Int Conf on Sex Crimes Inv Int Outlaw Motorcycle Gang Inv Interception of Private Comm.

Total Sessions 2 2 3 1 1 13 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 2 1 1 1 1 1 4 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1

TPS Students Only 2 3 20 1 1 26 1 1 3 1 3 1 4 1 1 1 1 7 6 1 2 8 1 4 1 1 1 2 2 1 1 1 3 3 1 4

Title Intergraph Pub. Safety User Intermediate Incident Manage. Internal Audit - Looking Frwrd International Policing Policy Internet Examiner Cert. InterProv Organize Crime Forum Intl Airport Inv Training Symp Intl Assoc of Crime Analy Conf Intl Fugitive Invest. Conf. Intl PADI certification Intro Criminal Intel Intro to Christianity Intro to Crime and Justice Intro to Criminal Intelligence Intro to Greek Culture/Society Intro to Incident Mgmt Syst Intro to Intelligence Intro to Mobile Surveillance Intro to Operational Planning Intro to Politics Intro to Production Orders Intro to Roman History Intro to Sociology Intro to Undercover Tech. Introduction to C and UNIX Introduction to Intelligence Introduction to Politics Introduction to Undercover Tec Inv Commercial Veh Collisions Inv Interviewing Techniques Inv. Conf. on Sex Crimes Inv. Inv. Interview. Research Group Inv. Interviewing Techniques Investigation & Report Writing Investigative Interviewing Investigative Techniques

Total Sessions 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 2 2 4 1 2 1 1 1 2 1 1 3 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 2

TPS Students Only 1 1 2 1 1 1 5 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 2 7 38 25 2 1 1 1 7 1 3 4 1 2 2 1 1 2 2 3 5

Title Issues - Public Administration Issues in Community Policing Issues in Public Administratio IT Service Managment Certifica ITIL Foundations v3 ITIL Prac- Plan, Pro, Opt JS:Lift Truck Operators Theory JSOP Officer Program Justice Management Key Issues in Int. Terrorism Labour Relations Course Leadership Development Leadership Enhance Course A Leadership Essentials Leading Transformation Learning Pedagogies Legal Computer Applications Lift Truck Operations Refresh LPO Faculty Development Lunch & Learn Kronos Telestaff Major Case Management Command Major Cities Chief Major Crime Investigative Tech Major Events Security Major Ldership Research Paper Manage and Design for Security Management Accounting Managerial Finance Managing Garnishments Managing Inv. Using Powercase Master's Thesis course Masters Thesis Part I Mayfest 2012 ON Assoc for Deaf Media Relations MFOA- Reserves & Reserve Funds Mgmt of Excited Delerium

Total Sessions 1 8 1 1 1 1 1 1 2 1 1 1 1 1 1 4 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1

TPS Students Only 1 13 1 1 9 1 1 2 2 1 1 1 1 1 1 5 1 16 1 1 1 1 4 1 1 2 1 1 1 7 1 1 1 1 1 2

Title MIAA Fll Workshop 2012 Mic. Access 07 - Adv Datab Des Mobile Surveillance Course Mobile/Internet Game Developm Modern Standard Arabic lvl 3 MS Share 2010- Intro MTUG and APCO Conference N. Amer Police Equestrian Conf National Can Marine Adv Coun NENA Conference Network+ Certified Niagara Counterfeit FRD Wkshop NLE Child Exploitation Trning Non Profit Financ. Report Conf OACP - Wkplace Abuse & Harass. OACP 2012 Hate Crime 360 OACP 4th Alcohol & Gaming Wksp OACP Const Select. System Symp OACP Finance Budget Meeting OACP Liqour and Gambling Wkshp OACP Media Relations Officer OALEP 2012 Fall Symp OALEP 2012 Spring Busines Symp OAPE Annual Fall Meeting OAPSB Section 31 Fall Seminar OAPSB Sem - HR issues & Beyond Office of the Fire Marshall OH&S: Frontline Officer OH&S: Supervisor OHS: Frontline Officer OMBI Spring Forum ON Equestrian Fed Instr Test ON Equestrian Federation Conf ON Prov Strat Multi-Discip Trg ON Safety League Driving Instr ONGIA Conference

Total Sessions 1 2 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 3 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 3 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1

TPS Students Only 1 2 3 1 1 2 1 4 1 2 1 2 1 1 5 12 29 2 1 5 1 2 1 1 1 1 1 3 1 1 2 4 2 12 1 29

Title ONPEA GTA Conference 2012 Ont Gang Inv Conf Ontario Politics/Government Ontario Traffic Parking Wkshp Open House and Net. Meeting Operations Management OPP Home Explosive Workshop OPP Sniper Course Organizational Behavior Organized Crime OSHF 2012 Conf. and Meeting Ost/Shal Grave Rec Workshop Overview of Assessment & Eval. OWLE Fall Training Day OWLE Ldship & Empowerment OWLE Training Symposium Patrol Carbine Instructor Payroll Account. for Non-Accou Payroll Balance. and Reconcil. Payroll Essentials PEACE Training Peer to Peer Inv Certification Penn State Recon Training PeopleSoft PeopleCode Rel 8.50 PET Adv Electronics Course PET: Reconstruction & Recog. PFPO Meeting Photographic Techniques Photoshop for Forensics Pipeline Convoy Jetway Course Plng & Mng Windows 7 Environ. Police & Society Police Chaplain Assoc Trg 2012 Police Ethic & Accountability Police Explos Tech Validation Police Fitness Recertification

Total Sessions 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 4 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 3 1 1 3 1

TPS Students Only 3 11 1 11 3 1 1 1 12 1 2 2 1 5 8 1 2 1 1 1 1 3 3 1 2 2 1 1 2 4 1 13 1 1 3 2

Title Police Powers 1 Police Powers 2 Police Resp Track Level Emerg Police Veh Ops Facilitator Police Vehicle Operations Policing in Canada Politics of Work and Labour Portrait Photography 1 Post Blast Inv - Case Study Post Blast Investigation Post Blast Scene Tech PREP Appraiser Course Prevent Bullying-Get the Tools PRO Aquatics Conf Problem Mgmt/ RCA Workshop Prof Devel Wkshp for Supv Professional Dev. Seminar Project Management Professiona Promising Practices - Dom Viol Promoting Cultural Change Wksp Prov Asset Forfeitur Fall Conf Prov. Use of Force Trging Comm PSA, Complaints Res. & HRM Psychology of Law Psychology: Intro Psychology: Social Psychopharmacology of Drugs Pub. Health of Emerg Prep Public Admin. and Leadership Public Admin. Research Methods Public Administration Public Policy Challenges Public Speaking Purchasing Mgmt Assoc Canada Quant. Methods for Soc Sci Quantitative Methods

Total Sessions 1 1 87 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 4 4 1 1 1 1 4 5 1 1 1 7

TPS Students Only 1 1 111 1 1 1 1 1 1 4 2 5 1 1 15 1 1 1 1 2 6 1 5 1 4 5 1 4 1 1 5 27 1 1 1 16

Title Radar Refresher Stationary Radiation Basic Principles Rapid Response to Homicide Pro Reading & Writiing Effectively Recent Appellate Decisions Registry Analysis Workshop Research Methods Research Methods for Soc Sci Research Methods, Alpha Group Reserves and Reserve Funds Resp to Active Shooter Instrct Resp to Homicide & Shockknife Resp to Male Sexual Vicitimiz. Resp to Vics of Ident Crime Risk Management Courses OBPA River Rescue Trainer Cert. ROE Web Safe City Crime Prevent Conf. Safe School Initiative Seminar SAP 4.0 SAP T-T-T Focus Group Search & Rescue Navig. Exercis Search Warrant Seat Belt Course Security Essentials Bootcamp Sem. in Prof. Ethics & Liabil. Seminar in Penal Policy Senior Forensic Identification Senior Police Administration Serial No. Restoration, Intern Sex Offender & Risk Mgmt Conf Sexual Assault Inv Conference Sexual Exploitation of Child. Sexual Violence Sharepoint '10 Applic. Develop Shotgun Instructor

Total Sessions 2 1 1 4 1 1 8 1 2 1 1 1 1 5 1 1 1 1 1 5 1 1 7 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 2 1 1 1

TPS Students Only 2 1 1 12 1 3 14 2 11 1 1 1 1 5 1 1 1 2 1 5 1 2 15 1 1 1 1 2 1 1 1 2 2 1 2 6

Title Sim Elect Navig Ltd Radar SEN1 SiQuest Adv.Int.Forensic Train Site Safety Supervisor Crs. Social Networks - HR Branding Social Return Investment Acred Social Theory Social Unrest Seminar Sociology: Intro Sovereign Citizens Spct Appr Prst v.4 Refshr OL Special Event Planning Crse Spontaneous Edged Weapon Def. St. Johns Ambul. Child Seat Standard FirstcAid/CPR Stanhope - CPKN Statistics-Quantitive Measures Strategic Info System Planning Strategic Leadership Program Structl Collapse Resc lvl 1n2 Substance Abuse/Rest. Justice Tactical Clearing Course Tactical Driving Course Tactical Intelligence Analysis Taser CEW Subcomittee Meeting TASER Use of Force Seminar Teaching Across Generations Team Building Terrism:New Dim Frnt Ln Plcing Terrorist Ideol, Aims, Beliefs Terrorist Modus Operandi The ACIIS Query Online The New Landscape of Fraud Theories of Crime Theories of Risk and Crisis Theories of Techn. & Innovatio Threat Assessment Lvl 2

Total Sessions 1 1 3 1 1 1 1 5 2 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 2 1 1 1 1 1 2 1 1 3 1 1 1 4 1 1 1 1

TPS Students Only 2 1 4 1 1 1 1 5 2 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 2 1 1 3 1 1 2 1 1 3 1 1 1 4 1 1 1 1

Title To Serve and Protect TOGAF 9 Lvl1 & 2 Topic: Drug and Crime Tor. Gangs & Characteristics Toronto Fire/EMS Academy Traffic Officers Trends & Issues in Adult Edu. Trends in Gender Issues Trg on Sexual Violence Prosec. Tribunal Practice & Procedure Ultimate Training Day 2012 Update on Employment Law Urban Gang Dynamics Use of Force Trainer Use of Force Training Committe Vanc. Police Operat. Planning Verifiers Course Virginia Gang Inv Conf. VmWare Install, Config, Manage West Shore Mtd Search Rescue West. Canadian Robbery Inv. Who Else is Listening..? WIFI Tools & Troubleshoot wksp Windows 7 Desktop Supp Technic Wireless Networks Workshop Wise up to Counterfeiting Witness Protection &Relocation Work & Learning in Org. Workplace Inclusion Conference Wrkplace Violence & Harassment Wst Shore Mtd Search & Rescue Year End New Year Legisl Updat Youth in Focus TOTAL

Total Sessions 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 5 1 1 1 1 9 1 2 1 1 1 3 1 1 1 1 1 1 5 1 3 1 1 1 2 1 1575

TPS Students Only 1 1 1 14 1 4 1 25 2 1 5 1 13 7 2 4 1 8 9 1 1 1 2 1 1 5 2 3 8 1 1 4 3 4378

14. May 03, 2013 from William Blair, Chief of Police Re: Annual Report 2012 Service Performance A copy of the complete report has been circulated separately to Board members. May 3, 2013

To:

Chair and Members Toronto Police Services Board William Blair Chief of Police 2012 SERVICE PERFORMANCE REPORT

From:

Subject:

Recommendation: It is recommended that the Board receive the 2012 Service Performance Report. Financial Implications: There are no financial implications relating to the recommendation contained within this report. Background/Purpose: Each year, as part of the strategic planning process, the Service prepares an annual report on the activities of the previous year. The first section of the report provides the results of the measurement of the Service Priorities, using the performance indicators set out in the Business Plan. The second section of the report provides information on the two additional areas required by Section 31 of Ontario Regulation 3/99 (Adequacy and Effectiveness of Police Services). The Board has requested that the Service Performance Year End Report be provided in June of each year (Min. No. P75/06 refers). Discussion: In the 2009-2011 Business Plan, approved by the Board in December 2008, seven priorities were stated. Within these priorities there were eighteen individual goals; for each of the goals, a number of performance objectives/indicators were identified (Min. No. P328/08 refers). In late 2011, given the budget environment and ongoing initiatives (including the City of Torontos Service Efficiency Review and the Chiefs Internal Organizational Review), the Police Services Board approved the extension of the 2009-2011 Service Priorities into 2012, with some revision (Min. No. P320/11 refers). The revision involved the removal of six goals, either

because they were no longer relevant or feasible (for example, the goal dealing with recruiting), or because processes had been put into place to address the issue (for example, the goal dealing with emergency preparedness). The seven priorities, the remaining twelve goals, and the information relevant to each of the indicators for the fourth year of the Business Plan are presented in the 2012 Service Performance Report. To provide context to the measures, updated information is also provided on the activities that were undertaken by Service units to address the goals and priorities. Service performance was assessed by comparing the results of the performance indicators in 2012 with the results from 2008, the year prior to the implementation of the Business Plan. In summarizing Service achievements for 2012, a goal was considered to have been achieved if all of the performance objectives were accomplished; if none of the performance indicators were accomplished, the goal was considered as not achieved. In 2012, the additional year for the revised 2009-2011 Business Plan, most goals (9 of 12) were considered partially achieved. Three goals were considered achieved (that is, all performance objectives were accomplished); no goals were considered not achieved. It should be noted that, for a number of the performance objectives/indicators, the difference between years was occasionally quite small and may not have represented a significant change. The objectives merely require an increase or a decrease, not a specific magnitude of change, to be considered achieved or not achieved. It is also recognized that the results of surveys with a relatively small return rate, such as the agency worker surveys, tend to reflect the views of those who responded rather than the views of the larger population. Over the past four years, the Service has continued to offer new programs, improve existing programs, or simply provide a continuing service in a more efficient or effective manner. However, particularly in 2011 and 2012, significant restraints imposed by reduced staffing levels and decreased funding undoubtedly limited achievements. While not all the Services Goals were fully achieved within the above-noted strict definition of achievement related to the performance objectives, Toronto remains a safe city: crime rates, including the violent crime rate, continued to decrease, and most of the seven major crime indicators were lower at the end of 2012 than they were in the first year of the Plan. Conclusion: At this time, the 2012 Service Performance Report is provided for the Boards information, consistent with the requirements for an annual report in Section 31 of the Adequacy Standards Regulation (Ontario Regulation 3/99). Deputy Chief Mike Federico, Corporate Command, will be in attendance to answer any questions that the Board may have regarding this report.

Respectfully submitted,

William Blair, C.O.M. Chief of Police WB/cw 2102 Service Performance - Board.docx 2012 Service Performance Report.docx

15. May 14, 2013 from Christian Paradis, Minister of Industry and Minister of State Re: Correspondence Response to Recommendation for Legislation - Disabling Stolen Mobile Communication Devices

16. May 24, 2013 from Kathleen Wynne, Premier of Ontario Re: Correspondence Response to Recommendations Pertaining to the Interest Arbitration System in Ontario

17. (A)

June 06, 2013 from Alok Mukherjee, Chair Re: Status of Discussions: Toronto Transit Commission Special Constables and Toronto Port Authority Policing

June 6, 2013

To:

Members Toronto Police Services Board Alok Mukherjee Chair STATUS OF DISCUSSIONS: TORONTO TRANSIT COMMISSION SPECIAL CONSTABLES AND TORONTO PORT AUTHORITY POLICING

From:

Subject:

Recommendations: It is recommended that: (1) The Board receive this report and provide a copy to both the Toronto Transit Commission and the Toronto Port Authority. (2) The Chief of Police ensure that the Board is informed of the progress and the outcome of his discussions with the Toronto Port Authority. Financial Implications: There are no financial implications arising from the Boards receipt of this report. Background/Purpose: As directed by the Board, discussions are on-going with both the Toronto Transit Commission (TTC) respecting the re-establishment of a special constables program (Board Min. P58/12 refers) and with the Toronto Port Authority respecting options for the provision of police officers in the airports United States customs pre-clearance area (Board Min. P100/13 refers). Discussion: TTC Special Constables Board Members may recall that, in October 2010, the Board decided to terminate the agreement with the TTC governing its special constable program. Subsequently, in April 2012, the Board

decided to enter into discussions with the TTC and the Chief of Police with respect to the feasibility of entering into a new agreement regarding a TTC special constable program. For the past few months, legal counsel for the Board, the Service and the TTC have been meeting to discuss the contents of a new agreement between the Board and the TTC which would govern the re-establishment of a special constables program at the TTC. These discussions are progressing well and it is anticipated that once the discussions are concluded, a report will come to the Board recommending the re-establishment of a TTC special constable program and Board approval of an agreement with the TTC for that purpose. Toronto Port Authority At its meeting in April 2013, the Board determined that it would not approve the Toronto Port Authoritys request for armed special constables. In the alternative, the Board decided that I should meet with the Chief and representatives of the Toronto Port Authority (TPA) to consider options to move forward on the TPA's request for policing services. In accordance with the Boards direction, I convened a meeting with Chief Blair, Mr. Angus Armstrong, Harbour Master and Chief of Security, and Mr. Geoff Wilson, President and CEO of the TPA, on May 27, 2013, to discuss the TPAs security needs. Following an extensive discussion, the TPA clarified that its request was strictly and solely to meet the US Customs pre-clearance requirements. With respect to general policing, it was agreed that Toronto Police Service will continue to respond to regular calls for service in the usual way. In terms of moving forward, those at the meeting agreed that representatives of the TPA will work with Chief Blair to finalize the TPA's operational requirements. To that end, the TPA will supply Chief Blair with the specific details of its security needs so that all appropriate options may be considered with a view to identifying the most cost effective alternative. The Chief will keep the Board informed with respect to the progress of his discussions. Once the operational details have been worked out, an agreement will be developed by the Boards legal counsel, in collaboration with the TPA and TPS legal counsel, for consideration by the Board and the TPA, if it is required by the option that is chosen in the TPA's discussions with the Chief. Conclusion: With regard to the TTC special constables program, any re-establishment of the program will require the preparation of a report and an agreement for the Boards consideration and approval. With regard to the policing arrangements for the Toronto Port Authority, the Chief of Police will advise the Board of the outcome of his discussions with the Toronto Port Authority in order that the Board may proceed to the preparation of an agreement with the TPA, if required.

Respectfully submitted,

Alok Mukherjee Chair

A:\TTC_BBTCA

(B)

May 29, 2013 from William Blair, Chief of Police Re: Toronto Port Authoritys Request for Pre-Clearance Staffing by the Toronto Police Service at the Billy Bishop Toronto City Airport

May 29, 2013

To:

Chair and Members Toronto Police Services Board William Blair Chief of Police PRE-CLEARANCE STAFFING BY TORONTO POLICE SERVICE AT TORONTO PORT AUTHORITY

From:

Subject:

Recommendation: It is recommended that the Board receive this report. Financial Implications: There are no financial implications relating to the recommendation contained within this report. Service delivery to the Toronto Port Authority will be on a full cost recovery basis. Background/Purpose: The Toronto Port Authority is requesting the Toronto Police Service to provide staffing at the airport for the United States (US) Customs Pre-Clearance area. At its meeting on April 25, 2013, the Board approved the following motions: That the Chair and Chief meet with the Toronto Port Authority to consider options to move forward on the Toronto Port Authoritys request for police to meet US precustoms clearance requirement. That recommendation no. 4 in the foregoing report be approved; The Chief of Police report back to the Boards June 20, 2013 on the status of discussions with the Toronto Port Authority (Min. No. P100/013 refers). The purpose of this report is to provide the Board with an update in regards to a meeting that occurred with Chair Mukherjee, Chief Blair and representatives of the Toronto Port Authority. Discussion:

On Monday May 27, 2013, representatives from the Toronto Police Service, the Board and the Toronto Port Authority met to consider options to move forward on the Toronto Port Authoritys request for police to meet US customs pre-clearance requirements. Future discussions will continue relating to financial, facilities, and personnel requirements for service delivery for preclearance at Billy Bishop Toronto City Airport. This arrangement will be on a full cost recovery basis with the Toronto Port Authority being responsible for funding. This arrangement will cause an increase in the authorized uniform strength for the Toronto Police Service. Conclusion: Site visits will be arranged and discussions will continue with a view to preparing an agreement for the Boards consideration. Respectfully submitted,

William Blair, C.O.M. Chief of Police WB/jb Filename: PortAuthority-pre-clearance.doc

18. May 28, 2013 from Alok Mukherjee, Chair Re: Canadian Association of Police Boards: Amendment to By-Laws May 28, 2013

To:

Members Toronto Police Services Board Alok Mukherjee Chair CANADIAN ASSOCIATION OF POLICE BOARDS (CAPB): AMENDMENT TO BY-LAWS

From:

Subject:

Recommendation: It is recommended that the Board endorse the proposed changes to the CAPB By-laws and the Articles of Continuance and advise CAPB no later than July 12, 2013. Financial Implications: There are no financial implications arising from the recommendation contained in this report. Background/Purpose: The CAPB has developed an updated set of By-laws and Articles of Continuance, which is required by Industry Canada in order for CAPB to continue its existence under the new federal legislation, called the Canada Not-for-profit Corporations Act (CNCA). The CAPB is required to make the transition from the Canada Corporations Act to the new Canada Not-for-Profit Corporations Act (CNCA) by October 17, 2014. The purpose of the CNCA is to provide federally incorporated not-for-profit corporations with a modern corporate framework within which to operate. It incorporates modern legal principles that have applied to business corporations for many years, and also attempts to provide additional flexibility to corporations in structuring the types of meetings they can hold, as well as various options for voting at such meetings. In addition, the CNCA strives to strike a balance between flexibility of the corporation in operating its affairs, with the twin principles of accountability of the corporation to its stakeholders, including members, donors and funding agencies, and transparency of decision-making. The CNCA will replace the CCA and the CCA will eventually be repealed. The CNCA was proclaimed into force on October 17, 2011. All corporations incorporated under Part II of the CCA have three years from the proclamation date to transition to the CNCA. The deadline for transition is October 17, 2014. Until each corporation completes its transition process to the

CNCA, it still must comply with the rules in the CCA. This includes the method by which the continuance under the CNCA is approved. Discussion: The main changes to the By-laws are as follows: 1. Under the new By-law [Section 3.1], there will be just one class of membership, instead of the current three (Full Members, Associate Members and Honorary Members, with only Full Members having the power to vote). The reasons for this change are very practical and pragmatic since under the new CNCA legislation there are circumstances where even non-voting members get the right to vote as a class, and this could potentially result in a deadlock between classes of voters, which would paralyze the organization. Far better to have just one class of members, all of whom will have a vote, and to develop clear Operating Policies, which determine things such as how many non-police board members will be admitted to the organization. There will also be the need to find another way of recognizing Honorary Members for their service to the organization since that class of members will be eliminated. 2. Each Member (that is each organization that has been admitted to membership) will get just one vote at meetings [Section 4.14]. CAPBs current practice has been to allow every member of a member police board present at the annual general meeting to vote, which means that larger police boards that can afford to send more of their members to meetings are in fact given greater voting power. 3. The new By-law is much more specific about the voting process at meetings [Sections 4.11 to 4.14] and allows for both electronic, mailed in and proxy votes. Also, Quorum rules have been tightened up [Section 4.10]. 4. For very practical reasons, the new By-law takes a broader approach to the composition and size of the Board of Directors, specifying [in Section 5.2] that the Board shall be comprised of representatives of the geographic regions of Canada represented by its Members but leaving it up to Board, and ultimately the Membership, to establish Operating Policies regarding both the number of directors on the Board and the geographical representation of the Board [Section 5.1]. This is different from the current By-law, which not only limits the size of the Board at 13 but also specifically sets out how many directors each province shall have. 5. To amplify on the last point: under the CNCA, once a By-law is in place it becomes a complex and costly process to make revisions which may become necessary due to changing organizational needs. Therefore, it is vitally important to balance the amount of detail written into the By-law itself with what is written into Operating Policies which CAN be changed by the Board without going to the cost of revising the By-law itself. For instance, it is known that the organization is dynamic and growing, Manitoba and Prince Edward Island will be added this year, and may want

representation on the Board of Directors as a result, and it is more than likely that the organization will continue to expand its footprint in the years ahead. Therefore, in the Articles of Continuance, but not in the By-law itself, the maximum number of directors on the Board is set at 21. However, it is left up to the Board (and the Membership) on a year-to-year basis, to decide on how many directors are actually elected to the Board. 6. The new By-law gives a much more explicit role to the Nominations Committee [Section 5.9] in its selection of nominees for the Board of Directors prior to each AGM, with the requirement that the committee carry out its duties in accordance with any applicable requirements of the By-laws and Operating Policies of the Corporation. Note also [Section 5.3] that only appointees of Police Boards are eligible to become directors. 7. There has been in recent years some discussion at both the Board and Membership levels that the name of the organization, the Canadian Association of Police Boards (CAPB), is not truly descriptive of its mandate. Therefore, current directors on the Board are of the opinion that the transition to the new CNCA presents an opportunity to change the name. Hence, the new draft By-law proposes that the name of the organization be changed to the Canadian Association of Police Governance. CAPB board would like members feedback on this proposal. 8. The attached Articles of Continuance draft document, which is the document that will go to Industry Canada to transfer the organization to the CNCA, provides details of what has been set out in the new By-law in regard to the new name, the minimum and maximum number of Directors, the establishment of just one class of membership, and finally a detailed Statement of the Purpose of the Corporation in Schedule A. Conclusion: Copies of the draft CAPB By-laws and Articles of Continuance are attached to this report for review and feedback. Therefore, it is recommended that the Board endorse the proposed changes to the CAPB By-laws and the Articles of Continuance and advise CAPB no later than July 12, 2013. Respectfully submitted,

Alok Mukherjee Chair

19. June 05, 2013 from Alok Mukherjee, Chair Re: Motion from Toronto City Council Parking Ticket Activity June 5, 2013

To:

Members Toronto Police Services Board Alok Mukherjee Chair MOTION FROM TORONTO CITY COUNCIL PARKING TICKET ACTIVITY

From:

Subject:

Recommendations: It is recommended that the Board: (1) Request the Chief to review the item on Parking Ticket Activity considered by City Council at its meeting on May 7, 8 and 9, 2013 and report to the Board as to what by-law changes would be required to implement Councils direction; and (2) Forward a copy of this report to City Council for information.

Financial Implications: There are no financial implications arising from the recommendations contained in this report. Background/Purpose: I am in receipt of correspondence from the City Clerk, Toronto City Council, dated May 16, 2013 with respect to Government Management Committee Item 21.6 Parking Ticket Activity2012. This correspondence is attached for your information. Discussion: In this correspondence, it is noted that City Council adopted the following: 1. City Council request the Toronto Police Services Board to amend the Parking Enforcement Unit Guidelines to allow for no parking tickets to be issued until a period of 10 minutes has elapsed from the expiry of a paid parking time, excluding rush hour.

2. City Council direct the City of Toronto Municipal Law Enforcement Officers (MLEOs) not to issue parking tickets until a period of 10 minutes has elapsed from the expiry of a paid parking time. 3. City Council amend the City of Toronto Parking Ticket Cancellation Guidelines with respect to residential permit parking to provide for a grace period between 9:00 p.m. of one day to 12:01 p.m. of the next day when parking alternates from one side of the street to the other pursuant to by-law provisions and when on-street permit parking is in effect. It should be noted that Councils direction would require the Board to become involved in an operational issue, one that would require it to direct enforcement as well as to potentially fetter officer discretion. Under the Police Services Act, this is prohibited. Therefore, the item is more appropriately directed at the Chief of Police. The Chief can subsequently review the item and report to the Board as to what by-law changes would be required to implement Councils direction Conclusion: Therefore, it is recommended that the Board: (1) Request the Chief to review the item on Parking Ticket Activity considered by City Council at its meeting on May 7, 8 and 9, 2013 and report to the Board as to what by-law changes would be required to implement Councils direction; and (2) Forward a copy of this report to City Council for information.

Respectfully submitted,

Alok Mukherjee Chair

A:\city council_parking tickets.doc

20. June 05, 2013 from Alok Mukherjee, Chair Re: Motion from Toronto City Council Parks Plan 2013-2017 A copy of the Parks Plan 2013-2017 is available in the Board Office or can be accessed at: www.toronto.ca/legdocs/mmis/2013/pe/bgrd/backgroundfile-57282.pdf June 5, 2013

To:

Members Toronto Police Services Board Alok Mukherjee Chair MOTION FROM TORONTO CITY COUNCIL PARKS PLAN 2013-2017

From:

Subject:

Recommendations: It is recommended that the Board: (1) Request the Chief to review the Item entitled Parks Plan 2013-2017 considered by City Council at its meeting on May 7, 8 and 9, 2013 and report to the Board as to the current initiatives in place with respect to park safety and indicate what, if any, changes are required at this time. (2) Forward a copy of this report to City Council for information. Financial Implications: There are no financial implications arising from the recommendations contained in this report. Background/Purpose: I am in receipt of correspondence from the City Clerk, Toronto City Council, dated May 16, 2013 with respect to Parks and Environment Committee Item 201. Parks Plan 2013-2017. This correspondence is attached for your information. Discussion: In this correspondence, it is noted that City Council adopted, among others, the following recommendation:

11. City Council forward a copy of this Item to the Toronto Police Services Board for discussion and feedback on parks safety issues.

As the report states, [t]he Parks Plan will guide the City of Torontos delivery of parks services over the next five years. The Parks Plan aims to connect people and communities with parks, advance greening and environmental sustainability, improve the quality of the parks, and strengthen the parks systems as a legacy for Toronto. The report is wide-ranging in scope. The motion that has been sent to the Board is more appropriately directed at the Chief of Police as it deals with operational issues in the area of park safety. Therefore, the Board is requesting that the Chief review the Item and report to the Board as to the current initiatives in place with respect to park safety and indicate what, if any, changes are required at this time. Conclusion: Therefore, it is recommended that the Board: (1) Request the Chief to review the Item entitled Parks Plan 2013-2017 considered by City Council at its meeting on May 7, 8 and 9, 2013 and report to the Board as to the current initiatives in place with respect to park safety and indicate what, if any, changes are required at this time. (2) Forward a copy of this report to City Council for information.

Respectfully submitted,

Alok Mukherjee Chair

A:\city council_parks.doc

21. April 30, 2013 from William Blair, Chief of Police Re: Employee and Family Assistance Program Services Award April 30, 2013

To:

Chair and Members Toronto Police Services Board William Blair Chief of Police EMPLOYEE AND FAMILY ASSISTANCE PROGRAM SERVICES AWARD

From:

Subject:

Recommendations: It is recommended that: (1) the Board approve Morneau Shepell to provide Employee and Family Assistance Program services to the Toronto Police Service for a three year period commencing on August 1, 2013, to July 31, 2016, plus an additional one-year option at the discretion of the Board; and the Board authorize the Chair to execute all required agreements and related documents on behalf of the Board, subject to approval by the City Solicitor as to form.

(2)

Financial Implications: Funding to cover the costs of this contract has been included in the Services operating budget at the existing contract level. The compensation model for service delivery from Morneau Shepell is based on a standard Employee Assistance Program (EAP) calculation and includes direct invoicing to the Service for Employee and Family Assistance Program (EFAP) service delivery based on a per employee per month basis cost. At the Services current staffing levels, it is expected that an estimated $140,000 will be spent in 2013, and annualized to $336,000. This represents a 16.6% decrease from the 2012 costs. In year savings will be reflected in future variance reports, and annualized savings will be reflected in future budget submissions. Additional program supports, including Critical Incident Response support and Peer Support Training assistance are at additional cost, set at hourly and daily rates. On average, the Toronto Police Service EFAP responds to forty-four critical incidents per year. At approximately $400.00 to $800.00 per critical incident response, it is estimated that this support will have an additional cost range of $8,500 - $17,000 in 2013, annualized to $20,000 - $40,000, plus the cost of additional training. It is expected that an estimated $14,000 will be spent in 2013 and annualized to $20,000 per year, plus the cost of training sessions. Therefore, the estimated

overall cost of contracting the EFAP service in 2013 is $170,000 and the annualized estimated cost is approximately $400,000. The EFAP program includes the provision of psychological and counselling support services delivered by the external EFAP provider. These costs were reduced from the Services benefits budget when the external EFAP program was established. It is anticipated there will be continued corresponding savings in the cost of the same services provided through the Boards benefit plan and therefore, it is expected that the cost impact of the external program will continue to be offset by the anticipated savings. Background/Purpose: Prior to June 1, 2010, the Service operated an internal Employee & Family Assistance Program. This program operated under a hybrid model which involved a member contacting the internal staff at the EFAP and receiving a referral to a Community Mental Health Professional to address their personal needs. In 2008, the Service initiated a program review of the internal EFAP Program. The review found significant confidence issues as demonstrated by a low member utilization rate of less than 8%. The normative average at the time within the police sector was 12.53%. The Service commenced an external EFAP program on June 1, 2010, and since this time the member utilization rate has risen dramatically. In 2012, the TPS EFAP annualized utilization rate was 11.56%. The external EFAP Program continues to evolve and expand its capacity for training, support and services. Homewood Human Solutions is the current service provider of EFAP services, and its contract expires on August 31, 2013. Discussion: On March 1, 2013, an RFP (# 1133598-13) was issued by the Services Purchasing Support Services unit to potential vendors to provide EFAP services for a three year period with an option to renew for an additional one year term at the Boards discretion. The results of the RFP are summarized below: RFP Process and Results The Service advertised the RFP internationally using the worldwide web to interested vendors using MERX. MERX is Canadas leading electronic tendering service, designed to facilitate the procurement of goods and services worldwide. In excess of 9 vendors downloaded the RFP package. The evaluation criteria for the service provider submission selection were included in the RFP, and are as follows: Demonstrated high level of understanding of the requirements outlined in the RFP (10%) The proposed outline and plan in administrating the EFAP program (35%)

The profile and qualifications of the Proponent (35%) Cost of EFAP services (20%)

The RFP closed on March 25, 2013. Five proposals were received from: Aspiria Corporation Ceridian Corporation Family Services Employee Assistance Programs (FSEAP) Homewood Human Solutions Morneau Shepell (Shepellfgi) Purchasing Support Services reviewed the proposals for submission compliance and then released the submissions to the evaluation team. All five submissions met the mandatory requirements. An evaluation of the proposals was performed against the pre-determined evaluation criteria listed above. Each submission was compared with the needs of the Service for EFAP service delivery. A full cost analysis was performed on the pricing. Based on the evaluation, Morneau Shepell achieved the highest score from each member of the evaluation team. In addition, Morneau Shepell also provided the lowest cost for a comprehensive Employee and Family Assistance Program. Morneau Shepell also provided a fixed rate regardless of fluctuations in EFAP utilization rates, thereby ensuring the Service continues to receive the best financial value over the contract term. Conclusion: The recommendation to award this RFP to Morneau Shepell for a three year period will enable the Service to continue the delivery of EFAP services to its members in an efficient and effective manner and with no estimated additional cost impact to the Service. At the end of the three year term, an additional one year option can be exercised at the discretion of the Board. Deputy Chief Mike Federico, Corporate Command, and Mr. Tony Veneziano, Chief Administrative Officer, Administrative Command, will be in attendance to answer any questions the Board may have regarding this report. Respectfully submitted,

William Blair, C.O.M. Chief of Police WB/bm

22. June 07, 2013 from Alok Mukherjee, Chair Re: Ratification of Board Decision Appointment of Acting Vice-Chair: May 30, 2013 to June 11, 2013, Inclusive

June 07, 2013

To:

Members Toronto Police Services Board Alok Mukherjee Chair Ratification of Board Decision Appointment of Acting Vice-Chair: May 30, 2013 to June 11, 2013, Inclusive

From:

Subject:

Recommendation: It is recommended that the Board ratify a decision set out below made by a quorum of the Board on May 29, 2013 pertaining to the appointment of Dr. Dhun Noria as Acting Vice-Chair of the Board for the period between May 30, 2013 and June 11, 2013, Inclusive. Financial Implications: There are no financial implications arising from the recommendation contained in this report. Background/Purpose: Councillor Michael Thompson, Vice-Chair, Toronto Police Services Board, advised the Board office that he would not be able to perform the duties of Vice-Chair during the period between May 30, 2013 and June 11, 2013, inclusive, as he would be representing the City of Toronto at several meetings outside Toronto. Given that an Acting Vice-Chair would need to be appointed for duties that would commence prior to the next regularly scheduled meeting, it was necessary to conduct an email/telephone poll to determine an Acting Vice-Chair. Dr. Dhun Noria indicated that she would be available to perform the duties of Vice-Chair during Councillor Thompsons absence. Discussion: An email/telephone poll was conducted and on May 29, 2013 a quorum of the Board approved a recommendation to appoint Dr. Noria as Acting Vice-Chair during the period between May 30, 2013 and June 11, 2013, inclusive.

Conclusion: It is, therefore, recommended that the Board ratify the abovenoted decision made by a quorum of the Board on May 29, 2013.

Respectfully submitted,

Alok Mukherjee Chair

a:\ratify_acting vice chair_may2013.doc

23. May 31, 2013 from Alok Mukherjee, Chair Re: Special Fund Request for Funds: 2013 World Police and Fire Games Reception May 31, 2013

To:

Members Toronto Police Services Board Alok Mukherjee Chair REQUEST FOR FUNDS: 2013 WORLD POLICE & FIRE GAMES (WPFG) RECEPTION

From:

Subject:

Recommendation: It is recommended that, as an exception to the Boards Special Fund Policy, the Board approve an expenditure from the Special Fund in the amount of $1,500.00, inclusive of taxes, to support a reception for athletes participating in the 2013 World Police & Fire Games. Financial Implications: If the Board approves the recommendation contained in this report, the Special fund will be reduced in the amount of $1,500.00. The current balance in the Special Fund as at March 31, 2013 is $1,276,127.00. Background/Purpose: I am in receipt of correspondence dated May 22, 2013 from Staff Sergeant Charlene Baptist, President, Toronto Police Amateur Athletic Association (TPAAA), requesting that the Board contribute a third of the cost toward hosting a reception in support of over 100 Toronto Police Service (TPS) athletes participating in the 2013 World Police and Fire Games (WPFG) to be held in Belfast, Northern Ireland, from August 1 to 10, 2013. Discussion: In 1985, the WPFG Federation, a non-profit organization, established the WPFG. Today, the WPFG is an international sporting event, offering police officers, fire fighters, customs and correction officers from around the world an opportunity to showcase their athletic excellence in over 65 sporting events. In terms of the number of competitors, the WPFG is the third largest multi-sports event in the world, after the Olympics and the World Masters.

This year, the WPFG is being held in Belfast, Northern Ireland from August 1 to August 10, 2013. To date, over 100 TPS members are registered to compete. Police athletes dedicate thousands of hours to train for this event and are attending on their own time. This event is a great opportunity for TPS members to work together to reinforce the spirit of teamwork; to meet with other law enforcement officials from around the world, as well as provide an opportunity for TPS members to showcase the Service and the City of Toronto. In previous years the Board has partnered with the TPAAA in support of TPS participation in the WPFG by contribution towards the cost of the reception. This is an opportunity for the Board to encourage and provide its continued support of TPS members that are engaged in positive community relations. The WPFG reception for TPS athletes will be held on Wednesday, July 10th at 5:30 p.m., in the Toronto Police Association Building, 180 Yorkland Blvd, Toronto, Ontario M2J 1R5. The TPAAA has extended an invitation to all Board members who wish to attend. A copy of S/Sergeant Baptists correspondence is attached to this report for information. Conclusion: Therefore, it is recommended that, as an exception to the Boards Special Fund Policy, the Board approve an expenditure from the Special Fund in the amount of $1,500.00, inclusive of taxes, to support a reception for athletes participating in the 2013 World Police & Fire Games.

Respectfully submitted,

Alok Mukherjee Chair AM/edk A:\2013 WPFG-TPAAA reception

24. May 29, 2013 from Alok Mukherjee, Chair Re: Special Fund Request for Funds: Toronto Police Service Cricket Club and Standing Authority for Future Annual Funds May 29, 2013

To:

Members Toronto Police Services Board Alok Mukherjee Chair SPECIAL FUND REQUEST: TORONTO POLICE SERVICE CRICKET CLUB

From:

Subject:

Recommendation: It is recommended: 1. THAT the Board approve $9,000.00 from the Special Fund to help offset the 2013 maintenance cost of the Toronto Police Service Cricket Club (TPSCC) playing field; and THAT the cost of maintaining the TPSCC playing field be included in the list of annual request for Special Fund provided by the Chief, effective 2014.

2.

Financial Implications: If the recommendations contained in this report are approved, the Special Fund will be reduced in the amount of $9,000.00 in 2013 and the Special fund will incur an annual expenditure of $9,000.00. The current balance in the Special Fund is approximately $1,276,127.00. Background/Purpose: The Toronto Police Service Cricket Club was founded in 1992. Over the last 20 years the club has developed and sustained positive relationships with various communities including a wide cross section of youth organizations. In 1994 the TPSCC acquired land which the club dedicated to the memory of Police Constable Percy B. Cummins who was fatally shot in Toronto on September 23, 1981. The sustainability of the TPSCC is being threatened as a result of the downloading of land taxes to the club. Discussion: In 1994 the TPSCC negotiated a 5 year lease with Hydro valued at $1 dollar a year for a plot of land officially described as Lot 21 and 22, Concession 4, located at the south east corner of Whitheheather Blvd and McNicol Avenue and is 7. acres. The lease has been renewed at the

same rate since 1994. The agreement was made on the condition that the TPSCC would maintain and upkeep the land. Expenses associated with the cost of maintaining the ground is paid for from funds received annually from the Toronto Police Amateur Athletic Association, membership dues and social functions. Prior to 2008 the cost of the land tax was absorbed by Hydro One. However since 2008 the land tax has been downloaded to the TPSCC. The TPSCC has reviewed and explored various sources of funding and has managed to carry the costs, with some difficulty, from 2008 to 2009. In 2010, the Board approved $9,000 from the Special Fund to help offset the maintenance cost of the TPSCC playing field (Min. No. P286/10 refers). However, the TPSCC has not been able to secure sustainable funding to defray the cost of the tax. The additional cost of approximately $9,000.00 annually has created a financial burden which is threatening the clubs sustainability. The Club has formed on-going partnerships with local and US based cricket clubs to enhance the reputation of the Service. It continues to partner with community members and organizations to address and assist youth and at risk youth issues. Further, for many years, the Percy Cummins Cricket Ground was the only visible community tribute to Torontos only Black officer killed in the line of duty. The cricket ground continues to be a highly recognized tribute to Officer Cummins within the Black community. Since its inception over 20 years ago, the TPSCC continues to provide a unique opportunity for members of the Service and members of the public to join together and celebrate the diversity that makes Toronto a vibrant city, it continues to address youth issues, and serves as a means of promoting positive community-police relations. Appended to this report is a list of some of the community events/initiatives the TPSCC has initiated or participated in over the years. Conclusion: In 2010, the Board granted standing authority to the Chair and Vice Chair to approve expenditures from the Special Fund for annual internal and external community events and or initiatives involving the Board and or the Service that meet the Special Fund Policy criteria. The annual events/initiatives are submitted to the Board by the Chief for information annually at the beginning of each calendar year, with each individual event totalling less than $10,000.00 (Min. No. P208/10 refers). The TPSCC plays a vital role in community engagement and community policing, and it is recommended that it be included in the annual list of events. Further, TPSCC activities are in keeping with the Special Fund Policy Community Outreach provision which outlines the criteria for funding of community-oriented policing activities that involve a co-operative effort on the part of the Toronto Police Service and the community that addresses: a. Initiatives involving members of the Toronto Police Service that benefit children and/or youth and/or their families; and b. Initiatives addressing violence prevention or prevention of repetition of violence or the root causes of violence.

Therefore, it is recommended: 1. THAT the Board approve $9,000.00 from the Special Fund to help offset the 2013 maintenance cost of the Toronto Police Service Cricket Club (TPSCC) playing field; and 2. THAT the cost of maintaining the TPSCC playing field be included in the list of annual request for Special Fund provided by the Chief, effective 2014.

Respectfully submitted,

Alok Mukherjee Chair

A:\Filename.doc

TORONTO POLICE SERVICE CRICKET CLUB COMMUNITY INITIATIVES

Since its inception in 1992, the TPSCC has initiated or participated in the following community events:

Fundraising dance with proceeds to Variety Village to support athletic program. Partnership with schools to coach cricket and provide mentoring to students. In partnership with Pro Action, hosted children from various social service agencies (over 1000 hosted to date) at annual picnics. Collected and distributed education material to less privileged children. Partnered with the Toronto Breakfast Club to raise funds in support of its program. TPSCC members have also volunteered and served breakfast to participating children. Hosted Christmas parties for children and mothers fleeing abusive homes. Fundraising and participation in Camp Jumoke walkathon to raise funds to send Sickle Cell afflicted children to summer camp (over $50,000.00 raised thus far). This initiative is on-going. 3. Partnered with members of 13 Division and the local councillor to host community cricket matches aimed at building community relations Organized and hosted fundraising event to raise funds to assist the hurricane ravaged island of Grenada. 4. The TPSCC undertook to assist in rebuilding two schools damaged by the hurricane. This was completed with the assistance of Retired Constable Doreen Guy. 5. The TPSCC secured and shipped ten computers to Grenada to assist education endeavours Fundraising partnership with the Canadian Cricket Academy to raise funds for the Canadian Cancer Society. $10,000.00 raised and donated from recent event. Formed partnership with the Chartered Institute of Management Accountants to raise awareness of cricket in Toronto through competition for the Mayors Cup Cricket event On-going partnership with local and U.S. based cricket clubs to enhance the reputation of the Service. (The club includes community members on its team to further this objective).

Plan and host the annual Percy Cummins Memorial game. This game is played annually in July since 1998 at the Percy Cummings Grounds and commemorates the life and service of Const. Percy Cummins who was killed on duty in 1981. This event is publicized in local media and is attended by politicians, members of Police Service Board, members of the TPS Command, members of the Caribbean Consular Core and community members Partnership with the Employment Office to host cricket events aimed at targeted recruiting On-going partnership with Canadian Womens Cricket Association to enhance the profile of women in the game as well as to form positive relations On-going partnership with other community cricket clubs and organizations to enhance Police/community relations 6. Formed Law Enforcement partnerships with GTA Services and NYPC to participate in an annual competition (alternately hosted at The Percy Cummins Cricket Grounds and in New York city)

NEXT REGULAR MEETING: Date: Time: Thursday, July 18, 2013 1:30 PM

__________________________________________________________________________ Members of the Toronto Police Services Board: Dr. Alok Mukherjee, Chair Councillor Michael Thompson, Vice-Chair Councillor Michael Del Grande, Member Ms. Marie Moliner, Member Dr. Dhun Noria, Member Councillor Frances Nunziata, Member Mr. Andrew Pringle, Member

End.