Professional Documents
Culture Documents
What is culture?
Spend
5
minutes
brain
storming
and
try
to
come
up
with
a
deni7on
of
culture
What
is
Culture?
Culture
is
the
way
of
life
of
a
group
of
people.
Elements
of
Culture
Language Shelter Clothing Economy Religion Education Values Climate Government/Laws Recreation/Entertainment
Education
- the development of the mind and character through study and training
Language
- spoken or written words; human speech
Shelter
Clothing
Economy
Religion
Values
Climate
Government/Laws
Entertainment/Recreation
Definitions of culture?
warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning
warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning warning
Ideals, values, and assump7ons about life that are widely shared among people and that guide specic behaviors. (Brislin, 1993)
Can
be
dened
as
common
rules
that
regulate
interac7ons
and
behaviour
in
a
group
as
well
as
a
number
of
shared
values
and
aOtudes
in
the
group.
Lonner
(1995)
Culture shapes the mind. Hofstede (2002) Hofstede uses the analogy of the computer as a metaphor. He suggests that while individuals are born with an opera7ng system, it is not sucient to operate in society. Culture provides the program, which can be likened to the development of cultural schemas that inuence thinking, emo7ons and behaviour. Culture is therefore the Mental SoHware that is shared by members of a sociocultural group. It is transmiTed or learnt through language, daily interac7ons and feedback from other members of that group.
Cultural Norms
In
summary
Culture
is
a
set
of
aOtudes,
behaviors
and
symbols
shared
by
a
large
group
of
people
and
usually
communicated
from
one
genera7on
to
the
next.
the norms of an established group which are transmiTed across genera7ons and regulate behavior in accordance with the groups beliefs about acceptable and unacceptable ways of thinking, feeling and behaving.
Homework
Read
work
by
Triandis
on
Subjec7ve
Culture
available:
hTp://www.wwu.edu/culture/triandis1.htm
Although emics and etics are sometimes regarded as inherently in conflict and one can be preferred to the exclusion of the other, the compliment of emic and etic approaches to research is probably the best way to understand the mind and behaviour in context.
For theEmicApproaches
Behaviour is culturally specific
For theEmicapproaches
Scientific data is relative and biased by the culture of the researcher and individuals tested Cultural variations need to be recognised Scientists should re-examine their ideas to include cultural dimension and universal properties of cultures.
For theEticapproaches
Behaviour is compared across cultures Draws on the notion of universal properties of cultures, which share common perceptual, cognitive, and emotional structures.
Key Terms
What is the learning outcome for our current topic?
Using one or more examples, explain emic and etic concepts
So
far
Overall,
e7cs
and
emics
are
abstract
concepts
that
are
useful
to
researchers.
Example of research that shows why it is important to take emic description of a concept into account
Tabassum et al. (2000) study into depression, which shows why it is important to take emic descrip7ons of a westernised (e7c) concept into account.
Then we Consider John Berrys comments on using emics and e7cs properly in research.
ParNcipants
First
and
second-genera7on
Pakistani,
all
lived
in
a
poor
UK
urban
seOng.
Hard
to
get
sample
because
interviews
would
meet
in
family
group
seOngs
(males
would
not
typically
let
females
meet
alone
with
researcher).
In
fact,
only
7
families
would
allow
researcher
to
record,
making
transcrip7on
dicult
74
par7cipants
took
part:
22
males
born
in
Pakistan,
29
rst-genera7on
women,
and
23
second-genera7on
women
Method
Asked
ques7ons
about:
percep7on
of
causes
of
mental
disorder,
help-
seeking
behavior,
family
percep7ons
and
reac7on
to
mental
disorder,
and
the
community
status
of
people
with
a
mental
disorder
Findings
Par7cipants
were
fairly
knowledgeable
about
Western
e7c
mental
health
models
63%
viewed
aggression
as
a
main
symptom
of
abnormality
Some
par7cipants
used
the
terms
anxiety
and
depression
but
the
words
in
Urdu
had
dierent
meaning
from
Western
e7c
descrip7ons.
Pakistani
culture
is
collec6vist
and
emphasize
politeness
in
social
behavior,
so
aggressive
displays
are
viewed
as
abnormal,
more
important
than
anxious
or
depressed
symptoms
Many
of
the
other
iden7ed
causes
of
mental
disorder
were
similar
to
those
from
Western
models,
with
63%
emphasizing
stress
as
a
primary
factor.
Remember:
stress
is
an
eNc,
though
there
are
emic
features
of
how
the
Pakistani
display
stress
25%
aTributed
mental
disorders
to
supernatural
causes
and
35%
believed
in
faith
healers
Families
should
cope
with
mental
health;
hospitaliza7on
was
a
last
resort
Most
males
thought
a
general
prac77oners
(GP)
should
be
consulted
for
treatment.
Fewer
females
iden7ed
a
GP
as
the
rst
person
to
consult,
but
there
may
be
cultural
barriers
to
women
geOng
help
from
doctors.
These
dicul7es
include
language
barriers,
the
fact
that
many
doctors
are
males,
and
that
many
Muslim
women
have
diculty
with
hospitaliza7on
because
of
the
purdah.
One
prevalent
aOtude
was
that
families
should
cope
with
mental
health
problems.
Hospitaliza7on
was
a
last
resort.
Par7cipants
were
reluctant
to
discuss
in7mate
family
maTers
with
the
researchers,
even
at
7mes
saying
that
they
did
not
know
someone
rst-hand
with
a
mental
disorder,
contradic7ng
previous
statements
that
they
did.
Pakistanis
may
fear
s7gma
associated
with
mental
disorder.
ImplicaNons
One
of
the
main
implica7ons
of
Tabassum
et
als
(2000)
study
include
the
need
for
physician
training
and
ques7ons
about
how
we
collect
data.
For
example,
do
doctors
have
enough
informa7on
about
cross-cultural
views
of
abnormality?
How
can
we
collect
data
to
accurately
iden7fy
another
cultures
views?
John
Berrys
comments
abut
how
to
use
emics
&
e7cs
properly
in
research
The
goal
is
to
use
the
principles
of
emics
and
e7cs
to
benet
others.
Berry
(1969)
asked
how
psychologists
could
make
cross-cultural
comparisons
without
a
specically
iden7ed
methodology
that
aided
the
task.
Ideally,
cultural
psychologists
should
describe
both
emics
specic
to
a
group
and
ethics
that
make
comparisons
between
cultures
possible.
Berry
iden7ed
three
steps
to
create
universal
categories
that
were
really
useful
to
make
comparisons
between
cultures:
Three
steps
to
create
universal
categories
that
are
useful
to
make
comparison
between
cultures
1. Out
of
necessity,
psychologists
may
have
to
start
a
research
study
with
an
imposed
e7c.
Psychologists
should
remain
aware
that
the
imposed
e7c
is
a
poor
approxima7on
of
what
is
really
needed
for
the
nal
results,
which
is
to
create
true
emic
descrip7on
of
the
culture,
one
that
is
meaningful
to
people
in
the
culture
being
studied.
True
emic
descrip7on
of
a
culture
involve
con7nually
altering
the
imposed
e6c.
The
researcher
moves
on
to
step
2
only
if
this
can
be
done
without
completely
destroying
the
original
e7c
categories
used
for
scien7c
discovery.
Researchers
create
new
categories
that
reect
what
is
observed
in
another
culture.
Berry
called
these
new
e7cs
the
derived
e6cs.
The
derived
e7c
categories
are
now
useful
for
making
comparison
between
two
groups.
Finally,
derived
e7c
categories
are
applied
to
new
research
seOngs,
modied
emically
again,
and
then
more
new
e7c
categories
are
created.
It
is
only
when
all
groups
for
comparison
have
been
studied
this
way
that
we
have
real
universals
for
comparison.
2.
3.
The goal of this three-step process was to create instruments that were appropriate for measuring behavioural similarities and differences between cultures.
From Berrys criteria is Tabassums et al. (2000) research valuable? Tabassums (2000) research is a beginning in the process, it allows us to nd future variables that will lead to real comparisons between cultures.
Extension
work/reading
Wombles,
K
(2010)
The
Emic
and
E7c
of
cross
cultural
research
hTp://www.science20.com/ science_au7sm_spectrum_disorders/blog/ emic_and_e7c_crosscultural_research
Berry,
J.
W.
(1999)
Emics
and
e7cs:
A
symbio7c
concep7on.
Culture
&
Psychology
5,
165
171
hTp://psikologi.ugm.ac.id/uploads/resources/File/ Indigenous/4408157.pdf
Using one or more examples, explain emic and eNc concepts Examine the role of two cultural dimensions on behavior
Cultural Dimensions
In addition to cultural norms, another component of culture is dimensions the perspectives of a culture based on values and cultural norms.
Individualism
versus
CollecNvism
Power
Distance
Masculinity
versus
femininity
Uncertainty
avoidance
Long-term
versus
short-term
orientaNon
Indulgence
versus
Restraint
Polychronic
versus
Monochronic
Nme
Proximics
percepNon
and
use
of
space
Research Study
Hoefstedes
classic
study
(1973)
involved
asking
employees
of
the
mul7na7onal
company
IBM
to
ll
in
surveys
about
morale
in
the
workplace.
He
then
carried
out
a
content
analysis
on
the
responses
he
received,
focusing
on
the
key
dierences
submiTed
by
employees
in
dierent
countries.
His
research
looked
at
the
40
most
representaNve
countries
in
the
surveys.
The
trends
he
no7ced,
he
called
dimensions.
Hoefstede
found
a
number
of
dimensions,
only
some
are
outlined
here.
Understanding and respect for cultural norms can promote successful interactions
Confucian Dynamism
Hoefstede working with Bond, added another dimension. Bond (1988) argues that Chinese culture replaces the uncertaintyavoidance dimension with Confucian work dynamism: instead of focusing on truth, some cultures focus on virtue. China and other Asian countries have a long-term orientation. These cultures value persistence, loyalty, and trustworthiness. Relationships are based on status. They have a need to protect the collective identity and respect traditionwhat is often called saving face. Hoefstede found that Finland, France, Germany, and the US have a short-term orientation. In contrast to Confucian work dynamism, these cultures value personal steadiness and stability. There is a focus on the future instead of the past, and innovation is highly respected.
Individualism vs Collectivism
Triandis
(1995)
proposed
the
construct
Collec7vists
are
closely
linked
individuals
who
view
themselves
primarily
as
parts
of
a
whole,
be
it
a
family,
a
network
of
co-workers,
a
tribe,
or
a
na7on.
Such
people
are
mainly
mo7vated
by
the
norms
and
du7es
imposed
by
the
collecNve
enNty.
Individualists
are
mo7vated
by
their
own
preferences,
needs,
and
rights,
giving
priority
to
personal
rather
than
to
group
goals.
IndivualisNc
Ties
between
individuals
are
loose
Everyone
is
expected
to
look
ajer
themselves
There
is
more
emphasis
on
the
needs
of
the
individual
CollecNvist
Very
strong
7es
with
family
and
other
groups
Family
or
cultural
rules
apply,
e.g.
someone
breaks
these
rules
they
would
be
considered
an
outcast
Types of Space
InNmate
space
-
the
closest
"bubble"
of
space
surrounding
a
person.
Entry
into
this
space
is
acceptable
only
for
the
closest
friends
and
in7mates.
Social
and
consultaNve
spaces
-
the
spaces
in
which
people
feel
comfortable
conduc7ng
rou7ne
social
interac7ons
with
acquaintances
as
well
as
strangers.
Public
space
-
the
area
of
space
beyond
which
people
will
perceive
interac7ons
as
impersonal
and
rela7vely
anonymous.
United States ci7es, for instance, are customarily set out along a grid, a preference inherited from the Bri7sh, but in France and Spain a star paTern is preferred.
Key
Vocabulary
CollecNvism
vs.
individualism:
the
extent
to
which
societal
bonds
determine
behaviour.
In
individualis@c
socie@es
people
strive
to
be
self-reliant,
unique
and
successful.
In
collec@vis@c
socie@es
ones
family
and
culture
are
an
integral
part
of
their
decisions.
Collec@vis@c
socie@es
are
concerned
with
coopera@on,
tradi@on
and
saving
face.
Confucian
work
dynamism:
Also
known
as
long-term
orienta@on,
this
dimension
values
truth,
persistence
and
loyalty.
Pa@ence
is
also
valued,
whereas
in
short-term
orienta@on
impulsivity
and
spontanaiety
are
more
the
norm.
Conict
is
oJen
avoided
in
order
to
preserve
rela@onships.
Cultural
dimension:
the
perspec@ves
of
a
culture
based
on
values
and
cultural
norms.
Ecological
fallacy:
when
one
looks
at
two
dierent
cultures,
it
should
not
be
assumed
that
two
members
from
two
dierent
cultures
must
be
dierent
from
one
another,
or
that
a
single
member
of
a
culture
will
always
demonstrate
the
dimensions
which
are
the
norm
of
his/her
culture.
MiNgated
speech:
Indirect
speech
paEerns
in
which
ones
own
personal
views
are
not
directly
stated.
This
is
oJen
seen
in
cultures
with
high
power
distance,
as
seen
in
Greenburgs
study
of
Korean
Airlines.
Power
distance:
The
level
to
which
social
hierarchy
is
respected
in
a
society.
Low
power
distance
socie@es
have
a
sense
of
equality
even
between
boss
and
employee
or
adult
and
child.
High
power
distance
socie@es
have
a
rigid
structure
of
authority
that
is
respected
and
deferred
to.
Extension
work/reading
Wombles,
K
(2010)
The
Emic
and
E7c
of
cross
cultural
research
hTp://www.science20.com/ science_au7sm_spectrum_disorders/blog/ emic_and_e7c_crosscultural_research
Berry,
J.
W.
(1999)
Emics
and
e7cs:
A
symbio7c
concep7on.
Culture
&
Psychology
5,
165
171
hTp://psikologi.ugm.ac.id/uploads/resources/File/ Indigenous/4408157.pdf
Extension
work/reading
Cultural
psychology,
temporal
orienta7on;
prejudice
&
racism,
coping
and
stress
see
James
Jones
web
site:
hTp://www.psych.udel.edu/people/detail/james_jones/
White,
L.T.,
Valk,
R.,
&
Dialmy,
A.
(2011)
What
Is
the
Meaning
of
''on
Time''?
The
Sociocultural
Nature
of
Punctuality.
Journal
of
Cross-Cultural
Research
hTp://www.psychologytoday.com/les/aTachments/ 71977/the-sociocultural-nature-standards- punctuality.pdf
Extension
work/ac7vity
Explore
this
website,
you
can
also
compare
your
countrys
scores
on
the
dimensions
of
culture
to
those
from
other
countries.
Examine
the
dimensions
in
more
detail
and
have
fun!
hTp://www.geerthofstede.com/index
An
indepth
interview
with
Geert
Hofstede
discussing
the
main
aspects
of
his
work
hTp://www.youtube.com/watch? v=nLQxU8BbGCY