!"#
%$&'(
)*
+$,)-
/.0
%"1$2 34
*657 
%$,
8-"9  
:1;=<?>A@>CBEDGF
H4IKJML%NPO QRJTSVUWO FKX SZY ;=< O D SVUWO BE[4\ SZ]I ; UR^_] ;=>a` URbc^CURSVS < ^CUTb FRd UR^feES < Ng^fOih BE[kj9l SZUWOgS F
HkLnmoL @Bqp0rts+uvFucwcxcx y`#FK` UKNg] IRS+JtS FRj IRS'zS{O IRS <g>|; UKJRN F ]cL}Y2L ; L}~ >CBcDl ~2L}QtO l SVUWOgSEL}U >
B ~ ; b D SZ^ PS <VF
y NgN B ]{^ ; O S'H <?BE[ S+NgN BE<ZFKX SZY ;=< O D SVUWO BE[4\ SZ]I ; UR^_] ;=>2` URbE^CUTSZS < ^CURb FKd UR^feES < Ng^fOih BE[jl SVUWO S F
HALnm-L @B+prtsquWFuEw=xEx y`#FK` UKNg]ITS+JtS FRj ITS'zSVOgIRS <g>|; URJRN FR< L}I ; b D SV^ ?S <l ~2L}QtO l SVUWOgSEL}U >
`%< ^_]S+ Jvh F
HIRJ FKy ] B QKNPO ^_]VN X ^fet^_N?^ B U FKj zm,URN?Og^fO QtO S BE[ky YTY > ^CS+JHIhTN?^_]ZN F
HALnm-L @B+psqwcwvFrcExcx yX-FX S >C[ O FRj ITSozSVOgIRS <?>|; URJRN F eES+Jth  OgYMJL OgU B L}U >

(SYA) 24-1

M$* A 

j ITSY <?B Y ; b ; O ^ B U BE[ N B QRURJ l#; eSZN F JtSZTURS+J ; N ; U B Ng]V^ >C>|; O Bc< h D B O ^ B U l ^fOgIN D;=>C>#;D Y > ^fOgQKJtS^CU ;
] BcD Y < S+NgN?^C~ > S TQR^_J sVF ] ; U~S JTSZN ] < ^C~S+J~WhO IRS > ^CURS ;< ^CVS+J ` Q > S < S+Q ; O ^ B URNTK F QRURJTS < OgIRS ; N?
N?Q D YtO ^ B UKN O I ; OO IRS < S0^_NU B[ SZS+Jt~ ; ]O B O IRS D S ; Ut Bql; UKJOgI ; OSVS+]ON BE[ ev^_N ] B N?^fOh ; UKJITS ; O
] B UKJTQR]{Og^ B U] ; U0~SUTSZb > SZ]{OgS+JL
UO ITSTS > J Bc[k:BED YRQtO ; Og^ B U ;=>My S <gBW; ] B QKNPO ^_]VNK2a F ^fO9^_N l ^_JTS > h < S+] B bcUR^CZSZJO I ; OO IRSUWQ D S < ^_] ;=>
;=> b BE< ^fOgI D N ; YRY > ^CS+JO B N Bc> eSO ITSb B eS < UR^CUTboS+WQ ; Og^ B UKN D QKNPOI ; eSN?QR]{^CSZUO > h >CB+l UvQ D S < ^_] ;> JT^_N?YS <
N?^ B U ; URJJT^_NgN?^CY ; O ^ B U^CU BE< JTS < O B'; ]Z]{Q < ; O S > h N?^ D Q >|; OgS#OgIRS1Y <gB Y ; b ; O ^ B U Bc[; S <gB; ] B QKNPO ^_]9^CU [Bc<gD; O ^ B U2L
jAB OgIR^_N1SVUKJ F IT^CbEIRS < BE< JtS < Ng]ITS D S+N1] ; UG~SQKN?S+JML j ITS X ^_Ng] B UO ^CUWQ B QRN ;> S < v^CUak rvFRD S{O I B J
^_N ; UQ > Og^ D; O S > h] BcD Y ; ]{O%RUR^fOgSVS > S D SZUO D SVOgI B J l IR^_] I] ; U~S ; YRY > ^CS+JSV]{^CSZUWO > h B UQRUKNPO < QK]O Q < S+J
D SZNgITS+N F OgIvQKN ;>C>CBql ^CUTbbES BED SVO < ^_] ;>C> h] BcD Y > S p Y <?B ~ > S D NO B ~SI ; UKJ > S+JL,^CbEIRS < BE< JtS < IT^CbEITS <
O I ; UN?SZ] B URJt BE< JtS < ; ]Z]{Q < ; ]{h] ; U~S B ~TO ; ^CURSZJ < S >|; Og^feS > hS ; N?^ > h~SZ] ; QRN?S BE[ O ITS] BED Y ; ]O URSZNgN BE[
O ITS D S{O I B J F; OoOgIRSYSZU ;> Oh F I Bql S{eS <ZFBc[; U^CUR] < S ; N?^CUTbUvQ D ~S <-BE[ QTURvU Bql UKNoYS < S > S D SZUO+L y U
S p O SZURN?^feSGJtS+Ng] < ^CYTO ^ B U Bc[ O ITS ; YRY > ^_] ; Og^ B U BE[ OgIRS X ^_Ng] B UWO ^CUWQ B QKN ;> S < W^CU D SVOgI B J7^CU7O IRSRS > J BE[
K2^_N#bc^feSVU~h y O W^CUKNoV1cC FwWFtFuq L
j IRS < SZN?Q > ONY < S+N?SZUO S+J7^CUOgIRSY < S+N?SZUOY ; YS <;=< S B ~TO ; ^CUTS+J l ^fOgIOgIRSG] BED YRQtO S < ] B JtS2kqv F
l IT^_]I^_N~ ; N?SZJ B U ; UvQ D S < ^_] ;>;=> b BE< ^fO I D JtSVeS >CB YS+JO B N BE> eSO ITSR^CUO I < SZSJt^ D SVUKN?^ B URNZL BE<
O ITSGN?Y ; Og^ ;=> JT^_Ng] < SVO ^C ; Og^ B U Bc[ OgIRSGTOgIRS0Q ; J < ; OgQ < S{ [< SZS X ^_Ng] B UO ^CUWQ B QRN ;> S < W^CU D S{O I B J7I ; N
~SVSZU ; YTY > ^CSZJ Fl IT^ > SoO ITS'O ^ D S-^CUWOgSZb <; Og^ B U^_NYS <g[BE<gD S+J~h ;[B Q < iNPO SVY FK>CBql NPO BE< ; bcS#QTURbES{iQTOgO ;
;=> b BE< ^fOgI D L y OY < S+N?SZUOOgIRS ;> b Bc< ^fO I D ^_NN?SZ] B URJt BE< JtS <; ]Z]{Q <; O S0^CU~ B OgIN?Y ; ]VS ; UKJOg^ D SEL j IRS
UvQ D S < ^_] ;>;=> b BE< ^fO I D I ; N ;=>C< S ; Jth7~SVSZU ; YRY > ^CSZJO B; OgI < SVSVJT^ D SVUKN?^ B U ;=> ~ <gBW; JT~ ; UKJ] ; ev^fOhvU B ^_NgS
Y < S+JT^_]O ^ B UY <gB ~ > S D Fl ITS < S-^fO^_NY ;=< O BE[; OgI < SVSVN?OgSZY D SVOgI B JLUO IRSoOgI < SVSVN?OgSZY D SVOgI B J F O IRS
< N?OoN?OgSZYY <gB et^_JTSZNOgIRSOg^ D S{ ; eES < ; bESZJM2aN Bc> QTOg^ B U [<?BEDl IT^_]I F ^CUOgIRSN?S+] B UKJN?OgSZY F O Q < ~RQ > SZUWO
; S <gBW; ] B QKNPO ^_]N B Q < ]VS#O S <gD N [BE< O ITST ;=< S B ~TO ; ^CURSZJLUO IRS#O IT^ < JNPO SVY2Aqv^_N%QRN?S+J O B Ng^ D Q >|; O S
O ITS'Y <gB Y ; b ; Og^ B U Bc[ OgIRS ; S <?BW; ] B QRN?Og^_]Jt^_N?OgQ < ~ ; UR]VSZN#Y <gB JTQK]{S+JG~WhO ITS'N B Q < ]VSRS > JL
j IRS lBE< Y < SZN?SZUWOgS+J^CUOgIR^_N'Y ; YS < ] ; U~S < SZb ;=< JTS+J ; N ; ] B UWOg^CUvQ ; O ^ B U BE[ O IRS l9Bc< Y < S+N?SZUO S+J
^CU LU O lB eS < ^CR] ; Og^ B UY <gB ~ > S D N F OgIRS] B UWeES+]O ^ B U Bc[;r=X ] BcD Y ; ]{O ; ] B QKNPO ^_]Jt^_NPO Q < ~ ; UK]VS
; URJGOgIRS <; Jt^ ; Og^ B U [<gBED; O I < SZS{iJT^ D SZURNg^ B U ;> I ;=<?DB UT^_] DB U B Y BE> SoN B Q < ]{S Ftl S < SY < S+N?SZUO SZJLmURS BE[
O ITSo] B UR] > QKN?^ B UKNJ <;Zl U0^CU0O I ; OY ; YS < ^_N#OgI ; O ; ]V]VS > S <; O ^ B U Bc[ OgIRS ;=> b BE< ^fOgI D O B< S >|;qp< S+QR^ < S D SVUWO N
B U] BcD YTQTO ; O ^ B U ;=> SZ BE< O l1; NURSVS+JTSZJLS < S l SY < S+N?SZUO < SZN?Q > ON B ~TO ; ^CUTS+J [BE< O ITS < NPO Bc[ O ITS O l9B
aPP2=PP?+aqqc=c-Z{qqkq q2aP?iPV
s
Paper presented at the RTO AVT Symposium on Ageing Mechanisms and Control:
Part A Developments in Computational Aero- and Hydro-Acoustics,
held in Manchester, UK, 8-11 October 2001, and published in RTO-MP-079(I).

;=[BE< S D SVUWO ^ B URSZJeES < ^CR] ; O ^ B UY <gB ~ > S D N F1B ~TO ; ^CUTS+J l ^fOgI ; Y ;=< ;=>C> S > ^CVS+JeS < N?^ B U BE[ O IRS] B JTScL j IRS
;=> b BE< ^fOgI D ^_N'Y ;=< ;=>C> S > ^CVS+JS D Y >CB hv^CURb 
\ S+NgN ; bESH ; NgNg^CUTb0UWOgS <?[; ]{S ; UKJO IRS] B JTS^_N < QTU B U ;
s+xEr c
 Y >|; O [Bc<gD MRA sZx L yDBE< SO I BE<?B QRbcIJTS+Ng] < ^CYTOg^ B U Bc[ Y ;=< ;=>C> S > ^CZ^CURb ; AM~ ; N?S+JGK2
;=> b BE< ^fOgI DGF S D Y >CB hv^CURb F ^_NY < S+N?SZUO S+J^CU sEs L j IRS D; ^CU B ~v?SZ]{O ^feES+N BE[ O ITS lBE< Y < SZNgSVUWOgS+J ^CU O IRS
Y < S+N?SZUOY ; YS <;< S] B U
O ^CUvQ ; Og^ B U BE[ 9O ITS'eES < ^CK] ; O ^ B U BE[ O ITSoUWQ D S < ^_] ;=>;=> b Bc< ^fOgI D ; UKJ] B UKJtQK]O ^CURb
; YS <?[Bc<gD; UK]{SO SZNPO BE[ O ITSY ;<;>C> S > ^CZSZJ ;=> b BE< ^fO I D B U MRA=L
j IRS B QTO > ^CURS BE[ OgIRSY ; YS < ^_N ; N [Bc>C>CBql
N UOgIRS < NPO-N?SZ]{O ^ B UOgIRSb B eS < UR^CUTbSZWQ ; O ^ B UKN F ^L}SELO IRS
a^CUTS ;< ^CZSZJ ` Q > S < SZWQ ; O ^ B UKNERK FT;=< SY < S+N?SZUO S+JML4iUO ITSN?S+] B UKJN?SZ]{O ^ B UOgIRSQ ; J <; OgQ < SV [< SVS X ^_N?
] B UWO ^CUWQ B QKN# ;=> S < v^CU D SVOgI B J^_N9~ < ^CSVThJTS+Ng] < ^C~SZJL j IRSUTS p O1N?S+]O ^ B UGJtS+Ng] < ^C~SZNOgIRS] B UWeSZ]{Og^ B U BE[k;
O lB iJt^ D SVUKN?^ B U ;=> ] BED Y ; ]O ; ] B QRNPO ^_]JT^_NPOgQ < ~ ; UR]VS^CU ; QTUR^ [Bc<gD D S ; UG Bql L j IRS ; U ;=> hvOg^_] ;> N Bc> QTOg^ B U
BE[ OgIRS#Y <?B ~ > S D ^_NY < S+N?SZUO S+J ; UKJ OgIRS B ~tO ; ^CUTS+JUWQ D S < ^_] ;=>R< SZN?Q > ON ;=< S] BED Y ;< S+J l ^fO IO ITS ; U ;> hvOg^_] ;=>
N BE> QTOg^ B ULKQ < O ITS <?DBE< S < SZN?Q > ON BE[; YS <g[BE<gD; UR]VSGO SZN?O B U MRA ;< SY < SZNgSVUWOgS+JL vQT~KN?S+QRSVUWO > h F
] B UK] > QRJT^CUTb < S D;=< tN ; URJ0NgQTbEbcS+NPO ^ B UKN [Bc<#[ Q < OgIRS <1< SZNgS ;=< ]I ;< SbE^feESZUL
 .0-
%"#$2 34
%*(57
%$!58-"9  
:B UKN?^_JTS < OgIRS1Jt^ D SZURN?^ B U > SZNgN > ^CURS ;< ^CVS+J ` Q > S < S+WQ ; Og^ B UKN1ERKa^CU ] B URN?S < e ; Og^ B U [BE<gD ^CUOgI < SVS1N?Y ; O ^ ;=>
JT^ D SZUKN?^ B UKN
% $#"  & " ' $#"  ) (+*-, x "/.0 "
s
 0       0 !#"


l ITS < S
   0 21   43+/ 5" 1  (+6 798:,;6 798<"
r
l ^fOgI^CUR^fOg^ ;=>k; UKJG~ B QRUKJ ;=< h0] B URJT^fO ^ B UKNVLS < =S >(6 7 8 ^_N1O ITS'N B Q < ]VSOgS <?D/[BE< O ITSoR F *(+6 7?^_N
; U B YSZUJ BcD; ^CU l ^fOgI~ B QRUKJ ;=< h * ; URJ ( x "/.JtSZU B O SZN#Og^ D SEL j ITS-NgQ DD; O ^ B U] B UWeSVUWOg^ B U^_N
QKN?S+J B U0OgIRS < SZYS ; OgS+J0^CURJTS Ap @RFRl IR S < S @   s " r " BL C ' DFE'"/GHEI
"/GHEJ<"/GE? "%KE|M L FTl IRS < SOgIRSo] BED Y B UTSZUON
BE[ OgIRSeSZ]{O BE< JTSVU B OgSO IRSJt^ D SZURN?^ B U > SZNgN ; S <?BW; ] B QRNPO ^_]JTSVUKN?^fOhYS < OgQ < ~ ; Og^ B U F O ITSO I < SZSeS >CB ]{^fOh
YS < O Q < ~ ; O ^ B U] BED Y B UTSZUON ; URJoO ITS1Y < SZN N?Q < S9YS < OgQ < ~ ; Og^ B U FE< SZN?YS+]O ^feES > hL j IRS1] BED Y B URSZUON BE[ eES+]O BE<
 3 JtSZU B O SOgIRS'JT^ D SZUKN?^ B U > S+NgNQ ; UWO ^fOg^CS+N < S >|; OgS+JO B O IRS D S ; U0 B+l JTSVUKN?^fOh F OgIRSOgI < SZS'] BED Y B UTSZUON
BE[ O ITS D S ; UG B+l eES >CB ]V^fOh ; UKJO ITS D S ; U0 B+l Y < S+NgN?Q < SEL j IRS D; O < ^_]VSZN 1  ;< S'JTSVRURSZJ ;
N
I
J
NOO Q
x UWV
OO x  Q RS RTx RTx ? I VVV
x  Q  x RR J  V "
1    3   O x

x
x
x
Q
P x
 R? X
I
J
R R R? Q 
l< SZITNgYS < S+YS ]O Q ^feSI >"Th Q FK; J UK"TQ J ? ;< JTS'SVUO IRB S-O S+] N9BcOgD IRYS'B UR<gSVB UWUROS+N ] BcE[ S < O iITJtS S > D O ; S ; NPhUD ~ B+BEl > L \; ]ITUvQ D ~S < ^CU pMF h ; UKJVJT^ < SZ]{Og^ B U F
R&ZW
(SYA) 24-2

- "*-$"9-$
^]WZ$
%
/ "#
%$&'`_
4)-'*

UO IR^_NN?S+]O ^ B U l S#~ < ^CSVTh JTSZN ] < ^C~S1O ITSQ ; J < ; OgQ < S{ [< SZS X ^_Ng] B UWOg^CUvQ B QKN% ;=> S < W^CUN?Y ; O ^ ;> JT^_Ng] < SVOg^C ;
O ^ B U2LiU ;DBc< S#JTSVO ; ^ > SZJ JTS+Ng] < ^CYTOg^ B U ^_N4Y < S+N?SZUO SZJL j I <gB QTbEI B QTO4OgIR^_N4NgSZ]{Og^ B U l S1I ; eESBab(7 s "Tced F
[

(7 x "TQ ; URJ
(7 x "TQ L

aS{OQKNJTSVRURSoO IRSN Bc> QTOg^ B
~S'JTSVRUTS+J ; N

(SYA) 24-3

UNgY ; ]{S JtSZTURS+J B U * F > SVO  ( ; UKJ > SVOO IRS-^CURURS < Y <gB JTQK]O B U
 G " 
 :Gk% $A M%$A $#"
v
[<?BED l IT^_]I l S'] ; UJtSZRUTS sqrq O ITS  J U BE<?
D  G    G "/G
L
j IRSJ BED; ^CU * ^_N-Y ;< O ^fOg^ B UTS+J7^CUO B U B UT B eES <g>|; YRYT^CURbS > S D SZUONY* F * #* L5aS{O ~S
; RUR^fOgSVJT^ D SVUKN?^ B U ;=> N?QR~RNgY ; ]{S F N?Y ; UTURSZJ~h0O IRS > ^CURS ;=<g> h^CUKJtSZYSZUKJtSZUZ O~ ; N?^_N [ QTUKZ ]{Og^ B URN"! Z$# F2; UKJ > SVO
% (&'vLb%-^_N B ~TO ; ^CURSZJG~WhOgIRSY <gB ?SZ]{O ^ B U Bc[  B UO B OgIRSNgQT~KN?Y ; ]V
S '  (>K')+*-,.! Z$#0/
% 25 143 5 Z$#  ; ! Z$# % $A= <
w
I7 3:9
Z$6 #86
UOgIRS X ^_N ] B UO ^CUvQ B QRN# ;=> S < W^CU [Bc<gD Q >|; Og^ B UO IRSQTURvU Bql UG] B SZ]{^CSZUON 9 Z$# ;< S B ~TO ; ^CURSZJ~hN BE> ev^CURb
O ITSoNPhtN?OgS D BE[ SZWQ ; O ^ B UKN1bE^feESZU0~Wh
  >E0 "?! ZA@
  #"?! ZA@
&" B' aT"?
8 <

H ;< Og^ ;=> ^CUO SVb <; O ^ B U Bc[` L| hv^CS > JTN

 ! ZA@ "?! ZC#
 9 Z$#   ! ZA@ "T1  ! Z$#
ZC# FGH! ZA@ ! Z$#  1  *  Z$# JI   ! ZA@ "&K
0"LB' aT" "?
0 "
u
9
9
ED  
l ITS < MS I Z   * Z ; UK%J N^_N9O IRSQRUT^fO B QTO l#;=< JGU BE<gD;=> O B ~ B QRUKJ ;=< %h I Z L
:>CB N?S < ^CURNgYS+]O ^ B U BE[ ~ B O I ` L| ; URJ ` KL| u < SVeES ;=> N1O I ; OOgIRS'N BE> QtO ^ B U l ^fO IT^CU ; US > S D SVUWO B U > h
JTSVYSZURJRN B U-^CU [Bc<gD; O ^ B U l ^fOgIR^CU-OgI ; OS > S D SVUWO F ^L}ScLAO IRS < S^_NkU "B O ] BcDD QTUR^_] ; O ^ B U O ~SVO l SZSVU-S > S D SVUWO NZL
KQ < OgIRS <?DBc< SOgIRSb >CB ~ ;> N BE> QtO ^ B U^_N F ^CU bESZUTS < ;=>F JT^_Ng] B UWO ^CUWQ B QKN B eS <0; US > S D SZUOG^CUWOgS <g[; ]{SEL jAB
Y <?B et^_JtS9O ITS#] < QK]{^ ;=> ] B QRY > ^CUTb ; URJ-O B I ; UKJ > S9O ITS#Jt^_N ] B UO ^CUvQT^fOh ; O4S > S D SZUO^CUWOgS <g[; ]{S+N F O ITS1~ B QRURJ ;< hv
U Bc<gD;> RQ pF    >E *   1  *  % F ^_N DB JTS > SZJ~Wh D S ; UKN Bc[ ; U ; YTY <gB+p ^ D; O S1^CS D; URURQ p
QP  >R "T  * FWl IRS < :
S >R ; UKJ  < SZY < S+N?SVUWO % B USZ^fO ITS < N?^_JTS Bc[ O ITSS > S D SVUWO^CUO S <?[; ]VSEL Bc< O IRS
Y <  S+N?SZUO#^ D PY > S D  SVUWO ; O ^ B U BE[ OgIRS D S{P O I B J l S ; YRY <gB+p ^ D; O SOgIRS'1^CS D; URUGTQ p ~WhOgIRS  ;p i < ^CS+J < ^_] IKN
RQ pMFTl IT^_]I] ; U0~S l#< ^fOgOgSZU ; N
 P  SR "T P  *   rs ,v    SRM      P * 
  P >RM / "


l ITS < US NY B ^CUWON [<gBcD S > S D SVUW>O  O B S > S D SVUW;O 7 ; UKJ I ^_N ; DY T B N?^fO ^feSD Q ; UWO ^fOihO I ; O^_N >|;=< bES < ^CU
D; bEUR^fOgQKJtSOgI ; U0OgIRSSZ^CbESVUWe ;=> QRSZN BE[ OgIRWS V ; ] B ~R^ ; U BE[ J T   SRM      P *  L
Bc<; WQ ; J < ; OgQ < S{ [< SZS'^ D Y > S D SZUWO ; Og^ B U kBE[4` KL| u 9OgIRS-N B Q < ]VS{OgS <gD ^CUOgIRS-R ;> N B 1I ; N#O B ~S
Y <?B ?SZ]{OgS+J B UWO B '
X Y5 1K3 I 5 7 Z$#  ! Z$# ' $A8 <


3
[
Z$6 #Z6
v^CUR]VS0OgIRSER ;< S > ^CURS ;=<ZF    %c^_N S p Y ; URJTS+J^CU ; U ; O Q < ;=>9l#; h ; N] ; U~SN?SZSVU [<gBED ` L| u L
KQ < OgIRS <?DBc< S Fty O W^CUKN ; UR4J  B ] ;=< J w+< SZY BE< OO I ; O [BE< OgIRSN?^ D Q >|; O ^ B U Bc[ OgIRSNg] ; OgO S < ^CUTb Bc[A; ] B QKNPO ^_]
l#; eS+N l ITS < S ; U ; N N?Q D YTOg^ B U BE[2> ^CUTS ;< ^fOh] ; U~S D; JTSq^fO9^_N9N?QR]V^CSZUOO B< SZY < S+N?SVUWOO ITS D S ; U Bql
~Wh ;>CB+l S < Bc< JtS < Y Bc> htU BcD ^ ;> O B SZUKN?Q < SOgIRS [BE<?D;>aBc< JtS < Y <gB YS < O ^CSZN BE[ O IRS D S{O I B JL
V B ITUKN B U ; UKJ H4^fO  ;=\ < ; O ; rq Y <gB eEISO I ; O l ITSZU-OgIRS9~ ; N?^_N [ QRUK]O ^ B UKN ;=< SY BE> hvU BcD ^ ;=> N Bc[ JTSVb < SZS K F O IRS
BE< JTS <#Bc[; ]Z]{Q < ; ]{h^_N ; O > S ; NPO K= J LiU DB NPO#Y <; ]{Og^_] ;=> ] ; NgSZN' O IRS BE< JTS <1BE[; ]Z]VQ <; ]{h^_N B ~KN?S < eS+J

O B ~S K  s L
^fO IO ITS < S >|; O ^ B U~S{O l SZSZU5Q F K ; UKJ0O ITSoUvQ D ~S <BE[ N?Y ; ]VS{Og^ D S-JT^ D SZURNg^ B UUbE^feESZU
~Wh

Q K " t s  s   K= 0"
s+x
I
D
O IT^_N^ D Y > ^CS+NO I ; O^CU BE< JtS < O B0B ~TO ; ^CUN?S+] B UKJv BE< JTS <'; ]Z#Z]{6 Q < ; ]{h l S D QKNPO']I BWB N?S9K  scFa< S+N?Q > Og^CURb0^CU
Q  [BE< = L
` KL| u ^_Na] B UWeSVUR^CSVUWO > hS{e ;=> Q ; OgS+JO I <gB QTbEIO ITS^CUO <gB JTQR]{O ^ B U BE[ ] BED YTQTO ; O ^ B U ;> ] BWBE< JT^CU ; O SZNZL j IRSZNgS
] BWBE< Jt^CU ; O S+N ;< S >CB ] ;=> O B;< S [ S < SVUK]VSS > S D SVUWO [BE<-l IT^_]I l S0] I BvB N?S ; USZWQ ;> iN?^_JTSZJ7OgSVO <; ITS+J <gB UL
^fO IR^CUOgIRS < S [ S < SZUR]VS9S > S D SVUWO l S1JTSVRURSO ITS1~ ; N?^_N4N?SVO F ] B URN?^_N?Og^CURb BE[KD B U BED ^ ;> N Fv; N ! # ( , s "" "
/ L
j ITSO ^ D SG^CUWOgSZb < ; Og^ B U^_N YS <?[BE<?D SZJ~Wh ; NgSZ] B UKJt BE< JTS <; ]V]VQ <; OgS F%[B Q < NPO SZY F>CBql NPO BE< ; bcS1QRUTbESV
QtOgO ;;> b BE< ^fO I D s+q L
j IRS X ^_Ng] B UO ^CUWQ B QRN1 ;=> S < v^CU D SVO I B J F JtQRSO B ^fON >CB ] ;=> ]I ;<; ]{O S <ZF ^_NeES < h l S >C> N?QT^fO S+J [Bc< Y ;<;>C> S >
] ;> ]VQ >|; O ^ B UKNVL j IRSY < S+N?SZUO'Y ;=< ;=>C> S > ^ D Y > S D SZUO ; O ^ B U^_N~ ; N?SZJ B U ; J BED; ^CUJtS+] BcD Y B N?^fO ^ B U Bc[ O IRS
QRURN?O < QR]{O Q < SZJ D S+N?I^CUWO B N?S{eS < ;=> ~ >CB ] tN l ITS < SOgIRS] ;=> ]VQ >|; Og^ B U [Bc< S ; ]I~ >CB ]^_N'YS <?[Bc<gD SZJ B U ;
JT^CS < SVUWO9Y <?B ]{S+NgN BE< L j ITS 
 S+NgN ; bES
; NgN?^CURb-|UWO S <g[; ]VSq <gB QTO ^CUTS+N ;< SQKN?S+JO B ] BcDD QTUR^_] ; O SJ ; O ;
~S{O l SVSZUY <gB ]{S+NgN BE< N [Bc< O ITSoRQ p ] ;> ]VQ >|; O ^ B UKN ; OO ITSo^CUWO S <g[; ]VSZN Bc[ S > S D SZUON~S >CB URbE^CUTbO B JT^CS < SVUWO
Y ;< O ^fOg^ B URNZL j ITS~ >CB ]Y ;< Og^fO ^ B UT^CURb^fO NgS >C[F ^_Na~ ; N?S+J B UO IRS  s > ^C~ <;=< ^CS+N FE; UKJ^_N B YTOg^ D ^CVS+J'^CU
BE< JTS < O B; ] IR^CSVeES~ B OgI ; WQ ; N?^fQTUR^ [Bc<gD,>CB; Jt^CURb B U-OgIRSY <?B ]{S+NgN BE< N FE; URJoO B>CBql S < O ITS9] BED D QTUR^_] ; O ^ B U
] B N?O N#JTQ < ^CURb] BcD YTQTO ; O ^ B U7 D ^CUT^ D ^C ; O ^ B U BE[ O ITSUWQ D ~S <#BE[ ^CUWOgS <g[; ]{S+NL
(SYA) 24-4





%A 6"




"A  T T$"

 ! "#$&%')( *#+,( .-

UOgIR^_NeS < ^CK] ; Og^ B Uo] ; N?S4O ITST ` WNZL| s O B ? ;=< S%N Bc> eSZJ B U ; NgWQ ;=< S%J BED; ^CUo^CU l IT^_]I ; ] BcD Y ; ]{O
; ] B QKNPOg^_]YS < O Q < ~ ; O ^ B U^_N^ D Y B N?S+JOgI <?B QRbcIO IRS^CUT^fO ^ ;=> ] B URJT^fOg^ B UKNVL j IRSO l9B iJT^ D SZURNg^ B U ;> J BED; ^CU
I ; NJT^ D SZURNg^ B UKN  ( s+xEx " s+xcx0F / ( s+xcx " s+xcx; URJ7O IRS ; ] B QKNPO ^_]N B Q < ]VSG^_N^CUR^fO I ^ ;>C> h]VSZUO S < S+J
; O   /  x L j IRS D D S ; U Bql ^_NQTUR^ D [BE<gD l ^fOgI \; ]ItUvQ D ~S < ] BED Y B URSZUON Q  Q  x < w
; URJ Q J  xtF OgIRS < S ;=< SU B N B Q < ]VS+NM 21 ; UKJO IRS-^CUT^fO ^ ;=> ] B UKJt^fO ^ B U [Bc< O ITS rcX N BE> QTOg^ B UeES+]O BE<
  " / "   !% D E'"/GHE%" FE'"%KHE| L^_N#bE^feESZU0~Wh
344 6 " / 9
::
4 7 6 " / :
  " / " x b 
"
sEs
 
5 7.6/86  " / " / ;

l ^fOgI
6  " / =<,>8?A@CBEDGFIHJDK/"
sqr

* r " 7  x < x :<
j IT^_N9O SZNPO] ; N?SI ; N ;=> N B ~SVSZU ; JTJ < SZNgNgSZJ~Wh y O W^CUKN T ; URJ vIWQ L jAB bES{O IRS <9l ^fO I ; e BE< Og^_]V^fOih l1; eS^fO
^_N [ Q < OgIRS <gDBc< SJTSZN ] < ^C~S+J ; N%Y ;=< O Bc[ OgIRSaZ L= ; M Bc< vNgI B Y B U @ SVUK] I D;< H <?B ~ > S D N%^CU :BcD
YRQtO ; Og^ B U ;=>Ay S <gB; ] B QKNPOg^_]ZN- sqwq L1z B O S F I B+l SVeES <VF OgI ; O^CUOgIRS'~SZUK] I D;=< i] ; N?SO ITS'^CUR^fOg^ ;=> eES >CB ]{^fO ^CSZN F
GE ; UKS
J FE F;=< SO ; ESVU0SZWQ ;> O B ZS <gB L



(SYA) 24-5

- +,(G% $  +(  -

j ITSR F O B bES{O IRS <l ^fO IOgIRS] B UKJT^fOg^ B URN9JTSZN ] < ^C~S+J ; ~ B eS F ] ; U~SO < ; UKN [BE<gD S+J^CUWO B OgIRS l#; eSS+Q ;
O ^ B U
J

J
 x " l ^fOgI   Q  "

s+
J
 D
 H
l ITS < S
^_N1SZ^fO ITS <#B UTS Bc[ O ITSY < ^ D ^fO ^feESe ;< ^ ; ~ > S+N D E "G E " E Bc< K E L 
d Y B U^CUWO <gB JtQK]{^CURb ; ] BvBc< Jt^CU ; OgSNPhtN?OgS D DB et^CURb l ^fO IO ITS D S ; U Bql    "8   Q  "8  /F
O ITS l1; eESS+Q ; O ^ B U0] ; U~S l#< ^fOgOgSZU ; N
D
J

 !b  "  L <

 J   J
 x " 
s v


 D
 
zS p O l S^CUO <gB JTQR]VSY BE>|;< ] BWBE< JT^CU ; O SZN <"E Fkl IRS < MS 5] B N+ E ; UKJ   N?^CUAE ; UKJ ; NgN?Q D S
O I ; O
^_N#^CURJTSZYSZURJTSZUO Bc[ 
J
 J
s

sqw
 J
  J      x <
 D 

URN?OgS ; J Bc[ N Bc> et^CUTb ` KL| s+w [BE<B UTS BE[ O ITS0Y < ^ D ^fO ^feESe ;=< ^ ; ~ > S+N l S l ^ >C> N BE> eS0^fO [Bc< OgIRSGeS >CB ]{^fOh
Y B O SZUO ^ ;>   <"  Fl IT^_]I ;> N B N ; O ^_N?RSZNOgIRS l1; eSSZWQ ; O ^ B U2L ^fOgI GEH B ; URJ FEH H O ITSY < ^ D ^fO ^feES
e ;< ^ ; ~ > S+N ;< S < S >|; OgS+JO B O IRSeS >CB ]V^fOihY B OgSZUO ^ ;=> ~h
   G E "
   K E"
s+
l ITS < S G E ^_NO ITS <; Jt^ ;=> eES >CB ]V^fOh] BE D Y B URSZUO+L j ITSH^C UR^fOg^ ;=D > ] B UKJt^fO ^ B UKN'] ; U~S B ~tO ; ^CUTS+J [<gBcD OgIRSZNgS
O lB< S >|; O ^ B URN
7 <,>8? D "
  <" x b   G E  E " 
squ
r
!
D
   <" x   K E  <" x   <,>8T ? D8<
s
D
D

j ITSN BE> QtO ^ B U BE[` L| sqw [Bc<
 l ^fO IO IRSo^CUT^fO ^ ;> ] B URJT^fO ^ B UKNbE^feSVU~h ` L| s+u ; UKJ ` L| s E#] ; U
~S B ~tO ; ^CURS+JG] B UWeSVUR^CSVUWO > h~hS D Y >CB ht^CURb O IRS ; URES > O <; URN [BE<?D
  <"#    3 ! $&% 3 $ E( ' $ "#  $ "
s
' $ "#    3 !  % 3 $ E   <"# "<"
rcx
l ITS < S % 3 ^_N1O ITS'VS <?B O It Bc< JTS <@ S+NgN?S >[ QRUK]O ^ B U BE[ OgIRS < NPOv^CURJL d Y B U ; YRY > hv^CURb O ITS' ; UTES > O < ; URN?
[Bc<gD O ITSY <?B ~ > S D/< S+JTQR]VSZN1O B N BE> ev^CURb
J
 'J  $ J '  x "
rts

l ^fOgI
' $ " x b *) $ & "  ' $ " x  *+ $ 0 "
rEr



l ITS < S ) $ ; UKJ + $ ;=< Sbc^feSZU0~h

7
) $ b r  3 !  % 3 $ E<,>8? D"<"
D
+ $   T3 !  % 3 $ E<,>8? D" <
rc
D
<?BED < ; JRN?IO SVhvU ; UKJ9htVIR^C s+q2l S B ~TO ; ^CU
 3 !  % 3 $ E <,>8? D"  r s <,> D <
r v
T
j ITSoN Bc> QTO ^ B U BE[` L| rts 9] ; U0~S l#< ^fO?O SZU ;
N
rEw
' $ "#  *) $ v] B Nq $  + $ N?^CUA $ 8<
d N?^CURb ` KL| s EO B O < ; URN [BE<?D ~ ; ] [<gBcD $ O B  l S B ~TO ; ^CU $ [BE< O ITSeES >CB ]V^fOhY B O SZUO ^ ;>
s 7 !
!
  <"#  
rD r  3 $&% 3E $ v] B Nq $ <,> D  $   3 % 3E $ EvNg^CUa $  <,> D  $ < rc
j ITS'bcSZUTS <;> N BE> QtO ^ B T U F; N T [ QTUK]O ^ B U BE[  ; UKJ  F RU ;=>C> h~SZ] BED S+N
K E   "   r s  3 ! $&% 3 $ Et] B NZ $   <,> D  $ r 7  3 ! $ J % 3 $ EtN?^CUa $   <,> D  $ "
rEu
D
G E   "    T rD Q    3 ! $&% I $ EtN?^CUa $   <,> D  $ T  r 7  3 ! $ J % I $ Et] B NZ $   <,> D  $ "v r
 E   "   r /  T  3 ! $&% I $ EtN?^CUA $   <,> D  $  r 7  3 T ! $ J % I $ Et] B N+ $   <,> D  $ " r
T
T
l ITS < S
Ex
   Q J  / J "
; URJ D E KHELiU0OgIRS ; ~ B eSS p Y < SZN N?^ B UKN % I ^_N1O ITSD < NPOg BE< JtS <@ SZN N?S >[ QRUR]{Og^ B U Bc[ OgIRS < NPOv^CURJL
(SYA) 24-6























0! 8)(G% $ 0 +

Bc<; ] BE<g< S+]O^ D Y > S D SVUWO ; O ^ B U Bc[ O ITSG^CUR^fO ^ ;> ] B UKJt^fO ^ B U l SGI ; eSO B Y <gB ?S+]O   " / " x F bc^feSVU~Wh
` KL| scs FkB UWO B O IRS~ ; N?^_N [ QRUK]O ^ B UKNVL j ITS^CUWOgSZb < ; Og^ B UKN l IT^_]IOgIRSZUI ; eSO B ~SYS <?[BE<?D SZJ ;< SU B O
NPO <; ^CbEIO [Bc<?l1;=< JML y> O S < U ; O ^feES > h FRl S l ^ >C>A; YTY <gB+p ^ D; O SO IRS^CUR^fOg^ ;=> N BE> QTOg^ B U0~Wh ; N?S+] B UKJv Bc< JTS <; ]V]VQT
<; O S jk; h >CBc< NgS < ^CSZNS p Y ; URN?^ B U ;=<?B QRURJ O ITS]VSZUO <?B ^_J BE[ S ; ]IS > S D SVUWO ; N l#; N ;=> N B J B URS~h y O W^CUKN ; UKJ
vIWQ L
U BE< JtS < O B YS <g[BE<?D OgIR^_N rcX ] ;=> ]VQ >|; Og^ B U l ^fOgIO ITSGY < S+N?SVUWO cXD SVOgI B J ;>C> JtS < ^fe ; Og^feSZN^CUO IRS
iJT^ < S+]O ^ B U ;=< SO ; cSZUS+Q ;> O B VS <gB LKQ < OgIRS <?DBc< SNPh DD SVO < hvY >|; URS~ B QRURJ ;< h] B UKJT^fOg^ B URN ;< SQKN?S+J
[Bc< O ITSQRYTYS <; URJ >CBql S < ~ B QRURJ ;< h'^CU'O ITS JT^ < S+]{Og^ B UL%mU ;>C> O ITS B OgIRS < ~ B QTUKJ ;< ^CSZN Bc[ O ITS] BED YRQtO ;
O ^ B U ;=> J BED; ^CU]I ;=< ; ]{OgS < ^_N?Og^_]{~ ; N?SZJU B UT < SVRS+]O ^CUTbo~ B QRURJ ;< h] B UKJt^fO ^ B URN ;< SQKN?SZJL @B OgI~ B QRURJ ;< h
] B UKJT^fOg^ B URN ;=< SoJtS+Ng] < ^C~SZJG^CU7 uq L SO ; cS [BE< OgIRS rcX N Bc> QTOg^ B UGO ITS < SZN?Q > O^CUGO IRSY >|; URS<  x L
j IRSN?^ D Q >|; O ^ B UKN9I ; eS~SZSZU] ;=<?< ^CSZJ B QTO B UGJT^CS < SVUWO9OgSVO <; ITS+J <;=>D S+N?IRSZNZL j ITSYTIWhtNg^_] ;=> J BcD; ^CU F

* F ^_NY ;=< Og^fO ^ B URS+J^CUWO B c d9^_JtSZUO ^_] ;> O S{O <; IRSZJ <gB UKN B ~tO ; ^CURS+J~WhJT^fet^_Jt^CURbY*^CUWO B S+Q ;>C> hN?^CVS+J]{QR~S+N F
l TI ^_]IY <gB ev^_JTSZNQKN l ^fOgI ; ~ ; ] vb <?B QTUKJ D SZNgI FT; UKJOgIRSZUJT^fev^_JT^CURb-S ; ] I]{QR~S^CUO Bs+r ^_JTSZUO ^_] ;=> O S{O <;
IRSZJ <gB UKNVLiUO ; ~ > S s=F NgYS+]{^CK] ; O ^ B UKN BE[ O ITSJt^CS < SZUO D SZNgITS+N ;=< S0bE^feSVU2L j IRS~ ; ] vb <?B QTUKJ D S+N?I
JT^ D SZUKN?^ B UKN ;< Sbc^feSVUG~h4c B F c H ; UKJ;c Ftl IR^ > S"*KJtSZU B O SZNO ITSUvQ D ~S <9BEI[ Y <gB ]{S+NgN BE< N9QRNgSZJ^CUO IRS
] BcD YRQtO ; O ^ B UL
JTSVU B OgS+N ; ]I ;=<; ]{OgS < ^_NPOg^_] D S+N?ITN?^CZS FW; UKJ ^_NbE^feESZU~Wh
 L y>C> N?^ D Q >|; Og^ B URN%I ; eS
~SVSZU] ;<g< ^CSZJ B QTO l ^fOgI ;  v=UWQ D ~S <#BE[4x L sqw L
1

(SYA) 24-7



00
000
0FE

       "!

2
3"465 1 +"+
1+ 1+
4+ 4+
3+6B>582+"+
1
?&+"+ ?+"+ G
@+"+75H+"+"+
?A2+ ?&2+ @
?95H+>3"@6584+"+
E
?A@+ ?&@+ 4
265 1 G>B>58@+"+
EL0
D &OPQR 9S> !T#U "VW #X Y !Z% \[ ]_^
I 29`a &OPbc 9S> !Tde!f'*)a?YgihZPj !

#$ % &('*),+
375829+"+
?A275849+"+
2+5 +"+"+6I
2"475849+"+
G?5829+"+

:;<
C: : <
: <: <
:KJ: <
:NM <

./
2>= 1 9= 4>=7?A@>=93"2
2>D = 1 9= 4>=7?A@>=93"2>=@ 1 =7?A2"4
@1
?A2"4

j; ~ > S s lk,m&npoTnrqRmstUuvs_wyxNt{z>|}n~w6||6mcz"Zq_zys9mAnYnAz>YnL7nAm"rz>xNovms9z"Tqcyx wyxNt{z>|}nrz"xNovmZtUm_m|x

s_w6n_m&n

7i~>{'N'NlZZl>

U ] ; N?Si l#; N ;=>C< S ; Jvh] B UKN?^_JTS < S+J l ^fOgIO ITSU B UTY ;<;=>C> S > ] B JtSEL j ITS < S+N?Q > O N B ~tO ; ^CUTS+J l ^fOgIO IRS
]VQ <g< SVUWOeS < N?^ B U BE[ OgIRS] B JTSN?I B+l S+NU B JT^CS < SVUK]{S+N l ^fO IOgIRS < S+N?Q > O N B ~tO ; ^CURS+J l ^fO IOgIR^_NY < SVev^ B QRN
eS < N?^ B U BE[ O ITS'] B JTScL
^CbTL| s 2Y < S+N?SVUWONaOgIRS < S+N?Q > O N B ~tO ; ^CURS+J [BE< KE F;=>CB UTbO IRS > ^CURS  s+x[Bc<  r=xtFc[BE< OgIRS9] ; N?S+Na ; UKJ
; N l S >C>; NO IRS ; U ;=> hWO ^_] ;=> N BE> QtO ^ B U2L j IRS >CB ] ; O ^ B U BE[ O ITSJT ^_NPO Q < ~ ; UK]{S ^_N ; ]V]VQ <; OgS > h < SZN BE> eSZJ^CU
~ B O I] ; NgSZNVL j ITS D; bcUR^CK] ; Og^ B U Bc[ OgIRS < SVbE^ B U cx  sZxtF Y < SZNgSVUWOgS+JG^CU^CbTL| s L}~ F N?I B+l N1OgI ; O
O ITS < SZNgQ > O B ~TO ; ^CUTS+J [BE< ] ; NgS1N?I Bql N ; N > ^CbEIWOD > h0~SVO?O S < ] BED D Y ;=< ^_N B U l ^fOgI0O ITS ; U ;> hvOg^_] ;=> N Bc> QTOg^ B U F
O I ; UGO ITS < SZN?Q > O B ~TO ; ^CURSZJ [BE< ] ; NgS FK; N B URS D ^CbEIOI ; eESS p YSZ]{O SZJL
^CbTL| r Y < S+N?SZUONO IRS < SZNgQ > ON B ~tO ; ^CURS+J [Bc< K E F;=>CB URbO ITS > ^CURS  rcx0[BE<  xtFc< OgIRS] ; N?S+N
i ; UKJ ; N l S >C>9; NOgIRS ; U ;=> hWO ^_] ;=> N Bc> QTOg^ B U2L j IRS < SZN?Q > ON B ~TO  ; ^CURSZJ [Bc< ] ;  N?SN?I B+l ; ~SVO?O S <
; b < SZS D SVUWO l ^fOgI0OgIRS ; U ;> hvOg^_] ;=> N BE> QTOg^ B UGO I ; UO I B N?S BE[ ] ; NgSi-L
Uk^CbEQ < S+N- s ; UKJ7 r O ITSob <; YTI BE[ O ITS ; U ;> hvOg^_] ;=> N BE> QtO ^ B U^_N B ~tO ; ^CUTS+J~h ; YRY <?Bqp ^ D; Og^CURbO IRS
^CUWOgSZb < ;=> N1^CU ` KL| rcu ~Wh D S ; UKN BE[; ] BED Y B N?^fO eS v^ D YKN B U N < Q > SEL j IRSUvQ D ~S <#BE[ Q ; J <; O Q < SY B ^CUON
^_N] I B NgSVUN?QR]V^CSVUWO > hIR^CbEI F N B O I ; O [ Q < O ITS < ^CUK] < S ; N?^CURbO ITSUWQ D ~S <BE[ WQ ; J < ; OgQ < S-Y B ^CUWO N l ^ >C> U B O
~Set^_N?^C~ > S'^CUGO IRSRbcQ < SZNVL
Bc<   x` L| rcu ] ; U~S SVe ;=> Q ; O SZJS pR; ]{O > h Fl ^fO I B QTO ; UWhUvQ D S < ^_] ;>%; YTY <gB+p ^ D; O ^ B U2L BE< O IRS
Y < S+NgN?Q < SYS < O Q < ~ ; O ^ B U l S B ~tO ; ^CUO ITS ; U ;> hvOg^_] ;=> N BE> QtO ^ B ;U K E x " rcx 9  x < xTsZEr W RL SJtSZU B O S
O ITSUWQ D S < ^_] ;=>2; YRY <gB+p ^ D; O ^ B U BE[ K E x " r=x F ] BcD YTQTO SZJ B U I ;oD SZN?I l ^fO IG]D I ;<; ]{O S < ^_NPO ^_]N?^CZS
F ~Wh K  E L
U^CbTL| L ; l SoI ; eSY >CB O?O SZJ B K E KE x " r=x  WeTNV*L
> B U >CB b ;=< ^fO D ^_]oNg] ;> S+NVL j IRSe ;> QRS+N BE[ O IRS
]I ;=<; ]{OgS < ^_NPOg^_] D S+N?IN?^CZS
< S >|; O SZJO B O ITSe ;< ^ B QRNo] ; NgSZN ;=< SY < SZNgSVUWOgS+J^CUO ; ~ > S s L j IRS < S+N?Q > ON
BE[ ] ; NgSg? F ; URJ ;=>CD B NPO > ^CS B U ; D NPO <; ^CbcIWO > ^CURScL j ITS < S+N?Q > O B ~TO ; ^CURSZJ B UOgIRS ] B;=< N?S D SZNgI BE[
] ; NgSg B U > hJtSVev^ ; O SZN ;G> ^fOgO > S [<?BED O IR^_N > ^CUTSELz B O SO I ; O'OgIRS < SZNgQ > O B ~TO ; ^CURSZJ [BE< ] ; N?Si ^_N'U B O
O ; ESZU0^CUO B ] B UKN?^_JtS <; O ^ B U F N?^CUK]VSO IRS < S+N?Q > O^_N#U B O D S ; N?Q < S+JG^CU0OgIRSY >|; URS  x Ln j ITS'N >CB YS  Bc[ O IRS
> ^CURS-bE^feES+NQKNO ITS BE< JtS <Bc[ O IRS D S{O I B J^CUOgIRSoY B ^CUWO  <"   x " rcx L j IRSN >CB YS-N?QRbcbES+NPO N >w BE< JTS <
; ]V]VQ < ; ]h^CUO IRSN?YSZ]V^CR]Y B ^CUO' <" # ! x " r=x L4U squ+ Q ; URJ y Ogv^CURNY < S+N?SZUO < S+N?Q > O N BE[A; JTS{O ; ^ > S+J
NPO QKJvh BE[ NgY ; Og^ ;=>C> hY <gB Y ; b ; Og^CURb l1;  eES+N^CU ; AN?IRS D S ; YRY > ^CS+JO B;s+X NPhTNPO S D BE[a> ^CUTS JN; < IJ htYS < ~ BE> ^_]
S+Q ; Og^ B URNZL j ITSVh < SZY Bc< OO I ; OO ITSoYRI ; N?S-S <?<gBc< Bc[ OgIRSoYRIWhtN?^_] ;=>AD B JtSJtS+] ; hTN > ^CcfS
F Fl ITS < S K
u

(SYA) 24-8

0.15

0.15
analytic
V
VI

0.1

0.05

analytic
V
VI

0.1

0.05

-0.05

-0.05

-0.1

-0.1

-0.15
-50

-25

25

-0.15
-30

50

-25

^CbcQ < S s


-20

~

-15

z>Tqw6ptXn_z"|,z>R|v7 mYtFs_w
lAmAn"
NxKnlz yx w>tU|vm" rz" s_w6nAm w6|v

*rz"  

tNxNo xKom w6|w
 vxKtFs_w
nAz
ryxKt{z"| KE <" *ck wZ|tUus_wxKt{z"| z>xKom_mZt{z"|

rcx

cx

0.1

sZx w6|
sZx 

 

rcx 

0.1
analytic
IV
VI

analytic
IV
VI

0.05

0.05

p 0

p 0

-0.05

-0.05

-0.1
-75

-10

-50

-25

25

50

-0.1
-50

75

-45

-40

~

-35

-30

^CbcQ < S r

r=x w6|v   x 
x
=
w
x
cx 


D
D
^_NO ITSJTSVb < SVS Bc[ O IRS Y Bc> htU BcD ^ ;> N l IR^_]I ;=< SQKN?SZJ ; N~ ; N?^_N [ QRUK]O ^ B UKNVL j IRS{h ;> N B0< SVY Bc< OOgI ; OO IRS
b >CB ~ ;=> S <g<gBc<9D S ; N?Q < S [Bc< O IRSJtSZRUT^fO ^ B UGN?SZS s+uq < S+JtQK]VSZN ; O Bc< JTS <#r K9 s L SQRN?S~ ; N?^_N [ QRUK]O ^ B UKN
BE[ JTSVb < SZSeK  sl IT^_]I lB Q > J < S+N?Q > O ^CU ; JTSZ] ; h Bc[ OgIRSYRI ; N?SS <?<gBE<-> ^CES
 ; UKJ ; JTSZ] ; h Bc[ O IRS
b >CB ~ ;=> S <?<gBc<1D S ; N?Q < S > ^CES
? FK; N N?Q D ^CURbOgI ; O9O ITS < S+N?Q > O N B ~TO ; ^CUTS+J~WhQ ; UKJ y Ogv^CURN9^CU s+Xl9JFB Q > J
; YTY > hO BcX Lv Bql S{eS <ZF O IT^_N9NPOg^ >C> J B S+N%U B OS p Y >|; ^CU l Ih l S B ~RNgS < eES ; JTSZ] ; h BE[ OgIRSS <g<gBc<> ^CcS
F ? L
:> S ;=<g> h FK[ Q < OgIRS <1< SZNgS ;=< ]I B UGOgIR^_N1O B YR ^_]^_N#URSZ]VSZN N ;< hL
y NgN?Q D ^CUTbO I ; O B Q <D S{O I B J7^_N w BE< JTS <; ]V]VQ <; OgS^CU  <"  Y  x " rcx Fl S0] ; U ; YRY > h#^_] I ;< Jt
N B US p O <; Y BE>|; O ^ B U s oO BB ~TO ; ^CU ; Y < SZJT^_]O ^ B U Bc[ O IRSGS pT; ]{ON Bc> QTO ^ B U2L `D Y >CB ht^CUTb#^_] I ;=< JRN B U
z>Tqw6YtXnAz"| z>
|7m&YtFsAw
_mAn"
Nxrnz yx w>tU|vm" Kz>\sAw7nAm w>|
r z"  

tNxNo xKom w6|w
 vxKtFs_w
nAz
ryxKt{z"| KE <" *ck wZ|tUus_wxKt{z"| z>xKom_mZt{z"|

(SYA) 24-9

10

-2

-0.016

II

III

slope = 5
a+b.h

-0.0162
10-3
III

-0.0164

analytic

p
slope = 4

IV

VI

-0.0166
10

IV

-4

-0.0168
VI

10

-5

50

1/ h

100

150

-0.017

200

0.005

~

0.01

0.015

k ^CbEQ < S YtFs_z>|
6m& m&|vs9mnxy rz"\xNovm q_m&nn"6_m

S p O <; Y Bc>|; O ^ B U l S ; NgN?Q D SO I ; O1O IRS [Bc>C>CBql ^CUTbI Bc> JRN

! x " rcx 

q~m&9x&7"ZwxKt{z>|tU| <"  

Ts
d N?^CURb'O ITSUWQ D S < ^_] ;=>< SZN?Q > ON Bc[ ] ; NgSZN ; UKJ l S] ; U B ~TO ; ^CUO ITS] B SV]V^CSVUWO N ) ; UKJ !+L :B SZ]V^CSVUWO
)bc^feS+N9OgIRS 3 Y  J < 3 S+Jt^_]{O ^ B U Bc[ O IRSS pR; ]{ON BE> QtO ^ B U=KHE x " rcx Ftl S B ~tO ; ^CU%)Y x < xts+Ets+ E r L j ITS < S >|; Og^feS
S <?<gBE<  >  @ 3 @  J 3 K K  ^_N ; YTY <?Bqp ^ D; OgS > h x L xw
Lk^CbRL| L}~N?I Bql NO IRSY BE> htD U BED ^ ;=>%Bc[9` L| ts O B bcSVOgIRS <
l ^fOgI0O ITSUvQ D S < ^_] ;>2< S+N?Q > ON BE[ O IRSJT^CS < SVUWO] ; N?S+NVL
(yy &
y YS <?[Bc<gD; UK]{SO S+NPOI ; N ~SZSVU] ;<g< ^CS+J B QTO [BE< ] ; N?SGg ; UKJ B U MRA Fl IT^_]I^_N ;s+xEr c
Y >|; O [Bc<gD sZx 1] I BJ URN?^_N?Og^CURb BE[ O l9Bwvsqr P
 Tm < ^CbE^CU xEx N?htNPO S D NVL9OI ; N ; YS ; GYS <?[BE<?D; UK
]V S
BE[1s'j >CB YRN- sZx B; O ^CUTbY B ^CUO B YS < ; Og^ B UKN#YS < N?SZ] B URJ F ^fO^_NtOgOgS+J l ^fOgI wcxExc\ IR- s xExEx
 N
BE< b ; UT^CZSZJ^CU rEw= =P
 U B JTS+N ; UKJY B NgN?S+NgN?S+N s1j@ hvO S BE[ O B O ;=>tD S DBc< hEL j IRS#N?YSVS+JtQRY^_N D S ; N?Q < S+J
^CU-O S <gD N Bc[ OgIRS < ; Og^ BBc[ OgIRSQKN?S <
 O ^ D S+N F=l ITS < SOgIRSO l9B Y <?B ]{S+NgN BE< f B ~-NgS < eES+N ; N < S [ S < SZUR]VScLk <?BED
^CbTL|TL ; ^fOo] ; U~SN?SZSVUO I ; OURS ;< > ^CURS ;< NgYSZSZJtQTY^_N B ~tO ; ^CURS+J [BE< ] ; N?SL > ^CbEIO > hN?QTYS <?> ^CURS ;=<
N?YSZSZJtQRY^_N B ~tO ; ^CUTS+J B U7Y <gB ]VS+NgN BE< N [BE< ~ B OgI7] ; N?S? ; UKJi Fal IR^_] I7^_N-Y <gB ~ ; ~ > h] ; QKN?SZJ~Wh ;
DBc< S SZ]V^CSVUWO] ; ] IRSYS <?[BE<?D; UK]VScLok^CbRL|TL ; N?I Bql N [ Q < O ITS <?DBE< SOgI ; O~WhJT^fev^_JT^CURbOgIRS J BED; ^CU BE[
] ; NgS? B eS <DBE< SOgI ; UY <gB ]VS+NgN BE< N F O IRSUvQ D ~S <Bc[ S > S D SZUWO N ; N N?^CbcURS+JO B S ; ]IY <gB ]VSZN N Bc< ~S+] BED S+N
O BWB N D;>C>k; URJ0OgIRSo] BED D QRUT^_] ; O ^ B U B eS < IRS ; J0~S+] BED SZN ; YRY ;=< SVUWOZL1 <gBcD k^CbRL|RL}~ l S B ~KN?S < eSOgI ; O
[Bc< ] ; N?S l S'I ; eES ; URS ;=< > ^CURS ;=< N?YSZSZJtQRY F QTYGO B Y <gB ]VSZN N Bc< NVLmU s+r -Y <gB ]VSZN N Bc< N9O ITS < S >|; Og^feS
N?YSZSZJtQRY < S >|; O ^feESO B *K4 r I ; N#J <?B YTYS+JO BEx
L
mU s+r Y <?B ]VSZNgN Bc< N ; YTY <?Bqp ^ D; OgS > h < s+x  B; O ^CUTbY B ^CUO B YS <; O ^ B URN l S < SYS <?[BE<?D SZJYS < N?S+] B UKJ
B YKNL BE< O ITSYS <g[BE<gD; UR]VSO SZN?O [Bc< ] ; N?S F O IRS] BED YTQTO ; O ^ B U7^CUWe Bc> eSZJ sZxExcx Og^ D SNPO SVYKNVL
j ITS] BcD YRQtO ; O ^ B UO BvB > SZN NO I ; U D ^CUvQtO S+N B U s+r Y <?B ]VSZNgN Bc< NS >|; YRNgSZJO ^ D SqL MTMaI ; N ;
YS ; WYS <g[Bc<gD; UK]{S Bc[s B YKNYS < Y <?B ]VSZNgN Bc<ZF[BE< ] ; N?SOgIRS ] B JTS l#; N B ~KN?S < eSZJO BGB YS < ; OgS FB U
; eES <; bES F#; O sZx
BE[ OgIR^_NYS ; l IRSVUQRYO B Y <gB ]VSZN N Bc< N l S < SQKN?SZJL d N?^CURb^CUK] < S ; Ng^CUTb > h DBc< S
Y <?B ]VSZNgN Bc< N D BE< SO I ; U0 < S+N?Q > O S+J^CU ; b <; JTQ ;> J <gB YG^CUYS <g[BE<gD; UR]VSO B; YTY <gB+p ^ D; O S > h 
BE[ O IRS
YS ; WYS <g[Bc<gD; UK]{S FTl ITSZU sqr Y <gB ]VSZN N Bc< N l S < S'QRNgSZJ Ftl IR^_] I^_N1OgI B QTbEIOO B ~S'JTQTSO B O IRS^CUR] < S ; N?S+J
K  E  )9F!
H8.<

(SYA) 24-10

32

128
(87 %)

Linear
case IV
case II

28
24

96

20
(91 %)

16

Speed-up

Speed-up

Linear
case IV

112

58 %

12

80
(60 %)

64
48

(83 %)

76 %

100 %

32
117 %

(98 %)
(87 %)

16
(101 %)

(91 %)

12

16

20

24

28

32

Number of processors

16

32

48

64

~

80

96

112

128

Number of processors

^CbcQ < S0

qRm9m"
pq m_w7n"7Am" r z"s_w7nAm  ,xNtU mn9x mqn

w6|v s_w6nAm    xKtUmn9xm qn
z>|
Yt ZtU| *w  m&n>
NxKz>\s_w6n_m  w6|v  Kz>Tq xz \qvAz s_mAnYnAz>n  mAn"
NxKz>s_w6nAm  Kz>Tq
xz q_z s_mAnYnAz>Yn 


] BcDD QTUR^_] ; O ^ B U B eES < IRS ; JL

 4* ,
"#$&'
j ITS < S+N?Q > ONY < SZN?SZUWOgS+J^CUOgIRSY < S+N?SZUO1Y ; YS <#;=< S B ~TO ; ^CURSZJ l ^fO IO ITS] BED YTQTOgS < ] B JtS'kqv Ftl IT^_]I
^_N~ ; N?S+J B U ; UWQ D S < ^_] ;=>;=> b BE< ^fO I DGF JtSVeS >CB YS+JO B N Bc> eS0O IRS+2^CURS ;< ^CVS+J ` Q > S < S+Q ; Og^ B URNTK
^CUO I < SZSJT^ D SVUKN?^ B URNVL- Bc< O ITSN?Y ; O ^ ;> JT^_Ng] < SVOg^C ; Og^ B U BE[ O ITSROgIRSQ ; J < ; OgQ < S{ [< SZS X ^_Ng] B UWOg^CUvQT
B QRN ;> S < W^CU D SVO I B JI ; N~SZSVU ; YRY > ^CS+J Fl IT^ > SoO IRSO ^ D S-^CUO SZb <; O ^ B U^_NYS <g[BE<?D S+J~h ;[B Q < NPO SZY F
>CBql iNPO Bc<; bcSo#QTURbES{iQTOgO ;;> b BE< ^fO I D L j IRS ;=> b BE< ^fOgI D ^_N#NgSZ] B UKJt BE< JTS <; ]V]VQ < ; OgS^CU~ B O I0N?Y ; ]{S ; UKJ
O ^ D SEL j ITS D; ^CU B ~t?SZ]{Og^feS+N Bc[ O ITS l9BE< Y < S+N?SVUWO SZJ^CUGOgIRSY < S+N?SZUO#Y ; YS <;< S] B UO ^CUWQ ; Og^ B U Bc[ %O IRS
eS < ^CK] ; Og^ B U Bc[ O ITSUvQ D S < ^_] ;=>1;> b BE< ^fO I D ; UKJ7] B UKJTQR]{Og^CURb ; YS <?[Bc<gD; UK]{SOgS+NPO Bc[ OgIRSY ;<;=>C> S > ^CZSZJ
;=> b BE< ^fOgI D/B U TMa=L
y N ; eS < ^CR] ; Og^ B UY <gB ~ > S DGF O ITS] B UeS+]O ^ B U Bc[';rcX ] BcD Y ; ]{O ; ] B QKNPO ^_]Jt^_NPO Q < ~ ; UK]VSI ; N~SZSZU
] B UKN?^_JTS < S+J B UJt^CS < SZUO D S+N?IRSZN%S D Y >CB hv^CURb-Jt^CS < SZUOUWQ D ~S < N BE[ Y <gB ]VSZN N Bc< N B U TMa FR;s+xEr c
Y >|; O [Bc<gD ] B URNg^_NPOg^CURb BE[ O lBwtsqr P
 Rm < ^CbE^CU xcx NPhtN?OgS D NZL j ITS B ~tO ; ^CURS+JUWQ D S < ^_] ;=> N BE> QtO ^ B
UK N
N?I Bql eS < hGb BWB J ; b < SVS D SVUWO l ^fOgI0O ITS ; U ;=> hWO ^_] ;> N Bc> QTOg^ B U2L y b < ^_J0] B UeS < bESVUK]{SoNPOgQKJth [BE< O ITS'Y < SZN?
N?Q < S9YS < OgQ < ~ ; Og^ B U^CUOgIRS1]{SZUWO < S Bc[ O ITS1JTSZ] ; hS+J ; UKJ] B UWeES+]{OgS+J rcX ; QKNgN?^ ; UYTQ > N?S ; O%Jt^ D SZURN?^ B U > SZNgN
O ^ D S   rcxvF NgQTbEbcS+NPON%O I ; OO IRSUvQ D S < ^_] ;>M< S+N?Q > O9^CUOgI ; O9Y B ^CUWO9^_N "w  Bc< JtS <1; ]Z]{Q <; O S^CUO ITS]I ;=< ; ]{
O S < ^_NPO ^_] D S+N?IN?^CZSEL j IRS < S ; N B U [BE< OgIR^_NQTURS p YSZ]{O SZJIT^CbEI ; ]Z]VQ <; ]{h FvB ~TO ; ^CURSZJ^CUO I ; O1NgYS+]{^CK]Y B ^CUWO
l ^fOgIOgIRS1N?S+] B URJ Bc< JtS <; ]Z]{Q < ; O S ;> b BE< ^fO I D0F ^_NQTURWU Bql U ; OY < SZN?SZUWO ; UKJoURSZSZJRN [ Q < O IRS < ^CUWeES+NPO ^Cb ; Og^ B U2L
j IRS] B UKJTQR]{OgS+JYS <?[Bc<gD; UK]{SO S+NPON?I Bql S+N F OgI ; O [BE<';D S+Jt^CQ D N?^CZS+J D SZNgI Excx " xExcx S > S D SZUON F
URS ;=< > ^CURS ;=< NgYSZSZJtQTY^_N B ~tO ; ^CUTS+J l ITSZUQTYO BG Y <gB ]VS+NgN BE< N ;=< S-QKN?S+JML d Ng^CUTb sqr Y <gB ]VSZN N Bc< N [BE<
O ITSN ;=D SY <?B ~ > S D F N?I Bql S+NO I ; O ; ] BED YRQtO ; Og^ B U ;=> N?YSVS+J Bc[; YTY <gB+p ^ D; O S > h7 < s+x  BW; O ^CURbY B ^CUWO
B YS <; O ^ B UKN#YS < N?SZ] B URJ B YRN^_N B ~tO ; ^CUTS+JML


sZx

U ; JRJt^fO ^ B UO B [ Q < OgIRS < eS < ^CR] ; Og^ B U ; UKJe ;=> ^_J ; O ^ B U FR[ QtO Q < S ; ]O ^fev^fO ^CS+N l ^ >C> Y <?B ~ ; ~ > h^CUK] > QKJTS B YTO ^f
D ^C ; O ^ B U BE[ O ITS ;=> b BE< ^fO I D; UKJS p O SZURN?^ B U Bc[ O IRS ;=> b BE< ^fOgI D O B+l#;< JRN1IR^CbEITS < BE< JTS <; ]Z]{Q <; ]{hEL
2&'- 
*
%

j ITS ; QTOgI BE< N > ^CES1O B O I ; UR'O IRS#z ; O ^ B U ;=>:BED YRQtO ^CURb' ; ]V^ > ^fO ^CSZN2T [B QRURJ ; O ^ B U [Bc< b < ; UO ^CURb'] BED
YRQtO ^CURb Og^ D S B UGO ITS'N?QRYS < ] BED YRQtO S < MRA^ > SVUvQ D ~S < R xEr L
!
%Z
%$
% 

s L X L  ; UKJ ; Q ; UKJ ` L \ L 2^ [ N?IR^fOg F
 
  T { !#"$ T  V% =' &( *)+-,.c/ 0
1 F@ QTOgOgS <Pl9BE< O ItiSV^CURS D; UTU FT< SZY < ^CUO r=xExcx L
r+ : L V B ITUKN B U ; UKJ VRL1H4^fO ;\ <; O ;t3F 2  2 c/ )+45!4 t# 634K% 4.87#cC 9:4;0V4 <=-
> cC @?3)AR CBc/ EDGFK=%  FR\; OgIRS D; Og^_]ZN BE[:BED YRQTO ; Og^ B U F Bc> Lt vF z BGsqu=tF YTY2L s r=tFMs c L
q@ L :B ] v~TQ < U F@ L B Q ; UKJ : L ,L WIvQ F "H,JILKMN OPQT5 RS=c &T+VUV Z% W6XY% Y.
7#cC 9:4
4.Z
DC 0 K[ Z4 :Q\{ ]=c% ^R2 _`Qa,cbQ"$ TZ dT % Y63Y0 .ce  { F
\; O IRS D; O ^_]ZN Bc[:BcD YTQTO ; O ^ B U F Bc> L w K s x Fas E xvF YRYL w w w s L
'L %L y Ogv^CUKN ; URJ : L ,LB WIvQ gF f Kh gc%   O
  a0EAC 0 Kc% i!
634K% 4.87=_ 9Y
0V4 <:@3?3)AR CBc/ 3DeFRc% . FKy yy V B Q < U ;>F BE> L ctF YTY2L uEuEw u rvF2s EctL
w+ 'L %L y Ogv^CUKN ; UKJ X LHAL  B ] ;=< J 3F 2 ?3jN Ok[+ 
Z4 :8+4Nmln% V%   o7GQ4 T
2  qh %  2 c/ )YG!K= Y%  2 Y+g! =p'Nq c%  F=y yy H ; YS < Eq s wWFts cE F k^ [ O I
y yy L :y` y S <gB; ] B QKNPO ^_]VN :B U [ S < SZUR]VS FK\; h sZx s+r L
q 'L %L y Ogv^CUKN ; URJ : L ,LB WIvQ gF f Kh gc%   O
  a0EAC 0 Kc% i!
634K% 4.87=_ 9Y
0V4 <:@3?3)AR CBc/ 3DeFRc% . FKy yy iH ; YS < s+ vF2s E L
u+ 'L %L y O W^CUKN F K% 4.K g6' ]cVr As0 Ke !'4 T 634K% 4.t7#cC 9:4# V4 <=3-03Astq O
% c 2  ++h %  2 AhA/ c% . FRy yy iH ; YS < u s+w s=F2s c u L
: LHkL y L @>CBcD0Ft@ L j LE%S < I ;c;=<VF VRL : LEe ; UJTS < SZ^ gJtSZU ; URJ @ L}L B S D;=<?lB O BR.F 2 R'4 vuZ QDTTC 
Z4 <=@I V @&T  Z% g!X"=BTC J
aw MxyYV[ +4Ng"S40C OP ]=  = N 
r _d&T+AT {%   F

y yy H ; YS <r=xExts scs+xcxtFk y yy y S <?B N?Y ; ]VS t]{^CSZUR]VS+N \ SVSVOg^CURb ; URJ `4p IT^C~R^fO F #SVU BRF V ; U2L
r=xExts L
: LHkL y L @>CBED0F Lk ; b D SV^ ?S <ZF%y L @ ^CSZNgITSZQteS >9; URJ'L ,L \ L B SV^ D; ES < N F "$ *  OVY0 .c
f Rh  c%  C O/+ Z
634 K% 4.\7#cC 9:4z V4 <=d0EAsT=% c 2  +q{ %  FAy yy
H ; YS <rcxExts rts c F"u y yy L :`y y S <?BW; ] B QRNPO ^_]ZN :B U [ S < SZUK]{S FK\;c; NPO < ^_]IO FK\; h rcxExts L
s+xq'l1l#l LN ;<; L}U > L : QKNPO BcD S < L=NPhtN?OgS D N LN?bE^ xEx L
sEs-y L @1; bEb ; b F 'L %L y O v^CURN F: L m\ VO Q <; U FAX L2SVhES+N F &1  cCV/ vuZc% |!;kMB%UZ V OV  |lnsO
% V%    2  ++h %  > = ]=  F z y y L : 1 s Ec rcx x c F :9y ` #SVY Bc< Oz B L2c sEscF RSZ~ < QT
;< h s cEvL
sqr+-` Lc < S{hTN?Z^Cb F aK% +=V} )
wV% c 2 c/ )+4~-4 2 AhA c%  F V B IRU ^ > S{h - B UKN FRs u tL

(SYA) 24-11

scs

 s+q : L @9; ^ >C> h ; UKJ X LKVEQTeS F x30c > c/T% ! 2 %g&(+AT=NW=%8&T+{BZC0 lnYN\RcYsO
ju+DTt_3DeFKc%. FRy yy V B Q < U ;=>F Bc> L F z < L scF YRYL rcr r F V ; U2L r=xExEx L
s -L ;< htYT^_N F LQ D;<ZF dtf%C]=ZS9O}_) AT{%%.4N
 T0eZY Nqt_XNq A * F V B Q < U ;=>
Bc[ Y ;=<;>C> S >A; URJ0JT^_NPO < ^C~RQTOgS+J0] BcD YTQTO ^CUTb F BE> Q D S' F z B L scF YRY sqr F V ; UL s EctL
sqw+ 'L %L y O v^CURN sF 2 A{A/ c% #!@DT+{ K% =/ ) xyJ_=}) V4 <:} 2 ++h%
j_|&T+hBO
C 0 F H <gB ]VSZSZJT^CUTbN BE[ :y ` L  ; : BE< tN?I B Y B U @ SVUK]I D;< H <gB ~ > S D N^CU :BcD YTQTO ; O ^ B U ;=>
y S <?BW; ] B QRN?Og^_]ZN FM` JT^fOgS+J~Wh VRL : L ;=< JT^CU F VRLL1^_NPO Bc< ]VS >C> ^ ; UKJ : L L ,L j;D0F z y y: H cExExvF
YTY2L sqw rcvFas c w L
s+q L LW < ; JTNgIO S{htU F L \ L9htVIR^C F "Rh BZCE !aK Nq =  >   + wX&T+=V%  FEy ] ; JTS D ^_]H < SZN N F ^CUK]cL
s E x L
squ+ Ln-L+Q ; UKJoL L y Ogv^CURN F DTjN c/ T%  2 c/ )+4[ !%4 TT 634K% 4.H7#cC 9:4 V4 <=H_4
xysO:ln. 0 7[ F2y yy iH ; YS <orcxExts rts wvFAu y yy L :`y y S <gB; ] B QKNPO ^_]VN :B U [ S < SVUK]VS F
\;c; NPO < ^_]IWO FK\; h r=xExts L
s L ; JTS F c4 t 0c% Z?' J{B:9 FE< t]{^CSZUR]VS ; URJ ` URbc^CURSZS < ^CUTb F B Q < O I ` JT^fOg^ B U F WY < ^CUTbES <
S <?>|; b @ S <g> ^CUSZ^_JtS > ~S < b FAs EctL

(SYA) 24-12

s+r

(SYA) 24-13

Reference # of Paper: 24
Discussers Name:
Dr. Bastiaan Oskam
Authors Name:
Mr. Carl P. A. Blom
Question:
How great is the computational complexity of the DG method in comparison with the
DRP scheme on the same finite element mesh? Is it larger than a factor of four?
Answer:
That will depend on the actual wave propagation properties of one method in relation
to the other. I cant give a number at this stage because we dont have analytic values for the
dispersion and dissipation errors in three dimensions. (I also dont know if these numbers are
available for the DRP scheme in three dimensions.) However, on structured meshes the DRP
scheme would be expected to be more efficient.

Discussers Name:
Prof. Ir. Joop Slooff
Authors Name:
Mr. Carl P. A. Blom
Question:
Apparently you do not know precisely, on an analytical basis, what the order of
accuracy is of your scheme. You had to do a numerical mesh convergence experiment to find
out. Then, how do you intend to improve the order of accuracy of your method?
Answer:
We did a one dimensional wave propagation analysis that does give us that kind of
information. The one dimensional analysis is on a structured mesh. We do not know if we can
apply the results obtained in one dimension to three dimensional problems. We also dont
know if, and how, it applies to unstructured meshes. Dr Hu [Hu, F. Q., Hussaini, M. Y., and
Raestarinera, P., An analysis of the discontinuous Galerkin method for wave propagation
problems, Journal of Computational Physics, 141, 1998, pp. 921-946] has presented results of
his one-dimensional analysis of wave propagation and showed very promising results. We also
did this grid study to enable us to compare with analytical results that might be obtained at a
later stage.

This page has been deliberately left blank

Page intentionnellement blanche