Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Pelaez v. Au itor General Facts: =%rs%ant to )ec G8 o( t$e -#C t$e =resi!ent iss%e! 3Os 81D 1/1 1/0 an! 1/GD1/8 ,$ic$ create! 11 &rovinces. =elaeB instit%te! t$e &resent s&ecial civil action (or a ,rit o( &ro$ibition ,it$ &reliminar' in9%nction against t$e #%!itor General to restrain
15
11
1/
11
10
1C
$ilas v. Cit# o! Manila /supra- see p.41 Pa illa v. COM%L%C Facts: # &lebiscite in t$e matter o( t$e creation o( t$e M%nici&alit' o( 2%la'DNaDL%&a ,as $el! in t$e m%nici&alit' o( Labo &%rs%ant to -# 71CC an! t$e Constit%tion. Onl' /885 (avore! its creation ,$ile 118 vote! against it. 2$e =lebiscite Boar! o( Canvassers !eclare! t$e re9ection an! !isa&&roval o( t$e in!e&en!ent M%nici&alit' o( 2NL. Gov. =a!illa see+s to set asi!e t$e &lebiscite an! &ra's t$at a ne, &lebiscite be %n!erta+en beca%se t$e &revio%s one ,as a com&lete (ail%re an! t$e res%lts obtaine! ,ere invali! an! illegal beca%se t$e &lebiscite s$o%l! $ave been con!%cte! onl' in t$e &olitical %nits a((ecte! i.e. t$e 1/ baranga's com&rising 2NL to t$e e4cl%sion o( t$e remaining areas o( t$e mot$er %nit. *ss%e: 6ON t$e &lebiscite con!%cte! is vali!. :3). =a!illa>s contention t$at t$e 2an r%ling $as been s%&erse!e! b' t$e rati(ication o( t$e 1887 Constit%tion $ence reinstating t$e =are!es r%ling is %ntenable. Ol! la,: E&olitical %nit or %nitsF Ne, la,: E&olitical %nitsF 2$e !eletion o( t$e ,or!s E%nit orF !oes not a((ect t$e 2an r%ling. Concom !ebates: Davi!e as+e! (or !eletion o( E%nit orF beca%se t$e &lebiscite is to be con!%cte! in all %nits a((ecte!.
1G
17
18
1.
1.
1.
*ela
18
/5
/.
1.
0.
C.
/1
//
/1
Bina# v. *omingo Facts: -esol%tion G5 con(irming t$e ongoing b%rial assistance &rogram initiate! b' t$e ma'or>s o((ice. @n!er t$is &rogram bereave! (amilies ,$ose gross (amil' income !oes not e4cee! /+?mont$ ,ill receive a C55&$& cas$ relie( to be ta+en o%t o( %na&&ro&riate! available (%n!s e4isting in t$e m%nici&al treas%r'. 2$e Metro Manila Commission a&&rove! -esol%tion G5. 2$erea(ter t$e m%nici&al secretar' certi(ie! a !isb%rsement o( =055 555 (or t$e im&lementation o( t$e B%rial #ssistance =rogram. - G5 ,as re(erre! to t$e Commission on #%!it (or its e4&ecte! allo,ance in a%!it. Base! on its &reliminar' (in!ings CO# !isa&&rove! - G5 an! !isallo,e! in a%!it t$e !isb%rsement o( (%n!s (or t$e
/0
/C
/G
/7
/8
/8
15
11
1/
11
10
1.
(is$ermenT NO. )ince t$e Constit%tion !oes not s&eci(icall' &rovi!e a !e(inition o( t$e terms "s%bsistence" or "marginal" (is$ermen t$e' s$o%l! be constr%e! in t$eir general an! or!inar' sense. # marginal (is$erman is an in!ivi!%al engage! in (is$ing ,$ose margin o( ret%rn or re,ar! in $is $arvest o( (is$ as meas%re! b' e4isting &rice levels is barel' s%((icient to 'iel! a &ro(it or cover t$e cost o( gat$ering t$e (is$ ,$ile a s%bsistence (is$erman is one ,$ose catc$ 'iel!s b%t t$e irre!%cible minim%m (or $is liveli$oo!. )ection 111;&< o( t$e LGC ;-.#. No. 71G5< !e(ines a marginal (armer or (is$erman as "an in!ivi!%al engage! in s%bsistence (arming or (is$ing ,$ic$ s$all be limite! to t$e sale barter or e4c$ange o( agric%lt%ral or marine &ro!%cts &ro!%ce! b' $imsel( an! $is imme!iate (amil'." *t bears re&eating t$at not$ing in t$e recor! s%&&orts a (in!ing t$at an' &etitioner (alls ,it$in t$ese !e(initions. Besi!es )ection / o( #rticle J** aims &rimaril' not to besto, an' rig$t to s%bsistence (is$ermen b%t to la' stress on t$e !%t' o( t$e )tate to &rotect t$e nationHs marine ,ealt$. 6$at t$e &rovision merel' recogniBes is t$at t$e )tate ma' allo, b' la, coo&erative (is$ (arming ,it$ &riorit' to s%bsistence (is$ermen an! (is$,or+ers in rivers la+es ba's an! lagoons. #nent )ection 7 o( #rticle J*** it s&ea+s not onl' o( t$e %se o( comm%nal marine an! (is$ing reso%rces b%t o( t$eir &rotection !evelo&ment an! conservation. #s $erea(ter s$o,n t$e or!inances in .%estion are meant &recisel' to &rotect an! conserve o%r marine reso%rces to t$e en! t$at
1C
1G
17
18
(angalang v. )AC Facts: )t%!ies ,ere ma!e b' Ma'or :ab%t et al on t$e (easibilit' o( o&ening streets in BelD#ir calc%late! to alleviate tra((ic congestion along t$e &%blic streets a!9acent to BelD#ir. Base! on t$e st%!ies it ,as !eeme! necessar' in t$e interest o( t$e general &%blic to o&en to tra((ic #ma&ola Merce!es Zo!ia 7%&iter Ne&t%ne Orbit an! =aseo !e -o4as streets. #ccor!ing to BelD#ir t$e' o,n t$e streets an! as s%c$ s$o%l! not be !e&rive! o( t$em ,it$o%t 9%st com&ensation. *ss%e: 6ON t$e ma'or acte! arbitraril' in o&ening %& 7%&iter an! Orbit streets. NO.
18
05
01
0/
01
00
0C
0G
07
08
08
Mo a# v. CA Facts: 2$e )angg%niang Ba'an o( t$e M%nici&alit' o( B%na,an in #g%san !el )%r &asse! - 01D88 "#%t$oriBing t$e M%nici&al Ma'or to *nitiate t$e =etition (or 34&ro&riation o( a One ;1< Hectare =ortion o( Lot No. G118D=lsD0 #long t$e National Hig$,a' O,ne! b' =ercival Mo!a' (or t$e )ite o( B%na,an Farmers Center an! Ot$er Government )&orts Facilities." - 01D88 ,as a&&rove! b' t$en M%nici&al Ma'or #n%ncio C. B%stillo an! transmitte! to t$e )angg%niang =anlala,igan (or its a&&roval. 2$e )angg%niang =anlala,igan !isa&&rove! sai! -esol%tion an! ret%rne! it ,it$ t$e comment t$at "e4&ro&riation is %nnecessar' consi!ering t$at t$ere are still available lots in B%na,an (or t$e establis$ment o( t$e government center." B%na,an (ile! a &etition (or 3minent Domain against &etitioner =ercival Mo!a' as ,ell as $is &arents be(ore t$e
C5
C1
C/
C1
Mabelle O. Nebres | Local Governments Case Digests -esol%tion No. 1/8 )eries o( 1888 ,as &rom%lgate!
&%rs%ant to )ection 8 o( B.=. Blg. 117 t$e LGC ,$ic$ &rovi!es: # LG@ ma' t$ro%g$ its $ea! an! acting &%rs%ant to a resol%tion o( its sangg%nian e4ercise t$e rig$t o( eminent !omain an! instit%te con!emnation &rocee!ings (or &%blic %se or &%r&ose. )ection 8 o( B.=. Blg. 117 !oes not intimate in t$e least t$at local government %nits m%st (irst sec%re t$e a&&roval o( t$e De&artment o( Lan! -e(orm (or t$e conversion o( lan!s (rom agric%lt%ral to nonDagric%lt%ral %se be(ore t$e' can instit%te t$e necessar' e4&ro&riation &rocee!ings. Li+e,ise t$ere is no &rovision in t$e Com&re$ensive #grarian -e(orm La, ,$ic$ e4&ressl' s%b9ects t$e e4&ro&riation o( agric%lt%ral lan!s b' LG@s to t$e control o( t$e De&artment o( #grarian -e(orm. 2$e closest &rovision o( la, t$at t$e C# co%l! cite to 9%sti(' t$e intervention o( t$e De&artment o( #grarian -e(orm in e4&ro&riation matters is )ection GC o( t$e Com&re$ensive #grarian -e(orm La, ,$ic$ rea!s: )ec. GC. Conversion o( Lan!s. #(ter t$e la&se o( (ive ;C< 'ears (rom its a,ar! ,$en t$e lan! ceases to be economicall' (easible an! so%n! (or agric%lt%ral &%r&oses or t$e localit' $as become %rbaniBe! an! t$e lan! ,ill $ave a greater economic val%e (or resi!ential commercial or in!%strial &%r&oses t$e D#%&on a&&lication o( t$e bene(iciar' or t$e lan!o,ner ,it$ !%e notice to t$e a((ecte! &arties an! s%b9ect to e4isting la,s ma' a%t$oriBe t$e reclassi(ication or conversion o( t$e lan! an! its !is&osition: =rovi!e! 2$at t$e bene(iciar' s$all $ave (%ll' &ai! $is obligation. 2$e o&ening a!verbial &$rase o( t$e &rovision sen!s signals t$at it a&&lies to lan!s &revio%sl' &lace! %n!er t$e agrarian re(orm &rogram as it s&ea+s o( "t$e la&se o( (ive ;C< 'ears (rom its a,ar!." 2$e r%les on conversion o( agric%lt%ral lan!s (o%n! in )ection 0 ;+< an! C ;1< o( 34ec%tive Or!er No. 1/8D# )eries o( 1887 cannot be t$e so%rce o( t$e a%t$orit' o( t$e De&artment o( #grarian -e(orm to !etermine t$e s%itabilit' o( a &arcel o( agric%lt%ral lan! (or t$e &%r&ose to ,$ic$ it ,o%l! be !evote! b' t$e e4&ro&riating a%t$orit'. 6$ile t$ose r%les vest on t$e De&artment o( #grarian -e(orm t$e e4cl%sive a%t$orit' to a&&rove or !isa&&rove conversions o( agric%lt%ral lan!s (or resi!ential commercial or in!%strial %ses s%c$ a%t$orit' is limite! to t$e a&&lications (or reclassi(ication s%bmitte! b' t$e lan! o,ners or tenant bene(iciaries. )tat%tes con(erring t$e &o,er o( eminent !omain to &olitical s%b!ivisions cannot be broa!ene! or constricte! b' im&lication. 2o s%stain t$e C# ,o%l! mean t$at t$e LG@s can no longer e4&ro&riate agric%lt%ral lan!s nee!e! (or t$e constr%ction o( roa!s bri!ges sc$ools $os&itals etc ,it$o%t (irst a&&l'ing (or conversion o( t$e %se o( t$e lan!s ,it$ t$e De&artment o( #grarian -e(orm beca%se all o( t$ese &ro9ects ,o%l! nat%rall' involve a c$ange in t$e lan! %se. *n e((ect it ,o%l! t$en be t$e De&artment o( #grarian -e(orm to scr%tiniBe ,$et$er t$e e4&ro&riation is (or a &%blic &%r&ose or &%blic %se. Or!inaril' it is t$e legislative branc$ o( t$e LG@ t$at s$all !etermine ,$et$er t$e %se o( t$e &ro&ert' so%g$t to be e4&ro&riate! s$all be &%blic t$e same being an e4&ression o( legislative &olic'. 2$e co%rts !e(er to s%c$ legislative !etermination an! ,ill intervene onl' ,$en a &artic%lar %n!erta+ing $as no real or s%bstantial relation to t$e &%blic %se. 2$ere is also an ancient r%le t$at restrictive stat%tes no matter $o, broa! t$eir terms are !o not embrace t$e sovereign %nless t$e sovereign is s&eciall' mentione! as s%b9ect t$ereto. 2$e -e&%blic o( t$e =$ili&&ines as sovereign or its &olitical s%b!ivisions as $ol!ers o( !elegate! sovereign &o,ers cannot be bo%n! b' &rovisions o( la, co%c$e! in general term.
Me#caua#an v. )AC Facts: 2$e =$ili&&ine =i&es an! Merc$an!ising Cor&oration (ile! ,it$ t$e O((ice o( t$e M%nici&al Ma'or o( Me'ca%a'an B%lacan an a&&lication (or a &ermit to (ence a &arcel o( lan!. 2$e (encing o( sai! &ro&ert' ,as allege!l' to enable t$e storage o( t$e res&on!entHs $eav' e.%i&ment an! vario%s (inis$e! &ro!%cts s%c$ as large !iameter steel &i&es &ontoon &i&es (or &orts ,$arves an! $arbors bri!ge com&onents &reDstresse! gir!ers an! &iles large !iameter concrete &i&es an! &arts (or lo, cost $o%sing. *n t$e same 'ear t$e M%nici&al Co%ncil o( Me'ca%a'an $ea!e! b' t$en Ma'or Celso -. Legas&i &asse! -esol%tion No. /C8 )eries o( 187C mani(esting t$e intention to e4&ro&riate t$e res&on!entHs
C0
CC
,apocor v. +ocson Facts: 2$e N=C (ile! (or t$e ac.%isition o( a rig$tDo(D,a' easement over &ortions o( t$e &arcels o( lan! !escribe! in t$e com&laints (or its NegrosD=ana' *nterconnection =ro9ect &artic%larl' t$e Bacolo!D 2omonton 2ransmission Line. =rovisional val%es ,ere (i4e! on t$e basis o( t$e mar+et val%e an! t$e !ail' o&&ort%nit' &ro(it &etitioner ma' !erive. -es&on!ents so%g$t a reDeval%ation. 7%!ge increase! val%e ,it$o%t $earing an! !irecting t$e !e(en!ants to mani(est ,it$in t,ent'D(o%r ;/0< $o%rs ,$et$er or not t$e' are acce&ting
CG
C7
C8
C8
G5
G1
G/
G1
Cit# o! Manila v. Chinese Communit# o! Manila Facts: 2$e Cit' o( Manila allege! t$at (or t$e &%r&ose o( constr%cting t$e e4tension o( -iBal #ven%e Manila it is necessar' (or it to ac.%ire o,ners$i& o( certain &arcels o( lan! sit%ate! in Binon!o some o( ,$ic$ ,ere o,ne! an! %se! b' t$e C$inese Comm%nit' o( Manila (or cemeter' &%r&oses. 2$e C$inese Comm%nit' o( Manila !enie! t$at it ,as necessar' or e4&e!ient t$at t$e sai! &arcels be e4&ro&riate! (or street &%r&osesA t$at i( t$e constr%ction o( t$e street or roa! s$o%l! be consi!ere! a &%blic necessit' ot$er ro%tes ,ere available ,$ic$ ,o%l! (%ll' satis(' t$e &lainti((Hs &%r&oses at m%c$ less e4&ense an! ,it$o%t !ist%rbing t$e resting &laces o( t$e !ea!A t$at it $a! a 2orrens title (or t$e lan!s in .%estionA t$at t$e lan!s in .%estion $a! been %se! b' t$e !e(en!ant (or cemeter' &%r&osesA t$at a great n%mber o( C$inese ,ere b%rie! in sai! cemeter'A t$at i( sai! e4&ro&riation be carrie! into e((ect it ,o%l! !ist%rb t$e resting &laces o( t$e !ea! ,o%l! re.%ire t$e e4&en!it%re o( a large s%m o( mone' in t$e trans(er or removal o( t$e bo!ies to some ot$er &lace or site an! in t$e &%rc$ase o( s%c$ ne, sites ,o%l! involve t$e !estr%ction o( e4isting mon%ments an! t$e erection o( ne, mon%ments in t$eir stea! an! ,o%l! create irre&arable loss an! in9%r' to t$e !e(en!ant an! to all t$ose &ersons o,ning an! intereste! in t$e graves an! mon%ments ,$ic$ ,o%l! $ave to be !estro'e!A t$at t$e &lainti(( ,as ,it$o%t rig$t or a%t$orit' to e4&ro&riate sai! cemeter' or an' &art or &ortion t$ereo( (or street &%r&osesA an! t$at t$e e4&ro&riation in (act ,as not necessar' as a &%blic im&rovement. 2$e t$eor' o( t$e &lainti(( is t$at once it $as establis$e! t$e (act %n!er t$e la, t$at it $as a%t$orit' to e4&ro&riate lan! it ma' e4&ro&riate an' lan! it ma' !esireA t$at t$e onl' (%nction o( t$e co%rt in s%c$ &rocee!ings is to ascertain t$e val%e o( t$e lan! in .%estionA t$at neit$er t$e co%rt nor t$e o,ners o( t$e lan! can in.%ire into t$e a!visible &%r&ose o( &%r&ose o( t$e e4&ro&riation or as+ an' .%estions concerning t$e necessities t$ere(orA t$at t$e co%rts are mere a&&raisers o( t$e lan! involve! in e4&ro&riation
G0
*ss%e: 6ON t$e co%rts ma' in.%ire into an! $ear &roo( %&on t$e necessit' o( t$e e4&ro&riationT :3). *t cannot be !enie! i( t$e legislat%re %n!er &ro&er a%t$orit' s$o%l! grant t$e e4&ro&riation o( a certain or &artic%lar &arcel o( lan! (or some s&eci(ie! &%blic &%r&ose t$at t$e co%rts ,o%l! be ,it$o%t 9%ris!iction to in.%ire into t$e &%r&ose o( t$at legislation. *( %&on t$e ot$er $an! $o,ever t$e legislat%re s$o%l! grant general a%t$orit' to a m%nici&al cor&oration to e4&ro&riate &rivate lan! (or &%blic &%r&oses t$e co%rts $ave am&le a%t$orit' in t$is 9%ris!iction %n!er t$e &rovisions above .%ote! to ma+e in.%ir' an! to $ear &roo( %&on an iss%e &ro&erl' &resente! concerning ,$et$er or not t$e lan!s ,ere &rivate an! ,$et$er t$e &%r&ose ,as in (act &%blic. 2$e rig$t o( e4&ro&riation is not an in$erent &o,er in a m%nici&al cor&oration an! be(ore it can e4ercise t$e rig$t some la, m%st e4ist con(erring t$e &o,er %&on it. 6$en t$e co%rts come to !etermine t$e .%estion t$e' m%st not onl' (in! ;a< t$at a la, or a%t$orit' e4ists (or t$e e4ercise o( t$e rig$t o( eminent !omain b%t ;b< also t$at t$e rig$t or a%t$orit' is being e4ercise! in accor!ance ,it$ t$e la,. *n t$e &resent case t$ere are t,o con!itions im&ose! %&on t$e a%t$orit' conce!e! to t$e Cit' o( Manila : First t$e lan! m%st be &rivateA an! secon! t$e &%r&ose m%st be &%blic. 2$e legislative !e&artment o( t$e government ,as rarel' %n!erta+es to !esignate t$e &recise &ro&ert' ,$ic$ s$o%l! be ta+en (or &%blic %se. *t $as generall' li+e in t$e &resent case merel' con(erre! general a%t$orit' to ta+e lan! (or &%blic %se ,$en a necessit' e4ists t$ere(or. 6e believe t$at it can be con(i!entl' asserte! t$at %n!er s%c$ stat%te t$e allegation o( t$e necessit' (or t$e a&&ro&riation is an iss%able allegation ,$ic$ it is com&etent (or t$e co%rts to !eci!e. "*t is erroneo%s to s%&&ose t$at t$e legislat%re is be'on! t$e control o( t$e co%rts in e4ercising t$e &o,er o( eminent !omain eit$er as to t$e nat%re o( t$e %se or t$e necessit' to t$e %se o( an' &artic%lar &ro&ert'. For i( t$e %se be not &%blic or no necessit' (or t$e ta+ing e4ists t$e legislat%re
GC
GG
G7
/.
/.
G8
G8
75
71
7/
71
70
7C
%stanislao v. Costales Facts: 2$e )angg%niang =angl%nso! o( Zamboanga Cit' &asse! Or!inance No. 00 ,$ic$ im&oses a =5.51 ta4 &er liter o( so(t!rin+s &ro!%ce! man%(act%re! an!?or bottle! ,it$in t$e cit'. 2$e Minister o( Finance sent a letter to t$e )angg%nian s%s&en!ing t$e e((ectivit' o( t$e Or!inance on t$e gro%n! t$at it contravenes )ec 18 ;a< o( t$e Local 2a4 Co!e. Zamboanga a&&eale! t$e s%s&ension in t$e -2C. -2C: t$e ta4 im&ose! b' t$e Or!inance is not among t$ose t$at t$e )angg%nian ma' im&ose %n!er t$e Local 2a4 Co!e b%t %&$el! its vali!it' sa'ing t$at t$e Finance Minister !i! not act on it ,?in 1/5 !a's (rom recei&t o( t$e &etition. Finance )ecretar' a&&eale!. *ss%e: 6ON Or!inance 00 is vali!. NO.
7G
77
78
78
Facts: 2$e )angg%niang Ba'an o( Camalani%gan Caga'an a!o&te! -esol%tion No. 8 ,$ic$ solicits a 1Y !onation (rom t$res$er o&erators ,$o a&&l' (or a E&ermit to t$res$F ,it$in t$e m%nici&alit'>s 9%ris!iction to $el& (inance t$e constr%ction o( t$e m%nici&alit'>s )&orts an! N%trition Center. )%c$ 1Y s$all come (rom t$e val%e o( t$e &ala' t$res$e! b' t$em in t$e area. 2o im&lement t$e resol%tion M%nici&al 2reas%rer Ma&ag% &re&are! an agreement to !onate (or signat%re o( all t$res$er?o,ner? o&erators a&&l'ing (or a ma'or>s &ermit. 7%ra!o sent $is agent to t$e 2reas%rer>s o((ice to &a' t$e license (ee (or t$res$er o&erators. Ma&ag% re(%se! to acce&t &a'ment an! re.%ire! 7%ra!o to (irst sec%re a ma'or>s &ermit. Ma'or 2%Bon sai! t$at 7%ra!o s$o%l! (irst com&l' ,it$ -es 8 an! sign t$e agreement be(ore t$e &ermit co%l! be iss%e!. 7%ra!o ignore! t$e re.%irement an! sent $is license (ee
85
=roce!%re For #&&roval #n! 3((ectivit' O( 2a4 Or!inances #n! -even%e Meas%resA Man!ator' =%blic Hearings. S 2$e &roce!%re (or a&&roval o( local ta4 or!inances an! reven%e meas%res s$all be in accor!ance ,it$ t$e &rovisions o( t$is Co!e: =rovi!e! 2$at &%blic $earings s$all be con!%cte! (or t$e &%r&ose &rior to t$e enactment t$ereo(A =rovi!e! (%rt$er 2$at an' .%estion on t$e constit%tionalit' or legalit' o( ta4 or!inances or reven%e meas%res ma' be raise! on a&&eal ,it$in t$irt' ;15< !a's (rom t$e e((ectivit' t$ereo( to t$e )ecretar' o( 7%stice ,$o s$all ren!er a !ecision ,it$in si4t' ;G5< !a's (rom t$e !ate o( recei&t o( t$e a&&eal: =rovi!e! $o,ever 2$at s%c$ a&&eal s$all not $ave t$e e((ect o( s%s&en!ing t$e e((ectivit' o( t$e or!inance an! t$e accr%al an! &a'ment o( t$e ta4 (ee or c$arge levie! t$erein: =rovi!e! (inall' 2$at ,it$in t$irt' ;15< !a's a(ter recei&t o( t$e !ecision or t$e la&se o( t$e si4t'D!a' &erio! ,it$o%t t$e )ecretar' o( 7%stice acting %&on t$e a&&eal t$e aggrieve! &art' ma' (ile a&&ro&riate &rocee!ings ,it$ a co%rt o( com&etent 9%ris!iction.
81
8/
Mactan Cebu )nternational Airport Authorit# v. Marcos Facts: MC*## ,as create! b' -# G8C8 ,$ic$ &rovi!e! t$at it be e4em&te! (rom &a'ment o( realt' ta4es. 2$e O((ice o( t$e 2reas%rer o( Ceb% Cit' !eman!e! &a'ment (or realt' ta4es on several &arcels o( lan! belonging to MC*##. MC*## ob9ecte! claiming t$at it is e4em&t (rom &a'ment o( realit' ta4es. *t also sai! t$at as it is an instr%mentalit' o( t$e government &er(orming governmental (%nctions it is e4em&te! as &rovi!e! (or b' )ec. 111 o( t$e LGC. 2$e Cit' insiste! t$at MC*## is not ta4 e4em&t as its e4em&tion $a! been ,it$!ra,n b' )ections 181 an! /10 o( t$e
81
80
8C
8G
87
o! Assessment
Facts: BC see+s to ann%l an! set asi!e t$e Decision o( t$e CB## o( Ma' /8 1881 as ,ell as t$e -esol%tion o( 7%l' 1 1881 !en'ing its motion (or reconsi!eration ,$ic$ a((irme! t$e !ecision o( res&on!ent Local Boar! o( #ssessment #&&eals o( t$e =rovince o( Beng%et !eclaring as vali! t$e ta4 assessments ma!e b' t$e M%nici&al #ssessor o( *togon Beng%et on t$e b%n+$o%ses o( &etitioner occ%&ie! as !,elling b' its ran+ an! (ile em&lo'ees base! on 2a4 Declarations Nos. 8071 an! 150C0. 2$e =rovincial #ssessor o( Beng%et t$ro%g$ t$e M%nici&al #ssessor o( *togon assesse! real &ro&ert' ta4 on t$e b%n+$o%ses o( &etitioner Beng%et Cor&oration occ%&ie! (or resi!ential &%r&oses b' its ran+ an! (ile em&lo'ees %n!er 2a4 Declarations Nos. 8071 ;e((ective 188C< an! 150C0 ;e((ective 188G<. #ccor!ing to t$e =rovincial #ssessor t$e ta4 e4em&tion o( b%n+$o%ses %n!er )ec. 1 ;a< =.D. 70C/ ;LiberaliBing t$e Financing an! Cre!it 2erms (or Lo, Cost Ho%sing =ro9ects o( Domestic Cor&orations an! =artners$i&s< ,as ,it$!ra,n b' =.D. 18CC1 ;6it$!ra,ing )%b9ect to Certain Con!itions t$e D%t' an! 2a4 =rivileges Grante! to =rivate B%siness 3nter&rises an!?or =ersons 3ngage! in #n' 3conomic #ctivit' an! Ot$er =%r&oses<. =etitioner a&&eale! t$e assessment on 2a4
")ection 1. =%rs%ant to t$e above incentive s%c$ !omestic cor&orations an! &artners$i&s s$all en9o' ta4 e4em&tion on: ;a< real estate ta4es on t$e im&rovements ,$ic$ ,ill be %se! e4cl%sivel' (or $o%sing t$eir em&lo'ees an! ,or+ers . . ."
")ection 1. 2$e &rovisions o( an' s&ecial or general la, to t$e contrar' not,it$stan!ing all e4em&tions (rom or an' &re(erential treatment in t$e &a'ment o( !%ties ta4es (ees im&osts an! ot$er c$arges $ereto(ore grante! to &rivate b%siness enter&rises an!?or &ersons engage! in an' economic activit' are $ereb' ,it$!ra,n e4ce&t t$ose en9o'e! b' t$e (ollo,ing: . . . ;e< 2$ose t$at ,ill be a&&rove! b' t$e =resi!ent o( t$e =$ili&&ines %&on t$e recommen!ation o( t$e Minister o( Finance "
88
88
85
81
8/
81
80
8C
8G
87
88
88
155
151
15/
151
150
15C
15G
157
158
158
115
Facts: *n 18G8 !%ring a &rivate con(erence $el! at t$e o((ice o( t$e &etitioner Naga viceDma'or =ereB ,it$ 7 co%ncilors t$e matter o(
111
11/
111
Mabelle O. Nebres | Local Governments Case Digests *nvocation o( t$is r%ling is com&letel' ina&&osite. 2$e
!octrine t$erein lai! !o,n is base! on t$e &rinci&le o( se&aration o( &o,ers an! c$ee+s an! balances an! is not a&&licable to local governments. Moreover e4ec%tives at t$e local or m%nici&al level are veste! ,it$ bot$ legislative an! sometimes 9%!icial (%nctions in a!!ition to t$eir &%rel' e4ec%tive !%ties. B' e4&licit stat%tor' comman! co%rts are given a%t$orit' to !etermine t$e vali!it' o( m%nici&al &rocee!ings. *t is not !is&%te! t$at t$e &resent &rocee!ing (or &ro$ibition $as (or its ob9ective to &revent t$e &etitioner (rom "&artici&ating in t$e election o( )ecretar' o( t$e Boar! c$airmans$i& o( !i((erent committees an! in voting in ot$er legislative matters &ro&osals an! &rocee!ings ot$er t$an to brea+ a tie." *t is o%r vie, t$at t$e &etitioner in insisting to e4ercise t$e rig$t to vote t,ice in t$e m%nici&al boar! acte! ,it$o%t 9%ris!iction an! &o,er to !o so an! ma' be vali!l' &revente! an! restraine! b' a ,rit o( &ro$ibition. *n re&l' to t$e &etitionerHs assertion t$at t$e acts so%g$t to be restraine! are mere "&robable in!ivi!%al act%ations" be'on! t$e reac$ o( a &ro$ibitor' ,rit s%((ice it to state t$at &ro$ibition is essentiall' a "&reventive reme!'" an! is "not inten!e! to &rovi!e (or a reme!' (or acts alrea!' accom&lis$e!." 6it$al &etitionerHs t$reat o( voting t,ice in t$e m%nici&al boar! ,as not an em&t' or meaningless gest%re (or t$e recor! s$o,s t$at on Marc$ C 18G8 soon a(ter t$e ,rit com&laine! o( ,as li(te! b' t$e Co%rt o( #&&eals t$ro%g$ t$e latterHs restraining or!er o( Febr%ar' /5 18G8 t$e &etitioner &rocee!e! to act b' voting t,ice (or t$e a&&roval o( an allege! amen!ment to t$e r%les o( &roce!%re o( t$e m%nici&al boar!. 9omeo"ners Association o! the Philippines v. Municipal Boar o! Manila Facts: 2$e Cit' o( Manila &asse! M%nici&al Or!inance No. 0801 ,$ic$ reg%lates rentals o( lots an! b%il!ings (or resi!ential &%r&oses. 2$e Homeo,nersH #ssociation o( t$e =$ili&&ines *nc. an! its =resi!ent so%g$t to n%lli(' t$e or!inance. CF*: or!inance is %ltra vires %nconstit%tional illegal an! voi! ab initio. LC: str%c+ !o,n t$e .%estione! or!inance %&on t$e gro%n! t$at t$e &o,er to "!eclare a state o( emergenc' ... e4cl%sivel' &ertains to Congress"A t$at "t$ere is no longer an' state o( emergenc'" ,$ic$ ma' 9%sti(' t$e reg%lation o( $o%se rentalsA t$at sai! or!inance constit%tes an %nreasonable an! %n9%sti(ie! limitation on t$e %se o( &rivate &ro&erties an! arbitraril' encroac$es on t$e constit%tional rig$ts o( &ro&ert' o,ners"A t$at t$e &o,er o( t$e Cit' o( Manila to "reg%late t$e b%siness o( ... letting or s%bletting o( lan!s an! b%il!ings" !oes not incl%!e t$e a%t$orit' to &ro$ibit ,$at is (orbi!!en in sai! or!inanceA an! t$at t$e same cannot be !eeme! sanctione! b' t$e general ,el(are cla%se in t$e Cit' C$arter. *ss%e: 6ON t$e Or!inance is vali!. NO. 2$e a%t$orit' o( m%nici&al cor&orations to reg%late is essentiall' &olice &o,er. *nasm%c$ as t$e same generall' entails a c%rtailment o( t$e libert' t$e rig$ts an!?or t$e &ro&ert' o( &ersons ,$ic$ are &rotecte! an! even g%arantee! b' t$e Constit%tion t$e e4ercise o( &olice &o,er is necessaril' s%b9ect to a .%ali(ication limitation or restriction !eman!e! b' t$e regar! t$e res&ect an! t$e obe!ience !%e to t$e &rescri&tions o( t$e (%n!amental la, &artic%larl' t$ose (orming &art o( t$e Constit%tion o( Libert' ot$er,ise +no,n as t$e Bill o( -ig$ts S t$e &olice &o,er meas%re m%st be "reasonable". *n ot$er ,or!s in!ivi!%al rig$ts ma' be a!versel' a((ecte! b' t$e e4ercise o( &olice &o,er to t$e e4tent onl' S an! onl' to t$e e4tent S t$at ma' (airl' be re.%ire! b' t$e legitimate !eman!s o( &%blic interest or &%blic ,el(are. *( s%c$ !eman!s are bro%g$t abo%t b' a state o( emergenc' t$e inter(erence %&on in!ivi!%al rig$ts res%lting (rom t$e reg%lations a!o&te! to meet t$e sit%ation m%st be b' an! large coDe4tensive coDe.%al or coD termino%s ,it$ t$e e4istence t$ereo(. #n! since an emergenc' is b' nat%re tem&orar' in c$aracter so m%st t$e reg%lations &rom%lgate! t$ere(or be. *n t$e lang%age o( 7%stice Holmes "circ%mstances ma' so c$ange in time or !i((er in s&ace as to clot$e ,it$ s%c$ an interest ,$at at ot$er times or in ot$er &laces ,o%l! be a matter o( &%rel' &rivate concern." #s a conse.%ence a la, or or!inance a((ecting t$e rig$ts o( in!ivi!%als as a means to ti!e over a critical con!ition to be vali! an! legal m%st be (or a
110
11C
11G
Morata v. Go Facts: Kictor an! Flora Go (ile! a com&laint ,it$ t$e CF* against 7%li%s an! Ma. L%isa Morata (or recover' o( a s%m o( mone' &l%s !amages. 2$e &arties are all resi!ents o( Ceb% Cit'. 2$e Moratas (ile! a motion to !ismiss citing as gro%n!s t$e (ail%re o( t$e com&laint to allege &rior availment b' t$e Gos o( t$e baranga' conciliation &rocess re.%ire! b' =.D. 1C58 as ,ell as t$e absence o( a certi(ication b' t$e L%&on or =ang+at )ecretar' t$at no conciliation or settlement $a! been reac$e! b' t$e &arties. 2$e motion ,as o&&ose!. M2D !enie!. M- !enie!. *ss%e: 6ON t$e Matar%ngang =ambaranga' la, a&&l' to cases $ear! b' t$e -egional 2rial Co%rts. :3). )3C2*ON G. No com&laint &etition action (or &rocee!ing involving an' matter ,it$in t$e a%t$orit' o( t$e L%&on as &rovi!e! in )ection / $ereo( s$all be (ile! or instit%te! in co%rt or an' ot$er government o((ice (or a!9%!ication %nless t$ere $as been a con(rontation o( t$e &arties be(ore t$e L%&on C$airman or t$e =ang+at an! no conciliation or settlement $as been reac$e! as certi(ie! b' t$e L%&on )ecretar' or t$e =ang+at )ecretar' atteste! b' t$e L%&on or =ang+at C$airman or %nless t$e settlement $as been re&%!iate!. Ho,ever t$e &arties ma' go !irectl' to co%rt in t$e (ollo,ing cases: U1V 6$ere t$e acc%se! is %n!er !etentionA U/V 6$ere a &erson $as ot$er,ise been !e&rive! o( &ersonal libert' calling (or $abeas cor&%s &rocee!ingsA U1V
117
118
118
1/5
1/1
1//
1/1
1/0
Boni!acio La" O!!ice v. Bellosillo Facts: *n a letterDcom&laint !ate! #%g%st /8 1887 #tt'. -icar!o M. )alomon 7r. o( t$e Boni(acio La, O((ice c$arge! t$en acting 7%!ge -e'nal!o B. Bellosillo o( t$e Metro&olitan 2rial Co%rt o( W%eBon Cit' Branc$ 10 ,it$ ignorance o( t$e la, grave ab%se o( !iscretion an! obvio%s &artialit'. )alomon assails t$e Or!er !ate! #&ril / 188G re(erring t$e sai! e9ectment case bac+ to t$e baranga' (or conciliation &rocee!ings !es&ite t$e (act t$at it ,as allege! in t$e veri(ie! com&laint t$at t$e matter $a! alrea!' been re(erre! to t$e baranga' an! t$at a co&' o( t$e Certi(ication to File Motion ,as attac$e! UtoV t$e veri(ie! com&laint as #NN3J 3 t$ereo(. Be,il!ere! ,it$ s%c$ Or!er $e trie! to tal+ ,it$ res&on!ent 9%!ge b%t ,as &revente! to !o so beca%se o( t$e strict an! e4tremel' tig$t ]cor!on sanitaire> o( t$e latter. He t$en in.%ire! (rom t$e res&on!ent>s branc$ cler+ o( co%rt t$e reason
1/C
1/G
1/7
1/8
1/8
Mabelle O. Nebres | Local Governments Case Digests )econ!. 2$e Kol%ntar' #rbitrator $el! $o,ever t$at t$e
election (or members o( t$e )M cannot be consi!ere! a local election as t$e election (or Governors Kice Governors Ma'ors an! Kice Ma'ors an! t$e vario%s local legislative assemblies ;sangg%nians< beca%se t$e )M election is &artici&ate! in onl' b' t$e 'o%t$ ,$o are bet,een t$e ages o( 1C an! /1 an! (or t$is reason t$e !a' is not a non,or+ing $oli!a'. 2o begin ,it$ it is not tr%e t$at December 0 188/ ,as not a non,or+ing $oli!a'. *t ,as a non,or+ing $oli!a' an! t$is ,as anno%nce! in t$e me!ia. 7 *n =roclamation No. 118 !ate! December / 188/ =resi!ent -amos !eclare! t$e !a' as "a s&ecial !a' t$ro%g$ t$e co%ntr' on t$e occasion o( t$e )angg%niang Mabataan 3lections" an! en9oine! all "local government %nits t$ro%g$ t$eir res&ective C$ie( Local 34ec%tives UtoV e4ten! all &ossible assistance an! s%&&ort to ens%re t$e smoot$ con!%ct o( t$e general elections." # "s&ecial !a'" is a "s&ecial !a'" as &rovi!e! b' t$e #!ministrative Co!e o( 1887. 8 On t$e ot$er $an! t$e term "general elections" means in t$e conte4t o( )M elections t$e reg%lar elections (or members o( t$e )M as !isting%is$e! (rom t$e s&ecial elections (or s%c$ o((icers. 8 Moreover t$e (act t$at onl' t$ose bet,een 1C an! /1 ta+e &art in t$e election (or members o( t$e )M !oes not ma+e s%c$ election an' less a reg%lar local election. 2$e Constit%tion &rovi!es (or e4am&le (or t$e sectoral re&resentatives in t$e Ho%se o( -e&resentatives o( among ot$ers ,omen an! 'o%t$. 15 Onl' voters belonging to t$e relevant sectors can ta+e &art in t$e election o( t$eir re&resentatives. :et it cannot be !enie! t$at s%c$ election is a reg%lar national election an! t$e !a' set (or its $ol!ing a $oli!a'. 2$ir!. *n!ee! t$e CB# &rovision in .%estion merel' reiterates t$e &rovision on &ai! $oli!a's. 6$et$er in t$e conte4t o( t$e CB# or t$e Labor Co!e December 0 188/ ,as a $oli!a' (or ,$ic$ $oli!a' &a' s$o%l! be &ai! b' res&on!ent em&lo'er. Merca o v. Boar o! %lection (upervisors 2ellers ;B32< acting as t$e Boar! o( Canvassers on t$e basis o( its tall' ,$ic$ s$o,e! Merca!o ,inning b' one vote over $is rival &rivate res&on!ent Crisanto =. =angilinan. Merca!oH s victor' ,as $o,ever s$ortDlive!. *mme!iatel' a(ter Merca!oHs &roclamation as t$e ,inner b' t$e B32 =angilinan (ile! a (ormal &rotest .%estioning t$e res%lts o( t$e election. He allege! t$at t$e B32 C$airman !rin+ing gin an! Co+e !%ring t$e co%nting $a! invali!ate! some votes ,it$o%t cons%lting t$e ot$er boar! members. 2$e B3) or!ere! .t$e reo&ening o( t$e ballot bo4 an! t$e reco%nt o( t$e votes (or )M C$airman. 2$e reco%nt reverse! t$e earlier tall' to C1 to 08 in (avor o( =angilinan ,$o ,as t$ere%&on &roclaime! t$e !%l' electe! )M C$airman b' t$e B3) ,$ic$ iss%e! (or t$at &%r&ose its o,n Certi(icate o( Canvass an! =roclamation. Merca!o t$en (ile! ,it$ t$e -egional 2rial Co%rt ;-2C< o( Batangas Cit' a &etition (or certiorari an! man!am%s &ra'ing (or t$e ann%lment o( =angilinanHs &roclamation b' t$e B3) an! (or t$e iss%ance o( an or!er to com&el t$e De&artment o( *nterior an! Local Government ;D*LG< to recogniBe $im as t$e !%l' electe! )M C$airman o( Baranga' Mabalor an! to allo, $im to ta+e $is oat$ o( o((ice an! !isc$arge $is !%ties as s%c$. *n $is &etition !oc+ete! as Civil Case No. 1CGC Merca!o assaile! t$e 9%ris!iction o( t$e B3) to act on t$e &rotest (ile! b' =angilinan as t$e gro%n! cite! t$erein ,as allege!l' in t$e nat%re o( an election &rotest &ro&erl' cogniBable b' t$e Metro&olitan or M%nici&al 2rial Co%rt in accor!ance ,it$ )ection /C/ o( t$e Omnib%s 3lection Co!e. He (%rt$er claime! t$at ass%ming t$at t$e B3) $as 9%ris!iction over t$e &rotest t$e gro%n!s raise! t$erein ,ere !eeme! ,aive! b' =angilinanHs (ail%re to invo+e t$em at t$e level o( t$e B32 an! t$at t$e B3) acte! ,it$ grave ab%se o( !iscretion amo%nting to lac+ or e4cess o( 9%ris!iction in !en'ing t$e &etitioner o( !%e &rocess ,$en it or!ere! t$e reo&ening o( t$e ballot bo4 an! t$e reco%nting o( t$e votes ,it$o%t a((or!ing $im t$e o&&ort%nit' to be $ear!. *n its Or!er !ate! 11 7an%ar' 1881 t$e -2C !ismisse! t$e &etition (or lac+ o( 9%ris!iction 2$e trial co%rt state! t$at it ,as not a,are o( an' la, b' ,$ic$ it co%l! act on t$e matters raise! in Merca!oHs &etition since -esol%tion No. /088 o( t$e COM3L3C !i! not vest in t$e -2C 9%ris!iction over controversies a((ecting )angg%niang Mabataan electionsA constit%ting instea! t$e B3) ,$ic$ is %n!er COM3L3C 9%ris!iction as t$e (inal arbiter o( all election controversies ,it$in its level. Merca!o move! (or a reconsi!eration o( t$e !ismissal or!er. He arg%e! t$at t$e -2C ,as com&etent to act on $is &etition beca%se ;a< one mo!e o( see+ing 9%!icial revie,
Facts: 7ose M. Merca!o ,as &roclaime! ,inner in t$e 0 December 188/ election (or c$airman o( t$e )M o( Baranga' Mabalor *baan Batangas. 2$e &roclamation ,as ma!e b' t$e Boar! o( 3lection
115
111
11/
111
110
Montesclaros v. COM%L%C
11C
11G
1.
117
118
118
105
101
Lim an
Gara#blas v. CA
10/
101
100
/.
10C
10G
107
108
/.
108
/.
/.
/.
/.
1C5
1C1
Fo%rt$
1C/
1C1
Or illo v. COM%L%C Facts: 2$e &eo&le o( t$e &rovinces o( Beng%et Mo%ntain =rovince *(%gao #bra an! Malinga #&a'ao an! t$e cit' o( Bag%io cast t$eir votes in a &lebiscite $el! &%rs%ant to -# G7GG. 2$e COM3L3C res%lts s$o,e! t$at t$e creation o( t$e -egion ,as a&&rove! onl' b' a ma9orit' o( C 888 votes in onl' t$e *(%gao =rovince an! ,as over,$elmingl' re9ecte! b' 108 G7G votes in t$e rest o( t$e &rovinces an! cit' abovementione!. )ec o( 7%stice: consi!ering t$e &roviso t$at onl' t$e &rovinces an! cit' voting (avorabl' s$all be incl%!e! in t$e C#- t$e &rovince o( *(%gao being t$e onl' &rovince ,$ic$ vote! (avorabl' legall' constit%tes t$e C#-. #s a res%lt o( t$is Congress enacte! -# G8G1 ,$ic$ set t$e elections in t$e C#-. Or!illo et al t$en (ile! a &etition ,it$ t$e COM3L3C to !eclare t$e nonDrati(ication o( t$e Organic #ct (or t$e -egion. 2$e &resi!ent iss%e! #O 1G5 !eclaring t$at t$e Cor!illera 34ec%tive Boar! an! Cor!illera -egional #ssembl' an! ot$er o((ices create! %n!er 3O//5 are abolis$e! in vie, o( t$e rati(ication o( t$e Organic #ct. 2$e &etitioners maintain t$at t$ere can be no vali! C#- as t$e
1C0
MM*A v. Bel;Air /supra1 MM*A v. Garin Facts: Dante O. Garin ,as iss%e! a tra((ic violation recei&t ;2K-< (or &ar+ing illegall' along Gan!ara )treet Binon!o Manila. His !riverHs license ,as also con(iscate!. )$ortl' be(ore t$e e4&iration o( t$e 2K-Hs vali!it' t$e Garin a!!resse! a letter to t$en MMD# C$airman Oreta re.%esting t$e ret%rn o( $is !riverHs license an! e4&ressing $is &re(erence (or $is case to be (ile! in co%rt. -eceiving no imme!iate re&l' Garin (ile! t$e original com&laint ,it$ a&&lication (or &reliminar' in9%nction conten!ing t$at in t$e absence o( an' im&lementing r%les an! reg%lations )ec. C;(< o( -e&. #ct No. 78/0 grants t$e MMD# %nbri!le! !iscretion to !e&rive erring motorists o( t$eir licenses &reDem&ting a 9%!icial !etermination o( t$e vali!it' o( t$e !e&rivation t$ereb' violating t$e !%e &rocess cla%se o( t$e Constit%tion. 2$e res&on!ent (%rt$er conten!e! t$at t$e &rovision violates t$e constit%tional &ro$ibition against %n!%e !elegation o( legislative a%t$orit' allo,ing as it !oes t$e MMD# to (i4 an! im&ose %ns&eci(ie! X an! t$ere(ore %nlimite! D (ines an! ot$er &enalties on erring motorists. *n s%&&ort o( $is a&&lication (or a ,rit o( &reliminar' in9%nction Garin allege! t$at $e s%((ere! an!
1CC
/. 6ON t$e MMD# is veste! ,it$ &olice &o,er. NO. Metro Manila Develo&ment #%t$orit' v. BelD#ir Killage
#ssociation *nc. ,e categoricall' state! t$at -e&. #ct No. 78/0 !oes not grant t$e MMD# ,it$ &olice &o,er let alone legislative &o,er an! t$at all its (%nctions are a!ministrative in nat%re. 2racing t$e legislative $istor' o( -# 78/0 creating t$e MMD# ,e concl%!e! t$at t$e MMD# is not a local government %nit or a &%blic cor&oration en!o,e!
1CG
/.
1C7
League o! Cities v. COM%L%C Facts: 11t$ Congress: 11 bills converting 11 m%nici&alities into cities ,ere enacte!. Ho,ever Congress !i! not act on bills converting /0 ot$er m%nici&alities into cities. 1/t$ Congress: -# 8558 ,$ic$ amen!e! )ec. 0C5 o( t$e LGC b' increasing t$e ann%al income re.%irement (or conversion o( a m%nici&alit' into a cit' (rom =/5 million to =155 million ,as enacte!. 2$e rationale (or t$e amen!ment ,as to restrain in t$e ,or!s o( )en. =imentel Et$e ma! r%s$F o( m%nici&alities to convert into cities solel' to sec%re a larger s$are in t$e *nternal -even%e #llotment !es&ite t$e (act t$at t$e' are inca&able o( (iscal in!e&en!ence. #(ter t$e e((ectivit' o( -# 8558 t$e Ho%se a!o&te! 7oint -esol%tion No. /8 ,$ic$ so%g$t to e4em&t (rom t$e =155 million income re.%irement in -# 8558 t$e /0 m%nici&alities ,$ose cit'$oo! bills ,ere not a&&rove! in t$e 11t$ Congress. Ho,ever t$e 1/t$ Congress en!e! ,it$o%t t$e )enate a&&roving 7oint -esol%tion No. /8. 11t$ Congress: 7- /8 ,as reDa!o&te! as 7- 1 an! ,as (or,ar!e! to t$e )enate (or a&&roval. Ho,ever t$e )enate again (aile! to a&&rove t$e 7oint -esol%tion. Follo,ing t$e a!vice o( )en.=imentel 1G m%nici&alities (ile! t$ro%g$ t$eir res&ective s&onsors in!ivi!%al cit'$oo! bills. 2$e 1G cit'$oo! bills containe! a common &rovision e4em&ting all t$e 1G m%nici&alities (rom t$e =155 million income re.%irement in -# 8558. On // December /55G t$e Ho%se o( -e&resentatives a&&rove! t$e cit'$oo! bills. 2$e )enate also a&&rove! t$e cit'$oo! bills in Febr%ar' /557 e4ce&t t$at o( Naga Ceb% ,$ic$ ,as &asse! on 7 7%ne /557. 2$e cit'$oo! bills la&se! into la, ,it$o%t t$e =resi!ent>s signat%re. 2$e Cit'$oo! La,s !irect
1C8
1C8
/.
/.
/.
1G5
1G1
Mabelle O. Nebres | Local Governments Case Digests F%rt$ermore limiting t$e e4em&tion onl' to t$e 1G
m%nici&alities violates t$e re.%irement t$at t$e classi(ication m%st a&&l' to all similarl' sit%ate!. M%nici&alities ,it$ t$e same income as t$e 1G res&on!ent m%nici&alities cannot convert into cities ,$ile t$e 1G res&on!ent m%nici&alities can. Clearl' as ,or!e! t$e e4em&tion &rovision (o%n! in t$e Cit'$oo! La,s even i( it ,ere ,ritten in )ection 0C5 o( t$e LGC ,o%l! still be %nconstit%tional (or violation o( t$e e.%al &rotection cla%se. -e'es !issent: 1. 2$e cit'$oo! la,s !o not violate )ection 15 #rticle J o( t$e 1887 Constit%tion. )ec 15 man!ator'. 2$e %se o( t$e ,or! "s$all" in a constit%tional &rovision is generall' consi!ere! as a man!ator' comman! t$o%g$ t$e ,or! "s$all" ma' receive a &ermissive inter&retation ,$en necessar' to carr' o%t t$e tr%e intent o( t$e &rovision ,$ere t$e ,or! is (o%n!. 2$%s it is not al,a's t$e case t$at t$e %se o( t$e ,or! "s$all" is concl%sive. Ho,ever a rea!ing o( )ection 15 #rticle J cannot be constr%e! as an't$ing else b%t man!ator'. 2$e intent o( -.#. No. 8558 ,$ic$ amen!e! )ection 0C5 o( t$e LGC is to e4em&t res&on!ent m%nici&alities (rom t$e income re.%irement o( =155 555 555.55. 2$%s t$e cit'$oo! la,s ,$ic$ merel' carr' o%t t$e intent o( -.#. No. 8558 are in accor!ance ,it$ t$e "criteria establis$e! in t$e LGC " &%rs%ant to )ection 15 #rticle J o( t$e 1887 Constit%tion. 2$e cit'$oo! la,s contain a %ni(orml' ,or!e! e4em&tion cla%se ,$ic$ states: "34em&tion (rom -e&%blic #ct No. 8558. 2$e cit' o( UbbbV s$all be e4em&t (rom t$e income re.%irement &rescribe! %n!er -e&%blic #ct No. 8558." 6$at Congress $a! in min! is not at all times acc%ratel' re(lecte! in t$e lang%age o( t$e stat%te. 2$%s t$e literal inter&retation o( a stat%te ma' ren!er it meaninglessA an! lea! to abs%r!it' in9%stice or contra!iction.15C 6$en t$is $a&&ens an! (ollo,ing t$e r%le t$at t$e intent or t$e s&irit o( t$e la, is t$e la, itsel( resort s$o%l! be $a! to t$e &rinci&le t$at t$e s&irit o( t$e la, controls its letter. Not to t$e letter t$at +illet$ b%t to t$e s&irit t$at vivi(iet$. Hin!i ang letra na &%ma&ata' +%ng $in!i ang !i,a na nagbibiga' b%$a'.
1.
1G/
1G1
1G0
1GC
1GG
1G7
1G8
1G8
175
171
17/
171
170
17C
17G
177
178
178
185
181
Caasi v. CA Facts: Merito Mig%el ,on in t$e 1888 ma'oral elections in Bolinao =angasinan. =etitions ,ere (ile! see+ing to !is.%ali(' $im on t$e gro%n! t$at $e $ol!s a green car! iss%e! to $im b' t$e @) *mmigration )ervice ,$ic$ ,o%l! mean t$at $e $is a &ermanent resi!ent o( t$e @nite! )tates an! not o( Bolinao. COM3L3C !ismisse! t$e &etitions on t$e gro%n! t$at &ossession o( a green car! b' Mig%el !oes not s%((icientl' establis$ t$at $e $as aban!one! $is resi!ence in t$e =$ili&&ines. On t$e contrar' !es&ite $is green car! $e $as s%((icientl' in!icate! $is intention to contin%o%sl' resi!e in Bolinao as s$o,n b' $is $aving vote! in s%ccessive elections in sai! m%nici&alit'. Commissioner Ba!o'>s !issent: # green car! $ol!er being a &ermanent resi!ent o( or an immigrant o( a (oreign co%ntr' an! res&on!ent $aving a!mitte! t$at $e is a green car! $ol!er it is inc%mbent %&on $im %n!er )ection G8 o( t$e Omnib%s 3lection Co!e to &rove t$at $e "$as ,aive! $is stat%s as a &ermanent resi!ent or immigrant" to be .%ali(ie! to r%n (or electe! o((ice. 2$is res&on!ent $as not !one. Mig%el>s o&&onent Caasi also (ile! a &etition (or .%o ,arranto. Mig%el (ile! an M2D ,$ic$ ,as !enie! b' t$e -2C. C# or!ere! t$e -2C to !ismiss an! !esist (rom (%rt$er &rocee!ing in t$e .%o ,arranto case on t$e gro%n! t$at t$e COM3L3C $as alrea!' r%le! on $is .%ali(ications. *ss%es: 1. 6ON a green car! is &roo( t$at t$e $ol!er is a &ermanent resi!ent o( t$e @nite! )tates Consti: #rticle J* )ec. 18. =%blic o((icers an! em&lo'ees o,e t$e )tate an! t$is Constit%tion allegiance at all times an!
18/
/.
181
180
18C
18G
187
/.
188
a.
188
185
181
18/
181
180
Gali o v. COM%L%C
18C
18G
187
Mabelle O. Nebres | Local Governments Case Digests #rticle J c8 o( t$e Constit%tion &rovi!es: 2$e term o( o((ice
o( elective local o((icials e4ce&t baranga' o((icials ,$ic$ s$all be !etermine! b' la, s$all be t$ree 'ears an! no s%c$ o((icial s$all serve (or more t$an t$ree consec%tive terms. Kol%ntar' ren%nciation o( t$e o((ice (or an' lengt$ o( time s$all not be consi!ere! as an interr%&tion in t$e contin%it' o( $is service (or t$e (%ll term (or ,$ic$ $e ,as electe!. 2$is &rovision is restate! in c01;b< o( t$e LGC ;-.#. No. 71G5<: No local elective o((icial s$all serve (or more t$an t$ree ;1< consec%tive terms in t$e same &osition. Kol%ntar' ren%nciation o( t$e o((ice (or an' lengt$ o( time s$all not be consi!ere! as an interr%&tion in t$e contin%it' o( service (or t$e (%ll term (or ,$ic$ t$e elective o((icial concerne! ,as electe!. 2,o i!eas t$%s emerge (rom a consi!eration o( t$e &rocee!ings o( t$e Constit%tional Commission. 2$e (irst is t$e notion o( service o( term !erive! (rom t$e concern abo%t t$e acc%m%lation o( &o,er as a res%lt o( a &rolonge! sta' in o((ice. 2$e secon! is t$e i!ea o( election !erive! (rom t$e concern t$at t$e rig$t o( t$e &eo&le to c$oose t$ose ,$om t$e' ,is$ to govern t$em be &reserve!. *n !isc%ssing term limits t$e !ra(ters o( t$e Constit%tion !i! so on t$e ass%m&tion t$at t$e o((icials concerne! ,ere serving b' reason o( reelection. *n!ee! a (%n!amental tenet o( re&resentative !emocrac' is t$at t$e &eo&le s$o%l! be allo,e! to c$oose ,$om t$e' &lease to govern t$em. 2o bar t$e election o( a local o((icial beca%se $e $as alrea!' serve! t$ree terms alt$o%g$ t$e (irst as a res%lt o( s%ccession b' o&eration o( la, rat$er t$an election ,o%l! t$ere(ore be to violate t$is &rinci&le. )econ! not onl' $istorical e4amination b%t te4t%al anal'sis as ,ell s%&&orts t$e r%ling o( t$e COM3L3C t$at #rt. J c8 contem&lates service b' local o((icials (or t$ree consec%tive terms as a res%lt o( election. 2$e (irst sentence s&ea+s o( Et$e term o( o((ice o( elective local o((icialsF an! bars Es%c$ o((icialUsVF (rom serving (or more t$an t$ree consec%tive terms. 2$e secon! sentence in e4&laining ,$en an elective local o((icial ma' be !eeme! to $ave serve! $is (%ll term o( o((ice states t$at Evol%ntar' ren%nciation o( t$e o((ice (or an' lengt$ o( time s$all not be consi!ere! as an interr%&tion in t$e contin%it' o( $is service (or t$e (%ll term (or ,$ic$ $e ,as electe!.F 2$e term serve! m%st t$ere(ore be one E(or ,$ic$ Ut$e o((icial concerne!V ,as electe!.F 2$e &%r&ose o( t$is &rovision is to &revent a circ%mvention o( t$e limitation on t$e n%mber o( terms an elective o((icial ma' serve. Conversel' i( $e is not serving a term (or ,$ic$ $e ,as electe! beca%se $e is sim&l' contin%ing t$e service o( t$e o((icial $e s%ccee!s s%c$ o((icial cannot be consi!ere! to $ave (%ll' serve! t$e term no, ,it$stan!ing $is vol%ntar' ren%nciation o( o((ice &rior to its e4&iration. 2$ere is a !i((erence bet,een t$e case o( a viceDma'or an! t$at o( a member o( t$e Ho%se o( -e&resentatives ,$o s%ccee!s anot$er ,$o !ies resigns becomes inca&acitate! or is remove! (rom o((ice. 2$e viceDma'or s%ccee!s to t$e ma'ors$i& b' o&eration o( la,. On t$e ot$er $an! t$e -e&resentative is electe! to (ill t$e vacanc'. *n a real sense t$ere(ore s%c$ -e&resentative serves a term (or ,$ic$ $e ,as electe!. #s t$e &%r&ose o( t$e constit%tional &rovision is to limit t$e rig$t ot be electe! an! to serve in Congress $is service o( t$e %ne4&ire! term is rig$tl' co%nte! as $is (irst term. -at$er t$an re(%te ,$at ,e believe to be t$e inten!ment o( #rt. J c8 ,it$ regar! to elective local o((icials t$e case o( a -e&resentative ,$o s%ccee!s anot$er con(irms t$e t$eor'. =etitioner also cites #rt. K** c0 o( t$e Constit%tion ,$ic$ &rovi!es (or s%ccession o( t$e KiceD=resi!ent to t$e =resi!enc' in case o( vacanc' in t$at o((ice. #(ter stating t$at E2$e =resi!ent s$all not be eligible (or an' reelection F t$is &rovision sa's t$at ENo &erson ,$o $as s%ccee!e! as =resi!ent an! $as serve! as s%c$ (or more t$an (o%r 'ears s$all be .%ali(ie! (or election to t$e same o((ice at an' time.F =etitioner conten!s t$at b' analog' t$e viceDma'or s$o%l! li+e,ise be consi!ere! to $ave serve! a (%ll term as ma'or i( $e s%ccee!s to t$e latter>s o((ice an! serves (or t$e remain!er o( t$e term. 2$e (ramers o( t$e Constit%tion incl%!e! s%c$ a &rovision beca%se ,it$o%t it t$e KiceD=resi!ent ,$o sim&l' ste&s into t$e =resi!enc' b' s%ccession ,o%l! be .%ali(ie! to r%n (or =resi!ent even i( $e $as occ%&ie! t$at o((ice (or more t$an (o%r 'ears. 2$e absence o( a similar &rovision in #rt. J c8 on elective local o((icials t$ro,s in bol! relie( t$e !i((erence bet,een t$e t,o cases. *t %n!erscores t$e constit%tional intent to cover onl' t$e terms o( o((ice to ,$ic$ one ma' $ave been electe! (or &%r&ose o( t$e t$reeD
188
188
/55
/51
/.
/.
/5/
/51
/50
/5C
Mabelle O. Nebres | Local Governments Case Digests Hage!orn ,as electe! (or t$ree consec%tive terms in t$e
188/ 188C an! 1888 elections an! serve! in (%ll $is t$ree consec%tive terms as ma'or o( =%erto =rincesa. @n!er t$e Constit%tion an! t$e LGC Hage!orn co%l! no longer r%n (or ma'or in t$e /551 elections. 2$e Constit%tion an! t$e LGC !is.%ali(ie! Hage!orn ,$o $a! reac$e! t$e ma4im%m t$reeDterm limit (rom r%nning (or a (o%rt$ consec%tive term as ma'or. 2$%s Hage!orn !i! not r%n (or ma'or in t$e /551 elections. )ocrates ran an! ,on as ma'or o( =%erto =rincesa in t$e /551 elections. #(ter Hage!orn cease! to be ma'or on 7%ne 15 /551 $e became a &rivate citiBen %ntil t$e recall election o( )e&tember /0 /55/ ,$en $e ,on b' 1 518 votes over $is closest o&&onent )ocrates. From 7%ne 15 /551 %ntil t$e recall election on )e&tember /0 /55/ t$e ma'or o( =%erto =rincesa ,as )ocrates. D%ring t$e same &erio! Hage!orn ,as sim&l' a &rivate citiBen. 2$is &erio! is clearl' an interr%&tion in t$e contin%it' o( Hage!orn>s service as ma'or not beca%se o( $is vol%ntar' ren%nciation b%t beca%se o( a legal &ro$ibition. Hage!orn>s t$ree consec%tive terms en!e! on 7%ne 15 /551. Hage!orn>s ne, recall term (rom )e&tember /0 /55/ to 7%ne 15 /550 is not a seamless contin%ation o( $is &revio%s t$ree consec%tive terms as ma'or. One cannot stitc$ toget$er Hage!orn>s &revio%s t$reeDterms ,it$ $is ne, recall term to ma+e t$e recall term a (o%rt$ consec%tive term beca%se (act%all' it is not. #n invol%ntar' interr%&tion occ%rre! (rom 7%ne 15 /551 to )e&tember /0 /55/ ,$ic$ bro+e t$e contin%it' or consec%tive c$aracter o( Hage!orn>s service as ma'or. LonBani!a Case: Kol%ntar' ren%nciation o( o((ice (or an' lengt$ o( time s$all not be consi!ere! as an interr%&tion in t$e contin%it' o( service (or t$e (%ll term (or ,$ic$ $e ,as electe!.F 2$e clear intent o( t$e (ramers o( t$e constit%tion to bar an' attem&t to circ%mvent t$e t$reeDterm limit b' a vol%ntar' ren%nciation o( o((ice an! at t$e same time res&ect t$e &eo&le>s c$oice an! grant t$eir electe! o((icial (%ll service o( a term is evi!ent in t$is &rovision. Kol%ntar' ren%nciation o( a term !oes not cancel t$e reno%nce! term in t$e com&%tation o( t$e t$reeDterm limitA conversel' invol%ntar' severance (rom o((ice (or an' lengt$ o( time s$ort o( t$e (%ll term &rovi!e! b' la, amo%nts to an interr%&tion o( contin%it' o( service. *n Hage!orn>s case t$e nearl' 1CDmont$ &erio! $e ,as o%t o( o((ice alt$o%g$ s$ort o( a (%ll term o( t$ree 'ears constit%te! an interr%&tion in t$e contin%it' o( $is service as ma'or. 2$e Constit%tion !oes not re.%ire t$e interr%&tion or $iat%s to be a (%ll term o( t$ree 'ears. 2$e clear intent is t$at interr%&tion E(or an' lengt$ o( time F as long as t$e ca%se is invol%ntar' is s%((icient to brea+ an elective local o((icial>s contin%it' o( service. #!ormeo Case: an interr%&tion consisting o( a &ortion o( a term o( o((ice brea+s t$e contin%it' o( service o( an elective local o((icial. 2$e iss%e in #!ormeo ,as ,$et$er 2alaga>s recall term ,as a contin%ation o( $is &revio%s t,o terms so t$at $e ,as !eeme! to $ave alrea!' serve! t$ree consec%tive terms as ma'or. 2$e Co%rt r%le! t$at 2alaga ,as .%ali(ie! to r%n in t$e /551 elections stating t$at t$e &erio! (rom 7%ne 15 1888 to Ma' 1/ /555 ,$en 2alaga ,as o%t o( o((ice interr%&te! t$e contin%it' o( $is service as ma'or. 2alaga>s recall term as ma'or ,as not consec%tive to $is &revio%s t,o terms beca%se o( t$is interr%&tion t$ere $aving been a brea+ o( almost t,o 'ears !%ring ,$ic$ time 2agarao ,as t$e ma'or. *n t$e instant case ,e li+e,ise $ol! t$at t$e nearl' 1C mont$s Hage!orn ,as o%t o( o((ice interr%&te! $is contin%it' o( service an! &revents $is recall term (rom being stitc$e! toget$er as a seamless contin%ation o( $is &revio%s t$ree consec%tive terms. 2$e onl' !i((erence bet,een #!ormeo an! t$e instant case is t$e time o( t$e interr%&tion. *n #!ormeo t$e interr%&tion occ%rre! a(ter t$e (irst t,o consec%tive terms. *n t$e instant case t$e interr%&tion $a&&ene! a(ter t$e (irst t$ree consec%tive terms. *n bot$ cases t$e res&on!ents ,ere see+ing election (or a (o%rt$ term. 2$e &erio! o( time &rior to t$e recall term ,$en anot$er elective o((icial $ol!s o((ice constit%tes an interr%&tion in contin%it' o( service. Clearl' #!ormeo establis$e! t$e r%le t$at t$e ,inner in t$e recall election cannot be c$arge! or cre!ite! ,it$ t$e (%ll term o( t$ree 'ears (or &%r&oses o( co%nting t$e consec%tiveness o( an elective o((icial>s terms in o((ice. Hage!orn>s recall term !oes not retroact to incl%!e t$e ten%re in o((ice o( )ocrates. Hage!orn can onl' be !is.%ali(ie! to r%n in t$e )e&tember /0 /55/ recall election i( t$e recall term is ma!e to retroact to 7%ne 15 /551 (or
/5G
/57
/.
/58
1.
/.
1.
/58
/15
/11
/.
/1/
/11
/.
/10
/1C
/1G
Facts ;(irst case<: *n $is ca&acit' as baranga' c$airman o( Baranga' 77 Zone 7 Maloo+an Cit' an! as &resi!ent o( t$e Liga ng mga Baranga' sa =ili&inas Davi! (ile! on December / 188G a &etition (or &ro$ibition %n!er -%le GC o( t$e -%les o( Co%rt to &ro$ibit t$e $ol!ing o( t$e baranga' election sc$e!%le! on t$e secon! Mon!a' o( Ma' 1887. On 7an%ar' /8 1887 t$e )olicitor General (ile! $is (o%rD&age Comment si!ing ,it$ &etitioner an! &ra'ing t$at Et$e election sc$e!%le! on Ma' 1/ 1887 be $el! in abe'ance.F 2$e COM3L3C (ile! a se&arate Comment !ate! Febr%ar' 1 1887 o&&osing t$e &etition. On Febr%ar' 11 1887 t$e Co%rt iss%e! a -esol%tion giving !%e co%rse to t$e &etition an! re.%iring t$e &arties to (ile sim%ltaneo%s memoran!a. *t also re.%este! (ormer )enator #.%ilino W. =imentel 7r. to act as amic%s c%riae. *t note! b%t !i! not grant &etitioner>s @rgent Motion (or *ss%ance o( 2em&orar' -estraining Or!er an!?or 6rit o( =reliminar' *n9%nction !ate! 7an%ar' 11 1887 ;as ,ell as $is @rgent 34D=arte )econ! Motion to t$e same e((ect !ate! Marc$ G 1887<. #ccor!ingl' t$e &arties (ile! t$eir res&ective memoran!a. 2$e =etition (or Leave to *ntervene (ile! on Marc$ 17 1887 b' =%nong Baranga' -o!son F. Ma'or ,as !enie! as it ,o%l! 9%st %n!%l' !ela' t$e resol%tion o( t$e case $is interest li+e t$ose o( all ot$er baranga' o((icials being alrea!' a!e.%atel' re&resente! b' =etitioner Davi! ,$o (ile! t$is &etition as E&resi!ent o( t$e Liga ng mga Baranga' sa =ili&inas.F Facts ;secon! case<: On Febr%ar' /5 1887 =etitioner Liga ng mga Baranga' W%eBon Cit' C$a&ter re&resente! b' its &resi!ent -illon (ile! a &etition Eto see+ a 9%!icial revie, b' certiorari to !eclare as %nconstit%tional: 1. )ection 01;c< o( -.#. 71G5 ,$ic$ rea!s as (ollo,s: ;c< 2$e term o( o((ice o( baranga' o((icials an! members o( t$e sangg%niang +abataan s$all be (or t$ree ;1< 'ears ,$ic$ s$all begin a(ter t$e reg%lar election o( baranga' o((icials on t$e secon! Mon!a' o( Ma' 1880.> /. COM3L3C -esol%tion Nos. /885 an! /887 (i4ing t$e !ate o( t$e $ol!ing o( t$e baranga' elections on Ma' 1/ 1887 an! ot$er activities relate! t$eretoA 1. 2$e b%!getar' a&&ro&riation o( =055 million containe! in -e&%blic #ct No. 8/C5 ot$er,ise +no,n as t$e General #&&ro&riations #ct o( 1887 inten!e! to !e(ra' t$e costs an! e4&enses in $ol!ing t$e 1887 baranga' electionsAF Comelec -esol%tion /885 &rom%lgate! on December /7 188G an! re(erre!
/17
/18
/18
//5
Municipalit# o! Pililia v. CA Facts: On Marc$ 17 1888 t$e -2C o( 2ana' -iBal Branc$ 85 ren!ere! 9%!gment in Civil Case No. 5C7D2 in (avor o( t$e M%nici&alit' o( =ililla against ==C or!ering it to &a' b%siness ta4es as ,ell as storage ma'or>s &ermit an! sanitar' ins&ection (ees. 2$e )C a((irme! ,it$ mo!i(ication ;1881 =ililia Case<. 2$is 9%!gment became (inal an! e4ec%tor' on 7%l' 11 1881 an! t$e recor!s ,ere reman!e! to t$e trial co%rt (or e4ec%tion. On October 10 1881 in connection ,it$ t$e e4ec%tion o( sai! 9%!gment #tt'. Men!iola (ile! a motion in be$al( o( &lainti(( m%nici&alit' (or t$e e4amination o( !e(en!ant cor&orationHs gross sales (or t$e 'ears 187G to 1878
//1
///
//1
/.
/. 6ON t$e &etitioners ma' be $el! in esto&&els =etitioners cannot be $el! in esto&&el (or .%estioning t$e
legalit' o( t$e a&&earance o( #tt'. -omanillos not,it$stan!ing t$at t$e' .%estione! t$e ,itnesses o( res&on!ent m%nici&alit' !%ring t$e $earing o( its motion to !issolve t$e &reliminar' in9%nction. M%nici&alit' o( =ililla -iBal vs. Co%rt o( #&&eals $el! t$at t$e legalit' o( t$e re&resentation o( an %na%t$oriBe! co%nsel ma' be raise! at an' stage o( t$e &rocee!ings. 2$is Co%rt state! t$at: 2$e legalit' o( $is re&resentation can be .%estione! at an' stage o( t$e &rocee!ings. *n t$e cases $ereinbe(ore cite! t$e iss%e o( lac+ o( a%t$orit' o( &rivate co%nsel to re&resent a m%nici&alit' ,as onl' raise! (or t$e (irst time in t$e &rocee!ings (or t$e collection o( attorne'Hs (ees (or services ren!ere! in t$e &artic%lar case a(ter t$e !ecision in t$at case $a! become (inal an! e4ec%tor' an!?or $a! been !%l' e4ec%te!. 3lementar' (airness !ictates t$at &arties %na,are o( t$e %na%t$oriBe! re&resentation s$o%l! not be $el! in esto&&el 9%st beca%se t$e' !i! not .%estion on t$e s&ot t$e a%t$orit' o( t$e co%nsel (or t$e m%nici&alit'. 2$e r%le on a&&earances o( a la,'er is t$at %ntil t$e contrar' is clearl' s$o,n an attorne' is &res%me! to be acting %n!er a%t$orit' o( t$e
/.
//0
//C
Mabelle O. Nebres | Local Governments Case Digests )ec. 081 o( t$e LGC ;-#. No. 71G5< re.%ires t$e
a&&ointment o( a legal o((icer (or t$e &rovince ,$ose (%nctions incl%!e t$e (ollo,ing: -e&resent t$e local government %nit in all civil actions an! s&ecial &rocee!ings ,$erein t$e local government %nit or an' o((icial t$ereo( in $is o((icial ca&acit' is a &art'A =rovi!e! 2$at in actions or &rocee!ing ,$ere a com&onent cit' or m%nici&alit' is a &art' a!verse to t$e &rovincial government or to anot$er com&onent cit' or m%nici&alit' a s&ecial legal o((icer ma' be em&lo'e! to re&resent t$e a!verse &art'. M%nici&alit' o( Boca%e et al. v. Manoto+: LG@s cannot be re&resente! b' &rivate la,'ers an! it is solel' t$e =rovincial Fiscal ,$o can rig$t(%ll' re&resent t$em. @n!er t$e la, t$e =rovincial Fiscal o( B%lacan an! $is assistants are c$arge! ,it$ t$e !%t' to re&resent t$e &rovince an! an' m%nici&alit' t$ereo( in all civil actions. 2$is r%ling a&&lies s.%arel' to t$e case at $an! beca%se )ec. 081 o( t$e LGC is base! on )ec. 1G81 o( t$e -evise! #!ministrative Co!e ,$ic$ ,as t$e s%b9ect o( inter&retation in t$e abovecite! case. *n $iring &rivate la,'ers to re&resent t$e =rovince o( #lba' res&on!ents e4cee!e! t$eir a%t$orit' an! violate! t$e above.%ote! section o( t$e LGC an! t$e !octrine lai! !o,n b' t$e )%&reme Co%rt. Moreover t$e entire transaction ,as atten!e! b' irreg%larities. First t$e !isb%rsements to t$e la,'ers amo%nting to =7 185 015.11 ,ere !isallo,e! b' t$e =rovincial #%!itor on t$e gro%n! t$at t$ese ,ere ma!e ,it$o%t t$e &rior ,ritten con(ormit' o( t$e )olicitor General an! t$e ,ritten conc%rrence o( t$e Commission on #%!it ;CO#< as re.%ire! b' CO# Circ%lar No. 8GD/CC !ate! / #&ril 188G. 2$e res&on!ents attem&te! to !is&%te t$is (in!ing b' &resenting t$e )olicitor GeneralHs con(ormit' !ate! 1C 7%l' 1881. 2$is con(ormit' ,as $o,ever obtaine! a(ter t$e !isb%rsements ,ere alrea!' ma!e in 1885 an! 188/. 6$at is re.%ire! b' CO# Circ%lar No. 8CD/CC is a &rior ,ritten con(ormit' an! ac.%iescence o( t$e )olicitor General. #not$er irreg%larit' in t$e transaction concerns t$e la,'ers. -esol%tion No. 51D85 a%t$oriBe! t$e res&on!ent Governor to sign an! con(irm a retainer contract (or legal services ,it$ t$e Cortes P -e'na La, Firm at /5/ 3. -o!rig%eB )r. Blv!. W%eBon Cit'. 2$e retainer contract signe! b' res&on!ent Governor ,as $o,ever not onl' ,it$ t$e Cortes P -e'na La, Firm b%t also ,it$ #tt'. 7es%s -. Cornago o( 7amecca B%il!ing /85 2omas Morato #ven%e W%eBon Cit'. *n entering into a retainer agreement not onl' ,it$ t$e Cortes P -e'na La, Firm b%t also ,it$ #tt'. 7ose -. Cornago res&on!ent Governor e4cee!e! $is a%t$orit' %n!er -esol%tion No. 51D85. Com&licating (%rt$er t$e ,eb o( !ece&tion s%rro%n!ing t$e transaction is t$e (act t$at it ,as onl' #tt'. Cornago ,$o a&&eare! as collaborating co%nsel o( recor! o( t$e =rovince in t$e )%&reme Co%rt case ;G -. No. 87078<. 3ven t$e )olicitor General in $is letter to res&on!ent Governor !ate! 1C 7%l' 1881 note! t$at t$e =rovince is re&resente! in t$e )%&reme Co%rt b' #tt's. -ica(ort Cornago an! Glenn Mana$an b%t not b' t$e Cortes P -e'na La, Firm. F%rt$ermore t$e memoran!%m ,it$ t$e )%&reme Co%rt (ile! (or t$e =rovince ,as signe! b' #tt'. Cornago an! not b' t$e Cortes P -e'na La, Firm. Conse.%entl' t$e Cortes P -e'na La, Firm ,as not co%nsel o( recor! o( t$e =rovince in G.-. No. 87078. #n! 'et si4 o( t$e ten c$ec+s &ai! b' t$e =rovince an! amo%nting to more t$an =1.G million ,ere iss%e! in (avor o( t$e Cortes P -e'na La, Firm t$ro%g$ #tt'. #ntonio 7ose Cortes. *n ot$er ,or!s res&on!ents !isb%rse! mone' to t$e Cortes P -e'na La, Firm alt$o%g$ t$e latter !i! not a&&ear as co%nsel (or t$e =rovince in t$e )%&reme Co%rt in G.-. No. 87078. Finall' t$e attorne'Hs (ees agree! %&on b' res&on!ent )alalima an! con(irme! b' t$e ot$er res&on!ents are not onl' %nreasonable b%t also %nconscionable. 2$e contingent (ee o( 18Y o( t$e "=/10 million" claim o( t$e =rovince against N=C amo%nts to =18.C million. 2$e ,or! "%nconscionable" as a&&lie! to attorne'Hs (ee "means not$ing more t$an t$at t$e (ee contracte! (or stan!ing alone an! %ne4&laine! ,o%l! be s%((icient to s$o, t$at an %n(air a!vantage $a! been ta+en o( t$e client or t$at a legal (ra%! $a! been ta+en o( t$e client or t$at a legal (ra%! $a! been &er&etrate! on $im." 2$e =rovince $as a legal o((icer #tt'. -ica(ort ,$o $a! alrea!' (ile! a comment on N=CHs &etition against t$e =rovince. 2$e comment (ile! b' #tt'. -ica(ort alrea!' covers t$e basic iss%es raise! in t$e &etition. 6$en #tt'. Cornago
//G
//7
//8
//8
Ganzon v. CA /August 0DD0- supra- see p. D1 Ganzon v. CA /,ovember 0DD01 Facts: )ometime in 1888 a series o( 15 a!ministrative com&laints ,ere (ile! b' vario%s cit' o((icials against &etitioner GanBon t$e
/15
/11
/1/
/11
/10
Re#es v. COM%L%C Facts: -e'es ,as t$e inc%mbent ma'or o( t$e m%nici&alit' o( Bongabong Oriental Min!oro $aving been electe! to t$at o((ice on
/1C
/1G
/.
/.
/17
Facts: Criminal an! a!ministrative com&laints ,ere (ile! against Ma'or O%ano KiceDMa'or CaRete an! )angg%niang =anl%ngso! Member Ma'ol all &%blic o((icials o( Man!a%e Cit' b' Man!a%e Cit' Co%ncilors Dionson an! Berce!e ,it$ t$e O((ice o( t$e De&%t' Omb%!sman (or t$e Kisa'as. Co%ncilors Dionson an! Berce!e averre! t$at res&on!ent o((icials acting in cons&irac' $a! ca%se! t$e alteration an!?or (alsi(ication o( Or!inance No. 518?8/ b' increasing t$e allocate! a&&ro&riation t$erein (rom =1 080 1G0.C7 to =7 555 555.55 ,it$o%t a%t$orit' (rom t$e )angg%niang =anl%ngso! o( Man!a%e Cit'. 2$e' move! (or t$e &reventive s%s&ension o( res&on!ent o((icials in t$e se&aratel' !oc+ete! a!ministrative case. #si!e (rom o&&osing t$e motion (or &reventive s%s&ension res&on!ent o((icials on 5C #%g%st 188/ &ra'e! (or t$e !ismissal o( t$e com&laint on t$e gro%n! t$at t$e Omb%!sman s%&&ose!l' ,as bere(t o( 9%ris!iction to tr' $ear an! !eci!e t$e a!ministrative case (ile! against t$em since %n!er )ection G1 o( t$e LGC o( 1881 t$e &o,er to investigate an! im&ose a!ministrative sanctions against sai! local o((icials as ,ell as to e((ect t$eir &reventive s%s&ension $a! no, been veste! ,it$ t$e O((ice o( t$e =resi!ent. *ss%e: 1. 6ON t$e Omb%!sman $as 9%ris!iction. 2$e general investigator' &o,er o( t$e Omb%!sman is !ecree! b' )ection 11 ;1 < #rticle J* o( t$e 1887 Constit%tion 10 t$%s: )ec. 11. 2$e O((ice o( t$e Omb%!sman s$all $ave t$e (ollo,ing &o,ers (%nctions an! !%ties: ;1< *nvestigate on its o,n or on com&laint b' an' &erson an' act or omission o( an' &%blic o((icial em&lo'ee o((ice or agenc' ,$en s%c$ act or omission a&&ears to be illegal %n9%st im&ro&er or ine((icientA )ection 18 o( -.#. No. G775: #!ministrative com&laints. S 2$e Omb%!sman s$all act on all com&laints relating b%t not limite! to acts or omissions ,$ic$: 1. #re contrar' to la, or reg%lationA /. #re %nreasonable %n(air o&&ressive or !iscriminator'A 1. #re inconsistent ,it$ t$e general co%rse o( an agenc'Hs (%nctions t$o%g$ in accor!ance ,it$ la,A 0. =rocee! (rom a mista+e o( la, or an arbitrar' ascertainment
/18
/.
/.
/18
/.
/05
/.
/.
/01
/.
/0/
/.
/01
/00
/0C
/.
/0G
Mabelle O. Nebres | Local Governments Case Digests Moreover t$e &o,er o( t$e D*LG to investigate
a!ministrative com&laints is base! on t$e alterDego &rinci&le or t$e !octrine o( .%ali(ie! &olitical agenc'. 2$%s: @n!er t$is !octrine ,$ic$ recogniBes t$e establis$ment o( a single e4ec%tive all e4ec%tive an! a!ministrative organiBations are a!9%ncts o( t$e 34ec%tive De&artment t$e $ea!s o( t$e vario%s e4ec%tive !e&artments are assistants an! agents o( t$e C$ie( 34ec%tive an! e4ce&t in cases ,$ere t$e C$ie( 34ec%tive is re.%ire! b' t$e Constit%tion or la, to act in &erson or t$e e4igencies o( t$e sit%ation !eman! t$at $e act &ersonall' t$e m%lti(ario%s e4ec%tive an! a!ministrative (%nctions o( t$e C$ie( 34ec%tive are &er(orme! b' an! t$ro%g$ t$e e4ec%tive !e&artments an! t$e acts o( t$e )ecretaries o( s%c$ !e&artments &er(orme! an! &rom%lgate! in t$e reg%lar co%rse o( b%siness are %nless !isa&&rove! or re&robate! b' t$e C$ie( 34ec%tive &res%m&tivel' t$e acts o( t$e C$ie( 34ec%tive." 2$is !octrine is corollar' to t$e control &o,er o( t$e =resi!ent.2$e &o,er o( control is &rovi!e! in t$e Constit%tion t$%s: ")ec. 17. 2$e =resi!ent s$all $ave control o( all t$e e4ec%tive !e&artments b%rea%s an! o((ices. He s$all ens%re t$at t$e la,s be (ait$(%ll' e4ec%te!." Control is sai! to be t$e ver' $eart o( t$e &o,er o( t$e &resi!enc'. #s $ea! o( t$e 34ec%tive De&artment t$e =resi!ent $o,ever ma' !elegate some o( $is &o,ers to t$e Cabinet members e4ce&t ,$en $e is re.%ire! b' t$e Constit%tion to act in &erson or t$e e4igencies o( t$e sit%ation !eman! t$at $e acts &ersonall'. 2$e members o( Cabinet ma' act (or an! in be$al( o( t$e =resi!ent in certain matters beca%se t$e =resi!ent cannot be e4&ecte! to e4ercise $is control ;an! s%&ervisor'< &o,ers &ersonall' all t$e time. 3ac$ $ea! o( a !e&artment is an! m%st be t$e =resi!entHs alter ego in t$e matters o( t$at !e&artment ,$ere t$e =resi!ent is re.%ire! b' la, to e4ercise a%t$orit'. 6$en an a!ministrative com&laint is t$ere(ore (ile! t$e Disci&lining #%t$orit' s$all iss%e an or!er re.%iring t$e res&on!ent to s%bmit $is veri(ie! ans,er ,it$in (i(teen ;1C< !a's (rom notice. @&on (iling o( t$e ans,er t$e Disci&lining #%t$orit' s$all re(er t$e case to t$e *nvestigating #%t$orit' (or investigation. *n t$e case at bar &etitioner claims t$at t$e D*LG )ecretar' %s%r&e! t$e &o,er o( t$e =resi!ent ,$en $e re.%ire! &etitioner to ans,er t$e com&laint. @n!is&%tabl' t$e letterD com&laint ,as (ile! ,it$ t$e O((ice o( t$e =resi!ent b%t it ,as t$e D*LG )ecretar' ,$o or!ere! &etitioner to ans,er. )trictl' a&&l'ing t$e r%les t$e O((ice o( t$e =resi!ent !i! not com&l' ,it$ t$e &rovisions o( #.O. No. /1. 2$e O((ice s$o%l! $ave (irst re.%ire! &etitioner to (ile $is ans,er. 2$erea(ter t$e com&laint an! t$e ans,er s$o%l! $ave been re(erre! to t$e *nvestigating #%t$orit' (or (%rt$er &rocee!ings. Be t$at as it ma' t$is &roce!%ral la&se is not (atal. 2$e (iling o( t$e ans,er is necessar' merel' to enable t$e =resi!ent to ma+e a &reliminar' assessment o( t$e case.UG/V 2$e =resi!ent (o%n! t$e com&laint s%((icient in (orm an! s%bstance to ,arrant its (%rt$er investigation. 2$e 9%!gment o( t$e =resi!ent on t$e matter is entitle! to res&ect in t$e absence o( grave ab%se o( !iscretion. 6ON t$e D*LG erre! in !eclaring $im in !e(a%lt (or (iling a motion to !ismiss. *t is tr%e t$at a motion to !ismiss is not a &lea!ing &ro$ibite! %n!er t$e LGC o( 1881 nor in #.O. No. /1. =etitioner $o,ever ,as instr%cte! not to (ile a motion to !ismiss in t$e or!er to (ile ans,er. 2$rice $e re.%este! (or e4tension o( time to (ile $is ans,er citing as reasons t$e searc$ (or com&etent co%nsel an! t$e !eman!s o( $is o((icial !%ties. #n! t$rice $is re.%ests ,ere grante!. 3ven t$e or!er o( !e(a%lt ,as reconsi!ere! an! &etitioner ,as given a!!itional time to (ile ans,er. #(ter all t$e re.%ests an! seven mont$s later $e (ile! a motion to !ismiss. =etitioner s$o%l! +no, t$at t$e (ormal investigation o( t$e case is re.%ire! b' la, to be (inis$e! ,it$in one $%n!re! t,ent' ;1/5< !a's (rom t$e time o( (ormal notice to t$e res&on!ent. 2$e e4tensions &etitioner re.%este! cons%me! (i(t'D(ive ;CC< !a's o( t$is &erio!.UG1V =etitioner in (act (ile! $is ans,er nine ;8< mont$s a(ter t$e (irst notice. *n!ee! t$is ,as more t$an s%((icient time (or &etitioner to com&l' ,it$ t$e or!er to (ile ans,er. 2$e s&ee!' !is&osition o( a!ministrative com&laints is re.%ire! b' &%blic service. 2$e e((icienc' o( o((icials %n!er investigation is im&aire! ,$en a case $angs over t$eir $ea!s. O((icials !eserve to be cleare! e4&e!itio%sl' i( t$e' are innocent also e4&e!itio%sl' i( g%ilt' so t$at t$e b%siness o( government ,ill not be &re9%!ice!.
1.
/07
/08
/08
/C5
/C1
/C/
%var one v. COM%L%C Facts: 3var!one is t$e ma'or o( t$e M%nici&alit' o( )%lat 3astern )amar $aving been electe! to t$e &osition !%ring t$e 1888 local elections. He ass%me! o((ice imme!iatel' a(ter &roclamation. On 10 Febr%ar' 1885 #&ela!o #clan an! Nival (ile! a &etition (or t$e recall o( 3var!one ,it$ t$e O((ice o( t$e Local 3lection -egistrar M%nici&alit' o( )%lat. COM3L3C iss%e! a resol%tion a&&roving t$e recommen!ation to $ol! on 10 7%l' 1885 t$e signing o( t$e &etition (or recall against inc%mbent Ma'or 3var!one o( t$e sai! M%nici&alit'. 3var!one (ile! be(ore t$is Co%rt a &etition (or &ro$ibition ,it$ %rgent &ra'er (or imme!iate iss%ance o( restraining or!er an!?or ,rit o( &reliminar' in9%nction. )C iss%e! 2-O or!ering t$e res&on!ents to cease an! !esist (rom $ol!ing t$e signing o( t$e &etition (or recall. Central O((ice got it on t$e same !a' b%t (iel! agent got it 1 !a's later a !a' a(ter t$e com&letion o( t$e signing &rocess so%g$t to be tem&oraril' sto&&e! b' t$e 2-O. COM3L3C n%lli(ie! t$e signing &rocess $el! in )%lat 3astern )amar (or being violative o( t$e 2-O. #&ela!o et al. (ile! M- !enie!. Hence t$e &resent &etition (or revie, on certiorari. *ss%es: 1. 6ON COM3L3C -esol%tion //7/ is constit%tional. :3). 3var!one: #rticle J )ection 1 o( t$e 1887 Constit%tion re&eale! Batas =ambansa Blg. 117 in (avor o( one to be enacte! b' Congress. )ince t$ere ,as !%ring t$e &erio! material to t$is case no LGC enacte! b' Congress a(ter t$e
/C1
/.
/C0
Mabelle O. Nebres | Local Governments Case Digests 6$et$er or not t$e electorate o( t$e M%nici&alit' o( )%lat
$as lost con(i!ence in t$e inc%mbent ma'or is a &olitical .%estion. *t belongs to t$e realm o( &olitics ,$ere onl' t$e &eo&le are t$e 9%!ge. "Loss o( con(i!ence is t$e (ormal ,it$!ra,al b' an electorate o( t$eir tr%st in a &ersonHs abilit' to !isc$arge $is o((ice &revio%sl' besto,e! on $im b' t$e same electorate. 2$e constit%ents $ave ma!e a 9%!gment an! t$eir ,ill to recall t$e inc%mbent ma'or $as alrea!' been ascertaine! an! m%st be a((or!e! t$e $ig$est res&ect. 2$%s t$e signing &rocess $el! last 10 7%l' 1885 in )%lat 3astern )amar (or t$e recall o( Ma'or Feli&e =. 3var!one o( sai! m%nici&alit' is vali! an! $as legal e((ect. Ho,ever recall at t$is time is no longer &ossible beca%se o( t$e limitation &rovi!e! in )ec. CC ;/< o( B.=. Blg 117 ,$ic$ states: )ec. CC. 6$o Ma' Be -ecalle!A Gro%n! (or -ecallA 6$en -ecall Ma' not be Hel!.S ;/< No recall s$all ta+e &lace ,it$in t,o 'ears (rom t$e !ate o( t$e o((icialHs ass%m&tion o( o((ice or one 'ear imme!iatel' &rece!ing a reg%lar local election. 2$e Constit%tion $as man!ate! a s'nc$roniBe! national an! local election &rior to 15 7%ne 188/ or more s&eci(icall' as &rovi!e! (or in #rticle JK*** )ec. C S on t$e secon! Mon!a' o( Ma' 188/. 11 2$%s to $ol! an election on recall a&&ro4imatel' seven ;7< mont$s be(ore t$e reg%lar local election ,ill be violative o( t$e above &rovisions o( t$e a&&licable LGC ;B.=. Blg. 117< Garcia v. COM%L%C Facts: Garcia ,as electe! governor o( t$e &rovince o( Bataan in t$e Ma' 11 188/ elections. *n t$e earl' evening o( 7%l' 1881 some ma'ors viceDma'ors an! members o( t$e )angg%niang Ba'an o( t$e t,elve ;1/< m%nici&alities o( t$e &rovince met at t$e National =o,er Cor&oration com&o%n! in Bagac Bataan. #t abo%t 1/:15 #.M o( t$e (ollo,ing !a' 7%l' / 1881 t$e' &rocee!e! to t$e Bagac to,n &laBa ,$ere t$e' constit%te! t$emselves into a =re&arator' -ecall #ssembl' to initiate t$e recall election o( &etitioner Garcia. 2$e =-# &rom%lgate! -esol%tion 1 (or t$e recall o( t$e inc%mbent &rovincial governor Garcia (or loss o( con(i!ence. =etitioners (ile! ,it$ t$e COM3L3C a &etition to !en' !%e co%rse to sai! -esol%tion on t$e gro%n! t$at t$e =-#C (aile! to com&l' ,it$ t$e "s%bstantive an! &roce!%ral re.%irement" lai! !o,n in )ection 75 o( t$e LGC. 2$e COM3L3C !ismisse! t$e &etition an! sc$e!%le! t$e recall elections (or t$e &osition o( Governor o( Bataan. =etitioners t$en (ile! ,it$ t$e )C a &etition (or certiorari an! &ro$ibition ,it$ ,rit o( &reliminar' in9%nction to ann%l t$e sai! -esol%tion o( t$e res&on!ent COM3L3C. *ss%es: 1. 6ON section 75 o( -.#. 71G5 inso(ar as it allo,s a &re&arator' recall assembl' initiate t$e recall o( local elective o((icials is constit%tional -ecall is a mo!e o( removal o( a &%blic o((icer b' t$e &eo&le be(ore t$e en! o( $is term o( o((ice. 2$e &eo&leHs &rerogative to remove a &%blic o((icer is an inci!ent o( t$eir sovereign &o,er an! in t$e absence o( constit%tional restraint t$e &o,er is im&lie! in all governmental o&erations. )%c$ &o,er $as been $el! to be in!is&ensable (or t$e &ro&er a!ministration o( &%blic a((airs. Not %n!eserve!l' it is (re.%entl' !escribe! as a (%n!amental rig$t o( t$e &eo&le in a re&resentative !emocrac'. =: t$e rig$t to recall !oes not e4ten! merel' to t$e &rerogative o( t$e electorate to recon(irm or ,it$!ra, t$eir con(i!ence on t$e o((icial so%g$t to be recalle! at a s&ecial election. )%c$ &rerogative necessaril' incl%!es t$e sole an! e4cl%sive rig$t to !eci!e on ,$et$er to initiate a recall &rocee!ings or not. 2$ere is not$ing in t$e Constit%tion t$at ,ill remotel' s%ggest t$at t$e &eo&le $ave t$e "sole an! e4cl%sive rig$t to !eci!e on ,$et$er to initiate a recall &rocee!ing." 2$e Constit%tion !i! not &rovi!e (or an' mo!e let alone a single mo!e o( initiating recall elections. Neit$er !i! it &ro$ibit t$e a!o&tion o( m%lti&le mo!es o( initiating recall elections. 2$e man!ate given b' section 1 o( #rticle J o( t$e Constit%tion is (or Congress to "enact a LGC ,$ic$ s$all &rovi!e (or a more res&onsive an! acco%ntable local government str%ct%re t$ro%g$ a s'stem o( !ecentraliBation ,it$ e((ective mec$anisms o( recall initiative an! re(eren!%m . . ." B' t$is constit%tional man!ate Congress ,as clearl' given t$e &o,er to c$oose t$e e((ective mec$anisms o( recall as its !iscernment !ictates. 2$e &o,er given ,as to select ,$ic$ among t$e means an! met$o!s o( initiating recall elections are e((ective to carr' o%t t$e 9%!gment o( t$e electorate. Congress ,as not straig$t9ac+ete! to one &artic%lar mec$anism o( initiating recall elections. 6$at t$e
/CC
/.
/CG
/.
Garcia v. COM%L%C /supra- see p.D41 Paras v. COM%L%C Facts: =aras is t$e inc%mbent =%nong Baranga' o( =%la Cabanat%an Cit' ,$o ,on !%ring t$e last reg%lar baranga' election in 1880. # &etition (or $is recall as =%nong Baranga' ,as (ile! b' t$e registere! voters o( t$e baranga'. #cting on t$e &etition (or recall COM3L3C resolve! to a&&rove t$e &etition sc$e!%le! t$e &etition signing on October 10 188C an! set t$e recall election on November 11 188C. #t least /8.15Y o( t$e registere! voters signe!. 2$e COM3L3C $o,ever !e(erre! t$e recall election in vie, o( &etitioner>s o&&osition. On December G 188C t$e COM3L3C set ane, t$e recall election t$is time on December 1G 188C. 2o
/C7
/C8
/.
/C8
/G5
/G1
/.
/G/
/.
A ormeo v. COM%L%C /supra- see p. 0ED1 (ocrates v. COM%L%C /supra- see p. 05C1 Men ez v. Civil (ervice Commission Facts: On 7%ne 7 1880 t$en #cting -egister o( Dee!s o( W%eBon Cit' Colo'an (ile! an a!ministrative com&laint against Men!eB a
/G1
Mabelle O. Nebres | Local Governments Case Digests =%rs%ant to )ection 17 &aragra&$ ;b< o( =.D. 857 t$e cit'
ma'or as $ea! o( t$e cit' government is em&o,ere! to en(orce 9%!gment ,it$ (inalit' on lesser &enalties li+e s%s&ension (rom ,or+ (or one mont$ an! (or(eit%re o( salar' e.%ivalent to one mont$ against erring em&lo'ees. B' in(erence or im&lication t$e reme!' o( a&&eal ma' be availe! o( onl' in a case ,$ere t$e res&on!ent is (o%n! g%ilt' o( t$e c$arges (ile! against $im. B%t ,$en t$e res&on!ent is e4onerate! o( sai! c$arges as in t$is case t$ere is no occasion (or a&&eal. Macalingcag an Carlos v. Chang &o,er o( t$e )ecretar' o( Finance to iss%e t$e Or!er o( =reventive )%s&ension. M-: C$ang raise! a ne, arg%ment b' invo+ing )ection 8 34ec%tive Or!er No. 18/ entitle! "Constit%ting t$e Metro&olitan Manila #%t$orit' &rovi!ing (or its &o,ers an! (%nctions an! (or ot$er &%r&oses." a&&lication (or a ,rit o( &reliminar' in9%nction grante!. 2C: res&on!ents &ermanentl' !esist (rom en(orcing t$e Or!er o( =reventive )%s&ension. Hence t$is &etition (or revie, on certiorari.)econ! Division o( t$is Co%rt: !enie! t$e &etition (or $aving been (ile! o%t o( time b%t t$e same ,as reinstate! in a resol%tion !ate! #&ril 1C 1881. *n t$e resol%tion !ate! 7%l' 15 1881 t$e )econ! Division o( t$is Co%rt gave !%e co%rse to t$e &etition an! re.%ire! bot$ &arties to (ile t$eir sim%ltaneo%s memoran!a. *ss%e: 1. 6ON t$e )ecretar' o( Finance $as 9%ris!iction to iss%e an Or!er o( =reventive )%s&ension against t$e acting m%nici&al treas%rer o( Ma+ati Metro Manila. =: t$e Or!er o( =reventive )%s&ension became e((ective %&on recei&t t$ereo( b' res&on!ent C$ang an! not %&on t$e !esignation o( an o((icerDinDc$arge to re&lace $imA t$at t$e Or!er o( =reventive )%s&ension !ate! October G 1888 became e((ective be(ore t$e iss%ance o( 34ec%tive Or!er No. 18/ an! t$ere(ore can no longer be en9oine! b' reason o( t$e allege! trans(er o( t$e &o,er to s%s&en! (rom t$e )ecretar' o( Finance to t$e =resi!ent o( t$e -e&%blic o( t$e =$ili&&ines an! t$at t$e &o,er to s%s&en! an! remove m%nici&al o((icials is not an inci!ent o( t$e &o,er to a&&oint. -: a government o((icer is not s%s&en!e! %ntil someone $as ass%me! t$e &ost an! t$e o((icer s%b9ect o( t$e s%s&ension or!er $as cease! &er(orming $is o((icial (%nctionA t$at t$e im&lementation o( t$e .%estione! s%s&ension or!er ,as overta+en b' t$e iss%ance o( 34ec%tive Or!er No. 18/ creating t$e Metro&olitan Manila #%t$orit' an! t$at t$e &o,er to !isci&line is veste! solel' on t$e &erson ,$o $as t$e &o,er to a&&oint. =reventive )%s&ension is governe! b' )ec. 01 o( =.D. 857 or t$e Civil )ervice La, ,$ic$ &rovi!es: )ec. 01. =reventive )%s&ension. S 2$e &ro&er !isci&lining a%t$orit' ma' &reventivel' s%s&en! an' s%bor!inate o((icer or em&lo'ee %n!er $is a%t$orit' &en!ing an investigation i( t$e c$arge against s%c$ o((icer or em&lo'ee involves !is$onest' o&&ression or grave miscon!%ct or neglect in t$e
Facts: On October G 1888 Carlos signe! a (ormal a!ministrative c$arge a&&rove! b' Macalincag (or !is$onest' neglect o( !%t' an! acts &re9%!icial to t$e best interest o( t$e service. *t ,as allege! t$at C$ang !isb%rse! (%n!s inviolation o( t$e Omnib%s 3lection Co!e inc%rre! cas$ over!ra(ts in violation o( )ections 01 an! 00 o( =D 077 an! )ection 0;1< o( =D 100C trans(erre! t$e amo%nt o( =1 877 08/.55 (rom t$e 2reas%rer?Cas$ierHs sa(e to t$e -ealt' 2a4 DivisionHs sa(e t$%s s%b9ecting sai! m%nici&al (%n!s to &ossible lossA an! t$at s$e contin%all' (aile! to remit to t$e B%rea% o( 2reas%r' t$e national collection. 2$e basis o( t$e (ormal c$arge b' &etitioner Carlos ,as t$e &reliminar' eval%ation o( t$e CO# -e&ort !ate! 7an%ar' 18 1888 an! t$e a((i!avitDcom&laints o( Co%ncilor -oberto Brillante !ate! #&ril /7 1888 an! Ma' /1 1888. On t$e same !ate October C 1888 &etitioner Macalincag iss%e! an Or!er o( =reventive )%s&ension against C$ang. #lso on October G 1888 &etitioner Macalincag sent a letter to t$e "Governor Metro Manila Commission S #ttn: t$e O((icerDinDC$arge MMC Finance O((ice " see+ing t$e im&lementation o( t$e Or!er o( =reventive )%s&ension !ate! October G 1888 an! recommen!ing t$at an O((icerDinD C$arge be imme!iatel' !esignate! (rom t$e ran+s o( .%ali(ie! M%nici&al 2reas%rers an! #ssistant M%nici&al 2reas%rers in Metro Manila. B' virt%e o( t$e sai! letter t$e O((icerDinDC$arge MMC Finance O((ice (%rnis$e! res&on!ent C$ang b' or!inar' mail ,it$ a co&' o( t$e Or!er o( =reventive )%s&ension also !ate! October G 1888. On November 15 1888 res&on!ent C$ang (ile! a &etition (or &ro$ibition ,it$ ,rit o( &reliminar' in9%nction be(ore t$e -egional 2rial Co%rt ;-2C< o( Ma+ati against &etitioners Macalincag an! Carlos. 2-O on &reventive s%s&ension grante!. 2C: !enie! C$ang a&&lication (or a ,rit o( &reliminar' in9%nction an! s%staine! t$e
/G0
/.
Facts: Garcia is a -even%e Collector a&&ointe! to t$at &osition b' t$en Cit' Ma'or Manaois. He ,as or!ere! s%s&en!e! b' Cit' 2reas%rer =a9aro (rom 7%ne 1 1885 to Marc$ 1C 188/ an! !irecte! t$e ,it$$ol!ing o( $is salar' beca%se o( t$e Formal C$arge (ile! against $im. =etitioner $as been rating @nsatis(actor' in $is &er(ormance (or several semesters ,$ic$ is t$e reason a UFormalV C$arge ,as (ile! against &etitioner receive! b' $im on 7%ne 1 1885 15:55 a.m. an! as a matter o( &roce!%re i( t$e c$arge is a ma9or o((ense b' civil service la,s $e ,as &reventivel' s%s&en!e! (or ninet' ;85< !a's also !%l' receive! b' Mr. Garcia on 7%ne 0 1885 at /:55 &.m. 2$en an investigation ,as sc$e!%le! an! a s%b&oena ,as iss%e! to Mr. Garcia to a&&ear an! testi(' on #%g%st 1C 1885 !%l' receive! b' $im on #%g%st 1 1885 8:CC. #gain Mr. Garcia !i! not #ns,er an! re(%se! to $onor t$e s%b&oena to s%bmit $imsel( (or investigation. )o $e &rocee!e! ,it$ e4D&arte
/GC
/GG
/.
Facts: Cit' 3ngineer Divinagracia (ile! an a!ministrative case against #tt'. 7avellana an electe! Cit' Co%ncilor o( Bago Cit' Negros Occi!ental (or contin%o%sl' engaging in t$e &ractice o( la, ,it$o%t sec%ring a%t$orit' (or t$at &%r&ose (rom t$e -egional Director De&artment o( Local Government as re.%ire! b' DLG Memoran!%m Circ%lar No. 85D18 in relation to DLG Memoran!%m Circ%lar No. 70DC8 o( t$e same !e&artment. 7avellana also assails t$e constit%tionalit' o( Memoran!%m Circ%lars Nos. 85D18 an! 85D on t$e gro%n! t$at t$e )%&reme Co%rt $as t$e sole an! e4cl%sive a%t$orit' to reg%late t$e &ractice o( la,. *ss%e: 6ON t$e D*LG committe! a grave ab%se o( !iscretion in iss%ing t$e .%estione! DLG Circ%lars Nos. 85D15 an! 85D81 an! in !en'ing &etitionerHs motion to !ismiss t$e a!ministrative c$arge against $im. Com&laints against &%blic o((icers an! em&lo'ees relating or inci!ental to t$e &er(ormance o( t$eir !%ties are necessaril' im&resse! ,it$ &%blic interest (or b' e4&ress constit%tional man!ate a &%blic o((ice is a &%blic tr%st. 2$e com&laint (or illegal !ismissal (ile! b' 7aviero an! Cata&ang against Cit' 3ngineer Divinagracia is in e((ect a com&laint against t$e Cit' Government o( Bago Cit' t$eir real em&lo'er o( ,$ic$ &etitioner 7avellana is a co%ncilman. Hence 9%!gment against Cit' 3ngineer Divinagracia ,o%l! act%all' be a 9%!gment against t$e Cit' Government. B' serving as co%nsel (or t$e com&laining em&lo'ees an! assisting t$em to &rosec%te t$eir claims against Cit' 3ngineer Divinagracia t$e &etitioner violate! Memoran!%m Circ%lar No. 70DC8 ;in relation to )ection 7UbD/V o( -# G711< &ro$ibiting a government o((icial (rom engaging in t$e &rivate &ractice o( $is &ro(ession i( s%c$ &ractice ,o%l! re&resent interests a!verse to t$e government.
/G7
Mabelle O. Nebres | Local Governments Case Digests =etitionerHs contention t$at )ection 85 o( t$e LGC o( 1881
an! DLG Memoran!%m Circ%lar No. 85D81 violate #rticle K*** )ection C o( t$e Constit%tion is com&letel' o(( tangent. Neit$er t$e stat%te nor t$e circ%lar trenc$es %&on t$e )%&reme Co%rtHs &o,er an! a%t$orit' to &rescribe r%les on t$e &ractice o( la,. 2$e LGC an! DLG Memoran!%m Circ%lar No. 85D81 sim&l' &rescribe r%les o( con!%ct (or &%blic o((icials to avoi! con(licts o( interest bet,een t$e !isc$arge o( t$eir &%blic !%ties an! t$e &rivate &ractice o( t$eir &ro(ession in t$ose instances ,$ere t$e la, allo,s it. )ection 85 o( t$e LGC !oes not !iscriminate against la,'ers an! !octors. *t a&&lies to all &rovincial an! m%nici&al o((icials in t$e &ro(essions or engage! in an' occ%&ation. )ection 85 e4&licitl' &rovi!es t$at sangg%nian members "ma' &ractice t$eir &ro(essions engage in an' occ%&ation or teac$ in sc$ools e4&ect !%ring session $o%rs." *( t$ere are some &ro$ibitions t$at a&&l' &artic%larl' to la,'ers it is beca%se o( all t$e &ro(essions t$e &ractice o( la, is more li+el' t$an ot$ers to relate to or a((ect t$e area o( &%blic service. )%&erinten!ent o( *riga Cit' as )c$ools Division )%&erinten!ent ,it$o%t an' s&eci(ic !ivision. 2$%s res&on!ent &er(orme! t$e (%nctions o( )c$ools Division )%&erinten!ent in *riga Cit'. )%bse.%entl' on November 1 1887 )ecretar' Gloria !esignate! res&on!ent as )c$ools Division )%&erinten!ent o( Camarines )%r an! &etitioner as )c$ools Division )%&erinten!ent o( *riga Cit'. *n !ismissing &etitionerHs &rotest t$e Civil )ervice Commission $el! t$at )ection 88 o( t$e LGC o( 1881 contem&lates a sit%ation ,$ere t$e De&artment o( 3!%cation C%lt%re an! )&orts iss%es t$e a&&ointments ,$ereas res&on!entHs a&&ointment ,as ma!e b' no less t$an t$e =resi!ent in t$e e4ercise o( $is a&&ointing &o,er. Moreover t$e !esignation o( res&on!ent as )c$ools Division )%&erinten!ent o( Camarines )%r an! o( &etitioner as )c$ools Division )%&erinten!ent o( *riga Cit' ,ere in t$e nat%re o( reassignments in ,$ic$ case cons%ltation ,it$ t$e local sc$ool boar! ,as %nnecessar'. M-: !enie!. C#: !ismisse!. *ss%es: 1. 6ON )ec 88 o( t$e LGC is a&&licable. Clearl' t$e a(oreD.%ote! &ortion o( )ection 88 o( t$e LGCo( 1881 a&&lies to a&&ointments ma!e b' t$e D3C). 2$is is beca%se at t$e time o( t$e enactment o( t$e LGC sc$ools !ivision s%&erinten!ents ,ere a&&ointe! b' t$e D3C) to s&eci(ic !ivision or location. *n 1880 t$e Career 34ec%tive )ervice Boar! iss%e! Memoran!%m Circ%lar No. /1 )eries o( 1880 &lacing t$e &ositions o( sc$ools !ivision s%&erinten!ent an! assistant sc$ools !ivision s%&erinten!ent ,it$in t$e career e4ec%tive service. Conse.%entl' t$e &o,er to a&&oint &ersons to career e4ec%tive service &ositions ,as trans(erre! (rom t$e D3C) to t$e =resi!ent. 2$e a&&ointment ma' not be s&eci(ic as to location. 2$e &rerogative to !esignate t$e a&&ointees to t$eir &artic%lar stations ,as veste! in t$e D3C) )ecretar' &%rs%ant to t$e e4igencies o( t$e service as &rovi!e! in D3C) Or!er No. 7C )eries o( 188G. *n t$e case at bar t$e a&&ointment iss%e! b' =resi!ent -amos in (avor o( res&on!ent to t$e )c$ools Division )%&erinten!ent &osition on )e&tember 1 188G !i! not s&eci(' $er station. *t ,as )ecretar' Gloria ,$o in a Memoran!%m !ate! November 1 1887 assigne! an! !esignate! res&on!ent to t$e Division o( Camarines )%r an! &etitioner to t$e Division o( *riga Cit'.
Osea v. Mala#a Facts: On November /5 1887 &etitioner (ile! a =rotest Case ,it$ t$e Civil )ervice Commission. )$e averre! t$at s$e ,as a&&ointe! as O((icerDinDC$arge #ssistant )c$ools Division )%&erinten!ent o( Camarines )%r b' t$en )ecretar' -icar!o 2. Gloria o( t$e De&artment o( 3!%cation C%lt%re an! )&orts %&on t$e en!orsement o( t$e =rovincial )c$ool Boar! o( Camarines )%rA t$at !es&ite t$e recommen!ation o( )ecretar' Gloria =resi!ent Fi!el K. -amos a&&ointe! res&on!ent to t$e &osition o( )c$ools Division )%&erinten!ent o( Camarines )%rA t$at res&on!entHs a&&ointment ,as ma!e ,it$o%t &rior cons%ltation ,it$ t$e =rovincial )c$ool Boar! in violation o( )ection 88 o( t$e LGC o( 1881. Hence &etitioner &ra'e! t$at res&on!entHs a&&ointment be recalle! an! set asi!e (or being n%ll an! voi!. On Marc$ 11 1888 t$e Civil )ervice Commission iss%e! -esol%tion No. 885G88 !ismissing &etitionerHs &rotestDcom&laint. 2$e Civil )ervice Commission (o%n! t$at on )e&tember 11 188G =resi!ent -amos a&&ointe! res&on!ent ,$o ,as t$en O((icerDinDC$arge )c$ools Division
/G8
Mabelle O. Nebres | Local Governments Case Digests @n!er t$e circ%mstances t$e !esignation o( res&on!ent as
)c$ools Division )%&erinten!ent o( Camarines )%r ,as not a case o( a&&ointment. Her !esignation &artoo+ o( t$e nat%re o( a reassignment (rom *riga Cit' ,$ere s$e &revio%sl' e4ercise! $er (%nctions as O((icerDinDC$argeD)c$ools Division )%&erinten!ent to Camarines )%r. Clearl' t$ere(ore t$e re.%irement in )ection 88 o( t$e LGC o( 1881 o( &rior cons%ltation ,it$ t$e local sc$ool boar! !oes not a&&l'. *t onl' re(ers to a&&ointments ma!e b' t$e De&artment o( 3!%cation C%lt%re an! )&orts. )%c$ is t$e &lain meaning o( t$e sai! la,. 2$e "&lain meaning r%le" or verba legis in stat%tor' constr%ction is t$%s a&&licable in t$is case. 6$ere t$e ,or!s o( a stat%te are clear &lain an! (ree (rom ambig%it' it m%st be given its literal meaning an! a&&lie! ,it$o%t attem&te! inter&retation. #&&ointment s$o%l! be !isting%is$e! (rom reassignment. #n a&&ointment ma' be !e(ine! as t$e selection b' t$e a%t$orit' veste! ,it$ t$e &o,er o( an in!ivi!%al ,$o is to e4ercise t$e (%nctions o( a given o((ice. 6$en com&lete! %s%all' ,it$ its con(irmation t$e a&&ointment res%lts in sec%rit' o( ten%re (or t$e &erson c$osen %nless $e is re&laceable at &leas%re beca%se o( t$e nat%re o( $is o((ice. On t$e ot$er $an! a reassignment is merel' a movement o( an em&lo'ee (rom one organiBational %nit to anot$er in t$e same !e&artment or agenc' ,$ic$ !oes not involve a re!%ction in ran+ stat%s or salar' an! !oes not re.%ire t$e iss%ance o( an a&&ointment. *n t$e same vein a !esignation connotes merel' t$e im&osition o( a!!itional !%ties on an inc%mbent o((icial. 6ON =etitioner $as a veste! rig$t to t$e &osition o( )c$ools Division )%&erinten!ent o( Camarines )%r in vie, o( $er en!orsement b' t$e =rovincial )c$ool Boar!. Her .%ali(ication to t$e o((ice $o,ever lac+s one essential ingre!ient i.e. $er a&&ointment t$ereto. 6$ile s$e ,as recommen!e! b' )ecretar' Gloria to =resi!ent -amos (or a&&ointment to t$e &osition o( )c$ools Division )%&erinten!ent o( Camarines )%r t$e recommen!ation ,as not acte! %&on b' t$e =resi!ent. =etitionerHs !esignation as O((icerDinDC$arge #ssistant )c$ools Division )%&erinten!ent ,as e4&ressl' ma!e s%b9ect to (%rt$er a!vice (rom t$e De&artment o( 3!%cation C%lt%re an! )&orts.1G 2$%s $er !esignation ,as tem&orar'. *n (act t$ere ,as a nee! to recommen! $er to t$e =resi!ent (or a&&ointment in a &ermanent ca&acit'. *nasm%c$ as s$e occ%&ie! $er &osition onl' tem&oraril' &etitioner can be trans(erre! or reassigne! to ot$er &ositions ,it$o%t violating $er rig$t to sec%rit' o( ten%re. *n!ee! &etitioner $as no veste! rig$t to t$e &osition o( )c$ools Division )%&erinten!ent o( Camarines )%r.
/.
/G8
Facts: 2$e OsmeRa 6ater,or+s )'stem ,as constr%cte! t$ro%g$ a sale o( bon!s as a%t$oriBe! b' t$e =$ili&&ine Legislat%re t$ro%g$ #ct /558. B' stat%te t$e Cit' o( Ceb% came into e4istence as a &olitical bo!' cor&orate on /5 October 181G. 2$e ne,l' create! cit' absorbe! t$e (ormer m%nici&alit' o( Ceb%. #mong t$e general &o,ers grante! to an! !%ties im&ose! %&on t$e legislative bo!' o( t$e Cit' +no,n as t$e M%nici&al Boar! is t$at o( &rovi!ing (or t$e maintenance o( ,ater,or+s (or t$e &%r&ose o( s%&&l'ing ,ater to t$e in$abitants o( t$e cit' an! t$e &%ri(ication o( t$e so%rce o( s%&&l' an! t$e &laces t$ro%g$ ,$ic$ t$e same &asses an! to reg%late t$e cons%m&tion an! %se o( t$e ,aterA to (i4 an! &rovi!e (or t$e collection o( rents t$ere(orA an! to reg%late t$e constr%ction re&air an! %se o( $'!rants &%m&s cisterns an! reservoirs. )ec. 17D4. Common,ealt$ #ct C8<.=%rs%ant to t$e a(oresai! c$arter &rovision t$e M%nici&al Boar! t$e Cit' o( Ceb% $as been r%nning an! o&erating t$e OsmeRa 6ater,or+s )'stem. *ts m%nici&al Boar! &rovi!es (or t$e b%!getar' e4&enses o( t$e )'stem an! governs t$e !is&osition o( t$e )'stemHs reven%e.On 1G November 1808 t$e =%blic )ervice Commission grante! &lainti(( Cit' a certi(icate o( &%blic convenience to o&erate an! maintain t$e OsmeRa 6ater,or+s )'stem s%b9ect to t$e terms an! con!itions im&ose! t$erein. For t$e &%r&ose o( e4&an!ing t$e service to meet t$e ,ater nee!s o( its increase! &o&%lation t$e Cit' o( Ceb% on 11 December 18C5 (ile! ,it$ t$e De&artment o( #gric%lt%re an! Nat%ral -eso%rces an a&&lication (or t$e %se o( ,ater emanating (rom a nat%ral s&ring in a &rivate lan! belonging to t$e late Dr. =io Kalencia sit%ate! in Hag%biao Consolacion Ceb%. 2$e sai! a&&lication ,as in !%e time a&&rove! b' t$e !e&artment $ea!. On 17 7%ne 18CC !e(en!ant #%t$orit' ,as create! as a &%blic cor&oration. ;)ec. 1 -e&%blic #ct No. 1181<. =%rs%ant to its c$arter !e(en!ant s$all o,n an!?or $ave 9%ris!iction s%&ervision an! control over all territor' no, embrace! b' t$e Metro&olitan 6ater District as ,ell as all areas no, serve! b' e4isting governmentD o,ne! ,ater,or+s an! se,erage an! !rainage s'stems ,it$in t$e bo%n!aries o( cities m%nici&alities an! m%nici&al !istricts in t$e =$ili&&ines incl%!ing t$ose serve! b' t$e 6ater,or+s an! 6ells an! Drills )ections o( t$e B%rea% o( =%blic 6or+sH ;)ec. 1<.
/75
/71
Facts: =rior to its incor&oration as a c$artere! cit' t$e M%nici&alit' o( Zamboanga %se! to be t$e &rovincial ca&ital o( t$e t$en Zamboanga =rovince. On October 1/ 181G Common,ealt$ #ct 18 ,as a&&rove! converting t$e M%nici&alit' o( Zamboanga into Zamboanga Cit'. )ec. C5 o( t$e #ct also &rovi!e! t$at b%il!ings an! &ro&erties ,$ic$ t$e &rovince s$all aban!on %&on t$e trans(er o( t$e ca&ital to anot$er &lace ,ill be ac.%ire! an! &ai! (or b' t$e Cit' o( Zamboanga at a &rice to be (i4e! b' t$e #%!itor General. 2$e &ro&erties an! b%il!ings re(erre! to consiste! o( C5 lots an! some b%il!ings constr%cte! t$ereon locate! in t$e Cit' o( Zamboanga an! covere! in!ivi!%all' b' 2orrens certi(icates o( title in t$e name o( Zamboanga =rovince. *n 180C t$e ca&ital o( Zamboanga =rovince ,as trans(erre! to Di&olog. )%bse.%entl' or
/7/
/71
/70
/7C
Mabelle O. Nebres | Local Governments Case Digests Caga'an !e Oro Cit' li+e ot$er local &olitical s%b!ivisions is
em&o,ere! to enact or!inances (or t$e &%r&oses in!icate! in t$e LGC. *t is e4&ressl' veste! ,it$ t$e &olice &o,er %n!er ,$at is +no,n as t$e General 6el(are Cla%se. *n a!!ition )ection 0C8 o( t$e sai! Co!e s&eci(icall' !eclares t$at t$e )angg%niang =anl%ngso! as t$e legislative bo!' o( t$e cit' s$all enact or!inances a&&rove resol%tions an! a&&ro&riate (%n!s (or t$e general ,el(are o( t$e cit' an! its in$abitants. 2$is section also a%t$oriBes t$e LG@s to reg%late &ro&erties an! b%sinesses ,it$in t$eir territorial limits in t$e interest o( t$e general ,el(are. =: t$e )angg%niang =anl%ngso! ma' &ro$ibit t$e o&eration o( casinos beca%se t$e' involve games o( c$ance ,$ic$ are !etrimental to t$e &eo&le. Gambling is not allo,e! b' general la, an! even b' t$e Constit%tion itsel(. 2$e legislative &o,er con(erre! %&on local government %nits ma' be e4ercise! over all +in!s o( gambling an! not onl' over "illegal gambling" as t$e res&on!ents erroneo%sl' arg%e. 3ven i( t$e o&eration o( casinos ma' $ave been &ermitte! %n!er =.D. 18G8 t$e government o( Caga'an !e Oro Cit' $as t$e a%t$orit' to &ro$ibit t$em ,it$in its territor' &%rs%ant to t$e a%t$orit' entr%ste! to it b' t$e LGC. )%c$ inter&retation is consonant ,it$ t$e &olic' o( local a%tonom' as man!ate! in #rticle ** )ection /C an! #rticle J o( t$e Constit%tion as ,ell as vario%s ot$er &rovisions t$erein see+ing to strengt$en t$e c$aracter o( t$e nation. *n giving t$e LG@s t$e &o,er to &revent or s%&&ress gambling an! ot$er social &roblems t$e LGC $as recogniBe! t$e com&etence o( s%c$ comm%nities to !etermine an! a!o&t t$e meas%res best e4&ecte! to &romote t$e general ,el(are o( t$eir in$abitants in line ,it$ t$e &olicies o( t$e )tate. Kali! Or!inance: 1< *t m%st not contravene t$e constit%tion or an' stat%te. /< *t m%st not be %n(air or o&&ressive. 1< *t m%st not be &artial or !iscriminator'. 0< *t m%st not &ro$ibit b%t ma' reg%late tra!e. C< *t m%st be general an! consistent ,it$ &%blic &olic'. G< *t m%st not be %nreasonable. @n!er )ec. 0C8 o( t$e LGC LG@s are a%t$oriBe! to &revent or s%&&ress among ot$ers "gambling an! ot$er &ro$ibite! games o( c$ance." Obvio%sl' t$is &rovision e4cl%!es games o( c$ance ,$ic$ are not &ro$ibite! b%t are in (act &ermitte! b' la,. 2$e &etitioners are less t$an acc%rate in claiming t$at t$e Co!e co%l! $ave e4cl%!e! s%c$ games o( c$ance b%t !i! not. *n (act it !oes. 2$e lang%age o( t$e section is clear an! %nmista+able. @n!er t$e r%le o( noscit%r a sociis a ,or! or &$rase s$o%l! be inter&rete! in relation to or given t$e same meaning o( ,or!s ,it$ ,$ic$ it is associate!. #ccor!ingl' ,e concl%!e t$at since t$e ,or! "gambling" is associate! ,it$ "an! ot$er &ro$ibite! games o( c$ance " t$e ,or! s$o%l! be rea! as re(erring to onl' illegal gambling ,$ic$ li+e t$e ot$er &ro$ibite! games o( c$ance m%st be &revente! or s%&&resse!. 2$e a&&arent (la, in t$e or!inances in .%estion is t$at t$e' contravene =.D. 18G8 an! t$e &%blic &olic' embo!ie! t$erein inso(ar as t$e' &revent =#GCO- (rom e4ercising t$e &o,er con(erre! on it to o&erate a casino in Caga'an !e Oro Cit'. 2$e &etitioners $ave an ingenio%s ans,er to t$is misgiving. 2$e' !en' t$at it is t$e or!inances t$at $ave c$ange! =.D. 18G8 (or an or!inance a!mitte!l' cannot &revail against a stat%te. 2$eir t$eor' is t$at t$e c$ange $as been ma!e b' t$e LGC itsel( ,$ic$ ,as also enacte! b' t$e national la,ma+ing a%t$orit'. *n t$eir vie, t$e !ecree $as been not reall' re&eale! b' t$e Co!e b%t merel' "mo!i(ie! &ro tanto" in t$e sense t$at =#GCO- cannot no, o&erate a casino over t$e ob9ection o( t$e local government %nit concerne!. 2$is mo!i(ication o( =.D. 18G8 b' t$e LGC is &ermissible beca%se one la, can c$ange or re&eal anot$er la,. *t seems to %s t$at t$e &etitioners are &la'ing ,it$ ,or!s. 6$ile insisting t$at t$e !ecree $as onl' been "mo!i(ie! &ro tanto " t$e' are act%all' arg%ing t$at it is alrea!' !ea! re&eale! an! %seless (or all intents an! &%r&oses beca%se t$e Co!e $as s$orn =#GCO- o( all &o,er to centraliBe an! reg%late casinos. )trictl' s&ea+ing its o&erations ma' no, be not onl' &ro$ibite! b' t$e local government %nitA in (act t$e &ro$ibition is not onl' !iscretionar' b%t man!ate! b' )ection 0C8 o( t$e Co!e i( t$e ,or! "s$all" as %se! t$erein is to be given its acce&te! meaning. Local government %nits $ave no, no c$oice b%t to &revent an! s%&&ress gambling ,$ic$ in t$e &etitionersH vie, incl%!es bot$ legal an! illegal gambling. @n!er t$is constr%ction =#GCO- ,ill $ave no more games o( c$ance to reg%late or centraliBe as t$e' m%st all be &ro$ibite! b' t$e local government %nits &%rs%ant to t$e man!ator' !%t' im&ose! %&on t$em b' t$e Co!e. *n t$is sit%ation =#GCO- cannot contin%e to e4ist
/7G
/77
/78
/78
/85
/81
/8/
/81
/80
/8C
/8G
/87
Ganzon v. .a#anan Facts: On #%g%st /C 18CG -osales lo!ge! a veri(ie! com&laint against GanBon (or ta+ing a!vantage o( $is &%blic &osition. On )e&tember 11 18CG t$e 34ec%tive )ecretar' b' a%t$orit' o( t$e =resi!ent !esignate! Ma'anan to con!%ct t$e investigation o( sai! com&laint &%rs%ant to t$e &rovisions o( )ection G0;c< o( t$e -#C granting Ma'anan all t$e &o,ers given to an investigating o((icer b' )ections 71 an! C85 o( t$e same Co!e. On )e&tember 18 18CG res&on!ent serve! a co&' o( t$e com&laint on &etitioner an! set t$e investigation o( t$e c$arges on )e&tember /5 18CG. =etitioner $aving (ile! a motion (or &ost&onement res&on!ent !e(initel' set t$e investigation (or )e&tember /C an! /G 18CG. On )e&tember /0 18CG GanBon instit%te! in t$e CF* an action (or &ro$ibition ,it$ &reliminar' in9%nction .%estioning t$e a%t$orit' o( t$e =resi!ent to or!er $is investigation an! &ra'ing t$at res&on!ent be en9oine! to s%s&en! an! !esist (rom &rocee!ing ,it$ t$e investigation an! t$at &en!ing !ecision o( t$e case on t$e merits a &reliminar' in9%nction be iss%e! against res&on!ent. On )e&tember /G 18CG
/88
/88
/85
/81
/.
/.
/8/
/81
/80
/8C
/8G
/87
Mabelle O. Nebres | Local Governments Case Digests Having in min! t$e (oregoing &rinci&les ,e r%le t$at
Memoran!%m Circ%lar No. 87D181 o( t$e D*LG inso(ar as it a%t$oriBes t$e (iling a =etition (or -evie, o( t$e !ecision o( t$e B3) ,it$ t$e reg%lar co%rts in a &ost &roclamation electoral &rotest is o( !o%bt(%l constit%tionalit'. 6e agree ,it$ bot$ t$e &etitioner an! t$e )olicitor General t$at in a%t$oriBing t$e (iling o( t$e &etition (or revie, o( t$e !ecision o( t$e B3) ,it$ t$e reg%lar co%rts t$e D*LG )ecretar' in e((ect amen!e! an! mo!i(ie! t$e G@*D3L*N3) &rom%lgate! b' t$e National Liga Boar! an! a!o&te! b' t$e L*G# ,$ic$ &rovi!es t$at t$e !ecision o( t$e B3) s$all be s%b9ect to revie, b' t$e National Liga Boar!. 2$e amen!ment o( t$e G@*D3L*N3) is more t$an an e4ercise o( t$e &o,er o( s%&ervision b%t is an e4ercise o( t$e &o,er o( control ,$ic$ t$e =resi!ent !oes not $ave over t$e L*G#. #lt$o%g$ t$e D*LG is given t$e &o,er to &rescribe r%les reg%lations an! ot$er iss%ances t$e #!ministrative Co!e limits its a%t$orit' to merel' "monitoring com&liance" b' local government %nits o( s%c$ iss%ances./7 2o monitor means "to ,atc$ observe or c$ec+" an! is com&atible ,it$ t$e &o,er o( s%&ervision o( t$e D*LG )ecretar' over local governments ,$ic$ is limite! to c$ec+ing ,$et$er t$e local government %nit concerne! or t$e o((icers t$ereo( &er(orm t$eir !%ties as &er stat%tor' enactments. Besi!es an' !o%bt as to t$e &o,er o( t$e D*LG )ecretar' to inter(ere ,it$ local a((airs s$o%l! be resolve! in (avor o( t$e greater a%tonom' o( t$e local government. ,ational Liga ng mga Baranga# v. Pare es Facts: On 11 7%ne 1887 -a'os =%nong Baranga' o( Baranga' C/ District ** Zone C District ** Caloocan Cit' (ile! a &etition (or &ro$ibition an! man!am%s ,it$ &ra'er (or a ,rit o( &reliminar' in9%nction an!?or tem&orar' restraining or!er an! !amages be(ore t$e -2C o( Caloocan alleging t$at Davi! =%nong Baranga' o( Baranga' 77 Zone 7 Caloocan Cit' an! t$en &resi!ent o( t$e Liga C$a&ter o( Caloocan Cit' an! o( t$e Liga ng mga Baranga' National C$a&ter committe! certain irreg%larities in t$e notice ven%e an! con!%ct o( t$e &ro&ose! s'nc$roniBe! Liga ng mga Baranga' elections in 1887. On 11 7%ne 1887 t$e 34ec%tive 7%!ge iss%e! a tem&orar' restraining or!er ;2-O< e((ective (or sevent'Dt,o ;7/< $o%rs en9oining t$e $ol!ing o( t$e general members$i& an! election meeting o( Liga C$a&ter o( Caloocan Cit' on 10 7%ne 187C. Ho,ever t$e 2-O ,as allege!l' not &ro&erl' serve! on $erein &etitioner Davi! an! so t$e election (or t$e o((icers o( t$e LigaD Caloocan ,as $el! as sc$e!%le!. =etitioner Davi! ,as &roclaime! =resi!ent o( t$e LigaDCaloocan an! t$erea(ter too+ $is oat$ an! ass%me! t$e &osition o( e4Do((icio member o( t$e )angg%niang =anl%ngso! o( Caloocan. On 17 7%l' 1887 res&on!ent -a'os (ile! a secon! &etition t$is time (or .%o ,arranto man!am%s an! &ro$ibition ,it$ &ra'er (or a ,rit o( &reliminar' in9%nction an!?or tem&orar' restraining or!er an! !amages against Davi! Nanc' W%im&o =resi!ing O((icer o( t$e )angg%niang =anl%ngso! o( Caloocan Cit' an! )ecretar' Barbers.7 -a'os allege! t$at $e ,as electe! =resi!ent o( t$e Liga Caloocan C$a&ter in t$e elections $el! on 10 7%ne 1887 b' t$e members o( t$e Caloocan C$a&ter &%rs%ant to t$eir -esol%tion?=etition No. 551D87.8 On 18 7%l' 1887 t$e &resi!ing 9%!ge grante! t$e 2-O en9oining t$erein res&on!ents Davi! W%im&o an! )ecretar' Barbers (rom &rocee!ing ,it$ t$e s'nc$roniBe! elections (or t$e =rovincial an! Metro&olitan C$a&ters o( t$e Liga sc$e!%le! on 18 7%l' 1887 b%t onl' (or t$e &%r&ose o( maintaining t$e stat%s .%o an! e((ective (or a &erio! not e4cee!ing sevent'Dt,o ;7/< $o%rs. 3vent%all' on 18 7%l' 1887 at &etitioner Davi!>s instance )&ecial Civil #ction ;)C#< No. CDC1/ &en!ing be(ore Branc$ 1/G ,as consoli!ate! ,it$ )C# No. CDC58 &en!ing be(ore Branc$ 1/0. Be(ore t$e consoli!ation o( t$e cases on /C 7%l' 1887 t$e D*LG t$ro%g$ res&on!ent )ecretar' Barbers (ile! in )C# No. CDC1/ an @rgent Motion invo+ing t$e =resi!ent>s &o,er o( general s%&ervision over all local government %nits an! see+ing t$at t$e D*LG &%rs%ant to its !elegate! &o,er o( general s%&ervision be a&&ointe! as t$e *nterim Careta+er to manage an! a!minister t$e a((airs o( t$e Liga %ntil s%c$ time t$at t$e ne, set o( National Liga O((icers s$all $ave been !%l' electe! an! ass%me! o((ice. *ss%e: 6ON t$e Liga ng mga Baranga' is s%b9ect to D*LG s%&ervision. BitoDOnon v. Fernan!eB: Co%rt r%le! t$at t$e =resi!ent>s &o,er o( t$e general s%&ervision as e4ercise! t$erein b' t$e D*LG )ecretar' as $is alter ego e4ten!s to t$e Liga ng mga Baranga'. Does t$e =resi!ent>s &o,er o( general s%&ervision e4ten! to t$e liga ng mga baranga' ,$ic$ is not a local government
/88
/88
Mabelle O. Nebres | Local Governments Case Digests F%rt$ermore t$e D*LG ass%me! control ,$en it a&&ointe!
res&on!ent -a'os as &resi!ent o( t$e LigaDCaloocan C$a&ter &rior to t$e ne,l' sc$e!%le! general Liga elections alt$o%g$ &etitioner Davi!>s term $a! not 'et e4&ire!. 2$e D*LG s%bstit%te! its c$oice ,$o ,as -a'os over t$e c$oice o( ma9orit' o( t$e &%nong baranga' o( Caloocan ,$o ,as t$e inc%mbent =resi!ent &etitioner Davi!. 2$e latter ,as electe! an! $a! in (act been sitting as an e4Do((icio member o( t$e sangg%niang &anl%ngso! in accor!ance ,it$ t$e Liga Constit%tion an! B'DLa,s. :et t$e D*LG e4ten!e! t$e a&&ointment to res&on!ent -a'os alt$o%g$ it ,as a,are t$at t$e &osition ,as t$e s%b9ect o( a .%o ,arranto &rocee!ing instit%te! b' -a'os $imsel( t$ereb' &reem&ting t$e o%tcome o( t$at case. *t ,as ba! eno%g$ t$at t$e D*LG ass%me! t$e &o,er o( control it ,as ,orse ,$en it ma!e %se o( t$e &o,er ,it$ evi!ent bias an! &artialit'. #s t$e entit' e4ercising s%&ervision over t$e Liga ng mga Baranga' t$e D*LG>s a%t$orit' over t$e Liga is limite! to seeing to it t$at t$e r%les are (ollo,e! b%t it cannot la' !o,n s%c$ r%les itsel( nor !oes it $ave t$e !iscretion to mo!i(' or re&lace t$em. *n t$is &artic%lar case t$e most t$at t$e D*LG co%l! !o ,as revie, t$e acts o( t$e inc%mbent o((icers o( t$e Liga in t$e con!%ct o( t$e elections to !etermine i( t$e' committe! an' violation o( t$e Liga>s Constit%tion an! B'Dla,s an! its im&lementing r%les. *( t$e National Liga Boar! an! its o((icers $a! violate! Liga r%les t$e D*LG s$o%l! $ave or!ere! t$e Liga to con!%ct anot$er election in accor!ance ,it$ t$e Liga>s o,n r%les b%t not in obeisance to D*LGD!ictate! g%i!elines. Neit$er $a! t$e D*LG t$e a%t$orit' to remove t$e inc%mbent o((icers o( t$e Liga an! re&lace t$em even tem&oraril' ,it$ %nelecte! Liga o((icers. Li+e t$e local government %nits t$e Liga ng mga Baranga' is not s%b9ect to control b' t$e C$ie( 34ec%tive or $is alter ego. *n t$e BitoDOnon80 case t$is Co%rt $el! t$at D*LG Memoran!%m Circ%lar No. 87D181 inso(ar as it a%t$oriBe! t$e (iling o( a &etition (or revie, o( t$e !ecision o( t$e Boar! o( 3lection )%&ervisors ;B3)< ,it$ t$e reg%lar co%rts in a &ostD&roclamation electoral &rotest involve! t$e e4ercise o( control as it in e((ect amen!e! t$e g%i!elines alrea!' &rom%lgate! b' t$e Liga. O((icers in control la' !o,n t$e r%les in t$e !oing o( an act. *( t$e' are not (ollo,e! it is !iscretionar' on $is &art to or!er t$e act %n!one or re!one b' $is s%bor!inate or $e ma' even !eci!e to !o it $imsel(. )%&ervision !oes not cover s%c$ a%t$orit'. )%&ervising o((icers merel' see to it t$at t$e r%les are (ollo,e! b%t $e $imsel( !oes not la' !o,n s%c$ r%les nor !oes $e $ave t$e !iscretion to mo!i(' or re&lace t$em. *( t$e r%les are not observe! $e ma' or!er t$e ,or+ !one or reD!one to con(orm (or to t$e &rescribe! r%les. He cannot &rescribe $is o,n manner t$e !oing o( t$e act. 2$e amen!ment o( t$e G@*D3L*N3) is more t$an an e4ercise o( t$e &o,er o( s%&ervision b%t is an e4ercise o( t$e &o,er o( control ,$ic$ t$e =resi!ent !oes not $ave over t$e L*G#. #lt$o%g$ t$e D*LG is given t$e &o,er to &rescribe r%les reg%lations an! ot$er iss%ances t$e #!ministrative Co!e limits its a%t$orit' to merel' "monitoring com&liance b' local government %nits o( s%c$ iss%ances. 2o monitor means to ",atc$ observe or c$ec+" an! is com&atible ,it$ t$e &o,er o( s%&ervision o( t$e D*LG )ecretar' over local governments ,$ic$ is limite! to c$ec+ing ,$et$er t$e local government %nit concerne! or t$e o((icers t$ereo( &er(orm t$eir !%ties as &er stat%tor' enactments. Besi!es an' !o%bt as to t$e &o,er o( t$e D*LG )ecretar' to inter(ere ,it$ local a((airs s$o%l! be resolve! in (avor o( t$e greater a%tonom' o( t$e local government. *n 2a%le 8G t$e Co%rt r%le! t$at t$e )ecretar' o( Local Government $a! no a%t$orit' to &ass %&on t$e vali!it' or reg%larit' o( t$e election o( o((icers o( +ati&%nan ng mga baranga' or baranga' co%ncils. *n t$at case a &rotest ,as lo!ge! be(ore t$e )ecretar' o( Local Government regar!ing several irreg%larities in an! see+ing t$e n%lli(ication o( t$e election o( o((icers o( t$e Fe!eration o( #ssociations o( Baranga' Co%ncils ;F#BC< o( Catan!%anes. 2$en Local Government )ecretar' L%is )antos iss%e! a resol%tion n%lli('ing t$e election o( o((icers an! or!ere! a ne, one to be con!%cte!. 2$e Co%rt r%le!: Constr%ing t$e constit%tional limitation on t$e &o,er o( general s%&ervision o( t$e =resi!ent over local governments 6e $ol! t$at res&on!ent )ecretar' $as no a%t$orit' to &ass %&on t$e vali!it' or reg%larit' o( t$e o((icers o( t$e +ati&%nan. 2o allo, res&on!ent )ecretar' to !o so ,ill give $im more &o,er t$an t$e la, or t$e Constit%tion grants. *t ,ill in e((ect give $im control over local government o((icials (or it ,ill &ermit $im to inter(ere in a &%rel' !emocratic an! nonD&artisan
155
151
15/
151
150
15C
15G
157
158
/.
158
115
(an *iego v. Municipalit# o! ,au3an- Oriental Min oro Facts: 2$e m%nici&alit' o( Na%9an iss%e! -esol%tion 0G a,ar!ing t$e concession o( t$e B%tas -iver an! t$e Na%9an La+e to )an Diego. Contract: C 'ears (rom 7an%ar' 1 1808 to December 11 18C/ lease o( "t$e e4cl%sive &rivilege o( erecting (is$ corrals along t$e B%tas -iver beginning (rom its 9%nction ,it$ t$e )an #g%stin -iver %& to t$e Na%9an La+e itsel( " (or ann%al rental o( =/G 155.55. @&on &etition b' t$e lessee $o,ever t$e sai! co%ncil re!%ce! t$e ann%al rental b' /5Y b' virt%e o( -esol%tion C8 series o( 1808. On )e&tember C 18C5 t$e lessee re.%este! (or a (iveD'ear e4tension o( t$e original lease &erio!. 2$e re.%est ,as (or some time le(t &en!ing be(ore t$e m%nici&al co%ncil b%t on December 1 18C1 a(ter t$e lessee $a! reiterate! $is &etition (or e4tension (or t$e reason t$at t$e t'&$oon "6an!a" ,$ic$ too+ &lace t$at mont$ !estro'e! most o( $is (is$ corrals t$e co%ncil a!o&te! -esol%tion /// series o( 18C1 e4ten!ing t$e lease (or anot$er (ive ;C< 'ears beginning 7an%ar' 1 18C/ ,it$ t$e e4&ress con!ition t$at t$e &lainti(( ,o%l! ,aive t$e &rivilege to see+ (or re!%ction o( t$e amo%nt o( rent ,$ic$ ,as to be base! on t$e original contract. #(ter t$e resol%tion $a! been a&&rove! b' t$e =rovincial Boar! o( Oriental Min!oro t$e lessor an! t$e lessee on December /1 18C1 contracte! (or t$e e4tension o( t$e &erio! o( t$e lease. 2$e contract ,as a&&rove! an! con(irme! on December /8 18C1 b' -esol%tion //8 series o( 18C1 o( t$e m%nici&al co%ncil o( Na%9an ,$ose term ,as t$en abo%t to e4&ire. =%rs%ant to t$e sai! contract t$e lessee (ile! a s%ret' bon! o( =C/ 555.55 an! t$en reconstr%cte! $is (is$ corrals an! stoc+e! t$e Na%9an La+e ,it$ baRg%s (ingerlings.
111
11/
111
110
11C
11G
117
118
118
/.
1/5
Facts: On November 7 187C Bibiano Morta mar+et master o( t$e #g!ao =%blic Mar+et (ile! a re.%isition re.%est ,it$ t$e C$ie( o( =ro&ert' o( t$e Cit' 2reas%rerHs O((ice (or t$e reDem&t'ing o( t$e se&tic tan+ in #g!ao. #n invitation to bi! ,as iss%e! to #%relio Bert%lano Lito Catarsa Feliciano Bascon Fe!erico Bolo an! #ntonio )%Rer 7r. Bascon ,on t$e bi!. On November /G 187C Bascon ,as noti(ie! an! $e signe! t$e &%rc$ase or!er. Ho,ever be(ore s%c$ !ate s&eci(icall' on November // 187C bi!!er Bert%lano ,it$ (o%r ot$er com&anions namel' 7oselito Garcia 6illiam Liagoso #lberto Fernan!o an! 7ose Fa9ar!o 7r. ,ere (o%n! !ea! insi!e t$e se&tic tan+. 2$e bo!ies ,ere remove! b' a (ireman. One bo!' t$at o( 7oselito Garcia ,as ta+en o%t b' $is %ncle Danilo Garcia an! ta+en to t$e -egional Hos&ital b%t $e e4&ire! t$ere. 2$e Cit' 3ngineerHs o((ice investigate! t$e case an! learne! t$at t$e (ive victims entere! t$e se&tic tan+ ,it$o%t
1/1
1//
'orio v. &intanilla Facts: On October /1 18C8 t$e M%nici&al Co%ncil o( Malasi.%i =angasinan &asse! -esol%tion No. 1C8 ,$ereb' "it resolve! to manage t$e 18C8 Malasi.%i to,n (iesta celebration on 7an%ar' /1 // an! /1 18C8." -esol%tion No. 18/ ,as also &asse! creating t$e "18C8 Malasi.%i 2o,n Fiesta 34ec%tive Committee" ,$ic$ in t%rn organiBe! a s%bcommittee on entertainment an! stage ,it$ 7ose Macaraeg as C$airman. 2$e co%ncil a&&ro&riate! t$e amo%nt o( =155.55 (or t$e constr%ction o( / stages one (or t$e "BarB%ela" an! anot$er (or t$e "cancionan". 2$e "BarB%ela" entitle! "Mi!as 34travanganBa" ,as !onate! b' an association o( Malasi.%i em&lo'ees o( t$e Manila -ailroa! Com&an' in Caloocan -iBal. 2$e tro%&e arrive! in t$e evening o( 7an%ar' // (or t$e &er(ormance an! one o( t$e members o( t$e gro%& ,as Kicente Fontanilla. 2$e &rogram starte! at abo%t 15:1C oHcloc+ t$at evening ,it$ some s&eec$es an! man' &ersons ,ent %& t$e stage. 2$e "BarB%ela" t$en began b%t be(ore t$e !ramatic &art o( t$e &la' ,as reac$e! t$e stage colla&se! an! Kicente Fontanilla ,$o ,as at t$e rear o( t$e stage ,as &inne! %n!erneat$. Fontanilla ,as ta+en to t$e )an Carlos General Hos&ital ,$ere $e !ie! in t$e a(ternoon o( t$e (ollo,ing !a'. 2$e $eirs o( Kicente Fontanilla (ile! a com&laint ,it$ t$e Co%rt o( First *nstance o( Manila on )e&tember 11 18C8 to recover !amages. 2C: 34ec%tive Committee a&&ointe! b' t$e m%nici&al co%ncil $a! e4ercise! !%e !iligence an! care li+e a goo! (at$er o( t$e (amil' in selecting a com&etent man to constr%ct a stage strong eno%g$ (or t$e occasion an! t$at i( it colla&se! t$at ,as !%e to (orces be'on! t$e control o( t$e committee on entertainment conse.%entl' t$e !e(en!ants ,ere not liable (or !amages (or t$e !eat$ o( Kicente Fontanilla. 2$e com&laint ,as accor!ingl' !ismisse! in a !ecision !ate! 7%l' 15 18G/. C# reverse!. *ss%e: *s t$e celebration o( a to,n (iesta an %n!erta+ing in t$e e4ercise o( a m%nici&alit'Hs governmental or &%blic (%nction or is it o( a &rivate or &ro&rietar' c$aracterT
1/1
Mabelle O. Nebres | Local Governments Case Digests Hol!ing o( t$e to,n (iesta in 18C8 b' t$e m%nici&alit' o(
Malasi.%i =angasinan ,as an e4ercise o( a &rivate or &ro&rietar' (%nction o( t$e m%nici&alit'. C$a&ter on M%nici&al La, o( t$e -evise! #!ministrative Co!e &rovi!es: )ection //8/. Celebration o( (iesta. # (iesta ma' be $el! in eac$ m%nici&alit' not o(tener t$an once a 'ear %&on a !ate (i4e! b' t$e m%nici&al co%ncil. # (iesta s$all not be $el! %&on an' ot$er !ate t$an t$at la,(%ll' (i4e! t$ere(or e4ce&t ,$en (or ,eig$t' reasons s%c$ as t'&$oons in%n!ations eart$.%a+es e&i!emics or ot$er &%blic calamities t$e (iesta cannot be $el! in t$e !ate (i4e! in ,$ic$ case it ma' be $el! at a later !ate in t$e same 'ear b' resol%tion o( t$e co%ncil." 2$is &rovision sim&l' gives a%t$orit' to t$e m%nici&alit' to accelebrate a 'earl' (iesta b%t it !oes not im&ose %&on it a !%t' to observe one. Hol!ing a (iesta even i( t$e &%r&ose is to commemorate a religio%s or $istorical event o( t$e to,n is in essence an act (or t$e s&ecial bene(it o( t$e comm%nit' an! not (or t$e general ,el(are o( t$e &%blic &er(orme! in &%rs%ance o( a &olic' o( t$e state. 2$e mere (act t$at t$e celebration as claime! ,as not to sec%re &ro(it or gain b%t merel' to &rovi!e entertainment to t$e to,n in$abitants is not a concl%sive test. For instance t$e maintenance o( &ar+s is not a so%rce o( income (or t$e to,n nonet$eless it is &rivate %n!erta+ing as !isting%is$e! (rom t$e maintenance o( &%blic sc$ools 9ails an! t$e li+e ,$ic$ are (or &%blic service. 2$ere can be no $ar! an! (ast r%le (or &%r&oses o( !etermining t$e tr%e nat%re o( an %n!erta+ing or (%nction o( a m%nici&alit'A t$e s%rro%n!ing circ%mstances o( a &artic%lar case are to be consi!ere! an! ,ill be !ecisive. 2$e basic element $o,ever bene(icial to t$e &%blic t$e %n!erta+ing ma' be is t$at it is governmental in essence ot$er,ise t$e (%nction becomes &rivate or &ro&rietar' in c$aracter. 3asil' no governmental or &%blic &olic' o( t$e state is involve! in t$e celebration o( a to,n (iesta. 6ON %n!er t$e !octrine o( res&on!ent s%&erior &etitionerD m%nici&alit' is to be $el! liable (or !amages (or t$e !eat$ o( Kicente Fontanilla i( t$at ,as attrib%table to t$e negligence o( t$e m%nici&alit'Hs o((icers em&lo'ees or agents. :3). "#rt. /17G Civil Co!e: 6$oever b' act or omission ca%ses !amage to anot$er t$ere being (a%lt or negligence is oblige! to &a' (or t$e !amage !one. . . ." "#rt. /185. Civil Co!e: 2$e obligation im&ose! b' article /17G is !eman!able not onl' (or oneHs o,n acts or omission b%t also (or t$ose o( &ersons (or ,$om one is res&onsible . . ." On t$is &oint t$e Co%rt o( #&&eals (o%n! an! $el! t$at t$ere ,as negligence. 2$e trial co%rt gave cre!ence to t$e testimon' o( #ngel Nova!o a ,itness o( t$e !e(en!ants ;no, &etitioners< t$at a member o( t$e "e4travaganBa tro%&e" remove! t,o &rinci&al braces locate! on t$e (ront &ortion o( t$e stage an! %se! t$em to $ang t$e screen or "telon" an! t$at ,$en man' &eo&le ,ent %& t$e stage t$e latter colla&se!. 2$is testimon' ,as not believe! $o,ever b' res&on!ent a&&ellate co%rt an! rig$tl' so. #ccor!ing to sai! !e(en!ants t$ose t,o braces ,ere "mot$er" or "&rinci&al" braces locate! semiD!iagonall' (rom t$e (ront en!s o( t$e stage to t$e (ront &osts o( t$e tic+et boot$ locate! at t$e rear o( t$e stage an! ,ere (astene! ,it$ a bamboo t,ine. 2$at being t$e case it becomes incre!ible t$at an' &erson in $is rig$t min! ,o%l! remove t$ose &rinci&al braces an! leave t$e (ront &ortion o( t$e stage &racticall' %ns%&&orte!. Moreover i( t$at !i! $a&&en t$ere ,as in!ee! negligence as t$ere ,as lac+ o( s%&ervision over t$e %se o( t$e stage to &revent s%c$ an occ%rrence. #t an' rate t$e g%itarist ,$o ,as &ointe! to b' Nova!o as t$e &erson ,$o remove! t$e t,o bamboo braces !enie! $aving !one so. 2$e Co%rt o( #&&eals sai!. "#mor b' $imsel( alone co%l! not $ave remove! t$e t,o braces ,$ic$ m%st be abo%t ten meters long an! (astene! t$em on to& o( t$e stage (or t$e c%rtain. 2$e stage ,as onl' (ive an! a $al( meters ,i!e )%rel' it ,o%l! be im&ractical an! %n,iel!' to %se a ten meter bamboo &ole m%c$ more t,o &oles (or t$e stage c%rtain." 2$e a&&ellate co%rt also (o%n! t$at t$e stage ,as not strong eno%g$ consi!ering t$at onl' =155.55 ,as a&&ro&riate (or t$e constr%ction o( t,o stages an! ,$ile t$e (loor o( t$e "BarB%ela" stage ,as o( ,oo!en &lan+s t$e &osts an! braces %se! ,ere o( bamboo material. 6e li+e,ise observe t$at alt$o%g$ t$e stage ,as !escribe! b' t$e &etitioners as being s%&&orte! b' "/0" &osts nevert$eless t$ere ,ere onl' 0 in (ront 0 at t$e rear an! C on eac$ si!e. 6$ere ,ere t$e restT 2$e Co%rt o( #&&eals t$%s concl%!e!: "2$e co%rt a .%o itsel( attrib%te! t$e colla&se o( t$e stage to t$e great n%mber o(
/.
1/0
/.
1/C
1/G
1/7
1/8
1/8
115
111
11/
111
110
Mabelle O. Nebres | Local Governments Case Digests Having establis$e! t$at t$e com&romise agreement ,as
(inal an! imme!iatel' e4ec%tor' an! in (act as alrea!' en(orce! t$e res&on!ent co%rt ,as in error ,$ere it still entertaine! t$e s%&&lemental com&laint (ile! b' t$e res&on!entDa&&ellee (or b' t$en t$e res&on!ent Co%rt $a! no more 9%ris!iction over t$e s%b9ect matter. 6$en a !ecision $as become (inal an! e4ec%tor' t$e co%rt no longer $as t$e &o,er an! 9%ris!iction to alter amen! or revo+e an! its onl' &o,er t$ereo( is to or!er its e4ec%tion. #(ter t$e &er(ection o( an a&&eal t$e trial co%rt loses 9%ris!iction over its 9%!gment an! cannot vacate t$e same. 63 (in! no error in t$e or!er o( t$e res&on!ent Co%rt !ate! 7%l' /1 18G8. From t$e rea!ing o( t$e &remises an! &rovisions o( t$e contract an! agreement ,$ic$ ,as "(ormall' con(irme! an! o((iciall' a&&rove! b' t$e &arties" in t$e com&romise agreement later entere! into b' t$e same &arties s%b9ect onl' to t$e en%merate! c$anges an!?or mo!i(ications it is obvio%s t$at t$e contracting &arties envisione! a stage b' stage constr%ction ;on t$e &art o( t$e res&on!entDa&&ellee< an! &a'ment ;on t$e &art o( t$e !e(en!antDa&&ellant<. )%bD&aragra&$ B o( &aragra&$ 1 o( t$e Com&romise #greement to ,it: "B. 2$at imme!iatel' %&on (inal a&&roval $ereo( b' t$is Honorable Co%rt t$e &lainti(( contractor ,ill s%bmit an! (ile in (avor o( =asa' Cit' Government a ne, &er(ormance bon! in t$e amo%nt re.%ire! b' &ertinent la, r%les an! reg%lations in &ro&ortion to t$e remaining val%e or cost o( t$e %n(inis$e! ,or+ o( t$e constr%ction as &er a&&rove! &lans an! s&eci(ications . . ." -ea! toget$er ,it$ t$e stageDb'Dstage constr%ction an! &a'ment a&&roac$ ,o%l! inevitabl' lea! to t$e concl%sion t$at t$e &arties to t$e com&romise contem&late! a !ivisible obligation necessitating t$ere(ore a &er(ormance bon! "in &ro&ortion to" t$e %ncom&lete! ,or+. 6$at is cr%cial in s%bD&aragra&$ B o( &aragra&$ 1 o( t$e com&romise agreement are t$e ,or!s "in &ro&ortion." *( t$e &arties reall' inten!e! t$e legal rate o( /5Y &er(ormance bon! to re(er to t$e ,$ole %n(inis$e! ,or+ t$en t$e &rovision s$o%l! $ave re.%ire! t$e &lainti(( contractor to s%bmit an! (ile a ne, &er(ormance bon! to cover t$e remaining val%e?cost o( t$e %n(inis$e! ,or+ o( t$e constr%ction. @sing t$e ,or!s in &ro&ortion t$en signi(icantl' c$ange! t$e meaning o( t$e &aragra&$ to %ltimatel' mean a &er(ormance bon! e.%al to /5Y o( t$e ne4t stage o( ,or+ to be !one. #n! 6e note t$at in t$e Contract an! #greement t$e res&on!entDa&&ellee ,as allo,e! to (ile a &er(ormance bon! o( =/// /C5.55 ,$ic$ is b%t CY o( t$e total bi! o( =0 810 C55.85. # sec%rit' bon! ,as li+e,ise (ile! ,it$ an amo%nt o( =87 /85.55. 2$e s%m total o( bon! t$en (ile! ,as =1/5 C05.55 ,$ic$ is 9%st G.CY o( t$e total bi!. *t is rat$er c%rio%s ,$' all o( a s%!!en t$e &etitionersDa&&ellants are insisting on a /5Y &er(ormance bon! o( t$e entire %n(inis$e! ,or+ ,$en t$e' ,ere .%ite content ,it$ a bon! 9%st CY o( t$e entire ,or+. For @s to allo, t$e &etitionersD a&&ellants to a!amantl' stic+ to t$e /5Y &er(ormance bon! ,o%l! be tantamo%nt to allo,ing t$em to eva!e t$eir obligation in t$e com&romise agreement. 2$is cannot be allo,e!. 2$e bon! o( a contractor (or a &%blic ,or+ s$o%l! not be e4ten!e! be'on! t$e reasonable intent as gat$ere! (rom t$e &%r&ose an! lang%age o( t$e instr%ment constr%e! in connection ,it$ t$e &ro&osals &lans an! s&eci(ications an! contract. 2$e &remi%m o( t$e bon! ,ill be siBeable an! ,ill eat %& t$e &ro(it o( t$e contractor ,$o is (ace! ,it$ t$e (l%ct%ation o( &rices o( materials !%e to in(lation an! !eval%ation. -ig$t no, man' contractors cannot &rocee! ,it$ t$e im&lementation o( t$eir contracts beca%se o( t$e e4traor!inar' rise in cost o( materials an! labor. No contractor ,o%l! be ,illing to bi! (or &%blic ,or+s contracts %n!er t$e o&&ressive inter&retation b' &etitionersD a&&ellants. #gain t$e res&on!ent Co%rt ,as correct in r%ling t$at t$e s%bmission o( t$e bon! ,as not a con!ition &rece!ent to t$e &a'ment o( =G11 58G.55 to t$e &lainti((. No,$ere in t$e Contact an! #greement nor in t$e Com&romise #greement co%l! be (o%n! t$e (act t$at &a'ment b' t$e &etitionerD a&&ellants o( t$e amo%nt o( =G11 58G.55 ,as !e&en!ent %&on t$e s%bmission b' t$e res&on!entDa&&ellee o( t$e &er(ormance bon!. *t cannot be arg%e! t$at reci&rocal obligation ,as create! in t$e Com&romise #greement (or t$e obligation to &a' on t$e &art o( t$e &etitionersD a&&ellants ,as establis$e! several 'ears ago ,$en t$e
11C
11G
117
118