You are on page 1of 40

!"#$%&'()*'!(+$,-'.

'/&0&1&)#$(2'34(*'$)'56(17$0(25
.8#9"1:7;-'6(#1$,<'!,=1&2&77
>"81,&-'!87$,'.)(247$7?'@"2A'B?'C"A'D':E,#A?'FBBG;?'HHA'IIJKILM
68N2$79&*'N4-'Wiley
>#(N2&'O/P-'http://www.jstor.org/stable/853979 .
.,,&77&*-'FLQFFQIGFD'FG-RG
Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at .
http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp

.
JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of
content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms
of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact support@jstor.org.

Wiley is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to Music Analysis.

http://www.jstor.org

!"#$%&'()*&$+,+--(

).#%/+( "01( )"2%&3(


"($+4+$+0#%",( 15"1( %0(!"$-%4",(

#67(89:;<7(:6=:(>;??(@7(:67(9@A7*:(9B(B9*CD(;E(:67(FG7D7E:(D:CHI(;DJ(D:G;*:?I(
E9:(=(89:;<7(=:(=??(=**9GH;EL(:9(D:=EH=GH(CD=L7(9B(:67(:7G8M(%:(
DF7=K;ELJ(
:67(<7E7G=@?7(=EH(*9889E?I(
H97D(E9:(D=:;DBI(
=**7F:7H(H7B;E;:;9E(
L;<7E(@I(
=EH(
H7G;<7H( @I( 6;8( C?:;8=:7?I(BG98(7;L6:77E:6N*7E:CGI(
$;78=EEJ(
:679G;D:D(
DC*6(=D()=::67D9EJ(=**9GH;EL(
:9(>6;*6(=(89:;<7(;D(
*98F9D;:;9E=?(
O=( 87?9H;*( BG=L87E:(
>6;*6(;E( ;:D7?B(*9ED:;:C:7D(:67(D8=??7D:(CE;:(9B(
7PFG7DD;<7(87=E;ELMQ( 09G( ;D( ;:( ;E( :67(-*67EK7G;=E(D7ED7( =( 89:;<;*(
N(=(?;E7=G(F=::7GE(
:6=:(;D(G7F?;*=:7H(
=:(<=G;9CD(D:GC*:CG=?(
?7<7?D(=D(
F=G=??7?;D8(
=(<7G@9GL7E7(
09G(;D(;:(
;E(
=(
,7;:89:;<(
:67(
8
=EE7G(9B(
R;7H7G69?CELM(
R=LE7G;=E(
=EH(
,9G7ES(N(
=(
87?9H;*(
9G(
6=G89E;*(
R9?S9L7E(
F=::7GE(
FG9LG7DD;9E(
=DD9*;=:7H(*9ED;D:7E:?I(
>;:6(=(D;EL?7(DI8@9?(;E(:67(HG=8=M(%:(;D(E9:(7<7E(=(
DC*6(=D(:67(#G;D:=E(
G9?7(9B(>6;*6(
*69GHJ(:67(89:;<;*(
F=G:;*C?=G(
*69GHN:IF7J(
+GED:('CG:6(H789ED:G=:7H(
;E(6;D($98=E:;D*67(
9G(:67(
T=G89E;KJ(
@G;??;=E:?I(
=EH(:67(8ID:;D*67(
D69>E(@I(,9G7ES(:9(F?=I(=(D;8;?=G(
U=?D=8N"KK9GH(
"KK9GH(
G9?7(;E( !=GD;B=?MV(%EH77HJ( :67(89:;<7(CEH7G(*9ED;H7G=:;9E(67G7(;E<9?<7D(
E7;:67G(
=(87?9H;*(*7??J(E9G(=(?;E7=G(*9E:9CGJ(E9G(=(6=G89E;*(FG9LG7DD;9EM(
;:(;D(87G7?I(
:67(CE9GH7G7H(
>6;?7(E9:(
$=:67GJ(
F;:*6N*?=DD(
HI=H(W+J(4XJ(>6;*6J(
@7;EL(H7B;E=@?7(=D( =EI(9B(:67(89G7(B=8;?;=G(:IF7D(9B(89:;<7J(:=K7D(9E(
9B(*G9DDNG7B7G7E*7(
=EH(FG9*7DD;<7(
=DF7*:D(9B(=??(9B(:6783(:67(F9DD;@;?;:;7D(
:67(
H7<7?9F87E:(;E(:67($;78=EE;=E(89:;<7(=EH(:67(D9N*=??7H(,7;:89:;<Y(
6;HH7EJ(DC@?;8;E=?(E=:CG7(9B(:67(-*67EK7G;=E(
89:;<7Y(=EH(:67(6=G89E;*(
=EH(:6CD(:67(@G9=H(6=G89E;*(D:GC*:CG=?(
=8@;LC;:IJ(
B9G*7J(9B(:67(#G;D:=E(
*69GH(=EH(,9G7ESOD(8ID:;D*67(
"KK9GHM(%:(;D(:6CD(R=LE7G;=E(;E(:67(89D:(
=D(=(HG=8=:;*(DI8@9?J(=(
D7ED7J(B9G(;:(*=E(D7G<7(D;8C?:=E79CD?I(
F9>7GBC?(
8CD;*=?(*G9DDNG7B7G7E*7(
=EH( =( B9*CD(9B(6=G89E;*(=EH( ?=GL7ND*=?7(:9E=?(
"D( DC*6J(;:(*9ED:;:C:7D(
=( 89:;<7(9B(:67(89D:(B=GNG7=*6;EL(
9GL=E;S=:;9EM(
HG=8=:;*(=EH( 8CD;*=?( D;LE;B;*=E*7(;E( !=GD;B=?3(;:( 9**CGDJ( 9B:7E(>;:6(
*9ED;H7G=@?7(G67:9G;*=?(
:67(
78F6=D;DJ(;E(*?;8=*:;*(8987E:D(:6G9CL69C:(
HG=8=J(=EH( :6G9CL6(;:(:67(9F7G=(>9GKD(9C:(;:D(FG;E*;F=?(F6;?9D9F6;*=?(
:6787(N(:6=:(9B(D;EJ(DCBB7G;EL(
=EH(G7H78F:;9EM(
)Z-%&( "0",5-%-([3\J(][[^(

This content downloaded from 128.205.114.91 on Sat, 16 Nov 2013 10:40:26 AM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

VV_(

!"#$%&'(

)*&$+,+--(

%( #T+( 1$")"#%&( -#$Z&#Z$+( .4(!"$-%4",(


N( "8B9G:=DJ(
#67( HG=8=:;*(FG9*7DD(>67G7@I(:67(:6G77(*7E:G=?(*6=G=*:7GD(
N(
89<7(BG98(
=
(>9G?H(
D;E(=EH(
:9(9E7(9B(
=
EH(!=GD;B=?(
9
B(
'CEHGI(
DCBB7G;EL(
;
E(
O*98;*O(;E(
E9:(
=EH(
;DJ(;G9E;*=??IJ(
D:GC*:CG7J(
*9E:7E:J(
G7H78F:;9E(
=?:69CL6(
;:D(
G99:D(
?
;7(
;E(
:67(
8
7H;7<=?(
=EH(8;G=*?7(
4
9G(:67(
7F;*(
F?=IM(
=?:69CL6( ?;:7G=GI(
D:GC*:CG7(
;D(:67(FG9LG7DD;9E(
BG98(
=(D;:C=:;9E(
7DD7E*7(9B(=(*98;*(HG=8=:;*(
;E(
>6;*6(:6;ELD(
=G7(E9:(=D(:67I(D69C?H(@7(N(>67G7(G7?=:;9ED6;FD(
=G7(*9EBCD7H(
>;7?H(F9>7G(N( :9(9E7(;E(>6;*6(OG;L6:O(
=EH(>67G7(:67(O>G9ELO(*6=G=*:7GD(
=G7(=*6;7<7H(=EH(:67(
G7?=:;9ED6;FD(
OG;L6:O(*6=G=*:7GD(
L=;E(=D*7EH=E*I(:9(
:
6;D(
D
6;B:(
9<7G(
:
67(
*9CGD7(
9
B(
:
67(
H
G=8=(
9E(:67(9E7(
;
E<9?<7DJ(
Z
DC=??I(
F9>7GM(
9E(:67(F=G:(9B(:67(*7E:G=?(
6=EHJ(=( 8987E:(9G(8987E:D(9B(G7*9LE;:;9E(
9B(>6=:(:67(D;:C=:;9E(
*6=G=*:7G(
6=D(@77E(=EH(>6=:(;:(D69C?H(@7J(=EHJ(9E(:67(
:67(
9:67GJ(=(*98;*(:>;D:(:9>=GHD(:67(7EH(9B(:67(HG=8=(>6;*6(=G:;*C?=:7D(
:CGE(BG98(:67(>G9EL(D:=:7(9B(=BB=;GD(
:9(:67(G;L6:(9E7M( 4CG:67G89G7J(
:67(
=:(:67(7EH(L7E7G=??I(
;E<9?<7D(
:67(G7F?=*787E:(
9B(
*6=EL7(9B(F9>7G(7BB7*:7H(
=E(9?H7G(L7E7G=:;9E(
@I(=(I9CEL7G(
9E7M\(
T9>(:67(=@9<7(89H7?(;D(7PF?=E=:9GI(
B9G(!=GD;B=?(
D69C?H(@7(D7?BN7<;H7E:M(
#67( CE>69?7D987(D;:C=:;9E(=:(:67(@7L;EE;EL(9B(:67(HG=8=(;E<9?<7D(=(
B9G(7=*6(9B(:67(FG;E*;F=?(*6=G=*:7GDM(
"8B9G:=D(
6=DJ(
>G9EL(D:=:7(9B(=BB=;GD(
6;D(=??9>;EL(
6;8D7?B(
:9(@7(D7HC*7H(@I('CEHGIJ(
?9D:(:67(T9?I(-F7=G(
:6G9CL6(
:9('?;ELD9GY(
67(6;8D7?B(
;D(E9>(*CGD7H(>;:6(
:67(CE7EH;EL(
F=;E(9B(6;D(>9CEHJ(
=EH(:67(@G9:67G699H(
9B(:67(2G=;?(6=D(@7*987(*9?H(=EH(?;B7?7DDM(
'CEHGI(;D(
67G(
9>E(D;E(=EH(;D(=(D?=<7(
:9(:67(
H78=EHD(
9B(
@I(
7E:G=FF7H(
'?;ELD9GY(=EH(
D67(;8=L;E7DJ(;E("*:(%%J( :6=:(D67(*=E(@7( H7?;<7G7H(BG98(67G(@9EHD(@I(
D7HC*;EL(!=GD;B=?M(!=GD;B=?(6;8D7?B(G7FG7D7E:D(=( >G9EL(D:=:7(9B(=BB=;GD(
@7*=CD7(67(;D(*=F=@?7(9B(;EB?;*:;EL(
>;:69C:(
:6=:(67(
LG7=:(DCBB7G;EL(
KE9>;EL(
;D(H9;EL(D9J(=EH(@7*=CD7(67(;D(*=F=@?7(9B(D77;EL(DCBB7G;EL(
>;:69C:(
B77?;EL(
#67( >G9ELE7DD(9B(6;D(D;:C=:;9E(;D(78@9H;7H(;E(6;D(
F;:I(B9G(:67(DCBB7G7GM(
=EH(:6CD(E9:(I7:(>;DD7EH(
9G(
);:?7;H(
#9GJ(;E*=F=@?7(9B(B77?;EL(
@7;EL(H7G(G7;E7(
=@?7(:9(G7D:9G7(
?;B7(
:9(:67(:9GF;H(*988CE;:I(
;E(>6;*6(67(B;EHD(
6;8D7?BM(
"EHJ(
9B(*9CGD7J(:67(O>G9ELO(B;LCG7D(
>;7?H(F9>7G(7=G?I(;E(:67(HG=8=3("8B9G:=DOD(
D;E(6=D(G7EH7G7H(
6;8(:67(69?H7G(9B(F9>7G(;E(:67(@G9:67G699H(
9B(:67(2G=;?(
;E(E=87(9E?IJ(=EH(:67(G7=?(F9DD7DD9G(9B(F9>7G(N( 9<7G("8B9G:=DJ(
9<7G(
=D(>7??(N(;D('?;ELD9GM(
'CEHGI(=EH(;E(=(D7ED7(9<7G(:67(2G=;?('E;L6:D(
"*:D(%%(=EH(%%%J(:6G9CL6(
=(DC**7DD;9E(9B(8987E:D(9B(G7*9LE;:;9E(
=EH(9B(
=EH(G7D:9G7(
8=L;*J(D7:(:67(*9E<9?C:7H(D7:(9B(HG=8=:;*(
G7?=:;9ED6;FD(
D:G=;L6:(
67=?:6(:9(:67(@G9:67G699H(9B(:67(2G=;?M(%E("*:(%%( !=GD;B=?(?7=GED(BG98(
:6=:(67(*=CD7H(6;D(9>E(89:67GJ(
=EH(:6;D(G7=?;S=:;9E(
'CEHGI(9B(:67(DCBB7G;EL(
?7=HD( `C;*K?I(:9( 6;D( *7E:G=?(G7<7?=:;9E(;E( :67(7E:;G7(9F7G=M('CEHGIOD(
D7HC*:;<7(>9GHD(*?7<7G?I(
6;D(E7>?I(=>=K7E7H(D7ED7(9B(LC;?:(
@G;EL(:9L7:67G(
6;D(89:67GOD(
=EH(6;D(B;GD:(
9B(D7PC=?(F=DD;9E3(
G7L=GH;EL(
LG;7B(
7PF7G;7E*7(
67C:O(=?D()C::7GD7L7EOD(
?7:S:7E(
2GCDD(
MMM( D;7(@7C:(H;G(
H7G(,;7@7(7GD:7E(
'CDDM(

VVa(

)Z-%&( "0",5-%-([3\J( ][[^(

This content downloaded from 128.205.114.91 on Sat, 16 Nov 2013 10:40:26 AM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

"( $+4+$+0#%",(

15"1(

%0( !"$-%4",(

9B(67GD7?B(
=EH(!=GD;B=?OD(
'CEHGIOD(>9GHD(=EH(67G(K;DD(N(67G(=G:BC?(
87GL;EL(
9B(
=EH(67G(
=
EH(7G9:;*;D8(
N(:G;LL7G(
;E(
89:67GJ(
DCLL7D:;<7(
;E:7G>7=<;EL( LC;?:(
!=GD;B=?(
=(DCHH7E(=EH(D69*K;EL(
<;D;9E(9B("8B9G:=DOD(
=(D6CHH7G(
9B(
>9CEHJ(
9B(
G7<C?D;9E(
=EH(:6CD(6;D(B;GD:(
T
;D(;EE7G(
9B(
6
;D(
9>E(
B77?;EL( F;:IM(
G7*9LE;:;9E(
D;E(=EH(6;D(F;:I(CF9E("8B9G:=D(
=G:;*C?=:7(
:67(:CGE;EL(
F9;E:(9B(:67(HG=8=3(
);:?7;H(
6;D(
67(6=D(@7*987(
=EH(E9>(67(
B;P7D(
>;DD7EHJ(
:6G9CL6(
;ED:;E*:;<7?I(
6;D(7I7(9E(:67(2G=;?(WO+D( D:=GG:(
H7G(U?;*K(HC8FB(
=CB(H=D(T7;?DL7B=;DDOJ(
"*:(%%J(
@D( ]^b^NVXM( T7( DCHH7E?I(G7=?;S7D(:6=:(;:(>=D( 'CEHGIOD(D7HC*:;9E(9B(
"8B9G:=D(
:6=:(?7H(:9(6;D(>9CEH(=EH(?9DD(9B(:67(-F7=GJ(=EH(:6=:(;:(;D(9E?I(
6;D(
9B(:69D7(=H<=E*7D(:6=:(67(*=E(
:6G9CL6( W!=GD;B=?ODX(9>E(G7ECE*;=:;9E(
=*6;7<7(D=?<=:;9E(B9G(6;8D7?BJ(B9G('CEHGI(=EH( B9G("8B9G:=D(=EH( :67(
@G9:67GD(
9B(:67(2G=;?(WD77(:7P:(9B("*:(%%J(@D(]]^^NVc(=EH(]V_cN]\[bXM(T;D(
9B("*:(%%( :9(G7D;D:(
E7>?I(B9CEH(KE9>?7HL7(7E=@?7D(6;8(;E(:67(G78=;EH7G(
'CEHGI(=EH(:9( G7L=;E(:67(-F7=G( BG98('?;ELD9GJ(=EH(;E("*:(%%%( :9(@7(
G7;E7(
#9GJ(:9(@7(@=F:;S7HJ(:9(
G7*9LE;S7H(
@I(2CGE78=ES(=D(:67(?9ELN=>=;:7H(
:67(
@=F:;S7('CEHGI(=EH(:6CD(G789<7(67G(BG98(
'?;ELD9GOD(DF7??J(:9(G7:CGE(
>9CEH(8=L;*=??I(
-F7=G(:9(:67(#78F?7(9B(:67(2G=;?(=EH(67=?("8B9G:=DOD(
>;:6(;:D(:9C*6J(=EH(:9(=DDC87(:67(T9?I(.BB;*7(
6;8D7?BM(
T7(;D(:6CD(:67(=L7E:(
>69(G;L6:D(
=??(:67(>G9ELD(
D7:(CF(=:(:67(@7L;EE;EL(
9B(:67(HG=8=J(>69(*=CD7D(
:67(F9>7G(9B('?;ELD9G(:9(<=E;D6(=EH(>69J(=D(=(G7FG7D7E:=:;<7(
9B(=(I9CEL7G(
=EH(FCG7G(L7E7G=:;9EJ(
=D*7EHD(:9(F9>7G(;E(F?=*7(9B("8B9G:=DJ(
:6CD(7BB7*:;EL(
:67(D6;B:(
BG98(=(>9G?H(9B(D;E(=EH(DCBB7G;EL(
:9(9E7(9B(G7H78F:;9EM(
%:(;D(67(
>69(H7?;<7GD(
:67(@G9:67G699H(
9B(:67(2G=;?(BG98(
:67(?7<7?(9B(7<7GIH=I(
F=;ED(
=EH(F?7=DCG7D(:9(=(89G7(H;<;E7(F?=E7(N( :6=:(*9EH;:;9E(9B(:67(@G9:67G699H(
=F:?I(H7D*G;@7H(@I( &6=G?7D( !=DD=L7( =EH( T7?7E( )M( )CD:=GH(;E( :67(
;E:G9HC*:;9E(
:9(:67;G(+EL?;D6(:G=ED?=:;9E(
9B(R9?BG=8OD(!=GS;<=?(=D( OMMM( =(
H7H;*=:7H(D9*;7:IJ(D7G<;EL(
:67(2G=;?(=EH(G7FG7D7E:;EL(
=( DF67G7(DF;G;:C=??I(
7P=?:7H(=@9<7(:67(E9G8=?(G7=?8(9B(?;B7OMd(
%%( #T+( W+J(4X( 15"1(
#6=:(:67(W+J(4X(HI=H(;D(=(8CD;*=?(87=ED(>67G7@I(
:67(HG=8=:;*(
D:GC*:CG7(
;D(
>9GK7H(9C:(;D(E9>67G7(89G7(B9G*7BC??I(
CEH7GD*9G7H(:6=E(;E(:67(*G;:;*=?(
:CGE;EL(
F9;E:(;E("*:(%%( N( 'CEHGIOD(';DD(=EH(!=GD;B=?OD(=ELC;D67H(*GI(9B(
O"8B9G:=DeO(
7E?;L6:7E87E:J(
WD77(+PM]XM( T7G7(:67(HI=H(@7*987D(:67(8CD;*=?(
F9;E:(9B(B9*CD(:6=:(78@9H;7D(!=GD;B=?OD(HG=8=:;*(G7?=:;9ED6;F(@9:6(:9(
":(:67(8987E:(9B('CEHGIOD(K;DD(W"*:(%%J( @D(
'CEHGI(=EH(:9("8B9G:=DM(
:67(DC**7DD;9E(+fN+(*9E:G9?D(
:67(@=DD(W%( =8(=DDC8;EL(7E6=G89E;*(
[a\BBMXJ(
7`C;<=?7E*7J(9B(*9CGD7X3(+fJ(;E(@D( [a\NbJ(89<7DJ(:6G9CL6(=( *6=EL7(9B(
:9( 7V(;E(@M[acY( :67EJ(;E(@D( [a_Na( :67(DC**7DD;9E(+gN+(9**CGD(
G7L;D:7GJ(
;E(:67(@=DDJ(>;:6(=E(7P:7ED;9E(B;GD:(
:9(1L(=EH(:67E(:9(1( =D(>7??M(
?;:7G=??I(
"B:7G(:67(:6G77(@=GD(9B(:67(-76G(@7?7@7EH(
W@D( [[]N\XJ( !=GD;B=?OD(*GI(9B(
:67(W+J(4X( HI=H(=D(=(87?9H;*J(G=:67G(
G7*9LE;:;9EJ(
O"8B9G:=DeOJ(
=FFG9FG;=:7D(
:6=E(=D(=(@=DDJ(?;E7M(-;8C?:=E79CD?IJ(
:67(9G*67D:G=?(
D9E9G;:I(
=**98F=EI;EL(
)Z-%&(

"0",5-%-(

[3\J( ][[^(

This content downloaded from 128.205.114.91 on Sat, 16 Nov 2013 10:40:26 AM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

VV[(

!"#$%&'(

)*&$+,+--(

+PM(](!=GD;B=?J(
"*:(%%J(@D([aVN[_(
W-;7(6=:(;6GBB=CF:(Gc??;L( ;;@7G(H=D( D7;E;L7( L7E7;L:( CEH(67hO:7?(ECE(;6G7(
,;FF7E( SC( 7;E78(?=EL7E( 'CDD7( =CB( D7;E7E(T)CEHMX(

[aV(

G( N(

:7E( 'CDDe(

?=ELD=8M(
-7?GG(

W6;7G(B;6G?( !=GD;B=?(

M(

*G7D*M(

F?;;:S?;*6(8;:(7;E7G(27@;OGH7(H7D(6i*6D:7E(-*6G7*K7ED(=CB( D7;E7(T=??CEL( HG;?*K?(7;E7(BCG*6(:@=G7(/7G;;EH7GCEL(


D7;E7(TBEH7(L7>=?:D=8(L7L7E( H=D( U7GSJ(>;7(C8(7;E7E(S7GG7;DD7EH7E(-*687GS(SC(;;@7G>=?:;L7EMX(
=CDY7G( D:788:(

-76G(@7?7@7EHM(

NNJ( J(!j(
N*;3(

:A;;(

N(

NN(

_k(

!"$-%4",M(
;( 7:>=D(HGEL7EH(

"( "(

"8NB9G(N( :=De(
-*6E7??M(

6;D(9C:@CGD:(
<7G:;*=?;S7D(
:6=:(D=87(HI=H(>;:6;E(
:67(*9E:7P:(
9B(=(H;8;E;D67HN(
D7<7E:6(
*69GH(9E(+J(>;:6(:67(4( =*:;EL(=D(=E(=FF9LL;=:CG=M(
#6CD(FG7*;D7?I(
:67(D=87(89:;<;*(
=G:;*C?=:7D(
@9:6(:67(F7=K(9B('CEHGIOD(=H<=E*7D(
F;:*6NF=;G(
=EH(!=GD;B=?OD(DCHH7E(G7A7*:;9E(9B(:678(:6G9CL6(
6;D(<;D;9E(9B("8B9G:=DOD(
F=;EM(#67(W+J(4X(HI=H(@7*987D(=(8CD;*=?(DI8@9?(9B('CEHGIOD(;E:7G:>;E;EL(

V\^(

)Z-%&( "0",5-%-([3\J(][[^(

This content downloaded from 128.205.114.91 on Sat, 16 Nov 2013 10:40:26 AM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

"( $+4+$+0#%",(

15"1( %0( !"$-%4",(

;E(=( D;EL?7(
B9G(!=GD;B=?(:67(=L9EI(9B(LC;?:(=EH(:67(F?7=DCG7(9B(D7EDC=?;:I(
78@9H;7D(
=(*7E:G=?(
7
:6;*=?(
#67(
9B(
HI=H(=**9GH;EL?I(
=GLC87E:(
7PF7G;7E*7M(
:67(9F7G=3(:6=:(D7EDC=?(F?7=DCG7(=EH(@9:6(F6ID;*=?(=EH(FDI*69?9L;*=?(
F=;E(
N( :6=:(9E7(E7*7DD=G;?I(
=G7(;E7P:G;*=@?I(
;E:7G:>;E7H(
7E:=;?D(:67(9:67GJ(DC*6(
9B(:67(F?7=DCG7M(
:6=:(G7H78F:;9E(
BG98(:67(F=;E(G7`C;G7D(:67(G7ECE*;=:;9E(
;E(:67(
>
9GHD(9B(
!?=:9J(DF7=K;EL(:6G9CL6( 9*G=:7D(;E(:67(
.GJ(
6=CE:;EL(
7=G?;7G3(
*
7E:CG;7D(
H;=?9LC7(!6=7H9J(
T9>(D;ELC?=G(
;D(:67(:6;EL(
*=??7H(
=EH(69>(*CG;9CD?I(
G7?=:7H(
:9(
F?7=DCG7J(
>
6;*6(
@7(
:9(@7(:67(
B9G(
9B(
=G7(
;:Y(
F=;EJ(
9FF9D;:7(
:67I(
8;L6:( :69CL6:(
E7<7G(
:9(=(8=E(=:(:67(D=87(;ED:=E:Y(
=EH(I7:(67(>69(FCGDC7D(
FG7D7E:(
7;:67G(
;D(L7E7G=??I(
:67;G(
:9(:=K7(:67(9:67GY(
@9H;7D(=G7(:>9J(
*98F7??7H(
@C:(:67I(
=G7(A9;E7H(
@I(=(D;EL?7(
67=HMb(
;D(:67(
)CD;*=??IJ(:67(OD;EL?7(67=HO(:6=:(A9;ED(F?7=DCG7(=EH(F=;E(;E(!=GD;B=?(
W+J(4X(HI=HY(=EHJ(;E(:67(8CD;*=?(?=ELC=L7(9B(:67(9F7G=J(;:(;D(:6;D(HI=H(:6=:(
8CD:(@7(G7D9?<7H(9C:(9B(:67(D:GC*:CG7(
;E(9GH7G(:9(=G:;*C?=:7(
:67(
C?:;8=:7?I(
BG98(
OE9G8=?(?;B7O(:9(:67(OCF?;B:7HOJ(
H7H;*=:7H(D9*;7:I(
9B(:67(2G=;?(
"CB67@CEL(
=:(:67(*9E*?CD;9EM(
U7B9G7(:G=*;EL(BCG:67G(
;ED:=E*7D(9B(:67(HI=H(=EH(;:D(HG=8=:;*(;8F?;N(
*=:;9EDJ(?7:(CD(F=CD7(:9(*9ED;H7G(:>9(D=?;7E:(8CD;*=?(H7:=;?D(;E(:67(F=DD=L7(
H;D*CDD7H( =@9<7M( 4;GD:J(=D( >7( 6=<7( D77EJ( ;E( :67( 9G*67D:G=?(8CD;*(
=**98F=EI;EL(:67(K;DD(:67(E9:7NF=;G(W+J( 4X( ;D(>9GK7H(;E:9(?;E7=G(FG9N(
:67(F;:*67D(=(D78;:9E7(G789<7H(;E(7;:67G(
H;G7*:;9E3(
B9G(
LG7DD;9ED(
;E<9?<;EL(
VBV( ;E(:67(CFF7G(
7P=8F?7J(4N+N19(;E(:67(@=DD(9B(@D([a_NaJ(=EH(
*PVNH9VNN77VN(
<9;*7D(9B(:67(D=87(@=GDM(#67( :7EH7E*I(9B(:67(E9H=?(
W+J( 4X( :9(FG9LG7DD(
;E(7;:67G(H;G7*:;9E(;D(*6=G=*:7G;D:;*(
9B(:67(*6G98=:;*(<9;*7(
*6G98=:;*=??I(
:6=E(E9:J(:67(89:;<7(9**CGD(>;:6(=(
?7=H;EL(9B(:67(7E:;G7(
9F7G=Y(89G7(9B:7E(
*9E:;EC=:;9E(
9B(*6G98=:;*(D:7F>;D7(89:;9E(:9(7;:67G(1g(
W+cX( 9G(4( W&2_XM(
>67E(:67(89:;<7J(
:6CD(7P:7EH7HJ(9**CGD(D;8C?:=E79CD?I(
;E(=(
4CG:67G89G7J(
87?9H;*(<9;*7(=EH(:67(@=DDJ(;:(8=I(L7E7G=:7(=(*6G98=:;*(
<9;*7(7P*6=EL7(
G78;E;D*7E:(
9B(#G;D:=EJ(
=D(D69>E(;E(+PMVM(
+PM(V(&6G98=:;*(
/9;*7(+P*6=EL7D(;E(!=GD;B=?(
=EH(#G;D:=E(
##(

,(
dd(

,(

=(

$7HC*:;9E(9B(!=GD;B=?J( #G;D:=E(
!G7?CH7J(9F7E;EL(@=GD(
"*:(%%J(@D([a_N[^(
W*BM(+PM(]X(

)Z-%&("0",5-%-([3\J( ][[^(

This content downloaded from 128.205.114.91 on Sat, 16 Nov 2013 10:40:26 AM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

V\](

!"#$%&'(

)*&$+,+--(

*69GHJ(=:(:67(
W#67( *69GH(;E(@D([[\Nb(=EH([[_( ;DJ(9B(*9CGD7J(:67(#G;D:=E(
?7<7?(B9G(:67(7=G?;7G(9F7G=MXc(&9E:;EC=:;9E(9B(:6;D(
*9GG7*:(:G=EDF9D;:;9E(
:67(B;E=?(
@=GD(9B(
*6G98=:;*(
<9;*7(7P*6=EL7(;E(9FF9D;:7(H;G7*:;9ED(
89:;<=:7D(
:67(K;DD(=EH(:67(@7L;EE;EL(
:67(F=DD=L7(=**98F=EI;EL(
9B(:67(-76G(@7?7@7EH(
=:(
;
E(
+PM(\M(
=D(D69>E(
@M[[]J(
+PM(\($7HC*:;9E(9B(!=GD;B=?J(
"*:(%%J(@D([a_N[](W*BM(+PM(]X(

J( [N(
N87(
El4(

NMMM(

M(

#67(89:;<;*(HI=HJ(:67EJ(D7G<7D(67G7(E9:(9E?I(=D(=(F9>7GBC??I(
=G:;*C?=:7H(
@C:(=?D9(
G7B7G7E:;=?(
=D(
=(
D9CG*7(9B(8CD;*=?(
89:;<7J(
H7<7?9F87E:(=EH(
*9E:;EC;:IM(
8CD;*=?(
-7*9EHJ( :67(8CD;*(9B(:6;D(F=DD=L7( *98@;E7D(;:D(>G7E*6;EL(
:6787D(9B(F=;E(=EH(DCBB7G;EL(
=:(F;:*6(?7<7?D(:6=:(@G;EL(9C:(:67(W+J(4X( HI=H(
;E(89G7(DC@:?7(>=IDM(#67(:>9NE9:7(
87?9H;*(L7D:CG7(
WH7D;LE=:7H(
@I(,9G7ES(
=D(H7G(=CBD:G7@7EH7(
;E(@M[aaJ(
;
E:9(
:67(
-76G(
@
7?7@7EH(
?7=H;EL(
-7CBS7GX_(
W7gVNBgV(
N(
;E(@M[a[(
;E(
=EH(
;D(
=
(
BG98(
#G;D:=E(
!NLcO( @M[[^X( DCG7?I( `C9:=:;9E(
B`BV(
9B(@M[a[e(%:(@G;ELD(W;E(@D([aaN[X( :67(
7DF7*;=??I(L;<7E(:67(;E;:;=?(6=G89EI(
;E:9(G7?;7B(
87?9H;*(7gVhB(
;:(;E;:;=??I(
=L=;ED:(:67(+( 9B(:67(@=DDM(4CG:67G89G7J(
9**CGD(;E(:67(G;L6:(
=EH(W=:(?7=D:(;E(@M[aaX( >;:6(:67(G;L6:(
*6G98=:;*(
G7L;D:7G(
*6G98=:;*(=D*7E:J(=D( ;E(:67(7=G?;7G(9F7G=M(
DF7??;EL(:9( DCLL7D:(=( BCG:67G(
9B(:6;D(:>9NE9:7(
:7??D(CD(:6=:(
T9>7<7GJ(=:(@D([[^N](:67(*9E:;EC=:;9E(
L7D:CG7(
>7(=G7(;E(!=GD;B=?J(
E9:(#G;D:=EJ(
;:(:9(=(?9>7G(G7L;D:7G(
@I(:G=EDB7GG;EL(
W:67(
;E(>6;*6(!=GD;B=?(
>;??(D;EL(O"8B9G:=DeO(
B;<7(@=GD(?=:7GXJ(G7DF7??;EL(
;:(
G7L;D:7G(
:9(89<7(H9>E(G=:67G(
:6=E(CFJ(=EHJ(=:(:67(-76G(@7?7@7EHJ(
;E(:67(
@G;EL;EL(
-*687GS7EDB;LCG(
WBN@fN*ONH@OX(;E(DC*6(=( >=I(=D( :9( 78F6=D;S7(:67(ACP:=N(
F9D;:;9E(9B(B(9E(:67(H9>E@7=:(9B(@M[[](=EH(7O(9E(:67(H9>E@7=:(9B(@M[[V(
#67( @=DD(67G7(FG9LG7DD7D(
B;GD:(
BG98(2(
WD77(7EL?;D6(69GE(=EH(:GC8F7:DXM(
H9>E(:9(&gJ(
4(=EH(+( 9E(:67(B;GD:(
:>9(DIE*9F=:7H(
;E:G9HC*;EL(
D78;`C=<7GD(
@7=:(9B(@M[[]XJ(:67E(;E<7G:D(
;:D7?B(
:9(:G=<7GD7(
:67(D=87(F=:6J(:6;D(:;87(
W:6;GH(
:6G9CL6(+( =EH(+g(:9(G7=*6(:67(4g(9B(@M[[\M( W09:;*7(69>(:6;D(@=DD(?;E7(
:67(@=DD(9B(@D([a]N[^3(W2cXN+gN+N+KN1N1@(
9E(:67(9E7(6=EHJ(&gN(
G7*98F9D7D(
9E(:67(9:67GMX(-;8;?=G?IJ(
;E(@M[[VJ(:67(T7;?=EHDK?=L7(
;D(D7:(=:(=(
?7<7?(
DC*6(:6=:(
;:D(O=?:9O(?;E7(
:G=EDF9D;:;9E(
W7EL?;D6(69GEJ(T9GE(VX( F=DD7D(
1N+N+gN4M(
B( =EH(7O(;E(:67(8;HH?7(9B(:67(@=G(=EH(;:D(OD9FG=E9O(?;E7(W9@97DJ(
:6G9CL6(
9E(:67(87?9H;*(B( =:(:67(D=87(:;87(:6=:(:67(@=DD(
T9GE(]J(<;9?;EDX(=GG;<7D(
H7D*7EHD(:9(+( 9E(:67(H9>E@7=:(9B(@M[[dJ( =EH(DC*6(:6=:(;:D(B;E=?(BN7O(
H7D*7E:(;E(B=*:(
@7*987D(!=GD;B=?OD(
*GI(O"8B9G:=DeO(
#67( CD7( 9B(:67(W+J( 4X( HI=H(=D( =( E9H7(=G9CEH(>6;*6(:67(HG=8=:;*(
*=E(D67H(?;L6:(
9E(:67(G7BG=*:9GI(
8CD;*=?(
F9;E:(9B(:67(9F7G=(G7<9?<7D(
:CGE;EL(

V\V(

][[^(
)Z-%&("0",5-%-([3\J(

This content downloaded from 128.205.114.91 on Sat, 16 Nov 2013 10:40:26 AM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

"($+4+$+0#%",(

15"1( %0( !"$-%4",(

>;:6(G7DF7*:(
:9(;:D(7P:G=9GH;E=GI(
=D(=(>69?7J(F=G:;*C?=G?I(
?=ELC=L7(9B(!=GD;B=?(
9B(*6G98=:;*(
#67(
7E:;G7(F=DD=L7(
=
EH(H;=:9E;*(
;E:7G>7=<;EL(
FG9*7HCG7DM(
:
67(
;E(:67(
=G9CEH(
:
>9(
G
7<9?<7D(
7P=8F?7D(
F;:*6(*?=DD7D(+(
`C9:7H(
FG7*7H;EL(
=(:9E=?(*7E:G7J(
=EH(4M(#67D7(:>9(F;:*6(*?=DD7D(H9(E9:(;E(=EI(>=I(7D:=@?;D6(
=
D(=(89:;<;*(
B9*CD(
=D(G7B7G7E:;=?(
>6;*6(
D
7G<7(
@9:6(
@C:(;ED:7=H(BCE*:;9E(
F9?7D(
;E(=(
B9G(?9*=?(FG9LG7DD;9ED(
9B(8CD;*=?(9G;7E:=:;9E(
=EH(=D(F9;E:D(9B(H7F=G:CG7(
*6G98=:;*(
*9E:7P:M(57:J(;E(9:67G(F=DD=L7D(;E(:67(9F7G=J(=D(>7(D6=??(D77(;E(
=(
=EH(B9*=?(F;:*67D(*=E(9**CG(>;:6;E(
=@CEH=E*7J(:67(D=87(:>9(G7B7G7E:;=?(
G=:67G(
:
6=E(
>
;:6(
G7B7G7E:;=?(
*6G98=:;*J(D;:C=:;9EJ(
7`C=?(
FCG7?I(H;=:9E;*J(
B9G*7M(#6CDJ( :67(:>9(F;:*6(*?=DD7D(:678D7?<7DJ(
C::7G?I(
;EH7F7EH7E:(9B(
9B(=(
87?9H;*(9G(G6I:68;*(
=DDC87(:67(D:=:CD(
B7=:CG7DJ(
?=GL7ND*=?7(*G9DDN(
G7B7G7E:;=?(
89:;<7(=EH(=G7(=@?7(:9(D7G<7(=D(=(?;EK(@7:>77E(:67(*6G98=:;*(
F=DD=L7D(;E(:67(9F7G=(=EH(:67(89G7(H;=:9E;*(9E7DM(
.E7( H;=:9E;*(F=DD=L7( ;E( >6;*6(:67( HG=8=:;*(=EH( 8CD;*=?( *G9DDN(
G7B7G7E:;=?(
;D(:67(
87=E;EL(9B(:67(W+J( 4X( 89:;<7(;D(G7?=:;<7?I(
:G=EDF=G7E:(
8CD;*(;E(1( 8;E9G(:6=:(;D(;E:G9HC*7H(
9B("8B9G:=D(
=:(:67(7E:GI(
=EH(6;D(:G=;E(
;E("*:(%(W+PM(dXM(
7=G?I(
+PM(d(!=GD;B=?J(
"*:(%J(@D(VcVN_^(
VcV(

$=D:M(
G7D:e(

0=*6(
)I(

%(

)N(

>;?(

E;L6:(

BB(

N(

H7G(

9B(

-*687G(

F=;E(

%(

S7EDN( E=*6:(

6=D( B?7HJm(

ECE(

m(

8I(

H9?*;DD;89(

>;?(

H7G(
G(
-%68(

M(S7E(

9(

E=M( NQ(

%(

J(

)Z-%&( "0",5-%-([3\J( ][[^(

This content downloaded from 128.205.114.91 on Sat, 16 Nov 2013 10:40:26 AM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

ECE(

V\\(

!"#$%&'(

)*&$+,+--(

#67( @=DD( 87?9HI(67G7(;D( CD7H( :6G9CL69C:(:67( 9F7G=( :9( DI8@9?;S7(


>7(*=E(G7=?;S7(:67(D;LE;B;*=E*7(
9B(:67(4(
"8B9G:=DOD(
=EH(=?:69CL6(
DCBB7G;ELY(
=EH(+( ;E(:67(87?9HI(W=EH(;E(:67(8;HH?7(<9;*7(9B(:67(=**98F=EI;EL(
*69GHD(
=D( >7??X( 9E?I(;E( G7:G9DF7*:J(=B:7G(>7( CEH7GD:=EH(69>( :67I(BCE*:;9E(
;E(:67(G7D:(9B(:67(9F7G=J(:67G7(;D(7<7E(67G7(=( D?;L6:(
G67:9G;*=?(
89:;<;*=??I(
:678(B9G(9CG(=::7E:;9EM(
#67(F=DD=L7(;:D7?B(
78F6=D;D(9E(4(=EH(+( :6=:(8=GKD(
;E(=(>=I(:6=:(67;L6:7ED(
;D(;E:G9HC*7H(
9CG(=>=G7E7DD(=EH(67?FD(:9(;8FG7DD(
;:(
;:(;DJ(9B(*9CGD7J(=(E7>(:CE7(=EH(=(E7>(9G*67D:G=:;9EJ(
CF9E(9CG(8789GI3(
=EH(;:(*987D(=B:7G(
=?89D:(:>9(@=GD(9B(D;?7E*7(;E(=(D?9>(:78F9Y(=EH(:67(:=C:J(
6=G89E;*=??I(=8@;LC9CD(;E;:;=?(*69GHJ(:67( =CL87E:7H(:G;=H("N&DN4J(
:67(6=G89E;*(:7EH7E*I(9B(:67(/_(9B(4( ;E(@MVc]( =EH(:CGED(:67(
DC@<7G:D(
:9(1( 8;E9GM(#67(4(F?=ID(=(*GC*;=?(G9?7(67G7J(@7*=CD7(;:(
8CD;*(8987E:=G;?I(
:9(:67(;E;:;=?(:G;=H(;:D(
:9(+J( ;8F=G:D(
;D(:67(F;:*6(>6;*6J(=D(=E(=FF9LL;=:CG=(
D:G=;E7HJ(=CL87E:7H(`C=?;:IM(%E( =HH;:;9EJ(4( =EH( +( *98FG;D7(=( D;EL?7J(
D:GC*:CG7(
*GC*;=?(<9;*7(;E(:67(<9;*7N?7=H;EL(
W+PM(bXM(
"*:(%J(@D(VcVN_^(
+PM(b($7HC*:;9E(9B(!=GD;B=?J(

h(
"(

4!(Q( :V(

]%(

09>(D;8F?I(
:9(7P:G=*:(
:67(:>9(F;:*6(*?=DD7D(4(=EH(+( BG98(
:67(7P=8F?7(=EH(
*?=;8(D987(DF7*;=?(87=E;EL(B9G(:678(8=I(D778(FG7D*G;F:;<7(
;EH77HJ(=EH(
;
E(
;E(
B=*:(
D
778(
:9(
:67(
9
B(
B
=*7(
=
??(
*
=E9ED(
9B(
8
CD;*(
8=I(
B?I(
=**7F:7H(
=E=?ID;DM(
57:(;:(;D(FG7*;D7?I(
DC*6(=(87=E;EL(:6=:(%(=8(=::G;@C:;EL(
:9(:67(HI=HM(#67(
G7=D9E(B9G(H9;EL(D9(;DJ(:9(@7(DCG7J(E9:(@=D7H(D9?7?I(9E(:67(BCE*:;9E(
9B(:67(
:>9(E9:7D(;E(:67(FG7D7E:(*9E:7P:Y(;B(9E?I(:67(@=GD(9B(+PM( d( =G7(CEH7G(
:67G7(;D(E9(89G7(@=D;D(B9G(*699D;EL(4(=EH(+( =D(F=G:;*C?=G?I(
*9ED;H7G=:;9EJ(
:6=E(B9G(*699D;ELJ(D=IJ("(=EH(UJ(>6;*6(=?D9(*98FG;D7(=( D;EL?7(
D;LE;B;*=E:(
D:G=EH(9B(:67(<9;*7(?7=H;ELM($=:67GJ(:67(=GLC87E:(
G7D:D(CF9E(:67(HI=HOD(
*C8C?=:;<7(*G9DDNG7B7G7E:;=?(
B9G*7J(>6;*6(;D( =*6;7<7H(LG=HC=??I(@I( ;:D(
=DD9*;=:;9E(>;:6(*G;:;*=?(
:67(HG=8=J(=EH(>6;*6(;D(;E(@C:(=(
F9;E:D(:6G9CL69C:(
L7G8;E=?(D:=:7(67G7M(%( F9;E:(9C:(:67(FG7D7E:(;ED:=E*7(@7*=CD7(:67(HI=H(
9**CGD(;E(*9EACE*:;9E(
>;:6(:67(B;GD:(
=EH(>;:6(6;D(
=FF7=G=E*7(9B("8B9G:=D(
B;GD:(
87E:;9E(9B(6;D(F=;EJ(=EH(@7*=CD7(*7G:=;E(D;8F?7(6=G89E;*(G7?=:;9ED(
;E(+PM(d(N( ;E(F=G:;*C?=G(
:67("N&FN4(=CL87E:7H(:G;=HJ(>;:6(:67(
9**CGG;EL(
;8F?;7H(G7D9?C:;9E(@I(D78;:9E7(<9;*7(?7=H;ELJ(4N+J( :9(=( 8=A9G(:G;=H(W=(
G7D9?C:;9E(
E9:(?;:7G=??I(
=*6;7<7H(67G7X(N(G7D9E=:7D(
:67(HG=8=(D9(
:6G9CL69C:(
=D(:9(7D:=@?;D6(
=(*?7=G(E7:>9GK(
9B(?;EKD(
@7:>77E(:67(89:;<;*(
HI=HJ("8B9G:=DJ(
6;D(>9CEHJ(6;D(D7HC*:;9E(@I('CEHGIJ(6;D(?9DD(9B(:67(-F7=GJ(6;D(67=?;EL(
!=GD;B=?OD(G7:CGE(
9B(:67(-F7=G(=EHJ(9E(=E(7<7E(H77F7G(?7<7?J(:67(
:6G9CL6(

V\d(

][[^(

)Z-%&( "0",5-%-([3\J(

This content downloaded from 128.205.114.91 on Sat, 16 Nov 2013 10:40:26 AM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

"( $+4+$+0#%",(

15"1(

%0( !"$-%4",(

>7(*=EE9:(KE9>(;:(E9>J(
9B(&6G;D:(9E(:67(*G9DDM(%EH77HJ(=?:69CL6(
DCBB7G;EL(
=EH(
9B("(
:67(F=DD=L7(`C9:7H(;E(+PM(d(D7:D(CF(:67(F;:*67D(
+(
4J(;E(:67(*9E:7P:(
=
D(
:67(:9E=?(<76;*?7(
B9G(
:67(
=EH("(
8=A9G(
=CL87E:7H(:G;=HDJ(
67=?;EL(9B(
E7=G(:67(7EH(9B("*:(%%%M(
"8B9G:=D(
"( *GC*;=?(*9EE7*:;9E(67G7(;D( :6=:(@7:>77E("8B9G:=DOD(>9CEHJ(6;D(
D7HC*:;9E(@I('CEHGI(=EH(:67(G7?=:;9E(9B(@9:6(9B(:67(=@9<7(:9(!=GD;B=?M(
:9()=:6;?H7(R7D7EH9EK(;E(]abaNc^J(>67E(67(>G9:7(
4G98(R=LE7GOD(?7::7GD(
DK7:*6(
:67(7P:=E:(HG=B:D(
9B(:67(:7P:(>7(
:67(B;GD:(
9
B(!=GD;B=?J(
=EH(BG98(
FG9D7(
;
E(
BG98(
=E(
?;@G7::9(
R9?BG=8(
KE9>(:6=:(6;D(*7E:G=?(
FG9@?78D( B9GL;EL( 9F7G=(
9
E(:67(
9E7(
69>(:9(H7=?(>;:6(
<9E(+D*67E@=*6OD(G=8@?;EL(
>7G7J(
6=EHJ(
7F;*(
:67(7F;*OD(B9*CD(9E(!=GD;B=?OD(
`C7D:;9E(>67E(67(B;GD:(
D;8F?I(
=DK;EL(:67(G;L6:(
"8B9G:=D(W=(
7E:7GD(:67(#78F?7( 9B(:67(2G=;?(=EH( D77D( :67( DCBB7G;EL(
:6=:(D7787H(HG=8=:;*=??I(
89:;<=:;9E(
>7=K(:9(R=LE7GX(=EHJ(9E(:67(9:67GJ(
;E(:67(F?9:(:6=:(>7G7(@9:67GD987(
69>(:9(:;L6:7E(
CF(EC87G9CD(
;E*9ELGC;:;7D(
9B(6;D(*7E:CGIJ(
:9(=(HG=8=:;D:(
>69D7(<=?C7DJ(?;K7(:69D7(9B(89D:(=G:;D:D(
>7G7(
*9EH;:;9E7H(
=(H;D*CDD;9E(9B(:67D7(
@I(;H7=D(9B(9GL=E;*(*967G7E*7Ma(
"?:69CL6(
HG=8=:;*(FG9@?78D(>9C?H(?7=H(CD(B=G(=B;7?HJ(;:(;D(E7<7G:67?7DD(
;E:7G7D:;EL(
G7?7<=E:(
:9(9CG(H;D*CDD;9E(67G7(:9(KE9>(]X(:6=:(R=LE7G(H7=?:(>;:6(:67(B;GD:(
9B(:67(:>9(FG9@?78D(@I(8=K;EL(!=GD;B=?OD(G7*?=;8;EL(
=EH(G7:CGE;EL(
9B(:67(
:6=E(6;D(87G7?I(
9B(
-F7=GJ(G=:67G(
=DK;EL(=(`C7D:;9EJ(:67(*7E:G=?(89:;<=:;9E(
:67(HG=8=Y(VX( :6=:(67(=*6;7<7H(=E(=D:9E;D6;EL(
*967G7E*7(;E(:67(>9GK(@I(
:67(-F7=G(:6=:(=FF7=GD(;E(:67(HG=8=(D;8C?:=E79CD?I(
:67(-F7=G(:6=:(
8=K;EL(
>9CEH7H(&6G;D:(9E(:67(*G9DDJ(:67(-F7=G(:6=:(>9CEH7H("8B9G:=D(
=:(:67(
6=EHD(9B('?;ELD9G(=EH(:67(-F7=G(:6=:(!=GD;B=?(
G7*?=;8D(=EH(G7:CGED(
:9(:67(
@G9:67G699H(
9B(:67(2G=;?Y(=EH(\X(:6=:(67(7?;8;E=:7H(
8=EI(?99D7(7EHD(;E(:67(
9C:(9B(=(EC8@7G(9B(>987E(;E(6;D(D9CG*7D(=(E7>(>98=EJ(
F?9:(@I(*G7=:;EL(
'CEHGIJ(>698(67(B=D6;9E7H(=D(:67(D;EL?7(>98=E(>69(D7HC*7D("8B9G:=D(
=EH( :78F:D(!=GD;B=?J(:67G7@I(7BB7*:;EL(
=( ?;:7G=?(*9GG7DF9EH7E*7(
@7:>77E(
"8B9G:=DOD(
=EH(!=GD;B=?OD(
;E('?;ELD9GOD(G7=?8DJ(=EH(7D:=@?;D6;EL(
7PF7G;7E*7D(
;E(9E7(*6=G=*:7G(
=(87H;=:G7DD(
@7:>77E(:67(:>9(FG;8=GI(
8=?7(B;LCG7D(
;E(:67(
D;E(=EH(DCBB7G;ELJ(
=EH(!=GD;B=?OD(?7=GE;EL(
:9(
9F7G=(N( @7:>77E("8B9G:=DOD(
6;D(:78F:G7DD(
=EH(G7L=;E(:67(
7PF7G;7E*7(
F;:I(=EH(:6CD(@7;EL(=@?7(:9(G7D;D:(
-F7=GM(
"(*7E:G=?(
:67D;D(9B(:67(FG7D7E:(7DD=I(N( =(:67D;D(:6=:(;DJ(D9(B=G(=D(%(KE9>J(
BG98(
CEFG9<=@?7(
7P;D:;EL(H9*C87E:=GI(7<;H7E*7J(@C:(:6=:(;D( D:G9EL?I(
8CD;*(
DCFF9G:7H(@I(
=E=?ID;D(N( ;D(:6=:(:67(W+J(4X( HI=H(;D(=(8CD;*=?(G=8;N(
B;*=:;9E(
9B(:67(HG=8=:;*(O:;L6:7E;EL(
CFO(DC88=G;S7H(
=@9<7J(B9G(;:(;D(>9GK7H(
;E:9(=??(:67(B9*=?(D*7E7D(;E<9?<;EL(
"8B9G:=DOD(
9B(
>9CEHJ(:67(:78F:=:;9E(
=
EH(:67(?9DD(=EH(G7:CGE(
9
B(:67(
#9(
D77(69>(:67(8CD;*=?(
!=GD;B=?J(
-F7=GM(
8=E;B7D:=:;9ED(
9B(:67D7(HG=8=:;*(
;DDC7D(>9GKJ(
?7:(CD(?99K(B;GD:(
=:(:67(F=DD=L7(
;E("*:(%(>67G7(>7(?7=GE(9B("8B9G:=DOD(
D7HC*:;9E(=EH(6;D(?9DD(9B(:67(-F7=G3(
@D(bV^BBM(;E(2CGE78=ESOD(0=GG=:;<7M[(#67( F=DD=L7(;E(>6;*6(2CGE78=ES(
H7D*G;@7D("8B9G:=DOD(
D7HC*:;9E(;D(;E(B=*:(=(<=G;=E:(N( 9GJ(;B(>7(FG7B7GJ(
=(
N( 9B(:67(';DDJ(=?G7=HI(H;D*CDD7HJ(;E("*:(%%M(#67(6=G89E;*(
B9G7D6=H9>;EL(
=EH(87?9H;*(8=:7G;=?(
=G7(=?89D:(7P=*:?I(
:67(D=87(=D(;E("*:(%%J(
FG9LG7DD;9E(
)Z-%&(

"0",5-%-(

[3\J( ][[^(

This content downloaded from 128.205.114.91 on Sat, 16 Nov 2013 10:40:26 AM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

V\b(

!"#$%&'(

)*&$+,+--(

@D([a\N[^J(>;:6(:67(7P*7F:;9E(:6=:(;E("*:(%( :67(6=G89E;*(*9E:7P:(89G7(
:67(;;( ;H(
D:G9EL?I(
DCLL7D:D("(8;E9G(W7*697D(9B(#G;D:=E(
=L=;EeXJ(:6G9CL6(
@MbV^( =EH( :67(7P:7EH7H(H98;E=E:(9B(@D( bVVNdM( #67( F=DD=L7( *?7=G?I(
7D:=@?;D67D(
=E(=DD9*;=:;<7(
G7D9E=E*7(@7:>77E("8B9G:=DOD(
:67(K7I(
D7HC*:;9EJ(
9B("( WE9>(8;E9G(G=:67G(
:6=E(8=A9GX(=EH(:67(W+J(4X( HI=H(WD77(@=DD(9B(@D(
bV]N_XM(%E(:67(@=GD(:6=:(B9??9>(WbVaN\aXJ(:67(HI=H(;D(H77F?I(78@7HH7H(;E(
:67( @;S=GG7J(<;G:C=??I(=:9E=?( 8CD;*( =**98F=EI;EL(:67( H7D*G;F:;9E(9B(
"8B9G:=DOD(
?9DD(9B(:67(-F7=G(WD77(6=G89E;*(
G7HC*:;9E(
;E(+PM(cXM(
c(T=G89E;*($7HC*:;9E(9B(!=GD;B=?J(
]+PM(
"*:(%J(@D(bVaN\a(
bVa(

bV[(

3](
R;?(

b\^N](

b\V(

]J!(

b\\(

b\d(

____(

'N(

b\b(

H(

b\c(

__(

b\_(

b\a(

_:N(

%E(B=*:J(
=D(D69>E(;E(:67(7P=8F?7J(4(=EH(+(D778(A9;E:?I(
:9(B9G8(
=(?9E7(F9;E:(
9B(G7B7G7E*7J(
=E(=E*69G(=G9CEH(>6;*6(:67(89:;<;*=??I(
H7ED7(@C:(:9E=??I(
CEB9*CD7H(8CD;*(G7<9?<7DM(,=:7( ;E(:67(D=87( F=DD=L7J("( @7*987D(:67(
H98;E=E:(9B(1J( =( K7I(>6;*6(;D( DCLL7D:7H(;E(@D( b\cNa( =:(:67(7EH(9B(
9B('?;ELD9GOD(:=K;EL(
9B(:67(-F7=GJ(=EH(>6;*6(>;??(
2CGE78=ESOD(H7D*G;F:;9E(
L=;E( *?9D7G( =DD9*;=:;9E(>;:6( :67( -F7=G( =D( :67( 9F7G=( FG9LG7DD7DMO^(
=(B7>(@=GD(?=:7GJ(>67E(2CGE78=ES(*9E*?CH7D(:6;D(D7*:;9E(9B(
4CG:67G89G7J(
:67(E=GG=:;<7(
"8B9G:=DOD(
>9CEH(B9G(:67(B;GD:(
:;87(W@D(bd^NVXJ(
@I(H7D*G;@;EL(
:67(HI=H(W+J( 4X( ;E(:67(;EE7G(<9;*7D(=G:;*C?=:7D(
:67(*GC*;=?(>9GHD(O7;E7(
RCEH7OM( "D(;E("*:(%J( @D( VcdBBMJ(;:(;D(G67:9G;*=?(
78F6=D;D(N( :67(8CD;*(
:67(>9GHD(O7;E7(RCEH7O(;D(8=GK7H(DB9GS=EH9J(
=:(:67(*?;8=P(
=**98F=EI;EL(
9B( =( *G7D*7EH9J(=EH( :67(>9GHD(=G7( 78F6=D;S7H(>;:6(:67(;EH;*=:;9E(
N(=D(>7??(=D(9CG(KE9>?7HL7(
OSCG:;*K6=?:7EHO(
9B(:67(D;LE;B;*=E*7(
9B(:67(>9CEH(
;E(:67(D:9GIJ(
:6=:(@G;ELD(
:67D7(F=G:;*C?=G(
>9GHD(=EH(8CD;*(;E:9(G7?;7BM(
.E( =( H77F7G(DI8@9?;*(?7<7?J(:67(W+J( 4X( 89:;<7(@7*987DJ(=@9<7(=EH(
@7I9EH(;:D(=DD9*;=:;9E(>;:6("8B9G:=DJ(=( 8CD;*=?(BC?*GC8(*9EE7*:;EL(
"8B9G:=DOD(
:9(:6=:(9B(&6G;D:M(#67( G7?=:;9ED6;F(
;D(6;L6?;L6:7H(
;E(
DCBB7G;EL(
:6=:(F=G:(9B(2CGE78=ESOD(E=GG=:;<7(
>6;*6(H7D*G;@7D(
:67(FG7D7G<=:;9E(
9B(:67(
2G=;?(=EH(:67(-F7=G(=EH(:67;G(
:9(#;:CG7?(W"*:(%J(@D(b[VBBMXM(
@7;EL(7E:GCD:7H(
T7G7(:67(*9EB?C7E*7(9B(:7P:C=?(=EH(8CD;*=?(DI8@9?D(G7<7G@7G=:7D(
>;:6(
*G9DDNG7B7G7E:;=?(
87=E;ELM(":(@Mb[]J( 9E(:67(>9GH(O-*6=?7O( W<7DD7?XJ(:67(
2G=;?(89:;<7(@7L;ED(;E(+( =EH(FG9LG7DD7DJ(
=D(>7(>9C?H(7PF7*:(BG98(;:D(
:
9(=E("(
:G;=H(
9
E(:67(H9>E@7=:(9B(@Mb[VM(.E(
FG7<;9CD(=FF7=G=E*7DJ(
8=A9G(
:67(:6;GH(
@7=:(9B(:67(?=::7G(
:67(
=:(
@=GJ(69>7<7GJ( 89:;<7(;D(=?:7G7HJ(
FG7*;D7?I(
:67(=GG;<=?(
9B(:67(>9GH(O'G7CSO(;E(:67(:7P:M(#67( 7PF7*:7H(4g(
9B(:67(2G=;?(
89:;<7(
;D(*6=EL7H(:9(=E(4fJ(:6CD(@G;EL;EL(
:67(W+J(4X( 89:;<7(*?7=G?I(
;E:9(9CG(
=::7E:;9E(
;E(:67(89D:(FG98;E7E:(
9G*67D:G=?(
<9;*7D(;E(@D(b[V(=EH(b[\J(:67(

V\c(

][[^(

)Z-%&( "0",5-%-([3\J(

This content downloaded from 128.205.114.91 on Sat, 16 Nov 2013 10:40:26 AM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

"( $+4+$+0#%",(

15"1(

%0( !"$-%4",(

?=::7G(
9B(>6;*6(;DJ(8CD;*=??I(
=E(78F6=:;*(
9B(:67(B9G87GM(
DF7=K;ELJ(
G7F7:;:;9E(
#67(6=G89EI(
9B(:67D7(@=GD(ACP:=F9D7D(=E("(8=A9G(:G;=H(>;:6(:67(*69GH(2N(
>;:6(:67(G7F7:;:;<7(
87?9H;*(B;LCG7(
9E(+( =EH(4J(:67(
UN&gN4Y(=EH(:9L7:67G(
@=GD(*98FG;D7(:67(299H( 4G;H=I(89:;<7(:6=:(>;??(@7(D9(*GC*;=?(:9("*:(%%%MQ(
"?D9(D;LE;B;*=E:(
67G7(;D(:67(B=*:(:6=:(>6=:(>7(G7=??I(
6=<7(;E(@9:6(@D(b[V(=EH(
b[\( ;D( F=G=??7?(89:;9E(;E(:67(CFF7G(<9;*7D( WD77( 7DF7*;=??I(:67(<;9?;EDX(
@7:>77E(=E("(8=A9G(:G;=H(=EH(=(Un(
8;E9G(:G;=HJ(
>;:6(:67(:6;GH(
9B(:67(?=::7G(
=
D(
G=:67G(
:6=E(
1f(W+PM(_XM]V(
DF7??7H( &f(
+PM(_(!=G=??7?(B;B:6D(
;E("*:(%J(@D(b[VN\(

N(
"(N(
?;(
,,(
E(
Bjj3#f(
0,J(
/NX(

%E(@D(b[d(=EH(b[c(:67(G7?=:;9E(9B(&6G;D:OD(F=DD;9E(:9("8B9G:=DOD(
=L9EI(;D(
8=H7(8CD;*=??I(
:
67(
7E:G=E*7(
9B(
:
67(
7PF?;*;:(
@I( DB9GS=EH9(
"N&fN4(=CL87E:7H(
>6;*6(7D:=@?;D67D(
:67(F=G=??7?(@7:>77E(&6G;D:OD(>9CEH(=EH(:67(-F7=G(
:G;=HJ(
:6=:(*=CD7H(;:(WOH=SC( H7E(,=ES7EDF77GOJ(@D(b[bNcXJ(9E(:67(9E7(6=EHJ(=EH(
"8B9G:=DOD(
>9CEH(=EH(:67(D=87(-F7=GJ(9E(:67(9:67GM(09>(:67(>G7E*6;EL(
>6;*6(
:6G9@@7H(87?9H;*=??I(
@D(b[VNdJ(@7*987D(=(F;7G*N(
W+J(4XJ(
:6G9CL69C:(
6=G89E;*(
>7(67=G(:67("N&(
H;DD9E=E*7Y(
N4( =CL87E:7H(:G;=H(=EH(;:D(
;EL(
G7D9?C:;9E(
:9(
=E("(
:
G;=H(
E7*7DD=GI(
8=A9G(
D;8C?:=E79CD?IM(
#>9(BCG:67G(
67G7M(4;GD:J(
:67(
=DF7*:D(9B(:6;D(E=GG=:;<7(
F=DD=L7(=G7(G7?7<=E:(
@=DD(?;E7(FG9LG7DD7D(
;E(=(?;E7=G(H7D*7E:(BG98(
=(;E(@Mb[V(:9(L(=EH(B(W@D(b[dN(
_X( =EH(B(@(W@Mb[_XJ(@7B9G7(
"J(=E(9*:=<7(?9>7G(:6=E(:67(=(9B(@Mb[VJ(
G7=*6;EL(
;E(@Mb[[M(T9>7<7GJ(;E(@Mb[a(:67G7(;D(=(DCHH7E(?7=F(BG98(
( 9B(@Mb[_(:9(
:67(B@(
@=DD(89:;9E(;D(
":J(:67(L?9@=?(K7I(9B(:67(7E:;G7(
9F7G=J(D9(:6=:(:67(?9ELNG=EL7(
E9:(=NLNBNB@W7XN"J(
@C:(G=:67G(
JN"N"M(#67(D:G=EL7(
:CGE(
9B(:67(@=DD(=EH(
=NLNBNB(
9B(:67(6=G89EI(
;E(@Mb[a(;D(=E(7P=8F?7(9B(>6=:(1=<;H(,7>;E(6=D(*=??7H(
:67(O8=L;*=?O(H;DF?=*787E:(9B(=( 6=G89EI(@I(=( D78;:9E7N(
ODC@D:;:C:;9EOJ(
G7?=:7H(6=G89EIJ(
;E(!=GD;B=?MO\(
"?:69CL6(%(6=<7(E9:(I7:(=8=DD7H(DCBB;*;7E:(
7<;H7E*7(:9(D69>(69>(,7>;EOD(;H7=D(=G7(G7?7<=E:(
:9(:67(=GLC87E:(
=E=?I:;*=?(
9B(:67(FG7D7E:(
G7B7G7E*7(
:9(:67(K7I(9B(
7DD=IJ(%(E9:7(;E(F=DD;EL(:6=:(:67(@G;7B(
:67(>69?7(9F7G=(?7EHD(>7;L6:(:9(:67(*9E:7E:;9E(
:6=:(>7(=G7(H7=?;EL(67G7(
>;:6(=(B9*=?(F=DD=L7(@9:6(:7P:C=??I(
=EH(8CD;*=??IJ(
=EH(:6=:(:67(G7?=:;9ED6;F(
9B(9CG(D78;:9E=?(HI=H(:9(,7>;EOD(D78;:9E=?(6=G89E;*(H;DF?=*787E:D(
>;??(
@7=G(89G7(;E<7D:;L=:;9E(
?=:7GM(
-7*9EHJ(:67(@=GD(:6=:(B9??9>(:67(@G;7B(:CGE(:9("JJ(9E(:67(>9GHD(OH7G(
9B(>6=:(
o7CL7EL;;:7G(
6G*6D:7D(RCEH7GLC:O(W@D(b[[Nc^\XJ(@G;EL(=(G7:CGE(
>6;*6(B;GD:(
,9G7ESJ(B9??9>;EL(
R9?S9L7EJ(*=??D(:67(+EL7?89:;<JOd(
=FF7=GD(;E(
@D(b_bBBMJ(
=D(2CGE78=ES(
H7D*G;@7D(
:67(H7D*7E:(9B(67=<7E?I(
=EL7?D(:9(=;H(:67(
2G=;?(@G9:67G699H(
:9(:678(:67(D=<;EL(*CF(=EH(:67(-F7=GM(":(
@I(7E:GCD:;EL(
@D( b[[BBMJ(9E?I(:67(D7*9EH(9**CGG7E*7(9B(:67(FG9LG7DD;9E(
;E(:67(9F7G=J(
N(
6=G89E;*(
9E7(:6=:(
;
E<9?<7D(
@9:6(:67(
R=LE7G(8=K7D(=(*G;:;*=?(
=HACD:87E:(
@C:(E9>(;E(=(*9E:7P:(
W+J(4X(HI=H(=EH(,7>;EOD(;H7=(9B(DC@D:;:C:;9EJ(
G7?7<=E:(
)Z-%&("0",5-%-(
[3\J(][[^(

This content downloaded from 128.205.114.91 on Sat, 16 Nov 2013 10:40:26 AM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

V\_(

!"#$%&'(

)*&$+,+--(

:9(9CG(FG7D7E:(
H;D*CDD;9EM(":(@Mb[[(:67(+EL7?89:;<(
FG9LG7DD;9E(
@7L;ED(>;:6(
:67("(8=A9G(:G;=HJ(>6;*6(6=D(D*=G*7?I(
@77E(=@D7E:(BG98(
=(D;EL?7(@=G(D;E*7(
@Mb[]M(T=H( R=LE7G(:G=EDF9D7H(:67(FG9LG7DD;9E(
BG98(
@D(b_bBBM(?;:7G=??I(
;E(
@D(b[[BBMJ(
>7(>9C?H(=GG;<7(
"(8=A9G(:G;=H(=:(@Mc^VM(T9>7<7GJ(9E(
=:(=E9:67G(
:67(:6;GH(@7=:(9B(@Mc^]J( :67(87?9H;*(E9:7(:6=:(>9C?H(6=<7J(CEH7G(7P=*:(
@77E(=E( 7V(;D( *6=EL7H(:9( BVJ(=EH(:67(6=G89EI(=HACD:7H(
:G=EDF9D;:;9EJ(
D9(:6=:(
=:(@Mc^V(>7(G7=*6(E9:(:67(7EH(9B(:67(FG9LG7DD;9E(
9E(=E(
=**9GH;EL?IJ(
"( 8=A9G(:G;=HJ(@C:( =E( 7?;H7H( @7L;EE;EL(
9B(=( G7F7:;:;9E(9B(:67(D=87(
9E(=(Un(8=A9G(:G;=HM(R6=:(:6;D(:G=EDB9G8=:;9E(
B9G:6(
;DJ(
FG9LG7DD;9E(
@G;ELD(
9E(:67(8CD;*=?(D;H7J(E9:(9E?I(:67(H;G7*:(ACP:=F9D;:;9E(
9B(7V(=EH(B!(=D(:67(
B;B:6D(
9B(:67(8=A9G(:G;=HD(9E("(=EH(UnJ(
@C:(=?D9(=(G7*=??(9B(:67(
G7DF7*:;<7(
:G;=HD(;E(:67(299H( 4G;H=I(
ACP:=F9D;:;9E(9B(:67("( 8=A9G(=EH(Un(8;E9G(
9B(@D(b[VNdY(=EH(9E(:67(HG=8=:;*(D;H7J(:67(;E7D*=F=@?7(*9EN(
FG9LG7DD;9E(
E7*:;9E(@7:>77E(D;E( =EH( DCBB7G;EL(
9E( :67(9E7( 6=EHJ( =EH( ?9<7( =EH(
9E(:67(9:67GM(T7G7(:67(G7FG7D7E:=:;<7(
9B(?9<7(=EH(G7H78F:;9E(
G7H78F:;9E(
?=:7G(;:(>;??(@7(!=GD;B=?J(
&6G;D:M(
#6=:(:67(299H(
;DJ(9B(*9CGD7J(&6G;D:Y(
:6G9CL6(
4G;H=I(FG9LG7DD;9E(ACP:=F9D7D("( 8=A9G(=EH(Un(8;E9G(:G;=HDY(:6=:(OH7G(
o7CL7EL:;:7G(
RCEH7GLC:O(
ACP:=F9D7D("(8=A9G(=EH(Un(
8=A9G(:G;=HDY(
6c*6D:7D(
:6=:(DC*6(ACP:=F9D;:;9ED(
;E(=( D;EL?7(<9;*7(:67(W+J(
;E7<;:=@?I(
@G;EL(:9L7:67G(
;E(*9EACE*:;9E(
>;:6(:67(;E9:;<;*(
4X( HI=HY(:6=:(:67("(8=A9G(:G;=HJ(7DF7*;=??I(
"8B9G:=DOD(
=EH(N(:9(*G9>E(
HI=HJ(6=D(@77E(*?9D7?I(=DD9*;=:7H(>;:6(
DCBB7G;ELY(
:67(>69?7(8CD;*=?(*98F?7P(N(:6=:(:67(Un(
:67(K7I(;E(
8=A9G(:G;=H(=G:;*C?=:7D(
>6;*6(!=GD;B=?(
D99E(>;??(7E:7G(W@M_dVX( =EH(>;:6(>6;*6(67(>;??(@7(=DD9*;=:7H(
;E("*:D(%(=EH(%%%3( =??(:67D7(G7?=:;9ED(
D:G9EL?I(
F9;E:(:9(:67(HI=H(=D(=(D;EL?7(
E9H7(=G9CEH(>6;*6(:67(HG=8=:;*(;DDC7D(9B(D;E(=EH( DCBB7G;ELJ(
?9<7(=EH(
G7<9?<7M(%:(;D(=?89D:(=D(:69CL6(R=LE7G(6=D(:=K7E(-9*G=:7D(=(
G7H78F:;9EJ(
:6=:(E9:(D;8F?I(F6ID;*=?(F=;E(=EH(F?7=DCG7J(@C:(=?D9J(=:(:67(
D:7F(BCG:67G3(
7:6;*=?(*9G7(9B(6;D(
HG=8=J(D;E(=EH( G7H78F:;9E(=G7(:678D7?<7D(
H77F7D:(
=
(
67=HOM(
OA9;E7H(@I( D;EL?7(
#67(=DD7G:;9E(
:6=:(:67(F=DD=L7(=:("*:(%J(@D(b[]Nc^a(;D(=(B9*=?(F9;E:(;E(
:67(HG=8=:;*(
=EH(8CD;*=?(D:GC*:CG7(
;D(G7;EB9G*7H(
9B(:6;D(
@I(=(<=G;7H(G7:CGE(
8CD;*(:9(=G:;*C?=:7(
:67(7EH(9B(2CGE78=ESOD(E=GG=:;<7(
=:("*:(%J(@D(_]^NV_M(
#67(HG=8=:;*(;DDC7(67G7(;D(:67(*9EH;:;9E(;E(>6;*6("8B9G:=D(
>=D(?7B:(=B:7G(
6;D(7PF?9;:DJ(
=EH(;E(>6;*6(67(9@<;9CD?I(
G78=;ED(
E9>3(
/9G(H78(<7G>=;DO:7E(
T7;?;L:6C8(
;E(@G;;ED:OL78(
U7:7E(
?=L("8B9G:=DJ(
7;E($7::CELDS7;*67E(
@=EL(7GB?767EH3(
ECE(H7C:?;*6(
SC(;68(
7;E(67;?;L(
#G=C8L7D;*6:(
DFG;*6:(
HCG*6(
67??(7GD*6=C:7G(
R9G:7S7;*67E(
)=?73(
O1CG*6(
);:?7;H(
H7G(G7;E7(
>;DD7EHJ(
#69GJ(

6=GG7(D7;EOJ(H7E(;*6(7GK9GMO(

2CGE78=ESOD(*?9D;EL(>9GHD(;E(:67(E=GG=:;<7J(
>6;*6(6=D(=F:?I(DC88=G;S7H(
:67(7<7E:D(?7=H;EL(CF( :9(:67(FG7D7E:(HG=8=:;*(D;:C=:;9EJ(:6CD(H9<7:=;?(
V\a(

)Z-%&(

"0",5-%-(

This content downloaded from 128.205.114.91 on Sat, 16 Nov 2013 10:40:26 AM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

[3\J( ][[^(

"($+4+$+0#%",(

15"1( %0( !"$-%4",(

;E:9(:67(B;GD:(
9B(:67(#69G7EDFGC*6J(
:67(9G=*C?=G(
D899:6?I(
*98F?7:7(D:=:787E:(
9B(!=GD;B=?(
G7BG=;E(
:6=:(67G7(FG7F=G7D(:67(;88;E7E:(
=EH(:6=:(
=FF7=G=E*7(
"*:(
%(D7G<7D(
=D(=(H78=G*=:9G(
9B(
:
67(
D:GC*:CG=?(
H;<;D;9EDMQ(
:6G9CL69C:(
?=GL7D:(
#67(F=DD=L7(=:(@M_]^(@7L;ED(>;:6(:67(2G=;?(FG9LG7DD;9EJ(
E9>(D:=G:;EL(
9E(
=E(4g(
8;E9G(:G;=HM(T9>7<7GJ(:67(B;GD:(
@=G(9B(:67(2G=;?(;D(D7`C7E*7H(=(8=A9G(
:6;GH(WDF7??7H( =D( =( H;8;E;D67H(B9CG:6X(6;L67GJ(D9( :6=:(@I( @M_]d( :67(
*=E(B77H(;E:9(:67(D=87(8CD;*(H;D*CDD7H(=@9<7(N(B9G(@D(_]dN]_(
FG9LG7DD;9E(
=E(CE:G=EDF9D7H(
*
9ED:;:C:7(
<=G;=E:(9B(@D(b[\WD7*9EH(6=?BXN_J(>;:6(
*?7=G?I(
:67(D=87(89:;<;*(
=EH(:9E=?(G7D9CG*7D(W1( 8;E9GJ(:67(89:;<;*(
HI=H(=EH(:67(
8;E9G(
=
EH("(
5
7:(:67(
H
;BB7G7E*7D(
@7:>77E(
:67(:>9(
U
n(
8=A9G(:G;=HDXM(
F=G=??7?(
%
E(
=G7(
:67(
=
(
?=::7GJ(
F=DD=L7D(
:7??;ELM(
:6G9CL6( D?;L6:(=HACD:87E:(9B(:67(
;E(:67(
:67(
@
=DD(9B(
CE?;K7(:67(B( 9B(@Mb[_J(;D(=??9>7H(:9(
4f(
@
M_]_J(
6=G89EIJ(
89<7(H9>E(:9(=(G7=?(@=DD(+fJ(>6;*6(D7G<7D(=D(=(H98;E=E:(9B("J(=EH(:6CD(
:67(H7D*G;F:;9E(
9B(:67(2G=;?(;E("JJ(G=:67G(
:6=E(;E(:67("(:6=:(G7DC?:7H(
@G;ELD(
BG98(
@D(b[_N[M(%E(@M_V](:67(2G=;?(89:;<7(:CGED(
:9(1fJ(G7*=??;EL(
:67(7EH(9B(
:67(7=G?;7G(
9E(:67(>9GH(R9G:7S7;*67E(
F=DD=L7(WD77(@D(c^bN_XJ(=EH(FG7*;D7?I(
;E( @M_]dX( :67( 1f( 8=A9G( :G;=H(
WF7G6=FD( F=G=??7?;EL($7::CELDS7;*67E(
=(*6G98=:;*(
:6;GH(
:9(=E("(8=A9G(:G;=H(W>;:6(4N(
89:;9EJ(
FG9LG7DD7DJ(
:6G9CL6(
7V(=D( =E(;EE7G(<9;*7XJ(7P=*:?I(=D( ;E(@D( c^_NaY( =EH(;:(;D(:6;D(:G;=H(:6=:(
@7*987D(:67(H98;E=E:(9B(1( 8;E9GJ(:67(K7I(9B(:67(#69G7EDFGC*6M(
#6CDJ(;E(
@D(_]dNVa(>7(6=<7(<7E:CG7H(
BG98(1( 8;E9G(:6G9CL6(
=EH(
@=*KJ(
"J(8=A9G(
:67("cN1(G7?=:;9ED6;F(
8=H7(7PF?;*;:(
:67G7@I(
FG7B;LCG;EL(
@I(:67(G7?=:;9ED6;F(
9B(:67(#69G7EDFGC*6(
:9(:67(9F7G=(=D(=(>69?7M(
#67(G7BG=;E(
;:D7?B(
=?D9(6=D(=(G9?7(:9(F?=I(;E(:67(*98F?7P(9B(8CD;*=?(=EH(
HG=8=:;*(;H7=D( DCGG9CEH;EL(
"8B9G:=D(=EH( 6;D( >9CEHJ(:67( -F7=G( =EH(
&6G;D:M(
%:(;D(;E(B=*:(:67(87=ED(:6G9CL6(
>6;*6(!=GD;B=?(
>;??(7E:7G(
:6;D(D>;G?;EL(
9B(DI8@9?D(
=EH(C?:;8=:7?I(
=GG=I(
@G;EL(HG=8=:;*(=EH(:9E=?(9GH7GM("D(;E(9CG(
B;GD:(
H;=:9E;*(7P=8F?7(BG98(
"*:(%( W:67(7E:G=E*7(
9B("8B9G:=D(
=EH(
7DD7E:;=??I(
6;D(:G=;EXJ(:67(#69G7EDFGC*6(
;D(;E(1( 8;E9G(=EH(=FFG9FG;=:7D(
:67(89:;<7(W+J(
BCE*:;9EM(
4X( B9G(=( D;LE;B;*=E:(
<9;*7N?7=H;EL(
+P=8F?7(a=J(>6;*6(D69>D(:67(
:67(DCGB=*7(;EE7G(?;E7(>6;*6(89<7D(BN7ON7@OY(=EH(
#69G7EDFGC*6J(
6;L6?;L6:D(
+PM( a@J(>6;*6(D69>D(:67(CEH7G?I;EL(
<9;*7(?7=H;ELJ(D69>D(:67(78@7HH7H(
?;E7(7NBNBg(
;E(:67(87?9HIM(
=D*7EH;EL(
#67(G7BG=;E(
:6CD(78@7HD(@9:6(:67(H7D*7EH;EL(
D78;:9E7(
89:;9E(:6G9CL6(
4(=EH(+(:9(+c(=EH(:67(=D*7EH;EL(D78;:9E7(
89:;9E(:6G9CL6(
+(=EH(4(:9(4g(
:6=:(>7(D=>(;E(:67(8CD;*(9B(:67(';DD(;E("*:(%%J(=EH(;:(F?=E:D(:67(;H7=(:6=:(
@9:6(>;??(@7(*GC*;=?(:9(:67(7<7E:C=?(
8CD;*=?(OG7D9?C:;9EO(
9B(:67(W+J(4X(B;LCG7M(
&?9D7G(:9(:67(DCGB=*7(;E(:67(8CD;*(=G7(:67(H7D*7EH;EL(87?9H;*(B;B:6D(
=D(=(
G7?=:;<7?I(
:G=EDF=G7E:(
DI8@9?(9B(:67(;EE9*7E*7(9B(:67(OFCG7(B99?OJ(=EH(:67(
9B(7PF7*:=:;9E(
:6=:(:67(:7P:(?7=HD(CD(:9(=DD9*;=:7(>;:6(:67(K7I(9B(1( N(
B77?;EL(
=(B77?;EL(
:6=:(>;??(@7(=8F?I(
G7>=GH7H(
?=:7GM(
%E(:67(;887H;=:7(
D7ED7J(:67(7PF7*:=:;9E(
L7E7G=:7H(
@I(:67(B;GD:(
*98F?7:7(
D:=:787E:(
9B(:67(#69G7EDFGC*6(
;D(BC?B;??7H(
9<7G(:67(D>=E(W@D(
@I(:67(BCG9G7(
:67(7E:G=E*7(9B(!=GD;B=?(W@M__\XM( R7(6=<7(
_dVBBMX(=EHJ(D99E(:67G7=B:7GJ(
E9:7H(=@9<7(:67(D;LE;B;*=E*7(
9B(U@(=D(:67(K7I(9B(!=GD;B=?OD(
;E;:;=?(
=FF7=G=E*7M(
)Z-%&( "0",5-%-( [3\J(

][[^(

This content downloaded from 128.205.114.91 on Sat, 16 Nov 2013 10:40:26 AM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

V\[(

)*&$+,+--(

!"#$%&'(

+PM(a(
"*:(%J(@D(]d^dN]V(
=X(!=GD;B=?J(
]("?:M(
?( "?:9DM(
%(

V("?:M(
V(H"?:9DM(

N(

;GJO(

!!(

Q1CG*6( );:( N( ?7;H(


Q)=H7( >;D7( :6G9CL6(
!!(

MMMMMMd(

?7;H(
I(

N(

<9??(
>;D7J(

?7;H(
I(

N(

N(

<9??(
>;D7J(

N(
N(

?7;H(
I(

N(

<9??(
>;D7J(

Q17G( );:(
#7E9G( Q#6G9CL6(F;:(
]G(
!!(
](
-:#7E9GDM(

N(
N(

Q17G( );:(
VJ(#7E9G( Q#6G9CL6(F;:(

N(

(
V(H#7E9GDM(

>;D(N(D7EHJ(
F;:(N( IJ(

H7G(
:67(

G7;( N( E7(
69?( N( ?I(

%(
M(
G7;(

#69G3(
B99?M(

E7(
?I(

#69G3(
B99?M(

G7;(
69(

N(

E7(
?I(

#69G3(

N(

G7;(
69(

N(
N(

E7(
?I(

#69G3(
B99?Mm(

69(

!!M(

Q17G( );:(
Q#6G9CL6(F;:(

O(

N(
N(

B99?Mmm(

@X(,;E7=G($7HC*:;9E(9B(:67(=@9<7(

%(E(

"MMM(

6=G( N( G7( D7;EJ(


R=;:( B9G(6;8J(

H7E( ;*6(
:67( 9E7(

7G(N( K9GeQ(
%( *69D7MQ(

6=G( N( G7( D7;EJ(


R=;:( B9G(6;8J(

H7E( ;*6(
:67( 9E7(

7G(N( K9GeQ(
%( *69D7MQ(

6=GN(

G7(
D7;EeQ(

R=;:(

%%!!(

6=G(
R=;:(

B9G(
6;8MQ(

N(

G7(D7;EeQ(
B9G(
6;8MQ(

fONQ(
Vd^(

)Z-%&( "0",5-%-(

This content downloaded from 128.205.114.91 on Sat, 16 Nov 2013 10:40:26 AM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

[3\J(][[^(

"($+4+$+0#%",(

15"1(

%0( !"$-%4",(

2;<7E(:67(F=G=H9P;*=?(=DD9*;=:;9E(9B(:67(W+J( 4X( 89:;<7(;E(2CGE78=ESOD(


E=GG=:;<7(
>;:6(@9:6(D;E(=EH(G7H78F:;9EJ(
;:(;D(DCGFG;D;EL(
E7;:67G(
:6=:(:67(
;D(78@7HH7H(
;E(:67(
8CD;*(
:6=:(
;E:G9HC*7D(
CD(:9(!=GD;B=?J(
E9G(
HI=H(
*?7=G?I(
:6=:(;:(>9GKD(@9:6(>=ID3(:6=:(;DJ(D;E*7(>7(6=<7(ACD:(@77E(:9?H(:9(=>=;:(
D9879E7(>69( DCFF9D7H?I(>;??(H7?;<7G("8B9G:=D(BG98(6;D(8;D7GIJ(;:(;D(
H;BB;*C?:(
E9:(:9(;E:7GFG7:(
!=GD;B=?(
=D(=(G7H7787G(
9B(D9G:DY(>6;?7(=:(:67(D=87(
:;87(:67(*GC7?(=*:(:6G9CL6(
>6;*6(67(8=K7D(6;D(=FF7=G=E*7(D69>D(6;8(:9(@7(
6;8D7?B(
=(OD;EE7GOJ(
N(
#6CDJ(:67(8CD;*(;E(U@(=:(@D(_dVBBM(
;E*=F=@?7(9B();:?7;HM(
8CD;*(:6=:(D;8C?:=E79CD?I(
D778D(:9(BC?B;?(
9CG(69F7D(B9G(=(H7?;<7G7G(
=EH(:9(
H;D=FF9;E:(:69D7(69F7D(@7*=CD7(9B(:67(<;9?7E:(=*:(:6=:(:67I(=**98F=EI(N(
78@7HD(;E(;:D(H;=:9E;*;D8(
:67(*6G98=:;*(
89:;9E(7]VNBV(
W.@97(VJ(/;9?;E(VJ(@D(
+<7E(89G7(
;D(:67(
CD7(9B(
:67(
_dbNaXM(
D:G;K;EL(
W+J(4X( HI=H(=(B7>(8987E:D(
>
67E(
;E(=(@G;7B(
8
987E:(
9
B(G7<7?=:;9E(
:6=:(=E:;*;F=:7D(
6;D(
?=:7GJ(
!=GD;B=?J(
89G7(HG=8=:;*(
;E(
"*:(
:
9(
:
67(
9B(
%%J(@7L;ED( LG=DF( ;8F?;*=:;9ED( 6;D(
=>=K7E;EL(
H77H(=EH(9B(:67(F=;E(:6=:(67(6=D(;EB?;*:7HM(
#67( HG=8=:;*(;8F9G:(9B(:67(
;D(*?7=G(
@9:6(
BG98(
:
67(
H;G7*:;9ED(
N( O!=GD;B=?(6=D(?;D:7E7H(:9(
F=DD=L7(
D:=L7(
>;:6(LG9>;EL(
;E:7G7D:(
=EH(789:;9EY(E9>(67(@G7=KD(6;D(@9>(=EH(
2CGE78=ES(
6CG?D(6;D(=GG9>D(=>=IO(N( =EH(BG98(2CGE78=ESOD(`C7D:;9EJ(O"G7(I9C(E9>(
*9ED*;9CD(9B(I9CG(8;DH77HfQOc(
%E(@D(a_cN_(:67(G7?=:;9E(
9B(:67(W+J(4X(HI=H(:9(
!=GD;B=?OD(D:=:7(9B(D;E(;D( 8=H7( 7<7E(89G7(7PF?;*;:(:6=E(;:(>=D( =:(:67(
@7L;EE;EL(9B(:67( D*7E7J( D;E*7(;:(E9>( ?7=HD( H;G7*:?I(;E:9(:67(87?9HI(
;H7E:;B;7H(
;E(@D(a__Na^(W7EL?;D6(69GEJ(T9GE(
@I(,9G7ES(=D(:67();:?7;H89:;<(
;D(D9?;H;B;7H(;E(@Ma__J( >6;*6(*9E:=;ED(:67(W+J( 4X(
\XM]_( #67( G7?=:;9ED6;F(
89:;<7(WH9C@?7(@=DDXJ(=EH(FG7*;D7?I(
:67(D=87(H;8;E;D67HND7<7E:6(
*69GH(=D(
:6=:(>6;*6(=**98F=E;7D(!=GD;B=?OD(4N+( *GI(9B(G7*9LE;:;9EJ(
;E(
O"8B9G:=DeOJ(
"*:(%%M( 4CG:67G89G7J(
@D(a_aNa^(B7=:CG7(=E(9C:N9BNF6=D7(
*6G98=:;*(
<9;*7(
7P*6=EL7(:6=:(DCLL7D:D("*:(%%J( @D( [a_N[^Y( =EH(:67(9G*67D:G=:;9EJ(
D:G;EL(
9B(@Ma_[J( =EH( ACP:=F9D;:;9E(
9B("(
:G789?9J(6=G89EI(=EH(!N7O( BG=L87E:(
:G;=HD(;E(@D(a_[Na^(@G;EL(
!=GD;B=?(
8=A9G(W>;:6(D7<7E:6X(=EH(Un(
8;E9GN8=A9G(
;E:9(:67(8CD;*=?(=EH( DF;G;:C=?(G7=?8(9B(@D( b[]Nc^a( 9B(2CGE78=ESOD(
E=GG=:;<7M(
4G98(:67(=@9<7(7P=8F?7D(>7(*=E(<7E:CG7(:9(DCLL7D:(:6=:(:67(W+J( 4X(
89:;<7(D778D(:9(G=H;=:7(BG98(
:67(*7E:G=?(:CGE;EL(
F9;E:(;E("*:(%%(;E:9(:67(
*G;:;*=?(
HG=8=:;*(
=EH(8CD;*=?(8987E:D(
;E("*:(%Y(=EH(>7(D6=??(?=:7G(D77(:6=:(
;:(F7G87=:7D(
"*:(%%%( 7<7E(89G7(7PF?;*;:?IM(
#6CD(>6=:(;D(9<7G:(=:('CEHGIOD(
K;DD(=EH(!=GD;B=?OD(
G7<7?=:;9E(
;D(DC@87GL7H(
;E(;EE7G(<9;*7DJ(9G(;E(BG=L87E:D(
9B(?9EL7G(
;E:9(*?7=G(G7?;7B(
;E("*:D(%%(=EH(%%%M(
87?9H;7DJ(;E("*:(%J(=EH(@G9CL6:(
R=LE7G(6;8D7?BJ(;E(=( *9887E:(8=H7( :9( &9D;8=( ;E( ]a_aJ( =D( 67(>=D(
:9>=GHD(:67(7EH(9B("*:(%( W@D( ]Vb[N]d^dXJ(
*98F9D;EL(:67("8B9G:=DK?=L7(
L;<7D(=(6;E:(9B(:6;D(FG9*7DD3(
>;:6(>6;*6(!=GD;B=?(
$p;*6=GHq(DF7=KD(9B(:67(F7GF?7P;:I(
?;D:7ED(:9(
"8B9G:=DOD(
6;D(8ID:7G;9CDJ(
CE*9ED*;9CD(
9B(B7??9>(
*98F?=;E:DY(
L7D:CG7D(
>6;*6(
*987D(9C:(;E:9(
:67(9F7E(>;:6(
DCBB7G;ELJ(
K;DD(
=EH(9E?I(
'CEHGIOD(
:67E(
@7*987D(
*?7=G(
:9(6;8MOQ(
)Z-%&( "0",5-%-( [3\J(

][[^(

This content downloaded from 128.205.114.91 on Sat, 16 Nov 2013 10:40:26 AM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

Vd](

!"#$%&'(

)*&$+,+--(

R=LE7GOD( *9887E:D(G7B7G(DF7*;B;*=??I(:9( !=GD;B=?OD(D;?7E:J(L7D:CG=?(


G7=*:;9E(:9(:67("8B9G:=DK?=L7M(
"?:69CL6(:67G7(;D(E9(7<;H7E*7(:6=:(67(>=D(
:9(:67(W+J(4X(HI=H(=D(=(8CD;*=?(DI8@9?J(
D:;??(=E=?ID;D(
6=D(D69>E(CD(
G7B7GG;EL(
:6=:(E9:(9E?I(6=D(!=GD;B=?OD(
OB7??9>(
@77E(=DD9*;=:7H(>;:6(:6=:(HI=H(
DCBB7G;ELO(
D;E*7(6;D(B;GD:(
@C:(=?D9(:6=:(:67(>69?7(HG=8=:;*N8CD;*=?(
7E:G=E*7J(
*98F?7P(
=EH(G7H78F:;9E(
6=D(:CGE7H(9E(:67(HI=H(=:(?7=D:(D;E*7(
;E<9?<;EL(
DCBB7G;EL(
"8B9G:=DOD(
9>E(7E:G=E*7(7=G?I(;E("*:(%M(R6;?7(:67("8B9G:=DK?=L7(
;:D7?B(
N(
?7=D:(:9E=??I(B9*CD7H(8CD;*(;E(=??(9B("*:(%(N(
F7G6=FD(:67(89D:(*6G98=:;*J(
8CD:(G78=;E(@7I9EH(:67(D*9F7(9B(9CG(7BB9G:D(
67G7J(:67(@G;7B(*;:=:;9E(9B(=(
B7>(7P=8F?7D(=EH(:67;G(=DD9*;=:7H(:7P:D(>;??(D69>(69>(:67(HI=H(W+J( 4X(
*9E:;EC7D(:9(7P7G:(=E( ;EB?C7E*7M(#67( T7;?=EHDK?=L7(
W:6=:(;DJ(:67(8CD;*(
;E(@D(]Vb[Nc^XJ(=(*7E:G=?(
"8B9G:=D(
89:;<7(67G7J(ACP:=F9D7D(
=**98F=EI;EL(
;E(:67(6;L67D:(
9G(;E(:67(E7P:(:9(6;L67D:(
:;87(;:(
<9;*7J(7<7GI(
B(=EH(7VJ(7;:67G(
=FF7=GD(;E(@D( ]Vb[N]d^dM( !=G:;*C?=G?I(
:7??;EL(;E(:6;D(G7L=GH(=G7(:67(:>9(
9**CGG7E*7D(9B(:67(89:;<7(;E(=DD9*;=:;9E(>;:6(:7P:(*9E*7GE;EL(&6G;D:(=D(
$7H7787G(W@D(]\c[N_]J(]\_VNdXM("(?9ELJ(=D*7EH;EL(?;E7J(7ONBNOBrJ(
DF=ED(:67(
9G*67D:G=?(
=
D(
;E(@D(
G7BCD7D(
#;:CG7?OD(
]Va^N[J(
=**98F=E;87E:( "8B9G:=DJ(
H78=EH(:9(CE*9<7G(:67(2G=;?M("(D;8;?=G(H7D*7EH;EL(?;E7J(LNBgNB:N7J(
9G;7E:D(
"8B9G:=DOD(
87?9H;*(?;E7(9E(:67(*GC*;=?(>9GHDJ(OR=D(;D:(H;7(RCEH7J(;6G7G(
-*687GS7E(RC:6( L7L7E( H;7( 09:6J( H;7( Tc]]7EF7;EJ(SC( H;7D78("8:(
<7GH=88:(
SC(D7;EfO(WR6=:(;D(:67(DF7=G>9CEH(
=EH(;:D(:9G87E:(
*98F=G7H(:9(
:67(F=;EJ(:67(67??;D6(6CG:(9B(@7;EL(*9EH78E7H(:9(D7G<7(:67(2G=;?fXM(.:67G(
HG=8=:;*(
9**CGG7E*7D(
9B(:67(HI=H(N(=EH(67G7(;:(D69C?H(@7(DCBB;*;7E:(
D;8F?I(
:9(E9:7(@=GD(;E(:67(D*9G7J(D;E*7(:67(8CD;*=?(=EH(HG=8=:;*(
F9;E:(;D(@7*98;EL(
N( ;E*?CH7(@D( ]\^aN]dY( ]\]cNVVJ( 7DF7*;=??I(9E( :67(>9GH(
D7?BN7<;H7E:(
:67(/;9?;E(](?;E7(LONLfOWBrOXNBJ(
O2E=H7EG7;*67EOY][(]\bcNc]J(>;:6(
:G=EDB7GG;EL(
:9(:67(@=DD(+(;E(@M]\c]Y(=??(9B(@D(]\aVN[VJ(@C:(7DF7*;=??I(
:67(?;E7(7@ON7ON!NBrO(
;E(:67(/;9?;E(VJ(@D(]\aVNdJ(=EH(:67(?;E7(BdONBNBN7O(
@C:(
W<=G;9CD(;ED:GC87E:DJ(
;E(:67(<9*=?(D*9G7X(;E(@D(]\adN[VY(=EHJ(=:(:67(*?;8=P(
7=DI(7E9CL6(:9(B9??9>(
=EH(*9E*?CD;9EJ(:67(?;E7(BgN7JNBJ(
:9(
W<;9?=J(@D(]\[dNcXJ(*9EE7*:;EL(
B?ON7N7(
@
D(
:67(
9B(
@=DD(?;E7(
@
D(]\[aN[(
9B(*9CGD7J(
VJ(
W
/;9?;E(
+
N4(
=EHJ(
]\[_NaXJ(
HfONHO(
"8B9G:=DOD(
B;E=?(
:>9(E9:7DJ(B(=EH(7M(
>9GHJ(OL7DCEH7OJ(>;:6(:67(B;E=?(
#6CD( H97D( !=GD;B=?J(:67(LC;?7?7DD(B99?J(@7L;E(:9(?7=GE(:67(87=E;EL(9B(
#6=:(6;D(LG9>:6(
:9>=GHD(>;DH98(=EH(*98F=DD;9E(;D(:67(*GCP(9B(
DCBB7G;ELM(
:67(HG=8=J(=EH(:6=:(:67(89:;<;*(HI=H(W+J( 4X( =G:;*C?=:7D(:6=:(LG9>:6J(
@7*987(7<7E(89G7(7<;H7E:(;E("*:(%%M( #6;D(*98F?7PJ(*6G98=:;*(
=*:(;DJ(;E(
7DD7E*7J( =@9C:( '?;ELD9GOD( :6G7=:(:9( !=GD;B=?J(=D( 78@9H;7H( ;E( :67(
:67(U?C87E8HH*67E(
=EH( 'CEHGIM(%:(F9D7D(:67(`C7D:;9E(9B(
o=C@7GD*6?9DDJ(
>67:67G(
:67(FCG7(B99?(*=E(@7*987(>;D7G3(:6G9CL6(
);:?7;H(*=E(67(@7*987(
>;DD7EHf(&=E( 67(G7E9CE*7(:78F:=:;9E(G=:67G(:6=E(DC**C8@(:9( ;:J(?;K7(
;E(:67(D=87(D;:C=:;9Ef(
"8B9G:=D(
#67( H=EL7G(9B('?;ELD9GOD(:6G7=:(
;D(;8F?;*;:(
;E(6;D(9F7E;EL(>9GHDJ(O1;7(
o7;:(;D:(H=O( W"*:(%%J(@D(c[N_^XM(#67(F;:*67D(:9(>6;*6(:67D7(>9GHD(=G7(DCELJ(
9B(:67(7NBNBI(
89:;9E(:6=:(>=D(78@7HH7H(;E(:67(
*98FG;D7(=(G7:G9LG=H7(
BBNBN7J(
;E("*:(%( N( =EH( =?D9J( ;:(8;L6:(@7( =HH7HJ( =( G7:G9LG=H7(
9B(
#69G7EDFGC*6(
VdV(

)Z-%&(

"0",5-%-(

This content downloaded from 128.205.114.91 on Sat, 16 Nov 2013 10:40:26 AM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

[3\J( ][[^(

"($+4+$+0#%",(

15"1(

%0( !"$-%4",(

:67(D=87(F;:*67D(;E(:67(D;EC9CD(?;E7(W&?=G;E7:(\X(:6=:(=**98F=E;7D(
FG7*;D7?I(
:67(D=87(>9GHDJ(O1;7( o7;:(;D:(H=O( ;E(@D( ]^c_Na(9B("*:(%J( :67G7(DCEL(@I(
:67(/7G>=EH?CELD8CD;KM(
=D(D67(B=??D(=D?77F(;887H;=:7?I(
@7B9G7(
'CEHGI(
G
78=;EH7G(
9B(
:
67(
=EH(4(G7*CG(
=D(=(HG=8=:;*(
:67(
=EH(
=*:J(+(
#6G9CL69C:(
8CD;*=?(=P;D(=G9CEH(>6;*6('?;ELD9GOD(:6G7=:(:9(!=GD;B=?(CEB9?HDM()9D:(
#6;D(;DJ(9B(*9CGD7J(
9**CG(=D(:67(@=DD(?;E7(9B(:67(o=C@7G89:;<M(
BG7`C7E:?I(
:67I(
:67(
8
CD;*(
9
B(
:
67(
=EH(
>7(*=E(=?D9(67=G(
;:(=D(
:67(FG9LG7DD;9E(
';DDJ(
CEH7G?I;EL(
:9('?;ELD9GOD(
=E(=**98F=E;87E:(
B;GD:(
9B(
;E(
:67(
=*:(
H7D*G;F:;9E( 'CEHGI(7=G?I(
57:(:67G7(
=
G7(EC87G9CD(
9
:67G(
*
G9DDNG7B7G7E:;=?(
9**CGG7E*7D(
9B(
W@D(a]NVXM(
=:(:67(7EH(9B(
:67(W+J(4X( HI=H(=D(:67(=*:(H7<7?9FDM("D(;E(:67("8B9G:=DK?=L7(
;ED:=E*7D(9B(:67(89:;<7J(
"*:(%J(%(D6=??(;E:G9HC*7(9E?I(:67(89D:(D;LE;B;*=E:(
D;E*7(=??(9B(:678(:9C*6(CF9E(:67(
=EH(>;:6(=(8;E;8C8(9B(*9887E:=GIJ(
9B(D;E(=EH(DCBB7G;EL3(
:6787D(
FG7<=;?;EL(
s( ":(@D( ]\VNd]J('CEHGIJ(D:;??(=FF=G7E:?I(
=D?77FJ(G;D7D(:9('?;ELD9GOD(*=??M(
#67( 89:;9E(BVNBr(;D(>9GK7H(B;GD:(
;E:9(:67(D7*9EH(6;L67D:(<9;*7(9B(:67(
:67E(;E:9(:67(6;L67D:(
<9;*7M(
T7;?=EHDK?=L7J(
s( ":(@D( ]bVNbJ(ACD:(=B:7G(
'CEHGI(6=D(C::7G7H(67G(D7*9EH(*GI(9B(8;D7GIJ(
/;9?;E(](=EH(&?=G;E7:(\(F?=I(:67(?;E7(Br?NB?N7?NHfOJ(
@D(b[VN\(9B("*:(
G7*=??;EL(
;E(
:67(
@
=DD(
=EH(B(
%J(@C:(E9>(>;:6(:67(7PF?;*;:(
FG9LG7DD;9E(
W@D(]b\NdXJ(
4fN+(
=EH(+(DCF7G;8F9D7H(
;E(@M(]bdM(
6=G89E;*=??I(
s( ":(@D(]ccN_J('CEHGIOD(B;GD:(
DCEL(E9:7D(9B(:67(=*:J(9E(=(69=GD7(89=EJ(=G7(
7O(=EH(B!M(
s(":(@D(V]dN\bJ(;E(:67(H;=?9LC7(?7=H;EL(CF(:9('?;ELD9GOD(H7D*G;F:;9E(
9B(6;D(
:67(9GH7G7H(F;:*6(*?=DD7D(2J(4fJ(4(=EH(+( :G=*7(=(G7?=:;<7?I(
D7?BN8C:;?=:;9EJ(
D:=@?7(?;E7(:6G9CL6(
=(D7G;7D(9B(6=G89E;7D(
:6=:(*987D(*?9D7(:9(@G7=K;EL(
:67(
@9EHD(9B(:9E=?(?9L;*M(":(@MVVdJ(:67(9G*67D:G=?(
*69GH(9E(:67(>9GH(OK7CD*6O(;D(
:67(D=87(=D(:6=:(>6;*6(=**98F=E;7D(!=GD;B=?OD(
O"8B9G:=DeO(
*GIJ(
s( ":(@D(V[_N\^bJ(:67(@=DD(?;E7(2N2&N4N+(=G:;*C?=:7D(
:9(
'CEHGIOD(G7BCD=?(
D7HC*7(!=GD;B=?(
=D(>7??(=D('?;ELD9GOD(D;L6:;EL(
9B(6;8(;E(:67(H;D:=E*7M(%E("*:(
%%J( =D(;E("*:(%J(:67(K7I(9B(Un(8=A9GJ(;E(=DD9*;=:;9E(>;:6(:67(W+J(4X( HI=HJ(
=**98F=E;7D(!=GD;B=?OD(
=FFG9=*6M(
s( ":(@D(_\[Nb]J(:67(;EE7G(D:G;ELD(
:G=*7(:67(?;E7(L:ON!N7ONWHOXN7@O(
CEH7GE7=:6(
9B(
'CEHGIOD(;E;:;=?(D7HC*:;<7(*GI(:9(!=GD;B=?M(#67( D=87(?;E7J(>;:6(D6;B:D(
;D(;E:7G>9<7E(
;E:9('CEHGIOD(<9*=?(?;E7M(U9:6(:67(F?7=DCG7(=EH(:67(
G7L;D:7GJ(
;E(:67(B;GD:(
>9GHD(:6=:('CEHGI(C::7GD(
F=;E(9B(:67(';DD(=G7(:6CD(DC@87GL7H(
:9(!=GD;B=?M(
s( ":(@D( []cN][J(=(<9;*7(7P*6=EL7(WHON7fON7ONBO(;E(:67(CFF7G(D:G;ELD(
=EH(
>;:6(
>;EHDJ(4N+N1( ;E(:67(@=DDX(@G;ELD(;E(:67(W+J(4X( 89:;<7(;E(*9EE7*:;9E(
!=GD;B=?OD(
G7=?;S=:;9E(
:6=:(67(6;8D7?B(
8CD:(@7=G(:67(@?=87(B9G(6;D(89:67GOD(
=
EH(
B9G(
:67(
D
;8;?=G(
<9;*7(
H7=:6J( FG7F=G7D(
7P*6=EL7(=:(:67(';DDM(
s( !=GD;B=?OD(
B;GD:(
*G;7D(=B:7G(
6;D(8987E:(
9B(G7*9LE;:;9E(
=ELC;D67H(
W@D([[dNcX(
=G7(F7G87=:7H(>;:6(:67(W+J( 4X( 89:;<7J(=D(;D(:67(=**98F=EI;EL(
9G*67D:G=?(
8CD;*M("(D;8;?=G(D=:CG=:;9E(
9**CGD(9E(:67(>9GHD(OtC=?( H7G(,;7@7MMMO( =EH(
:67(8CD;*(:6=:(B9??9>D(;E( @D( ]^\_NdcM( 09:7( 7DF7*;=??I(:67( B?LB?B?(
)Z-%&( "0",5-%-( [3\J(

][[^(

This content downloaded from 128.205.114.91 on Sat, 16 Nov 2013 10:40:26 AM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

Vd\(

!"#$%&'(

)*&$+,+--(

78@7HH7H(;E(:67(<9*=?(?;E7J(=EH(:67(2:N4N+(;E(:67(@=DD(9B(@D(]^d]NcM(#67(
DC**7DD;9E(LVmNB!7V(
9B(:67(FG9LG7DD;9E(
;D(=?D9(78@7HH7H(;E(:67(@7L;EE;EL(
:6=:( =**98F=E;7D( :67( >9GHD( O+D( D:=GG:(H7G( U?;*K( HC8FB(=CB( H=D(
=G7(OA9;E7H(@I(=(D;EL?7(
67=HOM(
T7;?DL7BH;DDMMMOY(=L=;EJ(D;E(=EH(G7H78F:;9E(
s("E9:67G(
;E(
>6;*6(
:
67(
*
?=DD7D(
=EH(
4J(+(
?9EL(F=DD=L7(
F;:*6(
FG9<;H7(
4gJ(
1g(
=E( 7?787E:(9B(D:=@;?;:I(
;E(:67(*9E:7P:(9B(:67(89D:(D:=G:?;EL(
6=G89E;*(
=D(;E(@D(V]dN\bJ(;D(@D(]]b[N[]J(;E(:67(F=DD=L7(:6=:(*?;8=P7D(
FG9LG7DD;9EDJ(
>;:6('CEHGIOD(H789E;*(?=CL6(=:(&6G;D:M(
BG98(
H7:=;?7H(
"L=;EJ(%(D6=??(G7BG=;E(
@C:(D;8F?I(
*=??(=::7E:;9E(
:9(:67(<9*=?(?;E7(9B(@D(]]caN_d(=EH(:9(:67(
=E=?ID;D(
9G*67D:G=(
=:(@D(]]acN[^M(
"*:(%%%( @G;ELD(
=EH(@=F:;D8(:9('CEHGI(=EH(!=GD;B=?J(
G7H78F:;9E(
67=?;EL(
:9("8B9G:=DJ(
=EH(=(G7E7>7H(?;B7(;E(:67(&988CE;9E(D7G<;*7(:9(
H7?;<7G=E*7(
:67(KE;L6:D(
9B(:67(2G=;?M(%E(:67(*98F?7P(>7@(9B(:9E=?(G7?=:;9ED(:6G9CL6(
;E(:67(G7D9?C:;9E(
>6;*6(:67(8CD;*(F=G:;*;F=:7D(
9B(HG=8=:;*(
:67(W+J(
*9EB?;*:DJ(
*G9DDNG7B7G7E*7(
=EH(
G9?7J(@9:6(=D(=(DCGB=*7(
4X( 89:;<7(=L=;E(F?=ID(=(*7E:G=?(
=:(:67(<7GI(
=D(=(B9*CD(9B(H77F7G(D:GC*:CG=?(
%:D(G9?7(;D(7PF?;*;:(
G7?=:;9ED6;FDM(
9B(:67("*:(%%%( !G7?CH7J(>67G7(:67(B;GD:(
B9CG(E9:7D(9B(:67(87?9HI(
@7L;EE;EL(
=G:;*C?=:7(:67(89:;9E(B(N7O( ;E(:67(*9E:7P:(9B(U@(8;E9GM(#9( @7( DCG7J(=E(
67G7(;D(:6=:(9B(Uc(=EH(+J(>6;*6J(;E(:IF;*=?(
7`C=??I(;8F9G:=E:(
G7?=:;9ED6;F(
B9G7D6=H9>(
:67(UN+( F9?=G;:I(
9B(:67("*:(%%%( /7G>=EHN(
R=LE7G;=E(B=D6;9EJ(
>67G7(:67D7(:>9(K7ID(=G7( H;G7*:?I(ACP:=F9D7H(W@D( a]]N]VJ(
?CELD8CD;KJ(
@=GD(9B(:67(!G7?CH7(:67G7B9G7(
=:(
aVcN_XM(#67(4(=EH(+(;E(:67(;E;:;=?(
F7GB9G8(
?7=D:(:6G77(BCE*:;9ED3(
=(?9*=?(<9;*7N?7=H;EL(
7
D:=@?;D6(
*9EE7*:;9E(
B;GD:J(
:67I(
>;:6;E(:67(:9E=?(*9E:7P:(9B(Uc(8;E9GJ(G=:67G(=D( :67I(H9( B9G(!=GD;B=?OD(
;E("*:D(%(=EH(%%(;E(U@(8=A9GY(D7*9EHJ(:67I(
7E:G=E*7D(
B9G8(
*G9DDN(
?=GL7ND*=?7(
G7B7G7E:;=?(
>;:6(
:
67(
;
E(
9
:67G(
:67(
W+J(4X(F=;GD(
G7?=:;9ED6;FD(
8=EI(
9F7G=Y(=EH(
=
G7(7DD7E:;=?(
:
9(:67(
=E(
9B(
7?787E:(
9B(:67(
:6;GHJ(
:67I(
FG7B;LCG;EL(
;8F9G:=E:(
:9E=?(D:GC*:CG7(
9B(:67(=*:(=D(=(>69?7M(
"D(:67(=*:(FG9LG7DD7DJ(
;:(
LG=HC=??I(
H7<7?9F;EL(;:D(:6787(9B(G7H78F:;9EJ(
:=K7D(
9
B(:67(>7??N7D:=@?;D67H(
89:;<;*(
G
7D9E=E*7(
9B(4(
E=:CG=??I(
=H<=E:=L7(
=EH(+( =:(;:D(*7E:G=?(HG=8=:;*(8987E:DM(#67( 89D:(*98F7??;EL(;ED:=E*7D(
;E*?CH7(2CGE78=ESOD(>=K;EL(
9B('CEHGI(W@=DD(9B(@D(b_NaJ(acN]^d(=EH(]^cN(
;E(
@?=*K(
=G89CG(
_XY(!=GD;B=?OD(
7E:GI(
W@D(]_bNabX(N(:6;D(7E:G=E*7(
@7;EL(;E(U@(
:6=E(8=A9GJ(>;:6(:67(8CD;*(*98@;E;EL(
6;D(67G9;*(69GE(*=??(
8;E9GJ(G=:67G(
=EH(:67(9F7E;EL(87?9HI(9B(:67("*:(%%%(!G7?CH7J(=EH(>;:6(9<7G:(
78F6=D;D(9E(
:67(W+J(4X(HI=HY(2CGE78=ESOD(G7*9LE;:;9E(
9B(:67(-F7=G(W@D(\\dN_Y(D77(E9:7(
]V(@7?9>XY( 2CGE78=ESOD(:7??;EL(!=GD;B=?(9B(#;:CG7?OD(H7=:6(W@D(d]\NV_XY(
G7B7G7E*7(
'CEHGIOD(>=D6;EL(9B(!=GD;B=?OD(B77:(W@D(bdaNc^XJ(>;:6(=E(7PF?;*;:(
:9(@D(b[VN\(9B("*:(%Y( 2CGE78=ESOD(=EE9CE*;EL(
:6=:(;:(;D(299H( 4G;H=I(W@D(
9B(#;:CG7?OD(BCE7G=?(
cc\NaXY( =EH(:67(@7L;EE;EL(
FG9*7DD;9E(W87?9HI(9B(@D(
ac\BBMXM(
#67(=*:(G7=*67D(;:D(F9;E:(9B(LG7=:7D:(
=D(:67(BCE7G=?(
;E:7ED;:I(
FG9*7DD;9E(
>;:6(:67(F9DD;@;?;:I(
:6=:(:6;D(>;??(@7("8B9G:=DOD(
7EHDJ(=EH(>7(=G7(*9EBG9E:7H(
B;E=?(
:;87(N(H=D(?7:S:7(
)=?(N(:9(D7G<7(T9?I(&988CE;9EM(T7G7(9E*7(89G7J(=:(
Vdd(

)Z-%&(

"0",5-%-(

This content downloaded from 128.205.114.91 on Sat, 16 Nov 2013 10:40:26 AM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

[3\J( ][[^(

"( $+4+$+0#%",(

15"1(

%0( !"$-%4",(

:67(8CD;*(:CGED(:9(:67(89:;<;*(W+J( 4X(
:67(F7=K(9B("8B9G:=DOD(
:9G87E:J(
G7=?;S7H(;E(:67(8CD;*(=**98N(
;
D(89D:(
=
DD9*;=:;9E(
%:D(
BC??I(
HI=HM( DI8@9?;*(
:67(
B;E=?(
>9GHD(
9
B(
:
67(
B
CE7G=?(
)=?eO(
FG9*7DD;9EJ(OoC8(?7:S:7E(
F=EI;EL( LG;8(
9
B(
"
8B9G:=DOD(
B;E=?(
>
9GHD(
=EH(:67(;887H;=:7?I(
W+PM([XM(
FG=I7G(
DC**77H;EL(
9B(4(=EH(+( :9(FG9LG7DD(
R7(6=<7(D77E(;E(FG7<;9CD(7P=8F?7D(:67(:7EH7E*I(
N(:9(4g(
;E(7;:67G(
H;G7*:;9E(
=@9<7(9G(+c(@7?9>M(%E(:67(FG7D7E:(
*6G98=:;*=??I(
#67( BN7ONHrO( 9B(:67(
=EH(>;:6(
G
78=GK=@?7(
7BB7*:M(
@9:6(=G7(
CD7HJ(
7P=8F?7(
)=?O(N(E9:7(
69>(G78;E;D*7E:(
:6;D(F=DD=L7(
OoC8(?7:S:7E(
>9GHD(
:6G7=:7E;EL(
=(H7D*7EH;EL(*6G98=:;*(
89:;9E(
;D(9B('?;ELD9GOD(O1;7( o7;:(;D:(H=O(N(;E;:;=:7(
=EH(=GG;<7D(
=:(HO(=:(@M[VVM( ":(
=:(@D([]aBBM(
:6=:(F=DD7D(;E:9(:67(CFF7G(D:G;ELD(
?;E7(@7L;ED(
*6G98=:;*(
:6;D(F9;E:J(=D("8B9G:=D(
@7L;ED(:9(DF7=KJ(=E(=D*7EH;EL(
9B(:67(:>9(;E(@M[VdJ( :67(
;E(:67(@=DDJ(+N4N2JN2N":JM(
":(:67(;E:7GD7*:;9E(
:6CD(=DD7G:;EL(
9B(:67("*:(%%%(!G7?CH7(7E:7GDJ(
:67(@7L;EE;EL(
I7:(
87?9HI(BG98(
=EH(
9
B(:67(
:67(
/7G>=EH?CELD8CD;KJ( D;8C?:=E79CD?I(
=L=;E(
UN+( F9?=G;:I(
B9G(
"8B9G:=DOD(
:9G:CG7H(
OR767e(R767eOJ(FG7*;D7?I(
=D(=(DCFF9G:(
*GIJ(
*G7=:;ELJ(
:67(
:67(D=87(D9E9G;:I(
:6=:(=**98F=E;7H(!=GD;B=?OD(
ACD:(=B:7G(
*GI(O"8B9G:=DeO(
';DD(;E("*:(%%M(
%%%( #T+( W+J(4X( 15"1( "01( #T+( #.0",( -#$Z&#Z$+( .4(
!"$-%4",3(1"/%1( ,+R%0O-( "0",5-%-( .4(")4.$#"-O-( !$"5+$(
"01( #T+( +01( .4(#T+( .!+$"(
:9(#;:CG7?(N(6;D(B;E=?(
"8B9G:=DOD(
>9GHDJ(Ok=J(R767e(R767eOJ(@7L;E(6;D(FG=I7G(
9B(:67(9F7G=J(=E(9C:@CGD:(:6=:(
D9?9( D*7E7J(=EH(;E(:67(B9G8=?(D:GC*:CG7(
9B("*:(%MV^( T7G7J(;E(:67(H;D:9G:7H(
=EH(:>;D:7H(
F=G=??7?D(:67("8B9G:=DK?=L7(
6=G89E;7D(9B(:67( K;ELOD(B;E=?(=ELC;D6J(;:(;D( B9G(CDJ( ;E( 9CG( `C7D:( :9(
CEH7GD:=EH(
=(D7G7EH;F;:9CD(
*9;E*;H7E*7(:6=:(9E?I(B9G(:6;D(D*7E7J(:9(
!=GD;B=?J(
:67(@7D:(9B(8I(KE9>?7HL7J(
H97D(:67G7(7P;D:(=E(=E=?ID;D(
>6;*6(:=K7D(E9:7(9B(
:67(W+J( 4X( B;LCG7(
=D(=( HI=H(9B(D:GC*:CG=?(
;E(:67(9F7G=M(#6=:(
D;LE;B;*=E*7(
O"8B9G:=DOD(
=E=?ID;D(;D(1=<;H(,7>;EOD(8=D:7G?I(
!G=I7G(:9(#;:CG7?(=EH(:67(
$9?7(9B(1( ;E(!=GD;B=?3(
#67(#9E=?(-F=*7D(9B(:67(1G=8=(=EH(:67(+E6=G89E;*(
87E:;9E7H(@G;7B?I(
=@9<7M(,7>;EOD(=G:;*?7J(
:9(@7(DCG7J(H97D(E9:(:=K7(
&/hUOJ(
:67(W+J(4X(HI=H(=D(;:D(FG;E*;F=?(
;DDC7M(T;D(FG;8=GI(
B9*CD(;D(9E(:67(
=E=?I:;*=?(
G7?=:7H(;H7=D(9B(7E6=G89E;*;D8(
=EH(DC@D:;:C:;9EJ(
;E(:67(*9E:7P:(
B;GD:(
9B(:67(
;:D7?B(
=EH(:67E(;E(:67(*9E:7P:(
9B(:67(7E:;G7(
>9GKM(
!G=I7G(
,7>;EOD(=E=?ID;D(
=@9CEHD(>;:6(9G;L;E=?(
;E:9(!=GD;B=?(
=EH(;E:9(:67(
;ED;L6:D(
8
CD;*=?(
8=L;*=?(
?=ELC=L7(;E(>6;*6(:67(HG=8=(CEB9?HDM(T;D(CEH7GD:=EH;EL(
9B(:67(CE;`C7(>=I(;E(>6;*6(:67(:9E=?(DID:78(
>9GKD(;E(:67(9F7G=(;DJ(;E(8I(
=EH(;:(
6=D(7P7G:7H(
*
9ED;H7G=@?7(
;EB?C7E*7(
9E(8I(9>E(
<;7>J(7P:G=9GH;E=GIY(
=(B7>(
=E=?ID;DM(#67(FG7D7E:(D:CHIJ(*9E*7;<7H(=EH(7<7E(FC@?;*?I(
FG7D7E:7H(
I7=GD(=L9V](FCG7?I(
;E(:7G8D(
9B(:67(W+J(4X(HI=HJ(6=D(@7E7B;:7H(
;887=DCG=@?I(
BG98(;:D(7E*9CE:7G(>;:6(,7>;EOD(=E=?ID;DJ(>6;*6(FG9<;H7D(=( L?9@=?(:9E=?(
:679GI(:6=:(:67(W+J( 4X( 89:;<;*(6IF9:67D;D(*98F?787E:D(=EH( DCFF9G:DM(
%EH77H(;:(;D(FG7*;D7?I(;E("8B9G:=DOD(!G=I7GJ(:67(F7EC?:;8=:7(D*7E7(:6=:(
)Z-%&( "0",5-%-( [3\J(

][[^(

This content downloaded from 128.205.114.91 on Sat, 16 Nov 2013 10:40:26 AM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

Vdb(

!"#$%&'(

)*&$+,+--(

"*:(%%%J(@D([]dNVc(
+PM([(!=GD;B=?J(

)=?(D7;(H7D("8:7D(L7N8=6E:e(
oC8(?7:S(N(:7E()=?e(

)=??(
2G=?ODJSC8(?7:SN:7E( )=?(D7;H7D"8:7DL78=6E:e(oC8?7:SN:7E(

Q(

-7;( H7D("8:7D(L7N8=6E:(SC8(?7:S(N(:7E()=??(

8=6E:JSC8(?7:SN(:7E( )=?(D7;(H7D"8:7DL7N8=6=:?(

"/(
;;(@( ;*(-9( =(

"(
%)(`(
;(
[][(

oC8?7:SN:7E()=??(

7;E( 7E;L(=CBG;*K?7EHMX(
8=( :(

W;*6(
")4.$#"-(

[V(
[Vd(

[VV(

N(
67e(
k=( R7(
FF(

F:C(!(

M(M(
JJ(MM(
R76ON(
4(

][(
MM(
LG;??D(D%(

Vdc(

R7(

N67(

MMM(

J( J(

8;*6( -9(
;;(
NE@7G(

uW( ;(%( MMMMM(MMM(

M(

[(V(
M%-(

)Z-%&(

"0",5-%-(

This content downloaded from 128.205.114.91 on Sat, 16 Nov 2013 10:40:26 AM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

[3\J( ][[^(

"( $+4+$+0#%",(

15"1( %0( !"$-%4",(

FG7F=G7D(B9G(:67(B;E=?(G7D9?C:;9E(9B(:67(HG=8=:;*(=EH(:9E=?(;DDC7D(9B(:67(
=EH(8;E7(;E:7GD7*:Y(
=EH(6;D(;H7=D(>;??(
9F7G=J(:6=:(,7>;EOD(9@D7G<=:;9ED(
=
E(7P:G=(
9
B(
B9G(
9
>E(=D(>7(
DCGL7( 7E7GLI( 8I(
FG9<;H7(
=FFG9=*6(:67(8C?:;F?7(
:9E=?(G7D9?C:;9ED(
:6=:(CEB9?H(
=:(:67(*9E*?CD;9E(9B(:67(>9GKM(
,7>;EOD(=E=?I:;*=?(
B9*CD(9E(DC@D:;:C:;9E(
=EH(7E6=G89E;*;D8(
@7L;ED(>;:6(
=(H;D*CDD;9E(9B(:67(!G=I7G(
T7(E9:7D(
:
6=:(
:
67(
7
E:;G7(
B9G8C?=;*(
;:D7?BM(
U=GB9G8(
9B(:67(D7*:;9E(*=E(@7(*9ED:GC7H(
;E(:7G8D(
9B(=(D;8F?7J(O2?C*K;=E("CDD7ED=:SO(
;E(1( 8;E9GJ(>;:6(:67(FCSS?;EL(7P*7F:;9ED(:6=:(=( F=DD=L7(;E(19( 8;E9G(
B9G(1( 8;E9G(;E(:67(B;GD:(
DC@D:;:C:7D(
-:9??7E(
@D([\\NbcXJ(
W;E(,7>;EOD(=E=?ID;DJ(
=EH(:6=:(F=DD=L7D(;E(1f(8=A9G(
DC@D:;:C:7(
B9G(1( 8;E9G(;E(:67(D7*9EH(-:9??7E(
W@D([b_N_bX(=EH(B9G(1( 8=A9G(;E(:67("@L7D=EL(
W@D([_cN[\XMVV(#67( O*=H7E*7N(
9**CGD(EC87G9CD(:;87D(;E(
:67(
4N+(
D77K;ELO(
CFF7G(<9;*7( 9B(,7>;EOD(
"CDD7ED=:SM(%:( 9**CGD(;E;:;=??I(;E(:67(CE=**98F=E;7H(B;GD:(<;9?;ED(=:( =(
HG=8=:;*(8987E:(W@D( [\cN_X( 7=G?I(;E(:67(!G=I7GJ(>67G7(:;87(<;G:C=??I(
D:=EHD(D:;??(=D("8B9G:=D(
?;B:D(
6;8D7?B(
:9(=HHG7DD(#;:CG7?OD(@9HI(
CF(=EH(:CGED(
B9G(:67(B;GD:(
:;87M(,7>;E(=?D9(F9;E:D(;:(9C:(;E(@D([cbNc(9B(:67(D7*9EH(-:9??7E(
<9E(;68J(H=U(D7;E(
=HHJ(;:(=**98F=E;7D(:67(>9GHD(O7GB?767(
W>67G7J(%(8;L6:(
;E(=DD9*;=:;9E(
>
;:6(
:
67(
D
=87(*69GH(
:
6=:(>7(67=GH(>;:6(
U
?C:OJ(
67;?;L7D(
<7GI(
:67(HI=H(9E(:67(>9GHD(OH=G7;E(=8('G7CS(D7;E(Lc::?;*6(
U?C:(=C*6(B?9DDO(;E(
"*:(%X(=EH(@D([a\Nd(9B(:67("@L7D=ELM(
09>( ,7>;E(H97D(E9:(7P:G=F9?=:7(BG98(:67(?9*=?( 4N+( L7D:CG7(9B(:67(
:9(B;EH(D;LE;B;*=E*7(
B9G(;:(;E(:67(9F7G=(=D(=(>69?7J(D;E*7(;:(;D(9E?I(=(
!G=I7G(
9B(6;D(=GLC87E:M(
B7=:CG7(
T7( H97DJ(;E(=(B99:E9:7J(
G7?=:7(:67(HI=H(
D7*9EH=GI(
:9(:>9(9B(;:D(9:67G(
;8F9G:=E:(
=FF7=G=E*7D(;E("*:(%%%3(
#67(4N+(L7D:CG7(
=G;D7D(
BG98(
88M([\cN_M(#67(6=G89EI(
9B(88M(
?9*=??I(
G78;EHD(
[cbMbN[c_Mb(
CD(:6=:(
:67(87?9H;*(
>=D(78@7HH7H(
;E(:67(
L7D:CG7(
89:;<7D(9B(:67(.H7( p"*:(%%%J( @D( ]NVq( =EH( R=BB7ED*68C*K(
p:67(
:G=EDB9G8=:;9E(
9B(!=GD;B=?OD(
69GE(*=??J(=:("*:(%%%J( @D( ]c[N_]J(:6=:(
6;D(:6;GHN=*:(
H;G7*:?I(
FG7*7H7D(
7E:G=E*7qMV\(
6;D(*7E:G=?(*9E*7GED(;E(;E:G9HC*;EL(
:67(89:;<7(=G7J(9E(:67(
07<7G:67?7DDJ(
?9*=?(?7<7?J(:9(D69>(69>(:67(4N+( L7D:CG7(D:G9EL?I(
DCLL7D:D(=E(;8F7GB7*:(
*=H7E*7(=EH(=?D9(D:G9EL?I(
OD77KDO(=(F7GB7*:(
*=H7E*7(;E(1( 8;E9GY(=EH(9E(=(
H98;E=E:N:9E;*(
L?9@=?(?7<7?J(:9(D69>(69>(:67D7(9D:7ED;@?I(
D:G=;L6:B9G>=GH(
;E(:67(1( 8;E9G(9B(:67(!G=I7G(@7*987(O8=L;*=??IO(7E:=EL?7H(
G7?=:;9ED6;FD(
>;:6(:67(;DDC7D(9B(DC@D:;:C:;9E(
=EH(7E6=G89E;*;D8(
;E(:67(9F7G=(=D(=(>69?7M(
.B(F=G:;*C?=G(
;E:7G7D:(
>;:6(G7L=GH(
:9(:67(;E:7GD7*:;9E(
9B(8I(O4N+O( ?;E7(9B(
=EH(,7>;EOD(ODC@D:;:C:;9E=?O(
?;E7(9B(:6;EK;EL(
;D(=E9:67G(
;ED:=E*7(9B(
:6;EK;EL(
:67(HI=H(E9:7H(@I(,7>;EM(%E(@D([c[N_\(9B(:67(!G=I7GJ(
67(E9:7DJ(=(F=DD=L7(
;E(1( 8=A9G(DC@D:;:C:7D(
B9G(9E7(;E(1( 8;E9GM(%E(6;D(1( 8;E9G("CDD7ED=:S(
9B(
:6;D(F=DD=L7(N( :6=:(;DJ(:67(6IF9:67:;*=?(
<7GD;9E(9B(:67(8CD;*(:6=:(>9C?H(
N( :67(W+J(4X( HI=H(9**CGD(;E(@D(
9**CG(>;:69C:(:67(D78;:9E=?(DC@D:;:C:;9E(
=D(BN7?OY(@C:(;E(:67(G7=?(8CD;*J(>67G7(=(D78;:9E7(
[_VN\J(?;:7G=??I(
DC@D:;:C:;9E(
;D(:=K;EL(
F?=*7J(;:(9**CGD(=D(BrON7:O(
WD77(+PM(]^XM(
)Z-%&(

"0",5-%-(

[3\J( ][[^(

This content downloaded from 128.205.114.91 on Sat, 16 Nov 2013 10:40:26 AM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

Vd_(

!"#$%&'(

)*&$+,+--(

+PM( ]^(1=<;H( ,7>;EJ("E=?I:;*=?(


$7HC*:;9E(W"CDD7ED=:SX(
9B(!=GD;B=?J(
"*:(
@D([\\N[\(
%%%J(
?=M(-:9??7E(]M(
W( *?:67LGC?Y(

V(

%@M(-:9??7E( VM(

\(

d(
4(

N[(

43(

)(

%(*M("@L7D=ELM(

;mv(

)(
)":N,7;H(

+mNNNN(
M"cs"7;(

Vda(

^(_(

k(

)Z-%&( "0",5-%-(

This content downloaded from 128.205.114.91 on Sat, 16 Nov 2013 10:40:26 AM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

c(

[3\J(][[^(

"($+4+$+0#%",(

15"1( %0( !"$-%4",(

#6;D(7P=8F?7(@G;ELD(CF(:67(;E:7G7D:;EL(
`C7D:;9E3(OR67E(;D(W+J(4X( E9:(
B
9G(
=(G7=?(
W+J(4XfO(R67EJ( 7P=8F?7J(8;L6:(
W+J(4X( @7(H;DLC;D7H(=D(W+JJ(4]X(9G(
=D( W+fJ(4(X( =:(:67(DCGB=*7(9B(:67(8CD;*f()I(9>E(=ED>7G(67G7(;D(:6=:(DC*6(
DC@D:;:C:;9ED(
=G7(;EH77H(F9DD;@?7J(=EH(:6=:(:67I(F?=I(=(<;:=?(G9?7(;E(:67(
8CD;*=?(?=ELC=L7(9B(!=GD;B=?M(
@7(=HHC*7H(;E*?CH7(E9:(
+P=8F?7D(:6=:(8;L6:(
@
D([_VN\(;E("*:(
@C:(=?D9(@D(b[_Na(;E("*:(
%%%J(
%J(;E(:67(H;D*CDD;9E(9B(
9E?I(
>6;*6(%(@G;7B?I(
;E:G9HC*7H(
,7>;EOD(;H7=(9B(DC@D:;:C:;9E(
=@9<7M(%E(:67(7=G?;7G(
>
7(
"?(DC@D:;:C:7D(
;E(@Mb[a(B9G(
;ED:=E*7J(>67G7J( E9:7HJ(
"J(;:(;D(*?7=G(:6=:(
2CGE78=ESOD(87?9H;*(?;E7J(B(N7cJ(
;E(@D(b[_Na(:78F9G=G;?I(
DC@D:;:C:7D(
B9G(BN(
7M(4CG:67G89G7J(
:67(;H7=(9B(DC@D:;:C:;9E(
=**9GHD(>7??(>;:6(:67(;H7=(:6=:(:67(
=( D78;:9E7(;E(7;:67G(H;G7*:;9EJ(=(
W+J( 4X( HI=H(;D( 7P:7EH7H(BG7`C7E:?I(
9
B(>6;*6(
>7(6=<7(D77E(;EEC87G=@?7(
F67E987E9E(
7P=8F?7D(=?G7=HIM(%E(
DC*6(*=D7D(;:(8=I(@7(H;BB;*C?:(
:9(=D*7G:=;E(
>67:67GJ(
D=IJ(:67(HI=H(W+:J(4.X(;D(
B9G(
9G(
;:M(
"(*=D7(;E(
DC@D:;:C:;EL( W+J(4X(
7P:7EH;EL(
F9;E:(;D(:67(F=DD=L7(=:(@D(
bVcNa(9B("*:(%( W:67(#G;D:=E(
>
67G7(
:
67G7(
;D(=E(W+J(4X( HI=H(N( 9GJ(
`C9:=:;9EXJ(
:9(@7(FG7*;D7J(=E(W+J(+gX(HI=H(N(@7:>77E(6;L67D:(
=EH(?9>7D:(<9;*7DY(I7:(:67(
7(^VNB9(9B(:67(CFF7G(<9;*7( @76=<7D(8C*6(=D( :67(HI=H(W+J( 4X( @76=<7D(
7?D7>67G7(
;E(:67(9F7G=M(ZEB9G:CE=:7?IJ(
:67(;DDC7(CEH7G(H;D*CDD;9E(
=?:69CL6(
67G7(;D(9B(:67(LG7=:7D:(
:679G7:;*=?(
=EH(=?:69CL6(:67G7(=G7(8=EI(
;E:7G7D:J(
9:67G(;E:7G7D:;EL(
9CG(FG7D7E:(7E7GL;7D(=G7(K7F:(89G7(
7P=8F?7D(;E(!=GD;B=?J(
:6=E(BC??I(
9**CF;7H(@I(G7=?(+D( =EH(4DJ( D9(>7(8CD:(@7(*9E:7E:(:9(6=<7(
:9C*67H(CF9E(W+J(4X( DC@D:;:C:7D(
;E(F=DD;EL(=EH(:9(D=<7(:678(B9G(=(BC:CG7(
7EH7=<9CGMVd(

R7(*=EE9:J(69>7<7GJ(
;B(>7(
7D*=F7(H7=?;EL(>;:6(:67(;H7=(9B(DC@D:;:C:;9E(
>;D6(:9(CEH7GD:=EH(
,7>;EOD(<;7>(9B(:67(:9E=?(D:GC*:CG7(
9B(:67(9F7G=J(=EH(;BJ(
89G7(;8F9G:=E:?IJ(
>7(>=E:(:9(G7?=:7(:6=:(:9E=?(D:GC*:CG7(
:9(:67(W+J(4X(HI=H(
:6=:(6=D( L9<7GE7H(9CG(H;D*CDD;9E(:6CD(B=GM(#9( *?=G;BI(
:67D7(;DDC7D(>;??(
BG98(
9CG(LC;H7H(W+J(4X(A9CGE7I(
:67(
G7`C;G7(=(DC@D:=E:;=?(
H;LG7DD;9E(
:6G9CL6(
B9G(DC*6(=( H;LG7DD;9E(
>;??(@7(:67(CEH7GD:=EH;EL(
9B(
9F7G=M(57:(:67(F=I9BB(
69>(:67(L?9@=?(G7D9?C:;9E(
:6=:(7EDC7D(;E(:67(B;E=?(]]](@=GD(9B(:67(9F7G=(W@D(
BG98(
:>9(H;BB7G7E:(
@C:(*98F?787E:=GI(
]^\^N]d]X(;D(=(G7D9?C:;9E(
F9;E:D(9B(
<;7>M(
,7:(CD(7P=8;E7(B;GD:(
,7>;EOD(=E=?ID;D(
9B(:67(?=GL7ND*=?7(
9B(1(
;8F?;*=:;9ED(
=D(:67(:9E;*(;E(:67(!G=I7GJ(
=EH(9B(;:D(DC@D:;:C:;9EDM(
-;E*7(,7>;EOD(=GLC87E:(
;D(D9(*9E*7E:G=:7HJ(
%(D6=??(@7(9@?;L7H(:9(`C9:7(6;8(H;G7*:?IM(
R;:6(G7DF7*:(
:9(
:67(DC@D:;:C:;9ED(
B9G(
1(;E(:67(!G=I7GJ(
67(E9:7D3(
":(:6;D(F9;E:J(
;:(>;??(@7(CD7BC?(
:9(*9ED;H7G(
D987(@G9=H(=EH(=@D:G=*:(
D:GC*:CG=?(
9B(:67(:9E=?(G7?=:;9ED(
>7(6=<7(ACD:(@77E(
;8F?;*=:;9ED(
d( p;E(,7>;EOD(
H;D*CDD;ELM(
R=LE7G(6=D(;EB9G87H(
CDJ(<;=(@G=*K7:(
"CDD7ED=:S(
9B(:67(D7*9EH(
=D(+PM]^(=@9<7qJ(
-:9??7EJ(
G7FG9HC*7H(
:6=:(
:67(
DC@D:;:C:7D(
B9G(
"N=DNH98;E=E:(
;D(;E(B=*:(
:67(<7GI(
>6;*6(
;D(
"J(>6;*6(
"@J(
:67(:9E;*(
9B(:67(HG=8=M(
R67E(
"?(=FF7=GD(
:6;D(
;E(=(H98;E=E:(
K7I(
;:(
G9?7J(
=(DC@H98;E=E:(
>6;*6(
DCLL7D:D(
9E7(8;L6:(
@C;?H(=(
:9E;*;S;EL(
1@(BG98(

)Z-%&(

"0",5-%-(

[3\J( ][[^(

This content downloaded from 128.205.114.91 on Sat, 16 Nov 2013 10:40:26 AM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

Vd[(

!"#$%&'(

)*&$+,+--(

;D( =(
B;E=?(F?=L=?(*=H7E*7(B9G(:67(9F7G=M(UC:(D;E*7("JN=DNH98;E=E:(
D;E*7(;:(;EB?7*:D(
DC@D:;:C:7(
B9G("N=DNH98;E=E:J(
1@(9E?I(=D(=(DC@D:;:C:7(
=G;D7D(:6=:(1( ;:D7?B(
B9G(1N=DN?9*=?N(:9E;*J(:67(=@D:G=*:(
F9DD;@;?;:I(
8;L6:(
D9(:6=:(:67(=?:7GE=:;<7(
D7G<7(=D(=(BCE*:;9E=?(
DC@H98;E=E:J(
WDC@D:;:C:7X(
"EH(;E(
F?=L=?(*=H7E*7(8;L6:(FG9*77H(BG98(1NB9GN1,(:9("%N=DN:9E;*M(
B=*:(:67(;H7=(:6=:(>7(=G7(=>=;:;EL(1( =D( :67(D:GC*:CG=?(
K7I(B9G(=E(
9B(:67(#69G7EDFGC*6M(
C?:;8=:7(*=H7E*7(;D(DCFF9G:7H(@I(:67(D:GC*:CG7(
#6=:(89:;<7(@7L;ED(9<7G(=(DCD:=;E7H(H98;E=E:(9B(1( =EH(:7??D(CD(:9(
=>=;:(D987:6;ELM(R7( *=E( FG7DC87(:67(OD987:6;ELO(;E( `C7D:;9E(:9(
1MVb(
;E<9?<7(
=(:9E;*;S7H(
,=:7GJ(DC88=G;S;EL(:67(!G=I7GOD(:9E=?(;8F?;*=:;9ED(B9G(:67(G78=;EH7G(9B(:67(
HG=8=J(67(*9E*?CH7D3(
;D(:6=:("%N9GN"N=DN(
#67( =@D:G=*:(;8F?;*=:;9E(9B(:67D7(;H7E:;B;*=:;9ED(
9B(
H98;E=E:(
>;??(DC889E(=(:9E;*;S7H(1%N9GN1J(BC?B;??;EL(
:67(FG9F67*I(
=:(:6=:(F9;E:(:67(DC@H98;E=E:(
*=E(*=H7E*7(
:67(#69G7EDFGC*6Y(
1N9GN1@(
=EH(:67(9F7G=(*=E(7EH(>;:6(:67(
F?=L=??I(;E:9("%N=DN:9E;*(W,;7@7D8=6?XJ(
"8B9G:=D(
*988CE;9E(D7G<;*7(;:D7?BM(
@7?;7<7D(:6=:(:67(9@?;L=:9GI(
1fN9GN(
:67(
1( ;D(6;D(9>E(H7=:6J(B9G(>6;*6(67(F?7=HD(7?9`C7E:?I(
HCG;EL( !G=I7G(
UC:(:67(KE;L6:D(
KE9>(@7::7GJ(
=D(:67(
=EH(:67(DC@D7`C7E:(/7GS>7;B?CELM(
1(
8
M([[\(:7??D(
"8B9G:=D(
6;D(
*=H7E*7(
*
=H7E*7(9B(
C
DJ(H7EI;EL(
H7*7F:;<7(
>;:6(=(LGC7D987(D69*KM(49G(;B("8B9G:=D(
H;7DJ(*=H7E:;=??I(
1fN(
:9E;*;S;EL(
9GN1J( >69(>;??(@7( ?7B:(:9( CE*9<7G(:67(2G=;?J(;M7MJ( :9(7P7*C:7(:67(
9@?;L=:9GI(
F?=L=?(*=H7E*7(BG98(
1JN9GN1(:9("%N=DN:9E;*fVc(

"G87H(
>;:6(
:67(=@9<7(=E=?ID;DJ(
>7(=G7(E9>(FG7F=G7H(
:9(89<7(@7I9EH(
:67(
;:D7?B(
=EH(:9(CEH7GD:=EH(
,7>;EOD(;E:7GFG7:=:;9E(
9B(:67(*9E*?CD;9E(
9B(
!G=I7G(
:67(9F7G=M(
,7>;E(
6;D(9>E(`C7D:;9E3(
*9E:;EC7DJ(
=ED>7G;EL(
.B(*9CGD7(>7(KE9>(:67(D9?C:;9E(:9(:6;D(FG9@?78M(%:(;D(!=GD;B=?J(
:67(G7;E7(
#69G(9B(:67(FG9F67*IJ(>69(;D(:9(:=K7(CF9E( 6;8D7?B(:67(;EH;*=:7H(
DC@H98;E=E:(>7;L6:(9B(1N9GN1,J(ACD:(=D( 67(:=K7D("8B9G:=DOD(
9BB;*7(
;E(:6=:(*=F=*;:I(67(>;??(F7GB9G8(
:67(F?=L=?(*=H7E*7(=EH(
CF9E(6;8D7?BY(
CE*9<7G(:67(2G=;?MV_(

DC@H98;E=E:(
=:(:67(8987E:(
=:(
#6CDJ(,7>;E(?9*=:7D(:67(?9ELN=>=;:7H(
>6;*6(
!=GD;B=?(
:=K7D(
9<7G(
"8B9G:=DOD(
9BB;*73(
:67(8=LE;B;*7E:(
1(8=A9G(
H9>EN(
@7=:(9B(@M(]^b_M(T7G7(!=GD;B=?(
=:(?=D:(
6=DJ(;E(:67(;887H;=:7?I(
@=GDJ(
FG7*7H;EL(
;H7E:;B;7H(
6;8D7?B(
=D(:67(7PF7*:7H(
E9>(
8=H7(
>
;D7(
:67(
B99?J(
:6G9CL6( F;:I(
:6=:(
67(6=D(?7=GE7H(
BG98(
"8B9G:=DOD(
D7;(H7;E(,7;H7EJ(
DCBB7G;EL(
WO27D7LE7:(

H=D( );:?7;HD( 6=*6D:7( 'G=B:J( CEH( G7;ED:7E(R;DD7ED( )=*6:( H78( S=L7E(


#69G7E( L=@eOXM( T7( E9>J(=:(@M]^b_J( FG7*;D7?I(*99GH;E=:7H(>;:6(:67(9ED7:(9B(
1( 8=A9GJ(*=E( G7:CGE(:67(-F7=GJ( :67(?9DD( 9B(>6;*6(:6G9CL6("8B9G:=DOD(D;E(
@G9CL6:(=@9C:( :67(>9CEH( ;E(:67(B;GD:(F?=*7J( =EH( =DDC87( :67(9BB;*7M("D(

Vb^(

)Z-%&( "0",5-%-([3\J( ][[^(

This content downloaded from 128.205.114.91 on Sat, 16 Nov 2013 10:40:26 AM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

"( $+4+$+0#%",(

15"1(

%0( !"$-%4",(

,7>;E(F9;E:D(9C:J(;:(;D(:6;D(8987E:J(@M]^b_J( E9:(!=GD;B=?OD(67=?;EL(9B(
6;D(>9CEH(>;:6(:67(-F7=G(W@M]^\bX( :6=:(*?=;8D(:67(
"8B9G:=D(
@I(:9C*6;EL(
D:GC*:CG=?(
#
67(
7E:;G7(F=DD=L7(DCGG9CEH;EL(
:67(67=?;EL(;:D7?B(W@D(
>7;L6:M(
;
E(
"(
;D(D7:(
:
67(
H
98;E=E:(
9B(
:9(=H9F:(,7>;EOD(
=EH(
1
J(
:6CDJ(
]^\^NbcX(
8=A9GJ(
:67(
9
B(
H98;E=E:(
:67(
=D(DC@H98;E=E:M(
"EH(D9J(=D(67(
1N=DN1f(
:7G8;E9?9LIJ(
E9:7DJ(
#67(*CG;EL(
9B("8B9G:=DOD(
;D(O:6G9>E(
>9CEH(
9E(:67(D:=L7J(
=>=IO(
HCG;EL(
:67("N8=A9G(
.CG(=E=?ID;D(
D69>D(
CD(:67(?9L;*(
67G73(
;:(;D(E9:(:67(
F=DD=L7M(
B;EHD(
>9CEH(
>6;*6(
"8B9G:=D(
=EH(;:(;D(
CE@7=G=@?7J(
F=;E(9B(:67(F6ID;*=?(
E9:(:67(67=?;EL(
9B(:67(>9CEH(>6;*6(:67(HG=8=(8=K7D(9@?;L=:9GIM(
;:(;D("8B9G:=DOD(
:9(F7GB9G8(
6;D(9BB;*7(
>6;*6(
67(B;EHD(
$=:67GJ(
;E=@;?;:I(
=EH(;:(;D(:67(G7?;7<;EL(
9B("8B9G:=D(
BG98(
:6=:(
>6;*6(
;D(
CE@7=G=@?7J(
HC:I(
:67(9@?;L=:9GI(
7<7E:MVa(
,7>;EOD(<;7>(67G7J(9B(*9CGD7J(E9:(9E?I(=**9GHD(>7??(>;:6(:67(8CD;*=?(
G7*=??(9B(!=GD;B=?OD(89:;<7X(=EH(
W9G*67D:G=:;9EJ(
HIE=8;*(?7<7?J(:G;C8F6=E:(
:7P:C=?(W!=GD;B=?OD(6=<;EL(ACD:(;H7E:;B;7H(
6;8D7?B(
=D(:67(?9ELN=>=;:7H(#69GX(
78F6=D;D(9E(@M]^b_J(@C:(=?D9(>;:6(:67(7PF?;*;:(:7P:(W`C9:7H(=@9<7X(BG98(
:67("8B9G:=DK?=L7(
9B("*:(%3( OR6=:(;D(:67(DF7=G>9CEH(=EH( ;:D(:9G87E:(
*98F=G7H(:9(:67(F=;EJ(:67(67??;D6(6CG:(9B(@7;EL(*9EH78E7H(:9(D7G<7(:67(
2G=;?fO( ,=:7GJ( :6;D(D=87( 1N=DNDC@H98;E=E:(=EH( 1( =D( BC?B;??;EL(
:67(
B9G(,7>;EJ(:67(1N:9N"l(
:6=:(;D(O:67(
=G:;*C?=:7DJ(
#69G7EDFGC*6(
FG9LG7DD;9E(
D:GC*:CG=?(
9B(:67(9F7G=O(=:(@D(]^adNa3(O!=GD;B=?J(
;E(
9@?;L=:9GI(
L7D:CG7(
B;G8?I(
*988=EH(9B(:67(9BB;*7J(
6;D(B9G79GH=;E7H(
:67(
H;D*6=GL7D(
HC:I(@I(H;G7*:;EL(
CE<7;?;EL(9B(:67( 2G=;?MOV[( .E?I(=:( :67(<7GI(7EH( 9B(:67( 9F7G=J(=:(:67(
*9E*?CD;9E(9B(=(FG9H;L;9CD(D7`C7E*7(9B(F?=L=?(*=H7E*7D(?7=H;EL(=G9CEH(:67(
*;G*?7(9B(B;B:6D(
BG98(1( =??(:67(>=I(:9("c(W@D( ]]^[NV_XJ(;D(:67(G7=?(DC@N(
H98;E=E:(
9B(1@(FG9?9EL7H(
=EH(78F6=D;S7HM\^(
6
=EH(;E(6=EH(>;:6(
:67(DC@D:;:C:;9E=?(
G7?=:;9ED(9C:?;E7H(@I(
R9GK;EL(
,7>;E(;D(=E9:67G(=DF7*:(9B(:67(G9?7(9B(1( ;E(:67(HG=8=3(;:D(=G;D;EL(
:6G9CL6(
=E(7E6=G89E;*J(
G=:67G(
:6=E(=(H;=:9E;*J(G7?=:;9E(
:9(:67(ZGN:9E;*(
9B("cM("B:7G(
6;D(H;D*CDD;9E(9B(:67(D;LE;B;*=E*7(
9B(@M]^b_J( 67(BCG:67G(
=GLC7D(B9G(:67(
;E(:67(
9B(1(
=D(=(>69?7(
:9(:67(
*7E:G=?;:I(
9F7G=(
@I(F9;E:;EL(
#69G7EDFGC*6(
D:G7::9(
=:(@D(]^b^Nc(W>67G7(!=GD;B=?(
;H7E:;B;7D(
6;8D7?B(
=D(:67(G7;E7(
#69GX(=EH(
E9:;EL3(
R7(6=<7(67=GH(:6;D(D:G7::9(
@7B9G7M(
"(89G7(7P:7EH7H(
<7GD;9E(
?7H(:9(
!=GD;B=?OD(
*9G9E=:;9E(
7=G?;7G(
;E(:67(=*:Y(:67G7(
:67(D:G7::9(
?7H(:9(=(D;8;?=G(
9B(:67(!=GD;B=?(
:67E(
;E(U(8=A9G(
=D(!=GD;B=?(
:G;C8F6=E:(
H;DF?=I(
:6787J(
G7=*67H(
=E(;8F9G:=E:(
;
E(
:67(FG9F67*IM(
#67(
FG7?;8;E=GI(
L9=?( BC?B;??;EL(
?7=HD(:6G9CL6(
U(;E(:6;D(
HG=8=M(
#67(1( 8=A9G(
9B(88M(
>=I(:9(1(9B:7E(
]^b_BBM(
G78;EHD(
!=GD;B=?(
B;GD:(
D7;S7H(*9E:G9?(
9B(:67(DF7=GJ(
CDJ(:99J(:6=:(
:9>=GH(
:67(7EH(9B(:67(D7*9EH(
1(*=87(9C:(9B(
:6=:(
=*:J(;E(1(8=A9GM(
p"EH(

:67(U(=8@;7E*7(
;E('?;ELD9GOD(G7=?8Mq\](
)Z-%&(

"0",5-%-(

[3\J( ][[^(

This content downloaded from 128.205.114.91 on Sat, 16 Nov 2013 10:40:26 AM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

Vb](

!"#$%&'(

)*&$+,+--(

#67(F;<9:=?(G7?=:;9E(
9B(:67(1( 9B(:67(#69G7EDFGC*6J(
:67(FG9F67*I(
:6=:(LC;H7D(
:67(HG=8=:;*(D:GC*:CG7(
=EH(C?:;8=:7?I(
:67(
1(
*=H7E*7(9B(
@M(]^b_J(:9(
@G;ELD(
;E(F=G:(@I(
:67(L?9@=?(:9E;*(9B("@(;D(:6CD(L9<7GE7H(;E(F=G:(@I(DC@D:;:C:;9EJ(
B9G(:67(:9E=?(89:;9E(9B(:67(9F7G=(=:(:67(@G9=H7D:(?7<7?(
7E6=G89E;*;D8J(
:=K7D(CD(BG98(:67("c(9B(:67(9F7E;ELJ(:6G9CL6(:67(U( 9B("*:(%%J( :9(:67(
=EH(7<7E:C=??I(
:67(=>7D987(
*?;8=*:;*(1( 9B("*:(%%%J( @D( ]^b_BBMJ(
:6G9CL6(
:6=:(G7:CGED(
*;G*?7(9B(H7D*7EH;EL(B;B:6D(
CD(:9("c(=:(:67(*9E*?CD;9EM(W&9C?H(
:6;D(
BG98(
:67(&(:6=:(7EHD("*:(%(=EH(:67(Uc(:6=:(@7L;ED("*:(%%%(@7(*9ED:GC7HJ(
BG98(
9E(7;:67G(
D;H7(9B(UfX("EH(;E(L7::;EL(
"c(
F9;E:(9B(<;7>J(:9(@7(DC@D:;:C:7D(
:9(U(:9(1J( ;:(;D(*GC*;=?(:9(E9:7J(>;:6(,7>;E(=EH(=L=;ED:(,9G7ESJ\V(:6=:(:67(
:67(
1( :9>=GHD(:67(7EH(9B("*:(%%%( ;D(E9:(+cc(G7=*67H(:6G9CL6(
D:GC*:CG=?(
:6=:(;:(
:6CD(=(K;EH(9B(H98;E=E:J(
@C:(G=:67G(
"&N&/N+@@=EH(
L?9@=?(FG9LG7DD;9E(
:67(@G9=H(FG9LG7DD;9E(
;D(G7=??I(
"/N&UN1J( >67G7(&f(;D(
1J( =*6;7<7H(:6G9CL6(
:>9(
D9(:6=:(1( ;D(G7=*67H(:6G9CL6(
=*:C=??I(*6=EL7H(:9(U( 7E6=G89E;*=??I(
=EH(
=EH(B9CG(
:6=E(:6G9CL6(
:>9(8;E9G(:6;GHD(
8;E9G(:6;GHD(
D*=?7(D:7FD(G=:67G(
D6;B:(
;DJ(=**9GH;EL(:9(,7>;EJ(:67(OB?=>OJ(
B;<7(D*=?7(D:7FDM(#6;D(7E6=G89E;*(
:67(ODF?;*7OJ(:67(O6;HH7E(D7=8O(:6=:(;D( O=( :9F9LG=F6;*=?(9G(L79LG=F6;*=?(
9B(:67(DF=*7D(;E(>6;*6(:67(8CD;*(p9B(!=GD;B=?q(
B7=:CG7(
89<7DOM\\(
9B(:67(
%EH77HJ('?;ELD9GOD(
8=L;*(&]hU(*=D:?7(;D( =E( 78@9H;87E:(
;E(
%:(
O=(B?=>(
:7GG=;E(
>6;*6(
;D(
MMM(
:
67(
87:=F69GMMMM(
:6G9CL6(
L79LG=F6;*=?(
9E7(DF=*7(9B(:67(HG=8=(
:9(=E9:67G(
=EH(@=*K(MMM(%E(
>7(*=E(89<7O(BG98(
;E("*:(%J(>7(H9(E9:(
-:CB7E(
@G9:67G699H(
:67(H;=:9E;*(
DF=*7(9B(:67(2G=;?(
;B(
>
7(
87=DCG7(
D
*=?7(
UC:(:67(8=L;*(
L9(>G9EL(
:9F9LG=F6I(
@I(
H7LG77DM(
=EH(8;G=*?7(9B(:6;ELD(
6=D(@77E(?9D:Y(>7(KE9>(;:(9E?I(;E(D:9GI(
=EH(=D(=(G7D;HC=?(
%E(:6;D(
:G=C8=(
W2CGE78=ESX(
"8B9G:=DXM(
W'CEHGIJ(
=G7(
=D(
B
9G(
:67(
8
;G=*?7D(
6=<7(
-:CB7EN>9G?HJ(
D778J(
:6;ELD( 7P=*:?I( :67I(
@77E(7PFG9FG;=:7H(
:67(
9B(
B9G*7D(
7<;?M(
:9(=EH(
@I(
.E?I(@I(<9I=L;EL(
:67(8=L;*(
:67(D7=8(:6=:(
=E(;E:7GB=*7(
>;:6(
:6G9CL6(
F7G8;:D(
&hU(*=D:?7J(
:67(9:67G(
*=E(!=GD;B=?(
B9G(
:67(
8
;G=*C?9CD(
>9G?HJ(
C?:;8=:7?I(
G7F=:G;=:7(
:67(
B9G*7D(
9B(L99HJ(
>;:6(
:67(
G7:CGE;EL(
-F7=GM\d(
,7>;E(?9*=:7D(:67(DF7*;B;*(
8987E:(
9B(:67(7E6=G89E;*(
D6;B:(
=:(:67(';DD(W"*:(
:6=:('CEHGI(*=H7E*7DJ(9E(:67(>9GH(
%%J(@M[a\XM( "D(67(E9:7DJ(=:(:67(;ED:=E:(
:67(9G*67D:G=(
;E(UM\b(
O'CDDOJ(9E(&fJ(R=LE7G(@7L;ED(E9:=:;EL(
R7( :6CD(6=<7(*987(BC??(*;G*?7J(@=*K(:9(:67(';DDJ( >;:6(>6;*6(9CG(
H;D*CDD;9E(9B(:67( W+J( 4X( 89:;<7(@7L=EJ(B;G8?I(
;E( F9DD7DD;9E(9B(:>9(
:6=E(ACD:(9E7M(UC:(=G7(:67(:>9(*98F=:;@?7J(
=E=?I:;*=?(
F9;E:D(9B(<;7>J(G=:67G(
6=<7(:9(H9(>;:6(9E7(=E9:67Gf(
#67(=ED>7GJ(
;:(D778D(
=EHJ(;B(D9J(>6=:(H9(:67I(
:9( 87J( ;D( 6;E:7H(=:( :9>=GHD(:67( 7EH( 9B(,7>;EOD( =G:;*?7M("E( 7=G?I(
8=E;B7D:=:;9E(
9B(:67("( k&/%UN1(
;E(:67(9F7G=(9**CGD(;E(:67(
FG9LG7DD;9E(
;E(:67(!G7?CH7(:9("*:(%( W@D(ddBBMXM(,7>;E(D69>D(
D7`C7E:;=?(2?=C@7ED:678=(
:6;D( FG9LG7DD;9E(D*678=:;*=??I(=D( B9??9>D(W+PM( ]]XM( T7( :67E(E9:7D(
:6=:(6;D(=@D:G=*:;9E(
;D(;E(B=*:(:67(o=C@7G89:;<J(
=:(:67(<7GI(
;887H;=:7?I(
F;:*6(
?7<7?(=:(>6;*6(;:(9**CGD(=:(:67(8987E:(9B(:67(';DDM\c($7B?7*:;EL(
9E(:67(
VbV(

)Z-%&( "0",5-%-([3\J( ][[^(

This content downloaded from 128.205.114.91 on Sat, 16 Nov 2013 10:40:26 AM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

"( $+4+$+0#%",(

15"1( %0( !"$-%4",(

+PM( ]](1=<;H(,7>;EJ($7HC*:;9E(W:>9(F9DD;@?7(DF7??;ELDX(9B(!=GD;B=?J(
"*:(%J(
@D(ddNbb(
=X(

:(

MMM[XJJ(

%%,(
A?!(
%,(

@X(
%!h(

@( JJ(

%%(

J(

;:(

M(

M(

9B(:6;D(89:;<7(
:67(9F7G=(=D(=(>69?7J(67(DCLL7D:D3(
G=8;B;*=:;9ED(
B9G(
=*:;9E(
9B(:67(9F7G=(;E<9?<7D(
%EH77HJ(:67(HG=8=:;*(
FG7*;D7?I(
O@G;EL;EL(
:67(8=L;*(
D7G<;*7M(
@=*KO(:9(:67(*988CE;9E(
;:(;D(E9:(*?7=G(
-;LE;B;*=E:?IJ(
;D(:6=:(
:67(-:CB7E(
:G=EDB9G8=:;9E(
o=C@7G(
@=*K(:9(:67(
ACD:(>6=:(
O@G;ELD(
,;7@7D8=6?MO\_(
T7(:67E(F9D7D(:67(B9??9>;EL(
W+PM(]VXM(
F9DD;@;?;:;7D(
+PM(]V(1=<;H(,7>;EJ(!9DD;@?7(+E6=G89E;*(
-F7??;ELD(9B(o=C@7G89:;<(
=X(

@X(

\\VV(
V(
AV(

f_\]\(

*X(

09>(>6;*67<7G(
9B(:67(F9DD;@;?;:;7D(
>7(*699D7(N( =EH(B9G(9CG(FCGF9D7D(;:(
N( :67(*GC*;=?(G7?=:;9ED6;F(@G9CL6:(9C:( @I( :67(
8=K7D(?;::?7(H;BB7G7E*7(
:67(o=C@7G89:;<(
;D(;E(B=*:(=(*6G98=:;*(
7P=8F?7(;D(:6=:J(=D(,7>;E(9@D7G<7DJ(
<7GD;9E(9B(:67(,;7@7D8=6?J(
:67(87?9HI(:6=:(9F7ED(:67("*:(%(!G7?CH7J(=EH(:9(
>6;*6(>7(G7:CGE(
=:(:67(7EH(9B(:67(9F7G=J(=B:7G(
:67(O8=L;*O(;D(G7:CGE7H(
:9(:67(
*988CE;9E(
D7G<;*7(
=
*:(
:67(
9B(
!
=GD;B=?M(
:6G9CL6(
%/( 1$")"#%&( $+-.,Z#%.0( "01( #T+( $+&Z!+$"#%.0( .4(
#T+( W+J(4X( 15"1(
T7G7(>7(8=I(=:(?=D:(*=GGI(
9E(>67G7(,7>;E(6=D(?7B:(
>;:6(
9BBJ(
;E*9GF9G=:;EL(
=??(:67(
:6=:(
>
7(6=<7(?7=GE7H(
B
G98(
=EH(*9EE7*:(
6;D(
LG=:;:CH7(
O8=L;*O(
6;8J(
<;7>D(9B(:9E=?(D:GC*:CG7(
:9(:67(W+J( 4X( 89:;<7M("?:69CL6(9E7( F9DD;@?7(
9B(:67(o=C@7G89:;<(
;D(:9(67=G(;:D(;E;:;=?(E9:7D(=D( D;8F?I(
;E:7GFG7:=:;9E(
:67("N&KN+,@@H;8;E;D67H(
=EH(:67E(F=DD;EL(:6G9CL6(
=GF7LL;=:;EL(
:G;=HJ(
+@(:9(
:67(E7;L6@9CG;EL(
D;P:6(
D*=?7(H7LG77J(]4(W=D(;E(+PM(]V=XJ(>7(*=E(=?D9(67=G(:67(
89:;<7(=D( =GF7LL;=:;EL(
=E( "l(8;E9G(:G;=HJ(DC*6( :6=:(1( ;D( =( ?9>7G(
=FF9LL;=:CG=(=EH( 4JJ( =L=;EJ(:67(CFF7G(E7;L6@9CG(W=D( ;E(+PM]V@XM( %:(;D(
:6;D(?=::7G(
:6=:(:67(o=C@7G89:;<(
@7=GD(DC*6(=(D:G;K;EL(
:6G9CL6(
;E:7GFG7:=:;9E(
G7D78@?=E*7(:9(:67(,;7@7D8=6?J(
D;E*7(@9:6(=GF7LL;=:7(
:67("cJ(
:G;=H(W8;E9G(
=EH(8=A9GJ(G7DF7*:;<7?IXJ(
:67E(89<7(CF(:9(:67(D;P:6(
H7LG77J(=EH(:67E(89<7(
)Z-%&("0",5-%-(
[3\J(][[^(

This content downloaded from 128.205.114.91 on Sat, 16 Nov 2013 10:40:26 AM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

Vb\(

!"#$%&'(

)*&$+,+--(

7;:67G(@=*K(:9(+@(W:67(o=C@7G89:;<X(
9G(9E(:9(:67(9*:=<7(W:67(,;7@7D8=6?XM(
#67( :7??;EL(H;BB7G7E*7(
@7:>77E(:67(:>9J(9:67G(:6=E(:67(89H7(9B(:67;G(
=EH(fc(D*=?7(
:G;=HDJ(;DJ(9B(*9CGD7J(:67(D78;:9E7(@7:>77E(:67(@c(
G7DF7*:;<7(
N(
:6=:(
=EH(4M(
:6CD(
;E<9?<7D(
@7:>77E(
.CG(*7E:G=?(
;DJ(
4%W+X(
H
I=H(
H7LG77D(
89G7(:6=E(=(FCG7?I(G7B7G7E:;=?(
D78;:9E7(;E(:67(9F7G=3(;:(;E(B=*:(78@9H;7D(
:6=:(D7F=G=:7D(:67(H;=:9E;*(>9G?H(9B(:67(2G=;?(W:67(,;7@7D8=6?X(
:67(*9EB?;*:(
;E(:6;D(O,7>;E7D`C7O(
=EH(:67(8=L;*(>9G?H(9B('?;ELD9G(W:67(o=C@7G89:;<XY(
D7ED7(;:(;D(:67(OB?=>OJ(:67(ODF?;*7OJ(:67(O6;HH7E(D7=8O(@7:>77E(:67(:>9(
>9G?HDM(.E(:67(9:67G(
@C:(H;BB7G7E:J(
6=EHJ(;E(:67(*98F=:;@?7J(
OW+J(4XO( D7ED7(
9B(:67(FG7D7E:(=E=?ID;D(N(=(D7ED7(B;G8?I(
DCFF9G:7H(
@I(:67(CD7(9B(:67(HI=H(
:67(9F7G=(N(;:(*=E(=?D9(@7(*9ED:GC7H(
:9(@7(O:67(>9CEHO(:6=:(;:(;D(
:6G9CL69C:(
:67(8;DD;9E(9B(:67(9F7G=(:9(67=?M("EH(:6;D(>9CEH(;D(E9:(9E?I(:67(F6ID;*=?(
>;:6(>6;*6J(=D(>7(6=<7(D77EJ(;:(;D(9B:7E(=DD9*;=:7H(
>9CEH(9B("8B9G:=DJ(
;:(;D( =?D9J(=:(=( B=G(89G7(FG9B9CEH(?7<7?J(:67(O>9CEHO(:6=:(
:6G9CL69C:Y(
CEH7G?;7D(:67(@G9=H( O*98;*O( D:GC*:CG7(9B(:67( 9F7G=J(:67(>9CEH(:6=:(
;E(>6;*6(:67(HG=8=(9F7EDM(
D:=:7(9B(=BB=;GD(
:67(DF;G;:C=??I(
>G9EL(
G7FG7D7E:D(
BG98(
;:D(
;D(;E(
=
(
=(
9B(=(*988CE;:I(
#6=:(DF;G;:C=?(
>9CEH(
B=*:( G;B:J( D7F=G=:;9E(
9**=D;9E7H(@I(D;EM(
9>E(O8=L;*OJ(=(D7F=G=:;9E(
"EH(69>(;D(:67(>9CEH(:9(@7(67=?7Hf(%:(8CD:(@7(67=?7HJ(:9(@9GG9>(=(
N(:6=:(;DJ(@I(>9GK;EL(
;:D(
BG98(
;:(:6G9CL6(
:7G8(
*G;:;*DJ(
?;:7G=GI(
@I(G7*CF7G=:;9E(
=
EH(
D:=:7(9B( >G9ELE7DD(9G( ;E*98F?7:;9E(;E:9( =E( 7BB7*:;<7(
G;L6:E7DD(
=EH(@I(DC*6(=(
>69?7E7DD(:6=:(*=E(@7(:67(@=D;D(9B(=E(9EL9;EL(D;:C=:;9EJ(
:G=EDB9G8=:;9E(
:9(G7EH7G(:67(D:9GIOD(*9E:;EC=:;9E(
.E( :67(
CEE7*7DD=GIM\a(
:
6=:(
;D(
=
D(H7D*G;@7H(
>7(
=*6;7<7H(
@I(,7>;EY( 7PF7*:(
L?9@=?(?7<7?J(
G7*CF7G=:;9E(
;E("Y(=EH(:67(*=H7E*7(;E(
=(L;L=E:;*(
*=H7E*7(;E(1J(FG7F=G7H(
@I(=(H98;E=E:(
;E(:67(C?:;8=:7(:9E;*(9B("JJ(
1( :CGED(9C:(:9(6=<7(=(DC@H98;E=E:(
BCE*:;9E(
>6;*6(;D(7<7E:C=??I(
G7D:9G7H(
=(G7=?(
D
C@H98;E=E:(
*=H7E*7J(1@(N("@M(
:6G9CL6(
&?9D7G(:9(:67(DCGB=*7J(
:67(W+J(4X( 89:;<7(=G:;*C?=:7D(
7<7GI(
<;G:C=??I(
D:7F(
"8B9G:=DOD(
:9(!=GD;B=?OD(
G7:CGE(
9B(
=?9EL(:67(>=I(BG98(
67=?;EL(=:(@D(]^V[BBM(
:67(-F7=G(=EH(6;D(=D*7EH;EL(:67(D:7FD(:9(:67(=?:=G(=:(@D(]^aaBBM(
#67(O?7:S:7(
)=?O( D9(B7=G7H(@I(:67(KE;L6:D(
@7B9G7("8B9G:=DOD(
:CGED(
;887H;=:7?I(
!G=I7G(
9C:(E9:(:9(@7(D9(B;E=?(=B:7G(
9B(
=??J(=EH(;ED:7=H(;:(@7*987D(:67(*7?7@G=:;9E(
=EH(:67(G7:CGE(
9B(?;B7(:9(:67(@G9:67G699H(
9B(:67(2G=;?M(#67(
G7H78F:;9E(
7BB7*:;<7(
=L7E:(;E(:6;D(B;GD:(
D:7F(9B(:67(G7H78F:;<7(
FG9*7DD(;DJ(9B(*9CGD7J(
!=GD;B=?(6;8D7?BJ(
B9G(:=K;EL(9<7G("8B9G:=DOD(
;E(
9BB;*7(
>69J(;E(FG7F=G=:;9E(
:67(*988CE;9EJ(
67=?D("8B9G:=DOD(
>9CEH(@I(:9C*6;EL(;:(>;:6(:67(
D7G<;EL(
E9>(G7*?=;87H(-F7=GM(":(@M(]^V[J(=:("8B9G:=DOD(
B;E=?(
>9GHJ(O2G=?OJ(:67(@=DD(
9B(:67(2G=;?(89:;<7J(67G7(;E( 4J( =GF7LL;=:7D(;E( H7D*7EH;EL(89:;9E(:67(
=EH(B=8;?;=G(
>;:6(:67(7PF?;*;:(
89:;9E(BON7O(
:G;=HJ(
F=;EBC?(
=CL87E:7H(
4N&gN"(
;E(:67(:6;GH(
!=GD;B=?OD(
B;GD:(
>9GHD(=:(@M]^\^(@G;EL(
:67("(:6=:(;D(:67(
:GC8F7:M(
H98;E=E:(9B(1J( >6;*6(;D(;:D7?B(
:67(DC@D:;:C:7(
DC@H98;E=E:(
9B(:67(C?:;8=:7(
:9E;*(9B(":JM(
.E(6;D(>9GHDJ(O0CG(7;E7(R=BB7(
:=CL:3(H;7(RCEH7(D*6?;7DD:MMMO(
6;D(<9*=?(?;E7(89<7D(CF(=D(B=G(=D(B:OY(=EH(9E(OH7G(-F77G(ECGOJ(67(D;ELD(:67(
=EH(7O(N(:67(<7GI(
;E(:67(
67=?;EL(E9:7DJ(7gO(
HI=H(:6=:(6=DJ(=:(<=G;9CD(8987E:D(
:67(D7HC*:;9E(9B("8B9G:=D(
9F7G=J(=G:;*C?=:7H(
@I('CEHGIJ(6;D(>9CEHJ(6;D(
Vbd(

)Z-%&( "0",5-%-([3\J( ][[^(

This content downloaded from 128.205.114.91 on Sat, 16 Nov 2013 10:40:26 AM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

"( $+4+$+0#%",(

15"1( %0( !"$-%4",(

6;D(69F7(9B(G7?7=D7(:6G9CL6(:67(DCBB7G;EL(
9B(&6G;D:J(!=GD;B=?OD(
DCBB7G;ELJ(
7E:G=E*7(;E:9(:67(HG=8=J(6;D(B;GD:(
9B(
6
;D(E7=GND7HC*:;9E(
B77?;ELD( F;:IJ(
@I(
6;D(G7ECE*;=:;9E(
9B(67G(:6G9CL6(
6;D(<;D;9E(9B("8B9G:=DOD(
'CEHGIJ(
F=;EJ(6;D(
9B('CEHGI(:6G9CL6(
@7;EL(6;8D7?B(OG7*CF7G=:7HOJ(6;D(9>E( OG7*CF7G=:;ELO(
6
;D(
"
8B9G:=D(
9B(
:67(G7:CGE(
9B(:67(
@=F:;D8(=EHJ(E9>J( OG7*CF7G=:;ELO(
:6G9CL6(
-F7=GM(
#67( F9>7GBC?(
"(8=A9G(:9E=?(*7E:G;*;:I(
9B(@D(]^\bBBM(
8=DKD(:67(=*:C=?(
=
EH(
9B(*G9DDNG7B7G7E*7D(
:6=:(*6=G=*:7G;S7D(
:67(
E7:>9GK;EL(
*98F?7P;:I(
*=H7E*7(9B(@D(]^\dNbM(#67(2g(
H98;E=E:(
;E(:67(D7*9EH(6=?B(9B(@M(]^\d(*9C?H(
/_(9G(:67(L?9@=?(DC@H98;E=E:J(
@7J(7E6=G89E;*=??IJ(
1@(W&fXM( .GJ(;:(*9C?H(
=?D9(G7D9?<7J(
=(>69?7(
:
9E7(
:
9(UnJ(
:67(K7I(>6;*6(;E(
=L=;E(7E6=G89E;*=??IJ(
CF(
@D(b[[Nc^V(9B("*:(%( DC@D:;:C:7H(
"
(=:(:67(B;GD:(
B9G(
87E:;9E(9B(:67(
@G;7B?I(
9B(H7?;<7G=E*7(
87=ED(9B(:67(
=EH(:67(2G=;?(BG98(
&6G;D:OD(
@I(
69F7(
-F7=G(
=EH(:67(K7I(;E(>6;*6(!=GD;B=?(
7E:7GD(
:67(HG=8=M(
&GC*;B;P;9EJ(
.B(*9CGD7J(:67(*=H7E*7(:6=:(G7=??I(9**CGD(;E(@M]^\b(;D(E9:(=(*=H7E*7(:9(
U@(9G(1@J(@C:(9E7(:9("Y( =EH(67G7(R=LE7G(B9??9>D(D9?;H?I(;E(:67(@7D:(
:G=H;:;9E(
9B(T=IHEJ()9S=G:J(U77:69<7E(=EH(-*6C@7G:(;E(:67(8=EE7G(;E(
>6;*6(67(@7L;ED(:9(G7D9?<7(:67(+N4(*9EB?;*:(
9C:(9B(:67(>9GKM(T7G7J(;E(:67(
*9E:7P:(9B("( 8=A9G(N( >6;*6J(>7(8CD:(G7878@7GJ(
;D(9E?I(=( FG7?;8;E=GI(
N(67(G7*CF7G=:7D(
G7D9?C:;9E(
:67(H;D:CG@;EL(
*6G98=:;*(
7?787E:(
:6=:(;D(*7E:G=?(
:9(:67(:9E=?(OF?9:O( 9B(:67(F;7*7(@I(;E*9GF9G=:;EL(
;:(;E:9(=E( 7DD7E:;=??I(
G7D9?<7H(
H;=:9E;*(D;:C=:;9E(
=D(U77:69<7E(H97D(>;:6(&f(=EH(4f(;E(:67(
WG=:67G(
*9H=( 9B(:67(B;E=?(89<787E:(9B(:67(-7<7E:6(-I8F69EIXM(#6CDJ( =:(@D(
>67G7("(8=A9G(G7;LED(
;E(CE`C7D:;9E7H(H;=:9E;*(DCFG78=*IJ(
>7(L7:(
]^\bBBMJ(
:67(*7??9(:6787(=DD9*;=:7H(>;:6("8B9G:=DOD(
F=;E(W"*:(%J(@D(VcdBBMXJ(E9>(
*?7=G?I(;E("(8=A9GJ(=(:6;GH(
6;L67G(:6=E(;E(;:D(9G;L;E=?(
=FF7=G=E*7J(D9(:6=:(
E9>(:67(<9;*7(@7=G;EL(
:67(W+J(4X(HI=H(;D(E9:(:67(@=DD(@C:(:67(:6;GH(
6;L67D:(
<9;*7(9B(:67(=**98F=EI;EL(
;:(:6CD(89<7D(CF(G=:67G(
:6=E(H9>EJ(
6=G89E;7DY(
=EH(;EH77H(:9(=(D=:;DBI;EL(
G7D9?C:;9E(
:9(:67(:9E;*(WD77(:67(D7*9EH(<;9?;E(?;E7J(
H9C@?7H( ;E( :67(>;EHDJ(7ON7gONBgONLgON=OXM(
:67(;E;:;=?(*69GH(
4CG:67G89G7J(
:67(*7??9(87?9HI(67G7(;D(E9>(=( 8=A9G(:G;=H(G=:67G(
:6=E(=(
=**98F=EI;EL(
H;DD9E=E:(9E7J(B9G(:67(4(:6=:(;E;:;=??I(
8=H7(:67(D9E9G;:I(
;D(E9>(
=CL87E:7H(
OG7D9?<7HO(:9(9G(G7F?=*7H(@I(+( W*BM(:67(9G;L;E=?(
=FF7=G=E*7(9B(:67(87?9HI(=:(
"*:(%J(@MVcdXM(
T9>7<7GJ(;:(;D(*?7=G(:6=:(:67(G7D9?C:;9E(9B(:67(W+J( 4X( HI=HJ(=:(?7=D:(
;ED9B=G(
=D(;:(;D(G7=??I(
G7D9?<7H(;E(:6;D(D7*:;9E(;E("(8=A9GJ(;D(H7F7EH7E:(?7DD(
?;E7=G(H;G7*:;9E(
:6=E( CF9E( :9E=?( =EH( HG=8=:;*(*9E:7P:(N( :67(
CF9E(
9
B(
:67(
89:;<7(;E:9(
=( G7?=:;<7?I(CE=8@;LC9CD(H;=:9E;*(
;E*9GF9G=:;9E(
D:GC*:CG7(
=EH(;:D(*9E:;EC=?(*99GH;E=:;9E(
>;:6(OG7D9?<;ELO(
>9GHD(;E(:67(:7P:M(
;:(
;D(
:67(
@
G9=H(
9B(
*9E:7P:( >6=:(>7(CEH7GD:=EH(
#6CDJ(
BG98(
:67(:7P:J(
9B(>6=:(
>7(67=G(;E(:67(8CD;*(WH;=:9E;*;D8J(
E7>(9G*67D:G=:;9E(
=EH(D9(
8=A9G(:G;=HDJ(
B9G:6X(=EH(9B(>6=:(>7(D77(9E( D:=L7(W:67(67=?;EL(9B("8B9G:=DJ(
6;D(B=*7(
D6;E;EL(O>;:6(69?I(G=F:CG7OXJ(=?9EL(>;:6(>6=:(?;:7G=??I(
6=FF7ED(:9(:67(
89:;<7J(:6=:(?7=HD( CD( :9( ;E:7GFG7:(;:( =D( 6=<;EL(@77E( G7D9?<7HM(R7(
B9G(:67(G78=;E;EL(W+J(4X(
;ED:;E*:;<7?I(
FG9<;H7(=( D;8;?=G(;E:7GFG7:=:;9E(
)Z-%&( "0",5-%-( [3\J(

][[^(

This content downloaded from 128.205.114.91 on Sat, 16 Nov 2013 10:40:26 AM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

Vbb(

!"#$%&'(

)*&$+,+--(

;E(:67("(8=A9G(F=DD=L7(=:(@D(]^\^Nbc3(B9G(!=GD;B=?OD(
ACP:=F9D;:;9ED(
7ONB(9E(
O-7;(67;?eO(W@D(]^\aN[XJ(B9G(:67(4N+(;E(:67(@=DD(9B(@D(]^d^N](9E(:67(>9GH(
B9G(:67(;EE7GN<9;*7(7VNBNBgV(
9E(:67(*GC*;=?(>9GHD(O17EE( ;*6(
O7E:D:;6E:OJ(
<7G>=?:7(
ECE(H7;E("8:OJ(B9G(:67(D=87(;EE7GN<9;*7(
=E(9*:=<7(
FG9LG7DD;9EJ(
?9>7GJ(9E(O27D7LE7:(D7;(H7;E(,7;H7EO(;E(@D(]^dcN_J(=EH(B9G(:67(G7:G9LG=H7(
9B(:67(D=87(FG9LG7DD;9EJ(
=E(9*:=<7(?9>7G(I7:J(9E(OH78(S=L7E(#69G7E(L=@O(
;E(@D(]^bdNbM(
"B:7G(:67(*?;8=*:;*(*=H7E*7(9E( 1( =:( @M]^b_J( :67(W+J( 4X( 89:;<7(;D(
:6787(D9CEHD(9C:(;E(=(@G;??;=E:?I(
H;=:9E;*(
=@D7E:J(=D(!=GD;B=?OD(
:78F9G=G;?I(
1( 8=A9GM(!=GD;B=?OD(
B;GD:(
>9GHD(=B:7G(
:6;D(*=H7E*7(=EE9CE*7(6;D(G7:CGE(
9B(:67(
9B(:67(2G=;?(WO17E( 67;?OL7E(-F77GJ(;*6(@G;EL(;6E(
-F7=G(:9(:67(@G9:67G699H(
7C*6(SCG:;*Ke(
.6e(R7?*67E(RCEH7GOD(6.*6D:7D(
2?:;*KeOXM(#67(8CD;*(67G7(
G7D9E=:7D(>;:6(G7B7G7E:;=?(
=EH( W+J( 4X( HI=HD(;E(=(
*69GHDJ(DC@D:;:C:;9ED(
G;9:(9B(R=LE7G;=E(DI8@9?;D8M(
<;G:C=?(
#67(2W(8=A9G(:G;=H(=:(:67(@7L;EE;EL(
9B(:67(+EL7?89:;<(
:9?H(9B(
W@M(]^cdX(G7*=??D(:67(2f(;E(>6;*6(2CGE78=ES(B;GD:(
:67(=EL7?OD(7E:GCD:;EL(
:67(2G=;?(=EH(-F7=G(:9(:67(KE;L6:D(
W"*:(%J(@D(b_bN[]J(
c]dNVVY( >7( 6=<7(E9:(H7=?:(=:( =??(;E(:6;D(=E=?ID;D(>;:6(:67(2&XM(#6;D(
9B(:67(89:;<7(
=??9>D(:67(ACP:=F9D;:;9E(
9B(FCG7(Un(
8;E9G(=EH("(
:G=EDF9D;:;9E(
8=A9G(:G;=HD(9E( :67(H9>E@7=:D(9B(@D( ]^cb( =EH( ]^ccJ( >;:6(:67(:G;=HD(
D7F=G=:7?I(9G( :9L7:67G(@7=G;EL(:67( =**C8C?=:7H(>7;L6:(9B( 87=E;EL(
=DD9*;=:7H(>;:6(!=GD;B=?(WUnXJ("8B9G:=DOD(>9CEH( W"( 8=A9G( :G;=H(;E(
=DD9*;=:;9E(>;:6(BN7V(9B(CFF7G(<9;*7X(=EH(&6G;D:OD(F=DD;9E(WACP:=F9D;:;9E(
9B(
8;E9G(=EH("(8=A9G(:G;=HDJ(=L=;E(>;:6(ACP:=F9D;:;9E(
9B(B( =EH(7VXM( #67(
Un(
9B(:67(+EL7?89:;<(
=(D78;:9E7(
;E(@D(]^c_N(
D7`C7E*7(W9G(DC@D:;:C:;9EfX(
6;L67G(
[( H7?=ID(:67(?;:7G=?(=FF7=G=E*7(9B(4N7V( CE:;?(@M]^c[Y( 69>7<7GJ(9E7( ;D(
:9(DF7*C?=:7(:6=:(:67(U(8;E9G(=EH(Un(
:78F:7H(
8=A9G(:G;=HD(9B(@D(]^c[(=EH(
]^_^(;E(B=*:(
B9G(
DC@D:;:C:7(
8;E9G(
=
EH("(8=A9G(:G;=HDJ(
DC*6(:6=:(
Un(
8=L;*=??I(
N
(
=
(DC@D:;:C:7(
B9G(
4
N7V(
9B(
D;E*7(
;D(G7=??I(
=(E9:(CE?;K7?I(
F;7*7( >;S=GHGIJ(
BgVNB(
:67(ACP:=F9D;:;9E(
9B(2(=EH(U(:G;=HD(
;E(@D(]^c_(=EH(]^ca(D:G9EL?I(
G7*=??(:67(
>9G?H(9B('?;ELD9GJ(
=EH(:67(*99GH;E=:;9E(
9B('?;ELD9GOD(K7I(9B(U(8;E9G(>;:6(
:67(>9GH(ORCEH7GO(9E(:67(H9>E@7=:(9B(@M]^ca( ;D(F=G:;*C?=G?I(
;E:G;LC;EL(
@=*K(9B(:67(8=L;*OfXM(
W:67(O@G;EL;EL(
!=GD;B=?OD(B;E=?(>9GHDJ(=:(@D( ]^_^NaaJ(@G;EL(:67(*7E:G=?(DI8@9?D(9B(:67(
HG=8=(N(:67(>9CEHJ(:67(-F7=G(=EH(:67(2G=;?(N(:9L7:67G(
B9G(
:67(?=D:(:;873(
17G(H7;E7(
RCEH7(
HCGB:7(
D*6?;7DD7EJ(
;68(
D76O(;*6(67;?OL7D(
U?C:(
7E:B?;7DD7E(
;E(-76EDC*6:(
E=*6(H78(<7G>=EH:7E(
tC7??7J(
H7G(H9G:(
B?;7DD:(
;E(H7D(2G=?7D(
R7??7M(
0;*6:(
D9;?(H7G(876G(
<7GD*6?9DD7E(
D7;Ee(
+E:6;;??7:(
H7E(2G=?J(
H7E(-*6G7;Ee(
.BBE7:(
T;D(>9GHD(67G7(=G7(D:G;*:?I(
*9ED;D:7E:(
>;:6(:67(F9;E:(9B(<;7>(7?=@9G=:7H(
:67(:7P:(9B(:67(HG=8=J(=EH(*9GG7*:?I(
9@D7G<7H(
:6G9CL69C:(
@I(,7>;E3(:6=:(;DJ(
Vbc(

)Z-%&(

"0",5-%-(

This content downloaded from 128.205.114.91 on Sat, 16 Nov 2013 10:40:26 AM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

[3\J( ][[^(

"($+4+$+0#%",(

15"1( %0( !"$-%4",(

=D(:67(>9CEH(=EH(;:D(67=?;EL(=G7J(:67I(=G7(D7*9EH=GI(:9(:67(
;8F9G:=E:(
9B(:67(-F7=GJ(:67(O9@?;L=:9GI(
G7:CGE(
D:GC*:CG=?(
L7D:CG7O(9B(:67(HG=8=M(#6CD(
:67(-F7=GJ(E9:(:67(>9CEHJ(;D(:67(DC@A7*:(9B(!=GD;B=?OD(
B;E=?(
:7P:M(
67(
"?:69CL6(
;E(6;D(
>
9GHD(
:
67(
:
6=:(
6=D(67=?7H(:67(
>9CEH(
=*KE9>?7HL7D(
9F7E;EL(
-F7=G(
W67( O:6G9>D(;:(=>=IOXJ(:67(:7P:(67G7(G7=??I(B9*CD7D(9E(6;D(8=*=@G7J(@C:(
<;D;9E3(67(D77D(:67(-F7=G(B?9>;EL(
>;:6(@?99HJ\[(
>6;*6(
7DD7E:;=?J(
DI8@9?;*=??I(
D77KD(:9(A9;E(:67(B9CE:=;E(
:6=:(;D(;:D(D9CG*7J(:67(2G=;?M(.GJ(:9(G7EH7G(:67D7(
DI8@9?D(=D( ;H7=DJ(!=GD;B=?J(6=<;EL(67=?7H(:67(=*:C=?(F6ID;*=?(>9CEH(9B(
>;:6(:67(-F7=GJ(*=E(E9>(89<7(9E(:9(67=?(:67(89G7(;8F9G:=E:(
"8B9G:=D(
G
N( :67(DID:78;*(
H;D7=D7(9B(>6;*6(:67(>9CEH(;:D7?B(;D(@C:(=(
DF;G;:C=?( ;B:(
N(
8=E;B7D:=:;9E(
:6=:(
6
=D(L;<7E(G;D7(:9(:67(7E:;G7(
HG=8=M(#67(G;:C=?(
F6ID;*=?(
9B(
:67(
@?99H(9B(
:67(
=EH(:6=:(
9
B(
:67(
2G=;?(
G7:CGED(
:67(8=L;*(
CE;:;EL(
-F7=G(
:6=:(>=D(?9D:(WDI8@9?;*=??IJ(
:67(-F7=GX(:9(;:D(D9CG*7(N( =(D9CG*7(:6=:(;DJ(@I(
:67(>=IJ(;H7E:;B;7H(
67G7(=D(7PF?;*;:?I(
=EH(:9(>6;*6(!=GD;B=?(
6;8D7?B(
;D(
H;<;E7J(
N( =EH(;:(;D(:6;D(G7*?=8=:;9E(9B(>6=:(>=D(>G9ELJ(>6=:(>=D(
DC@D7G<;7E:d^(
9B(:67(2G=;?J(:67(
;E*98F?7:7J(:6=:(F7G8;:D(6;8(:9(9GH7G(:67(CE*9<7G;EL(
9
B(
:
67(
=D(;:(
:
9(
:67(
H
G=8=:;*(
D:GC*:CG7M(
D
6G;E7J(
=EHJ(
>
7G7J(
9F7E;EL(
*98F?7:7(
;D(=?D9(F7GB7*:?I(
*9ED;D:7E:M(
#67( W+J( 4X(
R=LE7GOD(8CD;*=?(DI8@9?;D8(
67G7(=D(:6G9CL69C:(
:67(9F7G=J(DI8@9?;S7D(
@9:6(:67(F6ID;*=?(
>9CEH(
89:;<7J(
=EH(:67(DF;G;:C=?(
H;D:G7DD(
:6=:(;D(=:(:67(G99:(9B(:67(HG=8=M(#67( L9=?(9B(:67(
8CD;*(:9(>6;*6(!=GD;B=?OD(?=D:(>9GHD(=G7(D7:(;D(:9(G7D9?<7(:67(W+J(4X( 9C:(9B(
:67(:9E=?(D:GC*:CG7(
9E*7(=EH(B9G(=??J(>;:6;E(
:67(@G9=H7G(*9E:7P:(
9B(G7D9?<;EL(
:67(L?9@=?(:9E=?(D:GC*:CG7J(
9E( :67(
>6;*6J(9B(*9CGD7J(:CGED(FG;E*;F=??I(
D:GC*:CG=?(
:67(O8=L;*=?O(1( 9B(:67(-F7=G(:9(
O9@?;L=:9GI(
L7D:CG7O(9B(G7:CGE;EL(
:67("@(9B(:67(2G=;?M(
#67( 8CD;*(9B(@D( ]^_^Nb( FG7B;LCG7D(
:67(D:GC*:CG=?(
1N"J( 89:;9E(9B(
@D(]^adN_M(U=GD(]^_^NV(@7L;E(>;:6(:67(1( 8;E9Gh4(
8=A9G(=G7=(;E(>6;*6(>7(
F7G*7;<7H("8B9G:=DOD(
7PF7G;7E*7(9B(F=;E(W"*:(%J(@D(VcdBBMXY(:67E(:67I(=G7(
D7`C7E*7H(89G7(9G(?7DD(?;:7G=??I(
CF( =( 8;E9G(:6;GH(;E(@D(]^_\NbJ(>6;*6(
7D:=@?;D6("lJ(=EH(>6;*6(*G7=:7(=( 87?9H;*(=EH(6=G89E;*(
CE=8@;LC9CD?I(
B9G(:67(G6I87(
#67G7(=G7(=(EC8@7G(9B(E;*7(
F=G=??7?;D8(
D*6?;7DD7Eh7E:B?;7DD7EM(
:9E=?(=EH(89:;<;*(:9C*67D(67G7M(#67( D:G;EL(
:G789?9D(=EH(:67(6=G89E;*(
=8@;7E*7(G7*=??("*:(%J(@D(b[VN\M(":(:67(D=87(:;87J(:67(>9GH(ORCEH7O(;D(
G7=?;S7H(87?9H;*=??I(
9E(=N=GJ(DCLL7D:;EL(
7<7G(D9(B?77:;EL?I(
=(G7D9?C:;9E(
BG98(
:67("h1(=G7=(=DD9*;=:7H(>;:6(:67(>9CEH(:9(1@J(:67(OG7=?O(DC@H98;E=E:(
9B(
:67(>9GH(OD*6?;7DD7EO(;D(D7:(:9(:67(E9:7D(7NBY(:67(>9CEH(
"@M()9G7(9@<;9CD?IJ(
=D(:67(6=G89EI(
:CGED(:9>=GH(":M(
O*?9D7DO(9E(W+J(4X( FG7*;D7?I(
":(@D(]^c[J(
]^_V( =EH( ]^_bJ( :67( =D*7EH;EL(B9CG:6(89:;<7(W69GED(=EH( *?=G;E7:DX(
=DD9*;=:7H(>;:6(:67(-F7=G(=EH(CDC=??I(;E(1( 9G(1@(;D(D7`C7E*7H(:6G9CL6(
D:=:787E:D(
9E(BJ(=@?(=EH(@OJ(DC*6(:6=:(]X(:67(DC**7DD;<7(
B;GD:(
E9:7D(
@7L;EE;EL(
9B(:67(:6G77(D:=:787E:D(
=G:;*C?=:7(
=(H;8;E;D67H(
:G;=H(:6=:(6;E:D(=:(:67(>9G?H(
9B(o=C@7G(:6=:(;D(67G7(@7;EL(G7*?=;87H(B9G(:67(B9G*7D(9B(L99HY( VX( :67(
D:=:787E:(
;E("@J(
;D(*99GH;E=:7H(>;:6(:67(:7P:(H7D*G;@;EL(
:67(*?9D;EL(9B(:67(
E9:7(9B(:67(:6G77(D:=:787E:D(
;D(BJ(:67(?=D:(7V(N( =(
>9CEHY(=EH(\X( :67(B;GD:(
G7?=:;9ED6;F(
6;L6?;L6:7H(
@I(!=GD;B=?OD(
r( ;E(@M]^c[(=EH(6;D(7V(;E(@M]^_bJ(>;:6(
)Z-%&( "0",5-%-( [3\J(

][[^(

This content downloaded from 128.205.114.91 on Sat, 16 Nov 2013 10:40:26 AM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

Vb_(

!"#$%&'(

)*&$+,+--(

E9(6;L67G(
E9:7D(;E(:67(;E:7G;8M(
#67(B;GD:(
>6;*6(G7;:7G=:7(
:67(89:;<7(
<;9?;EDJ(
@D(]^_VN\J(=*6;7<7(LO(=:(:67(H9>E@7=:(9B(@M(]^_dJ(=:(>6;*6(
7ONB(:6G9CL69C:(
H;G7*:;9E(
=EH(89<7(@=*K(:6G9CL6(
B( =EH(B@O(=D(:67(:7P:(
F9;E:(:67I(G7<7GD7(
:9(H7D*G;@7(
:67(
9B(:67(
@?99H(@=*K(:9(:67(2G=;?M(
@7L;ED(
B?9>;EL(
-F7=GOD(
=G:;*C?=:7(
:67(
4;E=??IJ(:67(87?9H;*(E9:7D(:9(:67(G6I87(
D*6?;7DD7Eh7E:B?;7DD7E(
89:;9E(7ONB(NLON=]OJ(:67G7@I(
:67(
;E:9(
:67(
G7=?8(
9B(
W+J(4X(
@G;EL;EL(
"@(
HI=H(
G=:67G(
:6=E(:6=:(9B(:67("(9B(:67(=*:C=?(67=?;EL(9B(:67(>9CEH(W*BM(@D(]^\bN[XM(
":(:67(;ED:=E:(
=:(>6;*6(:67(@?99H(9E(:67(-F7=G(@7L;ED(:9(B?9>(:9>=GHD(
:67(2G=;?(W@M]^_bXJ( =??(:67(8CD;*=?(B9G*7D(;E(:67(F=DD=L7(*9=?7D*7(:9(FG7DD(
:9>=GHD(:67(*9E*?CD;<7(/N%(*=H7E*7(;E("@(=:(@D(]^a_NaM(U7B9G7(*9ED;H7G;EL(
:67(8=EI(>9EH7GBC?(
H7:=;?D(9B(:67(F=DD=L7J(>7(D69C?H(G7<;7>(@G;7B?I(
:>9(
*9EB?;*:;EL(
F9;E:D(9B(<;7>(*9E*7GE;EL(:6;D(*=H7E*7M( ,9G7ES( =::G;@C:7D(
7E9G89CD(D:GC*:CG=?(
>7;L6:(:9(:67(H98;E=E:(*=H7E*7(=EH( CD7D( ;:J(;E(
:9( =GLC7(B9G(6;D( L?9@=?( :9E=?( ;E:7GFG7:=:;9E(
9B("*:( %%%( =D(
G7:G9DF7*:J(
=(FG9LG7DD;9E(
BG98(
8;E9G(=:(:67(@7L;EE;EL(
Un(
;E<9?<;EL(
WCD;EL(6;D($;78=EE(
BCE*:;9E(
:9(1( 8;E9GJ(
:67(,7;::9E>7*6D7?K?=EL(
9B(UnJ(
=EH(
DI8@9?D(-F(;E(":X(
:6CD(C?:;8=:7?I(
=(K;EH(9B(/h/(;E(":J(
;E("8B9G:=DOD(
:9(:67(+f(:G;=H(9B(
!G=I7GJ(
:6CD(L;<;EL(
:67(?=GL7ND*=?7(
@M]^_aJ(:9(:67("c(9B(@D( ]^aaBBMJ(
W;E(
FG9LG7DD;9E(
$;78=EE;=E(:7G8DX(-FNW1XNp1qN#Md]( ,7>;EJ(9E(:67(9:67G(6=EHJ(DCLL7D:D(
:6=:(:6;D(G7=H;EL(
<;9?7E*7(
:9(=??(:67(
B7=:CG7D(
9B(:67(
1Y(
F?=L=?(
?=GL7ND*=?7(
MMM( H97D(7P:G787(
;:(DCG7?I(
:
99(
B
=GM(
6;D(
;D(
@;S=GG73(
6;D(
U7D;H7DJ( FG9LG7DD;9E(=@D:G=*:?I(
L97D(
=(?=GL7ND*=?7(
E7<7G(
CE?7DD(
,9G7ES(
+c(>6;*6(
W1X(p1q(:9E;*;S7D(
=FF7=GDJ(
+?( 6=G89EI(
87=ED(:67(D9?;:=GI(
9B(p@M]^_aq(:9(*=GGI(
:67(D:GC*:CG=?(
H98;E=E:(
B9G(
:67(
7E:;G7(
D7*9EH(
6=?B(
9B("*:(%%%MdV(
>7;L6:(
87G;:D(
9B(,9G7ESOD(G7=H;EL(=EH(6;D(9>E(
29;EL(9E(:9(*98F=G7(:67(G7?=:;<7(
6;D(
:67(
89<787E:(
;E(@D(]^adN_(=D(:67(D:GC*:CG=?(
W:6=:(;DJ( ;H7E:;BI;EL(
1N"J(
>
;:6(
67(
E9:7D3(
*=H7E*7J(
F?=L=?(87=E;ELXJ(
H98;E=E:(
1(8;E9G(
B9G(
=D(=(
UC:J(ACD:(=D(,9G7ESOD(
G7=H;EL(
L97D(:99(B=G(
D9(
9B(
]^adNac(
?=GL7ND*=?7(
F67E987E9EJ(8I(
F?=L=?(
G7=H;EL( %%%J(
L97D(:99(
B=G(
=D(=(?9*=?(G7=H;ELJ(
;ED9B=G(
=D(;:(H7E;7D(
B9G*7(
:9(
:
67(
9
@<;9CD(
?9*=?(
=EI(
W1v(11X( p1qY(#Md\(
G7=H;EL(
)I(9>E(<;7>(;D(:6=:(:67(O?9*=?(*=H7E*7O(=:(@D(]^adNa(;DJ(=D(;:(;D(B9G(
,9G7ESJ(=(L?9@=?(/N%(*=H7E*7Y(@C:(:6=:J(
,7>;EJ(:67(:9E=?(D;:C=:;9E(
B9??9>;EL(
9B(:67(9F7G=(=?D9(H78=EHDJ(=EH(G7*7;<7DJ(
=(DC@H98;E=E:(
*=H7E*7J(DC*6(:6=:(
"8B9G:=DOD(
;E(BCE*:;9EJ(
@C:(:67(*=H7E*7(67G7(@9:6(
!G=I7G(;D(DC@H98;E=E:(
H98;E=E:(
=EH(L?9@=?(;E(7BB7*:M(
69>(:67D7(*=H7E*7D(>9GK(G7`C;G7D(=( *?9D7(?99K(=:(:67(
ZEH7GD:=EH;EL(
@=DD(?;E7J(@7L;EE;EL(
>;:6(;:D(*6=EL7(9B(H;G7*:;9EJ(
;E(=DD9*;=:;9E(>;:6(:67(
=:(@D(]^_dBBM(
:7P:J(9E(:67(>9GHD(OU?C:(7E:B?;7DD7EO(
+P=8F?7(]\(D69>D(:67(
@=DD(?;E7(9B(@D]^_dNaaM( #67( 87=E;EL(9B(:6;D(@=DD(?;E7(%( :=K7(:9(@7( =D(
Vba(

)Z-%&( "0",5-%-([3\J( ][[^(

This content downloaded from 128.205.114.91 on Sat, 16 Nov 2013 10:40:26 AM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

"( $+4+$+0#%",(

15"1( %0( !"$-%4",(

"*:(%%%J(@D(]^_dNaa(
+PM(]\(U=DD(,;E7(9B(!=GD;B=?J(
?c[[( ?(

:9(
?;E7(BG98(:67(+f(9B(@M]^_d( =::78F:D(
B9??9>DM(#67( =D*7EH;EL(*6G98=:;*(
67G7(
*
6G98=:;*(
7?787E:(
:67(
*
GC*;=?(
;E:9(
W
+J(4XJ(
D
F7?:(
G7*CF7G=:7( "@(
4c+N+f(
@7*=CD7(:67(?;E7OD(
69>7<7GJ(;D(CEDC**7DDBC?J(
W@D( ]^_bNcXM( #6;D( =::78F:J(
=D*7E:(:9>=GHD("@(;D(;E:7GGCF:7H(
@I(:67(1( 9B(@M]^_aM( #6;D(1( 6=D(:>9(
BCE*:;9EDM(
4;GD:J(;:(;8F=G:D(=( FG9B9CEH(H9C@?7(87=E;EL(:9(:67(
;8F9G:=E:(
:9(;:D(D9CG*7J(:67(2G=;?(W;E("@XJ(@C:(:67(
>9GH(OtC7??7O3(:67(@?99H(;D(G7:CGE;EL(
D9CG*7(9B(:6=:(@?99H(>=D(&6G;D:OD(W=EH(@I(7P:7ED;9EJ(
G7=?N?;B7(
"8B9G:=DODX(
:9(1( ;E(@M]^_a(;D(B9G7D6=H9>7H(
@I(:67("(8=A9G(
W;E(1XM( #6;D(:CGE(
DCBB7G;EL(
9B(@D(]^_cN_(
:G;=H(=EH(:67(FCEL7E:(
7VN+f(H;DD9E=E*7(;E(@M(]^_cJ(:67(DF7??;EL(
D:=:787E:(
=EH(:67(/V(.B(1(;E(@M(]^__Y(;:(=?D9(8=K7D(F9DD;@?7(=(?=D:(6=G89E;*(
9B(1(8;E9GM(-7*9EHJ(:67(:CGE(
W;E(@M]^_aX( 9B(:67(W+J(4X(HI=H(;E(:67(*9E:7P:(
:9(1( 67G7J(=?9EL(>;:6(:67(1( 8;E9G(DF7??;EL(9B(@D( ]^_cNaJ(8=K7D(;:(*?7=G(
;:D(?9ELNG=EL7(
89:;9E(@7L=E(9E("JJ(;E<9?<7D(
:6=:(:67(@=DD(89:;9EJ(=?:69CL6(
B9G(:67(:;87(@7;EL(E9:(=( D:7F>;D7(=D*7E:(:9("JJ(@C:(=E(=D*7E:(:9("( W=D(
B9G(
DC@D:;:C:7(
"@XM(
9B(:67(
=D(=(H98;E=E:(
":(@M(]^a^(:67(1( ;D(=HACD:7H(:9(+cJ(>6;*6(BCE*:;9ED(
;
E(:CGE(
:
67(
89:;9E(
>6;*6(
;:D(
=GG;<=?(
*98F?7:7D(
?9ELNG=EL7(
W@M]^a]XJ(
@
I(
":J(
@M]^a](:67(@=DD(89:;9E(:9>=GHD(:67(
BG98(+c(:9("@(;E(@D(]^_dNa]M("B:7G(
;D(
>;:6(=?:7GE=:7(
@=GD(@7L;EE;EL(
=:(
*=H7E*7(
89G7(
D:GC*:CG=?(
D:G=;L6:B9G>=GHJ(
@M(]^a](=G:;*C?=:;EL(
:67(89:;9E("Ni4(
N4N+/N"@M(
#67(CFF7G(F=G:D(9B(@D(]^_bNa]J(?;K7(:67(@=DDJ(@7L;E(=(DCGL7(:9>=GHD(
:67(
;E(
=GG;<=?(
9B(:67("@(
@M(
@C:(
H
9(E9:(
=*6;7<7(
G
7D9?C:;9E(
:9(
]^a]J(
6=G89EI(
:67I(
#67(
@D(
G7<7GD7D(
;
:D(H;G7*:;9E(
-F7=G(89:;<7J(@ON*%VNH(VN7VJ( 9B( ]^_bNcJ(
"@M(
>67E(;:(G7=*67D(;:D(6;L67D:(
<;9?;ED(H;H(;E(@D(]^_VNdM(":(
E9:7J(ACD:(=D(:67(B;GD:(
:6;D(7V(9B(@M]^_cJ(!=GD;B=?OD(
<9*=?(?;E7(87GL7D(>;:6(:67(87?9HI(:6=:(@7L=E(
>;:6(:67(-F7=G(89:;<7(;E(:67(FG7*7H;EL(
@=GM(#67(87?9HI(69<7GD(=G9CEH(7]V(
=EH(HVJ(:67(D78;:9E7D(9E(7;:67G(D;H7(9B(7/VJ(
:67E(H7D*7EHD(;E(>6=:(*9C?H(
@
7*987(=(-*67EK7G;=E(
D:GC*:CG=?(
H7D*7E:(
;E(@D(]^_aNa]J(7P*7F:(:6=:(
7=D;?I(
:67(D78;:9E7D(
H9(E9:(
G7D9?<7(
:
9(
7/(
;:J(=EH(:67(7PF7*:7H(=@O(9B(
DCGG9CEH;EL(
@M]^a]( ;D( G7F?=*7H(@I(=( 87?9H;*(@O](>6;?7(=( D7<7E:6(;D(=HH7H( :9(:67(
!=GD;B=?OD(7V( =EH(HV(G7D9?<7(:9(:67(
"@(
G7D9?<;EL(
6=G89EIM(07<7G:67?7DDJ(
;E(
?9>7GN9*:=<7(
@M(
B9G(
9B(:67(D=87(E9:7D(;E(
]
^a]J(
7@(
FG7F=G;EL( :67(G7D9?C:;9E(
:67(*9GG7*:(
;E(@D(]^a_NaM(
G7L;D:7G(
)9G7(:9(:67(F9;E:(>;:6(G7DF7*:(:9(:67(=E=?I:;*=?(<;7>(9B(:67(FG7D7E:(
7DD=IJ(@D( ]^_bNaa(B;E=??I(
FCGL7(:67(:G9C@?7D987(W+J( 4X( HI=H(BG98(:67(
;E(:67(9G*67D:G=(
9F7G=M(#6;D(FCGL;EL(
6=FF7ED(;E(:>9(D:=L7D(N(B;GD:(
W@D(]^_aN(
a^X( =EH(:67E(;E(:67(<9*=?(?;E7( W@D( ]^a\NaXM( 4;GD:(?7:(CD( ?99K(=:(:67(
9G*67D:G=?(
G7D9?C:;9EM(
R7(6=<7(D77E(:6=:(@D(]^_c(=EH(]^_a(G7;E<9K7(
:67(
)Z-%&("0",5-%-(
[3\J(][[^(

This content downloaded from 128.205.114.91 on Sat, 16 Nov 2013 10:40:26 AM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

Vb[(

!"#$%&'(

)*&$+,+--(

"(
:6=:(DCLL7D:D(
D;E(=EH(DCBB7G;EL(
WT7;?=EHDK?=L7J(
HI=H(;E(=(8CD;*=?(*9E:7P:(
;E(
N(
:6=:(
6
=D(@77E(
:67(
1
(
=
??(
9
B(
:
G;=HJ(
;EH77HJ(
>G9EL(
9
F7G=(
8;E9GX(
8=A9G(
K7I(
:67(-F7=G(=EH(
=EH(:6=:(;:(;D(!=GD;B=?OD(HC:I(67G7(:9(*9GG7*:(=D(67(G7:CGED(
9B(:67(W+J(4X(HI=H(9**CGD(;E(
CE;:7D(;:(>;:6(:67(2G=;?M(#67(C?:;8=:7(
FCGL;EL(
/;9?;E(VJ(@D( ]^_aNa^M(%E(:67(D7*9EH(6=?B(9B(@M]^_aJ( :67(D7*9EH(<;9?;ED(
;E:G9HC*7(:67(F;:*6(BO(;E(:67(6=G89E;*(*9E:7P:(9B(1( 8;E9GM(#67( BO(;D(
DCDF7EH7H(:9(@M]^_[J(>67G7(;:(;D(G7D9?<7H(:9(7O(9E(:67(D7*9EH(@7=:(;E(:67(
:78F9G=GI(WDC@D:;:C:;9E=?X(*9E:7P:(9B("( 8;E9GM(.E( :67(:6;GH(@7=:( 9B(
:9(7@O(=:(:67(
;D(*9GG7*:7H(
@C:(:6;D(:;87(;:D(G7D9?C:;9E(
@M]^_[J(:67(B(G7:CGEDJ(
:CGED(
:9("@M(#67(BON7O(9B(@M]^_[(
H9>E@7=:(9B(@M]^a^(N(ACD:(=D(:67(6=G89EI(
@D(
;E(:67(9F7G=(W>;:6(9E7(7P*7F:;9EJ(
9**CGG7E*7(
8=GKD(:67(?=D:(9G*67D:G=?(
=D(
9B(:67(W+J(4X(HI=HJ(7;:67G(
]]\\N\bJ(>6;*6(;D(*?7=G?I(
9E?I(=(G78;E;D*7E*7X(
#67( 87=E;EL(9B(:67(:7P:C=?(=EH(
=(?;E7=G(=HA=*7E*I(9G(=D(=( D;8C?:=E7;:IM(
67G7(%(:=K7(:9(@7(:6=:J(=:(:67(8987E:(>67E(:67(@?99H(
8CD;*=?(DI8@9?;D8(
:67(8=L;*(W1X( -F7=G(B?9>D(;E:9(:67(T9?I(W"@X(2G=;?J(:67E(:67(W+J(4XN(
BG98(
9G(G7H7787H(
=@9C:(:67(W+J(4XN>9CEH(*=E(@7(G7*CF7G=:7H(
D;E(:6=:(@G9CL6:(
W+J( 4XN=*:( 9B(&6G;D:J(@7*=CD7( W;B(>7( 8=I(F=G=F6G=D7(
@I(:67(D=*G;B;*;=?(
>6;*6(;D(DCG7?I(G7=?;S7H(
:67(%E*=GE=:;9EJ(
&6G;D:;=E(:679?9LIJ(
F=G:;*C?=G?I(
=*:(
:67(
G7H78F:;<7( W+J(4X( 9B(:67($7H7787G(
=G:;D:;*=??I(
@I(R=LE7G(67G7XJ(
9B(6C8=EK;EH(=:(=(
>9GKD(9E?I(@7*=CD7(67(:=K7D(9E(:67(W+J(4X( DCBB7G;EL(
:
9(=(
H;<;E7(
6
C8=EK;EH(
6C8=E(?7<7?J(:67G7@I(
W+@J(4eX( ?7<7?M(%E(
7P=?:;EL(
=EH(
=G7(
;D(:6=:(
:
6;D(
8
7=ED(
>6=:(
W+J(4X( DCBB7G;EL( W+J(4X(G7H78F:;9E(
!=GD;B=?(
D=*G;B;*;=?(
:67(
O8;:?7;H<9??O(
=EH(:6=:(
=(
9E?I(:6G9CL6(
OA9;E7H(@I( D;EL?7(67=HOJ(
=*:(9B(&6G;D:J(=D( 7PF7G;7E*7H(W);:?7;HXJ(CEH7GD:99H(WR;DD7EX(=EH(=*:7H(
9B(:67(2G=;?(@7( CF?;B:7H(
CF9E(W)=*6:X(@I(!=GD;B=?J(*=E(:67(@G9:67G699H(
:9(:67(H;<;E7(pW+JJ(4X( ;E("cq(
;:D(W+J(4X( *9EH;:;9E(9B(D;E(=EH(DCBB7G;EL(
BG98(
*9EH;:;9E(=FFG9FG;=:7(:9(:67(@G9:67G699H(9B(:67(2G=;?J(:67(OH7H;*=:7H(
7P=?:7H(
=( DF67G7(DF;G;:C=??I(
D9*;7:IJ(D7G<;EL(:67(2G=;?(=EH( G7FG7D7E:;EL(
G7=?8(9B(?;B7OM(
=@9<7(:67(E9G8=?(
9B(W+J(4X( BG98(
:67(<9*=?(?;E7(;E(@D(]^aVNa(9**CGD(=D(!=GD;B=?(
#67(FCGL;EL(
C::7GD(
6;D(?=D:(G;:C=?(
>9GHD3(
0;*6:(
<7GD*6?9DD7E(
D7;EY(
D9;?(H7G(876G(
H7E(2G=?J(
+E:6;;??7:(
.BBE7:(
H7E(-*6G7;Ee(
#67(B;E=?(
9B(+(=EH(4(;E(:67(9F7G=(;D(@G9CL6:(
;E:9(G7?;7B(
<9*=?(ACP:=F9D;:;9E(
7O(=EH(B(9B(@D(]^a\(=EH(]^acM(-I8@9?;*=??IJ(
:67(@G9:67G699H(
@I(!=GD;B=?OD(
8CD:(E7<7G(?7:(:67(2G=;?(@7(<7GD*6?9DD7E(
W7OXY( :67I(8CD:(CE*9<7G(;:(WBXM( .GJ(
;E(8CD;*=?(:7G8DJ(
;E(:67("@(9B(:67(#78F?7(9B(:67(2G=;?J(:67I(8CD:(E7<7G(
6=<7(=( W*6G98=:;*X(*9EH;:;9E(9B(+( W)c(
=@9<7(bJ(9G(=?:7G7H(b(F=DD;EL(:9(cX(
G7?=:;EL(:9( 4J( @C:(=( WH;=:9E;*X(*9EH;:;9E(9B(++(WOaBBE7:(H7E( -*6G7;EeOX(
:9(4M(
G7?=:;EL(
;E(:67D7(@=GDJ(:67(B9??9>;EL(
>;:6(:67(W+J(4X( G7D9?C:;9E(
-;8C?:=E79CD?I(
G7D9?C:;9ED(
:=K7(F?=*7(=D(>7??M(4;GD:J(:67(;H7=(9B(DCGG9CEH;EL(
>;:6(:67(
7@](
Vc^(

)Z-%&(

"0",5-%-(

This content downloaded from 128.205.114.91 on Sat, 16 Nov 2013 10:40:26 AM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

[3\J( ][[^(

"( $+4+$+0#%",(

15"1( %0( !"$-%4",(

=@9<7(=EH(@7?9>J(;E:G9HC*7H(
@C:(E9:(BC??I(
G7D9?<7H(;E(@D(]^_cN(
D78;:9E7D(
;D(
G7=?;S7H(
67G7(
;
E(
!=GD;B=?OD(
<9*=?(
?;E7(
>
;:6(
:
67(
7O(9B(@M]^a\J(:67(HO(
a]J(
BC??I(
9B(@M]^ab(=EH(:67(7@?(
9B(@D(]^a_NaM(#67(-F7=G(89:;<7(9B(@D(]^_bNcJ(@VN*VN(
:9( :67(H;=:9E;*(>9G?H(9B( ":(:6G9CL6(:67( ?9>7G(
HVmN7VJ(;D( G7F=:G;=:7H(
?;E7(
7
8@7HH7H(
;E(!=GD;B=?OD(
*9E:G=FCE:=?(
87?9HI(;E(@D(]^aVNa3(@ON*fONHON7]OM(
;E(
:67(6=G89E;*(
:67(
G7=?8J(
4;E=??IJ(
H7D*7EH;EL(@=DD( ?;E7(",N22N4N+f(
@=GD(@7L;EE;EL(
>;:6(@M(]^a]X(DF;ED(9BB(
:6;GHD(
BG98(
;:D(
W=?:7GE=:7(
H7D*7EH;EL(
B;GD:(
:6G77(E9:7D(:9(@G;EL(]X(=(6=G89E;*(D:=:787E:(
9B(:67(D78;:9E7D(
=@9<7(
=EH(@7?9>(+JJ(;E(:67(+( 8=A9G(=EH(1( 8=A9G(:G;=HD(9B(@D(]^aV(=EH(]^adY(VX(
,7>;EOD(D:GC*:CG=?(
H98;E=E:(
F?=L=?(1(;E(@M]^adY(=EH(\X(,9G7ESOD(D:GC*:CG=?(
;E(@M(]^a_M(
:67(D*9G7(;E(!=GD;B=?OD(
B;E=?(G;:C=?(
T=<;EL(@77E(D:GC*:CG=??I(
FCGL7H(BG98(
:7P:J(:67(W+J( 4X( 89:;<7(G7:CGED(9E?I(9E*7( 89G7J(=EH(:67E(=D( =( @G;7B(
G78;E;D*7E*7M(
%:(=G;D7D(=:(@D( ]]\\NbJ(ACD:(=D(:67(D9FG=E9DO(B;E=?(=V( H;7D(
89<7D(
=>=IM(T7G7(:67(DC@H98;E=E:(
1@J(E9>(B;E=??I(
6=G89EIJ(
FG9?9EL7HJ(
B9G(=(D;EL?7(@=G(:9("(8;E9G(6=G89EI(
N(D67(
W*BM("*:(%J(@D(c^_NaXJ(=D('CEHGI(
;E(>698(:67(W+J( 4X( >9G?H(9B(D;E(>=D(78@9H;7H(N( D;EKD(?;B7?7DD(:9(:67(
:9(:67(*988CE;9E(
=EH(:67(W+J(4X(
LG9CEHM(#67(8=L;*(6=D(G7:CGE7H(
D7G<;*7J(
;E:9(:67(H;=:9E;*(>9G?H(9B(:67(2G=;?M(
HI=H(6=D(@77E(G7*CF7G=:7H(
/( T%-#.$%&",( $")%4%&"#%.0-(
%E( :67(*9CGD7(9B(9CG( =E=?ID;D(D987(G7=H7GD(8=I(6=<7(>9EH7G7H(69>(
=EH(
R=LE7GOD(CD7(9B(=(D;EL?7(F;:*6N*?=DD(
HI=H(B9G(@9:6(89:;<;*NG7B7G7E:;=?(
:9E=?ND:GC*:CG=?(
;E:9(6;D(97C<G7(=D(=(>69?7M(#67(`C7D:;9E(;D(=(
FCGF9D7D(B;:D(
H;BB;*C?:(
9E7J( =EH( 9E7( :6=:(%( =8( CE=@?7( :9( =ED>7G(BC??IY(@C:( ;:(;D(
E7<7G:67?7DD(
G7?7<=E:(
=EH(;E:G;LC;ELJ(
=EH(>9G:6I(
9B(=(@G;7B(
H;D*CDD;9E(67G7M(
:67(*9CGD7(9B(
*=G77G(BG98(
1
7G(B?;7L7EH7(
-CG7?I(
T9??=EH7G(:9(
R=LE7GOD(
9E(:67(9E7(6=EHJ(:67(*98F9D7GOD(L=;E;EL(
=G:;*C?=:7DJ(
!=GD;B=?(
FG9LG7DD;<7?I(
:;L6:7G(
?=GL7ND*=?7(*9E:G9?(9<7G(6;D(F;:*6(8=:7G;=?D(
=EHJ(9E(:67(9:67GJ(6;D(
:9(
CD7(=(
89G7(
*
6G98=:;*(
DCGB=*7M(
4G98(:67(F9;E:(9B(
:7EH7E*I(
FG9LG7DD;<7?I(
<;7>(9B(:9E=?(9GL=E;S=:;9EJ(
6;D(LG7=:(=*6;7<787E:(
;E(:67(7=G?I(F=G:D(9B(#67(
=B:7G(:67(
$;EL(N( CF( :9( =EH( ;E*?CH;EL(:67( D7*9EH( =*:( 9B( -;7LBG;7HJ(
#G;D:=E(
=EH(
*98F9D;:;9E(9B(>6;*6(67(=@=EH9E7H(:67(*I*?7(:9(>G;:7(B;GD:(
N( >=D(:9(H7<7?9F(=(L?9@=?(87=ED(9B(:9E=?(D:GC*:CG7(
:67E(1;7()7;D:7GD;EL7G(
:67(G7B7G7E:;=?(
CD7(9B(K7IDJ(>;:6(:67(67?F(9B(=(:7P:J(8=H7(F9DD;@?7(
>67G7@I(
:67(*967G7E:(CD7(9B(=??(:>7?<7(8=A9GN8;E9G(
K7ID(;E(=( D;EL?7(89EC87E:=?(
>9GKJ(DC*6(:6=:(:67(:9E=?(O@=*KLG9CEHO(>=D(*9E:G9??7H(
E9:(@I(:67(?;E7=G(
CEB9?H;EL(9B( =( D;EL?7(:G;=H(@C:( @I( :67( *69;*7J( @=D7H( 9E( HG=8=:;*(
9B(<=G;9CD(9B(:67(:>7?<7(
*9ED;H7G=:;9EDJ(
K7ID(B9G(*7G:=;E(
DI8@9?;*(
FCGF9D7DM(
N
(
"??(:6;D(>9GK7H(
>7??(
;
B9G(
:67(89D:(F=G:(=**9GH;EL(
F7GB7*:?I(
;EH77HJ(:(>9GKD(
:9(:67(H;*:=:7D(
9B(.F7G=(=EH(1G=8=(N(7P*7F:(:6=:(>67EJ(CEH7G(:67(;EB?C7E*7(
9B(,;DS:J(67(@7L=E(:9(CD7(=(B=G(89G7(*6G98=:;*(
DCGB=*7(
;E(-;7LBG;7HJ(
67(>=D(
CE=@?7(:9(ACD:;BI(
DCGB=*7(*6G98=:;*;D8(
>;:6(@=*KLG9CEH(D:GC*:CG7J(
=EH(;E(
)Z-%&( "0",5-%-( [3\J(

][[^(

This content downloaded from 128.205.114.91 on Sat, 16 Nov 2013 10:40:26 AM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

Vc](

!"#$%&'(

)*&$+,+--(

:67(B;GD:(
:>9(=*:D(9B(:6=:(9F7G=(:67(H;=:9E;*;D8(
9B(8CD;*(DC*6(=D(:67(49GL;EL(
=EH(:67(
4
9G7D:(
)
CD;*(*97P;D:D(
>;:6(:67(*6G98=:;*(
8CD;*(
-9ELD(
=>K>=GH?I(
9B();87J("?@7G;*6(
=EH(4=BE7GM(
.E7( G7=D9E(>6I(:67(*6G98=:;*;D8(
;E( #G;D:=E(
8=K7D(DC*6(;E:C;:;<7?I(
@7::7G(
:9E=?(D7ED7(;D(:6=:(R=LE7GJ(
G=:67G(
:6=E(CD;EL(ACD:(K7ID(
=D(6;D(FG;8=GI(
:9E=?(=EH(HG=8=:;*(DI8@9?DJ(=D(67(6=H(;E(:67(F=D:J(=?D9(CD7H(=( D;EL?7J(
=EH(:9E=?(DI8@9?M(%E(H9;EL(
:9E=??I(
=8@;LC9CD(*69GH(=D(=(*GC*;=?(HG=8=:;*(
D9(67(:99K(:67(D:7F(9B(=::G;@C:;EL(
:9E=?(
?=GL7ND*=?7(
87=E;EL(=EH(HG=8=:;*(
=E(
:9(
*
6G98=:;*(
G
=:67G(
:6=E(G7D7G<;EL(:6=:(
>7;L6:(
7DD7E:;=??I(
7E:;:IJ(
=EH(
B9G(
H;=:9E;*(
=EH(
67( :6CD( :6GCD:(
87=E;EL(
7?787E:DY(
>7;L6:(
*6G98=:;*;D8(
B=G(H77F7G(;E:9(:67(D:GC*:CG=?(
B=@G;*(
9B(:67(9F7G=(=D(=(>69?7M(
"E( 9F7G=( *9C?H( D:;??(89<7(BG98(9E7( D:G9EL?I(
7D:=@?;D67H(K7I(=:( :67(
:9(=E9:67G(
=:(:67(7EHJ(=D(;E(:67(7=G?;7G(
@7L;EE;EL(
F=G:D(9B(#67($;ELJ(@C:(:67(
>69?7(D:GC*:CG7(
N( =EH(
>9GKD(8C*6(@7::7G(
@7*=CD7(:67(*6G98=:;*(
7?787E:D(
9E7(*6G98=:;*(7?787E:(;E(F=G:;*C?=G(N( F?=E:(:67(D77HD(9B(BC:CG7(:9E=?(
=:(=(H77F(?7<7?(=D(=(BC?*GC8(
9E(>6;*6(:9(
9EJ(=EH(:67E(BCE*:;9E(
LG9>:6(
7=G?I(
:CGE(
=E(=*:(BG98(
9E7(K7I(=:(:67(@7L;EE;EL(
:9(=E9:67G(
=:(:67(7EHMdd(
#67(C?:;8=:7(D9CG*7(9B(R=LE7GOD(CD7(9B(:67(W+J(4X( HI=H(;E(!=GD;B=?(
;D(
*69GHJ(B9G(:67(:>9(D6=G7(:67(7DD7E:;=?(B7=:CG7D(9B(
FG9@=@?I(:67(#G;D:=E(
D7:(9B(F;:*6(*?=DD7DJ(VX(:9E=??I(
@7;EL(]X(=(CDC=??I(CE:G=EDF9D7H(
=8@;LC9CDJ(
H;=:9E;*(K7ID(;E(:67(9F7G=J(=EH(
\X(*=F=@?7( 9B(G7D9?C:;9E(:9( D:GC*:CG=?(
>;:6(DI8@9?;*(
;E(:67(HG=8=M("(*?9D7G(D9CG*7(;D(
dX(67=<;?I(
>7;L6:7H(
87=E;EL(
F7G6=FD(:67(D=87(*69GH(;E(2=::7GHH887GCELJ(
>67G7J(;E(:67(09GEDO(-*7E7(
*69GH(:6=:(;D(D9(;E:7G>9<7E(
;E:9(:67(+4(
W!G9?9LC7(:9("*:(%XJ(:67(4N"BN&/N+f(
8;E9G(
8CD;*(9B(:67(DF;EE;EL(
9B(:67(G9F7(9B(:;87(;D(7<7E:C=??I(
:G=EDF9D7H(
CF(
=(D78;:9E7J(
:9(4fN"N&N+J(=D(:67(G9F7(@G7=KD(=:(:67(7EH(9B(:67(D*7E7J(>67G7(
:67(8CD;*(:CGED(:9(U( 8;E9GJ(D9( :6=:(;:(BCE*:;9ED(
=D( =( BC?*GC8(;E(:67(
OH9C@?7N:9E;*(
R;:6(:67(*69GH(;E(2H::7GHH887GCEL(
:67G7(;D(
*98F?7PO(+RhUMdb(
=HH7H(:9(:67(B9CG(B7=:CG7D(
E9:7H(=@9<7(B9G(:67(#G;D:=E(
*69GH(:67(*GC*;=?(
=HH;:;9E=?(7?787E:(
9B(=(D:GC*:CG=?(
>6;*6(7<7E(89G7(
D78;:9E7(
:G=EDF9D;:;9EJ(
?99KD(
B
9G>=GH(
:9(
7PF?;*;:?I(
!=GD;B=?M(
#9(@7(DCG7J(@9:6(:67(#G;D:=E(
*69GH(=EH(:67(G7B7G7E:;=?(
*69GH(9B(:67(D=87(
=:(
:67(
D
=87(
;E(
D778(
:IF7(W=EH(
F;:*6(?7<7?eX( 29::7GHH887GCEL( ;E(=(>=I(89G7(
9@<;9CD(=EH(?7DD(6;HH7E(:6=E(:67(W+J( 4X( HI=H(;E(!=GD;B=?M(57:(%( >9C?H(
8=;E:=;E(
:6=:(:67G7(;D(=(L7E7:;*(G7?=:;9ED6;F(
:67(:6G77J(
E9:(9E?I(
*9EE7*:;EL(
@7*=CD7(9B(69>(:67I(BCE*:;9EJ(
@C:(=?D9(@7*=CD7J(;G9E;*=??I(
7E9CL6J(:67I(=??(
:6G77(;E<9?<7(:67(D=87(*69GHJ(4N"BN&/N+c(
9G(;:D(7E6=G89E;*(
%:(
7`C;<=?7E:DM(
>9C?H(@7(H=EL7G9CD(:9(=::G;@C:7(
:99(8C*6(D;LE;B;*=E*7(
:9(:67(B=*:(:6=:(:67(
=EH(:67(;E;:;=?(
#G;D:=E(
*69GH(9B(:67(
*69GHJ(:67(*69GH(9B(:67(09GEDO(DF;EE;EL(
';DD(;E(!=GD;B=?(
=G7(:67(D=87M(UC:J(*9;E*;H7E*7(9G(E9:J(:9(:G=*7(:67(8=E;B9?H(
9B(:6;D(D;EL?7(*69GH(;E(:67(:6G77(9F7G=D(;D(:9(:G=*7(R=LE7GOD(
;8F?;*=:;9ED(
:9(;E:7LG=:7(
*6G98=:;*;D8(
;E:9(=??(D:GC*:CG=?(
?7<7?D(9B(
LG9>;EL(
=@;?;:I(
BC??I(
:67(:9E=?(?=ELC=L7(9B(:67(?=:7G(E;E7:77E:6(
*7E:CGIM(

VcV(

)Z-%&(

"0",5-%-(

This content downloaded from 128.205.114.91 on Sat, 16 Nov 2013 10:40:26 AM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

[3\J( ][[^(

"($+4+$+0#%",(

15"1( %0( !"$-%4",(

0.#+-(
CEH()7:G;K(W,7;FS;LJ(
]M( TCL9( $;78=EEJ(-ID:78(H7G(8CD;K=?;D*67E(
$6I:68;K(
][^\XJ(FM]dM(
T=G89E;K(
CEH(;6G7(
'G;D7(;E(R=LE7GD(
VM( +GED:('CG:6J($98=E:;D*67(
#G;D:=E(
WU7G?;EJ(
"?BG7H(
1
=D(2767;8E;D(
H7G(
49G8(
$
;*6=GH(
/9?M(dM(17G(
@
7;(
,9G7ESJ(
][V^XY(
R=LE7GJ(
8CD;K=?;D*67(
"CB@=C(<9E($;*6=GH(R=LE7GD(
!=GD;B=?(WU7G?;EJ(][\\XJ(FFM]dN]bJ(
V[BBM(
CD7H(67G7(;D(H7G;<7H(BG98(09G:6G9F(4GI7J(
\M( #67( 89H7?(9B(*98;*(D:GC*:CG7(
!G7DDJ(][b_XJ(FFM]c\N(
W!G;E*7:9E3(!G;E*7:9E(ZE;<7GD;:I(
"E=:98I(
9B(&G;:;*;D8(
_]M(
<9E(+D*67E@=*63(
dM( T7?7E()M)CD:=GH(=EH(&6=G?7D(+M( !=DD=L7J(R9?BG=8(
!=GS;<=?(
W07>(59GK3('E9FBJ(][c]XJ(FM<;;M(
;E(#67(!9G:=@?7(
UM(k9>7::J(
!?=:9(W07>(59GKJ(][daXJ(FM(][dM(
bM( !?=:9J(!6=7H9J(:G=EDM(
;D(F9;E:7H(9C:(;E(,9G7ESJ(!=GD;B=?J(
cM( #6;D(G7?=:;9ED6;F(
FM]VbM(
_M( %@;HMJ(FM]\^M(
aM( #67(@7D:(H;D*CDD;9E(9B(R=LE7GOD(=H=F:=:;9E(9B(R9?BG=8OD(!=GS;<=?(;E:9(:67(
;D(,C*I(U7*K7::J($;*6=GH(R=LE7G3(
9F7G=(?;@G7::9(
!=GD;B=?(W&=8@G;HL73(&Z!(
][a]XJ( FFM_N]_M( 49G( :67( ;8F9G:=E:(?7::7GD(:9( )=:6;?H7(R7D7EH9EKJ(D77(
$;*6=GH(R=LE7G(CEH()=:6;?H7(R7D7EH9EKJ(
7HM( RM( 29?:67G(WU7G?;EJ(][^[XJ(
7DF7*;=??I(
FFMbVN\J(]V^J(]daJ(VdVNdM(
[M( 49G(:6;D(=EH(8=EI(BCG:67G(
:9(:67(
:67(G7=H7G(H;G7*:?I(
7P=8F?7D(%( 8CD:(G7B7G(
:6=E(G7FG9HC*7(
D*9G7(G=:67G(
:67(?7EL:6I(
7P*7GF:M(
]^M(#67(=D*7EH;EL(B9CG:6(
89:;<7(9B(:67(-F7=G(;D(;E:G9HC*7H(
;E:9(:67(9F7G=(;E(:67(
9B(@Md(;E(:67(!G7?CH7(:9("*:(%M( 2CGE78=ESOD(E=GG=:;9E(
9B(69>(;:(
=JN@@N*ONHrO(
>=D(?9D:(@7L;ED(;E(1@J(I7:(;:D(G7:CGE(
:9(:67(#78F?7(9B(:67(2G=;?(@I(!=GD;B=?(
;E(
"*:(%%%J(@D(]^b_BBMJ(
;D(;E(1M( #67(G7?=:;9E(
9B(1@(:9(1(>;:6(G7DF7*:(:9(:67(-F7=GJ(
=EH(9B(@9:6(9B(:67(=@9<7(:9(:67(9F7G=OD(*7E:G=?(
>6;*6(G7FG7D7E:D(
:67(
K7I(9B("@J(
9:67G(FG;8=GI(
<;DC=?(DI8@9?(9B(:67(>9GKJ(>;??(:=K7(9E(FG9LG7DD;<7?I(
89G7(
D:GC*:CG=?(
=D(>7(FG9*77HM(
;8F9G:=E*7(
]]M( -77J( B9G(7P=8F?7J(:67(G7*CGG7E*7(
9B(:67(89:;<7(=:("*:(%%%J( @D( bdaNb\J( =D(
>=D67D(
!
=GD;B=?OD(
B77:M(
'CEHGI(
]VM(%:(;D(=(?=:7GJ(
D7:(9B(F=G=??7?(B;B:6D(
:9(
:G=EDF9D7H(
=FF7=G=E*7(9B(:6;D(7P:G=9GH;E=GI(
>6;*6(R=LE7G(G7B7GG7H(
;E(=( *9887E:(G7*9GH7H(;E(&9D;8=OD( H;=GI(9E(V](
17*78@7G(]a_aJ(=D(67(>=D(*98F9D;EL("*:(%%%M( #67( H;=GI(G7=HD3(O%( p&9D;8=q(
H;H(E9:(I7:(KE9>(2CGE78=ESOD(A9I(>67E(67(G7*9LE;S7D(
:67(DF7=GM(pR=LE7G3q(
QT7(69>?D(B9G(A9IJ(=EH(:67(F=G=??7?(B;B:6D(
%O<7(L9:(:67G7J(
I9CO??(@7(=8=S7HeQO(
&9D;8=(R=LE7GOD(1;=G;7DJ(/9?M(%%3( ]a_aNa\J(7HM( =EH( =EE9:=:7H(@I()=G:;E(
=EH(1;7:G;*6()=*KJ(:G=EDM(279BBG7I(
-K7?:9E(W07>(59GKJ(][__XJ(
2G7L9GN17??;E(
=:(DC*6(=(
FMV\bM( 49G(:67(8CD;*=?(F=DD=L7(D77("*:(%%%J( @D(\\dBBM(%E*;H7E:=??IJ(
*?;8=*:;*(8987E:J(;:(;D(E9( DCGFG;D7(
:6=:J(H7DF;:7(:67(K7I(9B(&f(8=A9GJ(:>9(
9**CGG7E*7D(
9B(:67(W+J(4X(89:;<7(
=G7(>9<7E(;E:9(:67(F=DD=L7M(
]\M(1=<;H(,7>;EJ(O"8B9G:=DOD(
:9(#;:CG7?(=EH(:67($9?7(9B(1( ;E(!=GD;B=?3(
#67(
!G=I7G(
#9E=?( -F=*7D(9B(:67(1G=8=(=EH(:67(+E6=G89E;*(&9hUOJ(][:6N&7E:CGI(
)CD;*J(
/9?M(_J(09M(\(W"FG;?(][adXJ(FFM\\cNd[M(
)Z-%&( "0",5-%-([3\J(][[^(

This content downloaded from 128.205.114.91 on Sat, 16 Nov 2013 10:40:26 AM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

Vc\(

!"#$%&'(

)*&$+,+--(

]dM( !=GD;B=?J(
FFMb\NdM(
G7BG=;E(
%(=8(;EH7@:7H(:9(
]bM(49G(:67(*9E*7F:(9B(:67(#69G7EDFGC*6(
=D(=(?=GL7ND*=?7(
$9@7G:(U=;?7IM("**9GH;EL(
:9(U=;?7IJ(B9CG(9B(:67(B;<7(O89<787E:DO(
9B("*:(%(=G7(
:67(B;GD:(
=:(@D(\V^BBMJ(
:67(9G*67D:G=?(
=G:;*C?=:7H(
@I(:67(#69G7EDFGC*63(
FG7F=G;EL(
:67(:6;GH(
:G=ED;:;9E(
=:(@M\cbY( :67(D7*9EH(=:(@M_VaJ(@7B9G7(!=GD;B=?OD(7E:G=E*7Y(
=:(@D(]]^cBBMY(
:67(B9CG:6(
=:(
E9:(:67(#69G7EDFGC*6J(
@I(:67(/7G>=EH?CELD8CD;KJ(
=:(:67(7EH(9B(:67(=*:M(
@M]d^dY(=EH(:67(B;B:6(
:67(-*6;G87G(
<9*=?(D*9G7M(
]cM(#67(:G=ED?=:;9ED(
67G7(=EH(7?D7>67G7(
=G7(BG98(
]_M( ,9G7ESJ(!=GD;B=?J(
FFMb_NaM(
9B(]](k=EC=GI(
]a_aM(
/9?M(VJ(FM]aM(+E:GI(
]aM( &9D;8=(R=LE7GOD(
1;=G;7DJ(
:6=:(R=LE7GOD(*9887E:(:9(
][M(%:(;D(:9(F=DD=L7D(DC*6(=D(:6;D(;E(:67("8B9G:=DK?=L7(
#67( !7:7GD(
&9D;8=(;E(7=G?I(]a_a( WD77(FG7<;9CD(E9:7X(8CD:(6=<7(G7B7GG7HM(
>6;*6(;E*?CH7D(=EE9:=:;9ED(
=HH7H(
+H;:;9E(9B(:67(9G*67D:G=?(
D*9G7(9B(!=GD;B=?J(
;E( ]aaVJ(;ED7G:D(;E(:67D7(@=GD(
BG98(R=LE7GOD(9>E(F7GB9G8=E*7(
DCLL7D:;9ED(
7G("8B9G:=D(
D767E(K=EEM(+G(
O!=GD;B=?(D:76:(D9J(H=U\(
W]\]cNVVX( :67(H;G7*:;9EJ(
H7DD7G(27@=G7E(8;:(D:=GG7G(
"CB87GKD=8K7;:MO(
B9?L:(
V^M( "(F9;E:(E9:7H(;E(,9G7ESJ(!=GD;B=?J(
FM]aaM(
=:(=(877:;EL(
9B(:67(
V]M( O"()9:;<;*(!G9@?78(;E(R=LE7GOD(!=GD;B=?OJ(
F=F7G(H7?;<7G7H(
V^(.*:9@7G(][a\M(
"87G;*=E(
,9C;D<;??7J(
'7E:C*KIJ(
)CD;*9?9L;*=?(-9*;7:IJ(
VVM( ,7>;EJ(O"8B9G:=DOD(
!G=I7GO(
FFM\\_N[M(
V\M( %@;HMJ(FM\\[M(
;E(:67(8CD;*(9B(!G9K9B;7<(
=EH(
DC@D:;:C:;9ED(
VdM( 49G(=E(;E:7G7D:;EL(
F=F7G(9E(D;8;?=G(
9B(
&6G98=:;*(
O!G9K9B;7<OD(
D77(
$;*6=GH(
-69D:=K9<;*6J(
U=DDJ(
#7*6E;`C7(
1;DF?=*787E:OJ()CD;*("E=?ID;DJ(/9?M( _J( 09M( V( WkC?I(][aaXJ( FFM][_NV]dM(
=(H;G7*:(
?;EK(:9(R=LE7G(D778D(CE?;K7?IJ(
DC@D:;:C:;9E(
6;D:9G;*=?(
"?:69CL6(
*G9FD(
;
E(
=D(=(*9889E(
:67(
8
CD;*(
9
B(
$
CDD;=E(*98F9D7GD(
*98F9D;:;9E=?(
:7*6E;`C7(
CF(
;E(:67(B;GD:(
6=?B(9B(:67(:>7E:;7:6(
*7E:CGIM(
VbM( O"8B9G:=DOD(
!G=I7GOJ(
FFM\\[Nd^M(
VcM( %@;HMJ(FM\d](
V_M( %@;HMJ(FM\d]M(
VaM( %@;HMJ(FM\d]M(
V[M( %@;HMJ(FM\dVM(
\^M( %@;HMJ(FM\d\M(
\]M( %@;HMJ(FFM\d]NVM(
\VM( 49G(,9G7ESOD(<;7>J(D77(!=GD;B=?J(
FM]aVM(
\\M( O"8B9G:=DOD(
!G=I7GOJ(
FM\d_M(
\dM( %@;HMJ(FM\d_M(!7G6=FD(:67(?9DD(9B(8=L;*(;E(:67(G7=?8(9B(:67(2G=;?(7PF?=;ED(:67(
D987>6=:(
*9E<7E:;9E=?(
&( 8=A9G(8CD;*(:6=:(@G;ELD(
CD(;E:9(:67(#78F?7(
9<7G?I(
9B(:67(2G=;?(=B:7G(
:67(/7G>=EH?CELD8CD;K(
;E("*:(%M( R=LE7G(8;L6:(
@7(8=K;EL(
:6;D(8CD;*(H7?;@7G=:7?I(
=EH(7<7E(D?;L6:?I(
*9E<7E:;9E=?J(
@=E=?J(;E(K77F;EL(>;:6(
:67(G7=?(?9DD( 9B( DF;G;:C=?(67=?:6(:6=:(=BB?;*:D(
:67(@G9:67G699H(67G7M(#67(
:9(89*K(:67(E=GG9>8;EH7HE7DD(
9B(D987(9B(
:7*6E;`C7(G7*=??D(-*6C@7G:OD(
=@;?;:I(
:67(@9CGL79;D(B;LCG7D(
:6=:(67(F9G:G=IDJ(
=D(;E(O"8(47;7G=@7EHO(=EH(O17G(k=;L7GO(
BG98(
1;7(D*6=E7(
);??7G;EM(
\bM( %@;HMJ(FM\d[M(

Vcd(

)Z-%&("0",5-%-(
[3\J( ][[^(

This content downloaded from 128.205.114.91 on Sat, 16 Nov 2013 10:40:26 AM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

"($+4+$+0#%",(

15"1( %0( !"$-%4",(

\cM( %@;HMJ(FM\daM(
\_M( %@;HMJ(FM\d[M(
\aM( -77J( B9G(7P=8F?7J(k9E=:6=E(&C??7GJ( -:GC*:CG=?;D:(
!97:;*D(W%:6=*=J( ][_bXJ(
FFM]_aBBM(
\[M( #67( @?99HN:;FF7H(-F7=G(;DJ(9B(*9CGD7J(=E( 7?787E:(:=K7E(@I(R=LE7G(BG98(
;:(;D(;8@C7H(>;:6(*9ED;H7G=@?I(
89G7(DI8@9?;*(
R9?BG=8J(
=?:69CL6(
D;LE;B;*=E*7M(
-77(U7*K7::J(
!=GD;B=?J(
FFM]cN]_M(
d^M( %E( :6;D(G7DF7*:(:67(:7P:(DCFF9G:D(U7*K7::OD(:69G9CL6L9;EL(
&6G;D:;=E(;E:7GN(
9B(!=GD;B=?M(
-77(;@;HMJ(
FFM(]V[BBM(
FG7:=:;9E(
d]M( ,9G7ESJ(!=GD;B=?J(
FM]aVM(
dVM( O"8B9G:=DOD(
!G=I7GOJ(
FM\d\M(
d\M( %@;HMJ(FM\d\M(
ddM( -77( $9@7G:(U=;?7IOD(7PF?=E=:;9E(9B(6;D(:7G8(OH9C@?7N:9E;*(*98F?7PO(>;:6(
;E($;*6=GH(R=LE7GM(!G7?CH7(
=EH(#G=EDB;LCG=:;9E(
#G;D:=E(
G7DF7*:(:9(#G;D:=E(
BG98(
=EH(%D9?H7(W07>( 59GK3(09G:9EJ(][a_XJ(FFM]V]BBM(49G(=(H7:=;?7H(=E=?ID;D(9B(
69>( :67( G7B7G7E:;=?(
4N"(N&(
*69GH(>9GKD(;E( :67( 09GEDO( -*7E7( 9B(
N+J( =EH(:67(09GEDOJ(;E("E=?IS;EL(
D77(8I(O-*67EK7G(
2;::7GHH887GCELJ(
.F7G=J(7HM(
9B(&=?;B9GE;=(
!G7DDJ(
&=G9?IE("@@=:7(=EH($9L7G(!=GK7G(WU7GK7?7I3(
ZE;<7GD;:I(
][a[XM(
dbM( -77( $9@7G:(U=;?7IJ(O#67( -:GC*:CG7(9B(:67($;EL(=EH(%:D( +<9?C:;9EOJ(][:6N(
)CD;*J(/9?M(](W-C887G(][__XM(
&7E:CGI(

)Z-%&( "0",5-%-(

[3\J(][[^(

This content downloaded from 128.205.114.91 on Sat, 16 Nov 2013 10:40:26 AM


All use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions

Vcb(

You might also like