Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Stephen Toulmin in his 1958 book The Uses of Argument 0 Assertion + because statements 0 http://www.draughtshisto ry.nl/toulmin.htm
be omitted) Optional Components: 0 Backing-Support for the warrant 0 Rebuttal- Explain the other sides position but show why yours is better 0 Qualifier-Indicate precisely the conditions under which your claim does or does not apply (words such as sometimes, possibly, may, perhaps, etc.)
Claim
Claim-Assertion or thesis: A major objective of this countrys space program should be to land a crew of astronauts on Mars
Data
Data-information to support your claim: Because knowing about Mars will help us understand our own planet and the life it supports since Mars may have had water-and life-at one time
Warrant
Warrant-why the data supports the claim (sometimes can be omitted): it is important that we understand our planet (this would probably be assumed)
Backing
Backing-Support for the warrant: Understanding our own planet and the life it supports is crucial to our survival as a species, and knowing about Mars will help us do that
Rebuttal
Rebuttal- Explain the other sides position but show why yours is better: While space flight with astronauts is expensive, in terms of our total economy those costs are small and the possible knowledge we could gain is priceless
Qualifier
Qualifier-Indicate precisely the conditions under which your claim does or does not apply (words such as sometimes, possibly, may, perhaps, etc.): Major objective of the space program may be the exploration of Mars by humans, especially if expeditions by robots continue to gather evidence that Mars may have once had life