REPUBLIC OF THE PHILLIPINES REGIONAL TRIAL COURT Region VII Branch 8 Cebu, Ci !

"ERC# $E$AL CRU% P'ain i-0&er(u(0 "ARICEL SUAN A#ING $e-en1an 2000000000000000000000000000000000000000000002 Ci&i' Ca(e No) *+, For . Co''ec ion -or Su/ o- "one!

ANSWER
with COUNTERCLAIM
DEFENDANT, "ARICEL SUAN A#ING) hrough un1er(igne1 coun(e', o he Honorab'e Cour , /o( re(3ec -u''! a&er( he -o''o4ing.

5) $e-en1an , Fi'i3ino ci i6en, o- 'ega' age, /arrie1, an1 /a! be (er&e1 4i h no ice( an1 o her cour 3roce((e( a No) 5*7805*95 ") :) CUENCO AVENUE "ABOLO, CEBU CIT#) +) $e-en1an a1/i ha (he ob aine1 a 'oan -ro/ he 3'ain i-- in he a/oun oT4o Hun1re1 Pe(o( ; +<<,<<<)<< = -or 4hich (he e2ecu e1 an1 1e'i&ere1 o 3'ain i-- a 3ro/i((or! no e, a co3! o- 4hich i( here o a ache1 a( >Anne2 A?, an1 /a1e 3ar o- hi( co/3'ain , o 4i . ;co3! PN=

,) $e-en1an 1enie1 ( a e/en nu/ber hree ha (he 1i1 no incurre1 an! 3a!/en o he 3'ain i-- 4i hin he !ear) A( (ho4n in he recei3 herb! a ache1 a( > Anne2 5? 1u'! ac@no4'e1ge b! he 3'ain i-- ha (he recei&e ;P+*,<<<= T4en ! -i&e hou(an1 3e(o(, 1a e1 :u'! +*,+<55) 4. $e-en1an a1/i ( a e/en nu/ber ha ,on Se3 e/ber +5, +<55 1e-en1an again ob aine1 a 'oan -ro/ he 3'ain i-- in he a/oun o- One Hun1re1

Thou(an1 Pe(o( ; 5<<,<<<)<< = 4i h he in ere( o- -i&e 3er cen u/ 3er annu/ -or 4hich (he e2ecu e1 an1 1e'i&ere1 o 3'ain i-- a 3ro/i((or! no e, a co3! o- 4hich i( here o a ache1 a( >Anne2 B?, an1 /a1e 3ar o- hi( co/3'ain , o 4i . ;co3! PN= *) $e-en1an 1enie1 ( a e/en nu/ber (i2 ha (he 1i1 no incurre1 an! 3a!/en o he 3'ain i-- 4i hin he !ear) A( (ho4n in he recei3 herb! a ache1 a( > Anne2 +? 1u'! ac@no4'e1ge b! he 3'ain i-- ha (he recei&e ;PA<,<<<= For ! hou(an1 3e(o(, 1a e1 $ece/ber +, +<55)

PRAYER
WHEREFORE, 3re/i(e( con(i1ere1, i i( hereb! 3ra!e1 ha , a- er hearing, Bu1g/en be ren1ere1 or1ering he -o''o4ing.

5) $i(/i(( he co/3'ain ) +) Or1ering he 3'ain i-- o 3a! he 1e-en1an he -o''o4ing. a) One Hun1re1 an1 For ! T4o Thou(an1 Pe(o( ;Ph35A+,<<<)<<= a( he o a' ac ua' 1a/age(C b) T4o Hun1re1 Thou(an1 Pe(o( ;Ph3+<<,<<<)<<= -or 1e-en1an a( /ora' 1a/age(C an1 c) One Hun1re1 Thou(an1 Pe(o( ;Ph35<<,<<<)<<= a( -or a orne!D( -ee( an1 'i iga ion e23en(e() FURTHER RELIEFS, Bu( an1 eEui ab'e, are 'i@e4i(e 3ra!e1 -or)

CEBU CIT# PHILIPPINES APRIL +, +<5,)

FRANCISCO, ARCENAS and ASSOCIATES LAW OFFICES Counsel for the Defendant

Uni A, 88 A#ALA AVENUE, Cebu Ci !, Cebu 7<<<

By:

ALVIN A. FRANCISCO
ROLL NO) *A,+5 PTR NO) 95+<+<80<8F<9F+<<80CEBU IBP LIFETI"E "E"BER NO) 5+,A* Co3! -urni(he1.

"ERC# $E$AL0 CRU% A orne! -or he P'ain i-Roo/ 5A,,"$C B'1g, :one( S ), Cebu Ci !

VERIFICATION AND CERTIFICATE OF NON-FORUM SHOPPING

I, MARICEL SUAN AYING, o- 'ega' age, Fi'i3ino, /arrie1, an1 4i h 3o( a' a11re(( a No) 5*7805*95 ": CUENCO AVENUE "ABOLO, CEBU CIT#, a- er being 1u'! (4orn in accor1ance 4i h 'a4, 1e3o(e an1 ( a e, ha .

5) I he 1e-en1an ( in he abo&e0en i 'e1 ca(eC +) I -i'e1 hi( An(4er 4i h coun erc'ai/ in connec ion 4i h he co/3'ain -or (u/ o- /one! an1 1a/age( -i'e1 again( u( b! 3'ain i-- "()"erc! 1e1a'0Cru6C ,) The a''ega ion( herein are rue an1 correc ba(e1 on our o4n 3er(ona' @no4'e1ge an1 e2i( ing recor1( an1 1ocu/en (C A) Ge -ur her cer i-! ha 4e ha&e no here o-ore co//ence1 an! o her 3rocee1ing in&o'&ing he (a/e i((ue( in he Su3re/e Cour , he Cour o- A33ea'(, or an! o her ribuna' or agenc!, ha o he be( o- our @no4'e1ge, no (uch ac ion or 3rocee1ing i( 3en1ing in he Su3re/e Cour , he Cour o- A33ea'( or an! o her ribuna' or agenc!, ha (hou'1 i be 'earne1 ha a (i/i'ar ac ion or 3rocee1ing ha( been -i'e1 or i( 3en1ing be-ore he Su3re/e Cour , he Cour o- A33ea'( or an! o her ribuna' or agenc!, 4e un1er a@e o re3or ha -ac o hi( Honorab'e Cour 4i hin -i&e ;*= 1a!( here-ro/)

MARICEL SUAN AYING Affiant

SUBSCRIBE$ AN$ SGORN TO be-ore /e hi( nd da! "# APRIL , $%& at C'() Ci"t!, Phi*i++in',, a--ian ( e2hibi e1 o /e her Co/3an! I$ 4i h E"PLO#EE NU"BER A95*987) I((ue1 No&e/ber +A 5888)

NOTARY PU-LIC Doc. No. Page No. Book No. Series of __________ __________ __________ __________