2. Duncan Association of Detail Man vs Glaxo Welcome Phil. GR No. 162994 3. Manuel Vs. N.C. construction Supply GR No. 127553 4. Pascual Jr Vs Board of Medical Examiners GR No. L-25016 May 26, 1969 5. Tabigue Vs International Copra Export Corp GR No. 183335 Dec 23, 2009 6. Insular Hotel Employees Union -NFL vs Waterfront Insular Hotel Davao GR No. 174040-41 Sept, 2010 7. Manila Electric Company vs Quisimbing GR No 127598 Jan. 27, 1999 RA No. 8042 as amended by RA no. 10022 March 8, 2010 8. People Vs de Leon GR No. 104995 August 26, 1993 9. People vs Saulo GR No. 125903 Nov. 15, 2000 10. Sunance Int'l Management Services Inc Vs NLRC GR No161757 Jan 25, 2006 11. Chavez vs Bonto- Perez GR No 109808 March 1, 1995 12. Place well Intl services Corp Vs Camote GR No 169973 June 26, 2006