You are on page 1of 38

Preliminary Environmental Impact Assessment Report for the Proposed

Sabah Ammonia Urea (SAMUR) Plant



EXECUTIVE SUMMARY





May 2011 ES-1
ES1 INTRODUCTION

Project Title

The title of this Report is Preliminary Environmental Impact Assessment for the Sabah
Ammonia Urea (SAMUR) Plant and throughout the report shall be referred to as the Project or
SAMUR Plant.


Project Proponent and EIA Consultant

This EIA Study covers the proposed Sabah Ammonia Urea (SAMUR) Plant and the 8.3 km gas
pipeline connecting the SAMUR Plant to the Sabah Sarawak Gas Pipeline (SSGP) tie point and
hence falls under the Prescribed activities Item 8 (a) and 8 (b) of the Environmental Quality
(Environmental Impact Assessment) Order 1987 and subject to Section 34A of the
Environmental Quality Act, 1974, which requires the submission of an Environmental Impact
Assessment (EIA) Report for the approval of the Director General of Environmental Quality before
the project may commence.

The project Proponent is PETRONAS Chemicals Group Bhd (PCG). This EIA Study was carried
out by Golden Ecosystem Sdn. Bhd. (GESB).


Project Location

The proposed site is located at Sipitang District, approximately 145 km south of Kota Kinabalu
and 20 km to the south of the Sipitang town. Positioned at longitude E 115 30 13 and latitude N
5 00 47, the Project site lies within a parcel of land with Gazettal Notification No. 68/88
19200072 Tanah Simpanan Kerajaan Negeri di Mengalong river. Total land area allocated for the
SAMUR plant is 153 acre at an altitude of approximately 5.5 m above sea level.



























Cadastral Map (Soumber IEC, 2011)
ES - 2
Figure 1

Preliminary Environmental Impact Assessment Report for the Proposed
Sabah Ammonia Urea (SAMUR) Plant

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY





May 2011 ES-3
ES 2 PROJECT DESCRIPTION

The SAMUR Plant is proposed to be located on a 153 acres plot of land within a proposed
development area known as Sipitang Oil and Gas Industrial Park (SOGIP) (Figure 2).

SOGIP development covers an area of 4,065 acres encompasses the state land and the
Mengalong Forest Reserves. Currently, SOGDC is managing the land acquisition matters with the
Land and Survey Department and conversion of the current landuse status from agriculture and
forest reserve to industrial area with the Sabah Forestry Department. In parallel, SOGDC is also
in the midst of resolving all issues related to the proposed SOGIP development and this include
the relocation of the existing settlements on the state land and the existing police shooting range.
Preparation of the SOGIP development masterplan is also ongoing comprises the industry plot
plans, access road within the SOGIP, demarcation of the buffer zones for the development and
the drainage system.


Statement of Need

The Asian petrochemical market is expected to remain vibrant as regional economy growth
remains resilient with forecast growth for the next 5 years at approximately 4.9 percent. Following
this, PCG, a subsidiary of Petroliam Nasional Bhd (PETRONAS) plans to set up a plant producing
urea and ammonia in Sipitang, Sabah. The initiative shall enhance PCGs profile as one of the
key producer of ammonia and urea in the Southeast Asia region.

SAMUR will trigger the further development in south west corridor of Sabah to be the oil and gas
hub leveraging on the availability of the gas supply from offshore Sabah. SAMUR implementation
shall be in parallel with the development of Kebabangan Field Development, the Sabah Sarawak
Gas Pipeline (SSGP), Sabah Oil and Gas Terminal (SOGT) and the Kimanis Power Plant (KPP).
The spin off industries is expected to create job and business opportunities for the Sipitang
districts and be one of the main economic generators for the state.


Project Components

PETRONAS Chemicals Group Bhd (PCG), a subsidiary of downstream PETRONAS Group of
companies intends to implement the Sabah Ammonia Urea (SAMUR) Plant in Sipitang, Sabah.
The plant shall utilize the natural gas supplied via the Sabah Sarawak Gas Pipeline (SSGP) as
the main feedstock. This plant is designed to cater an average of 2,100 MTPD anhydrous liquid
ammonia for ammonia plant, Urea melt equivalent to 3,500 MTPD of granular urea at the Urea
Synthesis Plant and 3,850 MTPD of granular at the Urea Granulation Plant. Layout of the SAMUR
Plant is presented as in Figure 3.

The development of the SAMUR Project consists of three (3) main components:

i. Process Plant
Facilities
- Consist of ammonia, urea and granulation plant, jetty facilities,
integrated utility units including cogeneration plant, process
buildings, laboratory building and central control building.

ii. Non Process Plant
Facilities and
- Consist of the administrative complex, maintenance workshop,
warehouse and the Health, Safety and Environmental (HSE)
Building.

iii. Gas Pipeline and
Metering Facilities
- These components consist of the Gas Pipeline and its metering
facilities for Natural Gas Feedstock from Sabah Sarawak Gas
Pipeline (SSGP) to SAMUR Plant.

Figure 2
Location of the SAMUR within the SOGIP development
ES-4
Figure 3: SAMUR plant layout
TO JETTY
(NOTE 2)
EFFLUENT
AND
STORM
WATER
DISPOSAL
TO JETTY
(NOTE 2)
ES-5

Preliminary Environmental Impact Assessment Report for the Proposed
Sabah Ammonia Urea (SAMUR) Plant

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY





May 2011 ES-6
Process Description
Raw Materials

Raw materials for the proposed SAMUR Plant are the natural gas, raw water and urea
formaldehyde.

Product Specifications

The final product from the process plant facilities will be the ammonia, carbon dioxide and urea
granules. Detail composition and specifications is discussed in the following section.

Process Description

Process for SAMUR Plant will involve four (4) different units i.e. ammonia plant, urea Plant, urea
granulation plant and urea formaldehyde plant. The overall process flow diagram is shown in
Figure 4, while Figure 5, Figure 6 and Figure 7 presents the flow diagram designed for both
Ammonia Plant, Urea Plant, Urea Granulation Plant and utility unit respectively.

Summary of major processes involved in each plant is described below:
Ammonia Production Plant Urea Production Plant
Urea Granulation
Plant
Mercury Removal Unit (MRU)
Desulphurization Unit
Reforming Unit
CO Conversion Unit
CO2 Removal Unit
Process Condensate Treatment Unit
Methanation Unit
Synthesis Gas (Syngas) Compression
Unit
Ammonia Synthesis Loop/Unit
Refrigeration Unit
Purge Recovery Unit
Hydrogen Recovery Unit
Urea Synthesis and
high pressure
recovery
Urea purification and
low pressure
recoveries
Urea concentration
Process condensate
treatment section
Auxiliary installations

Granulator
Product cooler


Utility

The following utility systems with sufficient capacity and design margin will be provided in SAMUR
Plant in order to meet requirement of all production units. The simplified process flow diagram for
utility unit is presented as in Figure 8:

Raw Water System
Potable Water System
Fire Water System
Cooling Water System
Demineralised Water System
Boiler Feed Water System
Steam Generation System
Natural Gas Receiving and Distribution System
Instrument Air / Plant air System
Electric Power Generation System
Emergency Diesel Generator (EDG)
Nitrogen Generation Unit
Effluent Treatment Plant (ETP) and Sludge Handling
Chemical Storage and Handling System
Diesel Oil Storage and Distribution System
Figure 2-2 Page 2-6 Process Flow Diagram
UTILITY PLANT
AMMONIA
PLANT
UREA PLANT
UREA GRANULATION
PLANT
BULK UREA
STORAGE
JETTY
Natural Gas (as
feed & fuel)
80 MMSCFD
Raw Water
From Jabatan Air Negeri
Sabah
21,000 m
3
/day
Electricity
(COGEN UNIT)
20 MW
NH
3
CO
2
LIQUID
AMMONIA
STORAGE at -
33C
Urea
Formaldehyde
Urea
Solution
Urea Granules
Bulk Urea for ship loading
Ammonia Loading
Urea Formaldehyde
Unloading
COOLING WATER SYSTEM
Open Evaporative
EFFLUENT
TREATMENT PLANT
Raw Water
From Jabatan Air Negeri
Sabah
26,400 m
3
/day
Natural Gas (as
feed & fuel)
90 MMSCFD
Electricity
(COGEN UNIT)
30.8 MW
Natural Gas (as feed & fuel)
80 MMSCFD
Simplified process flow diagram for
SAMUR Plant
Figure 4 ES-8
Ammonia Plant Process Flow Diagram Figure 5 Page ES-9
Urea Plant Process Flow Diagram Figure 6 Page ES-10
Urea Granulation Plant Flow Diagram Figure 7 Page ES-11
Utility Process Flow Diagram Figure 8 ES-12

Preliminary Environmental Impact Assessment Report for the Proposed
Sabah Ammonia Urea (SAMUR) Plant

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY





May 2011 ES-12
Jetty

Jetty is part of the SAMUR Plant process facilities. Conceptually, the jetty operational design is
based on four (4) ships/vessels shall be able to berth and operate simultaneously at any one time.
The jetty terminal is designed to allocate three (3) different terminals i.e. Urea Terminal, Ammonia
Terminal and Urea Formaldehyde Terminal. The layout of the jetty is presented as in Figure 9.


Gas Metering Station and Pipeline

The gas pipe line will be tie-in to the SSGP pipeline and connect to the proposed SAMUR Plant.
This pipeline will be approximately 8.3 km in length and will acquire land with total area of 12.1 km
and is foreseen to have three (3) road crossings (i.e Jalan Sindumin Sipitang and two (2) small
village road) and one (1) crossing at the Mengalong River (Figure 10).

Figure 9 Page ES-14 Proposed Jetty Layout
Mengalong River
Paddy Field
Watermelon Farm
ITC Quarters
Kg. Pantai
SFI Residental Area
Kg. Kuala Mengalong
Jalan Pantai Luagan
Tar Road
Unpaved road to access
to the Project Site
LEGEND
Pipeline Crossing
Sipitang Sindumin
Road
Figure 10 ES-15 Pipeline locations and its crossing

Preliminary Environmental Impact Assessment Report for the Proposed
Sabah Ammonia Urea (SAMUR) Plant

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY





May 2011 ES-15
ES3 EXISTING ENVIRONMENT

Topography and Geology

The topography of SAMUR area is low lying area with elevation ranged from 8 m above mean sea
level to 24.6 m above mean sea level. Only the area to the southeast of the proposed Project site
is consist of rolling area as the elevation is 19.7 m above mean sea level.

Regional geology of the proposed project site is underlain by hard dark Clay with Shale (Sand
Stone) fragments. The granite bedrock is predominantly megacrystic consisting of alkaline
feldspar megacryst set in an allotriomorphoic to hydiomorphic groundmass probably aged Late
Triassic. Based on Geological Memoir 17 The Geology and Mineral Resources of the Labuan
and Paths Valley Area, Sabah, Malaysia by Geological Survey Borneo Region, Malaysia. The
general geological setting of the site consists of Meligan Formation, Liang Formation and Recent
Alluvium deposits


Drainage System

Surface runoff from the project site flows into the existing unnamed streams which were not
gazetted as river by the Department of Drainage and Irrigation (DID) and known as Stream 1 and
Stream 2. These streams flow from the Southeast to the Southwest of project boundary. On the
Northwest of project boundary, there was Sg. Senulop which flows from the Southwest and
subsequently flows into the South China Sea (Figure 11). The existing streams within the project
boundary consist of two (2) types which is Sg. Senulop maintains a constant flow, Stream 1 and
Stream 2 are only ephemeral due to small catchment area, and high infiltration into the sandy
soils below.


Landuse

The areas surrounding the proposed SAMUR Plant is dominated by scrub forest. The proposed
Project site is bounded by the Brunei Bay and South China Sea on the north, Mengalong Forest
Reserve on the east and shooting range on the west.

The proposed new pipeline route is bounded by the Mengalong Forest Reserve and the South
China Sea on the north, Mengalong River, secondary forest, residential and industrial area on the
east, Mengalong River, paddy field and residential area on the west and secondary forest on the
south (Figure 12).


Meteorology

Based on meteorological data, the Project area has a tropical climate with high relative humidity
and uniform temperature ranging from 27.3 C to 28.5C . The main wind direction is from the
South (15.3%), Southwest (14.3%), West (13.9%) and North (13.7%). The percentage of calm
wind is 8.1%. The climate is strongly influenced by the Southwest and Northeast Monsoons.
Figure 11 ES-17 ES-16
Figure 12
ES-17

Preliminary Environmental Impact Assessment Report for the Proposed
Sabah Ammonia Urea (SAMUR) Plant

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY





May 2011 ES-18
Soil Quality

Baseline soil quality was measured at three (3) sampling stations within the Project site.
Parameters measured were Total Petroleum Hydrocarbon, heavy metals (e.g. Arsenic, Beryllium,
Cadmium, Chromium, Cobalt, Copper, Lead, Mercury, Molybdenum, Nickel, Tin, Zinc, Zinc, Iron,
Manganese, Vanadium and Barium) and Oil & Grease. The results of analyses show the values
are below the Optimum Standard of the New Dutch List (DIV) at each sampling station site.


River Water Quality

Baseline river water quality was measured at seven (7) sampling stations within the Project site.
35 parameters measured were pH, temperature, Biochemical Oxygen Demand (BOD), Chemical
Oxygen Demand (COD), Total suspended Solids (TSS), Heavy Metals, Fluoride, Phenol, Free
Chlorine, Sulphide, Oil & Grease, Ammoniacal Nitrogen, Formaldehyde, Colour, Faecal Coliform
and Total Coliform. The results of analysis show the values are within the Interim National Water
Quality Standard (INWQS).


Ambient Air Quality

Baseline ambient air quality was measured at eight (8) sampling stations within the Project site.
Six (6) parameters measured were Total Suspended Particulates (TSP), Particulate Matter 10 m
(PM10), Sulphur Dioxide (SO
2
), Nitrogen Dioxide (NO
2
), Carbon Monoxide (CO), Ammonia (NH
3
)
and Volatile Organic Compound (VOC) and the results of analyses show the values are below the
Malaysian Recommended Air Quality Guidelines (MRAQG) at each sampling station site.


Noise Levels

Noise levels were measured at seven (7) different locations within the Project site during day time
and nighttime. Four (4) stations located within the proposed SAMUR Plant site and another three
(3) stations located within the proposed SAMUR pipeline site. Noise level within the SAMUR Plant
recorded during day and nighttime were within the permissible level of 70dBA and 60dBA
respectively as stipulated in the DOE Guidelines - The Planning Guidelines for Environmental
Noise Limit and Control. Noise sources observed during day and nighttime were mainly from
the vehicles movement in and out of the Project site and the community activities within the area.

Noise level within the SAMUR Pipeline recorded during day and nighttime were slightly higher
than the permissible level of 50dBA and 40dBA respectively as stipulated in the DOE Guidelines
- The Planning Guidelines for Environmental Noise Limit and Control. Noise sources
observed during day and nighttime were mainly from the paddy farmers activity and intermittent
pubic vehicular movement.

Flora and Fauna
The flora of proposed Project site is typical of disturbed secondary Kerangas Forest dominated by
Acasia mangium. The Acasia mangium and Baeckea frutescens also dominated the nearby area
of the Mengalong Forest Reserve. The surrounding areas are prone to forest fire based on field
observation. Most of the trees are seedling or juvenile

The results of the observation on wildlife indicated that the habitat is a simple and very much
altered environment. The majority of the species that have been observed are birds that have
adapted to small bush, orchards, reeds and grass, and coastal mudflats. Otherwise, none of the
observed species are listed in any of the endangered list either under the Sabah Wildlife
Enactment or under the International Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN) initiatives.



Preliminary Environmental Impact Assessment Report for the Proposed
Sabah Ammonia Urea (SAMUR) Plant

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY





May 2011 ES-19
Land Traffic

Land traffic was carried out at two (2) locations; LT1 at T-Junction at the main road of Kota
Kinabalu Lawas and LT2 at T-Junction at Kg. Kuala Mengalong Jln Pantai Luagan from 7.00
a.m. to 7.00 p.m. Analyses indicates that more vehicles were heading from Lawas to Kota
Kinabalu (202 vehicles per hour) than from Kota Kinabalu to Lawas (174 vehicles per hour). Rate
of vehicles from Lawas entering the Kg. Kuala Mengalong Pantai Luagan road per hour are 14
vehicles per hour while vehicles entering the road from Kota Kinabalu is 17 vehicles per hour.


Marine Water Quality

Marine water sampling was carried out at seven (7) locations within 750 m from shoreline up to
the control station located 3,600 m from shoreline. The parameters analyzed for marine water
were in-situ readings (e.g. temperature , salinity, pH, dissolved oxygen (DO), conductivity,
turbidity), Total Suspended Solids (TSS), Chlorophyll-a, Total Petroleum Hydrocarbon (TPH),
Total Organic Carbon (TOC), Oil & Grease (O&G), Heavy Metals, Phenol, Nitrate and Sulphide.
Generally all the parameter levels were within the CLASS 2 of Marine Water Quality Criteria
and Standards for Malaysia (MWQCS).


Seabed Sediment Quality

Sediment samples were collected from seven (7) sampling stations at the same locations for the
marine water samples. The key parameters analyzed for sediment quality are Heavy Metals,
Total Hydrocarbon, Total Petroleum Hydrocarbons (TPH), Oil & Grease and Particle Size
Distribution (PSD). The results of analysis were within The New Dutch List (DIV) Standard.


Marine Traffic

Total annual number of vessels within 20 nm of the proposed Project at Sipitang, Sabah is
estimated to be 5,240 vessels, where the main type vessels contributor are identified as Ferry
(97.5%) followed by Container (1.3%), Merchant (1.1%) and Supply (0.1%) vessels.

There are a few major ports operating in the in the vicinity of the proposed Project site and
Sipitang port such as Labuan Port at (Sabah), Muara Port (Brunei Darusalam), Tanjong Salirong
Port (Brunei Darusalam), Lawas Port (Sarawak) and Menumbok Jetty (Sabah). Sipitang port
which is located approximately 5 nm away from the proposed Project site is considered as an
area with less marine traffic as it has only one shipping route.


Fisheries

Fisheries survey was carried within the Project area. Based on the fishing survey it is found out to
be that the area has a comparatively low Catch Effort. Interview with the fishermen revealed that
most of the fishermen do not fish within the Project area as they know that catches are low and
unreliable and most of their catches are for self-consumption. Findings from the fish market
survey indicate that almost 100% of the fishes sold in the market are imported from other districts.









Preliminary Environmental Impact Assessment Report for the Proposed
Sabah Ammonia Urea (SAMUR) Plant

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY





May 2011 ES-20
Marine Biology

In this study, Chlorophyll-a recorded at all sampling stations were less than 5 mg/L and
comparable to chlorophyll-a recorded at control station.

Total species of phytoplankton identified at the marine water sampling stations varies between 29
to 35. The average phytoplankton density is about 1.49 X 10
6
cells/m
3
which indicated that
phytoplankton community in the area is high in diversity. The five (5) most dominant diatoms
species found in the study area were Chaetoceros diversus, Coscinodiscus sp, Thalassionema
nitzschioides, Chaetoceros coarctatus and Chaetoceros pseudocurvisetus . The Shannon-Wiener
Diversity Index (H) ranged from a value of 3.3028 to 3.5074 with an average of 3.3864 which
indicate that the water in the surrounding area is considered healthy and free from pollution

Average density of zooplankton recorded at all sampling stations is 230 ind/m
3
with total no.of
species recorded at all stations ranged from 16 species to 28 species. The zooplankton
community were represented by six (6) different groups and mostly dominated by the copepods
(84.5%). The Shannon-Wiener Diversity Index (H) ranged from a value of 2.2883 to 2.7666 and
indicate that the water in the surrounding area is considered healthy and free from pollution.

Average density of macrobenthos recorded at all sampling stations is 236 ind/m
2
with total no. of
species recorded at all stations ranged from 14 species to 27 species. The zooplankton
community were represented by six (6) different groups and mostly dominated by the Annelida
(61.1%). The Shannon-Wiener Diversity Index (H) ranged from a value of 2.3807 to 3.5236 and
indicates that the water in the surrounding area is considered healthy and free from pollution thus
concludes that the macrobenthos species in this area are diverse.


ES4 SOCIO-ECONOMY

Based on the findings from the socio economic study, it can be concluded that the population of
Sipitang is responding positively towards the proposed SAMUR Project as they foresee the
project as potential for upgrading their standards of living. SAMUR development is seen as their
potential source of income from the non lucrative and non dependable income in the agriculture
and fisheries sector. Based on the past similar development by PETRONAS in other part of
Malaysia, the implementation of a downstream oil and gas industries will also requires the existing
infrastructure to be upgraded and this includes a good land, marine and air transportation
systems, supporting retail businesses and adequate housing and accommodations to support the
potential influx of workers. At the same time, ample job opportunities will also be created for the
locals and there will be demands for both skilled and non skilled workers. The development will
results in the transformation of a small township into a busy oil and gas hub with self sustaining
facilities. In summary, the implementation of SAMUR project will generate beneficial economic
advantages that will ripples beyond the Sipitang District to Sabah State. Sabah will have the
advantages of exploiting the States resources from the offshore and expand its income from the
oil and gas sector.

ES5 POTENTIAL IMPACTS AND MITIGATION MEASURES

The Project generates both beneficial and potential impacts on the environment in terms of
physical and social aspects. The environmental impact assessment takes into consideration the
activities carry out during the pre-construction, construction of SAMUR Plant, construction of
SAMUR Jetty, installation of gas pipeline from SSGP tie-in point to SAMUR Plant and operation of
the Project. During land clearing, earthworks, construction and operation, the impacts are air,
noise and marine pollution; solid wastes and Scheduled Wastes disposal; traffic and socio-
economic. The assessment of the potential environmental impacts has been found to be mainly
localized, short-term and insignificant. Appropriate mitigation measures are recommended to
minimize the potential impacts to within acceptable levels as summarized in Table 1.

Preliminary Environmental Impact Assessment Report for the Proposed
Sabah Ammonia Urea (SAMUR) Plant

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY





May 2011 ES-21
Table 1: Summary of potential impacts and proposed mitigation measures

ACTIVITIES ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT PROPOSAL FOR MITIGATING MEASURES
MONITORING
PROGRAMMES
A. Pre-Construction Phase
1) Geotechnical survey
2) Site Topography Survey
3) Soil Investigation
4) Environmental Baseline
Survey
Activities carried out during the pre-construction
phase are localized and are not expected to
result in significant and long term impacts.


No Mitigation Measures Recommended

Not Applicable

B. Constructi on Phase (SAMUR Pl ant)

1) Vegetation removal and
clearance
2) Site Preparation works
which include import
and export of soil and
leveling of the platform
level
3) Construction of :
- Temporary and
permanent infrastructures
- Non Process Buildings
- Installation of process
equipment


Soi l Erosi on and Sedimentati on

Gully and rill erosion on slopes
Clogging and obstruction of the site drainage
system.
Increased sediment load in the rivers,
leading to clogging of streams and local
flooding.
Increase in sediment discharge may lead to
moderate siltation if no erosion controls are
adopted.



Project Construction Teams and Contractor to prepare
and implement an Erosion and Sediment Control Plan
(ESCP) which include provision of sediment basin at
appropriate locations prior to the Plant boundary
Stabilize disturbed areas as soon as possible to
minimize erosion and this can be done by compacting
the soil to reduce from being washed off
Earthworks to be carried out preferably in dry weather to
reduce the impact from surface water runoff on barren
land.
Site clearing shall be limited to the areas of the
boundary of the project site. Vegetation cover should
not be cleared until earthworks are ready to begin to
reduce potential of siltation and soil erosion
Existing vegetation at areas not utilised for construction
to be retained as to reduce impact from surface runoff.



Ensure that
sediment basin are
maintained and de-
silted regularly
Monitoring of the
discharge quality
from the sediment
basin to ensure
Suspended Solids
(SS) content is
maintained at level
not exceeding 100
mg/l.

Preliminary Environmental Impact Assessment Report for the Proposed
Sabah Ammonia Urea (SAMUR) Plant

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY





May 2011 ES-22
ACTIVITIES ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT PROPOSAL FOR MITIGATING MEASURES
MONITORING
PROGRAMMES
Water Quali ty

Siltation due to surface runoff causing
increase in the TSS and turbidity levels of
the receiving water bodies.
Spillage and/or leakage of fuel, oils and
lubricants from the construction sites
results in oil or grease contamination of the
nearby water bodies.
Solid waste and construction debris
washed by surface runoff can cause
clogging of the receiving water bodies flow.




A total of three (3) sediment basin locations are
recommended to retain the sediment carry over by
surface runoff to ensure discharge into the nearby
water causes is non polluting. The design of the
sediment basin shall be based on the Urban Storm
Water Management Manual for Malaysia.
All sediment basin must be maintained regularly to
achieve maximum efficiency and TSS level nor
exceeding 100mg/l.
Inspection of the sediment basin and earth drain and
other mitigation measures should be carried out after
every storm event.
Before the commencement of earthworks, temporary
perimeter earth drains shall be constructed to channel
surface runoff for control of sediment discharge.
Portable toilets shall be provided to prevent direct
discharge of sewage into the water bodies.
Good housekeeping practices with regard to rubbish
and other dwelling wastes and regular waste collection
are to be adopted.


Water quality monitoring
at sediment basin
discharge and marine
water.
The water discharged
from the sediment basin
should not contain TSS
load exceeding 100
mg/l.

Ai r Quali ty

Emission of fugitive dust which may
generated from:
- Site clearing and earthworks activities
e.g. filling, levelling, compaction etc.);
- Movements of construction vehicles into
and out of the Project site. The
transportation of earth, waste and
construction material will contribute to
increased particulate levels in the air.
- Heavy construction vehicles may also
collect mud on their tyres, which will be
dislodged when they travel on tarred
road;


Burning of waste shall not be allowed under any
circumstances.
Site-spraying with water shall be carried out to
minimize fugitive dust emission in and around the
earthwork areas and access routes.
Vehicles transporting construction materials or debris
should be properly covered with canvas sheet and
secured properly to minimize dust and particulate
dispersion to the surrounding atmosphere.
All vehicles or machinery used for the construction
activities should be checked and maintained regularly
to ensure they are in good working condition so that no
excessive gaseous pollutants or dark smoke are


Periodical air monitoring
should be carried out to
monitor the possible
degradation of the
existing air pollution.


Preliminary Environmental Impact Assessment Report for the Proposed
Sabah Ammonia Urea (SAMUR) Plant

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY





May 2011 ES-23
ACTIVITIES ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT PROPOSAL FOR MITIGATING MEASURES
MONITORING
PROGRAMMES

- Materials handling (delivery, unloading
and use of construction aggregates and
structural fill); and
- Material/soil tracked out of the site and
deposited on local roads.
emitted from the exhausts;
Driving speeds of vehicles within the construction site
shall not exceed 30km/hr;
The wheels of construction vehicles shall be cleaned at
the wash trough to remove soil and earth materials
prior to entering public roads.
All completed slopes shall be turfed as soon as works
are completed to reduce dust dispersion. If turfing is
not possible, the slopes should be covered with plastic
sheets.



Noi se

During the construction stage, the main
sources of noise pollution are expected
from heavy vehicles, machinery operating,
piling and general construction activities
within the Project site


Heavy vehicles movements will be via the identified
access road that avoid disturbance to the existing
populations
Movement of heavy vehicles will be restricted to day
time periods, which is from 7 a.m. to 7 p.m. and to be
driven at low speeds not exceeding 70 km/hr.
Construction activities should be avoided to be carried
out during weekends especially near to residential and
public areas.
Driving speeds of vehicles within the construction site
and areas near passing through kampongs should be
limited to 30 km/hr.
All construction equipment must be properly
maintained so that they do not produce higher noise
level.
All construction workers, who are involved with
extensive noise emission activities, should be
equipped with hearing protective devices.






Noise monitoring shall be
conducted regularly
during the construction
period.

Preliminary Environmental Impact Assessment Report for the Proposed
Sabah Ammonia Urea (SAMUR) Plant

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY





May 2011 ES-24
ACTIVITIES ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT PROPOSAL FOR MITIGATING MEASURES
MONITORING
PROGRAMMES
Terrestri al Ecol ogy
The removal of flora at the proposed project
site will not affect the biodiversity of plant
species.
No significant fauna were observed during
the site visit and they are not expected to
be inhabited at the project site as there is
no food and shelter.

Vegetation should be collected at the identified
biomass disposal area for composting prior to removal
of the remaining to designated waste disposal site
Landscaping/turfing/paving should commence as soon
as possible.
Not applicable
Bi omass
The removal of the secondary forest
comprising mainly of the acacia trees will
generate approximately 180.95 tonnes of
biomass to be managed at site

No open burning allowed within the proposed Project
site without approval from the Department of
Environment.
The biomass shall be chipped to smaller size and
disposed at the designated area for further
decomposition.

Not Applicable
Traffi c

The increase in traffic from the construction
activities mainly involves the transport of
workers, materials and wastes in and out of
the project site.



The traffic volume at the current access roads to the
site is low and increase of traffic volume shall be
insignificant
Vehicles speed limit will be low at the access roads to
the site to reduce probabilities of accidents, localized
dust and spillage;
Transportation routes will be judiciously chosen to
avoid congested traffic routes and populated zones;
Temporary crossings/access routes should be
provided to local residents when their normal routes
are affected.
Where necessary, traffic signs or workers directing
traffic will be used to control traffic.


Not Applicable

Preliminary Environmental Impact Assessment Report for the Proposed
Sabah Ammonia Urea (SAMUR) Plant

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY





May 2011 ES-25
ACTIVITIES ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT PROPOSAL FOR MITIGATING MEASURES
MONITORING
PROGRAMMES
Sol i d Waste

Solid waste generated from the
construction stage includes construction
debris as well as domestic waste from site
office.
May cause environmental degradation in
terms of water contamination, aesthetic
problems and health issues.
May lead to pest transmitted disease as
well as pollution to the water bodies.






All solid wastes generated from the operational plant
shall be collected at a designated collection area prior
to disposal at approved Municipal Solid Waste
Disposal location. As there is no licensed landfill in
Sipitang or nearby the proposed SAMUR Plant at the
moment, proper arrangement needs to be made with
the local council.
Wastes segregation shall be carried out.
Implementation of a proper and adequate waste
collection system shall be in place. All collected solid
waste shall only be disposed at an approved/licensed
landfill. As there is no licensed landfill nearby the
proposed SAMUR Plant at the moment, proper
arrangement needs to be made with the local council.
A comprehensive Solid Waste or Scheduled Waste
Management Plan shall be developed to outline the
appropriate procedure in managing the generated
waste.
Solid waste must be temporarily stored inside proper
containers and disposed at the approved disposal site.
Used containers shall be reuse where possible or else
sent back to the suppliers.



Not Applicable
Schedul ed Wastes

Scheduled wastes will be made of waste
oil, lubricants, paints and other chemicals
used during the construction phase.
May cause environmental degradation in
terms of water contamination, aesthetic
problems and health issues.
May lead to pest transmitted disease as
well as pollution to the water bodies.

All scheduled wastes must be properly stored and
labeled as per DOE requirements of the Environmental
Quality (Scheduled Waste) Regulations 2005. These
include disposal of scheduled waste to be carried out
by DOE approved licensed contractor and at the
approved sites only.
All chemical spillage to be cleaned up immediately.
Ample supply of absorbent material must be kept on
site in case of accidental spillage.
No waste chemicals, oil and grease or lubricants is
permitted to be discharged into the drainage system or
any water body.


Preliminary Environmental Impact Assessment Report for the Proposed
Sabah Ammonia Urea (SAMUR) Plant

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY





May 2011 ES-26
ACTIVITIES ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT PROPOSAL FOR MITIGATING MEASURES
MONITORING
PROGRAMMES
An accurate and up-to-date inventory of scheduled
waste generated, treated and disposed shall be
maintained at site. It shall contain the categories and
quantities of hazardous waste being generated, treated
and disposed as well as materials or products
recovered from the waste.
Assessment and identification of a designated
scheduled waste storage area within SAMUR complex
according to the waste/ hazard classification shall be
included during the design stage.
The transporting of waste shall conform to the
consignment note system whereby the movement of
waste is monitored until it reaches the approved
destination.
A comprehensive Scheduled Waste Management Plan
shall be developed to outline the appropriate
procedure in managing the generated waste.

Soci o economi c

The proposed SAMUR Project will be
located within the SOGIP development
area. Land acquisition matters are still
being resolved by SOGDC.
A minor impact from the disruption of
aesthetic from construction taking place at
the Project site which may cause nuisance
to the public.
Improper housekeeping and waste
management at the work areas provides
breeding ground for mosquitoes, flies and
rats
Proposed development will create business
opportunities for local people



SOGDC is in the midst of resolving all issues related to
the proposed SOGIP development and this include the
relocation of the existing settlements on the state land
and the existing police shooting range.
Landscaping and/or turfing should commence as soon
as possible
During the construction stage, clear signboards and
night-light indicating and highlighting danger areas
should also be put up.
Construction activities will be closely controlled and
monitored by the responsible party at the Construction
site and and complaints by the public shall be attended
immediately.
Work areas should be kept clean at all time.

Not Applicable

Preliminary Environmental Impact Assessment Report for the Proposed
Sabah Ammonia Urea (SAMUR) Plant

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY





May 2011 ES-27
ACTIVITIES ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT PROPOSAL FOR MITIGATING MEASURES
MONITORING
PROGRAMMES
C. Constructi on Phase (SAMUR Jetty)

1) Earthwork
2) Pilling works and
Construction of SAMUR
Jetty
Hydrodynamic Condi ti ons

Changes in wave flow across the jetty line
are seen to be small and the overall
hydrodynamic conditions are considered to
be insignificant.





No Mitigation Measure is required.


Not Applicable






Coastal and Coastal Structure

The construction of a piled jetty will not
cause any blockage of littoral transport and
it will not cause increased sedimentation
near the site. Hence, only localised impacts
with minimum scour and deposition around
the piles are expected.



Preservation of the mangrove vegetation is important to
maintain the stability of the coastal profile.


Not Applicable
Sediment Pl ume Dispersi on

The sediment plumes generated by the piling
works for the construction of the jetty will have
a limited extend mainly deposit within the
work area. and sediments is brought into
suspension is due to weak currents
Sediment concentrations above the normal
visible limit will occur for shorter periods only
at the shallow areas where the background
concentration is high.
Sediment concentrations and sedimentation
critical to marine habitats is not to be
expected outside the work area.





Appropriate control of drainage from surface runoff from
the site is necessary to minimize sedimentation.
Effective siltation basins shall be in place prior to
discharge to the sea. Silt basins must be monitored and
maintained regularly to ensure its effectiveness


Not Applicable

Preliminary Environmental Impact Assessment Report for the Proposed
Sabah Ammonia Urea (SAMUR) Plant

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY





May 2011 ES-28
ACTIVITIES ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT PROPOSAL FOR MITIGATING MEASURES
MONITORING
PROGRAMMES
Water Quali ty

The pipeline installation will involve
crossing of the Mengalong River with a top
width of 30 m. Clearing of vegetation, land
grading, excavation, and storage of topsoil
in the Project area may result in increased
soil erosion and sediment load carried by
surface runoff from the disturbed areas.

Mobilization and operation of equipment,
fuel and materials storage and transfer
operations, equipment maintenance
activities, operating accidents and waste
disposal may contaminate the surface
water bodies.
The location of the river crossing point shall take into
consideration on the river morphology. This is because
crossing at the straight sections of the river are less
likely to erode laterally then on curved sections;
Disturbance to the riverbank vegetation must be
minimized to the absolute minimum for access and
construction. In the event of removal of the riverbank
vegetation to be carried out, replantation and
restoration of the vegetation need to be done;
No temporary site camp or accommodation to be
located within 50 m from the riverbank;
The pipeline to be buried at least 2 m below the
riverbank and 1 m below the riverbed;
The corner points of the pipe (bottom of bank) must be
placed on strong, piled foundations to be self supporting
in case of riverbank movement or bank collapse;
Domestic wastewater generated at workers cabin or
other areas with large number of workers must be
treated prior to disposal; and
Sanitary waste facilities constructed for the project will
be dismantled and removed following project
construction. Solid waste management practices will
include at a minimum containment of solid waste and
debris at recepticals located at appropriate intervals.
Proper handling of solid waste will prevent water quality
impacts to surface and ground waters.


Mangrove Ecosystem
Piling activity from the jetty constructions may
generate noise disturbance at 70 90 dB(A)
which is minimal and temporary impact to the
mangrove ecosystem at Brunei Bay.


No Mitigation Measures


Not Applicable
Mari ne Bi ol ogy

Disturbance to the seabed condition may
cause an increase in turbidity and will lead to
smothering resulting in decrease in the
benthic community.


No mitigation measure is required as it is seen that
most sediment are deposited almost immediately after
it is brought into suspension.


Not Applicable

Preliminary Environmental Impact Assessment Report for the Proposed
Sabah Ammonia Urea (SAMUR) Plant

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY





May 2011 ES-29
ACTIVITIES ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT PROPOSAL FOR MITIGATING MEASURES
MONITORING
PROGRAMMES
Navi gati on Safety

Impact to the local boat traffic is expected to
be minimal as nearest port (Sipitang Port) is
considered as an area with low marine
traffic.



Ship owners/charters and ferry operators operating
regular runners on the main routes passing the
location should be identified and contacted prior to any
activity taking place to allow them to pre-plan
avoidance action in advance of embarking on their
voyage.

The operators of the SAMUR plant should inform of the
proposed activity well in advance to ensure details of
the proposed jetty is circulated via Notices to Mariners,
NAVTEX and NAVAREA warnings. Typically this
should be done 6 months prior to any offshore activity
(construction period).



Not Applicable
D. Constructi on Phase (Install ati on of SAMUR Gas Pi peline)


Vegetation clearance
and the site preparatory
works
Construction and
installation of SAMUR
Pipeline

Soi l Erosi on

Vegetation removal and site preparatory
works where soils are physically disturbed by
excavation and backfilling may increase
potential of soil erosion.


Site clearing and earthwork activities should be carefully
planned to be carried out in phases to minimize ground
exposure to erosion
Close turfing shall be carried out as soon as the slope
construction completed to prevent erosion.
Exposed grounds should be compacted and protected
against erosion.
Filling areas should be properly compacted to achieve
the required density to minimize settlement after
construction works.


Ensure that sediment
basin are de-silted
regularly and the
suspended solids (SS)
content is maintained
at level not exceeding
100 mg/l.

Preliminary Environmental Impact Assessment Report for the Proposed
Sabah Ammonia Urea (SAMUR) Plant

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY





May 2011 ES-30
ACTIVITIES ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT PROPOSAL FOR MITIGATING MEASURES
MONITORING
PROGRAMMES




Water Quali ty

Site clearance and works within the ROW of
the pipeline may increase the soil erosion and
lead to sedimentation in the nearby water
bodies



Domestic wastewater generated at workers cabin or
other areas with large number of workers must be
treated prior to disposal.
Proper handling of solid waste will prevent water
quality impacts to surface and ground waters.




Water quality
monitoring at sediment
basin discharge and
marine water.
The water discharged
from the sediment
basin should not
contain TSS load
exceeding 100 mg/l.
Ai r Quali ty

The emission of fugitive dust generated from
construction activities and emissions from
vehicles and machineries.


The use of water spray on areas of exposed soils to
dampened the soil
Final grading and turfing of the exposed areas to be
carried out as soon as backfilling works and pipeline
installation are completed.
Volatile chemicals containers must be tightly closed
and stored in a room/covered shed.
All engines and machinery used must be well
maintained.
Open burning is not allowed and all construction waste
must be collected and disposed at an approved site.
Trucks bringing soil in and out of the working site
should not be overloaded and must be properly
covered.
To prevent mud from being carried to the public roads,
water trough should be installed at the exit point of the
pipeline ROW site.


Periodical air
monitoring should be
carried out to monitor
the possible
degradation of the
existing air pollution.


Preliminary Environmental Impact Assessment Report for the Proposed
Sabah Ammonia Urea (SAMUR) Plant

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY





May 2011 ES-31
ACTIVITIES ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT PROPOSAL FOR MITIGATING MEASURES
MONITORING
PROGRAMMES
Noi se

The installation of new pipeline would
cause temporary increase in the ambient
sound environment in the immediate vicinity
of the construction site from the machines
such as dozers, backhoe, crane and pile
drivers



The noise impact can be minimized by restricting the
construction works to day time e.g. 7.00 a.m. 7.00
p.m.
All equipment and machinery shall be properly
maintained to minimise the amount of noise generated.
The workers direct exposure to equipment with high
noise level can me minimised with the use of
appropriate Personal Protective Equipment (PPE).
Appropriate signage must be posted at the high noise
generating area.




Noise monitoring shall be
conducted regularly
during the construction
period.
Soci o economi c
The proposed SAMUR Project will be
located within the SOGIP development
area. Land acquisition matters is still being
resolved by SOGDC.
A minor impact from the disruption of
aesthetic from construction taking place at
the ROW which may cause nuisance to the
public.
Improper housekeeping and waste
management at the work areas provides
breeding ground for mosquitoes, flies and
rats
Proposed development will create business
opportunities for local people


SOGDC is in the midst of resolving all issues related to
the proposed SOGIP development and this include the
relocation of the existing settlements on the state land
and the existing police shooting range.
Landscaping and/or turfing should commence as soon
as possible
During the construction stage, clear signboards and
night-light indicating and highlighting danger areas
should also be put up.
Construction activities will be closely controlled and
monitored by the responsible party at the Construction
site and and complaints by the public shall be attended
immediately.
Work areas should be kept clean at all time.

Not Applicable
E. Testi ng, Commissi oni ng and Operati on Phase

Management of Chemicals

Effluent dischargeand spillage is expected to
occur especially during loading and unloading
operations at the jetty.


No mitigation measure is as the chemical
concentration discharged is very minimal.

Not Applicable

Preliminary Environmental Impact Assessment Report for the Proposed
Sabah Ammonia Urea (SAMUR) Plant

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY





May 2011 ES-32
ACTIVITIES ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT PROPOSAL FOR MITIGATING MEASURES
MONITORING
PROGRAMMES

Discharge of effluent
Water Quali ty

Potential impact on water quality during
operation may be from the non compliance
of effluent discharge into the water body.

The design of the proposed ETP shall meet the
discharge quality as stipulated in the Malaysian
Environmental Quality Act 1974 (Industrial Effluent)
Regulations 2009, Standard B of 5
th
Schedule and
Regulations 12 (d) of 7
th
Schedule;
Reduce, Reuse and Recycle (3R) concept shall be
implemented when and where necessary as this will
ensure efficient use of water in the process and
minimize risks and eventually contribute to the long term
sustainability of the SAMUR plant development and
operations; and
Effluent generated shall be segregated based on the
characteristic of the effluent streams. Pre-treatment at
the source by installing oil baffle or oil trap at the source
collection pit shall be incorporated wherever possible
before transfer to the ETP.
The entire plant complex is managed continuously by
competent staff to avoid mistakes that may lead to
acci dental discharge of effluent to the water bodies.
Written OP shall be made available during design stage.
The instructions and operating procedures shall provide
a clear guidance to operators for all plant operations
scenarios which include normal, startup, shutdown as
well as abnormal plant conditions.
Selection of the technology for the SAMUR ETP is
based on the well proven technologies and Best
Available Technologies (BAT).


Design of the WWTP
to incorporate the
IETS requirements
for self monitoring of
the effluent treatment
performance to
ensure compliance to
the required
discharge standards.
The monitoring result
is also to be
submitted to DOE on
a routine basis.


Flaring and venting
Ai r Quali ty

The simulated and predicted urea dust
(PM10), nitrogen dioxide and sulphur
dioxide using the US EPA ISCST3 Model
are below the standard levels and thus
meet the Malaysian Recommended
Ambient Air Quality Guideline and ammonia
comply with the Arizona Ambient Air Quality
Guideline.
It is recommended that the Project Proponent to install
Continuous Emission Monitoring System (CEMS) which
is linked to the process control system at the urea plant;
In the event that gas emission/particulates are
unavoidable, a scrubber system and flare shall be
utilized in ensuring that the gas release meeting
statutory requirement and hence, eliminate the impact
to people, environment and asset.
Flare system shall be designed to handle the largest
gas release from ammonia plant.
All emission data from
SAMUR Plant shall be
monitored routinely
and compliance result
will be sent to DOE on
a routine basis or upon
request by DOE.


Preliminary Environmental Impact Assessment Report for the Proposed
Sabah Ammonia Urea (SAMUR) Plant

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY





May 2011 ES-33
ACTIVITIES ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT PROPOSAL FOR MITIGATING MEASURES
MONITORING
PROGRAMMES
Scenario of modeled PM10 during the
failure of the control measures, indicated
that the readings is above the guideline
limit .
Scenario of modeled ammonia during the
failure of the control measures, indicated
that the readings is within the guideline
limit.
Sulphur dioxide was also assessed and the
results showed that the impact is negligible
as the emissions are insignificant
Periodical stack sampling to be conducted at the stack
of urea plant;
Periodical ambient air quality monitoring is to be carried
out at the nearest sensitive receptors to ensure
continuous compliance with ambient air requirement for
parameters dust and ammonia level;
Workers within the plant boundary are not to be
exposed beyond the allowable limit as per DOSHs
requirement;
The entire plant complex is managed continuously by
competent staff to avoid or reduce acci dental incidents
which may lead to unnecessary gas release incidents.
Implementations of Reduce, Reuse, Recycl e (3R)
concept in SAMUR Plant such as CO2 produced in
Ammonia Plant will be used as a feed to Urea Synthesis
to produce Urea.
Written operating procedure shall be made available
during design stage to provide a clear guidance to
operators for all plant operations scenarios which
include normal, startup, shutdown as well as abnormal
plant conditions.
Control & Instrumentation will provide the first layer of
protection from any deviations of operating variables
from normal operating conditions.
Alarm Management system will alert operators to
intervene in case of deviations from normal operating
parameters to prevent any overlooked situation which
could hamper plant safety and normal operations.
In order to detect flammable and toxic releases from our
plant process, Fire and Gas Detection System and
appropriate flammable and toxic gas detectors shall be
installed in critical areas to give early warning
Equipment engines such as cranes engines,
compressors and pumps shall be regularly inspected
and serviced to minimize green house gas emissions.


Preliminary Environmental Impact Assessment Report for the Proposed
Sabah Ammonia Urea (SAMUR) Plant

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY





May 2011 ES-34
ACTIVITIES ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT PROPOSAL FOR MITIGATING MEASURES
MONITORING
PROGRAMMES


Management of Noise Level
Noi se

Generator set, engines, pumps, control
valves within the SAMUR Plant may
generate high noise levels.



Post Wear Hearing Protection signs at the entrance
for all personnel working/entering the areas with noise
levels above 85dBA.
Design basis of the Plant shall comply to noise level
requirement for worker exposure and noise level at
plant boundary as required by DOSH and DOE




Noise level will be
routinely monitored by
Plant HSE team to
ensure compliance to
regulated limit
Sol i d Waste

Solid waste generated from the
construction stage includes construction
debris as well as domestic waste from site
office.

May cause environmental degradation in
terms of water contamination, aesthetic
problems and health issues.

May lead to pest transmitted disease as
well as pollution to the water bodies.






All solid wastes generated from the operational plant
shall be collected at a designated collection area prior
to disposal at approved Municipal Solid Waste
Disposal location. As there is no licensed landfill in
Sipitang or nearby the proposed SAMUR Plant at the
moment, proper arrangement needs to be made with
the local council.
Wastes segregation shall be carried out.
Implementation of a proper and adequate waste
collection system shall be in place. All collected solid
waste shall only be disposed at an approved/licensed
landfill. As there is no licensed landfill nearby the
proposed SAMUR Plant at the moment, proper
arrangement needs to be made with the local council.
A comprehensive Solid Waste or Scheduled Waste
Management Plan shall be developed to outline the
appropriate procedure in managing the generated
waste.
Solid waste must be temporarily stored inside proper
containers and disposed at the approved disposal site.
Used containers shall be reuse where possible or else
sent back to the suppliers.



Not Applicable

Preliminary Environmental Impact Assessment Report for the Proposed
Sabah Ammonia Urea (SAMUR) Plant

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY





May 2011 ES-35
ACTIVITIES ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT PROPOSAL FOR MITIGATING MEASURES
MONITORING
PROGRAMMES
Schedul ed Wastes

Scheduled wastes will be made of waste
oil, lubricants, paints and other chemicals
used during the construction phase.
May cause environmental degradation in
terms of water contamination, aesthetic
problems and health issues.
May lead to pest transmitted disease as
well as pollution to the water bodies.

All scheduled wastes must be properly stored and
labeled as per DOE requirements of the Environmental
Quality (Scheduled Waste) Regulations 2005. These
include disposal of scheduled waste to be carried out
by DOE approved licensed contractor and at the
approved sites only.
All chemical spillage to be cleaned up immediately.
Ample supply of absorbent material must be kept on
site in case of accidental spillage.
No waste chemicals, oil and grease or lubricants is
permitted to be discharged into the drainage system or
any water body.
An accurate and up-to-date inventory of scheduled
waste generated, treated and disposed shall be
maintained at site. It shall contain the categories and
quantities of hazardous waste being generated, treated
and disposed as well as materials or products
recovered from the waste.
Assessment and identification of a designated
scheduled waste storage area within SAMUR complex
according to the waste/ hazard classification shall be
included during the design stage.
The transporting of waste shall conform to the
consignment note system whereby the movement of
waste is monitored until it reaches the approved
destination.
A comprehensive Scheduled Waste Management Plan
shall be developed to outline the appropriate
procedure in managing the generated waste.




Traffic movement into and
out of the Plant
Traffi c

Slight increase of traffic at the existing Kg.
Kuala Mengalong- Jalan Pantai Luagan
and the main road (Kota Kinabalu Lawas
road)



No mitigation measure is required.



Not Applicable

Preliminary Environmental Impact Assessment Report for the Proposed
Sabah Ammonia Urea (SAMUR) Plant

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY





May 2011 ES-36
ACTIVITIES ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT PROPOSAL FOR MITIGATING MEASURES
MONITORING
PROGRAMMES
F. Proj ect Abandonment

Soil erosion at the cut and fill area
Sedimentation and water pollution of the
existing stream (i.e. Stream 1, Stream 2
and Sg. Senulop) downstream from the
Project site due to the increased TSS and
turbidity; and this will be carried over o the
coast
Unsightly view of the Project site.


Construction Team and Project proponent must
prepare a Project Abandonment Plan and vacate the
Project site in an environmentally responsible manner
where all ongoing works are to be made good.

Not Applicable



Preliminary Environmental Impact Assessment Report for the Proposed
Sabah Ammonia Urea (SAMUR) Plant

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY






May 2011 ES-37
ES6 RESIDUAL IMPACT

In regards to the assessment carried out for the potential impact that may be generated due to the
project implementation, it is predicted that there will be some residual impacts; impacts that may
remain even after mitigation measures have been adopted and implemented. These impacts are
odour to the surrounding areas, noise due to the plants operation and in case of abnormal
activities (e.g. shut down, turn around, etc.) and impact to marine water and marine ecology due
to the effluent discharge from the waste water treatment plant or chemical spillage during the
loading and unloading activity at the jetty.


ES7 QUANTITATIVE RISK ASSESSMENT

A QRA study for Sabah Ammonia and Urea (SAMUR) Plants was conducted based on
consideration of releases that may occur as a result of loss of containment from the onsite
hazards and external hazards. The calculated levels of risk concluded that The 1 x 10-6, 1 x 10-5
and 1 x 10-4 fatalities per year risk contours are mostly within the plant boundary, whereby no
residential and industrial facilities are affected with a risk greater than 1 x 10-6, 1 x 10-5 and 1 x
10-4 fatalities per year respectively. The risk levels of 1 x 10-6, 1 x 10-5 and 1 x 10-4 fatalities per
year for the underground natural gas pipeline from the SSGP pipeline tap in point towards
SAMUR is non-existent.

It is to be noted that the ammonia transfer pipelines and jetties are also part of the SAMUR
facilities whereby the risk due to the operations of the pipeline are inherently present for the
facilities based on its industrial activities. Risk from the operations are within the accepted DOE
risk criteria, whereby the risk levels of 1 x 10-6, 1 x 10-5 and 1 x 10-4 fatalities per year do not
impact any residential areas or neighboring existing or proposed industrial activities.

The above results are in line with the risk acceptance criteria as no industrial facility and
residential areas are exposed to a risk level greater than 1 x 10-6, 1 x 10-5 and 1 x 10-4 fatalities
per year due to operation of the proposed SAMUR facilities.

Some of STEL and IDLH hazard zones for the worst case scenario (WCS) do extend into
residential areas situated 2.6 km away from the proposed SAMUR plant. However, there are no
high-rise developments within the hazard zone. Therefore in the event of such non-credible
events taking place a proper notification for evacuation and offsite contingency plan should be
made available during operation of the proposed plan. This is in anticipation that SAMUR will be
the only facility within the proposed project area.

It is assumed that implementation of an effective Emergency Response Plan (ERP) for the
SAMUR facilities will provide for rapid intervention during a spill incident, thereby militating against
escalation of events.


ES 8 ENVIRONMENTAL MANAGEMENT PLAN

An Environmental Management Plan (EMP) and a monitoring program will be prepared to guide
the Project Proponent/Contractors in managing the environmental impacts during the Project
implementation. This is to ensure that all the EIA Approval Conditions are complied with and all
the mitigation measures recommended are systematically implemented whilst observing all the
related Regulations in environmental management.






Preliminary Environmental Impact Assessment Report for the Proposed
Sabah Ammonia Urea (SAMUR) Plant

EXECUTIVE SUMMARY






May 2011 ES-38
ES9 EMERGENCY RESPONSE PLAN

A general emergency response plan (ERP) for the proposed SAMUR Plant is established to
provide a basic guideline on handling any emergency incidents or accidents that may occur
during the construction and operational of the SAMUR Plant.



ES10 CONCLUSION

Base on the baseline survey and EIA Study, there is no major environmental concern with
regards to the location of the SAMUR Plant and the proposed pipeline for the Project. Minor
impacts to the environment is expected, however this impact is temporary in nature and can be
reasonably minimized with appropriate mitigation measures as proposed in this EIA Report. This
project will bring additional economic gain to Sabah State and the country. Furthermore, it will
contribute to the socio economic growth to the people of Sabah in particular and Malaysia in
general. This EIA shows that, with the incorporation of appropriate design, operation and
mitigation measures the proposed SAMUR Plant project by PCG can be implemented in an
environmentally sound manner. The numerous positive contributions of the proposed project
development to the nation outweigh its minimal environmental impacts. At the same time, its
business objectives can be achieved for the benefit of PCG and the nation as a whole.

You might also like