You are on page 1of 12

61



, , ,

(Carey, 1985 Driver R.
.., 1998). ,
/
(.
Zimvrakaki and Athanassiou, 2005 Zogza
and Papamichael, 2000 , 2006
, 2003),
. ,
-

,
, ( ,
2001)
(Chi et al.,
1991).
, ,
,
(Gellert,
1962 Sungur et al., 2001 Yip, 1998).
,

(Arnaudin and Mint-


.
** .
*** , .
...

154 (2008)

*, **, ***

62

zes, 1985). Arnaudin and


Mintzes (1986)
,
.


11-14
: )
)
( ).

,
.

( )

(

).

154 (2008)




11-14
,
. : )

( , 2000), )


)


(Robson, 2007).
.
-,
20
22 ,
.


(Arnaudin and Mintzes, 1985 Arnaudin and Mintzes, 1986 Gellert, 1962
Mintzes et al., 2001 Sungur et al., 2001
Yip, 1998).
42
,

.
(
) (15) - (
) [8 (
), 2
, 3
2
-],
(. ).

63

)
[ (1-6): , ,
, ],
) [ 7-14 ( 10):
, , , ]
)
,
( 10 15).
,
.


. ,
,
,
(, 1990).
, ,
2004-2005, 210
( ):
109 ( ),
59 (54%) 50

(46%) 101 ( ), 47 (47%)


54 (53%) .
, 38 (35%)

71 (65%) .
, 59 (58%)

42 (42%) .


(
). .


,
.

, (11-15 )
.

: )
) ,

,
.

154 (2008)


,



( .., 2003 .., 2004):

64

1: (%)

1
(%)

2
(%)

3
(%)

95,2

74,3

64,8

70,5

4,8

25,7

35,2

154 (2008)

100,0

100,0

100,0

4
(%)

5
(%)

6
(%)

7
(%)

8
(%)

9
(%)

10
(%)

11
(%)

12
(%)

13
(%)

14
(%)

15
(%)

40,9

32,4

84,8

80,5

30,5

35,2

31,4

99,5

42,9

63,8

57,6

29,0

43,3

30,5

14,8

19,5

69,5

59,5

68,6

0,5

54,3

36,2

42,4

0,5

15,7

37,2

0,5

100,0

100,0

100,0

100,0

100,0

100,0

1,
5 6,
[5.

; 6.
( );], (15,7%
37,2% ),
10 13, ( 5,2%
2,9% ). ,
( ).
: 9. ; (
), 10.
, ,

; ()
11.
(),
: 12.
( ), 1. ( ) ; () 8.
( ).

5,2
100,0

100,0

100,0

2,9
100,0

100,0 100,0


, 5. ;, 7. : . , . , . , . ,
. 13.

;. , 5 (2 = 6,256, df = 2,
p < 0,05)

, 7 (2 = 4,221, df = 1, p < 0,05)
13 (2 = 3,897, df = 1, p < 0,05)

( 2, ).


= 0,05,
,

3.


.

65

2: (%) *

5


;

7

: . ,
. , . , .
,
.

13



;

34,6%

19,2%

80,2%

90,3%

37,3%

51,0%

42,3%

58,6%

19,8%

9,7%

62,7%

49%

23,1%

22,2%

100%

100%

100%

100%

100%

100%

* (p
< 0,05) .

3: (%) *

4

10

11

13

14

15

. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%
%

36,0 22,9

49,4

53,1

28,7

11,0

83,1

56,9 46,0

79,8

80,2

57,8

42,6

68,9

59,4 14,7 53,5

32,1

64,0 77,1

35,4

18,4

71,3

89

16,9

43,1 54,0

20,2

19,8

42,2

57,4

31,1

40,6 85,3 46,5

67,9

15,2

28,6

100,0

100,0

100,0

100,0

100,0

100,0 100,0

100,0

100,0

100,0

100,0

100,0

100,0 100,0 100,0

100,0

100,0 100,0

,

( ),
,
.

,
(
),

.

154 (2008)

* (p < 0,05) .

66

154 (2008)

(F1,521 = 0,309, p >


0,05),
,
, 5,6, 2,7 5,8,
2,6. ,
(F2,521 = 19,424, p < 0,001). ,
( = 6,24, .. = 2,1)
( = 6,17, .. = 1,7),

() ( = 4,77, .. = 3,4).
, (F2,521 =
6,745, p < 0,005). , 4,
,


.

,
,
,

. ,

-
,
, 1
12, (95,2% 99,55
). 5, 6
7 ( ).

.
, .

,


4:
,



Arnaudin and Mint-zes

..

..

..

..
(1985).

6,38 2,09 5,56 1,62 5,05


3,59 5,56 2,67

6,10 2,09 6,77 1,58 4,50
3,23 5,75 2,63

6,24 2,08 6,17 1,71 4,77


3,42 5,66 2,65

67

(
()
(%)
(. 2)

42
77,8

12
22,2

54
100,0
). , (. 3)

18
24,3

49
66,2

5
6,8
(

2
2,7

74
100,0

(. 4)
1
15
24,2
). 2
32
24,2
,
3
15
51,6

62
100,0

6: :

. ,


()
(%)

(. 8)
[5.

11
26,8


3
7,3

7
17,1
; (
20
48,8
), 10.

41
100,0
, (. 9)
,

68
46,6


74
50,7
; (),

4
2,7

146
100,0
13.

(. 7)

2
6,3
;]

27
84,4

()
3
9,4

32
100,0
,
( 9
) - . , , (Gellert, 1962 Reiss, 2001). ,

154 (2008)

5:

68



(Porter, 1974).


:
()
(%)

29
32,6



45
50,6

15
16,8
(
89
100,0
, 2004).
)
(Arnaudin and ,
Mintzes, 1985 Chi, 2005),
-
. - ,
,

:
)
( .., 2003) - - . , , , , -
(,
. - 2001 Alkha-waldeh, 2007).
,


,


, ,
.
, , - . ,
-
,
-
. , , ,

-

154 (2008)

7:
-

69


. ,
Crider (1981),
,
,
(Carey, 1985, . 46-48).
,

(
) :
( )
,

( , ).

Alkhawaldeh S., Facilitating conceptual change


in ninth grade students understanding of human circulatory system concepts, Research in
Science and Technological Education 25 (3),
2007, . 371-385.
Arnaudin M. and Mintzes J., The cardiovascular
system: childrens conceptions and misconceptions, Science and Children 23 (5), 1986,
. 48-51.
Arnaudin M. and Mintzes J., Students alternative conceptions of the human circulatory system: a cross-age study, Science Education 69
(5), 1985, . 721-733.
Buckley B.C., Interactive Multimedia and Model-based learning in Biology, International
Journal of Science Education 22 (9), 2000, .
895-935.
Carey S., Conceptual Change in Childhood, Bradford books, MITPress, Cambridge, MA, 1985.

154 (2008)

.
7 15 ( .. 2004),

(Arnaudin and Mintzes, 1985 uckley, 2000) (Su Yuen Mak .., 1999). ,
(Terzidis .., 2001)

,


.
,


( ) ( )

,
Arnaudin
Mintzes (1985),
.

(84,4%
),

154 (2008)

70
Chi M.T.H., Commonsense conceptions of emergent processes - Why some misconceptions
are robust, Journal of the Learning Sciences
14 (2), 2005, . 161-199.
Chi M.T.H., Chiu M.H., de Leeuw N. and LaVancher C., The use of self-explanations as a learning tool, University of Pittsburg, LRDC,
Pittsburg, PA, 1991.
Crider C., Childrens conceptions of the body interior, in: R. Bibace and M.E. Walsh (eds),
Childrens conceptions of health, illness and bodily functions, Jossey-Bass Inc, San Fransisco,
CA, 1981, . 49-65.
Driver R., Squires A., Rushworth P. and WoodRobinson V., -
, . . , .
. , . - , , 1998.
Gellert E., Children's conceptions of the content
and function of the human body, Genetic
Psychology Monographs 65, 1962, . 293-405.
Mintzes J.J., Wandersee J.H. and Novak J.D.,
Assessing understanding in biology, Journal
of Biological Education 35 (3), 2001, . 118124.
Porter C.S., Grade school children's perceptions
of their internal body parts, Nursing Research
23 (5), 1974, . 384-391.
Reiss M. and Tunnicliffe S.D., Students understandings of Human Organs and Organ Systems, Research in Science Education 31,
2001, . 383-399.
Robson C., ,
. . . , .
Gutenberg, , 2007.
Sungur S. and Tekkaya C., Students achievement in Human Circulatory System Unit: The
effect of reasoning ability and gender, Journal of Science Education and Technology 12
(1), 2003, . 59-64.
Su Yuen Mak, Din Yan Yip and Choi Man Chung,
Alternative conceptions in biology-related
topics of integrated Science Teachers and Implications for Teacher Education, Journal of
Science Education and Technology 8 (2), 1999,
. 161-170.
Sungur S., Tekkaya C. and Geban O., The contribution of conceptual change texts accompanied by concept mapping to students understanding of the human circulatory system,
School Science and Mathematics 101 (2), 2001,
. 91-102.
Terzidis A., Koutroumpa A., Skalkidis I., Matzavakis I., Malliori M., Frangakis C., DiScala C.

and Petridou E., Water safety: age-specific


changes in knowledge and attitudes following
a school-based intervention, Injury Prevention 13, 2007, . 120-124.
Yip D., Teachers' misconceptions of the circulatory system, Journal of Biological Education
32(3), 1998, . 207-216.
Zimvrakaki E. and Athanassiou K., Childrens
representations about their body and sexual
development, in: M. Ergazaki, J. Lewis and
V. Zogza (eds), Trends in Biology Education
Research in the New Biology Era, Patras University Press, 2005, . 371-381.
Zogza V. and Papamichael Y., The development
of the concept of alive by preschoolers through
a cognitive conflict teaching intervention,
European Journal of Psychology of Education
10 (2), 2000, . 191-205.
. .,
: , 136, 2004,
. 53-67.
., ., .,
., . . (. .), , -
, .... - .. - ....,
, 2004.
.,
, : .
. (.),
21
- , .
, , 2001, . 243-252.
., - , . , , 2006.
. .,
:
, : . (.)
, , 2001, . 113.
.,
, ,
..., , 1990.
., ., - ., ., . - ., , , ...., , 2003.
.,

71
: ,
- 6, 2003, . 37-43.
., ., Tunnicliff S.D.
and Reiss M., ;, : . , .
. (.),

- ,
, . , ...., ,
2004, . 251-259.
. .,
/-

, : .
(.),
, . -
, , 2000, . 111-147.

1. () ;

2.
;

4. :
.
.
.
.
5. ;

154 (2008)

3. :
.
.
.
.
.

72

6. ( );

7. :
.
.
.
. ,
.
8. :
.
.
.
.
.
9. ;
. .
. .
. .
. .
10. , ,
;
11. .

12. :
.
.
.
.
.

154 (2008)

13.
;
14. : ,
, .

15. ;
. .
. .
. .
. .

You might also like