Scribd Logo
Upload

Welcome to Scribd!

  • The Hadiths in Imam Tabari's Books

    Uploaded by

    takwania
    174 views1 page
    HadithAnswers.com is a site that seeks to serve the Muslim World by attending to queries that pertain to the Noble Traditions of Rasulullah (sallallahu’alaihi wasallam). All questions are either answered or checked by Moulana Haroon Abasoomar (hafizahullah) who is a Shaykhul Hadith in South Africa, or by his son, Moulana Muhammad Abasoomer (hafizahullah) a Hadith specialist. Answers are kept as brief as possible. Lengthy analysis are posted on www.Al-Miftah.com This site was inspired by the advices of Shaykh Muhammad ‘Awwamah (hafizahullah) the Grand Syrian Muhaddith currently residing in Madinatul Munawwarah. The Respected Shaykh (hafizahullah) during his first visit to South Africa (in June 2012) stressed on the need for specialisation in the various Islamic fields of knowledge. The site was launched to coincide with Shaykh ‘Awwamah’s next visit to South Africa in January 2014. He was pleased to hear of it & blessed the site with his du’as & also offered some principle guidelines on how to attend to Contemporary Hadith queries. Moulana Muhammad is the Shaykh’s student (and a student of other Senior Contemporary Hadith scholars). Follow him on Twitter: @MoulanaMuhammad and on his blog: www.Al-Miftah.com Disclaimer HadithAnswers.com does not attend to questions related to fiqh (Jurisprudence). Please consult your local Mufti/Darul ifta for such queries. All answers issued by HadithAnswers.com carry the following disclaimer: 1. The classification of the authenticity of hadiths is based on the verdicts of the Muhaddithun (Hadith Scholars) of the past. We prefer to –as far as possible- to abstain from grading a hadith according to our own discression. 2. Since the field of Al-Jarh wa Ta’dil (verification of narrators) is based on individual Ijtihad (analogical deductions) of the scholars, it is therefore prone to difference of opinion. Hence, if there be any disagreement concerning the classification of any hadith, it should be understood in this light. However, we welcome any logical constructive input on the relevant matter. 3. The proofs provided by ourselves regarding any fiqhi (theoretical) issue is solely for the purpose of proving the Hanafi standpoint (unless stated otherwise) and is to establish the fact that that the Hanafi School is also substantiated by clear proofs and sound arguments. Therefore if there exists any difference of opinion of any of the other 3 madhabs concerning the relevant issue, we intend no disrespect to them, neither do we wish to enforce our opinion on them. We respect the opposing views and likewise encourage others to respect ours. 4. At times the nature of the question or questioner is such that it requires a staunch approach. This approach is solely to assure the confused reader of the in exactitude of the questioner. 5. Its important to understand that matters such as these should not be a means of causing disunity and friction among the Muslim Ummah. More so in an era like ours wherein the Muslim Ummah at large is in dire need of absolute unity as well as mutual love and understanding. 6. When we are unable to trace a hadith, it demands caution in quoting it. One should never relate a hadith which is untraceable, as it could be a fabrication. 7. Lastly, admin reserves the right to edit questions & to use its discretion before posting anything. May Alah Ta’ala guide us all. Ameen. And Allah Ta’ala Knows best. Admin

    Original Title

    The Hadiths in Imam Tabari’s Books

    Copyright

    © © All Rights Reserved

    Available Formats

    DOC, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd

    Did you find this document useful?

    Is this content inappropriate?

    Report this Document
    HadithAnswers.com is a site that seeks to serve the Muslim World by attending to queries that pertain to the Noble Traditions of Rasulullah (sallallahu’alaihi wasallam). All questions are either answered or checked by Moulana Haroon Abasoomar (hafizahullah) who is a Shaykhul Hadith in South Africa, or by his son, Moulana Muhammad Abasoomer (hafizahullah) a Hadith specialist. Answers are kept as brief as possible. Lengthy analysis are posted on www.Al-Miftah.com This site was inspired by the advices of Shaykh Muhammad ‘Awwamah (hafizahullah) the Grand Syrian Muhaddith currently residing in Madinatul Munawwarah. The Respected Shaykh (hafizahullah) during his first visit to South Africa (in June 2012) stressed on the need for specialisation in the various Islamic fields of knowledge. The site was launched to coincide with Shaykh ‘Awwamah’s next visit to South Africa in January 2014. He was pleased to hear of it & blessed the site with his du’as & also offered some principle guidelines on how to attend to Contemporary Hadith queries. Moulana Muhammad is the Shaykh’s student (and a student of other Senior Contemporary Hadith scholars). Follow him on Twitter: @MoulanaMuhammad and on his blog: www.Al-Miftah.com Disclaimer HadithAnswers.com does not attend to questions related to fiqh (Jurisprudence). Please consult your local Mufti/Darul ifta for such queries. All answers issued by HadithAnswers.com carry the following disclaimer: 1. The classification of the authenticity of hadiths is based on the verdicts of the Muhaddithun (Hadith Scholars) of the past. We prefer to –as far as possible- to abstain from grading a hadith according to our own discression. 2. Since the field of Al-Jarh wa Ta’dil (verification of narrators) is based on individual Ijtihad (analogical deductions) of the scholars, it is therefore prone to difference of opinion. Hence, if there be any disagreement concerning the classification of any hadith, it should be understood in this light. However, we welcome any logical constructive input on the relevant matter. 3. The proofs provided by ourselves regarding any fiqhi (theoretical) issue is solely for the purpose of proving the Hanafi standpoint (unless stated otherwise) and is to establish the fact that that the Hanafi School is also substantiated by clear proofs and sound arguments. Therefore if there exists any difference of opinion of any of the other 3 madhabs concerning the relevant issue, we intend no disrespect to them, neither do we wish to enforce our opinion on them. We respect the opposing views and likewise encourage others to respect ours. 4. At times the nature of the question or questioner is such that it requires a staunch approach. This approach is solely to assure the confused reader of the in exactitude of the questioner. 5. Its important to understand that matters such as these should not be a means of causing disunity and friction among the Muslim Ummah. More so in an era like ours wherein the Muslim Ummah at large is in dire need of absolute unity as well as mutual love and understanding. 6. When we are unable to trace a hadith, it demands caution in quoting it. One should never relate a hadith which is untraceable, as it could be a fabrication. 7. Lastly, admin reserves the right to edit questions & to use its discretion before posting anything. May Alah Ta’ala guide us all. Ameen. And Allah Ta’ala Knows best. Admin

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as DOC, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Flag for inappropriate content
    174 views1 page

    The Hadiths in Imam Tabari's Books

    Uploaded by

    takwania
    HadithAnswers.com is a site that seeks to serve the Muslim World by attending to queries that pertain to the Noble Traditions of Rasulullah (sallallahu’alaihi wasallam). All questions are either answered or checked by Moulana Haroon Abasoomar (hafizahullah) who is a Shaykhul Hadith in South Africa, or by his son, Moulana Muhammad Abasoomer (hafizahullah) a Hadith specialist. Answers are kept as brief as possible. Lengthy analysis are posted on www.Al-Miftah.com This site was inspired by the advices of Shaykh Muhammad ‘Awwamah (hafizahullah) the Grand Syrian Muhaddith currently residing in Madinatul Munawwarah. The Respected Shaykh (hafizahullah) during his first visit to South Africa (in June 2012) stressed on the need for specialisation in the various Islamic fields of knowledge. The site was launched to coincide with Shaykh ‘Awwamah’s next visit to South Africa in January 2014. He was pleased to hear of it & blessed the site with his du’as & also offered some principle guidelines on how to attend to Contemporary Hadith queries. Moulana Muhammad is the Shaykh’s student (and a student of other Senior Contemporary Hadith scholars). Follow him on Twitter: @MoulanaMuhammad and on his blog: www.Al-Miftah.com Disclaimer HadithAnswers.com does not attend to questions related to fiqh (Jurisprudence). Please consult your local Mufti/Darul ifta for such queries. All answers issued by HadithAnswers.com carry the following disclaimer: 1. The classification of the authenticity of hadiths is based on the verdicts of the Muhaddithun (Hadith Scholars) of the past. We prefer to –as far as possible- to abstain from grading a hadith according to our own discression. 2. Since the field of Al-Jarh wa Ta’dil (verification of narrators) is based on individual Ijtihad (analogical deductions) of the scholars, it is therefore prone to difference of opinion. Hence, if there be any disagreement concerning the classification of any hadith, it should be understood in this light. However, we welcome any logical constructive input on the relevant matter. 3. The proofs provided by ourselves regarding any fiqhi (theoretical) issue is solely for the purpose of proving the Hanafi standpoint (unless stated otherwise) and is to establish the fact that that the Hanafi School is also substantiated by clear proofs and sound arguments. Therefore if there exists any difference of opinion of any of the other 3 madhabs concerning the relevant issue, we intend no disrespect to them, neither do we wish to enforce our opinion on them. We respect the opposing views and likewise encourage others to respect ours. 4. At times the nature of the question or questioner is such that it requires a staunch approach. This approach is solely to assure the confused reader of the in exactitude of the questioner. 5. Its important to understand that matters such as these should not be a means of causing disunity and friction among the Muslim Ummah. More so in an era like ours wherein the Muslim Ummah at large is in dire need of absolute unity as well as mutual love and understanding. 6. When we are unable to trace a hadith, it demands caution in quoting it. One should never relate a hadith which is untraceable, as it could be a fabrication. 7. Lastly, admin reserves the right to edit questions & to use its discretion before posting anything. May Alah Ta’ala guide us all. Ameen. And Allah Ta’ala Knows best. Admin

    Copyright:

    © All Rights Reserved
    Download as DOC, PDF, TXT or read online from Scribd
    Flag for inappropriate content
    of 1

    The Hadiths in Imam Tabaris books

    http://www.hadithanswers.com/the-hadiths-in-imam-tabaris-books/#more-2923
    Question
    I recall hearing from scholars to beware of man of the narrations found in the !istor "#aareekh$ of
    al-#abari as man of them are weak.
    !owe%er& I wanted to ask if he was more stringent in his selection of !adiths in his #afseer than in his
    #aareekh' If so& did he specificall sa that he will onl use a certain grade of narrations or on the other
    hand did later scholars sa anthing about his selection of narrations in his #afseer'

    (nswer
    #he #afsir of Imam Ibn )arir #abari "rahimahullah$ is considered among the popular sources for #afsir
    based on traditions "#afsir bir *iwaah$
    Imam (bu !amid (l-Isfaraini "rahimahullah$ said:
    +If someone had to tra%el all the wa to ,hina for this book& it would be worth his while.
    "-afahat min sabril +.lama& pg.29/$
    I ha%en0t seen an such distinction made between his 2 books specificall.
    !owe%er& +(llamah Ibn #amiah "rahimahullah$ has mentioned that Ibn )arir0s "rahimahullah$ #afsir
    is among the the more reliable ones.
    "1a2mu0 3atawa Ibn #amiah& %ol.43 pg.356-355$

    (s a general rule& if the author of an book hasn0t undertaken to ensure that all the !adiths contained
    therein will be authentic "sahih$& then that particular book is prone to ha%e all tpes of !adiths7
    authentic as well as unauthentic.
    8ne commonl encounters weak narrations in the books of histor as well as tafsir.

    (nd (llah #a0ala 9nows best&

    (nswered b: 1oulana 1uhammad (basoomar

    You might also like