Current Conditions of Lake Broadwater Conservation Park in Respect to
Biodiversity Assets and The Status of Targeted Threatened Species 3606ENV Conservation Biology Emma Murrell-Orgill
Date Due: 15 th May 2014
Word Count: 2702 #
ABSTRACT
Lake Broadwater Conservation Park is situated on the Darling Downs and plays host to a large array of diverse species. In particular the conservation status of threatened species within the park was assessed, along with the condition of current biodiversity assets through the use of a variety of surveying techniques to directly observe these species. Threatened species focused on included the Koala, with scats being found showing its still abundant; the Pale-Headed Snake, found on a couple of sites also showing that it is still abundant; and the same found for the Golden-Tailed Gecko. These positive results confirm that their conservation status is not declining and possibly inclining. The condition of the biodiversity assets was also shown to have positive results, with a large variety of different species spotted and identified, even though not found in previous years.
INTRODUCTION
The condition of Lake Broadwater needs to be consistently assessed in order to ensure the biodiversity assets, and to monitor the change over the years in order to fully understand its dynamics. This can also be used in order to prevent species from developing a threatened conservation status, and possibly develop ways in which to increase numbers and increase their status back to safe numbers (Nichols and Williams, 2006). Surveys were conducted over a five-day period using Biodiversity and Integrated Environmental Monitoring (Magnusson et al, 2013) as a key reference in order to successfully gain an understanding on current conditions. At current there are 17 permanent long-term ecological research (LTER) plots present at Lake Broadwater, with the targeted threatened species including the Pale-Headed Snake, Koala, and Golden- Tailed Gecko. These species are threatened by a number of processes. Feral species are present throughout the park and not only cause predation but also compete with indigenous species for food and habitat. These species include Wild Pigs, Cats, Wild Dogs, Foxes, and Rabbits. Another invasive species includes the Prickly Pear Cactus, $ Opuntia inermis, which successfully colonised Australia due to it being a highly successful reproducer by cloning when pads break away to form new plants (Hart and Lyons, 2013). The plant itself holds a low nutrient content, with the protein levels falling below what is needed to maintain rumen function and it contains a high amount of indigestible fibre (Hart and Lyons, 2013). It also poses a threat to native plant species, through competition and prevention of forage production (Hart and Lyons, 2013). However biological control is currently implemented through the Cactus Moth larva Cactoblastis cactorum, which eats the cacti and successfully kills it without threatening other species (Solis et al, 2004). Another threat imposed on the park is the recent Coal Seam Gas mine emplaced on the surrounding property. This has lead to mass clearings of vegetation, not only destroying vital habitats but also causing isolation of small mammal species. When a well is initially built, a 50 metre radius from the base must be cleared to prevent tree roots from destroying pipes. Small mammals will not cross these mass clearings, as the risk of predation is very high causing them to remain in small, isolated populations and leading to inbreeding (therefore reducing reproductive success). The introduction of mining also led to the creation of lakes which contain toxic substances along with the ground water that is drawn up whilst coal seam extraction takes place. These lakes have the potential to poison surrounding ground water and also seep into the Gully, which leads straight to Lake Broadwater. This contamination of the Lake possesses a greater threat to humans as it is consistently used for Ski-boats and Jet-skis. This human recreational use also acts as a threat to the biodiversity assets, by disrupting normal ecological processes and destroying habitats. Although there is a large number of threatening processes throughout the park, conditions are frequently assessed and management techniques are currently being implemented. The condition of the park and its effectiveness correlates with management applied to it such as enforcement, boundary highlighting, and direct care taken to local communities like Prickly Pear control (Bruner et al, 2001). The aim of this report is to assess the current conditions of Lake Broadwater and provide a conclusion as to the current wealth of biodiversity assets and find the key threatened species present on the site.
% METHODS
Each of the 17 plots was visited with the following surveys conducted (Figure 1.). A variety of variables were tested at each of these sites. Bird Watching Survey The dependent variable within this survey to be measured was the diversity of bird species within each site. Following the transect line, the researchers walked slowly pausing to search for birds, using binoculars and a bird guide to identify them. The zone included anything within 40 metres either side of the transect line, with the exception of birds which flew over the zone (recorded with side note flying). The common name, distance along transect, distance to transect and height were all recorded (metres) on the datasheets. All three transects were visited and measured three times (each morning), within a 20 minute period. Prickly Pear Survey The abundance of prickly pear along the transect was the dependent variable within this survey. Two team members stood alongside each other on either side of the transect line at 5 and 15 metres. The zone included any found within 20 metres of the transect line. Walking at the same speed, researchers proceeded forward and stopped whenever anyone spotted an alive or dead prickly pear. The height (centimetres), distance along transect and health status (alive or dead) was recorded for EACH individual specimen found. Each site was surveyed once for abundance, covering the whole plot. Reptile Spotting Survey The diversity of different reptile species was tested within this survey. Two members walked along the transect at 5 and 15 metres on either side, stopping whenever a reptile was spotted. When a reptile was encountered it was captured in order to identify it. However if the reptile got away and was unable to be identified, it was still recorded with a side note stating any identifiable features. Trees, logs and rocks were looked at more closely. Species name, distance along transect, distance from transect, and any notes were recorded (in metres). Each site was surveyed once, with a duration of 30 minutes usually in the late morning. Spotlighting Survey & Abundance and diversity of nocturnal species was investigated within this survey and abundance of the Golden-Tailed Gecko and Pale-Headed Snake. Using head torches, two members surveyed either side of the transect. The ground was searched, along with tree trunks and tops, and logs. Tree trunks were searched as a pair, with a member on either side in order to counteract the movement of lizards, which usually hide on the other side of a tree when approached. The eye shine was usually sighted initially and then the species was captured and identified. Each site was surveyed twice for 30 minutes. Mammal Trapping This survey aimed at determining the abundance and diversity of mammals. Elliot traps were used with a peanut, oat and honey ball placed in each trap to attract the mammals. They were set at every 20 metres along the transect starting at 10 metres along the transect, and placed 10 metres out next to something to protect it. Once captured, they were put in bag, measured, identified and then clipped. Measurements were made on tail length, body length (excluding tail), and note on which side of hind had hair clipped. They were also sexed. Once completed they were released where captured. The pitfall trap was set at 125 metres along transect. A hole was dug to place a bucket (ground level with fence placed directly above), extending 10 metres along (bucket in middle). If a mammal was caught, the same process as above was used to record data. If any other organism was caught like a frog, it is identified and released. Both types of trapping methods were set on day one and packed up on day four. Koala Scat Survey The dependant variable used within this survey was the abundance of Koalas. Members walked along transect and randomly chose 30 trees with a DBH >10. If there were less than 30 trees with this DBH then trees were chosen off the plot. For two minutes the base of the tree was searched in order to find scats from mammals. The radius included anything found within a metre from the base. Those that were unidentifiable were kept and keyed out using a scat field guide. It was performed at every site once. Statistical Analyses Statistical analysis was performed in order to observe any relationships found in the prickly pear data through the use of a stacked column graph. The Koala scat records were ' also placed in a column graph, to compare counts found at all the plots. All analysis was performed using Microsoft Excel.
RESULTS
Both alive and dead Prickly Pear plants were found (figure 2.). There were a higher number of alive plants around 0-50cm found, with a total of 1168 plants found, with the greatest amount found at B1, a Piliga vegetated area (figure 2.). This was nearly ten times greater the dead plants with 198 in total around 0-50cm (figure 3.). It was also observed that more of the alive plants grew taller than any of the dead ones found, with 17 of the alive plants recorded being >200cm and 4 of the dead plants >200cm (figure 2 and 3.). There is a total of 48 mammal species present, with 12 of these found during the research period (see appendix). Two of the species present are threatened and were not recorded as being sighted apart from the Koala, which is listed as vulnerable Australia-wide. Although no Koala species were physically observed a large number of scats were encountered suggesting that there still is abundance present throughout the plots. Four out of the 17 plots contained scats with the highest number being 19 counts, documented at plot C4 being a Bull Oak and Cyprus Pine region (figure 4.). Out of the total 252 bird species found at Lake Broadwater, there was only 79 sighted (see appendix)(Queensland Government Wildlife Online, 2013). 10 birds are listed as threatened, with one of these species sighted during surveillance (Turquoise Parrot, Neophema pulchella)(Queensland Government Wildlife Online, 2013). Both the Pale-headed Snake and Golden-tailed Gecko were spotted during research. The Snake was found in the River Red Gum region, North of the Lake on plot A2. The Gecko was sighted at plot D4, which is a mostly Grassland area, on an Acacia deanei tree. Its snout to vent length was 34mm and total length 64mm, with the average length around 70mm (Queensland Government, 2013). There was also a large number of other reptiles sighted, with 19 out of a total of 60 present sighted (Queensland Government Wildlife Online, 2013). DISCUSSION Condition ( After assessing the results it was found that the condition of Lake Broadwater has not declined, however further research needs to be conducted. Although there was a large number of dead Prickly Pear plants observed and the Cactus Moth larva Cactoblastis cactorum was found to be successful in culling the plant, there is still a vast amount of alive cacti found throughout the Park. Plants are now isolated from each other and it is possible that the larva is unable to reach other plants in time before they regrow elsewhere (Scott, 1988). The dead plants were also found to being shorter than the remaining alive ones, possibly suggesting the plants are getting stronger and growing taller. There is still a great deal of disturbance occurring on the plots near the boundary of the Park, due to intrusion of cattle from neighbouring properties. This increase in disturbance has undoubtedly lead to the increase in cacti presence, with a greater number observed on these plots (figure 2.), however further research needs to be conducted. It was also found that there was human error during the recordings of data, with a couple of the plots not properly surveyed (C4, C5, D4, D5), therefore making the results unreliable and inaccurate. Cattle intrusion also impacts local birds species like the Rufous Fantail, Rhipidura rufifrons, through scaring off insects when passing though grassy areas, as they are sit and wait type predators and rely on insects as their main food source. Through looking back at the records in 1988, the Rufous Fantail was not present however it was previously recorded in 1984-1987, suggesting that conditions have improved since disappearing in 1988 and they have been able to successfully recolonise the area. Whilst visiting the plots, there was rubbish found at each of the sites and tyre tracks, suggesting that humans still frequently visit the Park even though it is listed as a Conservation Park. This could have future impact on the land through pollution. Biodiversity Assets When comparing the species observed in 2014 to those found in the Lake Broadwater: The Natural History of an Inland Lake and its Environments, there was a number of species found that have not been here since recorded in 1988. The Koala, Phascolarctos cinereus, was also not previously recorded on the mammal species list, being a recent inhabitant. Another example is the Delicate Mouse, Pseudomys delicatulus, a native to Australia that is constantly threatened by a range of factors including predation and ) competition. The risk of predation was observed to be particularly high, as all of the feral observed species were observed, with cats and dogs being the highest threat for small mammals, and could possibly lead to detrimental effects (i.e. disappear completely from the park). Biodiversity is important in any environment, as it is essential for conservation to occur and prevent species from becoming extinct, as a diverse environment is a healthy environment (Lamoreux et al, 2005). From the appendix it can be observed that Lake Broadwater plays host to a diverse array of different vertebrate groups and species numbers could possibly be inclining. Threatened Species All three key threatened species were located on the plots doing survey time. This means that there they are still abundant throughout the plots, however estimates of population can not be made without further research. Although Koala scats were found, most of it was old which does not provide an accurate estimate into the presence and abundance. However Koalas are active movers and do not stay in the same area for an extended period of time (Prevett, 1991) suggesting that the scats that were found could have been from an individual that passed through the area but are still present in the Park. One other major implication imposed on Koalas is that studies have shown that they will move long distances in short periods of time due to stressful factors such as Wild Dogs, which could eventually lead to the movement of Koalas away from the Park, with a massive reduction in population numbers (Prevett, 1991). Although Koalas are only listed as threatened throughout Australia in general and of least concern in Queensland (Queensland Government Wildlife Online, 2013), management still needs to be enforced in order to remove Wild Dogs from the Park to provide safety for the local species, both threatened and common. There was error in the results however during surveying, as some groups only searched for Koala scats and not others, and some groups recorded YES to finding scats, without realising it meant ONLY Koalas. This also makes the scat data inaccurate and unreliable. Cattle scratch their body against the base of trees, which removes all of the bark. After a period of time this can result in the ring barking of trees, which could result in the decline in the species such as the Golden-tailed Gecko which have been found to prefer Brigalow trees (Queensland Government, 2013) and the Pale-headed Snake which uses bark and * tree hollows to hide beneath and locate prey also hidden (Gibbons and Lindenmayer, 2002). The shift of Golden-tailed Geckos has already been observed, as the one that was found during the survey time was found on an Acacia deanei tree, however no conclusion can be made without further research. The Pale-headed Snakes found were juveniles, suggesting a positive outlook in regards to conservation status. Their age suggests that successful reproduction is occurring and there are no barriers preventing them from reproducing. However the biggest factors that cause threat to them is clearing and fragmentation including activities which result in loss of old or dead trees, as these also play a vital component in respect to habitat (Beatson, 2013), so consistent monitoring needs to be ensured to prevent this from happening. Overall it is looking positive for the key threatened species present at the park, as they were all present and healthy, however further research needs to be conducted.
REFERENCES
Beatson, Cecilie. Pale-headed Snake. Australian Museum. Date created: 24 th June 2013. Last submitted: 10 th May 2014. http://australianmuseum.net.au/Pale-headed-Snake
Bruner, A. G., Gullison, R. E., Rice, R. E., & Da Fonseca, G. A. (2001). Effectiveness of parks in protecting tropical biodiversity. Science, 291(5501), 125-128.
Gibbons, P., & Lindenmayer, D. (2002). Tree hollows and wildlife conservation in Australia. CSIRO publishing.
Hart, Charles R., Lyons, Robert K. (2013). Pricklypear Biology and Management. Texas AgriLife Extension publication, 8(10), 1-8.
Lamoreux, J. F., Morrison, J. C., Ricketts, T. H., Olson, D. M., Dinerstein, E., McKnight, M. W., & Shugart, H. H. (2006). Global tests of biodiversity concordance and the importance of endemism. Nature, 440(7081), 212-214.
"+ Magnusson, W., Braga-Neto, R., Pezzini, F., Baccaro, F., Bergallo, H., Penha, J., Pontes, A. R. M. (2013). Biodiversity and Integrated Environmental Monitoring.
Martin, T. G., Kuhnert, P. M., Mengersen, K., & Possingham, H. P. (2005). The power of expert opinion in ecological models using Bayesian methods: impact of grazing on birds. Ecological Applications, 15(1), 266-280.
Nichols, J. D., & Williams, B. K. (2006). Monitoring for conservation. Trends in Ecology & Evolution, 21(12), 668-673.
Prevett, P. T. (1991). Movement paths of koalas in the urban-rural fringes of Ballarat, Victoria: implications for management. Nature Conservation 2: The Role of Corridors, Conference/Workshop, Busselton, Western Australia.
Queensland Government Wildlife Online. Species list generation. Last submitted: 13 th
December 2013. Date viewed: 10 th May 2014. https://www.ehp.qld.gov.au/wildlife/wildlife-online/
Queensland Government. Golden-tailed Gecko. Department of Environment and Heritage Protection. Last submitted: 10 th January 2013. Date viewed: 10 th May 2014. http://www.ehp.qld.gov.au/wildlife/threatened-species/near- threatened/goldentailed_gecko.html
Scott, Gillian. (1988) Lake Broadwater, The Natural History Of An Inland Lake And Its Environments. Darling Downs Institute Press. Toowoomba.
Solis, M. A., Hight, S. D., Gordon, D. R., & Florida, P. O. (2004). Tracking the cactus moth, Cactoblastis cactorum Berg as it flies and eats its way westward in the US. News of the Lepidopterists' Society, 46, 3-5.
""
FIGURES
Figure 1. Map showing all of the LTER plots to be assessed.
Figure 2. Number of alive Prickly Pear observed at each plot and the size classing. N.B not all plots were assessed and some data was unable to be interpreted correctly. + &+ "++ "&+ #++ #&+ ," ,# ,% ,& -" -& -' ." .# .% .& /$ /% /& ! " # $ % &
Figure 3. Dead Prickly Pear numbers observed at each of the sites. N.B not all plots were assessed and some data was unable to be interpreted correctly.
Figure 3. Total Koala scat counts present at each of the plots.
MAMMALS OBSERVED IN LAKE BROADWATER COSERVATION PARK ORDER MONOTREMATA SUBCLASS PROTOTHERIA Family Phascolarctidae Phascolarctos cinereus Koala ORDER POLYPROTODONTA Family Dasyuridae Phascogale tapoatafa Brush-tailed Phascogale Sminthopsis murina murina Common Dunnart Antechinus flavipes Yellow-footed antechinus ORDER DIPROTODONTA Family Petauridae Petaurus breviceps Sugar glider Family Phalangeridae Trichosurus vulpecula Common Brushtail possum Family Macropodidae Macropus giganteus Eastern Grey Kangaroo Macropus rufogriseus Red-Necked Wallaby Wallabia bicolor Swamp Wallaby "( SUBCLASS EUTHERIA ORDER CHIROPTERA Pteropus spp. Flying-fox ORDER RODENTIA Family Muridae Mus musculus House Mouse Pseudomys delicatulus Delicate Mouse ORDER LAGOMORPHA Family Leporidae Oryctolagus cuniculus European Rabbit ORDER CARNIVORA Family Canidae Vulpes vulpes Red Fox Canis familiaris/Canis lupus dingo Dingo Hybird Family Felidae Felis catus Domestic Cat ORDER ARTIODACTYLA Family Suidae Sus scrofa Wild Boar ORDER CHIROPTERA Family Molosidae Austronomous australis White-striped Free-tailed Bat
REPTILES OBSERVED IN LAKE BROADWATER COSERVATION PARK Chelidae TURTLES Chelonidae spp. Gekkonidae GECKOES Gehyra dubia Dubious or Northern Dtella Gehyra variegate Tree Dtella Oedura robusta Robust Velvet Gecko Heteronotia binoei Bynoe's Gecko ") Strophurus taenicauda Golden-tailed Gecko Diplodactylus vittatus Wood or Eastern Stone Gecko Pygopodidae FLAP-FOOTED LIZARDS Lialis burtonis Burtons Legless Lizard Agamidae DRAGONS Pogona barbata Eastern Bearded Dragon Amphibolurus burnsi Burns Dragon Scincidae SKINKS Egernia striolate Tree Skink Ctenotus robustus Eastern Striped Skink Cryptoblepharus virgatus Snake-eyed or Fence Skink Tiliqua rugosa aspera Shingleback Varandiae MONITORS Varanus gouldii Sand Goanna Varanus varius Lace Monitor Elapidae SNAKES Pseudechis guttatus Spotted Black Snake Pseudechis porphyriacus Red-bellied Black Snake Hoplocephalus bitorquatus Pale-headed Snake FROGS OBSERVED IN LAKE BROADWATER CONSERVATION PARK Family Myobatrachidae Limnodynastes terraerginae Northern Banjo Frog Platyplectrum ornatum Ornate Burrowing Frog Limnodynastes salmini Salmon-striped Frog Limnodynastes peronii Striped-marsh Frog Neobatrachus sudelli Painted Burrowing Frog Limnodynastes tasmaniensis Spotted Marsh Frog Limnodynastes fletcheri Barking Marsh Frog Uperoleia rugosa Wrinkled Toadlet Uperoleia lavigata Smooth Toadlet Pelobates fuscus Common Spadefoot Toad "* Family Hylidae Litoria nasuta Striped Rocket Frog Litoria latopalmata Broad-palmed Frog PLANT SPECIES OBSERVED IN LAKE BROADWATER COSERVATION PARK Callitris glaucophyla White Cyprus Pine Eucalyptus populnea Poplar Box Allocasuarina luehmannii Bull-oak Eucalyptus tereticornis Forest Red Gum Eucalyptus Crebra Narrow-leaved Ironbark Acacia melvillei Yarran Cormbia tusselaris Moreton Bay Ash