Topic What is nationalism? Grade Level 20-1 Subjects English & Social & Phys Ed & Art Time Frame 5-6 Weeks Developed by Sara Brooke Koscielnuk, Michelle Kurchak, Amanda Mullen, Adam Pratt, Nicole Safruk
SS: Students will be able to become critical thinkers regarding the concept of nationalism from multiple perspectives and its relation to government, international affairs, national development, and identity formation.
ELA: Through inquiry students will critically manage and interpret information, creatively, and respectfully in a globalized world.
Enduring Understandings/Big Ideas:
SS: Students will understand how national identity formation occurs through varying perspectives and how this contributes to international society.
ELA: Students gather meaning, and interpret different forms of written and verbal expression
Students will learn how to express their personal experiences and opinions through academic writing
Essential Questions:
Overarching Question: What is Nationalism?
SS: How do individual nations contribute to their own national development while maintaining international relationships?
ELA: Where does individual expression and opinion appropriately contribute to research-based inquiry? Knowledge objectives (key outcomes):
SS: Students will engage with critical perspectives regarding national identity in order to understand and appreciate diverse national perspectives in an international arena.
Students will work collaboratively, respectfully, and ethically in a globalized setting.
ELA: Students will cooperate to achieve a shared goal of understanding and creating different types of texts.
Students will utilize and develop effective individual and group communication skills.
Skills/Attitudes objectives (key outcomes): Students will be able to . . . SS: Respect and appreciate attitudes towards diverse identities and nations Develop their own sense of identity though critical thinking Formulate collaborative and leadership responsibilities to problem solve and formulate collective positions ELA: Express their ideas, thoughts, and opinions in individual and collective settings through multiple modalities Will be able to interpret and critically assess different perspectives Stage 2 Assessment Evidence Performance Task(s):
Development of a presentation on a student-generated nation-state in terms of course themes and knowledge. (My Country)
Students will create and present a sport to the class that directly relates to their created nation in terms of the nations values and beliefs.
Students will gain knowledge about their nation, as well as their peers nations, in order to facilitate a Nations United debate.
Once the debate has been completed, students will write an in-class essay encompassing all of the information they have obtained during their presentation and debate participation.
Formative Assessments
Students will have multiple opportunities to examine their progress in terms of teacher- provided formative assessments, as well as opportunities to engage with peers.
- KWL charts - Submission of first drafts for presentation components (Eg. National flag/anthem, article of faith etc.) - Journaling - Dice game used to gauge student understanding of economic principles - Practice debate - Use of tools such as POMS, and Fist to Five
Summative Assessments
My Country Presentation: Students will be evaluated on their ability to incorporate classroom knowledge with their own research regarding their chosen country. Students will also be evaluated on the individual components comprising their overall project. Additionally, student presentation skills and clarity will be evaluated to determine a partial grade for both Social Studies and English Language Arts.
Sport Creation: Students will be evaluated on their creativity, connections to historical themes (beliefs and values), and their presentation skills. Additionally, students will be evaluated on their ability to provide constructive peer feedback.
Nations United Debate: Students will demonstrate, and be evaluated on, their debate skills as well as their knowledge pertaining to their chosen country and its values.
In-class Essay: Students will be evaluated on their written presentation of ideas pertaining to concepts taught during the interdisciplinary nationalism unit.
Teachers will work together to determine grade allocations between the disciplines.
Stage 3 Learning Plan # Lesson Title Lesson Activity Key Outcomes Evidence Materials Resources 1 Review
Nationalism review, KWL chart on nation of personal interest
Term understanding, KWL completion, ELA 2.1.3 KWL chart KWL chart, PPT Journal Writing In class writing assignment on country they want to learn about and why (Based on KWL from SS) ELA 1.1.1 Journal Journal Notebook 2 Organizati on Group organization based on KWL responses (assign groups based on areas of interest), discuss KWLs within groups, talk about country name and basic premise for ELA 2.1.3, Benchmark Skills and Processes Collaborative efforts KWL Chart project Meaning Making Examine national flags, and anthems through a brief teacher-led discussion. Students will then begin to design a flag and/or an anthem. Teacher will make sure it is unique, and based on researched symbolism and ideas. ELA 3.1.1 -- formative assessment of KWL Creation of flag or anthem Computer access, Poster paper, Pencil crayons, markers, pencils 3 Design Flag/Anthem Design within groups teacher- support through group discussions Flag: Investigate (A) (C) Impact (A) (B) Articulate (C) Relationship 2(A) Sources of Images (C)
Anthem: Organizations (B) Creation of flag or anthem (submit design) Computer access Rationale Write rationale on chosen country flag. Include symbolism and why it is important. Write in an academic format provide brief review of academic writing if necessary ELA 5.1.1 Written rationale Computers and notebook 4 National Sport Lecture on national sports (cultural associations vs. assigned national sport Hockey vs. Lacrosse). German Third Reich Olympics, Vancouver Olympics as examples of nationalism in sport SS. 2.7, Understand outcomes (Chosen sport) PPT National Sport Introduce PE assignment. Talk about Canadas National sport (Lacrosse). What about Hockey? Summarize an article about the Canadian / USSR game. Have students begin thinking about the sport they will later create in their groups ELA 5.1.3, ELA 2.3.1
P.E C 20-4 P.E D 20-3 Active listening, discussion Research and development PPT Computers/iPad s 5 History Lecture on relationship b/w nationalism and ultranationalism during times of conflict SS 2.7, 2.8, 3.7 Active Listening PPT Mandates Look at International mandates Read several different national mandates, and begin thinking about what they say and how theyre written (briefly describe upcoming Article of Faith assignment) SS 3.7, ELA 2.1.2 Active listening PPT 6 Modern Ties Lecture on the Vietnam and Iraq wars national perspectives and international actions in a modern context SS. 3.4, 3.5 Active Listening PPT Article of Faith Students write their own Article of Faith for their groups chosen country. Students can receive peer feedback through Think, Pair, Share of their Articles of Faith. ELA 2.1.2 Group collaboration Computer access 7 Modern Ties Contd Continue Modern Ties lecture, and provide time for discussion on current conflicts (eg. Russian invasion of Ukraine) SS. 3.4, 3.5 Discussion Article of Faith Students to continue writing their article of Faith. Finalize document using previous classs peer review feedback. ELA. 3.1.1, 3.2.1 Group collaboration Computer access 8 Economic s Lecture on the economic foundations of nations. Look into national budgeting look up national GDP of region of choice and begin allocating funds based on numbers they find online SS. 3.4, 3.8 Group collaboration, active research (presentation) Computer Access Economic s Continue research on economic foundation of nations. Budgeting (GDP of region of choice) Create a final budget for nation ELA 3.1.1, 3.2.1 Group collaboration, active research Computer access 9 Economic Turmoil Impact of natural disaster, disease etc. lecture (Haiti, Ebola). Follow lecture with SS. 3.6, 3.8 Group collaboration Dice for each group, the die rolling game impact of uncontrollable events -- impact economic ramifications explanation of possible losses Economic Turmoil Die rolling game - researching impacts on other countries examine their natural disaster type and how it has affected other nations - Use die game to alter budget (finalize revised budget in class) SS 3.8 Group collaboration, active research Dice for each group, explanation of possible losses 10 National Sport Research athletic activity in library (choose activity type) begin thinking of rules and necessary resources ELA 3.1.2 Research accomplishment Computer access, book access National Sport Look at sport equipment and begin development (write rules) work in the gym ELA 3.1.2 Group collaboration Access to gym, pencil and paper 11 Work Period Provide time to develop all activities Receive teacher and peer feedback (Think, Pair, Share) students can choose what project component they want to receive feedback on ELA 2.2.1 Think, Pair, Share activity
Feedback Give feedback on research done so far. Get students to do a self-reflection on where they need to go from there. ELA 2.2.1, 4.2.4 Collect self- reflection from students
12 Govt Resource s Mini-lesson on national and international government types (autocratic, democratic, etc.). Give time for groups to decide on a style that works with their nations values, and have students look into how this impacts national decisions SS 2.9, 3.5, 3.7 Cohesive decision on govt type (submit) PPT, library resources Proposal Formulate presentation proposal. Ensure teacher feedback is given and presentation ideas are approved before students continue on ELA 1.1.1 Group collaboration
13 Resource s contd Continue on with government types discussion examine available national resources online, and decide how these will be utilized. Ask students for rubric suggestions that may be incorporated into the final rubric design SS 2.5, 2.9, 3.5, 3.7 Development of resource allocation (submit) Library resources Presentati on Building Begin building presentation provide guidelines on what they can do for their final presentation (poster, travel ad, travel website, PowerPoint, podcast, etc.) ELA 1.1.1 Group collaboration Computer access 14 Developin g My Country Presentati on Begin developing presentation on nation state values, govt, resources, allocation etc. 15 minutes set aside at the end of class to set up for sport presentations in the following English class ELA 1.1.1, Covers all Dimensions of Thinking Submit work so far for supportive evaluation Computer access, access to gym Sport Presentati on Present sport / activity. 3 groups will have 25 minutes to present and teach the class. Each group will then have 5 minutes to receive constructive peer feedback verbally. Students will be asked to formally write their feedback as homework. ELA 4.2.1 C20-5, C20-6, C20-4, C20-1 D20-3 Active listening and participation Access to the gym 15 Culture and identity Lecture on the historical factors of culture and identity in nationalism vs. ultranationalism (Causes of genocide, impact on self-determination, etc.) -- encourage students to discuss modern contributing factors of culture and identity SS 2.8, 2.9 Active Listening, discussion contributions PPT View Movie Show Triumph of the Will. Have students write notes for discussion next class. ELA 2.2.2 Articulate (C) Active listening Access to television and Sources of Images (A,B,C) movie 16 Culture and identity Contd Continue with ideas of modern examples from previous day. Teacher-led in depth discussion on how this could impact their nations development. Provide time for students to incorporate these ideas into their project. SS 2.8, 2.9 Discussion contributions, project development PPT Movie Discussio n Discussion on Triumph of the Will movie in relation to themes from the ELA POS. ELA 2.2.2, 2.3.1, 2.3.3 Active participation
17 Work Period Provide time to work on project and integrate previous information on what the culture and identity of nation will be Provides room for students to Research for Deliberative Inquiry and develop communication skills Project Development
Review Review and go over impact of nationalism and identity on selves. (Revisit Dice game)
Active listening and participation
18 Triumpth of the Will Lead discussion on themes of Triumph of the Will, and how it relates to ultranationalism and views. Brief lecture on historical importance. Provide chance for individuals to write on films impact on nation ideas in the form of a journal entry. SS 2.5, 2.7 Written component PPT Sport Presentati on 3 groups will have 25 minutes to present and teach the class their activity. Each group will then have 5 minutes to receive constructive peer feedback verbally. Students will be asked to formally write their feedback as homework. ELA 4.1.4, 4.2.1 C20-5,C20-6, C20-4,C20-1 D20-3
A20-11, A20-10, A20-11, A20-3, A20-5
A20-1, A20-5, A20-8, A20-9, A20-12 Active listening and participation Access to the gym 19 Work Period Work period to develop final presentation (to be given the following week) Group progress Library access Work Period Work period to allow students to catch up on any components they are behind on. Students can receive peer and teacher feedback. ELA 4.2.1 Group collaboration, active listening PPT, access to computers 20 Mini Debate Provide mini-lecture on debate protocol discuss appropriate behaviours and communication styles. Give students a mock- debate question. Provide 20min for groups to develop their debate rationale. Then have a 30 min debate between groups. Provide feedback and suggestions at the end of class. ELA 2.2.1, Increased Historical Communication skills Debate skills Work Period Final work period for presentation Group collaboration, active participation Access to computers 21 Presentati ons Present nations to class (15 minutes per group) 5 minutes to receive and answer class questions Fulfills all Benchmark Skills and Processes, ELA 4.2.1 Presentation quality Presentation supplies Presentati ons Present nations to class. Each group will be allowed 15 minutes to present, 5 minutes to receive and answer class questions Fulfills all Benchmark Skills and Processes, ELA 4.2.1 Active participation, active listening Access to class computer, SMART board 22 Feedback Provide peer feedback through a class discussion. Additionally, provide teacher feedback students can incorporate into the final Nations United debate ELA 2.2.1, 4.3.4, Benchmark Skills and Processes Quality of peer feedback
Feedback Give students remaining feedback from presentations. Hand out debate questions to allow students to begin developing their debate rationale. ELA 2.2.1, 4.3.4, Benchmark Skills and Processes Active listening PPT 23 Debate Prep Provide class time to prepare for the final debate Benchmark Skills and Processes Use of class time
Debate Prep Provide class time to prepare for the final debate Benchmark Skills and Processes Active participation Access to computers 24 Debate Provide time for debate. Provide assessment based on debate skills and the information presented. Look for consistency with the groups initial presentations in terms of following their aforementioned national ideals Benchmark Skills and Processes Debate skills and attitudes
Essay Topics Continue debate. In remaining class time give topics for in-class essay. Allow students to think about questions over the weekend to allow for preparation. Answer questions students may have Benchmark Skills and Processes Active listening PPT 25 Potluck Potluck with representational foods groups should explain the importance of their national dish to their national identity. Benchmark Skills and Processes Potluck explanations
In class essay Students will write about their experiences in a final reflective essay ELA 2.2.1, 4.3.4 Essay Completion and success
Stage 4 Reflection Considerations Comments
How has learner differentiation been addressed? The provision of learner opportunities to engage with the material from various perspectives allows all learner types to internalize learning through group collaboration, individual work, computer research, textual interpretation, and presentation development. For example, students who may not be strong public speakers have the opportunity to showcase their strengths through creative writing exercises. Varying elements of choice in activities and assignments will also help in addressing the needs of individual students and groups.
ELL students are able to acquire knowledge throughout many subject areas via meaningful and effective teaching and content that engages them in English language learning. If the needs of ELL students can be addressed in this way, it will prevent them from being removed from class to do extra work in English. The inclusion of different countries within this unit plan also allows ELL learners to open up about their experiences and add to the depth of classwork. Opportunities for ELL students to teach other students about their first language and home country will also exist. This will allow students to incorporate their interests and experiences, thus enriching classroom learning as well as and understanding and appreciation of other students. In summary, this unit serves to enhance ELL learning through inclusion and allows ELL students to understand the essential value of their experiences and first language. How does the unit design include a variety of teaching experiences that includes: FNMI, Through the examination of nationalism and its associated concepts, we are providing students opportunities to examine multiple ways of knowing through active research. Additionally, many of the examples provided through lecture and reading materials directly relate to distinct cultures and historical contexts and can multicultural, and interdisciplinary activities. be related to FMNI history and culture within Canada.
Evaluation of Unit Plan In order to ensure students are progressing appropriately throughout the project there are many formative assessment and student lead feedback opportunities. The provision of multiple work periods allows the teacher to interact with each group, and its contributing individuals, in order to examine whether students are on the right track, or if they need further guidance. If a particular concept is being shown to be too challenging, there is available time built in to the unit to revisit confusing concepts to ensure deep understanding. By keeping running notes on successes and necessary changes for the duration of the unit teachers will be able to enhance the unit in previous years, furthering its effectiveness.
From: Wiggins, Grant and J. McTighe. (1998). Understanding by Design, Association for Supervision and Curriculum Development, Alexander, Virgina.