Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Matters
An analysis of a mentoring
program between Coalhurst
Elementary and High Schools.
Table of Contents
Acknowledgements
Our Goals
Implementation
Recommendations
Conclusion
Bibliography
11
Appendices
12
I.
Letter To Parents
12
Consent Form
13
III.
15
IV.
20
Parts of a Leaf
22
VI.
23
VII.
24
VIII.
30
35
36
XI.
37
XII.
39
II.
V.
IX.
X.
1|
Acknowledgements
We would like to acknowledge Chris McIntyre and
Dawn Ronne for allowing our students to be brought together
during regular classroom hours to participate in our mentorship
analysis. Without their cooperation we may not have been able
to inspire as many grade tens to join this experience.
A special thank you to Mrs. Fraser for allowing the high
school students to be a part of her grade two-three classroom.
Our students deserve a huge thank you for all of their
efforts and their willingness to learn. It was with their cooperation and eagerness that our project was a success. We look
forward to seeing what may come from these interactions and if
we have inspired any students to support their community in
new ways they didnt know they could before.
Phil Collins
2|
3|
4|
Our Goals
Our research goals focused on:
How do high school students take on the mentorship
role?
How does the mentorship program benefit elementary
school students?
Work collaboratively between the two schools and
administrators to create an environment that is mutually
beneficial for students but beneficial for the community
as a whole.
Many of the grade tens started out not wanting to participate
and not excited to work with younger kids. By the end of the
first mentorship day grade tens were chatting excitedly about
the students they worked with and were discussing what the
next time could be like. Some students even volunteered to go
to the school to help the elementary students paint pumpkins.
These actions are what prompted the idea of creating a club for
those interested in being more involved in their community in a
positive mentorship role.
A lot of people have gone further than they thought they could because someone else thought they could.
Unknown
5|
Implementation of Program
We thought it would be best for the first Mentorship day
to have the grade tens running a particular station and have the
two-threes rotating through. This set up we thought would
work best for the two-threes to get comfortable and establish a
rapport with the grade tens. It would also be better for the grade
tens to get to know the two-threes without committing to a
particular student right away. This was the safest way to
integrate these two groups, especially with grade tens who
seemed skeptical of the mentorship project at the beginning.
The grade tens would also be in groups with peers that could
help them out if they were to come across any issues with a
particular student or being able to feed off of what techniques
peers use to help teach the elementary students about the
activity they are engaging in.
Ms. Annett placed her grade two-threes into eight
groups. Ms. Toth explained to the grade tens what the eight
activities would be and the product that would be created out of
this. Grade ten names were chosen randomly and upon having
their name called signed up for the activity that they wanted to
participate in. This way of choosing would gear the grade tens
to an activity they were interested in rather than a specific
group of peers. This would also mix the grade tens up and allow
them to work alongside students they may not otherwise work
with on a regular basis. This form of choosing who ran each
station had more than one benefit.
Grade ten students were sent home with a permission slip
so parents were aware that students would be walking from the
High School to the Elementary school and would be
participating in this mentorship program. The mentorship
program at this age has an Alberta Education Curriculum
component with the grade two-threes it addresses the theme of
Our Community while the program addresses the grade ten
curriculum of globalization as well as their SLOs that have
them involved in making their community better.
PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT: Mentorship Matters
6|
Leaders should influence others in such a way that it builds people up,
encourages and edifies them so they can duplicate this attitude in others.
Bob Goshen
PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT: Mentorship Matters
7|
Recommendations
We feel that it is important for all educators to involve
themselves in a mentorship program and take time to plan for the
success of the students. Planning is essential for the success of the
program. Moreover, if teachers are available to connect with both
older and younger students directly before entering the program,
both sets of students will benefit.
Some further recommendations include:
Gearing the activities towards benefitting
elementary students in their curriculum in
engaging ways
Show high school students that this process and
activity is worthwhile in their community
Try to get to know the students that will be
involved in this process before pairing them up,
this way you can try to match students who are of
similar personalities together or even an outgoing
student with someone a little quieter to build off of
each other.
Young children are cognisant of how a role model
or older person behaves and reacts so it is
recommended that responsible and positive people
work with these children, it will bring about the
best in the younger students
Just about ANY personality trait or skill can be learned: simply find it in someone you know and copy it.
Then watch what happens.
Steve Goodier
PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT: Mentorship Matters
8|
Conclusion
We utilized two trial dates to determine how beneficial a
mentorship program would be to the community and there were
a few things that we noted about the encounters between the
two age groups. First it enabled the grade ten students, those
who have not worked with younger students before, the efforts
that are needed to work with young children. Teaching young
students and keeping them engaged and occupied is not an easy
task, and the grade tens came to this realization as they worked
with the elementary students. Also young children learn a vast
amount of new information outside their classroom, and they
often become more engaged by people who are not in the
teaching profession and they do not see often.
The next step in this program would be to implement a
permanent program that could occur once a week at the
Elementary school that will begin by building relationships
between students before moving onto subject matter. The High
school students in this program need to be those who want to
help and work with younger ones and understand that they are
constantly being watched and are expected to be role models.
The Elementary students involved are those seeking extra help
in their studies from a new source. Students may be more
receptive to someone they do not see on a regular basis and are
closer to their age.
Some possible advantages of this program for elementary
students include:
One-on-one time to practice new skills
Improve students attitudes and interests in their reading,
writing, and listening skills
New learning experiences
Variety of learning techniques
PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT: Mentorship Matters
9|
The best help we can offer the youth of today is to prepare them for tomorrow.
Mark W. Boyer
PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT: Mentorship Matters
10 |
Bibliography
DuBois, D.L., & Silverthorn, N. (2005). Natural mentoring relationships and
adolescent health: Evidence from a national study. American Journal of
Public Health, 95, 518-524.
Grossman, J.B., & Tierney, J.P. (1998). Does mentoring work? An impact
study of the Big Brothers Big Sisters program. Evaluation Review, 22, 403426.
Robert Ingersoll
11 |
Sincerely,
Ellie Annett
12 |
13 |
14 |
15 |
varied in level. The grade two-threes will pick a book they want to read and will sit
with a grade ten and read the book to them. The job of the grade ten is to listen and
help the elementary student with tough words while monitoring their reading ability.
If a book is too difficult it is best to help them find another book to read. Once all the
students have read to the grade tens, the grade tens may choose a book to read to the
two-threes.
Materials:
Several books about the fall/autumn
Several books about Halloween
Several books about Thanksgiving
Quiet room to read in
What the center is designed to accomplish:
This activity center is based upon the principles of the reading buddy system that
many schools utilize. The academic demands upon students seem to be increasing
over and often students are entering school without the literacy background they need
to be successful or fall behind the grade standards. This center is designed to help in
this area. On the other hand, upper-year students tend to lack the confidence they
require to be better readers and writers themselves, thus this activity allows students
to gather confidence in their own reading abilities, whatever level they are at.
What we would do differently next time:
Emphasize with the grade tens that it needs to be more about the two-threes reading.
Sometimes the grade tens can get excited about reading to the younger ones, this is an
important part of the learning process but the focus really needs to be on the
elementary students and improving their reading skills and comprehension.
3. Art Pointillism Trees
Description:
Students will travel to the art center to work on a tree done in the style of pointillism.
Here, the grade 2/3 students will be given a printed tree, bare of leaves. Their task is
to use Q-tips dipped in paint to position on the branches of the tree. The colors are
done in traditional fall shades and the grade 10 students will help them with the
plotting of colors.
Materials:
Q-tips
Acrylic Paints
Paper towel
Water
What the center is designed to accomplish:
This center is designed to have students focus on color, position and of course for
socialization with each other. We found that this center, the younger children really
PROFESSIONAL DEVELOPMENT: Mentorship Matters
16 |
began to feel comfortable with the older ones, and enjoyed each others company.
Also, this center allowed for experimentation in art and we found children were
doing just that. Adding in different images into their work really helped them think
outside the box.
What we could do differently next time:
Next time, it would be best to choose a project that required more focus than simply
plotting paint on a sheet of paper. Having students rely on their fine motor skills
would be a better activity for the younger students and possibly allowing the 10s to
be involved with the project a bit more.
17 |
Materials:
Smartboard
Website. www.primarykids.com
What the center is designed to accomplish:
This center is designed to engage students with technology and have the 10s assist
the 2/3s with their understanding. Technology is an important asset to learning and it
is best to have as much practice with it as possible. The 2/3s are experiencing
different learning but of the same material and the 10s have the opportunity to assist
the younger children with their already learned knowledge of technology.
What we could do differently next time:
To continue with this theme of technology, I feel that if we were to use individual
devices such as iPads, students would have had more time to experience the
technology. Also, this would allow for more one-on-one help from the 10s.
18 |
because after the first group they noticed that playing the same game or two got
tiresome for both age groups. The tens asked the two-threes what games they knew
and in turn the tens were taught by the younger ones which is a wonderful twist but
great to see.
19 |
20 |
21 |
22 |
23 |
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
What did you enjoy the most about going over to CES
What did you not enjoy about going over to CES
What would you want to keep for the next trip
What do you suggest needs to change for the next trip
Overall how did yesterday go for you? Share some information about how you got along
with the kids; were there some you got along with more than others? Did you find the
kids enjoyed the activity you did with them?
6. Do you think that a mentorship program such as this is beneficial for yourself? For other
students in your school?
7. Do you think that a mentorship program such as this is beneficial for the elementary
students? Could you see any evidence of this yesterday?
8. Lastly, since we will be doing this again in December, which will have a Christmas
theme, share any activities that you think might be fun for the young ones and for
yourself.
24 |
25 |
26 |
27 |
28 |
29 |
30 |
31 |
important part of the learning process but the focus really needs to be on the
elementary students and improving their reading skills and comprehension.
32 |
33 |
34 |
35 |
36 |
37 |
38 |
39 |
40 |
41 |
42 |
43 |
44 |
45 |