wen
CHILDREN OF FATE
Childhood, Class, and the State in Chile, 1850-1930
[Nara B. Milanich
ae Unive Pree Durham nd London
Algjuadia Re
Dae 2212
Gouda dyepera neineienioenintRopuctioN
aad
State, Class Society, and Children in Chile
‘The Chie, ade andthe Dota
‘The tia opr brought to the ade anion in November 254
concer he nec shred cre ing ins oor gor
od Sng An oil wi pce 0 6 Mai Sew, baat
recounted in hs epor, th wttan who opened the door war
‘lly ancoperaiv, At Ea se ete to pean the cen in
(Tieson and then predcd te eaty-Lokeg one Eventually, he
(Sa ssh 5 gl wove aly condition made me suspect (he
epor of abut war ra” Aer ordering the arto the wma and
‘evel other ines, he etched the ase ad ound to oer
hte wh haben hen der aed
"Theol ets th younger De, ido and jot Man
‘et Pin sbingrberecen he apes ofepprccmattyevenand ten He
(eared th dren "ed mate des dened in thy gh hey
‘bed hangerin the tre senaefthe wor" Dla worms ee
Sopdet Manel an Rd apy “tines at proved
act” Photographs tle atthe jegnsruton how the chien
ood ons caesne set witha wonden cr at prop, bf,
‘inthe a rap. sing piney athe camer of ft 0 ose
"The jd pad for he crn tobe ated ad fe st his penal
per and not dy qed them about ha stan. They
Coofee they wor orphane Ing wth rvs and decribed f=
tment ht wld lt be eserdinand death newooapes,
ow thy ably page ot fac. The threo cou ot
5) bw od they we and i not aw the nyo the moter oFQideotn he Pin cen en hy fata ecm a
|
bo ng he pares haben ded Subequet eon cond
they were lpia, bor fan adtous and post acs
tion of wl fete ahd poorer woman whom be asad.
The “ne of Mab See” generated eens pes covge at»
smement flossing ube preosspsson wth por chee, Eves
‘Ad wha came of thee? Sever dae afer they were taken
into eoarecsody, Doss Eran Saber apete ble the
Judge. reunsing that thy be vered ther care A prominent mec
‘bef he Sacgo ete nd wid of Don Mek Concha y Tor
‘haul fare, Dae Emlans had no psn eaneton te
‘se Bathe wished place the clren a he la tha she and an
‘ssc, Dota Jona Gara de Joan, had ecely ude The
ge rte er roan nd he los fhe Scie ever ea
Tne coed the Paina na he vey ft warded 1
Inston ttn ssccndng dead, woul aor ee of towns
tf por ehiren. Aer stay eure aration thea placed
‘Del ad jot Mal wth "ed stir fr whom they probly
wert ae eva in each formate eteance and orl te
{Wage Acorn th lg jos Manel an hi rather Rito west
vertu sent eotops soci wih antag la epenage
whe they would eet insracton natn trades, Thereer
acrenary wast of the Patina nih bu pobebl ate can be
reconsructd fm the expense of ote the: poor a ae
les minors ths soe Dela wut come of age x dome
vant the dependency of an npoveritied cidood morphing seas
Ta eto te saboraton of lt sevice, Aker fw ye inthe
Weaihzprerbsther wold emerge with ew pope fo beeing
Independene arising tal engloment na wn Nosed
cr pehaps arr esate The to woul fon anne ad epen
deat underae
‘My earch on cle ad amy i lotth cet Ce ad
mein soothe offcs of Das Ata Nunta de ose. Themen
er ofa prominent, Doss Alc wa the president of he Scat
retecra da nfnc the eam rgd bythe Pinas which
‘nd ert Is centenary sve ers ule She ad ped overshout th oration which provide seve to more hh 9
sei children and employ sw of undress wl the rt
enon sng. Dots Ale bond withthe Protector es ot et =
roduc fhe yes she ha deveed tts good wera howe Her
‘aos was more intimate and profane aml Fo she
‘pn ome, Dota outing the rots second founder va at
[Beat gendnother And Dona Elana who ad ced the Pacis
from the eur, wa the rse-gandmete her husband For oe
entry far generation of worsen om th ee tity kt le clan
dod the Poector. Prompted by my qottos shot the spt
story, Dota Als nd er shad Don ge ams povided ceca
‘xp of thr especie pansies The coupes inne of tet
fal histor was sng they could sponte ito
‘welche af great gundmnoter, This gene veation
Shae ale generis of Ciesn ete spate copy.
os shen tha aps de the Protectors have hissy rece
then the the Poenas—poar abandoned, grate o arpa
‘nos wthlieifanyknwedgeof he ntact.
Dot Akin, Don ogee pet-gandimatery and he Pana
‘in fhe imi the ce oe sentiments domestic eng
‘pent and chdearng™
Sach anaes of etl power eine te rl bie they tie
end, seni cre an tbe domestics Nitorle lemie, slo
\ alm, ntnaion, pds frmstion- tthe sae ine a cles
ff the sate have posted xt sch anaes pose pl Repltony
los can ape epishenmensl dahon eer explain
them we eso sme genene dn ipa ether than nla
lng he spect ris, content. and lector, Narr fer
‘venaon ees ima anary morn“ where none exe
‘And an emphasis on top-down projects iy oversee acti ie
ec® Bde bor Cie mgpes sever onl ekiaes int,
Posing the elstionahip beeen publi etry ed the rate sphere
{5 zao-nim cont obec the extent to which hee to ese
cual dew on common wellofeltul bles price A dxpy
Senne soils ctrl etry, Kishi ws sl etal to the
‘chet ofc iw nd teal person. This shred since
‘yo means peed toon Dewees te sd amy bate dows
sug hiretonaipwascharcterinnd by ore thant metic
onpation.
‘second entqu concems the regulatory inet el thre as
ay nineteen Lath Alpen ste wh the wheel 0
“impos win the pve sper tar the Cen oe Laan it
sonal developments a wel th etna entiation of cl
‘ood an maton would wn oie rate king al en
chldeno sate fomason and naton using Yea wl ho bra
Sitar tibia unieional empleo tp own neve:
oa than competing np, onlin beeen pation sno
‘lated dreamacrpon of ple acon Sate shes empased i
tevemion Sate pacts pod dint abiguas,
1 tte sparen contratone ae fay const wth the
pola eae ht Chen Iberal sposted. At Chan A Fake fas
‘Steere, lean embod Sinden tensa sosaaing
Ipc imps an expesion of ate power (the expense flips
‘thoy bt fr empha on pera eedom and See wil ine
omic an roc fe smpes ste conticion® The hor of e-
ron and fry Che ys bare eon theater al of he
runt eta he ate tematic appro aspect ol he
‘Church eactonl dominion over mrage and ety, tifa
‘coli eonsracts of pe nd pray, coupled with ewe Ural
lets of pcy ad peonl Sead, mtaneouy withew
from some sear had once coged Most consi wa the do
eptn fre: and exumaclocally Af he 850 the cour
‘ay pursed carer of mance, o i ions, which they
a ane proceed wh mote gor Meu departing rm)
long anding canon an Tran pl adi th il Cade end a
ecogaze onal he marge promi exchanged between panes
‘at someine nse eal elton:
In the mow fr-echng refer, explore in prs athe Code
cotlaved poet iveigton, and teed bith reptey made te
‘erding filma ptetr ens oto ving eer sia
‘noon of fami Rone oie th eves Uber ea fe
‘roan an pro ones publ utes etd tems
Paves of the power acer lpm in lations eting
thers the uneete freedom to renpie ont ofsping. The di‘cipal frm of eras n Chie bls tht sie
eal equ one tar of priya nda ert, had ae
aly ferent oasgueneesformen an fo wore I preeuay
ected clon
The impuse to ckcurserption satya inthe Nery of
Publebenecence. As wil be dace in par Il. he epson 3
Sat faded cl were pra represented a cha ablation
of pul espns pon chien san serena. Chlrens
‘sams pated socal ssane othe oor and pce by ering
1 deughouse for cowting chen we er sd tases
espe he oierou thor ote rmcendetal ue iene
| io other woes dd welare continued to be oxteze o pete
oust and acene had be nt li er The expan
lon ofthese yams wich contin eu he et decades ofthe
‘went ent, peed and perp een enhanced the cil
Imparance of informal apd pate pronion for poe chien. The
> enduring enraiy of pinta houses ta sate wear sraey com
| ple biray model of down itrention an popu essance
‘uma hlter not aly epee the tna inherent inthe
ras porue tard he pre they partly dopace th pc
Inga emphasis on the tte ager As explored in prt
foeason cle nd id renring recto nos xa a
‘eracule veut of power icing he naples,
nd paonage win beso Sudha oct ngs tothe oe quot
an pcos of sci epaduton and zeltone of éomintion be
ten masts and sera das apd minor and elite ad pb
‘Anditreelshow houschols bot wealthy and humble expt poor
nd paren acs In shor den dere cl gedesae
enero ower at operated ihn and aoe hols, tt
‘exerci bene "ae and Soc” As Mig! Centens g
‘etl dcpinein Latin Aeneas ecu ne rina in sca
‘be ary, othe pnterty a Earope or Noth Aer, bat
thin fae an hounolde nde, ete Ue of ate
‘etecention often reference imple er xp he wk of Michel
Foucault, Foul ant argued tht owes wast ony not even
mary nestedin there "Rltionsofpowerandhencethwne
hat must be made of hem, ecm extend Beyond the in of he
Se hens "The Sts supestrctartin clan toa west
& ower etc tht invert the ody, seal, the falas.
now, techolog, =" Ix Chil, eracleKoi, elec |
practonand partca fect damon rine cositedvame
‘hose "pectin of power tat fection oui below a ange |
‘hese panne onamich move minute every"
‘Uttely shitingou ln thst ote evel of coc
power has addon latary ec. Anajes of top-down tren
oni sepng endo ary nati, nd cldood signer
nly to the exe that sey ae ate of repulaton and estnce oe
cusses of ther cltons of pone Such amet
‘eng butte dare teint signee ofthe mesons
ofhuan experience’ Ths igifcance isan undeng premise of ths
sau
Sours, Methods Framevorks
‘has whl tis book concerned withthe eon of pl eines
see oomaton, snd cs elton, ako 2 Natori ethnography
of dren spd aon faa Latin American sc. doping al
enscoudy soc stra approach, [sok To tenet vc
‘etd one in which chieennuringon he sop running ete in
‘hesrcts coming ofageinhabe ec evan quees—ate
igo This oa mews ster anaemia round betwen
uneconstucted empire and whelealeposerachliem,ctsng
rnysourcesto yell prcicesewel x cours ol eperiene eel
‘soci comtrscion Atte mm tine, dont ake "te and"
(ypc and “pate or amo bended nites wh ad
‘or pdetemined meaning In hsping th acl hrc a>
otc Seok to show aw the denis ofthe elena
‘co social group and oe tine
‘One sch category cen. Who or what wa cil? Ar itr
a end ensopsngts of chdhond fave shown the ane eo thi
{ston from obvious, varying eth tiger ncn
Curly In Engin etc “hl hat two dierent eigs
‘feo minors wells to pogeny (ln cons Spans has parte‘teams forthe tw concepts ie and he) Tir ok ds wih bath
nso elven” The nla ton in pare probes he heing
ening: fier progeny. The catego of heen te mies
bat mos scholars mean when te ak abut «tayo eerie
morta pla down becaze for met ppl nnetenth-cenry
(Chen inaded,"chldhoo” 0 nent cong tht ey
recesses epic efaion
“The chi exception was inthe ea oft Niue etary cl
law la diingued been cen an al ol beter
al moe and maorty adopting egos tat en echoed
‘howe dnl celal and nederdel en
tins of minor were ot care trnspone it ol ndertand
Inpef childhood however Age wa baton dimension athe deft
fhildhoodforas Banca emote ln Suish Asc,
“tobe mito wa slant ¢ mich an age based stats In
oscslonal Cito, inary wastrel cle
vere sumed tobe scaly ad Ing dependent sts On the
‘ther Md ser tat den were “dependent” tel ws Ite be
‘hse abe ave se, "dependeny could acbrmach thy int
socal nd tater
‘Therelatoniy of chon fur itarsed by considering how
leben crn sass pein ad contrary fect ee
stats cider On the one band in Chie aah, abort
ocalsans was ected with inttin. Aco ober
oper family xen-yer-d svar Mala Cabra wa "ery ay”
‘uch that‘one had to cota salt ero doe ook One when
he aby er mists she ered the Bl wth brooch
But wasn he tres wh cmmected one ls od ni
Isard the being m4 he set even yur on * Gracy
tts ad pede) trumped a in shaping peeption of mina i
tis rdaohin On theater hance plea sata cul
‘compel he precios intone scl seasons uch those
of paconage we uly asocate with ade When couch Las
Alber Ava was area with scent lig ¢ pest, be re
‘senedsever pon wh sted tobi "enor "fem
“mepeahable conduct” Proving aac efron ups
as rouine practice for thoes seeking ll nec, Bat ae Abeta
waten yas old Whee poo hen Were ended "ounge ee
“de by itu ofthe ds the experience of hand wa sp
‘ible fo the scoecnorc ats Neve despite he impor
tance of sats in apis chldhood, one can dicer sneer
cull an egal consene ening the ence of he eater
"eater" and edhod” i the ew place i Less Albee. al
parte endl greed “hr af young ge had na snes eng
feashe and ht el an erminl eaponiy fo the cient ay
‘eth the ale amployers Lae Alberta, we an den, a 8S”
vente pies di ot expres preci how they ined thet
"Tie ten shstory fren However ot epic famed
round th tees tat dominate hissing ld xn nat
pray concrne wih the Hite evel of setnent,cld
[abo elution dinar isons, or changing coneracon of
chlchod (hough Thape my Ens seg ons number of ese
‘hers. Becae they rae he arate agence of Hlé wth a
{exe Intend have famed hi ay rund wo bing cen of
[en Ameria tory en ltorlograpy, aay, tt formation nit
the dar of else Thas arene, of ou, hme set hs
eon Apropos of rez sory of denn the Ue Sates, the
Sesh torah Hugh Cantngham nqued. "What wold he sory
dood lok ke ewe a part fh ony fl
‘le dy une in ain Amer, where oiler o ly
‘eae prt wel sated suggesting anaes In endete
Ingo do so, hope to sbow Lan Ameristar at cen
fra pooctvln fraying th tat and casa wl as abo,
Traian pricy. nd pts sce ad to encourage
‘temsndecone moreacie prepa ins een yin compar
‘ee clue on childhood Ian hope hath boos ep in
‘Ameranfamewore septs hol of other eins skeeve
{peons taketh history orn se aly
‘Weting the hatary of choo a Hor ofc nes a in
tle reoinder why not wee itas aston of ice and eth istend
(cease)? Ts book oeuses on heres ofc for thedascreason
‘hate Chea ozs, whe externa eh in many cmeos,Speakon sey nrc nd etn ctegoris. Ti matin, bow-
‘vec canbe payed to enalveavestage Rae rane cero
Afrentaton and simian and nde anepcil crv one in
‘he history of Lan Americ. Bu ti a teeny one apse
(Che etinraci categories were paral mit sh ny eter
the my of unoemly meta Cie prove expedient to ation
whose wos formative aed ones wee waged aie eral os
(Pera Biv en utonamoue Mapuche ndany)consiued ate
ther Inthe words rac erence waft not eect
cutie not inside national order ne tho beers meanhde
‘ther cteii of ierenc prove expedient On a ewe fry.
‘Whatere the rae quent ft te har ocho
pos dint methodol chalenges. Ae uy ita have
‘mena chlden can be norrosy she his sajecs. The
‘ours aber ieee nd ecy-tenset-enay Ce
Ib sgn ap nd Imtatons, peas the eter which
‘ha vial al fhe wae generated by these Sl chide rt
surprisgy abigatosin hs itl red anes ntend to show
state sources reve art a, brent patie and psec
normed cael thy cn lo ate vere pace
‘wd wich he te tore oslo tent
Atte ear of hs amass boy of oc thn hownd ju
css rom ch cial nd etl outs Ate Pula case
Fuge, cin iveenons of aun inte and ch sar
Sonnet ay taze the ver presen pasta lid poor chen Vo
mous pater ue yl chara offen Spanning ead
tol bates waged by pret godparents carters masse
wea the ve of ein, he deity of hd reusing atngemers
thes cates, asia the phoropph af the Pacis ch sibjecs are
stl unstated berate igh bet fica sertiry
‘et ven when the vetigevespight coe mo fcus on cen
ers, nthe usm fhe cottyphotopap of See cent
‘which aro whine hover tthe i hy ae il here he
peounbes ofthe acuentary eer fen when he cour atten
‘Soni tracy ther matec that dil inventions prove mat
reveling about chldhod. A divorce ease inadvertently cee ie
rama the jgpominous te ofthe busbands enramara progeny. A
‘Sina commplint gun thieving servant ngs to ight tous
esl other chdhoo. An iutogtion of bigamy spe prompt
‘heacrundtonarate side rangng chile fh youth kent
ole he oil eats prove fequent gpa of inorsand some
‘Se mae prs oraconstis te etal cours fn
salves Ths porults futher enced by more than 0 wil dn
‘om bch ua sd lees. ear of dee soc bake
‘pounds dapoe ofthe propery, he arte iin lato. in
Ship putonsge and rama(Cres and yout in shot wre reyes in Chis host,
‘eet an acindas. (les tnmerabie” wots Bish rer out
se Vlas, “chen amor emt the fi And shy are
lige, times shadowy, Sues he document en
ants of hwo adopt tlt inset dtr ans
ct Angus Orrago Lc cle race "the cle ft” ae
‘jos del arto ese copoor hire bu loo relrne be
steaon of hidren ath se Rerareir owl athe in mete
hors though which power laon eres ln exes.
Tn ation tfc and otra eres, Lda on extrerdwty
ch materi om Sago Casa de Hens Smelter
tthe exphanage wit formal eters of eet and eters ith tly
Inet passer on erapsof apt Th deparare documented
In the reuse oe zens setng 1 “ter cilen fom the
sym In pue daceurse endemic of child abandonment
‘sce oun deploe, bt thee ttl reveal rales consieiy
‘moc comple thn and often sicgy aod wih ach pyre
Wie ele eres derouncel the por fr clot sandoing tt
hee, the Car fer evans he statesman Bejan
lea Mackenna 2s well oof the anu own aioe,
seve yng plc th ifs of wren they had ied ome
thie own len Wo encounter he feminit jaiedoutpen
vo fo wren rd cre gt a St Cut Om rit
ingen bal of poor woman acing a hl mn he Cam x cla
ely to Boome tn explo save in he ous. We can also
lsum the econs sed erin of poor parents tenses soe.
‘mes feed ough the wore of pt, smeines expres tn
‘her om shay peamanati and ete them longi presepve
‘pecan nina paces
Te eoud be aged thar fron etic, kines, abendon-
‘net and hates averemphazs normative, een patalge
specs of eal practice Tar om alc thee eld bs
ser such oes apt the ate ou ing xegres Wis
‘erin the cate that powetlnomatve veces ake ey toe
‘ential phenomana whassoca meanings were ever peated
ghar, for ample, ld et neers edt fll sci a
tlusiovably sumed Yesome ioral snes ung gt
thn praia Indeed, could be rgd that ego he es
imag cannot be divested te nara agg th conse
sits rening
‘Thetis, Rowever an anars ana fo fect en sath phe-
some AS solar fede know he norte lent the
memati tt paral tarp ree Afra on Kleine vere to
reeonsrct the clu and breuerate seas of Kish The
‘perinces of legate nde domers Murat he cl
‘on of dhe wie bee of ncaa wih el ech, an
‘he meng of dependency. Moreoen whe thse practi ay ave
ne nonoeativs they ere ay xeon Ihe ene es
lyn perc anny othe phenomena eo here gi
macy wes ranean "aorta lias ede
‘And in Double ofall level, es lena cen,
sre omnipresent. Th wbigiy i ot jt an sion ofthe ete
Sirk mora torte chide an ample evidence spite the
sat sda dep fs them,
Taisbook races sich phenmens oer the cue of gy years of
(Chet modern tay The tv begins thee th a ta
Sermons a pl ct woh by he ew Chl Code a
Conchdes ssn when charges nfl pracon, ple hte.
‘nd niga a ingrtn en the Nato toe Cie sae
‘lsat mils, and chen Th tenpoaarecagturera tan
fenatve peri nthe county’ Mtr. In 86, Cae war anaton of
soe 4 millon people, of whom pehps three-quarters edi he
Corin A fly entzenched ded icy preted ort
seid piel spheres neporte economy band on ning
‘spealtre. Tis asthe oct whose ep Vita Macken could
‘harscrrtan as ty often” Bys5n0,Ches popalton hc ped
‘osome a millon inhabitant anos half whem now Ine in ban
ares A pot society of ees had came 2 Sees ply of
‘tines The emergence of opus celormist me can reels
srhing crs and sma bor roverent tearm te By
lic beyond region. Once ararchst saiis, and comma
‘ss entered the pla scene, theo eso conic between
‘ostent-centry bea and concrete ppd pen sl
[nthe cone of mounting cs trad he ey nde eeVm
= teen
{samme
Pacte
‘ocean
[se IS
Sopef lor rote hey abo appre dency sbdued The pow of
Uheaigzcy war amination thewans, andthe promis no gue
the seity fs modenang, adi and move desecrate te
‘Sian seopotil expan sesimpaia these desogapic.
seonanis nd pall hanes nthe couse of hs me pid Che
fn pstonal tert tiled in ae sheen vay, he eau
Isto core, expanded both nonvard snd muta. Fost Cie
‘wed the note dsr om Pere a Ba inthe War ofthe
Pi (74-89) thera ssborinted ther eri io
cay dominated by sem-auosomous Mapacie Inne (8809). The
took eases pinay though no exci n he etre, he
‘mex populous and ban put ofthe coun nd the aes eh the
esse eenary bse Tracking falar historical deveopnets
‘trough theles of cen ad fre te arate rev impertat
soci ange ding this rematre eid Ba peap aoe al
{he str tld here non of stn contin
‘Thebookisddedintothee sections Par "Chdan and Strangers:
‘lssion in aw and Practice” explo he tans of wae
ep care wrought by the Chilean Ch Code, wich was aot oly
‘doped in Cie but ao nluened claw thoaghout Latin Amerie
‘Ofte any chang the Cade inttaedin aaya,peraps the ost
sigan the abolion of pterity iesgaton. Chap
‘eubs how the Cale econizare Eton zoning rll
of emtac, granting fiers unter fofom feng et
‘har ilpmate crn. The onctuloation and concita
reaertzston of son enhanced steal but in caving eat
ea inleable penal nights to feedom and poy the Code
Ukinatly enpowered mena he expense nt oly of wosen snd he
“ren but ho ofthe cour therses: Caper» eae ote
(Coe pate sts ed retrace by pope ban bere the Code
(Couseaplled cats ed wanda iahip ad into doing became
le arena for he rmsrpen osc diftrence. Tere ht
ke the evry procs by whch dren became acl it pa
‘ear cas aes And thy reve ow cer nog rp
‘poi and mati ern pace comingntend uae,
Pu I Clze of Den Nobo Kinship ad Sei recy =plore the enduring spteance of inp soicla wel as
lea areas, tsory in epebean Chile, Chapter 3 decries «
shadowy, ignatnd “neds of por people who ge op
lt orld after ytetage oat provenance Kinet st
{orm fc margialty hele lint the utara eld
ep sgiiace of shee the way hed rue case
chien Chapter 4 argues hat eclectic nd cl buena dee
on famy membership tS nv acon leper
hood: Yet the uth deployment of inept oie, For even at
ep kinshp bere nergy emporant wee spins he ney
ined il rgaty, and cv law sptenatealy doped ein
‘edad oft otal
Pr I “Other Pope hrs: The ties of Cu Cation”
lescrbes what became of youngsters detach fom the moorings of
‘salina, terplrs the demographic and mater underpinning
full eengs, a scales of chld ration «ile
‘died prac that habe ere wierd ero Latin Amer
Icahixeely. Chapters mendes th gine of hd eng f9
been fly Geman nd ean ifn end etl made of
‘well provsn fr den enero orphan by waar
Fostrge hamster fer el ear ania
opal racice Chapter evans anotwc eich celta
thereof poe deptimat, and Areindan chen a emetic
servants Ade fo frm of bn tht oie gal sey by more
an centr tty sera fe lennon porage deme
‘onstuting partly ak ems hw chdhod elie th
aban ar sacres aly te oplogue "Marginal tthe Cente
sary One Hundred Yas of Hach ves anges and contnes
inthe fist hee decoder ofthe vent ctr. Aer the nf the
cetyl los anew ecnomi sis Beato ale the
conor of lepnacy neon and cd ction. Yet young
acho lately eel ine eto eet he scl and
litical enancisement fe woring lis.
‘Whe the et photograph ta ofthe Pana cen dpi vee
young vcs f ele snd abil image shows hem ace hey
en ene, end od, Dl's wr is args tn Be
Bo. Ee,
Chen th fad: on chien ne had
Seer ote and Sur Arh Nana8 sears, enaesocuery, eo CHILDREN AN CHE
‘ard an Jou Manuel ate deed in cap nd buon down sue ke
nature woes The "ef" and “er” photo arate the Pu
‘ensfomton fom ios del ca cen off ord pri,
dren oft fatherland That anctematon, core coe
the sss of eels than he aad experencs of oot cle
re Thepotopaphsin ths sense cope he mage dence
prescription and rey. They aude tthe pote fr that sounded
‘he case an nite us to ponder he mations of the age who
eed her rao, Bathe photographs ao change fo oni
Daler and os Mansel ain a someting ethan pr
senations” They prompt tk empl bt power ene out
‘who they were ed wy they mastered Ths bok pees ete spa
ons, ste aon, lp andertandlngs of Sato, and the poli
roeaigs of leben elchocd. Bt ove ltl the sory of the
Chien hemseeran oft als ho thy cae.
PARTI
Children and Strangers
‘lation in Law and Practice
2