Notan: Design in Light and Dark by Sharon Himes

What is dark is not light and what is light is not dark. This is the basis of all design and an
important guiding principle of art. It seems so simple but an artist can spend a lifetime exploring
the possibilities of light and dark.
"Notan" is the term used by the Japanese to express "light-dark" as an
element of design. In the west we use separate terms such as positive space
and negative space, dividing the idea of light-dark into separate components.
On paper it is easy to see that dark shapes cannot exist without a surrounding
area of white. White shapes cannot exist without dark to define it. The two
elements are really one. This is an eastern concept of yin-yang that each is
what the other is not.
It is usually the dark aspects of a design that we see first and we are intrigued
by optical illusions that seem to switch from one picture to another in our minds. We speak of
negative space and mean the white holes in a dark design. In using the term "negative" we are
giving it a connotation of null-ness or even sinister aspects. A dark pattern is considered
"positive" and therefore dominant when that is not always the case. Sometimes the primary
subject is light against an area of dark and thus a positive element.
How does the artist use this concept of notan? We usually draw with dark pen or pencil on light
paper and tend to think in terms of the dark aspects of our work. Sometimes it is useful to draw
with white chalk or pastel on dark paper or use scratchboard or other dark media to help see that
the dominant areas of a design can be the light ones.
All art is based on light and dark even when color is involved. In a low-light situation we can only
see the values, or light and dark of a painting. Hang a painting in a dim room and only the
strongest contrasts of light and dark can be identified. These abstract forms of light and dark tell
us a lot about the art, even when we are not immediately aware of a specific subject or scene. It
is the design of the art that we see when color, texture and representation are set aside.
has its values
Simple elements of light and dark can be expressive. When limited to the basic characteristics of
black and white on a two dimensional plane, design still can express tension, movement and
balance. Edges between light and dark catch our attention and we unconsciously follow them with
our eyes. A gently curving edge is followed slowly by our eyes and a more sharply curved edge is
passed over quickly, giving a subconscious sense of movement. Convoluted edges can suggest
texture or just be confusing.

Light spaces within an area of dark or dark spots in a light shape change the balance. Like dark
windows on a light house or light bubbles in a dark liquid, the main shape is alleviated by the
disruption.
A design shows balance or imbalance (tension) through the distribution of light and dark space.
Rarely is the artist likely to divide the space perfectly evenly as that would be static and
uninteresting. Dividing the space into areas of light and dark that are uneven suggests interaction
and movement.
Separating the space into separate forms creates movement and interest as the various shapes
seem to interact.

Using the computer can assist the artist in analyzing the design basis for a painting. Open a
digital photograph or scan of the painting and use any graphics program to decrease color depth
to just two colors (gray values).

When you plan a painting, consider the areas of light and dark in the overall design. Sketch
frequently with a broad (brush-like) marker pen to create small thumbnail drawings with or without
any intent to make representational pictures. Analyze the sketches to explore use of positive and
negative spaces, balance and the tension implied by various edges.
Artists spend much of their creative time thinking about color. The light and dark underlying
design of a painting sets the stage for color, texture and representational aspects of a picture. An
artist who understands and pursues the possibilities of light and dark builds a strong basis for his
art.

Learn more about :

Bonnard: Woman in
the Bath
Ingres: Grand
Odalisque
Whistler: Studio
Methods