Arens1

AlyssaArens
Dr.KendraParker
ENGL11303
Turnindate
BeaWoman
InDisneys1998animatedpicture,Mulan,themalesoldiersoftheChinesearmy
singAGirlWorthFightingForastheymarchtobattleagainsttheHuns:
Iwantherpalerthanthemoon
witheyesthatshinelikestars
Mygirlwillmarvelatmystrength,
adoremybattlescars
Icouldn'tcarelesswhatshe'llwear
orwhatshelookslike
Italldependsonwhatshecookslike
(Mulan,n.p.)
Inresponsetotheirsong,Mulan,awomanwhocutsherhairandputsonarmorto
taketheplaceofherfatherinthewar,suggests,Howboutagirlwhosgotabrain?
Whoalwaysspeakshermind?inwhichthemenreply,Nah!.Thesesoldiers,justlike
allmen,havetheirpictureperfectidealisticwoman.Althougheachmanmayhavehis
ownpreferences,therearemanycommonthemesandcharacteristicsthatareshared
amongstthemajorityofmen,suchasbeautyandobedience.Thesefemininetraits
affecttheresponsibilitiesandrolesthatwomenhaveinsocietyandcreateanevident

Arens1
divisionbetweengendersforwhatisappropriateandwhatisexpected.TheDisneymovie
MulanstronglyupholdsthegenderexpectationsthatareexistentintheUnitedStates
today.AlthoughthemovietakesplaceinancientChina,therearetrendsincurrentculture
thatmimicthehistoricalpremisesofwomen,evenintheUnitedStates.DisneysMulan
characterizestheidealwomanasbeautifulandobedient;thus,creatingalongstanding
divisionbetweengenderroles,which21stcenturyAmericansarebeginningtobridge
throughtheempowermentoffeministmovementsaimingtowardsgenderequality.
TheportrayalandinfluencesofidealisticwomeninMulanestablishesgender
expectationsforawomansroleinsociety,whichsetstheattitudesforwhatanormal
womanactslikeintwentyfirstcenturyAmericanculture.Atthebeginningofthemovie,
Mulanispreparingforhervisittothematchmaker,inwhichitwillbedecidedifsheis
suitableforahusband.AfteradayofpamperingandpracticerecitingTheFinal
Admonition,Mulanfinallymakesanappearancewiththematchmaker.Duetoaseries
ofaccidents,thematchmakerbelittlesMulaninfrontofherfamilyandtherestofthe
village,proclaiming,Youareadisgrace!Youmaylooklikeabride,butyouwillnever
bringyourfamilyhonor!(Mulan,n.p.).Fromthispointon,itisevidentthroughoutthe
filmthatthesolepurposeofbeingawomanistobecomeabride.Itcanbenotedthatthe
maledoesnotneedtogothroughamatchmakingprocesswhereheshowshisskillsin
ordertobedeemedasuitablehusband.Rather,itisthewomanthatneedstoputon
makeup,getherhairdone,wearabeautifuldress,andshowhertraitsofobedienceand
wit,alltoachieveherworthinessasabride.Althoughamatchmakingprocessisnot
typicallyaprecursortoanAmericanmarriage,thereexistmanysimilarattitudesofthe

Arens1
bridetobe.ManylittlegirlsintheUnitedStatesgrowupfantasizingabouttheirwedding
days.Theydoodleheartsandboysnamesontheirnotebooks,playwithBarbieandher
perfectboyfriend(Ken),andaretaughtfromayoungagethattheirgoalistofindaman
whowilllovethemfortherestoftheirlives.Thatgoalisreflectiveofthetaskswomen
performonadaytodaybasis.Littlegirlsgrowuplearninghowtosew,dolaundry,wash
thedishes,andamultitudeofotherhouseholdchores.Itistheboyswhoperformoutdoor
activities,getdirty,andusetheirmachostrengthtogetworkdone.Whengirlsgrowinto
youngwomen,theygetjobsasbabysittersornannies;inwhichtheyreceivepractice
caringforchildren,justastheyareexpectedtodoasmothers,inhopethattheywillraise
strongsons.Men,ontheotherhand,takeondifferentjobs,becominglandscapersand
mechanics.Aftermarriage,ifonespouseisexpectedtogiveuphisorherjobtotakecare
ofthechildren,itwillalmostalwaysbethewoman.Itcanbearguedthatthisisduetoa
womansmorenurturingsideandtheexpectationthatmenshouldbethebreadwinnersof
theirfamilies,butitisnottosaythatwomenshouldhavetoforfeittheireducationsand
careerstobetheobedienthousewivesfortherestoftheirlives.Thisthemeisdepictedin
MulanasarmygeneralLiShangsings,DidtheysendmedaughterswhenIaskedfor
sons?(Mulan,n.p.).Itisthementhatareexpectedtocomeandfightfortheirfamilies.
Itisalsothementhathavethedutyofbringinghonortothefamilyname,ataskthatthe
ancientChineseculturedidnotseesuitableforwomen.Thisthemeisstillprevalentin
21stcenturyAmericanculture,whichcanbeseenbylookingatthemotherlyrolesof
thewomenandthemanlyrolesofthemen.
Thepossibilityofchangingattitudestowardswomensrolesandgenderequality

Arens1
ishinderedbythehistoricalfactorsthathavecontributedcrossculturallytotheportrayal
oftheidealisticwomaninMulan.AncientChinesephilosophyisbasedontheconcepts
ofyinandyang.Yinandyangisaunitedsymbolofharmony,eachpiececomplementing
theother.Yinisthepassiveandfeminine,andiscomplementedbyyang,theactive
masculinepiece(Cartright,2012).Althoughthetwobalanceoneanother,itisthefemale
(yin)thatisgiventheinferiorandobedientcharacteristics,asopposedtothemale,whois
giventhedominantandfirmmasculinetraits(ShenandDAmbrosio,n.d.).This
philosophyhasproducedgenderexpectationsfortherolesofmenandwomeninsociety.
WhenChiFuentersMulansvillagetodelivertheorderofwarfromtheEmperor,he
informsMulansfatherstepsforwardtothathewillrepresenttheFafamilyinthewar
againsttheHuns.Mulan,havingsympathytowardsherfatherskneeinjury,justasher
womanlyinstinctwouldtellhertodo,objectstoherfathersacceptanceoftherole.In
response,ChiFuhisses,Silence!Youwoulddowelltoteachyourdaughtertoholdher
tongueinaman'spresence,(Mulan,n.p.).Herfathersolemnlyreplies,Mulan,you
dishonorme,(Mulan,n.d.).Thisscenedepictsthesuperioritymenhadoverwomenin
ancientChineseculture.Themanwastheheadofthehouseholdandwastorepresentthe
familyname.Daughtersareraisedtohonorherfamilythroughobedienceand
maintainingpeace.Thesethemescanalsobeseeninthecontextof21stcenturyAmerican
culture.In19thand20thcenturywartimes,themenwouldbecalledtobattleasthe
womenstayedhometoraisethechildren.Theywouldcook,clean,andsew,unabletogo
tocollegeorreceiveanyfurthereducation.Althoughgreatstrideshavebeenmade
socially,menarestillseenasthedisciplinaryheadofthehousehold.Iamsurethatevery

Arens1
punishedchildhasheardfromhisorhermother,justwaituntilyourfathergets
home....Itisasifwomendonotinhibitenoughpersonalstrengthnorpowertobe
leaders.
MulansdepictionoftheidealisticwomanhascausedAmericanstoreevaluatethe
standardmentalitiesforhowaperfectwomanshouldbe,whichhasincreasedfeminist
ideologiesandstridestowardgenderequality.MulanisarguablythefirstDisneyprincess
tobreakthetypicaldamselindistressrole.InthesongReflection,Mulanquestions
heridentity,askingherself:
NooneknowswhoIam.
Musttherebeasecretme,I'mforcedtohide?
MustIpretendthatIamsomeoneelseforalltime?
Whenwillmyreflectionshow,whoIaminside?
(Mulan,n.d.)
Mulanscharacterresemblesextremebraveryandcouragetobreakthebarrierof
genderexpectationsforhercultureandtimeperiod.Lookingbeyondthedangershe
enteredbybeingawomaninthearmy,Mulanwillinglyfoughttobringnotonlyhonorto
herfamily,buthonortoherself.Hercharactershowsthatwomenarenotalwaysfighting
formen,butrather,forthemselvesandtheirownidentities.Thiscanbeseeninthe
UnitedStatestodayintheemergenceoffeminism.Womenhavemadeenormousstrides
towardsequalrightsthatwouldhavebeendeemedimpossibleinthepreviouscentury.
Theyhavegainedaccesstohighereducation,whichhasresultedinsendingwomeninto
space,becomingdoctorsandlawyers,andfollowingotherprestigiouscareerpaths.

Arens1
Furthermore,womenhaveapproachedfeminisminalightthatisnotdiminishingto
males.Ratherthantryingtogetaheadoftheoppositesex,womenfightforequal
opportunities.Beingapowerfulwomanisnotreflectiveofeducation,occupation,or
salary.Rather,itisapictureofawomanfollowingherpassions.Ifbeingastayathome
momisawomansdreamandiswhereshefindsherprideandjoy,thensobeit.The
purposeofequalrightsissothatbothmenandwomenhavethesameopportunitiestodo
astheywish.Duetothelonglastinggenderexpectationsthathavebeenengraved
throughouthistory,feministmovementswilltakeaprolongedefforttocontinueseeing
results.WomenlikeMulaninspirewomentoinhibittheidentitythattheywish,notan
identitythatisexpectedofthem.
TheDisneyfilmMulanpresentsideasofwhatanidealwomanshouldlookand
actlike.Thesedesirablewomanlycharacteristicshavebeenupheldforcenturies,
datingbacktoearlyphilosophyinancientChina.Althoughthingshavealwaysbeenthis
wayandwomenhavealwaysfelttheneedtoadheretocertainstandards,the21stcentury
Americanopinionaboutgenderequalityischanging.WomenlikeMulanrepresent
breakingdownthebarriersofthewallbetweengenders.Thisisanongoingprocessthat
willtaketheworkofmanymore,bothmenandwomen,toachieveitsgoalsofequality.
Slowlybutsurely,stridesarebeingmadewithinthefeministmovement.Americans,after
alltheseyearsofequality,areseeingthatthedividebetweengendersisstillevidently
inplace.Afterall,itwasMulanthatbroughthonortousall(Mulan,n.d.).

Arens1

References
http://www.ancient.eu/Yin_and_Yang/
http://www.iep.utm.edu/genderc/#H4