Department of
Education
‘Carmen Fria, Chancelor
ANNUAL PROFESSIONAL PERFORMANCE REVIEW (APPR)
EVALUATOR FORM
Teacher ID: 1224405 Teacher Nami BEATRISS STAROBINSKY
School Year: 2014-2015 ‘School Name/DBN: 20K069-P.S. 69 Vincent D. Grippo School
CLASSROOM OBSERVATION:
In each observation, all components for which there is observed evidence must be rated. Each form must
contain lesson-specific evidence for each of the components observed during a classroom observation.
This observation was: (check one)
% | Formal observ
n (full period) Informal Observation (15 minute minimum)
Date of Observation: 03/02/2015 Time/Period: 1:30/Period 7
emonstrating knowledge of content and pedagogy
The teacher displays extensive knowledge of the important concepts in the
discipline.
-Your lesson included strands identified in the Blueprints for the Arts in Music by
understanding elements of music through performance activities; becoming aware
of themselves as musicians; and taking responsibility for their instruments.
-Students demonstrated musical literacy, including applying understanding of
notation, describing qualities of music and using basic music vocabulary.
4- Highly Effective
1e (obs): Designing coherent instruction 4- Highly Effective
The sequence of learning activities follows a coherent sequence, is aligned to
instructional goals, and is designed to engage students in high-level cognitive
activity
2a: Creating an environment of respect and rapport 4- Highly Effective
Classroom interactions between the teacher and students and among students are
highly respectful, reflecting genuine warmth, caring, and sensitivity to students as
individuals.
-You frequently compliment students for their participation and encourage them to
try.
-When a student responded, you complimented their choice of the word "pizzazz"
and said "| like that word!"
-When a student offered a suggestion you complimented him by replying, "Joseph
railed it”
-When small groups of students shared their ideas of how to make the piece "more
musical,” you asked the others to “let's give them a round of applause.”
2d: Managing student behavior 4- Highly Effective
Last Revised: 03/15/15 11:08:59 PM By jcapeta2Student behavior is entirely appropriate.
-You use cues to get student attention, such as raising your right hand to signal for
auiet
-Similarly, to begin playing their instruments, you count "1, 2, 3, 4" and also give a
signal cue to end,
-You include little "musical happy notes" to compliment behavior and provide a
check for understanding.
3b: Using questioning and discussion techniques 3- Effective
While the teacher may use some low-level questions, she poses questions
designed to promote student thinking and understanding,
-Questions included, "What does it mean if| ask you to make a song more
musical?" Responses included to "add notes" "add more instruments" and "add
pizzazz." Additional discussion included using music vocabulary of "staccato"
“legato” “forte” “andante*and “allegro” and trying to determine which would make a
“more musical" variation and provide a reason why. Follow up questions included,
"How should we try?"
-When groups worked on their variations, you asked others to determine, "What
did they do?" and listen for the differences.
3o: Engaging students in learning 4- Highly Effective
Virtually all students are intellectually engaged in challenging content through well-
designed learning tasks and activities,
-Students demonstrated independence i
positions at the start of class.
-Children also had the opportunity to work in small groups.
-Students were eager to play their instruments.
At the end of the lesson, all students also contributed to the routines of putting
away the stands and instruments.
setting up and getting to their warm-up
3d: Using assessment in instruction 4- Highly Effective
Assessment is fully integrated into instruction.
-You included opportunity for students to "turn and talk.”
-As students worked in small groups, you circulated throughout and monitored for
progress. You checked in to conference with them. You also had a clipboard to
take notes.
-You had set up a self-assessment for students to use on the side of their music
stands.
~You include little “musical happy notes” to compliment behavior and provide a
check for understanding.
4e (obs): Growing and developing professionally 4- Highly Effective
‘Teacher seeks out opportunities for professional development and makes a
‘systematic effort to conduct action research. The teacher soli feedback on
practice from both supervisors and colleagues. The teacher initiates important
activities to contribute to the profession.
-You have made a significant contribution to our Showcase visits and Shadow
visitors.
-You have attended city wide professional development and continued to meet
with the Literacy Coach and senior Music Teacher for new teacher mentoring.
-You have assisted in community events, including a visit with the chorus to a local
nursing home.
-You continue to work well with your colleagues in the Music Department.
Last Revised: 03/15/15 11:08:59 PM By jcapeta2Teacher ID 1224405 Teacher Name BEATRISS STAROBINSKY
ASSESSMENT OF PREPARATION AND PROFESSIONALISM:
In this section of the form, evaluators should rate evidence for components 1a, 1e, and 4e that was
observed within fifteen (15) school days prior to the classroom observation as part of an assessment
of a teacher's preparation and professionalism. Each form must contain teacher-specific evidence
for each of the components observed.
‘ComponentRationale for Score : if
1a (p&p): Demonstrating knowledge of content and pedagogy 4- Highly Effective
The teacher displays extensive knowledge of the important concepts in the
discipline,
Your lesson included strands identified in the Blueprints for the Arts in Music by
understanding elements of music through performance activities; becoming aware
of themselves as musicians; and taking responsibility for their instruments.
-Students demonstrated musical literacy, including applying understanding of
notation, describing qualities of music and using basic music vocabulary.
Te (p&p): Designing coherent instruction 4- Highly Effective
Designing coherent instruction
the learning activities are aligned with the instructional outcomes and follow an
organized progression suitable to groups of students.
-Your lesson included set-up, warm-up, making a selection "more musical," and
practice of "Eagle March Summit.”
4e (p&p): Growing and developing professionally 4- Highly Effective
‘Teacher seeks out opportunities for professional development and makes a
‘systematic effort to conduct action research. The teacher solicits feedback on
Practice from both supervisors and colleagues. The teacher initiates important
activities to contribute to the profession.
-You have made a significant contribution to our Showcase visits and Shadow
visitors.
~You have attended city wide professional development and continued to meet
with the Literacy Coach and senior Music Teacher for new teacher mentoring.
-You have assisted in community events, including a visit with the chorus to a local
nursing home.
~You continue to work well with your colleagues in the Music Department.
Additional Evaluator Notes (please attach more pages, as necessary):
| enjoyed visiting your Fifth Grade Orchestral Band class on March 2, 2015 for this formal observation. We
had met on February 24, 2015 for your pre-observation and also on March 10, 2015 for your post-observation
feedback.
‘You have many areas of strength and | was especially impressed with your rapport with your students.
Your caring manner and encouragement have provided an opportunity for them to excel in playing a musical
instrument and to develop their skills. They clearly want to please you and show the respectful talk, active
listening and turn-taking that are hallmarks of a supportive classroom environment. Itis particularly
noteworthy because your program includes general education, ESL and special needs students from five
different classes. You conduct your class and model your expectations so that all are treated equally and
Last Revised: 08/15/15 11:08:59 PM By feapeta2Teacher ID 1224405 Teacher Name BEATRISS STAROBINSKY
fairly. This practice is exemplary. In addition, you have included small-group instruction to enhance the
opportunity for music making and for children to articulate their learning. During this time period, you have
also made great contributions to the Showcase Schools program by having city wide visitors observe your
classes.
Looking at where you can reflect, in this lesson you had intended to include a self-assessment for
students to indicate whether they felt they needed your assistance or mastered the task by moving a
clothespin on the edge of their music stands, Although you did not have an opportunity to use this, | suggest
you consider including a mid-workshop interruption to provide a specific time in the lesson to ask students to
do this quick self-check. You can also incorporate this as an end of lesson self-assessment. We also
discussed that due to the end of the period, other students began entering the auditorium for dismissal. Your
students quickly adapted and assisted in putting away their instruments and music stands. However, the
interruption prevented the lesson closure you had planned, Please be mindful of the time and consider
adjusting your lesson to end a ittle earlier.
‘Thank you for this opportunity to visit your classroom. Your hard work and dedication to our students and
‘school community is valued and appreciated.
Teacher's signature: = Date_3,
(Ihave read and received a copy of the above and understand that a copy will be placed’ in my file.)
Evaluator’s name (print)
CAPETANAKIS, JAYNEMARIE
7
Evaluator's signature: