Professional Documents
Culture Documents
VIKRAM CEMENT
RELIABILITY BASED MAINTENANCE
EXPERIENCE & BENEFITS
2
RELIABILITY BASED MAINTENANCE
UTILIZES
DETERMINE
THE
ZERO
BASE
OPTIMUM
APPROACH
TO
MAINTENANCE
3
NEED OF RELIABILITY BASED MAINTENANCE
B)
C)
RBM ORGANIZATION
PLANNED MAINTENANCE
SUB-COMMITTEE CHAIRMAN
RBM CO-ORDINATOR
RBM
CORE
GROUP
REM
TEAMS
MEMBER
(MECH.)
MEMBER
(ELECT.)
MEMBER
(INSTT..)
MEMBER
(PROD.)
RBM
CONSULTANT
PHASE - I
FOCUSSED IMPROVEMENT
LUBRICATION
BRGFAILURE STUDY
(FORMATION OF
- REM SHEETS
- CHECKLIST
- RELIABILITY
CALCULATION)
SPARE ENGINEERING
ADD NEW M/CS
CHRONIC CASES
FAILURE
ANALYSIS
PHASE-II -
CONTINUE
6
RELIABILITY BLOCK DIAGRAM
OF COOLER SECTION (VC-1)
GRATE
1
ESP
GRATE
2
CLINKER
CRUSHER
ESP
RAL-1
COOLER
FAN 1
COOLER
FAN 2A
COOLER
FAN 3
COOLER
FAN 4
COOLER
FAN 5
LUB
PUMP
CD FAN-1
DPC-2
Standby
CD FAN-2
DPC-1
ESP
RAL-2
COOLER
FAN 2B
ESP
RAL-3
ESP
SC-1
ESP
SC-2
ESP
SC-3
ESP
SC-4
ESP
SC-5
PHASE - I
FOCUSSED IMPROVEMENT
LUBRICATION
BRGFAILURE STUDY
(FORMATION OF
- REM SHEETS
- CHECKLIST
- RELIABILITY
CALCULATION)
SPARE ENGINEERING
ADD NEW M/CS
CHRONIC CASES
FAILURE
ANALYSIS
PHASE-II -
CONTINUE
8
EQUIPMENT CRITICALITY RATING CHART
LP
BAND
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
DOWN
TIME
0 - 10 min
10 - 30 min
30 - 60 min
1 - 2 hrs
2 - 4 hrs
4 - 8 hrs
8 - 16 hrs
10 - 32 hrs
> 32 hrs
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
COST
0 - 15,000
15,000 - 25,000
25,000 - 1.0 L
1.0 - 2.0 L
2.0 - 5.0 L
5.0 - 10 L
10 - 20 L
20 - 50 L
> 50 L
BAND
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
CR = FR/10 ( LP+RC+SD+S+E)
FR = FAILURE RATE ( NO OF FAILURES / YEAR)
RISK
Minimal
Significant
Serious
Potentially fatal
Disaster
CALCULATION OF CRITICALITY
UNIT :VC
EQPCODE
EQUIPMENT NAME
LP
RC
SD
FR
FR/YEAR CR
3.9
2.7
2.4
1.8
1.5
1.2
1.0
1.0
1.0
1.0
1.0
1.0
1.0
1.0
1.0
1.0
1.0
DISCHARGE GATE 9
1.0
LUB PUMP 1
0.6
0.5
0.5
CALCULATION OF CRITICALITY
UNIT : VC
10
EQPCODE
EQUIPMENT NAME
LP
RC
SD
FR
FR/YEAR CR
1CLDP01 - CV001DPC 1
45
81.0
1CLDP02 - CV001DPC 2
40
68.0
3.0
1.5
DISCHARGEGATE 11
1.0
DISCHARGEGATE 12
1.0
DISCHARGEGATE 13
1.0
DISCHARGEGATE 14
1.0
0.5
0.5
0.5
0.5
0.5
0.5
0.5
0.5
11
PHASE - I
FOCUSSED IMPROVEMENT
LUBRICATION
BRGFAILURE STUDY
(FORMATION OF
- REM SHEETS
- CHECKLIST
- RELIABILITY
CALCULATION)
SPARE ENGINEERING
ADD NEW M/CS
CHRONIC CASES
FAILURE
ANALYSIS
PHASE-II -
CONTINUE
Buckets Uclits
Welding
cracked
Rail
Worn out
Guide
rail
Support
bracket
weld cracked
.
Overload of
drive
Poor welding
MAINT.
TYPE
PM
DOM
CBM
PM
52 W
Once
52 W
4 hrs
1W
Welding inspection
to be done.
Check the motion
sensing flag &
actuation .
12
3W
PM
DOM
CBM
13
MAINT.
TYPE
PM
DOM
PM
OFM
DOM
PM
CBM
CBM
14
PHASE - I
FOCUSSED IMPROVEMENT
LUBRICATION
BRGFAILURE STUDY
(FORMATION OF
- REM SHEETS
- CHECKLIST
- RELIABILITY
CALCULATION)
SPARE ENGINEERING
ADD NEW M/CS
CHRONIC CASES
FAILURE
ANALYSIS
PHASE-II -
CONTINUE
15
CHECK FOR
COUPLING
AND GEAR TRAIN
MISALIGNMENT
OUTPUT
COUPLING
MISALIGNMENT
CORRECTED
FOUNDATION
STRUCTURE OF
GEAR BOX
STRENGTHENED
TO AVOID
JERK ON
GEAR BOX
SCRATCHES ON
SHAFT SURFACE
CHECK
ABRASIVE
CONTAMINATES
IN LUBRICANT
(OIL
CENTRIFUSED)
MEASURE
SHAFT
DIMENSION
>40 RC
(FOUND 52 RC)
INADEQUATE
INTERFERENCE
FIT BETWEEN
SHAFT & SEAL
CHECK SHAFT
DIMENSION
(FOUND O.K.)
16
17
RESULTS:- NEW PLATE TYPE HEAT EXCHANGER WITH SURFACE AREA (20 M2)
INSTALLED
- IMPROVEMENT IN OIL TEMPERATURE REDUCTION
IN NEW HEAT EXCHANGER = 8 DEG.C
- WATER TEMPERATURE RISE = 10 - 12 DEC.C
- SIGNIFICANT REDUCTION IN GEAR BOX OIL TEMPERATURE =
57 (BEFORE) - 43 (AFTER) = 14 DEG. C
- OIL SEAL LIFE AT INPUT AND OUTPUT END INCREASED BY 2.5 YEARS
18
19
PHASE - I
FOCUSSED IMPROVEMENT
LUBRICATION
BRGFAILURE STUDY
(FORMATION OF
- REM SHEETS
- CHECKLIST
- RELIABILITY
CALCULATION)
SPARE ENGINEERING
ADD NEW M/CS
CHRONIC CASES
FAILURE
ANALYSIS
PHASE-II -
CONTINUE
20
21
PHASE - I
FOCUSSED IMPROVEMENT
LUBRICATION
BRGFAILURE STUDY
(FORMATION OF
- REM SHEETS
- CHECKLIST
- RELIABILITY
CALCULATION)
SPARE ENGINEERING
ADD NEW M/CS
CHRONIC CASES
FAILURE
ANALYSIS
PHASE-II -
CONTINUE
22
COMPONENT
LESS THAN
STANDARD LIFE
WEAR
5, 7, 8
3
RANDOM
6, 1, 2, 9
LIFE
FULL LIFE
SELECT HIGH
COST AREA FOR
IMPROVEMENT
TOO EARLY
9, 8,3
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
OPERATION IMPROVEMENT
MAINTENANCE IMPROVEMENT
INSPECTION IMPROVEMENT
STORAGE / TRANSPORT
ENVIRONMENT IMPROVMENT
VENDOR IMPROVEMENT
LUBE / OTHER CONDTION
IMPROVEMENT
MATERIAL
DESIGN REVISION
23
24
FOCUSSED IMPROVEMENT
LUBRICATION
BRGFAILURE STUDY
(FORMATION OF
- REM SHEETS
- CHECKLIST
- RELIABILITY
CALCULATION)
SPARE ENGINEERING
ADD NEW M/CS
CHRONIC CASES
FAILURE
ANALYSIS
PHASE-II -
CONTINUE
25
STANDARD CHECKING PROCEDURE
OF L.T. MOTOR
26
PHASE - I
FOCUSSED IMPROVEMENT
LUBRICATION
BRGFAILURE STUDY
(FORMATION OF
- REM SHEETS
- CHECKLIST
- RELIABILITY
CALCULATION)
SPARE ENGINEERING
ADD NEW M/CS
CHRONIC CASES
FAILURE
ANALYSIS
PHASE-II -
CONTINUE
27
28
29
PHASE - I
FOCUSSED IMPROVEMENT
LUBRICATION
BRGFAILURE STUDY
(FORMATION OF
- REM SHEETS
- CHECKLIST
- RELIABILITY
CALCULATION)
SPARE ENGINEERING
ADD NEW M/CS
CHRONIC CASES
FAILURE
ANALYSIS
PHASE-II -
CONTINUE
30
BENEFITS OF RELIABILITY BASED MAINTENANCE
NO.OF PLANTS UNDER RBM
- 3
RESULTS OF RBM
EQUIPMNT UNDER CBM
PREVIOUS
`
208
AFTER
322
% PM ACTIVITIES
100
58 Reduction by 42%
28
82:18
31
VIKRAM CEMENT
12000
B/D HOURS
10000
8000
BETTER
6000
6189
5052.8
4000
2000
4014.9
2488.8
2174.4
1554.7
999.9
1375.86
1362.47
1106.46
0
91-92 92-93 93-94 94-95 95-96 96-97 97-98 98-99 99-00 00-01 '01-02
YEAR
32
VIKRAM CEMENT
3000
2688
B/D FREQUENCY
2500
2372
2171
2000
1500
1981
BETTER
1450
1263
1000
803
646
500
739
529
391
0
91-92 92-93 93-94 94-95 95-96 96-97 97-98 98-99 99-00 00-01 '01-02
YEAR
33
VIKRAM CEMENT
IMPROVEMENT IN MTTR
RBM
IMPLEMENTATION
3.65
HOURS
2.85
2.55
2.13
2.13
1.97
2.02
1.93
2.09
BETTER
1.84
1.49
1
0
91-92 92-93
93-94
94-95
95-96 96-97
YEAR
97-98
98-99
99-00
00-01 '01-02
34
VIKRAM CEMENT
IMPROVEMENT IN MTBF
130
120.8
120
110
90
HOURS
112.6
DUE TO AFFECT OF
PETCOKE ON
SPARE LIFE
100
87.02
79.8
80
70
BETTER
69.32
RBM
IMPLEMENTATION
60
50
40
30
20
28.02
27.65
35.83
39.24
43.19
20.86
10
0
91-92 92-93 93-94 94-95 95-96 96-97 97-98 98-99 99-00 00-01 '01-02
YEAR
35
VIKRAM CEMENT
IMPROVEMENT IN MAINTENANCE COST
160
157.48
148.71
140
128.22
120
100
BETTER
106.4
98.27
84.11
80
61.24
65.27
60
RBM
IMPLEMENTATION
40
20
0
94-95
95-96
96-97
97-98
YEAR
98-99
99-00
00-01
'01-02
36
PHASE - I
FOCUSSED IMPROVEMENT
LUBRICATION
BRGFAILURE STUDY
(FORMATION OF
- REM SHEETS
- CHECKLIST
- RELIABILITY
CALCULATION)
SPARE ENGINEERING
ADD NEW M/CS
CHRONIC CASES
FAILURE
ANALYSIS
PHASE-II -
CONTINUE
37
PROCUREMENT PROCEDURE
38
A WAY FORWARD
MAJOR CHALLENGES
CASTING LIFE GET REDUCED DUE TO PETCOKE AFFECT
INCREASED SULPHUR
INCREASED TEMPERATURE