ADJUDICATION

FORMS
HKSBP FORMAT

TIMING
Role
1st Government
1st Opposition
2nd Government
2nd Opposition
3rd Government
3rd Opposition
Reply Speech
(Opposition)
Reply Speech
(Government)

Time

Timekeepers Name
Signature
Date

ADJUDICATORS SCORESHEET
(TEAM: GOVERNMENT)
NAME OF SCHOOL:

ROLE
NAME

TOPIC :

NAME
FIRST GOVERNMENT
MARKS

SECOND GOVERNMENT

THIRD GOVERNMENT

REPLY SPEECH

26-30

21-25

16-20

11-15

6-10

26-30

21-25

16-20

11-15

6-10

26-30

21-25

16-20

11-15

6-10

14-15

12-13

10-11

8-9

6-7

18-20

15-17

12-14

9-11

6-8

18-20

15-17

12-14

9-11

6-8

18-20

15-17

12-14

9-11

6-8

9-10

7-8

5-6

86100

70-85

5669

4055

2439

86100

7085

5669

4055

2439

86-100

70-85

5669

4055

2439

45-50

3644

3035

2429

18-23

SUBSTANCE
(30)
STRATEGY
(30)

MARKS
LANGUAGE
(20)
STYLE
(20)
TOTAL (100)

GRAND TOTAL :
/350
GOVERNMENT/OPPOSITION

WINNING TEAM :

ADJUDICATORS NAME :
ADJUDICATORS SIGNATURE :

DATE :

ADJUDICATORS SCORESHEET
(TEAM: OPPOSITION)
NAME OF SECONDARY:

ROLE
NAME

TOPIC :

NAME
FIRST OPPOSITION
MARKS

SECOND OPPOSITION

THIRD OPPOSITION

REPLY SPEECH

26-30

21-25

16-20

11-15

6-10

26-30

21-25

16-20

11-15

6-10

26-30

21-25

16-20

11-15

6-10

14-15

12-13

10-11

8-9

6-7

18-20

15-17

12-14

9-11

6-8

18-20

15-17

12-14

9-11

6-8

18-20

15-17

12-14

9-11

6-8

9-10

7-8

5-6

86100

70-85

5669

4055

2439

86100

7085

5669

4055

2439

86-100

70-85

5669

4055

2439

45-50

3644

3035

2429

18-23

SUBSTANCE
(30)
STRATEGY
(30)

MARKS
LANGUAGE
(20)
STYLE
(20)
TOTAL (100)

GRAND TOTAL :
/350
GOVERNMENT/OPPOSITION
ADJUDICATORS NAME :

WINNING TEAM :

ADJUDICATORS SIGNATURE :

DATE :

REPLY SPEECH
OPPOSITION

GOVERNMENT

REBUTTAL

REBUTTAL

SUMMARY

SUMMARY

ADJUDICATORS NOTES
1ST GOVERNMENT

1ST OPPOSITION

2ND GOVERNMENT

2ND OPPOSITION

3RD GOVERNMENT

3RD OPPOSITION

NAME :

NAME :

NAME :

NAME :

NAME :

NAME :

POI (INTERJECTED)

POI (INTERJECTED)

POI (INTERJECTED)

POI (INTERJECTED)

POI (INTERJECTED)

POI(INTERJECTED)

POI (ANSWERED)

POI (ANSWERED)

POI (ANSWERED)

POI (ANSWERED)

POI (ANSWERED)

POI(ANSWERED)

Definition:

Defn Agree/Refute
New Definition :

Defn Agree/Refute
Redefine :

Rebut 2nd
Government :

Rebut 2nd
Opposition :

Rebut 3rd
Government :

Rebut 1st Opposition :

Rebut 2nd Government

:

Rebut 1st
Government
Specify Stand :

Specify Stand :

Rebut 1st Opposition :

Rebut 1st
Government :

Specify Role :

Specify Role :

Argument 2 :

Argument 2 :

Argument 1 :

Argument 1 :

Argument 3 :

Argument 3 :

Reaffirm case :

Reaffirm case :

Reaffirm case :

Reaffirm case :

POI

POI

POI

POI

Rebut 1st Government

:

Reaffirm Case :

Reaffirm Case :

POI

IP

HKSBP FORMAT
ELABORATIONS ON ASPECTS OF ADJUDICATION
1.

SUBSTANCE

2.

STRATEGY

3.

Covers structure and time

Good speech has beginning, middle and ending
Speaking within the time limit
Appropriate amount of time given to issues in the speech
Focus of rebuttal mainly on main issues presented in the debate
Critical issues with weak rebuttal would mean lower score for SUBSTANCE but reasonable marks may be
awarded for STRATEGY because the right arguments were addressed

LANGUAGE

4.

Arguments divorced from speaking style

Assess weight of rebuttal
Assess points of argument
Assess weight of argument without influence of oratory

Appropriate expression
Correct sentence structure and grammar
Pronunciation, fluency, rhythm, intonation and clarity
Good language and expression appropriately used e.g. idioms and figures of speech

STYLE

Presentation on the way the debaters speak include body language, eye contact and voice modulation. (Be tolerant of
speaking style and speed of delivery)

Ministry of Education Malaysia

HKSBP FORMAT

RESULTS

HKSBP FORMAT

RESULT
(Adjudicators vote)

WINNING TEAM
TEAM

: GOVERNMENT / OPPOSITION

Adjudicators Signature :

1/2/3/4/5

_____________________________
(

HKSBP FORMAT

VOTING

BEST DEBATER

DEBATER

Adjudicator
1

Adjudicato
r2

Adjudicato
r3

Name

Adjudicator
4

Adjudicato
r5

Signature

Chief Adjudicator : ..

..

Adjudicator 1

: ..

..

Adjudicator 2

: ..

..

Adjudicator 3

: ..

..

Adjudicator 4

: ..

..

Date

: ..

HKSBP FORMAT

RESULT

BEST DEBATER
TEAM

GOVERNMENT / OPPOSITION

NAME

_________________________
_________________________

CHIEF ADJUDICATOR
SIGNATURE : ________________________
(

HKSBP FORMAT

RESULT

TEAM

PRELIMINARY (Zone .. / QUARTER FINAL / SEMI FINAL / FINAL

SECONDARY

WINNING
TEAM
BEST DEBATER

16 of 27

HKSBP FORMAT

RESULT

WINNING TEAM

TEAM

: GOVERNMENT / OPPOSITION
Name

Signature

Chief Adjudicator : ..

..

Adjudicator 1

: ..

..

Adjudicator 2

: ..

..

Adjudicator 3

: ..

..

Adjudicator 4

: ..

..

Date

: ..