Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Page 2
Foreign Direct Investment
Page 3
Foreign Direct Investment
Page 2
Foreign Direct Investment
is arguably the most important source of foreign improved during last four financial years mainly
capital. In addition to filling the savings- due to consistent economic policies of the
investment gap, FDI yields a number of government. In 2005-06, FDI crossed the $3
advantages to the host country including transfer billion mark for the first time as the total FDI was
of technology and managerial know-how, registered at $3.52 billion. However, the source
employment generation, revenues to the of nearly half of the FDI was proceeds from the
government, provision of quality products to sale of state enterprises.
consumers, creation of backward and forward
linkages, broadening of industrial base, and As regards the direction of FDI, financial
increase in exports. services, telecommunications and the energy
sector have received the bulk of FDI. The
In order to increase the level of foreign capital manufacturing sector, especially the all-important
inflows, developing countries liberalize their textile sector, has received meager FDI inflows.
trade and investment regime by relaxing This also means that Pakistan has received very
governmental controls and offering a number of little export-oriented FDI, thus limiting the role
financial and trade incentives like tax of FDI as a tool of export promotion.
concessions and tariff reductions. Though
exceedingly important, the right level of foreign (Source: Board of Investment, State Bank of Pakistan)
investment is not enough. What also matters is
the direction of investment, that is, in which Coming to FDI regime of Pakistan, over past
sectors it is made. one decade Pakistan has opened its economy
through privatization and deregulation and
Having outlined the importance of FDI, let’s presently it has a very liberal FDI regulatory
glance at foreign investment regime of Pakistan. regime. The regulatory framework for foreign
However, before doing this it seems appropriate investment consists of three laws: Foreign Private
to look at the level of FDI in Pakistan during last Investment (Promotion & Protection) Act 1976;
one decade. Furtherance and Protection of Economic Reforms
Act 1992; and Foreign Currency Accounts
Total FDI inflows into Pakistan from 1995-96 (Protection) Ordinance 2001. Taken together,
to 2005-06 stand at $10.93 billion, which come to these laws protect FDI as follows:
$994 million a year. This of course is far below
the desired level. In 1995-96, Pakistan attracted One, there is freedom to bring, hold and take
the (then) record $1.1 billion FDI, which was out foreign currency from Pakistan in any form.
mainly due to agreements with Independent Two, fiscal incentives provided by the
Power Producers (IPPs). government cannot be altered to the disadvantage
of the investor. Three, the privatisation of an
However, the next year FDI registered a sharp enterprise is fully protected. Four, no foreign
fall as the successive government, repudiated enterprise can be taken over by the government.
agreements with IPPs. Thus ensued a row Five, original foreign investment as well as
between the Government of Pakistan and IPPs, profits earned on it can be repatriated to the
which severely affected foreign investor’s country of origin. Six, equal treatment is
confidence in Pakistan. Pakistan’s decision to go provided to a foreign investor and local investor
nuclear in 1998 prompted several countries to in terms of import and export of goods. Seven,
impose economic restrictions, which also reduced FDI is not subject to taxes in addition to those
FDI inflows. The sudden freezing of foreign levied on domestic investment. Eight, foreign
currency accounts following the nuclear blasts currency accounts are fully protected and they
increased the risk of doing business in Pakistan cannot be freeze.
and severely affected FDI. The FDI level
Page 5
Foreign Direct Investment
(Source of facts & Figures: Foreign Currency Accounts copyright legislation in conformity with
Ordinance 2001)
international copyright laws, the government has
not been able to curb piracy. This increases the
Pakistan business strengths are investor- cost of doing business in Pakistan.
friendly policies allowing 100 percent foreign
equity, protection to private investment, Factors affecting FDI in Pakistan
remittance of profit, royalty and technology fee,
zero import duties on raw materials for
Let’s turn to social, economic and political
production of export, large and growing domestic factors that have bottlenecked the growth of FDI
market, well-established infrastructure, skilled, in Pakistan. Take political uncertainty first.
qualified and cost effective manpower, regional Political instability has been endemic in Pakistan.
hub in view of gateway to Central Asian During 1990s four governments and parliaments
Republics and strong links with Gulf region and were dismissed and three general elections held
South Asia. towards the close of the decade, the civilian set-
up was replaced with a military regime.
There is huge potential of investment of Rs Furthermore, whenever a civilian government
594.4 billion in engineering industry in Pakistan was in office, speculations of its sack were ripe.
Political uncertainty increased the risk of doing
against existing Rs 289.8 billion in this sector business in Pakistan and decreased its
including potential in Automotive & Agriculture attractiveness as a market for investment.
Implements of around Rs 110.3 billion, against
existing Rs 65.3 billion, Rs 26 billion in heavy Frequent changes in government also made
machinery against existing Rs 17.5 billion, Rs 13 continuity of policies difficult. In our country
billion in Consumer Durables against Rs 9.5 there is a tendency on the part of a government to
billion, Rs 21 billion in Surgical & Cutlery undo the policies of its predecessor. The row
between the Nawaz Sharif government and IPPs
against existing Rs 15 billion, Rs 251.5 billion in
has already been mentioned. Policy aphorism
Steel against existing Rs 83.5 billion and Rs also begets uncertainty and increases the
172.6 billion in others against existing Rs 99 investment risk.
billion.
Another important factor is law and order.
As regards investment policy, all economic During last one decade, Pakistan has been subject
sectors including the service sector are open to to twin menaces of religious extremism and
FDI. Foreign equity up to 100 per cent is ethnics, which have taken a heavy toll on our
allowed. No government sanction is required for economy. Ironically ethnic violence ran rampant
setting up an industry in terms of field of activity, in Karachi, Pakistan’s business capital. There
location and size except in case of four sectors were several incidents of murder and kidnapping
relating to national security. Under the for ransom. Of late, Pakistan has faced a series of
deregulation policy, government controls on suicide attacks in different parts of the country. A
business activity are being relaxed. To avoid couple of years back, the president had a narrow
double taxation on income earned by foreign escape in two incidents occurred in the same
investors, Pakistan has concluded agreements place in a heavily guarded area.
with 51 countries. The list includes nearly all the
developed economies. However, one area in the The fourth factor is lack of human capital.
regulatory regime needs a lot of improvement is Workers are widely regarded as the principal
the protection of Intellectual property rights asset of a firm and the capital source of its
(IPRs), particularly copyrights. Despite bringing competitive advantage. That is why there is so
Page 2
Foreign Direct Investment
Page 7
Foreign Direct Investment
Page 2
Foreign Direct Investment
He said that our government is India has discouraged FDI. India received 7
committed to good governance through billion dollars in FDI in FY 05 and China 72
transparency and accountability. Democratic billion dollar. India’s cumulative stock of
institutions have been strengthed while a FDI was at 6% at the end of 2005 and
deep routed process of decentralization has Pakistan’s 9%, China’s 14% and 61% for
been set in motion due to FDI. Vietnam. The reason FDI is low in India is
because of India’s unwillingness to fully
This huge increase in FDI has helped embrace the market forces. He is than telling
in developing deeper and more liberal about the strategies adopted by India to not
agriculture markets. Apart from this it has allow the FDI which are as follows. When
also helped in developing markets in media, India faced with rising inflation in early
energy and telecom sectors. The foreign 2007, the response was not to allow rising
investment has modernized several of the key prices to prompt an increase in supply, but to
agencies including civil service, monopoly ban wheat exports for the nest of year and
control authority and the police. This has of suspend future trading ‘curb-speculation’ –
course been done by deepening the very market forces that the Indian
decentralization, developing greater economy needs to break strangle hold of
transparency, utilizing the latest technology bureaucracy.
and relying on a high degree of professional
and technocratic management. Mr. Riaz Haq then pinpoints that Mr.
Greenspan wrote the words, the FDI in
Page 9
Foreign Direct Investment
Pakistan has continued to rise and has (Ref.: southasianinvestor.com, May 2008)
remained the success story.
(6) Major economic targets
He says that the total investment grew
achieved (2007)
by 21.4% of the GDP and FDI has posted a
growth of 71% from 3.5 billion dollar to 6 This article highlights the major
billion dollar in the year 2007. The FDI economic targets achieved during the fiscal
represents a deeper and longer term year 2007 and has briefed about the major
commitment than portfolio investments role that FDI has played in achieving these
which tend to be less durable and less goals. The major economic targets were real
reliable. According to him the increase in GDP growth, agriculture, services sector,
FDI to Pakistan has been made possible by investment, tax revenue during 2007 fiscal
the Pakistani Government’s liberal policies year.
of allowing foreign investments in many
The State Bank of Pakistan, in its
sectors of the economy. It is also highlighted
annual report on the state of economy, said
the continuous rise in the profits has boomed
that Pakistan’s economy witnessed a
with GDP doubling over the past 5 years.
moderate recovery during 2007 financial year
Foreign investors sent $ 519 million with real GDP reaching 7%, as compared to
as their profits abroad during first 7 months 6.6% growth seen in 2006 financial year and
of the current fiscal year as compared to this was contributed by a surge in domestic
467.9 million dollar of the corresponding private investment and record foreign direct
period of 2006-07 which depicts an upsurge investment flows.
of 11%.
As a result, the economy looks well
State Bank’s statistics show that poised to continue on a high growth
profit by foreign investors registered a trajectory in the coming years. This article
significant increase of $51.4 million during also sheds some light on the darker aspect
2006-07, the major share repatriation was that is despite the improvement the
seen in the power sector. He also added that investment to GDP ratio remains low in
according to business recorder, foreign Pakistan.
investors have made new investments during
Even though the savings, the GDP
the last few years due to power shortage.
ratio had also increased 18 percent during
In the end, he concludes by saying 2007 financial year compared with 17.2
one of the downsides of liberalization has percent in the preceding year, it was still low
been an upsurge in inflation in Pakistan as compared to regional and international
which India has attempted to curb by actions standards.
such as banning export of wheat and
suspending future trading.
Page 2
Foreign Direct Investment
Page 11
Foreign Direct Investment
$1.656 billion during the same period of last (10) FDI: Linked Policies to be
fiscal year.
continued: Dar (2008)
(Ref.: Business Recorder March 20th, 2008)
Finance Minister Ishaq Dar has invited
American entrepreneurs to avail investment
(9) Foreign investors ready to
opportunities Pakistan offers in various
invest in Pakistan (2008) sectors.
Foreign investors are hungry for
Ishaq Dar was addressing the members of the
investing in banking, real estate, telecom and
US-Pakistan Business Council, said, the
the country’s steel industry: Salman Taseer,
newly elected government in Pakistan will
Federal Minister for Industries, Production
continue the FDI linked policies, which we
said.
had introduced and which the previous
Salman Taseer said that the foreign government continued. Obviously, there will
investors would be ready to invest in be continuity in these policies.
expanding the Pakistan steel Mills to enhance
He informed the entrepreneurs about
its production capacity. India has an edge
the new coalition government's priorities and
over Pakistan in the steel industry because of
said it had given market economy to the
good governance while its bank in abroad
country (in the 1990s), introduced foreign
direct the flow of investment into India by
direct investment policies as well as various
guiding investors. Presently, China and India
other economic reforms.
are buying steel on a large scale pushing its
high prices internationally. The situation will Earlier, the finance minister had a
not be improved unless we develop local meeting with chairman US-Pakistan Business
resources. Presently, we are buying coal from Council, Jay Collins, who said he had been
Australia and Canada and iron ore from India "extremely impressed with the candor and
and China. However Pakistan steel will sign vision" of the new top Pakistani finance
an agreement with the Sandac project on Jan. official.
29 to buy 50,000 to 60,000 tonnes of iron
ore. "I was both pleased and reassured that the
fundamental premises of the new minister in
Concluding, the Engineering terms of kinds of policies that will allow
Development Board CEO Almas Hyder said Pakistan's economy to grow, allow the global
that the EDB will appoint foreign consultants investment community continues to have
for identification of iron ore and coal sites in faith in Pakistan, will be implemented by this
Pakistan, the volume of investment needed government so I am very supportive of what
for their exploration and future prospectus. I heard."
(Ref.: Business Recorder Jan. 26th, 2008)
Page 2
Foreign Direct Investment
In 2004, FDI figure was 798 million In our research, we found that all
dollar which was raised to 949 million dollar things were going smoothly till fiscal year
in only one year. In 2006 it was further raised 2007. But after 2007 the Foreign direct
to 2 billion dollars with a sharp rise of 70.6 investment droped on a large scale which has
percent over last year. In 2007, according to been mentioned in the articles and their
government figures, it was further raised to reviews.
20 percent more. In the current fiscal year
Page 13
Foreign Direct Investment
It was mainly due to political unrest need, but also create a lot of job
and bad security environment. Pakistan is opportunities, bringing back to life the
blessed with a very ideal geo-strategic industries, which have been closed. And
location which includes world’s most most interaction of Pakistani market with the
booming economy. China as its neighbor. whole world.
Central Asian states looks towards Pakistan’s
see route for the mode of trade. By this, we We should atleast learn from our
found that Pakistan has got all the necessary neighbors like China and India…
tools for enhancing our FDI, which mainly Two of world’s fastest growing
includes availability of cheap labor, fertile economy countries. What they have got in
land of Punjab and Sind, world’s most which Pakistan is lacking behind? Law and
organized irrigation system and the most order situation, smooth functioning of
important of all, the Arabian Sea, which is government, proper power (electricity, water,
the back bone of all trade done in Pakistan. gas) facilities, tax free zone and interaction
It is matter deep sadness for all of us, with WTO, can bring revolutionary change in
to know that investors all over the world, Pakistan’s economy.
who were looking towards Pakistan’s
political and law in order situation, and
changing their plans are moving towards “This is continuation of trend of expansion
other investment areas, like India and of existing investment in Pakistan and will
Bangladesh, which is not at all in favor of hopefully mark the state of real upward
Pakistani economy. trend in FDI.”
Page 2
Foreign Direct Investment
FY
Fiscal Year
PTC
WTO
PSDE
SECP
PIDE
GLOSSARY GDP
Page 15
Foreign Direct Investment
IPRS
IPP
SBP
GDR
http://www.jang.com.pk/thenews/
http://www.fdimagazine.com/
WEBSITES VISITED:
Wikipedia
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Foreign_direct_investmen
t
Business Recorder
http://www.brecorder.com/index.php?
http://sbp.com.pk/
Page 2
Foreign Direct Investment
http://google.com.pk
Page 17