Because of many reasons, the US should join WWI.

One reason was because

of the Lusitania sinking. Colonel Edward House said after the sinking, America has
come to the parting of the ways and that we cannot remain neutral anymore.
Secondly, another reason was the Zimmerman Telegram. According to the telegram
itself, Germany was Mexico to attack the US. Although all of these reasons, Eugene
Debs said that the upper-class had been declaring the wars, but the common-class
had been fighting them. However, President Wilson in his declaration of war, said
that right is more precious than peace. If the US joins WWI, there will be many
good things to come out of it.
Mark - you have reasons that are OK, but you need to remember to give supporting
details for them. The details should come from the documents you were given.
This makes your argument stronger. You had a good start on your counterclaim, but
you need to complete it.