Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Allen begins by explaining the differences between Red Light and Green
Light classrooms. The concept of Red Light vs. Green Light is easy to
understand and apply. Basically, Red Light classrooms represent the status
quo, or the way things have always been done in the past. Red Light
classrooms rely heavily on top down teaching. For example, the teacher
most likely spends the most time lecturing to the students in a traditional
lecture format. Then, the students may complete worksheets or simple
assignments reinforcing the lecture material or reading from a textbook.
Lastly, the students complete the unit by taking a traditional test, focusing
on content knowledge gained.
Early in the book, Mr. Allen also references the Ferris Bueller movie
classroom scene as a great example of Red Light teaching. The movie,
released in 1986 features the antics of a teenage boy. The scene referenced
shows a teacher lecturing to the class in an incredibly monotone voice. The
camera pans by the students in the room, whom are in various stages of
boredom and completely disengaged from the lesson. I've actually seen that
clip played in professional development on two different campuses. We all
laugh because we know it's true, yet most teachers have ended up in that
place during a lesson at least once. The example serves to remind readers in
a humorous way that lecturing for an entire class period is never successful
and equals a Red Light classroom.
The second through tenth chapters of the book focus on different
elements of teaching; including memory, connections, movement, novelty,
The other chapter that greatly stands out for me is Chapter 9, Drama.
As a former Theatre teacher, I enjoy the connections of drama to other
subjects. I have long known that role-playing leads to opportunities for
problem-solving and higher level thinking. Allen states, Guided properly,
drama can trigger a wealth of healthy emotions and positive learning for
everyone involved in any aspect of the production, large or small (Allen
133). Although all of the strategies presented in Green Light Classrooms
share connections, I especially like the connection of drama to the previously
mentioned strategies, movement and novelty. Most theatrical acts
inherently contain novelty and need movement to come to fruition, creating
a trifecta of learning.
Many teachers may be scared to incorporate drama due to fear of the
unknown. The examples in Chapter 9 show that simple strategies can be
utilized by anyone. The first example demonstrates how with guidance, the
students can be the creators and producers of their own works. Not only will
they learn content as they dive into the material to create a script, they will
learn problem-solving and have opportunities to show cooperation and
leadership through their interactions with their classmates. Later, follow-up
group discussions and self-reflections can lead to more engagement with the
content. Additionally, by experiencing something novel, students may
discover a path they otherwise would have failed to find (Allen 145).
The end of the book contains a Final Note in which Mr. Allen
integrates a few important concepts of Red Light vs. Green Light teaching by
offering advice. The first piece of advice is start small (Allen 171). Allen
advises not trying every strategy at once. Teachers should pick one with
which they feel comfortable and build from there. Along the way, it is
important to evaluate the progress and commit to make changes. Once a
teacher feels confident that strategy is working well, he/she should try a new
one.
The second bit of advice in the Final Note is to teach the students,
not the content (Allen 171). This phrase is common and presented in many
other texts. It is easy to say, but hard to explain. It is absolutely true that
teachers must transfer the knowledge of content to their students. The
concept is that by focusing on the students, the content will be learned.
Every student is different and each class will have a different energy. A
lesson plan that excels in one class may fall flat in another. Teachers must
focus on the individual learning needs of their students and build lessons
that utilize strategies that will best help those specific children. Whether it is
the following year, or the following class period, the teacher will need to
reevaluate the plan to discover the most successful path for the next group.
In conclusion, Green Light Classrooms is a well-written book identifying
strategies for student-led learning. Many of the ideas presented are also
presented by other authors, but the concept of Green Light vs. Red Light
helps draw a correlation in the minds of teachers that may help them identify
more successful teaching methods. The examples in the book are easy to
follow and adjust for various age groups and content areas. The research
presented by Mr. Allen seems sound and backed up by other studies and
real-world examples. Overall, it is a good text for teachers in all stages of
their teaching career.
Reference:
Allen, R. (2008). Green Light Classrooms: Teaching Techniques That
Accelerate Learning.
Thousand Oaks, CA: Corwin Press.