Trial #2-2012!06!05 Revised TECH EVAL 63000 ICT Building - 63k SF

Page 1
2012-04-24 Revised TECH EVAL 63000 ICT Building - 63k sf
CONSULTANT'S NAME:
No.
No. of
of
Similar years
Projects Est.
TECHNICAL
APPROACH &
METHODOLOGY
WORK PLAN
ORGANIZATIO
N & STAFFING
ADEQUACY OF THE PROPOSED METHODOLOGY & WORK

PLAN
SPECIFIC
EXPERIENCE
EVAALUATION SHEET: REQUEST FOR PROPOSALS FOR DESIGN CONSULTANCY SERVICES FOR MONTEGO
BAY FREE ZONE
10 YEARS
OVER 15 YEARS
3
5
2
3
5
ONE PROJECT
TWO PROJECTS
THREE PROJECTS
TECHNICAL APPROACH & METHODOLOGY
Considera
tions
Understanding of Terms of Reference
Quality of proposal
Method of carrying out Activities
10
3
7
WORK PLAN
Considera
tions
Main Activities
Content & Duration
Phasing & Interpretation
Milestones & Deliverables
4
3
1
2
ORGANIZATION & STAFFING

Considera
tions
Structure & Composition of Team
Technical Support Staff
8
2
MAXIM
UM
POINT
S
APEC
1
EVALUATOR
2
3
AVERAGE
SCORE
10
10
10
10
10
10.0
20
17
18
15
17
16.8
10
10
10
9.5
10
10
10
9.0
17.25
17.25
36
36
36
36
36
36.0
6.0
110
105.3
107.3
98.2
105.3
104.5
GENERAL QUALIFICATION
>15yrs 10>yrs<15
Prof.
Reg.
MSc.
BSc
TEAM LEADER 15
ARCHITECT 10
7
3.5
2
1
2
1.5
1
1
5
4
STRUCTURAL / CIVIL ENG.10
3.5
1.5
ELECTRICAL ENG.10
3.5
1.5
MECHANICAL ENG.10
3.5
1.5
QUANTITY SURVEYOR 5
2.5
0.5
17.25 ### 17.25
17.3
18
ADEQUACY OF
ASSIGNMENT
ADEQUACY OF ASSIGNMENT
EXPERIENCE IN REGION &

LANGUAGE
KEY PROFESSIONAL STAFF QUALIFICATION & COMPETENCE FOR ASSIGNMENT
KEY PROFESSIONAL STAFF
5 or more projects/
less than
over 5 yrs experience 5
TEAM LEADER
ARCHITECT
STRUCTURAL /
CIVIL ENG.
ELECTRICAL ENG.
MECHANICAL ENG.
QUANTITY
SURVEYOR
9
7
6
5
5
4
7
5
4
3
3
2
EXPERIENCE IN REGION & LANGUAGE
TEAM LEADER
ARCHITECT
STRUCTURAL / CIVIL ENG.
ELECTRICAL ENG.
MECHANICAL ENG.
QUANTITY SURVEYOR
6 years
5 or less
2
2
2
2
2
2
1
1
1
1
1
1
Languag
e
-English
1
1
1
1
1
1
Page 2
CONSULTANT'S NAME:
MAXIM
UM
POINT
S
No.
No. of
of
Similar years
Projects Est.
TECHNICAL
APPROACH &
METHODOLO
GY
WORK PLAN
ORGANIZAT
ION &
STAFFING
ADEQUACY OF THE PROPOSED METHODOLOGY &

WORK PLAN
SPECIFIC
EXPERIENCE
BAY FREE ZONE
10 YEARS
OVER 15 YEARS
3
5
2
3
5
ONE PROJECT
TWO PROJECTS
THREE PROJECTS
ADeB
EVALUATOR
2
3
AVERAGE
SCORE
10
10
10
10
9.5

Considera
tions
Quality of proposal
10
3
7
20
14
16.5
12.5
13.0
WORK PLAN
Considera
tions
Main Activities
Content & Duration
4
3
1
2
10
7.5
6.1

Considera
tions
8
2
10
10
8.5
13.8
13.8
13.8
13.8
13.8
36
36
29
36
36
34.3
6.0
110
90.8
92.8
88.8
92.3
91.2
>15yrs 10>yrs<15
BSc
Prof.
Reg.
2
MSc.
ARCHITECT 10
3.5
1.5
3.5
1.5
ELECTRICAL ENG.10
3.5
1.5
MECHANICAL ENG.10
QUANTITY SURVEYOR 5
3.5
2.5
1
1
1.5
1
1
0.5
4
1
TEAM LEADER 15
18
ADEQUACY OF
ASSIGNMENT
EXPERIENCE IN
REGION & LANGUAGE
TEAM LEADER
ARCHITECT
STRUCTURAL /
CIVIL
ENG. ENG.
ELECTRICAL
QUANTITY
MECHANICAL ENG.
SURVEYOR
5 or more projects/
over 5 yrs9experience
7
6
5
5
4

TEAM LEADER
ARCHITECT
ELECTRICAL ENG.
MECHANICAL ENG.
QUANTITY SURVEYOR
6 years
2
2
2
2
2
2
5 or less
1
1
1
1
1
1
less than
5
7
5
4
3
3
2
Languag
e
-English
1
1
1
1
1
1
Page 3
CONSULTANT'S NAME:
MAXIM
UM
POINT
S
No.
No. of
of
Similar years
Projects Est.
TECHNICAL
APPROACH &
METHODOLO
GY
WORK PLAN
ORGANIZAT
ION &
STAFFING

WORK PLAN
SPECIFIC
EXPERIENCE
BAY FREE ZONE
10 YEARS
OVER 15 YEARS
3
5
2
3
5
ONE PROJECT
TWO PROJECTS
THREE PROJECTS
TYA
EVALUATOR
2
3
AVERAGE
SCORE
10
10
10
10
10
10.0

Considera
tions
Quality of proposal
10
3
7
20
18
17
19
18
18.0
WORK PLAN
Considera
tions
Main Activities
Content & Duration
4
3
1
2
10
10
8.8

Considera
tions
8
2
10
10
10
9.3
16.95
16.95
16.95
16.95
17.0
36
36
36
36
36
36.0
6.0
110
107.0
104.0
104.0
105.0
105.0
>15yrs 10>yrs<15
MSc.
1
1
BSc
1.5
1.5
3.5
1.5
3.5
1.5
2.5
0.5
TEAM LEADER 15
ARCHITECT 10
7
3.5
2
1
3.5
ELECTRICAL ENG.10
MECHANICAL ENG.10
QUANTITY SURVEYOR 5
Prof.
2
Reg.
5
4
18
ADEQUACY OF
ASSIGNMENT
EXPERIENCE IN
REGION & LANGUAGE
TEAM LEADER
ARCHITECT
STRUCTURAL /
CIVIL
ENG. ENG.
ELECTRICAL
QUANTITY
MECHANICAL ENG.
SURVEYOR
5 or more projects/
7
6
5
5
4

TEAM LEADER
ARCHITECT
ELECTRICAL ENG.
MECHANICAL ENG.
QUANTITY SURVEYOR
6 years
2
2
2
2
2
2
5 or less
1
1
1
1
1
1
less than
5
7
5
4
3
3
2
Languag
e
-English
1
1
1
1
1
1
Page 4
CONSULTANT'S NAME:
MAXIM
UM
POINT
S
No.
No. of
of
Similar years
Projects Est.
TECHNICAL
APPROACH &
METHODOLO
GY
WORK PLAN
ORGANIZAT
ION &
STAFFING

WORK PLAN
SPECIFIC
EXPERIENCE
BAY FREE ZONE
10 YEARS
OVER 15 YEARS
3
5
2
3
5
ONE PROJECT
TWO PROJECTS
THREE PROJECTS
CARL C. CHEN
EVALUATOR
2
3
AVERAGE
SCORE
10
7.0
10.0
10.0
10.0

Considera
tions
Quality of proposal
10
3
7
20
16.0
17.0
16.0
16.0
16
WORK PLAN
Considera
tions
Main Activities
Content & Duration
4
3
1
2
10
10.0
8.5
9.0
9.0

Considera
tions
8
2
10
10.0
7.0
8.0
8.0
16.7
16.7
16.7
16.7
17
36
36.0
36.0
36.0
36.0
36
6.0
6.0
6.0
6.0
110
101.7
101.2
101.7
101.7
101.5
>15yrs 10>yrs<15
BSc
Prof.
Reg.
2
MSc.
3.5
1.5
3.5
1.5
ELECTRICAL ENG.10
MECHANICAL ENG.10
3.5
1.5
3.5
1.5
QUANTITY SURVEYOR 5
2.5
0.5
TEAM LEADER 15
ARCHITECT 10
18
ADEQUACY OF
ASSIGNMENT
EXPERIENCE IN
REGION & LANGUAGE
TEAM LEADER
ARCHITECT
STRUCTURAL /
CIVIL
ENG. ENG.
ELECTRICAL
QUANTITY
MECHANICAL ENG.
SURVEYOR
5 or more projects/
7
6
5
5
4

TEAM LEADER
ARCHITECT
ELECTRICAL ENG.
MECHANICAL ENG.
QUANTITY SURVEYOR
6 years
2
2
2
2
2
2
5 or less
1
1
1
1
1
1
less than
5
7
5
4
3
3
2
Languag
e
-English
1
1
1
1
1
1
Page 5
CONSULTANT'S NAME:
MAXIM KINGSLAND SCOTT BAUER ASSOC

UM
AVERAGE
EVALUATOR
POINT
SCORE
1
2
3
4
S
No.
No. of
of
Similar years
Projects Est.
TECHNICAL
APPROACH &
METHODOLO
GY
WORK PLAN
ORGANIZAT
ION &
STAFFING

WORK PLAN
SPECIFIC
EXPERIENCE
BAY FREE ZONE
10 YEARS
OVER 15 YEARS
3
5
2
3
5
ONE PROJECT
TWO PROJECTS
THREE PROJECTS
10
10
10
10
9.3

Considera
tions
Quality of proposal
10
3
7
20
16
14
12
16
14.5
WORK PLAN
Considera
tions
Main Activities
Content & Duration
4
3
1
2
10
5.5
7.1

Considera
tions
8
2
10
10
10
8.8
16.35
16.35
16.35
16.35
16.4
36
36
36
36
36
36.0
6.0
110
99.35
97.85
95.35
99.35
98.0
GENERAL
QUALIFICATION
>15yrs 10>yrs<15
BSc
Prof.
Reg.
2
MSc.
ARCHITECT 10
3.5
1.5
3.5
1.5
ELECTRICAL ENG.10
3.5
1.5
MECHANICAL ENG.10
QUANTITY SURVEYOR 5
3.5
2.5
1
1
1.5
1
1
0.5
4
1
TEAM LEADER 15
18
ADEQUACY OF
ASSIGNMENT
EXPERIENCE IN
REGION & LANGUAGE
TEAM LEADER
ARCHITECT
STRUCTURAL /
CIVIL
ENG. ENG.
ELECTRICAL
QUANTITY
MECHANICAL ENG.
SURVEYOR
5 or more projects/
7
6
5
5
4

TEAM LEADER
ARCHITECT
ELECTRICAL ENG.
MECHANICAL ENG.
QUANTITY SURVEYOR
6 years
2
2
2
2
2
2
5 or less
1
1
1
1
1
1
less than
5
7
5
4
3
3
2
Languag
e
-English
1
1
1
1
1
1
301768666.xls
POINTS
No. of years
Est.
No. of Similar
Projects
TECHNICAL
APPROACH &
METHODOLOG
Y
WORK PLAN
ORGANIZATIO
N & STAFFING

PLAN
SPECIFIC EXPERIENCE
EVAALUATION SHEET: REQUEST FOR PROPOSALS FOR DESIGN CONSULTANCY SERVICES FOR MONTEGO BAY FREE ZONE
10 YEARS
OVER 15 YEARS
ONE PROJECT
TWO PROJECTS
THREE PROJECTS
APEC CONSULTANTS LTD.
ADeB CONSULTANTS LTD.
10
10
5
TYR DESIGNS
CARL C. CHEN & ASSOCIATES
10
KINGSLANDNSCOTT BAUER
ASSOCIATES.
7
2
7
2

Considerations
10
Quality of proposal
3
7
Main Activities
Content & Duration
4
3
1
2
9
20
17
14
18
16
16
WORK PLAN
Considerations

Considerations
8
2
10
4
2
1
2
8
10
2
2
2
0
1
4
3
1
2
10
10
4
3
1
2
10
10
3
2
1
2
10
10
>15yrs
TEAM LEADER 15
10>yrs<15 Prof. Reg.
MSc.
BSc
15
ARCHITECT 10
3.5
1.5
3.5
1.5
ELECTRICAL ENG.10
3.5
1.5
MECHANICAL ENG.10
3.5
1.5
QUANTITY SURVEYOR 5
2.5
0.5
18
17.25
10
14
16.95
10
14
16.65
7.5
10
10
10
7.5
4.5
4.5
4.5
4.5
16.35
5 or more projects/ over
5 yrs experience
less than 5
TEAM LEADER
ARCHITECT
9
6
ELECTRICAL ENG.
MECHANICAL ENG.
QUANTITY SURVEYOR
5
4
3
2
5
4
5
4
5
4
5
4
5
4
36
9
36
9
7
36
9
36
9
36
6 years
5 or less
Language
-English
TEAM LEADER
ARCHITECT
ELECTRICAL ENG.
MECHANICAL ENG.
QUANTITY SURVEYOR
2
6
110
EVALUATOR 1
10
14
13.8
36

LANGUAGE
2
2
2
6
105.25
2
2
2
2
90.8
2
6
106.95
2
2
2
6
101.65
2
2
99.35
301768666.xls
POINTS
No. of years
Est.
No. of Similar
Projects
TECHNICAL
APPROACH &
METHODOLOG
Y
WORK PLAN
ORGANIZATIO
N & STAFFING

PLAN
SPECIFIC EXPERIENCE
10 YEARS
OVER 15 YEARS
ONE PROJECT
TWO PROJECTS
THREE PROJECTS

Considerations
Quality of proposal
APEC CONSULTANTS LTD.
10
10
5
20
4
3
1
2
10
3
6
2.5
10
5
18
TYR DESIGNS
10
5
10
3
7
10
5
15.5
10
5
17
ASSOCIATES.
17
14
WORK PLAN
Considerations
Main Activities
Content & Duration

Considerations
4
3
1
2
10
8
2
10
2
3
2.5
1
1
3
2
1
2
7.5
10
3.5
2
2
1
10
8.5
10
2.5
1.5
0.5
1
5.5
10

TEAM LEADER 15
MSc.
BSc
ARCHITECT 10
3.5
1.5
15
3.5
1.5
10
ELECTRICAL ENG.10
3.5
1.5
MECHANICAL ENG.10
3.5
1.5
QUANTITY SURVEYOR 5
2.5
0.5
18
7
17.25
14
13.8
10
14
16.95
10
14
16.65
7.5
10
10
10
7.5
4.5
4.5
4.5
4.5
16.35
5 or more projects/ over 5 yrs
experience
less than 5
TEAM LEADER
ARCHITECT
ELECTRICAL ENG.
MECHANICAL ENG.
QUANTITY SURVEYOR
3
2
5
4
5
4
5
4
5
4
5
4
9
36
6 years
5 or less
TEAM LEADER
Language
-English
1
ARCHITECT
1
6
9
36
9
7
36
9
36
9
7
36
36
3
6.0
ELECTRICAL ENG.
MECHANICAL ENG.
QUANTITY SURVEYOR
110
EVALUATOR 2

LANGUAGE
>15yrs
107.25
98.8
103.95
101.2
97.85
301768666.xls
POINTS
No. of years
Est.
No. of Similar
Projects
TECHNICAL
APPROACH &
METHODOLOG
Y
WORK PLAN
ORGANIZATIO
N & STAFFING

PLAN
SPECIFIC EXPERIENCE
10 YEARS
OVER 15 YEARS
ONE PROJECT
TWO PROJECTS
THREE PROJECTS
APEC CONSULTANTS
LTD.
5
10
10
5
TYA DESIGNS
10
10
ASSOCIATES.
10
5
10
5

Considerations
10
Quality of proposal
3
7
Main Activities
Content & Duration
4
3
1
2
7
20
15
19
16
12
WORK PLAN
Considerations

Considerations
10
4
3
1
1
8
2
10
1
3
2
1
0
4
1
1
2
4
3
1
1
2
1
1
1
>15yrs
TEAM LEADER 15
MSc.
BSc
15
ARCHITECT 10
3.5
1.5
3.5
1.5
ELECTRICAL ENG.10
3.5
1.5
MECHANICAL ENG.10
3.5
1.5
QUANTITY SURVEYOR 5
2.5
0.5
18
17.25
10
14
16.95
10
14
16.65
7.5
10
10
10
7.5
4.5
4.5
4.5
4.5
16.35
experience
less than 5
TEAM LEADER
ARCHITECT
ELECTRICAL ENG.
MECHANICAL ENG.
QUANTITY SURVEYOR
3
2
5
4
5
4
5
4
5
4
5
4
9
36
6 years
5 or less
TEAM LEADER
Language
-English
1
ARCHITECT
1
6
9
36
9
7
36
9
36
9
36
36
3
6
ELECTRICAL ENG.
MECHANICAL ENG.
QUANTITY SURVEYOR
110
EVALUATOR 3
10
14
13.8

LANGUAGE
100.25
88.8
103.95
101.65
92.35
301768666.xls
POINTS
No. of years
Est.
No. of Similar
Projects
TECHNICAL
APPROACH &
METHODOLOG
Y
WORK PLAN
ORGANIZATIO
N & STAFFING

PLAN
SPECIFIC EXPERIENCE
10 YEARS
OVER 15 YEARS
ONE PROJECT
TWO PROJECTS
THREE PROJECTS
APEC CONSULTANTS
LTD.
5
10
10
5
TYA DESIGNS
10
10
ASSOCIATES.
10
5
10
5

Considerations
10
Quality of proposal
3
7
Main Activities
Content & Duration
4
3
1
2
8
20
17
1.5
12.5
18
16
16
WORK PLAN
Considerations

Considerations
8
2
10
4
3
1
2
10
7
10
2
3
2
1
0
4
2
1
2
4
3
1
1
2
2
1
2
>15yrs 10>yrs<15 Prof. Reg.

TEAM LEADER-15
MSc.
BSc
15
ARCHITECT-10
3.5
1.5
STRUCTURAL / CIVIL ENG.-10
3.5
1.5
ELECTRICAL ENG.10
3.5
1.5
MECHANICAL ENG.-10
3.5
1.5
QUANTITY SURVEYOR-5
2.5
0.5
18
17.25
10
14
16.95
10
14
16.65
7.5
10
10
10
7.5
4.5
4.5
4.5
4.5
16.35
experience
less than 5
TEAM LEADER
ARCHITECT
ELECTRICAL ENG.
MECHANICAL ENG.
QUANTITY SURVEYOR
9
36
9
36
9
7
36
9
36
9
36
6 years
5 or less
TEAM LEADER
Language
-English
1
ARCHITECT
ELECTRICAL ENG.
MECHANICAL ENG.
QUANTITY SURVEYOR
3
6
110
EVALUATOR 4
10
14
13.8
36

LANGUAGE
3
6
105.25
3
6
92.3
3
6
104.95
3
6
101.65
99.35
CONSULTANT NAME
APEC
ADeB
TYA
KINGSLAND
SCOTT
CARL CHEN
EVALUATOR1
EVALUATOR2
EVALUATOR3
EVALUATOR4
105
91
107
102
99
107
93
104
101
98
98
89
104
102
95
105
92
105
102
99
TOTAL AVERAGE SCORE
104
91
105
102
98
RANK
Technical (Quality) Weighted

Tech Score
Weighted
Quality
Score
Consultant
105
105 x 60
110
57.3
APEC Consultants
104
56.7
Carl Chen Associates
102
Kingsland Scott Bauer

Assocs.
98
104 x 60
110
102 x 60
110
98 x 60
110
ADeB Consultants
91
91 x 60
110
49.7
Tya Design
55.4
53.4
Cost Score Weighting

Financial Offer
Weighted
Financial
Score
Financial Score
TYA
APEC
CARL CHEN
KINGSLAND SCOTT
ADeB
CONSULTANT NAME
TYA
APEC
CARL CHEN
KINGSLAND SCOTT
ADeB
88,526,250.00 40,939,072.46x40
88526250
46,000,000.00 40,939,072.46x40
46000000
51,350,000.00 40,939,072.46x40
51530000
US$471,757.00 40,939,072.46x40
or
40,939,072
J$40,939,072.46
18.50
49,909,016.00 40,939,072.46x40
49,909,016
32.81
Weighted
Quality Score
57.3
35.60
31.89
40.00
Weighted
Total Score
Financial Score
18.50
75.8
56.7
35.60
92.3
55.4
31.89
87.3
53.4
40.00
93.4
49.7
32.81
82.5

Trial #2-2012!06!05 Revised TECH EVAL 63000 ICT Building - 63k SF

Uploaded by

Document Information

Original Title

Copyright

Available Formats

Share this document

Share or Embed Document

Sharing Options

Did you find this document useful?

Is this content inappropriate?

Copyright:

Available Formats

Trial #2-2012!06!05 Revised TECH EVAL 63000 ICT Building - 63k SF

Uploaded by

Copyright:

Available Formats

Page 1

2012-04-24 Revised TECH EVAL 63000 ICT Building - 63k sf

ADEQUACY OF THE PROPOSED METHODOLOGY & WORK

ORGANIZATION & STAFFING

STRUCTURAL / CIVIL ENG.10

17.25 ### 17.25

EXPERIENCE IN REGION &

KEY PROFESSIONAL STAFF QUALIFICATION & COMPETENCE FOR ASSIGNMENT

KEY PROFESSIONAL STAFF

EXPERIENCE IN REGION & LANGUAGE

2012-04-24 Revised TECH EVAL 63000 ICT Building - 63k sf

ADEQUACY OF THE PROPOSED METHODOLOGY &

TECHNICAL APPROACH & METHODOLOGY

ORGANIZATION & STAFFING

STRUCTURAL / CIVIL ENG.10

KEY PROFESSIONAL STAFF QUALIFICATION & COMPETENCE FOR ASSIGNMENT

KEY PROFESSIONAL STAFF

EXPERIENCE IN REGION & LANGUAGE

2012-04-24 Revised TECH EVAL 63000 ICT Building - 63k sf

ADEQUACY OF THE PROPOSED METHODOLOGY &

TECHNICAL APPROACH & METHODOLOGY

ORGANIZATION & STAFFING

KEY PROFESSIONAL STAFF QUALIFICATION & COMPETENCE FOR ASSIGNMENT

KEY PROFESSIONAL STAFF

EXPERIENCE IN REGION & LANGUAGE

2012-04-24 Revised TECH EVAL 63000 ICT Building - 63k sf

ADEQUACY OF THE PROPOSED METHODOLOGY &

TECHNICAL APPROACH & METHODOLOGY

ORGANIZATION & STAFFING

KEY PROFESSIONAL STAFF QUALIFICATION & COMPETENCE FOR ASSIGNMENT

KEY PROFESSIONAL STAFF

EXPERIENCE IN REGION & LANGUAGE

2012-04-24 Revised TECH EVAL 63000 ICT Building - 63k sf

MAXIM KINGSLAND SCOTT BAUER ASSOC

ADEQUACY OF THE PROPOSED METHODOLOGY &

TECHNICAL APPROACH & METHODOLOGY

ORGANIZATION & STAFFING

KEY PROFESSIONAL STAFF QUALIFICATION & COMPETENCE FOR ASSIGNMENT

KEY PROFESSIONAL STAFF

EXPERIENCE IN REGION & LANGUAGE

ADEQUACY OF THE PROPOSED METHODOLOGY & WORK

APEC CONSULTANTS LTD.

ADeB CONSULTANTS LTD.

CARL C. CHEN & ASSOCIATES

TECHNICAL APPROACH & METHODOLOGY

ORGANIZATION & STAFFING

KEY PROFESSIONAL STAFF

10>yrs<15 Prof. Reg.

STRUCTURAL / CIVIL ENG.10

STRUCTURAL / CIVIL ENG.

STRUCTURAL / CIVIL ENG.

EXPERIENCE IN REGION & LANGUAGE

KEY PROFESSIONAL STAFF QUALIFICATION & COMPETENCE FOR ASSIGNMENT

ADEQUACY OF THE PROPOSED METHODOLOGY & WORK

TECHNICAL APPROACH & METHODOLOGY

APEC CONSULTANTS LTD.

CARL C. CHEN & ASSOCIATES

ADeB CONSULTANTS LTD.

ORGANIZATION & STAFFING

KEY PROFESSIONAL STAFF

10>yrs<15 Prof. Reg.

STRUCTURAL / CIVIL ENG.10

STRUCTURAL / CIVIL ENG.