IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA (CRIMINAL ORIGINAL JURISDICTION WRIT PETITION (CR.) NO. 25 OF 2016 (Petition under Article 32 ofthe Constitution of Inala) IN THE MATTER ©} NN. D JAYAPRAKASH Petitioner versus UNION OF INDIA & ANR. Respondents INDEX PARTICULAR cident Report dated ¥ 17.02.2016 [supporting AMTigavie z NT Ni DELHI POLICE: 0, MAHRAIcIDENT REPORT DATED 17/02/0316 Vide FIR No, 110/16, u/s 1244/1206/94 IC, dated 11.02.2016, PS Vasant Kunj Norh, South District, Deh, the accused Kanaiya Kumar, resident of JNU Student Unlon was to be produced on 17.02.2016 at Patile House Court No. 4 of Sh. Loreier Singh, Ld BM, Pai ‘Courts ater 2 days of PC remand. In vew the incident that ocurred on 15,022016 in Pala House Courts complex wherein ew groups of lawyer had suddenly indulged in incdenta ef. vilenee” elaborate pale srrangenients were made in and around the Court complex. A total of 04 ‘oy (275 approx. Including male & fel tof CREF under 0 Arista (Commandant and 08 Inspectors, 01 coys (0 approx. male aa) of ITEP under Of Assistant Commandant and 01 Inspector, 03 coy & 02 PL Tota 268 approx) of CP reserve, Delhi Plc were deployed. nation to this 15 Inspector and 06 ACEP and approximately 150 police personnal rm New Di District were deployed unde the eer supervision ofthe DCP New Delhi District, Besides, 02 ACS, 04 Inspects and epprox. 90 other pale Devnnel under the supervision of Add. DCP South Disuict were oy prepostioned to augment the existing arrangements made By New Del Distt tthe Pata House Cou. 2. On 17.02.2016 in maming twas planed to produce the accused Kanhaiya at about 5:00 PM before the Ld MH at Patiala House du tthe prevaliag law and order situation tthe Cort peri as well a or the personel safety ofthe accused. However, in the mesntine, the order of Hon'ble Supreme Court of Inala mas conned through the Ué, District, Judge, Pale House Court to produce Kanha inthe Court of Ld KM at 200 Pa. Immediately, «posse of pie pertonnel comprising of 40 police personnel incuding an ACP and 15 pain cthes policemen escorted him fom PS Vasant Kun North o Pain House our in cateadecoiting of se orcas to ensure the safety an person secur of the accused nt lly on the way to the Court but alto while beng produced in the Court, ‘The plain doth deployment as done so that they could act and eset non suspeesingly and efectirely while merging withthe general baskgrend of the cromd, Some of the components of polit personnel accompanying the Krew Sin Cemmissone Pel foun oe sentientpe “cee ssa carted body protectors and the histo deal wth any Kind of cveatualiy — White dhe accused wns being escorted, information was rccved f0 hat the carade fr & while as see arrangements Inthe Court were Eng mace by the Register General of Home High Court of Dei os pe he tirecdons of Honble Supreme Court of India, The carsnde halted at C- Hagen for few minutes, The excarting ty longi the accused er rhe on geting & go een fem the Court move, towards the Court ad Tensing the lw and order sustion i ad around the Court premises, He otic personnel escorting him i plain cates formed «close inne rng Wich was further augmented fy an oxter cng consisting of unifrmed pullce personnel to ensure aelty and serio the noused 44, The accused Kantilya Kumar was srought by team of oie officers ftom South Distt and with the satarce of New Del Distt police was cote inade the Court Complex throgh the shortest posable route. A rou of awyers which had lady assembled nade the court complex in vious sich groups emerged a red esau the accused fom dierent Tides, The ring round tam & the pice men deplnyed on the route fureunded him ffom al sides and gre body protection and thwarted tepeed attempts to maniande the ected Lot of commen fone Bat re wes eocorted tfey 19 the Court Rowm by the policemen deaite seme iupa. Later, the accused Kanbaia urar alge hat he was ace tyr lneyers and a group of goons and bathed him up, toe his cates and bused him and damage his sppers and jacet, and plucked hs a. Ths happened in the presence. of gle. The policeman wert also besten UP during this period. Te accu submited & write appicaton alising hove. Afr the Court proceetngs, the cused was mca examined in the court Room itself by the doctar of RAL Hospital end the MLC wes prepared io the court vel Te MUC reflects examination fo chest ln land cough indicating BP 110/70, pulse 2/minute, CNS-consous oriented siting ennortably an chal, normal vascular breath YA, sof aon end “The oa! examination indicates tenders at rit oe, two gbrsions ate foot and one abaion at not which mht have occured whe ringing i ud ule the court. The MLC esi shows tat he had mnobeesions“4 (foo nd toe snd onthe nak. Iwas also found tat one of he awe of the acd wating ete qn eds 5. tela ne of evden cpings ing hewn in tia clay sow that pune have town protects ag, eoundag and oectng vo he center fk MM al «ft tat in te oot wich might hae reste nthe abrasionson i 6. Whe Kantaga Kamar was og rh the Cot 6.4 a he & game pnt ere byte oe Tem (sh a pst end 8 a ein ther peo taking advange oe prevaing cnn and commotion rest Ue ert Pray or 4 “The DCP New San bir vad eed fm ering the au Wo. 4 ta aoe ta people eter te co o,f Rave to Beene pe te vb Supe Cort ore, Ten Kare Kumar along wih he eat ry ete Cot No. or enti by Hone Regs seer ely yes Ranh Kaas ran Som cur Wo. © Cote ween te wl cour roam wef of pol eign manetay nth Rage Covet oss nt er we eee ber f NU were engin abut the wel ag of aca Taser ema al hone unient pea nung pe erent seta dte were dee to ore ot deconges andting ater sano No.5 no that MISaY Rear Oswell ems 2 enn fhe pape who ere persed ene the tl om seaeetpe DCP Rew De Dispel sond wdor of Cos Rom ve amen that no uncer person entered tea corto The va gue teen court oo, sgt cong 1 ta sae pron fay he be a oral, eye ember ef he pu aot ence orto, and a0 hat Ld, Cou oa wp Kes xn eer ert No 4 hut any pln. In ress Kenai Karel Hole Regis Goal tt ead sen pan nh ace in sing te se shane wh SESS Bonne ga ener le ier of ana Kamar anmerepln and he ple fli presen nae crus oS and He sper immediatly tried searching te two pers about whom he :y ice wes alerted. A proper search wee launched to nab these fos but mo uy ty then, they had disappeared lato the mob outlde the court ofce/chamber. The lawyers af Kanhsiye Kumar started shouting and blaming the pole ofits eng the DCP New Delhi Disrietthat they vrere hand Inglore wih the stackere and hd helped the attackers espe However, this isnot correct a the polio las had got Court Room No, and the alley between both the cot roxma de-congeted and enwued that cour om No, 4 es fe from any wrested efeon, As son as the police got to know tht two persans who Pad aizgedly attacked Karka | ‘unas were the ones who had come to cout No 5, police launched sere, for them but they had disappeazed by thes. There was.go manhanding beating or any kind of auch incident wih Kaaiya Kumar within the court building abd inside the court rom on 17.02.2086 after he was Brought i the court and until safely escorted to Shr Jail, 7. ving his attempted ansaut bythe group of lamers, 10 poiemen hve leo been ejured ~ 1 Pursuant to the directions of the Hon'ble Supreme Court, wa ensured that ony authorized lawyer and mda persons were lowed inthe trial court rom without the mete phones 9, Subsequent tothe ensuing meee, few projectiles were also ued toma diferent groupe and on the visng lawyers who had come on the reetion of the Honble Supreme Court. This was coupled with heal nage of abusive language. 10, Aer the court proceedings were over accused Kanha Kumar was t efety escorted othe Thar Jail jn complace ofthe Hone Court order td hasbeen provided neparate cll bythe Jl authorities arta all security parameters nto considerations 11, 10 pertinent to mention here that on 15.02.2016, JNU Students Union President Mr. Kanaiya Kumar was tobe produced inthe Hone Court af Sh. Loreeen Singh, Court No, , Pla House Courts, New Det Around 1400 bra, «group of lawyers sbjeced tothe presence of fe INU Indy teachers laside the Court room. Argument took pace betwen the Toners and the lady teaches, The poe immeiately intervened nd FA eeS Peeps te a grope ate ay tnchecn were suey esgorted ut of the Cour room and the Court premises, mediately, thereafter multiple guys of langers at dierent paces onthe Court premises started caging slogans, sell with some persons who were taking id rophs/photogaphs (ichuding the media persons) and pushed them round. Many of those who were targried by the lawyers were mea pervs, who were aio present in large number nat Just inside the Court premises but also outside gate No. 2, The pie prevented exelton of violence between layers and other groupe by separating them and by ‘losing the main gate. Subsequent, the myers esembled and started sloganeering clsiing that they wil handle Mr Kanhalya Kumar in thie ‘own way and would’ tolerate any ati-tnda slogans, Further even outa the Cour ate No. 2 two groupe who were ulsing counter slogans got ita bras! amongst themes. tn thie bacground of prevaing House vironment the SHO PS Vasant Kn North requested th Hon'ble Dstrce ‘Judge to bit the yenue ofthe appearance of accused anhiaya Kuma. Considering the application move, Mantle Distt Judge was pleased to shit the venue and curt proceedings were eld on 18/2/16 et DCP oe ‘omplex, Hoag Khas. I wa leo cbeersed tnt siting of venue di ead to annoyance of certain sections. oe ‘Considering the wurcharged atmosphere in the lat fow day and the cores Ge ies ST WHR wy FAW heresies of th lB fac an 38 saved by the Bar that they will help the police in maintaining oderiness {Ste pr Post experienc a howe wed in Dey 1980 & ny Chena, Alahabul eave cy shown athe pale at thay tena the sein fan, re cng er ‘ici ae of to fo ot ercnng igh reins in the wkd tee he court rei. Khas so Bernsen tht my te ely face ede of ny an an the rly oes mage ct ie, Hence th Pde perl ple eh out ples Ie mie sue ea. Ite sin rare ete fei That pers wo ae Spon ot pls of emacuy ad Gee human wigs cd revert to rept scy he yslsi b eval, Blocking ofthe gates, targeting the media person, chasing the sents ete coud not be vnuatie in nal cognition, 18, The prescribed measures of rom jes which incude use of ear 85, water cannon and lath charge in open space wich pes crowd the option to loperse and retest, cold not have ben resorted oat the sone of action of 17.02.2016 4. Patina House Cour complex which compres of ‘rious structural buldings, vehicle parking pace which i ul of vehicle on working ay and ther structures ke layers chambers which make it very congested are. Thecefore, any se oflthi charge or tear gos would have made the eroud to rereat fo closed spices and would have incensed ‘he probability ofa stampede endangering human ies, Further fasetonng ofthe eae court premises woul have been eoprdied boone of tea gi ‘sneaking into the court roms, Hence consous decision was taken ogo Jn for miskmum colateral damage as any sich pesrbed cow peal measures would have led to unnecessary confrontation lnpacing the Judea ofcers, InoeentIaners, tga, journal and oer innocent bystanders. 14. After the Hone High Cour was sind of the matter suo, i ‘wos also presumed that semblance of sei! spine would preva in the Inwpere community cutting acrots the Sins, but unfortunately i¢ was not persed oo the ground, 15, The Paila House Courts isa huge complex with OB gates All the : persons fret the ones in layers attire) ereing the Court premises are ‘risked and chesked but bloc cost entry br anjone not connected with rofesia, cannot be ruled ou. Ase the comslex approximately houses 26 Wherein lots of Iiigats enter the premises without rumters of our showing any identity 16, LEGALACTION BY POLICE: Two separate FIRS _weve registered su-moto after the ensuing brevis on 15.02.2016 vide HR Na, L (69/16, u/s 147/149 427/929 IPC, PS. Tik Marg & FIR No. 70/16, w/sI t tan/149/909/941 IPC, FS- Tek Marg Further two cases have teen registred onthe ineldents of 1702:2016, FIR No, 75/16, u/a 94 IR FS “Take Marg has Den egistred on the complaint of oe Ragen Verma r/0 Sonepat, Haryana and FIR No, 76/16, u/s 197/149/427/928/960/ 186/292/959 IPC, PS- Tilak Marg hes been registered suombto, Os 15.02.2016, 08 MLCs were prepared ct puble men, However, of 17.02.2016, 02 MCs were prepared of public while 10 MALCe of inured pullemen wee prepared. The cass are under investigation Subuated pease cere HA Fink SENT NE 20\6 prune woman eas sont conassronen 9» Pouce oat ean EW DEL pe one ' Sma “geIN THE SUPRENE COURT OF INDIA CRIMINAL ORIGINAL JURISDICTION WRIT PETITION (CRL) NO. 25 OF 2016 INTHE MATTER OF:~ N, D JAYAPRAKASH Petitioner Versus UNION OF INDIA & ANR, Respondents ‘AFFIDAVIT 1, Mukesh Kumar Meena, Joint Commissioner of Police, New Delhi Range, Delhi Police Headquarters, New Delhi, do hereby solemnly state and affirm as under:~ 4, That I am working as Joint Commissioner of Police, New Delhi Range and have been authorized to fle this ‘affidavit in support of Status Report/ incident Report dated 17.02.2016. 2. That the Status Report has been prepared on the basis of record avaiable in my office and the contents thereof are true and correct ta the best ‘of my knowledge based on the record of the case. ARE ENToan VERIFICATION:- ewes Se {te above named depner heey vey thatthe contents ofthe above afin tated In par No.1 2 are ue a cove ge brat one based onthe record he case, angeobing material has been concealed tert i) Verified at New Delton shis 14 of ATTESTED aa NX oun 00 sion, BERANE) eae women ONY sue 4~ OI INTHE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA WRIT PETITION (S) (CRIMINAL) NO, 25 OF 2016 INTHEMATTER OF: N.D. Jayaprakash, --Pettoner VERSUS Union of India And Ane. _ Respondent AEEIDAVIT ON BEHALF OF BAR COUNCILOF 1, Astok Kumar Pandey, S10 She SL Pandey, aged bout 40 yest, Joint Seewtay, Rar Coon of Ila thang ofc at 2, Rou Aven, Tastutonal Are, ‘Near Bal Bhawan, Nv Delhi 0001, do rey slay afm and dere asunder= 4. ‘That am the Jolt Sontary of Bar Cuneo nda and as sch wel equated and conversant wth the fats and cheumstnos ofthe present case on the ‘ase of the reords thereot and 1 am duly authored and as such competent to swear this affidaviterie as 2% That the Genet! Council of Bar Coun of Indi in ‘Ns emergent meting dated 2.022036 ha resolved the folloing:- Mectig of the Ceeret Come of the Bar Cone of ‘dia wos held on Sunday the 208 February, 2018 at 0 (24 0 New Debi endfor considering the deton of ‘49a! Béwation Connites, the Coun again met at 2:30 PI, The following Members were present- 4 Mr. Manan Kumar Mishra, Chairman, Bar Coif Tia 2 Mr. Satish A. Deshnukh, Vice-Chairman, Bar Coun af ia 3 Mr.8. Prabakaran, Co-Chairman, Bar Courcilef tiaaE 10. Mr. Ashok Kumar Deb Member, Bar Council India ‘Mr. Apurba Kumar Sharma, ‘Mamber, Bar Counell fia ‘Mr. Ramehandler Rao N., ‘Member, Bar Coun of ia _Mr, Dinesh Pathak, ‘Member, Bar Coun ef ia ‘Mr. Ramesichandra @. Shah Member, Bar Counell Tia ‘Mr. Bhoj Chandr Thakur, ‘Member, Bar Coun of Tria (Mr, Debi Prasad Dia, ‘Member, Bar Coun o Iria Mr. YR, Sadastva Reddy ‘Member, Bar Couto Inia Mr. Pratap Mehta, ‘Member, Bar CounellafTlia414, Mr. ShailendraDubey, Member, Bar Coun of tia Mr. Maku Rohatgi Attorney Genero dia and Mr. Rant Rumar, Salitr General of nda, Ex Ofiio Members, Bar Couneil finda, HonBle Members Mr. Wieu Bhatt, Mr. Rajnder Singh Rona, Mn Bir ‘Sinohsinsinsor and Mr. Ait Rana arent present The absence of Members is condoned, Honble Mr. Manan Kumar Mishra, Chairman, Bar Couneiof nia presided over the meeting ManNo. 90/2016 To consider the incidents which took place on 15% and 178 February, 2016 in Patiala House Court campus and also to consider about the aifidavit (0 befiled in Supreme Court inthis matter, Resolution ' The Counc has ly sc and deliberated ovr the Incdets which tok plae on gh and sy February, 2016 in Patiala House Court campus and th Gey Hon'ble Chairman passed om 15 on Fan‘ncomecton with thee tu cides. Orders posed by the Chairman, BCI on 98 and ip February, 2016 are hereby rate. Hole Members appeared tbe overs views on tis Sue. Some ofthe Hole Members were ofthe view that the conduct of the Lawyers shouldbe examined inthe light of the backgroud of the enfortunate incidents which ook place in he Jauaharll Nehru Uriversi(LN) as well os tx adepur Uriversty (West Bengal, And bese tase incidents re more grove in nataradvey danger the xtry the Ines of Pata Hos Cort compl ht bg outset reaction tos oe Enwever, the excess smi, bi yo tical Fe Hot tne opined that the part of ast of some Lawyers i mankanding some of te meta people, shouldbe considered seperately and iat ll itis proved, this an be segregated from other part ofthe occurrence fand the Committee constituted for this purpose may examine as to who all ave involved in the incidents of ‘marpit/quarrel or manandling of the journalists/medtia people. The Council is of unanimcus view that in a democracy Ie tia Maia sono song pir onertre any ton na by nly cnn Ce‘by the Counell. Hone Oharman has already tendered spology to the media. The Count appeals othe entre legal fraternity to allow the media people to discharge their duties peccehily and properly; ond also to cooperate them in ther faction, Therefore, this part of Incident ‘has been taker to be very serious. The Committe isto enquire io this aspect of the mater very cautiously and separately, So fr the other part of tue incidents Le, quarreling or ‘mankandling of studens or teacher of JNU is concerned, several Advowates of Patiala High Court campus have informed the Coun that large number of ‘outsiders, politician, students ond teachers from JU. ‘hal come on 58 and 17 February both by 34 buses and they had entred in the Court complet, And there also, they tried to shout slogans and used. provocative words forthe nation and for Advooates which ld to ‘untoward incident in whichbot sides took part. Hon'ble Members have saif that any tue citizen or a Lawyer of India, és supposed to strongly react to the ‘slogans tke Pakistan Zindebad, Hindustan Murdabad, Bharat tere tukade hope Iioa Alla-2, india Go Back, Afzal Hum Sharminda Hoi, Tere Qatil sinda hai, Pakistan lng ive, Inia dour down et, Such acts of anybody always deserve to, cand need tobe dpposed strongly; Butian be done toga ways and not by indecent methods like the alleged incident. Be thot os it may, these were the incidents which occured in the premises of JU. and Jedaupur Universiy and wheter sitar slogans were aly shouted inthe previsesof Patiala House Court campus 4 fact be enqubed sy the Commitee constated by Howble Caiman. Whatever might be the background or reason, the class of Advocates isnot suposed to indulge inthe incidents of abusing or commiting ony untoward ocurrenc inthe cour premises or aryuters, that 100 in robes. All the Honble ‘Members are ‘anions on tis poi tht these who are suposed to Protect the aw and saters of Law are not expected to ‘ake Law t thet oon hard The Counc axcorinly resales to proved with the nig 1 ter eed o bring the orders pased by Honble Charman abguith this esatuton ty the note of Hontle apex Curt on 2222016, If Hontle ape Cort allows the Stun to proved with te nai oly then th restion ofthe Coune i stand rated, otherwise is eto te inl ode ofthe ontop Cort desing wth iste 1s frter made clear ot he Chara has aed Me oe og Meribers of thé team conttuted by MIE areCourt This conduc of tx Advocates is very unfortanate ‘and the Comite ito examine aud enquire into these aspects also Resolved accordingly.” 23. That the copy of he order dated 15.2016 and s7a.aois passed by Hon'ble Chairman, Bat Councl of India is annesed herewith and marked as Anmexure -R (coll). 44 That the aveomentsmade hereinabove ae tre and core othe best f my owed & VHRIEICATION ‘Verified at New Delon this the 21 day of February, 2016.1, the above-name deponent, do hereby verify thet the contents of the abowealfdavit are trucand corret No part oft is alee and nothing material has been concealed om on ceeerae SoeeguoeFebruary 15,2016 ORDER have taken the inet lh tok ae day the Pia House Cor campus Sensors 0 he ean a ap the ter lees, # ‘aly aty acing fo Gh of ap pooh ull sen ef pl fam avail Nebr Unies tho ld fe wes ti cat ‘anlar senting ann sou premise al ‘SSID acne neonate a. Toere ofc inoerety Sy ‘Aer wating te and ating the inoemay coated the Heats Mena {the Coane sed thy all were of he opto hat whatever igs have bee sution or the rien blip the let, bute cant Ioae and tle ‘mseondue on they of dea. ar ensuttion withthe Houle embers, hae elo conatue gh Leve esis ene ent, et eer ig ae ‘Sing te stents ef te peple who hae aigey bes manana aod to ‘rng te steel aA Ofc Bae fala Ca Br ‘souaton, ideas Manis Gm cag fo im Ci etl igh owe Just L Nal Rady, ae ee | 6 Cou actals ney ME. EN Keshnaa eo Conl , ‘Pabacan, Hoa foe Cl Stn wt the Chiperson ofthe. ao | ‘ea hy rent he Cooma he nay eee 2 Wate te ld he procenigs on day day fan" scant ah Shergent meting he Col on 2 Febery, 8 7 rie acndingy ‘Put uphie order for aio in te meting he Counc on 212.2016 ee peg ‘Manan Kaas ebr Gineman, Bar Coe of tain Annerare~ (gabhy)FF coonne Aoneare- Cal) ye ? ‘onpeR cg ving anv il net SL en Co a tp nt ae ape ae ey vy me To mame Fe Hee OU ge Hama fy pe 08 et Gout renin rey t “The bit of th eae ta ven atte th oo | BRGSREASSE alerts sod cuenta ar ‘tlhe et perc segue Commie pian morte eas Fie Seth eo 9 hun ne ts th 2 aay L- egies f Se AES nt eee lr riche yoo ot ee tee ‘che eng apa gee TE Me uo a So a ne a On Pe ged be Ho dc whe a Cel a toute maf tient fy at rm anos ofl em ugar NE Ss ee er ae a a a ee Jean ae UnveutGNO) a AST "Beet ovarde techs of dou. sont ve rane thn ae ona aC he seated a ening ne aa ee ef de rd ae cat i oe Pare an Bat, ee PO ston amine temas. reese contacted he Hone mabe fh COE, cer this dreamt peop no Hae ade hee poy fom ie sad ponle a om TE Sy bee nbd bythe Abort, rete ele to make a et otha one eS igh delet gaan wen a a ae inde te se ogy exeniany and a wil ia ee te mined op ee snd mt ee ‘oor whi Sod of was fom ee a pel rr) eatin ote Cae utp the ster before the Gene! House F280 onder sondingy tsa pth ana Kumnar Mishra, Ustiman, Bar Counc of ncean as Y . IPT OF THE VIDEO RECORDIN Ms, Vrinda When we came here, the Registrar General Grover: was here, the DCP is here, Mr, Jatin Narwal, various other senior police officers are here We were asked :0 show Court the Supreme Court Order. We showed that, The names of hose Tawyers, sn fact Mr, Bumkin's two 2 Juniors, were actually on record in the Vakalatnania. They said they will not be permitted, Only the lawyers whose names are there, We said Yes. Only those people Would appear. Waen we were entering, there as lot of sloganeering,” told you that they ere too very ansious and there was far in Us I repeatedly tld the police ad I told the Registrar General in as many words “Please ensure the safety. There is a hostile atmosphere in the Patiala House premises ‘ahd safety is paramount and we have to be cscorted til our venicles." This sloganeering hhas continued. Thereafter, went to the terrace here from where this court is directly Visible and the slogineering happened here. ‘gnin brought it to the attention of the Registrar General and the DCP “Please remove these scoundrels. This is an intimidating environment." Thereafter, when y the was produced, he was immediately taker there, Our phones were also takeis from us Which is unprecederted, And, thus, phones ere put away. We were told to wait here, We are waiting hee. Our [Cards wereNs. Vind Grover: Mr. Kapil Sibal: Ms. Vrinda Grover: Mr. Kapil Sib: Ms, Vrinda Grover Unidentified vice: Ms. Grover Vrinda ‘checked. We complied with every requirement by the Registrar General. The Faculty Member Mr. Himanshst (Slight interrupticn. Ms. Vrinda Grover seys Ihe has gone tothe e804 onan) {taterraption) Kanhaiya aap pease yahan aajo, Bahar Daitho aap. (Kanhsiva please come here, you please sit here) He has been assaulted while being brought to tie court. He was assaulted? Yes, (interruption) Just now in this ecut room. ast now? ‘That is what I ar saying. No lawyer was allowed to come in (@reryone walks tovards Kankaiya Kumar) Uski chappaluttar gayi hai. (his sandala got removed) Pani zara lao (get some water) and get a soft drink (for Kanhaiya Kumar) He came in dark glasses - suited booted ‘man. If [can just fins what I am saying. ‘Thereafter, | suddealy sensed that there is ‘something happening there because T can see something. One man comes out and the DCP, who is the senior-most officer here.This man is wearing dark glasses. He is ‘wearing coat. itis not a lawyer's coat. itis Justa black coa He asks him court mein agpka naam kya hot” what is your nas) ‘This man takes dPhis dark glasses and says “mein apna naar: yun bataon?” (why should disclose my nane) And he hulfs him away and he walks pass. Nobody’ stops him, How did that man came in through the security and how di he exit? (Thereafter, Ms, Vrinda Grover points to a person ‘and says ths is Mr. Himanshu, a JNU Faculty Member.) Yas, Himanshu, T raised objection, The court Registrar Faculty Membeti General was stanting next to me. 1 tld him Kanhaiya was posting out that this guy has beaten me along with 25 other people, arrest hhim, 1 was shovting and all three officials allowed him to go. I wae chouting, { wae telling the police officers that this guy is the ‘one who has beaten the Kanhaiya is saying, Please stop him. Please arrest him, And they allowed hifn to go. All of them allowed , him to g0, Ms. Vrinda But Kanhaiya peiley (fist) got beaten up Grover: ‘outside, He lost his chappal. The police cficer accompanying has no nameplate because he was pulled. Thereafter, two man ‘were allowed to ceme in, They beat him in fam absolutely their presence and scandalized, Sir, (taterruption) 30 of them. a I aMs, Vrinda And those two people come in, assaulted Grover him, ‘The senior most officer allows them to go and then they come and tell us “we do not know who they are” It has happened: in front of our eyes and I ad told them this is going to happen, Mr. Himanshu, And the police had 5-10 minutes, They Paoulty Member asically wer, Me. Harin Raval: Should we not ak the gentleman who isin change of the Security? Ms. Vrinda DCP Jatin Narwal and the Registrar General Grover: of the High Cour, Please asl the Registrar General, High Court. Mr, Harin Raval: Who is the senior most officer in-charge, Security, because he will have to report to the Supreme Court Mr, Himanshu, The Court Registiar, He played a very very Faculty Member: 1 told him tas guy has beaten, please stop him, [DOP, New Delhi, enters the scene accompanied by DCP, Security, Supreme Cour.) Mr. Kapil Sibal: Jab inhonay aapto bataya Ki woh banda Lychan aqya, maa rahe hain to aapne unko arrest kyo nahi kiya? (when he told you tha person had come here and ws why did you arrest him? Mr, Jatin Narwal, (Ina stammering voice) 1 immediately POP, New Delhi; rushed, I dino know by that time that they were attackers. Ms. Dushyant How did you allow -he attack?Dave: Mr. Dave: Dushyant Dushyant Dushyant Mr. Jatin Narwal, ¥ Dop, New Delhi: Mr Dushyant Dave: Mr. Jatin Narwal, DoP, New Delhi: Mr. Dushyant Dave: Ms. Jain Narwal, DoP, New Delhi: Mr Daves Dushyant ‘Mr. Kapil Sibal Ms. Himanshu, Paculty Member: Mr. Kapil Sibal Mr, Jatin Nazwal, (toterruptions How did you allow the attack? (Asking everyoneto be quite) Ek minutel How do you alloy the attack to take place in court premises? The attack has not taken place. What happened sounds ‘Your men are posted everywhere? (Our men are posted So what were they doing, sleeping? Hamara arrangement tha aur in Jock isko aru zayada, (we had arrangement and in feta ot ‘Arrangement kya tha, Ke mame dein? (what ki rangement. Tht et him be beaten) ‘What is your arrangement, Sit? Band nahi tha, coat nahi tha! (Were was no band. no coat Striped dress not black! Isko ane kyon diya? (why did vou let bisa With escort party he came,|: DCP, New Deli: Mr. Kapil Sibel! Unidentified Voice: Mr. Kapil Sib: Mr, Jatin Narwal, DCP, New Delhi Unidentified Voice: Mr. Jatin Narwal, DOP, New Deli Mr. Kapil Siba: Me. Harin Raval Me. Jatin, Narwal, DCP, New Dei ‘Mr. Harin Rava Mr. Jatin Narwal, Dep, New Dethi Mr, Dushyant Dave: Mr. Jatin Narwal, cP, New Delhi: Me. Kapil Siba: Which escort party? How do you allow someone to come? Onder only says § of the lawyers and 6 of, those people How did they come? “They entered that room. (Pointing outside the oor) How could he come, how did he enter? He was coming fom the Gate No. 5. How did you know that he was coming from Gate No.5? How did you that he was coming with an escort party and wno authorised that escort? ‘Which escort? Nabi, Si, You yourself saié that’ he came with an escort sir, Was he on your tis? No. No, Sir. How did he come then? re TaeMr. Dushyant Dave Ms. Jatin, Narwal, cP, New Deli YMe.— Dushyant Dave: Me. Jatin Narwal, DCP, New Dei Mr. Dushyant Dave: Mr. Jatin Narwal, DCP, New Dei Mr. Dushyant Dave ‘Me. Kapil Sibal Mr, Dushyant Dave: Mr, Himanshu, Faculty Member Mr, Jatin Narwal, Dep, New Delhi Mr. Dushyant Dave: Me. Jatin Narwal, DCP, New Dethi How ald he get in? ‘There were diferent oicers from What ig his name? Have you now arrested hima or i you allow him to run away? No, no, we wil identify and then arrest him, Sir What do you mean “Identify"? How can he 0 away from court premises? Nahi, Sir, nab, sir. We did not know that he What do you mean, you don't know? What fare your men doing? Your men_have instructions not tointervene? ‘When he pointed oat, why did you not arrest him? It is_a shame, Didyou not know of Supreme Court order? Just @ minute, Did you not know of Supreme Court order? He had a copy of the order, ‘That is why we ha made the arrangements No, Sir, you are deiberately doing it, We wil ‘ask for suspension ofall these offices. No, Sir, nothing deliberately, We had made ‘our arrangements but since the escort partyMs. Dushyant Dave Mr. Kapil Sibal: Mr, Jatin Warwal, Dep, New Delhi Me. Kapil Sibal Ms Dushyant Dave Mr. Jatin Narwal, DCP, New Delhi Mr. Dushyant Dave ‘Mr. Kapil Sibal Mr. Jatin Narwal, Dep, New Dethi Me, Jatin Narwal, DCP, New Delhi: Mr, Kapil Sabi: Mr. Dushyant Daves, was from other District Who is the No. 2? Who are the officers? Give us he names, Give the names ofa the officers When he tld yu. was not there ‘Then who was there? Mr, Meena washere or not? Tell me. ‘The officers from South District. ‘They are all notin Bulao unko, seb ko bulao (call them, cal Sir, please mer baat suniyeh (listen to me) ‘The moment I got to know that these tio persons oun The two persons were siting inside were the attackers, I ran to arrest them. Sir please mer! baat suniye listen to me) ‘Bulao unko, Jo yahan jiski yahan duty thi lunko yahan bulao, (cll them, Whosoever was on duty ere call them) How did you allow them to go out. Aap dahar kaise jane diye is assault ke baad. Ander ana to Samajh sakte hai bahar kaise Ea HyMr, Kapil Sib: Ms, Dushyant Dave: (SHO steps in| Mr, Dushyant Dave: SHO Me. Kapil Sibal Mz, Dushyant Dave SHO Mr, Kapil Sibal HO Me, Rajiv Dhawan SHO Mr. Rajiv Dhawan gaye. (how could vou let him go out afer ‘assault, We can understand him getting in, Duthow did he A ski duty thi usho bulao. (whosoever was on tut call them ‘sabke naam dijiyeh give every bodies name) ‘Who isthe SHO hese? SHO kan hai is area ka? ‘Kya naam ha aap ka? what is your nase?) Sushil Kumar. ‘Aap yahan the? (were you hee? ‘Aapko Supreme Cowt ka order pata tha? were you aware ofthe supreme court order) ar wens ‘Aapme uss aadmi ko aane kaise diya anciar? thow did vow allo that man to enter?) ahi mujhe nabi pata is aadmi ke baare ‘main baat kar rahe hain. (don't know which ‘perann js being sooken about) ‘Aap kabse hain yahan per? (since when were you here? us baje se. (since 10:00 am Dus baje se andar hain idhar? (you were ide since 10:00 amMs. Dushyant Who was the Additional Commissioner who Dave was present her? Mr, Rajiv Dhawan Andar the He was present here from 10 o! clock. Andar the aap idhar present the koi ‘andar gaya wo aap kitist mein nahi tha, (yo ‘were present inside and stil someone whose ‘ame was not inthe list could enter? Ms, Dushyant. Was Mr. Meena athe court premises? Dave |Another police afer steps in Mr, Kapil Sibel: Aap the yahon (vere vou here Police Offer: Haan (ys si) Me. Kapil si Phir woh andar kaise aaye? (how could he come in then?) Police Officer: Hamein nahi paia sir hum to accused ke saath the. Woh bot rake hain hum lawyer hain inke saath. (_dont know sir, Las with scone He was lin as ® Jaxer wth hem) Me. Ray Dhawan Aap acased ke sath the? Uti pla! kaise hui agar aap accused ke saath the? (you wer ie accused? How could he get beaten up ifvou wace with him} Police Ofcer: Woh Bole mein luyer hoon inka, (he said ' that e Mr, Dushyant Nah, toh pita kar sokta hai (no, but then be Dave an beat up}Mr. Kopi Sibal Police Onicer Mr. Kapil sibal Police officer Mr, Kapil Sibal Unidentified voice: Price Otice Mr, Rav Daan Mr Havin Rawal Mr Dushyant Dave Police Officer Mr Dushyant Dave Police Ofcer Me. Kapil Sibal Phir usne maara When be beat bit ‘Nahi nahi kisi re nahi mada. (no-no, no one aseaulte| Usne maara ino ki nahi? (Aid he beat him or nol) Yeh mujhe nahi pata. (his, | don't know) Aachha aapko pata nahi (oh! So vou don't kaon) Tok aap kaon the (so where were vou?) ‘Mein andar he tha, Andar Sir. (Lwas inside, ‘Apne deka nal you didn't see®) ‘Accused ke saath kaw tha? (who was with the accused?) ‘Aapka kya naam ha? (what is your nazne?) Virender Jain Aapki postion kya haP (what is your position/designatin?) ‘Mein SHO hoon, Se, Vasant Kuni, South (f ‘am SHO sir, Vasant Kun, South) visko (nko) andar ane diya ioho kau Offcers hain. Unko bulao na. Jisne andar wane diya who awn officers. hatin nko ‘andar balao. Unka naam bataeyeh who areMr. Rajiv Diawan Me. Kapil Sibal Mr. Rajiv Dhawen Mr Dushyant Dave YM. Kapil sibal Mr. Kapil sibal Mr. Dushyant Dave Mr, Rajiv Dhawan (Mr. Jatin Narwal, DCP, Ney Delhi: (Me. Kapil Sibal Ms. Jatin Narwal, DCP, New Delhi Mr. Kapil Sibal: ue oflicers who let him inside, Call them 32 ate the officers who let him inside. Call ‘hem. Please give us their ‘Sabka naam betaeyeh. (digclose every ones same) Aur accused ko faun leh ke aaye? (and who brought the aceused?) Dekhiye humko Supreme Court ko report ‘arma hai toh aap bulacyeh please. (ce we 1o report i to the Supreme Cour please call them We are fastening responsibilty on all police officers who were here. ‘We must get the names of those fellows, ‘aun the woh offer jo yahan the? (who were ‘the oicers who were here?) Where did the assault tae place? Inside! Assault didn't take place here, si. Inside ‘nahi hua Sir. Kahan husa phi? (ure di it happen then?) ‘Raaste mein kahin hua hai, Si. (happened Somewhere on the fos, sit Arey raaste mein nahi hua yaar. (it didn’, ‘happen on the road)Me. Rajiv Dhawan Reastepeh bh Tua (also happened on the sad) Mr, Himanshu, You call the tree people, the Registrar Faculty Member General and others and 1 was pointing to ' ‘her, Kanhaiya nas pointing out to that guy chat guy siting inthe corer. Unidentifed voice: Kahan pe hua? (where did it happen?) Ms, Himanshu, Yahan pe. Aandar mein. (here, inside) Faculty Member Mr, Harin Raval: Agpke hisab se andar hua assaul? (as pee you, the assault happened inside?) Me. Himanshu, Uss kamre mein, fin that room) Faculty Member Mr, Rajiv Dhawan Lets call Kanhaiya Unidentified voice: Kanhaiya agra statement —dljyeh (Kanhaiva give your statem [sine Kanhaija was hurt he as notable io stand up and apes Tete, he was asked tobe ected on the chai and ge is stone ; | ni Kail Sibel & Aap cinta mat tar sa kh bat. nt nie Doshyent wom. naate etna) Dave to Kanhaiya sumer Kanbaiya Kumar Si Pole mij by hark ange. Toh sabse , poh gate poh thar ea rai thi dontMr. Kapil Sibal Kanhaiya Kumar Ionow the gate nunber. Gate ke pans media walon ne gher liga. Paice ne unse jhe achateh hye jyun hi gate ke andar teh arke aaee, Uske baad ek mob ne vakil ke apde pehan rakhey the, Unho ne mere par attack kiya, Is dovan gira diya sir the police got me here. First ofall was brought from the gate this way. I don know te number. media _peosle scarrounded me near the gate. N di the police escort me out of the media, and ide the gate, a mob, dressed in advocates atlce attacked me, Asa result [fell down) Gate se kine andar the? (how far inside the te were vou? ‘Bus ghuse hi the, Aise lag raha tha ki jaise woh is taiyaari mein bathe the attack karme ki Kyonki jo tog peet rahe the na unmein se uch log aur logos ko bula rahe the. Yaogaya aagaya is tarkey se. Aur pure raste mein ‘kabhi gadian gir gayee kabhi mein gad par ‘ir gaya. Jahanse hum jab court entry karte hai woh machine hota hai uske doran jab rmuje dhakka det kar andar kya jar aha tha ‘mera pant kil gaya, Uske baad meri Tshirt, chapel Kul gaye. Mere paer mein injury hu, ‘mere pact mein lane ghuse se. Ek aadmi se choot raha than doosra aadimi peet raha ha jad just entered, It as if ther we waiting with full preparation to attack since fom amongst the people who were b sme, some were ealing out others by shoutin he he has come’, On theMr. Dushyant Dave Mr, Kapil Sibal- Kanhaiya Kumar ~ Mr, Kapil Sibal~ Kanhaiya Kumer~ Mr, Kapil Sibal- Ms. Jatin Narwal, DCP, New Dethi Mr. Kapil Sibal~ simes motor bikes sometimes | was falling on it i the court premiss near the X-ray machine, twas pushed insie it in such @ manner that ‘my_pants came down, Thereafter, my t-shirt and sandals also came out._My leg was injured and { vas kicked and punched in my abdomen. As som as | managed to rescue ‘myself from the clutches of one person, another person would start be Kitni Police aaphe saath the us wag? (how ‘many police were with you at that time?) Kaun policewala tha agpke saath? Aap pehchante ho? (who were the police officers svith sou? Can vou recognise them?) ‘Mere saath jo palcewate the unki Bhi peetai I (the policemen with me also got beaten ua) Unkd bhi poeta hui? (hey were also beaten} Hoan (yes) si Phir bachayja kisre? (who saved you then?) Sir blade mara hai poicewala ko. Piche mein Jo fai South Distt se jo hai escort kar raha tha (a piiceman has been attacked swith blade, Theone in the rear, from South District who was escorting. TToh phir wahan police kya kar rahi thi agar ‘police wala Dhi maar kha raha that of Them. what were the police doing if policemen were being beaten up?)Mr, Dushyant Dave Mr. Havin Raval ~ ‘eanhaiya Kumar ~ Rajiv Dhawan — Kanbaiya Kumar ~ Me. Kapil Sibal ~ Kanhaiya Kumar Mr. Kapil Sibal~ Mr, Harin Raval = Kanhaiya Kumar ~ Lath charge kyon sahi kiya. Agpki simedari nahi hal protect kama. (why didn't you resort to Iathicharge? Wasn't it_your duty to protect?) Police ko bhi blade agaye aise aap bol. (you said that the polize was also attacked by blade) Wohjo police hai nao mujhe escort kar rahey the unki bhi pest hut. (the police who was ‘escorting me got beaten up) ‘ur joh record kar rahe the? Koi record kar raha tha yeh? (what about the ones sesording? Was there anyone recording this?) ‘Nahi No) sir. toh baki wakan aur policewale thi the wahan tus samay? (were there other policemen also neesent at that ime) Policemen the, Sek mob tha (there was mob sis ‘Mob tha saath met policemen bhi toh the? there was a me there were policemen also?) ‘Aas paas policemen toh the woh kya kar rahe ‘the? (there were policemen around, what were they doing?) Woh tok mein kuch nahi dekh paa raha tha sir. Mujhe toh gra diya tha. (he gestures that hhe bad fallen facesiown), Mujhe peet rahe the laatse ghusay se Pit mein, chest mein. couldn’ see anything sit, Lwas Wing in the‘was teing beaten up with kc id punches on my stomaéh and e Mr. Kapil Sibal- That means thatthe police was around there and they did nothing Mr. Kapil Sibal t Now 1 want you t find out who those ffcers fare who were peted there and give us the ‘Mr, Jatin Narwal, = aa ss DeP, New Deni MES Mr’ Dushyant And, frst and foremost, Dave~ Mr. Rajiv Dhawan Aandar kya fuya uske baad? (what : ‘happened inside efter that?) Kanhaiya Kumar Uske baad jo haina gate tak ghus gaye hat Uske baad ustiein se ek aadmi jo hai wok chase karte hue yeh saamne wale kamrey etn ghus jata hai, (Kanhaiya pointed to a room outside) aur pichhe jaa karke bah jaa hai. Main jo hai ehta’ hoon, jo hamare teacher hain, sir, woh adi mujhe peet raha ‘tha. Phir jo hai police fo hai us aadmi ko poochti hai “cap kaun hai. ‘Tok reply mein wor hehta hai, “tum awn ho apna heard dikhao’. Is tarke se poochta hat, pir, kuch thee, mujhe baad nein pata chala Supreme Court ke officers the, (after that managed to get inside the gate aller one of them chased me_an¢ managed to get inside the adjoining room went bshind 1 told jt this man was beating me, Thereafter Pes rae ts eam aaa EREMr, Rajiv Dhawan Kinhaiya Kumar (ndds in agreement] ~ Mr. Kapil Sibal Kenhaiya Kumar— Mr, Kapil Sibal~ Mr, Harin Raval ~ Kanhaiya Kumar ~ the police inquires about the identity of that ‘person, However be replies questioning the e officers ag to who they are and asks for ther i.cards, This is how he asks, then there ‘whom 1 got to know later were Supreme Court Officers High Court ke oficer unko kehne ke baad woh jata hai. Police ko {o woh kuch nahimanta aur police ke saamne ‘se woh aadimt rikal gaya. (after apprising nem, he leaves. He didn’ give a damn about the police and w right in front them) Police ne kuchh nahi kiya? (police didn’ do any thing?) -Kuchh bhi nahi, Saarne se nikal gaya biti Usko wahein pe pakda jaa sakta tha. Meiney kaha ki sir yeh radi mujhe peet raha hai. 1s aad ke upar mujhe complaint kara hai labsolutely nothing. He managed his exit ight in front of them. He could have been ed rit there. I told them that sir this wan_was beating me, [want to fle ‘complaint against him) ‘Aapko maloom hai ke kis policeman ne aapio aha tha. (gan you recollect which police joer itt02 ‘Aap pehchan sokte ho? (can you recognise hing) Haan pebchan:sakte hain. tyes sir, 1 can i emMe. Kapil Sibal ~ Kanbaiya Kumar ~ Mr, Harin Rawal — Someone says ~ ‘Kanaiya Kumar ~ ' Me. Dave - Dushyant recognise] ‘Kaun hai woh? (whp was i) amare joh vatil aayi hai na Vrinda unho ay poocha hai k aapka nameplate kahan rai aap isko eseut kar rahe hain. Mera haath wok pakde huae the. Woh bole hi hakkamukki ke Cauran mera nameplate gir ‘gaya, Unko bhi mein ne kaha hat is aad ko ppakdein. (my advocate Vrinda asked him where his ‘name plate was shor he was accompanvin ‘me, He was holding my hand. He said that his nameplate must_bave fallen of in th sculle. 1 had ali» told him to arrest this man) ‘That SHO did not ave a nameplate No he isthe over guy: meine nko kaha ki i aadmi key Wilaf complaint kara Fal mujhe. Yeh mujhe peet raha tha. I can identify, kyonki, woh pela ‘aadmi thaa naa je gate ke pas mujhe atack ‘kiya tha. Meinay usko deka tha, (told bisa that 1 want to file complaint against this sas eating me up. can identi as ‘he was the first person to beat me up m the gate, [have sen him) See his safety is your responsibility. If a single hand is now on him we will move for your suspension straight away. Lets be very clear Mr. Do rot give excuses. This is unbelievable! “Right in the heart of DelhiYou are now under Supreme Court's orders Not Commissioner Bassi's orders. Lets be very lear about it {While Mr. Dave was speaking as aforementioned, Mr. Kanhaiya ‘Kumar was simultaneously stating a follows} Ms. Kanhalya Baki joh og they woh is tartkay se peet rahe Kumar + the na jaise ek andi se choot raha hai na {oh samney se aakar koi lat mar raha hai Wohh jor baar wae, samaney se, pait mein. Iske saath saath woh bol rahe hain, galiyan de rahe hain theek a (the_manner in which these people were ‘esting me up was such that no sooner did ‘one guy Jeave me, that another guy would ‘come from the fent and Kick me. Alongwith eatin hurling abuses at me. Mr. Kapil Sibal- Tok yeh dus Rhade huay hein apna? (so they wore just standing by themselves?) Kanhaiya Kumar- Meine detail mein saaf saaf mention kar diya hai t have mentioned everything in etal). 1 don't know they are lawyer or not but what they are saying, 1 think they are highly politically motivated persons. Mr. Rajiv Dhawan uske baad kya hua? (what happened after S that?) Kanhaiya Kumar~ uske baad idhar aagaye. Phir jo hai mayhe bithaya gaya, me lawyer aayee, mere saath mere professor saab the. Uskey. baadMe. Kapil Sibal ~ Kanhaiya Kumar Mr. Kapil Sibal ~ Kanbaiva Kumar ~ ‘unhonay thoda pani playa uskey baad hum Daith key theda shaant Fuge, Phir meri lawyer ne poocha “iski chappal kahan hai? Ike hapdey kaise phatay>* (we came hereafter that. Then Iwas made to sit. My lawyer cane. My professor was there with me. They gave me rink ‘Thereafter | sat and pacified myselt Then my Jawwer asked, “where are his sandals? How did is clothes tear?") tis shocking Phir police se java manga gaya ki kaise court premises rein aapke rehte hae yeh pitt raha hai? Uske baad mein aya hoon, meine Judge sach ko kaha hai. (When_the asked as to how dé i presence in the caurt premises, Iwas beated. ‘Theneafier, [came [told the jue) Toh Judge sahib ne kuch’ nahi Kiya? (id the judge do anything thereafter?) Judge sabi ko meine yahi kaha Ki sir mein Liab pehli boar aapki court mein aaya tha, ‘mere saath chaar log the. Kot attack nahi pu tha. Normally mein produce hu. tha ‘Aur poora narrate kiya tha incident. Meine kaha tha Judge sahib ko ki sir mere paas us din koi lawyer nati tha, aap yaad Kiye woh din meine us din bhi Kaha tha, ki mein is desh ka naurjawan hoon. (at this point Kanhaiya breaks down and starts erying) Mein JIU mein pata karta hoon. (this is wh judge, that sir when.first came to vour court, there were only 4 persons. Nobody had attacked, 1_was normally rated the entice incident. 1 judge that day thet 1 no lawyer, please recollect had also told the ju ‘a vound citizen ofthis country lat his point a bres down 1 crying), | study in JNU) [Mr, Kapil Sibal and others try pacifying him] Kanhaiya Kumar- Mujhe yeh bol hurke ki yeh deshatohi hat ‘media mera tril ar rah ha, aur poor media rahi kar rahi hoi (by portraying me as a traitor, media is conducting my trial, not the media Mr. Dushyant Beta don't worry about that uss ko ehodiye . Dave and others- aaj ke baray mein bataeyeh Judge Sahib ne ‘kya kiya, (son, dont worry about tha that, Tell us about today. What did the 02) Kanhaiya Kumar - Ustke baad aaj meine kaha Judge sai se ki sir dekhiyeh yeh tna highlight ho chu hai i aaj mein aapko pele di kaha tha ii f fave fall faith in my indian Constitution. | (afir that {told the judge that see sir this {issue has been highlighted so much and that ‘nad told you on she first day that have full {ith in the constitution) Mr. Kapil Sibal Wohh theek hai yeh atao ki Judge Sahib ne | gpdotiere- fy ae hit nah, Pls tl up whatthe judge said) Kanhoiya Kumar- Judge Sahib. ne kaha ki” theele hat hum dokhtey hain Meri Lawyer ne kaka ki iska ‘medical examination hoga. Judge Sahib ne yeh kaha bi aap bahar fey jayeingay to phir attack ho sakta hat, Unonay yeh reply kiya. ‘Tok mein yatin se jo hat dispensary se iska tlagj karatah hoon. Humney kaha bi Sr, aap note iiyeh Ki mein deshat mein hoon, mein arr hu bon, (he judge said that he will see. My lawyer examination. The judge said that if vou take him outside, there is a possibilty that he ‘may be attacked once again. This was bis wil got him tated here Srom the dispensary ons. told the iudge that sic lease note tat Lam terrovised/scandalised and Lam in astateof feet) [One Advocate sid we requested the court take all hese facts fon record, He was litle reluctant, so we said he (Kanhaiya Xuma) will make a statement, which what be was writing just row da that wll come on record Mr. Rey Dhawan. Aacha uske bead eourt mein attack huc? (was : ‘here an atack in the court thereat Kanhaiya Kumar 1s room men nahi (not_io_tis_room) (indicating thit there was no attack in the oom he was siting at presen). Us room (other room (pointing tothe room outside. Mr, Rafiv Dhawan Uss room ka batco (ell us about the other : rom)Kanhalya Kumar- They ted. Wohk aadimi ne kiya koshish. ‘Mere saath mere Sir the. that man attempted 0. My sir was vith me, Mr. Rajiv Dhawan Aur jo chashmey wale the? (what about the : cone withthe gasses?) Kanhaiya Kumar— Wahi aadmi uss room mein ghusa hat. Aur ‘woh aacini bait karkey plan mein tha ki mere saath kuch zarvor kata kyonki jis tarah se y Jaan leon hala hua hai aur woh mere saath Ji tarak se ghusa hai ...[he is the same ‘man who entered the room. He was sitting and planning to definitely do somethi me ‘manner ip which [ was altacked and che manner in_which_he centered with me..) Mr. Kapil Sabil- Iss ka matlab bahar koi arrangement nahi tha, gate par ioi arrangement nahi tha, ‘andar koi arrangement nahi tha. Yahiiss se ‘sabit hota hoi, his means there was _no arrangement either outside, near th ‘nor inside. This is what gets proved by i Ms. Vrinda Grover He was allowed te cote in, Mr. Dushyant What time was that? Dave Ms. Vrinda Grover ‘This has happened between 2.90 and Har. Dushyant So after Suprem> Court's order. Was it Dave- ‘communicated to lice? Ms, Vrinda Grover Yes, Sir it was. Thave myself given copes of ORE eTMr. Dushyant Dave - Ms, Vrinda Grover Mr Dushyant Dave~ Mi, Kapil Sibal (Ms. Vrinda Grover to Mr, Himanshu Faculty Member; (Ms. Vrinda Grover Mr. Kapil Sibal ~ Ms, Vrinda Grover the order, That's important ‘We were frsked. How did that man come in? ‘That's very serious, They knew about the Supreme Court order: Lets go out, Show us the place the fellow cane in rom, Aap bata dein because you were present. [Everyone moved out of the room they were {in and walked out and stood in the earidor) | made repeated appeals for security, They did not put security here, 1 repeatedly expressed apprehensions and they Kept saying “haan, haon, haan” and not listening to me, This kine of security has come in ‘ow, when you people have arrived. (pointing to the large number of policemen standing there} Please tll us where was he? Aap bataeyek ea (vou tellus please) (pointing towards « door) he was brought in from here, sr. This was not the bandobast. 1 requested for bandobest, they would not listen. He was brought in fom here, we mere sitting in that room (pointing to the room ‘rom where she had just come out) and the Registrar General and the Judge in-charge oawere present [vote inaudible as Ms. Vrinda and others wall iato the court room) Ms, Vrinda Grover That man has ht him here. These people : ‘know him (pointing towards some advocetes and court staf) [Persons indicated, including the Registrar General ofthe Hon'ble High Coust of Delhi, say that yahan par hit nahi kiya, 12-13 log the policewale, Yahan par kuch nahi hua hamare samane, Bk caadmi daadi thi uski yahan pe ake... (no hitting tol place here, 12 = 19 policemen were bere, Not warded man came here and, Unidentified voice Kaun tha wot? (who was itt) Registrar General We do not know. Mr. Dushyant. Nobody checked? Dave Me. Himanshu was standing next to you. All of you three were here. Tint guy came from here (pointing to the door), Kanbaiya was brought to sit here (pointing to the chair ‘That guy who bit im was sitting there Registrar General We have not see1 hitting him. Lekin hurt ey yeh kaha yok Kaun hai, bhagao isse akan se (out ve did question who he was and asked him tobe sent away) Mr. Himanshu Woh chair tak pahooncha kaise? (How did he reach near the chair?) I said that arrest hin Me. Dushyant Aap ko Supreme Court ka order pata ar? (areDave to the you auare of tie Supreme Court's Order) Registrar General How did you allow him to conte im? Mr. Himanshu Maine aqpko bola arrest kame (tld you ta Registrar General Humne toh abeady directions de diye (we had already given ditections) DCP was here. Mr. Dushyant Woh andar kaise aaya (how could he get Dave inside Registrar General Si, ab yeh toh poicewalon ka Woh toh upar terrace ye bhi chaley gaye the. (st, this is palcem had infact climbed ‘upon the terrace as well) (indistinct voice as too many people speaking atthe same time) Someone asks the Ek baat batao jab Supreme Court ne clear kar Registrar General di ki 6 vakil aqyenge, S wohh aayenge toh woh aad andar kaise aaye. (tell us one ‘thing, i the Supreme Court had clarified that ‘Sadvocates will come, 5 of theirs (meaning joumalists| would come, then how did_9 ‘mmoner go ise) Registrar General- Hlumne sabko destin de di thi, DCP ko hum sab ne (we bad given dizections to everyone, tothe DOP) Mr. Harin Rawal~_ Sir, Thave avery simple question if you were aware of the Supreme Court order, and you found someone who was not looking like on advocate did you try and enquire who he is. Registrar General Sir humne poocha kaun hai, isse pakdo (sir ‘we asked who he was, to catch him)Mr. Kapil Sibal~ Registrar General Mr. Kapil Sibat~ Mr, Kapil iba ~ Registrar General Mr. Kapil Sibat- Registrar General Ye Kapil Sibal ~ Ms, Registrar General Mr, Kapil Sibal Registrar General Mr. Kopi Sibal ~ Registrar Geheral That's not the soint. How did you let him 20? How did yo. let him in and how did you let him out? ‘Si; humne kaha isse action to, isske, kaun hai veh aadmi sit we told to take action ‘gains him) ‘What do you mean by that? When a person is not entitled tc be here he should not be allowed go, Aapne arrest kyen nahi karaya unko? (why didnt vou get his arrested?) ‘Si, meine kaha DCP ko (Sie tld that DCP) isko Kaha batac, You have said ki histko ‘aha ab batao kis ko kaha, (ell us who you told it to, You heve said ki you have tok Someone, now telus who ito) ‘Sh 1219 officers Hey mainey sabhiko bola (six_12:13 office's ere, everyone) Kaun 12-13, unmet se ek-do ko pebchaniye ‘agp. (which 12-13, pl 0} Yes Bataeyeh kau hat (ll us who itis) DCP was there, Which Dep? ‘Mr, Jatin Nar(Me. Jatin Narwal enters the room and comes in) Mr, Kapil Sibal Wohh kehte hain ki unhonay bola tha ki yeh asks the DCP kaise andar acya isse arrest karo. the is ing e asked vou How that man came in and also asked you to arest him) Mr. Jatin Narwal, Sir arrest ki koi baat hi nahi i thi (sit there pep was no talk of ares) Registrar General Meine kaha nahiss aad ko pakdo, (didn 1 ‘ask you to cateh this guy Mr, Jatih Narwal, Sir unko jo hai enqube kar rahe the, (sr, we pep were inquiring him) Mr. Dushyant Toh aap andar aaye the kamre mein? (go Dave to the Mr. were vou inside the room?) Jatin Narwal, DOP Registrar General He was there (Mr. Kapil Sibal- Haan, Haan, Haan he was there. He told him ke isko pale, He did not do it. Registrar General Sir inke saath 10:12 aur bhi police officer the yahon par. sir there wece 10-12 other police ffcers here slong with him) Mr, Kapil Sibal- You and joh bhi :0-12 officers the yahan par lunke naam chakiye hamein, Unke naam chahiye aur unke designation chahiye (we need your name and the names of the other 10-12 officers who were present along with their designation}. Because we have to go ‘back tothe Suprene Court and report it Mr, Jatin Narwal, Lasked them how did you come here? peMr. Kapil sibal~ Registrar General Mr. Jatin Narwal pep Mr. Dushyant Dave~ Mr, Jatin Narwal, pep- Mr. Kapil Sibel — Mr, Harin Reveal - Mr. Havin Rawal ~ per- Registrar General ‘of High Court ~ (Me. Kapil Sibal ~ No asl! How did he get in. And when they told you ie isko paleo how did he get out? Sir, we have aso glven him (DCP] a copy of the order (voice uncteae) ‘That was the escort party. Sir mein jaise hi nse naam poscha woh kehte hein ki haan bata rake hain (air Ube moment Lasked him his name he told me that he wil tll me! ‘Aapke soath 12-13 kaun they woh batacye Jaam bataeyeh. (who were the 12-19 others ‘with you. Tel their names} Sir, South Distt ki team thi (ie it was the south district team). Get us the names of the South District Teas, And please just one question when the Registrar General says that he asked you to arrest that mar, did you or winy did you not arest bien, ‘The moment [gt to know fran ‘Bu he said you were inside the room, Sir mein inside nahi tha mein udhar gaya tha (sit I was not inside, 1 had gone out) (pointing outside the door [No sir he was inside the room alongwith 10- 12 other police officers ‘Then?pep Nahi, sir, there was a time gap. The moment I got to know thet they were there I ran and ‘chased them. (ate. Sanjay Bhatia, Additional DCF, from the South District ‘Team enters the room) Ms, Dushyant Dave Additional DCP ~ Mr. Me. Kapil Sibal ~ Mr, Jatin, DCP - Mr. Kapil Sibal Registrar General of High Court ~ Ms, Dushyant Dave ‘Addl. DOP ~ ‘Aap South Distrit Team se hain. Agpka aur ‘sabka naam dejyeh (you are from south istrict team, Please give all our names) Sir mein te loonk sab ke naam jaan? (si, can Igo and get everyone's name} Haan, Haan, Please. Sir the moment I got to know that they are the attackers I chased them. [No question of chasing them. How can you say that I was chesing them, ‘Sir ek aadmi ne uss ko pakad bhi rakha tha accused ko taaii woh bhaag na jayeh (someone had held the accused to prevent bhi ffor running) Bk aadmi wahan jaa ke bith gaya (one man went and sat there) (pointing to a chair in the comer of the room) Yeh (Adal, DCP) heh rahe hain hi andar in i team nahi thi (his Addl. DCP is saving that hs team di not came inside Andar tok tum he hi nahi saitey, Sir. Wohh to jo escort party ‘hi woh thi andar. (we cant be inside st. The escort party was isiMr. Dushyant Dave~ pep- Me. Rajiv Dhawan to Registrar General Registrar General Revistrar_ General Mr, Himanshu ~ Mr. Kapil Sibal ~ Registrar General Mr, Harin Rawal to the Registrar General Registrar General Kish thi escort party? Kishi hai escort part? twhose escort party was i?) Si, South District i ‘Aapne jaate nahi dokha na? (you didn’ see him going ou? Meine wahan bathe huay dekha usko (1 saw him sitting ther) [Again indistinct voices} He says they were two but! saw one One in grey suit, one in white suit. Kisine record nai kiya? (no one recorded?) Mobile sabki rakh di andar (every ones mobile was kept inside} as per court order. Sir I am stopping the recording now and at this moment... (rst video ends second video starts and the conversation in between is lost. | apprehend that this phone may not be working so I am sending it right now in presence af allo you, ‘Theeke hai sir¥ 25 of 2016 @ REPORT OF )MMIITTEE APPOINTED VIDE V‘ LORDSHIPS ORDER DATED 17.02.2016. ‘This report hes been fled pursuant toe directions rendered by this Hobe Court inthe above mentioned proceedings, by the Commit, appointed by your Lordships order dated 17.02.2016 ist the Cour premises af Patiala oute Court Complex where secutedHanhaiya Kumar was to be produced cd to report the existing state of ats in respect of which @ mention was made by Shei Prshant Bhushan, Advoste and Ms. India daising, Se Advoste,purmuant 19 the Seformationreeied by them in respect of the proceedings before the Praia House Court ad commenced at 2 PM when scouted Kenia Kumar was produced bere he sid Court 1 be mentioned that ter hearing he abore mentioned mater, an pre vas rendered by this Hon'ble Court inthe morning sesion of 17.02.2016, ony whereof Ie enlossd herewith for rnd reference and masked as Bacio. [At around 2.18 PM an extordicary mension wee made before thi Fombe Court, in site ofthe order passed inthe forenoon, in view of the tensed stution bung un nthe Patil House court complex where a group of lanjers and others were sat to be cesring to violence, threatening secuty of accused Kanalya Kumar aa well az his Counsle ere 5 other Journalists who were permitted under the order ofthis Hon'ble Court pessed {in the forenoon to alten the ald proceedings. Jn lew ofthe sel mentioning this Hon'ble Court deemed i sppropiate 0 depute members ofthe Bar of his one Court to observe the ation ard eeprtt this Court, Accaningly the folowing Adwostes were deputed w proceed to Patil House Court Complce and eeport the factual situation existing there, The members of the Comite re 1, Sh Kap Sil Senor Adoni) 2, Shri (Dr) Ralf Dhavlan (Senior Advccate} 5, Shi it Kumar Sina (Senior Avot] 4, Shri Dusyant Dave (Senior Avoca [5 Shel Harn P. Raval (Senior Advocate 6. Shel ADIN. Rao (Advocate caer leened advocates were presnt in Court, Mr Dushyant Dave was 1, excep Me, Dushyane Dave lltelephonically informed with a request fo resch the Patila Howse Court Complex immediate, [Mer the order wes pasted ty this Honble Court, the Members of Commitee sraghtavay went to the Offee ofthe Deputy Commislner of Police (Supreme Court Compound) Mr, Barada, which is located atthe (round Floor of the Supreme Cour Prenives. Aer wating for sbout 10 minis for le aria, evo telephone calls were made to his personal mobile number 9818994381, frst 9:02 P.M, and again at SS PAL, by Me. Raval ‘Hom his mobile, but could not connect tom, as his phane was engaged. A quest was then made to his staff to convey the message on the wireless ot Aspatch some palize personnel oroquest is presence, sto depute ase ‘eam of ofcers to accompany the member of the Comite tothe Pai House Court Complex for ascertaining acta to rept the mater o thie Hon ble Court Upon ie ara took shout 10 minutes fr the members of Commitee 19 depart tom the premises. It was deemed Bt by the members of the Commitee to proceed to the Palla House Court Complex Ia Pace ‘vehicles on eccount ofthe law and order sitaon as was macatd before thie ose Court at the me when the matr was mentioned The DCP Mr. Bharadwaj slong with his men personally accompanied the members of the Commie an together they proceeded ote Patiala House Courts Complex Wl onthe way, a phone cal was rested rom motile number 9582151000, ‘woe sesied onthe col phone of Mr, Rava at 319 PA The caller ienifed Fimsel tobe a Juno of Ms Venda Grover (earned Couns! ofthe accused find narrated ore the phone tt they were all inside the Court Room which had tobe locked and that they were eng cprehensiveebout personal nry to themaetves. Mr. Raval normed that they were onthe way along with al te team member, and weuld erive shorty athe Patiala House Court Compex Another phone cll was received fom mele number 9717116182, at 315 PM, by br, Raval on his moble. This tine he caller Wenifed himself a the ‘Junior of Ms. Rebecea John (ld Sr. Adveat) and informed that he was present ettbe Patola House Court and narrated thir fear and anxiety on account of the slogtne belng rsted zepatedly by the cromd that had assembled outside It wa infor by Mr Raval tet they were on sway to ‘the Court. Plce shoud hae taken an eal urn to each which they din, ‘On account of severe tafe congestion onthe way tothe Pati House court Complex, t was decided bythe Comittee Members to get down fom the Police vehicles and to wal othe Cor Complex. Accordingly all members cof the Committe along withthe D.C. ant accompanying Police perunnel alighted atthe Northern End ofthe Patil House Court Complex bung‘Tia Marg end started walking in the bacelane of the building, sows teach the Cour premits. ‘While they were walking at 3:21 PAM. another cal was received rom the umber 9582151000, who had eave call Mr, Raval enquiing as to where the menbers ofthe Comite ha rechal, o which Mr. Raval replied that ‘hey were about o enter the Cour. Te all expressed his asiety and fee ia view ofthe situation deseribed by hm as tense. Thereafter two missed calls were also rceed fim Mable Nos: 9532151000 at 3:21 pm and from 717114182 at 8:28 pm respectively om te Raval’s mobile, while they were proendng on fo to the Court as sated abr, ‘The Commitee members entered ine the Court premites and went the Court House Building, nd proceeded tovards Courts No. 110 10, a8 Indicated by an arrow on the signboard. At the entry tothe Court House ‘Building, wes noticed dat the Entry Gate was locked, and police personne sere present ‘Atte Ratrance there were bartcdes at dintance ofS 10 ft behind uber here was largest of ampere shasting slogans. The atmosphere was furcharged and intimidating. The Commitee members entered the Court tnulding and went stright othe Court Room onthe Right Hand Side, where the Langer of eccused, Ms Vida Greer was present with her other colleagues. She was tesfed. On being asked she narrated what had happened, whieh recording format. ‘restated, she narrted the foing: captured on the Phone of Me Haein Rava, x vies ‘that when they (leu the ter of lawyers sepresenting the nocused anya) ached Ptinln Hooke Court the Restrar General is ofcer or feel es the DCP Me. Jatin Warwal were tare, They wee aed to show the Supreme Court order which was shown, Ther I-Cards were demanded, ‘The phones were deposited and according to he only te Iyer who were named fn the onder were permited to atlend the hearing and not even the advocates tho ad fied Vakatngna as the advoeates.on record and who were asked Trove, She frter stated that when they were entering, there was @ tof slogan caling. They fet very itinidated as the stuaton was extemety hone, Accontig to her she sepeately told the pie and the Resta oneal to enmare te aft as there war ast amoephere and she frthes cane repeat request to the plc offcrw reminding them that he safety of the aceuned fx paramount and tht the do mutt be safely escorted to thls whine, She stated that they were in fer. Acording t her the slogeaningcontinued and several persons went to terre from which the Court was ret visible. She brought i to the notee of the Regt General andthe ‘DCP wit the request to remove the couse since thet wa a intimidating * —eavronmest. When the accused was peduced, he was immediately taken to ‘he court room on the other side and ths phones ofthe Counsls were elo taken, They were told to wait inthe Court room opposite to the Court roam Isher the accused as fo be produced. ‘Thi ent cars were checked and ‘ery oer requirement requested by the Regetrar General wa complied wih ‘She then sated thet the accused war subjected to assout end beating According to the cts sated, the accused was manhandled and beaten not ‘only tthe ine of entering the court premises bt alo inside the court rom ‘She sated that while she was in the court so0m on the other sie she sensed something in other cour oom aid rian came out ofthe cout rom here the ssused was produce, wesing uk nd dark dasseand when he | as sed his name bythe poe, the man tok of his lasts and questioned the police as to why he shoud disclose hi ase and he welded passed the pale offers and aobody stopped him. she wondered a to how thin man uid come in and ext ‘hereafter she intedueed the Jawaharlal Nehra University fecly member Mr, Himanshu who stated that fe accused Katha Kumar had Plnted the man inslde the rom a the ene who was bestng and asad on him and the faculy member Mr. Himanshi equeted the thre High Cour, official aswell as plc cers to please sbp hi, and a plese arrest him ae this isthe man who Kanbaiya Kuna was stelle by and yet they allowed the ald ma to go. Me. Venda Grover then stated that he was st beaten up outside. He lst ie sleepers and his eahes were torn in the process of entering inside the Court. However, surpringy these (wo nidented men were alowed to go inde the Court. Aesoring oer those to mn care a and asanuted Kanhalya Kumar and the sini mast poceofers allowed them to gp. According to her the incident tad happened in nt ef er eyes. Ls. Grover axed the Commitee member over hes cts foot DCP Mr ‘tn Sarva and the Reistrar General th High Cour, Mr Raval requested DCP Mr data Nar to and ate is eof the version co as to ecuraaly report to tla Henle court According faculty rember Mr. Himanshs, the Registrar Genial of the High Court who was ‘was aaroited, Then Mr Sib asked the DCP Sh tn Narva as to why he fp SD capac conDCP replied that he did nt know by ha ne that they were the tacks Mr, Dave who had by then decety rated the Court alo asked DCP wheter he llwed the attack to take place in Cour premies. Mr. Dave ala asked a ‘o wheter Mr, Jatin Nareal gsted his poleman and et to what they were Going? According to DCP ir. Jatin Nac there was an errangement. Me Sibel asked the DCP as to why persoa who was not in court unm or not wearing a band was allowed inside the court premives despite the Supreme ‘Court Order He wat net eren wearing the blck se but a gry stipes suit ‘According tothe DCP Shit Jtin Narva, the sid person came with an eco party. Me. AD.N. Rao also asked as to wly the aid person a allowed inelde ‘when the order of this Hon'ble cour aly permed 6 named lawyers and § Journalists to be present. According to 02, the ani peron had come fom ste No, 5. Mr, Raval eked the DCP ae o how had he come with an escort, party and who authored the escort. Then the DCP ani that i ¢ nt an ‘escort party to which Mr. Sal content im that a moment agp esd thatthe sid person came with an escort arty. Dr. Dhawan asked in a o ‘whether the name ofthe sid person was is it. Mr, Dave then asked the DCP as to ow have you arrested Ne oryou Rave allowed hit torn aa Mr Dave asked as o how he was ale to excep to wich the DCP reed that they do not know. Acording to DOP they knew of the Supreme Court order end that is why they made the arangement but the escort party wis from another dlarct According tothe DCP Mr. arwsl, he was aot there lose (this statement later on gets contacted By the Regier Genel ha inthe presence of DCP ad ater sated tat he wan very mach inthe cour vom) ‘According 12 DOP there were oflars (em the South District that ona the esoore party. Ascording tote DCP, the moment he got know ‘ha thee are two persons sting inside the court, he ran to ae them. Me Dave sepeately Kept esking him that how could have they allowed anybody tlee to enter the courtroom. The commitee members were wondering 810 ‘ow they could enter and sf they entered tow could hey lave, without they ‘being arrentd despite security errangemens, Mr. Sibel asked the person to be culled whose duty it was. The SHO of the area was rusted to ome frward, Me, Sushil Kumar (who had ao ameplate om hi wifrm, came forward ex dented himeelf as SHO, Tae Marg Poice Sttlon. Mr Dave asked at to whether he was anare of the Supreme Courts order, to which he replied the aiatie. ir, Sibal asked 4 to how then the sid person was elloned to enter the court room. The ‘Sarin Nagar Police Station SHO was als present there. Nobody could replysto how 2 men entered into the cour rot despite the order of the Supreme Court mbich permite ony the named pons therein to enter, Mr. Dhawan, ‘ad Me Sibel repeatedly ened all the poise personne! oto how the person ‘whose name was not on the tas pe the Supreme Court order could ener te Court oom, ‘The police oficial Mr. Viender Jain who had elf tated to hare ‘accompanied the accused wat ated sto how persons oter than those ‘named in the err ofthe Supreme Court were permite to enter, According 9 ‘Shri Virender dain, the sid person when ale, replied that he was he lawyer of the accused. He was specically asket as to whether the accused wat besien/asonuted by the anid pers who had managed to enter the Court room to which Mr Virender Jain repid that he des not know whether the taldpecron was inside the Court Room, fe was suresing though he wat fn the Court Icom with the accused and yet he could not ascertain whether the couse wes infact beaten up of not. Mr Sal then asked the plc personnel to ell the ofcer who permite the ai persons to ener the Court room, Me Dhawan asked to cll al those ofere who wee presenta the time when the ating took place, Acconing t9 Commitee members unanimously, the responatilty had tobe fastened onal th police pervnnel who were present there aad were aware of the dection of thin Hon'ble Court despite this ‘unauthoiely two persons were Knowingly permite to enter and let asst tae plac inthe Gout Poon an sie the Court press : Me, Sal repeatedly kept asking as to who are the ofcers? Mr Dave asked an to whether the annul had take pace inthe room tha they were Ghandng to which the DCP responded tha“ id nt tke place", meaning the Court om where Weare standing Aczrding to the DCP the ass ok place somewhere on the way. Mr. imam fclty member requested the 1 Oenerl ofthe Commitee members to ecetsn the same from the Regist high Court of Beth. The Commitee menbers asked the facuhy member to confirm whether the astouitdi in foc take place in the Court Roam, which tres replied ta by the Feclty member tet the essault tok pace ise the ‘court Room, ‘the Commitee Members scored the entire statement of Kenkaie kumar, accuse, who came isie the other Court room where the Commitee vmumbers were present. Amongst other tings inthe Tongs xatement of ‘what i remarkable tnt he stated that he ha eepentaty Kastan Kumar, on wh ad assaulted brought to the attention ofthe personnel tht the pers tin at an earlier occasion was inside the Court Room, despite which no actionas taken ether by the Police a the egies General, According to him he hd alo bought the facts tothe nots a the Le Magica as regards the assault Kanha Kuma locked intimated, tee, injured and oul not ‘¥en standup from his char. He narra the entire inient inte owing ‘word, which cane Brey stated under: "That the police brought me to the Cou and Idd not now the gate number from where we entered. Fist he was atcked aa soon as entered ise the premises ofthe Patiala House Court, in which process eren mia persons ere injured, hereafter there was @ mi, wbich asl dress of Advocate, fd which stacked him. Me Sibel askel him opto when was he attacked to ‘vhf responded saying while entre nse the Court. According to hie the mob was prepared to attack him. Out af these perons ithe mob, sone persons were cling ater partons to jolt them inthe assault by dnsneiey shouting “He has come" “He has came’. He was ten assed end det wth ly i and ik bows in stomach and oter parts of he ty, When Me, Sibel fond Mr. Dave asked him as to who were the Folitmen with whom he was ‘ccompanied and whether he could dently the asaulte? He replied that even ‘the policemen were being ase and cou not en the ase he was being besten ‘The DCP tied to intervene while Me. Dave nt Mi, Sbal eked him as to whet teas the potce doing and how di uney aot resort to Lathicharge and oter police measures to atop the asaul? Accding to he pole, sme peceon ako inted bade injury ona olceman. Ever accontng to the accuse, Kania Kumar, the palice who had escorted the aid accused were also assaults Mr Sal asked as to whether dere were ote poisnien at the place where he m5 beaten? To which he responded the afimatie. coring to the accused, there was # Mob. He was ase to whether there were policemen © nearby and whet they weee doing? Kanhuve Kumar repli tht there were paltmen but he could not se as a what they were doing ase had fal © the ground on account ofthe repeated fsck Bows ta his bay Mr Sib Asko the DCP as to whether e was listen t tote statements? DCP ha + pore f Mr Sibal asked the DCP to give the names of all those police personel wha ‘were present there. According to the acc they have come ight inside tom 7 the trance gas, and ou af them ene pen from the mob managed ta get Inside the Cour oom, who then came and au behind the accited. Asoring to the scouted he Immediately informed the faculty member, Me Himansh ‘that the person siting Behind was the peron who had sessed ie art, snd he had Wenig hin The poe then asked the asd person as to what v ea ig? To wi esl ero rd he pe olin aosho are they, and asked them 19 show ther 1D Cards, According to the scoured, thee were Supreme Court ofces present ther, which Mr, Dhawan aie tobe the ollers ofthe Delhi High Cour cording tothe accused, ‘he sid persons at afer attacking him in fon of he pice andthe Pl id ating. According to the accused, this person oul ave been arrested there and the, ‘The accused farther sith he told evsone (the police and the Of of ‘he High Cour that tle person hes eased him, Mr. Sibal and Commitee members aed ato wheter he could Sen the Police personnel who were resent therewith him to which he reed inthe alimatv. According jo hi “is lawyer Ua. Grover also one the pole olcer about hls name and his ‘ame pate, o which the ple in unr: without the nameplate cepled thet Arne pushing the same plate must hae fallen down. The acused tld the said police ofcer that eis complinng aud tha he has etd that person to be one of them who had asaulted him while he was brought to the Court He wes te fat person near the gi, an he Sit one who attacked him and thereore the accused hed seen hlm and oul identity him. According t the sccused he as del wih fits and cB, amide constant sloganing fad husing of abuses st hi, M, Sibel eked a o wheter the Paice was a mute spectator? According othe accused, the assallants wee highly plclly rmotateé persons, The accused stated that be wes rough inside the Court. ‘The lawyer, Ms. Grover cate ede and met him, and he was thereat given & ‘gaze of water Ms, Grover then eed the oie oles as to why he had last his slippers and why were his clothes tore, and how could he be attacked in the presence ofthe police? Kany mar tte that he alo explained these ‘hot before the li. Magistrate, The acsute stated that he informed the Hone Jog that when he we let produced bebre him on the esc day, nothing had happened. According t him, he ed ascated th ene incent despite him having no lawyer. He further sated at he was a student of Jabal Near University, and tin of this Coustry and was curently pursuing hit PHD, Ae. Sbal asked a to whether the Howle Judge di anything? Aesording to the accused, the Monte Jge sid that he Would ok into. The were demanded for his medial examination. Acconting to the I Juda, the strong kelhood of aaher accused was taken out ofthe Cou, there ws Unc on the accused, Therefore he was given primary treatment in the Cau ispenaary there e requested the Honble Judge to make snote tht he was funder treat, ear and ntidation, According tothe Ud, Lawyer, the Hone “judge was ite reluctant t take all these facts on retod and therefore the fccuned was penning down these fat inh own handwriting tobe made part ofthe recor, The Honble Judge sad that et the accused make a sateeatfrmen wows ten come on recra. ur unnwan epconcny anna at wo | ‘hethertheener he was attacked ints Court Room? To which the accuse replied, notin the Court, in which the Commitee members had come, but in the other Courtroom, Acoaring tthe accuse, the prtonwhowns nade hed ales penned to do somthing tim. According othe sooued there waa fe teeing sak made on him. According to Mr. Sal, te consequene ofthe evens woul show thet there was neither any aerangeent on the gate, nr inde he Curt Room, Accering to Me. Grover the incest ook pace afer 230 P.M, Mr, Date hed 99 10 whether the Supreme Cour: order was communicate, aad the ‘order was isthe alimatv, stating tha the copies of the order were ge, According to Ms. Grover if hey ere isk, how wa thet othe man wae lowed to ente inside the Court Roos. The Commie members unanimously Supreme Court's oder, how col thie have ever append? | Ma Grover aad Mr. Himanshu, facut member, to nara te eve 8 Ne ms present there, According to Ms. Grove, she made repeated request to the Pie to provide the sect, which the pie did at provide. Aeonting to ter, she repeatedly expremed her appreendon. although the Pace cers leapt saying “yer “yes, but thay di nat ke any steps. Arcading to he the security arrangements snd bandobast wich ws recorded in the video ad ume in only now inside the Court room when the people appointed By the ‘Supreme Cour to witness the event hace and Sind at he ac were sent Ma, Grover showed the ir endothe navy rom where ne eas trough, and said that there was no arrangement when the accused was brought in, despite hee repented requests, He was bought the hallway, and they were siting Inside te Cour room were the accused Was produced, The Reitar General ‘as siting inside the Court Room. (nthe bekground, the slogans shoxting ren againat Mr, Sibel, 8 mersber ofthe Commit re distinc heard in he video recorting. It may te: mentioned chat there was continuous slogan shouting which escalted the suchargng of amosphere, There was a lear attempt to create an atmosphere of far al atinidation, which was witnessed ly the Members ofthe Fac nding Comite, ‘The Ld. Registrar General tefuted to ecknoledge thatthe Accused was hit in bis presence, and that according 10 hit he bod not seen it Though the | Registrar Geral had acknowledge the fst that this person who was ot one of he persons permite bythe Hon'ble Supreme Court we very much present fenide he Court Room, Mr, Hina, Facly member, then narrated that he atic cient took place inthe pesene othe Reiter General According to he Regntar General ea not seen tha: the accused was boing hit by thatas and tht he should be removed anéarested. Mr, Dave asked him at whether the Reiser General was area te Supreme Cour order and to how person not named therein may Ye allowed to enter inside the Court Room, The lf. Registrar General rep that he was aware ofthe ode ofthis Hon'ble Court and according to him, he had aendy gen cicecton to the Pie, Furthermore he had dectd the DCP and a copy of the Onder ofthe Supreme Cour wae ‘The K.Reistrar General was eked, ote how wich person could come ins the rt oon, whieh he aber ft nl he ae pened ho cul ep Me AD Rane th ea eer fe Hae Supreme Court hd nad ny i ye ade jal hy ee emily leh Cor Row olay tes pon tert tr ar ate a ey spe sino te Rept en he Sure Curt ero hin ni pron wo us tng eae, an peso ie he Cnt le Rega Gener ifn sow he pono Ts nih he Rear eet ep tat ‘eight pron wnt he i, esl be ee rap Stl ate te Rego! ahah we ee ih. th Regi ena repel hat he we 12 19 pene, Sta tad hy de tein re ih he, eps ener td ht be i i ctw ht i old te ant, Sa tsk sho ithe Rater ona ne rae tr a Irene tht pleat. pte glo wc an we ahd mate a Reis Gea pnb si ch anderen the pole pl owe par ho. we Dee oe he we cole le of ch of ie ef oe sot mie ete pe pesca ih te re ‘eto he He See ot in te en Mh eet he ra sven to him, ld. Registrar General to ientfy one or tu ofthe twee or thitesn pie perunnel to whom he asked regarding making ofthe acest? According to the Registrar General, the said request was mide to the DCP. He sald that the DCP, Mr, Jatin Nerval was also there. I as then thatthe DCP Me, Nar ed by Mr Sibel as to why he dd not arrest that man, despite the Rejotrer Generel asking him todo eo? The OCP fai reused that he ied by the Registrar General to make tne arrest, to which the gitar Cenerat rterated saying that he did ase the DCP male the art According to Ld, Reger Genera there wee 10 ~ 12 other personel in don tothe DCP wh were al fod oarest the man Mr, Sb asked DCP to ive the names ofall the police persnne ith ther designations, Acording tw DCP, on bring quessaned a to who weretose 12 to 13 pole persons, he ae"A specie question was esked to DCP bye. Rava that when the I. Rego [General aged the DCP 9 ares tht min why and how di he na rest hin? According tothe BCP when he got to low, he ran but Mi, Raval nterapted him that aceording to the Regstrer Geral the DCP was inside the Cure Room, The Li, Registrar General eters thatthe DCP was nade the Court room alongwith his 10~ 12 other policanan. According the DOP there was 3 time gap nd the moment he got to knw of the cient, eran and chased ‘them, Mr, Rar told the Commitee members tht me proced an the base of the version given tous by the La, Reger General, which was unenizausy goed to by the Commit. ‘The ofcer who was from te South Dirt tam was the additonal DCR end vas anked to te the name ofthe plcunen deplyed ini the Court Room, He than said that he wl tale the names and infrm us. He wae Mr Snisy ‘Bhatia. The DCP sid that the mament se eae to know, he chased thet a, Ik inn fact and rather unelevabe, thatthe sid man ns not arested despite ‘the DCP chasing that man in presence alsa many pole peeronne!. Mr hts ssi his team was not there and he could not be inside the court esom, ‘According to Mr. Bhatia, was the escort pty (hie appears to be 8 clear attempt to pats onthe burden to an athe According tthe Registrar General, thre were two people inside the court som, which was confimed bythe ote ffcers of the Hone High Court Aosoring to LA, Reyatear General thet were two men but he hed sen only ene, Acording to faculty member Mr. Himanshu, one was in gre sult and one ‘asin blak sit, At that moment Mr Harin aval stops the receding end eda: to a junior through whatapp message “ince there was an pprehenson that a by then everybody would came to now tht there is & resorting of events happening, dere mght be an etempt to even take the phone or eause any damage to The Fhone was gven to Mr. AD. Rao 80 thatthe word ypresd hat the recording was done by Me. Raval at least the phone which contained rearing colt ely reach this Hon'ble Cour for true tnd accurate reporting ofthe event whieh were captured on ideo. Mr Dave before leaving insteusted the DOP that the any ofthe ecused he notin persons andthe counsels of the excused had tobe personally ensured ly the DCP in terms ofthe Orders pase by this Hon'ble Court Tle was recorded onan another motile phone of Mir Raval sine the erie Phone wat ‘ready handed overt Mr. Rao whe had ayted to leave with the oer ‘That ar guthring all the fact fom Inide the two court rooms, the members ofthe Commitee left to come to the Hone Supreme Court, The TT. a eeninatignton to ltmidate the commie eter un rat an owt ar ar end tzpe. The upbeat mood ef tbe aowd in lagers dens whe tinsScly were shouting slogans and aquest present feoring ‘Gooiphee wes cary wsble The pole tum which bad accord eemmlnce members fom the Hone Supreme Court realized the prey of cer runton and enced the commitee members by forming Securing rine ater an the comes miemibera started walking from the cot wom) venarda the ate ogo the Supreme Court inthe pac ekises. The sald nk re then 9 ocasons by the Ieee of ple officesjeordon was broken on vhs were premnt in the Court Compound dep the presence of other Do Tones prsonnel Tere was conouous slogan rising, shout, hung of cine tough out. Air coming out of the Court busking witha the eat fhe Pala House cos sada how oe Hem ern came, Bren ahggiece of broke Sawer potas aso sow artnet patie mater bulls were lin town The iuimating shows and venntng a alguns cominsed. Tat but forte acuny rng proved bee eee ofthe Supreme Court Secury pale, t would not have Ben posse fer the commice members to cme ouzuascaled. T wes oly on SUN dhe ecu cover povided by DCP Mr. Brava ofthe Supreme COWES the pevonnel accompanying he meres at te cots ERE ld tary enacted om Court premises, Though there wes erg mus of wiper pn! epee eld mt ata ie oe eer ee forge number to intimidate one and al. "Ar committee members ft that the aosphere, 1 sy the teat Hot sein ata congens, was sucha, tenening and gheing and OF ear completly adn it duty 1 ean the atmosphere and (he cso. Dawan ‘biel sarrated the ene at video rearing ofthe ter reaching this Court, Me tncient. Me. Ral apprised thi Honbe Court sre ct ding nig on psoas pone wat made, 1 WAS vo is Hout Cou ha forthe pone hang te wil sppssed oer damage, he had se tren incase of les of pone oon ecru of ae espa nn eal om Pal Hate Cos om el 0 swe ep could be preserved even H he pt wat Ore es Tee eo the de wa terse contaminated ot ampere wh sermon that Ht map on acount of sched eImoners de vr cheaepeeenutions wee dered sppropiats © BE ape clengs of Mr Ral eve ben resus ot 9 pr FD SOP sa ao anpoe. A couplet rest wre ser fem he st ME be poet share the vide clip, Te regent Snidatng situation the ‘val nquting wheter iwere denied, The vdeo clips have recordin the phone snd were transferred fon the office computer by Mr. Raval i his office where fom they were transfered toa newly purchased pe dri of tn dic make, ‘he el video ‘corings have been transfered into 2 spate pen-ries each containing the same recording a are Being presen two seperate seaed cores. ‘The transcript of recording has also been made under personal supervision of olleague of Mr. Rata, The eld transits are also produced for perusal ofthis Honble Court in a separate sled coves, Utmost attempt has been made to se that trensrpts dept the vdeo recordings ee euthaly and'ponible ‘The Commite is beholden to the diction ofthis Hane Court forthe rurpose of proving security through the DCP attaced to Supreme Court ‘Security without whose asltance and els ie mou never have been posible (o reach the premises much lees complete heft dig ng rsted by this Hone Court nor would it hae been posible to come out unsethed in view of this highly surcharge snd intimidating atmosphere created at che Pan Howe Cour Wi4ne pat ‘Shei Kal Stel Se. Advocate) Shi De) Ran Sr Aden) cefeine ‘Shri Ale Kumar Sinha fr. Advoate) Shr Dusjant Dave (SF, Advocate) of Si Hain Pet Se Aaoeste She ADM, Rao Advocate}a Cals Pury mv oh ‘Account of Happening 7.22016 wtnsed by Lawyers tepresstngKanaly Kumar Palla Hou Cours The Hon‘ble Supreme Cout passed a dead order dt, 172206 (oencon) giving exesve derins to ensure and ele fee and it ead procedings inthe Patan Cour athe sa ater a 200 PM. ‘At around 145 PM the undersigned lawyers alongwith Pro Himanshu "were escorted it the Peta Howse Court comple by the pice As we wereetering the cat preies we wineseda huge crow of Iawyers and nonlayers already preset inde the cout, Tey were shouting logan anid were cel stl and ot of conto. Aa agresive trod Had ao already ave ote the cout and was indulging in Sogn shouting We als noted song ple consinget meaning the gts of the cout complexes ls eyo Be court bling ‘We met with the Reiter General, Di High Cour inside the cout building as we poceded tovanls Cou, the desigted cout of St Levelen Ki, Hee ten fo Cour here he pbee ofl and the Cour Ofelasveried our dent tod got ou mele phones surendered ‘Nerve eatin of ou identi, we ere Cou Hal No, 3 which $sight oposite Court Hal a4 Pro Hina was asked stay back with tie Couric ‘With the passage of time fom out Hal 4 we oud ea he slogans geting louder els hard le someton ight the ney he out Gta locted merely 20 fet away fom te sid cout ballon male occasion andthe dors were a feng tang Attia point one of us bro ito the aterton othe Register that ve there large pbs cotnget outside he cour complex ad he our bulge eur nie the ort ling was igh indegut ‘Fao they af co Bui into oog os of the crowd baking the conan ad ening te bung which would fave put he ves fall presen imide te court o gave dang 1 wa ao oie oo by us tat ther armed poe psoael tthe dor ofthe Courtroom na tor Courtroom na 3 ‘Aline, we ne forth wndo fhe court hal hata huge cro bd gathered onthe tac of heaping ulin having ict fw to the sng eine Eur al They were outing sags end ‘Covina Ths wat alo brougit oe atenton ofthe Register Genel TEENS DEP preset here as tea ear ring danger of anhing = TT ee‘that may be thrown though the window despite the irom gills, given the sheer numberof people present all arcund and shuting lou. Therenterve sw Kaas beng ought o Court Room itt of policemen tela presen ouside the ort all Son there ent en average bil man wearing dark seeing Court Room Nore DCP ‘ks fim to dle hen fo which Be we her him eying “yo wil sok me my tet? Why should I tll you ho Tam (Com mulsenerananpoockogeyinaiyustastinoaaun), ser hich be 'sallowed to lene the alway. We cul als ea loud nae coming fom the Cour Room 3a which pine one fut sve but al oom n.d go so Courtroom 0.8 We were mos suprised at he wey a when we jer nou robe, were idee so sticly as pr odes of this Cou, how could @ sang be permite to eter the court ll, math es leave the out hall afer sing the cased in rot of ctf present thre as wel as enor pole pena Knipe was siting shouting hate vas tay Duten a he was brought to the cout ad inside th curt all a3 aswell Kanai as absolutely shocked and wily sla afer what bad happened to Ki He ‘2 hat he was thoroughly roughed on way taths Cour, ands ten repent and even inde the Cour no 3 the sd unertid man bad eaten Rim pin reece of al the ho were presen Court oa. He alo tld ws that such wes te ines of tack tthe castro Police personel accompanying him xn Vasant Kun PS had alo reeves ies in ying to prot Kahaia om he eb. Attire al of the rena ayes wet rom Court o0m 0. 4:to Courtroom no, 3. Ite nla th a auory a gh 8 he Repatar Genstal of Det High Court slang with igh ranking pale ofc wee resent in Cout room no 3 when itident happened. Po, Hinansh, ‘who ites tht happening in Cot ooo 3, lire that the niente person was not guest epte him asking everone ncang he Rita Genel there tats hin en we aw Kanblay, he was at able tt prope and we asked ‘he police cl suzounding him allow sme esha to come He was pa. He ha some injury his al nfo. and he tld us that be was parked in the cst and stoic and shai wee pul He was wiht afoot eaera a ithe vicece inde and outside the Court wom hg ‘eppenet deplete categoria des of tis Henle Come oe (aie and examen ofthe meb oaide seemed to he ono increasing Hind and which point we thought i necessary 0 bg al a nn Stone he Bech baci th mater and regard fora ‘Phones tobe glen backand made anc elle or Mectes ode rent he Proesigs menced and Kishi prayed nate sleet searing the vce dat has happen Cera injures voting Aon BON on which Maga sed im tne rg. A copy ofthe said orders amexad heen rec lends mel agian of Kaj, on whch « Lite was cline the Court or Mes theories, eg Prstdiogs were ove by shot «pm. Ven ake fr our fo i soTered Fl fs sid they ee lng er “enough ti we mato wat faba 3 hous tnt Cou nee Tei t grew dak an there ssl sloganeering hafpeing comes reflzed that the station may once agin go out of eateo ot chee Feit we made calla some ofthe CourConmisiones end eves at rept canbe dne for our sf extn epee the reply of Del Plan "garding not having “enough re” to alow our ae ex serra 8 mae of 1 minus the Pte deny sprang it ata rane e984 S527 pn we wre dropped ot Deh High Cony Deth Poke ruescirase ‘This, nal there was a greathosity and an environment 3 of fear and agizession andthe situation there treughout remained very tense and nat conducive for normal functioning of Iwyers or courts, and notions offre and fle acces a jute against the arch ar = ae Siddharth tare raetateINTHE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA CRIMINAL ORIGINAL JURISDICTION WRIT PETITION (CRL) No.25 of 2016 (Petition under Ace 22 Of The Consttuton of nda) INTHE MATTER OF ND. JAYAPRAKASH Petitioner Versus UNION OF INDIA & ANR. Respondents (* 10 Parlours 1 Tinident Report dated 7322016 of Su AS ———~| Kumar Sina S, Advocate | (Ajit Kurtar Sinha) Sr. Advocate2. 16 We reached Patiaia House cour around 3:10 PM and entered Cour no 4. We were informed that Kanhaiya Kumar was abused, heckled, mantanled while he was brought othe Cour by the Lawyers. n any case we also witnessed slogan shoutng and abusive languages being used about 10 meters avay ‘rom the Cour room Inside Court NO. the acused, thei wpe, some fculy members, Poce Personnel and Cout sts were present In Court No.6 which is adjacent to ‘Court No, the Ld Registrar General fhe High Court and other members {fom the Dei High Court Registy were present | was also informed by the Ld. Regstar General that 1 or 2 persons aso entered unauthorisedly in Court No ané upon being questioned they fed ‘aay inthe melee, However both the La Regletar General andthe Police Personne denied thatthe two unauthorized person entered court no 4 andor rmanhaneled the accused, ‘The team of visting lamers who went onthe diecons of the Hon'ble Supreme Court while returing also recehed verbal abuses and some mud ‘and pieces of broken pot wee als hurled fom a distance. ‘The accused along wit hi lawyers and some facuty members were vating in Court no. for medical examination as te doctor was called. The visting team et round 4:00pm mm ic Son Sr. Advocate Date:19.02.2016 New DelhiRepost of Regsrar General Hon'ble High Court of Delhi 1 6 #6 In the Habe Supreme Cour of rit eto) (Criminal) No). 282016 ND. Japapratash Petiones) Vers noma nia and Ane (Respond!) mint to over dated 17.2016 (reunch) of this Hon'ble Coat in Wet elon) No, 250016 and fering the Hon'ble Ce ate of High Cou of Deli, {eacho Pas House Cours Complex, New Deli st boat 110 ‘PM vite te Chamber f Sh Ana Nath LA Dsus & Sésons oe, Pte House Courts, New Dei Inthe haber of Sh. Amar Nah, Ld Dist & Sessions Judge, Paina House ‘nat with Sh Jin Nawal, DCP, New Delhi aod Sh. Seley 1. Disc. cous, New Dei ‘ht, Add, DCP (Sou), who were eset inthe complex & cal by 8 Sesons Jule only iafored the abou hit of hed f ts Hoe Cut yt ine, Bath ote ft he eet ht 9) oni 06 itn gen by his Hon Cour tha at recived 27 ‘were apis of the drt of his Hon'ble Court 10 ral Advts sal be allved nite he Coat Room: ) and 05 mame est reporters al he allowed ie Be Cut on (tet otk ein nk vc yh nine for ey eb oft eed en 0 stowed nie the Court Room jet 1 triton by the ecu) ot iy mele, obey tember oo NU and oe er tte abence ofthe fo my to be pei from INU, (objet to hi eet By beacuse) 8 inside the Cout Room. Meal at sbost 140 PM, Som out washed overt ey court stall. cop thc wa supe in Nr, DCP, New Debs Sh Sanay Bh, AB, DCP (Sot). uno as deve at 8 ofthe Onder ted (7.022016 of hs Hon’ by mt Keeping in vw the reveling 2 seine produced efi te Cost of Ll MM, Sh. Laven, a Cou Room Nos. slong wih Sh. Amar Nah, Lt Diet & Sess, Pata Hse Cou Ne —eh ant soe air jai terol Sh Bhat Pt, Spel as (CBI Sh. Sot DL. COMM, Ft House Cou and Sb, Amiubh Rava ‘NC, ata Howse Cots sl tin Cort Room Noi. ate eau AD, ‘Sh SS: Rai just opost toh Coxt of Sk Laven, MM, The wom of Le ADH ‘Sh $8 Rt vo al vosed theo) ws ale eve by LA, Ds Season Jue inode to este canine of the ores of his Hone Co ae fers were deste nal emits pesos sie he desis ie the vacant cout no. frien and aso tenets «aut 2 PM, 06 lvyers sl Sh. Sil Bsn SH Seth Shar SH rsa Sane Sh Pb, Sh. anki K Kohno and Ms Vida Gover as snide vcant Cou Root N03 fs veihing ht Meni, Leaps of lem to eave tc motile phones he sd ot ely with te cour sult re ong Cot Ros Nod, Thre ee jo vers eomaning is 0 pn eign abr Hoe Cost uf ae ot Room No, ‘One Sh Hint, Asie Paes, JNU, who cae with seuss HOS Wat pene in acs Coat Roo No, hu ey wos chek WY me |S read tn abut hele of fe Cou he it a inne he femly menbes of anced Kaui Kista (ele thm ol Be emit ated hepsi He td me ut to fay eb of iS pea twas a cue an hn 0 whee ay eat fo IND, we ry nent jon te etings srl at et Hein 9 veo Hove, S, Hina sted hat hgh nun of ses Se ut noe ible enter inside. ‘to the five jounaiss, who wet be emit 10 Be allowed iid He est sey S,Abihe As FT Me nip Kar Kasia ANS: ein Sig AN Mr Suit yes ae ean Ct Room real he juts rat wt alle og 1 Cut Rou Nod a their ent wasted. spn 134 pected SMS my mle an nile 981019568 a8 jr tr nsdn heel 8M Ba Si oe HT ring at How es bt Deli Police is Supe Couns a este ey ett reereg te juni tee Timely bog 1 ent of DCF SE vl al rove ile mar fe depart afer once NS ie ratteto. feed neg tht ef en the es forte. Leet ant resem Ms. Bins Si 0 fit Hat Sh. Srth L (AS Advocate) formed he tallow “reece vaste at oot 250 pb 1010 2 pole oles isa Sh jn Naval DCP New Del an soup inside ews Cout Reo NO, veer tr udesgned ssn akog with Sar Nah La Diss & Sessont jpg Pins Hoe Cuts, New Dein sme aia fess ay Se Bh Fase, Speci ue, CBI, Sk Sot Das, Ld, CMM, Patil Hose Coes and Sp, Amitath Ret, LA. AC, Pin House Cos Teed yale he ace an pried hin oft rd of ts Ho os i egy egg om te acd as my es ho ma wa vad th oes atin hwnd at eon fy ee ve eb [ wanged ishing wu fo tn acised gh tof a rer pret witha in Cont Ro N03 14 he ce at et of dhe Howe Soame Court one ese an ne suet coud lowed it COM se deanenes of fnily mene an! he lo evil Sh nash ote MS teaches stati te ws cnmoton al ieee pro pin cate Sn 9 pot our Ren No et te window: imei hed ie pies OME, sare ar a i eons oe iret nie Cu ocean was ase esd oe ae dle be was rag bao ie cout 11h pli of ing so iaa Nara, DCP New Diet append dares ei Fn vices th was poet in 08 pings ih eB 0 oe yaad he ue he amie, Cvs fr ec) ‘int Gover and Sh Ste! Ba at i secant Cost Ron No.3 fon Crt Rows Not ‘ove, acused tod er ht has en as bie “Terai, Ma, Vind Groves, Abst, een wa pean Cut ana Non pint on AB rare ine alse! fom tan Nara OP New 8 i eso ti ten aed: Howe th DP med a by thee seed ve came Adonis ofthe acised cane ide ‘nein nguied by MB inde idan th tee ws test 1 ied rom Shin Nar, DCP, New! the sid oe ctsie ook forthe iden bomen‘Mat tht ine Ms inde Grover, Avot equ tha sh be provide Ber mobile phone ah nods to info her caleagusin Hote Supreme Cou of Ii. “psconingly, be oie phone was de avaible to hey ad she mae smells tnd again depose ber mile instant wih he sto the sou. Ms. Vins Cove thereat ta steel ofthe assed be recoded an MLC be got repre and eb al provid wil papers enw wit the enti niet hvmdingly, acco Kanal Kom was ade aaa bak poper an ps 9 hah may pt a wing never bbs ost Tn te meatime, hy stated that the wl get te incident rd a judicial poeeings befor Si. Lovle, Ld Mn, Theres, scused is ten 1 Cont Roorn Noo with all he, Defence Coumels and Asointe Profs Sh. Minanshu & judi potetings commenced 0 round 3PM and conte for some te, 1s. Ding tint ine Halong with ote Jul Oct Kept siting in wasnt Court Room No.3 and fr seuity rasan he dor ofthe Cout Room Nod wes ep los At hat tne judicial te undersigned that hee was ont noe eid person posit rant Cour Room No who bide 16. At about 330 PM, afr conesion of he pressings [alongwith rors reeset wns fumed that he Cort of Li MMs emanded he ase ji Cosy 203-2016 and a hry of cused and his couse he one hur hd dicted the metic exointon of te acused to be conde i he out itl as owing tthe lag rove a5 ot esl kee ves ode to the Pata House Court pes fo medal exaittion, Te ole flrs fet sted hat ey wil ang ome dor fm RRL oa Se He “perso Pata House Cours 0 hse. 17. Suu, ea of senior advoctes aml Sh Kel Stal, Sb, Dustast Devs Sh jee Dhawan, Sb Ajit Sau and Sh Ha Raval wb Sh, ADIN, Re ‘Adve for How'le Supreme Cat ni came ina seer cordan and wet staighny toh ou of. MM Sh, Lvl Court Room Nos 1a Shonly bee ava adie el fo nile 97739480 of ie Fesistr Sh, Max Agaval Hoyle High Cour of Det my note ne haa Commiteof cir Lawyers Ben dept bythe Hon'ble Supreme Cou fin ovis, assess and eport the grou suo. to. Aer visting the cancermed Cout Room of Sh Loe, La. MM (Cou Room No.) te en of Sein Advocate ent Cou Roots NOS whe = Se 6a 20. a 2. 2 m4 ntesignd along wih Sb, Amar Nah Li. Disc & Sessions Judge & oboe Sli! Offs wete pest sal ey eure fom us os what adem ad the sme was videngaped by Sh Hain Rava, Sh. Advocate on his mobile hoe. On hie uy 1d thom Hat te acid ad aot een ase in or presen. Ate the id eat of senor voc et the comple, oe dost Dr, Say om ML Hospital was rout by the pie oes or conduting mia exaninion fees Konya Kua. “The metic] examination of cs, as dete by SH Laveen, MIM, was cond othe Court Roo Not th LMM ba ately ered oi hab. ‘ag the couse of meal evan the Ld, Defence Cousets came back 1 cant Court Roo No.3 sal eo offers were asked to ein outside the Court Root, Sometine Int, LA, Defece Counel Ms, Venda Grover an Sb ‘Himanshu came to Court Room Nos. Afer conducting the prosedngs the dsr sited tat as accused Kasi Kumars complaining of pin pees 0 eodsto be conducted which is pase ony lhe ost teas this sage LA Defoe Counsel MS. Veinds Grover cane Room No 3a ‘nfnmed me that the doco sot ecoxing the complete istry of asta is ‘ng nly seus Kanha Kama “To undersigned gael Dr. Sint 10 ecard whee is being sted by arsed anya Kun ut the docr sed ara he bs coe © Patiala Howse Cours Compe for carving out medial exainaton snd he had rsrded exesry ‘afomaton and itany Frist of sts to be recorded then aad soul ‘token fr medi exon at bsp where MLC wl be prepare this i. Coun Ms Vind Grover stat! hat sb wl te eton he si facts the coeered cout of Sh Lol, L4 MM. On bsring commotion, Ld MM cae i the Dasa we left Court No, 4a Ld. MM and came back to aan Court Room, No. The aes yrovedings wee oer by about $10.PM, ‘Nawal, DCP, New Deli nd oer pie oie preset informed ws ta 0 hey a ke aud to Thar Jil ad te way by wil get his Xray conducted, A thats A Defece Counsel fees Kaya Kamar ated tat hey be also provide sear sect long vi St Hans, Assan Prfes, NU lst tiny roy be harmed According, Sh, Jain Nac, DCP, New Deh and St ag tense a whish poit Sh JatinMukesh Kamar Mens, Joint Conmisonec of Police were dicts 12 make necessary angen fr fe ser 28 The axused Kaiya Kara as an tie the Cost Room in my pres and apt inte ear portion of ti eovere galery inde the bulig a sane of about 15" flom the door of the Cout Ronn No.4 and the police oes preset tere ‘aformed one tht hey were Beng howto ens i sa ent lo he Cot ‘Cmple. Thera, cued was ten cut om the Patil Howe Cot Compe st about 7pm an hen win about 10 ints the 14. Defence Cousels ad Sh FHinasbu were als escorted salou of he cout prises as informed by the police offices, 1 the report submited by Lé, MM tote Li Dis & Sesion Jae, Patil Hose ‘cous, New Deli dated 1702.21 6alog wth copy f oder set dt 7.022016 are so eciotedforknd pes of his Hon'ble Coe suite, 22 Dat: 17.02.2016 Vid Goel Regie Genera ' igh Cour of Dei gestDated: 7.022006 fhe Leama istic & Sessions judge, New Sen bie Pata House Court, ew Beh Sw, Report rosarding the proceedings ded 17-02-2016 in FIR No, aan aspected Si, "et humbly submit tha the above eld eater was taken up at ‘s70und 3.00 pm. after having been produced the accused Kanhaiya Kamae r "he court of undersigned. The accused Kanhaja kumar nes represented y al Ssh counsel whese names were mention inthe order pased by Hon'ble Supreme Court of inca tosay se. Authorize! media persone were ato Present there, he investigating agency sought il custody ofthe accused onteiya Kumar for 14 days ster hearog both the sidesthe accused anniya Kum was remanded to jul custody i 02-03.2006. The accused Kanhalye Kumar state in the curt that he was asouted hile Being produced inthe cou ofthe undersigned. Accordingly, at his on ‘eauest.s hand statement of Kanhaja Kumar was taken on recor A eopy of the same a5 supped tothe OCP, New Delhi District for infomation. Ld Counsel or te eccused requested thatthe accused Kanhaye Kumar be got medially examined. Prayer was alowed and necator directions were given Since there were apprehensions about the safety af the accused Kaahaya Kumar, deena were mage to DCP, New Deli Ost to ensure thatthe secused be safely transferred to Js cstoy.Pctengs were concluded, Report is submited please, A copy of eer sheet date 1702-2016 ' ato diner herewith for your kind perusal. | “Thanking you. : i , rs aha, Xe v WOWLEEN) se27eHC, Noo 1022018 ST aa Too SS ee eeFR No, 120716 5 Vasant Ku] North lus izaa20.934 PC Troz2006 “This is an application moved by Inspector Prabhu Dayal seeking 16 doys JC remand of the accuted Kanhaiya Kumar. Present: Sh. vkas Goswami, Ld Substitute AP for State {Inspector Prabhu Bayalin person. Accused Kanhalya Kuma peduces rom polce custody fans represented by lr. Sur Bala, Ay, Pr. Saaharth Srorme, ad, Me Rishabh Sancnes, A, Me, Path, Av, te. Bani, Ad. and Ws. Vrioda Grover, A. Sh.Jtin Narva, DP, New De District I ls present ‘Areply has ben fled by Ito the application moved on behalf of accused Us 91 CKRC. At request of Ld. Counsel for accused, the said application shal be ‘ken up for esposa onthe next date of hearing, In Wee of the averments made In the present pplication, the accused Kanhalya Kumar Is remanded to Juda ‘ustod/ 02-03-2016. -Atthls stage, an applation has been maved by accused Xanhalya Kua seeking protection of hs if and lim. Keeping In view the hostile condtons prevalent ouside te cour room (asi evden rom the sloganeering avalible nde the court room end as also submited by La. Counsel Hs. Vendo Grover, Adv) and the statement giver in wing by the accused today inthe cout (regarding an alleged assaut committed agaist him ust before tis hearing) ts erecta that OCP concerned sal. personally ensure te safety ofthe acused Kanhaiya Kumar tl Ns Lronsportaton to the jall premises. The Jal Superintendent concerned stall also take necessary sts In order to prevent any harm to the lle or person of the accused Kanhalys. Kumar, Compliance report be fled by OCP concamed as well as [all Superintendent cancemed before his ceut on 18-02-2016. Since CotFR Wo. 10/16 Ps vacont Kun Nor us 1244120938 IP 11022016. ‘he accused Kanhaiye Kumar has alleged that he wag assaulted outside the courtroom, Its ected tat accused Kanha Kumee be medically examined before being taken to Thar Jl In view of the apprehension of the inuy t te person of the accused - Karinalya Kumar, fis rected that accused be medially examines ine courtroom Itsel, i Application stands disposed Couns! for accused ts, Vrnds Grover now submis that OC? Jatin Narwal may nat be entrusted wit the task of ans of accuse to jl premises as he has fale to ensure the safety of accused before belng produced inthis court despite the categorical ‘ection of the Howale Apex Court. | have considered the said submision. No other Senlr Police Otel is avainbe in the court room right now, Accorinly, tis rected that OCP Jatin Nawal shall take ll appropriate steps in order 10 comply with the above rections made by his cout. Copy dst to Ld. Counsel fer accused as ato OCP tn Narwal. A copy of the statement made in writing by the accuses Karnalya Kumar today be also supped the OC? Jatin Narwal for information. Copy of this order be also annexed with the custody warrants for compllance by al superintendent concerned de (towesN) MM.a2/PHC, New Det ir02 2016 FT tee eee