DESIGN OF BASE PLATE & ANCHOR BOLT FOR L/6<e<L/2

Grid
As-33
LOAD DATA :-

Node No.

43

LC

Un Factored loads from Support Reactions

Vertical Load

Sum

Py =
Fx =
Fz =
Hz =
Mx =

Resultant Shear
Moment
DESIGN DATA :COLUMN SIZE
BASE PLATE SIZE
Length
Breadth
Thickness
Assume Size of Bolt
Assume Total Nos. of Bolt
Edge Dist. for Bolt
Centre To Centre of Bolt
Projection of Plate From Column
LOAD FACTOR

189

1.00
17.04
-62.37
64.66
45.81

Support Piping
reaction
load
0.00
1 kN
17.04
kN
-62.37
kN
64.658
kN
-45.81
0 kN - m

B1000X600
L=
B=
T=
=

1200
1600
63
50
4
200
800
300

ed =
s=
l' =

D =
mm
mm
mm
mm
Nos.
mm
mm
mm

600

mm

Ref. Figure
Ref. Figure

CONCRETE

M25

Characteristic comp. strength

Permissible stress in bending comp.
Permissible bearing stress 0.25fck
Permissible bond in tension
m -Modulur Ratio
BOLTS:
Permissible Tensile stress

fck =
cbc =
b =
bd =

25
8.5
6.25
0.9

= 280/3cbc

10.98

tf =

120 N/mm

Pt
x

Pv

IS:456-1978 Table 2
IS:456-1978 Table 15
IS:456-1978 cl. 33.4
IS:456-1978 Table 15

IS:800-1984 Table 8.1

DESIGN PARAMETERS :f

N/mm
N/mm
N/mm
N/mm

PC

c
y/3

y
L

f:\5593\dsn\rrk\pr3C\306765537.xls j-23-MX

ed

RRK/ST

03/01/2016

As - Area of Holding down Bolts.

Calculation 3 Unknowns Pt, y, s
From Vertical Equilibrium
0.5 y c B - Pt - Pc = 0.0

Structural Steelwork
Connections by

Moment About Column centroid

G.W.Owens & B.D.Cheal,

pg 170

Pt f +( Pt + Pc ) (L/2 - y/3) -Pc *e =0.0

Plane sections condition

s / Es
c / Ec

L/2 -y+f
y

liminating Pt & c from these equations

Here Pt = s As
y3

+ 3 ( e - L/2) y 2

+ 6 m As (f +e) y

- 6 m As (L/2 +f)(f+e)

B
K1 =

=0

3 ( e - L/2)

K 2 = 6 m As (f +e)
K 3 = - 6 m As (L/2 +f)(f+e)
B
f
=
Net area Bolts for tension

= K2 *(L/2+f)
400 mm

(Ats) =
=

Area of bolts for shear

Eccentricity

e =

K1 =

3.14 x 50/4 x4x 0.8x

3142 mm2

(A ss) =

3.14 x 50/4 x4x 0.8

=
6283 mm2
45814.000 mm
e>b/6
OK
135642.000

k2 =

5978229.060

k3 =

5978229060.3

f(y) = y3+ K1 y2 + K2 y - K3 =0

Solving Cubical Equation by

Differential Method

f1(y) = 3y2+ 2 K1 y + K2
Assume Y =
Y1 =

y - f(y)/f1(y)

188.94 mm
=

188.94

Y2 = y1 - f(y1)/f1(y1) =

188.94

f:\5593\dsn\rrk\pr3C\306765537.xls j-23-MX

RRK/ST

03/01/2016

Y3 = y2 - f(y2)/f1(y2) =

188.94

Y4 = y3 - f(y3)/f1(y3) =

188.94

Y5 = y4 - f(y4)/f1(y4) =

188.94

Y6 = y5 - f(y5)/f1(y5) =

188.94

Y7 = y6 - f(y6)/f1(y6) =

188.94

x = D/2 -y/3 =

188.94 mm

f(y) =

0.0000

537.021 mm

Force in anchor bolts Pt = -Pc X

(x - e)
(x + f)
= 1.0E03X(537.0-45814.0)/(537.0+400.0)
=
48320 N

Pt =

48320 N

Pv = Pc + Pt

COMP. IN CONC.

= 1.0 E03 +48320.0

=
49320 N
CHECK FOR COMP. STRESS IN CONCRETE
c = Pv/(*y*B)
49320.0 /( x188.9X1600.0)
0.33 N/mm
CHECK c < b ?

0.33 < 6.3

SAFE

CHECK FOR TENSILE STRESS IN BOLTS:

ft = Pt /Ats
= 48320.00/3141.59
=
15.38 N/mm
CHECK ft < tf ?

15.38 < 120

SAFE

Moment due to tension per bolt

=
=

(48320/2)*100/1000000
2.42 kN.m

LENGTH OF BOLT:
l = T/(bd * *

= (48320/2)/(0.9X 22/7 X50)

l = 170.83

mm

DESIGN OF BASE PLATE BETWEEN STIFFENERS

Base Plate is Stiffned by Gusset Plates
Projection of plate from column l
f:\5593\dsn\rrk\pr3C\306765537.xls j-23-MX

300 mm
RRK/ST

03/01/2016

PRESSURE AT FACE OF COLUMN

= (0.33 X (188.94 - 300.0)) / 188.94
=
-0.19 MPa

y = 188.94
l' =300.0

fc =0.33
PR. AT THE FACE OF COLUMN=

-0.19
-0.19

0.52

p1

0.52

p2

p3

PRESSURE DIAGRAMS

(THREE EDGES FIXED ONE EDGE FREE)

USING MOODY'S CHARTS

2a

a
b

=
=
a/b

250 mm
300 mm
0.83

MOMENT = Coffi. x fc' x b

MOMENT @ COLUMN FACE
COFFI.
COFFI.

M= M1 + M2 - M3

MOMENT DUE TO
P1
P2
P3
0.205
0.205
0.038
-3579.06
9594
1778.4

Max design moment at column face

DESIGN
MOMENT
4236.54

4236.54 N.mm

CRITICAL DESIGN MOMENT

4237 N.mm

REQUIRED TH. FOR BASE PLATE = ((6 X M)/(0.66 X fy))0.5

tr

= ( 6 X4236.54)/( 0.66 x 250)

f:\5593\dsn\rrk\pr3C\306765537.xls j-23-MX

12.41 mm

RRK/ST

03/01/2016

CHECK

tr < T

12.41 < 63

f:\5593\dsn\rrk\pr3C\306765537.xls j-23-MX

SAFE

RRK/ST

03/01/2016

DESIGN OF BASE PLATE & ANCHOR BOLT FOR e<L/6

LOAD DATA :-

Un Factored loads from Support Reactions

Vertical Load
Py =
Moment
Mx =
Mz =
With Extra piping load

Py =
Mx =
Mz =

3511.77 kN
-96.552 kN - m
-1301.754 kN - m

Node No.
LC

43
168

3512.77 kN
96.55 kN - m
1301.75 kN - m

Max. comp. stress

cmax = Pc/(L*B)+6Mx/(B*L)+6Mz/(B*L)
3512771 /(1200X1600)+6*96552000/(1600*1200)+6*1301754000/(1200*1600)
=
4.62 N/mm
<
7.81
N/mm
SAFE

Min. comp. stress

cmin = Pc/(L*B)-6Mx/(B*L)-6Mz/(B*L)
3512771 /(1200X1600)-6*96552000/(1600*1200)-6*1301754000/(1200*1600)
=
-0.96 N/mm

DESIGN OF BASE PLATE FOR FULL WIDTH

Moment due to tension in bolts

=
=

Projection of plate from column l'

DESIGN MOMENT @ COLUMN FACE

48320*(300-200)
4832000 N.mm

LC

189

300 mm
=

4.62x1600x 300 / 2
332891569 N.mm

CRITICAL DESIGN MOMENT

332891569 N.mm

Allowable bending stress

151.8 N/mm2

Thickness of gusset plate

Height of gusset plate
No. of stiffener plates

=
=
=

16 mm
600 mm
3

=
=
=

105.17 mm
335892.60 cm4
6021.38 cm3

CG of gusset plate

Bending stress

f:\5593\dsn\rrk\pr3C\306765537.xls j-23-MX

y
Ixx
Zxx
b

=
=

M/Zxx
55.28 N/mm2

RRK/ST

<

151.8 N/mm2

03/01/2016

1
Node
1844
43
1845
1846
1847
1848
1849
1850
1851
1852
1853
1854
1855
1856
1857
1858
1859
1860
1861
1862
1863
1864
1865
1866
1867
1868
1869
1870
1871
1872
1873
1874
1875
1876
1877
1878
1879
1880
1881
1882
1883
1884
1885
1886
1887
1888
1889
1890
1891
1892
1893
1894
1895
1896
1897
1898
1899
1900
1901
1902
1903

2
L/C
101
102
103
104
105
106
107
108
109
110
111
112
113
114
115
116
117
118
119
120
121
122
123
124
125
126
127
128
129
130
131
132
133
134
135
136
137
138
139
140
141
142
143
144
145
146
147
148
149
150
151
152
153
154
155
156
157
158
159
160

3
FX
-5.897
-3.609
-6.463
-5.589
-4.132
47.919
-55.137
45.065
-57.992
45.939
-57.117
47.397
-55.66
18.641
-84.415
0.408
-102.648
65.861
-37.196
47.625
-55.432
17.915
-85.141
-0.318
-103.374
66.939
-36.117
48.703
-54.353
95.756
-7.301
75.442
-27.615
87.776
-15.281
67.461
-35.595
93.776
-9.281
73.462
-29.595
90.107
-12.949
69.793
-33.263
3.201
-99.855
-15.032
-118.088
65.837
-37.219
47.601
-55.455
86.597
-16.46
66.283
-36.774
81.471
-21.586
61.157

4
FY
4443.268
4457.234
4448.872
4453.14
4455.694
4437.411
4477.057
4429.049
4468.695
4433.317
4472.963
4435.871
4475.517
4259.607
4299.253
4294.268
4333.913
4292.7
4332.345
4327.352
4366.998
4260.146
4299.792
4294.806
4334.452
4294.888
4334.534
4329.541
4369.186
4348.056
4387.702
4388.907
4428.553
4327.446
4367.092
4368.293
4407.939
4343.962
4383.608
4384.813
4424.458
4334.268
4373.914
4375.115
4414.761
2359.094
2398.739
2393.754
2433.4
2406.279
2445.924
2440.931
2480.577
2450.408
2490.054
2491.259
2530.904
2438.16
2477.806
2479.007

5
FZ
32.493
29.799
34.702
34.253
29.637
29.421
30.177
34.324
35.08
33.875
34.631
29.259
30.015
31.497
32.253
32.49
33.246
27.999
28.755
28.992
29.748
31.01
31.766
32.003
32.759
27.874
28.63
28.868
29.624
23.903
24.659
23.628
24.384
45.36
46.116
45.084
45.84
28.357
29.112
28.081
28.837
40.295
41.051
40.019
40.775
30.959
31.715
31.952
32.708
30.557
31.313
31.55
32.306
27.365
28.121
27.089
27.845
43.919
44.675
43.643

6
MX
22.383
9.377
33.304
30.451
8.079
8.255
10.499
32.182
34.426
29.329
31.573
6.957
9.201
18.371
20.615
23.396
25.64
1.538
3.782
6.564
8.808
15.447
17.691
20.472
22.716
0.311
2.555
5.337
7.581
-16.69
-14.446
-17.781
-15.537
83.217
85.461
82.125
84.369
4.384
6.628
3.293
5.537
57.991
60.235
56.9
59.144
15.656
17.9
20.681
22.925
13.328
15.572
18.354
20.598
-0.189
2.055
-1.28
0.964
75.791
78.035
74.699

7
MZ
-185.24
-193.59
-181.52
-185.55
-191.96
-392.91
5.733
-380.84
17.805
-384.87
13.776
-391.28
7.366
-310.62
88.026
-266.84
131.803
-438.71
-40.067
-394.93
3.721
-305.74
92.904
-261.97
136.681
-445.99
-47.34
-402.2
-3.552
-514.07
-115.43
-465.12
-66.476
-483.85
-85.205
-434.9
-36.253
-506.03
-107.38
-457.08
-58.432
-494.29
-95.643
-445.34
-46.691
-226.67
171.979
-182.89
215.756
-458.57
-59.923
-414.78
-16.136
-475.99
-77.341
-427.04
-28.391
-457.84
-59.192
-408.89

9
Py
4443.27
4457.23
4448.87
4453.14
4455.69
4437.41
4477.06
4429.05
4468.70
4433.32
4472.96
4435.87
4475.52
4259.61
4299.25
4294.27
4333.91
4292.70
4332.35
4327.35
4367.00
4260.15
4299.79
4294.81
4334.45
4294.89
4334.53
4329.54
4369.19
4348.06
4387.70
4388.91
4428.55
4327.45
4367.09
4368.29
4407.94
4343.96
4383.61
4384.81
4424.46
4334.27
4373.91
4375.12
4414.76
2359.09
2398.74
2393.75
2433.40
2406.28
2445.92
2440.93
2480.58
2450.41
2490.05
2491.26
2530.90
2438.16
2477.81
2479.01

10
Fx
32.49
29.80
34.70
34.25
29.64
29.42
30.18
34.32
35.08
33.88
34.63
29.26
30.02
31.50
32.25
32.49
33.25
28.00
28.76
28.99
29.75
31.01
31.77
32.00
32.76
27.87
28.63
28.87
29.62
23.90
24.66
23.63
24.38
45.36
46.12
45.08
45.84
28.36
29.11
28.08
28.84
40.30
41.05
40.02
40.78
30.96
31.72
31.95
32.71
30.56
31.31
31.55
32.31
27.37
28.12
27.09
27.85
43.92
44.68
43.64

11
Fz
-5.90
-3.61
-6.46
-5.59
-4.13
47.92
-55.14
45.07
-57.99
45.94
-57.12
47.40
-55.66
18.64
-84.42
0.41
-102.65
65.86
-37.20
47.63
-55.43
17.92
-85.14
-0.32
-103.37
66.94
-36.12
48.70
-54.35
95.76
-7.30
75.44
-27.62
87.78
-15.28
67.46
-35.60
93.78
-9.28
73.46
-29.60
90.11
-12.95
69.79
-33.26
3.20
-99.86
-15.03
-118.09
65.84
-37.22
47.60
-55.46
86.60
-16.46
66.28
-36.77
81.47
-21.59
61.16

1904
1905
1906
1907
1908
1909
1910
1911
1912
1913
1914
1915
1916
1917
1918
1919
1920
1921
1922
1923
1924
1925
1926
1927
1928
1929
1930
1931
1932
1933
1934
1935
1936
1937
1938
1939
1940

161
162
163
164
165
166
167
168
169
170
171
172
173
174
175
176
177
178
179
180
181
182
183
184
185
186
187
188
189
190
191
192
193
194
195
196
197

-41.9
213.09
110.033
213.121
110.064
-129.367
-232.424
-129.336
-232.393
75.459
-27.597
8.264
-94.793
75.414
-27.643
8.371
-94.685
76.125
-26.932
7.598
-95.459
76.086
-26.971
7.699
-95.358
139.893
36.836
88.364
-62.372
-165.429
-113.901
60.868
-42.188
9.34
16.652
-42.188
-34.876

2518.653
3744.085
3783.731
3744.324
3783.969
3511.532
3551.178
3511.771
3551.417
3648.797
3688.442
3606.821
3646.467
3648.874
3688.52
3607.22
3646.866
3648.895
3688.54
3606.723
3646.369
3649.109
3688.755
3606.985
3646.631
2620.755
2660.401
2640.578
2458.771
2498.417
2478.594
2553.898
2593.544
2573.721
2525.628
2593.544
2545.45

44.399
61.261
62.017
61.207
61.963
7.149
7.905
7.095
7.851
66.227
66.983
2.183
2.939
66.192
66.947
2.111
2.867
66.98
67.736
1.429
2.185
66.938
67.694
1.364
2.12
48.725
49.481
49.103
17.041
17.797
17.419
52.921
53.677
53.299
12.845
53.677
13.223

76.943
143.67
145.914
143.306
145.55
-96.189
-93.945
-96.552
-94.308
168.823
171.067
-121.342
-119.098
168.554
170.798
-121.799
-119.555
172.393
174.637
-124.912
-122.668
172.086
174.33
-125.331
-123.087
95.327
97.571
96.449
-45.814
-43.57
-44.692
117.287
119.531
118.409
-67.774
119.531
-66.652

-10.24
542.603
941.249
542.393
941.039
-1301.5
-902.9
-1301.8
-903.11
-215.99
182.658
-542.95
-144.31
-215.94
182.706
-543.42
-144.77
-221.28
177.37
-537.67
-139.02
-221.2
177.442
-538.16
-139.51
187.82
586.466
387.143
-897.48
-498.83
-698.16
-244.84
153.803
-45.52
-464.82
153.803
-265.49

174.637 941.249
-125.331 -1301.8

2518.65
3744.09
3783.73
3744.32
3783.97
3511.53
3551.18
3511.77
3551.42
3648.80
3688.44
3606.82
3646.47
3648.87
3688.52
3607.22
3646.87
3648.90
3688.54
3606.72
3646.37
3649.11
3688.76
3606.99
3646.63
2620.76
2660.40
2640.58
2458.77
2498.42
2478.59
2553.90
2593.54
2573.72
2525.63
2593.54
2545.45

44.40
61.26
62.02
61.21
61.96
7.15
7.91
7.10
7.85
66.23
66.98
2.18
2.94
66.19
66.95
2.11
2.87
66.98
67.74
1.43
2.19
66.94
67.69
1.36
2.12
48.73
49.48
49.10
17.04
17.80
17.42
52.92
53.68
53.30
12.85
53.68
13.22

-41.90
213.09
110.03
213.12
110.06
-129.37
-232.42
-129.34
-232.39
75.46
-27.60
8.26
-94.79
75.41
-27.64
8.37
-94.69
76.13
-26.93
7.60
-95.46
76.09
-26.97
7.70
-95.36
139.89
36.84
88.36
-62.37
-165.43
-113.90
60.87
-42.19
9.34
16.65
-42.19
-34.88

12
Hz
33.02
30.02
35.30
34.71
29.92
56.23
62.85
56.65
67.78
57.08
66.80
55.70
63.24
36.60
90.37
32.49
107.90
71.57
47.01
55.76
62.91
35.81
90.87
32.00
108.44
72.51
46.09
56.62
61.90
98.69
25.72
79.06
36.84
98.80
48.58
81.14
58.04
97.97
30.56
78.65
41.32
98.71
43.04
80.45
52.62
31.12
104.77
35.31
122.53
72.58
48.64
57.11
64.18
90.82
32.58
71.60
46.13
92.55
49.62
75.13

13
Mz
185.24
193.59
181.52
185.55
191.96
392.91
5.73
380.84
17.81
384.87
13.78
391.28
7.37
310.62
88.03
266.84
131.80
438.71
40.07
394.93
3.72
305.74
92.90
261.97
136.68
445.99
47.34
402.20
3.55
514.07
115.43
465.12
66.48
483.85
85.21
434.90
36.25
506.03
107.38
457.08
58.43
494.29
95.64
445.34
46.69
226.67
171.98
182.89
215.76
458.57
59.92
414.78
16.14
475.99
77.34
427.04
28.39
457.84
59.19
408.89

14
Factor
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1

189
101
102
103
104
105
106
107
108
109
110
111
112
113
114
115
116
117
118
119
120
121
122
123
124
125
126
127
128
129
130
131
132
133
134
135
136
137
138
139
140
141
142
143
144
145
146
147
148
149
150
151
152
153
154
155
156
157
158
159
160

101
102
103
104
105
106
107
108
109
110
111
112
113
114
115
116
117
118
119
120
121
122
123
124
125
126
127
128
129
130
131
132
133
134
135
136
137
138
139
140
141
142
143
144
145
146
147
148
149
150
151
152
153
154
155
156
157
158
159
160

e
###
###
9377
###
###
8079
8255
###
###
###
###
###
6957
9201
###
###
###
###
1538
3782
6564
8808
###
###
###
###
311
2555
5337
7581
###
###
###
###
###
###
###
###
4384
6628
3293
5537
###
###
###
###
###
###
###
###
###
###
###
###
189
2055
1280
964
###
###
###

b/6
200
200
200
200
200
200
200
200
200
200
200
200
200
200
200
200
200
200
200
200
200
200
200
200
200
200
200
200
200
200
200
200
200
200
200
200
200
200
200
200
200
200
200
200
200
200
200
200
200
200
200
200
200
200
200
200
200
200
200
200
200

c,all c<c,all ft
ft,all ft<ft,all
Treq. Tprov.
e>b/6 c
SAFE
0.3
6 SAFE
15 120 SAFE
12
63
SAFE
0.2 6.25 SAFE
7 120 SAFE
9
63
SAFE
0.1 6.25 SAFE
3 120 SAFE
6
63
SAFE
0.2 6.25 SAFE
11 120 SAFE
11
63
SAFE
0.2 6.25 SAFE
10 120 SAFE
10
63
SAFE
0.1 6.25 SAFE
3 120 SAFE
5
63
SAFE
0.1 6.25 SAFE
3 120 SAFE
5
63
SAFE
0.1 6.25 SAFE
3 120 SAFE
6
63
SAFE
0.2 6.25 SAFE
11 120 SAFE
10
63
SAFE
0.3 6.25 SAFE
12 120 SAFE
11
63
SAFE
0.2 6.25 SAFE
10 120 SAFE
10
63
SAFE
0.2 6.25 SAFE
11 120 SAFE
10
63
SAFE
0.1 6.25 SAFE
2 120 SAFE
5
63
SAFE
0.1 6.25 SAFE
3 120 SAFE
6
63
SAFE
0.1 7.81 SAFE
6 150 SAFE
8
63
SAFE
0.2 7.81 SAFE
7 150 SAFE
9
63
SAFE
0.2 7.81 SAFE
8 150 SAFE
9
63
SAFE
0.2 7.81 SAFE
9 150 SAFE
9
63
SAFE
0.0 7.81 SAFE
0 150 SAFE
2
63
SAFE
0.0 7.81 SAFE
1 150 SAFE
4
63
SAFE
0.1 7.81 SAFE
2 150 SAFE
5
63
SAFE
0.1 7.81 SAFE
3 150 SAFE
5
63
SAFE
0.1 7.81 SAFE
5 150 SAFE
7
63
SAFE
0.1 7.81 SAFE
6 150 SAFE
8
63
SAFE
0.2 7.81 SAFE
7 150 SAFE
9
63
SAFE
0.2 7.81 SAFE
8 150 SAFE
9
63
SAFE
0.0 7.81 SAFE
0 150 SAFE
0
63
SAFE
0.0 7.81 SAFE
1 150 SAFE
3
63
SAFE
0.0 7.81 SAFE
2 150 SAFE
4
63
SAFE
0.1 7.81 SAFE
2 150 SAFE
5
63
SAFE
0.1 7.81 SAFE
5 150 SAFE
8
63
SAFE
0.1 7.81 SAFE
5 150 SAFE
7
63
SAFE
0.1 7.81 SAFE
6 150 SAFE
8
63
SAFE
0.1 7.81 SAFE
5 150 SAFE
7
63
SAFE
0.6 7.81 SAFE
28 150 SAFE
17
63
SAFE
0.6 7.81 SAFE
29 150 SAFE
17
63
SAFE
0.6 7.81 SAFE
28 150 SAFE
16
63
SAFE
0.6 7.81 SAFE
28 150 SAFE
17
63
SAFE
0.0 7.81 SAFE
1 150 SAFE
4
63
SAFE
0.1 7.81 SAFE
2 150 SAFE
5
63
SAFE
0.0 7.81 SAFE
1 150 SAFE
3
63
SAFE
0.0 7.81 SAFE
2 150 SAFE
4
63
SAFE
0.4 7.81 SAFE
20 150 SAFE
14
63
SAFE
0.4 7.81 SAFE
20 150 SAFE
14
63
SAFE
0.4 7.81 SAFE
19 150 SAFE
14
63
SAFE
0.4 7.81 SAFE
20 150 SAFE
14
63
SAFE
0.1 6.25 SAFE
5 120 SAFE
7
63
SAFE
0.1 6.25 SAFE
6 120 SAFE
8
63
SAFE
0.2 6.25 SAFE
7 120 SAFE
9
63
SAFE
0.2 6.25 SAFE
8 120 SAFE
9
63
SAFE
0.1 6.25 SAFE
4 120 SAFE
7
63
SAFE
0.1 6.25 SAFE
5 120 SAFE
7
63
SAFE
0.1 6.25 SAFE
6 120 SAFE
8
63
SAFE
0.2 6.25 SAFE
7 120 SAFE
9
63
REVISE
0.0 6.25 SAFE
0 120 SAFE
0
63
SAFE
0.0 6.25 SAFE
1 120 SAFE
2
63
SAFE
0.0 6.25 SAFE
0 120 SAFE
2
63
SAFE
0.0 6.25 SAFE
0 120 SAFE
2
63
SAFE
0.5 6.25 SAFE
26 120 SAFE
16
63
SAFE
0.6 6.25 SAFE
26 120 SAFE
16
63
SAFE
0.5 6.25 SAFE
25 120 SAFE
16
63

61.05
221.72
126.31
221.74
126.31
129.56
232.56
129.53
232.53
100.40
72.45
8.55
94.84
100.34
72.43
8.63
94.73
101.40
72.89
7.73
95.48
101.34
72.87
7.82
95.38
148.14
61.69
101.09
64.66
166.38
115.23
80.66
68.27
54.11
21.03
68.27
37.30

10.24
542.60
941.25
542.39
941.04
1301.54
902.90
1301.75
903.11
215.99
182.66
542.95
144.31
215.94
182.71
543.42
144.77
221.28
177.37
537.67
139.02
221.20
177.44
538.16
139.51
187.82
586.47
387.14
897.48
498.83
698.16
244.84
153.80
45.52
464.82
153.80
265.49

1
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1

161
162
163
164
165
166
167
168
169
170
171
172
173
174
175
176
177
178
179
180
181
182
183
184
185
186
187
188
189
190
191
192
193
194
195
196
197

161
162
163
164
165
166
167
168
169
170
171
172
173
174
175
176
177
178
179
180
181
182
183
184
185
186
187
188
189
190
191
192
193
194
195
196
197

###
###
###
###
###
###
###
###
###
###
###
###
###
###
###
###
###
###
###
###
###
###
###
###
###
###
###
###
###
###
###
###
###
###
###
###
###

200
200
200
200
200
200
200
200
200
200
200
200
200
200
200
200
200
200
200
200
200
200
200
200
200
200
200
200
200
200
200
200
200
200
200
200
200

SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE

0.6
1.0
1.0
1.0
1.0
0.7
0.7
0.7
0.7
1.2
1.2
0.9
0.9
1.2
1.2
0.9
0.9
1.2
1.2
0.9
0.9
1.2
1.2
0.9
0.9
0.7
0.7
0.7
0.3
0.3
0.3
0.8
0.9
0.8
0.5
0.9
0.5

6.25
7.81
7.81
7.81
7.81
7.81
7.81
7.81
7.81
7.81
7.81
7.81
7.81
7.81
7.81
7.81
7.81
7.81
7.81
7.81
7.81
7.81
7.81
7.81
7.81
6.25
6.25
6.25
6.25
6.25
6.25
6.25
6.25
6.25
6.25
6.25
6.25

SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE

26
49
49
48
49
32
32
33
32
57
58
41
40
57
58
41
40
58
59
42
41
58
59
42
42
32
33
33
15
15
15
40
40
40
23
40
22

120
150
150
150
150
150
150
150
150
150
150
150
150
150
150
150
150
150
150
150
150
150
150
150
150
120
120
120
120
120
120
120
120
120
120
120
120

SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE

97

16
22
22
22
22
18
18
18
18
24
24
20
20
24
24
20
20
24
24
20
20
24
24
20
20
18
18
18
12
12
12
20
20
20
15
20
15

63
63
63
63
63
63
63
63
63
63
63
63
63
63
63
63
63
63
63
63
63
63
63
63
63
63
63
63
63
63
63
63
63
63
63
63
63

Treq.<Tprov. Check
Bolt length
y
y<L f(y) =0
SAFE
SAFE
171
189 Large e
0
SAFE
SAFE
82 190.76 Large e
0
SAFE
SAFE
33 195.81 Large e
0
SAFE
SAFE
124 189.59 Large e
0
SAFE
SAFE
113 189.81 Large e
0
SAFE
SAFE
29 197.23 Large e
0
SAFE
SAFE
29
197 Large e
0
SAFE
SAFE
38 194.87 Large e
0
SAFE
SAFE
119 189.67 Large e
0
SAFE
SAFE
128 189.51 Large e
0
SAFE
SAFE
109 189.91 Large e
0
SAFE
SAFE
117 189.72 Large e
0
SAFE
SAFE
24 198.91 Large e
0
SAFE
SAFE
33
196 Large e
0
SAFE
SAFE
67 191.55 Large e
0
SAFE
SAFE
76 191.07 Large e
0
SAFE
SAFE
86 190.61 Large e
0
SAFE
SAFE
95 190.31 Large e
0
SAFE
SAFE
4 248.11 Large e
0
SAFE
SAFE
12 209.39 Large e
0
SAFE
SAFE
23 199.63 Large e
0
SAFE
SAFE
31 196.38 Large e
0
SAFE
SAFE
56 192.38 Large e
0
SAFE
SAFE
65 191.72 Large e
0
SAFE
SAFE
75 191.1 Large e
0
SAFE
SAFE
84 190.71 Large e
0
SAFE
SAFE
0 881.09 NOTS
0
SAFE
SAFE
8 221.17 Large e
0
SAFE
SAFE
18 202.62 Large e
0
SAFE
SAFE
27 197.91 Large e
0
SAFE
SAFE
61
192 Large e
0
SAFE
SAFE
53 192.74 Large e
0
SAFE
SAFE
65 191.69 Large e
0
SAFE
SAFE
57 192.35 Large e
0
SAFE
SAFE
312 188.16 Large e
0
SAFE
SAFE
320 188.13 Large e
0
SAFE
SAFE
308 188.17 Large e
0
SAFE
SAFE
316 188.14 Large e
0
SAFE
SAFE
15 206.17 Large e
0
SAFE
SAFE
23 199.51 Large e
0
SAFE
SAFE
11 212.94 Large e
0
SAFE
SAFE
19
202 Large e
0
SAFE
SAFE
217 188.57 Large e
0
SAFE
SAFE
225 188.52 Large e
0
SAFE
SAFE
213 188.6 Large e
0
SAFE
SAFE
221 188.55 Large e
0
SAFE
SAFE
57 192.31 Large e
0
SAFE
SAFE
66 191.66 Large e
0
SAFE
SAFE
76 191.06 Large e
0
SAFE
SAFE
85 190.68 Large e
0
SAFE
SAFE
48 193.22 Large e
0
SAFE
SAFE
57 192.34 Large e
0
SAFE
SAFE
67 191.55 Large e
0
SAFE
SAFE
76 191.07 Large e
0
SAFE
Pure comp.
0 1222 NOTS
0
SAFE
SAFE
6 230.59 Large e
0
SAFE
SAFE
3 263.58 Large e
0
SAFE
SAFE
2 298.39 Large e
0
SAFE
SAFE
284 188.25 Large e
0
SAFE
SAFE
292 188.22 Large e
0
SAFE
SAFE
280 188.27 Large e
0

c,COMP,MAX bc <165
Check
Large eccentri
1.9
55.3
Large eccentri
1.8
55.3
Large eccentri
1.8
55.3
Large eccentri
1.8
55.3
Large eccentri
1.8
55.3
Large eccentri
1.8
55.3
Large eccentri
1.8
55.3
Large eccentri
1.8
55.3
Large eccentri
1.8
55.3
Large eccentri
1.8
55.3
Large eccentri
1.8
55.3
Large eccentri
1.8
55.3
Large eccentri
1.8
55.3
Large eccentri
1.8
55.3
Large eccentri
1.8
55.3
Large eccentri
1.8
55.3
Large eccentri
1.8
55.3
Large eccentri
1.8
55.3
Large eccentri
1.8
55.3
Large eccentri
1.8
55.3
Large eccentri
1.8
55.3
Large eccentri
1.8
55.3
Large eccentri
1.8
55.3
Large eccentri
1.8
55.3
Large eccentri
1.8
55.3
Large eccentri
1.8
55.3
SAFE
1.8
55.3
Large eccentri
1.8
55.3
Large eccentri
1.8
55.3
Large eccentri
1.8
55.3
Large eccentri
1.8
55
Large eccentri
1.8
55.3
Large eccentri
1.8
55.3
Large eccentri
1.8
55.3
Large eccentri
2.0
55.3
Large eccentri
2.0
55.3
Large eccentri
2.0
55.3
Large eccentri
2.0
55.3
Large eccentri
1.8
55.3
Large eccentri
1.8
55.3
Large eccentri
1.8
55.3
Large eccentri
1.8
55.3
Large eccentri
1.9
55.3
Large eccentri
1.9
55.3
Large eccentri
1.9
55.3
Large eccentri
1.9
55.3
Large eccentri
1.8
55.3
Large eccentri
1.8
55.3
Large eccentri
1.8
55.3
Large eccentri
1.8
55.3
Large eccentri
1.8
55.3
Large eccentri
1.8
55.3
Large eccentri
1.8
55.3
Large eccentri
1.8
55.3
pure comp.
1.8
55.3
Large eccentri
1.8
55.3
Large eccentri
1.8
55.3
Large eccentri
1.8
55.3
Large eccentri
2.0
55.3
Large eccentri
2.0
55.3
Large eccentri
1.9
55.3

Check for pure compression

SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE

SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE

SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
97

288
540
548
538
547
361
352
362
354
635
643
456
447
634
642
457
449
648
657
469
461
647
655
471
462
358
366
362
171
162
167
440
449
445
254
449
249

188.24
187.76
187.75
187.76
187.75
188
188
188
188
187.68
187.67
187.86
187.87
187.68
187.67
187.86
187.87
187.67
187.66
187.84
187.85
187.67
187.66
187.84
187.85
188
188
188
188.94
189
189
187.88
187.87
187.88
188.37
187.87
188.39

Large e
Large e
Large e
Large e
Large e
Large e
Large e
Large e
Large e
Large e
Large e
Large e
Large e
Large e
Large e
Large e
Large e
Large e
Large e
Large e
Large e
Large e
Large e
Large e
Large e
Large e
Large e
Large e
Large e
Large e
Large e
Large e
Large e
Large e
Large e
Large e
Large e
96

0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0

Large eccentri
Large eccentri
Large eccentri
Large eccentri
Large eccentri
Large eccentri
Large eccentri
Large eccentri
Large eccentri
Large eccentri
Large eccentri
Large eccentri
Large eccentri
Large eccentri
Large eccentri
Large eccentri
Large eccentri
Large eccentri
Large eccentri
Large eccentri
Large eccentri
Large eccentri
Large eccentri
Large eccentri
Large eccentri
Large eccentri
Large eccentri
Large eccentri
Large eccentri
Large eccentri
Large eccentri
Large eccentri
Large eccentri
Large eccentri
Large eccentri
Large eccentri
Large eccentri
1

2.0
2.1
2.1
2.1
2.1
2.0
2.0
2.0
2.0
2.2
2.2
2.1
2.1
2.2
2.2
2.1
2.1
2.2
2.2
2.1
2.1
2.2
2.2
2.1
2.1
2.0
2.0
2.0
1.9
1.9
1.9
2.1
2.1
2.1
1.9
2.1
1.9
2.2

55.3
55.3
55.3
55.3
55.3
55.3
55.3
55.3
55.3
55.3
55.3
55.3
55.3
55.3
55.3
55.3
55.3
55.3
55.3
55.3
55.3
55.3
55.3
55.3
55.3
55.3
55.3
55.3
55.3
55.3
55.3
55.3
55.3
55.3
55.3
55.3
55.3

SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
98

Solving the equation of third degree

K1
K2
K3

Ref: Mark's Engineering Handbook (Page No. 2-4)

135642
5978229.06029995
-5978229060.29995

y
=
y1-k1/3
3(k1/3)2-k2
A
=
B
=
-2(k1/3)3+k2(k1/3)-k3
p
=
2042313052.9799
q
=
-92293103321447.7
Case 1, if q2-p3 positive FALSE
y11
=
662.3910326062

Y
298.39103

Case 2, if q2-p3 zero

y12
=
=

Y
FALSE
FALSE

FALSE
#VALUE!
45191.4645892347

6.13E+009
-1.8E+014

FALSE
Case 3, if q -p negative TRUE
u
=
2

y13

=
=
=

3.1335002853

45402.9359123721
-90383.5868417711
44980.650929399

Y
188.93591
-135597.59
-233.34907
188.94

Actual Y

188.94 mm

ing Handbook (Page No. 2-4)

DESIGN OF BASE PLATE & ANCHOR BOLT FOR L/6<e<L/2

Grid
As-33
LOAD DATA :-

Node No.

43

LC

Un Factored loads from Support Reactions

Vertical Load

Sum

Py =
Fx =
Fz =
Hz =
Mz =

Resultant Shear
Moment
DESIGN DATA :COLUMN SIZE
BASE PLATE SIZE
Length
Breadth
Thickness
Assume Size of Bolt
Assume Total Nos. of Bolt
Edge Dist. for Bolt
Centre To Centre of Bolt
Projection of Plate From Column
LOAD FACTOR

189

2458.77
17.04
-62.37
64.66
897.48

Support Piping
reaction
load
2458.77
0 kN
17.04
kN
-62.37
kN
64.658
kN
-897.48
0 kN - m

B1000X600
L=
B=
T=
=

1600
1200
63
50
4
200
1200
300

ed =
s=
l' =

D =
mm
mm
mm
mm
Nos.
mm
mm
mm

1000 mm

Ref. Figure
Ref. Figure

CONCRETE

M25

Characteristic comp. strength

Permissible stress in bending comp.
Permissible bearing stress 0.25fck
Permissible bond in tension
m -Modulur Ratio
BOLTS:
Permissible Tensile stress

fck =
cbc =
b =
bd =

25
8.5
6.25
0.9

= 280/3cbc

10.98

tf =

120 N/mm

Pt
x

Pv

IS:456-1978 Table 2
IS:456-1978 Table 15
IS:456-1978 cl. 33.4
IS:456-1978 Table 15

IS:800-1984 Table 8.1

DESIGN PARAMETERS :f

N/mm
N/mm
N/mm
N/mm

PC

c
y/3

y
L

f:\5593\dsn\rrk\pr3C\306765537.xls j-23-MZ

ed

RRK/ST

03/01/2016

As - Area of Holding down Bolts.

Calculation 3 Unknowns Pt, y, s
From Vertical Equilibrium
0.5 y c B - Pt - Pc = 0.0

Structural Steelwork
Connections by

Moment About Column centroid

G.W.Owens & B.D.Cheal,

pg 170

Pt f +( Pt + Pc ) (L/2 - y/3) -Pc *e =0.0

Plane sections condition

s / Es
c / Ec

L/2 -y+f
y

liminating Pt & c from these equations

Here Pt = s As
y3

+ 3 ( e - L/2) y 2

+ 6 m As (f +e) y

- 6 m As (L/2 +f)(f+e)

B
K1 =

=0

3 ( e - L/2)

K 2 = 6 m As (f +e)
K 3 = - 6 m As (L/2 +f)(f+e)
B
f
=
Net area Bolts for tension

= K2 *(L/2+f)
600 mm

(Ats) =
=

Area of bolts for shear

Eccentricity

3.14 x 50/4 x4x 0.8x

3142 mm2

(A ss) =

3.14 x 50/4 x4x 0.8

=
6283 mm2
365.011 mm
e>b/6
OK
-1304.968

e =

K1 =
k2 =

166444.676

k3 =

233022545.963

f(y) = y3+ K1 y2 + K2 y - K3 =0

Solving Cubical Equation by

Differential Method

f1(y) = 3y2+ 2 K1 y + K2
Assume Y =
Y1 =

y - f(y)/f1(y)

1313.33 mm
=

1313.33

Y2 = y1 - f(y1)/f1(y1) =

1313.33

f:\5593\dsn\rrk\pr3C\306765537.xls j-23-MZ

RRK/ST

03/01/2016

Y3 = y2 - f(y2)/f1(y2) =

1313.33

Y4 = y3 - f(y3)/f1(y3) =

1313.33

Y5 = y4 - f(y4)/f1(y4) =

1313.33

Y6 = y5 - f(y5)/f1(y5) =

1313.33

Y7 = y6 - f(y6)/f1(y6) =

1313.33

x = D/2 -y/3 =

1313.33 mm

f(y) =

0.0000

362.223 mm

Force in anchor bolts Pt = -Pc X

(x - e)
(x + f)
= 2458.8E03X(362.2-365.0)/(362.2+600.0)
=
7124 N

Pv = Pc + Pt

COMP. IN CONC.

= 2458.8 E03 +7124.0

= 2465895 N
CHECK FOR COMP. STRESS IN CONCRETE
c = Pv/(*y*B)
2465895.0 /( x1313.3X1200.0)
=
3.13 N/mm
Comp. stress from minor axis

0.33 N/mm

Total compressive stress

3.46 N/mm

CHECK c < b ?

3.46 < 6.3

SAFE

CHECK FOR TENSILE STRESS IN BOLTS:

Tension due to Mx
=
48320 N
Pt = 7124+48320.0
Pt =
55444 N

Total tension

ft = Pt /Ats
= 55444.00/3141.59
=
17.65 N/mm
CHECK ft < tf ?

17.65 < 120

Moment due to tension per bolt

SAFE
=
=

(55444/2)*100/1000000
2.77 kN.m

LENGTH OF BOLT:

f:\5593\dsn\rrk\pr3C\306765537.xls j-23-MZ

RRK/ST

03/01/2016

l = T/(bd * *

= (55444/2)/(0.9X 22/7 X50)

l = 196.01

mm

DESIGN OF BASE PLATE BETWEEN STIFFENERS

Base Plate is Stiffned by Gusset Plates
Projection of plate from column l

300 mm

PRESSURE AT FACE OF COLUMN

= (3.46 X (1313.33 - 300.0)) / 1313.33
=
2.67 MPa

y = 1313.33
l' =300.0

fc =3.46
PR. AT THE FACE OF COLUMN=

2.67
2.67

0.79

p1

0.79

p2

p3

PRESSURE DIAGRAMS

(THREE EDGES FIXED ONE EDGE FREE)

USING MOODY'S CHARTS

2a

a
b

=
=
a/b

MOMENT = Coffi. x fc' x b

MOMENT @ COLUMN FACE
COFFI.
COFFI.

150 mm
300 mm
0.50

M= M1 + M2 - M3

MOMENT DUE TO
P1
P2
P3
0.0852
0.0852
0.0151
20470.82
6057.72
1073.61

f:\5593\dsn\rrk\pr3C\306765537.xls j-23-MZ

RRK/ST

DESIGN
MOMENT
25454.93

03/01/2016

Max design moment at column face

CRITICAL DESIGN MOMENT

25454.93 N.mm
25455 N.mm

REQUIRED TH. FOR BASE PLATE = ((6 X M)/(0.66 X fy))0.5

tr

= ( 6 X25454.93)/( 0.66 x 250)

CHECK

tr < T

30.42 < 63

f:\5593\dsn\rrk\pr3C\306765537.xls j-23-MZ

30.42 mm

SAFE

RRK/ST

03/01/2016

DESIGN OF BASE PLATE & ANCHOR BOLT FOR e<L/6

LOAD DATA :-

Un Factored loads from Support Reactions

Vertical Load
Py =
Moment
Mx =
Mx =

3511.77 kN
-96.55 kN - m
-1301.75 kN - m

Py =
Mx =
Mz =

3511.77 kN
96.55 kN - m
1301.75 kN - m

Node No.
LC

43
168

Max. comp. stress

cmax = Pc/(L*B)+6Mz/(B*L)+6Mx/(B*L)
3511771 /(1600X1200)+6*1301754000/(1200*1600)+6*96552000/(1600*1200)
=
4.62 N/mm
<
7.81
SAFE

Min. comp. stress

cmin = Pc/(L*B)-6Mz/(B*L)-6Mx/(B*L)
3511771 /(1600X1200)-6*1301754000/(1200*1600)-6*96552000/(1600*1200)
=
-0.96 N/mm

DESIGN OF BASE PLATE FOR FULL WIDTH

Moment due to tension in bolts

=
=

55444*(300-200)
5544400 N.mm

PROJECTION OF PLATE FROM COLUMN

DESIGN MOMENT @ COLUMN FACE

l'

LC

189

300 mm
3.46x1200x 300 / 2
186840000 N.mm

CRITICAL DESIGN MOMENT

186840000 N.mm

Allowable bending stress

151.8 N/mm2

Thickness of gusset plate

Height of gusset plate
No. of stiffener plates

=
=
=

16 mm
600 mm
5

=
=
=

160.24 mm
469135.58 cm4
9331.16 cm3

CG of gusset plate

Bending stress

f:\5593\dsn\rrk\pr3C\306765537.xls j-23-MZ

y
Ixx
Zxx
b

=
=

M/Zxx
20.02 N/mm2

RRK/ST

<

151.8 N/mm2

03/01/2016

1
Node
1844
43
1845
1846
1847
1848
1849
1850
1851
1852
1853
1854
1855
1856
1857
1858
1859
1860
1861
1862
1863
1864
1865
1866
1867
1868
1869
1870
1871
1872
1873
1874
1875
1876
1877
1878
1879
1880
1881
1882
1883
1884
1885
1886
1887
1888
1889
1890
1891
1892
1893
1894
1895
1896
1897
1898
1899
1900
1901
1902
1903

2
L/C
101
102
103
104
105
106
107
108
109
110
111
112
113
114
115
116
117
118
119
120
121
122
123
124
125
126
127
128
129
130
131
132
133
134
135
136
137
138
139
140
141
142
143
144
145
146
147
148
149
150
151
152
153
154
155
156
157
158
159
160

3
FX
-5.897
-3.609
-6.463
-5.589
-4.132
47.919
-55.137
45.065
-57.992
45.939
-57.117
47.397
-55.66
18.641
-84.415
0.408
-102.648
65.861
-37.196
47.625
-55.432
17.915
-85.141
-0.318
-103.374
66.939
-36.117
48.703
-54.353
95.756
-7.301
75.442
-27.615
87.776
-15.281
67.461
-35.595
93.776
-9.281
73.462
-29.595
90.107
-12.949
69.793
-33.263
3.201
-99.855
-15.032
-118.088
65.837
-37.219
47.601
-55.455
86.597
-16.46
66.283
-36.774
81.471
-21.586
61.157

4
FY
4443.268
4457.234
4448.872
4453.14
4455.694
4437.411
4477.057
4429.049
4468.695
4433.317
4472.963
4435.871
4475.517
4259.607
4299.253
4294.268
4333.913
4292.7
4332.345
4327.352
4366.998
4260.146
4299.792
4294.806
4334.452
4294.888
4334.534
4329.541
4369.186
4348.056
4387.702
4388.907
4428.553
4327.446
4367.092
4368.293
4407.939
4343.962
4383.608
4384.813
4424.458
4334.268
4373.914
4375.115
4414.761
2359.094
2398.739
2393.754
2433.4
2406.279
2445.924
2440.931
2480.577
2450.408
2490.054
2491.259
2530.904
2438.16
2477.806
2479.007

5
FZ
32.493
29.799
34.702
34.253
29.637
29.421
30.177
34.324
35.08
33.875
34.631
29.259
30.015
31.497
32.253
32.49
33.246
27.999
28.755
28.992
29.748
31.01
31.766
32.003
32.759
27.874
28.63
28.868
29.624
23.903
24.659
23.628
24.384
45.36
46.116
45.084
45.84
28.357
29.112
28.081
28.837
40.295
41.051
40.019
40.775
30.959
31.715
31.952
32.708
30.557
31.313
31.55
32.306
27.365
28.121
27.089
27.845
43.919
44.675
43.643

6
MX
22.383
9.377
33.304
30.451
8.079
8.255
10.499
32.182
34.426
29.329
31.573
6.957
9.201
18.371
20.615
23.396
25.64
1.538
3.782
6.564
8.808
15.447
17.691
20.472
22.716
0.311
2.555
5.337
7.581
-16.69
-14.446
-17.781
-15.537
83.217
85.461
82.125
84.369
4.384
6.628
3.293
5.537
57.991
60.235
56.9
59.144
15.656
17.9
20.681
22.925
13.328
15.572
18.354
20.598
-0.189
2.055
-1.28
0.964
75.791
78.035
74.699

7
MZ
-185.24
-193.59
-181.52
-185.55
-191.96
-392.91
5.733
-380.84
17.805
-384.87
13.776
-391.28
7.366
-310.62
88.026
-266.84
131.803
-438.71
-40.067
-394.93
3.721
-305.74
92.904
-261.97
136.681
-445.99
-47.34
-402.2
-3.552
-514.07
-115.43
-465.12
-66.476
-483.85
-85.205
-434.9
-36.253
-506.03
-107.38
-457.08
-58.432
-494.29
-95.643
-445.34
-46.691
-226.67
171.979
-182.89
215.756
-458.57
-59.923
-414.78
-16.136
-475.99
-77.341
-427.04
-28.391
-457.84
-59.192
-408.89

9
Py
4443.27
4457.23
4448.87
4453.14
4455.69
4437.41
4477.06
4429.05
4468.70
4433.32
4472.96
4435.87
4475.52
4259.61
4299.25
4294.27
4333.91
4292.70
4332.35
4327.35
4367.00
4260.15
4299.79
4294.81
4334.45
4294.89
4334.53
4329.54
4369.19
4348.06
4387.70
4388.91
4428.55
4327.45
4367.09
4368.29
4407.94
4343.96
4383.61
4384.81
4424.46
4334.27
4373.91
4375.12
4414.76
2359.09
2398.74
2393.75
2433.40
2406.28
2445.92
2440.93
2480.58
2450.41
2490.05
2491.26
2530.90
2438.16
2477.81
2479.01

10
Fx
32.49
29.80
34.70
34.25
29.64
29.42
30.18
34.32
35.08
33.88
34.63
29.26
30.02
31.50
32.25
32.49
33.25
28.00
28.76
28.99
29.75
31.01
31.77
32.00
32.76
27.87
28.63
28.87
29.62
23.90
24.66
23.63
24.38
45.36
46.12
45.08
45.84
28.36
29.11
28.08
28.84
40.30
41.05
40.02
40.78
30.96
31.72
31.95
32.71
30.56
31.31
31.55
32.31
27.37
28.12
27.09
27.85
43.92
44.68
43.64

11
Fz
-5.90
-3.61
-6.46
-5.59
-4.13
47.92
-55.14
45.07
-57.99
45.94
-57.12
47.40
-55.66
18.64
-84.42
0.41
-102.65
65.86
-37.20
47.63
-55.43
17.92
-85.14
-0.32
-103.37
66.94
-36.12
48.70
-54.35
95.76
-7.30
75.44
-27.62
87.78
-15.28
67.46
-35.60
93.78
-9.28
73.46
-29.60
90.11
-12.95
69.79
-33.26
3.20
-99.86
-15.03
-118.09
65.84
-37.22
47.60
-55.46
86.60
-16.46
66.28
-36.77
81.47
-21.59
61.16

1904
1905
1906
1907
1908
1909
1910
1911
1912
1913
1914
1915
1916
1917
1918
1919
1920
1921
1922
1923
1924
1925
1926
1927
1928
1929
1930
1931
1932
1933
1934
1935
1936
1937
1938
1939
1940

161
162
163
164
165
166
167
168
169
170
171
172
173
174
175
176
177
178
179
180
181
182
183
184
185
186
187
188
189
190
191
192
193
194
195
196
197

-41.9
213.09
110.033
213.121
110.064
-129.367
-232.424
-129.336
-232.393
75.459
-27.597
8.264
-94.793
75.414
-27.643
8.371
-94.685
76.125
-26.932
7.598
-95.459
76.086
-26.971
7.699
-95.358
139.893
36.836
88.364
-62.372
-165.429
-113.901
60.868
-42.188
9.34
16.652
-42.188
-34.876

2518.653
3744.085
3783.731
3744.324
3783.969
3511.532
3551.178
3511.771
3551.417
3648.797
3688.442
3606.821
3646.467
3648.874
3688.52
3607.22
3646.866
3648.895
3688.54
3606.723
3646.369
3649.109
3688.755
3606.985
3646.631
2620.755
2660.401
2640.578
2458.771
2498.417
2478.594
2553.898
2593.544
2573.721
2525.628
2593.544
2545.45

44.399
61.261
62.017
61.207
61.963
7.149
7.905
7.095
7.851
66.227
66.983
2.183
2.939
66.192
66.947
2.111
2.867
66.98
67.736
1.429
2.185
66.938
67.694
1.364
2.12
48.725
49.481
49.103
17.041
17.797
17.419
52.921
53.677
53.299
12.845
53.677
13.223

76.943
143.67
145.914
143.306
145.55
-96.189
-93.945
-96.552
-94.308
168.823
171.067
-121.342
-119.098
168.554
170.798
-121.799
-119.555
172.393
174.637
-124.912
-122.668
172.086
174.33
-125.331
-123.087
95.327
97.571
96.449
-45.814
-43.57
-44.692
117.287
119.531
118.409
-67.774
119.531
-66.652

-10.24
542.603
941.249
542.393
941.039
-1301.5
-902.9
-1301.8
-903.11
-215.99
182.658
-542.95
-144.31
-215.94
182.706
-543.42
-144.77
-221.28
177.37
-537.67
-139.02
-221.2
177.442
-538.16
-139.51
187.82
586.466
387.143
-897.48
-498.83
-698.16
-244.84
153.803
-45.52
-464.82
153.803
-265.49

2518.65
3744.09
3783.73
3744.32
3783.97
3511.53
3551.18
3511.77
3551.42
3648.80
3688.44
3606.82
3646.47
3648.87
3688.52
3607.22
3646.87
3648.90
3688.54
3606.72
3646.37
3649.11
3688.76
3606.99
3646.63
2620.76
2660.40
2640.58
2458.77
2498.42
2478.59
2553.90
2593.54
2573.72
2525.63
2593.54
2545.45

44.40
61.26
62.02
61.21
61.96
7.15
7.91
7.10
7.85
66.23
66.98
2.18
2.94
66.19
66.95
2.11
2.87
66.98
67.74
1.43
2.19
66.94
67.69
1.36
2.12
48.73
49.48
49.10
17.04
17.80
17.42
52.92
53.68
53.30
12.85
53.68
13.22

-41.90
213.09
110.03
213.12
110.06
-129.37
-232.42
-129.34
-232.39
75.46
-27.60
8.26
-94.79
75.41
-27.64
8.37
-94.69
76.13
-26.93
7.60
-95.46
76.09
-26.97
7.70
-95.36
139.89
36.84
88.36
-62.37
-165.43
-113.90
60.87
-42.19
9.34
16.65
-42.19
-34.88

12
Hz
33.02
30.02
35.30
34.71
29.92
56.23
62.85
56.65
67.78
57.08
66.80
55.70
63.24
36.60
90.37
32.49
107.90
71.57
47.01
55.76
62.91
35.81
90.87
32.00
108.44
72.51
46.09
56.62
61.90
98.69
25.72
79.06
36.84
98.80
48.58
81.14
58.04
97.97
30.56
78.65
41.32
98.71
43.04
80.45
52.62
31.12
104.77
35.31
122.53
72.58
48.64
57.11
64.18
90.82
32.58
71.60
46.13
92.55
49.62
75.13

13
Mz
185.24
193.59
181.52
185.55
191.96
392.91
5.73
380.84
17.81
384.87
13.78
391.28
7.37
310.62
88.03
266.84
131.80
438.71
40.07
394.93
3.72
305.74
92.90
261.97
136.68
445.99
47.34
402.20
3.55
514.07
115.43
465.12
66.48
483.85
85.21
434.90
36.25
506.03
107.38
457.08
58.43
494.29
95.64
445.34
46.69
226.67
171.98
182.89
215.76
458.57
59.92
414.78
16.14
475.99
77.34
427.04
28.39
457.84
59.19
408.89

14
Factor
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1

189
101
102
103
104
105
106
107
108
109
110
111
112
113
114
115
116
117
118
119
120
121
122
123
124
125
126
127
128
129
130
131
132
133
134
135
136
137
138
139
140
141
142
143
144
145
146
147
148
149
150
151
152
153
154
155
156
157
158
159
160

101
102
103
104
105
106
107
108
109
110
111
112
113
114
115
116
117
118
119
120
121
122
123
124
125
126
127
128
129
130
131
132
133
134
135
136
137
138
139
140
141
142
143
144
145
146
147
148
149
150
151
152
153
154
155
156
157
158
159
160

e
365
42
43
41
42
43
89
1
86
4
87
3
88
2
73
20
62
30
102
9
91
1
72
22
61
32
104
11
93
1
118
26
106
15
112
20
100
8
116
24
104
13
114
22
102
11
96
72
76
89
191
24
170
7
194
31
171
11
188
24
165

b/6
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267

c,all c<c,all ft
ft,all ft<ft,all
Treq. Tprov.
e>b/6 c
SAFE
3.5
6 SAFE
18 120 SAFE
30
63
REVISE
3.5 6.25 SAFE
21 120 SAFE
31
63
REVISE
3.4 6.25 SAFE
17 120 SAFE
30
63
REVISE
3.6 6.25 SAFE
25 120 SAFE
31
63
REVISE
3.5 6.25 SAFE
24 120 SAFE
31
63
REVISE
3.4 6.25 SAFE
16 120 SAFE
30
63
REVISE
3.6 6.25 SAFE
15 120 SAFE
31
63
REVISE
3.2 6.25 SAFE
17 120 SAFE
30
63
REVISE
3.7 6.25 SAFE
24 120 SAFE
32
63
REVISE
3.4 6.25 SAFE
25 120 SAFE
31
63
REVISE
3.7 6.25 SAFE
23 120 SAFE
32
63
REVISE
3.4 6.25 SAFE
25 120 SAFE
30
63
REVISE
3.6 6.25 SAFE
15 120 SAFE
31
63
REVISE
3.2 6.25 SAFE
17 120 SAFE
30
63
REVISE
3.4 7.81 SAFE
19 150 SAFE
31
63
REVISE
3.3 7.81 SAFE
20 150 SAFE
30
63
REVISE
3.5 7.81 SAFE
21 150 SAFE
31
63
REVISE
3.4 7.81 SAFE
22 150 SAFE
30
63
REVISE
3.5 7.81 SAFE
13 150 SAFE
31
63
REVISE
3.1 7.81 SAFE
15 150 SAFE
29
63
REVISE
3.5 7.81 SAFE
15 150 SAFE
31
63
REVISE
3.2 7.81 SAFE
17 150 SAFE
29
63
REVISE
3.4 7.81 SAFE
18 150 SAFE
30
63
REVISE
3.3 7.81 SAFE
19 150 SAFE
30
63
REVISE
3.4 7.81 SAFE
20 150 SAFE
31
63
REVISE
3.4 7.81 SAFE
21 150 SAFE
30
63
REVISE
3.5 7.81 SAFE
12 150 SAFE
31
63
REVISE
3.1 7.81 SAFE
14 150 SAFE
29
63
REVISE
3.5 7.81 SAFE
14 150 SAFE
31
63
REVISE
3.1 7.81 SAFE
16 150 SAFE
29
63
REVISE
3.7 7.81 SAFE
18 150 SAFE
32
63
REVISE
3.3 7.81 SAFE
18 150 SAFE
30
63
REVISE
3.7 7.81 SAFE
18 150 SAFE
32
63
REVISE
3.3 7.81 SAFE
19 150 SAFE
30
63
REVISE
4.2 7.81 SAFE
40 150 SAFE
34
63
REVISE
3.8 7.81 SAFE
42 150 SAFE
32
63
REVISE
4.1 7.81 SAFE
40 150 SAFE
33
63
REVISE
3.8 7.81 SAFE
42 150 SAFE
32
63
REVISE
3.6 7.81 SAFE
13 150 SAFE
31
63
REVISE
3.3 7.81 SAFE
16 150 SAFE
30
63
REVISE
3.6 7.81 SAFE
13 150 SAFE
31
63
REVISE
3.2 7.81 SAFE
15 150 SAFE
30
63
REVISE
4.0 7.81 SAFE
32 150 SAFE
33
63
REVISE
3.6 7.81 SAFE
34 150 SAFE
31
63
REVISE
4.0 7.81 SAFE
32 150 SAFE
33
63
REVISE
3.6 7.81 SAFE
34 150 SAFE
31
63
REVISE
2.0 6.25 SAFE
12 120 SAFE
23
63
REVISE
2.0 6.25 SAFE
13 120 SAFE
23
63
REVISE
2.0 6.25 SAFE
14 120 SAFE
23
63
REVISE
2.1 6.25 SAFE
15 120 SAFE
24
63
REVISE
2.3 6.25 SAFE
10 120 SAFE
25
63
REVISE
1.9 6.25 SAFE
13 120 SAFE
23
63
REVISE
2.3 6.25 SAFE
12 120 SAFE
25
63
REVISE
1.9 6.25 SAFE
15 120 SAFE
23
63
REVISE
2.3 6.25 SAFE
6 120 SAFE
25
63
REVISE
1.8 6.25 SAFE
8 120 SAFE
22
63
REVISE
2.3 6.25 SAFE
6 120 SAFE
25
63
REVISE
1.8 6.25 SAFE
8 120 SAFE
22
63
REVISE
2.8 6.25 SAFE
31 120 SAFE
27
63
REVISE
2.4 6.25 SAFE
34 120 SAFE
25
63
REVISE
2.7 6.25 SAFE
31 120 SAFE
27
63

61.05
221.72
126.31
221.74
126.31
129.56
232.56
129.53
232.53
100.40
72.45
8.55
94.84
100.34
72.43
8.63
94.73
101.40
72.89
7.73
95.48
101.34
72.87
7.82
95.38
148.14
61.69
101.09
64.66
166.38
115.23
80.66
68.27
54.11
21.03
68.27
37.30

10.24
542.60
941.25
542.39
941.04
1301.54
902.90
1301.75
903.11
215.99
182.66
542.95
144.31
215.94
182.71
543.42
144.77
221.28
177.37
537.67
139.02
221.20
177.44
538.16
139.51
187.82
586.47
387.14
897.48
498.83
698.16
244.84
153.80
45.52
464.82
153.80
265.49

1
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1.25
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1

161
162
163
164
165
166
167
168
169
170
171
172
173
174
175
176
177
178
179
180
181
182
183
184
185
186
187
188
189
190
191
192
193
194
195
196
197

161
162
163
164
165
166
167
168
169
170
171
172
173
174
175
176
177
178
179
180
181
182
183
184
185
186
187
188
189
190
191
192
193
194
195
196
197

4
145
249
145
249
371
254
371
254
59
50
151
40
59
50
151
40
61
48
149
38
61
48
149
38
72
220
147
365
200
282
96
59
18
184
59
104

267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267

REVISE
REVISE
REVISE
REVISE
REVISE
SAFE
REVISE
SAFE
REVISE
REVISE
REVISE
REVISE
REVISE
REVISE
REVISE
REVISE
REVISE
REVISE
REVISE
REVISE
REVISE
REVISE
REVISE
REVISE
REVISE
REVISE
REVISE
REVISE
SAFE
REVISE
SAFE
REVISE
REVISE
REVISE
REVISE
REVISE
REVISE

2.3
4.3
4.9
4.3
4.9
5.2
4.3
5.2
4.3
4.0
4.0
4.0
3.6
4.0
4.0
4.0
3.6
4.0
4.0
4.0
3.6
4.0
4.0
4.0
3.6
2.7
3.3
3.0
3.5
2.7
3.0
2.9
2.8
2.7
2.8
2.8
2.5

6.25
7.81
7.81
7.81
7.81
7.81
7.81
7.81
7.81
7.81
7.81
7.81
7.81
7.81
7.81
7.81
7.81
7.81
7.81
7.81
7.81
7.81
7.81
7.81
7.81
6.25
6.25
6.25
6.25
6.25
6.25
6.25
6.25
6.25
6.25
6.25
6.25

SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE

34
58
56
58
55
36
37
37
37
68
69
50
51
68
69
50
52
69
70
52
53
69
70
52
53
40
38
39
18
20
18
47
48
48
29
48
30

120
150
150
150
150
150
150
150
150
150
150
150
150
150
150
150
150
150
150
150
150
150
150
150
150
120
120
120
120
120
120
120
120
120
120
120
120

SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE

25
34
36
34
36
37
34
37
34
33
33
33
31
33
33
33
31
33
33
33
31
33
33
33
31
27
30
28
30
27
28
28
28
27
28
28
26

63
63
63
63
63
63
63
63
63
63
63
63
63
63
63
63
63
63
63
63
63
63
63
63
63
63
63
63
63
63
63
63
63
63
63
63
63

Treq.<Tprov. Check
Bolt length
SAFE
SAFE
196
SAFE
Pure comp.
233
SAFE
Pure comp.
184
SAFE
Pure comp.
274
SAFE
Pure comp.
264
SAFE
Pure comp.
179
SAFE
Pure comp.
172
SAFE
Pure comp.
194
SAFE
Pure comp.
263
SAFE
Pure comp.
283
SAFE
Pure comp.
252
SAFE
Pure comp.
273
SAFE
Pure comp.
167
SAFE
Pure comp.
189
SAFE
Pure comp.
207
SAFE
Pure comp.
224
SAFE
Pure comp.
229
SAFE
Pure comp.
243
SAFE
Pure comp.
139
SAFE
Pure comp.
162
SAFE
Pure comp.
162
SAFE
Pure comp.
183
SAFE
Pure comp.
196
SAFE
Pure comp.
213
SAFE
Pure comp.
218
SAFE
Pure comp.
232
SAFE
Pure comp.
135
SAFE
Pure comp.
158
SAFE
Pure comp.
157
SAFE
Pure comp.
179
SAFE
Pure comp.
195
SAFE
Pure comp.
203
SAFE
Pure comp.
203
SAFE
Pure comp.
210
SAFE
Pure comp.
446
SAFE
Pure comp.
471
SAFE
Pure comp.
446
SAFE
Pure comp.
469
SAFE
Pure comp.
149
SAFE
Pure comp.
173
SAFE
Pure comp.
149
SAFE
Pure comp.
172
SAFE
Pure comp.
351
SAFE
Pure comp.
376
SAFE
Pure comp.
351
SAFE
Pure comp.
374
SAFE
Pure comp.
132
SAFE
Pure comp.
144
SAFE
Pure comp.
154
SAFE
Pure comp.
163
SAFE
Pure comp.
109
SAFE
Pure comp.
141
SAFE
Pure comp.
134
SAFE
Pure comp.
162
SAFE
Pure comp.
61
SAFE
Pure comp.
91
SAFE
Pure comp.
70
SAFE
Pure comp.
89
SAFE
Pure comp.
346
SAFE
Pure comp.
377
SAFE
Pure comp.
348

y
1313
2256
2251
2259
2256
2252
2115
2378
2123
2370
2121
2373
2116
2377
2162
2320
2195
2290
2074
2354
2107
2380
2166
2317
2198
2287
2069
2349
2102
2380
2026
2303
2063
2337
2046
2323
2082
2357
2032
2308
2068
2342
2039
2316
2076
2350
2093
2166
2152
2115
1811
2308
1872
2362
1800
2288
1868
2348
1819
2310
1887

y<L f(y) =0
NOTS
0
NOTS
0
NOTS
0
NOTS
0
NOTS
0
NOTS
0
NOTS
0
NOTS
0
NOTS
0
NOTS
0
NOTS
0
NOTS
0
NOTS
0
NOTS
0
NOTS
0
NOTS
0
NOTS
0
NOTS
0
NOTS
0
NOTS
0
NOTS
0
NOTS
0
NOTS
0
NOTS
0
NOTS
0
NOTS
0
NOTS
0
NOTS
0
NOTS
0
NOTS
0
NOTS
0
NOTS
0
NOTS
0
NOTS
0
NOTS
0
NOTS
0
NOTS
0
NOTS
0
NOTS
0
NOTS
0
NOTS
0
NOTS
0
NOTS
0
NOTS
0
NOTS
0
NOTS
0
NOTS
0
NOTS
0
NOTS
0
NOTS
0
NOTS
0
NOTS
0
NOTS
0
NOTS
0
NOTS
0
NOTS
0
NOTS
0
NOTS
0
NOTS
0
NOTS
0
NOTS
0

Check
SAFE
pure comp.
pure comp.
pure comp.
pure comp.
pure comp.
pure comp.
pure comp.
pure comp.
pure comp.
pure comp.
pure comp.
pure comp.
pure comp.
pure comp.
pure comp.
pure comp.
pure comp.
pure comp.
pure comp.
pure comp.
pure comp.
pure comp.
pure comp.
pure comp.
pure comp.
pure comp.
pure comp.
pure comp.
pure comp.
pure comp.
pure comp.
pure comp.
pure comp.
pure comp.
pure comp.
pure comp.
pure comp.
pure comp.
pure comp.
pure comp.
pure comp.
pure comp.
pure comp.
pure comp.
pure comp.
pure comp.
pure comp.
pure comp.
pure comp.
pure comp.
pure comp.
pure comp.
pure comp.
pure comp.
pure comp.
pure comp.
pure comp.
pure comp.
pure comp.
pure comp.

c,COMP,MAX
3.2
2.7
2.7
2.8
2.8
2.7
3.1
2.4
3.1
2.5
3.1
2.4
3.1
2.4
2.9
2.5
2.8
2.6
3.1
2.3
3.0
2.3
2.9
2.5
2.8
2.6
3.1
2.4
3.1
2.3
3.3
2.5
3.2
2.5
3.4
2.7
3.3
2.6
3.3
2.5
3.2
2.4
3.4
2.6
3.3
2.5
1.7
1.6
1.7
1.7
2.2
1.4
2.1
1.4
2.2
1.5
2.1
1.4
2.4
1.6
2.3

bc <165
20.02
20.1
19.7
20.5
20.5
19.6
20.8
18.8
21.6
19.8
21.6
19.6
20.7
18.8
19.9
18.9
20.0
19.4
20.2
18.1
20.3
18.2
19.8
18.8
19.9
19.4
20.2
18.1
20.3
18.2
21.6
19.2
21.5
19.1
24.0
21.8
23.8
21.7
20.9
18.8
20.7
18.6
23.0
20.9
22.9
20.7
11.6
11.5
11.7
12.2
13.4
10.9
13.4
11.1
13.2
10.6
13.0
10.5
16.1
13.7
15.9

Check for pure compression

SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE

SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE

Pure comp.
Pure comp.
Pure comp.
Pure comp.
Pure comp.
SAFE
Pure comp.
SAFE
Pure comp.
Pure comp.
Pure comp.
Pure comp.
Pure comp.
Pure comp.
Pure comp.
Pure comp.
Pure comp.
Pure comp.
Pure comp.
Pure comp.
Pure comp.
Pure comp.
Pure comp.
Pure comp.
Pure comp.
Pure comp.
Pure comp.
Pure comp.
SAFE
Pure comp.
SAFE
Pure comp.
Pure comp.
Pure comp.
Pure comp.
Pure comp.
Pure comp.
5

376
649
617
647
615
404
413
405
415
756
767
559
571
755
766
561
573
770
781
573
584
768
780
574
586
444
424
438
196
223
197
522
535
533
319
535
330

2370
1947
1641
1947
1641
1298
1625
1298
1625
2204
2233
1930
2263
2204
2233
1930
2262
2199
2237
1934
2267
2199
2237
1934
2267
2166
1723
1942
1313
1784
1546
2093
2203
2329
1831
2203
2068

NOTS
NOTS
NOTS
NOTS
NOTS
NOTS
NOTS
NOTS
NOTS
NOTS
NOTS
NOTS
NOTS
NOTS
NOTS
NOTS
NOTS
NOTS
NOTS
NOTS
NOTS
NOTS
NOTS
NOTS
NOTS
NOTS
NOTS
NOTS
NOTS
NOTS
NOTS
NOTS
NOTS
NOTS
NOTS
NOTS
NOTS
0

0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0

pure comp.
pure comp.
pure comp.
pure comp.
pure comp.
SAFE
pure comp.
SAFE
pure comp.
pure comp.
pure comp.
pure comp.
pure comp.
pure comp.
pure comp.
pure comp.
pure comp.
pure comp.
pure comp.
pure comp.
pure comp.
pure comp.
pure comp.
pure comp.
pure comp.
pure comp.
pure comp.
pure comp.
SAFE
pure comp.
SAFE
pure comp.
pure comp.
pure comp.
pure comp.
pure comp.
pure comp.
5

1.5
3.4
4.2
3.4
4.2
4.6
3.9
4.6
3.9
2.8
2.7
3.3
2.5
2.8
2.7
3.3
2.5
2.8
2.7
3.3
2.5
2.8
2.7
3.3
2.5
2.0
2.8
2.4
3.2
2.4
2.8
2.1
2.0
1.7
2.4
2.0
2.0
4.6

13.5
24.6
28.4
24.6
28.4
30.2
25.1
30.2
25.1
23.1
23.1
23.1
20.6
23.1
23.1
23.2
20.6
23.3
23.2
23.3
20.7
23.3
23.2
23.3
20.8
15.7
19.0
17.2
20.0
15.4
17.4
16.7
16.4
15.6
16.2
16.4
14.7

SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
SAFE
98