You are on page 1of 4

REPUBLIC OF THE OF PHILIPPINES

REGIONAL TRIAL COURT


FIRST JUDICIAL REGION
BRANCH 1
BAGUIO CITY
RE: IN THE MATTER OF THE
PETITION FOR HABEAS
CORPUS IN THE PERSON OF
RUDY YUGYOG
ARCHIVAL L. LIGOS
Petitioner,
-versusP/SUPT. ACE VARGAS, in his
capacity as the Chief of Police of
Baguio City Police Station
(BCPO),
P/INSP.
ALISON
FANGKINGAN, in his capacity
as the Station Commander of
Police Sub-Station 5, (BCPO)
Baguio City, and four (4) John
Does Policemen also assigned at
BCPO Police Station 5, Baguio
City

Spec. Proc. No. CBN191522

Respondents.
x-----------------------------------------------x
COMMENTS/OBJECTIONS
(To the Petitioners Formal Offer of Documents)
RESPONDENTS by the undersigned counsel and unto this Honorable
Court, most respectfully comments and/or objects to the Specific Purposes
of the formal offer of exhibits as follows:

EXHIBIT

DESCRIPTION

COMMENTS/OBJECTIONS

Judicial Affidavit by
ARCHIVAL LIGOS

Respondents, by counsel admit


the existence and authenticity of
said exhibit, but objects to the
purpose to which it was offered
for being immaterial and
irrelevant.
The statement of the witness
does not prove anything and it is
purely self-serving and hearsay.

Sworn Statement by
GIN BOY

Respondents, by counsel admit


the existence and authenticity of
said exhibit, but objects to the
purpose to which it was offered
for being immaterial and
irrelevant.
The statement of the witness
does not prove anything and it is
purely self-serving.
The witness is incapable to
perceive and identify the alleged
police officer who allegedly
whipped gun and punched the
victim due to the circumstances

of the event such as: dimly


lighted backyard, tipsy, nervous
and eye defect.
C

Sworn Statement by
EMPE RADOR

Respondents, by counsel object


to the admission of this
document since it was not duly
identified by any witness.
There was no testimonial
sponsor who testified on the said
object.

MUSAR MUSIC
STUDIO OFFICIAL
RECEIPT

Respondents, by counsel object


to the admission of the receipt
for being misleading and
immaterial
The said receipt is not conclusive
proof that Rudy Yogyog is
incapable to commit crime on
August 31, 2015 since he can go
in and out of the musar studio
anytime he wanted to.

RELIEF
WHEREFORE, Respondents respectfully pray that this Honourable
Court deny the admissions of the foregoing exhibits offered by the Petitioner
for the reasons stated above.
Respondents further pray for such other reliefs just and equitable
under the premises.
Baguio City, Philippines, February 19, 2016.
Respectfully Submitted:
Counsel for Respondents
CIPRIASO MAMILIG LAW OFFICES
Room 103, BBCCC Bldg,
Baguio City

MELODY B. MAMILIG
Roll No. 123456
PTR NO. 4191986/ January 4, 2012/ Iloilo City
IBP NO. 812345 / January 4, 2012/ Iloilo City
MCLE Compliance III-000913, April 19, 2010

Copy furnished through Personal Service To:


VALENTINE LAGIMAN
Counsel for Petitioner
3rd Floor Saklot Plaza,
Legarda Rd, Baguio City

You might also like