Name: ____________________________

Peer Evaluator: ____________________________

This I Believe Peer and Self Evaluation Rating Scale
Curriculum Outcomes
-This paper has a wellcrafted topic.
-The topic is personally
meaningful and engaging.
(4.1.3 a.)
-This paper focuses clearly
on a controlling idea.
-The form of the writing
effectively supports the
controlling idea.
(4.1.3 c.)
-The content of the essay
effectively supports the
controlling idea.
-The content of the essay
produces a strong unifying
effect.
(4.1.3 e.)
-The essay contains
examples from personal
experience.
-The essay contains
concepts or ideas from
personal exploration.
(4.1.3 g.)
-There is evidence the
details within this essay
were reviewed for
relevance to the controlling
idea.
-There is evidence the
details within this essay
were reviewed for accuracy.
(4.2.1 b.)

Did the Student Meet the Outcome?

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Yes

Not Quite

Not Quite

Not Quite

Not Quite

Not Quite

Student Comments

Additional Notes/Comments: