You are on page 1of 251

HRM 09 - Strategic Human

Resource Management

ligo@macfast.org

HRM 09 - Strategic Human Resource


Management
Module I
Business Strategy and Organizational
Capability-SHRM overview-Linking HR strategy
with Business Strategy-Steps in SHRM - Role of
HR during Organizational Growth, Turn
around,
Retrenchment
-Mergers
and
Acquisitions.

ligo@macfast.org

HRM 09 - Strategic Human Resource


Management
Module II
Strategic HR Planning and AcquisitionBusiness Strategy and HRP- Job Analysis and
SHRM -HRP Process-HRP and OutsourcingStrategic Recruitment and Selection-IT
enabled acquisition -Alternatives to hiring.

ligo@macfast.org

HRM 09 - Strategic Human Resource


Management
Module III
Strategic Human Resources Development Corporate Strategy and Career Systems-The
Need for Training and Development-HRM
approaches to Training and DevelopmentLinkage between Business Strategy and
Training -New Developments in Training and
development.

ligo@macfast.org

HRM 09 - Strategic Human Resource


Management
Module IV
Strategic
Performance
Management,
Compensation
and
Employee
RelationsPerformance Measurement approaches-Effective
performance
Measurement-Compensation
Reward Approaches-Trends in Top level Executive
Compensation-Strategic Linkage of Performance
Management and CompensationManaging Employee Relations: Unions and
Strategic Collective Bargaining.
ligo@macfast.org

HRM 09 - Strategic Human Resource


Management
Module V
Global Environment of HR-Change &
Diversity-Difference between Global HRM and
Domestic HRM-Cross Cultural contextStrategic HR Issues in Global AssignmentsCompetencies of HR Professional in a SHRM
Scenario.

ligo@macfast.org

Books to refer
Strategic Human Resource Management by
Tanuja Agarwala, Oxford Publications

ligo@macfast.org

HRM 09 - Strategic Human Resource


Management
Module I
Business Strategy and Organizational
Capability-SHRM overview-Linking HR strategy
with Business Strategy-Steps in SHRM - Role of
HR during Organizational Growth, Turn
around,
Retrenchment
-Mergers
and
Acquisitions.

ligo@macfast.org

Business Strategy
Strategy is the determination of the basic long-term
goals and objectives of an enterprise, and the
adoption of courses of action and the allocation of
resources necessary for carrying out these
goals.(Chandler, 1962)
Business strategy is concerned with the match
between the internal capabilities of the company and
its external environment. (Kay, 1999)
ligo@macfast.org

The Concept of Strategy


The concept of strategy is based on three subsidiary
concepts:
Competitive advantage
Distinctive capabilities
Strategic fit.

ligo@macfast.org

Competitive advantage
The concept of competitive advantage was formulated by
Michael Porter(1985).
Three generic strategies that organizations can use to gain
competitive advantage. These are:
Cost leadership
Differentiation
Focused

A distinction has been made by Barney (1991) between the


competitive advantage that a firm presently enjoys but others
will be able to copy, and sustained competitive advantage,
which competitors cannotligo@macfast.org
imitate.

Porters Classification of Business Strategies ((1985)


Type of Business Characteristics
strategy

Examples

Cost Leadership

The firm increases its efficiency, cut cost so that products Retailers Such as
or services may be priced lower than the industry average Big Bazar
Assumes that a small change in price will significantly
affect customer demand
Customers show greater price sensitivity than brand
loyalty

Differentiation

The firm distinguishes its products / services from its


competitors or at least attempts to make consumers
perceive that there are differences
The firm charges a premium for its products
The firm seeks to develop brand loyalty

Nike, Sony

Focus

The firm recognizes that different segments of market


have different needs and attempts to satisfy one
particular group

Cloths
manufactures
that cater to
kids, milouw,
baby shop etc

ligo@macfast.org

Distinctive capabilities
Distinctive capabilities are those characteristics that
cannot be replicated by competitors, or can only be
imitated with great difficulty.
Reproducible capabilities are those that can be
bought or created by any company with reasonable
management skills, diligence and financial resources.
Most technical capabilities are reproducible.

Distinctive capabilities or core competences describe


what the organization is specially or uniquely capable
of doing.
ligo@macfast.org

Basis of SHRM
Most distinctive capability of all is that
represented by the knowledge, skills,
expertise and commitment of the employees
of the organization.

ligo@macfast.org

Strategic fit
The concept of strategic fit states that to maximize
competitive advantage a firm must match its capabilities and
resources to the opportunities available in the external
environment
External Fit: is a theory that proposes that differences in
business orientation or strategies of organisation call for
different types of people as well as different HR Strategies
Internal Fit: refers to the development and implementation of
several HR practices together so that they are interrelated and
internally consistent with each HR practice, complementing
and reinforcing the other.
ligo@macfast.org

SHRM
Strategic HRM defines the organizations intentions
and plans on how its business goals should be
achieved through people.
Wright and McMahan (1992) defined SHRM as the
pattern of planned human resource deployment and
activities intended to enable the firm to achieve its
goals.
ligo@macfast.org

Four components of SHRM


It focuses on an organisations human resources as the
primary source of competitive advantage of the organisation
The pattern and plan imply that there is a fit between HR
strategy and the organisational business strategy and
between all of the HR activities
The activities highlight the HR programmes, policies and
practices as the means through which the people of the
organisation can be deployed to gain competitive advantage
The people practices and planned pattern are all purposeful ,
that is, directed towards the achievement of the goals of the
organisation.
ligo@macfast.org

Human Resources as assets


Of all the resources available to an
organisation, human resources are considered
as the most important for attaining the
objectives of the organisation.

ligo@macfast.org

Main features of Human Resources


Assets
HRs are not owned by
the firm
Value of HR assets may
decline if
An individual is placed
in job that does not fit
with the individuals
skills etc
Individual performs
below potential due to
reduced motivation

HR Assets
Sum of individuals
knowledge, skills,
experience and
competencies

Can walk over to other


organisations taking with
them their accumulated
knowledge, skills and
experience

Value grows with time as


individual gains
experience
Cannot be duplicated
ligo@macfast.org

Human Resources as Assets- The


VIRO Framework
Four criteria of human resources as a
source of competitive advantage

Value
HR can create
value and hence
become a source
of competitive
advantage by
decreasing cost
and increasing
revenue

Rareness
Develop and exploit
rare characteristics of
human resources

Imitability
HR Characteristics
cannot be easily
imitated by the
competitors

ligo@macfast.org

Organisation
It is important for
the organization
to have its
systems and
practices in place

Objectives of SHRM
To ensure the availability of a skilled , committed and
highly motivated workforce in the organisation to
achieve sustained competitive advantage
To provide direction to the organisation so that both
the business needs of the organisation and the
individual and collective needs of its workforce are
met. This is achieved by developing and
implementing HR practices that are strategically
aligned.

ligo@macfast.org

Differences between SHRM and Traditional HRM


Traditional HRM

SHRM

Responsibility for HR Programmes

Staff personnel in the HR


department

Line managers, all managers


responsible for people are HR
mangers

Focus of HR activities

Employee Relations ensuring


employee motivation and
productivity, compliance with law

Partnership with internal, external


stakeholders

Role of HR

Reactive and transactional

Proactive and transformational

Initiative for Change

Slow, fragmented, not integrated


with larger issues

Fast, flexible, systematic

Time Horizon

Short term

Consider various time frames as


necessary( short , medium, long
term)

Control

Bureaucratic control through rules,


procedures and policies

Organic control through flexibility

Job design

Focus on scientific management


principles, division of labour,
specialization

Broad job design, flexibility

Important Investments

Capital, products, technology and


finance

People and their knowledge, skills


and abilities

Accountability

Cost centre

Investment centre

ligo@macfast.org

HR Strategies
Two basic types of HR strategies are:
Overarching strategies
specific strategies relating to the different aspects of
human resource management.

ligo@macfast.org

Overarching strategies
Overarching strategies describe the general
intentions of the organization about how people
should be managed and developed and what steps
should be taken to ensure that the organization can
attract and retain the people it needs and ensure so
far as possible that employees are committed,
motivated and engaged.
They are likely to be expressed as broad-statements
of aims and purpose

ligo@macfast.org

Overarching strategies- Examples


GlaxoSmithKline:
We want GSK to be a place where the best people do
their best work.

B&Q:(British

multinational DIY and home improvement


retailing company )
Enhance employee commitment and minimize the loss
of B&Qs best people.
Position B&Q as one of the best employers in the UK.

ligo@macfast.org

Specific HR strategies
Specific HR strategies set out what the organization intends to
do in areas such as:
talent management how the organization intends to win the war for
talent
continuous improvement providing for focused and continuous
incremental innovation sustained over a period of time
knowledge management creating, acquiring, capturing, sharing and
using knowledge to enhance learning and performance
resourcing attracting and retaining high-quality people
learning and developing providing an environment in which employees
are encouraged to learn and develop
reward defining what the organization wants to do in the longer term to
develop and implement reward policies, practices and processes that will
further the achievement of its business goals and meet the needs of its
stakeholders
employee relations defining the intentions of the organization about
what needs to be done and what needs to be changed in the ways in
ligo@macfast.org

Specific HR strategies-examples
Diageo:
These are the two broad strands to the Organization and
People Strategy:
Reward and recognition: use recognition and reward
programmes to stimulate outstanding team and
individual performance contributions.
Talent management: drive the attraction, retention and
professional growth of a deep pool of diverse, talented
employees.

ligo@macfast.org

Steps in SHRM
SHRM involves three steps:
Forecasting
Forecasting is the attempt to predict future events that
will impact the organization
Strategy formulation
Involves the development of initiatives that are aligned
with the organizations, mission statement
Implementation
Putting the HR plan into action with HR programs that
support the organization's overall strategy.

ligo@macfast.org

Strategic HRM model

ligo@macfast.org

Strategic HRM
Strategic HRM is a concept that integrates traditional human
resource management activities within a firms overall
strategy planning and implementation.
Focuses on the linking of all HR activities with the
organisations strategic objectives

ligo@macfast.org

Strategies at different levels

ligo@macfast.org

Linking Business strategy and HR


strategy
Business strategy

Cost leadership strategy

Differentiation strategy

HR Strategy
Explicit job Descriptions
Hiring employees with required qualification skills
Job Specific training
Paying employees based on job held
Performance appraisal as a controlling tool to weed out
poor performers
Emphasize innovation, flexibility
External recruitment at all levels
Pay based on performance
Performance appraisal as a tool for development

Focus strategy
Hiring employees belonging to the target market
(relies on low cost &
Extensive training
differentiation strategy to High employee participation.
cater to a narrow
segment)
ligo@macfast.org

Miles and Snows Classification of Business


strategy and HR Strategy
Dominant Culture of the organization
(Business strategy)

HR Strategy

Defenders
Seeks stability
Finding change threatening
Favor strategies which encourage continuity and
security
Centralized control
Formal hierarchy

Bureaucratic approach
Build Human resources
Likely to emphasize training programmes
and internal promotions

Prospectors
Respond well to change
Broad range of product and services
Uneven growth
Product based structure

Creative and flexible management style


Little opportunity for long term HR
planning
Acquire Human resources
Likely to emphasize recruitment, selection,
and performance based compensation

Analyzers
Operates in 2 types of product/market domainsstable & changing

Low levels of monitoring and coordination


Buy as well as make key human resources
Emphasize HR planning

ligo@macfast.org

Linking HR with Corporate Objectives


Discuss with the various other departments like
sales/ production/ distribution/accounting/ IT etc
about their requirements .
For manpower.
Recruitments
Replacements
Training etc

ligo@macfast.org

Linking HR with Corporate Objectives

Once you get their departmental requirements, HRM develops


-recruitment /selection plans
-training plans / programs
-rewards plans / programs
-development plans / programs
-payroll plans / programs
- performance management plans
Which is converted into company
-HR policies
-HR procedures
-HR practices.
-HR plans etc.
ligo@macfast.org

Example of ALIGNING HR plans with CORPORATE


OBJECTIVE.

Corporate Strategy: Expand into the global market.


Corporate Objective:

Phase 1: enter the European market.


Obtain 2% of the market in the first 18 months.

ligo@macfast.org

Marketing Objective: Gain 2 % market share in the first 18


months.
Marketing Strategy: Develop new products. Develop product
promotions, with multilingual media plan.
Marketing Needs:
Key employees will need to be able to communicate in
a language of Europe.
product managers need orientation in European
culture.
HR contribution:
Language training.
European culture orientation
ligo@macfast.org

Linking HR with Corporate Strategy


Now as a HR manager, you know
-what the corporate objectives/ strategies are.
-What the marketing / sales objectives / strategies are
-what the marketing /sales needs are
-what the HR contribution should be
and also what/ how your HR plans impact the business
results.

ligo@macfast.org

Role of HR during Organizational Growth,


Turn around, Retrenchment -Mergers and
Acquisitions.

ligo@macfast.org

Role of HR during Organizational


Growth
Force a set of clear choices- connect people priorities
with business priorities
Guide the allocation of people investments to the
most important activities
Energize the people with a sense of purpose

ligo@macfast.org

HR Practices Corresponding to
stages of Organizations Life cycle
Life Cycle Stages

HR practices

Start-up

Recruitment of highly motivated and committed employees


Competitive pay
No unions

Growth

More sophisticated recruitment and selection


Training and development
Performance management processes
Developing stable employee relations

Maturity

Decline

Attention to the control of labour costs


Focus on increasing productivity
Emphasis on rationalization of workforce and downsizing
Trade unions have a marginalized role
Retraining and career consulting services
ligo@macfast.org

Turnaround strategy
Turnaround strategy means to convert, change
or transform a loss-making company into a
profit-making company.

ligo@macfast.org

Role of HR during Organizational Turn around


HR need to understand the turnaround process thoroughly and get
a perspective of the top managements objectives and agenda.
The change agents have to be identified
The ones resistant to change or blockers to turnaround strategy
have to be kept on the vigil.
Mechanisms have to be devised to weed out extra manpower, and
policies have to be defined with respect to layoffs and
compensation.
Performance problems have to be identified
Managing the talent and developing individual development plan
for high performers have to be in place
Coaching and counseling also play pivotal role.
Decision-making and partnership building take on as the primal
training and development input
ligo@macfast.org

Retrenchment
Retrenchment is a corporate level strategy that aims
to reduce the size or diversity of an organization.
This strategy is often used to cut down expenses with
the goal of becoming more financially stable
business.
Typically the strategy involves withdrawing from
certain markets or the discontinuation of selling
certain products or services in order to make a
beneficial turn around.
ligo@macfast.org

Role of HR during Retrenchment


Ensure smooth exit for the departing
employees
Retaining Key employees
Providing outplacement services
Counselling to employees

ligo@macfast.org

The Role of Human Resources in


Mergers & Acquisitions
Deal with Company Culture checking the cultural compatibility before
merger and helping the organisation to instill a
similar culture throughout the organisation
after merger
Managing Employee Benefits Programs
Managing the Employee Concerns
Managing the Changing Roles and Structure

ligo@macfast.org

Environment Trends and Human


Resource Challenges
Globalization and
Increased competition

Managing Global workforce


Ensuring availability of employees who have the skills for
global assignment
Focusing Increasingly on employee productivity to ensure
competitiveness
Ensuring legal compliance when conducting business
abroad

Mergers and
acquisition

Managing Employee insecurity during mergers


Ensuring continued employee productivity
Developing HR initiatives to manage employee morale

Downsizing

Managing organisational relationship with survivors


Managing morale and commitment of survivors
Providing outplacement services or relocation for
employees who lose jobs
Providing personal and family counselling to employees
who lose their jobs
ligo@macfast.org

HRM 09 - Strategic Human


Resource Management
Module-II

ligo@macfast.org

HRM 09 - Strategic Human Resource


Management
Module II
Strategic HR Planning and AcquisitionBusiness Strategy and HRP- Job Analysis and
SHRM -HRP Process-HRP and OutsourcingStrategic Recruitment and Selection-IT
enabled acquisition -Alternatives to hiring.

ligo@macfast.org

HRP: An overview
HRP is the process of analyzing and identifying the need for and
availability of human resources so that the organisation can meet its
objectives
It seeks answers to questions such as
What are the implications of the proposed strategic plans with
respect to human resources?
What are the implications of proposed strategic plan for staffing,
training, and development and management succession?
How will a projected shortfall in the supply of skilled employee
impact various HR practices of the firm?
What are the implications for attracting , retaining, motivating and
rewarding workers with skills that are short in supply?
ligo@macfast.org

HRP: An overview
HRP is a proactive process.
It anticipates changes in the industry,
marketplace,
economy,
society
and
technology to ensure that the organisation is
well prepared to meet these changes.

ligo@macfast.org

The transition from Reactive HRP to


proactive HRP
Traditional HRP
Reactive
Strategic business
decisions taken in
isolation without
considering their HR
implications

Contemporary HRP
Proactive
Integration of
business planning and
HRP. All strategic
decisions consider HR
issues

Changes in business,
economic, social, legal
and technological
environment.
ligo@macfast.org

Business strategy and HRP


Business Strategy
(Classification by porter)

HR Strategy

HRP Activities

Cost leadership
Cost control
Stable business
environment
Efficiency and quality

Job and employee


specializations
Employee efficiency
Long HR planning horizon

Internal Promotions
Emphasis on training
Hiring and training for
specific capabilities

Differentiation
Long term focus
Growth
innovation
Decentralization

Shorter HR planning
horizon
Hire the HR capabilities
required
Flexible jobs and
employees

External staffing
Hire and train for board
competencies

ligo@macfast.org

Relationship between Business strategy of a firm and HRP


Business strategy
(Classification by miles and Snow)

HR strategy

HRP

Defender
Bureaucratic Approach
Finds change threatening
Planned and regularly
Favors strategies which encourage maintained policies to
continuity and security
provide for lean HR

Build
human
resources
Likely to emphasis
training programmes
and internal promotion

Prospector
Creative and flexible
Thrives on change
management style
Favors strategies of product and/ or Have high quality human
market development
resources
Emphasis redeployment
and flexibility of HR

Acquire
human
resources
Likely to emphasize
recruitment, selection,
and
performance
based compensation

Analyzer
Emphasis HR planning
Seeks to match new ventures with the
present business setup
Launches ventures new to the firm
but not new to the market

Buy as well as make


human resources

ligo@macfast.org

Perspective of HRP
Macro HRP
Assessing and
forecasting the demands
for and availability of
skills at the national or
at the global level

HRP
The process of analyzing
and identifying the need
for and availability of
human resources for a
firm , an industry, a
country or at a global
level.

Micro HRP
Process of forecasting
demand for and supply
of human resources for a
specific organisation

ligo@macfast.org

Objectives of HRP
To prevent overstaffing and understaffing
To ensure employee availability
To ensure that the organisation is responsive to the
environment
To provide direction to all HR activities

ligo@macfast.org

HRP Process

ligo@macfast.org

Human Resources Planning


Key Steps Involved

Forecasting
demand

Analyzing
supply

ligo@macfast.org

Planning and implementing


programs to balance
supply and demand

Human Resource Planning

ligo@macfast.org

HRP Process
Environmental Scanning

Organisational Objectives
HR Demand Forecast

HR Supply Forecast
HR Programming
HRP Implementation
Control & Evaluation

Surplus - Restricted Hiring,


Lay Off, VRS, Reduced Hours

Shortage - Recruitment &


Selection

ligo@macfast.org

Environmental scanning
It includes monitoring of the external forces
influencing the organization
It includes

Economic factors
Technological changes
Demographic changes
Political and legislative issues

ligo@macfast.org

Organizational Objectives & Policies


HR plans need to be based on organizational objectives.
Specific requirements in terms of number and characteristics
of employees should be derived from the organizational
objectives

ligo@macfast.org

Employee Demand Forecast

ligo@macfast.org

Demand Forecasting
It is the process of estimating the quantity and quality of
people required to meet future needs of the organization.
Forecasting techniques
Trend Analysis
Managerial judgment
Delphi Technique
Ratio Analysis
Computerized forecasting
Scatter plot

ligo@macfast.org

Trend Analysis
Studying a firms employment levels over a period of years to
predict future needs.
Example

2001-02production of units
2001-02
no. of workers
Ratio
2003-04 estimated production
No. of workers required

:5000
:100
:100:5000
:8000
:8000*100/5000=160

If the supervisors have a span of 20 workers, 8 supervisors are also


needed in 2003-04

ligo@macfast.org

Ratio Analysis
Making forecast based on the ratio between some casual
factors like sales volume and the number of employees
required like the sales people.
Trend analysis and ratio analysis assume that the productivity
of the employees remains the same.

ligo@macfast.org

Computerized Forecasting
A computer program will be developed to predict the future
requirements based on historical data.
The computer program/ software then can be used as a
powerful simulation tool to project the future requirements.

ligo@macfast.org

Managerial Judgment
Managers sit together, discuss and arrive at a figure which
could be the future demand of labour
It can either top down or bottom up approach

ligo@macfast.org

Scatter plot
Scatter plot show the relationship between two variables by displaying
data points on a two-dimensional graph.
Example: relationship between the number of employees and sales .

75

Sales

50

10
10 20 30 40 50 60
ligo@macfast.org
no of employees

Delphi Technique
Its systematic, interactive forecasting method which relies on
a panel of independent experts
Selected experts answers questionnaires in two or more
rounds.
Facilitator provides the anonymous summary of experts from
the previous round as well as reasons for their judgments
The participants are encouraged to revise their earlier
answers in light of replies of other members of group.
After some rounds the group will converge to a correct
number.
There is an absence of interaction among the experts.
ligo@macfast.org

Employee Supply Forecasting

ligo@macfast.org

Supply Analysis
Process of estimating future quantity and quality of
manpower available internally & externally to an
Organisation.
Two sources of supply are
Internal
External

ligo@macfast.org

Forecasting Supply of Employees: Internal Labor Supply

Staffing Tables
Markov Analysis
Skill Inventories
Replacement Charts
Succession Planning

ligo@macfast.org

Forecasting Internal Labor Supply


Staffing Tables
Graphic representations of all organizational jobs, along
with the numbers of employees currently occupying those
jobs and future (monthly or yearly) employment
requirements.
Markov Analysis
A method for tracking the pattern of employee movements
through various jobs.

ligo@macfast.org

Hypothetical Markov Analysis for a Retail Company

ligo@macfast.org

Internal Supply Forecasting Tools

Skill Inventories
Files of personnel education, experience, interests,
skills, etc., that allow managers to quickly match job
openings with employee backgrounds.

ligo@macfast.org

Existing Human Resources


Capability / Skills Inventory using HR Information System
G e n e r a l In fo rm a tio n Nam e:
P re s e n t A d d re s s :
S e x:
DOB:
M a r it a l
S ta tu s :
P e rm a n e n t A d d re s s :
Q u a l i f i c a t io n D e g r e e / D ip lo m a

I n s t itu t io n

D e p a r tm e n t :
D e s ig n a t io n :
D O J:
S a la r y :
G ra d e :

C la s s

Year of Pass

E x p e r i e n c e / S k il l s O r g a n is a t io n
J o b T it le /
B r ie f
S k ill/
A p p o in t m e n t
R e s p o n s ib ilitie s S p e c ia lis a t io n
O u ts ta n d in g A c h ie v e m e n t / A d d itio n a l In fo r m a tio n A w a rd s
P e r fo r m a n c e
D is c ip lin a r y A c tio n
P r o m o tio n s
M e r it R a t in g
A b s e n t e e is m
A c h ie v e m e n t s
C a r e e r P la n s :
ligo@macfast.org

Internal Supply Forecasting Tools

Replacement Charts
Listings of current jobholders and persons who
are potential replacements if an opening
occurs.

ligo@macfast.org

An Executive Replacement Chart

ligo@macfast.org

Replacement Chart Example

ligo@macfast.org

HR Programming

Balancing Demand and Supply

Vacancies filled in by the right employee at the right


time

ligo@macfast.org

HR Plan Implementation

Recruitment, Selection & Placement


Training & Development
Retraining & Redeployment
Retention Plan
Downsizing Plan

ligo@macfast.org

Control & Evaluation

Are Budgets, Targets & Standards met?


Responsibilities for Implementation & Control
Reports for Monitoring HR Plan

ligo@macfast.org

Strategies for Managing Shortages

Recruit new permanent employees


Offer incentive to postpone retirement
Rehire retirees part-time
Attempt to reduce turnover
Work current staffs overtime
Subcontract work to another company
Hire temporary employees
Redesign job processes so that fewer employees are
needed
ligo@macfast.org

Strategies for managing Surplus

Hiring freeze
Do not replace those who leave
Offer VRS / Early Retirement, Golden Handshake
Reduce work hours
Pay cuts
Reduce outsourced work
Redeployment /transfer of employees to sister organizations or other
companies.
Work sharing
Layoff
Leave of absence without pay
Sabbaticals
ligo@macfast.org

Job Analysis and SHRM

ligo@macfast.org

Job Analysis
Job analysis is a formal and detailed examination of jobs.
Its a systematic investigation of the tasks, duties and
responsibilities necessary to do a job.

ligo@macfast.org

Uses of job analysis

Human resource planning


Recruitment
Selection
Placement and orientation
Training
Counseling
Employee safety
Performance appraisal
Job design and redesign
Job evaluation

ligo@macfast.org

The process of job Analysis

Organizational analysis.
Selection of representative positions to be analyzed.
Collection of job analysis data.
Preparation of job description.
Preparation of job specification.

ligo@macfast.org

Methods of Collecting Job Analysis Data

Job performance
Personal observation
Critical incidents
Interview
Panel of experts
Diary method
Questionnaire method

ligo@macfast.org

Methods of Job Analysis


Observation Method
Analyst observes incumbent

Directly
Videotape
Useful when job is fairly routine
Workers may not perform up to expectations

ligo@macfast.org

Methods of Job Analysis


Interview Method
Individual
workers are interviewed individually
The answers are consolidated into a single job
analysis

Group
Employees are interviewed simultaneously
Group conflict may cause this method to be
ineffective
ligo@macfast.org

Methods of Job Analysis


Questionnaires
Employees answer questions about the jobs
tasks and responsibilities
Each question is answered using a scale that
rates the importance of each task

ligo@macfast.org

Typical Areas Covered in a


Job Analysis Questionnaire

ligo@macfast.org

Methods of Job Analysis


Diary Method
Employees record information of their daily tasks
into diaries
Record the time it takes to complete tasks

Must be over a period of several weeks or months

ligo@macfast.org

Methods of Job Analysis


Critical Incident Technique (CIT)
Takes past incidents of good and bad behavior
Identifies the effective and ineffective behaviour
from the part of the employee

ligo@macfast.org

Job description
A JD is a written statement of what the job holder does , how
its done, under what conditions it is done .

Contents

Job title
Location
Job summary
Job Duties
Job activities
Roles & Responsibilities
Supervision given or received
Working conditions
Equipment used
ligo@macfast.org
Hazards

Specimen of job description

Title :compensation manager


Code :HR/2310
Department: Human Resource Department
Summary:
responsible for the design and administration of employee compensation
programmes

Duties :

conduct job analysis


Prepare job description for current and projected positions
Act as a chairman for job evaluation committee
Conduct periodic salary survey
Develop and administer performance appraisal programmes

Working conditions: normal, eight hours per day, five days a week
Report to: director, human resource

ligo@macfast.org

Job Specification
JS summarizes the human characteristics needed for
satisfactory job completion.
The personal attributes that are described through job
specification can be classified in to
Essential attribute (KSA a person must possess)
Desirable attributes (qualification a person ought to
possesses)
Contra-indicators (attributes that will become a handicap
to successful job performance)

ligo@macfast.org

Job specification of compensation manager


Education:

MBA with specialization in HRM/ PG Diploma in HRM/MA in Industrial


Psychology
A degree or diploma in Labour laws is desirable
Experience:

knowledge of compensation practices in a large manufacturing


company
Skills, knowledge, abilities:
skill in writing job description, conducting job analysis
interviews,performing group presentations.
Ability to plan meetings, to plan and prioritise work
Age:

preferably below 30 years

ligo@macfast.org

Job Analysis Input for various HR


Activities
HRM Activity

Input Provided by Job Analysis

HR Planning

Number and type of employees that the firm will need in order to
accomplish goals

Recruitment
and selection

The KSAs that the potential employee should be tested for

Compensation

Compensation for a job deponds on skills, education, knowledge etc


required to perform a job

Performance
Appraisal

To compar each employees performance against standards


established in job analysis

Training &
Development

To determine the nature of training to be imparted to the employees

Safety and
Health

To identify the possible job hazards and working conditions


associated with a job

Industrial
Relations

Specific job descriptions reduce grievances by clearly specifying the


tasks covered under a job
ligo@macfast.org

HR Outsourcing
What is Outsourcing?
Outsourcing is a strategic decision to give a
task or activity to an independent contractor
who determines how best to do the task or
activity.
The firm and the independent contractor
become partners and may establish a longterm relationship.
ligo@macfast.org

Pros and cons


Pros
Cost and savings
Financial and operational
flexibility
Access to quality, expertise
and better management
skills

Cons
Need greater coordination
with agencies
Reduces organizational
learning by depleting its skill
base
Loss of control
Adverse affects on morale
and motivation
Job insecurity

ligo@macfast.org

Which functions/sub-systems
to outsource

Recruitment preliminary screening and short listing

Training Trg. Needs identification, content development, delivery, logistics, third


party evaluation

Performance management - on line automation

Compensation pay roll and compensation surveys

Safety -- inspections

welfare transport, security, catering

Labour contract contract employees doing the job which was earlier done by
regular employees

Which function not to outsource


Decision making in each of the sub functions
Leading change and transforming the organization
ligo@macfast.org

Outsourcing Process
It consists of 4 stages

Analysis and evaluation


Contracting and negotiation
Initiation and transition
Stabilization and maintenance of outsourced
relationship

ligo@macfast.org

Model of HRP during Outsourcing


Stage 1

Stage 2

Stage 3

Stages in the
outsourcing
process

Analysis and
evaluation

Contracting
transitioning
and negotiating

Stabilization
and
improvement

Best practices
for HRP

Retain HR
Talent
Do not
outsource HRP
Consider
alternatives to
outsourcing

Evaluate
vendor
organisation
Design
the
internal
organsation to
manage
the
vendor
by
developing a
dedicated
vendor
management
ligo@macfast.org
team.

Build in
continuous
improvement
and flexibility
at the vendor

Employ a
phased
approach to
transition
Build a
transition team

Stage 4

Strategic Recruitment and


selection

ligo@macfast.org

The staffing Process


Organisational Goals
and objectives
Human Resource
Planning
Alternatives to
recruitment

Recruitment
Internal Sources

External Sources

Internal methods

External methods
Application pool

Initial screening
Selection methods
Rejected Candidates
ligo@macfast.org

Selected candidates
Job offer

Factors influencing staffing


External
Labour market conditions
Government regulations and legal considerations
Internal influences on staffing
Organisational policies and practices
Organisational image
Job attractiveness

ligo@macfast.org

Sources of Recruitment
Recruitment is a process of searching for prospective
employees and stimulating them to apply for jobs
The methods are
Internal sources
External sources

ligo@macfast.org

Sources of Recruitment
Internal source

Organisational database
Promotion
Departmental exam
Transfer
Former employees
Internal advertisement/job
posting
Employee referrals
Previous applications

External sources

ligo@macfast.org

Advertisement in radio & TV


Professional and trade association
Employment agency/
consultants/head hunters
Employment exchanges
Campus recruitment
News paper advertisement
Internet advertisement
Walk in, write-ins
Competitors
E- recruiting / web recruitment
Displaced persons
Casual callers
Labour contractors
Gate recruitment

Process of selection
1.
2.
3.
4.
5.
6.
7.
8.
9.
10.
11.

Reception
Preliminary/ screening Interview
Application Blank
Selection Tests
Selection Interviews
Checking of References
Selection decision
Physical Examination
Job offer
Employment contract
Evaluation

ligo@macfast.org

ligo@macfast.org

Strategic recruitment & selection


Recruitment and selection facilitate the achievement of the
firms business strategy.
Shift in central focus of recruitment :Person-job fit to person
organisation- fit
Increased use of sophisticated selection techniques and
greater involvement of line managers in the process of
selection

ligo@macfast.org

Linkage between business strategy and


SR&S Effectiveness
Business
strategy

Defender

Hiring
managerial
talent

Promoted
within

Prospector

Analyzer

from Often acquired Drawn


from
internal
from outside
promotions,
external
recruitment, mergers and
acquisition.

Staffing process Individuals are hired Experienced


Employees are hired at both
at lower level and employees are lower and higher levels
provide on the job hired
training
Recruitment
methods

Internal sources

External
sources

Mixture of sources

Selection
methods

Assess potential and emphasize on Use a combination of methods


Promotability
work history

Selection
decision

Greater corporate Greater


control over hiring
influence
ligo@macfast.org
hiring

line A mix of two


in

Linkage between business strategy and SR&S


Effectiveness
Business
strategy

Defender

Prospector

Analyzer

Recruitment
Messages

Convey information about


centralization of control,
emphasis
on
internal
promotion, high investment
in employee development

Indicate dynamism in
job, emphasis on
technological
and
marketing innovation

Message similar to
defenders in stable
areas and more like
prospectors in change
oriented sectors

Focus
on
achievements,
individuals with
tolerance
ambiguity

Focus on both past


achievements
and
future
Clearly
articulate
selection criteria
potential

Criteria
Hiring

for Emphasize relatively narrow


range of specialized skills
Clearly articulate selection
criteria

past
seek
high
for

Selection
methods

Assess
potential
Promotability

and emphasize on work Use a combination of


history
methods

Selection
decision

Greater corporate control Greater


line A mix of two
over hiring
influence in hiring
ligo@macfast.org

E- recruitment
Methods

Advantages

Disadvantages

Job Boards/ job Useful for generating applicant Many individuals accessing sites
placement
response
are only job lookers not serious
websites
applicants
Professional career Targets applicants interest in
websites
specific industry or profession
Reduces number of less
qualified applicants
Saves recruiters time and effort

Since professionals other than


the target applicants do not
normally access the website, they
remain
unaware
of
the
employment development in
these professions

More effective and efficient


Can be put up inexpensively
compared to print
Firm may be able to attract
individuals
otherwise
inaccessible
Attracts the attention of
candidates worldwide

Many employer websites are


difficult to navigate since they do
not
present
career
and
employment information.
May lead to negative image of
the organisation if not updated
regularly.

Company websites

ligo@macfast.org

Advantages and disadvantages of


internet recruiting
Internet recruitment
Advantages

Disadvantages

Organisational
perspective

Cost effective compared to


newspaper advertising, search
firms etc
Generates more applicant resumes
Responses start coming in the day
the advertisement is posted on the
internet
Saves time, as recruiters can
respond to qualified candidates
more quickly.

May get applications from more


unqualified candidates
May create additional work for
HR recruiters

Employee
perspective

Allows individuals quick access to


information on various job
possibilities
Saves applicants time as they can
respond quickly to job
postings
ligo@macfast.org

Individuals from disadvantaged


sections of society may have
limited access to internet

Alternatives to hiring permanent


employees

Overtime
Independent contractors/ consultants
Outsourcing
Employee leasing/ staff sourcing
Temporary staffing services
Rehiring former employees
Hiring from non- tradition labour pool eg:
housewives, retired employees, ex service
men etc
ligo@macfast.org

HRM 09 - Strategic Human


Resource Management
Module-III

ligo@macfast.org

120

HRM 09 - Strategic Human Resource


Management
Module III
Strategic Human Resources Development Corporate Strategy and Career Systems-The
Need for Training and Development-HRM
approaches to Training and DevelopmentLinkage between Business Strategy and
Training -New Developments in Training and
development.

ligo@macfast.org

121

Corporate Strategy and Career


Systems

ligo@macfast.org

122

Changing Notions of Career


Success
Contemporary
Notion

Traditional Notion

Using an individuals full potential


Facing challenges
Greater responsibility
Increased autonomy
Meaningful work

Vertical advancement in
hierarchy or increasing
salary levels

ligo@macfast.org

123

Career Planning, Career Development and


Career Management
Career Planning
Personalized ongoing process
Individual chooses
occupations, organizations, and
jobs
Individual establishes career
goals and identifies means for
achieving these goals

Career Development
Activities and processes
undertaken by the
organisation to help
individuals attain their
career objectives
Career

Career management
Life long on going process of preparing,
implementing and monitoring career
plans undertaken by the individual in
partnership with the organisation
ligo@macfast.org

124

Organisational Career
management practices

Performance appraisal as a basis for career planning


Assessment centre
Peer appraisal
Career counseling by direct supervisor
Career counseling by HR department
Formal mentoring
Career workshops
Written career planning
Retirement planning programmes
Books and or pamphlets on career issues
Postings regarding internal job openings
Formal education as part of career development
Lateral moves to create cross functional experience.
ligo@macfast.org

125

Career Stages

ligo@macfast.org

126

Objectives of career planning


Methods/ Practices
Career Planning
Methods/ Practices

objectives

Communication

To provide career related information to employees

Counselling

To help employees with their personal assessment of interests,


aptitudes and capabilities

Career planning
workshops

To help employees set personal career goals and plans for


development

Self development
materials

Providing employees with materials aimed at career planning

Assessment
Programmes

To identify specific developmental needs required for


achieving employees career goals

ligo@macfast.org

127

Career development Interventions for each career stage


Career stages

Career development needs

Establishment Challenging initial jobs


stage
Variety in job activities
Opportunities for development of relevant
skills
Feedback on performance and potential

Career development
interventions
Realistic job preview
Job pathing
Performance feedback and
coaching

Advancement
stage

Opportunity to do challenging work


Exposure and visibility on the firm
Opportunity to demonstrate potential
Dual
Dual career concerns

Challenging and visible


assignments
Mentoring
Assessment
Assessment centre
Dual career accommodation

Maintenance
stage

Leveling off and maintaining career


Redefine role in company
Opportunity to develop others
Autonomy

Developmental training
Assigning mentoring jobs
Rotation to jobs requiring
new skills
Mid career counselling

Withdrawal
stage

Adjust to role of retired person


Continue to use experience to help others
Establish a meaningful life outside the
organisation
ligo@macfast.org

Consultative roles
Phased retirement
Retirement counselling
128

Career management systems

ligo@macfast.org

129

Viewpoints in career management


Career management
Systems
Individual centered
Focus on individual's
career rather than on
organisational needs

Organisation- centered
Focus on ensuring the
fulfillment of organisational
goals

Individual career
management strategies
Self assessment
Assessment of job
opportunities
Formulating career goals
Matching individuals to
jobs
Seeking opportunities
for professional growth

Organizational career
management programmes
Career planning workshops
Assessment centers
Providing mentors to individuals
Developing career paths for
employees
Establishing realistic career
plans with employees
ligo@macfast.org

130

Individual centered career


management system

Identify the individuals career goals


Assessing the individuals personal abilities and interests
Planning the individual's life and work goals
Assessing alternative career paths inside and outside the
organization
Drawing a career path for the individual
Noting changes in interests and goals as career and life stages
changes.

ligo@macfast.org

131

Organisation centered career


management system

Identify organisational objectives


Determining future manpower staffing needs of the firm
Identifying available career paths within the firm
Communicating with employees about opportunities
Assessing employees potential as well as training needs
Matching organisational needs with individual needs

ligo@macfast.org

132

Designing and implementation of


Career management systems
Identify career planning needs and develop a
strategy
Develop necessary resources
Introduction of a pilot programme
Introduction of the full programme
Involvement of HR and line mangers
Top management support
Alignment with culture
ligo@macfast.org

133

Career management techniques for


specific HR issues
HR issues

Career Management techniques

How to reduce turnover among recently


hired employees

Challenging first job


Job enrichment
Assigning new employee to demanding
bosses

How to develop high potential


candidates for management positions

Assessment centers
Job pathing

How to provide promotion


opportunities in a stable or contracting
organisation

Cross functional moves


Fall back positions

How to reward and retain technical and


professional employees

Dual career paths

How to motivate plateaued employees

Lateral movements
Skill based pay systems
Seminars and university courses
Rotation

ligo@macfast.org

134

Training and Development

ligo@macfast.org

135

Training and development: A comparison


Training

Development

Process designed to bring about a


relatively
permanent
change
in
employees skills, knowledge, attitudes, or
behaviour in order to improve their
performance on currently held job

Process designed to impart learning


experiences in order to help employees
acquire skills and competencies for future
responsibilities

Imparts technical skills

Imparts managerial skills

Focus on small number of technical skills Focus on board range of skills applicable
specific to current job
more generally across different situations
Directed towards
personnel

non

Present focused , short run

management Directed towards managerial personnel


Future- focused, long run

Activity designed to manage an existing Activity designed to be a continuous


performance problem
process
ligo@macfast.org

136

Need for Training and Development

Performance improvement
Skill updating
Solving organisational problems
New employee orientation
Preparation for promotion
Opportunities for personal growth

ligo@macfast.org

137

Benefits of Training and Development


Benefits of Training and
Development

Organisational Benefits
Increased efficiency and
profitability.
Reduced
employee
turnover (voluntary).
Reduced
involuntary
turnover
(terminations
due to skill deficiency).
Enhanced productivity.
Makes employees more
accountable as they gain
more knowledge and
skills.

Customer Benefits
Better quality of products
and services

ligo@macfast.org

Employee benefits
Improved performance
Increase in employability
( skilled workers seen as
more attractive by
competitors.
Enhanced motivation.
Jobs becomes more
rewarding.
Opportunity for upward
mobility in the firm.
138

Emergence of Training as a strategic


Organisational Activity: Reasons
Re-structuring
Employee
mobility

Advances in
technology

Reasons
T& D
significance

Workforce
diversity

Work
redesign
Mergers
and
acquisition
s
ligo@macfast.org

139

HRM Approaches and Training and


development in organisations
HRM Approaches

T & D in organisations

Human Capital Approach

Training is an investment in human


resources that gives returns in the form of
increased productivity.

Strategic Framework

Training results in the development of


those skills and competencies in
employees that are unique and superior
to competitors, leading to competitive
advantage.
Dependency
relationship
between
training and business strategy of the firm.

Contingent Approach
ligo@macfast.org

140

Linkage between business strategy and staffing


and training practices
Type of business
strategy

Characteristics

HRM Requirements

Staffing and Training Practices

Defender
Compete on
the basis of low
price and high
quality; stable
environment.

Limited product line.


Skills in production efficiency,
process engineering and cost
control.
Long term perspective.
Functional structure.
Division of labour.

Skill specialization.
Emphasis on
production and
finance functions.
Build skills.

Skill type
Staff and train for narrow skills.
Staff and train for production
and finance functions.
Skill source
Internal staffing.
High amount of training.
In-house training.

Prospector
Compete on
the basis of
new markets
and new
products;
unstable
environment.

Diverse product lines.


Skills in product research and
development and product
engineering.
Rapid growth.
Decentralized structure.
Product or geographically
divisionalized structure.

Skill flexibility.
Emphasis on
marketing/ sales
and on research
and development.
Buy skills.

Skill type
Staff and training for broad skill.
Staff and train for marketing
research and development.
Skill source
External staffing.
Low amount of training.
External training when required.

ligo@macfast.org

141

The Training process

ligo@macfast.org

142

Organisational goals and


objectives

Phase 1

Training need Assessment

Gap between Skills needed and


available

Need for T& D


Phase 2

Program design and


development
Phase 3

Implementation

Phase4

Evaluation
ligo@macfast.org

143

Sources of need analysis data


Types of analyses in training need Sources of Data
analysis
Organisational analysis ( where training Strategic initiatives of the organisation
emphasis should be placed)
Technological change
An examination of the environment , Data about turnover, accidents etc
strategies, organisational goals, resources
of the organisation, etc to determine
where the training emphasis should be
placed in the organisation
Job descriptions
Job analysis (what should be taught)
Job descriptions and specifications to Job specifications
determine the content of training
programme to ensure that the trainee
performs well on the job
Attitude survey
Person analysis (who needs training )
To determine which employees need Questionnaires
training and which do not
Exit interviews
Employee performance document
ligo@macfast.org

144

Principles of Learning
Goal Setting

Goals and objectives of training are clearly communicated to


the trainees

Meaningful presentation

Materials should be meaningfully arranged and subsequent


information build up on previous information

Practice and repetition

Trainees should be given an opportunity to practice what


have been learned

Feedback and reinforcement

Knowledge about how well one has performed is motivating.


Verbal encouragement or other extrinsic rewards reinforce
desired behaviour

Whole Vs part learning

Complex jobs should be broken down in to parts

Massed Vs spaced learning

Practicing a new skill with rest pauses in between ( spaced ) is


more effective than massed practice

Individual differences

People learn at different rates and in different styles

Transfer of learning

Transfer occurs when trainees use on their job what they


have learned in training.
ligo@macfast.org

145

Classifications of training and


Development Methods
T& D methods

On- the job


Methods

Training methods
Apprenticeship
Job instruction
training

Off- the-job methods

Training Methods
Class- room
Development Method
instruction
Coaching/understudy
Lectures
Job rotation
Seminars and
Special/ committee
conferences
assignments
Programmed
internship
instruction
ligo@macfast.org
Audio visuals

Development methods
Simulation
Case study
Role play
Management games
In basket
Behaviour modeling
Outdoor oriented
programmes 146

Stages of Training Evaluation


Pre training evaluation

Training Evaluation

Intermediate evaluation

Post training evaluation

ligo@macfast.org

147

Donald Kirkpatricks Evaluation Model


Level

Questions

1.Reacton

Were the participants pleased with the programme?

2.Learning

What did the participants learn in the programme?

3.Behaviour

Did the participants change their behaviour based on


what they have learned?

4.Results

Did the change in the behaviour positively affect the


organisation?

ligo@macfast.org

148

Types of evaluation criteria


Evaluation
criteria

Data Collection methods

Information Obtained

Reactions

Administering questionnaires at the end


of each session or day or at the end of the
programme, popularly known as course
evaluation form

Trainees degree of
satisfaction with
The trainer
Subject matter and content
Training environment

Learning

Paper and pencil tests


Performance tests
Simulation tests

Trainees level of
understanding before and
after the training to determine
gains in knowledge

Behaviour

Performance appraisal
Observation of trainees on job
Interviews with thee trainees and their
managers

Ratings of trainees before and


after training to assess the
degree to which training has
changed their performance

Results

Productivity data records


Annual reports of company
Measures such as turnover, grievances,
absenteeism, sales target etc

Before and after data on


performance criteria
measures.

ligo@macfast.org

149

Special forms of training and


development

Team training
Diversity training
Training for global assignments
Training for leadership skills
Orientation training

ligo@macfast.org

150

Checklist of Topics in an
Orientation programme
Company History
Organisations purpose and
strategy
List of Chain of command
Who are the key executives
Introductions
to
other
employees
Expectations for attendance,
conduct and appearance

Conditions of employment
Explanation of job duties,
standards and appraisal criteria
Safety regulations
Rules,
Policies
and
procedures(
Standard
Operating Procedures manual)

ligo@macfast.org

151

Roles of HR and Line in Orientation


Training Program
Orientation Training
Roles and Responsibilities

HR Manager
Co-ordinate activities
Provide information about
conditions of employment
Provide general
organizational information

ligo@macfast.org

Line manger
Prepare the workgroup to receive
the new employee
Provide information on
newcomers responsibilities
Provide information about
expected performance standards
Introduce newcomers to coworkers and subculture of
workgroup
Provide feedback and coaching

152

New Developments in Training and


Development
New Developments

Technology and training


Computer- based training
Distance training and video conferencing
E- training

ligo@macfast.org

Competency- based approach to


development
Competency assessment
Competency modeling

153

Technology and Training


Computer based training (CBT)
Computer assisted instruction (CAI)
Computer managed instruction ( CMI)
Virtual reality training
Distance training and video conferencing

ligo@macfast.org

154

Technology and Training


Computer based training (CBT)
Organisations use computers to train employees
especially in technical skills
IN CBT , the trainee uses computer based systems to
interactively increase his/ her knowledge and skills.
It uses multimedia, audio animation, graphics, and
interactive videos and photos.
Two types of techniques used in CBT , they are
Computer assisted instruction (CAI)
Computer managed instruction ( CMI)
ligo@macfast.org

155

Technology and Training


Computer assisted instruction (CAI)
CAI delivers training material directly to the trainee
through a computer terminal in an interactive format.
These are expert systems that are used to tutor the
trainee, monitor trainee knowledge and provide
adaptive tutoring based on the responses of the trainee

Computer managed instruction ( CMI)


CMI uses computer to manage the administrative
functions of training such as registration , record
keeping, scoring, grading etc.

Virtual reality training


It places the trainee in a simulated situation , which is
ligo@macfast.org
156
virtually same as the
physical environment

Technology and Training


Distance Training and video conferencing
Tele-training
It involves offering training program over satellite based
network.
The trainer is in a central location and the teaches a
group of employees at remote location.

Video conferencing
Through audiovisual equipment, video conferencing
allows people form geographically dispersed locations
to communicate live with each other.
ligo@macfast.org

157

Technology and Training


E- training/ cyber learning
Its a high tech training method which uses internet or
the intranet of an organisation to conduct training
online.
Employee training is managed online and e- learning is
used for skill Upgradation.

ligo@macfast.org

158

Competency- based approach to


development
Competency:
Its a cluster of related knowledge, skills and attitudes
that affects a major part of an individual job, that
correlates with performance on the job, that can be
measured against well- accepted standards and that
can be improved via training and development (
Training magazine, July 1999)

ligo@macfast.org

159

Competency Assesment
Its is the process of identifying the competencies among a
group of employees.
Task analysis Vs competency assessment
Task analysis bases training on what people do,
whereas competency assessment bases training on
who the successful performers are
Task analysis focuses on jobs with an emphasis on
psychomotor skills whereas competency assessment
conducts training for employees who perform decision
making tasks and are knowledge workers such as
mangers and professionals
ligo@macfast.org

160

Competency Model
A competency model is a success profile created on
the basis of competency assessment.
A competency model is an organizing frame work
that list the competencies required for effective
performance in a specific job, organisation or a
process.
These competencies are associated with exemplary
performers and tied to corporate culture.

ligo@macfast.org

161

ligo@macfast.org

162

ligo@macfast.org

163

ligo@macfast.org

164

ligo@macfast.org

165

Strategic Approach to Competency


Assessment
The approach consists of five main building blocks
The strategic review
Identifying strategic areas of competence
Determining competency requirements
Assessing competency gap( competency requirement & Competency
possessed by employees)
Application( Managers competencies are tested in this stage) i
Every line manager should engage in at least 4 activities which relate to
performance in job ( selection, assessment, development & Succession)
ligo@macfast.org

166

HRM 09 - Strategic Human


Resource Management
Module-IV

ligo@macfast.org

HRM 09 - Strategic Human Resource


Management
Module IV
Strategic
Performance
Management,
Compensation and Employee RelationsPerformance Measurement approaches-Effective
performance
Measurement-Compensation
Reward Approaches-Trends in Top level Executive
Compensation-Strategic Linkage of Performance
Management and CompensationManaging Employee Relations: Unions and
Strategic Collective Bargaining.
ligo@macfast.org

Performance Appraisal to
performance management
Performance appraisal is a system by which an organisation
assigns some score to indicate the level of current and/or past
performance of a person.
Performance management is an integrated process that
consolidates

goal

setting,

employee

development,

performance appraisal and rewarding performance in to a


single common system.

Objectives of Performance
management
Human resource planning
Recruitment and selection
Personnel decisions such as promotions, layoff
etc
Career planning and development
Feedback motivation and development
Training and development
Compensation and rewards

Classification of performance
management objectives
Classification of performance
management objectives

Evaluative Objectives
Validating selections
Bonuses and incentives
Promotions
Salary increases
Manager is a judge and make reward
decisions

Development Objectives
Feedback
Motivation
Training and development
Career planning
Human resource planning
Manager is a coach who helps in
performance improvement

Developing performance
management systems
Identifying dimensions of job performance
Defining and communicating performance standards
Determining who will conduct the appraisal
Choosing appropriate methods of performance appraisal
Communicating appraisals to employees

Process of performance
Management system

Types of Performance Evaluation


Criteria
Types of evaluation Criteria

Trait based
Seeks information about
subjective characteristics
such as attitude, initiative
etc
Graphic rating scales
Essay method
Ranking method
Forced distribution method

Behaviour Based
Performance measure
focus on specific
behaviours that lead to
success on the job
Critical- incident
method
Checklists
Behaviorally anchored
rating scales

Results Based
Measurement is easy
and there is a tangible
output
Productivity measures
Management by
objectives

Behaviorally Anchored Rating Scales (BARS):


Its a combination of rating scale and critical incident
technique.
The procedure for BARS is usually five stepped.
Collect the critical incidents
Identify performance dimension
Reclassification of incidents
Assigning scale values to the incidents
Producing the final instrument

BARS

Determining who will conduct


performance evaluation

Appraisal by manager or supervisor


Self appraisal
Subordinate appraisal
Peer appraisal
Team appraisal
Customer appraisal
Multisource feedback

Sl Classification Approaches
No
I

Absolute measures evaluate employees


performance standards of the job

Methods of performance
Appraisal
relative

to BARS, Graphic rating scales,


CIT, Checklists

Relative measures evaluate employees in comparison to co- Ranking, Paired comparison,


workers
forced distribution
II

Category rating methods evaluate employees against a Graphic


standard
checklists

rating

scale,

Comparative methods evaluates employees by comparing Ranking, Forced distribution


the performance against each other
Narrative methods assess employees by describing their Essay
actions and behaviours
Behavioural methods evaluate employees behaviour instead BARS
of their characteristics
III

Trait based methods measure the extent to which an Graphic Rating scale, Forced
employee possesses certain characteristics important for choice
method,
forced
job
distribution
Behaviour based methods describe which actions should be CIT, BARS, checklists
exhibited on the job
Results
based
methods
evaluate
employees Productivity measures, MBO
accomplishments they achieve through their work

Problems in Performance
Management
Ambivalence towards
performance evaluation on the
part of appraiser and appraise

Problems in performance
management system

Problems in design and


implementation of performance
management system

Rater biases and errors

Rater errors
Rater Errors

Brief Description

Varying standards

Managers appraise different employees by using different


standards and expectations

Recency effect

Managers gives higher weightages to most recent instances


of performance

Primacy effect

Information about individual performance obtained first


gets the highest weightage

Central tendency error

Appraiser avoids using high or low ratings and rates all


employees as falling in a narrow range, everyone is average

Leniency error

Appraise rates all employees at higher end of the scale as


good performers

Strictness error

All employees are assigned low ratings

Personal bias error

A manager may have personal bias against a particular


caste, nationality, or region

Rater errors
Rater Errors

Brief Description

Halo effect

A manager rates an employee high on all performance


criteria because of high performance on a single criterion

Contrast error

Employees are rated relative to others rather than to an


objective standard

Similar to me or
different to me

Managers compare the employees against their own


characteristics.

Sampling error

The rater sometimes observes only a small sample of an


employees work. if 95 % of the work of the employee has
been very good, but the boss saw only the 5% that was
unsatisfactory, the supervisor is likely to rate the employee
as a poor performer.

Strategic Choices in Performance


Management systems
Purpose of the system
Evaluative or developmental

Who evaluates
What to evaluate
Traits, Behaviour, results

Approaches to evaluation
Absolute/ Relative

Means/Tools of evaluation

Characteristics of effective
performance management systems
Separation of evaluative and development
appraisal
Use of job related performance criteria
Effective
performance
management
system

Specifying performance standards for each


criteria
Using appropriate performance data
Improving superior- subordinate relationship
Providing on-going feedback
Upward appraisals
Using multiple raters
Training raters
Appeal process
Top management support and fit with
organisational culture

Strategic linkage of performance


management

Linkage between organization life cycle , competitive


status, organizational strategy & hr strategy
Org. Life
Cycle

Competiti
ve status
of the
firm.

Org.
strategie
s

Needed
employee
characteristic

HR strategy

Aligning
performance
mgt.

Inception
[startup]

Weak

Value
creation

Innovative.
Risk - taking.
Long term
orientation

Focus on
exploratory
knowledge of
employees

Qualitative
methods

Growth

Strong

Value
accumul
ation

Flexibility
Co -operative

Focus on
exploitative
knowledge

Quantitative
methods

maturity

Stable

Value
maintena
nce

Efficiency
Results with
low level of
risk

Harvest
strategy to
maintain
competitive
status

Qualitative
methods

Strategic performance management


system.
Step 1

Step 2

Step 3

Identify competitive
status of the firm.

Determine strategies.

Align the performance


management system.

Internal analysis of
strengths and
weaknesses of the
organization.

Setting corporate
strategy.
Setting HR strategy.
Determine needed
employee behaviors.

Define performance
criteria.
Select the type of
appraisal method.

Compensation and rewards


management

Compensation and rewards


Compensation is the sum total of all forms of payments and
rewards provided to employees for performing tasks to
achieve organisational objectives.

Total Compensation

Financial
(Extrinsic rewards)

Direct
Wages , salaries,
incentives, bonus etc

Indirect
Benefits

Non- financial
Intrinsic rewards

Satisfaction derived
from job

Praise and
recognition

Components of financial compensation and Rewards


Components of Financial
Compensation

Indirect
Direct
Benefit
Base pay
Wage
Salary

Variable pay
Individual incentives
Group/ team
incentives
Organisation wide
incentives

Mandatory
benefits
Provident fund
Gratuity
Maternity leave
Medical leave

Voluntary benefits
Paid holidays
Family friendly
benefits
Retirement benefits

Job Evaluation Methods


Job evaluation is the process of determining the relative value
of job to assign wage rate to job
Method

Description

Ranking

Examine each job description and arrange the job in the order of
importance

Classification

Jobs are classified and grouped in to a number of grades. Each successive


grade or class requires increasing amounts of job responsibility, skill, ability
etc

Factor
comparison

Evaluators establish the relative degree of difficulty of each compensable


factors ( mental effort, skill, physical effort, responsibility and working
conditions ) for each key job. The monetary rates assigned to each job on
each factor are added to obtain the total monetary value of job

Point

The job is broken down in to specific components such as skill, effort,


responsibility etc. and numerical values are assigned to each of these
components. Weights are assigned to each job component depending on
the relative importance of each criterion on performing job.

Type of incentives

Description

Individual incentives
Piecework plans

(Number of units produced) X (Rate per unit)

Merit pay

Salary increase for performance. Increase becomes part of base salary

Bonus

One time payment and not become part of base salary

Individual incentives for sales personnel


Salary plan

Sales personnel are paid fixed salary

Commission

Salespeople are paid for results

Combination plan

Combination of salary and commission

Group/ team based incentives


Gain sharing

Share of greater than expected profit with the employees

Organisational incentives
Profit sharing plans

Employees receive a share of the firms annual profit

Employee stock option


plans ( ESOP)

Allow the employee to gain stock ownership in the organisation

Structuring the benefits for the


employees
One- Size
fits- all
Approach

Flexible Approach/
cafeteria approach

Segmentation
Organisations segment the employees in to categories and customize the
compensation package based on what employees of that category wants.

Compensation and rewardsDeterminants

Internal Determinants
Compensation policy of the
organisation
Employers ability to pay
Worth of a job

Pay levels

External determinants
Labour market conditions
Economic conditions
Area wage rates
Government controls
Cost of living
Union influences

Equity in reward decisions


Perceptions of equity and inequity
Equity perception

Self

Significant others

Outcomes

outcomes

inputs

inputs

Inequity perception
Under compensation
inequity

Outcomes

Overcompensation
inequity

outcomes

inputs
inputs

<

outcomes
inputs
outcomes

>

inputs

Types of Equity
Types of Equity

Internal Equity
Employees
are
paid
according to relative value
of their jobs

External equity
Employees
are
paid
comparable to employees
performing similar jobs in
other organisations

Individual Equity
Compensation based on
performance
appraisal
and perceived as fair
when compared with
what others in similar jobs
in the organisation are
earning/ ensure equal pay
for equal job.

Executive Compensation
Compensation or remuneration for the executive
managers is different from that of other employees
in most the organizations.
Executive compensation covers employees of the
C-Suite. which include presidents of company, chief
executive officers (CEOs), chief financial officers
(CFOs), vice presidents, occasionally directors of the
company, and other upper-level managers.

ligo@macfast.org

Indian Top executive pay chart in


Indian corporate sector: 2014

Bharti Airtel's Sunil Mittal (Rs 21.3 crore)


Hindalco's D Bhattacharya (Rs 19.5 crore)
JSW Steel's Sajjan Jindal (Rs 18.18 crore)
Amara Raja Batteries' Jayadev Galla (Rs 17.23 crore).

Components of executive
compensation

Perquisites
Long term incentives
Short Term Incentives/Annual Bonus
Executive Salary

ligo@macfast.org

Executive salary
Salaries of executives vary by type of job, size
of organization, region of the country, and
industry.
On average, salaries make up about 40-60% of
the
typical
top
executive's
annual
compensation total.

ligo@macfast.org

Executive Bonus plans


STIs( short term incentives) are designed to motivate the
short term performance of managers and are tied to company
profitability.
Bonus is tied to some performance measure like return on
investment, earnings per share, or net profits before taxes.
Short-term incentives are paid on quarterly or annual
performance
Eg: Sales Director's performance related bonus may be based
on incremental revenue growth turnover

ligo@macfast.org

Performance incentives-long term


incentives
Performance-based incentives attempt to tie executive
compensation to the long-term growth and success of the
organization.
ESOP-( Employee stock options Plan) A stock option gives an
individual the right to buy stock in a company, usually at an
advantageous price.

ligo@macfast.org

Long term incentives for Executives


Type

Description

Phantom stock option

company promises to pay cash at some future date, in an


amount equal to the market value of a number of shares of
its stock. Allows executives to hold shares without owing
them personally.

Stock appreciation
rights (SAR)

Certain number of shares are allotted to the employee. After


the vesting period, the employee is free to exercise his
options, and if the value of the share is appreciated he is
given share or cash worth his appreciated value. If shares are
allocated he can sell it after a lock in period.

Restricted stock plans

Grants of stock at a reduced price with the condition that it


may not be sold before a specified date

Sweat equity

Refers to the equity shares issued by a company to


employees or directors at a discount for providing knowhow
or some sort of value addition.
ligo@macfast.org

Executive perquisites
Perquisites (perks) are special executive benefitsusually
noncash items.
Perks are useful in tying executives to organizations and in
demonstrating their importance to the companies.
Visible symbols of status allow executives to be seen as "very
important people (VIPs)" both inside and outside their
organizations.
Perks can offer substantial tax savings because many perks
are not taxed as income.

ligo@macfast.org

Perquisites
Transportation

Financial/ Legal

Memberships

Company car

Financial planning

Country club

First class air travel

Tax planning

Health club

Company air plane usage

No or low interest loans

Special dining privileges

Spouse travel

Legal counselling

ligo@macfast.org

Recent trends in CEOs


compensation
ESOP- Employee stock option plan
Retention bonus
Free residence ( if the employee stays on, the organisation
gifts to the employee the house that he/she is living in)
Joining bonus or a golden hello ( to compensate the loss of
the existing job)
Severance pay ( if one party decides to cancel the contract, it
will pay a certain amount to other
Pre-joining holiday
A golden parachute (is an agreement between a company and
an employee (usually upper executive) specifying that the
employee will receive certain significant benefits if
employment is terminated. )

Business strategy and


compensation strategy linkage
Business strategy
Miles and Snow Typology

Compensation strategy

Defender ( maintain current market Mechanistic strategy


share)
Provide pay package and policies to
maintain in grown talent needed to
enhance the existing business
Reward work experience
Prospector ( actively search for new
products and markets and pursue
opportunities both within and outside
current area of expertise)

Organic strategy
Seek external equity in compensation
strategies
Higher level of incentive pay
Reward outcomes rather than behaviour
used to attain goals

Analyzer

Mixed compensation strategy


Provides both control and autonomy

Organisational life cycle and


compensation strategy
Organisational life cycle Compensation strategy

Start up stage

Low base pay ( to conserve cash)


High emphasis on incentive pay
Low benefits ( to control costs)

Growth stage

High dependence on incentive pay to attract and retain


R&D scientists and engineers
Stock options, profit sharing, bonus

Mature stage

Less likely to use incentive pay strategy

Decline stage

High base salary and benefits


Less flexibility to offer pay incentives

Managing Employee Relations:


Unions and Strategic Collective
Bargaining.

Significance of IR
Industrial relations is concerned with anticipating, addressing
workplace issues that may interfere with an organizations
business objectives, as also with resolving disputes between
and among management and employees.

Trade Unions
It refers to an association of workers who are from
one or more different department coming together
with the aim of protecting and safeguarding their
interest and fulfilling the unfulfilled need, if any.

Why do workers join Union


Motivation to join Union
Greater Bargaining Power.
Make their Voices Heard.
Minimize Discrimination.
Sense of Security.
Sense of Participation.
Sense of Belongingness.

Why Employers Dislike Union?

Perception of reduced managerial power


Threat of strike and loss of market
Delay in decision making
Fear of losing employee commiyment and
loyalty

Objectives of Trade Unions

Wages and salaries


Working conditions
Discipline
Welfare
Employee- employer relationship
Negotiating machinery

Collective Bargaining
Its a process by which representatives of
management and workers negotiate over
wages, hours and other terms and conditions
of employment.

Legal Framework of collective


bargaining
Trade union Act 1926
Allows 7 or more workmen for forming an association
or trade union and get registered by Registrars of Trade
Union in each state

Industrial dispute Act 1947


Provides protection to workmen in exercise of their
rights to organize or form trade union for the purpose
of collective bargaining

Industrial employment Act 1946


Defines conditions of employment in an organisation.

Collective Bargaining process


Environment
Preparing for negotiation
Bargaining Issues
Negotiating
Negotiation
Breakdown

Yes

No
Reaching the Agreement
Ratifying the Agreement
Administration of the
Agreement

Overcoming Breakdowns

Types of Bargaining
Conjunctive/distributive/bargaining
Each parties tries to maximize their respective
gains

Cooperative bargaining
Both parties tries to negotiate the terms of
employment in a flexible way

Types of Bargaining
Productivity bargaining
Productivity standards are set and if the workers
exceed the standard they will get substantial
benefit

Composite bargaining
Workers bargain for things other than wages and
working conditions like sub contracting,
environmental policies etc.

Advantages in Union Involvement


in Company strategic Plan

Cost Control Through Productivity bargaining


Credibility to strategy Information
Strategic suggestion from the Union
Ease in strategy Implementation

HRM 09 - Strategic Human


Resource Management
Module-V

ligo@macfast.org

HRM 09 - Strategic Human Resource


Management
Module V
Global Environment of HR-Change &
Diversity-Difference between Global HRM and
Domestic HRM-Cross Cultural contextStrategic HR Issues in Global AssignmentsCompetencies of HR Professional in a SHRM
Scenario.

ligo@macfast.org

Introduction

Internationalization of business
Globalization is gaining momentum
Markets are no longer protected from foreign competition
A large proportion of workforce is located in other countries away from
their home and home countries
Quality human resources are a must for implementing global competitive
strategies.
Organisations differ in the degree of internationalization

International Human Resource


Management
All those activities undertaken by an organization to utilize its human
resources effectively make HRM.
Those activities include:
Human Resource Planning
Staffing
Performance management
Training and development
Compensation and benefits
Labor relations
The above activities will have a change whenever a firm or its HRM goes
international.

A Model of IHRM

225

HR Activities
The three broad human resource activities:
procurement, allocation, and utilization.

Type of countries involved


The three national or country categories
involved in international HRM activities:
The host country where a subsidiary may be located
The home country where the firm is headquartered
Other countries that may be the source of labor or
finance.

Type of Employees
The three types of employees of an international
firm:
Host-country nationals (HCNs),
Parent -country nationals (PCNs)
Third country nationals (TCNs).
Eg: IBM employs Australian citizens (HCNs) in its
Australian operations, often sends U.S. citizens
(PCNs) to Asia-Pacific countries on assignment, and
may send some of its Singaporean employees on all
assignment to its Japanese operations (as TCNs).

IHRM-Defnition
Process of managing people in international
settings.
Morgan defines international HRM as the interplay
among these three dimensions-human resource
activities, types of employees, and countries of
operation.

Difference between Domestic HRM


and IHRM
International human Resource
Management

Domestic HRM

Addresses a broad range of HRM activities Addresses a narrow range of HR activities


HR issues relate to employees belonging
to more than one nationality

HR issues relate to employees belonging


to single nationality

Greater involvement of HR manager in


the personal life of employees

Limited involvement of HR manager in the


personal life of employees

Greater exposure to risks in international


assignments

Limited risks in domestic assignments

Has to manage several external factors


such as government regulation of foreign
country

Limited external factors to deal with.

More HR Activities
International environment requires the HR
department to undertake more HR activities than
those in domestic HR.
They are :

Pre-departure training for international assignments.


international relocation and orientation
host government relations
language translation services
international taxation
Compensation issues in international assignments
Repatriation

International staffing- Sources of Staffing


international Business operations
Parent Country Nationals
(PCNs)

Host Country Nationals(HCNs)


International staffing Sources

Third Country Nationals( TCNs)

Three sources of international staffing


Advantages

Parent country nationals


(PCN)

Host Country
Nationals (HCN)

Third country
nationals (TCN)

ensure proper linkage


between foreign
subsidiary and the
headquarters

Are familiar with


local norms and
culture
Not expensive like
PCN

Are less costly than


PCN
Have substantial
international
experience

May have a local


view rather than a
global view about
the operation

TCNs pose greater


HR challenges in
terms of cross
cultural diversity
management

When the
subsidiary is well
established
To establish
networks locally for
business expansion

Have proven
technical expertise

Disadvantages Expensive
Lack of awareness about
local culture

Most suitable

When MNC is in the


start-up phase
To ensure that foreign
subsidiary complies with
policies of headquarters
When host country lacks
technical expertise.

Approaches to managing and


staffing subsidiaries of MNCs
Three Approaches to managing
subsidiaries of MNCs

Ethnocentric

Polycentric

Regiocentric

Geocentric

Ethnocentric approach
Parent -country nationals hold the key positions.
This means that few subsidiaries have any autonomy
and the strategic decisions are made at
headquarters.
Headquarters management personnel hold key jobs
in either domestic or foreign operations.
Expatriates manage subsidiaries.
Eg: korean firms in india such as LG, Samsung,
Hyundai.

Polycentric approach
Polycentric approach uses host-country nationals to
staff the subsidiary while parent country nationals
hold positions at headquarters.
In this context, the multinational enterprise treats
each subsidiary as a distinct national entity with
some decision making autonomy.
Local nationals are rarely promoted to positions at
headquarters.
PCNs are also never posted to foreign subsidiary.

Regiocentric approach
In a regiocentric approach regional staff are utilized
and developed for positions anywhere within the
region.
In this approach, regional managers may not be
promoted to Headquarters positions but enjoy a
degree of regional autonomy in decision making.

Geocentric approach
Focuses on competence and ability rather than
nationality.
Develops international executive team having cross
cultural skills.

The phases of cultural adjustment

The phases of adjustment


Phase -1: Tourist
At the beginning of the assignment , everything
seems to be different and unique
Expatriate experience (positive emotions)
excitement, surprise, (negative emotions) fear,
frustrations at this phase
This phase is also known as honeymoon period for
expatriate

The phases of adjustment


Phase 2: culture shock
Expatriates starts realizing the differences between
home and host country and feeling of culture shock
sets in.
This is the most critical time in the expatriates life

Phase 3: pulling up
Expatriate begins to adapt to the foreign culture and
gradually moves to a neutral state

The phases of adjustment


Phase 4: Adjustment
Expatriate is naturalized to a great extent.
This phase represent healthy recovery from initial
shock.
Expatriate focus on the task at hand.

CCT- Cross Cultural Training


Success of an Expat largely depends on how
fast he/she can acculturate in a host country.
Acculturation demands the expats to be aware
of the culture of the host country.
MNCs offer CCT to teach the expats about the
host countries appropriate norms and
behaviour

Two phases of pre departure Training


programme ( Guy and Mattock 1991)
Sl No

Phases of Training programme

Content of the Programme Phase

For the manager

Job description
Objectives and goals of the manager
Relationship between the subsidiary and
the parent company and with other
subsidiaries
Management practices of the host country
Political, legal and economic environments
of the host country.

For the manager and his/ her


family

Language training
Area study ( host countrys culture,
climate, geography, currency etc)
Cross cultural training

Causes of failure of expatriate


Managers
Bad selection
Cultural adjustment
Lack of understanding of work practices of the
foreign country
Failure of family to adjust to the foreign
country
Poor performance
Repatriation issues

Strategic HR issues in global


assignments

Pre departure training for international assignments


Language training
Cultural training
Managing personal and family life
Performance management on international
assignments
International compensation
Repatriation

Challenges of Performance
appraisal in IHRM

Cultural Adjustment
Host Country Environment
Variations in the stages of business
Separations by time and distance
Rater Bias/ Rater competencies
Non comparable data

International compensation
package
The major components of International
compensation includes

Home Leave and Travel Allowance


Childrens Education Allowance
Currency Differential payment
Relocation allowance
Housing Allowance
Cost of living adjustment (COLA)
Payment to protect from negative tax consequences
Hardship posting allowance

Repatriation
Is the process of bringing an expatriate home
after he/she has completed the international
assignment.
Fears and concerns of expatriates

Key characteristics required for


success in global Assignments

Organisational Requirements
Technical abilities
Job related skills
Managerial skills
Organisational knowledge

Cultural Adjustment
Cultural Empathy
Cultural Adaptability
Diversity Awareness
Global Exposure
Diplomatic skills

Personal Characteristics
Flexibility and risk taking
Emotional stability and maturity
Tolerance of Ambiguity
Coping with stress

Key Characteristics
required for Global
Assignments

Personal / Family Factors


Personal life demands
Adaptability of family
Career development
Financial concerns

Communication skills
Language capabilities
Nonverbal awareness
Conflict resolution Abilities

You might also like