Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Diet 3231w
Cover Letter
By,
Andrew Crotty
I.
Introduction
It is a general consensus that obesity is a major health concern, and a
pandemic in the world. In the United States and from the Behavioral Risk
Factor Surveillance System, the prevalence in adults ranges from as high as
>35% in West Virginia, Arizona, and Mississippi to between 20 and 25% in
California, Colorado, Massachusetts, and Vermont (figure 1). The rate of
obesity is on the rise. According to the National Health and Nutrition
Examination Survey, the national rate of obesity rate rose 1.5% from 2011 to
2014 (CDC 2014). Such evidence propels the need for action on factors that
contribute to or diminish the prevalence of obesity. Obesity is related to
energy imbalance, whereas caloric intake outweighs energy expenditure.
Acting on obesity starts with the younger generation, whom develop their life
long habits during their adolescent years.
Adolescents are significantly affected by obesity based on their obesity
rate, which is contributed to by the lack of efforts to lose weight and
excessive television viewing. Based on data from the United States, and the
High School Youth Risk Behavior Survey the rate of obesity in adolescents
has risen from 10.6% in 1999 to 13.7% in 2013 (HSYRBS 2013). Contributing
to this is the fact only 52.3% of adolescent claimed to be attempting to lose
weight. Another contributing factor is evident as 32.5% of adolescents report
watching television for over three hours daily. Energy imbalance can be
The Youth Risk Behavior Survey reports that in 2013, out of 13,228
adolescent students, 52% do not attend physical education on at least one
day per week. This figure includes 57% of females and 46.7% of men (YRBS).
In accordance, females were less likely to participate in adequate moderate
to vigorous physical activity. In analysis of data, adolescents ability to be
active for at least 60 minutes per day on at least 5 days produced similar
results; 63% of females were unable to meet this exercise goal, while less
than 43% of males fell short.
According to the 2015 Dietary Guidelines, adolescents should engage
in 60 minutes of MVPA on at least three days of the week (DG 2015). Only
27.1% of students surveyed had participated in at least 60 minutes of
activity per day (CDC 2013). The comparison of the YRBSS and these
recommendations demonstrate a great discrepancy between exercise
recommendations and exercise obtainment, and therefore, obtainment of
MVPA.
By searching disparities youth physical activity in PubMed, 315
studies were discovered. The study reviewed was chosen due to its ability to
identify any disparities in physical activity over age, race, and gender
differences amongst adolescents.
A secondary analysis of NHANES revealed lower activity levels among
females, and adolescents relative to children (Gortmaker, Lee et al. 2012).
Race disparities in physical activity were also found. This secondary analysis
reviewed objective accelerometer data from the National Health and
upon follow up, the participants, at median age of 46 years at the end of the
follow up, were rather young relative to the age that high blood pressure
typically occurs.
This was based on survey responses in regards to physical activity and SBM
use occurring in a typical week (Iannotti, Kogan et al. 2009).
Through analysis of these various studies it becomes abundantly clear
that socio-ecological factors can attribute to the inability of adolescents to
maintain an active lifestyle. The research also clarifies that it is improbable
that lack of physical activity is resulting from a sole barrier. Rather,
diminished activity can be occurring due to a multitude of factors in
combination of one another.
V. Interventions directed at increasing MVPA
This section will review data analyzing interventions designed to
overcome socio-ecological barriers hindering MVPA obtainment. Research
involved PubMed a search with the term vigorous physical activity while
restricting to meta-analysis. This search uncovered 45 articles. Metaanalyses selected were those demonstrated a high level of data quality and
that thoroughly determined the relative abilities of interventions in
promoting MVPA in adolescents.
A meta-analysis of 14 studies revealed that interventions can be
successful in increasing the amount of time spent in MVPA (Lonsdale,
Rosenkranz et al. 2013). These results are depicted in Figure 3. The
generalized types of intervention included teaching strategy, fitness infusion,
and other interventions. Teaching strategy interventions require alteration of
Figure 3: This forest plot was obtained from the study, A systematic review
and meta-analysis of interventions designed to increase moderate-tovigorous physical activity in school physical education lessons. It serves to
reiterate findings of success in regards to increases of physical activity as
result of interventions.
A successful infusion intervention involved 86 adolescents is
demonstrated in one study, which was included in the meta-analysis. The
results of this study suggest that incorporating intervals of MVPA into skill
improve the physical activity levels of children: Design and rationale of the
Active Classrooms cluster randomized controlled trial was uncovered.
This cluster randomized control study is currently underway and
consists of an eight-week classroom based intervention directed at
increasing MVPA students. Subjects are the students of randomly selected
primary schools in Ireland. The outcome will be measured in change of time
spent performing MVPA. The intervention itself is targeted at increasing
classroom-based physical activity. The findings of this study will be crucial in
determining the effectiveness of incorporation of physical activity into the
classroom setting in regards to raising MVPA (Martin, Murtagh 2015b).
Another meta-analysis that has since been completed has found that
walking to and from school could contribute significantly to MVPA obtainment
in school aged children (4-19 years old). The meta-analysis reviewed studies
that used objective data in the form of heart rate monitoring, or
accelerometry to quantify active commuting in the form of walking and its
effect on MVPA. The study aimed to determine whether activiley
communiting to school, in the form of walking, could significantly contirbute
MVPA to the lives of school aged children. The samples analyzed included
3422 children along with 2600 adolescents from studies in Europe and the
United States.
The MVPA accumulated during the day when adolescents commuted
actively was increased by an average of 13 minutes per day. For those who
actively commuted, the analysis showed the commute contibuted 36% of
daily MVPA on schooldays. Similar results were found in the studies involving
children, whereas they gained and average of 17minutes of MVPA per school
day. These results emphasize the importance of commuting actively to
obtainment of MVPA in adolescents and children.
All studies used were rated as high quality, meaning the meta-analysis
presents a high level of evidence. However, the study could be limited by its
lack of inclusiveness (only 13 studies) due to strict criteria. An example of
this is the fact that no studies were used that were carried out prior to 2004,
this was to keep the information recent and relevant. Regardless of
limitations, this study demonstrates a direct correlation to increased MVPA as
a result of active commuting. This suggests intervations such as policy
adjustment or promotion of active commuting could likely be succesful
interventions in regards to increasing MVPA in adolescents (Martin, Boyle et
al. 2016).
In the context of the ability for pupils to obtain physical activity by
actively commuting to school, perceived neighborhood disorder is taken
under consideration. It has been determined that neighborhood disorder
negatively influences MVPA, therefore making it intuitive that it has this
same effect upon students willingness to actively commute to school. With
this in mind, policies have intervened in hopes of establishing routes to
school that are perceived as safe for students to walk. The Safe Routes to
School National Partnership is a non-profit that advances policy change that
increases neighborhood walkability in terms of students safely traveling to
BIBLIOAGRAPHY
BRONIKOWSKI, M., LAUDANSKA-KRZEMINSKA, I., BRONIKOWSKA, M. and
MORINA, B., 2015. How is Classmate and Pe Teacher Support Associated with
the Level of Physical Activity in Young Adolescents from Kosovo? the Role of
Gender and Age. Central European journal of public health, 23(3), pp. 252257.
CRUMP, C., SUNDQUIST, J., WINKLEBY, M.A. and SUNDQUIST, K., 2016.
Interactive Effects of Physical Fitness and Body Mass Index on the Risk of
Hypertension. JAMA internal medicine, 176(2), pp. 210-216.
DULIN-KEITA, A., KAUR THIND, H., AFFUSO, O. and BASKIN, M.L., 2013. The
associations of perceived neighborhood disorder and physical activity with
obesity among African American adolescents. BMC public health, 13, pp.
440-2458-13-440.
FIELDS, L.E., BURT, V.L., CUTLER, J.A., HUGHES, J., ROCCELLA, E.J. and
SORLIE, P., 2004. The burden of adult hypertension in the United States 1999
to 2000: a rising tide. Hypertension, 44(4), pp. 398-404.
GORTMAKER, S.L., LEE, R., CRADOCK, A.L., SOBOL, A.M., DUNCAN, D.T. and
WANG, Y.C., 2012. Disparities in youth physical activity in the United States:
2003-2006. Medicine and science in sports and exercise, 44(5), pp. 888-893.
JODKOWSKA, M., MAZUR, J. and OBLACINSKA, A., 2015. Perceived barriers to
physical activity among Polish adolescents. Przeglad epidemiologiczny,
69(1), pp. 73-8, 169-73.
LONSDALE, C., ROSENKRANZ, R.R., PERALTA, L.R., BENNIE, A., FAHEY, P. and
LUBANS, D.R., 2013. A systematic review and meta-analysis of interventions
designed to increase moderate-to-vigorous physical activity in school
physical education lessons. Preventive medicine, 56(2), pp. 152-161.
MARTIN, A., BOYLE, J., CORLETT, F., KELLY, P. and REILLY, J.J., 2016.
Contribution of Walking to School to Individual and Population ModerateVigorous Intensity Physical Activity: Systematic Review and Meta-Analysis.
Pediatric exercise science, .
MARTIN, R. and MURTAGH, E.M., 2015a. An intervention to improve the
physical activity levels of children: design and rationale of the 'Active
Classrooms' cluster randomised controlled trial. Contemporary clinical trials,
41, pp. 180-191.
Nutrition, Physical Activity and Obesity Data, Trends and Maps web site. U.S.
Department of Health and Human Services, Centers for Disease Control and
Prevention (CDC), National Center for Chronic Disease Prevention and Health
Promotion, Division of Nutrition, Physical Activity and Obesity, Atlanta, GA,
2015.
(Fields LE, Burt VL, Cutler JA, Hughes J, Roccella EJ, Sorlie P. The burden
of adult hypertension in the United States 1999 to 2000: a rising
tide. Hypertension. 2004;44(4):398-404.
Sacchetti, R., Ceciliani, A., Garulli, A., Dallolio, L., Beltrami, P., & Leoni, E.
(2013). Effects of a 2-year school-based intervention of enhanced physical
education in the primary school. The Journal of School Health, 83(9), 639646. doi:10.1111/josh.12076 [doi]