Professional Documents
Culture Documents
THE PROGRAMME
Myanmars Democratic Transition:
What does that mean for the Persecuted Rohingya?
One-Day Open Research Conference, the University of Oxford
Most sessions will be webcast LIVE at
http://live.oxfordvideostreaming.co.uk/myanmarspersecutedrohingya.html
Objectives:
To bring together researchers and practitioners in international law,
history, public health, sociology, politics and economics as well as
Rohingya human rights defenders:
1. to scrutinise and debate the meanings of the terms genocide,
persecution, democratisation and their relationships in theory and in
history;
2. to continue shining a critical spotlight of university and independent
research onto what is increasingly recognized as Myanmars slow
genocide of the Rohingya not only by international genocide and legal
scholars but by world icons such as George Soros, Desmond Tutu,
Mairead Maguire, Amartya Sen, Jody Williams, Shirin Ebadi, and
Adolfo Perez Esquivel, Leymah Gbowee and Tawakkol Karman.
3. to call attention to recent research into the deplorable human
conditions under which over 1 million Rohingya live in vast open
prisons (i.e., Rohingya villages and towns) and Internally Displaced
Persons (IDP) camps, which the New York Times has called the 21st
century concentration camps;
4. to present evidence to convince Myanmars Aung San Suu Kyi
government that the end of decades-long state persecution of the
Rohingya minority should be a top priority; and
5. to brainstorm critical and constructive ideas which may enable
Myanmars democrats to remove one of the greatest obstacles to
genuine democratization the continued destruction of a large
community of people because of their distinct ethnic identity
CONFERENCE AGENDA
Genocide Roundtable:
The Politics of the United Nations, International Human Rights and
Sociology of Genocide
Chair Professor Penny Green, Professor of Law and Globalization &
Director, International State Crime Research Initiative, Queen Mary
University of London
Professor Daniel Feierstein, past President of the International
Association of Genocide Scholars (2013-15) & Director, Centro de Estudios
Sobre at the National University of Argentina and author of Genocide as
Social Practice: Reorganizing Society Under the Nazis and Argentina's
Military Juntas (Rutgers University Press, 2014)
Tomas Ojea Quintana, Human Rights Lawyer & former UN Special
Rapporteur on the human rights situation in Myanmar, (2008-2014)
Shapan Adnan
Shapan Adnan obtained a BA (Honours) degree in Economics from the University of
Sussex and a PhD in Social and Political Sciences from the University of
Cambridge. He is currently an independent scholar based in the UK. He has
formerly taught at the National University of Singapore as well as the Universities
of Dhaka and Chittagong. Shapan Adnan has been a visiting research fellow at the
University of Oxford and is currently an Associate of its Contemporary South Asian
Studies Programme (CSASP). He is a member of the international advisory board of
the Journal of Peasant Studies and the Chittagong Hill Tracts Commission. The
subjects of his research and publications extend across political economy,
sociology, anthropology and development. He has undertaken fieldwork in areas of
Bangladesh bordering Arakan state of Myanmar, including the Chittagong Hill
Tracts and Coxs Bazar district where most of the Rohingya refugees are located
Adnin Armas
Adnin Armas graduated in Philosophy in International Islamic University Malaysia,
1997. He holds a M.A degree in Islamic Thought from the International Institute of
Islamic Thought and Civilization-International Islamic University Malaysia in 2003.
He writes articles and a few books on Islam and its Challenges in Indonesia. He is
the editor in-chief in a magazine, published monthly in Indonesia. He is the
chairman of Indonesian Society Coalition Caring for Rohingya.
I will talk about the stateless Rohingya in Indonesia. Some challenges and
recommendations to overcome them.
Maung Bo Bo
A Burmese native, Bo attended the Institute of Medicine where he earned a
M.B.B.S. More passionate about politics and literature, he spent his teenage years
in his family collection of Burmese books. Bo is a fourth generation writer from a
renowned literary family with a very strong progressive view, which has faced
persecution under successive military regimes. His maternal grandparents, Ludu U
Hla and Daw Ahmar, were Leftist comrades of the late Aung San, Aung San Suu
Kyi's martyred father, and other nationalist leaders and founded anti-colonial
journals such as Kyipwaye (Progress) and Ludu (People) since the 1920's. Bo has
been writing for Burmese publications for almost 20 years, covering politics and
history of Burma. Bo holds a MA in history from SOAS and is currently working
on his PhD on the Burmese military propaganda in Burma, from the early Cold
War period till 1962 when the military led by General Ne Win seized state power
and ended the countrys experiment with parliamentary democracy.
Michael W. Charney
Michael W. Charney is Professor of Asian and Military History at SOAS, The
University of London, where he joined the faculty in 2001 after completing a PhD
dissertation on early modern Arakan at the University of Michigan in 1999 and a
two-year postdoctoral research fellowship at the National University of Singapore
(1999-2001). He has published monographs on warfare in the premodern South
East Asian region (Southeast Asian Warfare, 1300-1900, 2004), the rise of
monastic, military, and ministerial elites and their impact on the religious and
intellectual life of the precolonial Burmese kingdom (Powerful Learning: Buddhist
Literati and the Throne in Burma's Last Dynasty, 1752-1885, 2006), and a history
of the twentieth century in Burma before and during the lengthy period of military
rule (A History of Modern Burma, 2009). His most recent work focuses on the role
of railways in war, premodern warfare across the Indian Ocean world, and South
East Asia during the Cold War.
State and Society in Arakan since the Fourteenth Century: From Inclusion to
Polarisation and Exclusion (Abstract) - Michael W. Charney
Arakan today is being depicted very much like any other part of lowland Myanmar,
part of a nation-state that today emphasises a Burman, Theravada Buddhist
religious, cultural and political heritage that has dominated the Irrawaddy Valley
from the classical period. Archaeological sites, texts, and other sources are being
remade or expunged to develop a historical record that emphasises an
unchallenged cultural and religious homogeneity to the region Arakan as part of
a greater Burma is an imaginary that has eased Arakans integration into the
Myanmar nation-state but has simultaneously undermined Arakanese society itself
and miscast an area of movement, inclusion, and immigration into one of stasis,
exclusion, and closure. This short presentation highlights some of the major
elements of this change, from a religious and culturally heterogeneous immigrant
society on the crossroads of Bengal and Burma to one that has been mis-imagined
by some as a sort of Theravada Buddhist Burman nativist bastion on the frontiers
of the Muslim world.
Daniel Feierstein
Professor Feierstein is a renowned genocide scholar, and his books and articles
have been critical in the qualification of the crimes committed in Argentina as
genocide, established by 9 different tribunals from 2006 on.
Professor Daniel Feierstein is a researcher at Argentinas National Scientific and
Technical Research Council (CONICET) and a senior lecturer at the National
University of Tres de Febrero (UNTREF), and the University of Buenos Aires (UBA).
He directs the UNTREF Centre for Genocide Studies, the first Genocide Studies
Research Center in Latin America, founded in 2007. He was also the founder of the
Genocide Chair at the University of Buenos Aires (UBA) in 2001.
Professor Feierstein is the author of several books on genocide, including: State
Violence and Genocide in Latin America: The Cold War Years (co-edited with Marcia
Esparza, Henry R. Huttenbach); Sobre la elaboracin del genocidio. Memorias y
Representaciones (Working through Genocide: Memories and Representations,
2012); Sobre la elaboracin del genocidio II: Juicios (Working through Genocide II:
Judgments, 2015); Genocide as Social Practice: Reorganizing Society Under Nazism
and Argentinas Military Juntas, 2014; Hasta que la muerte nos separe, 2005;
Genocidio: La administracin de la muerte en la modernidad, 2004; and Seis
estudios sobre genocidio, 2000.
His conceptual work on genocide was central to the development of Queen Mary
University of London International State Crime Initiatives research on the genocide
of the Rohingya in Myanmar.
Professor Feierstein previously served as the President of the International
Association of Genocide Scholars (2013-2015), and has been a consultant for the
United Nations on a number of projects on Human Rights. He was a Judge in
various sessions of the Permanent Peoples Tribunal dealing with the cases of Sri
Lanka (2010 and 2012) and Mexico (2014), among others.
Penny Green
Professor Penny Green is Professor of Law and Globalisation at Queen Mary
University of London, UK, and Founder and Director of the International State
Crime Initiative (ISCI), UK. She joined Queen Mary University in September 2014
following eight years as Professor of Law and Criminology at Kings College London.
Professor Green has published widely on state crime, resistance to state violence,
the genocide of Burma's natural disasters, Turkish criminal justice and politics,
transnational crime and asylum and forced migration.
She is, with Thomas MacManus and Alicia de la Cour Venning, the author of
Countdown to Annihilation: Genocide in Myanmar (2015)
Barbara Harrell-Bond
Dr Barbara Harrell-Bond, OBE, Emerata Professor and Associate, is a legal
anthropologist who founded/directed the Refugee Studies Centre (1982-96).
Previously she was conducting research in West Africa from 1967-1982, while
employed by the Departments of Anthropology, University of Edinburgh &
University of Illinois-Urbana,USA, the Afrika Studiecentrum, Leiden, Holland, & the
Faculty of Law, University of Warwick. On retirement from the RSC, she conducted
research in Kenya and Uganda (1997-2000), and was Honorary Adjunct Professor,
American University in Cairo (2000-2008). Barbara is also an awardee of the Franz
Boas Award for Exemplary Service to Anthropology awarded by the American
Anthropologist Association, and was awarded the Lucy Mair medal for applied
anthropology in 2014. She is now responsible for the information portal,
www.refugeelegalaidinformation.org that promotes legal assistance for refugees
around the world.
Barbara Harriss-White
Barbara Harriss-White, Emeritus Professor of Development Studies , Oxford
University and Emeritus Fellow and Co-ordinator South Asia Research Cluster,
Wolfson College, Oxford. A working lifetimes experience of teaching and
researching the political economy of South Asia through fieldwork, focussing on
rural development, the informal economy, Indias capitalist transformations and
aspects of poverty and deprivation. Current research is on waste and on natural
resource crimes.
She will discuss her first hand experience of being a persecuted Rohingya.
Dr Nancy Hudson-Rodd
Dr Nancy Hudson-Rodd (PhD Universit d Ottawa), human geographer, former
Director Centre of Development Studies, Edit Cowan University, Western Australia,
University Associate School of Land and Food University of Tasmania, discipline
geography, affiliated with the Asia Institute University Tasmania has conducted
research in and on Burma for over a decade on arbitrary confiscation of farmers
land.
She will discuss critically the international complicity in Burmas brutal internal
violence.
Dr. Azeem Ibrahim
Azeem Ibrahim is an RAI Fellow at Mansfield College, University of Oxford and
Research Professor at the Strategic Studies Institute, US Army War College. He
completed his PhD from the University of Cambridge and served as an
International Security Fellow at the Kennedy School of Government at Harvard and
a World Fellow at Yale. Over the years he has met and advised numerous world
leaders on policy development and was ranked as a Top 100 Global Thinker by the
European Social Think Tank in 2010 and a Young Global Leader by the World
Economic Forum. He tweets @AzeemIbrahim
Nurul Islam
Nurul Islam was born in 1948 in northern Arakan/Rakhine State of Myanmar. He
studied law in Rangoon and London. He has long been involved in Rohingya
movement for the restoration of their rights and freedom in Myanmar. He has been
living in the U.K. since 2004. Nurul Islam is the current Chairman of the Arakan
Rohingya National Organisation (ARNO), which is committed to pursuing a peaceful
political settlement of the Rohingya problem exploring all available avenues.
Summary of presentation by Nurul Islam at Oxford on 11 May 2016
Rohingya are being destroyed due to intolerant state policies and systematic
persecution. They have been rejected the right to exist in Myanmar. Since 2012,
series of state sponsored genocidal onslaughts were carried out against them and
other Muslims. Even the word Rohingya is blacklisted and not mentionable in the
country.
Despite democratic transitions, Rohingyas were excluded from 2014 UN sponsored
national census; their National Registration Cards (NRCs) and IDs were seized and
invalidated depriving them of voting rights and continue to be denied their legal
right to citizenship. Even NLD did not choose Muslim candidates as MPs. The Nazilike extremist Buddhist movements like 969 and Ma Ba Tha are doing colossal
damages to the Muslims.
Over 140,000 Rohingyas are still confined in squalid segregated semi-concentration
camps. In her 18 March report, Special Rapporteur Yanghee Lee called upon the
NLD "to take immediate steps to put an end to the highly discriminatory
policies and practices against the Rohingya and other Muslim communities. On 23
March the UN Human Rights Council adopted a resolution urging the Myanmar
The NLD government must uphold their Responsibility to Protect Rohingya and all
population, and hold accountable all perpetrators of human rights, including those
who have incited ethnic and religious intolerance and violence. It should abolish
the bias Rakhine Action Plan and end institutionalized discrimination against
Rohingya. It must allow unhindered humanitarian assistance to the needy people
in Rakhine state, and facilitate the safe and voluntary return of IDPs to their
communities, and must demonstrably improve the welfare of the Rohingya and
other ethnic and religious minorities. It must repeal 1982 Myanmar Citizenship
Law or amend it to conform to international human rights law and citizenship
standards and restore their citizenship and ethnic rights. The new
government's reform process must include constitutional reform that
addresses the needs of ethnic minorities, as well as the development of an
independent judiciary. The international community should urge the government to
develop a comprehensive reconciliation plan, including establishing a commission
of inquiry into crimes committed against the Rohingya; and neighbouring countries
should offer protection and assistance to Rohingya asylum seekers.
Dr Hla Kyaw
Dr. Hla Kyaw is born and raised in Maung Daw, Rakhine state, where thousands of
Rohingya have been persecuting on daily basis. After finishing high school in
Maung Daw, he was fortunate enough to be allowed to study Medicine in the
University of Medicine, Magwe, Myanmar. He graduated as a Medical doctor in
2007. He left the persecution in 2010, and currently living and working in exile in
Amsterdam, the Netherlands.
The Rohingya Genocide: slow in nature and worse than previous ones, and what
could be done (Abstract) - Dr Hla Kyaw
We are suffering from no less a crime other than what Dr. Zarni et al. described as
a slow-burning genocide. As a victim of the genocide, I have a feeling that the
genocide we are suffering from is worse than the previous ones in the sense that: a)
It is slow in nature; therefore, there is victims psychological adaptation of the
suffering giving the perpetrators a chance to advance the genocide agenda
without a serious resistant from the victims. It is like people in the prison with bar
(physical prison) compared to people in the prison without bar (mental prison).
People in the prison without bar see their prison-hood, and would be serious to
liberate themselves by any means necessary, while the people in the mental prison
are unaware of their prison-hood, and therefore would not be serious enough for
their liberation; b) It is slow in nature; therefore, no external power is serious for
the victims' liberation from genocide although external power is well aware of the
seriousness of the suffering; c) Complete silence from the fellow citizens (including
Thomas MacManus
Dr Thomas MacManus is a Postdoctural Research Fellow at ISCI and is based at
Queen Mary University of Londons School of Law. He holds a BA (Hons) in Law and
Accounting from the University of Limerick (2002), an LLM (with Distinction) in
International Law from the University of Westminster (2005) and a PhD in Law &
Criminology from Kings College London (2011). MacManus was admitted to the
New York State Bar in 2004 and the Role of Solicitors of Ireland in 2008. Following
three months of data collection in Burma/Myanmar in 2014/15, MacManus coauthored the ISCI Report on the situation facing the Rohingya - COUNTDOWN TO
ANNIHILATION: GENOCIDE IN MYANMAR.
MacManus will present and elaborate on elements of this report, which analyses
the persecution of the Rohingya against the six stages of genocide outlined by
Daniel Feierstein. The report concludes that the Rohingya have suffered the first
four of the six stages of genocide.
Ro Shwe Maung
A mechanical engineer by training, Ro Shwe Maung was born and raised in the
predominantly Rohingya region of Northern Arakan or Rakhine, Myanmar. He
was elected to Myanmar parliament in 2010 representing Buthidaung
Constituency, Rakhine State. As an MP he served as a member of Reform and
Modernization Assessment Committee of Pyithu Hluttaw and of Land Confiscation
Review Committee of Pyidaungsu Hluttaw (Union Parliament) until his resignation
in 2015. Shwe Maung is Founder and President of AiPAD (Arakan Institute for
Peace and Development), Board Member of APHR (ASEAN Parliamentarians for
Human Rights) (www.aseanmp.org) and Founding Member of IPPFoRB
(International Panel of Parliamentarians for Freedom of Religion or Belief
(www.ippforb.com). He is currently exiled in the United States.
Some concrete ideas for ending Myanmars Persecution of the Rohingya: Summary by Ro Shwe maung
Ex-MP Ro Shwe Maung will share his eye-witness account of the destruction of
whole Rohingya and Kaman Muslim neighborhoods in June 2012 and suggests
concrete steps that the Aung San Suu Kyi government need to take to end
Myanmars Rohingya genocide including stopping all forms of persecution and
human rights violations against Rohingya minority, releasing all Rohingya Political
Prisoners, falsely imprisoned after the 2012 violence, resettle 140,000 Rohingya
Internally Displaced Persons (IDPs) to their original house land and ending
segregration between Rakhine and Rohingya Communities.
Dr Ambia Perveen
Dr Ambia Perveen, MD, consultant pediatrician at Sankt Marien Hospital in
Dueren, Germany. Dr Perveen is a longstanding Rohingya activist, and lobby
member of the European Rohingya Council.
Dr Perveen will discuss her work on the vulnerabilities prevalent among the
Rohingya populations in terms of public health.
Congress. He was Special Rapporteur for the situation of human rights in Myanmar
(2008-2014). He taught human rights law at University of Buenos Aires, at
University for Peace in Costa Rican, and at the Diplomat Institute in Argentina
His presentation will address the question: Is the UN really convinced that
Rohingyas are the most persecuted minority in the world?
Matthew Smith is a founder and executive director of Fortify Rights and a 2014
Echoing Green Global Fellow. He previously worked with Human Rights Watch
(2011-2013), where he authored several reports on critical rights issues in
Myanmar and China. Matthew also served as a project coordinator and senior
consultant at EarthRights International (2005-2011). His work has exposed
wartime abuses and forced displacement, crimes against humanity, ethnic
cleansing, multi-billion dollar corruption, "development"-induced abuses, and
other human rights violations. He has written for the New York Times, the Wall
Street Journal, CNN, and other outlets. Before moving to Southeast Asia in 2005,
Matthew worked with Kerry Kennedy of the Robert F. Kennedy Center for Justice &
Human Rights on Speak Truth to Power. He also worked as a community organizer
in New York City and as an emergency-services caseworker in Mobile, Alabama. He
has an M.A. from Columbia University and a B.A. from Le Moyne College.
Why the world must listen to the Rohingya (Abstract) by Gayatri Chakravorty Spivak
As an activist from the region, I will be giving witness rather than offer fresh
information for public awareness. I will emphasize why this is a genocide. I will
suggest that all of us need to go beyond passive digital intervention because of
information overload. Whatever our area of involvement, we must now situate the
oppression of the Rohingyas within the global map of injustice. I hope to learn
from the experts in the area during my brief stay in Oxford.
Maya Tudor
Dr. Maya Tudors research investigates the origins of stable, democratic and
effective states across the developing world, with a particular emphasis upon South
Asia. She was educated at Stanford University (BA in Economics) and Princeton
University (MPA in Development Studies and PhD in Politics and Public Policy).
She has held Fellowships at Harvard Universitys Belfer Center for Science and
International Affairs and Oxford Universitys Centre for the Study of Inequality and
Democracy.
Her book, 'The Promise of Power' (Cambridge University Press, 2013), was based
upon her 2010 dissertation, which won the American Political Science Associations
Gabriel Almond Prize for the Best Dissertation in Comparative Politics. The book
investigates the origins of India and Pakistans puzzling regime divergence in the
aftermath of colonial independence. She is also the author of articles in
Comparative Politics, Journal of Democracy, and Party Politics.
Before embarking on an academic career, Maya worked as a Special Assistant to
Chief Economist Joseph Stiglitz at the World Bank, at UNICEF, in the United
States Senate, and at the Bangladesh Rural Advancement Committee. A dual
citizen of Germany and the United States, she has lived and worked in Bangladesh,
Germany, France, India, Kenya, Pakistan, the Philippines, the United Kingdom and
the United States.
She will reflect comparatively on the mobilization of ethnic nationalisms and
racisms to shed some critical light on the case of Myanmars persecution of the
Rohingya people.
Ro Tun Khin
Ro Tun Khin was born and brought up in Arakan State, Burma. His grandfather
was a Parliamentary Secretary during democratic Period of Burma. Although wellestablished and respected, alongside a million other ethnic Rohingya, Tun Khin
was rendered stateless by a 1982 nationality law that excluded the Rohingya from
a list of groups considered indigenous and therefore eligible for Burmese
nationality. He is current President of Burmese Rohingya Organisation UK which
has been a leading voice for Rohingya people around the world. Tun Khin has
briefed officials on the continuing human rights violations committed against
Rohingya populations at the US Congress and State Department, British
Parliament, Swedish Parliament, European Union Parliament and Commission, the
UN Indigenous Forum in NY and the UN Human Rights Council in Geneva.
Tun Khin has been a featured speaker on Rohingya rights for the BBC, Sky Al
Jazeera, and many other outlets. He has also published opinion pieces in the
Huffington Post, Democratic Voice of Burma and Mizzima
Burmese Media outlets. Tun Khin received a leadership award from Refuges
International Washington DC in April 2015 for his relentless effort working on
Rohingya issue.
He will discuss first-hand knowledge of the 6-methods Myanmar governments have
used systematically to destroy his Rohingya people: laws which discriminate
against us; incitement and encouragement of hatred against us; to disenfranchise
us from any political representation; to starve us by stopping economic activity and
restricting humanitarian access; to use state violence against us; and to encourage
and allow non-state violence against us
Maung Zarni
Zarni or Maung Zarni has been a Burmese activist, organizer, scholar and educator
for almost 30 years. He is an outspoken critic of his countrys autocratic rulers,
an opponent of Buddhist racism and hate speech and an advocate for minority
rights. In the last 4 years, he has developed and run a genocide education program
for Burmese religious leaders through the Sleuk Rith Institute of Cambodia and
organized three previous international conferences on the Rohingya persecution at
the London School of Economics (LSE), Harvard University, and the Norwegian
Nobel Institute. In April 2015, Zarni delivered the Annual Owen Kupferschmid
Memorial Lecture at Boston College School of Law on the Rohingya genocide. For
his contributions to global interfaith social movements through a combination of
scholarship and activism Zarni was awarded the Cultivation of Harmony award
by the worlds oldest interfaith organization, the Parliament of the Worlds
Religions, in 2015. He has written extensively on Burma and held leadership,
teaching, research or visiting fellowships at the Rockefeller Foundation,
Georgetown, Harvard, Oxford, LSE, Institute of Education at the University of
London, Chulalongkorn University, the Universiti Malaya and the Sleuk Rith
Institute of Cambodia. He holds an MA from the University of California and a PhD
in the sociology and politics of education at the University of Wisconsin where he
developed a keen interest in the rise of Fascism and ideological movements. With
Professor Daniel Feierstein, Zarni served as a Judge on the Permanent Peoples
Tribunal on Sri Lanka (2013).
Unlike the increasingly mainstreamed view of Muslims and Islam as violent and
extreme, the world holds a rose-tinted view of the world of Buddhists. Based on
my on-going multi-year research on the systematic persecution and popular
violence and hatred of the Rohingya minority in particular and racisms in Buddhist
South East Asia, I will argue that the Orientalist views of Buddhists is deeply
problematic and warrants a rigorous, empirical examination. A crucial component
in the process of Buddhist killing any "Anthropological Other" involves Buddhist
killers, monks and laymen and -women alike, performing a mental acrobatics
whereby they construct their targets, other Muslims or Rohingya Muslims as an
existential threat'. I will stress that episodes of large scale violence are both
organized and organic. Finally, I will argue that they are a direct outcome of an
evolving symbiosis between the state and the society at large and an interface
between history, economy and culture or ideology.
Aung San Suu Kyi meeting with Senior General Min Aung Hlaing,
3 December 2015 (New York Times)