Professional Documents
Culture Documents
June 7, 1994
No. 93-1902
JAMES J. WHITMAN,
Plaintiff, Appellant,
v.
DONALD R. VENTETUOLO,
Defendant, Appellee.
____________________
APPEAL FROM THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE DISTRICT OF RHODE ISLAND
[Hon. Ernest C. Torres, U.S. District Judge]
___________________
____________________
Before
Torruella, Selya and Cyr, Circuit Judges.
______________
____________________
James J. Whitman on brief pro se.
________________
Michael B. Grant, Senior Legal Counsel, Rhode Island
_________________
of Corrections, on brief for appellee.
Departm
____________________
____________________
Per Curiam.
___________
James
W.
Whitman,
a Rhode
Island
damages pursuant to 42
U.S.C.
1983.
Whitman claimed
Laws
court,
state statute
42-56-25 (repealed
endorsing
then in effect.
June 1988).
magistrate-judge's
See
___
The district
report
claim
because, at
its
core,
the complaint
R.I.
and
to state
essentially
subordinate, and,
claims.
report
and
recommendation,
to
which
we
add
these
comments.
To begin,
explicitly request
to be
but
a reduction of sentence;
rather, he asks
entitled
to 320
seeks $150
from
conduct, he
days of
his sentence
opportunity to
would otherwise
good-time.
have been
In addition,
had defendant
donate blood
a recognition, that
had deducted
not deprived
in exchange for
Whitman
him "of
the
a commensurate
sentence reduction."
-2-
Although
he
wants neither
insists
that the
sought is
nor early
solely
release, he
to redress
his
deprivation of
Moran,
_____
551
F.
Supp.
294
(D.R.I.
1982),1
and
in Raso v.
____
that
the
designated
for purposes of
have
he had
earned if
not been
much time he
denied the
could
opportunity to
donate blood.
To
duration
found
the extent
of his
that Whitman
confinement, the
district court
corpus, with
its
seeks to
shorten the
correctly
concomitant requirement
of exhaustion
of
____________________
1.
__
-3-
475,
2254(b).
500 (1973).
McDonnell,
_________
though
418
Whitman's
custody,
the
apply.
U.S. 539,
v. Rodriguez,
_________
Whitman, however,
Preiser
_______
555
adjudication of
seeks
Id.
___
complaint
also
does
not
his
Wolff v.
_____
Nonetheless,
seek
1983
even
release
claims,
from
at this
of
utilized
determine
to
program.
the constitutionality
The "core"
denial
of
the
reduce
his sentence
eligibility
for
of state
the
of Whitman's complaint
constitutionally
protected
by donating blood.
blood
donor
is the alleged
opportunity
Raso,
____
procedures
to
in deciding
could be taken
considered in Wolff
_____
that
sentence
"directly
affects
and possibly
confinement."
Id.
___
the duration
affects
Wolff, 418
_____
the actual
of
an
inmate's
duration of
his
F.2d 874,
be the exclusive
federal
-4-
remedy
not
just
invalidation or
requested relief
when
state
prisoner
requests
________
the
predicate a
determination
Solem,
823
F.2d 1256,
1257
(8th
Cir.
1987) (
1983
_____
complaint
for
declaratory
relief
and
damages
indirectly
of
federal-state
request
to
comity
amend
See Bressman v.
___ ________
requiring
would not
exhaustion).
yield
different
district
court should
stay
rather than
dismiss the
suit.
1974); cf.
___
1993) (
Heck v. Humphrey,
____
________
1983
281, 285
F.2d 1249,
997 F.2d
1112,
355,
dismissed
____________________
2.
While
(1994).
Thus,
staying Whitman's
given
the
the district
1983 action
opportunity
constitutional
error
to
involving
granted, 62 U.S.L.W.
_______
court
should
consider
courts are
allegations
administration
of
of the
inmate early release blood donor program under R.I. Gen. Laws
42-56-25.
The district court judgment is
affirmed insofar as
________
it directs
relating to alleged
violations
of any
Laws
liberty interests
42-56-25;
dismisses
the
the judgment
1983 action.
is
The
inherent in
reversed insofar
________
action is
1983 claims
further district
claims should
remedies.3
be
it
Unless the
are timeadequate to
court proceedings on
stayed pending
as
remanded for
________
R.I. Gen.
exhaustion of
the
state
Affirmed in
________ __
part; reversed
____ ________
in part; remanded
__ ____ ________
for
___
further proceedings.
_______ ___________
____________________
3. Alternatively, the district
court may consider the
propriety of a conditional stay. See, e.g., Dewyer v. Davis,
___ ____ ______
_____
842 F. Supp. 1304, 1305 (W.D. Wash. 1993).
-6-