Professional Documents
Culture Documents
No. 96-1949
ABIODUN ABRAHAM and HENRY AJAO,
Plaintiffs, Appellees,
v.
JOSEPH NAGLE,
Defendant, Appellant.
____________________
No. 96-2008
v.
JOSEPH NAGLE, ET AL.,
Defendants, Appellees.
__________
____________________
APPEALS FROM THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
____________________
Before
____________________
Susan
M. Weise,
_________________
Department, with whom
Chief
of
Litigation,
City
of
Boston
Counsel, was
with whom
was
____________________
June 9, 1997
____________________
Abiodun Abraham
sued several police officers and the City of Boston for false
arrest
and for
other
false
arrest claim
alleged wrongs.
a verdict
against
the
During trial,
in favor of
defendant
Ajao on
officer
the
his
Joseph
claims.
Nagle.
that
most
favorable
Corp., 892
_____
to Nagle.
for
in the light
K mart
______
On August 18,
from
Milo
nightclub in Boston.
minutes,
the group
reached the
club entrance.
The three
The
bouncer told
club because he
was wearing
enter the
because Abraham
The plaintiffs
and
said that
When Abraham
continued
Boston
he could not
jeans and
little intoxicated."
real
Abraham that
to
police
protest, a
officer
club
who
employee
was
-2-2-
"on
summoned Nagle,
detail"
at
another
telling them
that they
told
him
should leave;
of
the
to protest loudly,
chest.
Nagle
he says
alleged
the
plaintiffs for 15 to
not going to
that the
then
plaintiffs never
discrimination.
During
increasingly agitated,
20 minutes,
continued
arrested Abraham
for
the
in
assault and
Nagle
sought
struggled free.
by
officer
to
Nagle
Thomas
handcuff
Abraham
but
Boyle.
Together,
the
latter
soon joined
Nagle
and
Boyle
which was
going limp.
Abraham resisted by
car, Ajao circled the officers and yelled, "why are you doing
this to my
white
racist cops."
According to
said that he
Several
officers
to "get
away."
Eventually,
then
with Ajao
into the
still present,
back seat of
closing by kicking
the car;
the
he
at it, but
-3-3-
In the meantime,
quarter of the
from
car.
as Abraham continued to
it and
came up behind
the left
rear
that Ajao might try to open the car door and release Abraham.
Ajao
failed to move.
Nagle then
In due course,
charged with
conduct.
ch. 265,
53.
in state
police officers,
various other
42 U.S.C.
wrongs.1
1983
and other
with
1995.
granted
Ajao's motion
for a directed
verdict in
his favor
____________________
during
trial,
charged
defendants
prior to
with
false
-4-4-
the trial
judge declared
an oral ruling,
liable under
both
of
the
court's
that
latter's First
and
primary rationale,
Fourth Amendment
as we
read the
rights.
The
transcript, was
. . ."
Ajao's
damages at
false
$8,500 to
free
speech rights.
On
vindicate his
no separate award
all of
jury fixed
"rights against
for violation of
the plaintiffs'
remaining
the defendants.
Thereafter,
attorney's fees
of $24,858.50.
directed verdict
against him.
urging
that
they
On
to
an
The plaintiffs
are entitled
unsuccessful claims,
attorney's fees.
to
new
injunction,
from the
also appeal,
trial on
and
to
their
increased
review of a
directed verdict, we
most
reasonable jury
victor.
Smith v.
_____
Cir. 1996).
question
had inevitably
is
to
decide in
favor of
the
whether Nagle
at the
-5-5-
time
of the
arrest had
of disorderly conduct.
arrest
claim under
Dore, 103
____
both federal
and state
law.
Logue v.
_____
Of
course, it
would
Nagle,
charge
kicked him.
to
the
would
easier to
of events, had
conclude that
probable cause to
arrest, the
conduct.
be much
We
arise
only
reserve for
if the
pertinent
another
original
charge was
day various
arrest
disorderly
issues that
were unjustified
but
resistance
to
it
provided
grounds
for
valid
charge.
Cir.
53 provides
disorderly
persons."
rejected
challenge
unconstitutionally
the
Model
Alegata v.
_______
In 1967,
this
of
"idle and
Judicial Court
provision
interpreting it
definition
Commonwealth, 231
____________
the Supreme
that
vague by
Penal Code's
inter alia, of
__________
was
to incorporate
disorderly conduct.
(Mass. 1967).
A person
is guilty of disorderly
-6-6-
alarm, or recklessly
(a)
engages in
violent
or
fighting
tumultuous
or
threatening,
behavior;
or
(b)
he:
or
in
makes
display, or addresses
abusive language
creates a hazardous
Id.
___
(quoting ALI,
250.2
(Proposed Official
Draft 1962)).
Several years
down
subsection
overbroad.
(Mass. 1975).
ruled
that
(b)
later, the
Supreme
of this
definition
Commonwealth
____________
And
the
v.
A Juvenile,
__________
Judicial Court
as unconstitutionally
334
N.E.2d 617,
remaining
subsections
struck
(a)
and
622
the court
(c)
must
be
"lawful exercise of a
Id. at 628;
___
see
___
also Commonwealth v. LePore, 666 N.E.2d 152, 155 (Mass. App. Ct.)
____ ____________
______
must disturb
than speech
. . .
the conduct
."), review
______
Nagle
testified
that he
arrested Ajao
under subsection
conduct prior
_____
Thus,
had violated
act
-7-7-
the actor."
any
We think
that a reasonable
jury, if
it accepted the
defense version
of
An arrest
serious
business.
blocked by a
Yet, assuming
defendant--here, Abraham--is a
Even without a
police cruiser,
violence and of
repeated
of a struggling
there is a
injury both to
the truth
requests to get
gathering crowd
out of
potential for
the suspect
of the defense
and traffic
and to the
serious
police.
evidence, Ajao--despite
the way--circled
the officers
while shouting, at least once got directly in their way, and then
Such
actor."
Indeed,
a number
of Massachusetts
cases have
created
a safety threat.
1995); Commonwealth
____________
police orders
v. Bosk, 556
____
upheld
145 (Mass.
(Mass. App.
1338 (Mass.
Literal
language is
not
the full
story.
The
state's
activities
are
Amendment right."
themselves
the
"lawful
exercise
wherever the
of
First
-8-8-
this distressed
or annoyed the
police.
But by
"the
by speech
conduct law.
We
a conviction" under
have
very
little
speech
policemen
109
from
not protected.
his
difficulty
protected
is
the disorderly
physical
separating
interference
with
First Amendment.
two
upheld a conviction
Ajao's
Indeed, in Colten
______
in
refusing
In
some
cases,
peaceful
demonstration
and
protected
expression
may appear
Commonwealth
____________
where
peaceful
merge.
v. Feigenbaum,
__________
did not
to
extend to
political
Possibly,
536 N.E.2d
the blocking
rally
But Ajao's
disrupting a
police attempt
325, 328
of traffic in
(Mass. 1989),
to arrest a
the course
defendant's
alleged conduct in
of a
purpose was
the present
case--
struggling companion--
-9-9-
explain
because the
legitimate.
this may
Further, even
if Feigenbaum
__________
up to
a jury
protected
arrest.
most extreme
to determine
whether Ajao
was acting
would be
to express
the
In
the police
benign
version of the
account
contradictions
of
events.
their
conduct
and
the plaintiffs on
the witness
We simply disagree
have to accept
there
jury's province,
believed.
were
thought that
was a
some
stand to decide
whom the
jurors
district judge
a more
mistaken view of
If the
fell within
the governing
rule.
____________________
2At
suggest
least two
state
that an extreme
court decisions
reading is
after Feigenbaum
__________
unwarranted and
that a
See
___
Mulero,
______
3Nagle
points to
discussing jury
the
trial judge's
comment (made
in
basing my findings
-10-10-
arrest based on
probable cause
might still be
police
acted
for
officer
protected speech.
simply
There is
the
some law on
that an
unlawful if
purpose
of
the
punishing
this subject,
compare
_______
Whren v. United States, 116 S. Ct. 1769, 1774 (1996), with Sloman
_____
_____________
____ ______
v. Tadlock, 21
_______
speech, and
certainly
nothing would
to suppress
remotely justify
deciding
The second is
a qualified
immunity
defense for
district
court, has
where a police
call on a
Nagle.
This
defense,
been successfully
invoked in
preserved in
E.g., Joyce
____ _____
this circuit
if arguably mistaken,
v. Town of Tewksbury,
_________________
city
the
F.3d 1, 3
on the merits.
-well after
the incident
in this case--Massachusetts
enacted a
situations
____________________
-11-11-
arrest of another.
32B.
We need not
consider whether Ajao could have been charged under this statute,
There is no
indication
alter
was meant to
eliminate or
as a less
activity.
on
their other
claims which
were rejected
the evidence,
the propriety
by the
a new trial
jury.
The
of closing arguments,
and possible
The
discretion.
Bogosian v.
________
Mercedes-Benz
_____________
of
__
Without describing
104 F.3d
472,
482 (1st
Cir.
1997).
detail, we find
mentioned.
pool
may
have
potentially more
excluded
serious claim is
minorities, but
the
that the
jury
plaintiffs
have
-12-12-
training
bulletin
definition
of
subsection
(b) has
Court.
that
sets
disorderly conduct
been
forth
the
but
fails
struck down
by
Model
Penal
Code
to indicate
that
the Supreme
Judicial
in
faced
any
real threat
of future
injury,
Angeles v. Lyons,
_______
_____
exercising its
e.g., by
____
in the future.
equitable authority
threats to
City of Los
____________
to grant or
deny injunctive
false arrest
now-mooted award of
the
attorney's fees
against him and otherwise affirm the judgment entered on the jury
______
defendants.
It is so ordered.
_________________
is
-13-13-