Professional Documents
Culture Documents
High Quality
Acous3c Habitat
Iden%fying areas of
rela%ve natural quiet
Rice, et al. Varia3on of ocean acous3c environments along the western North Atlan3c coast: A case
study in context of the right whale migra3on route. Ecological Informa3cs 21 (2014) 89-99
SOHN
Van Opzeeland, I., Samaran, F., Staord, K. M., Findlay, K., Gedamke, J.,
Harris, D., & Miller, B. S. (2014). Towards collec3ve circum-antarc3c passive
acous3c monitoring: the southern ocean hydrophone network (SOHN).
Polarforschung, 83(2), 47-61
Clark, Berchok, Blackwell, Hannay, Jones, Ponirakis, Staord. A year in the
acous3c world of bowhead whales in the Bering, Chukchi and Beaufort Seas.
Progress in Oceanography 136 (2015) 223-240
Backcountry access
Vehicles of all kinds
Red: poten%al
10% of region
5 frequency bands
Varying call types &
source levels
Fin whales: least impact
Orcas: most impact
Humpbacks: mixed
popula3on
density
species-weighted
shipping noise
RISK
OPPORTUNITY
Rob Williams, Chris3ne Erbe, Erin Ashe, Christopher Clark. Quiet(er) marine protected areas.
Marine Pollu3on Bulle3n (2015), hAp://dx.doi.org/10.1016/ j.marpolbul.2015.09.012
Policy Guidance, Oce of Na3onal Marine Sanctuaries. Human-induced acous3c impacts on marine life. March 2009. Daniel J. Bastra, Director.
Leila T Hatch, Kurt M Fristrup. No barrier at the boundaries: implemen3ng regional frameworks for noise management in protected natural areas.
Mar Ecol Prog Ser Vol. 395: 223-244, 2009.
CONSERVING MARINE WILDERNESS , Marine Wilderness Working Group Consensus Version, 2011, 2013.
Jim Cummings. Sound/Noise and Marine Life: Why assessing, monitoring, and perhaps regula3ng sound
in MPAs could be helpful. Marine Wilderness 10+10 Workshop, February 2015.
10x20 Project
10% of oceans by 2020
Making a dierence
Federal land management dicult to get trac%on
NPS doing great science
Pushing forward into
tougher ques=ons
Dicult to implement policy
changes to reduce noise
GCNP air tours, 20-yr process
NPS proposed ight-free %mes
around sunrise and sunset
(fantas;c idea!)
Rare Senate bipar%sanship:
Drat Environmental Impact Statement Special Flight Rules Area in the Vicinity of Grand Canyon Na3onal Park
McCain, Reid succeed in quest to stop Grand Canyon overight rules, AEInews, 7/2/12 hAp://aeinews.org/archives/1998.
Making a dierence
Federal land management dicult to get trac%on
2015: FAA rebued NPS input
on new Bay Area airports ight pa`erns
New corridor over a rela=vely quiet part of Point Reyes;
con=nued heavy impact on Yosemite
We have a long history of
[the FAA] not agreeing with us.
We feel were obligated to get this
noise o of the wilderness areas;
were just trying to do our job,
and theyre just ignoring us.
FAA spurns opportunity for quiet area protec3on in trac paAern updates. AEInews, 6/30/15. hAp://aeinews.org/archives/2809
Denver FAA revision just beginning! hAp://www.metroplexenvironmental.com/denver_metroplex/denver_introduc3on.html
Making a dierence
Local and regional conserva%on more poten%al for success?
Iden%fy areas with
conserva%on value for
acous%c habitat
and quiet recrea%on
(nd pockets near ci=es!)
Tucson
MenniA, K Fristrup, K Sherrill, L Nelson. (2013) Mapping sound pressure levels on a con3nental scale using a geospa3al sound model. Internoise 2013.
Making a dierence
Local and regional conserva%on more poten%al for success?
All levels of rela%ve natural quiet
have conserva%on value
Good enough for local recrea%on
No extreme noise (airports, highways)
Chronic local trac noise is faint
High value recrea%on/conserva%on
Opportuni3es for extended
noise-free periods
Making a dierence
Local and regional conserva%on more poten%al for success?
Eric Brunsdon, Donald Killorn. The Coastal Soundscape Study of the Outer Bay of Fundy. Eastern CharloAe Waterways, 2016.
Final thoughts
Protec%ng rela%ve natural quiet
Les Blomberg, NPC:
So far, protec%on of quiet isnt a policy decision.
It is an accident of geography and economics.
Public Outreach Workshop: Noise in Communi3es and Natural Areas, Denver, August 27, 2013. NAE, NPS, AQuieterFuture.org
hAps://www.theguardian.com/science/2015/feb/17/noise-pollu3on-is-making-us-oblivious-to-the-sound-of-nature-says-researcher
Acous%cEcology.org
AEInews.org
Below are supplemental slides, deleted from the presentation for brevity
See hAp://cetsound.noaa.gov
P Tyack, G Frisk, I Boyd, E Urban, S Seeyave, Editors. Interna3onal Quiet Ocean Experiment Science Plan. 2015. Interna3onal
Council for Science, Scien3c CommiAee on Oceanic Research; Partnership for Observa3on of the Global Oceans.
Parks, Miklos-Olds, Denes. Assessing marine acous3c diversity across ocean basins. Ecological Informa3cs 21 (2014) 8188
SEE ALSO: Sirovic, Wiggins, Oleson. Ocean noise in the tropical and subtropical Pacic Ocean. J. Acoust. Soc. Am. 134 (4), October 2013
ONC / IOOS
LIDO
Some surprises
Seismic survey sounds in remote polar Atlan%c
Increases to ambient:
Airguns
5-10dB, up to 20dB
Some3mes greater
than other major
noise sources
(winter storms &
whales, both 10dB)
Klink et al, Seasonal presence of cetaceans and ambient noise levels in polar waters of the North Atlan3c. J. Acoust. Soc. Am. 132 (3), September 2012
Some surprises
Shipping noise not rising in all areas
North Pacic
1960s-1990s 3dB/decade
trends have changed
Indian Ocean
S3ll increasing
South Atlan%c
Equatorial Pacic
Signs of recent leveling,
but likely higher than 80s
JL Miklos-Olds, SM Nichols. Is low frequency ocean sound increasing globally? J. Acoust. Soc. Am. 139 (1), January 2016, 501-511
Andrew, R. K., Howe, B. M., and Mercer, J. A. (2011). Long-3me trends in ship trac noise for four sites o the North American West Coast, J. Acoust. Soc. Am. 129, 642651.
Miksis-Olds, J. L., Bradley, D. L., and Niu, X. M. (2013). Decadal trends in Indian Ocean ambient sound, J. Acoust. Soc. Am. 134, 34643475.
Miksis-Olds, J. L., Bradley, D. L., and Niu, X. M. (2014). Erratum: Decadal trends in Indian Ocean ambient sound [J. Acoust. Soc. Am. 134(5), 34643475 (2013)], J. Acoust. Soc. Am. 135, 1642.
Making a dierence
Chicago-region resource protec%on areas
Not designed as sound-related
Seeking linkages (light green)
between exis3ng public
open spaces (dark green)
Could readily be combined with
regional detail from the NPS
con3nental-scale noise map
featured earlier to focus on areas
of rela3vely lower human noise.
(but good luck; this aint no Tucson!)
8 Arc3c countries
6 regional indigenous councils
hAp://pame.is/images/03_Projects/AMSA/AMSA_Documents/Progress_Reports/AMSArecommenda3ons2015_Web.pdf
hAp://www.pewtrusts.org/en/research-and-analysis/reports/2016/04/the-integrated-arc3c-corridors-framework
48 companies, 55 vessels
40,000 people/year
So far, safety limita3ons are concentra3ng the impact:
77% of visitors on under 500 acres
Combines 100s of
data sets
Seasonal
distribu%ons
Next:
Overlay sound data
and/or models
K Dudzinski, SM van Parijs, Eds. Biologically Important Areas for Cetaceans Within US Waters. Aqua3c Mammals 2015, 41(1), 1, DOI 10.1578/AM.41.1.2015.1
IUCN
Beginning to integrate
Important Marine Mammal Areas
with their terrestrial
Key Biodiversity Areas
Joint Statement by the The IUCN WCPA-SSC Joint Task Force on Biodiversity and Protected Areas and
the IUCN WCPA-SSC Joint Task Force on Marine Mammal Protected Areas. 4 November 2015