You are on page 1of 47

ACI STRUCTURAL JOURNAL

TECHNICAL PAPER

Title No. 111-S97

ACI-DAfStb Databases for Shear Tests on Slender


Reinforced Concrete Beams with Stirrups
by Karl-Heinz Reineck, Evan Bentz, Birol Fitik, Daniel A. Kuchma, and Oguzhan Bayrak
An extensive database was created in 1999 that contained the shear
test data of beams with shear reinforcement subjected to point
loads. The data were not only collected but were also critically
reviewed, and criteria were developed to achieve a reliable database for assessing shear design relationships. This database was
considerably expanded until 2006 and then even more in the recent
years by a joint ACI-DAfStb group.
Because many of the 886 collected tests do not fully conform to
either ACI or European design code limits, two final databases are
presented in this paper. The larger of the two released evaluation
databases contains 157 tests that are appropriate for comparisons
to ACI 318 shear provisions. The second small evaluation database
is a subset of the large database, contains 87 tests, and is appropriate for comparisons to shear design provisions such as those of
the EC2 or fib and FIP standards.
Keywords: beams with shear reinforcement; database; reinforced concrete;
shear strength; shear tests.

INTRODUCTION
Code provisions for the shear capacity of structural
concrete members with shear reinforcement have been,
more or less, semi-empirically derived with only partial
reference to a truss model. In the provisions of ACI 318-11
(ACI Committee 318 2011), the truss model is used to determine the stirrup contribution to shear capacity, and then an
empirically derived concrete term is added. The shear design
of most European codes is solely based on the truss model
with strut angles flatter than 45 degrees. In both codes, the
maximum shear capacity or the strength of the inclined struts
is also based on tests.
DIBt (1999) and Reineck (1999) presented a database with
shear tests on beams with shear reinforcement subjected
to point loads that comprised 493 tests. This database was
considerably extended to 818 tests in 2006 by merging it with
the database collected by Kuchma, and published by Reineck
et al. (2010, 2012). More recently, a joint ACI-DAfStb group
was formed that consists of members of ACI Subcommittee
445-D, Shear Database, and a similar group in the German
Committee for Structural Concrete, Deutscher Ausschu
fr Stahlbeton (DAfStb). This group added new tests and
checked the data so that the collection database now contains
886 tests, in which 511 are tests on slender beams with shear
span-depth ratios a/d > 2.4.
The same conversion factors for the concrete strengths
that were used by Reineck et al. (2003, 2010, 2012, 2013).
Likewise, the sanctioned set of criteria defined in 2003 was
kept to with only a few modifications, which were developed
for accepting a test result into an evaluation-level database.
Examples of these criteria include a minimum compressive
ACI Structural Journal/September-October 2014

strength, a minimum overall height and width, and checks


against flexural and anchorage failures.
RESEARCH SIGNIFICANCE
Code provisions for the shear capacity of structural
concrete members with shear reinforcement have been
primarily derived from test data with respect to the required
amount of shear reinforcement and the calculation of
maximum shear capacity. Therefore, the selection of reliable tests is of utmost importance for calibrating the design
methods. A database with shear tests of reinforced concrete
(RC) beams with stirrups was jointly established by an
ACI-DAfStb group based on several previous databases, and
represents what the authors contend is the most significant
international and representative database of shear test results
of RC beams.
OVERVIEW OF DATABASE AND PROCEDURES
Overview of collected data
This section includes a brief summary on the databases for
beams with vertical stirrups, and the principles are described
concerning the collection and control of the data and the
selection of the data for the evaluation database. The data
were stored in a spreadsheet, and in the process, several
files were generated. In this way, the collection of data was
strictly separated from their subsequent control and of the
selection of tests for the evaluation database. Each file was
given a distinct name so that it was possible to recognize
what kind of tests it contained and in which state of the
process the database was in.
In control files of the database different control criteria
koni were defined (the abbreviation kon is a German
acronym for control criterion, and i is the running number)
and were checked for:
koni = 0 not fulfilled; no transfer to evaluation file;
koni = 1 fulfilled; transfer.
The criteria were for removing those beams from the
database that did not satisfy the relevant requirements; the
remaining beams were transferred to the data evaluation database file. The individual criteria are defined in a following
section and presented with the results of the checks.
The tests on beams with vertical stirrups were performed
as simple span beams subjected to point loads, and were
ACI Structural Journal, V. 111, No. 5, September-October 2014.
MS No. S-2013-078.R1, doi: 10.14359/51686819, was received March 19, 2013,
and reviewed under Institute publication policies. Copyright 2014, American
Concrete Institute. All rights reserved, including the making of copies unless
permission is obtained from the copyright proprietors. Pertinent discussion including
authors closure, if any, will be published ten months from this journals date if the
discussion is received within four months of the papers print publication.

1147

collected in the file vsw-RC-DS with 886 tests, from which


646 had a rectangular cross section. From the collected tests,
125 had to be removed from the database by the selection
criterion konx (Fig. 1) because essential information was
missing, such as the yield strength of the longitudinal reinforcement or the attained ultimate shear force. The criterion kon61 for the slenderness was then applied, and the
data separated into two files, as presented in Fig. 1. The file
vsw-DK-sl contains the tests on slender beams with shear
span ratios of a/d > 2.4, as defined in the following section.
The remaining tests with smaller a/d were transferred to
the database vsw-DK-24. Only the databases with slender
beams are further presented and used in this paper.

center of the applied load that causes that shear; thus, care
is required when considering cases of a single point load, as
shown in Fig. 2(b). In this case, the total load is shown to be
divided into two forces F, each equal to the shear force, and
thus the distance a is defined in a consistent way for single
or double point loads.
The values for the material strengths for the concrete and
steel were determined as described in detail by Reineck et al.
(2003, 2010, 2012). For the concrete compressive strength,
the values determined on different control specimens were
converted by different conversion factors into the uniaxial
compressive strength f1c, which corresponds to the compressive strength of a slender prism, and is equal to

Definition and notation


The notation for beams with point loads is given in Fig.2.
For the 240 T-beams, many details for the shape were
collected as described by Reineck et al. (2012). A typical
test setup is shown in Fig. 2(a), where two point loads are
applied each a distance a from the support axis. The distance
a is the shear span from the center of the support to the

f1c = 0.95 fc,cyl (1)

Fig. 1Sorting and selecting tests according to primary


selection criteria: (a) beam with point loads; and (b) definition of shear span a in case of single point load.

where fc,cyl is the strength of a standard cylinder 150 mm;


and h = 300 mm (6 x 12 in.).
Many test reports do not provide data for consideration of
self-weight of the beams, so that the self-weight was determined in the way described by Reineck et al. (2003, 2010,
2012, 2013)
Determination of stirrup stress at failure
During the data collection, it was found that important
data was often not reported or not measured in some of the
tests. This observation particularly applied to the stirrup
stress, because for only approximately half of the tests,
either measurements of stirrup strains were reported or clear
statements could be found in the reports that yielding of
stirrups occurred at or before failure. From measurements
of the stirrup strain, the stirrup stress at failure was determined by extrapolating the measured value from the load
levels before failure, and in the database, this measured
value was then entered under the value sw,meas. The authors
thereby acknowledge that strain measurements in stirrups
can vary depending on the location of the gauge in relation
to thecrack.

Fig. 2Notation for simple span beams with point loads and definition of shear span.
1148

ACI Structural Journal/September-October 2014

If no measured value for the stirrup strain was reported,


then in the report, a clear statement about stirrup yielding
was searched for, and if such a statement was found, then the
value sw,ass = fyw was entered into a column of the data bank.
If neither of these two cases applied, then sw = 0 was entered.
SURVEY OF TESTS ON BEAMS WITH POINTLOADS
Control of data
The database vuct-RC-DK_sl for slender beams subjected
to point loads comprises 511 tests (Fig. 1). Beam selection control criteria were used to either filter the tests into
different datasets or to remove those beams from the database that did not satisfy specific requirements, as explained
previously. The individual criteria are defined in Table 1,
and further explained as follows along with the results of
the data control. Many of these criteria followed the rules
of the FIP Recommendations (1999), which is based on the
internationally accepted CEB-FIP MC90 (1993). Thus, it is
hoped that the resulting evaluation database is also internationally acceptable. If the often very different criteria of the
many available national codes would be applied, it would
result in many different evaluation databases, and could lead
to some confusion when comparing design proposals.
It is noteworthy that criterion kon1 filtered out 9% of
the tests that had a uniaxial compressive strength of only
f1c<12MPa (1740 psi). This limit corresponds to the
minimum concrete classes required in many codes. The
criteria kon2, kon3, kon4, and kon7 (for the height x of the
flexural compression zone) are fulfilled by almost all tests.
If, however, instead of kon3 the limit for the lowest allowable width is increased from bw = 50 to 100 mm (2 to 4 in.)
using criterion kon31, then 41 further tests would be eliminated. The similar increase for the height from h = 70 to 150
mm (2.76 to 6 in.) in the criterion kon41 had no effect.
The criterion kon8 (flex < 1.00) for the flexural check is
only met by 65% of the tests. By accounting for some of
the conservativeness of the standard flexural strength calculations, the criterion kon81 shows that an additional 10%
allowance on the flexural check allows a significant increase
by 108 tests (21%) that pass the flexural failure check.
The criterion kon9 confirms that the compressive stress
in the diagonal struts of the web did not exceed the uniaxial
compressive strength f1c. The calculation of this stress
depends on knowing the stirrup stress at failure, but this
was only available for 247 tests, as checked by the criterion kon12. Of these 247 tests, only (247 232) = 15 beams
failed to meet kon9.
The criterion kon101 showed that almost all beams
(92%) had ribbed longitudinal reinforcing bars. According
to the criterion kon102, however, only 54% of the beams
had ribbed stirrups. Both conditions are fulfilled by only
263tests (52%) according to the criterion kon10.
The criterion kon11 (lb = lb,req/lb,prov < 1.0) for the check
of the anchorage length lb at the end support is performed
according to the rules of the FIP Recommendations (1999),
which is based on the internationally accepted CEB-FIP
MC90 (1993). This criterion was not met by 65 beams
(13%), and these were marked in the database as AF for
ACI Structural Journal/September-October 2014

Table 1Results of evaluation of tests in respect


of individual criteria koni
No.
Percent
satisfying of 511

No.
violating

Criterion

Condition for criterion

kon1

f1c > 12 MPa (1740 psi)

463

90.8

47

kon2

f1c < 100 MPa (14,500 psi)

506

99.2

kon3

bw 50 mm (2 in.)

510

100

kon31

50 bw < 100 mm (4 in.)

41

8.0

kon4

h > 70 mm (2.76 in.)

510

100

kon41

70 < h < 150 mm (5.9 in.)

kon5

a/d > 2.89

378

74.1

132

kon6

2.4 a/d 2.89

123

24.1

387

kon7

test = x/d 0.5

490

96.1

20

kon8

flex = u/flex < 1.00

330

64.7

180

kon81

1.00 < flex < 1.10

108

21.2

kon9

u = cw/f1c 1.0

232

45.5

278

kon101

fr = r: ribbed

471

92.4

39

kon102

frw = r: ribbed

274

53.7

237

kon10

= kon101 kon102

263

51.6

248

kon11

lb = lb,req/lb,prov < 1.0

445

87.3

65

kon12

sw,rep

247

48.4

263

kon131

w > 0.06228fc /fyw


0.5

468

91.8

42

kon132

w >

0.08fck0.5/fyw

418

82.0

82

kon133

w > 0.16f1ct,cal/fyw

406

79.6

94

kon134

w,min_ACI < w < w,min_DIN

62

12.2

kon141

sw 0.7h

369

72.4

141

kon142

sw 300 mm (12 in.)

462

90.6

48

kon14a

= kon141 kon142

333

65.3

177

kon143

sw 0.55d

354

69.4

156

kon144

sw 610 mm (24 in.)

506

99.2

kon14b

= kon143 kon144

354

69.4

156

kon15

No other failure type (oft)

415

81.4

95

kon161

fyw 414 MPa (6000 psi)

264

51.8

246

kon162

fyw 552 MPa (8000 psi)

405

79.4

105

anchorage failure, meaning that the anchorage check was


not fulfilled.
The criterion kon12 sw,rep for the reported stirrups stress
is to check whether the stirrups yielded at the shear failure or
not. This fact was either reported or the stirrups strains were
measured (refer to previous section) for only 247 beams
(48%), which is a fairly low number.
The criteria kon131 to kon133 checked whether the tests
exceeded the required minimum ratio of the web reinforcement defined in three different codes. The criterion kon131 (in
SI units) is that of ACI 318-11, which is v,min=0.75f
c /fyt
(in U.S. units), and it was fulfilled by 92% of the tests, that
is, 8% of the 510 tests had reinforcing ratios lower than this
minimum. Criterion kon132 is the minimum value for the fib
1149

Table 2Subsequent application of individual


selection criteria for KONA0
Selection
criterion

Combination of
individual criteria

Added
criterion

KONA0a

kon1kon3kon4

KONA0akon7

test
= x/d 0.5

444

KONA0c

KONA0bkon15

No other
failure type
(oft)

356

88

KONA0d

KONA0ckon101

fr = r: ribbed

322

34

KONA0

KONA0dkon143

sw 0.55d

207

115

KONA0b

Remaining
of 510
Difference
463

47

(A2c+A2c) =
(A2b+A3b)kon12

(A2d+A3d) =
(A2c+A3c)kon9

A21b

A22b

A31b

A32b

76

31

38

12

107

Combination of criteria

Fulfilled
number

Percent of 207
dataset A0

KONA21a

KONA0kon5kon8

95

45.9

KONA22a

KONA0kon5kon81

32

15.5

KONA31a

KONA0kon6kon8

41

19.8

KONA32a

KONA0kon6kon81

12

5.8

Dataset
(A2a+A3a)

Sum of aforementioned
datasets

180

87.0

Small dataset
(A2+A3) =
(A2d+A3d)kon11

A21c

A22c

A31c

A32c

51

23

17

100

26

A21d

A22d

A31d

A32d

48

22

17

96

26

A21

A22

A31

A32

44

17

17

61

157

50

70

Selection
criterion

87

26

All of the evaluated tests had to fulfill the following set


of criteria:
KONA0 = kon1kon3kon4kon7kon15kon101kon143

MC (2010), and was fulfilled by 82% of the tests. Criterion


kon133 is that of DIN 1045-1 (2008), and was fulfilled by
80% of the tests. As the difference between the latter two
is only marginal, the final database is based on the more
restrictive kon133. The criterion kon134 defines the tests
that fall between ACI and DIN limits. For comparisons with
the fib MC (2010), care should be taken to include the appropriate number of tests that fall within the limits of kon134.
The maximum spacing sw of the stirrups was checked
for the rules of two codes. The first was the rules of EC2
respectively DIN 1045-1 checked by the criteria kon141and
kon142, and the combined criterion kon14a was fulfilled by
65% of all tests. The second was the rules of ACI318-11
checked by the criteria kon143 and kon144, and the
combined criterion kon14b was fulfilled by 69% of all tests.
This more restrictive criterion was selected in the following
for the large dataset.
Criterion kon15 is a check against failure modes not
reported as shear failures and these were marked in the database as oft for other failure type This check that no oft
occurred was fulfilled by 81% of the collected tests.
Selection of tests for evaluation
To be transferred to the evaluation file, several criteria had
to be fulfilled simultaneously for a beamthat is

1150

180

74

Table 3Result of sorting tests with respect to


slenderness and flexural check

As decribed for the individual criteria, it was checked


KONAi = 0 no transfer to evaluation file;
KONAi = 1 transfer

(A2a+A3a)
Large dataset
(A2b+A3b) =
(A2a+A3a)kon131

19

KONAi = kon1 kon2 kon3 ... koni

Table 4Result of subsequent application of


further criteria for 180 tests on reinforced concrete
beams of dataset (A2a+A3a)

(2)

The results of the subsequent application of these criteria


are listed in Table 2. In the resulting dataset A0, 207 tests of
the 510 remainedthat is, 41%.
Different alternatives were selected in the evaluation file
for sorting the tests into different datasets with respect to
flexural failures (kon8 and kon81) and slenderness (kon5
and kon6), and the results for the four datasets are listed
in Table 3. From the 207 tests in the dataset A0, 180 tests
(87%) remain in the end, so that altogether 27 tests were
eliminated as flexural failures with flex > 1.10.
Subsequently, different criteria were applied to the 180tests
of the dataset (A2a+A3a), and the results are listed in Table
4. The criterion kon131 was selected because it eliminated
the lowest number of 23 tests with very low web reinforcement ratios below the required minimum of ACI318-11, so
that 157 tests remained in the dataset (A2b+A3b). This large
dataset was used for comparisons with some code relationships, as explained in a followingsection.
The criterion kon12 eliminated 57 tests where the stirrups stress at failure is not known, and this led to the
dataset (A2c+A3c) with 100 tests. The role of this criterion for comparisons with code relationships is discussed
in the following section. The next criterion, kon9, applied
to a further four tests so that 96 remained in the dataset
(A2d+A3d). From these, nine tests did not comply with
the anchorage check so that for a strict selection, 87 tests
remained in the final small dataset (A2+A3). This small
dataset only comprises indisputable tests for the evaluations
and for comparisons with code relationships.
If instead of kon3 the limit for the lowest allowable width
was increased from bw = 50 to 100 mm (2 to 4 in.) using
the criterion kon31, however, then seven further tests would
beeliminated.
ACI Structural Journal/September-October 2014

Fig. 3Number of beams versus concrete compressive


strength for large dataset A2b+A3b.
PRESENTATION OF LARGE DATASET
In this section, the number of the beams of the evaluation database vsw-RC_A2b+A3b with the large dataset
(A2b+A3b) with 157 tests is plotted versus important test
parameters to obtain an overview of the distribution of the
test parameters. The parameters are thereby subdivided into
class intervals, and the number of tests in each interval is
plotted. In the diagrams, the 68 tests on beams with plain
stirrups can be discerned from the 89 tests on beams with
ribbed stirrups. Previous comparisons by Reineck et al.
(2012) between the results of separate datasets for plain and
ribbed stirrups showed that both yielded results in the same
ranges, so that the following evaluations are performed for
the whole dataset.
In Fig. 3, the number of beams n is plotted versus the
uniaxial concrete compressive strength f1c subdivided into
class intervals of f = 5 MPa (725 psi). The predominant
number of test beams had a uniaxial concrete compressive
strength of f1c < 40 MPa (5800 psi), that is, 78 tests (50%). A
total of 54 beams (34%) had a uniaxial concrete compressive
strength of f1c > 60 MPa (8700 psi), and can thus be classified as high-strength concrete beams. The two tests with
a compressive strength of f1c >115 MPa (16,675 psi) were
performed by Roller und Russel (1990).
In Fig. 4, the number of beams is plotted versus the yield
strength of the stirrups fwy of the beams subdivided in class
intervals of fsy = 50 MPa (7.25 ksi). Most beams were in the
range of fyw < 450 MPa (65.25 ksi), that is, 75 tests (48%).
Only 59 beams (38%) had yield strengths of fyw > 550 MPa
(79.7 ksi).
In Fig. 5, the number of beams is plotted versus the
mechanical reinforcement ratio l = l fsy /f1c (with l =
As/(b d)) of the longitudinal reinforcement subdivided into
class intervals of l = 0.05. Most tests of the evaluation
database had mechanical reinforcement ratios of l < 0.30.
The majority of the beams with 113 tests (62%) were in the
range of 0.10 < l < 0.25. Only five beams (3%) had a low
mechanical reinforcement ratio of l < 0.10, and four of
these had plain stirrups.
In Fig. 6, the number of beams is plotted versus the slenderness = a/d subdivided in class intervals of = 0.4. The
majority of tests were carried out on beams with a slenderACI Structural Journal/September-October 2014

Fig. 4Number of beams plotted versus yield strength of


stirrups for large dataset A2b+A3b.

Fig. 5Number of beams plotted versus mechanical reinforcement ratio of longitudinal reinforcement for large
dataset A2b+A3b.

Fig. 6Number of beams plotted versus slenderness = a/d


for large dataset A2b+A3b.
ness of 2.4 < < 3.6that is, 129 of the 157 beams, which
is 82%.
In Fig. 7, the number of the beams is plotted versus the
effective depth d subdivided into class intervals of d = 100
mm (4 in.). Most beams had an effective depth 200 < d <
1151

in ACI 318-11); fyw is the yield strength of stirrups (fyt in


ACI318-11); and d is the effective depth.
From Eq. (3), (4b), and (5) follows (in SI units)
Vu,ACI = (Asw/sw) fyw d + 0.166

fc bw d (6)

The shear force should not exceed a maximum value.


According to Section 11.4.7.9 of ACI 318-11, it is for Vs
Vs,max 8

fc bw d in U.S. units

(7a)

fc bw d in SI units

(7b)

Vs,max 0.664

Fig. 7Number of beams plotted versus effective depth d for


large dataset A2b+A3b.
400 mm (8 in. < d < 16 in.), that is, 98 beams, respectively
62%. Altogether, 28 beams (12%) had an effective depth of
d > 600 mm (23.6 in.). The two beams with d > 1200 mm
(47.2 in.) were out of the series tested by Bhal (1968) and
Aparicio et al. (1997).
COMPARISON OF TEST WITH DESIGN EQ. (11-3)
IN ACI 318-11
Shear design in ACI 318-11
In Chapter 11 of ACI 318-11, the shear strength is defined
by Eq. (11-2) for members with shear reinforcement

Vn = Vc + Vs (3)

where Vn is the nominal shear force; Vc is the nominal shear


force provided by the concrete; and Vs is the the nominal
shear force provided by shear reinforcement.
The shear force Vc is defined in ACI 318-11,
Section 11.2, and for non-prestressed members
Eq. (11-3) applies

Vc = 2 fc bw d

(4a)

where Vc, lb; fc, psi; and bw and d, in.


Converting into SI units gives
Vc = 0.166

fc bw d (4b)

where Vc, N; fc, MPa; and bw and d, mm.


It should also be noted that the value of fc is to be limited
to 8.30 MPa (100 psi), so that the influence of concrete
strengths fc above 69 MPa (10,000 psi) is neglected.
The shear force Vs carried by vertical shear reinforcement
is defined by Eq. (11-15) of ACI 318-11
Vs = (Asw/sw) fyw d (5)
where Asw is the area of shear reinforcement (Av in
ACI318-11); sw is the spacing of shear reinforcement (s

1152

Therefore, according to Eq. (3), the maximum shear


forceis
Vn,max = Vc + Vs,max = (2 + 8) fc bw d = 10

in U.S. units
Vn,max = (0.166 + 0.664)

fc bw d = 0.830
in SI units

fc bw d

fc bw d

(8a)
(8b)

Because only the uniaxial compressive strength f1c had


been transferred to the evaluation database, the cylinder
strength fc has to be calculated as fc,cyl = f1c/0.95 (Eq. (1)).
From this average value, the characteristic cylinder strength
was calculated assuming a scatter of f = 4 MPa (580 psi)
fck = fc,cyl 4 (MPa)

(9)

This characteristic cylinder strength fck is used in European codes (EC 2, DIN 1045-1, CEB-FIP MC 90 1993,
fibMC2010; FIP Recommendations 1999), and it is a
5% fractile value. Because fc represents a 9% fractile, the
following relationship can be derived
fc = fck + 1.60 (MPa)

(10)

Further explanations are given by Reineck et al. (2003,


2010, 2012).
Comparison with tests of large dataset
The comparison of tests with the aforementioned relationships for the shear force is done by calculating the model
safety factor

mod = Vu,test/Vu,cal (11)

where Vu,cal = Vu,ACI is either given by Eq. (6), or by Eq. (8),


Vu,cal = Vn,max.
In Fig. 8, the model safety factor mod for the shear strength
calculated with ACI 318-11 is plotted versus the mechanical web reinforcement ratio wy calculated for the 157 tests
of the large dataset (A2b+A3b). It can clearly be seen that
the design relationships of ACI 318-11 are very conservative with model safety factors up to 3; the average value
is mod=1.59, and the coefficient of variation is v = 0.252.
There are only six tests (4% of all) with values mod < 1.0,
which is less than the 5% fractile, but two values for beams
ACI Structural Journal/September-October 2014

u =

Vu
(12)
bw z fcwu

wu = wy

Fig. 8Model safety factor for shear design of ACI 318-11


calculated for 157 tests of large dataset (A2b+A3b) plotted
versus mechanical web reinforcement ratio wy.
with very low web reinforcement ratios are very low with
mod = 0.72 and 0.73.
COMPARISON WITH SMALL DATASET
Design relationships in non-dimensional diagram
The comparison of different design relationships with
tests is very instructive in a non-dimensional wu-u diagram
as shown in Fig. 9, where the non-dimensional shear force
u is plotted versus the mechanical reinforcement ratio wu
for the stirrups, as explained by Reineck (2002). In a design
the shear force is given, and it is plotted as an independent
variable on the x-axis, and the required amount of stirrups
is plotted on the y-axis. The terms wu and u are defined
as follows

sw
(13)
f yw

where sw is stirrup stress at failure measured from


stirrupstrains.
For the truss model with struts inclined at the angle , the
ultimate shear force Vu corresponding to yielding of the stirrups at failure (sw = fyw) is
Vu =

Asw
f yw z cot (14)
sw

where Asw/sw is the area of stirrups at spacing sw; fyw is yield


strength of stirrups; z is the inner lever arm between tension
and compression chord; and is the angle of inclined struts
in the web.
The inner lever arm z between the tension and compression chords is calculated for the test beams, and is thus given.
For the design relationships of RC beams, normally a value
of z = 0.9 d is assumed.
Dividing Eq. (14) by (bw z fcwu) leads to the nondimensional shear force
u =

f yw
f yw
Asw

cot = w
cot = wy cot (15)
bw sw fcwu
fcwu

Fig. 9Location of some tests in wu-u-dimensioning diagram in case of false assumption () of stirrup yielding and correct
location () in case of measured stirrup stresses.
ACI Structural Journal/September-October 2014

1153

where

wy = w fyw/fcwu (16)

w = Asw/(bw sw) = reinforcement ratio for stirrups (17)

where bw is the width of web; fcwu is 0.80f1c = strength of


inclined struts; and f1c is the uniaxial compressive strength
= 0.95fc.
For the truss model of Mrsch (1912), the struts are
inclined at = 45 degrees, and thus, in Eq. (15), the value
cot45 degrees = 1. The strength calculated for this model is
shown with a dashed line (u = wy) in Fig. 9. The dashed
circle corresponds to the plasticity theory (PT) for which the
stirrups yield, and likewise, the struts attain their strength
fcwu = 0.8f1c (Thrlimann 1978). The second inner circle
applies to the German code DIN 1045-1 (2008) for the
slightly lower strut strength of fcwu = 0.75f1c. In Fig. 9, as
an example, the design relationship V = Vs + Vc of the FIP
Recommendations (1999) is also plotted, which is comparable to that of DIN1045-1 for low concrete strengths.
The non-dimensional format for ACI 318-11 is attained
by dividing Eq. (6) and (8) by (bw z fcwu), and this gives
(in SI units)
u, ACI =

fc d
Asw f yw d

+ 0.166
(18a)
bw fcwu z
fcwu z

and with the definitions for w and wy, this gives

fc d
u, ACI = wy + 0.166

fu z (18b)

From Eq. (8b) follows the non-dimensional maximum


shear force (in SI units)
u, max , ACI = 0.830

fc d
(19)
fcwu z

where fc and fcwu need to be inserted in MPa.


Location of tests in diagram for design
relationships
The reason for applying kon12 and using the small dataset
(Table 4) is that in all design approaches for members with
shear reinforcement using the relationship V = Vs + Vc, the
required amount of stirrups is determined from Vs assuming
that the yield stress is reached in the stirrups. Therefore, it
is logical that this condition should also be fulfilled for a
test used for comparison with this design approach, so that
at first, only those tests can be considered where yielding
of the stirrups occurred. In cases where the stirrups did not
yield but the stirrup strains were measured, the tests could
also be considered with the measured stirrup stress as
explainedpreviously.

1154

From a very strict experimental perspective, if tests


were considered without knowing the stirrup stresses but
assuming that always yielding occurred then the validity and
safety of a design equation V = Vs + Vc cannot be assessed,
and this is explained in Fig. 9. In many cases of beams
with a large quantity of stirrups, the ultimate load predicted
by a design equation is not reached, which means that in
Fig.9 such a test point lies well above the line representing
the design equation because stirrup yielding is assumed,
although this was not the case. If, instead, the stirrup stress
actually attained is considered, however, then the test points
lie far lower in the diagram of Fig. 9, such as demonstrated
for tests No. 637 and 640 by Regan (1971) and tests No. 490,
491, 495, and 499 by Leonhardt and Walther (1963). Some
of these tests are now on or near the safe side compared
with the design relationship V = Vs + Vc of the FIP Recommendations (1999). Test No. 640 ends on the Mrsch line
slightly to the left of the plasticity circle for the German code
DIN1045-1(2008).
For the comparison with Eq. (19) of ACI 318-11 or of
any code using the relationship V = Vs + Vc, it is therefore
justified to eliminate the tests where the stirrup stress is not
known by means of the criterion kon12, and this leads to
the dataset (A2c+A3c) with 142 tests with known stirrup
stresses (Table 4).
This dataset still contains nine tests with AF, that is, the
tests where the anchorage check at the end support was not
fulfilled. Likewise, this dataset contains the tests with excessive high shear forces (kon9), which exhibit stresses in the
inclined struts of the truss model exceeding the uniaxial
compressive strength, and are located outside the outer
circle in the diagram. These tests are disputable, and should
not be used as a proof for the safety of any design relationship. Therefore, it appears to be justified to not use the tests
without AF (kon11) and the tests complying with kon9 for
comparisons with design relationships, and this leads to the
indisputable small dataset (A2+A3) with 87 tests (Table 4).
Only for comparisons with other codes than ACI 318-11,
the limit kon131 for the minimum reinforcing ratio needs
to be reconsidered, and leads to further elimination of some
tests in the very low shear range by using criteria kon132 or
kon133 (Table 1).
The result is shown in the non-dimensional Fig. 10, where
wu is plotted versus the ultimate shear force u as defined by
Eq. (12) and (13). This diagram now clearly shows that the
shear strength calculated with ACI 318-11 is very conservative in the whole range of data with respect to Vu,ACI =Vc+ Vs
of Eq. (18b), as well as with respect to the limit for maximum
shear of Eq. (19). The FIP Recommendations (1999) appear
to better fit to the results.
SUMMARY AND CONCLUSIONS
A database for shear tests on beams with shear reinforcement was established by a joint ACI-DAfStb group, which
is an extended version of the database published by Reineck
et al. (2010, 2012). From the originally collected 886 tests,
125 tests were filtered out due to missing important data;
511 tests on slender beams remained. The sanctioned set
of criteria were kept, which had been defined in previous
ACI Structural Journal/September-October 2014

rounds of checking, and therefore would appreciate if these


are reported to the ACI-DAfStb group so that an updated
version of the database can be provided.
AUTHOR BIOS

Karl-Heinz Reineck, FACI, is the retired Academic Director of the Institute for Lightweight Structures Conceptual and Structural Design (ILEK)
at the University of Stuttgart, Stuttgart, Germany, and Associate Professor
of the University of Sarajevo, Sarajevo, Bosnia and Herzegovina. He is a
member of Joint ACI-ASCE Committee 445, Shear and Torsion.
Evan C. Bentz, FACI, is an Associate Professor at the University of Toronto,
Toronto, ON. He is Chair of ACI Committee 365, Service Life Modeling,
and a member of Joint ACI-ASCE Committee 445, Shear andTorsion.
Birol Fitik is a Structural Engineer for Zilch+Mller Ingenieure GmbH in
Munich, Germany. He received his Dipl-Ing in 2004 from the University
of Stuttgart, and Dr-Ing from the Technical University of Munich, Munich,
Germany, in 2012.
Daniel Kuchma, FACI, is an Associate Professor of Civil and Environmental Engineering at the University of Illinois, Champaign, IL, and is the
Burton and Erma Lewis Faculty Scholar. He is Chair of Joint ACI-ASCE
Committee 445, Shear and Torsion, and is a member of ACI Subcommittee
318-E, Shear and Torsion (Structural Concrete Building Code).

Fig. 10142 tests of small dataset (A2+A3) compared with


shear design of ACI 318-11 (ACI Committee 318 2011), DIN
1045-1 (2008), and FIP Recommendations (1999).
databases since 1999 for accepting a test result into an
evaluation-level database. After applying basic filtering
criteria including a flexural failure check, a subset of
180tests remained. Of those, 23 had reinforcement ratios
below the minimum required by ACI 318-11, resulting in
an evaluation data set with 157 tests. The comparisons with
these tests showed that the shear strengths of ACI 318-11
are very conservative (Fig. 8), and this observation particularly applies to the maximum limit for shear. If comparisons
are performed with design relationships assuming yielding
of the stirrups such as in the commonly used relationship
V =Vc + Vs, however, then the small dataset with 87 tests
should be used, because only for these either stirrup stresses
were reported or clear statements were found that the stirrups yielded. Likewise, four tests were eliminated because
they had excessive failure loads (kon9), and nine tests were
eliminated because they did not comply with the anchorage
check at the end support. Thus, these 87 tests are indisputable tests that can be used for the comparison of the test
results with shear design relationships assuming yielding of
the stirrups such as in DIN 1045-1 and FIP Recommendations (1999), which fit well with the test results.
Finally, it should be noted that the MS Excel version of
the evaluation database is provided to the research community with this paper. The original collection database and the
control database are passed on to interested researchers as
PDF and spreadsheet versions under the conditions described
in Appendix A,* and can be obtained by contacting the first
or the fourth author of this paper. The authors acknowledge
that the datasets might still contain errors despite several
*
The Appendix is available at www.concrete.org/publications in PDF format,
appended to the online version of the published paper. It is also available in hard copy
from ACI headquarters for a fee equal to the cost of reproduction plus handling at the
time of the request.

ACI Structural Journal/September-October 2014

Oguzhan Bayrak, FACI, is a Professor in the Department of Civil, Environmental, and Architectural Engineering and holds the Charles Elmer
Rowe Fellowship in Engineering at the University of Texas at Austin,
Austin, TX, where he serves as Director of the Phil M. Ferguson Structural
Engineering Laboratory. He is a member of ACI Committees 341, Earthquake-Resistant Concrete Bridges; E803, Faculty Network Coordinating
Committee; and Joint ACI-ASCE Committees 441, Reinforced Concrete
Columns; and 445, Shear and Torsion.

ACKNOWLEDGMENTS

The contributions of the members of the joint ACI-DAfStb Working


Group listed in Appendix A are acknowledged. The assistance of E. Schnee
is greatly acknowledged for improving the drawings.

REFERENCES

ACI Committee 318, 2011, Building Code Requirements for Structural


Concrete (ACI 318-11) and Commentary, American Concrete Institute,
Farmington Hills, MI, 503 pp.
Aparicio, A.; Calavera, J.; and del Pozo, F. J., 1997, Testing Strut
Compression Shear Failure in Beams, Polytechnic University of Madrid,
Madrid, Spain, 55 pp.
Bhal, N. S., 1968, ber den Einflu der Balkenhhe auf die Schubtragfhigkeit von einfeldrigen Stahlbetonbalken mit und ohne Schubbewehrung
(On the influence of beam depth on the shear capacity of single span reinforced concrete beams with and without shear reinforcement), Otto-GrafInstitut, H.35, Stuttgart, Germany.
CEB-FIP MC 90, 1993, Design of Concrete Structures: CEB-FIP Model
Code 1990, Comit Eurointernational du Beton (CEB), Thomas Telford.
DIBt, 1999, berprfung und Vereinheitlichung der Bemessungsanstze fr querkraftbeanspruchte Stahlbeton- und Spannbetonbauteile aus
normalfesten und hochfesten Beton nach DIN 1045-1 (Check and unification of the shear design of DIN 1045-1for normal and high strength r.c.- and
p.c.-beams), Abschlubericht DIBt - Forschungsvorhabens IV 1-5-876/98.
Deutsches Institut fr Bautechnik, RWTH Aachen, Universitt Leipzig, TU
Mnchen, Universitt Stuttgart, Dec.
DIN 1045-1, 2008, Deutsche Norm: Tragwerke aus Beton, Stahlbeton und Spannbeton - Teil 1: Bemessung und Konstruktion. S. 1 - 183.
(Concrete, reinforced and prestressed concrete structures - Part 1: Design
and construction), Normenausschuss Bauwesen (NABau) im DIN
Deutsches Institut fr Normung e.V. Beuth Verl., Berlin, Germany, Aug.
fib MC, 2010, fib Model Code 2010. Final draft, Fdration Internationale du Bton (fib), Lausanne, Switzerland, Mar.
FIP Recommendations, 1999, Practical Design of Structural Concrete,
FIP-Commission 3, 1996, Practical Design, Fdration Internationale de
la Prcontrainte (FIP) Publ.: SETO, London, UK, Sept. 1999. (Distributed
by: fib, Lausanne, Switzerland, http://www.fib-international.org)
Leonhardt, F., and Walther, R., 1963, Schubversuche an Plattenbalken
mit unterschiedlicher Schubbewehrung (Shear tests on T-beams with
different amounts of shear reinforcement), DAfStb H.156, Beuth Verlag,
Berlin, Germany.

1155

Mrsch, E., 1912, Der Eisenbetonbau (Reinforced Concrete Construction). 4. Aufl., K. Wittwer, Stuttgart, Germany.
Regan, P. E., 1971, Shear in Reinforced ConcreteAn Experimental
Study, CIRIA-Report to the Construction Research and Information Association, Imperial College of Science and Technology, Department of Civil
Engineering, Concrete Section, Apr.
Reineck, K.-H., 1999, Querkraftbemessung von Bauteilen mit Querkraftbewehrung in DIN 1045-1 - Erluterungen und Vergleiche mit
Versuchen (Shear design of members with shear reinforcement in DIN
1045-1 - Explanations and comparison with tests), Teilbericht Kapitel 3.2,
97 S. und Anlagen 143 S. mit Datenbanken fr Stahlbeton- und Spannbetonbalken in: DIBt.
Reineck, K.-H., 2002, Shear Design in Consistent Design Concept for
Structural Concrete Based on Strut-and-Tie Models 165186, fib Bulletin
16, Design Examples for the FIP Recommendations Practical Design of
Structural Concrete, fib, Lausanne, Switzerland, Jan.
Reineck, K.-H.; Kuchma, D. A.; Sim, K. S.; and Marx, S., 2003, Shear
Database for Reinforced Concrete Members without Shear Reinforcement,
ACI Structural Journal, V. 100, No. 2, Mar.-Apr., pp. 240-249. Discussion
by Baant and Yu and closure in ACI Structural Journal, V. 101, No. 1,
Jan.-Feb. 2004, pp. 139-144.

1156

Reineck, K.-H.; Kuchma, D. A.; and Fitik, B., 2010, Extended Databases with Shear Tests on Structural Concrete Beams without and with
Stirrups for the Assessment of Shear Design Procedures Research Report,
ILEK, University of Stuttgart and University of Illinois, Champaign,
IL,July.
Reineck, K.-H.; Kuchma, D. A.; and Fitik, B., 2012, Erweiterte Datenbanken zur berprfung der Querkraftbemessung von Konstruktionsbetonbauteilen ohne und mit Bgel (Extended databases with shear tests on
structural concrete beams without and with stirrups for the assessment of
shear design procedures), DAfStb H. 597, Beuth Verlag, Berlin, Germany.
(in German)
Reineck, K.-H.; Bentz, E.; Fitik, B.; Kuchma, D. A.; and Bayrak, O.,
2013, The ACI-DAfStb Database with Shear Tests on Slender Reinforced
Concrete Beams without Stirrups, ACI Structural Journal, V. 110, No. 5,
Sept.-Oct., pp. 867-875.
Roller, J. J., and Russel, H. G., 1990, Shear Strength of High-Strength
Concrete Beams with Web Reinforcement, ACI Structural Journal, V. 87,
No. 2, Mar.-Apr., pp. 191-198.
Thrlimann, B., 1978, Shear Strength of Reinforced and Prestressed
Concrete Beams, CEB Bulletin No. 126, pp. 16-38.

ACI Structural Journal/September-October 2014

vsw-RC-A2b-A3b_sl_Large

ACI-DAfStb Large Collection Database for r.c.-beams with stirrups

ACI-DAfStb Large Evalution Database vsw-RC_A2b-A3b_sl


1

13

14

15

16

17

18

Bez.

Einheiten

bw

hf

hh,top

10

11
hw

12
hft

hh,bot

Ac

zc2

aA

aF

bA

a/d

cc

bw

hf

hh,top

hw

hft

hh,bot

bft

Ac

zc2

aa

af

ba

kap

cc

mm

mm

mm

mm

mm

mm

mm

mm

mm

Querschnittswerte - Section properties


Nr.

Ahmad_1996_003_NNW-3
Ahmad_1996_006_NHW-3
Ahmad_1996_007_NHW-3a
Ahmad_1996_008_NHW-3b
Ahmad_1996_009_NHW-4
Angelakos_1999_001_DB0.530M
Angelakos_1999_004_DB140M
Aparicio_1997_001_VHA
Aparicio_1997_002_HA-45
Bhal_1968_001_B1S
Bhal_1968_002_B2S
Bhal_1968_003_B3S
Bhal_1968_004_B4S
Bresler_1963_001_A-1
Bresler_1963_007_C-1
Cladera_2002_010_H 100/2
Cederwall_1974_003_734-46
Guidi_1963_001_V
Guralnik_1960_004_IB-2R
Guralnik_1960_005_IC-1R
Guralnik_1960_006_IC-2R
Guralnik_1960_008_ID-2R
Hamadi_1976_002_GT-2
Hamadi_1976_004_GT-4
Hamadi_1976_005_GT-5
Hegger_2001_001_SVB 3b
Hegger_2003_001_NSC 3L
Hegger_2003_002_NSC 3R
Johnson_1989_001_1
Johnson_1989_002_2
Johnson_1989_005_5

19
22
23
24
25
40
42
45
46
62
63
64
65
111
117
132
137
213
217
218
219
221
243
245
246
247
248
249
260
261
264

Lit.

Ahmad;
Xie;
Yu (1996)

Angelakos; Bentz;
Collins P. (1999)
Aparicio; Calavera
del Pozo (1997)
Bhal (1968)

Bresler;
Scordelis (1963)
Cladera; Mari (2002)
Cederwall; Hedman; Losberg (1974)
Guidi; Radogna (1963)
Guralnik (1960)

Hamadi (1976)
Hamadi, Regan (1980)
Hegger, J.; Grtz, S.; Will, N.(2001)
Hegger, J; Grtz, S. (2003)
Johnson;
Ramirez (1989)

App-B3_vsw-RC_A2b-A3b_sl_Large_2013-07-16

SI / A

mm

mm

mm

NNW-3
NHW-3
NHW-3a
NHW-3b
NHW-4
DB0.530M
DB140M
VHA
HA-45
B1S
B2S
B3S
B4S
A-1
C-1
H 100/2
734-46
V
IB-2R
IC-1R
IC-2R
ID-2R
GT-2
GT-4
GT-5
SVB 3b
NSC 3L
NSC 3R
1
2
5

A
A
A
A
A
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
A
A
SI
SI
SI
A
A
A
A
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
A
A
A

127,0
127,0
127,0
127,0
127,0
300,0
300,0
585,0
1450,0
240,0
240,0
240,0
240,0
307,3
154,9
200,0
139,0
250,0
584,2
584,2
584,2
584,2
500,0
500,0
500,0
220,0
400,0
400,0
304,8
304,8
304,8

127,0
127,0
127,0
127,0
127,0
300,0
300,0
75,0
150,0
240,0
240,0
240,0
240,0
307,3
154,9
200,0
139,0
80,0
177,8
177,8
177,8
177,8
120,0
120,0
120,0
180,0
80,0
80,0
304,8
304,8
304,8

254,0
254,0
254,0
254,0
254,0
1000,0
1000,0
800,0
1450,0
350,0
650,0
950,0
1250,0
561,3
558,8
400,0
260,0
400,0
387,4
387,4
387,4
387,4
400,0
400,0
400,0
500,0
500,0
500,0
609,6
609,6
609,6

140,0
280,0

87,1
130,0

60,0
101,6
101,6
101,6
101,6
100,0
100,0
100,0

40,0

90,0
90,0

20,0
20,0

285,8
780,0

200,0
150,0

200,0
285,8
285,8
285,8
285,8
300,0
300,0
300,0

60,0

280,0
280,0

90,0
90,0

87,1
110,0

40,0

20,0
20,0

19

20

21

22

23

24

Laststellung und Geometrie - loading and geometry

585,0
950,0

250,0

400,0
400,0

mm

mm

mm

mm

mm

32258
32258
32258
32258
32258
300000
300000
277821
830000
84000
156000
228000
300000
172522
86580
80000
36140
59200
110161
110161
110161
110161
86000
86000
86000
100000
104000
104000
185806
185806
185806

127,0
127,0
127,0
127,0
127,0
500,0
500,0
420,5
550,1
175,0
325,0
475,0
625,0
280,7
279,4
200,0
130,0
200,0
140,1
140,1
140,1
140,1
133,7
133,7
133,7
241,7
250,0
250,0
304,8
304,8
304,8

50,8
50,8
50,8
50,8
50,8
152,0
152,0

31,8
31,8
31,8
31,8
31,8
76,0
76,0

400,0
180,0
180,0
210,0
210,0
127,0
127,0
150,0

320,4
180,0
240,0
270,0
300,0
152,4
152,4
75,0

100,0
152,4
152,4
152,4
152,4
150,0
150,0
150,0

76,2
76,2
76,2
76,2
75,0
75,0
75,0

100,0
100,0
101,6
101,6
101,6

100,0
100,0
228,6
228,6
228,6

127,0
127,0
127,0
127,0
127,0
308,8
308,8
600,0
450,0
300,0
300,0
300,0
300,0
0,0
0,0
220,0
50,0
150,0
304,8
304,8
304,8
304,8
250,0
250,0
250,0
200,0
450,0
450,0
235,0
235,0
235,0

S-2013-078: Reineck; Bentz; Fitik; Kuchma; Bayrak

1219,2
31,8
1188,7
31,8
1188,7
31,8
1188,7
31,8
1585,0
31,8
5400,0
76,0
5400,0
76,0
12000,0
0,0
21850,0 320,4
1800,0 180,0
3600,0 240,0
5400,0 270,0
7200,0 300,0
3657,6 152,4
3657,6 152,4
2160,0
75,0
3000,0 1800,0
2463,8
2438,4
2489,2
2514,6
2500,0
2500,0
2500,0
3000,0
4500,0
3000,0
4254,5
4254,5
4254,5

593,7
578,5
578,5
578,5
776,6
2662,0
2662,0
2400,0
4189,8
810,0
1680,0
2565,0
3450,0
1752,6
1752,6
1042,5
600,0
1500,0
635,0 914,4
609,6 914,4
660,4 914,4
685,8 914,4
75,0 1212,5
75,0 1212,5
75,0 1212,5
1500,0
1500,0 1500,0
100,0 1450,0
914,4 1670,1
914,4 1670,1
914,4 1670,1

mm

2,92
2,92
2,92
2,92
3,92
2,88
2,88
3,41
3,06
2,70
2,80
2,85
2,88
3,76
3,78
2,95
2,56
3,95
2,97
3,06
2,95
2,99
3,46
3,46
3,46
3,33
3,19
3,09
3,10
3,10
3,10

28,6
28,6
28,6
28,6
28,6

42,9
42,9
25,0
14,0

22,0
22,0
22,0

25,4
25,4
25,4

18.01.2013

vsw-RC-A2b-A3b_sl_Large

ACI-DAfStb Large Collection Database for r.c.-beams with stirrups

ACI-DAfStb Large Evalution Database vsw-RC_A


2

25

26

27

28

35

36

37

38

39

43

44

45

46

47

48

49

50

Bez.

ds

ns

st

29
frs

30
As

31
a

32
s

33
sv

34
fsy

sy

ftk

ftk/fsy

uk

ds2

ns2

st2

As2

fsy2

nsw

Asw

frw

sw

sw / h

sw/d

ds

ns

dst

fR

As

alphaa

rhos

rhosw

fsy

esy

ftk

ftk/fsy

euk

ds2

ns2

dst2

As2

fsy2

dw

nsw

Asw

frw

sw

sw/h

MPa

MPa

mm

Lngsbewehrung (Zugbewehrung) - longitudinal tensile reinforcement


Nr.

19
22
23
24
25
40
42
45
46
62
63
64
65
111
117
132
137
213
217
218
219
221
243
245
246
247
248
249
260
261
264

Lit.

Ahmad;
Xie;
Yu (1996)

Angelakos; Bentz;
Collins P. (1999)
Aparicio; Calavera
del Pozo (1997)
Bhal (1968)

Bresler;
Scordelis (1963)
Cladera; Mari (2002)
Cederwall; Hedman; Losberg (1974)
Guidi; Radogna (1963)
Guralnik (1960)

Hamadi (1976)
Hamadi, Regan (1980)
Hegger, J.; Grtz, S.; Will, N.(2001)
Hegger, J; Grtz, S. (2003)
Johnson;
Ramirez (1989)

App-B3_vsw-RC_A2b-A3b_sl_Large_2013-07-16

41

42

compr. Reinforcement

mm

mm

mm

mm

MPa

NNW-3
NHW-3
NHW-3a
NHW-3b
NHW-4
DB0.530M
DB140M
VHA
HA-45
B1S
B2S
B3S
B4S
A-1
C-1
H 100/2
734-46
V
IB-2R
IC-1R
IC-2R
ID-2R
GT-2
GT-4
GT-5
SVB 3b
NSC 3L
NSC 3R
1
2
5

203,2
198,1
198,1
198,1
198,1
925,0
925,0
704,0
1369,0
300,0
600,0
900,0
1200,0
466,1
463,6
353,0
234,0
380,0
307,8
299,2
309,6
306,1
350,0
350,0
350,0
450,0
470,0
470,0
538,7
538,7
538,7

203,2
198,1
198,1
198,1
198,1
925,0
925,0
704,0
1369,0
300,0
600,0
900,0
1200,0
466,1
463,6
353,0
234,0
380,0
307,8
299,2
309,6
306,1
350,0
350,0
350,0
450,0
470,0
470,0
538,7
538,7
538,7

2
4
4
4
4
2
4
24
24
2
4
6
8
4
2
2
3
8
2
2
2
2
4
4
4
6
5
5
5
5
5

19,1
19,1
19,1
19,1
19,1
29,9
29,9
20,0
32,0
24,0
24,0
24,0
24,0
28,7
28,7
32,0
12,0
12,0
22,2
32,3
32,3
22,2
20,0
20,0
20,0
25,0
20,0
20,0
32,3
32,3
32,3

r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r

823,4
1140,1
1140,1
1140,1
1140,1
1400,0
2800,0
7640,4
19301,9
904,8
1809,6
2714,3
3619,1
2578,9
1289,5
1608,5
339,3
1017,9
775,9
2410,4
2410,4
1345,9
1256,6
1256,6
1256,6
2945,2
3581,4
3581,4
4086,3
4086,3
4086,3

1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
0,01
0,01
1,00

3,1907
4,5311
4,5311
4,5311
4,5311
0,5045
1,0090
1,8552
0,9724
1,2566
1,2566
1,2566
1,2566
1,8003
1,7953
2,2783
1,0431
1,0714
0,4314
1,3790
1,3326
0,7527
0,7181
0,7181
0,7181
2,9750
1,9050
1,9050
2,4885
2,4885
2,4885

3,1907
4,5311
4,5311
4,5311
4,5311
0,5045
1,0090
14,4704
9,3995
1,2566
1,2566
1,2566
1,2566
1,8003
1,7953
2,2783
1,0431
3,3483
1,4175
4,5309
4,3785
2,4733
2,9920
2,9920
2,9920
3,6361
9,5250
9,5250
2,4885
2,4885
2,4885

420,7
420,7
420,7
420,7
420,7
550,0
550,0
500,3
520,2
425,8
425,8
425,8
425,8
555,2
555,2
500,0
818,5
490,5
583,5
576,9
576,9
601,6
400,0
655,0
655,0
532,0
500,0
500,0
524,8
524,8
524,8

2,10
2,10
2,10
2,10
2,10
2,75
2,75
2,50
2,60
2,13
2,13
2,13
2,13
2,78
2,78
2,50
4,09
2,45
2,92
2,88
2,88
3,01
2,00
3,28
3,28
2,66
2,50
2,50
2,62
2,62
2,62

1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
0,70
0,70
0,70

40

710,00
710,00
636,77
513,06
513,06
513,06
513,06
957,93
957,93
848,24
755,37
1011,72
967,76
967,76
1020,49
565,00
820,00
820,00
673,00

0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
1,29
1,29
0,00
1,22
1,21
1,21
1,21
1,21
1,73
1,73
0,00
1,04
1,54
1,73
1,68
1,68
1,70
1,41
1,25
1,25
1,27
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00

15
15
15
15

mm

mm

mm

38,1
38,1
38,1
38,1
38,1
75,0
75,0

2
2
2
2
2
2
2
4
8
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
4
2
2
2
2
4
4
4

12,7
12,7
12,7
12,7
12,7

12,0
10,0
10,0
10,0
10,0
10,0
12,7
12,7
8,0
8,0
6,0
22,2
32,3
32,3
22,2
12,0
12,0
12,0

253,4
253,4
253,4
253,4
253,4
400,0
400,0
653,5
1030,4
157,1
157,1
157,1
157,1
253,4
253,4
100,5
100,5
113,1
775,9
2410,4
2410,4
1345,9
452,4
452,4
452,4

2
2
2

28,7 1289,5
28,7 1289,5
28,7 1289,5

25,0
25,0
25,0
25,0
50,8
50,8
35,0
20,0

46,0
46,0
46,0

S-2013-078: Reineck; Bentz; Fitik; Kuchma; Bayrak

51

52

53

54

Bgelbewehrung - Stirrups

421 6,4
421 6,4
421 6,4
421 6,4
421 6,4
483 9,5
483 9,5
500 12,0
500 12,0
443 6,0
443 6,0
443 6,0
443 6,0
346 6,4
346 6,4
540 6,0
6,0
491 6,0
584 6,4
577 12,7
577 6,4
602 6,4
350 6,0
350 8,0
350 8,0
8,0
6,0
6,0
540 6,4
540 6,4
540 6,4

mm

mm

2
2
2
2
2
1
1
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2

63,3
63,3
63,3
63,3
63,3
71,3
71,3
226,2
226,2
56,5
56,5
56,5
56,5
63,3
63,3
56,5
56,5
56,5
63,3
253,4
63,3
63,3
56,5
100,5
100,5
100,5
56,5
56,5
63,3
63,3
63,3

0
0
0
0
0
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r

101,6
99,1
76,2
63,5
99,1
300,0
300,0
170,0
90,0
160,0
160,0
160,0
160,0
209,6
209,6
165,0
100,0
100,0
146,1
88,9
146,1
146,1
125,0
160,0
125,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
133,4
266,7
133,4

0,40
0,39
0,30
0,25
0,39
0,30
0,30
0,21
0,06
0,46
0,25
0,17
0,13
0,37
0,38
0,41
0,38
0,25
0,38
0,23
0,38
0,38
0,31
0,40
0,31
0,20
0,20
0,20
0,22
0,44
0,22

zw1

zw2

fyw

zw1

zw2

rhow

fyw

mm

0,50 171
0,50 166
0,38 166
0,32 166
0,50 166
0,32 877
0,32 877
0,24 644
0,07 665
0,53 270
0,27 570
0,18 870
0,13 1170
0,45 434
0,45 432
0,47 323
0,43 204
0,26 350
0,47 276
0,30 236
0,47 278
0,48 274
0,36 320
0,46 310
0,36 310
0,22 410
0,21 440
0,21 440
0,25 507
0,50 507
0,25 507

mm

MPa

146
141
141
141
141
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
380
378
303
206
0
0
0
0
0
306
306
306
0
0
0
488
488
488

0,4909
0,5035
0,6545
0,7854
0,5035
0,0792
0,0792
1,7741
1,6755
0,1473
0,1473
0,1473
0,1473
0,0983
0,1951
0,1714
0,4068
0,7069
0,2439
1,6029
0,2439
0,2439
0,3770
0,5236
0,6702
0,5585
0,7069
0,7069
0,1558
0,0779
0,1558

324,1
324,1
324,1
324,1
324,1
508,0
508,0
500,3
582,0
441,5
441,5
441,5
441,5
325,5
325,5
530,0
436,5
490,5
529,0
340,7
529,0
529,0
320,0
480,0
480,0
514,0
550,0
550,0
479,3
479,3
479,3

18.01.2013

vsw-RC-A2b-A3b_sl_Large

ACI-DAfStb Large Collection Database for r.c.-beams with stirrups

ACI-DAfStb Large Evalution Database vsw-RC_A


2

55

56

57

58

59

Bez.

fyw * w/100

fwtk

fwk / fyw

wuk

fwtk/fyw

ewuk

60

61

62

63

fcwu

f1ct,test

fcwu

64

65

66

67

ct,test

f1ct,m,cal

ct,cal

betacttest

f1ctmcal

compressive strength
Nr.

19
22
23
24
25
40
42
45
46
62
63
64
65
111
117
132
137
213
217
218
219
221
243
245
246
247
248
249
260
261
264

Lit.

Ahmad;
Xie;
Yu (1996)

Angelakos; Bentz;
Collins P. (1999)
Aparicio; Calavera
del Pozo (1997)
Bhal (1968)

Bresler;
Scordelis (1963)
Cladera; Mari (2002)
Cederwall; Hedman; Losberg (1974)
Guidi; Radogna (1963)
Guralnik (1960)

Hamadi (1976)
Hamadi, Regan (1980)
Hegger, J.; Grtz, S.; Will, N.(2001)
Hegger, J; Grtz, S. (2003)
Johnson;
Ramirez (1989)

App-B3_vsw-RC_A2b-A3b_sl_Large_2013-07-16

fyw_rhow_100

fwtk

MPa

MPa

NNW-3
NHW-3
NHW-3a
NHW-3b
NHW-4
DB0.530M
DB140M
VHA
HA-45
B1S
B2S
B3S
B4S
A-1
C-1
H 100/2
734-46
V
IB-2R
IC-1R
IC-2R
ID-2R
GT-2
GT-4
GT-5
SVB 3b
NSC 3L
NSC 3R
1
2
5

1,59
1,63
2,12
2,55
1,63
0,40
0,40
8,88
9,75
0,65
0,65
0,65
0,65
0,32
0,64
0,91
1,78
3,47
1,29
5,46
1,29
1,29
1,21
2,51
3,22
2,87
3,89
3,89
0,75
0,37
0,75

778,00
778,00
669,63
567,51
567,51
567,51
567,51
429,66
429,66
680,00
755,37
591,03
595,66
591,03
591,03
430,00
720,00
720,00

0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
1,53
1,53
0,00
0,00
1,29
1,29
1,29
1,29
1,32
1,32
1,28
0,00
1,54
1,12
1,75
1,12
1,12
1,34
1,50
1,50
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00

diaa

f1cttest

Method

mm

MPa

MPa

MPa

39,46
95,17
87,18
99,99
95,74
30,40
36,10
42,25
41,14
25,88
24,18
25,34
24,49
22,87
28,11
82,65
28,69
32,37
15,99
32,30
32,30
32,30
23,63
29,43
18,56
66,50
27,55
27,55
34,59
34,59
53,07

cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cu
cu
cu
cu
cyl
cyl
cyl
cu
cu
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cu
cu
cu
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl

31,57
76,14
69,74
80,00
76,59
24,32
28,88
33,80
32,91
20,70
19,34
20,27
19,59
18,29
22,49
66,12
22,96
25,90
12,79
25,84
25,84
25,84
18,90
23,54
14,85
53,20
22,04
22,04
27,67
27,67
42,46

0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
4,21
2,26
2,39
2,67
2,14
2,57
2,81
0,00
0,00
0,00
1,42
2,16
2,16
2,16
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00

15,0
15,9
15,9
15,9
15,9
20,0
20,0
20,0

19,1
19,1
19,1

f1c

Method

68

69

70

71

72

73

74

75

76

Vg

Vu,g+F,Rep

Vu,Rep

Vu_g+F

Vu_Rep

Vu_gF

kN

kN

mech. reinforcement ratios

19,1
19,1
19,1
19,1
19,1
10,0
10,0

30,0
30,0
30,0
30,0
19,1
19,1
12,0

1
2
1
1

f1c

sp
fl
fl
fl
fl
fl
fl

fl
fl
fl
fl

betactcal

s
oms

l
oml

MPa

0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,1024
0,0873
0,0988
0,1055
0,0875
0,1123
0,1000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0891
0,0668
0,0668
0,0668
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000

3,39
5,11
4,96
5,20
5,12
2,78
3,17
3,56
3,49
2,46
2,33
2,42
2,36
2,23
2,62
4,86
2,66
2,92
1,65
2,92
2,92
2,92
2,29
2,72
1,88
4,51
2,58
2,58
3,07
3,07
4,16

0,0858
0,0537
0,0568
0,0520
0,0535
0,0916
0,0878
0,0843
0,0849
0,0950
0,0964
0,0955
0,0962
0,0975
0,0933
0,0588
0,0929
0,0902
0,1035
0,0903
0,0903
0,0903
0,0969
0,0923
0,1013
0,0678
0,0937
0,0937
0,0888
0,0888
0,0784

0,3401
0,2003
0,2187
0,1906
0,1991
0,0913
0,1537
0,2197
0,1183
0,2067
0,2213
0,2111
0,2185
0,4371
0,3546
0,1378
0,2975
0,1623
0,1575
0,2463
0,2380
0,1402
0,1216
0,1598
0,2534
0,2380
0,3457
0,3457
0,3775
0,3775
0,2461

0,3401
0,2003
0,2187
0,1906
0,1991
0,0913
0,1537
0,2197
0,1183
0,2067
0,2213
0,2111
0,2185
0,4371
0,3546
0,1378
0,2975
0,1623
0,1575
0,2463
0,2380
0,1402
0,1216
0,1598
0,2534
0,2380
0,3457
0,3457
0,3775
0,3775
0,2461

wy
omwy

Vg

Vu_F+g,rep

kN/m

kN

kN

kN

0,0504 0,77 0,24 87,03


0,0214 0,77 0,24 102,37
0,0304 0,77 0,24 108,22
0,0318 0,77 0,24 122,54
0,0213 0,77 0,31 93,72
0,0165 7,20 9,86 256,00
0,0139 7,20 9,50 270,00
0,2626 6,67 8,00
0,2963 19,92 44,32
0,0314 2,02 1,17 127,53
0,0336 3,74 1,87 247,70
0,0321 5,47 3,97 365,42
0,0332 7,20 13,50 459,11
0,0175 4,14 3,94 233,52
0,0282 2,08 1,98 155,68
0,0137 1,92 1,07
0,0774 0,87 1,04
0,1339 1,42 1,07
0,1009 2,64 2,05
0,2113 2,64 2,01
0,0499 2,64 2,08
0,0499 2,64 2,12
0,0638 2,06 1,33
0,1067 2,06 1,33
0,2166 2,06 1,33
0,0540 2,40 1,80
0,1764 2,50 3,74
0,1764 2,50 1,93
0,0270 4,46 5,76 338,50
0,0135 4,46 5,76 222,40
0,0176 4,46 5,76 382,53

S-2013-078: Reineck; Bentz; Fitik; Kuchma; Bayrak

87,27
87,27
102,61 102,61
108,46 108,46
122,78 122,78
94,03
94,03
265,86 265,86
279,50 279,50
886,82 894,83
3384,45 3428,77
128,70 128,70
249,57 249,57
369,39 369,39
472,61 472,61
237,46 237,46
157,66 157,66
225,55 226,62
95,65
96,69
122,63 123,69
140,11 142,16
411,88 413,90
225,07 227,15
217,51 219,62
148,50 149,83
227,50 228,83
222,50 223,83
427,00 428,80
334,00 337,74
349,00 350,93
344,26 344,26
228,16 228,16
388,29 388,29

18.01.2013

vsw-RC-A2b-A3b_sl_Large

ACI-DAfStb Large Collection Database for r.c.-beams with stirrups

ACI-DAfStb Large Evalution Database vsw-RC_A


2

77

Bez.

78
xr

betar_meas

xr_meas

[]

mm

80

81

82

83

84

85

sl,a

79

sw,meas

sw,ass

sw

wu

andere Bruchart

Mu

xr

sigsw

Versuch - Test results


Nr.

19
22
23
24
25
40
42
45
46
62
63
64
65
111
117
132
137
213
217
218
219
221
243
245
246
247
248
249
260
261
264

Lit.

Ahmad;
Xie;
Yu (1996)

Angelakos; Bentz;
Collins P. (1999)
Aparicio; Calavera
del Pozo (1997)
Bhal (1968)

Bresler;
Scordelis (1963)
Cladera; Mari (2002)
Cederwall; Hedman; Losberg (1974)
Guidi; Radogna (1963)
Guralnik (1960)

Hamadi (1976)
Hamadi, Regan (1980)
Hegger, J.; Grtz, S.; Will, N.(2001)
Hegger, J; Grtz, S. (2003)
Johnson;
Ramirez (1989)

App-B3_vsw-RC_A2b-A3b_sl_Large_2013-07-16

NNW-3
NHW-3
NHW-3a
NHW-3b
NHW-4
DB0.530M
DB140M
VHA
HA-45
B1S
B2S
B3S
B4S
A-1
C-1
H 100/2
734-46
V
IB-2R
IC-1R
IC-2R
ID-2R
GT-2
GT-4
GT-5
SVB 3b
NSC 3L
NSC 3R
1
2
5

1380

321
1300
1975

86

87

88

89

90

91

92

u,test

sl

test

test

ztest

zetatest

z_test

Bruchschnittgren

sigswmeas

sigswass

mm

MPa

MPa

297
289
289
289
388
1331
1380
1200
2108
321
1300
1975
1725
876
876
521
300
750
457
457
457
457
606
606
606
750
750
725
835
835
835

324

324
324
508
508
297
357
438
441
441
441

530

320
480
480
514
0
0

omwu

andbr

MPa

324
0
0
324
324
508
508
297
357
438
441
441
441
0
0
530
0
0
0
0
0
0
320
480
480
514
0
0
0
0
0

0,0504
0,0000
0,0000
0,0318
0,0213
0,0165
0,0139
0,1557
0,1818
0,0312
0,0336
0,0321
0,0332
0,0000
0,0000
0,0137
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0638
0,1067
0,2166
0,0540
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000

Mu

u
muu

93

94

96

97

98

99

flex

95

u_flex

u,flex

flex

Bbem

zeta

z_

muflex

Mu_flex

Vu_flex

betaflex

BB

mm

kN

Kontrolle Biegung

vutest

kapc

sigsl

xsitest

kNm

MPa

mm

51,81
59,36
62,74
71,03
73,03
707,71
744,04
2128,38
14180,23
104,25
419,29
947,48
1630,50
416,18
276,31
235,14
57,39
183,94
128,12
376,63
205,80
198,89
180,06
275,84
269,78
640,50
501,00
506,05
574,93
381,04
648,46

0,2504
0,1251
0,1444
0,1425
0,1530
0,0907
0,0803
0,1738
0,1269
0,1865
0,2007
0,1923
0,1926
0,2726
0,2953
0,1142
0,2628
0,1574
0,1448
0,2229
0,1138
0,1125
0,1244
0,1530
0,2373
0,2162
0,2058
0,2079
0,1879
0,1245
0,1381

0,1309
0,0605
0,0708
0,0707
0,0571
0,0416
0,0367
0,5638
0,5390
0,0976
0,1021
0,0956
0,0953
0,1110
0,1220
0,0533
0,1540
0,1718
0,2185
0,3490
0,1702
0,1662
0,2005
0,2530
0,4133
0,1183
0,4651
0,4869
0,0865
0,0545
0,0617

0,842
0,619
0,651
0,600
0,617
0,878
0,856
0,831
0,835
0,896
0,903
0,899
0,902
0,909
0,888
0,669
0,885
0,871
0,936
0,871
0,871
0,871
0,906
0,882
0,926
0,734
0,890
0,890
0,862
0,862
0,788

378
297
318
365
378
550
302
449
520
426
426
426
426
424
555
457
818
491
584
577
297
519
400
655
655
532
343
348
298
188
326

0,363
0,228
0,254
0,275
0,290
0,104
0,099
0,237
0,142
0,231
0,245
0,235
0,242
0,368
0,400
0,188
0,336
0,186
0,168
0,283
0,141
0,139
0,134
0,181
0,274
0,324
0,267
0,270
0,249
0,157
0,194

0,818
0,886
0,873
0,862
0,855
0,948
0,951
0,881
0,929
0,885
0,878
0,883
0,879
0,816
0,800
0,906
0,832
0,907
0,916
0,859
0,930
0,931
0,933
0,909
0,863
0,838
0,867
0,865
0,875
0,922
0,903

166
176
173
171
169
877
879
620
1272
265
527
794
1055
380
371
320
195
345
282
257
288
285
327
318
302
377
407
407
472
496
486

S-2013-078: Reineck; Bentz; Fitik; Kuchma; Bayrak

0,798 162 0,2714


56,17
94,61
0,838 166 0,1679
79,66
137,70
0,832 165 0,1820
79,07
136,69
0,841 167 0,1603
79,93
138,17
0,839 166 0,1670
79,69
102,62
0,948 877 0,0865 675,24
253,66
0,910 842 0,1399 1296,52 487,05
0,868 611 0,1907 2335,34 973,06
0,929 1272 0,1099 12284,65 2932,03
0,885 265 0,1829 102,24
126,22
0,878 527 0,1942 405,64
241,45
0,883 794 0,1863 917,89
357,85
0,879 1055 0,1920 1625,11 471,05
0,759 354 0,3320 506,79
289,16
0,800 371 0,2838 265,55
151,52
0,897 317 0,1236 254,67
244,29
0,832 195 0,2475
54,06
90,10
0,907 345 0,1472 172,03
114,69
0,916 282 0,1442 127,65
139,60
0,859 257 0,2115 357,25
390,69
0,863 267 0,2055 371,73
406,53
0,919 281 0,1289 227,88
249,21
0,933 327 0,1134 164,12
135,36
0,909 318 0,1453 261,99
216,08
0,863 302 0,2187 248,66
205,08
0,838 377 0,1994 590,78
393,85
0,806 379 0,2786 678,12
452,08
0,806 379 0,2786 678,12
467,67
0,781 421 0,2948 902,25
540,25
0,781 421 0,2948 902,25
540,25
0,844 455 0,2077 974,90
583,75

0,92
0,75
0,79
0,89
0,92
1,05
0,57
0,91
1,15
1,02
1,03
1,03
1,00
0,82
1,04
0,92
1,06
1,07
1,00
1,05
0,55
0,87
1,10
1,05
1,08
1,08
0,74
0,75
0,64
0,42
0,67

BB

BB
BB
BB
BB
BB
BB
BB
BB
BB
BB

BB
BB
BB
BB

18.01.2013

vsw-RC-A2b-A3b_sl_Large

ACI-DAfStb Large Collection Database for r.c.-beams with stirrups

ACI-DAfStb Large Evalution Database vsw-RC_A


2

100

Bez.

sinp

101

102

103

104

uP

wp

cotu

Lit.

sin2thp
-

19
22
23
24
25
40
42
45
46
62
63
64
65
111
117
132
137
213
217
218
219
221
243
245
246
247
248
249
260
261
264

Ahmad;
Xie;
Yu (1996)

Angelakos; Bentz;
Collins P. (1999)
Aparicio; Calavera
del Pozo (1997)
Bhal (1968)

Bresler;
Scordelis (1963)
Cladera; Mari (2002)
Cederwall; Hedman; Losberg (1974)
Guidi; Radogna (1963)
Guralnik (1960)

Hamadi (1976)
Hamadi, Regan (1980)
Hegger, J.; Grtz, S.; Will, N.(2001)
Hegger, J; Grtz, S. (2003)
Johnson;
Ramirez (1989)

App-B3_vsw-RC_A2b-A3b_sl_Large_2013-07-16

cotp

thp

cotthp

105

vup

gamwp

cotthu

106

107

Querkraft - PT im Versuch

Querkraft - PT (mit=0,80
Nr.

u
thu

108

109

110

111

112

113

114

115

116

117

118

119

120

f1ck

fcm,cyl

fck

fc

f1ck
MPa
35,7
91,4
83,4
96,2
91,9
26,6
32,3
38,4
37,3
22,1
20,4
21,5
20,7
19,1
24,3
78,9
24,9
28,6
12,2
28,5
28,5
28,5
19,8
25,6
14,8
62,7
23,8
23,8
30,8
30,8
49,3

fcm_cyl
MPa
41,5
100,2
91,8
105,3
100,8
32,0
38,0
44,5
43,3
27,2
25,5
26,7
25,8
24,1
29,6
87,0
30,2
34,1
16,8
34,0
34,0
34,0
24,9
31,0
19,5
70,0
29,0
29,0
36,4
36,4
55,9

fck
MPa
37,5
96,2
87,8
101,3
96,8
28,0
34,0
40,5
39,3
23,2
21,5
22,7
21,8
20,1
25,6
83,0
26,2
30,1
12,8
30,0
30,0
30,0
20,9
27,0
15,5
66,0
25,0
25,0
32,4
32,4
51,9

fc_prime
MPa
39,1
97,8
89,4
102,9
98,4
29,6
35,6
42,1
40,9
24,8
23,1
24,3
23,4
21,7
27,2
84,6
27,8
31,7
14,4
31,6
31,6
31,6
22,5
28,6
17,1
67,6
26,6
26,6
34,0
34,0
53,5

121

122

123

124

125

126

anchorage
u

lb

nueu

betalb

VB

A2+A3

kon34

[ ]

[ ]

NNW-3
NHW-3
NHW-3a
NHW-3b
NHW-4
DB0.530M
DB140M
VHA
HA-45
B1S
B2S
B3S
B4S
A-1
C-1
H 100/2
734-46
V
IB-2R
IC-1R
IC-2R
ID-2R
GT-2
GT-4
GT-5
SVB 3b
NSC 3L
NSC 3R
1
2
5

0,05
0,02
0,03
0,03
0,02
0,02
0,01
0,26
0,30
0,03
0,03
0,03
0,03
0,02
0,03
0,01
0,08
0,13
0,10
0,21
0,05
0,05
0,06
0,11
0,22
0,05
0,18
0,18
0,03
0,01
0,02

12,97
8,42
10,04
10,28
8,39
7,39
6,78
30,83
32,98
10,21
10,56
10,32
10,50
7,60
9,67
6,73
16,15
21,46
18,52
27,37
12,91
12,91
14,63
19,07
27,74
13,43
24,83
24,83
9,46
6,67
7,62

4,34
6,76
5,65
5,52
6,78
7,71
8,41
1,68
1,54
5,55
5,36
5,49
5,40
7,49
5,87
8,47
3,45
2,54
2,99
1,93
4,36
4,36
3,83
2,89
1,90
4,19
2,16
2,16
6,00
8,55
7,47

0,22
0,14
0,17
0,18
0,14
0,13
0,12
0,44
0,46
0,17
0,18
0,18
0,18
0,13
0,17
0,12
0,27
0,34
0,30
0,41
0,22
0,22
0,24
0,31
0,41
0,23
0,38
0,38
0,16
0,12
0,13

0,60
0,42
0,41
0,40
0,40
0,33
0,31
1,28
1,18
0,56
0,57
0,54
0,53
0,85
0,74
0,46
0,58
0,50
0,73
0,85
0,78
0,76
0,82
0,82
1,00
0,52
1,22
1,28
0,53
0,47
0,47

2,60
0,00
0,00
2,22
2,68
2,51
2,63
3,62
2,97
3,13
3,04
2,98
2,87
0,00
0,00
3,88
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
3,14
2,37
1,91
2,19
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00

21,06
0,00
0,00
24,22
20,47
21,70
20,79
15,44
18,64
17,71
18,22
18,55
19,20
0,00
0,00
14,44
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
17,66
22,88
27,66
24,53
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00

0,31
0,00
0,00
0,15
0,14
0,10
0,09
1,76
1,42
0,27
0,28
0,25
0,25
0,00
0,00
0,18
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,56
0,57
0,80
0,25
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00

1,02
0,62
0,68
0,73
0,57
0,80
0,37
0,15
0,36
0,69
0,56
0,47
0,44
0,01
0,01
0,56
3,43
0,34
1,45
1,26
0,63
0,75
0,57
0,74
1,06
0,54
0,19
0,20
0,41
0,27
0,33

VB

0
0
0
1
1
1
1
0
0
1
1
1
1
0
0
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
1
0
1
0
0
0
0
0

1
1
1
1
1
1
1
0
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
0
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
0
0
1
1
1

VB
VB
VB

VB

KONA4 KONA5 A4+A5 Differenz AF

0
0
0
1
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
1
0
1
0
0
0
0
0

0
0
0
0
0
1
1
0
0
1
1
1
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0

0
0
0
1
1
1
1
0
0
1
1
1
1
0
0
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
1
0
1
0
0
0
0
0

0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0

S-2013-078: Reineck; Bentz; Fitik; Kuchma; Bayrak

AF

AF

Vct_ACI Vs_ACI
kN
kN
26,82
41,06
41,32
41,06
39,51
53,38
42,38
64,05
41,45
41,06
250,76
111,61
275,00
111,61
56,88
468,65
218,12
2002,57
59,60
46,81
114,83
93,61
176,75
140,42
231,28
187,23
110,75
45,86
62,20
45,61
107,85
64,12
28,49
57,77
28,42
105,40
34,53
70,62
49,67
290,51
51,40
71,03
50,81
70,21
33,07
50,67
37,29
105,56
28,88
135,11
110,61
232,53
32,21
146,18
32,21
146,18
159,06
122,65
159,06
61,32
199,42
122,65

Vcal_sACI Vmax_ACI rat_smax


kN
kN
67,88
134,08
0,506
82,39
206,62
0,399
92,89
197,53
0,470
106,44
211,92
0,502
82,51
207,26
0,398
362,37
1253,79
0,289
386,61
1375,00
0,281
525,53
284,40
1,848
2220,69
1090,62
2,036
106,41
298,02
0,357
208,45
574,17
0,363
317,17
883,75
0,359
418,51
1156,42
0,362
156,61
553,76
0,283
107,81
310,99
0,347
171,97
539,27
0,319
86,25
142,43
0,606
133,82
142,09
0,942
105,15
172,66
0,609
340,18
248,35
1,370
122,43
257,00
0,476
121,02
254,05
0,476
83,73
165,33
0,506
142,85
186,46
0,766
163,99
144,40
1,136
343,14
553,06
0,620
178,39
161,04
1,108
178,39
161,04
1,108
281,71
795,30
0,354
220,39
795,30
0,277
322,06
997,08
0,323

VACI_cal
kN
67,88
82,39
92,89
106,44
82,51
362,37
386,61
284,40
1090,62
106,41
208,45
317,17
418,51
156,61
107,81
171,97
86,25
133,82
105,15
248,35
122,43
121,02
83,73
142,85
144,40
343,14
161,04
161,04
281,71
220,39
322,06

18.01.2013

vsw-RC-A2b-A3b_sl_Large

ACI-DAfStb Large Collection Database for r.c.-beams with stirrups

ACI-DAfStb Large Evalution Database vsw-RC_A


2
Nr.

3
Lit.

127

Bez.

gmod_ACI
-

19
22
23
24
25
40
42
45
46
62
63
64
65
111
117
132
137
213
217
218
219
221
243
245
246
247
248
249
260
261
264

Ahmad;
Xie;
Yu (1996)

Angelakos; Bentz;
Collins P. (1999)
Aparicio; Calavera
del Pozo (1997)
Bhal (1968)

Bresler;
Scordelis (1963)
Cladera; Mari (2002)
Cederwall; Hedman; Losberg (1974)
Guidi; Radogna (1963)
Guralnik (1960)

Hamadi (1976)
Hamadi, Regan (1980)
Hegger, J.; Grtz, S.; Will, N.(2001)
Hegger, J; Grtz, S. (2003)
Johnson;
Ramirez (1989)

App-B3_vsw-RC_A2b-A3b_sl_Large_2013-07-16

NNW-3
NHW-3
NHW-3a
NHW-3b
NHW-4
DB0.530M
DB140M
VHA
HA-45
B1S
B2S
B3S
B4S
A-1
C-1
H 100/2
734-46
V
IB-2R
IC-1R
IC-2R
ID-2R
GT-2
GT-4
GT-5
SVB 3b
NSC 3L
NSC 3R
1
2
5

1,286
1,245
1,168
1,154
1,140
0,734
0,723
3,118
3,103
1,209
1,197
1,165
1,129
1,516
1,462
1,312
1,109
0,916
1,332
1,658
1,838
1,797
1,773
1,593
1,541
1,244
2,074
2,167
1,222
1,035
1,206

S-2013-078: Reineck; Bentz; Fitik; Kuchma; Bayrak

18.01.2013

vsw-RC-A2b-A3b_sl_Large

ACI-DAfStb Large Collection Database for r.c.-beams with stirrups

E
Kong_1997_001_S1-1
Kong_1997_002_S1-2
Kong_1997_003_S1-3
Kong_1997_004_S1-4
Kong_1997_005_S1-5
Kong_1997_006_S1-6
Kong_1997_007_S2-1
Kong_1997_008_S2-2
Kong_1997_009_S2-3
Kong_1997_010_S2-4
Kong_1997_011_S2-5
Kong_1997_013_S3-1
Kong_1997_014_S3-2
Kong_1997_015_S3-3
Kong_1997_016_S3-4
Kong_1997_017_S3-5
Kong_1997_018_S3-6
Kong_1997_019_S4-1
Kong_1997_021_S4-3
Kong_1997_022_S4-4
Kong_1997_024_S4-6
Kong_1997_025_S5-1
Kong_1997_026_S5-2
Kong_1997_027_S5-3
Kong_1997_031_S7-1
Kong_1997_032_S7-2
Kong_1997_033_S7-3
Kong_1997_034_S7-4
Kong_1997_035_S7-5
Kong_1997_036_S7-6
Kong_1997_037_S8-1
Kong_1997_038_S8-2
Kong_1997_039_S8-3
Kong_1997_040_S8-4
Kong_1997_041_S8-5
Kong_1997_042_S8-6
Krefeld_1966_010_26-1
Krefeld_1966_012_29b-1
Krefeld_1966_015_29a-2
Krefeld_1966_016_29b-2
Krefeld_1966_017_29c-2
Krefeld_1966_018_29d-2
Krefeld_1966_020_29f-2
Krefeld_1966_021_29g-2
Krefeld_1966_024_24.5-3
Krefeld_1966_034_39-3

359
360
361
362
363
364
365
366
367
368
369
371
372
373
374
375
376
377
379
380
382
383
384
385
389
390
391
392
393
394
395
396
397
398
399
400
420
422
425
426
427
428
430
431
434
444

Kong;
Rangan (1997)

Krefeld; Thurston (1966)

App-B3_vsw-RC_A2b-A3b_sl_Large_2013-07-16

hf

hh,top

hw

hft

hh,bot

bft

SI / A

mm

mm

mm

mm

mm

mm

mm

mm

mm

S1-1
S1-2
S1-3
S1-4
S1-5
S1-6
S2-1
S2-2
S2-3
S2-4
S2-5
S3-1
S3-2
S3-3
S3-4
S3-5
S3-6
S4-1
S4-3
S4-4
S4-6
S5-1
S5-2
S5-3
S7-1
S7-2
S7-3
S7-4
S7-5
S7-6
S8-1
S8-2
S8-3
S8-4
S8-5
S8-6
26-1
29b-1
29a-2
29b-2
29c-2
29d-2
29f-2
29g-2
24.5-3
39-3

SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A

250,0
250,0
250,0
250,0
250,0
250,0
250,0
250,0
250,0
250,0
250,0
250,0
250,0
250,0
250,0
250,0
250,0
250,0
250,0
250,0
250,0
250,0
250,0
250,0
250,0
250,0
250,0
250,0
250,0
250,0
250,0
250,0
250,0
250,0
250,0
250,0
254,0
254,0
254,0
254,0
254,0
254,0
254,0
254,0
254,0
254,0

250,0
250,0
250,0
250,0
250,0
250,0
250,0
250,0
250,0
250,0
250,0
250,0
250,0
250,0
250,0
250,0
250,0
250,0
250,0
250,0
250,0
250,0
250,0
250,0
250,0
250,0
250,0
250,0
250,0
250,0
250,0
250,0
250,0
250,0
250,0
250,0
254,0
254,0
254,0
254,0
254,0
254,0
254,0
254,0
254,0
254,0

bw

350,0
350,0
350,0
350,0
350,0
350,0
350,0
350,0
350,0
350,0
350,0
350,0
350,0
350,0
350,0
350,0
350,0
350,0
350,0
350,0
350,0
350,0
350,0
350,0
350,0
350,0
350,0
350,0
350,0
350,0
350,0
350,0
350,0
350,0
350,0
350,0
508,0
508,0
508,0
508,0
508,0
508,0
508,0
508,0
508,0
508,0

Ac

zc2

aa

af

ba

kap

cc

mm

mm

mm

mm

mm

mm

mm

mm

mm

87500
87500
87500
87500
87500
87500
87500
87500
87500
87500
87500
87500
87500
87500
87500
87500
87500
87500
87500
87500
87500
87500
87500
87500
87500
87500
87500
87500
87500
87500
87500
87500
87500
87500
87500
87500
129032
129032
129032
129032
129032
129032
129032
129032
129032
129032

175,0
175,0
175,0
175,0
175,0
175,0
175,0
175,0
175,0
175,0
175,0
175,0
175,0
175,0
175,0
175,0
175,0
175,0
175,0
175,0
175,0
175,0
175,0
175,0
175,0
175,0
175,0
175,0
175,0
175,0
175,0
175,0
175,0
175,0
175,0
175,0
254,0
254,0
254,0
254,0
254,0
254,0
254,0
254,0
254,0
254,0

100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
190,5
190,5
190,5
190,5
190,5
190,5
190,5
190,5
190,5
190,5

100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
50,0
50,0
50,0
50,0
50,0
50,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
127,0
127,0
127,0
127,0
127,0
127,0
127,0
127,0
127,0
127,0

370,0
370,0
370,0
370,0
370,0
370,0
370,0
370,0
370,0
370,0
370,0
360,0
360,0
370,0
370,0
380,0
380,0
350,0
370,0
470,0
450,0
320,0
400,0
370,0
380,0
380,0
380,0
380,0
380,0
380,0
370,0
370,0
370,0
370,0
370,0
370,0
304,8
304,8
304,8
304,8
304,8
304,8
304,8
304,8
304,8
304,8

1960,0
1960,0
1960,0
1960,0
1960,0
1960,0
1960,0
1960,0
1960,0
1960,0
1960,0
1980,0
1980,0
1960,0
1960,0
1940,0
1940,0
3100,0
2160,0
1960,0
1500,0
2260,0
2100,0
1960,0
1940,0
1940,0
1940,0
1940,0
1940,0
1940,0
1960,0
1960,0
1960,0
1960,0
1960,0
1960,0
3657,6
3657,6
3657,6
3657,6
3657,6
3657,6
3657,6
3657,6
3657,6
3657,6

500,0
500,0
500,0
500,0
500,0
500,0
500,0
500,0
500,0
500,0
500,0
500,0
500,0
500,0
500,0
500,0
500,0
500,0
500,0
500,0
500,0
500,0
500,0
500,0
50,0
50,0
50,0
50,0
50,0
50,0
500,0
500,0
500,0
500,0
500,0
500,0
127,0
127,0
127,0
127,0
127,0
127,0
127,0
127,0
127,0
127,0

730,0
730,0
730,0
730,0
730,0
730,0
730,0
730,0
730,0
730,0
730,0
740,0
740,0
730,0
730,0
720,0
720,0
1300,0
830,0
730,0
500,0
880,0
800,0
730,0
945,0
945,0
945,0
945,0
945,0
945,0
730,0
730,0
730,0
730,0
730,0
730,0
1765,3
1765,3
1765,3
1765,3
1765,3
1765,3
1765,3
1765,3
1765,3
1765,3

2,50
2,50
2,50
2,50
2,50
2,50
2,50
2,50
2,50
2,50
2,50
2,49
2,49
2,49
2,49
2,51
2,51
2,48
2,50
2,50
2,53
3,01
2,74
2,50
3,40
3,40
3,40
3,40
3,40
3,40
2,50
2,50
2,50
2,50
2,50
2,50
3,87
3,87
3,87
3,87
3,87
3,87
3,87
3,87
3,87
3,87

35,0
35,0
35,0
35,0
35,0
35,0
35,0
35,0
35,0
35,0
35,0
35,0
35,0
35,0
35,0
35,0
35,0
35,0
35,0
35,0
35,0
35,0
35,0
35,0
35,0
35,0
35,0
35,0
35,0
35,0
35,0
35,0
35,0
35,0
35,0
35,0

S-2013-078: Reineck; Bentz; Fitik; Kuchma; Bayrak

18.01.2013

vsw-RC-A2b-A3b_sl_Large

ACI-DAfStb Large Collection Database for r.c.-beams with stirrups

ds
-

359
360
361
362
363
364
365
366
367
368
369
371
372
373
374
375
376
377
379
380
382
383
384
385
389
390
391
392
393
394
395
396
397
398
399
400
420
422
425
426
427
428
430
431
434
444

Kong;
Rangan (1997)

Krefeld; Thurston (1966)

App-B3_vsw-RC_A2b-A3b_sl_Large_2013-07-16

ns

mm

mm

S1-1
S1-2
S1-3
S1-4
S1-5
S1-6
S2-1
S2-2
S2-3
S2-4
S2-5
S3-1
S3-2
S3-3
S3-4
S3-5
S3-6
S4-1
S4-3
S4-4
S4-6
S5-1
S5-2
S5-3
S7-1
S7-2
S7-3
S7-4
S7-5
S7-6
S8-1
S8-2
S8-3
S8-4
S8-5
S8-6
26-1
29b-1
29a-2
29b-2
29c-2
29d-2
29f-2
29g-2
24.5-3
39-3

292,0
292,0
292,0
292,0
292,0
292,0
292,0
292,0
292,0
292,0
292,0
297,0
297,0
293,0
293,0
287,0
287,0
524,0
332,0
292,0
198,0
292,0
292,0
292,0
278,0
278,0
278,0
278,0
278,0
278,0
292,0
292,0
292,0
292,0
292,0
292,0
455,7
455,7
455,7
455,7
455,7
455,7
455,7
455,7
455,7
455,7

292,0
292,0
292,0
292,0
292,0
292,0
292,0
292,0
292,0
292,0
292,0
297,0
297,0
293,0
293,0
287,0
287,0
524,0
332,0
292,0
198,0
292,0
292,0
292,0
278,0
278,0
278,0
278,0
278,0
278,0
292,0
292,0
292,0
292,0
292,0
292,0
455,7
455,7
455,7
455,7
455,7
455,7
455,7
455,7
455,7
455,7

2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
6
6
4
4
2
3
2
2
2
4
4
4
4
4
4
2
2
2
2
2
2
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4

dst

fR

mm

36,0 r
36,0 r
36,0 r
36,0 r
36,0 r
36,0 r
36,0 r
36,0 r
36,0 r
36,0 r
36,0 r
28,0 r
28,0 r
36,0 r
36,0 r
24,0 r
24,0 r
36,0 r
28,0 r
36,0 r
24,0 r
36,0 r.
36,0 r
36,0 r
32,0 r
32,0 r
32,0 r
32,0 r
32,0 r
32,0 r
36,0 r
36,0 r
36,0 r
36,0 r
36,0 r
36,0 r
28,7 r
28,7 r
28,7 r
28,7 r
28,7 r
28,7 r
28,7 r
28,7 r
28,7 r
28,7 r

ftk/fsy

euk

mm

MPa

MPa

2046,0
2046,0
2046,0
2046,0
2046,0
2046,0
2046,0
2046,0
2046,0
2046,0
2046,0
1232,0
1232,0
2046,0
2046,0
2760,0
2760,0
4092,0
2464,0
2046,0
1380,0
2046,0
2046,0
2046,0
3284,0
3284,0
3284,0
3284,0
3284,0
3284,0
2046,0
2046,0
2046,0
2046,0
2046,0
2046,0
2578,9
2578,9
2578,9
2578,9
2578,9
2578,9
2578,9
2578,9
2578,9
2578,9

As

alphaa

0,70
0,70
0,70
0,70
0,70
0,70
0,70
0,70
0,70
0,70
0,70
0,70
0,70
0,70
0,70
0,70
0,70
0,70
0,70
0,70
0,70
0,70
0,70
0,70
0,70
0,70
0,70
0,70
0,70
0,70
0,70
0,70
0,70
0,70
0,70
0,70
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00

2,8027
2,8027
2,8027
2,8027
2,8027
2,8027
2,8027
2,8027
2,8027
2,8027
2,8027
1,6593
1,6593
2,7932
2,7932
3,8467
3,8467
3,1237
2,9687
2,8027
2,7879
2,8027
2,8027
2,8027
4,7252
4,7252
4,7252
4,7252
4,7252
4,7252
2,8027
2,8027
2,8027
2,8027
2,8027
2,8027
2,2282
2,2282
2,2282
2,2282
2,2282
2,2282
2,2282
2,2282
2,2282
2,2282

rhos

2,8027
2,8027
2,8027
2,8027
2,8027
2,8027
2,8027
2,8027
2,8027
2,8027
2,8027
1,6593
1,6593
2,7932
2,7932
3,8467
3,8467
3,1237
2,9687
2,8027
2,7879
2,8027
2,8027
2,8027
4,7252
4,7252
4,7252
4,7252
4,7252
4,7252
2,8027
2,8027
2,8027
2,8027
2,8027
2,8027
2,2282
2,2282
2,2282
2,2282
2,2282
2,2282
2,2282
2,2282
2,2282
2,2282

rhosw

452,0
452,0
452,0
452,0
452,0
452,0
452,0
452,0
452,0
452,0
452,0
450,0
450,0
452,0
452,0
442,0
442,0
452,0
450,0
452,0
442,0
452,0
452,0
452,0
433,0
433,0
433,0
433,0
433,0
433,0
452,0
452,0
452,0
452,0
452,0
452,0
352,4
338,6
383,4
364,1
271,0
290,3
406,2
276,6
406,2
406,2

fsy

2,26
2,26
2,26
2,26
2,26
2,26
2,26
2,26
2,26
2,26
2,26
2,25
2,25
2,26
2,26
2,21
2,21
2,26
2,25
2,26
2,21
2,26
2,26
2,26
2,17
2,17
2,17
2,17
2,17
2,17
2,26
2,26
2,26
2,26
2,26
2,26
1,76
1,69
1,92
1,82
1,36
1,45
2,03
1,38
2,03
2,03

esy

559,00
559,00
559,00
559,00
559,00
559,00
559,00
559,00
559,00
559,00
559,00
562,00
562,00
559,00
559,00
544,00
544,00
559,00
562,00
559,00
544,00
559,00
559,00
559,00
541,00
541,00
541,00
541,00
541,00
541,00
559,00
559,00
559,00
559,00
559,00
559,00

ftk

1,24
1,24
1,24
1,24
1,24
1,24
1,24
1,24
1,24
1,24
1,24
1,25
1,25
1,24
1,24
1,23
1,23
1,24
1,25
1,24
1,23
1,24
1,24
1,24
1,25
1,25
1,25
1,25
1,25
1,25
1,24
1,24
1,24
1,24
1,24
1,24
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00

ds2

ns2

dst2

As2

fsy2

dw

nsw

Asw

frw

sw

sw/h

zw1

zw2

rhow

fyw

mm

mm

mm

MPa

mm

mm

mm

mm

mm

MPa

41,0
41,0
41,0
41,0
41,0
41,0
41,0
41,0
41,0
41,0
41,0
41,0
41,0
41,0
41,0
41,0
41,0
41,0
41,0
41,0
41,0
41,0
41,0
41,0
47,0
47,0
47,0
47,0
47,0
47,0
41,0
41,0
41,0
41,0
41,0
41,0

2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2

12,0
12,0
12,0
12,0
12,0
12,0
12,0
12,0
12,0
12,0
12,0
12,0
12,0
12,0
12,0
12,0
12,0
12,0
12,0
12,0
12,0
12,0
12,0
12,0
24,0
24,0
24,0
24,0
24,0
24,0
12,0
12,0
12,0
12,0
12,0
12,0

224,0
224,0
224,0
224,0
224,0
224,0
224,0
224,0
224,0
224,0
224,0
224,0
224,0
224,0
224,0
224,0
224,0
224,0
224,0
224,0
224,0
224,0
224,0
224,0
920,0
920,0
920,0
920,0
920,0
920,0
224,0
224,0
224,0
224,0
224,0
224,0

462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
452
452
462
442
442
442
442
442
442
462
462
462
462
462
462

4,9
4,9
4,9
4,9
4,9
4,9
4,9
4,9
4,9
4,9
4,9
4,0
4,0
4,0
4,0
4,0
4,0
4,9
4,9
4,9
4,9
4,9
4,9
4,9
4,9
4,9
4,9
4,9
4,9
4,9
4,9
4,9
4,9
4,9
4,9
4,9
6,4
6,4
6,4
6,4
6,4
6,4
6,4
6,4
6,4
9,5

2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2

38,3
38,3
38,3
38,3
38,3
38,3
38,3
38,3
38,3
38,3
38,3
24,6
24,6
24,6
24,6
24,6
24,6
38,3
38,3
38,3
38,3
38,3
38,3
38,3
38,3
38,3
38,3
38,3
38,3
38,3
38,3
38,3
38,3
38,3
38,3
38,3
63,3
63,3
63,3
63,3
63,3
63,3
63,3
63,3
63,3
141,9

0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r

100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
150,0
125,0
100,0
100,0
75,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
150,0
125,0
100,0
80,0
70,0
60,0
150,0
125,0
100,0
100,0
80,0
70,0
152,4
228,6
228,6
228,6
228,6
228,6
228,6
228,6
114,3
228,6

0,29
0,29
0,29
0,29
0,29
0,29
0,43
0,36
0,29
0,29
0,21
0,29
0,29
0,29
0,29
0,29
0,29
0,29
0,29
0,29
0,29
0,29
0,29
0,29
0,43
0,36
0,29
0,23
0,20
0,17
0,43
0,36
0,29
0,29
0,23
0,20
0,30
0,45
0,45
0,45
0,45
0,45
0,45
0,45
0,23
0,45

0,34
0,34
0,34
0,34
0,34
0,34
0,51
0,43
0,34
0,34
0,26
0,34
0,34
0,34
0,34
0,35
0,35
0,19
0,30
0,34
0,51
0,34
0,34
0,34
0,54
0,45
0,36
0,29
0,25
0,22
0,51
0,43
0,34
0,34
0,27
0,24
0,33
0,50
0,50
0,50
0,50
0,50
0,50
0,50
0,25
0,50

267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
267
277
277
273
273
267
267
499
307
267
173
267
267
267
253
253
253
253
253
253
267
267
267
267
267
267
424
424
424
424
424
424
424
424
424
408

222
222
222
222
222
222
222
222
222
222
222
227
227
223
223
217
217
454
262
222
128
222
222
222
208
208
208
208
208
208
222
222
222
222
222
222
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0

0,1533
0,1533
0,1533
0,1533
0,1533
0,1533
0,1022
0,1227
0,1533
0,1533
0,2044
0,0985
0,0985
0,0985
0,0985
0,0985
0,0985
0,1533
0,1533
0,1533
0,1533
0,1533
0,1533
0,1533
0,1022
0,1227
0,1533
0,1917
0,2190
0,2556
0,1022
0,1227
0,1533
0,1533
0,1917
0,2190
0,1636
0,1091
0,1091
0,1091
0,1091
0,1091
0,1091
0,1091
0,2182
0,2444

569,0
569,0
569,0
569,0
569,0
569,0
569,0
569,0
569,0
569,0
569,0
632,0
632,0
632,0
632,0
632,0
632,0
569,0
569,0
569,0
569,0
569,0
569,0
569,0
569,0
569,0
569,0
569,0
569,0
569,0
569,0
569,0
569,0
569,0
569,0
569,0
341,4
341,4
372,4
372,4
372,4
372,4
372,4
372,4
237,2
275,9

S-2013-078: Reineck; Bentz; Fitik; Kuchma; Bayrak

18.01.2013

vsw-RC-A2b-A3b_sl_Large

ACI-DAfStb Large Collection Database for r.c.-beams with stirrups

fyw_rhow_100
-

359
360
361
362
363
364
365
366
367
368
369
371
372
373
374
375
376
377
379
380
382
383
384
385
389
390
391
392
393
394
395
396
397
398
399
400
420
422
425
426
427
428
430
431
434
444

Kong;
Rangan (1997)

Krefeld; Thurston (1966)

App-B3_vsw-RC_A2b-A3b_sl_Large_2013-07-16

fwtk/fyw

ewuk

MPa

MPa

S1-1
S1-2
S1-3
S1-4
S1-5
S1-6
S2-1
S2-2
S2-3
S2-4
S2-5
S3-1
S3-2
S3-3
S3-4
S3-5
S3-6
S4-1
S4-3
S4-4
S4-6
S5-1
S5-2
S5-3
S7-1
S7-2
S7-3
S7-4
S7-5
S7-6
S8-1
S8-2
S8-3
S8-4
S8-5
S8-6
26-1
29b-1
29a-2
29b-2
29c-2
29d-2
29f-2
29g-2
24.5-3
39-3

0,87
0,87
0,87
0,87
0,87
0,87
0,58
0,70
0,87
0,87
1,16
0,62
0,62
0,62
0,62
0,62
0,62
0,87
0,87
0,87
0,87
0,87
0,87
0,87
0,58
0,70
0,87
1,09
1,25
1,45
0,58
0,70
0,87
0,87
1,09
1,25
0,56
0,37
0,41
0,41
0,41
0,41
0,41
0,41
0,52
0,67

614,00
614,00
614,00
614,00
614,00
614,00
614,00
614,00
614,00
614,00
614,00
687,00
687,00
687,00
687,00
687,00
687,00
614,00
614,00
614,00
614,00
614,00
614,00
614,00
614,00
614,00
614,00
614,00
614,00
614,00
614,00
614,00
614,00
614,00
614,00
614,00

fwtk

1,08
1,08
1,08
1,08
1,08
1,08
1,08
1,08
1,08
1,08
1,08
1,09
1,09
1,09
1,09
1,09
1,09
1,08
1,08
1,08
1,08
1,08
1,08
1,08
1,08
1,08
1,08
1,08
1,08
1,08
1,08
1,08
1,08
1,08
1,08
1,08
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00

f1cttest

Method

mm

MPa

MPa

MPa

7,0
7,0
7,0
7,0
7,0
7,0
7,0
7,0
7,0
7,0
7,0
7,0
7,0
7,0
7,0
7,0
7,0
7,0
7,0
7,0
7,0
7,0
7,0
7,0
7,0
7,0
7,0
7,0
7,0
7,0
7,0
7,0
7,0
7,0
7,0
7,0

diaa

58,51
58,51
58,51
58,51
58,51
58,51
66,70
66,70
66,70
66,70
66,70
62,01
62,01
62,01
62,01
62,01
62,01
80,32
80,32
80,32
80,32
82,25
82,25
82,25
68,82
68,82
68,82
68,82
68,82
68,82
68,63
68,63
68,63
68,63
68,63
68,63
38,13
35,77
35,31
39,31
22,93
28,89
39,70
14,94
33,68
40,56

f1c

Method

cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl

46,81
46,81
46,81
46,81
46,81
46,81
53,36
53,36
53,36
53,36
53,36
49,61
49,61
49,61
49,61
49,61
49,61
64,25
64,25
64,25
64,25
65,80
65,80
65,80
55,05
55,05
55,05
55,05
55,05
55,05
54,91
54,91
54,91
54,91
54,91
54,91
30,50
28,62
28,25
31,45
18,34
23,11
31,76
11,95
26,94
32,44

fcwu

0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
3,25
3,25
3,25
3,25
3,25
3,28
3,28
3,28
3,28
3,28
3,28
3,72
3,72
3,72
3,72
4,80
4,80
4,80
3,68
3,68
3,68
3,68
3,68
3,68
3,38
3,38
3,38
3,38
3,38
3,38
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00

sp
sp
sp
sp
sp
sp
sp
sp
sp
sp
sp
sp
sp
sp
sp
sp
sp
sp
sp
sp
sp
sp
sp
sp
sp
sp
sp
sp
sp
sp

betacttest

f1ctmcal

betactcal

oms

oml

omwy

Vg

Vu_F+g,rep

MPa

kN/m

kN

kN

kN

0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0487
0,0487
0,0487
0,0487
0,0487
0,0528
0,0528
0,0528
0,0528
0,0528
0,0528
0,0463
0,0463
0,0463
0,0463
0,0583
0,0583
0,0583
0,0535
0,0535
0,0535
0,0535
0,0535
0,0535
0,0493
0,0493
0,0493
0,0493
0,0493
0,0493
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000

4,31
4,31
4,31
4,31
4,31
4,31
4,51
4,51
4,51
4,51
4,51
4,40
4,40
4,40
4,40
4,40
4,40
4,82
4,82
4,82
4,82
4,86
4,86
4,86
4,56
4,56
4,56
4,56
4,56
4,56
4,56
4,56
4,56
4,56
4,56
4,56
3,30
3,15
3,12
3,38
2,24
2,68
3,40
1,56
3,01
3,45

0,0736
0,0736
0,0736
0,0736
0,0736
0,0736
0,0676
0,0676
0,0676
0,0676
0,0676
0,0709
0,0709
0,0709
0,0709
0,0709
0,0709
0,0600
0,0600
0,0600
0,0600
0,0590
0,0590
0,0590
0,0663
0,0663
0,0663
0,0663
0,0663
0,0663
0,0664
0,0664
0,0664
0,0664
0,0664
0,0664
0,0866
0,0880
0,0883
0,0859
0,0975
0,0927
0,0857
0,1043
0,0893
0,0852

0,2165
0,2165
0,2165
0,2165
0,2165
0,2165
0,1899
0,1899
0,1899
0,1899
0,1899
0,1204
0,1204
0,2036
0,2036
0,2742
0,2742
0,1758
0,1663
0,1577
0,1534
0,1540
0,1540
0,1540
0,2973
0,2973
0,2973
0,2973
0,2973
0,2973
0,1846
0,1846
0,1846
0,1846
0,1846
0,1846
0,2059
0,2109
0,2419
0,2064
0,2634
0,2239
0,2280
0,4125
0,2688
0,2232

0,2165
0,2165
0,2165
0,2165
0,2165
0,2165
0,1899
0,1899
0,1899
0,1899
0,1899
0,1204
0,1204
0,2036
0,2036
0,2742
0,2742
0,1758
0,1663
0,1577
0,1534
0,1540
0,1540
0,1540
0,2973
0,2973
0,2973
0,2973
0,2973
0,2973
0,1846
0,1846
0,1846
0,1846
0,1846
0,1846
0,2059
0,2109
0,2419
0,2064
0,2634
0,2239
0,2280
0,4125
0,2688
0,2232

0,0186
0,0186
0,0186
0,0186
0,0186
0,0186
0,0109
0,0131
0,0164
0,0164
0,0218
0,0126
0,0126
0,0126
0,0126
0,0126
0,0126
0,0136
0,0136
0,0136
0,0136
0,0133
0,0133
0,0133
0,0106
0,0127
0,0158
0,0198
0,0226
0,0264
0,0106
0,0127
0,0159
0,0159
0,0199
0,0227
0,0183
0,0130
0,0144
0,0129
0,0221
0,0176
0,0128
0,0340
0,0192
0,0208

2,10
2,10
2,10
2,10
2,10
2,10
2,10
2,10
2,10
2,10
2,10
2,10
2,10
2,10
2,10
2,10
2,10
2,10
2,10
2,10
2,10
2,10
2,10
2,10
2,10
2,10
2,10
2,10
2,10
2,10
2,10
2,10
2,10
2,10
2,10
2,10
3,10
3,10
3,10
3,10
3,10
3,10
3,10
3,10
3,10
3,10

1,31
1,36
1,31
1,41
1,29
1,18
1,08
1,34
1,31
1,20
1,41
1,33
1,28
1,18
1,22
1,28
1,28
2,03
1,40
1,26
1,05
1,37
1,37
1,34
1,04
1,04
1,04
1,04
1,04
1,22
1,27
1,31
1,22
1,29
1,29
1,13
2,93
2,93
2,93
2,93
2,93
2,93
2,93
2,93
2,93
2,93

S-2013-078: Reineck; Bentz; Fitik; Kuchma; Bayrak

Vu_Rep

Vu_gF

kN

kN

228,30
208,30
206,10
277,90
253,30
224,10
260,30
232,50
253,30
219,40
282,10
209,20
178,00
228,60
174,90
296,60
282,90
354,00
243,40
258,10
202,90
241,70
259,90
243,80
217,20
205,40
246,50
273,60
304,40
310,60
272,10
251,00
309,60
265,80
289,20
283,90
206,83
160,13
216,62
202,38
161,46
165,02
234,41
149,90
232,63
239,75

229,61
209,66
207,41
279,31
254,59
225,28
261,38
233,84
254,61
220,60
283,51
210,53
179,28
229,78
176,12
297,88
284,18
356,03
244,80
259,36
203,95
243,07
261,27
245,14
218,24
206,44
247,54
274,64
305,44
311,82
273,37
252,31
310,82
267,09
290,49
285,03
209,76
163,06
219,55
205,31
164,39
167,95
237,34
152,83
235,56
242,68

18.01.2013

vsw-RC-A2b-A3b_sl_Large

ACI-DAfStb Large Collection Database for r.c.-beams with stirrups

betar_meas
-

359
360
361
362
363
364
365
366
367
368
369
371
372
373
374
375
376
377
379
380
382
383
384
385
389
390
391
392
393
394
395
396
397
398
399
400
420
422
425
426
427
428
430
431
434
444

Kong;
Rangan (1997)

Krefeld; Thurston (1966)

App-B3_vsw-RC_A2b-A3b_sl_Large_2013-07-16

xr

sigswmeas

sigswass

sigsw

omwu

andbr

[]

mm

mm

MPa

MPa

MPa

S1-1
S1-2
S1-3
S1-4
S1-5
S1-6
S2-1
S2-2
S2-3
S2-4
S2-5
S3-1
S3-2
S3-3
S3-4
S3-5
S3-6
S4-1
S4-3
S4-4
S4-6
S5-1
S5-2
S5-3
S7-1
S7-2
S7-3
S7-4
S7-5
S7-6
S8-1
S8-2
S8-3
S8-4
S8-5
S8-6
26-1
29b-1
29a-2
29b-2
29c-2
29d-2
29f-2
29g-2
24.5-3
39-3

50
55
41
40

355
332
354
310
365
420
464
344
354
408
310
359
381
420
398
360
360
585
415
381

355
332
354
310
365
420
464
344
354
408
310
359
381
420
398
360
360
585
415
381
250
476
400
341
473
473
473
473
473
388
376
354
398
365
365
442
883
883
883
883
883
883
883
883
883
883

0
0
314
450
0
0
0
0
266
279
0
0
0
300
350
0
0
183
0
317
300
411
0
300
0
0
372
375
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
341
341
372
372
372
372
372
372
0
276

0,0000
0,0000
0,0103
0,0147
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0076
0,0080
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0060
0,0070
0,0000
0,0000
0,0044
0,0000
0,0076
0,0072
0,0096
0,0000
0,0070
0,0000
0,0000
0,0104
0,0131
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0183
0,0130
0,0144
0,0129
0,0221
0,0176
0,0128
0,0340
0,0000
0,0208

49
45
55
44
50
47
58
45
46
53
45

47
45

58
50
45
45

xr_meas

476
400
341

388
376
354
398

442

314
450

266
279

300
350

183
317
300
411
300

372
375

341
341
372
372
372
372
372
372
276

Mu

muu

vutest

kapc

sigsl

xsitest

betaflex

BB

kNm

MPa

mm

mm

kN

166,66
152,06
150,45
202,87
184,91
163,59
190,02
169,73
184,91
160,16
205,93
154,81
131,72
166,88
127,68
213,55
203,69
460,20
202,02
188,41
101,45
212,70
207,92
177,97
205,25
194,10
232,94
258,55
287,66
293,52
198,63
183,23
226,01
194,03
211,12
207,25
365,12
282,67
382,40
357,27
285,03
291,31
413,80
264,61
410,66
423,23

0,1336
0,1219
0,1206
0,1627
0,1483
0,1312
0,1336
0,1194
0,1301
0,1126
0,1448
0,1132
0,0963
0,1254
0,0959
0,1672
0,1595
0,0835
0,0913
0,1101
0,1289
0,1213
0,1186
0,1015
0,1544
0,1460
0,1752
0,1945
0,2164
0,2208
0,1358
0,1252
0,1545
0,1326
0,1443
0,1417
0,1816
0,1498
0,2053
0,1723
0,2357
0,1912
0,1976
0,3359
0,2312
0,1979

0,0740
0,0668
0,0660
0,0925
0,0832
0,0724
0,0744
0,0655
0,0721
0,0615
0,0815
0,0617
0,0519
0,0693
0,0517
0,0955
0,0904
0,0450
0,0492
0,0604
0,0714
0,0559
0,0600
0,0553
0,0646
0,0606
0,0750
0,0851
0,0973
0,0999
0,0758
0,0692
0,0879
0,0738
0,0813
0,0796
0,0667
0,0535
0,0769
0,0629
0,0889
0,0704
0,0738
0,1388
0,0883
0,0737

0,766
0,766
0,766
0,766
0,766
0,766
0,733
0,733
0,733
0,733
0,733
0,752
0,752
0,752
0,752
0,752
0,752
0,679
0,679
0,679
0,679
0,671
0,671
0,671
0,725
0,725
0,725
0,725
0,725
0,725
0,725
0,725
0,725
0,725
0,725
0,725
0,847
0,857
0,859
0,843
0,908
0,884
0,841
0,940
0,865
0,838

309
279
276
386
347
302
354
312
343
293
388
450
387
307
229
309
292
230
266
346
415
396
386
325
256
240
297
337
385
396
371
339
430
362
398
390
352
266
378
344
271
283
406
277
406
406

0,193
0,174
0,172
0,242
0,217
0,189
0,203
0,179
0,197
0,168
0,222
0,160
0,138
0,184
0,137
0,255
0,241
0,132
0,145
0,178
0,212
0,201
0,196
0,165
0,242
0,227
0,281
0,319
0,365
0,375
0,209
0,191
0,242
0,204
0,224
0,219
0,243
0,194
0,278
0,231
0,290
0,247
0,271
0,439
0,311
0,266

0,903
0,913
0,914
0,879
0,891
0,905
0,899
0,911
0,902
0,916
0,889
0,920
0,931
0,908
0,932
0,873
0,879
0,934
0,928
0,911
0,894
0,899
0,902
0,918
0,879
0,886
0,859
0,840
0,817
0,813
0,896
0,905
0,879
0,898
0,888
0,890
0,879
0,903
0,861
0,884
0,855
0,877
0,864
0,781
0,845
0,867

264
267
267
257
260
264
262
266
263
268
260
273
277
266
273
250
252
490
308
266
177
263
263
268
244
246
239
234
227
226
261
264
257
262
259
260
400
412
392
403
390
400
394
356
385
395

0,859
0,859
0,859
0,859
0,859
0,859
0,870
0,870
0,870
0,870
0,870
0,920
0,920
0,865
0,865
0,818
0,818
0,870
0,877
0,884
0,887
0,885
0,885
0,885
0,795
0,795
0,795
0,795
0,795
0,795
0,873
0,873
0,873
0,873
0,873
0,873
0,879
0,877
0,859
0,878
0,855
0,873
0,864
0,781
0,845
0,867

251
251
251
251
251
251
254
254
254
254
254
273
273
253
253
235
235
456
291
258
176
258
258
258
221
221
221
221
221
221
255
255
255
255
255
255
400
400
391
400
390
398
394
356
385
395

0,1859
0,1859
0,1859
0,1859
0,1859
0,1859
0,1653
0,1653
0,1653
0,1653
0,1653
0,1108
0,1108
0,1760
0,1760
0,2242
0,2242
0,1530
0,1460
0,1394
0,1361
0,1363
0,1363
0,1363
0,2363
0,2363
0,2363
0,2363
0,2363
0,2363
0,1611
0,1611
0,1611
0,1611
0,1611
0,1611
0,1809
0,1850
0,2079
0,1811
0,2252
0,1956
0,1971
0,3220
0,2270
0,1934

231,87
231,87
231,87
231,87
231,87
231,87
235,06
235,06
235,06
235,06
235,06
151,47
151,47
234,28
234,28
286,28
286,28
843,67
323,02
238,66
107,12
239,05
239,05
239,05
314,22
314,22
314,22
314,22
314,22
314,22
235,69
235,69
235,69
235,69
235,69
235,69
363,82
348,96
387,13
375,52
272,33
298,01
412,67
253,70
403,22
413,77

317,64
317,64
317,64
317,64
317,64
317,64
322,00
322,00
322,00
322,00
322,00
204,69
204,69
320,93
320,93
397,62
397,62
648,98
389,18
326,93
214,24
271,64
298,81
327,46
332,51
332,51
332,51
332,51
332,51
332,51
322,86
322,86
322,86
322,86
322,86
322,86
206,10
197,68
219,30
212,72
154,27
168,81
233,77
143,71
228,41
234,39

0,72
0,66
0,65
0,87
0,80
0,71
0,81
0,72
0,79
0,68
0,88
1,02
0,87
0,71
0,54
0,75
0,71
0,55
0,63
0,79
0,95
0,89
0,87
0,74
0,65
0,62
0,74
0,82
0,92
0,93
0,84
0,78
0,96
0,82
0,90
0,88
1,00
0,81
0,99
0,95
1,05
0,98
1,00
1,04
1,02
1,02

S-2013-078: Reineck; Bentz; Fitik; Kuchma; Bayrak

zetatest

10

z_test

zeta

z_

muflex

Mu_flex

Vu_flex

BB

BB

BB
BB
BB
BB
BB

18.01.2013

vsw-RC-A2b-A3b_sl_Large

ACI-DAfStb Large Collection Database for r.c.-beams with stirrups

sin2thp
-

359
360
361
362
363
364
365
366
367
368
369
371
372
373
374
375
376
377
379
380
382
383
384
385
389
390
391
392
393
394
395
396
397
398
399
400
420
422
425
426
427
428
430
431
434
444

Kong;
Rangan (1997)

Krefeld; Thurston (1966)

App-B3_vsw-RC_A2b-A3b_sl_Large_2013-07-16

betalb

VB

[ ]

[ ]

S1-1
S1-2
S1-3
S1-4
S1-5
S1-6
S2-1
S2-2
S2-3
S2-4
S2-5
S3-1
S3-2
S3-3
S3-4
S3-5
S3-6
S4-1
S4-3
S4-4
S4-6
S5-1
S5-2
S5-3
S7-1
S7-2
S7-3
S7-4
S7-5
S7-6
S8-1
S8-2
S8-3
S8-4
S8-5
S8-6
26-1
29b-1
29a-2
29b-2
29c-2
29d-2
29f-2
29g-2
24.5-3
39-3

0,02
0,02
0,02
0,02
0,02
0,02
0,01
0,01
0,02
0,02
0,02
0,01
0,01
0,01
0,01
0,01
0,01
0,01
0,01
0,01
0,01
0,01
0,01
0,01
0,01
0,01
0,02
0,02
0,02
0,03
0,01
0,01
0,02
0,02
0,02
0,02
0,02
0,01
0,01
0,01
0,02
0,02
0,01
0,03
0,02
0,02

7,85
7,85
7,85
7,85
7,85
7,85
5,99
6,57
7,35
7,35
8,49
6,43
6,43
6,43
6,43
6,43
6,43
6,69
6,69
6,69
6,69
6,61
6,61
6,61
5,90
6,47
7,23
8,09
8,65
9,35
5,91
6,47
7,24
7,24
8,10
8,67
7,78
6,55
6,89
6,53
8,56
7,62
6,49
10,62
7,97
8,29

thp

cotthp

7,26
7,26
7,26
7,26
7,26
7,26
9,53
8,69
7,76
7,76
6,70
8,87
8,87
8,87
8,87
8,87
8,87
8,52
8,52
8,52
8,52
8,63
8,63
8,63
9,68
8,82
7,88
7,03
6,57
6,07
9,66
8,81
7,87
7,87
7,02
6,56
7,32
8,71
8,28
8,74
6,65
7,48
8,79
5,33
7,15
6,86

0,14
0,14
0,14
0,14
0,14
0,14
0,10
0,11
0,13
0,13
0,15
0,11
0,11
0,11
0,11
0,11
0,11
0,12
0,12
0,12
0,12
0,11
0,11
0,11
0,10
0,11
0,12
0,14
0,15
0,16
0,10
0,11
0,13
0,13
0,14
0,15
0,13
0,11
0,12
0,11
0,15
0,13
0,11
0,18
0,14
0,14

vup

gamwp

0,55
0,49
0,49
0,68
0,61
0,54
0,72
0,58
0,57
0,48
0,56
0,55
0,47
0,62
0,46
0,86
0,81
0,39
0,43
0,52
0,62
0,49
0,52
0,48
0,63
0,54
0,60
0,61
0,65
0,62
0,74
0,62
0,70
0,59
0,58
0,53
0,50
0,47
0,65
0,56
0,60
0,54
0,66
0,77
0,64
0,52

cotthu

0,00
0,00
6,42
6,27
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
9,44
7,68
0,00
0,00
0,00
11,63
7,43
0,00
0,00
10,29
0,00
7,99
9,97
5,85
0,00
7,91
0,00
0,00
7,23
6,52
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
3,64
4,11
5,35
4,87
4,02
4,00
5,77
4,08
0,00
3,54

0,00
0,00
8,85
9,05
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
6,05
7,42
0,00
0,00
0,00
4,92
7,66
0,00
0,00
5,55
0,00
7,13
5,73
9,70
0,00
7,20
0,00
0,00
7,87
8,72
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
15,35
13,66
10,59
11,61
13,98
14,03
9,84
13,76
0,00
15,76

thu

0,00
0,00
0,35
0,48
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,55
0,38
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,65
0,31
0,00
0,00
0,37
0,00
0,39
0,58
0,27
0,00
0,36
0,00
0,00
0,44
0,45
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,21
0,19
0,34
0,26
0,30
0,24
0,35
0,48
0,00
0,23

nueu

0,29
0,27
0,27
0,36
0,33
0,29
0,32
0,28
0,31
0,27
0,34
0,33
0,28
0,28
0,22
0,19
0,18
0,03
0,13
0,23
0,43
0,32
0,27
0,27
0,17
0,16
0,19
0,21
0,23
0,24
0,33
0,30
0,37
0,32
0,35
0,34
0,30
0,24
0,33
0,28
0,34
0,29
0,33
0,47
0,37
0,33

A2+A3

kon34

0
0
1
1
0
0
0
0
1
1
0
0
0
1
1
0
0
1
0
1
1
1
0
1
0
0
1
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
0
1

1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1

KONA4 KONA5 A4+A5 Differenz AF

0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
0
0
0
0
1
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
0
1

0
0
1
1
0
0
0
0
1
1
0
0
0
1
1
0
0
1
0
1
1
0
0
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0

0
0
1
1
0
0
0
0
1
1
0
0
0
1
1
0
0
1
0
1
1
1
0
1
0
0
1
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
0
1

0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0

S-2013-078: Reineck; Bentz; Fitik; Kuchma; Bayrak

11

f1ck
MPa
54,7
54,7
54,7
54,7
54,7
54,7
62,9
62,9
62,9
62,9
62,9
58,2
58,2
58,2
58,2
58,2
58,2
76,5
76,5
76,5
76,5
78,4
78,4
78,4
65,0
65,0
65,0
65,0
65,0
65,0
64,8
64,8
64,8
64,8
64,8
64,8
34,3
32,0
31,5
35,5
19,1
25,1
35,9
11,1
29,9
36,8

fcm_cyl
MPa
61,6
61,6
61,6
61,6
61,6
61,6
70,2
70,2
70,2
70,2
70,2
65,3
65,3
65,3
65,3
65,3
65,3
84,5
84,5
84,5
84,5
86,6
86,6
86,6
72,4
72,4
72,4
72,4
72,4
72,4
72,2
72,2
72,2
72,2
72,2
72,2
40,1
37,7
37,2
41,4
24,1
30,4
41,8
15,7
35,4
42,7

fck
MPa
57,6
57,6
57,6
57,6
57,6
57,6
66,2
66,2
66,2
66,2
66,2
61,3
61,3
61,3
61,3
61,3
61,3
80,5
80,5
80,5
80,5
82,6
82,6
82,6
68,4
68,4
68,4
68,4
68,4
68,4
68,2
68,2
68,2
68,2
68,2
68,2
36,1
33,7
33,2
37,4
20,1
26,4
37,8
11,7
31,4
38,7

fc_prime
MPa
59,2
59,2
59,2
59,2
59,2
59,2
67,8
67,8
67,8
67,8
67,8
62,9
62,9
62,9
62,9
62,9
62,9
82,1
82,1
82,1
82,1
84,2
84,2
84,2
70,0
70,0
70,0
70,0
70,0
70,0
69,8
69,8
69,8
69,8
69,8
69,8
37,7
35,3
34,8
39,0
21,7
28,0
39,4
13,3
33,0
40,3

Vct_ACI Vs_ACI
kN
kN
93,28
63,69
93,28
63,69
93,28
63,69
93,28
63,69
93,28
63,69
93,28
63,69
99,84
42,46
99,84
50,95
99,84
63,69
99,84
63,69
99,84
84,92
97,78
46,24
97,78
46,24
96,47
45,61
96,47
45,61
94,49
44,68
94,49
44,68
197,20
114,29
124,94
72,41
109,89
63,69
74,51
43,19
111,24
63,69
111,24
63,69
111,24
63,69
96,60
40,42
96,60
48,51
96,60
60,64
96,60
75,80
96,60
86,62
96,60
101,06
101,33
42,46
101,33
50,95
101,33
63,69
101,33
63,69
101,33
79,61
101,33
90,99
118,09
64,65
114,14
43,10
113,36
47,02
120,02
47,02
89,63
47,02
101,75
47,02
120,66
47,02
70,17
47,02
110,51
59,91
122,02
78,05

Vcal_sACI Vmax_ACI rat_smax


kN
kN
156,97
466,41
0,337
156,97
466,41
0,337
156,97
466,41
0,337
156,97
466,41
0,337
156,97
466,41
0,337
156,97
466,41
0,337
142,30
499,21
0,285
150,79
499,21
0,302
163,53
499,21
0,328
163,53
499,21
0,328
184,76
499,21
0,370
144,02
488,92
0,295
144,02
488,92
0,295
142,08
482,34
0,295
142,08
482,34
0,295
139,17
472,46
0,295
139,17
472,46
0,295
311,49
985,99
0,316
197,36
624,71
0,316
173,58
549,45
0,316
117,70
372,57
0,316
174,93
556,21
0,315
174,93
556,21
0,315
174,93
556,21
0,315
137,03
483,02
0,284
145,11
483,02
0,300
157,24
483,02
0,326
172,40
483,02
0,357
183,23
483,02
0,379
197,66
483,02
0,409
143,79
506,65
0,284
152,28
506,65
0,301
165,02
506,65
0,326
165,02
506,65
0,326
180,94
506,65
0,357
192,31
506,65
0,380
182,74
590,47
0,309
157,24
570,71
0,276
160,38
566,79
0,283
167,04
600,10
0,278
136,65
448,14
0,305
148,77
508,74
0,292
167,67
603,28
0,278
117,19
350,85
0,334
170,42
552,56
0,308
200,07
610,10
0,328

VACI_cal
kN
156,97
156,97
156,97
156,97
156,97
156,97
142,30
150,79
163,53
163,53
184,76
144,02
144,02
142,08
142,08
139,17
139,17
311,49
197,36
173,58
117,70
174,93
174,93
174,93
137,03
145,11
157,24
172,40
183,23
197,66
143,79
152,28
165,02
165,02
180,94
192,31
182,74
157,24
160,38
167,04
136,65
148,77
167,67
117,19
170,42
200,07

18.01.2013

vsw-RC-A2b-A3b_sl_Large

ACI-DAfStb Large Collection Database for r.c.-beams with stirrups

12

gmod_ACI
-

359
360
361
362
363
364
365
366
367
368
369
371
372
373
374
375
376
377
379
380
382
383
384
385
389
390
391
392
393
394
395
396
397
398
399
400
420
422
425
426
427
428
430
431
434
444

Kong;
Rangan (1997)

Krefeld; Thurston (1966)

App-B3_vsw-RC_A2b-A3b_sl_Large_2013-07-16

S1-1
S1-2
S1-3
S1-4
S1-5
S1-6
S2-1
S2-2
S2-3
S2-4
S2-5
S3-1
S3-2
S3-3
S3-4
S3-5
S3-6
S4-1
S4-3
S4-4
S4-6
S5-1
S5-2
S5-3
S7-1
S7-2
S7-3
S7-4
S7-5
S7-6
S8-1
S8-2
S8-3
S8-4
S8-5
S8-6
26-1
29b-1
29a-2
29b-2
29c-2
29d-2
29f-2
29g-2
24.5-3
39-3

1,454
1,327
1,313
1,770
1,614
1,428
1,829
1,542
1,549
1,342
1,527
1,453
1,236
1,609
1,231
2,131
2,033
1,136
1,233
1,487
1,724
1,382
1,486
1,394
1,585
1,415
1,568
1,587
1,661
1,571
1,892
1,648
1,876
1,611
1,598
1,476
1,132
1,018
1,351
1,212
1,182
1,109
1,398
1,279
1,365
1,198

S-2013-078: Reineck; Bentz; Fitik; Kuchma; Bayrak

18.01.2013

vsw-RC-A2b-A3b_sl_Large

ACI-DAfStb Large Collection Database for r.c.-beams with stirrups

E
Leonhardt_1962_002_ET2
Leonhardt_1962_003_ET3
Leonhardt_1962_004_ET4
Leonhardt_1962_002_T1 ( r )
Leonhardt_1963_003_TA1
Leonhardt_1963_004_TA2
Leonhardt_1963_005_TA3
Leonhardt_1963_006_TA4
Leonhardt_1963_009_TA11
Leonhardt_1963_010_TA12
Leonhardt_1963_011_TA13
Leonhardt_1963_012_TA14
Leonhardt_1963_013_TA15
Leonhardt_1963_014_TA6
Leonhardt_1963_015_TA16
Levi_1989/1993_001_RC 30 A1
Levi_1989/1993_002_RC 30 A2
Levi_1989/1993_003_RC 60 A1
Levi_1989/1993_004_RC 60 A2
Levi_1989/1993_005_RC 60 B1
Levi_1989/1993_006_RC 60 B2
Levi_1989/1993_007_RC 70 B1
Lynberg_1974_001_5A-0
Lynberg_1974_002_5B-0
Maruyama_1988_001_RS2-WD
Moayer_1974_002_P20
zden_1967_002_T6
zden_1967_003_T7
zden_1967_004_T9
Ozcebe_1999_003_TS56
Ozcebe_1999_006_TS59
Ozcebe_1999_009_TS36
Ozcebe_1999_011_TH39
Ozcebe_1999_012_TS39
Petersson_1972_001_V1
Petersson_1972_002_VL1

483
484
485
490
491
492
493
494
497
498
499
500
501
502
503
504
505
506
507
508
509
510
511
512
523
525
534
535
536
553
556
559
561
562
564
565

Leonhardt; Walther;
DAfStb 151 (1962)
Leonhardt; Walther; DAfStb 152 (1962)
Leonhardt; Walther
DAfStb 156 (1963)

Levi;
Marro
(1989/1993)

Lyngberg
(1974)
Maruyama K., Rizkalla S. H. (1988)
Moayer; Regan (1974)
zden (1967)

Ozcebe; Ersoy;
Tankut (1999)

Petersson (1972)

App-B3_vsw-RC_A2b-A3b_sl_Large_2013-07-16

hf

hh,top

SI / A

mm

mm

mm

mm

mm

ET2
ET3
ET4
T1 ( r )
TA1
TA2
TA3
TA4
TA11
TA12
TA13
TA14
TA15
TA6
TA16
RC 30 A1
RC 30 A2
RC 60 A1
RC 60 A2
RC 60 B1
RC 60 B2
RC 70 B1
5A-0
5B-0
RS2-WD
P20
T6
T7
T9
TS56
TS59
TS36
TH39
TS39
V1
VL1

SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
A
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI

300,0
300,0
300,0
1500,0
960,0
960,0
960,0
960,0
960,0
960,0
960,0
960,0
960,0
960,0
960,0
900,0
900,0
900,0
900,0
900,0
900,0
900,0
700,0
700,0
650,0
599,4
400,0
400,0
400,0
150,0
150,0
150,0
150,0
150,0
175,0
301,0

150,0
100,0
50,0
100,0
160,0
160,0
160,0
160,0
160,0
160,0
160,0
160,0
160,0
160,0
160,0
120,0
120,0
120,0
120,0
120,0
120,0
120,0
120,0
120,0
86,3
149,9
110,0
110,0
110,0
150,0
150,0
150,0
150,0
150,0
175,0
120,0

bw

350,0
350,0
350,0
900,0
440,0
440,0
440,0
440,0
440,0
440,0
440,0
440,0
440,0
440,0
440,0
1050,0
1050,0
1050,0
1050,0
1050,0
1050,0
1050,0
600,0
600,0
490,0
320,0
355,0
355,0
355,0
360,0
360,0
360,0
360,0
360,0
353,0
307,0

75,0
75,0
75,0
150,0
80,0
80,0
80,0
80,0
80,0
80,0
80,0
80,0
80,0
80,0
80,0
130,0
130,0
130,0
130,0
130,0
130,0
130,0
90,0
90,0
60,0
81,3
80,0
80,0
80,0

63,0

10,0
10,0
50,0

hw

hft

hh,bot

bft

mm

mm

mm

mm

275,0
275,0
175,0
600,0
360,0
360,0
360,0
360,0
360,0
360,0
360,0
360,0
360,0
360,0
360,0
700,0
700,0
700,0
700,0
700,0
700,0
700,0
360,0
360,0
380,0
238,8
275,0
275,0
275,0

175,0

100,0
150,0

100,0
500,0

220,0
220,0
220,0
220,0
220,0
220,0
220,0
110,0
110,0

350,0
350,0
350,0
350,0
350,0
350,0
350,0
380,0
380,0

63,0

30,0
30,0

301,0

Ac

zc2

aa

af

13

kap

cc

mm

mm

mm

mm

mm

mm

mm

mm

mm

63750
50000
41250
362500
134400
134400
134400
134400
134400
134400
134400
134400
134400
134400
134400
278000
278000
278000
278000
278000
278000
278000
159600
159600
90550
84503
62250
62250
62250
54000
54000
54000
54000
54000
61775
60732

150,7
133,8
127,7
291,7
134,3
134,3
134,3
134,3
134,3
134,3
134,3
134,3
134,3
134,3
134,3
432,8
432,8
432,8
432,8
432,8
432,8
432,8
261,1
261,1
168,0
108,4
126,3
126,3
126,3
180,0
180,0
180,0
180,0
180,0
176,5
151,9

100,0
100,0
100,0
200,0
120,0
120,0
120,0
120,0
120,0
120,0
120,0
120,0
120,0
120,0
120,0

100,0
100,0
100,0
200,0
120,0
120,0
120,0
120,0
120,0
120,0
120,0
120,0
120,0
120,0
120,0

200,0
200,0
200,0
125,0
150,0
150,0
150,0
150,0
290,0
290,0
290,0
290,0
290,0
150,0
290,0
250,0
250,0
250,0
250,0
250,0
250,0
250,0
425,0
425,0
250,0
304,8
250,0
250,0
250,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
300,0
300,0

3000,0
3000,0
3000,0
6000,0
3000,0
3000,0
3000,0
3000,0
3000,0
3000,0
3000,0
3000,0
3000,0
3000,0
3000,0
9600,0
9600,0
9600,0
9600,0
9600,0
9600,0
9600,0
5000,0
5000,0
3000,0
1981,2
3000,0
3000,0
3000,0
3500,0
3500,0
2260,0
2260,0
2260,0
2600,0
2200,0

900,0
900,0
900,0
1000,0
750,0
500,0
500,0
500,0
500,0
500,0
500,0
500,0
500,0
500,0
500,0
2000,0
2000,0
2000,0
2000,0
2000,0
2000,0
2000,0
2000,0
2000,0
700,0
26,7
900,0
900,0
900,0
400,0
400,0
400,0
400,0
400,0
100,0
100,0

1050,0
1050,0
1050,0
2500,0
1125,0
1250,0
1250,0
1250,0
1250,0
1250,0
1250,0
1250,0
1250,0
1250,0
1250,0
3800,0
3800,0
3800,0
3800,0
3800,0
3800,0
3800,0
1500,0
1500,0
1150,0
977,3
1050,0
1050,0
1050,0
1550,0
1550,0
930,0
930,0
930,0
1150,0
900,0

3,50
3,50
3,50
3,03
3,00
3,33
3,33
3,33
3,33
3,33
3,33
3,33
3,33
3,33
3,33
4,04
4,04
4,04
4,04
4,04
4,04
4,04
2,78
2,78
2,89
3,50
3,52
3,52
3,52
5,00
5,00
3,00
3,00
3,00
3,57
3,24

76,2 26,7
120,0 130,0
120,0 130,0
120,0 130,0

175,0 100,0
300,0 100,0

S-2013-078: Reineck; Bentz; Fitik; Kuchma; Bayrak

ba

20,0
20,0

19,0
19,0
19,0

18.01.2013

vsw-RC-A2b-A3b_sl_Large

ACI-DAfStb Large Collection Database for r.c.-beams with stirrups

ds
-

483
484
485
490
491
492
493
494
497
498
499
500
501
502
503
504
505
506
507
508
509
510
511
512
523
525
534
535
536
553
556
559
561
562
564
565

Leonhardt; Walther;
DAfStb 151 (1962)
Leonhardt; Walther; DAfStb 152 (1962)
Leonhardt; Walther
DAfStb 156 (1963)

Levi;
Marro
(1989/1993)

Lyngberg
(1974)
Maruyama K., Rizkalla S. H. (1988)
Moayer; Regan (1974)
zden (1967)

Ozcebe; Ersoy;
Tankut (1999)

Petersson (1972)

App-B3_vsw-RC_A2b-A3b_sl_Large_2013-07-16

ftk/fsy

euk

ds2

mm

mm

mm

mm

MPa

MPa

mm

ET2
ET3
ET4
T1 ( r )
TA1
TA2
TA3
TA4
TA11
TA12
TA13
TA14
TA15
TA6
TA16
RC 30 A1
RC 30 A2
RC 60 A1
RC 60 A2
RC 60 B1
RC 60 B2
RC 70 B1
5A-0
5B-0
RS2-WD
P20
T6
T7
T9
TS56
TS59
TS36
TH39
TS39
V1
VL1

300,0
300,0
300,0
825,0
375,0
375,0
375,0
375,0
375,0
375,0
375,0
375,0
375,0
375,0
375,0
940,0
940,0
940,0
940,0
940,0
940,0
940,0
540,0
540,0
450,0
279,4
298,0
298,0
298,0
310,0
310,0
310,0
310,0
310,0
322,0
278,0

300,0
300,0
300,0
825,0
375,0
375,0
375,0
375,0
375,0
375,0
375,0
375,0
375,0
375,0
375,0
940,0
940,0
940,0
940,0
940,0
940,0
940,0
540,0
540,0
397,5
279,4
298,0
298,0
298,0
310,0
310,0
310,0
310,0
310,0
322,0
278,0

ns

4
4
4
16
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
20
20
20
20
20
20
20
8
8
2
4
4
4
4
8
4
6
2
2
3
5

20,0
20,0
20,0
26,0
24,0
24,0
24,0
24,0
24,0
24,0
24,0
24,0
24,0
24,0
24,0
24,0
24,0
26,0
26,0
30,0
30,0
30,0
20,0
20,0
16,0
15,9
20,0
20,0
20,0
16,0
20,0
16,0
20,0
20,0
16,0
16,0

dst

fR

r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r

1256,6
1256,6
1256,6
8464,0
2714,3
2714,3
2714,3
2714,3
2714,3
2714,3
2714,3
2714,3
2714,3
2714,3
2714,3
9047,8
9047,8
10618,6
10618,6
14137,2
14137,2
14137,2
2513,3
2513,3
402,1
791,7
1256,6
1256,6
1256,6
1608,5
2060,9
1206,4
1432,6
1432,6
603,2
1005,3

As

alphaa

1,00
1,00
1,00
0,01
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
0,70
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
0,01
0,01
0,01
0,01
0,01
1,00
1,00

1,3963
1,3963
1,3963
0,6840
0,7540
0,7540
0,7540
0,7540
0,7540
0,7540
0,7540
0,7540
0,7540
0,7540
0,7540
1,0695
1,0695
1,2552
1,2552
1,6711
1,6711
1,6711
0,6649
0,6649
0,1375
0,4727
1,0542
1,0542
1,0542
3,4591
4,4320
2,5943
3,0808
3,0808
1,0704
1,2014

rhos

2,7925
4,1888
8,3776
10,2594
4,5239
4,5239
4,5239
4,5239
4,5239
4,5239
4,5239
4,5239
4,5239
4,5239
4,5239
8,0211
8,0211
9,4136
9,4136
12,5329
12,5329
12,5329
3,8785
3,8785
1,0355
1,8909
3,8335
3,8335
3,8335
3,4591
4,4320
2,5943
3,0808
3,0808
1,0704
3,0135

rhosw

419,9
419,9
419,9
464,8
409,1
409,1
409,1
409,1
409,1
409,1
409,1
409,1
390,4
409,1
390,4
500,0
500,0
450,0
450,0
470,0
470,0
470,0
616,3
623,1
400,0
641,4
441,5
447,3
444,4
450,0
434,8
450,0
439,0
439,0
977,0
990,0

fsy

2,10
2,10
2,10
2,32
2,05
2,05
2,05
2,05
2,05
2,05
2,05
2,05
1,95
2,05
1,95
2,50
2,50
2,25
2,25
2,35
2,35
2,35
3,08
3,12
2,00
3,21
2,21
2,24
2,22
2,25
2,17
2,25
2,20
2,20
4,89
4,95

esy

524,84
524,84
524,84
549,17
535,63
535,63
535,63
535,63
535,63
535,63
535,63
535,63
518,95
535,63
518,95

ftk

1,25
1,25
1,25
1,18
1,31
1,31
1,31
1,31
1,31
1,31
1,31
1,31
1,33
1,31
1,33
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
1,18
1,18
0,00
1,46
1,02
1,00
1,01
1,60
1,60
1,60
1,60
1,60
0,00
0,00

725,00
733,00
937,93
448,32
448,32
448,32
720,00
695,61
720,00
702,46
702,46

ns2

dst2

As2

zw1

zw2

mm

mm

MPa

mm

mm

mm

mm

mm

MPa

2
2
2
11
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4
4

8,0
8,0
8,0
10,0
10,0
10,0
10,0
10,0
10,0
10,0
10,0
10,0
10,0
10,0
10,0

100,5
100,5
100,5
863,9
314,2
314,2
314,2
314,2
314,2
314,2
314,2
314,2
314,2
314,2
314,2

456
456
456

6
6
2

10,0
10,0
9,5

471,2
471,2
142,5

2
2
2
2
2
2
2

10,0
10,0
10,0
10,0
10,0
10,0
16,0

157,1
157,1
157,1
157,1
157,1
157,1
402,1

6,0
6,0
6,0
12,0
12,0
10,0
8,0
6,0
8,0
6,0
12,0
10,0
8,0
8,0
8,0
12,0
12,0
12,0
12,0
12,0
12,0
12,0
8,0
8,0
6,2
5,6
8,0
8,0
8,0
4,0
4,0
4,0
4,0
4,0
6,0
8,0

2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
1
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2

56,5
56,5
56,5
232,0
226,2
157,1
100,5
56,5
100,5
56,5
226,2
157,1
100,5
100,5
100,5
226,2
226,2
226,2
226,2
226,2
226,2
226,2
100,5
100,5
30,2
48,5
100,5
100,5
100,5
25,1
25,1
25,1
25,1
25,1
56,5
100,5

0
0
0
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r.ass
r.ass
r.ass
r.ass
r.ass
r.ass
r.ass
r
r
r
0
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
0
0

110,0
110,0
110,0
80,0
113,0
113,0
113,0
113,0
113,0
113,0
113,0
113,0
113,0
113,0
113,0
225,0
225,0
225,0
225,0
150,0
150,0
150,0
160,0
160,0
152,0
152,4
150,0
150,0
150,0
70,0
60,0
70,0
80,0
60,0
150,0
100,0

0,31
0,31
0,31
0,09
0,26
0,26
0,26
0,26
0,26
0,26
0,26
0,26
0,26
0,26
0,26
0,21
0,21
0,21
0,21
0,14
0,14
0,14
0,27
0,27
0,31
0,48
0,42
0,42
0,42
0,19
0,17
0,19
0,22
0,17
0,42
0,33

0,37
0,37
0,37
0,10
0,30
0,30
0,30
0,30
0,30
0,30
0,30
0,30
0,30
0,30
0,30
0,24
0,24
0,24
0,24
0,16
0,16
0,16
0,30
0,30
0,38
0,55
0,50
0,50
0,50
0,23
0,19
0,23
0,26
0,19
0,47
0,36

270
270
270
765
315
325
335
345
335
345
315
325
335
335
335
880
880
880
880
880
880
880
500
500
419
252
258
258
258
290
290
290
290
290
292
238

0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
500
500
0
0
260
260
260
0
0
0
0
0
0
0

0,3427
0,5141
1,0282
2,9000
1,2511
0,8688
0,5560
0,3128
0,5560
0,3128
1,2511
0,8688
0,5560
0,5560
0,5560
0,8378
0,8378
0,8378
0,8378
1,2566
1,2566
1,2566
0,5236
0,5236
0,2302
0,2123
0,6093
0,6093
0,6093
0,2394
0,2793
0,2394
0,2094
0,2793
0,2154
0,8378

313,9
313,9
313,9
426,6
426,7
425,8
417,9
440,5
417,9
440,5
426,7
425,8
417,9
417,9
417,9
480,0
480,0
480,0
480,0
480,0
480,0
480,0
674,0
647,0
645,0
310,3
272,7
272,7
272,7
255,0
255,0
255,0
255,0
255,0
323,0
366,0

S-2013-078: Reineck; Bentz; Fitik; Kuchma; Bayrak

fsy2

14

426
426
426
426
426
426
426
426
426
426
426

410
410
410
410
410
463
635

dw

nsw

Asw

frw

sw

sw/h

rhow

fyw

18.01.2013

vsw-RC-A2b-A3b_sl_Large

ACI-DAfStb Large Collection Database for r.c.-beams with stirrups

fyw_rhow_100
-

483
484
485
490
491
492
493
494
497
498
499
500
501
502
503
504
505
506
507
508
509
510
511
512
523
525
534
535
536
553
556
559
561
562
564
565

Leonhardt; Walther;
DAfStb 151 (1962)
Leonhardt; Walther; DAfStb 152 (1962)
Leonhardt; Walther
DAfStb 156 (1963)

Levi;
Marro
(1989/1993)

Lyngberg
(1974)
Maruyama K., Rizkalla S. H. (1988)
Moayer; Regan (1974)
zden (1967)

Ozcebe; Ersoy;
Tankut (1999)

Petersson (1972)

App-B3_vsw-RC_A2b-A3b_sl_Large_2013-07-16

fwtk/fyw

ewuk

MPa

MPa

ET2
ET3
ET4
T1 ( r )
TA1
TA2
TA3
TA4
TA11
TA12
TA13
TA14
TA15
TA6
TA16
RC 30 A1
RC 30 A2
RC 60 A1
RC 60 A2
RC 60 B1
RC 60 B2
RC 70 B1
5A-0
5B-0
RS2-WD
P20
T6
T7
T9
TS56
TS59
TS36
TH39
TS39
V1
VL1

1,08
1,61
3,23
12,37
5,34
3,70
2,32
1,38
2,32
1,38
5,34
3,70
2,32
2,32
2,32
4,02
4,02
4,02
4,02
6,03
6,03
6,03
3,53
3,39
1,48
0,66
1,66
1,66
1,66
0,61
0,71
0,61
0,53
0,71
0,70
3,07

376,70
376,70
376,70
536,42
536,61
537,59
525,82
569,96
525,82
569,96
536,61
537,59
525,82
525,82
525,82

fwtk

1,20
1,20
1,20
1,26
1,26
1,26
1,26
1,29
1,26
1,29
1,26
1,26
1,26
1,26
1,26
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
1,13
1,13
1,00
1,38
0,00
0,00
0,00
1,41
1,41
1,41
1,41
1,41
0,00
0,00

760,00
734,00
645,00
427,59

360,00
360,00
360,00
360,00
360,00

diaa

f1c

Method

fcwu

f1cttest

Method

betacttest

f1ctmcal

betactcal

oms

oml

omwy

15

Vg

Vu_F+g,rep

Vu_Rep

Vu_gF

mm

MPa

MPa

MPa

MPa

kN/m

kN

kN

kN

kN

kN

30,0
30,0
30,0
30,0
30,0
30,0
30,0
30,0
30,0
30,0
30,0
30,0
30,0
30,0
30,0

22,56
22,56
22,56
23,01
16,68
16,68
16,19
16,19
24,92
24,92
21,29
21,29
20,31
15,70
20,31
23,75
23,75
44,65
44,65
47,50
47,50
57,00
24,42
25,27
38,10
38,66
31,69
28,98
28,98
57,95
77,90
71,25
69,35
69,35
36,10
40,85

pr
pr
pr
cu
pr
pr
pr
pr
pr
pr
pr
pr
pr
pr
pr
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl

18,05
18,05
18,05
18,41
13,34
13,34
12,95
12,95
19,93
19,93
17,03
17,03
16,25
12,56
16,25
19,00
19,00
35,72
35,72
38,00
38,00
45,60
19,53
20,22
30,48
30,92
25,35
23,19
23,19
46,36
62,32
57,00
55,48
55,48
28,88
32,68

2,47
2,47
2,47
2,38
2,06
2,06
1,82
1,82
2,41
2,41
2,18
2,18
2,35
1,77
2,35
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
2,03
2,68
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00

fl
fl
fl
fl
fl
fl
fl
fl
fl
fl
fl
fl
fl
fl
fl

0,1093
0,1093
0,1093
0,1036
0,1235
0,1235
0,1127
0,1127
0,0969
0,0969
0,1023
0,1023
0,1159
0,1125
0,1159
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0829
0,1061
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000

2,21
2,21
2,21
2,24
1,72
1,72
1,67
1,67
2,39
2,39
2,11
2,11
2,03
1,63
2,03
2,30
2,30
3,71
3,71
3,88
3,88
4,27
2,35
2,41
3,30
3,33
2,87
2,68
2,68
4,29
4,76
4,62
4,57
4,57
3,17
3,47

0,0978
0,0978
0,0978
0,0974
0,1029
0,1029
0,1034
0,1034
0,0958
0,0958
0,0989
0,0989
0,0998
0,1038
0,0998
0,0968
0,0968
0,0830
0,0830
0,0816
0,0816
0,0748
0,0962
0,0955
0,0866
0,0863
0,0907
0,0926
0,0926
0,0740
0,0612
0,0648
0,0659
0,0659
0,0878
0,0850

0,2598
0,2598
0,2598
0,1381
0,1849
0,1849
0,1906
0,1906
0,1238
0,1238
0,1449
0,1449
0,1450
0,1965
0,1450
0,2252
0,2252
0,1265
0,1265
0,1653
0,1653
0,1378
0,1678
0,1639
0,0144
0,0784
0,1469
0,1627
0,1616
0,2686
0,2473
0,1639
0,1950
0,1950
0,2897
0,2912

0,2598
0,2598
0,2598
0,1381
0,1849
0,1849
0,1906
0,1906
0,1238
0,1238
0,1449
0,1449
0,1450
0,1965
0,1450
0,2252
0,2252
0,1265
0,1265
0,1653
0,1653
0,1378
0,1678
0,1639
0,0646
0,0784
0,1469
0,1627
0,1616
0,2686
0,2473
0,1639
0,1950
0,1950
0,2897
0,2912

0,0596
0,0894
0,1788
0,6719
0,4002
0,2773
0,1794
0,1064
0,1166
0,0691
0,3135
0,2172
0,1430
0,1851
0,1430
0,2116
0,2116
0,1126
0,1126
0,1587
0,1587
0,1323
0,1807
0,1676
0,0487
0,0213
0,0655
0,0717
0,0717
0,0132
0,0114
0,0107
0,0096
0,0128
0,0241
0,0938

1,53
1,20
0,99
8,70
3,23
3,23
3,23
3,23
3,23
3,23
3,23
3,23
3,23
3,23
3,23
6,67
6,67
6,67
6,67
6,67
6,67
6,67
3,83
3,83
2,17
2,03
1,49
1,49
1,49
1,30
1,30
1,30
1,30
1,30
1,48
1,46

1,94
1,17
0,97
15,23
3,02
2,82
2,82
2,82
2,82
2,82
2,82
2,82
2,82
2,82
2,82
19,35
19,35
19,35
19,35
19,35
19,35
19,35
6,70
6,70
2,01
1,02
1,46
1,46
1,46
1,26
1,26
0,86
0,86
0,86
0,93
0,73

129,00
125,08
97,12
784,80
335,50
319,32
272,23
229,55
335,50
264,87
343,35
333,54
292,34
232,50
293,32

131,94
127,53
99,08

130,94
126,25
98,08
800,03
338,53
322,14
275,05
232,38
338,32
267,69
346,17
336,36
295,16
235,32
296,14
676,00
688,00
990,00
938,00
1181,00
1239,00
1330,00
435,00
435,00
126,00
120,10
137,34
141,26
154,02
129,20
125,40
155,90
142,90
179,20
100,93
190,73

130,94
126,25
98,08
800,03
338,53
322,14
275,05
232,38
338,32
267,69
346,17
336,36
295,16
235,32
296,14
695,35
707,35
1009,35
957,35
1200,35
1258,35
1349,35
441,70
441,70
128,01
121,11
138,80
142,72
155,47
130,46
126,66
156,76
143,76
180,06
100,93
190,73

19,0
16,0
16,0
16,0
15,0
15,0
15,0
15,0
15,0
16,0
16,0

sp
sp

S-2013-078: Reineck; Bentz; Fitik; Kuchma; Bayrak

100,00
190,00

340,90
324,71
277,62
234,95
340,90
270,27
348,75
338,94
297,73
237,89
298,71

18.01.2013

vsw-RC-A2b-A3b_sl_Large

ACI-DAfStb Large Collection Database for r.c.-beams with stirrups

betar_meas
-

483
484
485
490
491
492
493
494
497
498
499
500
501
502
503
504
505
506
507
508
509
510
511
512
523
525
534
535
536
553
556
559
561
562
564
565

Leonhardt; Walther;
DAfStb 151 (1962)
Leonhardt; Walther; DAfStb 152 (1962)
Leonhardt; Walther
DAfStb 156 (1963)

Levi;
Marro
(1989/1993)

Lyngberg
(1974)
Maruyama K., Rizkalla S. H. (1988)
Moayer; Regan (1974)
zden (1967)

Ozcebe; Ersoy;
Tankut (1999)

Petersson (1972)

App-B3_vsw-RC_A2b-A3b_sl_Large_2013-07-16

sigswmeas

sigswass

[]

mm

mm

MPa

MPa

ET2
ET3
ET4
T1 ( r )
TA1
TA2
TA3
TA4
TA11
TA12
TA13
TA14
TA15
TA6
TA16
RC 30 A1
RC 30 A2
RC 60 A1
RC 60 A2
RC 60 B1
RC 60 B2
RC 70 B1
5A-0
5B-0
RS2-WD
P20
T6
T7
T9
TS56
TS59
TS36
TH39
TS39
V1
VL1

41

233

233
525
525
1250
563
625
625
625
625
625
625
625
625
625
625
1900
1900
1900
1900
1900
1900
1900
750
750
575
489
525
525
525
775
775
465
465
465
575
450

314
314
314
315
349
417
418
440
418
440
348
425
418
393
418
480
480
480
480
480
480
480
674

39
42

xr_meas

xr

647

273
273
273

310
255

323
366

sigsw

omwu

andbr

MPa

314
314
314
315
349
417
418
440
418
440
348
425
418
393
418
480
480
480
480
480
480
480
674
647
0
310
255
273
273
0
0
0
0
0
323
366

0,0596
0,0894
0,1788
0,4964
0,3275
0,2715
0,1794
0,1064
0,1166
0,0691
0,2556
0,2167
0,1430
0,1742
0,1430
0,2116
0,2116
0,1126
0,1126
0,1587
0,1587
0,1323
0,1807
0,1676
0,0000
0,0213
0,0325
0,0717
0,0717
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0241
0,0938

Mu

muu

vutest

kapc

sigsl

xsitest

zetatest

16

z_test

zeta

z_

muflex

Mu_flex

Vu_flex

betaflex

BB

kNm

MPa

mm

mm

kN

137,49
132,56
102,99
2000,06
380,84
402,67
343,81
290,47
422,91
334,62
432,72
420,45
368,95
294,15
370,18
2568,80
2614,40
3762,00
3564,40
4487,80
4708,20
5054,00
652,50
652,50
144,90
117,37
144,21
148,33
161,72
200,26
194,37
144,99
132,90
166,66
116,07
171,66

0,2257
0,2176
0,1691
0,0851
0,1692
0,1789
0,1573
0,1329
0,1257
0,0995
0,1506
0,1463
0,1346
0,1388
0,1350
0,1360
0,1384
0,1059
0,1004
0,1188
0,1246
0,1115
0,1309
0,1265
0,0370
0,0649
0,1281
0,1441
0,1571
0,2397
0,1731
0,1412
0,1329
0,1667
0,1772
0,1806

0,1881
0,2707
0,4042
0,5540
0,4694
0,4467
0,3902
0,3240
0,3038
0,2378
0,3679
0,3575
0,3288
0,3397
0,3298
0,3435
0,3502
0,2640
0,2491
0,2994
0,3156
0,2806
0,3731
0,3594
0,1233
0,0966
0,1796
0,2041
0,2230
0,0726
0,0508
0,0662
0,0617
0,0801
0,0703
0,1995

0,910
0,910
0,910
0,908
0,933
0,933
0,935
0,935
0,900
0,900
0,915
0,915
0,919
0,937
0,919
0,905
0,905
0,821
0,821
0,810
0,810
0,772
0,902
0,899
0,848
0,845
0,873
0,884
0,884
0,768
0,688
0,715
0,723
0,723
0,856
0,837

420
408
305
301
409
409
372
309
409
349
409
409
390
314
390
329
335
405
382
367
387
413
522
520
235
553
418
435
444
450
357
436
333
433
677
700

0,286
0,278
0,207
0,099
0,198
0,198
0,185
0,154
0,137
0,117
0,158
0,158
0,158
0,161
0,158
0,164
0,167
0,139
0,131
0,159
0,168
0,157
0,158
0,152
0,045
0,080
0,159
0,179
0,183
0,350
0,295
0,222
0,205
0,266
0,235
0,246

0,857
0,861
0,896
0,951
0,901
0,901
0,907
0,923
0,931
0,941
0,921
0,921
0,921
0,919
0,921
0,918
0,917
0,931
0,935
0,920
0,916
0,922
0,921
0,924
0,978
0,960
0,920
0,911
0,909
0,825
0,853
0,889
0,898
0,867
0,883
0,877

257
258
269
784
338
338
340
346
349
353
345
345
345
345
345
863
862
875
879
865
861
866
497
499
389
268
274
271
271
256
264
276
278
269
284
244

0,857
0,857
0,857
0,924
0,901
0,901
0,898
0,898
0,931
0,931
0,921
0,921
0,921
0,895
0,921
0,876
0,876
0,923
0,923
0,898
0,898
0,911
0,907
0,909
0,962
0,954
0,916
0,908
0,909
0,825
0,820
0,885
0,865
0,865
0,831
0,826

257
257
257
762
338
338
337
337
349
349
345
345
345
336
345
823
823
868
868
844
844
856
490
491
382
266
273
271
271
256
254
274
268
268
267
230

0,2227
0,2227
0,2227
0,1276
0,1666
0,1666
0,1711
0,1711
0,1153
0,1153
0,1334
0,1334
0,1335
0,1759
0,1335
0,1971
0,1971
0,1168
0,1168
0,1485
0,1485
0,1255
0,1522
0,1490
0,0621
0,0748
0,1345
0,1477
0,1469
0,2217
0,2029
0,1451
0,1687
0,1687
0,2407
0,2405

135,68
135,68
135,68
2998,92
375,13
375,13
373,97
373,97
387,77
387,77
383,42
383,42
366,06
372,74
366,06
3723,48
3723,48
4145,79
4145,79
5608,32
5608,32
5688,41
758,58
768,48
243,05
135,30
151,41
152,10
151,20
185,16
227,85
149,01
168,66
168,66
157,63
228,53

129,22
129,22
129,22
1199,57
333,45
300,11
299,18
299,18
310,21
310,21
306,73
306,73
292,85
298,19
292,85
979,86
979,86
1091,00
1091,00
1475,87
1475,87
1496,95
505,72
512,32
211,34
138,44
144,20
144,86
144,00
119,46
147,00
160,22
181,36
181,36
137,07
253,93

1,01
0,98
0,76
0,67
1,02
1,07
0,92
0,78
1,09
0,86
1,13
1,097
1,01
0,79
1,01
0,69
0,70
0,91
0,86
0,80
0,84
0,89
0,86
0,85
0,60
0,87
0,95
0,98
1,07
1,08
0,85
0,97
0,79
0,99
0,74
0,75

BB

S-2013-078: Reineck; Bentz; Fitik; Kuchma; Bayrak

BB
BB

BB
BB
BB
BB
BB

BB
BB

18.01.2013

vsw-RC-A2b-A3b_sl_Large

ACI-DAfStb Large Collection Database for r.c.-beams with stirrups

sin2thp
-

483
484
485
490
491
492
493
494
497
498
499
500
501
502
503
504
505
506
507
508
509
510
511
512
523
525
534
535
536
553
556
559
561
562
564
565

Leonhardt; Walther;
DAfStb 151 (1962)
Leonhardt; Walther; DAfStb 152 (1962)
Leonhardt; Walther
DAfStb 156 (1963)

Levi;
Marro
(1989/1993)

Lyngberg
(1974)
Maruyama K., Rizkalla S. H. (1988)
Moayer; Regan (1974)
zden (1967)

Ozcebe; Ersoy;
Tankut (1999)

Petersson (1972)

App-B3_vsw-RC_A2b-A3b_sl_Large_2013-07-16

betalb

VB

[ ]

[ ]

ET2
ET3
ET4
T1 ( r )
TA1
TA2
TA3
TA4
TA11
TA12
TA13
TA14
TA15
TA6
TA16
RC 30 A1
RC 30 A2
RC 60 A1
RC 60 A2
RC 60 B1
RC 60 B2
RC 70 B1
5A-0
5B-0
RS2-WD
P20
T6
T7
T9
TS56
TS59
TS36
TH39
TS39
V1
VL1

0,06
0,09
0,18
0,67
0,40
0,28
0,18
0,11
0,12
0,07
0,31
0,22
0,14
0,19
0,14
0,21
0,21
0,11
0,11
0,16
0,16
0,13
0,18
0,17
0,05
0,02
0,07
0,07
0,07
0,01
0,01
0,01
0,01
0,01
0,02
0,09

14,13
17,40
25,02
55,06
39,24
31,77
25,06
19,04
19,96
15,24
34,05
27,78
22,22
25,48
22,22
27,39
27,39
19,60
19,60
23,48
23,48
21,33
25,15
24,16
12,75
8,39
14,83
15,53
15,53
6,59
6,14
5,94
5,63
6,51
8,93
17,84

thp

cotthp

3,97
3,19
2,14
0,70
1,22
1,61
2,14
2,90
2,75
3,67
1,48
1,90
2,45
2,10
2,45
1,93
1,93
2,81
2,81
2,30
2,30
2,56
2,13
2,23
4,42
6,78
3,78
3,60
3,60
8,66
9,30
9,61
10,14
8,77
6,36
3,11

0,24
0,29
0,38
0,47
0,49
0,45
0,38
0,31
0,32
0,25
0,46
0,41
0,35
0,39
0,35
0,41
0,41
0,32
0,32
0,37
0,37
0,34
0,38
0,37
0,22
0,14
0,25
0,26
0,26
0,11
0,11
0,10
0,10
0,11
0,15
0,29

vup

gamwp

0,79
0,95
1,05
1,18
0,96
1,00
1,02
1,05
0,95
0,94
0,79
0,87
0,94
0,87
0,94
0,84
0,86
0,84
0,79
0,82
0,86
0,83
0,97
0,96
0,57
0,67
0,73
0,79
0,86
0,64
0,48
0,64
0,63
0,71
0,46
0,68

cotthu

3,16
3,03
2,26
1,12
1,43
1,65
2,17
3,05
2,61
3,44
1,44
1,65
2,30
1,95
2,31
1,62
1,65
2,35
2,21
1,89
1,99
2,12
2,06
2,14
0,00
4,53
5,53
2,85
3,11
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
2,92
2,13

17,59
18,27
23,87
41,86
34,90
31,29
24,70
18,18
21,00
16,21
34,79
31,22
23,51
27,15
23,44
31,64
31,14
23,09
24,32
27,93
26,70
25,24
25,84
25,00
0,00
12,44
10,24
19,34
17,81
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
18,93
25,19

thu

0,52
0,73
0,87
0,89
0,80
0,81
0,82
0,87
0,73
0,71
0,63
0,65
0,72
0,67
0,72
0,62
0,63
0,59
0,53
0,58
0,63
0,58
0,76
0,75
0,00
0,37
0,82
0,52
0,61
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,18
0,41

nueu

0,73
0,71
0,55
0,01
1,84
1,75
1,53
1,30
0,66
0,53
0,77
0,75
0,69
1,35
0,69
0,42
0,42
0,34
0,33
0,34
0,36
0,35
0,46
0,44
0,55
0,34
0,48
0,53
0,58
0,00
0,00
0,01
0,01
0,01
0,37
0,40

VB
VB
VB
VB

VB

A2+A3

kon34

1
1
1
1
0
0
0
0
1
1
1
1
1
0
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
0
1
1
1
1
0
0
0
0
0
1
1

1
1
0
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
0
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1

KONA4 KONA5 A4+A5 Differenz AF

1
1
0
1
0
0
0
0
1
1
1
1
1
0
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
0
0
0
1
1
1
1
0
0
0
0
0
1
1

0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0

1
1
0
1
0
0
0
0
1
1
1
1
1
0
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
0
1
1
1
1
0
0
0
0
0
1
1

0
0
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0

S-2013-078: Reineck; Bentz; Fitik; Kuchma; Bayrak

AF
AF
AF
AF

AF

17

f1ck
MPa
18,8
18,8
18,8
19,2
12,9
12,9
12,4
12,4
21,1
21,1
17,5
17,5
16,5
11,9
16,5
20,0
20,0
40,9
40,9
43,7
43,7
53,2
20,6
21,5
34,3
34,9
27,9
25,2
25,2
54,2
74,1
67,5
65,6
65,6
32,3
37,1

fcm_cyl
MPa
23,8
23,8
23,8
24,2
17,6
17,6
17,0
17,0
26,2
26,2
22,4
22,4
21,4
16,5
21,4
25,0
25,0
47,0
47,0
50,0
50,0
60,0
25,7
26,6
40,1
40,7
33,4
30,5
30,5
61,0
82,0
75,0
73,0
73,0
38,0
43,0

fck
MPa
19,8
19,8
19,8
20,2
13,6
13,6
13,0
13,0
22,2
22,2
18,4
18,4
17,4
12,5
17,4
21,0
21,0
43,0
43,0
46,0
46,0
56,0
21,7
22,6
36,1
36,7
29,4
26,5
26,5
57,0
78,0
71,0
69,0
69,0
34,0
39,0

fc_prime
MPa
21,4
21,4
21,4
21,8
15,2
15,2
14,6
14,6
23,8
23,8
20,0
20,0
19,0
14,1
19,0
22,6
22,6
44,6
44,6
47,6
47,6
57,6
23,3
24,2
37,7
38,3
31,0
28,1
28,1
58,6
79,6
72,6
70,6
70,6
35,6
40,6

Vct_ACI Vs_ACI
kN
kN
34,54
48,41
23,02
48,41
11,51
48,41
64,01
1020,61
38,79
320,33
38,79
221,94
38,13
139,42
38,13
82,66
48,65
139,42
48,65
82,66
44,58
320,33
44,58
221,94
43,41
139,42
37,45
139,42
43,41
139,42
89,07
453,60
89,07
453,60
125,12
453,60
125,12
453,60
129,26
680,39
129,26
680,39
142,19
680,39
51,95
228,68
52,95
219,52
39,60
57,65
43,03
27,59
30,29
54,47
28,87
54,47
28,87
54,47
59,12
28,38
68,91
33,11
65,81
28,38
64,89
24,83
64,89
33,11
55,84
39,21
35,30
102,29

Vcal_sACI Vmax_ACI rat_smax


kN
kN
82,95
172,68
0,480
71,44
115,12
0,621
59,93
57,56
1,041
1084,63
320,07
3,389
359,12
193,97
1,851
260,73
193,97
1,344
177,55
190,64
0,931
120,79
190,64
0,634
188,07
243,23
0,773
131,31
243,23
0,540
364,90
222,88
1,637
266,51
222,88
1,196
182,83
217,05
0,842
176,87
187,25
0,945
182,83
217,05
0,842
542,66
445,33
1,219
542,66
445,33
1,219
578,71
625,59
0,925
578,71
625,59
0,925
809,65
646,29
1,253
809,65
646,29
1,253
822,58
710,95
1,157
280,63
259,76
1,080
272,47
264,73
1,029
97,25
198,02
0,491
70,62
215,16
0,328
84,76
151,45
0,560
83,33
144,33
0,577
83,33
144,33
0,577
87,50
295,61
0,296
102,02
344,53
0,296
94,19
329,03
0,286
89,73
324,47
0,277
98,01
324,47
0,302
95,05
279,21
0,340
137,59
176,52
0,779

VACI_cal
kN
82,95
71,44
57,56
320,07
193,97
193,97
177,55
120,79
188,07
131,31
222,88
222,88
182,83
176,87
182,83
445,33
445,33
578,71
578,71
646,29
646,29
710,95
259,76
264,73
97,25
70,62
84,76
83,33
83,33
87,50
102,02
94,19
89,73
98,01
95,05
137,59

18.01.2013

vsw-RC-A2b-A3b_sl_Large

ACI-DAfStb Large Collection Database for r.c.-beams with stirrups

18

gmod_ACI
-

483
484
485
490
491
492
493
494
497
498
499
500
501
502
503
504
505
506
507
508
509
510
511
512
523
525
534
535
536
553
556
559
561
562
564
565

Leonhardt; Walther;
DAfStb 151 (1962)
Leonhardt; Walther; DAfStb 152 (1962)
Leonhardt; Walther
DAfStb 156 (1963)

Levi;
Marro
(1989/1993)

Lyngberg
(1974)
Maruyama K., Rizkalla S. H. (1988)
Moayer; Regan (1974)
zden (1967)

Ozcebe; Ersoy;
Tankut (1999)

Petersson (1972)

App-B3_vsw-RC_A2b-A3b_sl_Large_2013-07-16

ET2
ET3
ET4
T1 ( r )
TA1
TA2
TA3
TA4
TA11
TA12
TA13
TA14
TA15
TA6
TA16
RC 30 A1
RC 30 A2
RC 60 A1
RC 60 A2
RC 60 B1
RC 60 B2
RC 70 B1
5A-0
5B-0
RS2-WD
P20
T6
T7
T9
TS56
TS59
TS36
TH39
TS39
V1
VL1

1,579
1,767
1,704
2,500
1,745
1,661
1,549
1,924
1,799
2,039
1,553
1,509
1,614
1,330
1,620
1,518
1,545
1,711
1,621
1,827
1,917
1,871
1,675
1,643
1,296
1,701
1,620
1,695
1,848
1,477
1,229
1,655
1,593
1,828
1,062
1,386

S-2013-078: Reineck; Bentz; Fitik; Kuchma; Bayrak

18.01.2013

vsw-RC-A2b-A3b_sl_Large

ACI-DAfStb Large Collection Database for r.c.-beams with stirrups

E
Regan_1971_012_R21
Regan_1971_024_T6
Regan_1971_027_T9
Regan_1971_032_T17
Regan_1971_034_T20
Regan_1971_039_T26
Regan_1971_040_T27
Regan_1971_044_T32
Regan_1971_048_T36
Regan_1971_049_T37
Regan_1971_050_T38
Regan_1971_056_W1
Regan_1971_058_W3
Regan_1971_059_W5
Regan_1971_061_W7
Rehm_1978_001_RsIS / BQ II 0
Rehm_1978_004_RnIIS
Reineck_1991_001_Stb III
Reineck_1991_002_Stb I
Roller_1990_007_7
Roller_1990_009_9
Roller_1990_010_10
Sarsam_1992_010_BS4-H
Sarsam_1992_013_CS3-H
Sarsam_1992_014_CS4-H
Shin_1999_010_MHB 2.5-50
Shin_1999_022_HB 2.5-50
Soerensen_1974_003_T-23
Soerensen_1974_007_T-2-B
Stroband_1997_002_2
Stroband_1997_003_3
Stroband_1997_004_4
Stroband_1997_005_5
Taylor_1966_001_ST-2-C
Taylor_1966_004_HSS-1-B
Yoon_1996_003_N2-N
Yoon_1996_006_M2-N
Yoon_1996_008_H2-S
Yoon_1996_009_H2-N
Rosenbusch_2003_002_1.4-1
Rosenbusch_2003_004_1.7-1
Kautsch_2010_001_A2
Kautsch_2010_002_B2
Tanimura_2005_031_41

Plain
Ripp

593
605
608
613
615
620
621
625
629
630
631
637
639
640
642
643
646
647
648
658
660
661
671
674
675
685
697
702
706
711
712
713
714
783
786
803
806
808
809
817
819
820
821
874
157
68
89

Regan (1971)

Rehm; Eligehausen;
Neubert (1978)
Reineck (1991)
Roller; Russel (1990)

Sarsam;
Al-Musawi (1992)
Shin; Lee;
Moon; Gosh (1999)
Soerensen (1974)
Stroband (1997)

Taylor, R. (1966)
Yoon; Cook;
Mitchell (1996)

Rosenbusch (2003)
Kautsch (2010)
Tanimura; Sato (2005)

App-B3_vsw-RC_A2b-A3b_sl_Large_2013-07-16

hf

hh,top

hw

hft

hh,bot

bft

SI / A

mm

mm

mm

mm

mm

mm

mm

mm

mm

R21
T6
T9
T17
T20
T26
T27
T32
T36
T37
T38
W1
W3
W5
W7
RsIS / BQ II 0
RnIIS
Stb III
Stb I
7
9
10
BS4-H
CS3-H
CS4-H
MHB 2.5-50
HB 2.5-50
T-23
T-2-B
2
3
4
5
ST-2-C
HSS-1-B
N2-N
M2-N
H2-S
H2-N
1.4/1
1.7/1
A2
B2
41

SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
A
A
A
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
A
A
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI

152,0
610,0
610,0
610,0
610,0
610,0
610,0
610,0
610,0
610,0
610,0
610,0
610,0
610,0
610,0
900,0
950,0
838,0
837,0
457,2
457,2
457,2
180,0
180,0
180,0
125,0
125,0
400,0
400,0
500,0
500,0
500,0
500,0
304,8
304,8
375,0
375,0
375,0
375,0
200,0
200,0
655,0
655,0
300,0

152,0
152,0
152,0
152,0
152,0
152,0
152,0
152,0
152,0
152,0
152,0
64,0
64,0
64,0
64,0
250,0
450,0
77,0
77,0
457,2
457,2
457,2
180,0
180,0
180,0
125,0
125,0
110,0
110,0
90,0
90,0
90,0
90,0
114,3
114,3
375,0
375,0
375,0
200,0
200,0
200,0
155,0
155,0
300,0

bw

305,0
305,0
305,0
305,0
305,0
305,0
305,0
305,0
305,0
305,0
305,0
305,0
305,0
305,0
305,0
510,0
600,0
648,0
650,0
870,0
870,0
870,0
270,0
270,0
270,0
250,0
250,0
355,0
355,0
700,0
700,0
700,0
700,0
304,8
304,8
750,0
750,0
750,0
750,0
300,0
300,0
820,0
820,0
450,0

76,0
76,0
76,0
76,0
76,0
76,0
76,0
142,0
76,0
142,0
76,0
76,0
76,0
76,0
125,0
150,0
107,0
100,0

80,0
80,0
125,0
125,0
125,0
125,0
76,2
76,2

150,0
150,0

229,0
229,0
229,0
229,0
229,0
229,0
229,0
163,0
229,0
163,0
127,0
127,0
127,0
127,0
385,0
450,0
441,0
440,0

25,0
25,0
25,0
25,0

20,0
20,0

275,0
275,0
400,0
400,0
400,0
400,0
228,6
228,6

650,0
650,0

64,0
64,0
64,0
64,0

38,0
38,0
38,0
38,0

100,0
110,0

75,0
75,0
75,0
75,0

254,0
254,0
254,0
254,0

837,0
838,0

75,0
75,0
75,0
75,0

500,0
500,0
500,0
500,0

155,0
155,0

Ac
mm

46360
81168
81168
81168
81168
81168
81168
81168
111396
81168
111396
76786
76786
76786
76786
208750
345000
207323
209760
397741
397741
397741
48600
48600
48600
31250
31250
62250
62250
165500
165500
165500
165500
49355
49355
281250
281250
281250
281250
60000
60000
207100
207100
135000

zc2

aa

af

19

ba

kap

cc

mm

mm

mm

mm

mm

mm

mm

mm

152,5
103,4
103,4
103,4
103,4
103,4
103,4
103,4
104,9
103,4
104,9
113,3
113,3
113,3
113,3
180,1
251,1
318,2
333,1
435,0
435,0
435,0
135,0
135,0
135,0
125,0
125,0
126,3
126,3
335,5
335,5
335,5
335,5
118,8
118,8
375,0
375,0
375,0
375,0
150,0
150,0
282,6
282,6
225,0

60,0
60,0
60,0
60,0
60,0
60,0
60,0
60,0
60,0
60,0
60,0
75,0
75,0
75,0
75,0

75,0
50,0
50,0
50,0
50,0
50,0
50,0
50,0
50,0
50,0
50,0
50,0
50,0
50,0
50,0

300,0
300,0
300,0
300,0
300,0
300,0
300,0
300,0
300,0
300,0
300,0
305,0
305,0
305,0
305,0

160,0
160,0
133,4
133,4
133,4
100,0
100,0
100,0
22,5
22,5
100,0
100,0
91,4
91,4
91,4
91,4

700,0
700,0
152,4
152,4
152,4
150,0
150,0
150,0
100,0
100,0
250,0
250,0
346,2
346,2
346,2
346,2
762,0
533,4
350,0
350,0
350,0
350,0
100,0
100,0
200,0
200,0
300,0

75,0
50,0
50,0
50,0
50,0
50,0
50,0
50,0
50,0
50,0
50,0
50,0
50,0
50,0
50,0
1290,0
1644,0
160,0
160,0
133,4
133,4
133,4
400,0
400,0
400,0
22,5
22,5
900,0
900,0
69,2
69,2
69,2
69,2
304,8
304,8
75,0
75,0
75,0
75,0

876,9
889,4
889,4
1803,8
1346,6
889,4
889,4
889,4
889,4
889,4
889,4
890,0
890,0
890,0
890,0
1290,0
1644,0
2520,0
2515,0
2219,3
2219,3
2219,3
582,5
582,5
582,5
526,3
526,3
1050,0
1050,0
1654,3
1654,3
1654,3
1654,3
914,4
1143,0
2112,5
2112,5
2112,5
2112,5
875,0
875,0
1925,0
1925,0
1000,0

3,45
3,50
3,50
7,10
5,30
3,50
3,50
3,50
3,50
3,50
3,50
3,33
3,33
3,33
3,33
3,00
3,00
4,27
4,27
2,91
2,91
2,91
2,50
2,50
2,50
2,45
2,45
3,52
3,52
2,56
2,56
2,50
2,55
3,56
4,44
3,23
3,23
3,23
3,23
3,37
3,37
2,68
2,68
2,50

25,4
25,4
25,4
25,4
25,4
25,4
25,4
25,4
25,4
25,4
25,4
25,4
25,4
25,4
25,4

120,0
120,0
266,7
266,7
266,7
100,0
100,0
100,0

1828,8
1828,8
1828,8
3657,6
2743,2
1828,8
1828,8
1828,8
1828,8
1828,8
1828,8
1830,0
1830,0
1830,0
1830,0
3870,0
4932,0
5200,0
5190,0
4572,0
4572,0
4572,0
1565,0
1565,0
1565,0
1075,0
1075,0
3000,0
3000,0
5000,0
5000,0
5000,0
5000,0
2133,6
2590,8
4300,0
4300,0
4300,0
4300,0
1800,0
1800,0
4000,0
4000,0
2400,0

100,0
100,0
242,3
242,3
242,3
242,3

150,0 75,0
150,0 75,0
150,0 75,0
150,0 75,0
100,0 50,0
100,0 50,0
100,0 150,0
100,0 150,0
100,0 100,0

S-2013-078: Reineck; Bentz; Fitik; Kuchma; Bayrak

400,0

25,0
25,0
25,0

26,0
26,0

25,4
25,4
40,0
40,0
40,0
40,0
36,0
32,0
20,0
20,0

18.01.2013

vsw-RC-A2b-A3b_sl_Large

ACI-DAfStb Large Collection Database for r.c.-beams with stirrups

ds
-

593
605
608
613
615
620
621
625
629
630
631
637
639
640
642
643
646
647
648
658
660
661
671
674
675
685
697
702
706
711
712
713
714
783
786
803
806
808
809
817
819
820
821
874
157
68
89

Regan (1971)

Rehm; Eligehausen;
Neubert (1978)
Reineck (1991)
Roller; Russel (1990)

Sarsam;
Al-Musawi (1992)
Shin; Lee;
Moon; Gosh (1999)
Soerensen (1974)
Stroband (1997)

Taylor, R. (1966)
Yoon; Cook;
Mitchell (1996)

Rosenbusch (2003)
Kautsch (2010)
Tanimura; Sato (2005)

App-B3_vsw-RC_A2b-A3b_sl_Large_2013-07-16

ns

dst

mm

mm

mm

R21
T6
T9
T17
T20
T26
T27
T32
T36
T37
T38
W1
W3
W5
W7
RsIS / BQ II 0
RnIIS
Stb III
Stb I
7
9
10
BS4-H
CS3-H
CS4-H
MHB 2.5-50
HB 2.5-50
T-23
T-2-B
2
3
4
5
ST-2-C
HSS-1-B
N2-N
M2-N
H2-S
H2-N
1.4/1
1.7/1
A2
B2
41

254,0
254,0
254,0
254,0
254,0
254,0
254,0
254,0
254,0
254,0
254,0
267,0
267,0
267,0
267,0
430,0
548,0
590,0
589,0
762,0
762,0
762,0
233,0
233,0
233,0
215,0
215,0
298,0
298,0
647,1
647,1
661,5
650,0
257,2
257,2
655,0
655,0
655,0
655,0
260,0
260,0
719,4
719,4
400,0

254,0
254,0
254,0
254,0
254,0
254,0
254,0
254,0
254,0
254,0
254,0
267,0
267,0
267,0
267,0
430,0
548,0
590,0
589,0
762,0
762,0
762,0
233,0
233,0
233,0
215,0
215,0
298,0
298,0
647,1
647,1
661,5
650,0
257,2
257,2
655,0
655,0
655,0
655,0
260,0
260,0
719,4
719,4
400,0

8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
4
4
5
8
10
10
2
3
3
2
2
4
4
6
6
8
8
5
5
10
10
10
10
3
3

16,0
16,0
16,0
16,0
16,0
16,0
16,0
16,0
16,0
16,0
16,0
16,0
16,0
16,0
16,0
26,0
26,0
28,0
28,0
32,3
32,3
35,8
25,0
25,0
25,0
25,4
25,4
20,0
20,0
25,0
32,0
32,0
32,0
15,9
15,9
29,9
29,9
29,9
29,9
28,0
28,0
28,0
28,0
4 29,0

fR

ftk/fsy

euk

ds2

mm

MPa

MPa

mm

r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r

1608,5
1608,5
1608,5
1608,5
1608,5
1608,5
1608,5
1608,5
1608,5
1608,5
1608,5
1608,5
1608,5
1608,5
1608,5
4247,4
3355,2
6157,5
7081,1
6538,1
8172,7
10073,9
1182,8
1470,0
1470,0
1013,4
1013,4
1256,6
1256,6
3573,6
5227,6
6434,0
6836,1
989,7
989,7
7021,5
7021,5
7021,5
7021,5
1847,3
1847,3
3195,0
3195,0
2642,1

As

alphaa

1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
0,70
0,70
0,70
0,70
0,70
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
0,01
0,01
0,01
0,01
0,70

4,1662
1,0381
1,0381
1,0381
1,0381
1,0381
1,0381
1,0381
1,0381
1,0381
1,0381
0,9876
0,9876
0,9876
0,9876
1,0975
0,6445
1,2454
1,4364
1,8767
2,3459
2,8916
2,8202
3,5051
3,5051
3,7708
3,7708
1,0542
1,0542
1,1045
1,6157
1,9452
2,1034
1,2625
1,2625
2,8586
2,8586
2,8586
2,8586
3,5524
3,5524
0,6781
0,6781
2,2017

rhos

4,1662
4,1662
4,1662
4,1662
4,1662
4,1662
4,1662
4,1662
4,1662
4,1662
4,1662
9,4130
9,4130
9,4130
9,4130
3,9511
1,3606
13,5539
15,6134
1,8767
2,3459
2,8916
2,8202
3,5051
3,5051
3,7708
3,7708
3,8335
3,8335
6,1359
8,9759
10,8064
11,6856
3,3668
3,3668
2,8586
2,8586
2,8586
5,3600
3,5524
3,5524
2,8655
2,8655
2,2017

rhosw

630,0
630,0
630,0
630,0
630,0
630,0
630,0
630,0
630,0
630,0
630,0
630,0
630,0
630,0
630,0
469,0
746,0
514,6
514,0
472,4
472,4
431,0
502,3
543,0
543,0
410,1
410,1
419,9
457,1
600,0
560,0
560,0
560,0
441,4
441,4
400,0
400,0
400,0
400,0
550,0
550,0
468,1
468,1
750,0

fsy

3,15
3,15
3,15
3,15
3,15
3,15
3,15
3,15
3,15
3,15
3,15
3,15
3,15
3,15
3,15
2,35
3,73
2,57
2,57
2,36
2,36
2,16
2,51
2,72
2,72
2,05
2,05
2,10
2,29
3,00
2,80
2,80
2,80
1,75
1,75
2,00
2,00
2,00
2,00
2,75
2,75
2,34
2,34
3,75

esy

950,00
950,00
950,00
950,00
950,00
950,00
950,00
950,00
950,00
950,00
950,00
950,00
950,00
950,00
950,00
565,00
1007,00
605,00
603,78
741,24
741,24
690,55

ftk

1,51
1,51
1,51
1,51
1,51
1,51
1,51
1,51
1,51
1,51
1,51
1,51
1,51
1,51
1,51
1,20
1,35
1,18
1,17
1,57
1,57
1,60
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
1,71
1,67
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
1,38
1,38

716,13
765,18

648,18
648,18

dst2

As2

mm

mm

2
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
6
4
4
4
4
4

9,5
9,7
9,7
9,7
9,7
9,7
9,7
9,7
9,7
9,7
9,7
10,0
10,0
10,0
10,0
8,0

141,8
443,4
443,4
443,4
443,4
443,4
443,4
443,4
443,4
443,4
443,4
314,2
314,2
314,2
314,2
201,1

5
4

28,0 7081,1
28,0 6157,5

34,0
34,0
34,0

2
2
2
2
2

10,0
10,0
10,0
9,5
9,5

36,0

4
4
4
4
4
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
12
12
2

8,0 201,1
10,0 314,2
10,0 314,2
10,0 314,2
10,0 314,2
22,2 775,9
22,2 775,9
10,0 157,1
10,0 157,1
10,0 157,1
10,0 157,1
6,0
56,5
6,0
56,5
12,0 1357,2
12,0 1357,2
16,0 402,1

14

15
15

ns2

40,0
40,0
18,0 75,0
11,0 75,0

157,1
157,1
157,1
142,5
142,5

S-2013-078: Reineck; Bentz; Fitik; Kuchma; Bayrak

20

fsy2

dw

MPa

mm

270 6,3
270 9,5
270 6,3
270 6,3
270 6,3
270 6,3
270 6,3
270 9,5
270 6,3
270 9,5
270 9,5
275 10,0
275 10,0
275 10,0
275 8,0
11,0
8,5
514 8,0
515 10,0
9,5
9,5
9,5
450 4,0
450 4,0
450 4,0
392 6,4
392 6,4
6,0
262 5,0
8,0
12,0
12,0
12,0
278 6,4
278 5,2
9,5
9,5
9,5
9,5
550 4,0
550 8,0
585 8,0
585 8,0
10,0

nsw

Asw

frw

sw

sw/h

zw1

zw2

rhow

fyw

mm

mm

mm

mm

MPa

2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2

62,3
142,5
62,3
62,3
62,3
62,3
62,3
142,5
62,3
142,5
142,5
157,1
157,1
157,1
100,5
190,1
113,5
99,4
162,8
142,5
142,5
142,5
25,1
25,1
25,1
63,3
63,3
56,5
39,3
100,5
226,2
226,2
226,2
63,3
41,8
141,8
141,8
141,8
141,8
25,1
100,5
100,5
100,5
157,1

0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
0
0
0
r
r
0
0
r
r
r
r
0
0
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r

102,0
114,0
102,0
102,0
102,0
102,0
102,0
114,0
102,0
114,0
114,0
114,0
114,0
76,0
76,0
100,0
75,0
108,0
126,0
196,9
196,9
133,4
75,0
100,0
75,0
86,0
86,0
150,0
117,0
165,0
165,0
95,0
65,0
90,0
112,0
325,0
230,0
270,0
160,0
90,0
90,0
150,0
200,0
100,0

0,33
0,37
0,33
0,33
0,33
0,33
0,33
0,37
0,33
0,37
0,37
0,37
0,37
0,25
0,25
0,20
0,13
0,17
0,19
0,23
0,23
0,15
0,28
0,37
0,28
0,34
0,34
0,42
0,33
0,24
0,24
0,14
0,09
0,30
0,37
0,43
0,31
0,36
0,21
0,30
0,30
0,18
0,24
0,22

0,40
0,45
0,40
0,40
0,40
0,40
0,40
0,45
0,40
0,45
0,45
0,43
0,43
0,28
0,28
0,23
0,14
0,18
0,21
0,26
0,26
0,18
0,32
0,43
0,32
0,40
0,40
0,50
0,39
0,25
0,25
0,14
0,10
0,35
0,44
0,50
0,35
0,41
0,24
0,35
0,35
0,21
0,28
0,25

223
206
223
223
223
223
223
206
223
206
206
217
217
217
227
375
506
550
539
714
714
714
213
213
213
183
183
268
273
607
587
602
590
0
0
608
608
608
608
240
220
679
679
350

203
203
203
203
203
203
203
203
203
203
203
216
216
216
216
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
183
183
183
0
0
246
246
0
0
0
0
210
210
575
575
575
575
188
196
679
679
0

0,4021
0,8224
0,4021
0,4021
0,4021
0,4021
0,4021
0,8224
0,4021
0,8224
0,8224
2,1530
2,1530
3,2294
2,0668
0,7603
0,3363
1,1953
1,6780
0,1583
0,1583
0,2337
0,1862
0,1396
0,1862
0,5892
0,5892
0,3427
0,3051
0,6770
1,5232
2,6456
3,8666
0,6157
0,3262
0,1163
0,1644
0,1400
0,4430
0,1396
0,5585
0,4324
0,3243
0,5236

280,0
270,0
280,0
280,0
280,0
280,0
280,0
270,0
280,0
270,0
270,0
704,0
704,0
704,0
691,0
560,0
557,0
515,0
549,0
445,2
445,2
445,2
820,0
820,0
820,0
365,9
365,9
349,2
397,3
600,0
630,0
630,0
630,0
289,7
437,9
430,0
430,0
430,0
430,0
680,0
550,0
605,0
605,0
388,0

18.01.2013

vsw-RC-A2b-A3b_sl_Large

ACI-DAfStb Large Collection Database for r.c.-beams with stirrups

fyw_rhow_100
-

593
605
608
613
615
620
621
625
629
630
631
637
639
640
642
643
646
647
648
658
660
661
671
674
675
685
697
702
706
711
712
713
714
783
786
803
806
808
809
817
819
820
821
874
157
68
89

Regan (1971)

Rehm; Eligehausen;
Neubert (1978)
Reineck (1991)
Roller; Russel (1990)

Sarsam;
Al-Musawi (1992)
Shin; Lee;
Moon; Gosh (1999)
Soerensen (1974)
Stroband (1997)

Taylor, R. (1966)
Yoon; Cook;
Mitchell (1996)

Rosenbusch (2003)
Kautsch (2010)
Tanimura; Sato (2005)

App-B3_vsw-RC_A2b-A3b_sl_Large_2013-07-16

fwtk/fyw

ewuk

MPa

MPa

R21
T6
T9
T17
T20
T26
T27
T32
T36
T37
T38
W1
W3
W5
W7
RsIS / BQ II 0
RnIIS
Stb III
Stb I
7
9
10
BS4-H
CS3-H
CS4-H
MHB 2.5-50
HB 2.5-50
T-23
T-2-B
2
3
4
5
ST-2-C
HSS-1-B
N2-N
M2-N
H2-S
H2-N
1.4/1
1.7/1
A2
B2
41

1,13
2,22
1,13
1,13
1,13
1,13
1,13
2,22
1,13
2,22
2,22
15,16
15,16
22,74
14,28
4,26
1,87
6,16
9,21
0,70
0,70
1,04
1,53
1,14
1,53
2,16
2,16
1,20
1,21
4,06
9,60
16,67
24,36
1,78
1,43
0,50
0,71
0,60
1,90
0,95
3,07
2,62
1,96
2,03

460,00
435,00
460,00
460,00
460,00
460,00
460,00
435,00
460,00
435,00
435,00
1010,00
1010,00
1010,00
827,00
644,00
628,00
539,00
630,00
576,83
576,83
576,83

fwtk

1,64
1,61
1,64
1,64
1,64
1,64
1,64
1,61
1,64
1,61
1,61
1,43
1,43
1,43
1,20
1,15
1,13
1,05
1,15
1,30
1,30
1,30
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
1,35
1,31
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
1,04
1,04

470,88
519,93

631,00
631,00

11
13
20
19

20
14

diaa

f1c

mm

MPa

19,0 45,08
19,0 26,33
19,0 20,25
19,0 33,53
19,0 30,08
19,0 49,28
19,0 12,90
19,0 26,70
19,0 21,30
19,0 28,50
19,0 29,18
19,0 28,41
19,0 43,23
19,0 32,59
19,0 32,59
32,0 23,23
32,0 21,03
8,0 57,57
8,0 57,57
12,7 68,79
12,7 119,04
12,7 119,04
12,0 76,10
12,0 70,49
12,0 71,92
19,0 49,40
13,0 69,35
32,0 32,53
32,0 23,67
16,0 83,00
16,0 83,90
16,0 84,80
16,0 84,70
19,1 18,29
19,1 18,53
20,0 34,20
10,0 63,65
10,0 82,65
10,0 82,65
16,0 45,50
16,0 47,85
16,0 29,30
16,0 29,83
19,57

Method

f1cttest

Method

MPa

MPa

cu
cu
cu
cu
cu
cu
cu
cu
cu
cu
cu
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cu
cu
cu
cu
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
pr
pr
pr
pr
cu
cu
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cu
cu
cyl
cyl
cyl

36,06
21,06
16,20
26,82
24,06
39,42
10,32
21,36
17,04
22,80
23,34
22,72
34,58
26,07
26,07
18,59
16,82
46,05
46,05
55,03
95,24
95,24
60,88
56,39
57,53
39,52
55,48
26,02
18,94
66,40
67,12
67,84
67,76
17,86
18,09
27,36
50,92
66,12
66,12
36,40
38,28
23,44
23,86
15,66

fcwu

0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
2,70
3,31
2,92
3,02
0,00
0,00
4,32
4,32
3,79
5,07
5,07
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
6,12
6,30
6,75
6,21
0,00
0,00
2,79
4,14
5,49
5,49

sp
sp
sp
sp

2,51
2,48

sp
sp

sp
sp
sp
sp

sp
sp
sp
sp
sp

sp
sp
sp
sp

betacttest

f1ctmcal

betactcal

oms

oml

omwy

Vg

Vu_F+g,rep

MPa

kN/m

kN

kN

kN

0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0951
0,0766
0,0895
0,0925
0,0000
0,0000
0,0750
0,0750
0,0551
0,0426
0,0426
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0737
0,0751
0,0796
0,0733
0,0000
0,0000
0,0816
0,0650
0,0664
0,0664
0,0000
0,0000
0,0857
0,0833
0,0000

3,73
2,49
2,02
3,00
2,76
3,98
1,36
2,52
2,11
2,65
2,70
2,64
3,62
2,94
2,94
2,26
2,08
4,28
4,28
4,56
5,52
5,52
4,73
4,60
4,63
3,99
4,57
2,93
2,29
4,87
4,89
4,91
4,91
1,86
1,88
3,04
4,44
4,86
4,86
3,76
3,90
2,71
2,74
1,97

0,0828
0,0947
0,0998
0,0894
0,0918
0,0808
0,1056
0,0944
0,0989
0,0930
0,0925
0,0931
0,0837
0,0901
0,0901
0,0972
0,0991
0,0744
0,0744
0,0663
0,0464
0,0464
0,0621
0,0653
0,0644
0,0807
0,0659
0,0901
0,0969
0,0587
0,0583
0,0579
0,0579
0,0980
0,0978
0,0890
0,0697
0,0588
0,0588
0,0826
0,0815
0,0924
0,0920
0,1004

0,5823
0,2484
0,3230
0,1951
0,2175
0,1327
0,5070
0,2450
0,3071
0,2295
0,2242
0,2190
0,1439
0,1909
0,1909
0,2216
0,2287
0,1113
0,1283
0,1289
0,0931
0,1047
0,1862
0,2700
0,2647
0,3130
0,2230
0,1361
0,2036
0,0798
0,1078
0,1285
0,1391
0,3046
0,3008
0,3343
0,1796
0,1383
0,1383
0,4294
0,4083
0,1083
0,1064
0,8438

0,5823
0,2484
0,3230
0,1951
0,2175
0,1327
0,5070
0,2450
0,3071
0,2295
0,2242
0,2190
0,1439
0,1909
0,1909
0,2216
0,2287
0,1113
0,1283
0,1289
0,0931
0,1047
0,1862
0,2700
0,2647
0,3130
0,2230
0,1361
0,2036
0,0798
0,1078
0,1285
0,1391
0,3046
0,3008
0,3343
0,1796
0,1383
0,1383
0,4294
0,4083
0,1083
0,1064
0,8438

0,0312
0,1054
0,0695
0,0420
0,0468
0,0286
0,1091
0,1040
0,0661
0,0974
0,0951
0,6670
0,4383
0,8722
0,5479
0,2291
0,1113
0,1337
0,2000
0,0128
0,0074
0,0109
0,0251
0,0203
0,0265
0,0546
0,0389
0,0460
0,0640
0,0612
0,1430
0,2457
0,3595
0,0999
0,0790
0,0183
0,0139
0,0091
0,0288
0,0261
0,0802
0,1116
0,0822
0,1298

1,11
1,95
1,95
1,95
1,95
1,95
1,95
1,95
2,67
1,95
2,67
1,84
1,84
1,84
1,84
5,01
8,28
4,98
5,03
9,55
9,55
9,55
1,17
1,17
1,17
0,75
0,75
1,49
1,49
3,97
3,97
3,97
3,97
1,18
1,18
6,75
6,75
6,75
6,75
1,44
1,44
4,97
4,97
3,24

0,53
0,91
0,91
1,81
1,36
0,91
0,91
0,91
1,26
0,91
1,26
0,87
0,87
0,87
0,87
6,46
13,61
6,67
6,73
11,23
11,23
11,23
0,57
0,57
0,57
0,21
0,21
1,46
1,46
3,42
3,42
3,42
3,42
0,56
0,65
7,38
7,38
7,38
7,38
0,61
0,46
4,60
5,22
2,27

S-2013-078: Reineck; Bentz; Fitik; Kuchma; Bayrak

21

530,00
675,00

149,11
149,11
139,30
129,49

104,97
86,33

170,00
190,00
652,50
566,00

Vu_Rep

Vu_gF

kN

kN

153,00 153,53
205,00 205,91
154,00 154,91
134,00 135,81
138,00 139,36
179,00 179,91
132,00 132,91
216,00 216,91
179,00 180,26
209,00 209,91
238,00 239,26
160,00 160,87
199,00 199,87
190,00 190,87
162,00 162,87
594,78 601,24
744,73 758,34
536,67 536,67
681,73 681,73
787,83 799,06
749,40 760,63
1172,14 1183,37
206,90 207,47
247,20 247,77
220,70 221,27
149,32 149,32
149,32 149,32
140,76 140,76
130,95 130,95
548,00 551,42
891,00 894,42
1221,00 1224,42
1330,00 1333,42
105,53 105,53
86,98
86,98
483,00 490,38
689,00 696,38
598,00 605,38
721,00 728,38
170,61 170,61
190,46 190,46
657,10 657,10
571,22 571,22
324,00 326,27

18.01.2013

vsw-RC-A2b-A3b_sl_Large

593
605
608
613
615
620
621
625
629
630
631
637
639
640
642
643
646
647
648
658
660
661
671
674
675
685
697
702
706
711
712
713
714
783
786
803
806
808
809
817
819
820
821
874
157
68
89

Regan (1971)

Rehm; Eligehausen;
Neubert (1978)
Reineck (1991)
Roller; Russel (1990)

Sarsam;
Al-Musawi (1992)
Shin; Lee;
Moon; Gosh (1999)
Soerensen (1974)
Stroband (1997)

Taylor, R. (1966)
Yoon; Cook;
Mitchell (1996)

Rosenbusch (2003)
Kautsch (2010)
Tanimura; Sato (2005)

App-B3_vsw-RC_A2b-A3b_sl_Large_2013-07-16

ACI-DAfStb Large Collection Database for r.c.-beams with stirrups

R21
T6
T9
T17
T20
T26
T27
T32
T36
T37
T38
W1
W3
W5
W7
RsIS / BQ II 0
RnIIS
Stb III
Stb I
7
9
10
BS4-H
CS3-H
CS4-H
MHB 2.5-50
HB 2.5-50
T-23
T-2-B
2
3
4
5
ST-2-C
HSS-1-B
N2-N
M2-N
H2-S
H2-N
1.4/1
1.7/1
A2
B2
41

betar_meas

xr_meas

[]

mm

24
29

33
31
45
38

450
556
1000
875

xr

sigswmeas

sigswass

sigsw

omwu

andbr

mm

MPa

MPa

MPa

445
445
445
820
820
820

0
270
280
280
280
280
280
270
280
270
270
320
0
368
0
560
557
515
549
445
445
445
820
820
820
0
366
349
0
600
630
0
0
0
0
430
430
430
430
0
0
605
605
0

0,0000
0,1054
0,0695
0,0420
0,0468
0,0286
0,1091
0,1040
0,0661
0,0974
0,0951
0,3032
0,0000
0,4559
0,0000
0,2291
0,1113
0,1337
0,2000
0,0128
0,0074
0,0109
0,0251
0,0203
0,0265
0,0000
0,0389
0,0460
0,0000
0,0612
0,1430
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0183
0,0139
0,0091
0,0288
0
0
0,1116
0,0822
0,0000

438
445
445
902
673
445
445
445
445
445
445
445
445
445
445
645
822
1260
1258
1110
1110
1110
291
291
291
263
263
525
525
827
827
827
827
457
572
1056
1056
1056
1056
450
556
1000
875
500

270
280
280
280
280
280
270
280
270
270
320
368
560
557
515
549

366
349
600
630

430
430
430
430
0
0
605
605

Mu

muu

vutest

kapc

sigsl

xsitest

betaflex

BB

kNm

MPa

mm

mm

kN

134,17
182,33
136,97
241,71
185,83
159,20
117,40
192,11
159,20
185,88
211,68
142,40
177,11
169,10
144,18
767,27
1224,34
1352,40
1714,56
1748,45
1663,16
2601,35
120,52
143,99
128,56
78,58
78,58
147,80
137,50
906,56
1473,99
2019,91
2200,23
96,49
99,42
1020,34
1455,51
1263,28
1523,11
149,29
166,65
1264,91
1099,60
324,00

0,3035
0,1760
0,1719
0,1832
0,1570
0,0821
0,2313
0,1828
0,1899
0,1657
0,1844
0,1153
0,0942
0,1193
0,1018
0,1985
0,2041
0,0805
0,1026
0,0957
0,0526
0,0823
0,1621
0,2090
0,1829
0,2753
0,1961
0,1279
0,1635
0,0522
0,0839
0,1089
0,1230
0,2616
0,2662
0,1854
0,1421
0,0950
0,1145
0,2427
0,2576
0,1274
0,1088
0,3449

0,1456
0,2835
0,2749
0,1458
0,1649
0,1243
0,3862
0,2962
0,3084
0,2651
0,2996
0,4430
0,3585
0,4607
0,3879
0,3391
0,2051
0,2715
0,3516
0,0442
0,0239
0,0387
0,0936
0,1270
0,1078
0,1747
0,1184
0,1790
0,2345
0,1477
0,2445
0,3324
0,3744
0,2935
0,2384
0,0819
0,0617
0,0399
0,0919
0,1101
0,1194
0,2679
0,2285
0,1731

0,820
0,895
0,919
0,866
0,880
0,803
0,948
0,893
0,915
0,886
0,883
0,886
0,827
0,870
0,870
0,907
0,916
0,770
0,770
0,725
0,524
0,524
0,696
0,718
0,712
0,802
0,723
0,870
0,905
0,668
0,664
0,661
0,661
0,927
0,926
0,863
0,745
0,669
0,669
0,818
0,809
0,883
0,881
0,922

435
502
374
630
505
412
335
532
442
508
588
356
439
425
358
469
746
394
443
378
282
371
502
511
442
410
410
420
408
409
467
522
552
441
441
253
354
298
366
380
433
468
468
6

0,491
0,221
0,209
0,225
0,198
0,108
0,284
0,231
0,235
0,209
0,237
0,140
0,121
0,148
0,125
0,244
0,250
0,111
0,144
0,142
0,106
0,172
0,268
0,354
0,303
0,390
0,309
0,156
0,201
0,081
0,135
0,181
0,208
0,329
0,325
0,245
0,213
0,154
0,189
0,362
0,398
0,123
0,121
0,007

0,755
0,889
0,896
0,887
0,901
0,946
0,858
0,884
0,882
0,896
0,882
0,930
0,939
0,926
0,938
0,878
0,875
0,945
0,928
0,929
0,947
0,914
0,866
0,823
0,849
0,805
0,846
0,922
0,900
0,959
0,932
0,909
0,896
0,836
0,838
0,878
0,893
0,923
0,906
0,819
0,801
0,939
0,940
0,996

192
226
227
225
229
240
218
225
224
227
224
248
251
247
250
377
480
557
547
708
722
696
202
192
198
173
182
275
268
621
603
602
583
215
215
575
585
605
593
213
208
675
676
399

0,711
0,861
0,824
0,887
0,876
0,917
0,733
0,863
0,832
0,870
0,873
0,876
0,913
0,890
0,890
0,878
0,875
0,928
0,917
0,911
0,911
0,900
0,866
0,812
0,814
0,805
0,846
0,922
0,888
0,940
0,919
0,903
0,895
0,836
0,838
0,806
0,879
0,897
0,897
0,738
0,748
0,939
0,940
0,704

181
219
209
225
223
233
186
219
211
221
222
234
244
238
238
377
480
547
540
694
694
686
202
189
190
173
182
275
264
608
595
597
582
215
215
528
576
587
587
192
194
675
676
282

0,3367
0,2139
0,2662
0,1731
0,1906
0,1218
0,3715
0,2114
0,2555
0,1998
0,1957
0,1920
0,1314
0,1700
0,1700
0,1945
0,2001
0,1033
0,1176
0,1174
0,0848
0,0942
0,1612
0,2192
0,2155
0,2520
0,1886
0,1254
0,1807
0,0751
0,0991
0,1160
0,1244
0,2545
0,2519
0,2696
0,1580
0,1241
0,1241
0,3167
0,3052
0,1017
0,1000
0,3838

148,82
221,65
212,16
228,40
225,58
236,12
188,59
222,10
214,19
224,06
224,73
237,13
247,02
240,86
240,86
751,96
1200,41
1734,31
1965,35
2144,36
2680,57
2978,08
119,90
151,02
151,44
71,92
75,56
144,93
151,94
1304,59
1740,67
2151,88
2226,67
93,88
94,09
1483,37
1617,96
1649,54
1649,54
194,83
197,46
1009,81
1010,83
360,53

169,72
249,22
238,55
126,62
167,52
265,48
212,05
249,72
240,83
251,92
252,68
266,44
277,55
270,63
270,63
582,92
730,18
688,22
781,45
966,22
1207,83
1341,88
205,84
259,26
259,98
136,66
143,58
138,03
144,71
788,60
1052,20
1300,77
1345,98
102,67
82,32
702,19
765,90
780,85
780,85
222,66
225,67
524,58
525,11
360,53

0,90
0,82
0,65
1,06
0,82
0,67
0,62
0,86
0,74
0,83
0,94
0,60
0,72
0,70
0,60
1,02
1,02
0,78
0,87
0,82
0,62
0,87
1,01
0,95
0,85
1,09
1,04
1,02
0,90
0,69
0,85
0,94
0,99
1,03
1,06
0,69
0,90
0,77
0,92
0,77
0,84
1,253
1,09
0,90

S-2013-078: Reineck; Bentz; Fitik; Kuchma; Bayrak

zetatest

22

z_test

zeta

z_

muflex

Mu_flex

Vu_flex

BB

BB
BB

BB

BB
BB
BB

BB
BB

BB
BB

18.01.2013

vsw-RC-A2b-A3b_sl_Large

ACI-DAfStb Large Collection Database for r.c.-beams with stirrups

sin2thp
-

593
605
608
613
615
620
621
625
629
630
631
637
639
640
642
643
646
647
648
658
660
661
671
674
675
685
697
702
706
711
712
713
714
783
786
803
806
808
809
817
819
820
821
874
157
68
89

Regan (1971)

Rehm; Eligehausen;
Neubert (1978)
Reineck (1991)
Roller; Russel (1990)

Sarsam;
Al-Musawi (1992)
Shin; Lee;
Moon; Gosh (1999)
Soerensen (1974)
Stroband (1997)

Taylor, R. (1966)
Yoon; Cook;
Mitchell (1996)

Rosenbusch (2003)
Kautsch (2010)
Tanimura; Sato (2005)

thp

cotthp

vup

gamwp

cotthu

thu

nueu

[ ]

[ ]

R21
T6
T9
T17
T20
T26
T27
T32
T36
T37
T38
W1
W3
W5
W7
RsIS / BQ II 0
RnIIS
Stb III
Stb I
7
9
10
BS4-H
CS3-H
CS4-H
MHB 2.5-50
HB 2.5-50
T-23
T-2-B
2
3
4
5
ST-2-C
HSS-1-B
N2-N
M2-N
H2-S
H2-N
1.4/1
1.7/1
A2
B2
41

0,03
0,11
0,07
0,04
0,05
0,03
0,11
0,10
0,07
0,10
0,10
0,67
0,44
0,87
0,55
0,23
0,11
0,13
0,20
0,01
0,01
0,01
0,03
0,02
0,03
0,05
0,04
0,05
0,06
0,06
0,14
0,25
0,36
0,10
0,08
0,02
0,01
0,01
0,03
0,03
0,08
0,11
0,08
0,13

10,18
18,95
15,29
11,82
12,49
9,73
19,29
18,81
14,90
18,18
17,97
54,76
41,46
69,05
47,75
28,60
19,49
21,44
26,57
6,50
4,94
6,00
9,11
8,19
9,37
13,51
11,37
12,38
14,66
14,32
22,22
29,71
36,84
18,42
16,32
7,77
6,77
5,48
9,77
9,29
16,46
19,52
16,66
21,11

5,57
2,91
3,66
4,78
4,51
5,83
2,86
2,94
3,76
3,04
3,08
0,71
1,13
0,38
0,91
1,83
2,83
2,55
2,00
8,78
11,58
9,51
6,24
6,95
6,06
4,16
4,97
4,55
3,82
3,92
2,45
1,75
1,33
3,00
3,41
7,33
8,43
10,43
5,81
6,11
3,39
2,82
3,34
2,59

0,17
0,31
0,25
0,20
0,21
0,17
0,31
0,31
0,25
0,30
0,29
0,47
0,50
0,33
0,50
0,42
0,31
0,34
0,40
0,11
0,09
0,10
0,16
0,14
0,16
0,23
0,19
0,21
0,24
0,24
0,35
0,43
0,48
0,30
0,27
0,13
0,12
0,09
0,17
0,16
0,27
0,31
0,27
0,34

0,84
0,92
1,08
0,73
0,78
0,75
1,24
0,97
1,24
0,89
1,02
0,94
0,72
1,38
0,78
0,81
0,65
0,80
0,88
0,39
0,28
0,37
0,60
0,90
0,67
0,77
0,61
0,85
0,96
0,62
0,70
0,77
0,78
0,98
0,88
0,61
0,53
0,42
0,55
0,69
0,44
0,85
0,83
0,52

0,00
2,69
3,96
3,47
3,52
4,35
3,54
2,85
4,67
2,72
3,15
1,46
0,00
1,01
0,00
1,48
1,84
2,03
1,76
3,45
3,22
3,54
3,73
6,25
4,06
0,00
3,05
3,89
0,00
2,41
1,71
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
4,48
4,44
4,38
3,19
0,00
0,00
2,40
2,78
0,00

0,00
20,40
14,19
16,06
15,84
12,94
15,78
19,34
12,09
20,17
17,62
34,39
0,00
44,70
0,00
34,04
28,49
26,21
29,63
16,15
17,24
15,79
15,01
9,08
13,83
0,00
18,17
14,41
0,00
22,50
30,32
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
12,58
12,68
12,86
17,40
0,00
0,00
22,62
19,79
0,00

0,00
0,69
0,93
0,44
0,50
0,46
1,18
0,76
1,20
0,66
0,83
0,76
0,00
0,74
0,00
0,58
0,39
0,55
0,65
0,13
0,07
0,12
0,30
0,65
0,37
0,00
0,32
0,59
0,00
0,33
0,45
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,31
0,23
0,15
0,26
0,00
0,00
0,60
0,57
0,00

betalb

VB

0,25
0,46
0,43
0,25
0,28
0,24
0,58
0,48
0,48
0,44
0,49
0,29
0,26
0,31
0,26
2,00 VB
2,69 VB
0,10
0,12
0,71
0,44
0,63
0,63
0,64
0,57
0,90
0,77
0,49
0,59
0,25
0,36
0,35
0,38
0,16
0,19
0,30
0,29
0,22
0,27
0,01
0,01
0,02
0,02
0,63

A2+A3

kon34

0
1
1
1
1
1
0
1
0
1
1
1
0
1
0
0
0
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
0
1
1
0
1
1
0
0
0
0
1
1
1
1
0
0
1
1
0
87
55,4

1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
0
0
0
0
1
1
0
0
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
0
0
0
0
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
141
89,8

KONA4 KONA5 A4+A5 Differenz AF

0
1
1
1
1
1
0
1
0
1
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
1
1
0
0
0
0
0
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
1
1
1
0
0
0
0
0
56
35,7

0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
1
1
0
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
1
0
24
15,3

0
1
1
1
1
1
0
1
0
1
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
1
1
1
1
1
0
1
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
1
1
1
0
0
1
1
0
80
51,0

0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
0
1
0
0
0
1
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
7
4,5

AF
AF

23

f1ck
MPa
41,3
22,5
16,5
29,7
26,3
45,5
9,1
22,9
17,5
24,7
25,4
24,6
39,4
28,8
28,8
19,4
17,2
53,8
53,8
65,0
115,2
115,2
72,3
66,7
68,1
45,6
65,6
28,7
19,9
79,2
80,1
81,0
80,9
14,5
14,7
30,4
59,9
78,9
78,9
41,7
44,1
25,5
26,0
15,8

fcm_cyl
MPa
47,4
27,7
21,3
35,3
31,7
51,9
13,6
28,1
22,4
30,0
30,7
29,9
45,5
34,3
34,3
24,5
22,1
60,6
60,6
72,4
125,3
125,3
80,1
74,2
75,7
52,0
73,0
34,2
24,9
87,4
88,3
89,3
89,2
19,3
19,5
36,0
67,0
87,0
87,0
47,9
50,4
30,8
31,4
20,6

fck
MPa
43,4
23,7
17,3
31,3
27,7
47,9
9,6
24,1
18,4
26,0
26,7
25,9
41,5
30,3
30,3
20,5
18,1
56,6
56,6
68,4
121,3
121,3
76,1
70,2
71,7
48,0
69,0
30,2
20,9
83,4
84,3
85,3
85,2
15,3
15,5
32,0
63,0
83,0
83,0
43,9
46,4
26,8
27,4
16,6

fc_prime
MPa
45,0
25,3
18,9
32,9
29,3
49,5
11,2
25,7
20,0
27,6
28,3
27,5
43,1
31,9
31,9
22,1
19,7
58,2
58,2
70,0
122,9
122,9
77,7
71,8
73,3
49,6
70,6
31,8
22,5
85,0
85,9
86,9
86,8
16,9
17,1
33,6
64,6
84,6
84,6
45,5
48,0
28,4
29,0
18,2

Vct_ACI Vs_ACI
kN
kN
43,04
43,47
32,26
85,73
27,89
43,47
36,77
43,47
34,69
43,47
45,10
43,47
21,44
43,47
32,51
85,73
28,69
43,47
33,69
85,73
34,12
85,73
14,88
259,00
18,63
259,00
16,03
388,50
16,03
244,05
83,85
457,68
181,94
461,88
57,56
279,65
57,46
417,80
484,17
245,58
641,51
245,58
641,51
362,53
61,40
64,02
59,03
48,02
59,64
64,02
31,44
57,94
37,51
57,94
30,72
39,23
25,84
39,74
89,17
236,56
89,66
558,88
92,16
992,33
90,50
1425,03
20,05
52,42
20,19
41,99
236,48
122,86
327,90
173,60
375,24
147,88
200,13
249,55
58,26
49,37
59,82
159,73
98,76
291,68
99,73
218,76
85,03
243,79

Vcal_sACI Vmax_ACI rat_smax


kN
kN
86,51
215,19
0,402
117,99
161,30
0,731
71,36
139,45
0,512
80,25
183,87
0,436
78,16
173,43
0,451
88,57
225,51
0,393
64,91
107,20
0,606
118,24
162,56
0,727
72,16
143,46
0,503
119,42
168,44
0,709
119,85
170,60
0,703
273,88
74,42
3,680
277,63
93,16
2,980
404,53
80,15
5,047
260,08
80,15
3,245
541,53
419,24
1,292
643,83
909,71
0,708
337,22
287,81
1,172
475,27
287,32
1,654
729,75
2420,86
0,301
887,09
3207,54
0,277
1004,03
3207,54
0,313
125,43
307,01
0,409
107,04
295,13
0,363
123,66
298,19
0,415
89,38
157,18
0,569
95,45
187,53
0,509
69,95
153,60
0,455
65,57
129,18
0,508
325,73
445,83
0,731
648,55
448,31
1,447
1084,49
460,82
2,353
1515,53
452,51
3,349
72,47
100,23
0,723
62,19
100,95
0,616
359,33
1182,38
0,304
501,49
1639,48
0,306
523,12
1876,18
0,279
449,68
1000,63
0,449
107,63
291,28
0,369
219,55
299,09
0,734
390,44
493,81
0,791
318,49
498,65
0,639
328,82
425,14
0,773

gmod-ACI <
%

App-B3_vsw-RC_A2b-A3b_sl_Large_2013-07-16

S-2013-078: Reineck; Bentz; Fitik; Kuchma; Bayrak

6
3,8

VACI_cal
kN
86,51
117,99
71,36
80,25
78,16
88,57
64,91
118,24
72,16
119,42
119,85
74,42
93,16
80,15
80,15
419,24
643,83
287,81
287,32
729,75
887,09
1004,03
125,43
107,04
123,66
89,38
95,45
69,95
65,57
325,73
448,31
460,82
452,51
72,47
62,19
359,33
501,49
523,12
449,68
107,63
219,55
390,44
318,49
328,82
m
s
s
v=s/m
0,05
0,95

18.01.2013

vsw-RC-A2b-A3b_sl_Large

ACI-DAfStb Large Collection Database for r.c.-beams with stirrups

24

gmod_ACI
-

593
605
608
613
615
620
621
625
629
630
631
637
639
640
642
643
646
647
648
658
660
661
671
674
675
685
697
702
706
711
712
713
714
783
786
803
806
808
809
817
819
820
821
874
157
68
89

Regan (1971)

Rehm; Eligehausen;
Neubert (1978)
Reineck (1991)
Roller; Russel (1990)

Sarsam;
Al-Musawi (1992)
Shin; Lee;
Moon; Gosh (1999)
Soerensen (1974)
Stroband (1997)

Taylor, R. (1966)
Yoon; Cook;
Mitchell (1996)

Rosenbusch (2003)
Kautsch (2010)
Tanimura; Sato (2005)

App-B3_vsw-RC_A2b-A3b_sl_Large_2013-07-16

R21
T6
T9
T17
T20
T26
T27
T32
T36
T37
T38
W1
W3
W5
W7
RsIS / BQ II 0
RnIIS
Stb III
Stb I
7
9
10
BS4-H
CS3-H
CS4-H
MHB 2.5-50
HB 2.5-50
T-23
T-2-B
2
3
4
5
ST-2-C
HSS-1-B
N2-N
M2-N
H2-S
H2-N
1.4/1
1.7/1
A2
B2
41

1,769
1,737
2,158
1,670
1,766
2,021
2,034
1,827
2,481
1,750
1,986
2,150
2,136
2,371
2,021
1,419
1,157
1,865
2,373
1,080
0,845
1,167
1,650
2,309
1,785
1,671
1,564
2,012
1,997
1,682
1,987
2,650
2,939
1,456
1,399
1,344
1,374
1,143
1,603
1,585
0,867
1,683
1,794
0,985
1,592
0,407
0,166
0,256
0,922
2,263

S-2013-078: Reineck; Bentz; Fitik; Kuchma; Bayrak

18.01.2013

vsw-RC-A2b-A3b_sl_Small

ACI-DAfStb Small Evaluation Database for r.c.-beams with stirrups

ACI-DAfStb Evalution Database vsw-RC_A2b-A3b_sl - K. - H. Reineck, ILEK, University of Stuttgart


1

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

Querschnittswerte - Section properties


Nr.

Ahmad_1996_008_NHW-3b
Ahmad_1996_009_NHW-4
Angelakos_1999_001_DB0.530M
Angelakos_1999_004_DB140M
Bhal_1968_001_B1S
Bhal_1968_002_B2S
Bhal_1968_003_B3S
Bhal_1968_004_B4S
Cladera_2002_010_H 100/2
Hamadi_1976_002_GT-2
Hamadi_1976_004_GT-4
Hegger_2001_001_SVB 3b
Kong_1997_003_S1-3
Kong_1997_004_S1-4
Kong_1997_009_S2-3
Kong_1997_010_S2-4
Kong_1997_015_S3-3
Kong_1997_016_S3-4
Kong_1997_019_S4-1
Kong_1997_022_S4-4
Kong_1997_024_S4-6
Kong_1997_025_S5-1
Kong_1997_027_S5-3
Kong_1997_033_S7-3
Kong_1997_034_S7-4
Krefeld_1966_010_26-1
Krefeld_1966_012_29b-1
Krefeld_1966_015_29a-2
Krefeld_1966_016_29b-2
Krefeld_1966_017_29c-2
Krefeld_1966_018_29d-2
Krefeld_1966_020_29f-2
Krefeld_1966_021_29g-2
Krefeld_1966_034_39-3
Leonhardt_1962_002_ET2
Leonhardt_1962_003_ET3
Leonhardt_1962_004_ET4
Leonhardt_1962_002_T1 ( r )
Leonhardt_1963_009_TA11
Leonhardt_1963_010_TA12
Leonhardt_1963_011_TA13
Leonhardt_1963_012_TA14
Leonhardt_1963_013_TA15
Leonhardt_1963_015_TA16

24
25
40
42
62
63
64
65
132
243
245
247
361
362
367
368
373
374
377
380
382
383
385
391
392
420
422
425
426
427
428
430
431
444
483
484
485
490
497
498
499
500
501
503

Lit.

Ahmad; Xie; Yu (1996)


Angelakos; Bentz;
Collins P. (1999)
Bhal (1968)

Cladera; Mari (2002)


Hamadi (1976)
Hamadi, Regan (1980)
Hegger, J.; Grtz, S.; Will, N.(2001)
Kong; Rangan (1997)

Krefeld; Thurston (1966)

Leonhardt; Walther;
DAfStb 151 (1962)
Leonhardt; Walther; DAfStb 152 (1962)
Leonhardt; Walther
DAfStb 156 (1963)

App-B4_vsw-RC_A2b-A3b_sl_Small_2013-07-16

Bez.

19

20

21

22

23

24

Laststellung und Geometrie - loading and geometry

Einheiten

bw

hf

hh,top

hw

hft

hh,bot

Ac

zc2

aA

aF

bA

a/d

cc

bw

hf

hh,top

hw

hft

hh,bot

bft

Ac

zc2

aa

af

ba

kap

cc

mm

mm

mm

mm

mm

mm

mm

mm

SI / A

mm

NHW-3b
NHW-4
DB0.530M
DB140M
B1S
B2S
B3S
B4S
H 100/2
GT-2
GT-4
SVB 3b
S1-3
S1-4
S2-3
S2-4
S3-3
S3-4
S4-1
S4-4
S4-6
S5-1
S5-3
S7-3
S7-4
26-1
29b-1
29a-2
29b-2
29c-2
29d-2
29f-2
29g-2
39-3
ET2
ET3
ET4
T1 ( r )
TA11
TA12
TA13
TA14
TA15
TA16

A
A
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
A
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI

127,0
127,0
300,0
300,0
240,0
240,0
240,0
240,0
200,0
500,0
500,0
220,0
250,0
250,0
250,0
250,0
250,0
250,0
250,0
250,0
250,0
250,0
250,0
250,0
250,0
254,0
254,0
254,0
254,0
254,0
254,0
254,0
254,0
254,0
300,0
300,0
300,0
1500,0
960,0
960,0
960,0
960,0
960,0
960,0

127,0 254,0
127,0 254,0
300,0 1000,0
300,0 1000,0
240,0 350,0
240,0 650,0
240,0 950,0
240,0 1250,0
200,0 400,0
120,0 400,0 100,0
120,0 400,0 100,0
180,0 500,0
250,0 350,0
250,0 350,0
250,0 350,0
250,0 350,0
250,0 350,0
250,0 350,0
250,0 350,0
250,0 350,0
250,0 350,0
250,0 350,0
250,0 350,0
250,0 350,0
250,0 350,0
254,0 508,0
254,0 508,0
254,0 508,0
254,0 508,0
254,0 508,0
254,0 508,0
254,0 508,0
254,0 508,0
254,0 508,0
150,0 350,0 75,0
100,0 350,0 75,0
50,0 350,0 75,0
100,0 900,0 150,0
160,0 440,0 80,0
160,0 440,0 80,0
160,0 440,0 80,0
160,0 440,0 80,0
160,0 440,0 80,0
160,0 440,0 80,0

300,0
300,0

275,0
275,0
175,0 100,0
600,0 150,0
360,0
360,0
360,0
360,0
360,0
360,0

S-2013-078: Reineck; Bentz; Fitik; Kuchma; Bayrak

100,0
500,0

mm

mm

mm

mm

mm

mm

mm

mm

mm

32258
32258
300000
300000
84000
156000
228000
300000
80000
86000
86000
100000
87500
87500
87500
87500
87500
87500
87500
87500
87500
87500
87500
87500
87500
129032
129032
129032
129032
129032
129032
129032
129032
129032
63750
50000
41250
362500
134400
134400
134400
134400
134400
134400

127,0
127,0
500,0
500,0
175,0
325,0
475,0
625,0
200,0
133,7
133,7
241,7
175,0
175,0
175,0
175,0
175,0
175,0
175,0
175,0
175,0
175,0
175,0
175,0
175,0
254,0
254,0
254,0
254,0
254,0
254,0
254,0
254,0
254,0
150,7
133,8
127,7
291,7
134,3
134,3
134,3
134,3
134,3
134,3

50,8
50,8
152,0
152,0
180,0
180,0
210,0
210,0
150,0
150,0
150,0

31,8
31,8
76,0
76,0
180,0
240,0
270,0
300,0
75,0
75,0
75,0

578,5
776,6
2662,0
2662,0
810,0
1680,0
2565,0
3450,0
1042,5
1212,5
1212,5
1500,0
730,0
730,0
730,0
730,0
730,0
730,0
1300,0
730,0
500,0
880,0
730,0
945,0
945,0
1765,3
1765,3
1765,3
1765,3
1765,3
1765,3
1765,3
1765,3
1765,3
1050,0
1050,0
1050,0
2500,0
1250,0
1250,0
1250,0
1250,0
1250,0
1250,0

2,92
3,92
2,88
2,88
2,70
2,80
2,85
2,88
2,95
3,46
3,46
3,33
2,50
2,50
2,50
2,50
2,49
2,49
2,48
2,50
2,53
3,01
2,50
3,40
3,40
3,87
3,87
3,87
3,87
3,87
3,87
3,87
3,87
3,87
3,50
3,50
3,50
3,03
3,33
3,33
3,33
3,33
3,33
3,33

28,6
28,6

100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
50,0
50,0
127,0
127,0
127,0
127,0
127,0
127,0
127,0
127,0
127,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
200,0
120,0
120,0
120,0
120,0
120,0
120,0

1188,7
1585,0
5400,0
5400,0
1800,0
3600,0
5400,0
7200,0
2160,0
2500,0
2500,0
3000,0
1960,0
1960,0
1960,0
1960,0
1960,0
1960,0
3100,0
1960,0
1500,0
2260,0
1960,0
1940,0
1940,0
3657,6
3657,6
3657,6
3657,6
3657,6
3657,6
3657,6
3657,6
3657,6
3000,0
3000,0
3000,0
6000,0
3000,0
3000,0
3000,0
3000,0
3000,0
3000,0

31,8
31,8
76,0
76,0
180,0
240,0
270,0
300,0
75,0
75,0
75,0

100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
190,5
190,5
190,5
190,5
190,5
190,5
190,5
190,5
190,5
100,0
100,0
100,0
200,0
120,0
120,0
120,0
120,0
120,0
120,0

127,0
127,0
308,8
308,8
300,0
300,0
300,0
300,0
220,0
250,0
250,0
200,0
370,0
370,0
370,0
370,0
370,0
370,0
350,0
470,0
450,0
320,0
370,0
380,0
380,0
304,8
304,8
304,8
304,8
304,8
304,8
304,8
304,8
304,8
200,0
200,0
200,0
125,0
290,0
290,0
290,0
290,0
290,0
290,0

500,0
500,0
500,0
500,0
500,0
500,0
500,0
500,0
500,0
500,0
500,0
50,0
50,0
127,0
127,0
127,0
127,0
127,0
127,0
127,0
127,0
127,0
900,0
900,0
900,0
1000,0
500,0
500,0
500,0
500,0
500,0
500,0

25,0
22,0
22,0
35,0
35,0
35,0
35,0
35,0
35,0
35,0
35,0
35,0
35,0
35,0
35,0
35,0

18.01.2013

vsw-RC-A2b-A3b_sl_Small

ACI-DAfStb Small Evaluation Database for r.c.-beams with stirrups

ACI-DAfStb Evalution Database vsw-RC_A2b-A


2

25

26

27

28

29

30

31

32

33

34

35

36

37

38

39

40

Lngsbewehrung (Zugbewehrung) - longitudinal tensile reinforcement


Nr.

24
25
40
42
62
63
64
65
132
243
245
247
361
362
367
368
373
374
377
380
382
383
385
391
392
420
422
425
426
427
428
430
431
444
483
484
485
490
497
498
499
500
501
503

Lit.

Ahmad; Xie; Yu (1996)


Angelakos; Bentz;
Collins P. (1999)
Bhal (1968)

Cladera; Mari (2002)


Hamadi (1976)
Hamadi, Regan (1980)
Hegger, J.; Grtz, S.; Will, N.(2001)
Kong; Rangan (1997)

Krefeld; Thurston (1966)

Leonhardt; Walther;
DAfStb 151 (1962)
Leonhardt; Walther; DAfStb 152 (1962)
Leonhardt; Walther
DAfStb 156 (1963)

App-B4_vsw-RC_A2b-A3b_sl_Small_2013-07-16

Bez.

41

42

43

compr. reinf.

ds

ns

st

frs

As

sv

fsy

sy

ftk

ftk/fsy

uk

ds2

ns2

st2

As2

fsy2

ds

ns

dst

fR

As

alphaa

rhos

rhosw

fsy

esy

ftk

ftk/fsy

euk

ds2

ns2

dst2

As2

fsy2

mm

mm

MPa

mm

mm

mm

NHW-3b
NHW-4
DB0.530M
DB140M
B1S
B2S
B3S
B4S
H 100/2
GT-2
GT-4
SVB 3b
S1-3
S1-4
S2-3
S2-4
S3-3
S3-4
S4-1
S4-4
S4-6
S5-1
S5-3
S7-3
S7-4
26-1
29b-1
29a-2
29b-2
29c-2
29d-2
29f-2
29g-2
39-3
ET2
ET3
ET4
T1 ( r )
TA11
TA12
TA13
TA14
TA15
TA16

198,1
198,1
925,0
925,0
300,0
600,0
900,0
1200,0
353,0
350,0
350,0
450,0
292,0
292,0
292,0
292,0
293,0
293,0
524,0
292,0
198,0
292,0
292,0
278,0
278,0
455,7
455,7
455,7
455,7
455,7
455,7
455,7
455,7
455,7
300,0
300,0
300,0
825,0
375,0
375,0
375,0
375,0
375,0
375,0

198,1 4 19,1 r
198,1 4 19,1 r
925,0 2 29,9 r
925,0 4 29,9 r
300,0 2 24,0 r
600,0 4 24,0 r
900,0 6 24,0 r
1200,0 8 24,0 r
353,0 2 32,0 r
350,0 4 20,0 r
350,0 4 20,0 r
450,0 6 25,0 r
292,0 2 36,0 r
292,0 2 36,0 r
292,0 2 36,0 r
292,0 2 36,0 r
293,0 2 36,0 r
293,0 2 36,0 r
524,0 4 36,0 r
292,0 2 36,0 r
198,0 3 24,0 r
292,0 2 36,0 r.
292,0 2 36,0 r
278,0 4 32,0 r
278,0 4 32,0 r
455,7 4 28,7 r
455,7 4 28,7 r
455,7 4 28,7 r
455,7 4 28,7 r
455,7 4 28,7 r
455,7 4 28,7 r
455,7 4 28,7 r
455,7 4 28,7 r
455,7 4 28,7 r
300,0 4 20,0 r
300,0 4 20,0 r
300,0 4 20,0 r
825,0 16 26,0 r
375,0 6 24,0 r
375,0 6 24,0 r
375,0 6 24,0 r
375,0 6 24,0 r
375,0 6 24,0 r
375,0 6 24,0 r

mm

MPa

1140,1
1140,1
1400,0
2800,0
904,8
1809,6
2714,3
3619,1
1608,5
1256,6
1256,6
2945,2
2046,0
2046,0
2046,0
2046,0
2046,0
2046,0
4092,0
2046,0
1380,0
2046,0
2046,0
3284,0
3284,0
2578,9
2578,9
2578,9
2578,9
2578,9
2578,9
2578,9
2578,9
2578,9
1256,6
1256,6
1256,6
8464,0
2714,3
2714,3
2714,3
2714,3
2714,3
2714,3

1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
0,70
0,70
0,70
0,70
0,70
0,70
0,70
0,70
0,70
0,70
0,70
0,70
0,70
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
0,01
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00

4,5311
4,5311
0,5045
1,0090
1,2566
1,2566
1,2566
1,2566
2,2783
0,7181
0,7181
2,9750
2,8027
2,8027
2,8027
2,8027
2,7932
2,7932
3,1237
2,8027
2,7879
2,8027
2,8027
4,7252
4,7252
2,2282
2,2282
2,2282
2,2282
2,2282
2,2282
2,2282
2,2282
2,2282
1,3963
1,3963
1,3963
0,6840
0,7540
0,7540
0,7540
0,7540
0,7540
0,7540

4,5311
4,5311
0,5045
1,0090
1,2566
1,2566
1,2566
1,2566
2,2783
2,9920
2,9920
3,6361
2,8027
2,8027
2,8027
2,8027
2,7932
2,7932
3,1237
2,8027
2,7879
2,8027
2,8027
4,7252
4,7252
2,2282
2,2282
2,2282
2,2282
2,2282
2,2282
2,2282
2,2282
2,2282
2,7925
4,1888
8,3776
10,2594
4,5239
4,5239
4,5239
4,5239
4,5239
4,5239

420,7
420,7
550,0
550,0
425,8
425,8
425,8
425,8
500,0
400,0
655,0
532,0
452,0
452,0
452,0
452,0
452,0
452,0
452,0
452,0
442,0
452,0
452,0
433,0
433,0
352,4
338,6
383,4
364,1
271,0
290,3
406,2
276,6
406,2
419,9
419,9
419,9
464,8
409,1
409,1
409,1
409,1
390,4
390,4

2,10
2,10
2,75
2,75
2,13
2,13
2,13
2,13
2,50
2,00
3,28
2,66
2,26
2,26
2,26
2,26
2,26
2,26
2,26
2,26
2,21
2,26
2,26
2,17
2,17
1,76
1,69
1,92
1,82
1,36
1,45
2,03
1,38
2,03
2,10
2,10
2,10
2,32
2,05
2,05
2,05
2,05
1,95
1,95

710,00
710,00
513,06
513,06
513,06
513,06
565,00
820,00
673,00
559,00
559,00
559,00
559,00
559,00
559,00
559,00
559,00
544,00
559,00
559,00
541,00
541,00

524,84
524,84
524,84
549,17
535,63
535,63
535,63
535,63
518,95
518,95

0,00
0,00
1,29
1,29
1,21
1,21
1,21
1,21
0,00
1,41
1,25
1,27
1,24
1,24
1,24
1,24
1,24
1,24
1,24
1,24
1,23
1,24
1,24
1,25
1,25
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
1,25
1,25
1,25
1,18
1,31
1,31
1,31
1,31
1,33
1,33

S-2013-078: Reineck; Bentz; Fitik; Kuchma; Bayrak

15
15
15
15

mm

38,1
38,1
75,0
75,0
25,0
25,0
25,0
25,0
35,0

2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
4
4

12,7 253,4
12,7 253,4
400,0
400,0
10,0 157,1
10,0 157,1
10,0 157,1
10,0 157,1
8,0 100,5
12,0 452,4
12,0 452,4

421
421
483
483
443
443
443
443
540
350
350

MPa

41,0
41,0
41,0
41,0
41,0
41,0
41,0
41,0
41,0
41,0
41,0
47,0
47,0

2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2

12,0
12,0
12,0
12,0
12,0
12,0
12,0
12,0
12,0
12,0
12,0
24,0
24,0

224,0
224,0
224,0
224,0
224,0
224,0
224,0
224,0
224,0
224,0
224,0
920,0
920,0

462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
462
452
462
442
442

2
2
2
11
4
4
4
4
4
4

8,0
8,0
8,0
10,0
10,0
10,0
10,0
10,0
10,0
10,0

100,5
100,5
100,5
863,9
314,2
314,2
314,2
314,2
314,2
314,2

456
456
456
426
426
426
426
426
426

18.01.2013

vsw-RC-A2b-A3b_sl_Small

ACI-DAfStb Small Evaluation Database for r.c.-beams with stirrups

ACI-DAfStb Evalution Database vsw-RC_A2b-A


2

44

45

46

47

48

49

50

51

52

53

54

55

56

57

58

Nr.

24
25
40
42
62
63
64
65
132
243
245
247
361
362
367
368
373
374
377
380
382
383
385
391
392
420
422
425
426
427
428
430
431
444
483
484
485
490
497
498
499
500
501
503

Lit.

Ahmad; Xie; Yu (1996)


Angelakos; Bentz;
Collins P. (1999)
Bhal (1968)

Cladera; Mari (2002)


Hamadi (1976)
Hamadi, Regan (1980)
Hegger, J.; Grtz, S.; Will, N.(2001)
Kong; Rangan (1997)

Krefeld; Thurston (1966)

Leonhardt; Walther;
DAfStb 151 (1962)
Leonhardt; Walther; DAfStb 152 (1962)
Leonhardt; Walther
DAfStb 156 (1963)

App-B4_vsw-RC_A2b-A3b_sl_Small_2013-07-16

Bez.

nsw

Asw

frw

sw

sw / h

dw

nsw

Asw

frw

sw

sw/h

sw/d

59

60

61

62

63

64

65

66

67

ct,test

f1ct,m,cal

ct,cal

betacttest

f1ctmcal

betactcal

uckfestigkeit - compressive compressive

Bgelbewehrung - Stirrups
zw1

zw2

fyw

fyw * w/100

fwtk

zw1

zw2

rhow

fyw

fyw_rhow_100

fwtk
MPa

mm

mm

mm

mm

mm

MPa

MPa

NHW-3b
NHW-4
DB0.530M
DB140M
B1S
B2S
B3S
B4S
H 100/2
GT-2
GT-4
SVB 3b
S1-3
S1-4
S2-3
S2-4
S3-3
S3-4
S4-1
S4-4
S4-6
S5-1
S5-3
S7-3
S7-4
26-1
29b-1
29a-2
29b-2
29c-2
29d-2
29f-2
29g-2
39-3
ET2
ET3
ET4
T1 ( r )
TA11
TA12
TA13
TA14
TA15
TA16

6,4
6,4
9,5
9,5
6,0
6,0
6,0
6,0
6,0
6,0
8,0
8,0
4,9
4,9
4,9
4,9
4,0
4,0
4,9
4,9
4,9
4,9
4,9
4,9
4,9
6,4
6,4
6,4
6,4
6,4
6,4
6,4
6,4
9,5
6,0
6,0
6,0
12,0
8,0
6,0
12,0
10,0
8,0
8,0

2
2
1
1
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2

63,3
63,3
71,3
71,3
56,5
56,5
56,5
56,5
56,5
56,5
100,5
100,5
38,3
38,3
38,3
38,3
24,6
24,6
38,3
38,3
38,3
38,3
38,3
38,3
38,3
63,3
63,3
63,3
63,3
63,3
63,3
63,3
63,3
141,9
56,5
56,5
56,5
232,0
100,5
56,5
226,2
157,1
100,5
100,5

0
0
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
0
0
0
r
r
r
r
r
r
r

63,5
99,1
300,0
300,0
160,0
160,0
160,0
160,0
165,0
125,0
160,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
80,0
152,4
228,6
228,6
228,6
228,6
228,6
228,6
228,6
228,6
110,0
110,0
110,0
80,0
113,0
113,0
113,0
113,0
113,0
113,0

0,25
0,39
0,30
0,30
0,46
0,25
0,17
0,13
0,41
0,31
0,40
0,20
0,29
0,29
0,29
0,29
0,29
0,29
0,29
0,29
0,29
0,29
0,29
0,29
0,23
0,30
0,45
0,45
0,45
0,45
0,45
0,45
0,45
0,45
0,31
0,31
0,31
0,09
0,26
0,26
0,26
0,26
0,26
0,26

0,32
0,50
0,32
0,32
0,53
0,27
0,18
0,13
0,47
0,36
0,46
0,22
0,34
0,34
0,34
0,34
0,34
0,34
0,19
0,34
0,51
0,34
0,34
0,36
0,29
0,33
0,50
0,50
0,50
0,50
0,50
0,50
0,50
0,50
0,37
0,37
0,37
0,10
0,30
0,30
0,30
0,30
0,30
0,30

166
166
877
877
270
570
870
1170
323
320
310
410
267
267
267
267
273
273
499
267
173
267
267
253
253
424
424
424
424
424
424
424
424
408
270
270
270
765
335
345
315
325
335
335

141
141
0
0
0
0
0
0
303
306
306
0
222
222
222
222
223
223
454
222
128
222
222
208
208
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0

0,7854
0,5035
0,0792
0,0792
0,1473
0,1473
0,1473
0,1473
0,1714
0,3770
0,5236
0,5585
0,1533
0,1533
0,1533
0,1533
0,0985
0,0985
0,1533
0,1533
0,1533
0,1533
0,1533
0,1533
0,1917
0,1636
0,1091
0,1091
0,1091
0,1091
0,1091
0,1091
0,1091
0,2444
0,3427
0,5141
1,0282
2,9000
0,5560
0,3128
1,2511
0,8688
0,5560
0,5560

324,1
324,1
508,0
508,0
441,5
441,5
441,5
441,5
530,0
320,0
480,0
514,0
569,0
569,0
569,0
569,0
632,0
632,0
569,0
569,0
569,0
569,0
569,0
569,0
569,0
341,4
341,4
372,4
372,4
372,4
372,4
372,4
372,4
275,9
313,9
313,9
313,9
426,6
417,9
440,5
426,7
425,8
417,9
417,9

2,55
1,63
0,40
0,40
0,65
0,65
0,65
0,65
0,91
1,21
2,51
2,87
0,87
0,87
0,87
0,87
0,62
0,62
0,87
0,87
0,87
0,87
0,87
0,87
1,09
0,56
0,37
0,41
0,41
0,41
0,41
0,41
0,41
0,67
1,08
1,61
3,23
12,37
2,32
1,38
5,34
3,70
2,32
2,32

fwk / fyw

wuk

fwtk/fyw ewuk

778,00
778,00
567,51
567,51
567,51
567,51
680,00
430,00
720,00
614,00
614,00
614,00
614,00
687,00
687,00
614,00
614,00
614,00
614,00
614,00
614,00
614,00

376,70
376,70
376,70
536,42
525,82
569,96
536,61
537,59
525,82
525,82

S-2013-078: Reineck; Bentz; Fitik; Kuchma; Bayrak

0,00
0,00
1,53
1,53
1,29
1,29
1,29
1,29
1,28
1,34
1,50
0,00
1,08
1,08
1,08
1,08
1,09
1,09
1,08
1,08
1,08
1,08
1,08
1,08
1,08
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
1,20
1,20
1,20
1,26
1,26
1,29
1,26
1,26
1,26
1,26

f1c

diaa

f1c

Method

fcwu

f1ct,test

fcwu

f1cttest

Method
-

mm

MPa

MPa

MPa

19,1
19,1
10,0
10,0
30,0
30,0
30,0
30,0
12,0
20,0
20,0

99,99
95,74
30,40
36,10
25,88
24,18
25,34
24,49
82,65
23,63
29,43
66,50
58,51
58,51
66,70
66,70
62,01
62,01
80,32
80,32
80,32
82,25
82,25
68,82
68,82
38,13
35,77
35,31
39,31
22,93
28,89
39,70
14,94
40,56
22,56
22,56
22,56
23,01
24,92
24,92
21,29
21,29
20,31
20,31

cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cu
cu
cu
cu
cyl
cu
cu
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
pr
pr
pr
cu
pr
pr
pr
pr
pr
pr

80,00
76,59
24,32
28,88
20,70
19,34
20,27
19,59
66,12
18,90
23,54
53,20
46,81
46,81
53,36
53,36
49,61
49,61
64,25
64,25
64,25
65,80
65,80
55,05
55,05
30,50
28,62
28,25
31,45
18,34
23,11
31,76
11,95
32,44
18,05
18,05
18,05
18,41
19,93
19,93
17,03
17,03
16,25
16,25

0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
2,26
2,39
2,67
2,14
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
3,25
3,25
3,28
3,28
3,72
3,72
3,72
4,80
4,80
3,68
3,68
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
2,47
2,47
2,47
2,38
2,41
2,41
2,18
2,18
2,35
2,35

7,0
7,0
7,0
7,0
7,0
7,0
7,0
7,0
7,0
7,0
7,0
7,0
7,0

30,0
30,0
30,0
30,0
30,0
30,0
30,0
30,0
30,0
30,0

fl
fl
fl
fl

sp
sp
sp
sp
sp
sp
sp
sp
sp
sp
sp

fl
fl
fl
fl
fl
fl
fl
fl
fl
fl

MPa

0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0873
0,0988
0,1055
0,0875
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0487
0,0487
0,0528
0,0528
0,0463
0,0463
0,0463
0,0583
0,0583
0,0535
0,0535
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,1093
0,1093
0,1093
0,1036
0,0969
0,0969
0,1023
0,1023
0,1159
0,1159

5,20
5,12
2,78
3,17
2,46
2,33
2,42
2,36
4,86
2,29
2,72
4,51
4,31
4,31
4,51
4,51
4,40
4,40
4,82
4,82
4,82
4,86
4,86
4,56
4,56
3,30
3,15
3,12
3,38
2,24
2,68
3,40
1,56
3,45
2,21
2,21
2,21
2,24
2,39
2,39
2,11
2,11
2,03
2,03

0,0520
0,0535
0,0916
0,0878
0,0950
0,0964
0,0955
0,0962
0,0588
0,0969
0,0923
0,0678
0,0736
0,0736
0,0676
0,0676
0,0709
0,0709
0,0600
0,0600
0,0600
0,0590
0,0590
0,0663
0,0663
0,0866
0,0880
0,0883
0,0859
0,0975
0,0927
0,0857
0,1043
0,0852
0,0978
0,0978
0,0978
0,0974
0,0958
0,0958
0,0989
0,0989
0,0998
0,0998

18.01.2013

vsw-RC-A2b-A3b_sl_Small

ACI-DAfStb Small Evaluation Database for r.c.-beams with stirrups

ACI-DAfStb Evalution Database vsw-RC_A2b-A


2

68

69

70

71

72

73

74

75

76

77

mech. reinforcement ratios


Nr.

24
25
40
42
62
63
64
65
132
243
245
247
361
362
367
368
373
374
377
380
382
383
385
391
392
420
422
425
426
427
428
430
431
444
483
484
485
490
497
498
499
500
501
503

Lit.

Ahmad; Xie; Yu (1996)


Angelakos; Bentz;
Collins P. (1999)
Bhal (1968)

Cladera; Mari (2002)


Hamadi (1976)
Hamadi, Regan (1980)
Hegger, J.; Grtz, S.; Will, N.(2001)
Kong; Rangan (1997)

Krefeld; Thurston (1966)

Leonhardt; Walther;
DAfStb 151 (1962)
Leonhardt; Walther; DAfStb 152 (1962)
Leonhardt; Walther
DAfStb 156 (1963)

App-B4_vsw-RC_A2b-A3b_sl_Small_2013-07-16

Bez.

78

79

80

81

82

83

84

Versuch - Test results

85

86

87

Bruchschnittgren

wy

Vg

Vu,g+F,Rep

Vu,Rep

Vu_g+F

xr

sl,a

sw,meas

sw,ass

sw

wu

andere Bruchart

Mu

u,test

oms

oml

omwy

Vg

Vu_F+g,rep

Vu_Rep

Vu_gF

betar_meas

xr_meas

xr

sigswmeas

sigswass

sigsw

omwu

andbr

Mu

muu

vutest

kN/m

kN

kN

kN

kN

kN

[]

mm

mm

MPa

MPa

MPa

122,78
94,03
265,86
279,50
128,70
249,57
369,39
472,61
225,55
148,50
227,50
427,00
206,10
277,90
253,30
219,40
228,60
174,90
354,00
258,10
202,90
241,70
243,80
246,50
273,60
206,83
160,13
216,62
202,38
161,46
165,02
234,41
149,90
239,75
130,94
126,25
98,08
800,03
338,32
267,69
346,17
336,36
295,16
296,14

122,78
94,03
265,86
279,50
128,70
249,57
369,39
472,61
226,62
149,83
228,83
428,80
207,41
279,31
254,61
220,60
229,78
176,12
356,03
259,36
203,95
243,07
245,14
247,54
274,64
209,76
163,06
219,55
205,31
164,39
167,95
237,34
152,83
242,68
130,94
126,25
98,08
800,03
338,32
267,69
346,17
336,36
295,16
296,14

289
388
1331
1380
321
1300
1975
1725
521
606
606
750
354
310
354
408
420
398
585
381
250
476
341
473
473
883
883
883
883
883
883
883
883
883
233
525
525
1250
625
625
625
625
625
625

324
324
508
508
438
441
441
441
530

324
324
508
508
438
441
441
441
530
320
480
514
314
450
266
279
300
350
183
317
300
411
300
372
375
341
341
372
372
372
372
372
372
276
314
314
314
315
418
440
348
425
418
418

0,0318
0,0213
0,0165
0,0139
0,0312
0,0336
0,0321
0,0332
0,0137
0,0638
0,1067
0,0540
0,0103
0,0147
0,0076
0,0080
0,0060
0,0070
0,0044
0,0076
0,0072
0,0096
0,0070
0,0104
0,0131
0,0183
0,0130
0,0144
0,0129
0,0221
0,0176
0,0128
0,0340
0,0208
0,0596
0,0894
0,1788
0,4964
0,1166
0,0691
0,2556
0,2167
0,1430
0,1430

NHW-3b
NHW-4
DB0.530M
DB140M
B1S
B2S
B3S
B4S
H 100/2
GT-2
GT-4
SVB 3b
S1-3
S1-4
S2-3
S2-4
S3-3
S3-4
S4-1
S4-4
S4-6
S5-1
S5-3
S7-3
S7-4
26-1
29b-1
29a-2
29b-2
29c-2
29d-2
29f-2
29g-2
39-3
ET2
ET3
ET4
T1 ( r )
TA11
TA12
TA13
TA14
TA15
TA16

0,1906
0,1991
0,0913
0,1537
0,2067
0,2213
0,2111
0,2185
0,1378
0,1216
0,1598
0,2380
0,2165
0,2165
0,1899
0,1899
0,2036
0,2036
0,1758
0,1577
0,1534
0,1540
0,1540
0,2973
0,2973
0,2059
0,2109
0,2419
0,2064
0,2634
0,2239
0,2280
0,4125
0,2232
0,2598
0,2598
0,2598
0,1381
0,1238
0,1238
0,1449
0,1449
0,1450
0,1450

0,1906
0,1991
0,0913
0,1537
0,2067
0,2213
0,2111
0,2185
0,1378
0,1216
0,1598
0,2380
0,2165
0,2165
0,1899
0,1899
0,2036
0,2036
0,1758
0,1577
0,1534
0,1540
0,1540
0,2973
0,2973
0,2059
0,2109
0,2419
0,2064
0,2634
0,2239
0,2280
0,4125
0,2232
0,2598
0,2598
0,2598
0,1381
0,1238
0,1238
0,1449
0,1449
0,1450
0,1450

0,0318
0,0213
0,0165
0,0139
0,0314
0,0336
0,0321
0,0332
0,0137
0,0638
0,1067
0,0540
0,0186
0,0186
0,0164
0,0164
0,0126
0,0126
0,0136
0,0136
0,0136
0,0133
0,0133
0,0158
0,0198
0,0183
0,0130
0,0144
0,0129
0,0221
0,0176
0,0128
0,0340
0,0208
0,0596
0,0894
0,1788
0,6719
0,1166
0,0691
0,3135
0,2172
0,1430
0,1430

0,77 0,24 122,54


0,77 0,31 93,72
7,20 9,86 256,00
7,20 9,50 270,00
2,02 1,17 127,53
3,74 1,87 247,70
5,47 3,97 365,42
7,20 13,50 459,11
1,92 1,07
2,06 1,33
2,06 1,33
2,40 1,80
2,10 1,31
2,10 1,41
2,10 1,31
2,10 1,20
2,10 1,18
2,10 1,22
2,10 2,03
2,10 1,26
2,10 1,05
2,10 1,37
2,10 1,34
2,10 1,04
2,10 1,04
3,10 2,93
3,10 2,93
3,10 2,93
3,10 2,93
3,10 2,93
3,10 2,93
3,10 2,93
3,10 2,93
3,10 2,93
1,53 1,94 129,00
1,20 1,17 125,08
0,99 0,97 97,12
8,70 15,23 784,80
3,23 2,82 335,50
3,23 2,82 264,87
3,23 2,82 343,35
3,23 2,82 333,54
3,23 2,82 292,34
3,23 2,82 293,32

131,94
127,53
99,08
340,90
270,27
348,75
338,94
297,73
298,71

1380
321
1300
1975

41
40
55
47
58
53

47
45

41

354
310
354
408
420
398
585
381
476
341

233

S-2013-078: Reineck; Bentz; Fitik; Kuchma; Bayrak

320
480
514
314
450
266
279
300
350
183
317
300
411
300
372
375
341
341
372
372
372
372
372
372
276
314
314
314
315
418
440
348
425
418
418

kNm

71,03
73,03
707,71
744,04
104,25
419,29
947,48
1630,50
235,14
180,06
275,84
640,50
150,45
202,87
184,91
160,16
166,88
127,68
460,20
188,41
101,45
212,70
177,97
232,94
258,55
365,12
282,67
382,40
357,27
285,03
291,31
413,80
264,61
423,23
137,49
132,56
102,99
2000,06
422,91
334,62
432,72
420,45
368,95
370,18

0,1425
0,1530
0,0907
0,0803
0,1865
0,2007
0,1923
0,1926
0,1142
0,1244
0,1530
0,2162
0,1206
0,1627
0,1301
0,1126
0,1254
0,0959
0,0835
0,1101
0,1289
0,1213
0,1015
0,1752
0,1945
0,1816
0,1498
0,2053
0,1723
0,2357
0,1912
0,1976
0,3359
0,1979
0,2257
0,2176
0,1691
0,0851
0,1257
0,0995
0,1506
0,1463
0,1346
0,1350

0,0707
0,0571
0,0416
0,0367
0,0976
0,1021
0,0956
0,0953
0,0533
0,2005
0,2530
0,1183
0,0660
0,0925
0,0721
0,0615
0,0693
0,0517
0,0450
0,0604
0,0714
0,0559
0,0553
0,0750
0,0851
0,0667
0,0535
0,0769
0,0629
0,0889
0,0704
0,0738
0,1388
0,0737
0,1881
0,2707
0,4042
0,5540
0,3038
0,2378
0,3679
0,3575
0,3288
0,3298

18.01.2013

vsw-RC-A2b-A3b_sl_Small

ACI-DAfStb Small Evaluation Database for r.c.-beams with stirrups

ACI-DAfStb Evalution Database vsw-RC_A2b-A


2

88

89

90

91

92

93

94

95

96

97

98

99

100

Kontrolle Biegung
Nr.

24
25
40
42
62
63
64
65
132
243
245
247
361
362
367
368
373
374
377
380
382
383
385
391
392
420
422
425
426
427
428
430
431
444
483
484
485
490
497
498
499
500
501
503

Lit.

Ahmad; Xie; Yu (1996)


Angelakos; Bentz;
Collins P. (1999)
Bhal (1968)

Cladera; Mari (2002)


Hamadi (1976)
Hamadi, Regan (1980)
Hegger, J.; Grtz, S.; Will, N.(2001)
Kong; Rangan (1997)

Krefeld; Thurston (1966)

Leonhardt; Walther;
DAfStb 151 (1962)
Leonhardt; Walther; DAfStb 152 (1962)
Leonhardt; Walther
DAfStb 156 (1963)

App-B4_vsw-RC_A2b-A3b_sl_Small_2013-07-16

101

102

103

104

Querkraft - PT (mit=0,80

105

106

107

Querkraft - PT im Versuch

108 109

sl

test

test

ztest

flex

u_flex

u,flex

flex

Bbem

sinp

cotp

uP

wp

cotu

lb

kapc

sigsl

xsitest

zetatest

z_test

zeta

z_

muflex

Mu_flex

Vu_flex

betaflex

BB

sin2thp

thp

cotthp

vup

gamwp

cotthu

thu

nueu

betalb

VB

MPa

mm

mm

kN

[ ]

[ ]

NHW-3b
NHW-4
DB0.530M
DB140M
B1S
B2S
B3S
B4S
H 100/2
GT-2
GT-4
SVB 3b
S1-3
S1-4
S2-3
S2-4
S3-3
S3-4
S4-1
S4-4
S4-6
S5-1
S5-3
S7-3
S7-4
26-1
29b-1
29a-2
29b-2
29c-2
29d-2
29f-2
29g-2
39-3
ET2
ET3
ET4
T1 ( r )
TA11
TA12
TA13
TA14
TA15
TA16

0,600
0,617
0,878
0,856
0,896
0,903
0,899
0,902
0,669
0,906
0,882
0,734
0,766
0,766
0,733
0,733
0,752
0,752
0,679
0,679
0,679
0,671
0,671
0,725
0,725
0,847
0,857
0,859
0,843
0,908
0,884
0,841
0,940
0,838
0,910
0,910
0,910
0,908
0,900
0,900
0,915
0,915
0,919
0,919

365
378
550
302
426
426
426
426
457
400
655
532
276
386
343
293
307
229
230
346
415
396
325
297
337
352
266
378
344
271
283
406
277
406
420
408
305
301
409
349
409
409
390
390

0,275
0,290
0,104
0,099
0,231
0,245
0,235
0,242
0,188
0,134
0,181
0,324
0,172
0,242
0,197
0,168
0,184
0,137
0,132
0,178
0,212
0,201
0,165
0,281
0,319
0,243
0,194
0,278
0,231
0,290
0,247
0,271
0,439
0,266
0,286
0,278
0,207
0,099
0,137
0,117
0,158
0,158
0,158
0,158

0,862
0,855
0,948
0,951
0,885
0,878
0,883
0,879
0,906
0,933
0,909
0,838
0,914
0,879
0,902
0,916
0,908
0,932
0,934
0,911
0,894
0,899
0,918
0,859
0,840
0,879
0,903
0,861
0,884
0,855
0,877
0,864
0,781
0,867
0,857
0,861
0,896
0,951
0,931
0,941
0,921
0,921
0,921
0,921

171
169
877
879
265
527
794
1055
320
327
318
377
267
257
263
268
266
273
490
266
177
263
268
239
234
400
412
392
403
390
400
394
356
395
257
258
269
784
349
353
345
345
345
345

0,841
0,839
0,948
0,910
0,885
0,878
0,883
0,879
0,897
0,933
0,909
0,838
0,859
0,859
0,870
0,870
0,865
0,865
0,870
0,884
0,887
0,885
0,885
0,795
0,795
0,879
0,877
0,859
0,878
0,855
0,873
0,864
0,781
0,867
0,857
0,857
0,857
0,924
0,931
0,931
0,921
0,921
0,921
0,921

167
166
877
842
265
527
794
1055
317
327
318
377
251
251
254
254
253
253
456
258
176
258
258
221
221
400
400
391
400
390
398
394
356
395
257
257
257
762
349
349
345
345
345
345

0,1603
0,1670
0,0865
0,1399
0,1829
0,1942
0,1863
0,1920
0,1236
0,1134
0,1453
0,1994
0,1859
0,1859
0,1653
0,1653
0,1760
0,1760
0,1530
0,1394
0,1361
0,1363
0,1363
0,2363
0,2363
0,1809
0,1850
0,2079
0,1811
0,2252
0,1956
0,1971
0,3220
0,1934
0,2227
0,2227
0,2227
0,1276
0,1153
0,1153
0,1334
0,1334
0,1335
0,1335

79,93
79,69
675,24
1296,52
102,24
405,64
917,89
1625,11
254,67
164,12
261,99
590,78
231,87
231,87
235,06
235,06
234,28
234,28
843,67
238,66
107,12
239,05
239,05
314,22
314,22
363,82
348,96
387,13
375,52
272,33
298,01
412,67
253,70
413,77
135,68
135,68
135,68
2998,92
387,77
387,77
383,42
383,42
366,06
366,06

0,03
0,02
0,02
0,01
0,03
0,03
0,03
0,03
0,01
0,06
0,11
0,05
0,02
0,02
0,02
0,02
0,01
0,01
0,01
0,01
0,01
0,01
0,01
0,02
0,02
0,02
0,01
0,01
0,01
0,02
0,02
0,01
0,03
0,02
0,06
0,09
0,18
0,67
0,12
0,07
0,31
0,22
0,14
0,14

10,28
8,39
7,39
6,78
10,21
10,56
10,32
10,50
6,73
14,63
19,07
13,43
7,85
7,85
7,35
7,35
6,43
6,43
6,69
6,69
6,69
6,61
6,61
7,23
8,09
7,78
6,55
6,89
6,53
8,56
7,62
6,49
10,62
8,29
14,13
17,40
25,02
55,06
19,96
15,24
34,05
27,78
22,22
22,22

5,52
6,78
7,71
8,41
5,55
5,36
5,49
5,40
8,47
3,83
2,89
4,19
7,26
7,26
7,76
7,76
8,87
8,87
8,52
8,52
8,52
8,63
8,63
7,88
7,03
7,32
8,71
8,28
8,74
6,65
7,48
8,79
5,33
6,86
3,97
3,19
2,14
0,70
2,75
3,67
1,48
1,90
2,45
2,45

0,18
0,14
0,13
0,12
0,17
0,18
0,18
0,18
0,12
0,24
0,31
0,23
0,14
0,14
0,13
0,13
0,11
0,11
0,12
0,12
0,12
0,11
0,11
0,12
0,14
0,13
0,11
0,12
0,11
0,15
0,13
0,11
0,18
0,14
0,24
0,29
0,38
0,47
0,32
0,25
0,46
0,41
0,35
0,35

0,40
0,40
0,33
0,31
0,56
0,57
0,54
0,53
0,46
0,82
0,82
0,52
0,49
0,68
0,57
0,48
0,62
0,46
0,39
0,52
0,62
0,49
0,48
0,60
0,61
0,50
0,47
0,65
0,56
0,60
0,54
0,66
0,77
0,52
0,79
0,95
1,05
1,18
0,95
0,94
0,79
0,87
0,94
0,94

2,22
2,68
2,51
2,63
3,13
3,04
2,98
2,87
3,88
3,14
2,37
2,19
6,42
6,27
9,44
7,68
11,63
7,43
10,29
7,99
9,97
5,85
7,91
7,23
6,52
3,64
4,11
5,35
4,87
4,02
4,00
5,77
4,08
3,54
3,16
3,03
2,26
1,12
2,61
3,44
1,44
1,65
2,30
2,31

24,22
20,47
21,70
20,79
17,71
18,22
18,55
19,20
14,44
17,66
22,88
24,53
8,85
9,05
6,05
7,42
4,92
7,66
5,55
7,13
5,73
9,70
7,20
7,87
8,72
15,35
13,66
10,59
11,61
13,98
14,03
9,84
13,76
15,76
17,59
18,27
23,87
41,86
21,00
16,21
34,79
31,22
23,51
23,44

0,15
0,14
0,10
0,09
0,27
0,28
0,25
0,25
0,18
0,56
0,57
0,25
0,35
0,48
0,55
0,38
0,65
0,31
0,37
0,39
0,58
0,27
0,36
0,44
0,45
0,21
0,19
0,34
0,26
0,30
0,24
0,35
0,48
0,23
0,52
0,73
0,87
0,89
0,73
0,71
0,63
0,65
0,72
0,72

0,73
0,57
0,80
0,37
0,69
0,56
0,47
0,44
0,56
0,57
0,74
0,54
0,27
0,36
0,31
0,27
0,28
0,22
0,03
0,23
0,43
0,32
0,27
0,19
0,21
0,30
0,24
0,33
0,28
0,34
0,29
0,33
0,47
0,33
0,73
0,71
0,55
0,01
0,66
0,53
0,77
0,75
0,69
0,69

Bez.

138,17 0,89
102,62 0,92
253,66 1,05 BB
487,05 0,57
126,22 1,02 BB
241,45 1,03 BB
357,85 1,03 BB
471,05 1,00 BB
244,29 0,92
135,36 1,10 BB
216,08 1,05 BB
393,85 1,08 BB
317,64 0,65
317,64 0,87
322,00 0,79
322,00 0,68
320,93 0,71
320,93 0,54
648,98 0,55
326,93 0,79
214,24 0,95
271,64 0,89
327,46 0,74
332,51 0,74
332,51 0,82
206,10 1,00 BB
197,68 0,81
219,30 0,99
212,72 0,95
154,27 1,05 BB
168,81 0,98
233,77 1,00 BB
143,71 1,04 BB
234,39 1,02 BB
129,22 1,01 BB
129,22 0,98
129,22 0,76
1199,57 0,67
310,21 1,09 BB
310,21 0,86
306,73 1,13 BB
306,73 1,097 BB
292,85 1,01 BB
292,85 1,01 BB

S-2013-078: Reineck; Bentz; Fitik; Kuchma; Bayrak

110

anchorage

A2+A3
-

1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1

18.01.2013

vsw-RC-A2b-A3b_sl_Small

ACI-DAfStb Small Evaluation Database for r.c.-beams with stirrups

ACI-DAfStb Evalution Database vsw-RC_A2b-A


2
Nr.

3
Lit.

111

24
25
40
42
62
63
64
65
132
243
245
247
361
362
367
368
373
374
377
380
382
383
385
391
392
420
422
425
426
427
428
430
431
444
483
484
485
490
497
498
499
500
501
503

Ahmad; Xie; Yu (1996)


Angelakos; Bentz;
Collins P. (1999)
Bhal (1968)

Cladera; Mari (2002)


Hamadi (1976)
Hamadi, Regan (1980)
Hegger, J.; Grtz, S.; Will, N.(2001)
Kong; Rangan (1997)

Krefeld; Thurston (1966)

Leonhardt; Walther;
DAfStb 151 (1962)
Leonhardt; Walther; DAfStb 152 (1962)
Leonhardt; Walther
DAfStb 156 (1963)

App-B4_vsw-RC_A2b-A3b_sl_Small_2013-07-16

113

114

115

Bez.
kon34

112

NHW-3b
NHW-4
DB0.530M
DB140M
B1S
B2S
B3S
B4S
H 100/2
GT-2
GT-4
SVB 3b
S1-3
S1-4
S2-3
S2-4
S3-3
S3-4
S4-1
S4-4
S4-6
S5-1
S5-3
S7-3
S7-4
26-1
29b-1
29a-2
29b-2
29c-2
29d-2
29f-2
29g-2
39-3
ET2
ET3
ET4
T1 ( r )
TA11
TA12
TA13
TA14
TA15
TA16

1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
0
1
1
1
1
1
1
1

KONA4 KONA5 A4+A5 Differenz

1
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
1
1
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
0
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
0
1
1
1
1
1
1
1

0
0
1
1
1
1
1
1
0
0
0
0
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
0
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0

1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
0
1
1
1
1
1
1
1

0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
0

116

117

118

119

f1ck

fcm,cyl

fck

fc

f1ck
MPa
96,2
91,9
26,6
32,3
22,1
20,4
21,5
20,7
78,9
19,8
25,6
62,7
54,7
54,7
62,9
62,9
58,2
58,2
76,5
76,5
76,5
78,4
78,4
65,0
65,0
34,3
32,0
31,5
35,5
19,1
25,1
35,9
11,1
36,8
18,8
18,8
18,8
19,2
21,1
21,1
17,5
17,5
16,5
16,5

fcm_cyl
MPa
105,3
100,8
32,0
38,0
27,2
25,5
26,7
25,8
87,0
24,9
31,0
70,0
61,6
61,6
70,2
70,2
65,3
65,3
84,5
84,5
84,5
86,6
86,6
72,4
72,4
40,1
37,7
37,2
41,4
24,1
30,4
41,8
15,7
42,7
23,8
23,8
23,8
24,2
26,2
26,2
22,4
22,4
21,4
21,4

fck
MPa
101,3
96,8
28,0
34,0
23,2
21,5
22,7
21,8
83,0
20,9
27,0
66,0
57,6
57,6
66,2
66,2
61,3
61,3
80,5
80,5
80,5
82,6
82,6
68,4
68,4
36,1
33,7
33,2
37,4
20,1
26,4
37,8
11,7
38,7
19,8
19,8
19,8
20,2
22,2
22,2
18,4
18,4
17,4
17,4

fc_prime
MPa
102,9
98,4
29,6
35,6
24,8
23,1
24,3
23,4
84,6
22,5
28,6
67,6
59,2
59,2
67,8
67,8
62,9
62,9
82,1
82,1
82,1
84,2
84,2
70,0
70,0
37,7
35,3
34,8
39,0
21,7
28,0
39,4
13,3
40,3
21,4
21,4
21,4
21,8
23,8
23,8
20,0
20,0
19,0
19,0

120

121

Vct_ACI Vs_ACI
kN
kN
42,38
64,05
41,45
41,06
250,76
111,61
275,00
111,61
59,60
46,81
114,83
93,61
176,75
140,42
231,28
187,23
107,85
64,12
33,07
50,67
37,29
105,56
110,61
232,53
93,28
63,69
93,28
63,69
99,84
63,69
99,84
63,69
96,47
45,61
96,47
45,61
197,20
114,29
109,89
63,69
74,51
43,19
111,24
63,69
111,24
63,69
96,60
60,64
96,60
75,80
118,09
64,65
114,14
43,10
113,36
47,02
120,02
47,02
89,63
47,02
101,75
47,02
120,66
47,02
70,17
47,02
122,02
78,05
34,54
48,41
23,02
48,41
11,51
48,41
64,01
1020,61
48,65
139,42
48,65
82,66
44,58
320,33
44,58
221,94
43,41
139,42
43,41
139,42

S-2013-078: Reineck; Bentz; Fitik; Kuchma; Bayrak

122

123

124

Vcal_sACI Vmax_ACI rat_smax


kN
kN
106,44
211,92
0,502
82,51
207,26
0,398
362,37
1253,79
0,289
386,61
1375,00
0,281
106,41
298,02
0,357
208,45
574,17
0,363
317,17
883,75
0,359
418,51
1156,42
0,362
171,97
539,27
0,319
83,73
165,33
0,506
142,85
186,46
0,766
343,14
553,06
0,620
156,97
466,41
0,337
156,97
466,41
0,337
163,53
499,21
0,328
163,53
499,21
0,328
142,08
482,34
0,295
142,08
482,34
0,295
311,49
985,99
0,316
173,58
549,45
0,316
117,70
372,57
0,316
174,93
556,21
0,315
174,93
556,21
0,315
157,24
483,02
0,326
172,40
483,02
0,357
182,74
590,47
0,309
157,24
570,71
0,276
160,38
566,79
0,283
167,04
600,10
0,278
136,65
448,14
0,305
148,77
508,74
0,292
167,67
603,28
0,278
117,19
350,85
0,334
200,07
610,10
0,328
82,95
172,68
0,480
71,44
115,12
0,621
59,93
57,56
1,041
1084,63
320,07
3,389
188,07
243,23
0,773
131,31
243,23
0,540
364,90
222,88
1,637
266,51
222,88
1,196
182,83
217,05
0,842
182,83
217,05
0,842

125

VACI_cal
kN
106,44
82,51
362,37
386,61
106,41
208,45
317,17
418,51
171,97
83,73
142,85
343,14
156,97
156,97
163,53
163,53
142,08
142,08
311,49
173,58
117,70
174,93
174,93
157,24
172,40
182,74
157,24
160,38
167,04
136,65
148,77
167,67
117,19
200,07
82,95
71,44
57,56
320,07
188,07
131,31
222,88
222,88
182,83
182,83

126

gmod_ACI
1,154
1,140
0,734
0,723
1,209
1,197
1,165
1,129
1,312
1,773
1,593
1,244
1,313
1,770
1,549
1,342
1,609
1,231
1,136
1,487
1,724
1,382
1,394
1,568
1,587
1,132
1,018
1,351
1,212
1,182
1,109
1,398
1,279
1,198
1,579
1,767
1,704
2,500
1,799
2,039
1,553
1,509
1,614
1,620

18.01.2013

vsw-RC-A2b-A3b_sl_Small

ACI-DAfStb Small Evaluation Database for r.c.-beams with stirrups

Levi_1989/1993_001_RC 30 A1
Levi_1989/1993_002_RC 30 A2
Levi_1989/1993_003_RC 60 A1
Levi_1989/1993_004_RC 60 A2
Levi_1989/1993_005_RC 60 B1
Levi_1989/1993_006_RC 60 B2
Levi_1989/1993_007_RC 70 B1
Lynberg_1974_001_5A-0
Lynberg_1974_002_5B-0
Moayer_1974_002_P20
zden_1967_002_T6
zden_1967_003_T7
zden_1967_004_T9
Petersson_1972_001_V1
Petersson_1972_002_VL1
Regan_1971_024_T6
Regan_1971_027_T9
Regan_1971_032_T17
Regan_1971_034_T20
Regan_1971_039_T26
Regan_1971_044_T32
Regan_1971_049_T37
Regan_1971_050_T38
Regan_1971_056_W1
Regan_1971_059_W5
Reineck_1991_001_Stb III
Reineck_1991_002_Stb I
Roller_1990_007_7
Roller_1990_009_9
Roller_1990_010_10
Sarsam_1992_010_BS4-H
Sarsam_1992_013_CS3-H
Sarsam_1992_014_CS4-H
Shin_1999_022_HB 2.5-50
Soerensen_1974_003_T-23
Stroband_1997_002_2
Stroband_1997_003_3
Yoon_1996_003_N2-N
Yoon_1996_006_M2-N
Yoon_1996_008_H2-S
Yoon_1996_009_H2-N
Kautsch_2010_001_A2
Kautsch_2010_002_B2

504
505
506
507
508
509
510
511
512
525
534
535
536
564
565
605
608
613
615
620
625
630
631
637
640
647
648
658
660
661
671
674
675
697
702
711
712
803
806
808
809
820
821

Levi;
Marro
(1989/1993)

Lyngberg
(1974)
Moayer; Regan (1974)
zden (1967)

Petersson (1972)
Regan (1971)

Reineck (1991)
Roller; Russel (1990)

Sarsam;
Al-Musawi (1992)
Shin; Lee; Moon; Gosh (1999)
Soerensen (1974)
Stroband (1997)
Yoon; Cook;
Mitchell (1996)

Kautsch (2010)

bw

hf

hh,top

hw

hft

hh,bot

bft

Ac

zc2

aa

af

ba

kap

cc

SI / A

mm

mm

mm

mm

mm

mm

mm

mm

mm

mm

mm

mm

mm

mm

mm

mm

mm

mm

RC 30 A1
RC 30 A2
RC 60 A1
RC 60 A2
RC 60 B1
RC 60 B2
RC 70 B1
5A-0
5B-0
P20
T6
T7
T9
V1
VL1
T6
T9
T17
T20
T26
T32
T37
T38
W1
W5
Stb III
Stb I
7
9
10
BS4-H
CS3-H
CS4-H
HB 2.5-50
T-23
2
3
N2-N
M2-N
H2-S
H2-N
A2
B2

SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
A
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
A
A
A
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI
SI

900,0
900,0
900,0
900,0
900,0
900,0
900,0
700,0
700,0
599,4
400,0
400,0
400,0
175,0
301,0
610,0
610,0
610,0
610,0
610,0
610,0
610,0
610,0
610,0
610,0
838,0
837,0
457,2
457,2
457,2
180,0
180,0
180,0
125,0
400,0
500,0
500,0
375,0
375,0
375,0
375,0
655,0
655,0

120,0
120,0
120,0
120,0
120,0
120,0
120,0
120,0
120,0
149,9
110,0
110,0
110,0
175,0
120,0
152,0
152,0
152,0
152,0
152,0
152,0
152,0
152,0
64,0
64,0
77,0
77,0
457,2
457,2
457,2
180,0
180,0
180,0
125,0
110,0
90,0
90,0
375,0
375,0
375,0
200,0
155,0
155,0

1050,0
1050,0
1050,0
1050,0
1050,0
1050,0
1050,0
600,0
600,0
320,0
355,0
355,0
355,0
353,0
307,0
305,0
305,0
305,0
305,0
305,0
305,0
305,0
305,0
305,0
305,0
648,0
650,0
870,0
870,0
870,0
270,0
270,0
270,0
250,0
355,0
700,0
700,0
750,0
750,0
750,0
750,0
820,0
820,0

278000
278000
278000
278000
278000
278000
278000
159600
159600
84503
62250
62250
62250
61775
60732
81168
81168
81168
81168
81168
81168
81168
111396
76786
76786
207323
209760
397741
397741
397741
48600
48600
48600
31250
62250
165500
165500
281250
281250
281250
281250
207100
207100

432,8
432,8
432,8
432,8
432,8
432,8
432,8
261,1
261,1
108,4
126,3
126,3
126,3
176,5
151,9
103,4
103,4
103,4
103,4
103,4
103,4
103,4
104,9
113,3
113,3
318,2
333,1
435,0
435,0
435,0
135,0
135,0
135,0
125,0
126,3
335,5
335,5
375,0
375,0
375,0
375,0
282,6
282,6

26,7
130,0
130,0
130,0
100,0
100,0
50,0
50,0
50,0
50,0
50,0
50,0
50,0
50,0
50,0
50,0
160,0
160,0
133,4
133,4
133,4
100,0
100,0
100,0
22,5
100,0
91,4
91,4
75,0
75,0
75,0
75,0
150,0
150,0

250,0
250,0
250,0
250,0
250,0
250,0
250,0
425,0
425,0
304,8
250,0
250,0
250,0
300,0
300,0
300,0
300,0
300,0
300,0
300,0
300,0
300,0
300,0
305,0
305,0
700,0
700,0
152,4
152,4
152,4
150,0
150,0
150,0
100,0
250,0
346,2
346,2
350,0
350,0
350,0
350,0
200,0
200,0

9600,0
9600,0
9600,0
9600,0
9600,0
9600,0
9600,0
5000,0
5000,0
1981,2
3000,0
3000,0
3000,0
2600,0
2200,0
1828,8
1828,8
3657,6
2743,2
1828,8
1828,8
1828,8
1828,8
1830,0
1830,0
5200,0
5190,0
4572,0
4572,0
4572,0
1565,0
1565,0
1565,0
1075,0
3000,0
5000,0
5000,0
4300,0
4300,0
4300,0
4300,0
4000,0
4000,0

2000,0
2000,0
2000,0
2000,0
2000,0
2000,0
2000,0
2000,0
2000,0
26,7
900,0
900,0
900,0
100,0
100,0
50,0
50,0
50,0
50,0
50,0
50,0
50,0
50,0
50,0
50,0
160,0
160,0
133,4
133,4
133,4
400,0
400,0
400,0
22,5
900,0
69,2
69,2
75,0
75,0
75,0
75,0

3800,0
3800,0
3800,0
3800,0
3800,0
3800,0
3800,0
1500,0
1500,0
977,3
1050,0
1050,0
1050,0
1150,0
900,0
889,4
889,4
1803,8
1346,6
889,4
889,4
889,4
889,4
890,0
890,0
2520,0
2515,0
2219,3
2219,3
2219,3
582,5
582,5
582,5
526,3
1050,0
1654,3
1654,3
2112,5
2112,5
2112,5
2112,5
1925,0
1925,0

4,04
4,04
4,04
4,04
4,04
4,04
4,04
2,78
2,78
3,50
3,52
3,52
3,52
3,57
3,24
3,50
3,50
7,10
5,30
3,50
3,50
3,50
3,50
3,33
3,33
4,27
4,27
2,91
2,91
2,91
2,50
2,50
2,50
2,45
3,52
2,56
2,56
3,23
3,23
3,23
3,23
2,68
2,68

130,0
700,0
130,0
700,0
130,0
700,0
130,0
700,0
130,0
700,0
130,0
700,0
130,0
700,0
90,0 10,0 360,0
90,0 10,0 360,0
81,3
238,8
80,0
275,0
80,0
275,0
80,0
275,0

220,0
350,0
220,0
350,0
220,0
350,0
220,0
350,0
220,0
350,0
220,0
350,0
220,0
350,0
110,0 30,0 380,0
110,0 30,0 380,0

63,0
76,0
76,0
76,0
76,0
76,0
76,0
76,0
142,0
76,0
76,0
107,0
100,0

63,0

175,0
229,0
229,0
229,0
229,0
229,0
229,0
229,0
163,0
127,0
127,0
441,0
440,0

301,0

64,0 38,0 254,0


64,0 38,0 254,0
100,0
837,0
110,0
838,0

80,0
275,0
125,0 25,0 400,0 75,0
125,0 25,0 400,0 75,0

75,0 500,0
75,0 500,0

150,0 20,0 650,0


150,0 20,0 650,0

155,0
155,0

76,2
120,0
120,0
120,0
175,0
300,0
60,0
60,0
60,0
60,0
60,0
60,0
60,0
60,0
75,0
75,0
120,0
120,0
266,7
266,7
266,7
100,0
100,0
100,0
100,0
242,3
242,3
150,0
150,0
150,0
150,0
100,0
100,0

20,0
20,0
19,0
19,0
19,0

25,4
25,4
25,4
25,4
25,4
25,4
25,4
25,4
25,4
25,4

25,0
25,0
25,0
26,0

40,0
40,0
40,0
40,0
20,0
20,0

87
Plain
Ripp

35
52

App-B4_vsw-RC_A2b-A3b_sl_Small_2013-07-16

S-2013-078: Reineck; Bentz; Fitik; Kuchma; Bayrak

18.01.2013

vsw-RC-A2b-A3b_sl_Small

504
505
506
507
508
509
510
511
512
525
534
535
536
564
565
605
608
613
615
620
625
630
631
637
640
647
648
658
660
661
671
674
675
697
702
711
712
803
806
808
809
820
821

Levi;
Marro
(1989/1993)

Lyngberg
(1974)
Moayer; Regan (1974)
zden (1967)

Petersson (1972)
Regan (1971)

Reineck (1991)
Roller; Russel (1990)

Sarsam;
Al-Musawi (1992)
Shin; Lee; Moon; Gosh (1999)
Soerensen (1974)
Stroband (1997)
Yoon; Cook;
Mitchell (1996)

Kautsch (2010)

ACI-DAfStb Small Evaluation Database for r.c.-beams with stirrups

ds

ns

dst

fR

As

alphaa

rhos

rhosw

fsy

esy

ftk

ftk/fsy

euk

ds2

ns2

dst2

As2

fsy2

mm

mm

mm

mm

MPa

MPa

mm

mm

mm

MPa

RC 30 A1
RC 30 A2
RC 60 A1
RC 60 A2
RC 60 B1
RC 60 B2
RC 70 B1
5A-0
5B-0
P20
T6
T7
T9
V1
VL1
T6
T9
T17
T20
T26
T32
T37
T38
W1
W5
Stb III
Stb I
7
9
10
BS4-H
CS3-H
CS4-H
HB 2.5-50
T-23
2
3
N2-N
M2-N
H2-S
H2-N
A2
B2

940,0
940,0
940,0
940,0
940,0
940,0
940,0
540,0
540,0
279,4
298,0
298,0
298,0
322,0
278,0
254,0
254,0
254,0
254,0
254,0
254,0
254,0
254,0
267,0
267,0
590,0
589,0
762,0
762,0
762,0
233,0
233,0
233,0
215,0
298,0
647,1
647,1
655,0
655,0
655,0
655,0
719,4
719,4

940,0
940,0
940,0
940,0
940,0
940,0
940,0
540,0
540,0
279,4
298,0
298,0
298,0
322,0
278,0
254,0
254,0
254,0
254,0
254,0
254,0
254,0
254,0
267,0
267,0
590,0
589,0
762,0
762,0
762,0
233,0
233,0
233,0
215,0
298,0
647,1
647,1
655,0
655,0
655,0
655,0
719,4
719,4

20
20
20
20
20
20
20
8
8
4
4
4
4
3
5
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
8
4
5
8
10
10
2
3
3
2
4
6
6
10
10
10
10

24,0
24,0
26,0
26,0
30,0
30,0
30,0
20,0
20,0
15,9
20,0
20,0
20,0
16,0
16,0
16,0
16,0
16,0
16,0
16,0
16,0
16,0
16,0
16,0
16,0
28,0
28,0
32,3
32,3
35,8
25,0
25,0
25,0
25,4
20,0
25,0
32,0
29,9
29,9
29,9
29,9
28,0
28,0

r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r

9047,8
9047,8
10618,6
10618,6
14137,2
14137,2
14137,2
2513,3
2513,3
791,7
1256,6
1256,6
1256,6
603,2
1005,3
1608,5
1608,5
1608,5
1608,5
1608,5
1608,5
1608,5
1608,5
1608,5
1608,5
6157,5
7081,1
6538,1
8172,7
10073,9
1182,8
1470,0
1470,0
1013,4
1256,6
3573,6
5227,6
7021,5
7021,5
7021,5
7021,5
3195,0
3195,0

1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
0,70
0,70
0,70
0,70
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
1,00
0,01
0,01

1,0695
1,0695
1,2552
1,2552
1,6711
1,6711
1,6711
0,6649
0,6649
0,4727
1,0542
1,0542
1,0542
1,0704
1,2014
1,0381
1,0381
1,0381
1,0381
1,0381
1,0381
1,0381
1,0381
0,9876
0,9876
1,2454
1,4364
1,8767
2,3459
2,8916
2,8202
3,5051
3,5051
3,7708
1,0542
1,1045
1,6157
2,8586
2,8586
2,8586
2,8586
0,6781
0,6781

8,0211
8,0211
9,4136
9,4136
12,5329
12,5329
12,5329
3,8785
3,8785
1,8909
3,8335
3,8335
3,8335
1,0704
3,0135
4,1662
4,1662
4,1662
4,1662
4,1662
4,1662
4,1662
4,1662
9,4130
9,4130
13,5539
15,6134
1,8767
2,3459
2,8916
2,8202
3,5051
3,5051
3,7708
3,8335
6,1359
8,9759
2,8586
2,8586
2,8586
5,3600
2,8655
2,8655

500,0
500,0
450,0
450,0
470,0
470,0
470,0
616,3
623,1
641,4
441,5
447,3
444,4
977,0
990,0
630,0
630,0
630,0
630,0
630,0
630,0
630,0
630,0
630,0
630,0
514,6
514,0
472,4
472,4
431,0
502,3
543,0
543,0
410,1
419,9
600,0
560,0
400,0
400,0
400,0
400,0
468,1
468,1

2,50
2,50
2,25
2,25
2,35
2,35
2,35
3,08
3,12
3,21
2,21
2,24
2,22
4,89
4,95
3,15
3,15
3,15
3,15
3,15
3,15
3,15
3,15
3,15
3,15
2,57
2,57
2,36
2,36
2,16
2,51
2,72
2,72
2,05
2,10
3,00
2,80
2,00
2,00
2,00
2,00
2,34
2,34

725,00
733,00
937,93
448,32
448,32
448,32

950,00
950,00
950,00
950,00
950,00
950,00
950,00
950,00
950,00
950,00
605,00
603,78
741,24
741,24
690,55

716,13

648,18
648,18

0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
1,18
6 10,0
1,18
6 10,0
1,46
1,02
1,00
1,01
0,00
2 10,0
0,00
2 16,0
1,51
6 9,7
1,51
6 9,7
1,51
6 9,7
1,51
6 9,7
1,51
6 9,7
1,51
6 9,7
1,51
6 9,7
1,51
6 9,7
1,51
4 10,0
1,51
4 10,0
1,18
5 28,0
1,17
4 28,0
1,57
1,57
1,60
0,00
34,0 2 10,0
0,00
34,0 2 10,0
0,00
34,0 2 10,0
0,00
2 9,5
1,71 15
0,00
4 10,0
0,00
4 10,0
0,00
2 10,0
0,00
2 10,0
0,00
2 10,0
0,00
2 10,0
1,38 18,0 75,0 12 12,0
1,38 11,0 75,0 12 12,0

471,2
471,2

157,1
402,1
443,4
443,4
443,4
443,4
443,4
443,4
443,4
443,4
314,2
314,2
7081,1
6157,5

463
635
270
270
270
270
270
270
270
270
275
275
514
515

157,1
157,1
157,1
142,5

450
450
450
392

314,2
314,2
157,1
157,1
157,1
157,1
1357,2 585
1357,2 585

87
35
52

App-B4_vsw-RC_A2b-A3b_sl_Small_2013-07-16

S-2013-078: Reineck; Bentz; Fitik; Kuchma; Bayrak

18.01.2013

vsw-RC-A2b-A3b_sl_Small

504
505
506
507
508
509
510
511
512
525
534
535
536
564
565
605
608
613
615
620
625
630
631
637
640
647
648
658
660
661
671
674
675
697
702
711
712
803
806
808
809
820
821

Levi;
Marro
(1989/1993)

Lyngberg
(1974)
Moayer; Regan (1974)
zden (1967)

Petersson (1972)
Regan (1971)

Reineck (1991)
Roller; Russel (1990)

Sarsam;
Al-Musawi (1992)
Shin; Lee; Moon; Gosh (1999)
Soerensen (1974)
Stroband (1997)
Yoon; Cook;
Mitchell (1996)

Kautsch (2010)

ACI-DAfStb Small Evaluation Database for r.c.-beams with stirrups

dw

nsw

Asw

frw

sw

sw/h

zw1

zw2

rhow

fyw

fyw_rhow_100

fwtk

mm

mm

mm

mm

mm

MPa

MPa

MPa

RC 30 A1
RC 30 A2
RC 60 A1
RC 60 A2
RC 60 B1
RC 60 B2
RC 70 B1
5A-0
5B-0
P20
T6
T7
T9
V1
VL1
T6
T9
T17
T20
T26
T32
T37
T38
W1
W5
Stb III
Stb I
7
9
10
BS4-H
CS3-H
CS4-H
HB 2.5-50
T-23
2
3
N2-N
M2-N
H2-S
H2-N
A2
B2

12,0
12,0
12,0
12,0
12,0
12,0
12,0
8,0
8,0
5,6
8,0
8,0
8,0
6,0
8,0
9,5
6,3
6,3
6,3
6,3
9,5
9,5
9,5
10,0
10,0
8,0
10,0
9,5
9,5
9,5
4,0
4,0
4,0
6,4
6,0
8,0
12,0
9,5
9,5
9,5
9,5
8,0
8,0

2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2
2

226,2
226,2
226,2
226,2
226,2
226,2
226,2
100,5
100,5
48,5
100,5
100,5
100,5
56,5
100,5
142,5
62,3
62,3
62,3
62,3
142,5
142,5
142,5
157,1
157,1
99,4
162,8
142,5
142,5
142,5
25,1
25,1
25,1
63,3
56,5
100,5
226,2
141,8
141,8
141,8
141,8
100,5
100,5

r.ass
r.ass
r.ass
r.ass
r.ass
r.ass
r.ass
r
r
0
r
r
r
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
0
0
0
r
0
r
r
r
r
r
r
r
r

225,0
225,0
225,0
225,0
150,0
150,0
150,0
160,0
160,0
152,4
150,0
150,0
150,0
150,0
100,0
114,0
102,0
102,0
102,0
102,0
114,0
114,0
114,0
114,0
76,0
108,0
126,0
196,9
196,9
133,4
75,0
100,0
75,0
86,0
150,0
165,0
165,0
325,0
230,0
270,0
160,0
150,0
200,0

0,21
0,21
0,21
0,21
0,14
0,14
0,14
0,27
0,27
0,48
0,42
0,42
0,42
0,42
0,33
0,37
0,33
0,33
0,33
0,33
0,37
0,37
0,37
0,37
0,25
0,17
0,19
0,23
0,23
0,15
0,28
0,37
0,28
0,34
0,42
0,24
0,24
0,43
0,31
0,36
0,21
0,18
0,24

0,24
0,24
0,24
0,24
0,16
0,16
0,16
0,30
0,30
0,55
0,50
0,50
0,50
0,47
0,36
0,45
0,40
0,40
0,40
0,40
0,45
0,45
0,45
0,43
0,28
0,18
0,21
0,26
0,26
0,18
0,32
0,43
0,32
0,40
0,50
0,25
0,25
0,50
0,35
0,41
0,24
0,21
0,28

880
880
880
880
880
880
880
500
500
252
258
258
258
292
238
206
223
223
223
223
206
206
206
217
217
550
539
714
714
714
213
213
213
183
268
607
587
608
608
608
608
679
679

0
0
0
0
0
0
0
500
500
0
260
260
260
0
0
203
203
203
203
203
203
203
203
216
216
0
0
0
0
0
183
183
183
0
246
0
0
575
575
575
575
679
679

0,8378
0,8378
0,8378
0,8378
1,2566
1,2566
1,2566
0,5236
0,5236
0,2123
0,6093
0,6093
0,6093
0,2154
0,8378
0,8224
0,4021
0,4021
0,4021
0,4021
0,8224
0,8224
0,8224
2,1530
3,2294
1,1953
1,6780
0,1583
0,1583
0,2337
0,1862
0,1396
0,1862
0,5892
0,3427
0,6770
1,5232
0,1163
0,1644
0,1400
0,4430
0,4324
0,3243

480,0
480,0
480,0
480,0
480,0
480,0
480,0
674,0
647,0
310,3
272,7
272,7
272,7
323,0
366,0
270,0
280,0
280,0
280,0
280,0
270,0
270,0
270,0
704,0
704,0
515,0
549,0
445,2
445,2
445,2
820,0
820,0
820,0
365,9
349,2
600,0
630,0
430,0
430,0
430,0
430,0
605,0
605,0

4,02
4,02
4,02
4,02
6,03
6,03
6,03
3,53
3,39
0,66
1,66
1,66
1,66
0,70
3,07
2,22
1,13
1,13
1,13
1,13
2,22
2,22
2,22
15,16
22,74
6,16
9,21
0,70
0,70
1,04
1,53
1,14
1,53
2,16
1,20
4,06
9,60
0,50
0,71
0,60
1,90
2,62
1,96

fwtk/fyw ewuk

760,00
734,00
427,59

435,00
460,00
460,00
460,00
460,00
435,00
435,00
435,00
1010,00
1010,00
539,00
630,00
576,83
576,83
576,83

470,88

631,00
631,00

0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
1,13
1,13
1,38
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
1,61
1,64
1,64
1,64
1,64
1,61
1,61
1,61
1,43
1,43
1,05
1,15
1,30
1,30
1,30
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
1,35
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
1,04
1,04

20
19

20

diaa

f1c

Method

fcwu

f1cttest

Method

betacttest

f1ctmcal

mm

MPa

MPa

MPa

MPa

19,0
16,0
16,0
16,0
16,0
16,0
19,0
19,0
19,0
19,0
19,0
19,0
19,0
19,0
19,0
19,0
8,0
8,0
12,7
12,7
12,7
12,0
12,0
12,0
13,0
32,0
16,0
16,0
20,0
10,0
10,0
10,0
16,0
16,0

23,75
23,75
44,65
44,65
47,50
47,50
57,00
24,42
25,27
38,66
31,69
28,98
28,98
36,10
40,85
26,33
20,25
33,53
30,08
49,28
26,70
28,50
29,18
28,41
32,59
57,57
57,57
68,79
119,04
119,04
76,10
70,49
71,92
69,35
32,53
83,00
83,90
34,20
63,65
82,65
82,65
29,30
29,83

cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cu
cu
cu
cu
cu
cu
cu
cu
cyl
cyl
cu
cu
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
pr
pr
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl
cyl

19,00
19,00
35,72
35,72
38,00
38,00
45,60
19,53
20,22
30,92
25,35
23,19
23,19
28,88
32,68
21,06
16,20
26,82
24,06
39,42
21,36
22,80
23,34
22,72
26,07
46,05
46,05
55,03
95,24
95,24
60,88
56,39
57,53
55,48
26,02
66,40
67,12
27,36
50,92
66,12
66,12
23,44
23,86

0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
2,03
2,68
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
2,70
2,92
4,32
4,32
3,79
5,07
5,07
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
0,00
6,12
6,30
2,79
4,14
5,49
5,49
2,51
2,48

0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0829
0,1061
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0951
0,0895
0,0750
0,0750
0,0551
0,0426
0,0426
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0000
0,0737
0,0751
0,0816
0,0650
0,0664
0,0664
0,0857
0,0833

2,30
2,30
3,71
3,71
3,88
3,88
4,27
2,35
2,41
3,33
2,87
2,68
2,68
3,17
3,47
2,49
2,02
3,00
2,76
3,98
2,52
2,65
2,70
2,64
2,94
4,28
4,28
4,56
5,52
5,52
4,73
4,60
4,63
4,57
2,93
4,87
4,89
3,04
4,44
4,86
4,86
2,71
2,74

0,0968
0,0968
0,0830
0,0830
0,0816
0,0816
0,0748
0,0962
0,0955
0,0863
0,0907
0,0926
0,0926
0,0878
0,0850
0,0947
0,0998
0,0894
0,0918
0,0808
0,0944
0,0930
0,0925
0,0931
0,0901
0,0744
0,0744
0,0663
0,0464
0,0464
0,0621
0,0653
0,0644
0,0659
0,0901
0,0587
0,0583
0,0890
0,0697
0,0588
0,0588
0,0924
0,0920

sp
sp

sp
sp
sp
sp
sp
sp
sp

sp
sp
sp
sp
sp
sp
sp
sp

betactcal

87
35
52

App-B4_vsw-RC_A2b-A3b_sl_Small_2013-07-16

S-2013-078: Reineck; Bentz; Fitik; Kuchma; Bayrak

18.01.2013

vsw-RC-A2b-A3b_sl_Small

504
505
506
507
508
509
510
511
512
525
534
535
536
564
565
605
608
613
615
620
625
630
631
637
640
647
648
658
660
661
671
674
675
697
702
711
712
803
806
808
809
820
821

Levi;
Marro
(1989/1993)

Lyngberg
(1974)
Moayer; Regan (1974)
zden (1967)

Petersson (1972)
Regan (1971)

Reineck (1991)
Roller; Russel (1990)

Sarsam;
Al-Musawi (1992)
Shin; Lee; Moon; Gosh (1999)
Soerensen (1974)
Stroband (1997)
Yoon; Cook;
Mitchell (1996)

Kautsch (2010)

ACI-DAfStb Small Evaluation Database for r.c.-beams with stirrups

10

oms

oml

omwy

Vg

Vu_F+g,rep

Vu_Rep

Vu_gF

betar_meas

xr_meas

xr

sigswmeas

sigswass

sigsw

omwu

andbr

Mu

muu

kN/m

kN

kN

kN

kN

kN

[]

mm

mm

MPa

MPa

MPa

kNm

RC 30 A1
RC 30 A2
RC 60 A1
RC 60 A2
RC 60 B1
RC 60 B2
RC 70 B1
5A-0
5B-0
P20
T6
T7
T9
V1
VL1
T6
T9
T17
T20
T26
T32
T37
T38
W1
W5
Stb III
Stb I
7
9
10
BS4-H
CS3-H
CS4-H
HB 2.5-50
T-23
2
3
N2-N
M2-N
H2-S
H2-N
A2
B2

0,2252
0,2252
0,1265
0,1265
0,1653
0,1653
0,1378
0,1678
0,1639
0,0784
0,1469
0,1627
0,1616
0,2897
0,2912
0,2484
0,3230
0,1951
0,2175
0,1327
0,2450
0,2295
0,2242
0,2190
0,1909
0,1113
0,1283
0,1289
0,0931
0,1047
0,1862
0,2700
0,2647
0,2230
0,1361
0,0798
0,1078
0,3343
0,1796
0,1383
0,1383
0,1083
0,1064

0,2252
0,2252
0,1265
0,1265
0,1653
0,1653
0,1378
0,1678
0,1639
0,0784
0,1469
0,1627
0,1616
0,2897
0,2912
0,2484
0,3230
0,1951
0,2175
0,1327
0,2450
0,2295
0,2242
0,2190
0,1909
0,1113
0,1283
0,1289
0,0931
0,1047
0,1862
0,2700
0,2647
0,2230
0,1361
0,0798
0,1078
0,3343
0,1796
0,1383
0,1383
0,1083
0,1064

0,2116
0,2116
0,1126
0,1126
0,1587
0,1587
0,1323
0,1807
0,1676
0,0213
0,0655
0,0717
0,0717
0,0241
0,0938
0,1054
0,0695
0,0420
0,0468
0,0286
0,1040
0,0974
0,0951
0,6670
0,8722
0,1337
0,2000
0,0128
0,0074
0,0109
0,0251
0,0203
0,0265
0,0389
0,0460
0,0612
0,1430
0,0183
0,0139
0,0091
0,0288
0,1116
0,0822

6,67
6,67
6,67
6,67
6,67
6,67
6,67
3,83
3,83
2,03
1,49
1,49
1,49
1,48
1,46
1,95
1,95
1,95
1,95
1,95
1,95
1,95
2,67
1,84
1,84
4,98
5,03
9,55
9,55
9,55
1,17
1,17
1,17
0,75
1,49
3,97
3,97
6,75
6,75
6,75
6,75
4,97
4,97

19,35
19,35
19,35
19,35
19,35
19,35
19,35
6,70
6,70
1,02
1,46
1,46
1,46
0,93
0,73
0,91
0,91
1,81
1,36
0,91
0,91
0,91
1,26
0,87
0,87
6,67
6,73
11,23
11,23
11,23
0,57
0,57
0,57
0,21
1,46
3,42
3,42
7,38
7,38
7,38
7,38
4,60
5,22

676,00
688,00
990,00
938,00
1181,00
1239,00
1330,00
435,00
435,00
120,10
137,34
141,26
154,02
100,93
190,73
205,00
154,00
134,00
138,00
179,00
216,00
209,00
238,00
160,00
190,00
536,67
681,73
787,83
749,40
1172,14
206,90
247,20
220,70
149,32
140,76
548,00
891,00
483,00
689,00
598,00
721,00
657,10
571,22

695,35
707,35
1009,35
957,35
1200,35
1258,35
1349,35
441,70
441,70
121,11
138,80
142,72
155,47
100,93
190,73
205,91
154,91
135,81
139,36
179,91
216,91
209,91
239,26
160,87
190,87
536,67
681,73
799,06
760,63
1183,37
207,47
247,77
221,27
149,32
140,76
551,42
894,42
490,38
696,38
605,38
728,38
657,10
571,22

480
480
480
480
480
480
480
674

1000
875

1900
1900
1900
1900
1900
1900
1900
750
750
489
525
525
525
575
450
445
445
902
673
445
445
445
445
445
445
1260
1258
1110
1110
1110
291
291
291
263
525
827
827
1056
1056
1056
1056
1000
875

480
480
480
480
480
480
480
674
647
310
255
273
273
323
366
270
280
280
280
280
270
270
270
320
368
515
549
445
445
445
820
820
820
366
349
600
630
430
430
430
430
605
605

0,2116
0,2116
0,1126
0,1126
0,1587
0,1587
0,1323
0,1807
0,1676
0,0213
0,0325
0,0717
0,0717
0,0241
0,0938
0,1054
0,0695
0,0420
0,0468
0,0286
0,1040
0,0974
0,0951
0,3032
0,4559
0,1337
0,2000
0,0128
0,0074
0,0109
0,0251
0,0203
0,0265
0,0389
0,0460
0,0612
0,1430
0,0183
0,0139
0,0091
0,0288
0,1116
0,0822

2568,80
2614,40
3762,00
3564,40
4487,80
4708,20
5054,00
652,50
652,50
117,37
144,21
148,33
161,72
116,07
171,66
182,33
136,97
241,71
185,83
159,20
192,11
185,88
211,68
142,40
169,10
1352,40
1714,56
1748,45
1663,16
2601,35
120,52
143,99
128,56
78,58
147,80
906,56
1473,99
1020,34
1455,51
1263,28
1523,11
1264,91
1099,60

0,1360
0,1384
0,1059
0,1004
0,1188
0,1246
0,1115
0,1309
0,1265
0,0649
0,1281
0,1441
0,1571
0,1772
0,1806
0,1760
0,1719
0,1832
0,1570
0,0821
0,1828
0,1657
0,1844
0,1153
0,1193
0,0805
0,1026
0,0957
0,0526
0,0823
0,1621
0,2090
0,1829
0,1961
0,1279
0,0522
0,0839
0,1854
0,1421
0,0950
0,1145
0,1274
0,1088

0,3435
0,3502
0,2640
0,2491
0,2994
0,3156
0,2806
0,3731
0,3594
0,0966
0,1796
0,2041
0,2230
0,0703
0,1995
0,2835
0,2749
0,1458
0,1649
0,1243
0,2962
0,2651
0,2996
0,4430
0,4607
0,2715
0,3516
0,0442
0,0239
0,0387
0,0936
0,1270
0,1078
0,1184
0,1790
0,1477
0,2445
0,0819
0,0617
0,0399
0,0919
0,2679
0,2285

100,00
190,00

530,00
675,00

149,11
139,30

652,50
566,00

39
42

24
29

45
38

273
273
273

647
310
255

323
366
270
280
280
280
280
270
270
270
320
368
515
549
445
445
445
820
820
820
366
349
600
630
430
430
430
430
605
605

vutest

87
35
52

App-B4_vsw-RC_A2b-A3b_sl_Small_2013-07-16

S-2013-078: Reineck; Bentz; Fitik; Kuchma; Bayrak

18.01.2013

vsw-RC-A2b-A3b_sl_Small

504
505
506
507
508
509
510
511
512
525
534
535
536
564
565
605
608
613
615
620
625
630
631
637
640
647
648
658
660
661
671
674
675
697
702
711
712
803
806
808
809
820
821

Levi;
Marro
(1989/1993)

Lyngberg
(1974)
Moayer; Regan (1974)
zden (1967)

Petersson (1972)
Regan (1971)

Reineck (1991)
Roller; Russel (1990)

Sarsam;
Al-Musawi (1992)
Shin; Lee; Moon; Gosh (1999)
Soerensen (1974)
Stroband (1997)
Yoon; Cook;
Mitchell (1996)

Kautsch (2010)

ACI-DAfStb Small Evaluation Database for r.c.-beams with stirrups

kapc

sigsl

xsitest

zetatest

z_test

zeta

z_

muflex

Mu_flex

Vu_flex

betaflex

BB

sin2thp

thp

cotthp

vup

gamwp

cotthu

thu

nueu

betalb

VB

MPa

mm

mm

kN

[ ]

[ ]

RC 30 A1
RC 30 A2
RC 60 A1
RC 60 A2
RC 60 B1
RC 60 B2
RC 70 B1
5A-0
5B-0
P20
T6
T7
T9
V1
VL1
T6
T9
T17
T20
T26
T32
T37
T38
W1
W5
Stb III
Stb I
7
9
10
BS4-H
CS3-H
CS4-H
HB 2.5-50
T-23
2
3
N2-N
M2-N
H2-S
H2-N
A2
B2

0,905
0,905
0,821
0,821
0,810
0,810
0,772
0,902
0,899
0,845
0,873
0,884
0,884
0,856
0,837
0,895
0,919
0,866
0,880
0,803
0,893
0,886
0,883
0,886
0,870
0,770
0,770
0,725
0,524
0,524
0,696
0,718
0,712
0,723
0,870
0,668
0,664
0,863
0,745
0,669
0,669
0,883
0,881

329
335
405
382
367
387
413
522
520
553
418
435
444
677
700
502
374
630
505
412
532
508
588
356
425
394
443
378
282
371
502
511
442
410
420
409
467
253
354
298
366
468
468

0,164
0,167
0,139
0,131
0,159
0,168
0,157
0,158
0,152
0,080
0,159
0,179
0,183
0,235
0,246
0,221
0,209
0,225
0,198
0,108
0,231
0,209
0,237
0,140
0,148
0,111
0,144
0,142
0,106
0,172
0,268
0,354
0,303
0,309
0,156
0,081
0,135
0,245
0,213
0,154
0,189
0,123
0,121

0,918
0,917
0,931
0,935
0,920
0,916
0,922
0,921
0,924
0,960
0,920
0,911
0,909
0,883
0,877
0,889
0,896
0,887
0,901
0,946
0,884
0,896
0,882
0,930
0,926
0,945
0,928
0,929
0,947
0,914
0,866
0,823
0,849
0,846
0,922
0,959
0,932
0,878
0,893
0,923
0,906
0,939
0,940

863
862
875
879
865
861
866
497
499
268
274
271
271
284
244
226
227
225
229
240
225
227
224
248
247
557
547
708
722
696
202
192
198
182
275
621
603
575
585
605
593
675
676

0,876
0,876
0,923
0,923
0,898
0,898
0,911
0,907
0,909
0,954
0,916
0,908
0,909
0,831
0,826
0,861
0,824
0,887
0,876
0,917
0,863
0,870
0,873
0,876
0,890
0,928
0,917
0,911
0,911
0,900
0,866
0,812
0,814
0,846
0,922
0,940
0,919
0,806
0,879
0,897
0,897
0,939
0,940

823
823
868
868
844
844
856
490
491
266
273
271
271
267
230
219
209
225
223
233
219
221
222
234
238
547
540
694
694
686
202
189
190
182
275
608
595
528
576
587
587
675
676

0,1971
0,1971
0,1168
0,1168
0,1485
0,1485
0,1255
0,1522
0,1490
0,0748
0,1345
0,1477
0,1469
0,2407
0,2405
0,2139
0,2662
0,1731
0,1906
0,1218
0,2114
0,1998
0,1957
0,1920
0,1700
0,1033
0,1176
0,1174
0,0848
0,0942
0,1612
0,2192
0,2155
0,1886
0,1254
0,0751
0,0991
0,2696
0,1580
0,1241
0,1241
0,1017
0,1000

3723,48
3723,48
4145,79
4145,79
5608,32
5608,32
5688,41
758,58
768,48
135,30
151,41
152,10
151,20
157,63
228,53
221,65
212,16
228,40
225,58
236,12
222,10
224,06
224,73
237,13
240,86
1734,31
1965,35
2144,36
2680,57
2978,08
119,90
151,02
151,44
75,56
144,93
1304,59
1740,67
1483,37
1617,96
1649,54
1649,54
1009,81
1010,83

0,21
0,21
0,11
0,11
0,16
0,16
0,13
0,18
0,17
0,02
0,07
0,07
0,07
0,02
0,09
0,11
0,07
0,04
0,05
0,03
0,10
0,10
0,10
0,67
0,87
0,13
0,20
0,01
0,01
0,01
0,03
0,02
0,03
0,04
0,05
0,06
0,14
0,02
0,01
0,01
0,03
0,11
0,08

27,39
27,39
19,60
19,60
23,48
23,48
21,33
25,15
24,16
8,39
14,83
15,53
15,53
8,93
17,84
18,95
15,29
11,82
12,49
9,73
18,81
18,18
17,97
54,76
69,05
21,44
26,57
6,50
4,94
6,00
9,11
8,19
9,37
11,37
12,38
14,32
22,22
7,77
6,77
5,48
9,77
19,52
16,66

1,93
1,93
2,81
2,81
2,30
2,30
2,56
2,13
2,23
6,78
3,78
3,60
3,60
6,36
3,11
2,91
3,66
4,78
4,51
5,83
2,94
3,04
3,08
0,71
0,38
2,55
2,00
8,78
11,58
9,51
6,24
6,95
6,06
4,97
4,55
3,92
2,45
7,33
8,43
10,43
5,81
2,82
3,34

0,41
0,41
0,32
0,32
0,37
0,37
0,34
0,38
0,37
0,14
0,25
0,26
0,26
0,15
0,29
0,31
0,25
0,20
0,21
0,17
0,31
0,30
0,29
0,47
0,33
0,34
0,40
0,11
0,09
0,10
0,16
0,14
0,16
0,19
0,21
0,24
0,35
0,13
0,12
0,09
0,17
0,31
0,27

0,84
0,86
0,84
0,79
0,82
0,86
0,83
0,97
0,96
0,67
0,73
0,79
0,86
0,46
0,68
0,92
1,08
0,73
0,78
0,75
0,97
0,89
1,02
0,94
1,38
0,80
0,88
0,39
0,28
0,37
0,60
0,90
0,67
0,61
0,85
0,62
0,70
0,77
0,53
0,42
0,55
0,85
0,83

1,62
1,65
2,35
2,21
1,89
1,99
2,12
2,06
2,14
4,53
5,53
2,85
3,11
2,92
2,13
2,69
3,96
3,47
3,52
4,35
2,85
2,72
3,15
1,46
1,01
2,03
1,76
3,45
3,22
3,54
3,73
6,25
4,06
3,05
3,89
2,41
1,71
0,00
4,44
4,38
3,19
2,40
2,78

31,64
31,14
23,09
24,32
27,93
26,70
25,24
25,84
25,00
12,44
10,24
19,34
17,81
18,93
25,19
20,40
14,19
16,06
15,84
12,94
19,34
20,17
17,62
34,39
44,70
26,21
29,63
16,15
17,24
15,79
15,01
9,08
13,83
18,17
14,41
22,50
30,32
0,00
12,68
12,86
17,40
22,62
19,79

0,62
0,63
0,59
0,53
0,58
0,63
0,58
0,76
0,75
0,37
0,82
0,52
0,61
0,18
0,41
0,69
0,93
0,44
0,50
0,46
0,76
0,66
0,83
0,76
0,74
0,55
0,65
0,13
0,07
0,12
0,30
0,65
0,37
0,32
0,59
0,33
0,45
0,00
0,23
0,15
0,26
0,60
0,57

0,42
0,42
0,34
0,33
0,34
0,36
0,35
0,46
0,44
0,34
0,48
0,53
0,58
0,37
0,40
0,46
0,43
0,25
0,28
0,24
0,48
0,44
0,49
0,29
0,31
0,10
0,12
0,71
0,44
0,63
0,63
0,64
0,57
0,77
0,49
0,25
0,36
0,30
0,29
0,22
0,27
0,02
0,02

979,86 0,69
979,86 0,70
1091,00 0,91
1091,00 0,86
1475,87 0,80
1475,87 0,84
1496,95 0,89
505,72 0,86
512,32 0,85
138,44 0,87
144,20 0,95
144,86 0,98
144,00 1,07 BB
137,07 0,74
253,93 0,75
249,22 0,82
238,55 0,65
126,62 1,06 BB
167,52 0,82
265,48 0,67
249,72 0,86
251,92 0,83
252,68 0,94
266,44 0,60
270,63 0,70
688,22 0,78
781,45 0,87
966,22 0,82
1207,83 0,62
1341,88 0,87
205,84 1,01 BB
259,26 0,95
259,98 0,85
143,58 1,04 BB
138,03 1,02 BB
788,60 0,69
1052,20 0,85
702,19 0,69
765,90 0,90
780,85 0,77
780,85 0,92
524,58 1,253 BB
525,11 1,09 BB

87
35
52

App-B4_vsw-RC_A2b-A3b_sl_Small_2013-07-16

11

S-2013-078: Reineck; Bentz; Fitik; Kuchma; Bayrak

A2+A3
-

1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
87
100,0

18.01.2013

vsw-RC-A2b-A3b_sl_Small

ACI-DAfStb Small Evaluation Database for r.c.-beams with stirrups

kon34
-

504
505
506
507
508
509
510
511
512
525
534
535
536
564
565
605
608
613
615
620
625
630
631
637
640
647
648
658
660
661
671
674
675
697
702
711
712
803
806
808
809
820
821

Levi;
Marro
(1989/1993)

Lyngberg
(1974)
Moayer; Regan (1974)
zden (1967)

Petersson (1972)
Regan (1971)

Reineck (1991)
Roller; Russel (1990)

Sarsam;
Al-Musawi (1992)
Shin; Lee; Moon; Gosh (1999)
Soerensen (1974)
Stroband (1997)
Yoon; Cook;
Mitchell (1996)

Kautsch (2010)
87

35
52

RC 30 A1
RC 30 A2
RC 60 A1
RC 60 A2
RC 60 B1
RC 60 B2
RC 70 B1
5A-0
5B-0
P20
T6
T7
T9
V1
VL1
T6
T9
T17
T20
T26
T32
T37
T38
W1
W5
Stb III
Stb I
7
9
10
BS4-H
CS3-H
CS4-H
HB 2.5-50
T-23
2
3
N2-N
M2-N
H2-S
H2-N
A2
B2

1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
0
0
0
0
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
0
0
1
1
1
1
1
1
80
92,0

KONA4 KONA5 A4+A5 Differenz

1
1
1
1
1
1
1
0
0
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
0
0
0
0
1
1
1
0
0
0
0
1
0
0
1
1
1
1
0
0
56
64,4

0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
1
1
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
1
24
27,6

1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
0
0
0
0
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
1
0
0
1
1
1
1
1
1
80
92,0

0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
1
1
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
0
1
1
0
0
0
0
0
0
7
8,0

f1ck
MPa
20,0
20,0
40,9
40,9
43,7
43,7
53,2
20,6
21,5
34,9
27,9
25,2
25,2
32,3
37,1
22,5
16,5
29,7
26,3
45,5
22,9
24,7
25,4
24,6
28,8
53,8
53,8
65,0
115,2
115,2
72,3
66,7
68,1
65,6
28,7
79,2
80,1
30,4
59,9
78,9
78,9
25,5
26,0

fcm_cyl
MPa
25,0
25,0
47,0
47,0
50,0
50,0
60,0
25,7
26,6
40,7
33,4
30,5
30,5
38,0
43,0
27,7
21,3
35,3
31,7
51,9
28,1
30,0
30,7
29,9
34,3
60,6
60,6
72,4
125,3
125,3
80,1
74,2
75,7
73,0
34,2
87,4
88,3
36,0
67,0
87,0
87,0
30,8
31,4

fck
MPa
21,0
21,0
43,0
43,0
46,0
46,0
56,0
21,7
22,6
36,7
29,4
26,5
26,5
34,0
39,0
23,7
17,3
31,3
27,7
47,9
24,1
26,0
26,7
25,9
30,3
56,6
56,6
68,4
121,3
121,3
76,1
70,2
71,7
69,0
30,2
83,4
84,3
32,0
63,0
83,0
83,0
26,8
27,4

fc_prime
MPa
22,6
22,6
44,6
44,6
47,6
47,6
57,6
23,3
24,2
38,3
31,0
28,1
28,1
35,6
40,6
25,3
18,9
32,9
29,3
49,5
25,7
27,6
28,3
27,5
31,9
58,2
58,2
70,0
122,9
122,9
77,7
71,8
73,3
70,6
31,8
85,0
85,9
33,6
64,6
84,6
84,6
28,4
29,0

Vct_ACI Vs_ACI
kN
kN
89,07
453,60
89,07
453,60
125,12
453,60
125,12
453,60
129,26
680,39
129,26
680,39
142,19
680,39
51,95
228,68
52,95
219,52
43,03
27,59
30,29
54,47
28,87
54,47
28,87
54,47
55,84
39,21
35,30
102,29
32,26
85,73
27,89
43,47
36,77
43,47
34,69
43,47
45,10
43,47
32,51
85,73
33,69
85,73
34,12
85,73
14,88
259,00
16,03
388,50
57,56
279,65
57,46
417,80
484,17
245,58
641,51
245,58
641,51
362,53
61,40
64,02
59,03
48,02
59,64
64,02
37,51
57,94
30,72
39,23
89,17
236,56
89,66
558,88
236,48
122,86
327,90
173,60
375,24
147,88
200,13
249,55
98,76
291,68
99,73
218,76

12

Vcal_sACI Vmax_ACI rat_smax


kN
kN
542,66
445,33
1,219
542,66
445,33
1,219
578,71
625,59
0,925
578,71
625,59
0,925
809,65
646,29
1,253
809,65
646,29
1,253
822,58
710,95
1,157
280,63
259,76
1,080
272,47
264,73
1,029
70,62
215,16
0,328
84,76
151,45
0,560
83,33
144,33
0,577
83,33
144,33
0,577
95,05
279,21
0,340
137,59
176,52
0,779
117,99
161,30
0,731
71,36
139,45
0,512
80,25
183,87
0,436
78,16
173,43
0,451
88,57
225,51
0,393
118,24
162,56
0,727
119,42
168,44
0,709
119,85
170,60
0,703
273,88
74,42
3,680
404,53
80,15
5,047
337,22
287,81
1,172
475,27
287,32
1,654
729,75
2420,86
0,301
887,09
3207,54
0,277
1004,03
3207,54
0,313
125,43
307,01
0,409
107,04
295,13
0,363
123,66
298,19
0,415
95,45
187,53
0,509
69,95
153,60
0,455
325,73
445,83
0,731
648,55
448,31
1,447
359,33
1182,38
0,304
501,49
1639,48
0,306
523,12
1876,18
0,279
449,68
1000,63
0,449
390,44
493,81
0,791
318,49
498,65
0,639

gmod-ACI <
%

App-B4_vsw-RC_A2b-A3b_sl_Small_2013-07-16

S-2013-078: Reineck; Bentz; Fitik; Kuchma; Bayrak

3
1,9

VACI_cal gmod_ACI
kN
445,33
1,518
445,33
1,545
578,71
1,711
578,71
1,621
646,29
1,827
646,29
1,917
710,95
1,871
259,76
1,675
264,73
1,643
70,62
1,701
84,76
1,620
83,33
1,695
83,33
1,848
95,05
1,062
137,59
1,386
117,99
1,737
71,36
2,158
80,25
1,670
78,16
1,766
88,57
2,021
118,24
1,827
119,42
1,750
119,85
1,986
74,42
2,150
80,15
2,371
287,81
1,865
287,32
2,373
729,75
1,080
887,09
0,845
1004,03
1,167
125,43
1,650
107,04
2,309
123,66
1,785
95,45
1,564
69,95
2,012
325,73
1,682
448,31
1,987
359,33
1,344
501,49
1,374
523,12
1,143
449,68
1,603
390,44
1,683
318,49
1,794
m
1,556
s
0,361
s
0,131
v=s/m
0,232
0,05
0,962
0,95
2,150

18.01.2013

Copyright of ACI Structural Journal is the property of American Concrete Institute and its
content may not be copied or emailed to multiple sites or posted to a listserv without the
copyright holder's express written permission. However, users may print, download, or email
articles for individual use.