Professional Documents
Culture Documents
TECHNICAL PAPER
(1)
Received Nov. 21, 1986, and reviewed under Institute publication policies.
Copyright 1987, American Concrete Institute. All rights reserved, including
the making of copies unless permission is obtained from the copyright proprietors. Pertinent discussion will be published in the MayJune 1988 ACI Materials Journal if received by Feb. \, 1988.
259
where
Vc = V/bd = nominal shear strength at failure
Vc= shear force at failure
b
beam width
d
beam depth measured to the axis of longitudinal
reinforcement
do = maximum aggregate size
a = shear span (equal to the distance of the concentrated load from the support when a simply supported beam is loaded symmetrically by two concentrated loads)
p = steel ratio for longitudinal reinforcement
f: = standard cylindrical compressive strength in psi
(6895Pa)
kit Ao = empirical constants (k l = 10)
Zdenek. P. Bazant, FACI, is a professor at Northwestern University, Evanston, III., where he recently served a five-year term as director of the Center for
Concrete and Geomaterials. Dr. Bazant is a registered structural engineer and
is on the editorial boards of a number of journals. He is Chairman of ACI
Committee 446, Fracture Mechanics; a member of ACI Committees 209, Creep
and Shrinkage in Concrete; 348, Structural Safety, and Joint ACI-ASCE Committee 334, Concrete Shell Design and Construction; and a fellow of ASCE,
RILEM, and the American Academy of Mechanics; and Chairman of RILEM's Creep Committee and of SMiRT's Concrete Structures Division.
Hsu-Huei Sun is a structural engineer at Corddry Carpenter Dietz and Zack
Engineers and Planners. He received his M.S. degree from Northwestern University, Evanston, III., and B.S.E. degree from National Cheng Kung University, Tainan, Taiwan, Republic of China.
(2)
0.2~----------------------------------------~
(II)
0.1
PROPOSED FORMULA
C -0.1
"'<..
;>.
'-
~ -0.2
-0.3
nonlinear fracture mechanics - -0.4
-0.5+--.--r--r-'--~-r--r-.--.--.--r--r-.--.--.-~
0.6
0.8
1.4
1.2
1.6
1.8
2.2
log(dld)
0.2.-----------------------------------------~
(c)
#v
O+-----~~~------~~~------.r----------~
A
.......
1:
;>.
+
+
'b() -0.2
f1
3
C)
~"I"
'\.
-C
\.),
0.8
1.2
\,))"1"
+
+
+
V
d
tv
C - 10 pll3cv'f~.30()(hlp/(ald)5 J
0.6
+
+
-0.4
1.4
1.6
1.8
rIA
~A
i
i
+
2.2
xi
log(dld)
roo.0.0E- data
129
0.738
"Y
0.46
0.457
22.0
1.61
0
0
260
20
40
60
80
100
dido
ACI Materials Journal I July-August 1987
Eq. (2), which is quite similar to the formula currently used by ACI, has been derived by analyzing the
arch action and the composite beam action, and summing their contributions. 4
The size effect is due to the release of strain energy
from the beam into the cracking zone as the cracking
zone extends; the larger the structure, the greater is the
energy release. Eq. (1) expresses Bazant's size-effect
law,42 which was derived by dimensional analysis and
similitude arguments from two simplifying assumptions, namely that the energy loss due to cracking is a
function of both the fracture length and of the area of
the cracking zone assumed to have a constant width at
its front, proportional to the maximum aggregate size.
Although this size-effect law is approximate, it was
shown to capture the basic trend correctly when geometrically similar specimens of different sizes, failing in
a brittle manner, are considered.
For very small structure sizes d, such that d/'Aod.
<!i!: 1, Eq. (1) approaches the limiting case of plastic
limit analysis, which is characterized by absence of the
size effect. For very large structure sizes d, such that dl
'Aod. ~ 1, Eq. (1) approaches the limiting case of linear
elastic fracture mechanics. For normal beam sizes, Eq.
(1) describes a smooth transition between these two
limit cases.
Applicability of the size-effect law in Eq. (1) to
sfructures that contain no notches is further contingent
upon the assumption that the failure surfaces (cracks)
in beams of various sizes are geometrically similar, and
that the failure occurs when the front of the final crack
reaches approximately the same relative position within
the beam regardless of the size. These assumptions appear to agree with experimentally observed behavior.
It should be mentioned that the most general size-effect law for geometrically similar structures or specimens may be described by an asymptotic series expansion presented in Reference 43. The approximate sizeeffect law in Eq. (1) is then found to represent the first
two terms of this asymptotic series expansion. It has
been also shown45 ,53 that an improved size-effect law for
blunt fracture can be obtained as Vc = ~ (1 + ~~)- y"
with ~ = dl'Aod., in which r is an empirical constant.
In the course of the present study, however, it appeared that the existing test data for concrete, due to
their scatter as well as limited range, are insufficient for
determining r. The optimum values of r for the existing
diagonal shear data for beams ranged from 0.75 to 1;
the fits were about equally good for this entire range.
Therefore, the value r = 1 has been adopted.
Eq. (1) and (2) involve no size effect of beam width.
This means that the cracking is assumed to occur
roughly simultaneously through the thickness rather
than propagate across the thickness.
Fracture mechanics is not the only theory that yields
a size effect. A competing theory is the statistical Weibull theory. Although both theories can describe the
same size-effect data if their size range is rather limited, they have very different extrapolations to very
large sizes. While Weibull theory is certainly applicable
Vc
+ v'coldA
+ :d.
(3)
261
where Co = empirical material constant having the dimension of length. By optimizing the fits of the test
data described in the sequel, the optimum values of the
empirical constants were found to be Co = 0.2 in., Ao =
25 and kl = 6.5. Note that for the aggregate size d a =
0.69 in. (17.5 mm), Eq. (2) and (3) are equivalent to the
original Eq. (1) and (2). In Reference 53 it was also
shown that the factor 1 + (col dY', which gives the
effect of aggregate size, agrees reasonably well with the
test results of Taylor25 and of Chana,30 which include a
wide range of maximum aggregate sizes.
With regard to the identification of material parameter values, Eq. (3) has the advantage that it can be algebraically transformed to a linear regression plot. This
plot is described by the equation Y = AX + C in
which
d
x=d
(4)
X'
= _1_
.fd.
Y' =
Ve
d)-V,
(1 + :;:-l'Od
(5)
~
Fig. 2-EJJect oj aggregate size in beams without stirrups
262
,."
.s
0.2
3.6
l+dl25d.
t*
Proposed Formula
.J1..
~ 1+v"0.2/d
6.5 pll~ fc+3OOO pl(a/d) ~. = Yc
(cl
3.2
It
...
0
strength or yield criterion
"""'
~
..."
+
+
1.5
(b) BAZANT. KIM (1984)
~t
or yield criterion
I+d/25d.
3.2
...~
.;;
2.8
il
~
~
.;;
+
+
+
..
.2
2.4
eli
-0.4
C-
5
\0 pill
Yc' [..'fc +3000.Jp/(ald ~
!:;
""
\.6
3.6
(d) BAlm. KIM (1984)
E5
~~...
+t
~ -0.2
::5....,
]":1
0.2
.g
-0.4
'-
2.4
eli
.......
I:...>
...~
.;;
~
2.8
~.,
']> -0.2
.~
10 pl/l[';f~ .30()(),lpl(a/d)5 I
::5....,
1.5
log(dld,l
]":1
"E 5
~~...
1.6
1.6
2.4
2.8
3.2
3.6
Y., (Y.
in psi)
Fig. 3-Plots of measured versus calculated values of nominal shear strength for 461 available data for beams without stirrups (J psi = 6895 Pa)
ACI Materials Journal I July-August 1987
263
1)
b
(In)
(In)
d
d.
f.
(In) (In) (pol)
A.
(in')
V.
Ob)
Ub)
Al
A2
A3
A.
81
B2
83
U
CI
C2
C3
C4
]1. 5
31. 5
ll.5
31. 5
]1. 5
31. 5
31. 5
31. 5
31. 5
31. 5
31. 5
31. 5
7.
7.
7.
7.
7.
1.
7.
7.
7.
7.
7.
7.
33.
n.
n.
n.
n.
n.
n.
n.
H.
n.
33.
33.
1.35
7.35
1.10
7.35
1.n
1. ) I
1. ) I
1.31
1.40
7.10
1.10
1.10
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
4400
4500
4500
4510
3010
3110
2190
2UO
no
110
1000
980
1.56
1. SI
loU
1.76
1.19
1. 20
1.19
1.24
.fO
.62
.60
.62
13000
1'000
14000
ISOOO
11450
13500
12000
11900
4500
5500
5700
5650
11500
15000
17000
16000
12150
11500
12500
12500
4500
5500
5700
5650
I. (lM31 1"1
I. "
1.19
1.19
1.19
I.n
1.19
I.U
1.19
1.75
1.15
1.75
1.15
.75
.75
.75
.15
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
40fO
4110
4060
U60
SUO
4520
1520
5490
UIO
4110
500
5<90
1. 24
1.24
1. 24
1. 24
1. 24
1.24
1.24
1. 24
I
I
I
I
10lf4
10304
10416
1960
llnl
1l01l
11011
9HI
10416
9072
11200
10304
101&'
10304
10416
19tO
lltl4
Ilon
Ilon
'H4
10416
'012
ll200
10304
72.0
'0.0
126.0
12.2
12.0
12.1
l~
11
22
24
21.4
27.4
,1.1
51. 4
51. 4
51.
6.
6.
6.
6.
6.
6.
6.
18.15
11.35
11.17
.75
.75
.75
3210
)"0
5450
4.
S.
f.
30000
32500
35000
37500
40000
U500
10.
10.
10.
10.
10.
10.
10.
.15
.15
.75
15
.75
.75
.75
2410
6100
2690
3750
2620
2]40
42)0
f2
.62
1.16
.62
1. 21
1.16
1.16
1000
1l'00
11500
1000
1000
9000
11100
1200
12300
12600
7000
1000
'000
11100
6CC
CEC
SEC
6EC
4GC
5GC
6GC
6C
)UC
IUC
5MC
6MC
3AC
4AC
SAC
6AC
OCC
'CC
6CC
'EC
lEC
3MC
4MC
5MC
fMC
)AC
4AC
SAC
'AC
lCC
4CC
~CC
6CC
C
PC.
PCb
OC.
OCb
264
36.
36.
36.
36.
36.
36.
36.
36.
16.
36.
36.
36.
36.
36.
36.
36.
36.
36.
u.
U.
U.
U.
n.
60.
10.
60.
60.
72.
12.
......
12.
84.
36.
36.
36.
16.
36.
U.
U.
n.
n.
60.
60.
60.
72.
12.
16.
36.
16.
36.
U.
n.
CB.
U.
fO.
60.
60.
60.
60.
12.
72.
~O.
60.
ce.
12.
OCb
72.
I.
I.
6.
6.
6.
6.
6.
6.
f.
6.
6.
6.
6.
,.
6.
6.
6.
I.
6.
6.
6.
6.
..
f.
6.
6.
6.
6.
6.
f.
f.
f.
f
6.
f.
6.
6.
6.
I.
6'
6.
6.
6.
6.
6.
6.
6.
6.
6.
f.
6.
6.
6.
f.
6.
6.
I.
6.
8.
6.
6.
6.
f.
10.
10.
d
d.
f.
lin) lin) (pol)
A.
lin')
V.
lib)
ObI
3-polnl~nl
1S.36
15.36
12.36
'.36
12."
12.44
12 . . .
12 . . .
12.56
'.56
12.44
12.44
'.44
9.56
12."
...
9.36
'.36
10.00
10.Of
10.00
9.94
9.91
10.06
10.00
,.,.
'.Ii
,.,.
10.00
9.16
10.00
9."
9.16
9."
10.06
10.00
,.,.
'.16
10.06
10.00
'."
'.16
10.00
9."
9.16
, .94
9.16
10.06
10.00
'.'4
'.16
10.06
10.00
'."
9.86
10.06
10.00
9."
9.16
19.00
'.16
'.If
10.00
10.00
17."
17. , .
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
I.
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
0
030
010
U60
2100
2110
1210
3200
2190
1000
2920
1000
3220
3190
2110
2910
1050
2190
lHO
3020
2390
2660
3310
2970
2910
2950
2910
1010
2130
2110
10'0
1110
3100
2,20
SOlO
4235
4760
4990
4620
4420
41'0
U50
5570
500
5570
5HO
nOD
lUO
1110
2230
1940
1990
1810
2230
1100
1770
2080
2130
1910
2elO
5260
5260
'110
5660
'550
5550
2."
3.11
2.54
2.54
2.00
2.00
2.00
2.00
.60
.fO
1.00
1.00
1.00
1.20
2.00
2.00
2.54
1.11
.19
1. 20
1. 51
2.00
2.54
1.20
1. 58
2.00
2.54
1.58
2.00
2."
1.51
2.00
2.54
2.00
1. 20
1. 5'
2.00
2. ~4
1.20
1. 58
2.00
2. '4
1. 5'
2.00
2.54
2.00
2.5.
1. 20
1.58
2.00
2. '4
1.20
1. 58
2.00
2.54
1. 20
1. 58
2.00
2.54
2.37
2.54
2.54
1. 58
1. 5.
0.00
4.00
22500
22500
15000
12500
13000
13000
12000
12000
1500
6000
9000
11000
1500
'000
12000
'500
10000
14000
7000
'000
1500
1500
12000
1000
9000
10000
10000
9400
1900
9500
8000
150O
noo
11500
12000
12500
12000
13000
11000
11000
11000
12000
11000
12000
11500
'000
'000
'000
'000
10500
10000
1000
8000
9500
1000
6000
1900
7500
1500
19000
12000
12000
10000
11500
HOOO
29000
I~OO
9400
12000
1000
'000
10000
10000
9400
1900
'500
8)00
'100
9100
11500
12500
13000
12800
lJ'OO
12000
12100
12200
13300
11100
12,00
lnOO
12000
11000
'100
9600
11300
14000
1)00
9000
9100
9200
1000
1900
1700
1900
19000
12000
12000
10900
11100
nooo
10000
I.
f.
f.
I.
I.
II. 75
1l.75
1l.75
1l.75
1l.75
1l.75
11. 75
11. 75
11. 75
11. 75
.375
.375
.375
.375
.375
.375
.375
.:75
.375
.375
3273
4277
SUI
un
11112
11766
12123
1<7"
14477
12"1
2.37
1.14
2.37
2. )7
2.37
2. ]7
2. ]7
2.37
2. ]7
2.37
12750
ISOOO
11500
11500
20150
20100
21000
21500
20000
11500
ISOOO
11500
lIfOO
201S0
20100
21000
22500
22000
25000
Bhal, N. s. (1968)
lS.
lS.
lS.
t2M_
12Mb
UNe
f.
f.
6.
,1ae .nd
"9
WI
03
D2
33. f
H.I
,.I.
lJ.6
6.
ft
10.51
10.51
10.51
1.
1.
1.
10.
10.
10.
.75
.75
1.4]
2.If
4.29
5.72
I.U
1. 35
2.1S
2.02
15763
26345
]"76
3""
2)JU
2H12
30113
27557
H. H. (I'~21
U20
'020
.11
.11
.11
1700
9225
11950
lIOO
3600
4400
2. "
2."
2. "
10100
10100
11100
"'0
(1971)
.lS
24700
31300
16500
14400
IUOO
lUOO
16500
13500
10,00
1900
10100
11700
9400
9900
11400
10400
11100
11200
1500
9900
I.
f.
6.
f.
f.
81
35.U 9.45 11.11 1.18 .ose
12
70.17 9.45 23.12 1.11 5177
13
106.30 9.45 35.U 1.11 Cl07
II
141. 70 9.45 47.21 1.11 4409
15
70.17 9.45 23.12 1.11 4UI
70.17 9.45 23.62 1.11 U24
16
17
10t.30 9.45 35.U 1.11 on
II
106.30 ,. IS
3f.02 1.11 4850
o t:on, J. ft., sle , C. r. .nd """'.rk,
Z)
27 ...
Wilhoul .tlrr""
AO-3-3b
42.
AO-3-Jc
42.
AO-7-1a
42.
AO-7-3b
42.
AO-Il-3.
U.
AO-Il-3b
U.
AO-15-3.
U.
U.
AO-15-3b
AO-IS-3e
U.
AO-Il-2 n.375
IInl
10.]0
10. SO
10.55
10.13
10.50
10.55
10. f]
10.19
10.55
10.70
10.75
10.10
..
b
(In)
No.
1)
(l9~.)
Moody, K. G. et 01.
.....
D-l
D-2
D-3
D-4
1>-5
1>-6
1>-7
1>-1
D-'
1>-10
1>-11
D-12
1>-13
D-H
D-15
D-16
1>-11
D-II
1>-19
D-20
-1
E-2
E-3
-4
-5
U-I
A5-2
A5-3
A5-4
A5-5
A5-f
A5-1
-Yo
8-1
1-2
8-3
1-'
1-5
8-f
1-7
I-I
1-9
1-10
8-11
8-12
1-13
I-I<
8-15
1-16
20.
)0.
30.
10.
'0.
60.
......
f.
f.
f.
f.
f.
f.
I'. , Che.ter
9.91
9."
,. '4
,. '4
9."
9."
)050
3120
5320
4060
3HO
40'0
2.
2.
2.
2.
2.
2.
15000
1)000
1000
12000
11500
11100
26100
11000
11000
12000
11500
11450
.15
.75
.15
.15
.75
.75
1500
7330
UfO
6060
7330
1050
5500
U50
2510
4550
3260
lnO
)550
1010
1110
4420
3110
4160
0610
el30
11220
8060
7060
6190
3410
1590
)470
4010
3'00
4260
4590
'~10
5. SO
5.50
5. SO
5.50
~. '0
5. '0
~. SO
5.50
5.50
5.50
5.50
5.50
'.50
5. '0
5. '0
5. SO
5. '0
5. '0
'.50
5.50
5.50
5. '0
5. SO
5. SO
5.50
5.50
L6I
1.U
1.11
2.26
2 ...
5. SO
33000
29500
29000
30000
21500
21500
31'00
25500
20000
21500
2HOO
22500
22300
2.000
23000
25000
21500
23500
26000
2<000
33500
32500
29000
29000
22000
10000
22500
2lS00
21500
23000
25000
H'OO
30000
5120
2420
)HO
2230
4450
22'0
4410
1170
5nO
lHO
5530
2930
SUO
1210
1.2
1.2
1.2
1.2
1.2
1.2
1.2
1.2
1.2
1.2
1.2
1.2
1.2
1.2
1.2
1.2
11500
7500
11500
1500
10500
1500
10000
7000
11500
9500
11000
10500
10000
noo
11500
8000
F. J. (lMz) (")
,.
,,,...
19.5
IL14
. , .5
14.14
19.5
14.14
19.5
14.14
9.
lL14
19.'
19.5
14.l<
U.S
14.14
n.5
H.l<
n.5
14 .11
n.5
14.14
U.S
14.14
n.5
14.14
U.S
14.14
n.5
9.
14.1<
U.S
1<.14
n.5
9.
1<.14
14.14
U.'
19.5
9.
14.14
n.5
14.14
n.5
9.
14.14
fO.O
lLH
60.0
9.
lLH
60.0
9.
14.14
60.0
9.
14.14
60.0
9.
lLI4
n.5
12. 14.14
n.5
9.
lL39
n.5
9.
IL52
19.5
9.
14.47
39.0
lL56
39.0
14.1'
19.5
11.<4
G., et al. (195' )
,.,.,.
,.
,.,.
,.
,.
,.
,.
,.
,.
..
P. (960)
1.
I.
1.
1.
1.
1.
,.,.
,.
36.
36.
36.
36.
36.
36.
36.
36.
16.
36.
16.
36.
36.
36.
36.
36.
6.
6.
6.
6.
6.
6.
6.
6.
6.
f.
6.
6.
f.
6.
f.
10.56
10.56
10.56
10. ~6
10.56
10.56
10.56
10.56
10.56
10.56
10.56
10.56
10.56
10.5f
10. Sf
10.56
.75
.15
.75
.75
.15
.75
.75
.75
.15
.15
.75
.75
.15
.75
.75
.75
.15
.75
.75
.75
.lS
.75
.75
.75
. 15
.75
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
~no
2310
29~00
2'000
32500
29~00
31S00
31500
26500
20000
21500
2'500
2'000
22300
24000
21000
25000
21500
23500
26000
2.000
ll500
32500
29000
29000
22000
41500
22500
21500
21500
23000
27000
14500
13000
8000
111~0
'100
11700
7150
11500
7000
12000
11000
13500
10600
12~00
9700
11500
1500
11-4
1I1-5
III-6
Iv-7
IV-8
v_,
v-10
Vl-ll
vl-12
V 13
24.
2L
2L
24.
24.
24.
2L
24.
2424.
24.
24
24 .
I.
I.
I.
I.
I.
I.
I.
I.
I.
..
...
1S.1.6
15.16
15.16
IS .16
15.86
15.16
IS .16
15.86
15.16
15.16
15.16
15.86
15.86
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
3680
lHO
3170
38)0
3130
3110
3500
lUO
n50
3UO
1610
3720
1250
3.86
1.86
2. J!
2.19
2.35
2.35
2.36
2.36
1.41
1.41
1.41
1. 48
.95'
27500
21500
22500
25000
70350
69850
:'.':'0
2~000
2~000
"ISO
65HO
25000
21500
22500
24QOO
20000
22500
17500
68HO
50lS0
60150
50350
60350
50000
10]~0
6~375
.....
No.
2)
(In'
eI
eI.
".
"
fln')
y'
y,
(lb'
Ob)
V_I.
YI-15
YI-16
2"
24.
2"
10.
50.
'0.
10.
45.
45.
45.
10.
10.
lIh-17
111.-11
ve-l'
v.-20
YI1>-21
VI1>-22
Ylb-23
Ylb-24
Ylb-2S
'f.yloc, k.
-.
II.
30.
42.
...
32.
2 ..
21.6
II. e
16.
I.
32.76
2"57
22.11
A7
AI
A9
AID
All
AI2
BI
12
13
II."
11.31
1.19
31.76
23.12
21."
11.26
n."
.5
11
32.76
24.57
22.11
.1
"III
BlO
II.'.
11.31
Bl2
CI
C2
C3
ce
C1
CI
C,
CIO
Cll
CI2
1.19
29.00
21.75
U.SI
16.61
32.U
2""
21.95
11.70
16.2
1.13
'.n1, c.
47
52
5]
5e
55
5'
57
51
S9
'0
11
13
IC
91
n
"
95
"n
97
"
""
100
61
65
"51
"7172
,e
75
"79].41
30U
]~O
lOU
]045
]046
3041
271
272
273
274
".ni,
1.
I.
1.
I.
I.
1.
1.
1.
I.
1.
1.
1.
IS."
U."
u.n
IS. "
U.II
I~. "
3.,0
3700
3110
.240
3no
3410
3110
3790
3740
"]0
3120
.ue
.951
.951
].2]
3.23
1.11
1.11
1.07
1.07
1.07
.594
3740
.~,.
II.
II.
II.
II.
6.
11.
.75
.15
.15
.7S
.75
2572
2721
2704
2,.0
2592
1. 32
1.32
1. 32
1. 32
1. 32
."
...
U.II
lS.n
u.n
u.n
u.n
lS.n
I.
I.
6.
,.
54.
Al
A2
A]
Ae
AS
eo
41
H
n
I.
I.
I.
I.
I.
I.
I.
I.
I.
I.
I.
I.
N.
~.
5.
S.
5.
5.
5.
S.
5.
5.
S.
S.
5.
5.
5.
5.
S.
S
5.
5.
S.
5.
S.
5.
5.
S.
S.
S.
S.
S.
5.
5.
S.
5.
5.
II""
s.n
2t.42
13.31
32.00
10.70
10.70
2'.70
2'.70
21. eo
5.3e
5.3e
16.00
11.73
ZI.H
11.73
14.61
6.00
5.91
S.95
5. '5
S.95
5.95
'.00
S.'5
S.'S
S.U
'.03
'.03
6.00
6.0'
6.10
6.0e
'.14
5.'5
'.01
'.10
6.03
16.02
6 .. 01
32.0.
H.72
64.01
n.H
21.3'
2'.70 '.04
H.72 1.0]
32.10 '.00
21.75 ,.0]
26.75 '.00
21.00 1.03
H.72 6.16
IS." '.01
170."
S3.S0 5."
121.16 '.U
21.36
21. 3' '.11
&4.01 6.10
H.'O 6.00
&4 .20 '.00
64.20 6.00
53.50 '.00
149.'0 6.03
16.40 '.00
107.75 6.06
129.00 , .05
, .0
In.'
6.1
215.0
331.e
'.1
]73. I
'.1
64.2 24.06
5].5 24.05
42 2 .. 1
32.1 2( .1
'.15
,.U
I.
I.
I.
..
I.
I.
I.n
I.n
1.19
1.19
1.19
1.19
7."
7.,.
7.,.
7.,.
7.,.
1.19
I.n
1.19
1.19
1.19
1.19
7.25
7.25
7.25
7.2S
1.13
1.13
1.13
1.13
I.U
1.13
S.50
5.U
5.00
5.23
S.3S
5.20
S.2S
S.U
5.20
5.35
5.30
5.U
S.U
5.U
5.50
S.U
10.10
10.n
10.17
10.51
10."
10.76
10.13
10.13
10."
10.11
10.70
10.'2
21.32
21.37
21. 21
21.75
21.31
20.10
21.35
21. e2
21.12
20.60
20.n
20.31
21.90
43.20
43.10
n.oo
H.20
0.00
0.20
0.10
10.51
10.56
10.6.
10.64
20000
20000
20000
17500
Ino.
12000
Inoo
12500
12000
13500
10500
9000
UOOO
19100
IIUO
IU25
14115
U050
14025
""5
12250
11225
1232.
1001.
10521
noo
.,10
26]20
1232.
10521
"52
.,1
~0350
003~0
.5
.5
.5
.5
.5
.5
.5
.5
.5
.5
.5
.5
.5
.5
.5
.5
5
.5
.5
.5
.5
.5
.5
.5
.5
.!
.5
.5
.S
.5
5
5
5
.75
.75
.75
.7S
.7S
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
9590
959p
U90
9590
9StO
9590
9590
9stO
9590
U90
9590
95".
10560
10560
10560
IOS60
IOSlO
10560
10SIO
10510
105'0
10560
10550
10140
10140
10140
10140
lOUD
10140
10140
10140
10140
lOHO .
3no
3950
e060
3700
3700
3UO
3UO
3600
3110
3170
3UO
3950
3130
3950
3160
, . .0
3"0
3910
3"0
3910
e390
3510
3no
3170
"SO
JlOO
]100
]950
3110
]800
3730
]910
3130
4400
3970
3970
3500
3950
3,.0
"'0
3790
3900
3130
3910
nlo
ClOO
3"0
3170
)910
3910
"eo
".0
1. 5'
1. 51
1.51
1.51
1. 51
1.51
.71
.71
.71
.71
.71
.71
2.
2.
2.
2.
2.
.9
.9
.9
.9
.9
.9
2. e
2. e
2. e
2.0
1. 32
1.32
1.32
1.32
1.32
1.32
(J 91.,
13000
14000
14000
14300
17000
34500
1500
9500
11000
11000
12000
30000
11505
'12750
14000
14000
17500
10000
10500'
10501
12500
14000
25000
12000
11000
9000
12500
1000
10000
10000
U50
It 500
20000
...
.15
.11
4'"
13000
ISSOO
15500
21000
31500
90000
10500
11000
11000
11500
12500
50000
11510
U500
2UOO
32200
2eooo
10030
10500
11000
14400
27500
. . 000
12200
17000
15500
20000
10200
10000
10200
12100
20000
noon
6."
6."
7195
11565
1790
IH20
15520
"35
10'5
'495
34900
35450
7325
1295
7095
6500
11275
1135
11500
14600
12450
lIe55
120'5
2"50
U3S0
uno
140S0
17UO
17350
2SUO
31700
20950
17750
2S250
zoeoo
123UO
131600
22950
"250
2noo
24250
nlOo
11100
73300
Sl250
]7100
]5750
]C250
3U50
33050
"120
51200
U330
56225
.])0
.321
11900
7]00
.11
.11
.11
......
......
...
.11
.11
.11
.17
.11
1.10
1. 10
1.10
I. ,.
1.74
1.10
1.10
1.10
1. 75
1.75
1.75
1.76
3.35
].10
3.'0
3.61
3.'0
3.se
]
...
3."
].51
].51
].51
3.51
].59
7.06
7.06
7.06
7.0'
, .08
7.12
7.06
6."
,."
C. N. J. II.UI
16.02
26.50
,.oe
'.03
10.10
10.69
.....
No.
2)
(1960)
1-11
1-30
I-U
1-"
I-54
265
2"
(In'
.75 . 2630
.75 2120
251
2n
2"
270
241
HI
2.,
no
251
174
171
179
110
141
142
b
(In'
eI
(In'
"
".
lIn')
y'
v,
(lb'
Ubll
1.04
10. '0
10 e
10.77
10.74
10.10
11.10
10.15
10.77
10.11
10.70
10.10
10.00
10.10
10.53
10."
14]
10. '0
147
11. II
~.
HI
10
I.,
6.01
I n
UO
'.oe 10.75
UI
1.06 10.7]
152
5." 10.6]
15]
'.00 10.7]
102
I.oe
10.5'
10]
'.11 10.71
loe
'.05 10.10
lOS
n.75 6.00 10.70
26.70 6.05 10.5e
10'
107
5].00 '.01 10.51
109
11.02 1.0] 10.67
III
ZO.70 6.06 10.71
112
21.70 1.02 10.75
11]
16.05 '.00 10.71
lie
21.oe '.0] 10.'2
.........115
26.75 1.00 10.19
116
32010 6.00 lo.n
21. 36 6.0e 10.71
152
21.36 1.0' 10.St
162
16]
26.70 I.U 10.7]
U]
26.70 5.91 10.70
1&4
42.72
10.61
32.10 5.91 10.n
I"
32.10 1.05 10.10
I"
32.10 6.00 10.72
121
e2.10 5.9. 10. IS
122
12]
42.72 '.12 10.n
ue
S].40 '.01 10.61
126
32.0e 6.12 10.72
In
16.02 '.09 10.11
130
51.7C
10.15
131
26.75 5.95 10.79
132
26.75 6.05 10.66
5].50 1.06 10.7&
133
ue
21.40 '.0' 10.75
us
21.40 5." 10.79
24
16.02 '.00 10.61
21.36 '.00 10.n
25
21. 3' '.00 10.n
2'
27
26.70 '.00 10.n
26.70 '.00 10.n
21
29
".06 6.00 lo.n
30
" . 0 ' '.00 10.n
37.50
10.61
35
37.50 6.02 10.75
3'
21.36 '.06 10.19
III
5].00
112
10.51
16.02 '.05 10.67
IIC
H.72 6.09 10.70
116
III
21.36 ,.oe 10.90
32.10 6.05 10.13
191
19]
26.70 ,. De
10.fl
I,.
32.0e '.06 10.93
42.72 '.0] 10."
US
26.75 S. '2 10.77
197
71. eo 00 10.75
199
L.eonh.rdt., et 01.119621( 0 )
1.0]
1.05
1.00
1.0]
1.03
1.00
1.00
6.01
1.01
1.04
6.03
, .00
5.90
'.U
1.05
6.0.
,.
'.15
'.04
'.ll
,..,
DI/I
DI/2
D2/1
D2/2
DJ/I
DJ/2
DC/I
DC/2
Cl
C2
C3
ce
eI,
'.21
1.21
16.se
16.se
24.10
24.10
3].07
3].07
17.72
35.43
53.15
70.17
1.91
1.91
3."
].,.
5.91
5.91
7.17
7.17
,.,.
S.U
7."
I."
2.76
2.76
5.51
5.51
1.27
'.27
11.02
11.02
5.'1
11.11
17.72
23."
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.15
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.15
.15
.75
.75
.75
.15
.75
.n
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.59
.S9
3000
2910
2520
2910
0000
cooo
001.
0010
JlOO
5210
5000
4190
5000
2100
21
UI.
2. . .
2. . .
2UO
2610
2100
2nO
2nO
3610
4210
3610
JlOO
4110
3150
3UO
3920
3920
3700
3100
JlOO
]"0
0"0
e,.o
5130
5130
.,00
5130
5130
2950
2110
22]0
2230
2360
2550
2UO
2UO
2610
2110
2530
2530
.OCO
3UO
39]0
4320
4230
35'0
3no
3710
3710
Ouo
4920
5090
S090
. . 00
ono
S020
5020
5020
S220
5220
usa
&lSI
.59
UI6
.S9
""
.59
S9
.59
.59
1.11
1.11
1.11
1.11
6600
"00
6045
6005
""
""
""
""
]]0
]21
]2\
.321
.HO
.HO
.321
]21
.311
.]30
.]30
.)]0
.]30
.511
.51l
.0"
.475
SOl
.500
.500
.505
.,c
.en
.e.,
e"
..,
.e"
.e"
.en
.ell
..,1
.e91
.500
.512
. .,e
.e91
e,.
.e.,
.e,.
.e"
.476
.0"
.e"
1.19
1.11
1.17
1.11
1.17
1.17
1.11
1.19
1.17
1.11
1.11
1.11
1.20
1. 20
1.20
1. 20
1.20
1. 20
1.20
1.11
1.11
1.16
1.16
1.16
1.16
1.16
1.11
1.19
1.19
1.19
1.11
1.11
.093
.on
.3'0
360
.791
.791
I.ue
l.ue
.30'
.925
1.151
2.17
...
5500
IllS
2000.
tlOO
5700
1350
11100
12300
9UO
IUOO
13250
7550
SiOO
lOUD
IllOO
"95
nos
1795
9115
10llO
'005
7]00
1]75
10910
lao
1560
tl35
100)0
5765
lIUO
9135
. . SO
19500
11100
10115
'''0
13250
I3no
9100
IHO
1050
9050
liDO
11000
"25
1500
7200
"00
32200
tooo
11140
lIno
1"0
13no
17250
e0900
2lCOO,
17550
IlSS0
12200
9nO
loeoo
10100
11100
I4no
10960
,noo
12e50
20100
llUO
12750
11500
10125
12000
17250
1631
1609
e"2
S225
loni
""
16645
16021
e150
14550
22117
3U71
5-1
5-2
-]
s-e
1-5
1-'
.-1
s-'
5-12
5-13
...............
......
00.
eo.
H.
t.ylor, Hov.rd p.
Al
A2
II
12
.3
CI
C2
Cl
C,
6.06
6.0'
6.00
'.00
6.00
5.,.
'.00
5.,.
'.03
5."
~.
10.11
10 ...
10.50
10.S'
10.31
10.5]
10.56
10.30
10.51
10.0
.5
.5
.5
.5
.5
.5
.5
.5
5]00
..00
C200
.5
. . 00
e050
4500
e150
36eo
000
.5
)4140
36.61 1. 50
5210
4120
ono
e500
5110
... 0
.62
.51
eo
.33
.22
..16
]]
.16
1.01
'000
ICOO
6"0
6300
7550
6150
6150
5500
55]0
9000
(1912) (*)
110.20 15.75
110.20 15.75
S5.12 7 7
55.12 7.11
55.12 7.17
21.56
27.56 3."
27.S' 3."
27.56 ].
].,.
,.
36.U
11.31
11.31
11.31
, .15
9.15
9.15
, .15
.75
1. 50
.75
.315
.75
.]75
.]75
.]75
.,,0
.,10
3770
7.71
7.7.
1. 95
1. 95
1.95
,17
,17
'17
.17
10100
73900
2leOO
19600
19200
5060
5390
6110
506.
265
No.
(In)
(In)
A.
(In)
(In)
(p.1)
(in')
v
UbI
UbI
2)
C:~
.1.~6
C:6
27 .
Dl
D2
D3
DO
16.~'
3.,.
3. ,.
2.35
2. l6
2.35
2. ]6
~6
16 . ~.
16.~'
~!.
ll.
Chana, P. I. (1981)
2.10
2.lb
42.05
<2.0S
'2.0S
42.05
<2.05
42.05
20.tI
20.tI
20.91
20.91
ZO.t!
20.t!
20.91
20.t!
20.tI
12.U
12.52
12.52
12.52
12.52
12.52
12.52
12.52
20.01
20.01
20.01
20.0'
2.2.
2.2b
2. , .
2.3b
3.le
3.lb
3. z.
3.2b
l.la
3.3b
DI
D2
D3
4."
"lb
C.Z.
.. 2b
4.Ja
"3b
....
. 'b
S .le
S.lb
S.2.
S.2b
6.1
6.2
6.3
..
.
..
..
,. ,
010
~.U
.10
.10
.10
.10
5220
5100
5100
5100
5100
.3,.
.n.
3."
3."
2.31
6."
4.17
2.36
17
.. 17
4.17 .n7
4.17
4.17
<.17 .It,
.. 17 . It,
6.n .no
"12
"12
U.2
'571
7571
'571
7S71
.3,.
SI.S
SIH
.1'7
5751
S751
SU2
5511
Sill
n02
6102
UI2
nSI
3."
3." 6. t7 .n.
.3"
,,<
3."
I."
3. ,.
6.97 .3,.
.no
2. H
2.36
2.3'
2. ] I
2.36
2. Jl
.n7
.1"
. n,
.1"
.n,
,..,
I.n
I.n
I.n
7 .,
7.17
.717
I.IS
LIS
LIS
1.1S .0,.
LIS
1. IS .094
I.IS
I.IS
1.1S
.US
.US
.US
,2S
.US
.U5
.U5
.125
.U5
4.t'
HSO
7150
103<
1034
USI
ISU
500<
500<
53"
5337
Sill
5116
0513
I."
."0
6."
3,.
I." .".
.3,.
I."
I."
3. ,.
3. ,.
<.n
, . IS
14.02 .,.7
14.02 '17
14.02
14.02
14.02 .717
14.02 .717
3."
.. n
6.6
6.7
6. I
4060
S.U
S"
.. ,'" 7."
... ""
... ""
6.'
6.
.315
. .,
.0,.
.0,.
.0,.
.0,.
.0,.
.0,.
.0,.
14." 7.17
n
.13
".51 7.17 U.S 13
U.O< 7 . , 2I.3S .13
Mhrar H., NIl..on, Ar~hur
El&.n~y,
r'rll
,.
,.
,.
<2.0
42.'
42.0
rl2
7.
02.'
42.1
rl
rl3
FH
PI
F2
riO
7.
7.
'2.0
ca.'
42.0
r,
42.0
rl5
42.0
21.'
21.0
7.
7.
7.
7.
7.
7.
7.
7
7.
42
P3
r.
rs
... 2
63.0
PI
10.~
10.7
10. S
3. S.
4.72
7.0'
n.lS
21.22
]7.29
~
.S
S
.5
S
.S
S
.S
.S
S
.S
S
S
.S
10.7
10.7
10.S
10.7
10.7
10.S
10.7
10. S
10.S
10.1
10. S
10. ,
."
5060
'110
2UO
2720
2310
.122
.1%2
.122
.122
25!0
21512
21129
I."
I..,
I..,
1.19
I."
1."
U'"
21222
223"
21172
5350
5n3
SSOI
57J3
5'5'
5216
.
."
47,
.."
."
.." ...'9"
.47,
.,,,
.<"
."9
'.'3
UI2
5261
4111
2201
U45
2017
2113
2630
2116
2163
23S<
.11'
.1"
.119
.1"
.119
.119
.119
.1"
.,,,
.,,,
,.,
.,.021
..
.026
.026
.026
.026
.026
.021
61"
3000
3000
]000
5100
5100
noo
'SOo
noD
noo
I1S00
11500
10000
10000
uoo
.5 noD
r.
.,0
10000
12000
10300
10'00
14300
ll100
14100
17300
14100
.n
.to
1.'0
.to
1.10
2. '0
1.20
1.10
nooo
.'0
iliaD
1.'0
U'OO
.to
'"00
1. 10
u'OO
32.
10.61
192.2"
61
ve
5."
1.01
6.17
4." .5'
7." .5'
lo.n .59
3UI
lUI
3502
.n
.'12
I.U
3215
6768
12302
S 0
. 'S
10.47
21. 21
.7S
.75
40'0
4560
39.0
0.11
67'0
1.77
lanD
3.53
1700
(-:1
21.
ll.S
S.
20.25
10.13
, .15
10.13
6.
H2N3/2
~.06
3.
HIN31Z
HIN)A
3.37
20.25
20.25
20.25
10.ll
10.ll
10.13
6.75
"lH4
H2N4
K3M ..
HIH3
H2H3
H3HI
HIH]12
HIHlI
K1N3!)
K2N3A
H2Nli
H2NlC
H3N]t
H)N3e
I.
l.
2.
I.
3.
2.
2.
6.
,.
6.
3.
3.
I.
2.
2.
,. 7~
With sUrruDS.
5. 7~
.75
3.3' 37~
2. 2~
.2S
6.15 .75
3.37 .37~
2.2S .25
6.75 .75
3.37 .375
2.2S .25
6.75 .15
6.75 .375
6.7S
I.S
3.37 .75
3.37 .375
3.17 .25
2.25 .J7S
2.25
.2!o
...
5100
1.76
5000
60S0
1040
1200
.20
1.76
USO
5100
SIOO
6250
S750
5700
45'0
'SSO
6220
5700
6700
SSOO
14170
3,"0
1750
.
...
uno
.20
1.76
50'0
25'0
41000
10320
.20
1.76
1.76
17670
11 .. 0
1. '6
1'.00
6270
...
S'SO
0
'0
SOia
.'77
3020
1130
.20
.20
3-DO~nt ... ~t
72.
266
12.
U.
U-3
311-1
321-1
311-2
321-2
313.S-3
lII-3
321-]
72.
..
U.
U.
72.
72.
72.
72.
U.
10.
10.
10.
10.
10.
10.
10.
10.
10.
10.
10.
10.
10.
10.
10.
10.
10.
10.
10.
10. 17."
d
lin)
S120
Co
.16<
"500
.,son
fc
lpol)
33. I
I .
]].6
I.
I.
I .
I.
n."
17."
US
RI6
R21
n.o
SO.5
36.0
31.0
36.0
17."
17."
17.,.
17.'4
17."
17."
17.'4
I.
6.
I.
I.
6.
I.
I.
6.
6.
,7.
A-I
A-2
A-3
72.'12.1
'0.
12.
121. 12.1
72. 9.1
1-1
121.
t.
72.
1.1
6.
1.1
II.JS
11.27
11.35
11.15
11.33
11.13
11.25
11.21
11.01
.
.
1S.36
n.36
1S.36
U.36
to.
a-2
a-3
C:-I
C:-2
C-3
'0.
121.
36.
36.
"1-1
AI-2
AI-3
"1-4-
31.
36.
t.
).
17.,.
17."
12.0
12.'
12.4
RI4
5"0
S140
SltO
1000
3500
..10
'030
2210
5360
5450
I.
I.
I.
I.
I.
I.
11."
17.,.
I.
6.
SUo
I.
I.
17."
17.,.
17."
17 .'4
C:30S-DO J7 2 S. 91
C:310-DO
2 5. U
c:nO-D2D 37.2 S.t!
33.1
]].1
36.0
36.0
33.'
36.0
36.0
33.6
33.6
33. I
33.1
36.0
I.
I.
1.
17.'.
6
I.
I.
RIO
UI
U2
U3
5)
d.
(In)
17."
10.
10.
10.
10.
10.
10.
10.
10.
10.
10.
10.
10.
10.
10.
10.
10.
10.
10.
10.
R'
A
(In')
IJ."
(~)
V.
lib)
f ..
Ipol)
).
"'0
SliD
1.
5620
I.
s o
1.
SS10
).
).
1.
75
.7S
.15
.7S
7~
.n
.n
.n
.75
.15
.n
.n
.7S
'5
.15
.7S
.n
.75
.75
..
Ino
62<0
1200
l170
4.
.111
o 111
07\1
. . . 111
o 111
< 111
4. .111
< 111
. 111
074
4. .O~~
4. .111
. . . 122
4. .IO~
O. .122
. . . 105
4. .163
4. .122
4. .IOS
.1"
Uto .n6
.ns
SIS
3100 1.17
'UO 2. S
""0 2.5
UIO .nl
030 2.5
4!JIO
2.5
1150
.'CO .171
43tO . .,1
1230 .nl
2.5
UIO .176
CCIO
2.5
2. S
1910 2. S
0510 2. S
.1"
""0
"'0
.21
.41
.21
.21
.21
.41
.14
.41
.41
.21
.21
.41
.21
.41
.21
.21
n,oO
HOOO
3HOO
"'00
'HOO
3UOO
3HOO
HOOD
00
~.OOO
lnOO
3UOO
3noo
'0000
~'OOO
.noo
.,~oo
U~OO
U~OO
~'OOO
~'OOO
~'OOO
~.OOO
~'OOO
HOOD
~'OOO
36100
"100
HOOD
37~OO
~'OOO
41000
3UOO
UIOO
1"00
23S00
"'00
20100
2"00
))600
20100
31400
31<00
15'00
~'OOO
~<OOO
504000
504000
3USO
40600
HUO
)tUO
39UO
.0100
)tUO
CO'OO
CO'OO
3USO
)tUO
40100
)tUO
.41
.13
19000
2"00
20200
33600
1"00
20700
2HOO
21300
<0300
J9UO
)tUO
)tUO
.0100
ltUO
.21
<DiaD
.1
un
2UIO
2'''0
31120
51400
51400
SI'OO
.n
n
3490
3S20
SOlO
U90
snoo
S.
.1 HOOD
I.
.1 . USOO
. . . 1e7 50000
nooo
4 1.'
cOOOO
S 141
2 . 1" novo
4. .202 lHOO
4. .19' 3UOO
47200
47200
41200
<7200
"'200
47200
47Z00
47200
47200
.31
.31
]'
.31
50016
47016
50016
5S016
41020
41020
41020
41020
.:.000
.75
.75
.75
'liD
.75
.15
.7S
.75
5620
U90
lno
SOlO
3S75
3430
3)tS
3510
4.
3.11
1.11
3.11
l.11
.1
&-I-t
a-2-II
a-I-I
a-3-II
I-i-I
I-i-II
T-I-I
T-2-II
T-3-I
T-3-II
36.
36.
J6.
36.
36.
36.
36.
36
36.
12.
12.
12.
12.
12.
12.
12.
12.
C:205-DIO
C205-D20
C:210-DOA
C:2l0-10
.75
31'0
l~I;t
.auC
22500
12.
12.
12.
12.
12.
12.
.7S
.75
.1S
.7S
]UIl 1.11
31'01.19
31901.n
3190 1.11
3190 1.11
3190 1. 25
3190 1.17
3UO 1.13
n901.1]
.100
~ J oc
.100
.104
.104
.10'
.100
.100
.104
22515
UIO
"10
"SO
4170
.233
.2]]
. ",
"
12.
1;'.
nn.~h C. (193"
12.
12.
12.
12.
Z4.1 5.91
24.1 5.'1
2 . . . S."
24. IS. tI
12
12.0
12.4
12.4
.tr.ft09~
.*)
.1
(In)
(~)
lanl, C. N. J. (1'67) (~
U
II
72.
72.
72:
72.
72.
72.
72.
72.
022
RaO
025
02'
021
7600
1.10
:~1~~.-2
14r:.
211.-2
02
no.
15112
22n6
O. (1916)
.45
2'.-2
RII
RU
020
no
.t..
"7' .321
"5'
5041 1.77
H. end .l.t._,
2'.-2
29b-2
2'c-2
2td-2
107"
12l'.
125.,
411
611
531
500
5n
.021
211.~-~
U,
517
b
(In)
2'.-1
2'.-2
lOlUi
472
.026
&s27
"'&l n, J. C. tl"tla) ( .. )
Al
U
A3
No.
.)
'.ts
~
....
.7~
.75
.n
.75
.75
...
.1
.1
loti
1.52
1. tI
1. tI
2'COO
26425
23000
22750
21075
22150
211?0
221S0
30no
2nn
39190
"090
nooo
nooo
'SOOO
nooo
'5000
nooo
'SOOO
nooo
nooo
S1400
51400
SIIOO
51400
04
C5
01
42.
7.
7.
7.
10. S
10. S
10.5
.S
.5
.S
JJSOO
2S000
17500
55000
SSOOO
SSOOO
.SO
.50
41001
41006
31130
3920 I. 01 .211
4920 1.0 211
'3401.01 .221
13510
SOOOO
13~00
~OOOO
ISOOO
HOOO
3460
".
4.
3795
4700
3475
3455
3115
H20
H15
4 ]31
4. .331
4.
.21
51)00
67550
60475
SSOOO
SSOOO
55000
55000
9100 2.'0
5100 1. 10
3000 1.10
.n
.n
.19
I-I
. . . S.U 10.45
5-10
$-\1
CC.
6.
10 . 0
5
.S
.5
5'05 1.96
S0071.96
]712)
Moretto, Or te 0'''5)
J_V I/C
2-V 1/0
I-I
2-1
I-D
2-D
I_V
1/0
1/0
1/0
1/'
3/1
2-Y 3/1
I-I 3/1
l2.
32.
32.
32.
32.
32.
32.
l2.
32.
5.5
5.S
5.5
5.5
S.5
5.5
5.S
S.S
S.5
11.25
11.25
11.25
11.25
11.25
11.25
11.25
11.25
11.25
.n
.75
.75
.75
.75
.75
.7S
n
nos
28
28
. .2'
. . . US
4. .IlS
4. .143
66000
S,27S
70275
nus
71125
79S00
S~OOO
5S000
47900
47'00
47'00
Beam
"0.
(In)
slin-ups.
With
S)
2-1 )/9
1-0 )/8
2-0 )/8
la-V l/e
la_V 3/8
32.
32.
32.
32.
32.
D2-1
02-2
0)-1
OC-I
01-6
01-7
01-8
EI-2
02-6
D2-7
02-1
D4-1
D4-2
0'-)
O~-I
0~-2
O~-)
24.
24.
24 .
21.
24.
21.
24.
21.
24.
2 ..
24.
21.
2C.
2C.
18.
18.
lB.
lB.
18.
18.
21.
2C.
24.
2~
)0.
JO.
)0.
)0.
30.
)0.
)0.
)0.
)0.
d.
I,
(In)
(pel)
~. ~
18 . 2S
11.25
5. ~ 19.25
5. ~
I'. ~
5.5
I'. ~
~. ~
7~
.75
.75
.15
.75
4185
2855
)685
H'O
))H
P.
A.
( lnl,
..,.
2.
2.
(%)
v.
I ...
8e&ftl
Ob)
(pel)
No.
6)
.74)
.615
.61~
.28
615
14000
U8'S
71825
~)O~O
~'615
4'900
"'00
"'00
<6000
52000
(l'~ll
8.
8.
8.
8.
8.
8.
8.
8.
8.
8.
8.
I.
I.
I.
I.
I.
I.
8.
I.
8.
8.
I.
8.
8.
8.
I.
B.
I.
I.
6.
6.
6.
6.
6.
6.
6.
6.
6.
6.
6.
6.
6.
1S.)6
3398 ). II
.J?
62685
15.36
J5. )6
IS. )6
3680 ). II
)7
305 3. II
.31
.31
3380 3.81
3~10 3. II
)7
))10 ). II
.7)
.7)
3820 ).8l
.7)
361~ ). II
.31
6110 ).81
3120 2. ~,
.J<
.34
3820 2.H
.J<
3"~ 2. ~C
.3<
'210 2. ~,
)4)0 2 . 54
.69
362~ 2. ~4
"10 2. ~C
20CO 2. ~<
.34
2000 2.5<
.34
2020 2. ~,
.J<
3~~0 ).81
.34
.34
'~60 ).81
6480 ).81
.34
6900 ).81
.34
J800
2
lS60
)410
2.
.61
3755
.61
2.
.92
C090
J.
J)~O
2. I. 22
COlO 2.54
'060 2. ~,
4010 2. ~C
.7)
075 2. ~,
.61
.280 2.54
.61
H2O 2.54
)790 2.54
.61
3970 2.54
)720 2. ~4
3200 2. ~C
.)7
<020 2.54
.)7
4210 2. SC
.)7
3930 2.S'
5168~
I~.
)6
I~.
36
I~.
)6
I~.
36
I~. )6
B.36
I~. 36
I~. )6
I~.
36
I~. 36
I~. 36
I~. 36
I~. 36
I~. 36
15.36
...,.,
1~.36
I~.
36
15.36
I~. 36
IS. )7
I~. )7
15. )7
1~.
......
......"
..
I~. )7
)7
)7
15.
12. J6
12.36
12. J6
12. J6
12. )6
12. J6
12. )6
12.36
12.36
12.36
12. J6
12.36
12.36
"
.n
..,
'40l0
60280
5<280
"68~
720~
1~280
8~280
62CH
6,,)5
~~280
64280
6~19~
61615
'.'80
50210
'~O)O
42280
"5)0
9~210
91780
")~,
61"~
5168~
65115
70185
88781
701l~
39281
C0211
C1181
"8~'
371~'
)~JS9
37.~'
37859
)s3~'
)710'
32.~'
)~3~9
JS)5'
41020
4.020
48020
41020
41020
48020
4'020
41020
41020
'8020
48020
4'020
48020
4.020
41020
.a020
48020
4.020
48020
48020
4'020
48020
41020
48020
4'020
4a020
4.020
48020
.'020
48020
4.020
0418020
48020
.'020
41020
41020
48020
48020
'8020
Cl020
.a020
41020
( *)
6)
)0.
)0.
)0.
30.
)0.
)0.
)0.
30.
)0.
( In)
4-poinl-b~nt
Clark, Authur P.
8J-I
81-2
81-)
81-'
81-5
82-1
82-2
82-)
86-1
CI-I
CI-2
CI-)
CI-'
C2-1
C2-2
C2-4
CJ-I
C)-2
C)-)
C4-1
C5-2
C6-J
C6-C
01-1
01-)
( In)
'.lakas,
.75
BOO
6 ..
6161.
6J.
61.
61.
61.
82~
61.
AOO
A2~
A2Sa
A~O
ASOa
7.
7.
15.54
15. )1
15.26
15.42
I~. "
15. ~6
7.~
1.~
15.52
7.5
7. ~
1. ~
7.5
1~.70
.75
.7.0
.765
O.
16244
7~
7~
4720 .16~
'90 .76~
3110 . 76~
C060 .76~
"70 .76~
4640 ~7~
4410 ~75
0~2
0~2
.10C
.IOC
1~1
O.
0~2
20772
25954
24660
31966
16027
17670
.n
7~
.75
1~
7~
1927~
61000
61000
71400
12~00
(In)
(In)
d.
I,
( In)
(psi)
v.
p.
A.
(In ' ,
('!'o)
Ob)
(psi)
oSo
COO
C2~
U.
61.
61.
C50
H.
C7~
61.
1. S I~.H
7.5 B.41
7.5 I~. ))
7.5 15. "
7.5 I~. ~1
.n
.n
.n
.75
',1S
~ 390
.. 270
41100
.. 100
.. 260
575
.}O ..
O.
1. 0'
1.09 . 0~2
I. 0' .104
1. 09 . I ~1
HOSD
13270
1 )600
186~0
62100
7 )600
65100
)01 ~O
)1020
T26
T21
T)1
T32
T34
TH
T36
TJ7
T31
)).6
)J.6
)).6
)).6
)J.6
)6.0
) .. 6
)6 .0
)6.0
)). 6
36.0
)6.0
n.6
)6 .0
12 . 0
72.0
72.0
)).6
~4. 0
~LO
)).6
)J.6
36.0
)6.0
)).6
36.0
54-0
~
..
36.
36.
36.
6.
6.
6.
6.
6.
6.
6.
6.
6.
6.
6.
6.
6.
6.
5.
5.
6.
5.
6.
6.
6.
6.
6.
6.
6
6.
6.
6.
6.
6.
6.
10.
10.
10.
10.
10.
10.
10 ...
10.
10.
10.
10.
10.
10.
10.
10.
10.
10.
10.
10.
10.
10.
10.
10.
10.
10.
10.
10.
10.
10.
10.
10.
.75
75
75
.75
.n
.75
.n
.n
7~
.n
7~
7~
.n
.n
.75
7~
.75
.75
7~
.75
.75
.75
.75
.7~
7~
7~
.75
7~
7~
.75
7~
.75
4070 .816
)"0
.. 710 1.11
4.90 .876
J< 70 2.5
3970
1.1
C~)O
2. ~
29)0
2. ~
4090 . 876
2. ~
~360
2. ~
'HO
1150 .176
0
2. ~
4810
2. ~
4HO
2. ~
2. ~
" 790
"9aO .875
.. J40
2. ~
~~
2. ~
.,10 116
7,.0 . '76
1260
2. ~
1140
2. ~
, "5 .876
2. ~
'000
.920
2.5
2. ~
4880
)~OO
2. ~
461~
2. ~
2.5
4380
.21
O.
.21
.21
.41
.8J
.21
.21
.41
4050
. "6
...
...
.11
.21
.21
.)
.21
.11
.
..
..
o.
B~nt )
24700
391 SO
12)00
2HOO
24'00
31400
)9150
HI50
40600
J9I
~O
46000
2UDO
HI~C
28000
HI~O
)4100
C0600
HnO
'0600
)9~00
J6000
)2500
20200
,,)00
2HOO
20100
)0100
16800
J9I~O
HI~O
HI ~O
J'150
HI50
40600
.21
2~~00
21
.21
2~800
.21
I)
CO)OO
29700
21300
48600
)9150
<0600
40600
HI ~O
HI ~O
.21
34500
24600
H150
'0600
HI~O
2~200
HI~O
.21
2~100
.4\
40)00
.. 7100
53800
HI ~O
C0600
HI ~O
I)
.8)
HI~O
0.71)
Al
A2
AJ
A4
A~
0) ,
CI
C2
C3
C,
CS
0)
1
Mlehael H.
(In)
37.~
J7.
)7 .~
37.5
37. ~
50.525
63.75
63. 7~
63.75
63.75
63.75
90.
31. ~
E2
E)
E<
)7. ~
E~
)7.
31.
FJ
G)
G'
)7.
)7.~
~
~
31.~
31.5
61900
G~
)7 .~
HI
H2
)1.~
62100
J7.~
1.
7.
1.
7.
7.
15.
< 27~
15.
I~ .
15.
1~ .
4360
42)~
<14~
)II~
7.
15.
7.
1.
7.
1.
1.
7.
7.
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
1.
7.
1.
'Ol~
15.
3160
COlO
3500
)7)0
15.
1~.
I~
.
15.
15.
15.
15.
1~
.
15.
15.
15 .
15 .
I ~.
15.
I ~.
15.
"1~
42 OS
2020
2200
1980
U.s
2.7S
6515
)800
)810
)790
C2CO
40'0
..,.
...
..
.,...
.. . ,
..
...
O
.19
.CI9
078,
1. 26
C.
041,
O
.1,
4C. . . 9
.716
1.26
.419
C.
262~0
.. ]680
~OOOO
,.,65
87045
61005
196JS
~OOOO
389~~
~B4
~OOOO
~OOOO
52000
15
~OOOO
5912~
50000
50000
!tOOOO
lOBS
~C1IO
2236~
.19
38010
< 2~2S
56.,0
590'0
H130
7C 160
86205
96110
.7'6
1.26
C. .419
C. .419
.629
1.05
2. .419
6. .419
52000
6S~20
~2000
50000
50000
~OOOO
~OOOO
6J7J~
66200
6'200
66200
50000
11610
~OOOO
(6)
Vs represents the contribution of the yield forces in stirrups, and Vs represents the additional contribution due
to concrete. For the contribution of stirrups, plastic
limit analysis readily yields the expression
Vs
AJyv ( .
fu
smo: + coso:
(7)
where
Av
s
b
/Yv
0:
Placas <I97D
a
....8
-....
--
a
a
a
a
a
a
D
(8)
>
.......
>
Q.
>
(T-Section)
0.5
0.005
0.01
Fig. 4-Effect of stirrup reinforcement ratio on diagonal shear strength of beams without stirrups
liP,
-0.4
= 40011+
0.4
0.8
0.8
1.2
108
1.4
1.8
1.11
d.( 1 + P./P,)
268
3~-------------------'~--~
(al ACI
(bl "z.sUTIY
++
Vc.ISOI(p(dJal'Jln fora/d<2.S
v c 60(f:pdIal ln fora/d12.S t
+. +
'.~
""'
.S
2.5
X ~ 328 psi
Y = 360 psi
No. of data 87
S. D. = 65 . 3 psi
r = 0.956
= 305 psi
Y = 360 psi
No. of data 87
S.D.=105psi
r.>
0.923
= 0.292
0.181
.-----------------------~~
(e)
PROPOSED FORMULA
S.D.~
56.2 psi
348 psi
360 i
r
v
No. of Data 87
No. of Data 87
Vq
v, +
~
a
=
=
0.95
0.156
l)l<\'>
Yo
pi,.
t .,.[K.. JOOO.!PiWdi>I6.selntl?>
jlt
2Sd.U.p/Pol
2.5
2.5
Nominal U/tif1lJ1le Shear Stress with Stirrups Calculated. loe( v,). (v. in psj)
Fig. 6-Plots of measured versus calculated values of mean nominal shear strength
for beams with stirrups (1 psi = 6895 Pa)
pacity is small but nevertheless appreciable. For comparison, Fig.6(a) and (b) show the same plots for the
current ACI specificationssl and for Zsut1y's formula l8
[also see Eq. (15) and (18) of Reference 36]. We see that
the coefficients of variation of the vertical deviations
from the straight line are for these two formulas 0.292
and 0.181, which is distinctly larger than the value for
the presently proposed formula. Note also the increased separation of the 95 percent confidence limits.
The same set of 87 data points is plotted in Fig. 7 to
show the size effect, i.e., the dependence of Vc on the
relative size dlda. Comparison with the proposed formulas is shown in Fig. 7(c) and (d), and despite large
scatter the presence of a downward trend representing
a size effect is clearly visible. By contrast, the scatter in
Fig. 7(a) for the ACI specification is so large that no
size effect is easily detected. This means that it would
make no sense to introduce the size effect into the ACI
formula without improving the form of the existing
formula itself, which was previously shown possible for
beams without stirrups.45
In all the preceding comparisons with tests, the formulas were made to represent the mean trend of the test
data. The design formulas should, however, be introduced in such a manner that most of the test data are
ACI Materials Journal I July-August 1987
269
(a)Ael
(b)
0.4
Z'!trITY
C- I
sorr: P(dla)4)111
c. 60 (f~ pdIa)1I1
0.2
*
tl
+
+,
++
+t
C.1.2611;".
V.d
.0.2
13600p--~3.51t';"
M,
0.2 ~=====:::::r::::===,===,====,=======:::::r:==::;
(e)
~====:::c===,===,====,=======:::::r::::==;
(d) f>ROPOSED FORMt;LA.
PROPOSED fORMULA
JPS
0~--------~----------~~------------4i----------T----------~~----------~
~
}
-0.2
mechanics
1.6
1.4
1.2
1.4
1.2
1.6
/oS(dld,l
/og(dld"l
Fig. 7-Size-ejject plots jor various jormulas jor beams with stirrups in comparison with test data
3.-------------------------~
ACI
(a)
...
(b) ZSlTITY
++
tt+
t ,
I'
+t++++
, it,
+t
,t+
,++
'
tt
t ,.,
t
+
*tit
'.
t
'\fad
Ye
C y "0.15
for aId (2.5
Vc = C F 60 (f~pd/a)1I3 for aId) 2.5
2*--.--~.__.--r_,,_,--.__r~
cy 15()[f~p(dla)4Jl/3
3.---------------------------~
(e)
t.
PROPOSED FORMULA
'....
, 't, +
, t
,"
+'
.....
ttl
't' t
+ ,,~
'ft.
'+ +f'
.,, ,
+t
2.5
't+
'+
VII.
v. +
Va
v,. pjY"'
2f-_r-'r-.--.--.-,,-.--.-,,~
ft
~.
2.5
Nominal Ultimate Shear Stress with Stirrups Calculated. log(y,). (v. in psI)
REFERENCES
1. Johnston, Bruce, and Cox, Kenneth C., "High Yield-Point Steel
as Tension Reinforcement in Beams," ACI JOURNAL, Proceeding V.
36, No.1, Sept. 1939, pp. 65-80.
2. Moretto, Oreste, "An Investigation of the Strength of Welded
Stirrups in Reinforced Concrete Beams," ACI JOURNAL, Proceedings V. 42, No.2, Nov. 1945, pp. 141-164.
3. Clark, Arthur P., "Diagonal Tension in Reinforced Concrete
Beams," ACI JOURNAL, Proceedings V. 48, No.2, Oct. 1951, pp.
145-156.
4. Gaston, J. R.; Siess, C. P.; and Newmark, N. M., "An Investigation of the Load-Deformation Characteristics of Reinforced
Concrete Beams up to the Point of Failure," Civil Engineering Studies, Structural Research Series No. 40, University of Illinois, Urbana,
Dec. 1952.
5. Moody, K. G.; Viest, l. M.; Elstner, R. c.; and Hognestad, E.,
"Shear Strength of Reinforced Concrete Beams. Part I-Tests of
Simple Beams," ACI JOURNAL, Proceedings V. 51, No.3, Nov. 1954,
pp. 317-332.
6. Diaz de Cossio, Roger, and Siess, Chester P., "Behavior and
Strength in Shear of Beams and Frames without Web Reinforcement," ACI JOURNAL, Proceedings V. 56, NO.8 Feb. 1960, pp. 695735.
7. Taylor, R.,"Some Shear Tests on Reinforced Concrete Beams
without Shear Reinforcement," Magazine of Concrete Research
(London), V. 12, No. 36, Nov. 1960, pp. 145-154.
8. Leonhardt, Fritz, and Walther, Rene; "Beitrage zur Behandlung der Schubprobleme in Stahlbetonbau," Beton- und Stahlbetonbau (Berlin), Mar. 1962, pp. 54-64, and June 1962, pp. 141-149.
9. van den Berg, F. J., "Shear Strength of Reinforced Concrete
Beams without Web Reinforcement. Part 2-Factors Affecting Load
at Diagonal Cracking," ACI JOURNAL, Proceedings V. 59, No. 11,
Nov. 1962, pp. 1587-1600.
10. Rusch, Hubert; Haugli, Finn Robert; and Mayer, Horst,
"Schubversuche an Stahlbeton-Rechteckbalken mit gleichmassing
verteilter Belastung," Bulletin No. 145, Deutscher Ausschuss fur
Stahlbeton, Berlin, 1962, pp. 4-30.
11. Bresler, Boris, and Scordelis, A. C., "Shear Strength of Reinforced Concrete Beams," ACI JOURNAL, Proceedings V. 60, No.1,
Jan. 1963, pp. 51-74.
12. Mathey, Robert G., and Watstein, David, "Shear Strength of
Beams without Web Reinforcement," ACI JOURNAL, Proceedings V.
60, No.2, Feb. 1963, pp. 183-208.
13. Taylor, R., and Brewer, R. S., "The Effect of the Type of Aggregate on the Diagonal Cracking of Reinforced Concrete Beams,"
Magazine of Concrete Research (London), V. 15, No. 44, July 1963,
pp.87-92.
14. Krefeld, William 1., and Thurston, Charles W., "Studies of the
Shear and Diagonal Tension Strength of Simply Supported Rein-
271
37. Ahmad, Shuaib H.; Khaloo, A. R.; and Poveda, R., "Shear
Capacity of Reinforced High-Strength Concrete Beams," ACI JOURNAL, Proceedings V. 83, No.2, Mar.-Apr. 1986, pp. 297-305.
38. Reinhardt, H. W., "Similitude of Brittle Fracture of Structural Concrete, ': Advanced Mechanics of Reinforced Concrete,
IABSE Colloquim, Delft, 1981, pp. 201-210.
39. Reinhardt, H. W., '~Scale Effect in Shear Tests in the Light of
Fracture Mechanics," Beton- und Stahlbetonbau (Berlin), No. I,
1981, pp. 19-21. (in German)
40. Bazant, Zdenek P., and Oh, B. H., "Crack Band Theory for
Fracture of Concrete," Materials and Structures, Research and Testing (RILEM, Paris), V. 16, No. 93, May-June 1983, pp. 155-177.
41. Bazant, Z. P., "Mechanics of Distributed Cracking," Applied
Mechanics Reviews, V. 39, No.5, May 1986, pp.675-705.
42. Bazant, Zdenek P., "Size Effect in Blunt Fracture: Concrete,
Rock, Metal," Journal of Structural Engineering, ASCE, V. 110, No.
4, Apr. 1984, pp. 518-535.
43. Bazant, Zdenek P., "Fracture Mechanics and Strain-Softening of Concrete,"Proceedings, U.S.-Japan Seminar on Finite Element Analysis of Reinforced Concrete Structures (Tokyo, 1985),
American Society of Civil Engineers, New York, 1986, pp. 121-150.
44. Bazant, Z. P., "Fracture Energy of Heterogeneous Materials
and Similitude," Proceedings, RILEM-SEM International Conference on Fracture of Concrete and Rock (Houston, June 1987), Society for Experimental Mechanics, Bethel.
45. Bazant, Zdenek P., and Kim, Jin-Keun, "Size Effect in Shear
Failure of Longitudinally Reinforced Beams," ACI JOURNAL, Proceedings V. 81, No.5, Sept.-Oct. 1984, pp. 456-468. Also, Discussion, Proceedings V. 82, No.4, July-Aug. 1985, pp. 579-583.
272
46. BaZant, Zdenek P., and Cao, Zhiping, "Size Effect of Shear
Failure in Prestressed Concrete Beams," ACI JOURNAL, Proceedings
V. 83, No.2, Mar.-Apr. 1986, pp. 260-268.
47. BaZant, Zdenek P., and Cao, Zhiping, "Size Effect in Punching Shear Failure of Slabs," ACI Structural Journal, V. 84, No. I,
Jan.-Feb. 1987, pp.44-53.
48. BaZant, Zdenek P., and Cao, Zhiping, "Size Effect in Brittle
Failure of Unreinforced Pipes," ACI JOURNAL, Proceedings V. 83,
No.3, May-June 1986, pp. 369-373.
49. BaZant, Z. P., and Sener, S., "Size Effect in Torsional Failure
of Longitudinally Reinforced Concrete Beams," Report No. 86-9/
428s, Center for Concrete and Geomaterials, Northwestern University, Evanston, Sept. 1986. Also Journal of Structural Engineering,
ASCE, in press.
50. BaZant, Z. P.; Sener, S.; and Prat, P. C., "Size Effect Tests
of Torsional Failure of Beams," Report No. 86-12/428s, Center for
Concrete and Geomaterials, Northwestern University, Evanston, Dec.
1986, 18 pp.
51. ACI Committee 318, "Building Code Requirements for Reinforced Concrete (ACI 318-83)," American Concrete Institute, Detroit, 1983, III pp.
52. CEB-FIP Model Code for Concrete Strustures, 3rd Edition,
Comite: Euro-International du Beton/Federation Internatinale de la
Precontrainte, Paris (English Edition, Cement and Concrete Association, Wexham Springs), 1978, 348 pp.
53. BaZant, Zdenek P., and Kim, Jin-Keun, Authors' Closure to
Discussion of "Size Effect in Shear Failure of Longitudinally Reinforced Beams," ACI JOURNAL, Proceedings V. 81, No.4, July-Aug.
1985, pp. 580-583.