Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Project
Customer Satisfaction
with technology based
services provided by
banking sector
By: Syed Yasir Hussain
MBA – 08 - 0849
FINAL YEAR PROJECT ON
I
CUSTOMER SATISFACTION WITH TECHNOLOGY BASED
PREPARED BY:
SYED YASIR HUSSAIN (08-0849)
SUPERVISED BY:
ZAKI RASHIDI
SUBMISSION DATE:
MAY 9, 2009
II
Acknowledgement
I would like to appreciate all those people who give their precious
time to guide me and to fill questionnaires. I would like to express
my sincere gratitude to my Supervisor and FYP-Coordinator Mr. Zaki
Rashidi for his continuous guidance and support throughout the FYP.
III
Table of Contents
Acknowledgement...............................................III
List of Tables.........................................................I
List of Figures.......................................................I
Executive Summary..............................................II
1.0 Chapter – I Introduction..................................1
1.1 Introduction:......................................................................................1
IV
3.8.1 Statistical Tools.........................................................................48
3.8.2 Plan of Data Analysis................................................................49
3.8.3 Softwares Employed.................................................................49
References.........................................................74
Appendix............................................................80
V
List of Tables
Table 1 - Different Models for measuring customer
satisfaction........................................................11
Table 2 : Electronic Banking infrastructure...........15
Table 3: Conceptual Framework...........................45
Table 4: Reliability Statistics of ATM....................50
Table 5 : Regression Analysis of ATM...................51
Table 6 -ATM: Correlation between factors...........52
Table 7 : Descriptive Statistics of ATM.................54
Table 8 : Result of Hypothesis testing for ATM.....54
Table 9 - Reliability Statistics of Internet Banking 56
Table 10 : Regression Analysis of Internet Banking
..........................................................................57
Table 11 : Internet Banking: Correlation between
factors...............................................................58
Table 12 : Descriptive Statistics of Internet Banking
..........................................................................60
Table 13 : Result of Hypothesis testing for Internet
Banking..............................................................60
Table 14 : Reliability Statistics of TeleBanking.....62
Table 15 : Regression Analysis of TeleBanking.....63
Table 16 - TeleBanking: Correlation between factors
..........................................................................64
Table 17 : Descriptive Statistics of TeleBanking. . .66
Table 18 - Result of Hypothesis testing for
TeleBanking........................................................66
List of Figures
I
Executive Summary
II
electronic commerce because it will determine whether the
business will survive or fail in future.
The result of this study reflected that bank customers are satisfied
with all three technology based services that are ATM, Internet
Banking and TeleBanking services provided by banking sector and
also by all Efficiency, Reliability, Fulfillment, Responsiveness and
Privacy of ATM, Internet Banking and TeleBanking services provided
by banking sector.
III
1.0 Chapter – I Introduction
1.1 Introduction:
1
2004). IT-based distribution channels reduce personal contact
between the service providers and the customers, which inevitably
leads to a complete transformation of traditional bank-customers
relationships (Barnes and Howlett, 1998).
1.1.1 Background
1.1.2 Purpose
2
survive or fail in future. The purpose of this research is to gain a
better understanding of the service quality dimensions that affect
customer satisfaction with technology based services in the banking
sector. For this research the main research question was;
1.1.3 Objectives
3
To find the level of customer satisfaction with technology
based services?
• From which services bank customers are not satisfied & why?
4
monitored by other authorities such as Securities and Exchange
Commission and Controller of Insurance.
In Pakistan all banks & DFI’s works under the supervision of the
State Bank of Pakistan, the four major sectors in which STATE BANK
OF PAKISTAN has divided banks operations are Corporate, SME,
Agriculture and Consumer Banking. STATE BANK OF PAKISTAN
provide regulations according to which all banks should work and
continuously keep a track that banks are complying through the
regulations or not.
5
Allied Bank Limited, United Bank Limited, Habib Bank Limited were
also privatized by the government.
6
Banks are earning high spread by offering low rates on their
deposits and high rate on financing. This increases the bank
profitability but the consumer suffers because of high interest
spread.
Maintaining the critical balance between savings,
investment and borrowers debt-servicing ability is possible
if input prices remain stable affording business to sustain
their profitability and interest rates too remain stable to
ensure that in the medium term, debt servicing burden
remains affordable for both consumers and manufacturers.
(Shahid, 2003)
• Consumer Financing
• E-banking
Although small and medium banks are now offering on-line services
to their customers, the large banks, with more expanded branch
network and number of customers, are required to move more
expeditiously so as to optimally utilize the E-banking network. This
will not only lower the transaction costs but will also help in
improving the customer services
• Islamic Banking
7
Islamic banking is a relatively new concept in our banking system.
More and more banks are seeking license to open Islamic bank
Branches. At present six full fledged Islamic banks and many Islamic
banking branches of conventional banks are operating in Pakistan.
The banks are fully prepared to run Islamic branches with the help
of their Shariah Board, Shariah Advisors, Auditors and trained staff.
This is a sector where growth is expected and the banks should
capture this opportunity.
• Anti-Money Laundering
• Implementation of BASEL-II
8
1.3 Customer Satisfaction:
9
by Leeds (1992), who documented that approximately 40
percent of customers switched banks because of what they
considered to be poor service. (Cohen et al. 2006)
10
virtual world has been recognized. According to Fassnacht & Koese
(2006, p.19) ‘For providers of electronic services, quality is a major
driving force on the route to long-term success. Comprehensive
measurement of quality, in turn, is the key to effective quality
management.’
Technology offers a means to improve internal
communication, productivity and efficiency within the
organization to provide seamless service to customers to
create new and more effective service delivery and to
enhance customer satisfaction. (Hernon & Whitman, 2001)
customer satisfaction
11
(Dai & Yi, 2006)
1.4 Technology Based Services:
12
and also from bank to bank through telephones from many years.
Electronic commerce is very much assisted by the e-Banking through
electronic cash cheques and smart cards.
• Mobile/SMS Banking
• Telephone Banking
13
• Electronic funds transfers
• ATMs
• Interactive TV
• Branchless Banking
• Intranet
14
Table 2 : Electronic Banking infrastructure
15
Kaleem & Saima (2008) concluded that it was changing consumer
attitudes rather than bank cost structures that determine the
changes in distribution channels; they added that virtual banks can
only be profitable when the segment that prefers electronic media
is approximately twice the size of the segment preferring street
banks.
16
• User-friendly and secure
• 24-hour access – no more space and time constraints.
• User support from highly trained and experienced customer
service teams.
17
• Poor and/or lack of technological infrastructure and reliable
power supply
• Lack of proper legislation governing e-transactions
• Preference to paper money, as opposed to “virtual” cash in
transactions
• Balance between convenience and security.
• Designing products that offer a balance between competitive
pricing and functionality
• Keeping abreast with dynamism of customer needs &
innovation
• Lack of proper legislative framework to support the growth of
e-banking
18
The trend towards electronic delivery of banking products is
occurring partly as a result of consumer demand and partly because
of the increasing competitive environment in the global banking
industry. The internet has changed the customer behavior who is
demanding more customized products/services at lower cost. Banks
are repositioning themselves to accept new visions because they
are in people business and now people demands have changed. If
experience of the service increases the expectations customers had
of the service then satisfaction will be more.
19
During last few years a substantial growth of internet-based
services, both from internet business and from traditional
companies that are developing online service took place. One of the
key challenges of online service delivery channel is how they
manage service quality which holds a significant importance to
customer satisfaction. Dash and Mahapatra (2007) highlighted that
‘There is obviously a strong link between customer satisfaction and
customer retention. Customer's perception of Service and Quality of
product will determine the success of the product or service in the
market’
1.6 Justification:
20
The increasing number of advancements took place in technology
based services provided by the banking sector and day by day new
technologies are on their way, there is a need to measure that
those services actually satisfy the customer expectation or not. This
study explores the key areas of technology based services provided
by the banking sector in which customers are not satisfied and what
are its reasons, further this report has also recommend solutions for
those problems.
21
1.8 Assumptions:
Introduction
Theoretical
Framework
Methodology
Analysis &
Interpretation
22
Findings &
2.0 Chapter – II
Conclusion
Theoretical Framework
23
Chartered Bank and Prime Bank by ABN Amro Bank indicate foreign
interest in the domestic financial market.
24
2.2 E-banking in Pakistan:
25
electronic media in business. According to Kolachi (2006) Pakistani
banks provides the following online banking services and products.
(1) Inquiry: Account statement inquiry, Account balance inquiry,
Check statement inquiry, Fixed deposit inquiry (2) Payment:
Transfer of funds, Credit cards payments, Direct payments, Utility
bills payments (3) Request: Chequebook requests, Stop payment
requests, Demand draft requests, New fixed deposit requests (4)
Download: Customer profile, Statement download, Other
information and guidelines download.
26
Electronic distribution channels provide alternatives for faster
delivery of banking services to a wider range of customers. E-
channels have gained increasing popularity and have attracted the
attention of both academics and practitioners in Pakistan.
Banks have not only been early adopters of ecommerce, but other
businesses’ move to ecommerce has been highly dependent on the
electronic financial infrastructure that banks provide. Awad defines
ecommerce in banking as consisting of;
“Procedures that support commercial activities
electronically or via networking to apply to bank-to-bank,
bank-to customer or bank-to-vendor” (Awad, 2000)
27
and financial organizations to update their business processes still
further.
“In the USA, large organizations such as FleetBoston,
Citigroup and Wells Fargo are offering a one-stop shop,
which includes real time balances, corporate research and
stock trading” (Blount, Castleman & Swatman, 2002)
28
facility within the next five years (Booz et al, 1997). There will be
huge acceptance of online banking with the passage of time with
growing awareness and education. A great many people are shifting
to online banking and are readily accepting the usefulness of it.
29
the key to success. The customer must be at the very heart of the
company’s decision making. The customers want many things from
the companies, they work with. In the language of customer service,
these wants are often referred as needs, most customer need
quality products, quality service and friendly interaction with
knowledgeable people who care about them.
30
The web is the primary infrastructure for e-commerce. It is well
accepted that websites provided benefits for both corporation and
consumer. A corporation can display its identity and advertise its
products and services to many people. Also, corporations can get
feedback directly from customers. A website can also improve
communications with other corporations thus improving the
efficiency of business processes by increasing direct sales and
reducing costs. Online environment not only include web-sites but it
also include all kind on electronic services which don’t include any
physical process.
31
2.7 Rationale for Banks to provide online banking
services:
32
2.8 Traditional Service Quality Vs Electronic Service
Quality:
33
from a comparison of actual service performance with what it
should or would be has broad conceptual support, although some
still question the empirical value of measuring expectations and
operationalizing SQ as a set of gap scores; (b) the five SERVQUAL
dimensions of reliability, responsiveness, assurance, empathy, and
tangibles capture the general domain of SQ fairly well, (c) customer
assessments of SQ are strongly linked to perceived value and
behavioral intentions.
34
how customers judge e-service quality. This new model was drawn
up through a three-stage process involving exploratory focus groups
and two phases of empirical data collection and analysis. It contains
five broad sets of criteria as relevant to e-SQ perceptions: (a)
information availability and content; (b) ease of use or usability; (c)
privacy/security; (d) graphic style, and, (e) reliability/fulfillment.
Studies reveal important differences in acceptance and usage of
technologies across customers depending on their technology
beliefs and suggest that similar differences might exist in the
evaluative processes used in judging e-SQ. In other words,
customer-specific attributes (e.g., technology readiness) might
influence, for instance, the attributes that customers desire in an
ideal Web site and the performance levels that would signal
superior e-SQ.
35
One of the first definitions of eservice quality is conceptualized by
Zeithaml, Parasuraman, and Malhotra (2000). They state that
Internet service quality is the extent to which a web site facilitates
efficient and effective shopping, purchasing, and delivery of
products or services. Zeithaml (2002) state that some dimensions of
the SERVQUAL can be applied to eservice quality, but there are
additional dimensions in eservice, many of which are specifically
related to technology. The ESQUAL scale comprises 11 dimensions
in eservice quality, and later Parasuraman et al. (2005) developed
the ESQUAL into to a seven dimensions scale. The seven dimensions
are split into two separated scales the core dimensions and the
recovery dimensions. ESQUAL is the name of the scale for the core
dimensions: efficiency, system availability, fulfillment, and privacy.
The second scale is titled ERecSQUAL: responsiveness,
compensation, and contact (Parasuraman et al., 2005). It offers the
surface dimensions of eservice quality based on customers
experience and evaluation perspective, which are viewed also as
the antecedents to the adoption of eservice (Rowley, 2006).
36
3. Access: Ability to get on the site quickly and to reach the
company when needed.
4. Flexibility: Choice of ways to pay, ship, buy, search for, and
return items.
5. Ease of navigation: Site contains functions that help customers
find what they need without difficulty, has good search
functionality, and allows the customer to maneuver easily and
quickly back and forth through the pages.
6. Efficiency: Site is simple to use, structured properly, and requires
a minimum of information to be input by the customer.
7. Assurance/trust: Confidence the customer feels in dealing with
the site and is due to the reputation of the site and the products or
services it sells, as well as clear and truthful information presented.
8. Security/privacy: Degree to which the customer believes the site
is safe from intrusion and personal information is protected.
9. Price knowledge: Extent to which the customer can determine
shipping price, total price, and comparative prices during the
shopping process.
10. Site aesthetics: Appearance of the site.
11. Customization/personalization: How much and how easily the
site can be tailored to individual customers’ preferences, histories,
and ways of shopping
37
Service quality is the key to measure customer satisfaction (Pitt
et.al., 1995). Many studies to date have been undertaken to
indentify service quality dimensions and detailed aspects of online
services and their relationships with customer satisfaction. One of
the most widely used instruments for assessing customer
satisfaction is SERVQUAL developed by Zeithaml. SERVQUAL is a
widely recognized and used, and it is regarded as applicable to
number of industries including banking industry. In businesses
where the underlying products have become commodity-like,
quality of service depends heavily on the quality of its personnel.
Customer satisfaction has for many years been perceived as key in
determining why customers leave or stay with an organization
(Saha & Zhao, 2005).
38
From the literature that has been reviewed so far, customer
satisfaction seems to be the subject of considerable interest by both
marketing practitioners and academics since 1970s (Jones and Suh,
2000). Companies and researchers first tried to measure customer
satisfaction in the early 1970s, on the theory that increasing it
would help them prosper. Throughout the 1980s, researchers relied
on customer satisfaction and quality ratings obtained from surveys
for performance monitoring, compensation as well as resource
allocation and began to examine further the determinants of
customer satisfaction.
39
2.11 Risk associated with e-banking:
40
lack of opportunities to socialize and the development of a lazy
society (Black at al., 2001).
Secondary data collection has been done from various local and
international journals, books, newspapers, etc for literature review
after which primary data collection through Survey-Questionnaire at
branches of different bank have been conducted. Then the
compilation of data collected through Survey-Questionnaire and
data analysis - interpretation is performed.
41
3.3 Population & Sample:
3.3.1 Population
Currently there are four nationalized, twenty private, five Islamic
and seven foreign commercial banks in Pakistan with a total of 36
commercial banks and almost ninety percent of banks are providing
most of the technology based services.
Both primary and secondary sources are used for data collection,
primary data have been collected through Survey-Questionnaire
while secondary data will be collected from journals, articles,
newspapers and magazine.
42
The model used in this research is taken from study conducted at
Lulea University of Technology on Relationship between Online
Service Quality & Customer Satisfaction the model used in this
research is based on different e-SERVQUAL studies conducted by
Zeithaml, Malhotra & Parasuraman. This same model is applied on
all three different QUESTIONNAIRES on ATM, TeleBanking & Internet
Banking.
3.5 Variables:
1. Efficiency
2. Reliability
3. Responsiveness
4. Privacy
5. Fulfillment
43
6. Customer Satisfaction
Efficiency
Reliability
44
Service Quality Customer
Dimensions Responsive
ness Satisfaction
Fulfillmen
t
Privacy
3.7 Hypothesis:
Hypothesis for A T M
Customer Satisfaction
Efficiency
45
Ho : µ ≥3.5 Customers are satisfied with efficiency ATM services provided by
banking sector
H₁ : µ ≤3.5 Customers are not satisfied with efficiency of ATM services
provided by banking sector
Privacy
Reliability
Fulfillment
Responsiveness
Customer Satisfaction
46
Efficiency
Privacy
Reliability
Fulfillment
Responsiveness
Efficiency
47
Ho : µ ≥3.5 Customers are satisfied with efficiency TeleBanking services
provided by banking sector
H₁ : µ ≤3.5 Customers are not satisfied with efficiency of TeleBanking services
provided by banking sector
Privacy
Reliability
Fulfillment
Responsiveness
48
• Reliability Analysis – Cronbach’s Alpha
• Z-test
• Correlation
49
4.1 Data Analysis and Interpretation of ATM:
No. of Cronbach
Items ’s Alpha
Among all 21 0.920
questions
Efficiency 04 0.742
Reliability 03 0.663
Fulfillment 03 0.476
Responsiveness 03 0.773
Privacy 04 0.732
Customer 04 0.726
Satisfaction
50
reliability of two variables which are Reliability and Fulfillment.
Because when we performed Cronbach’s Alpha Test of Reliability on
overall questionnaire the result was α-value of 0.92 which reflected
very high internal reliability of overall survey data of ATM.
ANOVA
Model Sum of Df Mean F Sig.
Squares Square
Regression 75.813 5 15.163 80.21 .000a
8
Residual 51.034 270 .189
Total 126.847 275
Coefficients
Model Unstandard Standardize Unstandard t Sig.
ized d ized
Coefficients Coefficients Coefficients
(Constant) .683 .164 4.156 .000
Efficiency .226 .059 .238 3.820 .000
Reliability .271 .048 .315 5.609 .000
Fulfillment .047 .063 .049 .739 .461
Responsive .045 .044 .057 1.018 .310
ness
Privacy .255 .052 .269 4.939 .000
51
(Constant) .683 .164 4.156 .000
The above table reflected that Customer Satisfaction for ATM users
is highly dependent on three factors that are Efficiency, Reliability
and Privacy while the remaining two factors Fulfillment and
Responsiveness seems to be least dependent for Customer
Satisfaction from ATM. This means that when bank customers use
ATM the three most important factors they consider are Efficiency,
Reliability and Privacy so these three factors should be given more
importance by the banks to ensure high level Customer Satisfaction
from ATM.
Customer
Efficie Reliabili Fulfillme Satisfacti Responsive Privac
on
ncy ty nt ness y
Pearson
Efficiency Correlation 1 .606 **
.709 **
.675**
.538**
.673**
tailed)
tailed)
tailed)
52
N 276 276 276 276 276 276
Customer Pearson
Satisfactio Correlation .675 **
.653
**
.628
**
1 .541 **
.633**
n
tailed)
ness
tailed)
tailed)
The factors which have high correlation for ATM is Efficiency &
Reliability which
have correlation level of 0.709, the factors which have lowest
correlation for ATM are Reliability & Privacy and Privacy &
Responsiveness which have correlation level of 0.46 and 0.45
respectively while the factors which moderate correlation for ATM
are CustomerSatisfaction & Responsiveness and Responsiveness &
Efficiency which have correlation level of 0.54 and 0.53
respectively. The remaining factors have an above average
correlation for ATM which is greater then correlation level of 0.62 till
the correlation level of 0.67.
53
stated that they have bank accounts outside our sample list, were
excluded from this study. The table below gives us the descriptive
statistics of ATM data through which we can analyze that Efficiency,
Fulfillment, Responsiveness and Customer Satisfaction are among
most important factors which are highly marked (which reflect
positive response) towards these factors.
54
CustomerSatisf 3.5 276 0.05 3.856 0.679 8.7303 -1.65 Accep
2 t
action 9
This means that bank customers are satisfied with ATM services
provided by banking sector and also by Efficiency, Reliability,
Fulfillment, Responsiveness and Privacy of ATM services provided
by banking sector.
55
Banking survey data. When performing this test, we grouped
different items pertaining to the different quality factor/variable and
performed the test on each variable/factor separately and also on
overall questionnaire. Applying this test specifies whether the items
pertaining to each factor are internally consistent and whether they
can be used to measure the same construct. The table given below
highlights the result of Cronbach’s Alpha Test of Reliability.
No. of Cronbach
Items ’s Alpha
Among all 21 0.914
questions
Efficiency 03 0.680
Reliability 04 0.761
Fulfillment 03 0.731
Responsiveness 05 0.752
Privacy 03 0.497
Customer 03 0.652
Satisfaction
56
result was α-value of 0.91 which reflected very high internal
reliability of overall survey data of Internet Banking.
ANOVA
Model Sum of Df Mean F Sig.
Squares Square
Regression 41.72
41.232 5 8.246 .000a
9
Residual 19.959 101 .198
Total 61.191 106
Coefficients
Model Unstandard Standardize Unstandard t Sig.
ized d ized
Coefficients Coefficients Coefficients
(Constant) .227 .277 .820 .414
Efficiency .249 .112 .219 2.219 .029
Reliability .383 .081 .425 4.721 .000
Fulfillment .078 .111 .069 .697 .487
Responsive
.230 .089 .217 2.575 .011
ness
Privacy 9.285E-5 .053 .000 .002 .999
(Constant) .227 .277 .820 .414
57
The above table reflected that Customer Satisfaction for Internet
Banking users is highly dependent on three factors that are
Efficiency, Reliability and Responsiveness while the remaining two
factors Privacy and Fulfillment seems to be least dependent for
Customer Satisfaction from Internet Banking. This means that when
bank customers use Internet Banking the three most important
factors they consider are Efficiency, Reliability and Responsiveness
so these three factors should be given more importance by the
banks to ensure high level Customer Satisfaction from Internet
Banking.
Custome
Efficien Reliabili Fulfillm Responsive Priva r
Satisfacti
cy ty ent ness cy on
Pearson
Efficiency Correlation 1 .681** .780** .636** .432** .699**
Sig. (2-
.000 .000 .000 .000 .000
tailed)
Sig. (2-
.000 .000 .000 .000 .000
tailed)
Sig. (2-
.000 .000 .000 .000 .000
tailed)
58
Pearson
Responsiven Correlation
.636** .688** .631** 1 .440** .691**
ess
Sig. (2-
.000 .000 .000 .000 .000
tailed)
Sig. (2-
.000 .000 .000 .000 .000
tailed)
Sig. (2-
.000 .000 .000 .000 .000
tailed)
The factors which have high correlation for Internet Banking are
Efficiency & Fulfillment which have correlation level of 0.780 and
Reliability & Customer Satisfaction which have correlation level of
0.768, the factors which have lowest correlation for Internet
Banking are Privacy & Efficiency, Privacy & Reliability, Privacy &
Responsiveness and Privacy & Customer Satisfaction which have
correlation level of 0.432, 0.494, 0.440 & 0.435 respectively while
the factor which have moderate correlation for Internet Banking is
Privacy & Fulfillment which have correlation level of 0.510. The
remaining factors have an above average correlation for Internet
Banking which is greater then correlation level of 0.636 till the
correlation level of 0.69.
59
who have stated that they have bank accounts outside our sample
list, were excluded from this study. The table below gives us the
descriptive statistics of Internet Banking data through which we can
analyze that Efficiency, Reliability, Fulfillment and Customer
Satisfaction are among most important factors which are highly
marked (which reflect positive response) towards these factors.
Table 12 : Descriptive Statistics of Internet Banking
60
The above table represent the result of hypothesis testing of
Internet Banking according to the analysis all our hypothesis for
Internet Banking are accepted because they have z-value above
-1.65 which comes in acceptance region.
This means that bank customers are satisfied with Internet Banking
services provided by banking sector and also by Efficiency,
Reliability, Fulfillment, Responsiveness and Privacy of Internet
Banking services provided by banking sector.
61
TeleBanking survey data. When performing this test, we grouped
different items pertaining to the different quality factor/variable and
performed the test on each variable/factor separately and also on
overall questionnaire. Applying this test specifies whether the items
pertaining to each factor are internally consistent and whether they
can be used to measure the same construct. The table given below
highlights the result of Cronbach’s Alpha Test of Reliability.
No. of Cronbach
items ’s Alpha
Among all 21 0.935
questions
Efficiency 04 0.743
Reliability 04 0.755
Fulfillment 03 0.687
Responsiveness 03 0.723
Privacy 03 0.699
Customer 04 0.729
Satisfaction
62
of Reliability on overall questionnaire the result was α-value of 0.93
which reflected very high internal reliability of overall survey data of
TeleBanking.
ANOVA
Model Sum of df Mean F Sig.
Squares Square
Regression 84.23
91.197 5 18.239 .000a
6
Residual 43.522 201 .217
Total 134.720 206
Coefficients
Model Unstandard Standardize Unstandard t Sig.
ized d ized
Coefficients Coefficients Coefficients
(Constant) .476 .159 2.990 .003
Efficiency .307 .064 .307 4.795 .000
Reliability .196 .066 .213 2.971 .003
Fulfillment .223 .057 .243 3.899 .000
Responsive
.075 .052 .087 1.438 .152
ness
Privacy .082 .055 .096 1.507 .133
(Constant) .476 .159 2.990 .003
63
The above table reflected that Customer Satisfaction for
TeleBanking users is highly dependent on three factors that are
Efficiency, Reliability and Fulfillment while the remaining two factors
Privacy and Responsiveness seems to be least dependent for
Customer Satisfaction from TeleBanking. This means that when
bank customers use TeleBanking the three most important factors
they consider are Efficiency, Reliability and Responsiveness so
these three factors should be given more importance by the banks
to ensure high level Customer Satisfaction from TeleBanking.
Custome
Efficienc Reliabil Fulfillme Responsive Privac r
Satisfacti
y ity nt ness y on
Pearson
Efficiency Correlation 1 .710** .684** .642** .661** .743**
Sig. (2-
.000 .000 .000 .000 .000
tailed)
Sig. (2-
.000 .000 .000 .000 .000
tailed)
Sig. (2-
.000 .000 .000 .000 .000
tailed)
64
ess
Sig. (2-
.000 .000 .000 .000 .000
tailed)
Sig. (2-
.000 .000 .000 .000 .000
tailed)
Sig. (2-
.000 .000 .000 .000 .000
tailed)
65
The table below gives us the descriptive statistics of TeleBanking
data through which we can analyze that Efficiency, Reliability,
Privacy and Customer Satisfaction are among most important
factors which are highly marked (which reflect positive response)
towards these factors.
66
action 0 80869
5.1 Findings
67
flexibility, easy of navigation, access, efficiency, privacy, price
knowledge, aesthetics, customization/personalization
68
• Information technology developments in the banking sector
have speed up communication and transactions for clients. E-
banking is one of the technologies which are rapidly growing
banking practices these days. Easy set-up, User-friendly and
secure service & 24-hour access are the major reasons for
adopting technology for banking
69
• After conducting regression analysis we have found that
customer satisfaction of ATM users is highly dependent on
Efficiency, Reliability and Privacy, customer satisfaction of
Internet Banking users is highly dependent on Efficiency,
Reliability and Responsiveness while customer satisfaction of
TeleBanking users in highly dependent on Efficiency, Reliability
and Fulfillment.
• The factors which have high correlation for ATM is Efficiency &
Reliability, for Internet Banking are Efficiency & Fulfillment and
Reliability & Customer Satisfaction while for TeleBanking
Efficiency & Reliability, Efficiency & Customer Satisfaction,
Reliability & Privacy, Reliability & Customer Satisfaction and
Fulfillment & Customer Satisfaction have high correlation.
70
5.2 Conclusion
For the purpose of this study, a survey has been conducted with
800 people, from which the responses from 590 have been used for
the analysis. To analyze the data and test its reliability, Cronbach’s
Alpha Test of Reliability was conducted. The Cronbach’s Alpha Test
of Reliability proved the relative reliability of the dimensions used in
the model.
71
services. That is why being able to measure and evaluate the
quality of their online banking services is deemed important for
banks in order for them to take action to correct those features of
their online services which customers don’t find that satisfactory.
Consumer behavior is changing partly because of less spare time.
The way of use of financial services is characterized by individuality,
mobility, independence of place and time and flexibility.
Singh et al., (2000) feel that the challenge for financial institutions
is to find satisfactory answers to business issues of culture and
processes and to create a win-win game which both satisfies banks
and customers.
5.3 Recommendations
72
Some banks in Pakistan need to pay more attention to developing
Internet and TeleBanking services as they are not yet thoroughly
developed and thus, they can be exploited to the benefit of the
bank. Banks should try and publicize the e-banking services it
provides through advertisements, publications, though its website,
by means of pamphlets/brochures and encouraging bank employees
to talk about it with the customers. Also, attention should be paid to
different types of customers such as young and old customers, risk-
takers, regular and irregular customers.
At last but not the least is that Banks must adapt to the electronics
age and frequently update it. Because consumers demand it and
economics drives it. Banks must exploit it.
73
to be satisfactory, it should be accepted as a preliminary scale and
tested further with higher number of respondents.
References
74
Saho, P & Zhao, Yanni (2005), ‘Relationship between Online Service
Quality and Customer Satisfaction’, Master thesis, Lulea University
of Technology
75
Ekin, S and Polatoglu, VN (2001), ‘An empirical investigation of the
Turkish consumers’ acceptance of internet banking services’,
International Journal of Bank Marketing, Vol.19, No.4, pp.156-165
76
working paper, report No. 95-104, No.1-59, Marketing Science
Institute, Cambridge, MA
77
Sathye, M (1999), ‘Adoption of Internet banking by Australian
consumers: an empirical investigation’, International Journal of Bank
Marketing, Vol. 17 No.7, pp.324-334
78
Commerce Division-Lincoln University, viewed 6 September, 2008,
< http://hdl.handle.net/10182/324>
Dai, L, Huang, L & Yi, Y (2005), How B2C Service Quality Influences
website continuance, in Pacific Asia Conference on Information
Systems, Bangkok, Thailand, pp.1375-1381
79
Appendix
80