Professional Documents
Culture Documents
Notes
Variable Frequency Drives vs. Fluid
Couplings
1. VFD’s allow for improved process control vs. fluid coupling (0.1% to 0.5%
speed regulation throughout the operating speed range).
5. VFD’s not only can reach synchronous speed but can also overspeed the
motor if required to increase capacity (motor must be sized for this
capability). Fluid couplings always have a coupling slip making even attaining
synchronous motor speed impossible.
8. VFD’s are much more efficient than fluid couplings. The efficiency advantage
is approximately 5% at full speed and full load and can be more than 25%
more efficient as the speed and loading decreases (see attached graph).
This means that, if fluid couplings are used, the customer must purchase
motors that are significantly oversized (more $$) for the application because
of the HP losses in the fluid coupling.
9. VFD’s control the motor starting current. The starting current is usually very
close to or equal the motor rated full load current. The inrush current for the
motor used with a fluid coupling will be approximately the standard 600% of
full load current (NEMA B squirrel cage motor). This may cause voltage dip
problems on weaker power systems.
Fig.1 – Fluid coupling mechanical Fig.2 – Fluid coupling construction
cross section diagram
Efficiency
100
90
80
Variable Speed
70 Advanced Fluid Drive
Standard fluid Drive
60
30 40 50 60 70 80 90 100
Speed