CASE NO.

AOENCY:O9I ,#FW190700
Ml Ai.,AlBEACH
OFFENSE INCIDENT 2010-00127860
FIELD M06NE PEINTSUMMARV
CASE REPORT SUPPLEMENT
SUMMARY
OCCURRED LOCATION: 1700 CONVENTION CENTER DR MIAMI BEACH FL, 33140-
d OCCURRED INCIDENT TYPE: BATTERY-SIMPLE BUSINESS NAME MIAMI BEACH CITY HALL
❑ LOCATION TYPE,
SUPPLEMENT
Z DATE R EPORTED: 12/03/2010 TIME 20: 5'0 SIGNIFICANT EVENT:.

> OCCFROM DATE: TIME: BIAS MOTIVATION: NONE

THROUGH DATE: TIME: CHILD ABUSE CODE: NA
❑ ATT COUNTS: OFFENSE DESCRIPTION:
COM STATUTE NO: WEAPON TYPE: UCR CODE:
10 ATT COUNTS: OFFENSE DESCRIPTION:
to 2
U COM CR
STATUTE NO: WEAPON TYPE .
CODE:
IW ❑ ATT C OUNTS: OFFENSE DESCRIPTION:
O XCOM STATUTE NO: WEAPON TYPE: UCR CODE:
❑ ATT COUNTS: OFFENSE DESCRIPTION:
4
❑ COM STATUTE NO: WEAPON TYPE: UCR CODE:
NAME (LAST, FIRST, MIDDLE):
(S
Z LAST KNOWN ADDRESS:
N DOB: EYES: PRIMARY PHONE: TYPE:
y AGE: HAIR: OTHER PHONE: TYPE:
RACE: HEIGHT: OTHER CONTACT INFO
-
I-
2 SEX: WEIGHT: CASE SUBJECT TYPE
>
SYNOPSIS, OF. INVOLVEMENT:
NAME (LAST, FIRST, MIDDLE):
OS
Z LAST KNOWN ADDRESS:
N DOB. EYES: PRIMARY PHONE: TYPE:
2 AGE: HAIR: OTHER PHONE: TYPE:
RACE: HEIGHT: OTHER CONTACT INFO
SEX: WEIGHT: CASE SUBJECT TYPE
5
SYNOPSIS OF INVOLVEMENT:
NAME (LAST, FIRST, MIDDLE):
PRIMARY SUSPECT: ❑ UNKNOWN IPARTIAL: . ❑ UNKNOWN: ❑
LAST KNOWN ADDRESS:
DOB: EYES: PRIMARY PHONE: TYPE:
AGE OR RANGE: / HAIR: OTHER PHONE: TYPE:
RACE: HEIGHT RANGE (FROMITO): / PLACE OF BIRTH:'..
SEX: WEIGHT RANGE(FROMITO): / CITIZENSHIP:
W ALIAS/NICKNAME/ MAIDEN NAME:
N SOCIAL SECURITY NUMBER: ETHNICITY :
U7 DRIVER'S LICENSE NUMBER: SCARSI MARKS ITATOOS:
DL STATE: DISTINCTIVE FEATURES:
OCCUPATION:
EMPLOYER/SCHOOL NAME:
EMPLOYER/SCH OOL ADDRESS.
STATEMENT TYPE: OTHER CONTACT INFO
SYNOPSIS OF INVOLVEMENT:

THIS OFFICER RESPONDED TO MIAMI BEACH CITY HALL ON THE 4TH FLOOR IN REFERENCE TO A 32
SIGNAL. UPON ARRIVAL S # 01, V # 01 AND W # 01 WERE ALL SITTING AT A TABLE. W # 01 ADVISED
w THAT S # 01 HAD GRABBED AND ATTEMPTED TO HIT V # 01 AFTER A MEETING HAD GOTTEN VERBALLY
, _ HEATED .V # 01 AGREED THAT THE MEETING GOT HEATED AT WHICH POINT S # 01 ROSE FROM HIS
-
g CHAIR AND APPROACHED V # 01 WHO WAS SEATED AND GRABBED V # 01 AND ATTEMPTED TO STRIKE
V # 01 WITH HIS FREE HAND AT WHICH POINT W # 01 GOT BETWEEN BOTH INDIVIDUALS AND CALMED
THE SITUATION. ALL THREE MEN WERE SEATED AND CALM UPON OFFICERS ARRIVAL. V # 01 THEN
STATED WE ARE FRIENDS AND I ADVISED " WHAT WOULD YOU LIKE TO SEE DONE", AT WHICH POINT

Z REPORTING OFFICER (LAST, FIRST) Macleod Kenneth 342 DATE 12/03/2010

0 REVIEWING SUPERVISOR (LAST, FIRST) Nolan James 063 DATE 12/03/2010
d CASE STATUS CASE DISPOSITION

Case Supplement Report 2010-00127860 Page 1 OF 2



AG EN CYORI NFLal30700
MIAMI BEACH CASE NO.
CASE REPQRT SUMMARY
LICE NARRATIVE SUPPLEMENT 2010-00127860
V # 01 STATED "I WANT HIM ARRESTED, HE NEEDS TO LEARN A LESSON." V # 01 WAS ADVISED
THAT FROM WHAT WAS STATED BY HIMSELF AND W # 01 THAT NO ARREST WOULD BE MADE
AND HE WAS ADVISED OF ALL HIS OPTIONS. AT THIS POINT OFFICER R. SMITH ARRIVED AND I
REMOVED S # 01 TO GET HIS SIDE OF THE STORY.

S # 01 STATED THAT V # 01 AND HIMSELF HAVE BEEN HAVING AN ONGOING PROBLEM OVER
SOME PROJECTS AND THE ACTUAL CHAIN OF COMMAND. THIS HAS CONTINUED AND CAME TO
A BOIL THRU E-MAILS AND OTHER VERBAL CONVERSATIONS. S # 01 REQUESTED A SIT DOWN
MEETING TO RESOLVE THE SITUATION AND W # 01 WAS TO MONITOR. DURING THE MEETING S
# 01 ASKED W # 01 IF V # 01 WAS IN CHARGE OF HIM AND IT WAS STATED NO. S # 01 THEN
WENT ON TO EXPLAIN HE WAS ATTEMPTING TO DO HIS JOB AND V # 01 WAS INTERFERING AND
ATTEMPTING TO ACT AS HIS BOSS. S # 01 ADVISED THAT ACCUSATIONS BY V # 01 ABOUT HIM
COVERING UP FOR HIS ASSISTANT DIRECTOR AROSE AND THAT HE TRIED TO PUT THESE TO
REST BUT V # 01 WOULD NOT LET THE SITUATION GO AWAY. DURING THE MEETING THIS
AGAIN AROSE AT WHICH POINT S # 01 AGAIN ATTEMPTED TO LAY IT TO REST AND V # 01
BEGAN TO CALL S # 01 A "LIAR" ABOUT THE SITUATION. THE CONVERSATION CONTINUED AND
ON NUMEROUS OCCASIONS V # 01 CALLED S # 01 A "LIAR". THIS BEGAN TO IRRITATE S # 01
WHO ASKED V # 01 TO CEASE FROM SUCH AN ACCUSATION. V # 01 REFUSED AND CONTINUED
TO USE THE TERM "LIAR". AT WHICH POINT S # 01 STATED STOP CALLING ME A LIAR OR I WILL
COME OVER THERE AND MAKE YOU STOP. V # 01 THEN STATED "COME ON, COME GET IT,
COME ON" AT WHICH POINT S # 01 GOT UP WALKED AROUND THE TABLE AND WITH HIS LEFT
HAND GRABBED V # 01'S SHIRT AND RAISED HIS RIGHT HAND AS TO STRIKE V # 01 AT WHICH
POINT W # 01 INTERVENED AND S # 01 REMOVED HIS HAND FROM V # 01'S RIGHT SHOULDER
AREA. S # 01 THEN ADVISED THAT V # 01 THEN STATED " I GOT YOU NOW, IT WILL BE GREAT
TO SEE YOU LEAVE OUT OF HERE IN HANDCUFFS".

S # 01 STATED V # 01 NEVER ROSE FROM HIS CHAIR AND HE WENT BACK TO HIS CHAIR AS
WELL AS W # 01 RETURNED TO HIS AND THE POLICE WERE CALLED.

UPON THIS OFFICERS ARRIVAL NO VISIBLE SIGNS OF ANY ALTERCATION WERE VISIBLE BUT
WHILE ON SCENE IT WAS OBSERVED THAT V # 01 CONTINUALLY RUBBED HIS LEFT NECK /
SHOULDER AREA CAUSING IT TO BECOME SLIGHTLY RED OR IRRITATED. YET BOTH S # 01 AND
W # 01 ADVISED THAT ANY TYPE OF PHYSICAL CONTACT (THE GRABBING OF THE SHOULDER)
OCCURRED ON V # 01'S RIGHT SHOULDER.

SGT. HERNANDEZ WAS ON SCENE.

DUE TO NO ORIGINAL SIGN OF INJURY AND V # 01'S RUBBING OF THE OTHER SHOULDER CRIME
SCENE WAS NOT NOTIFIED.

z
REPORTING OFFICER (LAST,: FIRST) Macleod Kenneth 342 DATE:. 12/03/2010
4 REVIEWING'SUPERVISOR (LAST; FIRST) Nolan James 063 DATE: 12103/2010

Case Supplement Report 2010-00127860 Page 2 OF 2