5 Signs of Critically Weak Leadership

During a recent dinner with friends, the conversation turned to the difficulty of
working in an organization that lacks strong leadership. One of my friends was
particularly engaged and exasperated by the conversation. He remarked that
only one individual had been honest with him about the critical lack of senior
leadership in his current organization while he was hiring into the firm. This got
me thinking about the definitive signs of weak leadership and how one might
spot them during an interview. So here it is, 5 warning signs of critically weak
leadership.

1) Lack of a clear organizational mission, vision or strategy

During the interview process, can all of your interviewers speak about the
mission and vision of the organization? If they pull a card out of their wallet, it
is not necessarily a bad sign. Just make sure that they can then tell you how
the organization lives up to that mission, and more importantly how they see
themselves and your position living up to it as well.

2) Micromanagement or Tyrannical Management

While different types of leaders exhibit different leadership styles, extreme
micromanagement or even worse, tyrannical management styles are warning
signs of leadership that is having difficulty defining and then executing against
the big picture. Unfortunately, this type of management can become
contagious within organizations as the lack of a clearly defined strategy or
mission impacts more than just the C-level. When interviewing, ask individuals
to describe their supervisor’s leadership style. If their leader is truly corrosive,
you might not get a straight answer. That is a sign, in and of itself.

3) Poor communication
The inability to communicate is often cited as one of the biggest impediments
to organizational success. Successfully sharing ideas, information and
inspiration within an organization is increasingly a mark of even middle of the
pack leadership. Leaders must not only be effective communicators in their
own right, but they must also create an environment that values frictionless
communication. Ask your interviewers to describe communication in
the organization. Is information shared freely from the top down? Do people
say that they often know what they need to know, in a timely fashion? Do they
both understand and trust the messages they are getting from leadership? If the
answer is no, then perhaps there is a problem.

4) Lack of conflict or corrosive conflict.

Understanding how an organization deals with conflict will give you a clear
sense of the organization’s leadership. And unless you are working in the
military under a command and control structure, conflict should be an innate
and integral part of any successful team. Leaders that fear conflict tend to
create organizations that lack diverse thinking, or worse, they create passive
aggressive behaviors on the part of their frustrated employees. Â Ask how
the organization deals with differences in opinion. What is their model for
collaboration and consensus? You want to hear that different voices and
opinions are welcome, even though they may create conflict. Even better, if
they can report that better outcomes are reached as a result of recognizing
different voices you likely have strong leadership in place.

5) Lack of organizational resilience

How does the organization respond to setbacks? Solid leadership recognizes

that change and challenge are unavoidable parts of running an organization.
Resilient leaders find ways of turning those events into learning opportunities,
and eventually competitive advantage. This requires leadership to do more
than react to setbacks. Leaders should create a culture that uses even small
challenges as opportunities to grow and thrive. Simply inquire about how
the organization and its leadership handled its most recent setback.