Professional Documents
Culture Documents
cultural understanding
1
Dance: A Tool for Building Cultural Understanding
• Perceiving
• Sensing
• Becoming aware of meaning or cause of something,
• Knowing
• Remembering
• Reflecting
• Experiencing Understanding
• Retaining
• Comparing
• Imagining/ideating
• Interpreting or judging in a particular way
• Inferring or deducing a meaning of something new
through creation of mental models
This group of elements suggests that understanding is grasping the intrinsic or the
essential character of something or someone and these elements together form the core
2
characteristics of human understanding. The process of understanding involves explicit
and tacit acts of internalizing information in the environment with the purpose of using it
for personal and shared benefit. Personal benefit could be emotional (such as enhancing
one’s sense of self-esteem or a sense of joy) or cognitive (such as making sense of one’s
surroundings with the purpose of acting on it). Shared benefits could involve the ability
to achieve agreements or compatibility between self and other individuals, communities,
institutions or objects and events from everyday life. Understanding is the skill of the
human mind that helps maintain comfort (internal) and balance (with the environment).
If we refer to understanding as the goal, then we must identify the tools of human
consciousness that can be used to achieve this goal. I would like to propose that the three
main components of achieving understanding are Exchanging Ideas, Exchanging
3
Emotions and Exchanging Meanings between people of different cultures. These three
components can be explained, within the context of an art experience, as follows:
Cultivating Understanding
Ideas
Cultivating
global
Meanings
minds
Emotions
Cultural understanding develops when one is able to comprehend the main idea, context,
emotion and meaning of the artwork. Cultural ideas and meanings manifests in the
creative expressions of people. Dance, music, paintings, ritual, sculpture, architecture,
and language reflect the traditions, practices and beliefs of the people. Arts and artistic
expressions “ are not merely a tool giving rise to consumer products but one which opens
up the gates of a wider vision, a supramental consciousness of beauty and inner
perception of a world order”(Pathy, 1998, Para 6). Artistic expressions convey the vision
of the creator and the context in which the art is created.
4
As a mode of expression and communication art facilitates understanding and
imagination. As discussed in the previous paragraphs, a person seeking understanding of
an experience looks not only for a logical rationale or explanation of that experience at
explicit cognitive level but also a recognizable visual mental model and an enjoyable
sensory perception of that experience at the emotional level. The language of dance
covers both the cognitive and the emotional dimensions of understanding. Experiencing
dance or participating in dance helps people feel a range of emotions such as enjoyment,
curiosity, wonder, delight, frustration and sense of mystery, and evokes appreciation for
excellence or effort that has gone into making of the dance sequence. Since
communicative and creative abilities vary from person to person every dance becomes an
expression in relation to one’s own environment.
Ideological, cultural and social conditions drive people to use different artistic
elements in the creation of dance and as an expression of the people it becomes a creative
human activity that has a purpose, place and an intention. In order to identify the cultural
beliefs and ideas reflected in a dance it is vital to ask questions about the context or place
in which the dance originates and understand its function in the society. Professor June
Layson, in her essay on ‘Historical perspectives in the study of dance’ presents a simple
three-dimensional figure for the study of dance.
5
Dance Types B
Communal
Educational C
Recreational Dance Contexts
Religious
Social
Therapeutic Psychological
Aesthetic
Traditional Anthropological
Artistic
Cultural
Geographic
Political (Marxist, feminist etc)
Social
This figure illustrates three dimensions that can facilitate an in-depth enquiry and study
of a dance style. Professor Layson explains:
Dimension B- ‘Dance Types’- is explaining dances based on their function and time.
Professor Layson’s method for learning about dance using the historical, cultural,
and social perspectives enables determining the scope, rationale and defining
characteristics of the dance style. Dimension A, the systemic study on dance begins from
knowing the pre-historic background of the dance and finishes with the most recent and
encompasses learning about all the important aspects in the evolution of the dance style.
A period based study of dance includes exploring the important reasons/events, causes
and effects in the growth and decline of the dance style through certain eras or periods in
time. In comparison, an in-depth study of dance during an isolated period lends an
6
opportunity to look at particular events in relation to the time span of the selected area
(Layson, p.6) and understanding how it affects the structure of the dance. Keeping in
view the method suggested by Prof Layson I have in the following table listed questions
that can enable understanding a dance as a reflection of the culture in which it is created.
Musical accompaniment
What is the predominant form of music making?
Does it combine vocal and instrumental? What are the types of instruments used?
Is it a combination of music and dance? Or is it separate?
Is it a chorus? What is the structure of the songs? Is there a leader in the chorus, or does
everyone take an equal role?
7
Personal/previous experience
Did the dance remind you of any other dance style you know about?
What are the similarities and dissimilarities with other dance experience you have had
earlier?
Describe your familiarity with the music.
Where you familiar with the language used in the dance?
Did you relate to the symbolism/gesticulation in the dance?
Were the movements and expressions in the dance simple, complex or communicative?
What are the costume, props, and make up like and how does it complement the theme or
the main idea of the dance presentation.
Prof Layson’s method of studying dance can guide in acquiring the complete
metamorphosis of a dance form on one hand and on the other it can be a meaning making
process. Clifford Geertz brings into light this point in his book, ‘The Interpretation of
Cultures’ when he gives the example of the cathedral Chartres. He writes:
Chartres is made of stone and glass. But it is not just stone and glass; it is a
cathedral, and only a cathedral, and but a particular cathedral built at a
particular time by certain members of a particular society. To understand
what it means, to perceive it for what it is, you need to know rather more
than the generic properties of stone and glass and rather more than what is
common to all cathedrals. You need to understand also- and, in my
opinion, most critically- the specific concepts of the relations among God,
man, and architecture that, since they have governed its creation, it
consequently embodies (Geertz, 1973, p50).
Both these scholars have amply emphasized how and why identifying the connections to
the context in which the art is made and knowing the meaning is important. A deeper
understanding enables people to recognize and relate to diverse cultural concepts. The
meaning making process further leads to translating these concepts in relation to one’s
own life experience and comparing it to one’s own cultural ideas. This process
contributes in cultivating minds and assists in developing relationships amongst diverse
people.
Urs Fuhrer in his book ‘Cultivating Minds’ introduces the concept of identity as a
meaning-making practice which refers to people’s use of a range of cultural artifacts as
opportunities towards I – world relationships”. According to him, identity as a meaning
making practice is a process of cultivating minds, which is constituted through the
medium of culture. He views culture “as a medium for generating possibilities i.e. a
generative medium for the agentic, self referential, creative self”(2004, P 92). Given
below is Fuhrer’s Tetradic Mediational Model of Identity formation, which illustrates his
concept that “in this process meaning emerges from the effect that a sign or symbol
triggers in the consciousness of its interpreter”(2004, P. 93). The four interrelated
systems in this diagram are:
8
• The subject, with a distinctive biological makeup and a unique history of
experience
• The social partners with whom the subject collaborates
• The culture represented through the artifacts/artistic activity
• The objective world
Subject
Social Meanings as
partners action Artifacts
possibilities
World
The links or the mediational process between the subject and the world, through the
medium of cultural representation in artifacts or artistic activity result in co creation and
co construction of cultural meanings. George Simmel in his cultivation principle has
discussed a similar idea that individuals together with their artifacts experience
themselves as agents of their own meaning making activities or practices to cultivate their
selves. Identity and the character of one’s thoughts and feelings are substantially a
construct of one’s social context. I therefore propose that the process of understanding
includes formation of identity and relationship with others. The challenges in fostering
understanding should be viewed in terms of challenges in negotiating a sense of identity
between two or more groups of people belonging to different cultures.
9
As David Best (1986) says in his article ‘Culture Consciousness’,
The process of negotiating the identities would require a medium that lends itself
to reconciliation and appreciation of the other side. I propose that dance is one such
medium that is more likely to evoke a sense of reflection (about one’s own identity) and
reconciliation (towards a shared experience). Identity development can be compared to
building a wall. Every new experience/idea becomes an added brick in the process of
identity construction. In reference to this discussion I would like to share the results of a
research study conducted in the year 2001 with the students of the Denison University in
Granville, Ohio. This study was done to understand students’ experience in learning
Odissi, a classical dance form from India offered under the World Dance Program. The
World Dance Program is offered in the Department of Dance with the objective of
providing undergraduate students an opportunity to explore, experience and understand a
world culture through its dance forms. Two courses on Odissi dance were offered. While
one of the courses focused on the technique of this classical dance form, the other
(Honors) course was designed to help students understand the Indian culture through its
dance forms. There were 14 students in the technique class, and eight students in the
Honors class, a majority of the students were non-dance majors. All 14 students from the
technique class and five students from the Honors course participated in the assessment.
Each student was given a scrapbook to record his or her feelings at different points during
the five month long semester. The synthesis of the response received from the students
revealed common benefits as a result of the experience of the unfamiliar art form. The
students reported that the experience of learning Odissi dance:
While describing the experience of learning an unfamiliar dance form like Odissi,
one of the students said, “This experience will encourage me to not be afraid of new or
unfamiliar in my future. Instead of disregarding things that are different from my usual
life I will be curious about them and interested to learn about them”(2001, Elizabeth
Johnson). Responses received from the students reflected the overall value students
derived from this unfamiliar experience and how they developed the ability to understand
and accept the unfamiliar. Most students reported that they would be less hesitant in
seeking unfamiliar experiences from other cultures in the future. The impact of exposure
to an unfamiliar dance form on the students was two fold: internal transformative impact
10
that prepared them to better understand and enjoy an unfamiliar experience and secondly,
it enhanced their social skills in dealing with diversity.
Drawing from this study it is observed that participation in dance activities assists
people in overcoming cultural differences and in reaching out to each other. In 1954, at
the height of the Cold War, great American dancers, namely Jose Limon, Martha
Graham, and Alvin Ailey, traveled to many countries as cultural ambassadors of America
and through their artistic work demonstrated and reflected the ideals of liberty, freedom
of speech, equality, diversity and tolerance. Innumerable examples from various parts of
the world can be listed to support the view that dance and other art forms can be a tool for
communicating values, facilitating cultural understanding, cultivating ties between
countries, building relationships between people and initiating appreciation, respect and
mutual understanding.
References
CsikszentMihalyi, Mihaly & Robinson, Rick. (1990). The Art of Seeing, Getty
Publications, Los Angeles, CA
Fuhrer, Urs. (2004) Cultivating Minds, Routledge Taylor & Francis Group, New
York, NY
11
Gardner, Howard. (2004) Changing Minds, Harvard Business School Press,
Boston, MA
Jameson, Frederic & Miyoshi Masao (Eds). (1998) The Cultures of Globalization,
Duke University Press, Durham.
Lawrence, Paul R. & Nohria, Nitin. (2002). Driven-How Human Nature Shapes
Our Choices, Jossey-Bass, San Francisco.
Nisbett, Richard E. (2003), The Geography of Thought, The Free Press, N.Y.
Thomas, David C. & Inkson Kerr. (2004). Cultural Intelligence, Berrett- Koehler
Publishers Inc. San Francisco, California.
Williams, Jennifer. (1996). Across the Street Around the World- A handbook for
Cultural Exchange, British American Arts Association Ltd., London, U.K.
12