Professional Documents
Culture Documents
:
.. (-, ); . . (-, );
. (, ); .. (-, );
.. (-, ); .. (, );
. . ( , ); . (, );
.. (-, ); . (, );
.. (, ); .. (, );
.. (, )
E d i t o r i a l B o a r d:
Nicola Di Cosmo (Princeton, USA); Boris V. Erokhin (St. Petersburg, Russia);
Vladimir A. Goroncharovsky (St. Petersburg, Russia); Anatoly M. Khazanov (Madison, USA);
Yuly S. Khudjakov (Novosibirsk, Russia); Anatoly N. Kirpichnikov (St. Petersburg, Russia);
Boris A. Litvinsky (Moscow, Russia); Aleksandr V. Makhlayuk (Nizhniy Novgorod, Russia);
Mariusz Mielczarek (Toru, Poland); Valery P. Nikonorov (St. Petersburg, Russia);
Witold witosawski (Gdask, Poland); Aleksandr V. Simonenko (Kiev, Ukraine);
Yury A. Vinogradov (St. Petersburg, Russia)
A. V. Simonenko
. .
SarmatIAN riders
of north pontic region
-
C-
2009
:
..
..
. .
. .: , 2009. 328 ., . ( Historia Militaris).
ISBN 978-5-8465-??
II
. . . IV . . . . (, , , , , , ) (, , ,
. .), .
,
.
,
.
, , ,
, .
Simonenko A. V.
Sarmatian Riders of North Pontic Region. Faculty ofPhilology and Arts of
theSt.Petersburg State University, 2009. 328 p. (Historia Militaris)
The military art, weapons and horse trappings from Sarmatian graves of the 2nd cent. BC 4th cent.
AD from North Pontic region (modern Ukraine and Moldova) are investigated in the book. The author collected all weapons (the swords and daggers, spear- and arrow-heads, parts of bows, helmets, amours, shields)
and cavalry equipment (the bits, check-pieces, phalerae and other harness decoration, saddle depictions etc.)
many of which are published for the first time. In the book the typology and chronology of material are
proposed, the place of Sarmatian militaria in the system of Eurasian nomadic antiquities is determined. Basing on the review of the current scientific theories and analyzing the new material the author proposes new
solutions of such key questions of Sarmatian studies as the similarity and difference of Sarmatian and Scythian military art, problem of cataphractarii, the structure and organization of Sarmatian army, thechronology of thedevelopment of Sarmatian military art, its regional and chronological peculiarities etc.
ISBN 978-5-8465-??
. . , 2009
, 2009
. . , , 2009
( )
,
. ,
II. .., .
- .
.
II. .. (
) :
,
,
. , ,
II. ..
III. ..
. II. .. I. ..
.
( ..), (
I II. ..),
(III. ..). III. .. .
.
,
, . ,
.
I. .. .
, , .
, I.
..
.
, II. .. . ,
II. ..
,
()
III.
..
(
, ),
.
III. ..,
.
(, 1982, .78, 103). II I. ..
(, , , 1987,
.5663)
. , .
I. ..
, - .
, . , ,
.
(, 1989, .74). -
-, ,
-, ,
(, 1987, .110). , II. ..
.
,
, ,
.
- ( , , ).
III. ..
.
- (
-)
.
, .
,
.
III. ..
( )
,
, .
, , ,
-.
,
.
,
,
.
95. ,
. ,
. :
1148. II
III. ..
. ,
, . ,
.
-
. ,
, ( )
,
. , ,
,
. .
. -
, .. . : , , , , ,
.
: ;
(,
56). .
,
,
- .
(
)
().
(,
), , ,
( ), .
,
, 3
4 7080% (, 2000, .123).
.
-
. , , .
- .
, , , ,
.
-,
, , ,
; . , , ,
(,
),
.
-.
, .
,
.
,
.
. 600-
,
. , ,
.
:
,
.
. ,
, .
, .
.
, , ,
.
. : ,
, , , ,
. .
, . -
,
.
- . (Ginters,
1928).
.
..
(, 1954, .112 .). ,
. .. , ,
, . - . ..
, .
..
(, 1971).
, , . , ;
, .
( )
.. . ,
.
,
.
..
: , ,
,
, .
.. .
.
. . ,
.
(Brzezinski, Mielczarek, 2002),
(Mielczarek, 1993; 1999),
(
). . (, , ), .
Man-at-Arms, The Sr
matians
.
(Embleton) (1986) , (1991),
.
(
,
..).
:
, ,
.
- .. (, 2004).
,
.
..:
, ,
(, 1999).
, , .
, -
(. ).
.. (, 1986,
.217 .). , ..
, .
(. )
(,
1986),
.
(Simonenko, 2001).
10
, ,
, .
, ,
( ?) -
.
.
.
.
. ,
,
. .
: .
, , .
. .. - (, 1994;
1999). ,
.
.., .., ..
,
.
.
, .
. .
III.
..
.
(
),
, (, ), ( ),
,
( ,
). ,
(, , -,
, -) () .
:
,
, , . ,
(..4).
,
(Arnut.,
Ursu Naniu, 2000, .351).
.,
. . , ( )
, , ,
.
,
( ) .
(,
1982; -, , 1984),
, ,
(, 1986,
.76, 88, 89). , ,
(, , , 1990,
.124; , 1993, .90; ,
1993, .18; , 1994, .97; ,
1996, .57; , , 2002,
.8587; Brc, 2004, p.41). ,
Eurasia Antiqua
, ,
,
(Simonenko, 2001, S.214,
Funote87). ,
(, 2005,
.94), .
.
- ,
.. (, 1992), .. (, 1996), ..
(, 1990; 1992), .. (, 2000; 2004) (, 1989; 2001; 2004): (IIII. ..), (I II. ..),
( II IV. ..). ,
11
,
.
,
.
( ) ,
. , -
.
,
,
.
: , .
,
:
. (1974), .
(2002). ,
,
: , (2006).
.
, .
19962002. Fulbright Scholar Programm 2004
2005. , , --, ,
-,
, , ,
.
: ,
, -
.
- .
..
, .
. .
.., . . ..,
. . .., - .
.., ..,
..,
.
- . ..
(), .. ( ),
.. (), .. ( ), ..
.. (), ..
(), ..
...
. .
.. ..
. , , , . .
.
19952005 .
1.1.
11 (1).
. , , ,
:
, ,
,
. ; ,
, . :
.
(.1,1,2). ,
33,5 44, 4
5.
,
.
.. ,
,
, ,
: ,
,
,
, , .
.
1
0
2
4
4
8
. 1. .
13
1.
5
1
2
0
2
0
8
1
. 2. (1) (2)
. 3. (1) (2)
:
(.2,1; 3,1).
( .,
1974, .187188) , , , , . .. ,
(,
1971, .6).
.
, . (III. ..)
(, 1963, .19; ,
14
. 4. :
1 ; 2 ; 3 ; 4 .; 5
.
VIV. .. .
,
(, 2007, .106). ,
, ,
,
(.1,4), -
. ,
.
.
,
. ,
, .
,
,
, -
15
. (, 1963,
.18,19), 2- .
,
. ,
III. .., ..
(, 1998, .16),
. , IVII. ..,
.
. : (
12 8,5), , ,
. (.1,2) , , (.1,1).
(, 1963, .34).
.
. 5. (,
, , 2004)
16
1.
, , .
..
0,3 28
.
0,25 . - 0,53
0,55 (,
)
22. ,
0,620,56,
, .
, ,
.
(, , ,
2004, .130136).
- ,
. , .
.
, .
.
11,7 (.5,1).
,
. 12,8, 19,3,
4,22,9 (.5,2).
, ,
,
, -
III.
.. (, 2003, .118).
,
IV
II. .. (, , , 2004, .142).
.
(
, , ,
IV ).
.. IIIII. .. (,
2002, .160), II. .. ( , .159).
IV II. .. ( , .161).
, .. II. ..
, III II, ,
I. ..
, - .
,
,
III II.
.. , .
III. .. (,
1977, .283). .. , ,
IVII. .. (, 1984, .71).
, , .
, , IVIII. ..
,
, , III. ..
(,
, 1990, .84).
, ,
IVIII. .. - , (, 1984, .132).
,
,
(. ..) .
.
.
(.6,1),
. ..
(, 1983, .104),
(, 1991,
.24). (.6,2) ,
. .. (, 1984, .42, 55).
. .. (, 1982,
.65, .14,20).
,
(.6,5). ,
..,
,
. ..
(, 1963, .30), .. .
.. .
17
1.
2
0
4
0
20
40
. 6. :
1 ; 2 ; 3, 7 ; 4, 5 ; 6 (,
, 1994)
(.6,4).
III.
18
,
. ,
.
. , .., ,
,
(, , 1994,
.44, .25). (
13,2) (.6,6)
.
- .
. ..
. , III. ..
(.6,3),
,
- (.6,7).
, ( 1
2), . .. (Godowski, 1977, s.52).
c ,
(.. ) 1
, . .. (Dbrowska, 1988, s.302).
, 2 (
. ..)
( 8)
(ibid., s. 305). . ..
(, 1986, .42). -
. .. (, 1978, .84)
. .. . .. (, 1983, .118).
. ..,
(, 1980, .199).
,
.
..
.
.
. , ,
, , ,
.
.
.
,
(
IVIII III. .., ,
, )
. ,
( )
.
,
.
19
..:
,
(,
1918, .5960). , ..,
.. ..,
, , ..,
-
(, 1998, .144).
, . , ,
.
: , .
.
,
,
,
.
. , ..
,
II. ..
I. .. (, 1966, .158, .XXXIX;
XL) ,
IVIII. ..
20
1.
( ,
,
) .
, IVIII.
.. ,
. (, 1961, .27; , 1963, .34; , 2001, .172),
IV.
.. .. , ( , .3; , .2), ,
(, 2002, .29).
, , . 3 , ..,
(, , 1963, .11,33; , 1963,
.18,1)
.
(, 1963, .33),
.
,
,
(, 1963, .34; ,
2002, .29)
. . (, 2004,
.211214).
, , ,
, , .
...
..
homini est errare, ,
, .
,
(
, ).
..
,
3, VI. .. (, 1998,
.145), . , .
(, 2001, .172),
. . .
.. .. (,
2004, .213214), .
.., ,
( , , ,
, ,
)
.
(?!) IV.
.. (, 2001,
.172). ,
, , IV. ..,
III (
).
, ..
( , ) -
.
-
IV. .. ...
(!)
, , ,
(
),
: , (! ..)
, (!! ..)
(41
44 ), (!!! ..)
(, 2001, .169).
-
..,
.
. ..,
, , (,
2006, .92). ..,
, ..,
IV,
. ..
,
,
, .
, . .. ,
( ),
-
21
. .. ,
(, 1998,
.144). ,
IV. ..
.Quod erat demonstrandum.
IV. ..
, ,
.. (, 2001, .180
197).
.
(, 2001, .190,
.2,6), ,
, . (, 2001, .191, .3,8) ,
..
2004., .. ,
,
. .. , .. ( ,
.3,7).
, .
..
(?! ..) (
)
-, IV. .. .
..
.., -,
-,
, , ( , .183),
. ..
( , .4).
. (-
22
1.
)
(, 2001, .183, .5).
,
.
.., ,
, ( , .68)
,
, . ,
, III II. ..
, ,
( , .184185),
, . ..
,
(,
)
( , .185). ?
,
II.
..,
.
..
, ..,
IV. .. , III.
..
, ,
.., ?
(, 2001, .184).
..
: III. ..
.
.
, , ,
, () . (III. ..)
, , ,
, , .
:
, .
, ,
.
, :
( , .186)?
, ..
, .
,
? , ,
?
? ? ,
,
, ,
. ..
(. ).
, , .
,
.
:
(, ..)
.
.
,
. IVIII. .. , , :
.
.
..:
,
( .. ..)
,
.
.., ,
23
1.
3
1
0
. 7. ( ., 2006)
(, 1998, .149
150).
( )
. .. (, 2004, .216).
, , . ..
,
24
( ? ?
). ,
.
(.8,1), (, 1994, .34).
. 8. (1) (2)
( 1, 2)
25
1.2.
(.8,2) (2).
, . (.9) (.11,1)
(30 35)
(3,5 4).
,
15, 2,7 (,
1983, .232). , (.11,2) .
,
, 10 (.10,2). (6) ,
55
60.
, , 0,5
0,7.
( ).
. ,
.
,
. 89.
. .
:
(,
).
1,5; ,
, . -
1.
,
: ,
.
. ,
(I, 4/8). ..
I. ..
I. .. (, 1960, .20).
(, 1973, .86).
(.12,1) ,
, , (,
1984, .39).
(, 27/4, , 1/4, -V, 1/1), ( ) ( )
.
. .. IVIII. ..,
,
,
(, 1996, .25). ,
. (, .,
)
, (, 1980, .35, .12;13; .83, 15).
,
. 11. (1)
(2) (, 1983)
. 9.
,
.. .
26
,
, ,
.
. 10.
27
1.
. 12. :
1 ; 2
,
(.. ).
, (
) . ,
27 III.
..,
. .. (, 2006, .247).
-IX , , I. ..
,
. 10
,
(, 1975,
.138). (.12,2)
, . .. 10
28
. . .
.
,
.. ..
.. (, 1983, .223),
.
12 (.13).
(,
, 1981, .118) - (, 1984, .45).
III.
.. -2 (, 1985, .195,
.4,25), . .. . ( 1899.,
.57)
(, , 1983, .114).
, ,
10
0
8
6
11
12
. 13. :
1 (-, 1980); 2 ( ); 3 (,
, 1981); 4 ( 1899 .); 5 (, , 1983); 6
(, , 1977); 7 (, 1980); 8 . (, 1985);
9 (, 1998); 10 - (, , 2006); 11 - (,
1978); 12 (, 1966)
29
. 14. :
1 ( ); 2, 3 (
1899.); 3
- ( ), - (, ,
) (, ) (, 1990,
.125126).
( ) () (, 1980, .37).
( IV. ..),
. ..
(, 2001, .211212,
.58,13), (, 1978, .122, .4)
30
1.
, ,
. ( .., )
..
(.14,3).
, III. .. (, 1993, .70) . ,
.. , . , -,
, -,
, ,
.., .
III. .. ..
- -2.
,
de visu .. .
.. ,
- .
, , ,
..
.., -
(, 1993, .70).
(.13,2).
III.
.. . ,
, , ..:
.
.
, .
.. ,
(, 1990,
.126). ,
.
. .. (
, 1978, .122), .. . , ,
-
.
(, 1994,
.5559; , 1994, .60).
, , ,
.
,
- . ..
(, 1993, .151). ,
. -,
31
. -,
, .
, , ,
. (
) , - .
.. ..,
() (, , 2006, .37).
, :
- ,
.
:
(.13,7). - : , .
1.3.
.
74 (3). 20 , ,
,
. -
32
1.
.
. : ,
, , ,
(.15). 59 ,
( ), 51 .
. ,
(., ). ,
,
, , -
.
20 30,
3 4 (.16). 35 50.
( 66% ), ,
.
( 50
60) . ..
. 1951.
59 (.17,2), 85
1 5 II (.17,1),
61,5,
. .
(.17,3), 14
. . (,
1887, .4041).
1
5
2
. 15. :
1 , 7/10; 2 -, 66/1; 3 -, 63/1; 4 , 1/2;
5 , .12
33
1.
1
0
. 16. .
. ..
, 1,25 ( 89. ..); , ,
. .. (
,
),
, ,
.
4,
.
,
(
) . ,
34
. 17. :
1 , . ., 5/1 ( .,
1960); 2 , . , 3/1;
3 , . .; 4 , 26/1
. 18. ,
. , 2/2 (1947.)
,
, ,
,
-. (3,5)
II, 5/112.
(66,5) .
12
, .
. 19. :
1, 1 ; 2 ; 3, 3
, ..;
4, 4 ; 5
: , 1/1, ,
1947., 2/1 (.18).
, 0,71.
,
. (.19,15),
,
0,40,5.
35
1.
1
2
3
4
4
5
6
6
2
1
. 20. - :
1 - (, 1962); 2 ,
10/1 (, , 1999); 3 , 4/4
(, , 2003)
(, 1287 1288)
. ,
.
. , 113.
13
.
(, 1983, .44).
36
. 21.
: ,
, 0,2
0,3 (.19,1,3,4).
,
.
11,5
. 5
7 .
- ,
10
11
0
10
11
4
. 22.
37
2
0
5
0
. 23. :
1 , . . ;
2 , . , 1/1; 3 , 4/1; 4, 5
(.20,1).
(,
), , , .
.
. ,
(.21).
,
( , ).
38
1.
( 1288 ),
.
,
. , ,
8.
.
: ,
, 3, , (22,5)
. , - . , ..
. ,
, , ,
. ,
, .
.
.. ..
(?) ,
, . (.23,1).
.. , ,
(.22,2). , ,
.
.
(.22,1,3). , .
.
5,
0,5 1.
, .
. ( ) (.24,1)
I, 3/18
(.24,2) II
I. .. (, 1960, .20).
, , ,
.
-
I. ..
, I
II. ..
I. ..
,
.
I
II. .. I. .. -, 32/1 (
1- I,
..) -, 43/1
( ).
I. .. , , , , (, 29/1; , - , 2/1;
, 1/1; ,
.., 1/1; II, 10/1;
5/1). , 1/10 (.20,2),
I II.
..
70.
2
0
1
0
. 24. I,3/18:
1 ; 2
,
.
II
( , 2/1),
II. .. (, 1954, .232). ,
, (, 1998,
.7172; , , 2003, .301),
, (.20,3).
39
,
-.
, ,
, ,
,
. , ,
. , .
( II III. ..) (, 1988, .109110).
. (.25,3)
(.25,1,2), - (, 1987, .172; ., 1995, .114117).
, - ,
(, 1975, .24).
(Brc, 1999, p.110).
,
, .
.
(jszilvs)
(.25,5)
(Istvnovits, Kulczr, 2001,
p.151). .. IV.
.. - (Gva-Ka
tnahalom) (.25,4):
IIIII. (Istv
novits, Kulczr, 2001, p.151).
40
1.
.. , II. ..
(, 2005, .171185). 12,
( II, 1/13,14;
, 3/12; V, 1/6;
, 19/17; , 19/26).
.
..,
II. ..,
III. ..
(, 2005,
.182).
, .
, II. ..,
. ..
. .. .., ,
,
. , -,
.
-,
(. ..)
. ,
,
... , , - ,
. ..
.
. 25. :
1, 2 ; 3 (, 1987); 4 - (Istvnovits, Kulcsr, 2001);
5 (Tari, 1994)
41
1.
, , , ,
I. .. (,
2005, .181).
.. (, 1971, .89),
.
.. ,
. , ,
, , (, 2005, .182).
,
(.26,1).
,
. ,
, -
.
1.4.
2
42
: ( 100)
, . -
,
, .
, ,
, . 154 (.26,2; 4).
,
(, 1971, .15). ,
, ,
, .
.
.. - : 1-
; 2- ,
; 3- ,
;
4- ; 5-
(, 1971,
.17). 4- (
, )
,
.
.
1-
(4).
. (Simonenko, 1997, S.393).
,
, . , . . 81,3,
4,2, 18, 3
, 1,8 (.27,1).
.
. -
43
,
, (.27,1).
,
,
, .
(.44,3). , (, 1986,
.100,). ,
,
, (. ).
. ,
, 14.
..
(,
2000, .177). ,
.
(I, --, VI,
-, , 11/1, ,
2/3). .. 2128 (,
2000, .171).
(21)
(, .. 1981.).
1
0
10
. 27. - 1- :
1, 1 ; 2
44
1.
14
(
) . , (?!) .
,
.
,
, , .
1
0
10
. 28. - 2- :
1 ; 2 -, 37/1; 3 -, 40/1; 4 ;
5
45
(78,6)
.
: , , ,
, , (.27,2).
, , , .
, ,
(
., 1981, .160161). ,
,
:
.
, ..
.:
(, 1908, .131). 1-
. ..
(, ,
),
.
.
.
2- , ,
, .
,
. , . .
, 100,
2
(, 1969, .249). .,
46
1.
4
0
15
. . ,
(, , 2003, .294):
, ,
.
1
0
. 29 (). - 2:
10
. 30. - 2:
1, 2 ; 3 -, 1/22
1 ; 2 ; 3 ; 4
, 4/4 (, , 2003)
47
1.
3
1
4
0
. 31. -:
1, 5, 6 ; 2 ; 3 (, , 1990); 4
(, 1952)
, , 8 (, -, 1/1) 1415
(-, 37/1).
2-
.
2-
14. 8
, ,
. (, ) ,
, .
1- 2- ,
, .
, 3/9, , 2/3, , , 9/1.
48
. .
(, 1999, .210).
(sic!) 2,4
0,8,
(.31,4). , ,
, .
9 (
, , 1999, .177179, .2,15).
. ,
.
, , , , ,
. , , .
. .
,
(
).
,
(.31,2).
(, , 1999,
.186). , 317,
17
(, , 1999, .179,
.2,9) 2-.
de vizu (.32,2) ,
3-.
.
,
, -
-.
.. - , ..
(, 1971, .21). .. -
(, 2000, .169).
, ..
,
.
.
,
() . ,
,
(, .9, , .11, , .45) (,
) .
(53,9) (.29,2). (
2-)
. .. (, 1988, .103).
,
.
3- - ( 90)
49
1.
0
1
. 32. - 3- :
1 ; 2 , 9/1; 3 , 16/1
50
10
(6) (.32). ,
, , .
2-, , ,
,
.
3- , ( , , , ).
(Podobed,
Simonenko, 1998, p.99).
, . 3- :
88, 7,
, .
, ,
, 11,5, 3, 2.
(.32,1).
5- , -
(.33).
( , , , ,
.181)
3-. ..
20 ,
(,
1971, .116117).
56 , , , ,
(Soupault, 1996, .60
72).
,
(, - ).
,
, - .
5- 40, 5. 50 .
, .., , (,
1971, .24). , ,
(,
?).
.. (ukin, 1991, .14).
,
, 5-
.
,
(
,
) ,
.
,
.
.. ,
,
, .
..,
.., , 5-
, .. . ..
(, 2002, .43).
.. (, 2006, .193).
.. 5- (
51
1.
3
1
. 33. - 5- (, 2002)
52
,
) ,
(, 2004, .4147)18.
, .
-,
,
, IV. ..
. -,
5-
: ,
. -,
5-
.
..
;
(.34). .. ,
5- (,
2006, .193). ..
( ) . .. (, , 2006,
.146147). ,
5-
, , ,
.
.., . ...
18
. . (2006, .192)
. . , .
. 34.
5- (, 2006)
(, , 2006, .139141, 143).
,
, .
,
, .
,
. ,
,
. ,
; , .
5-,
-, (, , 1971, .2,18)
2-
. 5-
.
, - -
53
, 5-
( ., 2006, .119, .6,2).
, , -,
. , 5-
. 35.
54
1.
,
. ( , )
.
, - .
,
5
,
- ,
,
( ., 2006, .119).
,
, . (, ,
1999), ,
-.
5-
V
VI. I .
, ,
( ,
.119120). 5- :
.
(.35).
,
. ,
,
. .
.
-
,
.
..
(, --, -IV, -VI)
40
, .. . ,
(
), .
.
,
,
.
: ,
. ,
, ..
.
. ,
.
.. (, 1974, .280).
, VIVII.
-
,
(, 1966, .72).
. ,
- . ,
.
.
1- . (III.
..)
( ,
)
. .. (,
1999, .221) .. (, 2000, .1724). ,
.
..,
.
, .
. ..
( , .2729). ..
: 1-
(, 1971,
.19). :
.
, 1
.
. ,
.
1-
(I II. ..),
. ,
55
.
..
51 2 -.
..
(, 2000, .18), ..
(, 1999, .221).
. ,
.
, .
I. ..
1- () ,
(
), .
.. (, 2000, .169193).
, ,
, .
,
, , .
, .. ,
56
1.
(, 2000, .177),
,
-
, .
, 1-
. - , . , ,
: ( )
,
. ,
(.: , .179).
. , ,
. .. , . , , .
.
,
1148. , .
1- II III. .. (, , , , ).
. ,
.
2-
. . ..
1-,
. ,
, 1- 2-
( ,
). I
II. .. , 1- 2- , , -, 37/1, .
,
,
I. ..
( . ..) 2-
. ,
-, 1/22, (, 1993, .86),
(, , 1984, .34,
37, 44),
(, 1987, .172).
2- , (
IV. ..). ,
3
, IV. ..,
(.36,2), 3-, -
40
80
3
2
0
10
. 36.
( ., 1983)
57
, ,
(. 4).
2-
.
, , , (, 1993, .98), .
3-, .., IIIIV.
.. (, 1971, .20). ,
- (
65, 10)
, 16/1 (.37,1).
2- (, , 1992,
.2,2), (,
1993, .16, .4,2).
, - ,
..
.. ...
( ),
(.37,2). ,
1-, 2-, 3-.
,
- II. .. (, 1991,
.24). , .. - .
, .
3- I. ..
(, 1990, .132; , 1979, .262).
..
.
58
1.
3-,
. , , , . ,
.
3-
III IV. ..
2 , III. ..
(, 1966, .62). 3-
IV. (, 1998, .129131).
3-
(, 1963, .19, 25, 37, 41).
3- (5 ) .
, , ,
(Biborski,
1978, S.5365). 3- ,
,
.
, ,
. .
..
.
-
3-, . 3-
,
. 37. :
1 ; 2
59
1.
3
1
. 38.
, .
3-
.
IIIIV. (,
2001, .89). (-
60
F) 5-.
IV. , ,
, .
. -
1.5.
,
.
.
. ,
.
.
, .
-
.
. ,
,
.
(.22).
(.23,3)
-, 4/1.
-VIII, 1/11, .
,
1/1,
,
(.23,2).
. ,
.
, , , ,
( , 8/1, 6/1; ,
- , 1/1, 2/3;
, 1/1; , 29/1).
61
. 39. ( ..)
62
1.
in situ
.
, . ,
.
,
. . ,
,
8- .
; ,
(.39).
,
, . ,
.
, , (.40).
,
.. .
( , ); ,
, .
,
, .. (, 1971, .2627),
(Trousdale, 1975, .38109)
.. (, 2000, .177
178),
.
,
,
,
,
, (.41)
- ().
, ,
, D16 -
(.42), .
. 40.
63
1.
1
4
2
64
(
) . (V. ..)
. ,
, .
. , ,
..-,
,
(.44,4).
,
(Trousdale, 1975, .112).
..
(? ?)
.
- ,
( .
..) ,
(, 1998, .88). ,
, .
I. .. (
,
). (
) ( II III. ..).
, .
. 42. D 16 -
(Rau, 1927)
65
1.
. 43. :
1 (Trousdale, 1975); 2, 3
(2 . . ; 3 . . ); 4
( , , )
, 19, , .
19
(, 1998, .33).
66
-
(.43,1).
, .
. , , ,
.
..,
,
, ,
, , , , , (, 2000, .177178).
,
, 2/3 (.31,5,6).
, ,
. -
,
(.38,2,3),
. ,
:
, ,
(.36,3,4).
.. (, 1998, .34,
.3) ,
(.43,2).
. , ,
.
,
.
(.43,3).
( )
, ,
.
, -
(.43,4). ,
? 20
. , :
.
(, 1971, .27; ,
2000, .175). ( VII, 14/3, ,
80/3) .
,
, , , .
: ,
.
,
, .
, ,
,
. ,
20
4 5 . (,
1992, .250).
, . .
67
1.
, (.44,5,79)21.
,
,
70 80-.
. .. -
- , (, 1982,
.35 ; , , 1991, .83
88).
,
,
(
, 1986, .72, .101, 9,
101).
2 . ..
, ,
, ( , .43, 45).
, ,
( , .112,
10,100). , ,
, .
,
. ..,
, 2
,
. ,
, , ,
(.44,2).
(. 44, 10).
1-
. . .
,
( ). , ,
(), (?)
. ,
,
.
10
4
9
. 44. (, 1986):
1 . ; 2 ; 3, 3 ;
4, 4 ; 5 ; 69 ; 10
68
21
-
.
69
2.
2.1. ()
,
. , () .
IV (, 1971, .44): .
,
..,
, :
, ( , .73)?
, -
- ( ) .
(. Spear) ,
; (. Lance)
; (. Javelin)
.
, , , 1812.
.
70
.. :
,
,
(, 1971,
.44). ,
.
,
.
(. )
,
,
. .. ,
, ,
( ,
.45). ,
. , -
: , (.
5).
.
.. .
,
(Simonenko,
2001, S.206209), . , ...
, ,
, .
1. . , ,
14 10 , 24 . :
23 () 26 ()
4
3
2
0
. 45. 1:
1 ; 2
. 46.
(, 1951)
2/3 (.45).
( )
, .
. .
II. .. .,
2/4, , 1/12 (, 1996,
.291, 323, .71, 17, 18; 103, 3, 4).
..
1-
(, 1984, .92).
59 - (.46,2), IIII. .., .. 1- (,
1951, .182, .12,2).
,
. 1-
.. ,
, ,
.
71
2.
. 47. 2:
1 ; 2 ; 3
72
2. .
, . :
2 ,
(.47).
,
()
(; .48).
2025, 2,5,
16 () 20,5 () . ( )
, .
,
. ,
.-
(Jakounina-Ivanova, 1927,
.109). ,
, ,
. ,
1- (.
). , 1 2 ,
.
2b , 1/3
(.49,13). ,
. 20
25, 3 4,
910. .
, .
. 48.
73
2.
10
11
. 51.
. 49. 2 3:
2: 1, 2 ; 3 ; 3: 4 ; 5 ; 6 ; 7, 9, 10 ,
.58; 8 , . 203; 11 , .59 (710 , 2002)
.
3. . ,
; (.49,47).
, . 2025, 34;
(6 5) -
.
( 17)
(.50,3).
,
.
, ,
1
/3 . -
74
5 10. , -
. ,
(.51).
58
203 (7 6)
(.49,8,9).
4. (?) , . 58 59 (.49,10, 11).
,
, ,
58.
. 50. :
1 ; 2 (,
, 1997); 3
3 4
. : ,
2? ,
, , .
. 52.
( )
75
,
,
.
: ,
(, 1971,
.4748).
,
(Valer. Flacc,
VI.162). , , ,
.
I. ..
, (?) , , (.52).
2.2.
,
,
. ,
: ,
, , , .
10 (.50,1).
IV.
..,
.
,
, . , .. (.46,4).
3
3 .
76
2.
. .. (, 1988, .53).
4
( ..) 2
(, 1979, .160164, .1).
1 2,
(,
),
,
,
( ?)
(.53).
.. . .., , . ..
( ),
. . ..
. ..
. IV
. ..
. .. .
,
VIII.
,
; -
, , .
, , , , ,
.
.
.. (, , 2005, .52),
VIII () I
5
7
8
0
. 53. (, 1979)
77
. ..
. .., .. .
, ,
. ..
()
. (Srbu, Haruche, 2000, .150, fig.6, 7;
, , 2002, .89, .1,5).
2 . .. . ..
2 1 .
. , (.50,2).
,
2.
, .
10,
3,8 (.54,1).
. ..
(,
1966, .23).
1520, 812,
1,52, . . , .
.. ,
. ,
.
. ,
10 (, , 1994, .25, 244/1)
,
,
(Hviszdyrk)
(.54,2). ,
(Dinnys, 1991, .156), , ,
,
. ,
,
.
2.3.
1
2
0
. 54. :
1 ; 2 (Dinnys, 1991)
78
. (. ..)
1 2 .
, ,
,
.
2b
(), . 3-: - (, ), . . ..
3- (, 1983, .62) (, 1908, .162),
. .. - ( .,
1987, .126), ( ..).
2 3.
.
3 4
, IV. ..,
(, 2002, .70). ,
4- , IV VI.
.. (, , 1982, .126).
, ,
I. .. 10
I II. .. (,
, 1994, .37),
II. ..
(Dinnys, 1991, .186).
2.4.
, 4,5,
(, 1954,
.117; , 1971, .182;
) .. (, 1914, .330331).
.
,
? ,
.
.. (, 2004).
.
, . , ..
:
, ,
, , ,
, ,
( , 3, .99).
, , , ,
.
. .
.
.. (, 1977, .117).
,
, , , ,
(
).
79
, ..
,
- , .
.
,
35 (
). (
) 217.
- ,
.
, , ,
, , ..
70 ! , .
, .
, , .. :
3,5,
.. (, 2004, 4,
.89). , : , ,
(Dixion, Southern, 1992,
p. 50). ?
80
2.
.., . ( - ,
)
,
( , .9096)
.
,
. ,
( ), ,
.
.
, .
1986. ,
. .
, , . , in situ,
(. . ,
),
(-1, 6/5),
(, 253/2; , 2/4),
(, 12/1), (
-2, 17/1; , 3/7; ; - , 9/1),
, 1985.
(III , 2/1).
7 ,
, (, 1971,
.45),
( ,
.186).
21
,
. . , . , , , , 175180.
2,5
( 2,65,
).
,
,
,
,
.
,
..,
. : ,
.
.
3,1
3,2 (, 1984, .234).
,
.
,
, ,
4,5 (Junkel
mann, 1992, S.146). -
2.5.
?
..
(, 2001) ,
.
81
, ,
.. (
.: , 1999, .7576).
: ,
,
,
(
).
: (
) , , .
. , ,
, .
,
.
VI
IV. .. .. (1984, .5975). ,
.
( ):
, , , . ,
(
),
, , : ,
, (, 2000, .359).
82
2.
, ,
. ,
(Markle,
1977, .333339)
,
,
(Junkelmann, 1992,
S.144) (Hy
land, 1993).
, ( 15, ..
4,5)
(Markle, 1977, .334336).
, . ,
the Macdonians managed
the cavalry lance with only ne hand (ibid.,
.336). ,
..,
,
(.) .
, , , ,
(. ).
, . .., , ,
.
4,5.
, :
(Junkelmann, 1992, S.144)
., ..,
.
. !
,
,
(! ..) 1
. , ,
,
: , , ,
(.55).
,
(.56,2).
, ,
,
.
,
(.56,1).
,
IV. ..,
III. .. , ,
.
, , , (, 2007,
.154). - , . . (Dixon, Southern, 1992, p. 4950),
,
. ,
, . , (Coulston, 1986, p. 65) -
83
2.
. 56. :
1 ; 2 . ; 3
, . ,
. ,
,
.
, .
,
,
- .
Alternatively, it may be that without any historical
precedent this style had simply not developed (Dixon,
Southern, 1992, p. 50).
84
, , , . Aposse ad esse .
...
, ?
, ,
,
.
. ,
, : ,
. -
40- , .
, 3,5- 10. .., ,
(, 2007,
.153, .75) ? , ,
,
.
, ,
.
,
. , , ,
, , ,
( 30/). ,
, ,
11. , ( ),
10
..
, ,
(.. . ..) .
.. :
; , ,
.
11
, , , ,
.
.
, : (, ) ,
. ,
, ,
: .
(,
) .
: , . ,
.. :
, ,
(, 2007, .155).
( , .154),
,
.
.. .
(, , ) ,
, (.
: Markle, 1977, .334).
.,
, :
( . ..)
.
,
, . ,
, , ,
85
2.
. 57.
45.
. ,
.
( ), ,
. , ( . ..)
, , (, 2005, .90).
,
,
?
.. .. ,
:
, , ,
(,
, 1987, .210). ,
86
(.57),
(.58),
( !) (.59)
(, ).
(.60, 61), (,
2000, .169),
, . (, ) ,
. (, 1997,
.177).
,
, ,
I.
..,
I. ..
,
.
, ,
.
(.63)
, .
(galop allonge).
. 58. ()
87
2.
. 63. (, 1980)
. 61.
(I Tesori, 2005)
. 62.
( )
(canter)
(Reinach, 1925, .612).
,
, ,
, .
, , -
.
, , , ( , )
, (, 1975, .8889).
(?) ..
88
(.62):
, , ,
,
.
: -
1841. (. .6).
. ,
, ..
.
, ,
, ,
.
, , ( - ) (
),
, .
-
. 64.
( .)
89
. .
,
, , ,
,
(.64).
.. .. .. (..
)
.
. ,
. (-
90
, 2007, .150152), ,
, . , , ..,
. ,
, (
.. , ).
, ,
.
(. . 5).
3.1.
,
,
. , ,
,
,
. ..
(, 1982,
.17). ( )
VIIIII. .. .. (,
1980, .75). , , :
. ,
.
. 8 ( .,
1961, .103). .
I. .. . (Simonenko, 1997, S.392). ,
, , -
85 ( ). .
1984. 1 1 . (, , 1984,
.1214).
, . in situ.
.
(.65,5).
32
(.65,1,2).
. (.65,3,4).
in situ
2
0
3
2
. 65. :
1, 2 ; 35
91
,
.
,
120.
,
.. ,
, , (, 1986, .26 .).
.
( , .27, .2).
,
.
-
(Bar-Hill) (, 1971, .33, .17,
10), .
.
, , , .
. ,
-
( ).
c ,
, .
,
, -
92
3.
.
, . ,
, .
,
.
. , ..,
1 (, 1986, .26) ,
. , ,
.
, , ...
, , , ,
,
, ,
,
.
, . . .
:
11 3,
(, ,
) 15 2. , . ,
1-, .. . ,
, . , , ,
,
( ) .
, (, 1971, .33).
I. ..
. . ,
. ,
, .
, .
(Werner)
,
. ,
, ( II I. ..) () .
I. ..
,
- .
.
I. .. ,
.-, 29/1
(.66,1) , 51/1
(.66,2).
. 26
,
, .
1 7
(.66,4) -
II
III. ..
,
: 11/2 36/1
(.66,3). 28
.
,
, .
6
0
. 66.
:
1 . -, 29/1 (, ,
1994); 2 , 51/1 (, 1971); 3 , 36/1; 4 , 7/1 (, 1959);
5 VI, 16/8 (, 1988);
6 , 2 (, 1971)
93
II III. .. VI (.66,5). .
(.66,6), , , , .
,
( , 51/1, , 29/1, ,
7/36, VI, 16/8, , 1/1, .) ,
5 8,
33,5. ,
.
(
) .. (, 1971, .38).
I
III. ..
.
I. .. ..
200 33,4, .. (Simonenko, 1997,
S.392, 397).
II. ..
, , , ,
.
I. ..
. , ,
,
.
94
3.
,
, ( !), .
100 , 10
.
1
3.2.
,
.
.. (, 1971, .3637).
.
7
10
11
12
17
18
1.
1.
. , ,
2, 10,7,
2,5 1,8
(.67,14).
2.
.
,
. 2, 0,5, 2 (.67,5).
3. - .
2, ,
(.67,6).
1- (,
, , ) -
13
14
15
16
. 67. :
: 15 ; 6 (, 1984); : 7 ,2/1;
8, 12 , 7/2; 9 , 5/1; 10 ; 11 , . ., 2/1;
13 , 21/1; 14, 17, 18 , 14/1; 15 , 11/1; 16 -, 2/1
95
, (III. ..)
(
, 1990, .139). I. ..
(, 1986, .80)
(, 1972, .23; ,
1985, .196).
(, 1988, .67) (, 1992, .177). , ,
, I. .. III I.
.. (, , 1990, .8687;
, 1991, .24).
2- ( ) 1- 2- ().
.
( ). ..
, , (, 1988, .58).
,
, ,
- ..
.. -
(, 1965, .84).
3- ()
. .. ,
. .
.3 -
(, 1961, .26), I
II. .. ,
: .
96
3.
IVIII. .. (,
1984, .89). , , - . ..
IVIII. .. (, 1982, .71).
, . , ..,
, , . .. ,
(, 1963, .31).
, , .
II
I. .. (, , 1990,
.86).
2.
,
.
:
1. ,
. 2 ,
1. (41,8),
(.68,1).
1-
(, 1971, .38),
,
IIIII. ..
III. ..
(, 1965, .78, 81).
. 68.
97
I. ..
. , , - (Sarianidi,
1985, p.251).
.
2. ,
(.67,716; 68,2).
, .
3,5
1,5, 1,3 1.
, . 2-
, , , . 11 (, 1986,
.6567).
1 (5 .) 5, 1,7.
(.68,2).
2 ( 70 .) 3,5, 1,3.
,
(.67,7).
3 (6 .)
3,5, 1.
(.67,8).
4 (75 .)
3, 1,5. , . ,
(.67,9).
5 (55 .)
3, 1,2.
3- ,
. ,
(.67,10).
6 (46 .) , 2,5, -
98
3.
1,2. (.67,11).
7 ( 30 .) 2,5, 0,8.
,
,
, (.67,12).
8 (7 .)
2, 1,3. ,
. ,
(.67,13).
9 (4 .) 1,8, 1.
,
, ,
(.67,14).
10 (73 .)
1,5, 1,2. ,
(.67,15).
11 ( 10 .) 1,5, 1,4.
,
(.67,16).
3. ,
(.67,17,18).
(11,5)
6- 7- 2-.
, .
4. ,
, - (.68,3).
(.69), , ( 200.)
.
,
2,5, 1,5, -
1, 3.
. ,
1-,
. .. (,
; , 1965, .82, .7,
11, 12).
.
5. (.68,4). .
,
,
. . 4,7, 2,5,
2,5, 4.
.120
, 3- .
. ..
(, , , 1991,
.121).
. 69. ( . . )
99
,
- (, 1983,
.82). (-) (
.) II I. ..
.
(, 1986, .32,
.5, 14, 16, 26), .
,
. , ,
,
. ..
6. (.68,5).
(10.).
, 2,5 3,
0,5 0,9,
3. ,
.. ,
.
.. .. -
.
7. (.68,6).
.
,
,
. 3,
1,8. ,
. ,
, .
27- 2-
3,5 2,5:
100
3.
72,2%
; 812-
27,3%.
,
2,53,5,
. .
(,
1964, .16).
, ,
:
(.67,718).
, ,
. , ( ,
)
.
,
, . .
-
.
,
-.
. 200 ..
(82) 1 .. 1 2 60.
,
, 32., , 7/2, 19., ,
. , 2/2, 24., , , 12/2, 20., -, 14/4, 21. 10 15 -, 3/1,
3.3.
,
,
. ,
( ., 1961, .44).
,
.
:
., (I. ..) (I. ..).
50, 0,5, .
,
-
.
60,
.. .
?
3.4.
6 .
.
, 5010.
,
.
.
, . (. ,
2/1) .
.
60 .
2
.
(, 1954, .45).
,
82,
101
(, 1973, .86).
116 ( )
,
. . -
- -
3.
- (Simonenko,
1997, S.394, Abb.4,4, 7, 8). ,
,
-
.
, , ,
. , ,
- (3/1
8/1) ,
, . ,
.
,
. .
, - ( ) .
3.5.
. 70. ( . . )
102
( I
II. ..) ,
.., , .
10,84,6
(.70). (?) , in
situ, .
,
, . (, 1961, .36, .9,3
4). , , ,
. 71. :
1 ( .); 2, 3 , (Rawson, 1995)
103
,
.
104
3.
(. 71, 2, 3).
,
(
-)
(James,
1987, p.78).
. ,
1-, , ,
:
.
3.6.
. ..
(, , 1990, .87). ,
.
I. .. (, 1991,
.24).
I. ..
, ,
(, 1954, .236, 238;
, 1952, .47). ( II, . , VII/1;
-, 2/1; , 11/1) II. ..
.
. . .
.
105
. ,
II. .. ,
. -
.
, (
)
. 2-
II. .. IV.
.. 6-
- ,
.
,
;
(.72,2).
,
.
. ,
. ,
,
- . , (, 1994; 1999,
.159190; , 1986; 1989, .78
80; Simonenko, 2001, S.268280), ,
,
.
i . ,
(
1896., .215).
,
-. ..
II. .. 15 . (, 1984, .9091, .3/15,8, 25)
I III. ..
.:
(, 1992, .244273).
106
, , .
.. - .
..,
.
.
, , , (, 1978, .79). (, ,
)
,
:
.
, .
.., 1 1 .
(,
1960, .136). ,
. ,
29 (, 1963,
.108).
. ,
, .
,
.
, in situ,
.
,
, - . ,
.;
107
, , . : 90%
( ) ..,
- .
, .
,
, , ( ) .
,
.
4.1.
: , ,
, .
,
. . ,
. 64 (7).
, VIIIV. ..
,
III. ..
(
)
. ,
18
108
4.
. .
.
-
.
2
1
, . , , 3
,
(1018,
667 352). .
.. (,
1984, .86).
4
0 2 4 ,
. 73. :
1 , 7/6 (, 1971); .
2 , 11/9; 3 , 41/1; 4 ,
, 55/1 (, 1959)
0,5
(.74,3). - . 3,51, .
(, 1968, .131)
III (, 1971,
.XIII,2). .., , ,
, . ..
,
VIIIVII. ..,
- ,
,
3
1
:
18 IVIII. ..
(, 1987, .22). 0 1 2
2
,
III. .., . 74.
(, 1981)
109
. 75. (1)
(2)
91.
, , ,
32, 82. , , 20002, 28002.
48002.
6070
( ), ,
-
110
4.
, . .
,
.
,
.
. ,
.
( ),
(
, ), .
. ,
, (.58). , (.75,2),
,
100- .
.
, I.
..
. , , . ,
lorica segmentat . ,
. . (, 1987, .21).
3
0
. 76. :
1 . (, , 1989); 2 . (, 1901); 3
(, 1979)
.
.
.
IV. .. (,
1961, .75). ,
. (, 1978, .33; , 1957, .35;
., 1979, .167). ..
(, 1959,
.462).
.
, .
, .
.
, , ,
.
,
,
(.76).
.
111
2,51,5,
,
,
.
,
112
4.
, ,
. , ,
(Newstead), (Autdorp),
(Augsburg) (Robinson, 1975,
.173).
,
.. .
(, 1968, .30). ,
, .
(Watson, 1983, .18), , ,
(.77). ,
.
lorica plumata
(Simonenko,
2001, S.272). I. ..
I. .. (Palazzo
Ducale), (.78,1),
(.78,2). , ,
.
. , I. ..,
,
4847.
.. ,
,
, . ,
I. .. , , ,
I. . ..
, .
, , ,
(.79).
(
, ):
(, 2/1; ,
12/1, 15/1; , 16/1),
(,
1/1; , 1/1, 3/1, 10/1; ,
. . ..
.. .. .
26/1). . ,
(.79,4).
(.80), I II. .. (Ro
binson, 1975, p.154, pl.159). ,
( ),
,
, .
175. .. 8. , 5,5.
113
4.
11
13
12
14
15
10
16
17
20
18
21
23
22
19
25
28
29
26
27
3
4
30
I
7
5
0
III
IV
31
. 79. :
.
, .
(10,7), .
II
VI
114
24
(.79,6). ,
(.81,1). (, 2/1, 8/1, 17/1, 19/1, 20/1,
, 40/1, 51/1; -
VII
VIII
32
33
34
IX
35
37
36
38
115
4.
2
1
. 81. . 40
. (, 1902)
116
3
2
0
0
5
. 83. . ,
17/1
. 84. . ,
20/1
. 82.
. , 2/1
, (,
. ..)
,
,
(.81,3).
. .
, , ..
. , , , , ,
1
1
2
0
3
3
0
. 85. :
1 . , 26/1 (, , 1994);
2 . , 28/1; 3 . , 3/1
. 86. . ,
51/1
117
4.
. 87. . ,
(. . )
.
. . (,
118
1902, .129) .. (,
1971, .6061).
, .,
, . , , . ,
,
(.: :
,
; :
). , .
.
.
(.87). :
.
, 2/1, 8/1, 17/1, 19/1, 20/1, , 40/1, ,
26/1, 28/1, , 15/1. (
,
) : , ,
,
,
, . ,
. .
,
. , ,
. ,
, , , . -
,
,
(Robinson, 1975,
.153, pl.434).
, ,
: ,
. . , .
, . , 187
. ,
:
,
,
. .
9,5, 12 16
. ,
.
(.88).
-, , , (, 1971, .57, 6061; Ro
binson, 1975, .186). ,
manica segmentata (.89),
.
, .
- , , .
119
4.
1
. 89. -:
1 ; 2, 3
. 88.
(. . )
I II. ..
(, , 1994, .37).
, ,
-
120
- ( ) .
, ,
,
,
. .
, -
, 1901.
. , .
.
. (.1,
1901, .103, .54) 40 .
(.81,3),
.
- ( ).
, .
40 .
. ,
121
(, .1, 8, 9; , .1, 3,
10, 15). 9 .
-
5 7,54 (.90,3).
9 ..
(.91, 1) 33
-
(, , 1987, .9294,
.9, 10).
3
4
. 90.
., 9/1 (, , 1994)
122
4.
,
.
15
(, 1984, .91, .3,25).
, . , ,
S (.92). ,
;
( ),
;
0,5. ,
, .. .
,
,
.
, , (, , 1987, .144,
.4).
: , ,
,
(.91).
:
.
,
1
0
. 91. :
1 - (, , 1987); 2 ; 3
(, -, 1999)
123
4.
4
0
. 92. . , 15/1
. 93. (. . )
124
. 94.
(, , 1997)
.
(, -, 1999, .49, .2,6;
4,3, 4).
,
( )
I. ..
I. ..
(, , ) .
, .
. 95.
(, 2003)
, ,
, ,
XIX.
III. .. (.93).
(.94, 95)
, .
125
(
, , 1997; , 1998).
,
,
(Robinson, 1975,
.162).
(?) -
4.
..
(.62).
,
, .
( ).
1. . ,
-
. 98. :
1 ; 2 ..
(Robinson, 1975)
. 96. :
1, 2 . , 51/1; 3
, 44/1
126
. 97.
(Robinson, 1975)
. .
40 . , ,
.
, ,
, , ,
. 1
., 44
, 51 .
(.96). 1 .
. 1 . -
.
2 . (
., 1985, .230).
( ) ,
, .
.
II.
.. (.97),
, . , ,
127
4.
(Robinson,
1975, .164). (II.
..)
( 10 )
(Polyb., VI, 23, 15).
I. .. . ,
(.98,1), .. (.98,2) . ,
,
I. ..
(.99, 100)
III. .. .
. . ,
.
128
. 100. ()
. 101. ( )
I
(, 1918, .1314; , 1971, .52; , 2000, .312, .II,
1) (, , 1999, .126, .4,2)
.
(.102),
(, 2000, .314).
(muscle quirass),
.
, .
.
, .
,
.
II I. .. ,
I
,
.
129
4.
.
III. .. (Robinson, 1975,
.147).
.., ,
. ,
(ibid., .16,
147). -.
. , ,
,
,
, .
-
. , (. ..)
(Strabo, VII, 3).
:
, ,
,
(Paus., ll., I, 21, 5). (., Hist.,
I, 79) :
( . ..).
1
0
16
. 102. :
1 I (, 2000); 2 , 4/1 (, , 1999)
, , -
,
.
. -
130
VIIV. .. (, 1968,
.130). , , .
131
132
4.
.
,
,
; ,
,
. ,
.
4.2.
.., .., .., .., .., .. .
,
(Schrder), (Robinson), (Wau
rick), (Coarelli), (Schaaff) .
: , , , ,
- ( ) .
, .
7 (8)
(.104,2).
: ,
; ,
;
. ( ), .
(Schrder,
133
4.
0
0
. 105. ( )
(Dintsis, 1986, S.59).
..
134
10
2
. 106. (, 1968):
1 ; 2
. . ,
(.105).
,
,
.
(.106,2). 2723.
-
, , . ,
- ,
.
. (.107). 2622 (, 1941, .157
158).
18
(.108,1),
(.108,2),
(.108,3),
(.108,4) (, 1981,
.94100)
( ..).
: (, 1997, .7374, .1,3)
(, , 1997,
.145147).
.
(.109,2,3)
(.109,1).
,
III II. .. (Waurick,
1988, Bei. 1, 24),
III. .. (, 1997, .76).
. 107. -
(, 1941)
4
0
. 108. :
1 . ( . . ); 2 ( , 2007); 3
( ..); 4 (, 1981)
135
4.
. 109. :
1 - ; 2, 3 (Waurick, 1986); 4 (Srbu, Haruche, 2000)
( 180. ..),
(168. ..)
II (246226. ..)
(Waurick, 1988, S.172, Abb.4749, 5658).
, IV II. ..
,
, III II.
.., .
. III I.
..
136
, . (Gva
ni) ,
1971.
,
(.109,4).
IV III. ..
(Srbu, Haruche, 2000, p.141).
III. ..
.
(ibid.,
fig.8, 1,2).
358, II. ..
(, 1978, .54), , ,
368 I. .. ( , .55).
, , II I. ..
. ,
(Srbu, Haruche, 2000, .139),
-
. ,
,
(Brc).
, IV III. .. ;
II. ..
2-
II. .., :
12 8. .. (, , 1997, .145).
. (8).
, .
: ,
-
, ( ).
; .
, , .
:
, (, 1988, .38).
(.110112,1)
, .
(.111,2).
,
.
,
(.110,5). , ,
0,4 (.110,6).
-, ,
.
(.111,1). 2219,5, 21,5.
,
. ,
, (Robinson, 1975,
p.13).
137
4.
1
0
2
2
. 110. :
1, 2 ; 3 ; 4 ; 5 ; 6
138
. 111. ():
. 112. :
1 ; 2
1 ; 2
, ,
(.112,2;
113,1,2). .
(.113,1). , 0,4.
, .
(.113,5),
-
(.113,6).
, .
(.114,2).
-,
,
(.114,1).
,
.
2420, 22.
139
4.
. 113. :
1, 2 ; 3 ; 4 ; 5 ();
6 ()
140
,
(.115,1,2;
116,1). (1,8),
0,4.
0,5
0,4 (.115,1). , . 0,6
0,6 ,
.
.
( ). ,
.
,
(.115,4). ,
0,20,25,
(.115,5). 2420, 18,5.
.
:
.
-,
(Schaaff, 1988, S.318,
Abb.1). (?)
, , , .
,
.
.
,
. -
. 114. ():
1 ; 2
.
,
.
.
, , (.116,2; 117,1,2).
, 0,5
(.117,3).
(.117,4).
0,6
. :
, , ,
141
4.
2
0
. 115. :
1 ; 2 ; 3 ; 4, 5
4
0
5
0
11
22
. 117. :
. 116. :
1, 2 ; 3 ; 4 ; 5 ();
6 ()
1 ; 2
142
143
. 118. ():
1 ; 2
. 119. -
(Raev et alii, 1991)
144
4.
(.117,6);
5
,
; , , (.117,5).
,
( , ).
, (.118,2).
,
, .
. -, , . ,
(.118,1).
, . 2320,
19,5.
, 1942.
- , - . , .
,
.
. ,
,
. .
.
(.119).
.
-/-
B-/D-
. 120. . .
( )
, -.
( ), . , III. .. ( )
-2 (-).
(
), - .
.
, .
.
,
, .
, ,
( ).
, ()
.
.
.
( .: , , ,
1990, .125132; Raev, Simonenko, Treister,
1991, p.472494).
- (, 1987, .109), .. / (Raev, 1986, p.85).
.
,
IV
III. .. (, , ,
1990, .119; Raev, Simonenko, Treister, 1991,
p.469). .
- (D-). - - - D-
(.120).
.
145
(Mzquiz,
1993, p.100, 101, 106, 108, 115, 118, fig.4,
5, 13, 17, 27, 30). , - ;
. IIII. .. (Mzquiz, 1993,
.124, fig.35).
, (, , ), , III. ..
(Schaaff, 1988, S.318).
, II.
.. (ibid., S.322, Abb.45).
,
(, ,
, 1990, .119), .
,
IIII. ..
(Mzquiz, 1993, .101, fig.5).
..
.. , ,
,
, (, , , 1990, .124).
.. ,
(Bittel, 1976; 1978). , ,
, , -
146
4.
I, 7063. ..
(, 1987, . 4). ,
.
.. 10
, .
(Bittel, 1976, S.248) , (Bittel, 1978, S.172
173) , ,
, ,
(,
; ibid., S.173).
,
.. .
, -
. , .. . , (Raev, Simonenko,
Treister, 1991), ..
, : ,
,
. ..
- , .
II I.
..
. .. ,
VI
. ,
.., (,
1994, .143). .
(- ), ,
. , ,
, . -
? ,
, .
4.3.
(Strabo, VII, 3). , , ,
, (Tac., nn., I, 79).
,
.
1979.
II I. ..
0,40,4,
. ,
. ,
11.
,
10
- - ,
.
11
. . .
(-, , 1984,
.154155). 6042, 9
(.121,1). .. ,
, 1 (, 1968, .102).
,
(-, , 1984,
.156).
1.
0,3 (. 121,
2, 3). ,
1 ( ..) . ,
, .
,
.
, .
.
? .
, .. , (0,51
0,27) (, 1954, .84). ,
,
. ,
.. , .
:
,
(, 1976, .89, .3).
147
4.
2
1
1
. 121.
1 ; 2 ( ); 3 ( )
148
3
0
10
. 121. :
11 ; 2 ; 3
149
, (-,
, 1984, .156) .. (, 1955, .2223),
: ,
,
. , , , , .
.. ,
,
(,
1997, .74). ,
(,
) (, 1997, .74).
.
.. ()
(83,6
46,8) (, 1997,
.74, : Stead, 1991, p.5).
(Stead, 1991, p.23),
.. . , ,
. .
17 .
(9)
: , , , , , , ,
. , ,
. , , .
- .
5.1.
. 122.
(, 1984)
, ,
.
, ()
.
(. ..) (
) (,
, , ).
,
.
(.122, 122),
,
-: , , ..
,
, , .
150
. 122.
151
5.
2
2
3
0
3
0
10
. 123.
152
. 125.
:
1 ; 2 ; 3
. 124.
11
.., ,
(, 1984, .93),
.
: (.124,2).
.
, ( ) (.125).
810, .
(, , ) (, , ,
7
0
8
8
. 126.
(, 2004)
153
5.
1
1
. 127.
)
(.126).
(. . Trense, .. Trensen)
.
.
154
.
, 5/1,
(.127).
. 127. ()
155
. 128.
, .
,
. (.124,1),
- ,
.
, .
,
, (.128). ,
.., , , , -,
(, 2005, .92).
,
,
(, 2005,
156
5.
.8894). . . ,
:
,
(, 2005,
. 9192).
, , ,
-
( ).
. . ( , . . 89)
:
, .
. ,
, ,
.
, -
.
, ,
- , ,
( , . 92). , .
,
,
.. ,
:
(, , 1997, .57).
. ,
.
, ,
, , , . ,
,
. . : ,
, .
, ()
.
VI. . . ,
I ( . . ; . ),
.
1 II
.
, : ,
,
(
).
-
.
. . ,
I
. . .
, . .
-
(, 1996, . 72). .
1 II ..
(
), I, .. (, 2005, . 90).
I
. .
.., ..
, . ,
(.. ,
) .
, , , ,
. , .., .
I ( ,
) ..
IV III. .., .. III. .. (,
1996, .72).
. -,
..
. .. (, 1984, .93) , IV.
. -,
IV
. ..
. ..,
( ). ,
157
, .
,III. .. ..
(,
, 1990, .86). -, , .. (1). ,
.
,
,
,
. , ,
IV. ..,
. .., ,
. ..
, .
IV
, , -
, . .. ,
. .. (. ).
1 II
.. , :
. .. , .
.. ,
, ,
158
5.
. .. (, 1996, .73). , , ..- ..
. ..
, ..
: ,
.
.., .. ( )
,
. ..
.. .
.. ..
, -
.
,
, ,
, .
, ,
.
..,
. ..
, -
. ..
,
. .
. -
. 129. :
1, 2 : , , 1997; 3 : , 2005
- , .
,
(, 1996, .197
198, 377, 379, 383).
.
.
2-
.. .., (.129,1), , (, , 1997; , , 1998) ,
.
. .. ( ..;
),
.
.. ,
.
-2007
. . ,
( ) III. . .
159
5.
. 130. 1- 2- . . :
14 (, , 2006); 5, 6 - ( . . )
(.130) (,
, 2006, .74, .28:69)
1 -
( .. 1980.).
1.
.
(, 1996, .78),
,
.
. ,
, -
160
. , , : ,
,
,
.. , , .
.
,
( III
. ..)
.
-
. ,
(
? ?) .
,
, , ,
, .
: ,
(, 2005, .94) ..,
.
. .. , ,
. , . ..,
( ?)
.
:
. , ,
/
.
. 131.
( )
5.2.
. :
2 4 ,
.
. 131.
( )
161
5.
2
0
3
4
. 131b.
8
1:2
. 132. (, 1962)
. 131. ( )
162
8-,
.
1. -.
, . ,
. 19 (
, ) 14.
8- ,
.
-, .
1.1 (.124,1,2;
131; 131b,c; 132,46).
, , .. .
,
(-
163
5.
3
3
8
0
. 133. (, 1962)
1.1)
(.124,2, 4, 6).
1.1b
(.135,2).
1.2
(.122, 4; 134,3; 135,3,4).
(?)
.
164
. .
(, , ,
, ).
. .
.. (2003, .64, .2,2).
.
. 134.
(15 : , , 2003; 4 )
1.3
(.123, 4; 124,3). (,
)
.
2. (.136).
. 29 (,
2000, .141, .2,2). , (.133,1)
,
, .
3. (.125,1).
( -
.) ,
.
-.
8.
(. 184, 200).
4. - (.125,3).
165
5.
2
0
5
0
. 135.
. . , . ,
. 10.
5. .
. -, 66/1,
8- (, 1993, .74, .22,20),
166
. 136. :
1 , . 29; 2 , . 12; 3 , . 1;
4 , . 21; 5
. ,
. 1.1b 1.2,
.
. ..
(.136,14). (, 1979, .106,
.17,3), (,
167
5.
. 137. I (, 2005)
(.136,3; 137)
(,
1963, .117118, .XV,815).
, .. ..,
. .. (, 1996, .76).
911
58.
,
. .. (. ..),
(. ..).
:
, ,
. .
(, , 1989, .132,
.V,47). -
168
8.
. ,
.
, , . - :
,
- . , ..
, , . .
.. (, 1984, .73, .1,47;
.7 .).
()
() .
.
.
, -
. ,
, ..:
,
. ..
- .
,
.
. .. (,
2006, .141)
.
- (, 66/1) (, ) .
,
,
.
5.3.
,
in situ . ,
, .. , .
(.123,67;
138,34). , ,
.
IV. ..
2, 1,41,5, 21,4. -
. 138.
(5., ) (6., 3 ,
3 ).
.
14 (.139,1). ,
(.139,2),
(, 1963, .37, .21,8). 1
. . - . .
, .. (-, , 1984, .152),
.
169
3
0
. 139. :
1, 3 , . 14; 2 , . 4
(, 1914, .XVIII,9) , ,
,
.
(.140),
10, ..,
, - .
, ,
, 10 , , 130
(, 2004, .118120).
,
,
() ( 111., 467.,
130.)
,
- (.123,9; 138,5;
140,10,11; 141,3).
10,5, 0,2. ,
, ( 300) 10
170
.. -
5.
(. ) 31 . (.139,3).
, ,
. ,
.
11,
:
. ,
, ,
,
.
,
, , ,
(.123,11; 142,
11, 12; 163,3).
(.130,
7) . ..
.
. ..,
,
, ,
IV. ..
(.140,9). (.140,14).
, , . ..
.
,
, .
.
5,2 5,6
11
, , (, , 1981, .111).
8
1
11
9
10
0
13
12
14
0
. 140. -
171
5.
13
12
11
1
14
9
10
8
2
0
. 141.
(.143,1,2).
. , ( ), , ,
(?).
. (, 1909, .14, .,3,4;
Arnut, Ursu Naniu, 2000, .354).
.
172
(4,2), .
, ,
.
. , , .
(.144,2).
6 7
31 .
-
16
15
. 142. (, 1960)
,
(.143,35).
(.140,13; 144,1).
: , ,
.
(4,2) , , , .
(.143, 2; 146; 147) ( ,
, , ). ( ), ( , )
(), , 2,83, .
(, , ),
(
173
. 143. :
1 ( 1908 ., 1909); 2
(, 2001); 35 , . 31
2
0
. 144. :
1 ; 2
174
5.
).
26,
.
. ,
,
, (.148,2);
, (.133,7,8),
,
(.133,
14).
. ..
(2.), (7.) (1.)
, , 4 7,5 (Mordvinceva,2001,
S.7780, Taf.30,55, 56; 34,66; 38,71). , .
- ,
(.145), ,
.., .
,
, 12
5 , 4 , 4 , 6 123 .
(.145,4),
. ,
. ,
,
(
). -
3
2
6
8
9
0
10
. 145.
175
5.
3
2
2
0
. 146. ( )
,
.
6 ; ,
(.149). ;
,
;
176
. 3,7,
1,3 (, 1976, .178).
,
,
-
.
, , 6.
,
0
0
2
3
. 147. ( )
; ,
;
.
,
, (.150).
5 9 :
) ,
- (5.);
) ,
(4.).
177
5.
. 148. (, 1961)
, ,
.
.
: ,
.
,
178
(4.)
(5.) . ,
. 4,84,5,
0,8 (.127,1; 127a,1).
, .
.
.
,
.
.
, , .
, ,
,
.
. ,
, .
-,
.
,
. ,
. , , .
,
(.127,6; 127a,5,6).
2 - (.151)
(, , 1991)
13 . (, 1987, .3639, .V, V,
V). ,
. 149.
( )
. 150.
(, 1979)
179
5.
. 151. -I (, 2005)
. 152. -II
( )
180
(.152,
153)
(arov, 1994) -II (, 2005,
.3031, .5052).
.17
(.154). (?)
(, 2004, .217, .34,9
15). , .., ,
. .
.
,
,
.
..
14 31 :
(201194. ..), ,
, (244/220.
181
5.
2
1
6
5
9
4
10
11
12
13
14
15
. 154. (, 2004)
10
. 153.
182
..). ,
,
, , -
, .
( )
, . ,
-,
.
, , , , . ..
.. , 5 . .. (, 1990, .109).
183
5.4.
, .
- ,
(.155). .
, ...
-
184
5.
(, 2001, .112
113), ..,
(, 1993; 1994).
.
in situ . -:
II. .. (,
2005, .93) II I.
.. (, 2001, .98).
,
, 12, - .
, .
.
, .
. 126
(.140,12).
.
.
2 , .. IV
12
. . ..
, , 1
(, 2001,
.111): , , (, 2002, .160,
.5,1,2).
. 155. ( )
III. .. (, 1973,
.218, 234, .30).
.
- .
,
(, 1973, .214, .27).
14
,
(Agulnikov, Simonenko,
1993).
, . ,
, , .
:
,
(.156,1).
,
(, 1993, .18,57, 58; 19,58;
36,170), ,
( , ) ,
185
5.
5
2
0
. 156. , . 14
, ,
. ,
, ,
, ,
,
. 14 ,
, IV.
.., ,
(Agulnikov, Simonenko, 1993, p.95).
186
5.5.
.
. .
,
25 (, 1982). :
,
,
S- .
.
1. (3.).
(.131,1; 131b,2),
(.142,16) .
: , ()
(), . ()
(). ,
.
,
. 21,6 ()
20 () .
2. ,
(11.).
(, , , , , ),
( ,
), . 1215.
,
, , S- , (.135,1;
138,1,2; 140,15; 141; 157). ,
- , .
: (,
, ),
(-
, ). (),
,
S- (.159,2).
(.158) ,
()
();
, (.147).
. (
) (, , 2000,
.1415). , , (.159,1, 911,
. 157.
187
6
1
III
12
188
15
25
16
13
22
19
II
18
23
24
14
21
.. .. .
14
. . .
15
.: , 1982,
.244245; , 1992, .5066.
20
13
, ,
(.159,24).
, .
VIV. ..
.
(.159,),
(.159,IIIV) (, 1946, .6,1; ,
1964, .33; , 1965, .2,162),
(, 1910, .67;
, 1967, .96) (, 1954, .133, .19,6).
,
,
III. ..
17
17)13.
III. .. 14.
(, )
(.130,8; 148,3).
, (.159, 22),
..
(, 1983, .95, 97).
(.159,26),
o (.159,24), 1
15.
26
. 158.
. 159. :
11
10
IV
27
2
1, 911, 17, 27 ; 2 ; 3 ; 4 ; 5 ; 6 ; 7, 8 ;
12, 13 ; 14 ; 15 ; 16 ; 18 ; 19 ; 20
; 21 ; 22 ; 23 ; 24 ; 25 ; 26 ; IIV
IV. ..
5.
189
. 160.
( .. )
(,
1982, .243)
(.160).
(.158,1),
. , . , , -
190
5.
..,
(, 1992, .65).
. IIII. .. (,
1982, .242), ...
, , III.
.. (
),
IV. .. (, 1992,
.6465).
IIIII. ..
,
- , ,
(, , 2000, .1516; , 2003,
.5859; , 2005, .94). ,
:
.
, .. .
,
.., .., .. , ..
IV.
.. (, 1992, .59). ,
, IV. ..
.
. , ,
.., III. ..
(, 1953, .29).
,
( ). ,
,
-
(, 1984, .97). .. III.
.. (, 1966, .30).
,
II. .. .. III.
.. (, 1966, .30).
.., (
III. ..) o
(Treister, 2002, p.31, 45).
(, 1979, .49).
..,
. :
II I.
.. ( ),
II III. .. (, .2).
(
) (, 1979, .88; , 1987, .177).
..
IV. ..
, , ,
. , ,
IV III. .. .
.
1
, .
191
),
.
.
2, U- .
,
. . ,
.
( ). ( ) 17, 11,4 (.131; 131b,3).
..
(, 1992, .44).
V. ..
5.
,
( ,
. .., ).
, V-,
, (.161,24).
x ,
(elkovice), .., , -
(Sedlec-Hurka) (Soudska, 1976, s.631, obr.5,
2, 3).
, ,
,
. ,
, , , . .. -
2
0
10
192
,
(Raev et alii, 1991)
.
1 . , , ;
(, , 2006, .209,
.3,1). , (.162).
,
II - (, 1975, .257, .1,1;
, 1993, .62, .13,7). :
,
-. , (.163).
-
13
(Alexandrescu, 1983,
p.77, fig.7, 5; 8, 5), ..
.
-
, (.163). ,
,
.
(, 1992, .44).
,
? (, 1960, .9, .1),
,
13
. ,
, .
- (Alexandrescu, 1983, fig.7,4;
8,4), . .. :
,
,
.
,
( )
:
. ,
; , , , .
.
(
). ,
. ,
. ,
,
16.
,
;
. ,
16
, ..
, .
193
5.
6
7
10
11
12
13
. 162. (, , 2006)
194
. 163. (, 1975)
195
5.
1
5
,
. , .
.. , (, ,
2006, .215, .1). in situ
.
.
1902.
196
17.
, 4, 17
(. ) ,
. ,
:
(, 1996, .77, .72,10),
.
,
.
2
3
. 164. ( )
197
. ,
7 :
, ,
,
, , .
, .
(.164,1, 1).
. .
, . .
,
(.164, 2). ,
.
,
.
- , (.165,2).
, . . 35 (, 1903,
.3740; , , 1907, .10
11, .III,417, 418; , ,
1980, .155, .1,1,4).
,
, ,
.., ..
.. , -
198
5.
VI. .. ,
,
. , . (,
1996, .77). .. .., ,
IV. .. (, , 2005,
.166). ..
. .. (, 2002, .161). , .
.
..
. ,
, (?)
(, , 1997, .50, .3).
,
IV II. .. (
., 2000, .46; , 2002, .161).
, IV II. ..
8 (, , 2006, .15, 19, 25, 26, 32, 33,
.13,2; 19,2,3; 24,2,3; 28,10; 31,3;
32,5).
,
. , ,
- . ,
,
, .
, . 275
102,4. ,
18.
,
, . ,
,
,
17
(, 2004, .215,
.32,3).
5.6.
/ 19.
;
, ,
. .
,
,
.
I. ..
18
. .
.
19
(Mordvinceva, 2001, S.66), .
.. 20; ,
, .
.
, .
,
, . 1518, 58.
,
1.
.
(, ,
, ).
() (), ()
(, ). (.165167).
,
20
(, 2001, .161)
,
. (Mordvinceva,
2001, S.69)
(
). ,
(, , 2006, .38)
,
.
199
5.
. 165. (, 1940)
200
201
5.
..
(, 2001), .
, .
..
(, 2001, .164).
, ..:
, , ,
(, 2001, .138). ..
,
,
.
.
(), /
(Szrcse/Surcea)21 (Herstru)
() (, 1989,
.36; 2001, .152157).
.
(Fettich) (Harmatta),
..
, - . .. , -
. 167.
202
21
- ( .. ) . Szrcse
() () Surcea
().
,
, -
.
... ,
(, 1984, .113) (, 2001, .164;
Mordvinceva, 2001, S.64).
, - .
(
)
,
- . ,
( , )
.
, . ..
( ),
. ,
,
.
(.168)
(,
1997, .255256, .48).
. , ,
.
203
5.
. 168. (, 1997)
3
0
2
2
. 170. :
1 : 1908 ., 1909; 2 : , 2001; 3
(,
, 22).
3
0
. 169. :
1 ; 2, 3
204
22
, .
,
.
:
205
( ) 6- (
) .
.
, . 8,5,
9 (.169).
.
,
, .
Y-
.
,
. ,
9 (.169,2).
,
, ,
, 11 . .
. 16,2
(.170,1,2).
,
: ,
, ,
, .
, , ,
206
5.
.
..
() (, 1992,
.52),
- (.170,3).
, , ,
(, 1999, .8788).
.. , (III. ..)
.
I II. .. ,
, ..
.
,
..
, (, 2001, .112).
, , , : ,
. ,
.
(
) ( ).
, , ,
,
.
.. ,
, ..
.. (, , 1980,
.155) .. (, 1996, .72).
. 10 ()
-
, .
12,8 13,2.
:
;
, ;
. 171. , . 10 (, , 1999; )
207
, ,
(.171,1,2). : ,
- .
,
(, , 1999, .15).
,
.
, , , .
;
.. ..
. ..
.
26
.
,
.
70 72
C IVB
.. ( ): 2 (70
170.) 80140-. (, 2006, . 167). ,
I II. . .
I. . . (,
, 1999, . 15)
99 .
IV. .. 5
. 7,3 7,
208
5.
.
.
. ,
, , , .
.
-,
, .
-
,
.
: , , (.127,2,3).
.
, , . , .
(
, , , ,
)
4 (. M&LA 1923.7
16.26),
(Germanen, 1988, S.112, I, 16, k).
.
,
, V.
5.7.
,
. , ,
. ,
(.172,1).
.
. (.173). ,
. 52,5,
10,711,6, 1,07.
3,7;
. 1
. 0,4.
( ) . 1112.
,
. , ,
.
4, 2.
8
12,5
. 9 , 8- 4
5, -
6 7,5 2,35,4.
.
209
,
. ,
, . .
8-
5.
. 173. ( , : ., 2004)
. 174. ( )
210
16
. 14,8. 3,8
( ., 2004, .137, .3).
(, 1903, .3740; ,
, 1907, .1011, .III,415,
416; , , 1980, .155167,
.1,2,3). , . :
( ,
),
.
,
8 (.174).
, : ,
.
.. ..
(,
, 1980, .156).
,
.
1 (,
1914, .,1,2).
,
, (.175,1),
(.175,2) . (.175,39)
1 (, 2002, .158
159, .2,3), IV
(, , 2006, .15, 19, 20, 4041,
.13,1; 19,1,4; 38,1,5), 2 ( ., 2000, .4047, .2).
..,
.. .. ,
, -
.
,
, (,
, ,
) (, ), - (
, ).
.
..
II. .. (, 2002,
.159),
1 IIIII. ..
(, 2002, .160). ,
III.
.. ,
(, 1914, .40).
1
: , .. 4
,
, , ,
(, 1914, .XVIII,
211
5.
7
0
8
6
12
. 175. :
1, 2 (, 1914); 3 (, 2002);
48 (, , 2006)
212
III II, , I.
.. ,
. ..
(, 1914, .42),
( ) .
, , ,
.
.
..
, (, ,
2002, .79, .1,3).
.
:
,
( ), .
, . , .
. ( ) 167,5
(.176).
. ,
, .
.
,
. , ,
213
5.
. 176. ( )
,
. , ,
.
, ,
.., . .. ,
(, 1994, .193).
. ..
10 (,
, 1999)
, -
214
(.171,3). ,
. ,
.
4 (),
(, , 2003, .291292, .8).
, : ,
.
, (.177).
VI,
(, 2001, .246247, .13).
..,
, ,
- .
. .. (, 2001,
.241).
( 7,64,4; 6,53,7;
7,63,6; 7,43,4) .
, .
.
,
, , .
, ,
( ). , ,
( VI).
,
.
.
-
. 177.
(, , 2003)
. , , .
(.2)
1 (
, 2000, .122, .6,4,5, 8, 10, 11).
, ,
. ..23
.
.. 10 .
, .
.
,
.10
(, , 1992, .154, .12,10). ,
23
(,
2000, .111; , 2000, .141155).: , 2001, .170172.
215
. (
7,64,4; 8,24).
. .. (, , 1992, .159).
, , ,
( -
; , 2002, .241, .5). (
. ..)24
,
(, 1998,
.71).
, , 9
(, , 1984, .47,
.14,4).
, , ( 7,52,5; 7,63,6),
. ,
.
,
(.17,
152, 169, 222), ,
. ,
24
. .. (, 1998, .72), .
.
(, , 2003,
.301). ,
.
216
5.
5.8.
I. .. .
.
, Y-
.
,
. ,
,
(.172,2).
.
:
, . . ,
.
.
(.178,1), I. .. .,
.
,
. ,
.
, .
-
5 , .
14,
8, 2,1, 0,3
(Simonenko, 1997, S.392, Abb.5).
,
,
.
II I.
..: ,
, ..
I. .. ,
. , 100 ,
.
. (,
1986, . 260)
(. 178, 2). , 16,5 ,
3,5 .
, .
.
.
, . (
, ).
(?)
- ,
. ,
. I II.
. . (, 1990, .53).
,
I. . .,
1918. -
. (,
217
5.
3
4
0
. 178. :
1 ( ); 2 ( ); 3 ( Antikensammlung SMPK, Berlin);
4 (, 2005)
218
. (
,
),
(20; .: Mordvinceva 2001, S.81
16,5), ,
.
,
I. . . -
(Otchir-Goriaeva, 2002, S. 363, 370371,
Abb.8; 9, 4).
. - .
, .
-
.
, ,
.
. 31 ,
7 (.179, 1). , ,
. (Otchir-Goriaeva,
2002, S.363, 370371, Abb. 8; 9, 4).
.
,
(Schaaff, 1980, S.403).
,
. , ,
.
219
5.
2
1
(Raev, Simonenko,
Treister, 1991, p. 465 ff.).
II. ..
-
(. 179, 3), (, , , 1990, . 126, .41; Raev,
Simonenko, Treister, 1991, p. 476, fig.10).
,
, .
, , . ,
,
.
(. 179, 4).
, I. ..
(Otchir-Goriaeva, 2002, S.382).
5.9.
, -
(. 179, 2). ,
,
, -
220
. , .
I. . . (Schaaff,
1988, S.304, 307, Abb. 1, 24). ,
. ,
.
, (, ,
1999; , 2001; 2002; , 2001; , 2003; 2004; , 2004).
,
,
, (, 1988, .107). ,
.
.. ,
,
. ,
. . ,
, .
, ,
, ,
( , , . .). ,
. ,
,
26. , ,
,
.
, .
,
, ,
.
26
221
5.
. 180. ( ., 1991)
,
(.180),
, .
(, 2006, .110, 131137).
(
),
.
(2- )
(5-
).
,
(, ..-
222
). -27
5- (Rudenko, 1970, p.130, fig.66).
, ,
.
IVIII .. (, 2001, .126,
185) (.181,1) (.181,2).
-
27
( -):
.
28 .
.
,
, ,
. -
, .
. .
,
, - , .
(TheFirst Emperors, 1988, p.129, fig.112;
, 2006, .135136)29.
,
. .
,
.
.
,
.
(, 2006, .127, .10).
5-
(, 1953, .99).
,
28
. .
(, 2006, .135).
29
(, 1990,
.106, .5, 1; Bunker et alii, 1997, p. 95, fig. A148),
,
(, 2004,
.255). (, 1988, .74, .1, 3)
. de visu, ,
(.186, 7, 8)
.
. 181. . ..:
1 ( , 1993);
2
(The First Emperors, 1988)
(, , ,
) , ,
.
in situ . ,
. 3,65,
44,5
(, 1973, .61, .12,15). :
(.182,1).
,
223
5.
)
:
.
,
(.172,1).
,
(,
.).
(,
1973, .50).
6 ,
..,
( , .45). ,
, 6 ( ).
,
:
. ,
. ,
(179141. ..)
,
(.183,2),
(Chine: des chevaux, 1995, p.51).
. , .
. 182. (- )
,
., .
(, 1973, .60).
,
.
, .
224
,
.
5-
(Rudenko, 1970, p.130, fig.66).
,
( ,
. 183. :
1 (Pirazzoli-tSerstevens, 1982); 2 (Chine: des chevaux, 1995)
225
. 184. ( )
5.
. ,
, ,
.
8 I ,
2 -
(, , 1963,
.15,68, 10; 21,6,).
V. .. in situ.
.
. , ,
, .
. 185.
226
. ,
(.184)
XIX.
(.185).
, .
,
( ) ,
6 20 (.182,3,4).
, ,
,
. , .
-, () - ,
... ,
, .. .
,
. ,
,
, -
,
.
,
.
, .
,
( , -
). , .
. ,
.
3
(.182,7). ,
,
.
, .
(pad saddle) -
. ,
, 30.
.
.
, .
.
31.
30
, ,
.
31
-
. (. .: , 1994, .190; Hermann, 1989, p.773782)
.
227
32. :
,
.
. ,
, ,
.
I. ..
. (.186,1),
(.186,3,4)
(.186,2).
, , (. c.: Ilyasov,
Rusanov, 1997/98, p.131134),
. .
,
33.
,
, ,
,
34.
32
. . ,
;
..
(, 2006, .135).
33
.
34
,
(, 2000, .169179).
228
5.
,
, : (
), .
. ,
, - , , , ( ).
, . -,
, . ,
(?) ( )
. -,
:
(. ).
,
:
, ,
, , .
I. ..
(,
2001, .86), (Rostovtseff, 1935,
fig.4042, 57, 64, 79, 83), (Rozenfeld, 1967, p.182, fig.22),
(Haussig, 1993, S.168, no.285;
, 1971, .6,2), (Pirazzoli-tSerstevens, 1982,
2
1
. 186. :
1 ; 2 ; 3, 4 ; 5 ; 6 ; 7 (, 1988);
8 (, 1990; Bunker et alii, 1997)
229
230
5.
, .
.. (-).
: (, 1973, .96, .5,2). ..
.. , .. ,
. ,
: ,
,
,
.
,
,
.
, -
.
..
(, 1973, .8198).
,
.
..
:
, , , ( , .9495).
,
.
.
, .
,
.. (, 1973, .94, .5,2)
IVVI.,
.
,
, ..
( , .97; 1979, .229).
,
. ..
..
(, 1979, .219,
.5). ..
(VIVII.)
(, 1979,
.229231). ,
IV
V. .. , , ,
.
,
( )
I. ..
,
.. .
(
;
,
).
, ,
..
.
.
. :
, .
(,
). : ( ) , , ,
.
: (Junkelmann, 1992,
S.6366, Abb.69, 70, 72). - , .
.
, .
-,
- (.187).
( ), .
,
, ,
, .
,
. ,
,
. -
231
5.
. 187.
(Junkelmann, 1992)
.
, . ,
(Junkelmann, 1992, S.63).
, , ,
,
( VI, 16/8). , , , ,
, , .
232
XVII.,
. ( ) , ( ,
)
.
.
, -
. 188. VI ( : , 1988)
: , ,
.
,
(
:
).
8 16 VI
(, 1988, .106108). ..
-
233
, .
,
( , .3,14,15)
, :
- .
.
.
. ,
(,
1988, .3,29,30)
( , .3,22, 23) -
234
. ( , .3,24, 25, 28)
( , .3,32, 33)
.
( , .3,18, 19,
26, 27) . ( , .3,7, 8, 10)
(4.)
(1.). ( , .3,9), , .
. VI
.188.
II III. .. ( , .111).
6.1.
. , ,
.
, . .
.
, , .
, ..
: ,
,
.
, - ,
.
.
,
.
, .
. ,
.
. ,
.
. ,
, ,
,
, .
(, 1994, .144).
, .
,
,
(
.: , 1994, .32
34). , 112110. ..
(IOSPE, I2, 352). -
235
.
113. .. ,
, .
(,
, ),
, .
,
(. 910). ..
(, 1987, .69 .)
- ,
.
, :
, (, )
, .
, 112. ..,
, , status quo.
,
.
, 50.
(Strabo, VII, 3, 17). , ,
. ,
, (.1523). .
. ..,
.
89.
. -
236
6.
,
, 86. (App.,
Mithr., 41). ,
( ). 85. :
(App., Mithr., 57).
,
,
.
(7463. ..) :
( . ..)
.. (ibid, 67, 2).
, . . .., ,
. ( , 1-
, 2-
, , )
, .
,
. , ,
, :
? ,
,
- -
.
74 III. ..:
51 , 13
, 5 .
21 ,
.
,
.
,
.
. , , .
(, 31/1)
.
(, 4/17). (; , 12/3)
,
.
..
, .
.
, ,
. : , ,
(, 10 .),
- .
, -
. ,
.
IV III. ..
( 1980, .49). .
III. .. ,
.
, ,
(, 1981, .2021).
.., ,
(, 1963, .34).
(,
1983, .106).
,
, ..
.
II. ..
.
.
(, , 2007, . 268273), ,
.
. . -
237
, .
.
, (),
(, ).
( , , ),
(, ), .
. ,
(, ,
).
.. , ,
,
(, 1998, .5557; Mordvinceva, 2001,
S.4853). , , , , .
,
. . 1- (, 1998, .52).
.
, (Mordvinceva, 2001,
S.46), . ,
..
. ,
/ (, , , -
238
6.
). ,
,
. ,
,
,
(Mordvinceva, 2001, S.46).
,
,
,
, ( ..).
. , - ,
, :
, .
, .
. ,
15,5, 16,1,
13,7 (, ..). .
,
.
, . 14,3, 11 9,7,
7,4, 4,1.
(,
..,
),
,
.
( 17,65)
,
(13,413,7), (8,3
8,5), 4,5.
.
, ,
. .
, , ..,
, .
1- 2- (, ,
) ,
. 3-
. ..
(, , ) . I
II. .. (,
, , , ,
)
...
.
,
,
. , , III. ..
.
.., 91,4%
, .
35%. ,
1:5,
1:4 (, 1984, .83),
. , 2,4%
.
III. .. ,
.
, .. .
. I. ..
,
.
, -
. ,
()
..
II. .. ,
.. ,
(?) . ,
6. .., ,
,
(Dio Cass., 55, 30.4).
I. ..
,
2- 1- (Mord
vinceva, 2001, S.68), .
(, 1994, .152) 4
1012. ..
239
. , , , - ,
(Svet., Tib., III, 41). ,
67/68. , ,
.
, 69/70., 9
.
III , ,
,
(Tac., Hist., I, 79). , ,
,
.
- (Plin.,
NH, IV, 80). - 60-.
:
, ,
,
(IL., XIV, 3608).
(?), I. .. (,
1994, .204218; , , 1991,
.71 .).
(, 1988, .86). ,
I. .. -
,
.
240
6.
,
. (Svet., Dom., VIII,6)
89 92.
89. ,
(Svet.,
Dom., 31). 92. , . , ,
.
,
85., 86 8889. (
).
,
.
.
101102 105106.
,
.
II. ..
( 800).
220, .. 27,5%,
.
,
.
. . .. , .
, 6971. , ,
, .
20.
,
,
,
.
,
.
, , .
, . ..,
.
78,7%
.
(37,5%) .
, (10%
). ,
, .
,
.
, ,
.
, .
, (),
.
13. (2)
,
. ,
, . ,
(, , , ) -
(,
, ), , , -
, .
,
,
,
.
,
,
, , . . -,
. -,
,
,
. ,
, . ,
. .., (, 1980, .49).
23%
.
,
.
. , .
.
( ),
.
.
241
,
,
.
:
( . ..).
.
. , ,
. , ,
. ,
.
()
.
.
,
.
, -
-:
1
/31/4 , .. (.
, , .., 95,8%
).
- II.
..,
.
242
6.
, ..
,
(, 1991, .134). . ,
,
,
, .. , (, 1991, .30). .
II. ..
.
II II
(, 32, 33), ,
,
.
,
,
.
(
)
.
, , ,
.
-
. ,
..
.: , 1991, .32.
, . ,
(
),
, -
-
.
: ,
.
,
.
.
167. .. .
, , , ,
- .
.
,
. ,
,
175.
. 177.
,
.
,
.
divide et impero. , .
,
, .
,
.
180. .
II. .. .
,
III. ..
,
. ,
.
()
III. .. ,
, .
.
- ,
(, 2001, .90).
.
375. ..
700 II IV. ..
243
250
( 35% ).
. 84%
.
, .
, 100 . -
.
.
. , (,
, , .)
. , III
IV. ..
:
-.
- 2-,
;
.
( II
III. ..)
.
244
6.
, , , .
.
II. ..
.
III. .. -
. 2-
,
3-,
. IV. ..
5- .
. :
,
.
- ( III IV.
..) ( 3-
, , ),
( ).
6.2. .
.. -,
.
, ,
(,
, 1975, .38).
.
, , . ,
- . ,
(,
; , , ).
,
. ,
,
. ,
,
.
,
(
).
. ,
,
.
.
. (, 1971, .7576),
,
.
(Polib., XXXI, 3, 8; Liv., XXXV, 48), (Heliod.; Amm. Marc., XVI, 10, 8; XXIV,
6, 8; XXV, 1, 12), (Plut., rass XXI),
(Plut., Luc. XXVI; Strabo,
XI, 14, 9), (Strabo, XI, 14, 9), (Tac., ist., I, 79)
(Veg., I, 20).
,
.., .. . , ,
.
.. .. .. (, 1954, .114121; , 1968, .4451; , 1971,
.72). : 1)
; 2)
; 3)
, . ,
,
.
.. (, 1971, .71), I.
.. I. ..
.
,
.
,
245
. ,
, , apriori .
, - ( fantasy
.: , 2004, .2581).
, , ,
.
.
.
,
. ,
, .. . ,
9 (
. ..), ,
.
.. (, 1971, .75) .
(Arrian., Dis., 31) : ,
.
, ,
. . . , .. , .. , . . .
, , .
(, 1971, .49).
246
6.
,
.
, , , .
,
,
.
.
, . , , I. .. III .
..
( )
.
. ,
,, .
:
,
, I. .. (,
1971, .80).
II ... (, 1985, .30). ,
, .
( , .31).
.
(Sal., IV, 4, 6466).
. . (, 1971,
.87).
-
.
( )
1841. .. ,
- , -
(,
1914, .352). , .., .. (, 1972,
.75). , ,
,
(, 1973,
.35), , apriori
,
(, 1971, .245). .., , -
,
,
,
,
(, 1993, .80).
, . . , ,
,
,
, . , , .
,
.
, ,
247
248
6.
.
: , ,
(canter),
(Reinach, 1925,
.612); , (galop allonge).
,
,
.
, ( )
,
.
, ,
. ,
,
, . .
,
, . , ,
, (
) .
,
: . - (.
).
,
,
(Arrian., act., 16, 6), , (, 1968, .46).
,
,
, ,
(
). ,
..
. ,
- . , ,
,
.
(, 1984, .63
64).
, , , - . ,
, ,
, .. . , ,
,
. ,
, , .
, ..
.
,
,
.
: (, , ).
.
-
?
, ? - ,
. , ,
, , ,
. - ,
.
, , , . , , , . ,
, , ,
. , -
. , , .. , - .
( ), ,
.
,
, ,
, . ,
, ( ),
(
-,
249
), .
-
. ,
(. .5).
,
,
,
.
. , ,
.
!
.
.. ,
(, 1971,
.75).
5% ( ,
. . ).
, ( , .80).
,
(?).
,
, , I.
.. III. ..
, .
250
6.
,
, ,
.
,
.
I. .. I.
.. (, 1954, .114; ,
1968, .49; , 1971, .80).
. ,
(. .4) - ,
, . , .
,
.
, .
(.), - . (
, .)
. I. ..
,
.
( ), - ,
,
, ,
. ( : ,
( . . .),
- .
( - )
.
. ,
,
(, 1971, .67). . ,
(. ..) ,
, (Hippocr., Peri aeron, 24). , ,
(Mela, or. I, 114).
(, 1947, .106 .). ,
.
. ( ),
8,3%,
2,4%, . -
.
,
.
.., 29% IV. ..
(, 1985, .70), .. ,
(,
1964, .201). ..
(, 1983, .1419).
,
.
. , ,
.
,
,
, ,
, (,
1985, .71). -.
,
(, 1984, .193), , .
-:
(. ..) , ,
,
(Ps. Hip., De aero, 24).
, , .
251
, ,
,
. ,
,
-.
, , .
.
, , , .
,
.
,
(, 1975, .290).
. , ,
(, 1975, .293).
, , ,
,
.
.
, ,
252
6.
.
: , ,
, ,
,
, , ,
, ,
,
,
, :
, ,
,
, ,
.
,
,
(Lukian., ok., 48). ,
XVIIXVIII.
(, 1880, .19),
.
. ,
, (, 1984, .6768),
10. ,
,
. , : ( . ..)
.: , 1994,
.191.
10
, ,
.
,
(Amm. Marc., XVII, 12, 2).
I. .. .
(Ovid., ris. III, 55). 5870.
(Ios. Flav.,
De bel. VII, 4, 3; Tac., ist. I, 79).
, ,
, -,
. . (.. ) . ,
.
,
(Polyen, VIII, 56).
,
(Ambros., V, 1; Amm.
Marc., XVII, 12, 3). ,
.
1200 (Polyen,
VIII, 56). .., ,
, 155
160 (, 1972, .167). ,
190.
,
,
, . . : 72 ,
222 (
, ), 80100
1517 (, , 1953, .102,
106, 111). ,
, ..
...
1200 ,
(, 1984, .71).
.
,
,
,
, ( .
..), ,
, ,
, ,
(Amm. Marc.,
XVII, 12, 3).
.
,
:
, :
(Tac., nn. VI, 35). , , .
, , ,
-, - .
, ,
, , .
, . .
,
( , , ). ,
. , ,
. , ,
253
. ,
,
,
: ,
.
. 373374.
: (. ..)
,
, ,
, ,
(Amm. Marc., I,
13, 14).
-,
. ,
,
.
: . ,
, ,
, . ,
, :
(
), , , .
,
254
. , ,
,
. , . , ,
,
.
,
. , . .
, ,
. ,
, .
, ,
, , , .
,
. : ,
( );
,
, ,
.
( ), ( ) ( ) . , ,
.
(.
..) ,
,
.
.
- .
.
.
.
, .
( . ..) .
(
) , ,
. ,
,
. 3
. ,
(
)
, . , .
, , ,
.
. ,
,
. ,
.
.
, , , .
. ..
, ( ). . ..
, .
.
,
255
.
.
.
( II IV. ..)
- .
III. ..
. IV.
.. , .
. III. .. -
(
, , ) - (
,
, ).
,
: , ,
.
. IV. .. (,
). ,
.
54
,
2/2
., 2,
4,8
51
, , , 2004,
.138, .4,6; Simonenko, 2001,
S.217218, Abb.13, 5; ,
2007
, . .
4,2
48,5
, 1984, .131132,
.3,1; Simonenko, 2001, S.217
218, Abb.13, 4; , 2007
, . .
3,6
38,6
, , 1994, .43,
.24; , 2007
, 4/20
41
, .
2, 2/5
38*
--
, 2/3
38,4*
--
,
1/4
29,5*
, 31/1
18*
--
10
, 1/1
4,3
45*
11
, 4/17
43*
* . .
257
3.
, 1/5
35*
, 1/1
42,5*
, 1/1
,
.
, 1973, .8283,
.4,1
, 253/2
3,8
37*
, , 1984,
.7, .3,2; ,
1984, .133, .4
253/5
3,5
42,3
--
253/6
4,5
9*
--
, 3/2
17,2*
, 1907, .265
.8 ,
. .
3,5
51
, 1974, .189
, 1/4**
, 1/2
, 2/4**
5/3
10
, 9/1
11
, . 8,
1/16
12
. 8, 1/11
13
. 9, 7/1
14
,
. 28, 1/2
15
20,8*
. ..
1984.
2,7
23,5
, 1983, .222, .1
* . .
258
30*
4,5
1908, .162;
, 1971, .V,4
, .163
, 1979, .3031
42,5*
--
, 1980, .1980
21*
--
, 1976, .28
30,8*
--
, .47
3,2
42
38
37
--
--
4,5
48
--
, 1983, .62
. 28, 1/10
47
--
16
. 28, 1/12
3,5
46
--
17
-, 4/1
4,2
33
18
32/1
3,5
43,5
--
, 1993, .30,
.9,4
19
43/1
2,8
40
20
52/1**
21
58/1
22
62/1
23
66/1
5,5
24
, 5/9**
, 1960, .27,
.15,9
--
, . 46, .15,7
--
, .55
1,6
--
, .63
57
--
, .67, .22,2
55
--
, .73, .22,22
23*
, 1977, .271
259
3.
2,5
41,5
--
, 1984, .138,
.7,1
, 2000, .133
49
62,5
, .1,9
50
--
3,3
38
--
, .7,4
46
, .2
51
--
3,5
34,5*
--
40,5*
, 1984, .138,
.7,2
,
25/1**
26
26/6
3,8
27
29/1
28
, 3/8
29
4/8**
30
, . .,
5/1
31
8/1**
32
.., VI/1**
33
/1**
34
,
. , 1/1
85
., 1960,
.103
--
, .107
--
, .71, .57,4
--
, .73
40*
--
, .86, .67,14
3,6
13,5*
--
, .90
45,4*
--
. ..
1951.; Simonenko, 2001,
S.221, Abb.15,2
52
4,5
41,2
--
53
,
. .
47
54
,
. .
43
--
, .137
55
3,7
19*
, 1887,
.153
--
3,7
12,6*
--
--**
4,5
36*
--
. 89
56
57
58
, . 14
59
, . 17**
35
3/1**
4,5
60
--
, 1984, .138,
.6,4
36
I/1
3,5
40
--
., 1960, .39,
.20,1
60
. 18
61
. 29**
37
. , 2/1
6,5
59
--
, 1947, .45
62
38
., 4/1
3,5
50
--
., 1960, .46,
. 29,3
,
. .
63
39
8/1
40
, 6/1
4,7
40*
, 1960, .136,
.100,4
47,5
--
64
, 1/10
47
--
65
7/2**
--
--
, 1/10
33,3*
42,5
5,2
42
69
, 1/4
3,5
40
70
, 2/3
71
, 1/8
72
, 23/1,
4,5
46,5*
44
, 1/1**
4,5
34*
--
, .51, .14,2
45
,
1/2
57
--
, .53, .16,1
46
, 1/8**
47
, 5
48
, . .
, .47, .9,4
, .70,
.9,5
, ,
1969, .160, .60,8
, .137
68
, 3/4
--
-,
. .
, 23
43
67
41
--
61,5
, 1993, .62,
.12,2
4,5
, .4041
3,5
45
47,5*
, 1986, .84,
.3,5
42
, 1981, .58
, , 1961,
.135
66
41
260
25
.,
. .
, 1984, .138,
.6,1
, 1984, .138,
.7,5
. . .
1981 .
. . . 1974.
, 1971, .35
--
, , 1970,
.47
26*
--
., 1970, .133,
.
18,2*
--
, , 1984, .57,
.16,3
261
4. -
73
, 10/1
34,5
74
, 4/4
4,8
45
--
, , 1999,
.13
, 1962, .205;
, , 2003, .295,
.4,2
11*
75
, 9/13
32
--
76
,
..
13*
--
, 7/1
2,2
77
,
..
17*
--
,
1/1
3,9*
78
,
21/1,
3,7
37
--
99,5
79
, 6/15**
3,2
40*
--
. . . 1988.
, 4/1
28
--
80
, . 12
47,5
--
. . . 1986.
7/1
3,9
29
--
, .166, .8, 5
81
. 18**
8/2
2,6
93
--
, .168, .8, 13
82
. 29**
--
3,8
24
--
, .168, .8, 6
83
. 62
84
, . 1
85
. 2
86
. 3
87
. 4
88
. 5
40*
89
. 6
2,8
--
--
--
---
--
, 1984, .144
, 1952, .138.
, .
5
4,5
,
1/11
27,5
10
-,
1/22
5,95
98
11
37/1
86,5
, .8, 6
12
40/1
91*
, .
91
90
. . . 1983.
3,8
47,2
--
41*
--
., 1995, .113,
.3,3
45
--
, .114115, .5, 1
3,5
33*
--
, .116, .7, 1
--
, .8, 2
--
, .117, .9, 5
--
. , .228, 148
., 1987, .116,
.1, 11
--
, .120, .1, 20
90
,
25/9*
--
. . . 1989.
13
91
29/7**
--
. . . 1990.
14
, 1/45
91
. . . 1973.
, , 1991,
.1011, .4
15
, 1/3
4,5
99,6
. . . 1981.
16
, 8/3
75
17
, 16/1
3?
75*
, .15, .4, 2
18
, 3/1
5,5
51
19
, 1/1
4,2
91,5
20
, 2/3
3,5
110
., 1982, .132,
.1, 2, 3
21
, . 2
2?
2,5*
100*
, 1969, .249, . 1, 9, 10
92
, 1/1
52
93
, 5/1
24*
--
94
-, . 2
4,7
43,2*
. . . 1993.
, 1962, .68, .2:8
* . .
** . .
262
--
263
28
4. -
22
,
1/52
23
2/2
--
24
24
1/17
3,5
25,5*
25
1/53
24,5*
26
, . 5
27
, . 5
28
, . 2
29
. 9
2,5
30
31
- ,
7/1
32
33
-, 19/2
34
--
97,5
--
, , 1999, .177,
.2, 9
--
, , 1990, .22
--
, 1984, .143,
.10, 2
46
, . 9
5,3
, .10, 1
47
, . 16
48
. 17
, , 1984, .34
49
, 17/10
--
, .35
50
, .
.
32
--
, 1990, .81
--
, .44
51
, .
45
7580
--
, 1956, .50
19*
--
, .45, .13, 19
52
. 1
35
6570
--
, .51
7,5*
--
, .47, .13, 20
53
, 2/5
--
, 1990, .65
--
, , 1990, ,
.20, .12, 13
54
, 8/6
--
, .64
1,8
--
, .20, . 12, 7
55
, 13/3
36,5
--
, .71, .19, 7
6,2
100*
--
, .11, .6, 4
56
4/4
46*
--
, , 2003, .294,
.4, 1
4,5
50*
--
, .11, .6, 3
57
, 1/8
3,5
23*
--
, 1983, .39, ., 11
2?
45*
--
, , .15, .12, 1;
., 1998, .71,
.25, 8, 9
58
,
2/5
3,5
30*
--
, .40, ., 10
--
, , 1990, ,
.8
59
,
.
31*
--
, .42, ., 9
--
, .11, .9, 13
60
5,4
36*
--
, .46, ., 8
61
,
. 7
3,5
71*
--
., 1995, .118,
.11, 5
--
-
--
35
, 3/9
36
, 8/1
37
13/1
38
, .
1?
39
. 3
40
, . 16
5,5
65*
4,5
54
--
2,6
--
, .10, 4
, .10, 3
, 1908, .131
., 1983, .21,
.2930
--
45*
2,5
36*
--
, .11, 4
63
2/1
4,5
86
--
. . . 1987.
64
,
29/12
2,2
77,5
--
. . . 1990 .
65
66
-,
. 3
62
, .132
41
--
42
, . 6
43
. 7
44
. 8
67
. 4
45
. 9
68
. . 6
264
110
5
31
--
, 1963, .117
66
--
, .118
25
--
, .96
265
4. -
69
-, .
1940.
4,5
47,4
--
, 1947, .295
70
. 1941.
5,5
40*
--
, 1963,
.42
98
III,
.
83
99
.. 3
4,5
48,5
--
, .236
100
. 1
100
--
, .241242
. 40
--
50*
--
, .245
101
71
--
80*
--
72
--
4,5
35
--
102
-. 2
, 1977, .237
73
. . 1
37
--
, .29
103
--
3?
50*
--
74
. . 2
5,5
77
--
, .30
104
--
30,5
--
75
. . 3
5,3
32
105
. 2
5?
32
--
76
. . 1
, .16
106
. 3
5,5
52,5
--
, .248
77
. . 6
5,1
58,5
, .1819
107
, . 3
42,5
78
. . 15
2?
34
--
, .24
79
. . 16
39,5
--
, .25
108
--
6,6
41
--
, .15, .72, 8
80
. . 18
6,1
90
--
109
. 1819
41,6
--
, .18, .90, 1
41
--
110
--
4,4
34
--
, .19, .90, 2
4,5
68
--
, .34
111
--
3,8
29,5
--
, .90, 3
81
82
-. 2
, 2002, .16,
.72, 7
83
--
--
112
. 21
39
--
, .20, .101, 3
84
--
--
113
. 66
4,2
44,5
--
, .30, .164, 10
85
--
2,1
--
114
4,5
35
--
, .164, 3
5,5
--
, .37
115
, . 3
3,6
36
116
. 4
86
. 5
87
IV,
.163
88
. 184
89
. .
1971
90
-,
1968
. 1, . 3
4,3
31,3
91
80
23*
4,2
, .26, .10, 49
--
. . .
1996.
5,5
34
--
--
117
--
3,5
45,5
--
--
118
--
69
--
--
, , 2006,
.139, .1, 2
119
--
--
--
120
--
43
--
--
--
, .2, 2
121
. 9
4,4
27,5
--
---
75*
--
. 1979.
60*
--
6,9*
4,2
4,3
36,4
--
, .2, 1
122
. 15
26
--
93
. 1, . 4
4,8
43,3
--
, .140, .3, 6
94
. 3, . 2
4,8
29,8*
--
, .141, .6, 1
123
. 60
5,2
27,7
--
. ..
1997.
95
. 3, . 3
4,8
40,5
--
, .7, 1
124
8,8
31,8
--
96
. 6
4,8
39,5*
--
, .142, .9; 10
. 102, .
.
. ..
2000.
97
III
125
. 125
6,8
90,8
--
. ..
2001.
92
266
--
52
., 1976,
.146, .8, 52
267
--
2,6
126
5.
24
--
--
127
. 163
--
--
128
. 200
--
--
129
. 246
--
130
. 275
48
--
--
88,2
--
--
80,5
--
--
33*
--
--
54
--
--
131
--
132
--
133
. 280
134
. 285
. .. 2006.
135
--
44
--
--
136
--
31
--
--
--
--
137
. 288
138
,
. 26
139
. 29
4,75
140
141
-. 30
142
--
33*
--
, .62, 29
--
, 10/1
, 1984, .89
--
--
--
--
, 1/2
2/1
, 253/2
29,5
, 1908, .162
, . .
253,5
46
, 1962, .249, .
102
37
--
3,5
14,5*
. .. 1980.
--
--
--
, 2/4
20*
. . . 1976.
10
, . 3, 1/1
3,7
30*
, .63
4,25
40,75
--
, .110, .64
4,25
35,75*
--
--
143
. . 28
3,75
38,75*
11
, . 31, 3/15
30,5
--
, .8,
144
. 51
5,5
22*
, , 2003, .58,
.2, 9
12
, .11, 3/7
30*
--
145
. 52
6,75
13*
, .59, .6, 2
13
. , . 12, 2/8
22,5*
--
, .1, 11
146
. 53
6,75
86,5
, .60, .9, 4
14
-, 38/1
256
35
--
147
. 55
4,7
40
15
56/1
304,5
45
--
, .60, .20, 2
148
, . 1
16
, 26/2
19,53,6
31,5
149
. 2
4,6
42,2
--
--
17
, 4/1
--
--
4,5
, .13, 10
--
150
--
4,6
33,1
151
, . 3
4,5
27
152
-2, .
4
153
154
. .. 2005.
., 2001, .12, 9
18
, 4/17
234,5
31,5
. .. 1972.
19
, . 2, 2/1
234,2
32
. 6
--
--
194
28,5
. 9
--
--
* . .
268
20
--
, .63, .12, 4
--
, .10, .1, 3
, .18, .6, 3
--
21
35*
, .51
22
, . 58
72,3
14,5
, 2002, .27,
.142, 8
6.
23
--
4,5
10,5
--
, .142, 3
24
--
193,5
23*
--
, .28, .144, 9
25
. 59
1,5
21*
--
, .148, 6
26
, . 60
17,54,5
26,5
--
. . . 1998.
27
. 139
16,5
--
28
. 146
3,4
25
--
. . . 2001.
29
. 203
63
12,5
--
30
-, . . 2
--
, 1963, .93
, . .
3,5
, 31/1
, 1991, .24,
.2, 3
, 20,
, 1982, .240,
.2, 3
33
, . .
27*4,2
43,5*
34
--
22*4
38*
35
, .
.
4,5
42,4*
10*
38
,
. .
39
, 4/4
40
, 1/1
2,8
39,5
17*
7,8*
, .116
, 1984, .90
, .89
, , 1981,
.111; -, ,
1984, .158, .3, 1618
2.
-, , 1984,
.153154, .2,13
, 1982, .237,
.2,4
, 4/1
2,5
, 7/2
31,7
19
. .. 1971.
, 1/5
82
--
, 2/4
. . . 1976.
--
, 1/4
2,5
--
. .. 1979.
, 2/1
2,5
. 20
--
. .. 1980.
, 5/1
2,5
--
., 1960,
.71
--
, .73
--
, , 2002,
.79, .1, 4
, 1907, .265
, 1973
, , 2003,
.295
8/1
, , 1991,
.14, .7, 8
12/1
1,5
--
, .74
10
21/1
2,3
10
--
, .81
11
VII/1
--
, .87, .68, 7
* , .
270
12/3
183,5
25*
--
. . . 2006.
, 1/
3,6
--
32
37
22
, 10/2
. 2
--
1.
31
36
--
12
1952., 4/1
32,8
13
, 21/1
1,8
15
--
, .133
, .129
14
,
.., 2/1
3,52,2
60
--
, .44, .27, 3
15
2/2
32,2
24
--
, .45, .28, 3
16
4/1
13
17
, 3/1
1,5
, .46, .29, 4
, 1986
6.
18
, 31/1
19
,
21/1
1,1
11
20
26/6
3,3
21
29/1
1,7
22
, 12/2
2,5
20
23
, 14/1;
, 2/1.
1,71
3
4
2
---
24
-, 2/1
1,8
25
3/1
10
--
26
8/1
1,5
--
, .31
27
14/1
1,5
21
--
28
16/1
--
, .35
29
23/1
1,7
30
25/1
2,21,8
13
--
, .21, .6, 8, 9
31
32/1
1,5
--
32
37/1
1,7
21
33
43/1
1,71,5
52
34
56/1
2,71,5
35
58/1
36
37
38
, 14/1
39
--
47
, 11/1
, 2000, .133,
.1, 1
48
, . 1
--
, , 1984, .34
--
, .133, .1, 12
49
, 3/9
10
--
--
, .133, .3, 1i
, , 1990, ,
.15, .12,2
50
, . 6
, , 1967,
.126
51
, 1/1
52,5
32
, , 1991, .14,
.7, 27
52
, 9/13
53
, 16/1
3,5
, .85, .26, 4, 5
54
, 10/1
42
1215
, , 1999,
.14, .3, 13, 14
55
, . 285
3,5
. . .
56
, . 1
4,13,2
--
. . .
57
, . 4
--
, 2002, .46,
.75, 46
, .30, .9, 7
58
. 78
--
--
59
, 1/10
100
. . . 1987.
--
, .46, .15, 19
10
--
, .60, .20, 8
2,1
--
, .63, .21, 7
61/1
1,8
--
, .66, .21, 27
62/1
1,7
--
, .68, .22, 6
2,514
, 1961, .62
, . 91
40
. . . 1983.
40
, . 20
, , 1961,
.137
41
--
, 1982, .78;
Simonenko, 2001, S.194,
Abb.2, 8
42
32
--
, Abb.2, 2, 10, 13
43
, . .
2,51,7
30
44
, 1/1
3,4
.
200
45
, 1/4
, 1971, .34
46
, 2/3
272
(?)
--
, 1979, .129
, .7, 5
, 2006, .141,
.5, 2
, 1960, .26
, 1981, .117,
.2, 5
, , 1971, .47
273
7.
18
19/1
--
, .1, 1901,
.103, .48
19
20/1
. .
,
,
--
, , 1994, .46,
.9, 84; Simonenko, 2001,
S.272
20
22/1
, 1918, .1314; ,
2000, .312314, ., 1
21
32/1
, , 1999,
.126, .4,2
22
-, 36
23
40/1
. .
,
,
, , 1994, .48;
Simonenko, 2001, S.272
, .1, 1901,
.103, .4849
, 1/1
, 4/1
, 11/9
-, 55/14
--
--
24
44/1
--
1901., .84
, 7/6
--
--
. . . 1957.
25
47/1
--
--
, . 1, 1901,
. 103, .57
-, 2/1
26
48/1
--
--
1901., .72
27
49/1
--
--
, 41/1
--
. . . 1981.
-VII, 15/1
. .
.
--
. . . 1981.
28
51/1
10
-, 18,
29
-, 52
11
, 1/1
. ,
30
, 3/1
--
, . 1, 1901,
.103, .74
12
2/1
. .
,
,
31
5/1
--
32
9/1
--
13
3/1
33
10/1
. ,
--
, . 7475
14
8/1
. .
,
,
, .42
34
12/1
--
1902., .68
35
15/1
36
17/1
1902., .72
. ,
--
, , 1994, .41,
.5, 54, 56; Simonenko,
2001, S.273, 275, Abb.41,5;
42,2
37
3/1, 1908.
, , 1994, .77,
. 56,548
38
, 1/1*
. .
,
9/1
15
-.
. ,
--
--
. . . 1978.
., 1979, .167
, 1979, .103104,
.13, 3, 4
1901., .72; ,
, 1994, .41, .1, 4
Simonenko, 2001, S.273,
Abb.41, 8, 9
, .1, 1901,
.103, .2
--
--
--
--
. .
,
,
?
, . 52
, . 53
, , 1994, .51;
Simonenko, 2001, S.272
1901., .85
--
, .70
16
10/1
. .
,
--
39
3/1
--
17
17/1
. .
,
,
--
, , 1994, .46,
.7,78; Simonenko, 2001,
S.272
. .
,
,
40
6/1
--
, 1984, .80
275
8.
--
--
, .87
41
9/1
42
10/1
--
, .88, .2, 65
43
12/1
. ,
--
, .89
44
15/1
. ,
,
--
45
16/1
. .
--
, 1984, .94
46
, 26/1
. ,
, , 1994, .118,
.19, 178/13; Simonenko,
2001, S.273, Abb.41, 7
47
28/1
. ,
,
--
48
-, 29/1
. .
--
1902., .7778
49
31/1
--
, .79
50
35/1
--
51
37/1
--
, .82
52
40/1
. .
--
53
41/1
--
, .83
54
45/1
, .84
55
46/1
, .85
56
, 3/1
1906., .93
57
4/1
. ,
, 1971, .166,
., 2, 3; ,
, 1994, .75, .53, 528
58
, 1/1
. ,
, , 1989, .116,
., 112
59
, 1/1
. .
,
60
, 2/14
. .
., 1985, .229
61
1906., .95
62
1896., .87
63
, , 1989, .113
64
-,
.29
, 1963, .108
--
, . .
-,
. .
, .
.
, . .
--
, 1941, .157158,
.26
, , 2002, .78,
.1, 1
--
, , 1993,
.78, .2
, . .
--
,
-
--
, 1/
--
, .100, .V, 44
* . . 1977.
276
277
9.
+ +
+ +
28
29
30
31
32
, 1986, .258261
33
, 10/1
34
, 7/1
+ +
35
8/1
36
, . 3
37
. 21
, .20, .101, 4
38
. 64
, .29, .156, 1
39
. 69
, .32, .169, 16
40
. 78
, .34, .182, 17
41
. 84
, .35, .199, 1
42
. 85
, .36, .208, 1
, .1, 2
43
, . 4
. . . 1997.
, 1936, .V, 7
+ +
+ +
+ +
, , 1999, .12, .1
, 1987, .167; .8, 4
10
11
+ + +
44
. 35
--
12
+ + +
-, , 1984, .148161,
.1
45
. 56
--
, .158, .3; , ,
1981, .111
46
. 64
--
47
. 71
48
. 80
49
. 101
50
. 106
--
51
. 111
--
52
. 148
--
53
. 152
54
. 155
55
. 168
56
. 169
57
. 183
+ +
58
. 184
59
. 194
60
. 200
61
. 219
13
+ +
14
15
16
17
18
19
27
+ +
+ + +
+ +
+ +
, 29/1
., 2004, .137138, .3
+ +
26
+ + + + + +
+
, 1997, .77, .2
+ +
+ + +
+ +
20
+ +
. . . 1988.
21
+ +
22
-,
24/1
+ +
23
38/1
, .41, .13, 8
24
66/1
+ +
, .74, .22, 20
25
278
, 1960, .4, .1
, , 1992, .56
, 1976, .178, .5
. . . 1999.
-. . . 2000.
-. . . 2002.
-+
+ +
--. . . 2003.
279
62
. 222
+ +
63
. 251
64
. 271
65
. 275
66
. 294
--
67
, . 1
, 1977, .236252
68
. 3
69
, .
28
70
-, . 2
, 1963, .90123
71
. 4
+ +
72
. . 22
73
- , 16/1
+ . . . 1983.
74
17/1
75
, 9/1
76
12/2
77
- , 5/1
+ +
78
, 14/1
-. . . 2004.
--
--
1 ; 2 ; 3 ; 4 ; 5 ; 6
;7 .
280
Summary
The North Pontic region (in parts of present-day Ukraine and Moldova) was one of
the areas where Sarmatians, who played agreat
role in the ancient history of this land, lived.
Sarmatians appeared here in the 2nd century BC and very soon they became a main
ethnical and political force. Since that time,
the Sarmatian factor influenced the future
social, economical, and political development
of the neighboring lands and peoples.
The ethnopolitical background of the Sarmatian period in the North Pontic area was
acomplex one. The descendants of the steppe
Scythians were concentrated towards the 2nd
century BC in three enclaves (that doubtfully
had any political connection): on both shores
of the Dnieper river, in the Crimean piedmont,
and lowlands of the Dniester and Danube
rivers. Their culture, the so-called Late Scythian, continued to exist with the neighboring
Sarmatians until the middle of the 2nd century AD in the Dnieper and Danube river
areas, and until the middle of the 3rd century
AD in Crimea. On the right shore of the central Dniester area the neighbors of the Sarmatians from the 2nd century BCE until the end
of the 1st century AD were the tribes of the
Zarubinetskaya culture (the Bastarns). As the
Sarmatians moved to the west, at different
times they came into contact with Bastarns
of the Poeneti-Lukashivka culture (at theturn
of the millennium), Dac-Bastarns of the Lipitsa culture (during the second half of the
1st beginning of the 2nd century AD), and
the Germanic people of the Przeworsk and
Wielbark cultures (in the 1st2nd centuries
AD). From the middle of the 3rd century AD
the neighbors of the Sarmatians was the
ethnic and political union of the Goths
theTcherniakhiv culture. At the same time in
281
The main corpus of archaeological materials related to the Sarmatians of the North
Pontic region comes from the cemeteries, both
kurgan and ground ones. Apart of the objects
was found without apparent archaeological
context and it is very possible that we are
dealing with objects left on the places of ancient battles.
The historical sources written by the Sarmatians contemporaries are valuable but require careful critical approach. Some chronicles were based on the fragmentary narratives,
unverified stories, and quite often they contradict each other and are of fantastic nature.
The current typology of Sarmatian weaponry was offered by A.M.Khazanov (
, 1971). The types of side-arms were singled out by their pommel shape; arrowheads
by the angle between the blade and tang;
spearheads by the blades shape. As a whole,
this scheme is still accurate and I follow it in
my studies; one more type of swords and daggers could be added to it, namely one with
anantenna-pommel that was identified over
the last few years.
There are not many studies devoted to the
weaponry and warfare of the North Pontic
Sarmatians. Abrief survey on these subjects
was written in 1980s by M.I.Viazmitina
(, 1986, p.217 ff). Not all of the
weapons from the Sarmatian graves have been
published, only part of the materials is given
in works of different scholars (see References).
The first monographic study on the weaponry and warfare of the Sarmatians was published by the author in German (Simonenko,
2001). The present book is a significantly
revised and updated version of the German
edition.
The archaeological data in this book is
presented according to the new chronological
scheme of the Sarmatian historic and cultural
community established in works by C.V.Polin (, 1992), I.I.Marchenko (
, 1996), A.S.Skripkin (, 1990;
1992), I.V.Sergatskov (, 2000;
2004), and the author (, 1989;
282
Summary
Chapter 1
Swords and daggers
1.1. Weapons with the crescentpommel
In this category 11 items are cited (Appendix1).
Blades. Scythian, Saurormatian, and Sarmatian swords have two types of blades: ones
with parallels edges that narrowed only close
to the point and ones that narrowed immediately from the top and forming a triangleshaped blade. The amount of blades included
in the first category is more numerous. Most
of the blades are 33,5 to 44cm long and 4
5cm wide. All blades have the lens-shaped
cross-section; only one from Bolshaia Belozerka has a short lengthwise rib.
Guards. Almost all guards are straight, up
to 1cm wide. Taking into account the corrosion, the original width of such a guard should
not be over 0,60,8cm. The item from Ostry
has a guard that is slightly wider, 1,7cm.
Aguard on the sword from Grishino is archshaped. The ends of the guard go beyond the
blade on 11,5cm.
Handle. The handle of the majority of the
swords and daggers are narrow with rectan-
283
284
Summary
285
286
Summary
Chapter 2
Spears and javelins
2.1. Spears (lances)
Judging on the literary sources and representations, the spear was the one of the principal types of weaponry. Spearheads are rare
in the Sarmatian graves (Appendix5), and as
a ground for the typology the shape and proportions of the blade and socket were used.
Type 1. These are spears with a short leafshaped blade and a long socket. The blade
has a diamond cross-section, with rib, 14 and
10cm length, 24cm width. The length of
the socket varies insignificantly (2326cm)
and comprises 2/3 of the spearheads length
(fig.45).
The spearheads of type 1 originated in the
Kuban river region. The early Sarmatians of
the Ural piedmont and the Volga river regions
did not have such spearheads. In the North
Pontic region, the spearheads of type 1 were
found in so-called strange assemblages left,
most likely, by the migrants from the Kuban
river region.
Type 2. Spearheads with the long leafshaped blade. These spearheads have the
maximum width in the bottom part, just after
the socket. They are divided into two variants
by the length of the socket: 2a and 2b. The 2a
variant has the long socket that reaches up to
the half of the sockets length. The blade has
the diamond cross-section and a low central
rib. The length of the blade has 2025cm, its
width up to 2,5cm, the length of the socket
from 16 to 20,5cm (fig.47).
The spearheads were also found in the
strange assemblages and, probably, originated in the Kuban river region. It is interesting to note that the spearheads of type 1 and
type 2a are always found in pairs, presenting,
as would be, the required set of the weapon.
Type 2b presents the spearheads of the me
dium length that comprise up to 1/3 of the
spearheads length. All explored articles have
the lens-shaped cross-section and lack the rib.
2.2. Javelins
This weapon, so popular among the Scythians and Sauromatians, was practically not
used by the Sarmatians. The reason for this
could lay in the change of the fighting tactic:
instead of approaching the enemy lines and
throwing the spears and darts, as did the
Scythians, the Sarmatians attacked the enemy
formation with the spear assault.
A ten-centimeter fragment of the triangular blade of an iron dart was found in Velikoploskoe (fig.50:1). Its appearance resembles
the Scythian spearheads of the 4th century BC
but is atypical for Sarmatian weapons. This
type of javelins, disappeared in the North
Pontic region together with the Scythians,
was used by the Maeotians in the Kuban
river region.
In the Porohi tomb, near the arrowheads
(originally in the quiver?) was found a small
287
2.3. Chronology
The spearheads from the North Pontic region are significant in terms of their dating.
The spearheads of type 1 and type 2a and
javelinheads with triangular cuts were found
only in the strange assemblages of the early
Sarmatian period (2nd1st centuries BC). Thepa
rallels to them from the Kuban river region,
together with some other characteristics, once
more suggest that the strange assemblages
that included the mentioned spearheads,
should be connected to the Kuban river region.
The spearheads of type 2b appeared in the
early Sarmatian period in the first time but
were in use even later. The spearheads of type
3 are synchronous to them: they were found
in graves dated as to the early Sarmatian
aswell as to the middle Sarmatian periods.
Thespearheads of the types 3 and 4 from
Druzhnoe and Neizats are the latest ones.
They came from the multi-skeleton crypts of
the 4th century AD, where the last burials were
made at the end of that century (,
2002, p.70).
The sulitsa head from Porohi is dated,
similarly to the whole assemblage, to the last
quarter of the 1st century AD.
288
Summary
289
the attack at the full gallop, it was not necessary to hold the sarissa firmly, since the slash
gained strength due to the horses speed and
mass. After the charge, the rider threw sarissa
away and drew out the blade. M.Junkelmann
assured that it is not difficult to use a weapon
of the sarissas type at a gallop if holding it
in the middle of the shaft with the right hand
and the rein with the left hand (Junkelmann,
1992, S.144). The rider cannot hold the weapons recoil; rather the horse takes the brunt
of it, kept balanced with the help of the rein
on the croup.Otherwise, when the rein is
abandoned and the rider holds the spear with
both hands turning the torso he will fall out
of the saddle (fig.56).
Examples of the spears usage during the
battle in the recent times (by Lancers, Hussars,
and Cossacks) showed that often, after the
first thrust the lance stayed in the body of an
enemy, and the horseman drew his sword
(compare this with the opinion of M.Markle
on the usage of the sarissa). V.Littauer, who
undoubtedly knew the subject well, wrote:
Only those who would form the first
line carried lances. In a charge at full gallop
the lances were intended only for the first
shock; once they hit (or pierced) the enemy
they had to be dropped, otherwise the force
of the impact would have dislocated the lancers shoulder. As soon as he had dropped his
lance he drew his sword (highlighted by
yours truly. A.S.) (Littauer, 1993,
p.116).
The Sarmatian seat was created after
the paintings of the Bosporian crypts and
grave stelae of Roman times. The representations on them were made according to the
so-called frontal canon ( , 1997,
p.177). Until the end of the Hellenistic period in the classical art had dominated the
Greek-profile canon and the front side appeared in Palmyra and Syria at the end of the
1st century BC but wide distribution of it appeared in the 1st century AD.
In this canon everything is relative, from
the representation of the horse to representa-
290
Summary
tion of the rider. The pose in which the galloping horse is depicted does not exist in reality. The central figure was a horseman,
represented enface, in the majestic turn of his
body, with a spear in both hands. It was required by the composition; and the composition dictated to depict the rein abandoned.
Itis notable that in the few known representations that are not connected to the classical
canons (graffiti from Dura-Europos and Ilurat,
the plaque from the Orlat cemetery) the horsemen holds the spear with one hand and the
rein with the other. Especially representative
is the plaque from Orlat (fig.64).
I doubt the existence of the Sarmatian
seat, as V.D.Blavatski, A.M.Khazanov,
and S.M.Perevalov have explained it. It goes
from its physical and dynamical incompatibilities that were tested not only in field
experiments but during the centuries-old
experience in the spears use. Besides that,
theprimary iconographical sources for the
reconstruction are not totally correct.
Chapter 3
Bows and arrows
3.2. Arrowheads
3.1. Bow
In the North Pontic region, as in the other
Sarmatian territories, findings of bows are
rare. The bows of the Scythian type were found
in kurgan 8 of the Akkermen-II cemetery
( ., 1961, p.103) and in the
grave dated to the end of the 1st century AD
near the village of Vesniane, Nikolaev district
(Simonenko, 1997, S.392). The only bow of
the Hunic type was found in a kurgan near
the village of Porohi (, ,
1984, p.1214). Judging on the arrangement
of the bone plaques, its length in the released
state reached approximately 120cm.
Parallels to the bone plaques were found
in the Sarmatian graves of the Volga river
region and Kalmykia, as well as in the Hsiung-
291
Summary
3.4. Quivers
Quivers in the North Pontic region were
found in six sites. They are reconstructed as
a cylindrical case with oval or flat bottom.
The main material for quivers was either tree
bark or wood. In many cases the quivers were
covered by leather painted in one (more often
in red) or several colors.
292
Chapter 4
The armour
In this chapter the armour found in all
Sarmatian regions, is analyzed. It is necessary,
at least, to understand the reason of the lack
of Sarmatian armour on the territory of the
present-day Ukraine and Moldova.
In contrast to the Scythian armour, alot
of which was found in situ, almost all Sarmatian armours came from robbed tombs, were
broken. There are only samples of scales
and plates; in rare cases the fragments of the
sets that could be used as a ground for reconstructions were preserved. In the absence of
thematerial objects, the scarce evidence in
the written sources and image representations
are especially important.
4.1. Armour
Armour from the Sarmatian graves could
be divided into five types: scale, combined,
lamellar, mail, and cuirass.
The scale armour is typical for the Scythians of the 7th6th centuries BC and also known
from a few Sauromatian graves, were later
used by the Sarmatians in the 2nd1st centuries
BC.
The iron scales, as a rule, are rectangular
with rounded lower edge, their size varies
from 42,5cm to 65cm. Besides the size,
the scales differ from the Scythians by the
arrangement of the holes: two or three pairs
of holes run along the top edge, one beneath
another (fig.73:1, 2).
There are two types of bronze scales that
came from the Grushevskaya: curved scales
with a triangular lower edge and the straight
293
294
Summary
4.2. Helmets
The Sarmatian helmets of Eurasia came
in different types: pseudo-Attic, Celtic, Pilos,
Montefortino, Imperial-Gallic (according to
the Robinsons classification), and framed.
The separate group includes local helmets
that copied the classical types, and also helmets of a type which could not be established.
Seven helmets were found in the North
Pontic region, two pseudo-Attic type and five
Montefortino type.
Pseudo-Attic helmets were in the stray
finds near the villages of Bubueici (Moldova)
and Kamenka-Dneprovskaia (fig.105108).
This type of helmet was in use from the end
of the 4th century to the middle of the 2nd
century BC (Waurick, 1989, S.170). Assemblages where the helmets were found are
dated to the time of the Mithridate wars.
Helmets of the Montefortino type. There
are five helmets of this type from the North
Pontic area (Veselaya Dolina, Marievka, Be
lenkoe, Privillia, Melitopol). The crest-knob
and decoration of the helmets are typical for
the B-Robinson (D-Coarelli) type. The calotte
constitutes something in-between the A- and
B-Robinson and C- and D-Coarelly types
(fig.120), and in all characteristics it does
not have exact parallels in classifications of
Robinson and Coarelly.
4.3. Shields
The Roxolans shields, made of weaved
rods and covered by leather, are mentioned
by Strabo (Strabo, VII, 3). However, Tacitus
describing the Sarmatian warriors noted that
they have no habit to protect themselves
bya shield (Tac., nn., I, 79). In any case,
theexcavated shields are practically unknown.
A bronze convex, egg-shaped plaque of
6042cm, 9cm height (fig.121:1) found in
a strange assemblage near Velikoploskoe
is considered a piece of shield binding (, , 1984, p.154155). However, its small size suggests that the object,
more likely, was a shields model, e.g. avotive for the offering.
The iron shield-bosses of the Germanic
shields (fig.121) of types 1, 2 D after
N.Zieling were found in Crimea and Budzhak. These types of shields were used in
180350 AD by all Germanic warriors and
the Sarmatians got them from the neighboring
Goths.
295
Chapter 5
Horse harness
The horse harness has been analyzed according to its functional characteristic: bits,
check-pieces, bridle decorations, check-plates,
frontlets, phalerae, breastgirth decorations,
and saddles.
5.1. Bits
All bits found in the North Pontic area
were made of iron, they are two-pieced,
themouthpieces ends twisted into loops.
Themouthpieces are straight, with mainly
around or rarely square cross-section. Thedis
tinctive feature of the early bits (2nd1st centuries BC) are the twisted mouthpieces.
Insome graves of the Middle Sarmatian period, whole and fragmented bits with mouthpieces that had a plain, round, or square crosssection were found (fig.125). In the cemeteries
of Budzhak (Chaush, Kurchi, Kubei) and
Crimean piedmont (Neisats, Druzhnoe, Cherno
rechenskiy, Ozernoe) dated to the latest period, bits of the modern type with large moveable rings are a common find (fig.126).
The bits of the Early Sarmatian period with
twisted mouthpieces often have the cross-like
washers at the ends. They exerted pressure on
the corners of the horses mouth intensifying
the pain. Almost all of these bits were found
in strange assemblageds. They constitute
the memorial offerings with the standard set
of the warriors harness. The closest parallels
to the bits with the cross-like washers were
found in the Kuban river region and dated to
the beginning of the 1st century BC.
5.2. Check-pieces
According to their shape, the check-pieces could be divided into several types.
Type 1. C-shaped check-pieces of several variants:
1.1 with spherical or rounded-biconical
ends (fig.124:1, 2).
296
Summary
5.4. Check-plates
The strange assemblages from the village of Bubuieci (Moldova) included two
rounded-trapezoid bronze plates decorated
with compositions in relief (fig.155). Similar
check-plates laid on a horse skull in a grave
near the village of Chistenkoe, Crimea, dated
to the end of the 2nd beginning the 1st century BC. These objects are of the Celtic-Illyric
origin.
Two figured check-plates decorated in the
cloisonn style and dated to the second half of
the 4th century AD were discoveredinkurgan
14 near Kazaklia (Moldova) (fig.156:1).
5.5. Frontlets
According to the construction and shape,
the Sarmatian frontlets could be combined
into several types.
The most numerous are the so-called frontlets with hook (fig.159); most of them are made
out of bronze and in rare cases out of iron or
silver. As the prototypes for the frontlets with
hook served the analogues bridle ornaments of
Scythian horses of the 5th4th centuries BC. Their
latest shape, analyzed in this work, the frontlets
with hook got during the second half of the 3rd
century BC. Amold made from a handle of the
Rhodian amphora (fig.160) was found in Skythian Neapolis. The chronology of these frontlets spans several centuries, from the end of the
3rd century until the beginning of the 1st century BC (, 1982, p.242).
In a strange assemblage from Marievka,
alongside with a frontlet with hook was found
a bronze U-shaped staple (fig.131; 131,b).
M. Treister considered this object as a Celtic
check-piece (Raev et al., 1991, .484). How-
5.6. Phalerae
Phalerae, the large, convex or flat roundels, decorated the breastbands and/or crupper. In the first case the phalerae were placed
at the crossing of two straps: one strap ran
over the breast, and another one ran over the
withers; in the second case they were placed
at the crossing of the straps of the crupper,
going lengthwise and widthwise, approximately in the middle of croup, on both its
sides.
Phalerae of the 2nd1st century BC in the
North Pontic area could be combined into two
groups: hemispherical, gilded silver phalerae,
with vegetative dcor and anecdotic images
(fig.166168); flat silver and bronze phalerae with geometric design (fig.170).
The Sarmatians continued to decorate the
horse harness with phalerae during the Roman times as well. In kurgan 10 near Kazaklia (Moldova) two shoulder phalerae of the
unique schema were found: flat iron discs of
12,8cm and 13,2cm in diameter and decorated with encrusted golden foil (fig.171).
The Kazaklia grave has a reliable date, the
1st century AD (, , 1999,
p.15).
Two phalerae were included in a set excavated in kurgan 5 of the Chaush cemetery
(Ukraine) dated to the 4th century AD. They
are the flat bronze disks with 7,3cm and 7cm
diameter, covered with gilded silver plaque
decorated with a complex relief geometric
design and insertion of carnelians in the center (fig.127).
297
298
Summary
The earliest images of the Sarmatian saddled horses are dated to the 1st century AD.
One is a couldron horse-shaped handle from
the village of Kiliakovka (fig.186:1); these
are also representations of horses in the battle scenes on a silver vessel from Kosika
(fig.186:3, 4) and a bone plaque from Orlat
(fig.186:2).
The couldron handle and the representation
on the silver vessel display Sarmatian horses,
and on the plaque, according to a number of
scholars, the Hsiung-nu fighting each other or
Yueh-chihs are shown (Ilyasov, Rusanov,
1997/98, p.131134). Despite the schematic
nature of the representations, it is possible to
see that the saddles are very different from
theScythian ones: they have high arches
(thefront arch is slightly higher and steeper
than the rare arch) and a dip saddle-tree.
Here we have a very important source for
the study of the nomadic saddle from the
early Iron Age. Firstly, these representations
were made by Barbarian artisans who were
familiar with the object and independent of
the classical canon. Secondly, the schematic
nature of the images on the vessel from Kosika and couldron from Kiliakovka in particular make them trustworthy, because by only
sketching the saddles, the artisans underlined
the most distinctive features of this type of
saddle, namely, the dip saddle-tree and high
arches.
A saddle of a new type appeared in the
iconography of Bosporus, Parthia, Kushan
Empire, Bactria-Sogdiana, and the Late Han
from the 1st century AD. V.P. Nikonorov suggests that the Parthians, besides the horn
saddles borrowed from them by the Romans,
used the frame-saddle with the front and rare
arches (, 2001, p.116).
Thus, based on this iconographical material, asaddle of the new type was already in
use in the Eurasian steppes and neighboring
regions in the 1st century AD. It had to have
the hard wooden frame, since there was nothing else to which the high arches could be
attached.
Chapter 6
Sarmatian warfare
of the north pontic region
6.1. Armament of the Sarmatian
army
While analyzing archaeological materials,
it should be taken into account that the assemblages of weapons found in graves may
not adequately reflect the existed weaponry
assemblage. Historical writings and, in a less
degree, iconographical sources significantly
broadens our understanding, even so, using
the iconographical sources we have to be
strictly critical, since the depictions depended on a number of coincidences and circumstances unrelated to the history of arms, such
as the artistic qualities of a painter, specifics
of a certain canon or a monument when
animage is shown, etc.
The Early Sarmatian period. There are
74different sites belonging to this period:
51graves, 13strange assemblages, 5hoards
with phalerae, and several stray finds. Weapons
were found in 21graves and in all strange assemblages; horse harness were included in
strange assemblages and hoards.
During the early period, the Sarmatians
had a people-army military structure, e.g.
299
300
Summary
11
Here, of course, the author talks about the Sarmatians. It is well known that the classical authors did not
differentiate these groups (see: , 1971,
p.49).
301
302
Summary
303
304
. . : , , ,
:
,
. ., 1880. 145 .: .
.., . .
( )// . 1975.
1. .2842.
. .
// . 1962. 115. .274
283.
. .
// . 1969. 169. .310.
. . - .
, 1972. 76 .: .
. . . ., 1993. 238 .: .
.., . .
. .. .// ( 100- ..). ,
1999. .1015.
. . ., 2007.
511 .: .
. ., . ., . :
IV. .. ,
1991. 411 .: .
. . // 112. ., 1978. 105 .:.
. . //
. .,
1987. .160177.
. . //
. 1971. 7. .3241.
. .
// 130. ., 1966. 113 .: .
. . //
. 1973. 4. .8198.
. . . . // . 1979.
4. .229231.
. ., . . // : -
, ... ,
1992. .56.
. . // . V.
., 1887. .342390.
. . -
-// . 1951. 23.
.155207.
. .
// . 1958. 28. .6271.
. . IVIII. .. -
//
. , 1981. .94100.
. ., . . 3
..// . .6.
. 2006. .205228.
. . // . .109. .,
1935. .197213.
. 1934
1936.: . .; .,
1941. 328 .: .
.
.// -: . . , 2004.
.45. 132 .: .
.., . . . ., 1953. 132 .: .
. . //
. 1963. .. .90123.
. ., . .
//
.
., 1992. .115122.
. . // . .3. ., 2002. .157168.
..
// . 1988.
4. .103115.
.. .// VII
( ).
/, 1998. .8788.
.. ( )//
. /, 2000. .169193.
. . .
, 1997. 85 .: .
305
. ., . . 2
-I// - . .10.
, 1991. .8596.
. . .
// . 1961. . . .5663.
. ., . ., . .
. // . 1995.
.122128.
. . I. .. .// .
1985. 4. .163172.
. .
.// . 1992. 1. .175190.
. .
// -
19721979. . .3. 1987. .11
139.
. . //
. .. .; ., 1949. C. 9699.
. . .
., 1954. 160 .: .
. .
. .I. ., 1887.
248.: .
. .
1907.// .
.35. ., 1910. .4860.
. .
. . . (
- ) //
. , 1988. .7380.
. . . ., 1908.
280 .: .
. ,
// . 1991. 3. .2530
. ., . . - - // . 1993. 7. .7881.
.. ( ). , 1991.
158 .: .
. . (
IVIII. ..). , 1985.
227 .
.
, //
. .16. , 1986. 151 .: .
306
. // . 1993.
3. .1518.
.. // . 1963. .. .1589.
. ., . . -// . 1971.
1. .171180.
. . // Stratum + .
: 60 .. ...
., , 1997. .7380.
. .
. ..// . 1987.
1. .5587.
. . // - . ., 1984. .3743.
. . -
. ..// . 1994. 2.
.151170.
. ., . .
. ..// .
.112. ., 1967. .126131.
.. I.
. . II. . . . II: , , . ., 2006. 317.
. ., . .,
..
// . 2002. 3. .115120.
. ., . .
IVVI.// VVIII. .,
1982. .121165.
.., . . ,
:
// :
, , .
., 2006. .8893.
.. -
. , 1994. 206 .: .
. . .-// . ., 1954. .220
244.
. .
. // . 1960. .VIII. .17
21.
. . //
. .2. , 1971.
.185215.
. . . .,
1980. 256 .: .
. . ( )// . 19791980.
, 1983. .2853.
. . // . 1986. 1. .258261.
. .
-
. , 1990. 202 .: .
. .
I, III, IV
//
. /, 2000. .141
155.
. ., . .
//
. .VII.
, 1999. .177193.
. ., . . IIV. .. ,
1984. 118 .: .
. . :
. , 2001.
255.:.
. .
// . 1961. 2. .241246.
. . //
( 169). ., 1969.
.4352.
. .
..// (. .
.54). ., 1982. .2030.
. ., . . ..
(. ..
. ..)//
., 1989 (..
.70). .71149.
. ., . . ( ..)// . , 1992.
.4567.
. ., . .
. ., 1994.
170.: .
.., .., .., -..
--
307
// . 1978. ., 1979. .167168.
. . (1975
1976.). , 1982. 138 .: .
. .
// I . .,
1968. .4451.
. .
// . 1972. 4. .6877.
. . // . 1973. 4. .6980.
. . IIIII.
// - . , 1981. .116125.
. .
- // -
. , 1982. .8392.
. .
I. ..
IV. .. , 1993.
203.: .
. . - . , 2003.
239.: .
- . ., . . . // -
. , 1984. .148161.
. .
. // . 1979. 4. .212229.
. . //
(
). ., 1984. .95152.
.
VII. . .. , 1984. 175 .: .
//
. ., 1985. 495.:.
. ., . . (
19771992.)
(). , 1992. 20 .: .
-. . ., 1979.
607 .: .
. . //
- . , 1984. .7299.
. .
308
// . , 1988. .5468.
. . .. 1927. // . 1980. .162.
.3238.
. . : . . . . ., 1980.
. .
- VI. .. I. ..
//
- . .,
1984. .6568.
. . -
: pro contra//
. , 1994. .55
59.
. . ( )//
- . .,
1994. .94100.
. . ,
//
. 1994. , 1997. .102
118.
. .
//
: .
, 2005. .8894.
. ., . .
// . 2003. 3.
.6199.
. ., ..
// . ., 2/97. , 1997. .4959.
..
// . 1946. .III.
.950.
. ., . ., . .
. // .
.11. , 2004. .130144.
. .
// . . .. ., 1979. .87
113.
. .
( IVV. ..)//
. , 1983. .7083.
. . IV
V. ..// . .III. ,
1993. .23105.
. .
// . 1993. 1.
.6670.
. ., . . ..//
. , 1984. .148155.
. .
//
. . ., 2000. .304330.
. .
// : . , 2004. .205220.
. . -
//
. , 1993. .144161.
. . . .,
1984. 87 .: .
. . 1. ., 1901. 156 .: .
. . IV. ..//
. , 1973. .4263.
. . //
. /, 2000. .100140.
. .
- //
. /, 2002. .231242.
. . -
// .
.IV. , 1995. .238256.
. ., . ., . .
.
()// . 1985. 4. .228234.
. ., . . - .
// . ,
1987. .4748.
.. I.
.. ..// .
., 1967. .145150.
.., . .
( )// . .2. ., 1992. .113
126.
. .
, 2000. 352 .
/ . . . . , 1981. 120 .: .
. . - // - 19721979. , 1985. .135
259.
. . //
136. ., 1966. 146 .: .
..
.. 19351940.// . 1952. 25. .289
326.
. . I. ..
. , 1986. 150 .: .
. ., . .
//
.
, 1987. .75106.
..
- (III. .. III. ..): .
. . . . ., 1994.
.. //
. ., 1999.
.159189.
..
// . 1983. 2. .222224.
.., . .
. .2. , 1998. 88 .: .
., . . -// . .II. .1.
, 2006. .129160.
. . . , 1983.
182 .: .
. . // .
.1. , 1977. .114131.
. . . // .
.2. , 1978. .7986.
. .
// . .3. ,
1979. .124130.
. . III. ..
III. ..: . . . . .
., 1981.
. . // . , 1982. .6975.
309
. . // . , 1983. .5965.
. . //
. , 1984. .157166.
. .
( - ).
, 1993. 151 .: .
. ., . ., . .
- //
. , 1987.
.114127.
. ., . . //
. ,
1995. .158179.
. . //
-.
, 1987. .1922.
. . . //
. 1991. 3. .3133.
. . // . 1998.
4. .128134.
. ., . ., . .
// . 1987. 58.
.5663.
. ., . ., . .,
.., . .
1981. //
.
. ., . ., ..
2 // .
2000. 2. .4047.
. .
., 1997. 359 .: .
., .
. 40 // - . , 2003. .285312.
.., . ., . .
// . 1995. 1. .112
123.
. . // .
1973. 3. .2436.
310
. . -V
// V . . , 2006.
.192199.
. . ,
1901. // . .4.
., 1902. .120131.
. .
// 131. ., 1965.
138.:.
. . 3 //
. , 1988. .3554.
. ., . .
// :
. , 2005. .162167.
. . // . 1965. 2. .7591.
. .
( )// . 1966. 4. .5169.
. . (
). .2:
.
., 2001. 528 .: .
. : 19111920. , 2005.
256.: .
. .
19631965 .// . 1977. 4. .236252.
. . // :
. .230. , 1979.
.160164.
. . . // . 1952. .VII. .136141.
. ., . . // . .6. , 1997. .304323.
. . . /, 1983. 222 .: .
. . . , 1982. 182 .: .
. . . ., 1979.
151 .: .
. . //
. ; , 2000. .167170.
. .
.// . 1986. 56. .81
88.
. . . . // . , 1973.
.187234.
. . :
. ., 1974.
408.:.
. ., . . V // . .III. , 1999. .124146.
. . 3. .. . 2. .. //
. .1. , 1998. .5161.
. .
// . 2001. 2. .108114.
. .
IIII. ..
//
. ., 2001. .161166.
. ., . .
. . . ;
, 2007.
. ., . .
. , 2006. 139.:.
. .
// 110. ., 1963. 56 .: .
. ., - . .
//
. .1. ., 1974.
.21123.
.. // ..VIII. , 2001. .5166.
. ., . . //
. , 1980. .155168.
. ., . ., . .,
. . -
. ., 2006. 207 .: .
. . ., 1980.
213.: .
. .
135 .//
Stratum Plus. 1999. 3. .173188.
. . .
II. .. V. .. .,
2004. 189 .: .
311
. . (
, )//
.
.2. , 1993. .1520.
. .
// . , 1994. .2829.
. .
//
. 1985. 184. .3035.
. . //
. , 2001. .115
116.
. .
//
. , 2002.
.2127.
. ., . .
// :
.
.2. . ,
1999. .141154.
. . . ,
2002. 215 .: .
1896. ., 1898. 252 .: .
1899. ., 1902. 184 .: .
1901. ., 1903. 198 .: .
1902. ., 1904. 199 .: .
1906. ., 1909. 166 .: .
. .
// . 1978. 4. .115127.
.. . // . 1954. .IV. .4347.
.. IIIV.//
. , 1978. .87124.
1908. ., 1909. 60 .: .
. . // .
1995. 3. .200205.
. ,
//
. .3. ., 1903. .3740.
. , . ., ..
//
- .
, 1982. .131136.
.. II. ..
(
312
)// . .2.
; ., 1997. .129134.
.. (
)// . .3.
; ., 1998. .96101.
..
// . 1999. 4. .6576.
.. // . 2007. 3. .139
162.
. .
-// . ., 1975. .280313.
. .
. //
. ., 1994.
.129231.
. .
II ()// . 1975. 4. .256259.
. . VIII. ..// 14. ., 1967.
180 .
. . ,
-
( 100-
..)// -
. , 1999. .201203.
. . . , 1990.
198.:.
.
:. , 2004.
255.:i.
.. //
I. .. , 1983. .920.
. .
. , 1998.
84 .: .
.. // . 1984. .45.
.2434.
.. . , 1992.
200 .: .
.., . .
//
.
, 1990. .7695.
. .
// . , 1990. .101107.
. . . ,
2001. 334 .: .
. ., . .
I// . 1999. 34. .115121.
.., . .
10 // . 1992. 1. .142161.
. . . ., 1971.
203 .: .
. . . ,
1989. 200 .: .
. ., . ., . .
IIIIV. .. -
// . .VIII. , 2001. .3250.
. ., . ., . .
//
. , 1991.
.116121.
. . . //
. 1964. .102. .433.
. . //
. . .I. ., 1941. .99171.
. . // . 1988,
.194. .3739.
. ., . .
IV
. , 2006.
109.:.
. ., . . : // :
, , . .,
2007. .268273.
. ., . ., . .
-
// . , 1990. .117135.
. .
. ., 1975.
183.:.
. ., . .
II I. ..
// . .2. , 2002. .78
96.
. ., -. // : -
. .2.
. , 1999.
.4255.
. . // . .5. , 1975.
.358.
. .
// . .49.
., 1913. .133140.
. . . ., 1914. 537 .: .
. .
// . 1918. 37. .3102.
..
. .; ., 1960. 402 .: .
. .
// . 1977. 3.
.282283.
. ., . .
// . 1980. ., 1981.
.117119.
. .
//
. , 1992. .244274.
. . . .,
1908. 271 .: .
. .
// . .3. , 2000.
.113122.
. . //
: . , 2004. .3758.
. .
( )// . .8.
, 2006. .246247.
. // . , 1936. 2. .3650.
. . // . .V. , 1996.
.3559.
. . //
. , 1982.
.237245.
. .
//
. , 1984.
.129147.
. . III. .. III. ..:
. . . . , 1986.
313
. .
// .
1986. .55. .8088.
. . -
//
. , 1987. .104
113.
. .
// :
.. (. .). ,
1989. .117120.
. . //
: . , 1989.
.7880.
. . (
)// . 1991. 4.
.1728.
. . . , 1993.
142.: .
. .
III. ..: //
: . , 1993. .8990.
. .
// . 1994.
1. .3248.
. .
// .
. ., 1998. .164
167.
. .
// . .1. ,
1998. .6878.
. .
// . 1999. 1. .106118.
. .
// . .3.
, 2000. .133144.
. . // .
2001. 4. .7791.
. . .
..// . .4. , 2001. .92
106.
314
. . [.]
. /, 2000// . 2001. 34.
.166174.
. . ?//
(. .). ; , 2001.
.161166.
. . // .
2002. 1. .107122.
. .
// : . ,
2004. .134173.
. . //
.
, 2004. .222226.
. .
// Liber Archaeologicae:
, 60- ...
, 2006. .137152.
. .
//
: . , 2007. .99113.
. . ( ).
. ., . . I. .. ( . ). , 1991.
111.:.
. .
// . 1960. 78. .10168.
. . // Para
Bellum. 2004. 3. .87106; 4. .77102.
.. // .
1981. 36. .1926.
..
// .
, 1984. .82103.
. .
- .
1978. // . -1, 7349.
. . . ,
1990. 299 .: .
. . .
, : . . - . . .,
1992.
. . // . .3.
, 2000. .1740.
. .
// . .,
2005. .171185.
. ., . .
// . 1977.
.285287.
. .
// . 1940. 3/4.
.363366.
. . // . .
.2. ., 1953. 42 .: .
. .
// . ., 1954.
.196219.
. . // .
1961. 101. 160 .: .
. . . . ., 1964. 379 .: .
. . - //
. 1980. .162. .3845.
. . . ., 1984.
181.: .
. ., . . // 19.
., 1963. 39 .: .
. . .
// . 1962. .4. .5740.
. . // . 1954.
33. .123169.
. . : .
. . . . ., 1954.
. . : .
. . . ., 1954.
. . // .
1955. .58. .1425.
. . .
:
. , 2003. 223 .: .
. .
. , 1959. 175 . : .
. .
// .
. . 1.
, 1960. .149154.
. . // .
.29. ., 1909. .1853.
. . . ,
1980. 108 .: .
. . : // . .II. ., 2003.
.151154.
. . //
:
. .I. ., 2004. .231246.
. .
//
. .13. ., 2006. .103150.
. ., 1939.
135.:.
. ., . .
-
(). .. , 1990. 72 .: .
. ., . ., . .
. // . 1970.
.6. .130155.
. ., .. //
- . , 1981.
.102116.
. .
. //
. ., 1991. .143145.
. .
VVII.// . .2.
, 2004. .4047.
. ., . .
: - //
. 2006. 3. .3140.
. . // . 1976. 1. .8090.
. .
:
- .
., 1984. 246 .
. . -
. .; ., 1940. 178 .: .
. .
//
. , 1987.
.46.
. . // . 1992. 2. .3750.
. . (
)// . 1994. 1. .172204.
. .
//
315
:
8- .
, 1315 2001. ,
2002. .100103.
. . -
I. ..// . 1960. 89. 380 .: .
. . .
// . 1969. 169. .248253.
- . . // . 1980. 2. .235238.
. .
// . 1972. 3. .154174.
. .
// - .
, 1986. .157161.
. . //
. .2. -,
1990. .109110.
. . //
. .10. , 1998. .3540.
. . . //
. 1960. .VIII. .136140.
. .
- //
. ., 1966. .2944.
. . .
., 1971. 169 .: .
. . . ,
2000. 601 .
. ., . . // .
1979. .30. .1827.
. ., . . . .VI.
, 1907. 44 .: .
.
. ., 1983. 120 .
. . : . .
. , 1995. 83 .: .
. . (IIIIV.
..). Lublin, 2002. 313 .: .
. . // . .VI. ; , 2004.
238.: .
. . III. ..
// , ,
316
. .XVI/1. .; ,
2006. .104118.
. . , 2005.
30 .: .
. . .
, 1986. 268 .: .
. ., . . . ,
1987. 140 .: .
. . . , 1968.
190.: .
. . //
. ., 1971. .3538.
. . [.] . . . ., , 1971// .
1973. 2. .271273.
. . // . , 1977. .120
127.
. .
// . , 1980. .730.
. . . , 1982.
167 .: .
. . - . ,
1984. .5975. 1117 .: .
. . //
- . .,
1984. .231235.
. . // . ,
1984. .5975.
. . // . 1987. 4. .158173.
. . 1957. //
. -1, 1963.
. . //
. 1959. 60. .323523.
. .
. ., 1975. 208 .: .
. .
//
. ., 1978. .111117.
. . . 1902.//
. .9. ., 1904. .73177.
. ., . .
// .
1970. 6. .5115.
400. . . i . // i. 1973.
. 8. .2088.
. .
// .
. . 1.
, 1960. .149154.
. .
// . ,
1985. .7093.
. . .
, 1962. 280 .: .
. ., . ., . .,
. . // . 1974.
1. .181190.
. ., . .
VI
. , 1969. 327 .: .
. . .
// . 1982.
.37. .3542.
. .
.
// . 1987.
.28. .103118.
. . I. .. // . 1989. 1.
.7083.
. . : III. .. I. .. . ., 1994.
323.:.
. . (
)//
. ., 2001. .137
161.
. .
// :
: ,
77- . .,
2004. .445463.
. .
// . II .
.I. ., 1907. .108157.
. . //
. 1996. 3. .176179.
. ., . . (
.)//
( ). , 2000. .328.
. .
// .
. 89. ., 1962. .4252.
.., . .
// Stratum Plus. 2000. 4.
.226250.
Agulnikov S.M., Simonenko A.V. ALate Sarmatian
Bridle Set from Moldova// ComArHung. 1993.
P.9198.
Alexandrescu A. D. Tombes de chevaux et pices du
harnais dans la nkropole Gte de Zimnicea//
Dacia. 1983. XXVII. Nos.12. P.6778.
Arnut T., Ursu Naniu R. Considrations sur une
dcouverte faite aux alentours du village Bubuieci (Rpublique de Moldova)// Studia Antiqua
et Archaeologica. VII. Iai, 2000. P.351362.
Azzaroli A. An Early History of Horsemanship.
Leiden, 1985. 201 p.: Ill.
Brc V. Sarmatis Sword and Daggers with Ringshape Handle in the Northern and North-Western
of the Black Sea// Istros. Vol. IX. Brila, 1999.
P.99120.
Brc V. Cteva observaii cu privere la tezaurele i
depozitele sarmatice timpurii (sec. III a. Chr.)
din spaiul dintre Don i Prut// Studia Historica
et Archaeologica In Honorem Magistrae Doina
Benea. Timioara, 2004. P.3563.
Biborski M. Miecze z okresu wpyww rzymskich
na obszarze kultury przeworskiej// Materiay
Archeologiczne. 1978. T.XVIII. S.53165.
Bittel K. Die Galater in Kleinasien, archaologisch
Gesehen// Assimilation et rsistance la culture
grco-romaine dans la monde ancien: Travaux
di VIe Congrs Intrnational dEtudes Classiques
(Madrid, Septembre 1974). Bucureti; Paris,
1976. S.241249.
Bittel K. Die Galater, archaologisch Gesehen// Proceedings of the Xth International Congress of
Classical Archaeology (Ankara, Izmir, 1973).
Vol.I. Ankara, 1978. S.169174.
Brzezinski R., Mielczarek . The Sarmatians (Osprey
military elite series, v. 68). Oxford, 2002.
48p.:Ill.
Chine: des chevaux et des hommes: donation facques
Polain Paris, 1995. 198 p.: Ill.
Bunker E., Kawami T. S., Linduff K. M., Wu En, 1997.
Ancient Bronzes of the Eastern Eurasian Steppes
from the Arthur M.Sackler Collections. New
York. 401 p.: Ill.
Coulston J. C. Roman, Parthian and Sassanid tactical
developments // /Tthe Defence of the Roman and
Byzantine East. Vol. I(BAR international series
S297). Oxford, 1986. P.5975.
317
Dinnys I. Ahviszdyrki szarmata srok// A rgszeti tanulmnyok Pest medyebl. Studii Comitatensia 22. Szentendre, 1991. P.145158.
Dintsis P.Hellenistische Helme. Roma, 1986. 2 vol.:
Ill.
Dixon K. R., Southern P.The Roman Cavalry. From
the 1st to the 3rd Century AD. London, 1992.
256p.: Ill.
Gamber O. Kataphracten, Clibanarier, Normanenreiter// Jahrbuch der Kunsthistorischen Sam
mlungen in Wien. 1968. Bd64. 744.
Germanen, Hunnen und Awaren. Schtze der Vlkerwanderungszeit. Nrnberg, 1988.
Ginters W. Das Schwert der Scythen und Sarmaten
in Sdrussland. Berlin, 1928.
Han Zhongmin, Delahaye H. Das Alte China. 5000
Jahre Geschichte und Archologie. Freiburg,
1985.
Haussig H. W. Archologie und Kunst der Seidenstrae. Mainz, 1992. 329 S.: Ill.
Hermann G. Parthian and Sassanian Saddlery. New
Light from the Roman West// Archaeologia Iranica et Orientalis. Miscellinea in honorem Louis
Vanden Berghe. Vol. II. Gent, 1989. P.757809.
Hyland A. Training the Roman Cavalry: From Arrians Ars tactica. Stroud, 1993. 197 p.: Ill.
I Tesori della Steppa di Astrakhan. Milano, 2005.
183 p.: Ill.
Ilyasov J. Ya., Rusanov D. V. AStudy on the Bone
Plates from Orlat//Silk Road Art and Archaeology. Vol. 5. Kamakura, 1997/98. P.107159.
Istvnovits E., Kulczr V. Sarmatians through theeyes
of strangers. The Sarmatian warrior// International Connections of the Barbarians of the Carpathian Basin in the 1st5th centuries A.D.
Aszd; Nyregyhza, 2001. P.139169.
Jahn M. Die Bewaffnung der Germanen in der lterren Eisenzeit. Wrzburg, 1916. 200 S.: Ill.
Jakounina-Ivanova L. Une Trouvaille de lge de
LaTene dans la Russie meridionale// ESA. 1927.
Bd.1. P.101106.
James S.Dura Europos and the Introduction of
Mongolian Release. BAR International Series
336. (Roman Military Equipment). Oxford, 1987.
P.7783.
Junkelmann M. Die Reiter Roms. Teil III. Mainz,
1992. 277 S.: Ill.
Khrapunov I. N. ANew Account on the Contacts
between the Sarmatiansand the Germans in
Crimea (on the materials on the excavations of
the cemetery of Neyzats in 2001)// Monumenta Studia Gothica IV. Lublin, 2004. P.185
197.
318
Leskov A. Grabschtze der Adygeen: neue Entdechungen im Nord koukasus. Mnchen, 1990.
197S.: Ill.
Lor des amazones: peuples nomades entre Asie et
Europe, VIe sicle av. J.-C. IVe sicle apr.
J.-C.: Musee Cernuschi, Muse des arts de lAsie
de la ville de Paris, 16 mars 15 juillet 2001.
Paris, 2001. 300 .: Ill.
Markle III M. M. The Macedonin Sarissa, Spear and
Related Armor// AJA. 1977. Vol.81. . 336
339.
Mielczarek M. Cataphracti and Clibanarii. Studies of
the Heavy Armoured Cavalry of the Ancient
World. d, 1993. 145 p.: Ill.
Mielczarek M. The Army of the Bosporan Kingdom.
d, 1999. 102 p.: Ill.
Mordvinceva V. Sarmatische Phaleren. Archologie
in Eurasien. Bd.11. Rahden, 2001. 98 S.: Ill.
Mzquiz J. G.-M. Los cascos de tipo Montefortino
en la peninsula Iberica// Complutum. 1993.
Vol.4. P.95146.
Otchir-Goriaeva M. Das Sarmatische Grab von
Jakul, Kalmykien// Eurasia Antiqua. Bd.8.
2002. S.353387.
Pirazzoli-tSerstevens M. China zur Zeit der HanDynastie. Kultur und Geschichte. Stuttgart, 1982.
240 S.Ill.
Podobed V. A., Simonenko A. V. ALate Sarmatian
Burial in the Central Donetsk basin// ComArHung. 1998. . 99108.
Raev B. A. Roman Imports in the Lower Don basin//
BAR International Series 278. Oxford, 1986.
136p.: Ill.
Raev B. A., Simonenko A.V., Treister M. Ju. EtruscoItalic and Celtic Helmets in Eastern Europe//
JahrRGZM. Bd.38/2. 1991. S.465496.
Rau P.Prhistorische Ausgrabungen auf der Steppenseite des deutschen Wolgagebiets in Jahre
1926. Pokrowsk, 1927. 112 S.: Ill.
Rawson J. Chinese jade from the Neolithic to the
Qing. London, 1995. 436 p.: Ill.
Reinach S.La representation du galop dans lart
ancient et moderne. Paris, 1925. 126 p.: Ill.
Reinecke P.Ein neuer Bronzehelm italischer Form
aus der Ukraine// Festschrift fr Otto Tschumi.
Frauenfeld, 1948. S.9398.
Robinson H. R. The Armour of Imperial Rome.
Thatford, 1975. 200 p.: Ill.
Rostovtseff M. I. Dura and the Problem of Parthian
Art. New Haven, 1935. 304 p.: Ill.
Rudenko S.I. Frozen Tombs of Siberia: the Pazyryk
burials of Iron Age horsemen. London, 1970.
340p.: Ill.
Ammianus Marcellinus. Res Gestae.
Ambrosius. De excidio urbis hierosolymitanae libri
quinque.
Appianus. Mithridateios.
Arrianus, Flavius. Ektasis kat alanon.
Arrianus, Flavius. exne taktike.
Dio Cassius. Historia Romana.
Heliodorus. Ethiopika.
Hippocratus. Peri aeron, aidaton, topon.
Iosephus Flavius. De bello judico.
Titus Livius. Ab urbe condita libri.
Lukianus Samotasatensis. oksaris i filia.
Mela, Pomponius. De chorographia.
Ovidius Naso, Publius. ristia.
Pausanius. Graeciae descriptio.
Plinius Secundus. Historia naturalis.
Plutarchos. rassus.
Plutarchos. Lucullus.
Polyen. Strategematon.
Polybius. Historia.
Sallustius. De deis et mundo.
Strabo. Geographia.
Svetonius. Tiberius.
Tacitus, Cornelius. nnales.
itus, Cornelius. Historiae.
Vegetius, Flavius. Epitoma Rei Militaris.
319
-
. ;
- -
- -
-
. ..
320
-
-
.
- -
321
. 17. .34:
1 , . ., 5/1 ( .,
1960); 2 , . , 3/1;
3 , . .; 4 ,
26/1
. 1. . .13
. 2. (1)
(2) .14
. 3. (1) (2)
.14
. 4.
.15:
1 ; 2 ; 3 ; 4 .; 5
. 5. (,
, , 2004) .16
. 6.
.18:
1 ; 2 ; 3, 7 ; 4, 5 ; 6 (, , 1994)
. 7. ( ., 2006) .24
. 8. (1)
(2)
( 1, 2) .25
. 9. .27
. 10. .27
. 11. (1) (2) (, 1983) .27
. 12. .28:
1 ; 2
. 13. .29:
. 14. .30:
1 ( ); 2, 3 (
1899.); 3
. 15. .33:
1 , 7/10; 2 -, 66/1; 3
-, 63/1; 4 ,
1/2; 5 , .12
. 16. . .34
322
. 18. , . ,
2/2 (1947.) .35
. 19.
.35:
1, 1 ; 2 ; 3, 3 , ..; 4,
4 ; 5
. 20. - .36:
1 - (, 1962); 2 , 10/1 (, , 1999); 3 , 4/4 (, , 2003)
. 21. .36
. 22. .37
. 23. .38:
1 , . . ;
2 , . , 1/1; 3 , 4/1; 4, 5
. 25. .41:
1, 2 ; 3 (,
1987); 4 - (Istvnovits, Kulcsr,
2001); 5 (Tari, 1994)
. 28. - 2-
.45:
1 ; 2 -, 37/1; 3 , 40/1; 4 ; 5
. 29 (). - 2 .47:
1 ; 2 , 9/1; 3
, 16/1
. 38. .60
. 39. (
..) .62
. 40.
.63
. 41. (Trousdale, 1975) .64:
1 . ,
, ; 2, 3
(2)
(3); 4 ,
. 42. D 16 -
(Rau, 1927) .65
. 43. .66:
1 (Trousdale, 1975); 2,
3
(2 . . ; 3 ..); 4
( , , )
. 44. (,
1986) .68:
1 . ; 2 ; 3, 3 ; 4, 4 ; 5
; 69 ; 10
. 45. 1 .71:
1 ; 2
1, 2 ; 3 -, 1/22
. 46. (,
1951) .71
. 47. 2 .72:
1 ; 2 ; 3 ;
4 , 4/4
. 48. .73
. 49. 2 3 .74:
. 30. -
2 .47:
. 31. - .48:
1, 5, 6 ; 2 ; 3
(, , 1990); 4
(, 1952)
. 32. - 3-
.50:
1 ; 2 ; 3
2: 1, 2 ; 3 ; 3: 4 ; 5 ; 6 ; 7, 9, 10
, .58; 8 , . 203; 11 ,
.59 (710 , 2002)
. 50. .75:
1 ; 2 (,
, 1997); 3
. 51.
.75
. 52. ( ) .75
. 53. (,
1979) .77
. 54. .78:
1 ; 2 (Dinnys, 1991)
1 ; 2
. ; 3
. 57. .86
. 58. () .87
. 59.
(Junkelmann, 1992) .87
. 60. (1)
(2) .88
. 61. (I Tesori,
2005) .88
. 62.
( ) .88
. 63. (, 1980) .89
. 64. ( .) .89
. 65.
.91:
1, 2 ; 35
. 66.
.93:
1 . -, 29/1 (, ,
1994); 2 , 51/1 (, 1971); 3 , 36/1; 4 , 7/1 (, 1959); 5
VI, 16/8 (, 1988); 6 , 2 (, 1971)
. 67. .95:
: 15 ; 6 (, 1984); : 7 , 2/1; 8, 12 , 7/2; 9 , 5/1; 10 ; 11 , . ., 2/1; 13 , 21/1;
14, 17, 18 , 14/1; 15 ,
11/1; 16 -, 2/1
. 68. .97
. 69. ( . . ) .99
. 70. ( . . ) .102
. 71. .103:
1 ( .); 2, 3 ,
(: Rawson, 1995)
. 72. , (1)
(2) (
323
5, 6) .105
. 73. .109:
1 , 7/6 (, 1971); 2
, 11/9; 3 , 41/1; 4 , 55/1 (, 1959)
. 74.
(, 1981) .109
. 75. (1)
(2)
. 76. .111:
1 . (, , 1989);
2 . (, 1901); 3
(, 1979)
. 80. (Ro
binson, 1975) .115
. 81. . 40 . (, 1902) .116
. 82. . ,
2/1 .116
. 83. . ,
17/1 .117
. 84. . ,
20/1 .117
. 85. .117:
1 . , 26/1 (, , 1994);
2 . , 28/1; 3 . , 3/1
. 86. . ,
51/1 .117
. 87. . ,
(. . ) .118
. 88. (. . ) .120
. 89. - .121:
1 ; 2, 3
. 90.
., 9/1 (, , 1994)
.122
. 91. .123:
1 - (, , 1987);
2 ; 3 (,
-, 1999)
324
. 92.
., 15/1 .124
. 93.
(. . ) .124
. 94. (, , 1997) .125
. 95.
(,
2003) .125
. 96. .126:
1, 2 . , 51/1; 3
, 44/1
. 97.
(Robinson, 1975) .126
. 98. .127:
1 ;
2 .. (Ro
binson, 1975)
. 99.
(1) (2)
(Rusu, 1971) .128
. 100. () .128
. 101. (
) .129
. 102.
.130:
1 ; 2
. 112. .139:
1 ; 2
. 113. .140:
1, 2 ; 3 ; 4 ;
5 (); 6
()
. 114. () .141:
1 ; 2
. 115. .142:
1 ; 2 ; 3 ;
4, 5
. 116. .142:
1 ; 2
. 117. .143:
1, 2 ; 3 ; 4 ;
5 (); 6
()
. 118. () .144:
1 ; 2 -
. 121. .149:
1 ; 2
. 122. (,
1984) .151
. 122. .151
. 123.
.152
. 124.
.153
. 125. .153:
. 103. - (Robin
son, 1975) .131
. 104.
(1) (2)
(
7 8) .133
. 105. ( ) .134
. 106. (, 1968)
.134:
. 107. - (, 1941) .135
. 108.
.135:
1 . ( . . ); 2 ( , 2007); 3
( ..); 4
(, 1981)
. 109. .136:
1 - ; 2, 3 (Waurick, 1986);
4 (Srbu, Haruche, 2000)
. 110. .138:
1, 2 ; 3 ; 4 ;
5 ; 6
. 111. () .139:
11 ; 2 ; 3
1 ; 2 ; 3
. 130. 1- 2-
.. .160:
14 (, , 2006); 5,6
- ( . . )
. 131. (
) .161
. 131. ( ) .161
. 131b.
.162
. 131. ( )
.162
. 132. (, 1962) .163
. 133. (, 1962)
.164
. 134. (15 : , , 2003; 4 ) .165
. 135. .166
. 136.
.167:
1 , . 29; 2
, . 12; 3 , . 1;
4 , . 21; 5
. 140. - .171
. 141. .172
. 142.
(, 1960) .173
. 143. .174:
1 ( 1908 ., 1909); 2 (, 2001); 35 , .31.
. 144. .174:
1 ; 2
. 145.
.175
. 146.
( ) .176
. 147.
( ) .177
. 148. (, 1961) .178
. 149. (
) .179
. 150.
(, 1979) .179
. 151. -I (, 2005) .180
. 152. -II
( ) .180
. 152. -II (Lor, 2001) .181
. 153. .182
. 154.
(, 2004) .183
. 155. ( )
.185
. 156. ,
. 14 .186
. 157.
.187
. 158. .188
. 159. .189:
1, 911, 17, 27 ; 2 ; 3 ; 4 ; 5
; 6 ; 7, 8 ; 12, 13 ; 14 ;
15 ; 16 ;
18 ; 19 ;
20 ; 21 ; 22
; 23 ; 24 ; 25 ; 26 ;
IIV IV. ..
. 160.
( .. ) .190
. 161. (1) (2)
- (3, 4) .192
. 162. (, , 2006)
.194
. 163. (, 1975) .195
. 163.
(Alexandrescu, 1983) .196
. 164. ( ) .197
. 165. (,
1940) .200
. 166.
(Mordvinceva, 2001) .201:
1 ; 2, 3 (, 1969);
4
. 167. .202
. 168. (,
1997) .204
. 169. .204:
1 ; 2, 3
. 170. .205:
326
. 171. , . 10
(, , 1999; )
.207
. 172. (1)
(2) .209
. 173. (
, : ., 2004)
.210
. 174. (
) .210
. 175. .212:
1, 2 (, 1914); 3 (, 2002); 48 (,
, 2006)
. 176.
( ) .214
. 177.
(, , 2003) .215
. 178. .218:
1 ( ); 2 (
); 3 ( Antikensammlung
SMPK, Berlin); 4 (, 2005)
. 179. (Otchir-Goriaeva,
2002) .220:
1 ; 2
; 3 -; 4 ( )
. 180. ( ., 1991)
.222
. 181. . ..
.223:
1 ( , 1993); 2
(The First Emperors,
1988)
. 182. (- ) .224
. 183. .225:
1 (Pirazzoli-tSerstevens, 1982); 2 (Chine: des chevaux..., 1995) C.225
................................................................................................................................ 5
1
....................................................................................................................... 13
1.1. ............................................................................................ 13
1.2. ........................................................................................ 26
1.3. ................................................................................................ 32
1.4. -....................................................................................................... 43
1.5. ........................................................................................... 61
2
........................................................................................................................ 70
2.1. ().................................................................................................................................. 70
2.2. ......................................................................................................................................... 76
2.3. .................................................................................................................................... 78
2.4. ..................................................................................... 79
2.5. ?..................... 81
3
.............................................................................................................................. 91
3.1. .................................................................................................................................................. 91
3.2. ....................................................................................................................... 94
3.3. ............................................................................................................................... 101
3.4. ....................................................................................................................................... 101
3.5. .................................................................................... 102
3.6. .............................................................................................. 104
4
............................................................................................................ 107
4.1. ....................................................................................................................................... 108
4.2. ......................................................................................................................................... 132
4.3. ............................................................................................................................................ 147
5
.................................................................................................. 151
5.1. ........................................................................................................................................... 151
5.2. ......................................................................................................................................... 161
5.3. ............................................................................................................................ 169
5.4. .................................................................................................................................. 184
5.5. ................................................................................................................................... 186
5.6. ......................................................................................................................................... 199
5.7. .................................................................................................................................... 209
5.8. .................................................................................................................................... 217
5.9. ................................................................................................. 221
. 184. ( ) .226
. 185.
.226
. 186. .229:
6
............................................................. 235
.............................................................................................................................. 255
............................................................................................................................. 257
Summary................................................................................................................................... 281
................................................................................................................. 305
................................................................................................................ 320
.............................................................................................................. 322
1 ; 2 ; 3, 4 ; 5 ; 6 ; 7 (,
1988); 8 (, 1990; Bunker et
alii, 1997)
. .
. .
. .
. .
. .
000156 27,04,99. ??.??.2009
70 1001/16. . . . 20,5. 1000 . ???.
- .
199034, -, ., . 11.
.
199061, -, . .., . 41.